Part 1: Stalked & Followed 60 Miles Before Being Found Dead | Shannon Sanderson
54m 30s
Shannon Marie Baldridge, a mother of three, vanished on April 19, 1996, from her former father-in-law’s driveway in Memphis after being followed by a man in a red baseball cap. The incident occurred after she had gambled at Sam’s Town Casino in Tunica, where she won $5,100 and was escorted out by security. Surveillance footage confirmed her presence but showed no signs of foul play or her husband, Robert Sanderson. A tip from Gerald Lee Powers’ wife, Sharon, described the same man and vehicle as witnesses, but authorities dismissed it as a domestic dispute. Robert, who had a substantial business connection to security, was a primary suspect but lacked physical evidence. Other suspects, including Shannon’s ex-husband and ex-boyfriend Brett Muskamp, were eliminated by alibis and lack of ties. Shannon’s body was later found in a rural shed, showing signs of severe blunt force trauma and a gunshot wound, confirmed by dental analysis. The case exposed critical failures in investigative practices—particularly the dismissal of credible tips and the lack of attention to patterns of predatory behavior. Shannon’s family suffered deep emotional trauma, and her sister died shortly after, underscoring the devastating impact of unresolved violence. The man responsible, Gerald Lee Powers, had a detailed history of assaulting women, and his return to the same neighborhood and behavior patterns confirmed his identity as a repeat offender. The case remains a powerful example of how domestic violence, hidden patterns, and institutional negligence can lead to tragic outcomes.
It was almost 5.45 in the morning in Memphis, Tennessee on April 19th of 1996, and William
Dillon's dogs start losing their minds. They're barking hysterically and they won't stop. This
was aggressive and relentless, the kind of barking that pulls you right out of your sleep.
William opened up his eyes. He was lying there quietly for a moment. He was trying to make sense
of it. They just wouldn't stop. So he got up and he told them to be quiet. But then the motion
detector lights around his house turned on and he thought he could hear voices coming from outside.
That was concerning. What is going on? He quickly runs to the window. He looks outside into the
darkness and he sees a man in a red baseball cap bent over in his neighbor's driveway.
William steps away just for a minute to throw on some clothes so he can go outside,
and get a better look. It took maybe a minute or less. But by the time he made it back to the door
and looked outside, no one was there. At the same time, his neighbor, Edward Holland, had woken up
to William's dogs barking. He too realized it was way more intense than usual. He also thought he
heard noises, except these were coming from his driveway. It sounded like somebody talking.
He ran to a side door, he cracked it open, he looked outside, and he saw his former,
daughter-in-law's red Mitsubishi pulled into the driveway just like it always was when she came to
pick up her kids. Shannon had dropped them off earlier that evening, and he thought she must
be coming back for them now, just like she said she would. But something about what he was seeing
out there didn't make sense. Shannon was near her car, but her body was low and tense and she
was bracing herself like she was trying to hold her ground against something. And then he heard
her voice, sharp and scared.
Shannon, cutting through the dark, saying don't, don't. He too went to go get dressed and ran back outside, and by the time he did, Shannon was gone.
The man was gone. The only thing left in that driveway was her car, sitting there with the
driver's side door wide open. Was he seeing things? He didn't think so. So where was Shannon?
Van Duel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places.
Make this your most rewarding season ever with Fan Duel.
Age and location restrictions apply.
Product availability varies by market.
See FanDuel.com for eligibility.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The real cost of a break-in isn't your valuables.
It's the feeling that your home stopped being safe.
Simply Safe keeps danger away from your family with three layers of protection.
One, smart AI cameras and live U.S.-based agents help stop intruders before they break in.
Two, we sound the alarm at points of entry.
Three, our agents request emergency response.
Plans starting around a dollar a day.
Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at SimplySafe.com slash Spotify.
Outdoor deterrence plans start at $49.99 a month.
Visit SimplySafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information.
Hi, everyone.
Welcome back to my channel.
And if you have never been here before, I am Kimberlea.
It's nice to finally meet you.
These are the cases that didn't get the Netflix documentary.
They're the ones that slipped through the cracks of the news cycle.
The ones where the monster was hiding in plain sight.
And we dissect them.
Not just the what, the why, and the who, but the psychology, the manipulation,
the systems that failed, and the people who were let down by all of it.
Because some of the scariest people in this world don't live out in the shadows.
They could be walking around right next to you in town,
sitting at a booth while you're out for dinner.
And sometimes, like in this case, they're a predator in a red baseball cap,
watching, waiting, while the victim has absolutely no clue that they even exist.
The predator in the red baseball cap doesn't even sound horrific enough.
And he does have a name, and we're going to get there.
But he didn't come out of nowhere.
Now, the red baseball cap, that might have been new, but his pattern wasn't.
He didn't wake up on the morning of April 18th and snap and become a monster.
He had been one for a very long time.
He was the one that took Shannon from that driveway.
And he was someone that no one had on their radar.
No one was watching him.
He was just a man in a red baseball cap.
And Shannon had no idea that he was targeting her until it was too late.
But there was someone that did know.
They had been holding on.
The only person he confessed to was the woman who loved him the most, who was sleeping right
next to him in bed when he got home that night.
But it would take years, a lot of fear, and one FBI agent who refused to give up before
that confession was ever spoken out loud.
But there were women before Shannon.
1979, Murfreesboro, Tennessee.
A girl named Emily Dodson had just graduated from high school, and one night she's driving
home when she realized a car had been following her.
She pulls into her own driveway.
She gets out, but before she can process what's happening, a man jumps into the driver's seat
of her car, pulls out a knife, holds it to her throat, and instructs her to drive, demands
her to drive.
Emily fights back.
She manages to get the knife away from the driver.
He pulls out a wrench and hits her across the head with it, knocking her to the ground.
As he swings at her again, she grabs it.
She hits him back, and she runs for her front door.
She survived, and she identified him.
He pled guilty, but didn't serve any time in jail.
Just a slap on the wrist, a mistake.
But only one year later, in 1980, the same city failed.
The same city again.
An 18-year-old girl, this time, named Karen Cannon.
She meets a man at a Shoney's restaurant, and he seems harmless enough.
He's attractive, and he just needs a ride home.
They talk for a little while, and she agrees.
But on the way there, he pulls out a knife, breaks her nose with the handle, and then
he presses the blade against her side and starts directing her where to go.
Karen is brave.
She tries to stay alert, and she's spot a jail.
She pulls alongside it.
She grabs his hand, and she leans on the horn until a police officer comes out to the car.
She survives as well.
She identified him, too.
He pled guilty to aggravated violence again, and he did serve some time, but not enough.
He was free again by 1984 to strike for the third time, this time in Jackson, Mississippi.
And it's not a teenage girl.
It's a 74-year-old woman named Clio Griffin.
She's in her own home when a man breaks in, beats her with an iron skillet, and steals
her jewelry, her credit cards, and her pistol.
He buries everything in a plastic bag beside a tree in the next county, like he's done
this before.
Like he already knows how to plan for what's to come.
Because he had.
And he does.
But he is caught.
And for this one, he was sentenced to time in the Mississippi State Penitentiary.
FanDuel is now available everywhere in the US, so you can get in on the sports action
no matter where you are, including these places: Make this your most rewarding season ever
with FanDuel.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
1-800-GAMBLER.
1-800-GAMBLER.
1-800-GAMBLER.
1-800-GAMBLER.
1-800-GAMBLER.
1-800-GAMBLER.
He served seven years, but then they let him out again.
I guess he just hadn't committed a horrific enough crime to do more time.
And he had a routine.
And clearly, I'm not just talking about what he did after he went to work or with his kids
or school events or where he liked to hang out.
And yes, he had all of that too, but he also had a sinister routine.
But before we get into all of that, let's talk about Shannon, who seemingly disappeared
into the night from her former father-in-law's driveway.
Shannon Marie Baldridge.
Baldridge was born on August 28th of 1970 to her mother Stephanie and her father Ronnie.
She was one of two children.
She had a sister named Jennifer.
And they grew up in Memphis, Tennessee, a city humming with blues, soul, and southern warmth.
And from the moment she was old enough to understand it, Shannon felt a calling.
She carried this deeply without question.
She wanted to be a mom.
She couldn't wait.
And in high school, she met Michael Holland, her first true love.
The kind that feels like your entire world when you're that age.
And soon after graduation, they got married and they stepped together into adult life.
Over the next eight years, their family grew.
First came a son named Michael Jr., then a daughter Amber, and finally another son they named Chance.
The moment that those children arrived, Shannon's world rearranged itself around them completely and totally.
Without hesitation, her son Michael Jr. would later say,
the best thing about their mother, the very best thing,
was how she felt.
How much she loved them.
Him, his brother, his sister, just loved them with everything that she had.
And they truly loved her back.
To Shannon, motherhood wasn't a role, it was her purpose.
Every milestone, every scraped knee, every bedtime story was a moment that she treasured.
Her friends joked with her.
They said her heart was so big, it seemed designed specifically to hold her three children and still have space for everyone else.
The life is rarely straightforward, and we know it's not perfect.
Shannon and Michael, as strong as their love was, they eventually grew apart.
Their relationship had run its course, and they slowly drifted until they found themselves standing at a painful crossroad.
Divorce.
And at this point, Shannon was still a young woman with her whole life ahead of her.
She was in her early 20s, so it didn't really seem like the end of the world to her.
But to Michael?
He was struggling deeply.
He was completely heartbroken over losing the life that they had built together.
Shannon did her best to guide her children gently through all of the turbulence.
Even with the heartbreak, she stayed strong for the three of them.
And moving forward led her into the arms of another man, Robert Sanderson.
Now, Robert was a very wealthy and successful businessman.
He was actually the founder and chief executive officer of Protection Unlimited Incorporated.
A residential and commercial alarm monitoring company based in Memphis, Tennessee.
Shannon had been working there as a dispatcher, and the two became acquainted.
And eventually, what started as a professional relationship became something more.
Now, Robert's lifestyle was something so different from anything Shannon had ever known.
It was exciting and appealing, and of course, Shannon, she was stunning.
If you haven't been watching, maybe you're just listening, now is the time to look.
Or I can describe it.
I think about Tiffany Amber Thiessen from the 90s, or Marissa Tomei, and maybe a mix of both of them, and a little bit of Jennifer Love Hewitt.
Today's version of maybe Selena Gomez.
The deep, soulful brown eyes.
The big, voluminous dark hair.
And that sweet, innocent quality.
Kind of like the girl next door.
Shannon was also charismatic, kind, and she was young.
I mean, compared to Robert.
There was almost a 34-year. age gap between them.
Robert was almost 58 at the time, and Shannon was barely 25.
And I'm not going to pretend that it wasn't a significant detail, because it is.
And we're going to come back to it, and all of the dynamics of this relationship a little later.
But everything moved fast, and they got married.
And then soon afterward, Shannon and her three children moved into his upscale home
in the Woodland Hills area of Cordova, in the tranquil Cordova Cove.
It was a four-bedroom, three-bedroom apartment.
It was a four-bedroom, traditional brick home with a beautiful marble tile front entry.
A lot of natural lighting, a fireplace in the living room, and a big backyard.
Perfect for a family of five.
What I will say is that people close to Robert said that he was genuinely good with Shannon's kids.
He was already a dad.
He had kids of his own that he raised, and they were all grown up.
But he was still playful and engaged.
The kind of stepfather who ran around the house with the children and made them feel. happy that he was there.
And that mattered to Shannon.
Her children's happiness always mattered to her.
But Shannon herself was also a full person outside of being a mother and a wife.
She had a life that was entirely her own.
Her own identity that she formed outside of the household.
Hobbies.
And one of them was going to the casino.
To her, it was just one of these places she truly allowed herself to just be
herself.
No routine.
No responsibility.
No one needing anything from her.
She could get dolled up and disappear into the crowded, noisy atmosphere and let loose.
Now I know it might sound like kind of funny because it's a weird way
and a weird place to unwind.
It's not peaceful at all.
But an escape from stress and the day-to-day routine felt good.
And usually she and Robert would go together.
This was their thing.
And quickly.
Shannon figured out she had a knack for blackjack.
And frequently she would come home with, I'm talking substantial winnings.
Thousands of dollars in hand.
So that was another big reason she liked to gamble.
Because she loved nice things.
Gold jewelry.
Expensive outfits.
Luxury purses.
And she would certainly treat herself when she had a winning streak.
She tried to have a night out to the casino at least two, maybe three times a week if she could.
And there were times when Robert was busy.
She would go by herself.
Everyone knew her there.
The high rollers, the staff, the security guards.
She never felt unsafe.
And she wasn't just lucky.
She had a talent.
The casino floor was where Shannon got to be sharp and focused.
And completely in her element in a way that had nothing to do with anyone but herself.
I know I referred to it as being dolled up.
Well there's another way to describe it that's probably better.
She would dress for it.
So I would dress for it.
So I want you to picture this because it's a part of the excitement.
Shannon would take her time getting ready on casino nights.
She would do her hair.
Styling it just right.
She would do her makeup perfectly.
She would choose an outfit that made her feel beautiful.
Her nails were done.
Her jewelry was on.
It was date night casino nights.
And she would routinely go on nights that the kids were at her ex-husband Michael's house.
He didn't mind taking the kids on short notice either.
Especially since she would usually head out after dinner.
When the kids would be going off to bed anyway.
Now for a quick timeline.
She'd only been married to Robert for about a year by 1996.
And sometimes, especially with last minute plans or when Michael was working.
Her former in-laws, his mom and dad, would babysit.
She would drive the 20 minutes to Michael's dad Edward Holland's home in Memphis, Tennessee.
Drop off her three kids and head out.
And sometimes she would pick them up after her and Robert were done gambling.
This could be 2 a.m.
Or it could be 5.
This was a normal arrangement.
And it was a comfortable one.
And that was the plan on the night of April 18th of 1996.
But this was a special night.
Because this was Robert's birthday.
And the couple planned an evening at Sam's Town Casino in Tunica, Mississippi.
This was about an hour away across state lines.
They loved it there.
It's a nice big resort.
And as they call it, it has a gambling hall.
Probably to sound a little more fancy.
There's even a club inside for country/western dancing, a pool, a big theater.
But of course, Shannon and Robert were interested in the slots and the card games.
And there was plenty of them there.
Two whole stories full.
FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are.
From these places.
Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The best holiday finds aren't always the ones you went looking for.
At Ross, discover unexpected gifts, fashion, decor, and plenty of reasons to keep looking.
Ross.
Expect the unexpected.
So there was Shannon, dropping the kids off and saying goodbye.
And before she walked out that door, she hugged each one of her children.
She kissed them.
And she told them how much she loved them and that she would see them in a few hours.
There should have been nothing to worry about.
And after she pulled out of that driveway, she headed back home to meet up with Robert
before they planned to head out.
But when she got to her front door…
She realized there were unexpected visitors.
Now this threw an entire wrench in her night.
Shannon had already gotten completely ready.
She did her hair, her nails, she put her jewelry on, and she was dressed from head to toe in
a perfect outfit for a night out.
Only to be interrupted by Robert's adult daughters, Ashley and Connie, who were actually
not too far from Shannon's age.
Connie was actually four years older than Shannon.
So I think you can imagine her, the new wife, the young wife, younger than
you and she's with your father? Definitely tension in this household. But it was their father's
birthday. They came over and surprised him with a cake and gifts. They wanted to celebrate with him
and he didn't know how to say no. He thought casino night, it could wait. And Robert decided
they were going to stay home, leaving Shannon hurt and disappointed and angry. It was uncomfortable.
Shannon felt that Robert chose them over her, which he did. And rightfully so. They were his
children. And Shannon would have probably done the exact same thing, knowing how much she cared
about her own children and their feelings. But I understand it. You've gotten yourself ready.
You went out of your way to make plans, drop off the kids for the night. And now the evening you
were looking forward to is just canceled. Without a conversation, without a heads up, she felt like
she had been pushed aside. And she was just like, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't
know. And she told Robert this. The two of them got into an argument. And at some point, Shannon
left. She didn't want to stick around. She was determined not to waste a full face of makeup
or an evening of fun. She got into her red Mitsubishi and she drove away. But after she
cooled down, she called Robert from the road. And she was still emotional and she was still hurt.
And she asked, when are you going to be ready to join me? He told her he needed at least 30 minutes.
She was pretty much like,
don't bother. She was halfway to the casino. And she told him through tears that she felt like
he didn't love her. And she hung up. Shannon had no way to know that this would be their last
conversation. Robert stayed home with his daughters. Shannon drove to Tunica alone.
But I want to be clear about something here, because I already told you,
but this will come up later in the story. Shannon went to the casino alone all the time. This was
not unusual.
She knew that world. She was comfortable in it. She was not a woman wandering somewhere unfamiliar
and feeling completely vulnerable. This was her space. She knew exactly what she was doing when
she left. She arrived at Sam's Town Casino around seven o'clock in the evening, and she settled in
at one of the blackjack tables right away. Now, you're probably going to wonder how we know some
of this information. I'm going to tell you something. If you know anything about casinos,
they have probably the most
cameras out of any other kind of establishment. In 1996, casino surveillance was genuinely
sophisticated compared to almost any other industry at the time. Casinos had strong
financial incentives. There is money everywhere, and they want to watch everything. When there's
money, and I'm talking big money involved, it's worth it. So they invested heavily in camera
systems long before most businesses did. But sophisticated for 1996 still looks very
primitive by today's standards. There will be footage that I will show you in this case,
but the cameras were analog. They were recording on VHS tapes. There was no digital database,
no searchable footage, certainly not facial recognition software. A person had to watch
every single one of these tapes, every single minute, with their own eyes. And the quality,
you could have guessed, mostly grainy and in black and white. Coverage,
inside the casino floor, was fairly comprehensive, though, because that's where the money was moving.
The tables, the cashier, the entrances. But outside in the parking lot, it dropped off.
And crucially, cameras could be misaligned. And it's not for nothing that I'm giving you
all of this information. So just bank it away right now, because it will become significant.
Maybe being fueled by anger made Shannon more on point than ever, because that night, she quickly
found her rhythm. She was in a hurry, and she was in a hurry, and she was in a hurry, and she was
in a hurry, and she was in a hurry, and she was in a hurry, and she was in a hurry, and she was in a hurry.
Cards flipped. Chips piled higher and higher. She was on a winning streak. The table was buzzing
around her, and Shannon was staying completely focused and steady, like she always did. Reading
the game, making her moves, and by the time she finally looked up, it was close to three o'clock
in the morning. Time does fly when you're in the zone like that. And also, they purposely don't put
clocks or even windows in these types of establishments, because they don't want you to
know what time it is. So they don't want you to know what time it is. So you will keep gambling. By this time, Shannon knew it was time to cash out. She turned her almost ruined evening into over $5,000. Now, when she went to get her earnings, the casino staff encouraged her to take a check. But she said no. She wanted the cash. $5,100 bills. And she walked out to her car. What Shannon didn't know, and had no reason to know, was that she was being watched in that
casino. Not just by the cameras, and not just by turning heads because she was so gorgeous, which was true. But there was someone with very bad intentions watching her every move. From the second floor balcony overlooking that blackjack table, there was a man in a red baseball cap. He'd been watching her for who knows how long exactly, but at least the better part of about 45 minutes. Watching her win. Watching her stack her
chips. Watching her collect her money and stand up and walk towards the exit. She was safe. Because the security guard actually escorted Shannon to her car. Casinos will do this when someone leaves with a very significant amount of cash. The guard walked her out, said goodbye, and went back inside. But approximately 40 seconds later, 40 seconds, the man in the red baseball cap came through the same exit and followed her into the parking lot.
Nobody stopped him. Nobody even noticed. There was no reason to. He was just a man leaving the casino at 3am. That's not an unusual thing. What was unusual was who he was. And what he was capable of. And what his plans were. Because when Shannon got into a red Mitsubishi and headed back towards Memphis, just to pick up her children, the man got in his maroon Chevrolet Beretta and followed her. This was over an hour and a half.
An hour drive. She pulled into her former father-in-law's small driveway around approximately 4.30am. And that's where we left off earlier. So it turns out, Michael's father wasn't seeing things. Shannon did pull into his driveway that early morning. Now I think it's important for you to get a visual and an explanation of what this area looks like. With the street and where the houses were and how everything was positioned. Because the vantage points are going to make a lot more sense to you when you see the layout.
I'm a visual person, so it's a must. Michael's parents live in a modest home on Gerald Street in Memphis, Tennessee. 1351 to be exact. It had a paved driveway to the left of the front door. Actually, all the homes on this side of the street had pretty much the same layout. Now remember, I talked about a neighbor named William Dillon. He was the one that heard something because his dogs were barking early that morning, nonstop. And it also woke up Edward. Well, he didn't live directly next door. He lived next door.
He lived at 1361 Gerald Street, so just one house was in between them. But these homes were small enough and the distance was short enough that you could see over to your neighbor's driveway. And when Shannon pulled in that night, around 4.30am, the comforting normality of that entire night was shattered. Now you know why the neighbor's dogs were barking. Because they could sense something was very wrong. Shannon was out there, but she wasn't alone. And in the blink of an eye,
Shannon was missing. She was taken. And by sunrise on April 19th, the peaceful neighborhood in Memphis, Tennessee had actually transformed into a crime scene. Calls had been made already, of course, to Shannon's husband, Robert, and also to 911. Her former father-in-law, Edward, believed the man that he heard arguing with Shannon was probably Robert, which made sense to him. Who else would be with her? Except when Edward called Robert,
to ask if Shannon was with him, he said no. And he never came over there. He said he was home all night. He hadn't seen Shannon since she left the night before. Now when police spoke to Robert, he told them the same thing. And next they wanted to know, what did Shannon look like and what was she wearing? He said she was 5'5", about 130 pounds. He thought she was wearing a black dress, a purse, black loafers with a small heel, several gold rings, long pants.
He said she was wearing a pink fake Luan nails and a black jacket with metal buttons on it. There would be more questions to come. But for now, they were examining the evidence in the driveway. They found Shannon's red Mitsubishi still sitting where it was, and the driver's door was wide open, but the engine wasn't running. And on the ground near the car, they found two small metal buttons. They looked like they had been torn from a jacket in a struggle. And they found a single pink fake fingernail.
Well, of course, the men in Shannon's life, her ex-husband Michael, her current husband Robert, they're going to be the first persons of interest. She and Robert, they had an argument, and she stormed off. And by all accounts, Shannon's friends and family said the marriage had been rocky almost from the beginning.
Including these places.
Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Ross, expect the unexpected.
Robert could be controlling, verbally aggressive, and Shannon had reportedly considered leaving him.
And he'd not taken well to that at all.
There was actually a prenuptial, well, it was a post-nuptial agreement signed just two weeks before Shannon disappeared.
And that required Robert to pay her $10,000 and provide her with an apartment in the event they got divorced.
Two weeks.
That timing was not lost on investigators.
Robert also had no alibi for the early morning hours when Shannon was taken.
Now, we said he'd be at home, but he was alone and asleep.
And there was no one to confirm that.
He had known Shannon's plans for that evening.
And as someone who, let me remind you, owns and runs a security company called Protection Unlimited,
he had knowledge and resources and connections.
That the average person simply did not have.
Detectives began speaking with neighbors along that street,
trying to piece together the fragmented details of what happened in those critical moments.
Witnesses consistently described a maroon Chevy Beretta lurking nearby.
Several neighbors saw a man wearing a red baseball cap and a blue jean jacket.
And they saw him force Shannon into a vehicle before speeding off.
Anna Dillon, the wife to the man whose dogs are working,
told police she heard a scream followed by a thud after their motion detector lights came on.
She ran to the living room window, she looked out, she saw a second car,
possibly a Beretta, parked on the street with the dome light on.
She said that someone was behind the steering wheel, facing the rear of the car,
and leaning over the seat, the back part, and pushing something down.
She explained that after the person got through pushing downward,
they quickly turned around and looked at her.
She turned around, got into the driver's seat, and drove away at a high rate of speed.
Robert was still front and center in law enforcement's minds.
They interviewed witnesses at the casino, and an employee named Mark Birchfield claimed
he actually saw Robert at Samstown the night that Shannon had come in.
And not only that, he said she was scared.
She was so frightened, and she needed help.
She was crouched in a corner, telling staff,
that her husband was going to hurt her.
But Robert denied that ever happened.
Now, he did admit that Shannon got mad, stormed off in the night,
but that was after she came back from Gerald Street.
He was with his daughters.
He denied being anywhere near Gerald Street that night, or the casino,
and denied ever driving or having a maroon Chevrolet Beretta.
He said he loved Shannon, and he was worried sick about her.
And then he hired an attorney, and all further communication went through that lawyer.
The lack of communication did not help this man.
Neither did what Shannon's sister told investigators, that when the family was desperately trying
to make flyers right away to find Shannon, they reached out to Robert for just a photograph
of his wife, and he refused to help them.
In a moment where everyone who loved this woman was doing everything they could, her
own husband wouldn't even provide a photo.
But despite all of this, the investigators could not place Robert at the scene.
And they looked at the possibility that he could have hired someone to take her, but they found nothing.
The investigators went through all 512 surveillance cameras at the casino, tape by tape, minute by minute.
It was tedious, but necessary, and they finally spot Shannon.
She's sitting at a blackjack table, and if you're watching, here is the CCTV footage.
I know her hair could appear blonde, but it's just the way blonde people are.
appear blonde, but it's just the way black and white footage will capture shades. However, after
scanning and scanning, they never see Robert anywhere. He wasn't in the footage, not once,
and nothing on the camera ever showed an altercation, not with anyone, especially not
Robert. So that account that the employee gave, it fell apart. Robert and Shannon frequented that
casino, so the employee could have been referring to a different time, a different night, when he
might have saw them together, and tensions rose, but it wasn't this night. And without physical
evidence, suspicion, it wasn't enough. Robert Sanderson remained under a cloud of suspicion,
but they did not have enough to move forward. Plus, they didn't know what happened to Shannon
yet. Now, the second door that investigators knock on was Michael Hullins, Shannon's ex-husband,
the father of her three children. He had been paying child support. Shannon had
moved on with a wealthy man that she ended up marrying right away, and she had been taken
outside of his parents' home. That's a detail that, if you're building a theory, you could work
with. So detectives were. And when they checked Michael's time card at the chemical company where
he worked, it showed that he was there from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. that night, the time that Shannon was
taken. It confirmed exactly what he had told them. He had been at work the entire time,
and he had been at work the entire time. That was the reason he couldn't watch the kids to begin with,
and why his parents were babysitting. So Michael Hullins was eliminated within just a few days.
The third door cops showed up at was Brett Muskamp's. And this one had a lot more behind it.
Brett had dated Shannon sometime between her divorce from Michael and her marriage to Robert.
When things ended between them, he did not handle it well. He would obsessively call her, literally
harass her, follow her around, and then throw her out of the house and throw her out of the house.
And he was never allowed to leave the house. So he had to go to a different location. He had to go
to a different place. And then he had to go to a different place.
So she couldn't leave. He freaked her out so badly, she filed a criminal complaint against him and got
a restraining order. Robert had even told investigators that Brett wrote him a letter
warning him not to marry Shannon. And that's got to tell you something about how deeply Brett was
enraveled with this woman and how hard he was fighting not to let go. So they wonder, did he
ever let go? And then there was the timing. That protective order had been lifted just two days
before Shannon was taken. Two days. When investigators went to Brett's workplace
the day after Shannon disappeared, his boss says he didn't show up. And when they went to his house,
he wasn't there either. And for a brief,
very urgent moment, it did look like he could be on the run, possibly with Shannon. And then a few
days later, Brett walked into the homicide division himself. He told them he'd heard they
were looking for him. And he didn't want to just sneak around like something was wrong. He wanted
to speak to them directly. He admitted he had been very upset when Shannon ended things. And
he admitted he was angry when she married another man. But he denied everything else.
His alibi? The same as Robert's. He was home. He was asleep. But at least his was confirmed by his
mother. Which is still not exactly an ironclad alibi. But investigators also verify that Brett
did not own or drive a maroon Beretta. When he took a polygraph, he passed. So that door closed
too for the time being. Three suspects, three dead ends. And the investigation was running out of obvious places.
To look. But here's the thing. The right answer had already come in. They just didn't know yet.
Someone close to the person who took Shannon had tried. Once she saw Shannon's photo on the news,
her heart sank. Knowing that Shannon was a mother of three. And that she had loved ones that would
miss her. She took action. She tried to warn them. She called. She put in a tip less than 24 hours
after Shannon disappeared. Yet no one took it seriously. And speaking of Shannon's children.
When they woke up at their grandparents' house, their father had the difficult task of explaining
why mommy had not come to pick them up yet. Michael didn't have the heart to tell them their
mother had been kidnapped. Would they have even understood? Little Amber was only five. She recalled
just lying there in bed wondering, where's mommy? And then she sees her mother's face on the news.
Amber was so confused. She's like, daddy, daddy, look, there's mommy. Why is mommy on TV? Imagine
how hard that would have been. It's heartbreaking just to think about it. The people who loved
Shannon wanted answers. And yet there was one glaring right at investigators. But like I told
you, they hadn't taken it seriously. But I'm going to let you in on what this call was all about.
It was actually on the very day that Shannon was reported missing, April 19th. The caller was a woman
named Sharon Powers. That night, she saw a news segment. And later, she decided to call the
Crimestoppers hotline. Here are the details she provided.
Sharon said she thought her husband, Gerald, might have been involved.
The operator asked her why she thought that, and Sharon told them he had been out all night the night before,
specifically at the Sam's Town Casino.
She sounded pretty angry about that, and added that she saw him leave wearing a red baseball cap and a blue jean jacket,
just like the news reported the neighbors had told police the kidnapper was wearing.
Anything else they asked, and Sharon said, yeah.
He was driving my maroon Chevy Beretta.
Now, you would think that would check off all the boxes.
Every single detail matched what the witnesses on Gerald Street had saw, and they described.
Fan Duel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
I've been everywhere, man. Georgia, Houston, Cleveland, Minnesota, Buffalo, Lincoln.
Chi-Town, Arizona, Texas.
Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
But it's the way that Sharon came across.
When asked more in-depth questions about her husband, she was vague.
She agreed to allow officers to meet with her at her home and take a formal statement.
But when they got there, she clammed up.
Her details became inconclusive.
She couldn't give them much beyond that initial tip.
And investigators looking at the full picture, a wife whose husband had been out all night,
possibly gambling or with another woman, they chalked it up to a domestic dispute.
Now, I don't know how much of you know anything about the Ted Bundy case,
but his longtime girlfriend did the same thing.
She called in a tip.
She said, I'm worried that my boyfriend may be involved in those murders.
He drives a. VW Bug.
He's got brown hair.
His name is Ted.
In that case, it got the ball moving right away.
But here, all they did was take down a note with the name Gerald Lee Powers.
Except they put that at the bottom of the list.
And they kept working on other leads that they had prioritized.
That is so frustrating.
But you're getting to see behind the yellow tape.
Investigators did not have that privilege.
They did not dig deeper at that point.
Because Sharon. Was purposely holding back.
There were valid reasons for that.
It was one of the most consequential decisions of this entire investigation.
And it would take weeks before anyone truly understood what Sharon Powers actually knew.
20 days go by.
20 days of Shannon's family waiting by the phone,
putting up flyers, driving all around Memphis looking for any sign of her.
20 days of her three children asking questions.
Then nobody knew how to answer.
20 days of an investigation that had knocked on every door it could to find answers, but kept hitting walls.
I know the older children had seen more images of their mom on TV.
And Michael Jr., who was old enough to read, saw the word "missing" next to his mother's photo.
He said his world fell apart.
He cried all night because the reality had set in.
And then on May 9th of 1996.
A man named Marshall Mullins and his sister drove out to a piece of rural property in Eudora.
It was property that their father had left to them.
This location was about 40 miles outside of Memphis.
20 acres, an abandoned house, a small storage shed attached to the back.
They were there to check the condition of the place, to see what they had inherited.
And to their absolute horror, it was way more than they bargained for.
As Marshall entered the house, he heard a loud noise.
And then as Marshall is walking around the outside of the house, he starts to notice an odor.
It was the kind that stops you mid-step, and he assumes it's a dead animal.
It's the kind of thing you would find on a rural property that's been sitting empty.
But then his sister finds a brand new looking black loafer on the ground near the side of the house.
And then Marshall saw the other shoe on the back side.
He peers inside that small storage room, and that's when he saw a female leg from the mid-thigh down.
Sticking out from the dirt-covered floor.
He ran so fast out of there to find a phone, and he called the police.
This was around 4.30 in the afternoon when that call came in.
When officers arrived, they found the body of a woman inside that shed face down, fully clothed.
But the condition of the remains, which had been exposed to the heat, the elements, the insects,
for as long as it had been, made an immediate identification impossible.
There was another woman that was missing from Tate County at the time,
so the investigators could not assume it was Shannon,
even knowing that Shannon was still out there somewhere.
They had to be certain.
Jeffrey Pounders, the county coroner, actually went down to the location to look at the body,
and he made a note that it was very decomposed.
But he saw no jewelry like was described by Robert, only clothing.
Pictures were taken, and they were later sent to Robert, and he confirmed the outfit on that body
matched what his wife was wearing the night she left for the casino.
Now, Dr. Pounders sent the body to be autopsied at the University Hospital in Jackson.
The examination was conducted by Dr. Steve Hain in conjunction with Dr. Harry Mincer.
He was an expert in the area of forensic odontology.
He works with teeth, and he took the impressions of these teeth from the remains,
and he was able to determine that they matched dental x-rays taken of Shannon
and Shannon Sanderson back in 1994.
They had indeed located Shannon Marie Sanderson's remains.
And the autopsy, it was actually very difficult to hear,
because this doctor, this forensic anthropologist, he examined Shannon's skull,
and he found two distinctive types of trauma.
Blunt force injury came first, because someone had delivered at least one major blow to Shannon's face,
and he decided with enough force to fracture both sides of her jaw,
crack the bones around her eye sockets, fracture the roof of her mouth,
and knock out her upper right front tooth.
The bone in front of it had been broken away entirely,
and the second tooth had been chipped.
This was sustained deliberate violence.
a single 25 caliber bullet to the right side of her head behind her ear this doesn't have to be
said because i'm sure you know the manner of death was ruled a homicide and the cause
a single gunshot wound now back at the scene it was noted the one of shannon shoes had been found
pretty far away from the shed and investigators found drag marks leading back towards that
structure where she was located. This showed them that she was dragged all that way and that she had
fought. She had tried to run and she had fought for her life and it still wasn't enough. Her jewelry
was gone. The $5,000 she wanted at the blackjack table was gone. Her purse was gone and right away
that seemed to be the motive. And that was because it didn't appear that she had been violated and it
would have been really hard to tell since her remains were so badly decomposed. But all of her
clothing was still on when she was found. Of course, this was shocking news for her family.
Shannon's sister later said she had no idea how she found out that her sister was dead,
but she could not believe it. And in her words, it killed their mother. When she was told about
what happened to Shannon, she broke down and she was never the same. And then four years later,
she died of a broken heart. That's what Jennifer said. Shannon's ex-husband had now this impossible
job of telling their children what happened to their mother. There's no script for that
conversation. There's nowhere you can look to know how to say this to someone. No right words.
Michael Jr. was seven. Amber was five and Chance was only three. And Michael did the only thing he
could. He told his children their mother had been a good person, that she loved them deeply, and that
she always would, but she was never coming back. And that is so unfair to these precious little
babies. Now seven-year-old Michael Jr. would later say that he kept thinking, how could someone do
this to his mom? She had her whole life ahead of her. The idea that someone could hurt her like
that, it left him with the kind of anger and confusion that he never had felt before, and he
wouldn't fully know how to deal with it for a very long time. And somewhere in Clarksdale, Mississippi,
the man in the red baseball cap was watching the same news reports, pacing, looking out through his
windows, closing his blinds, trying to figure out how far ahead he was and how much time he had left
to plan his escape. Now I need to let you in on the other side of the story from Gerald's wife
Sharon's point of view. He left the night before and he didn't come home until 9 30 in the morning
and Sharon noticed immediately that something was off. Now on the surface the timing wasn't
that unusual. He would come home from the casino all hours of the morning and night but everything
about the way he was moving that night was wrong.
He was wired.
He was restless.
He was pacing the house.
He was opening and closing the blinds.
He was pulling the back slightly,
peering out to the street,
and then moving to another window
and doing the same thing.
like he was expecting something or someone to pull up outside at any moment. And then he went
outside and he washed their car obsessively. Now, that was not normal. And there was also the cut.
He had a cut on his forearm. And she asked, what happened? And instead of answering,
he defaulted to positive news that he had been on quite a winning streak at the casino.
He was flashing the cash. He said he even called a neighbor to pass along a message to the family
that he was going to be late because of how well he was doing at the tables. In a gesture that was
so out of character for him that it immediately struck Sharon as a very strange, he pulls one
of the hundred dollar bills out of the stack and he gives it to her. He says, go buy yourself
something nice. Gerald had never done anything like that before. Not once in their marriage.
Was it to silence?
Then he went to take a shower. And that's when Sharon's suspicion shifted in a much different
direction. Because Gerald never showered when he came home from gambling. He went straight to bed
because he was tired. He always went straight to bed. The shower felt like something was being
washed off. Evidence. And she was brave because she didn't let it go. She confronted him. But not
because she thought he killed anyone.
No, she thought he was cheating. She thought he had been with another woman. And to be fair,
that is the most logical explanation in that moment that she could have had. He'd been out
all night. He's acting strange. Now he's scrubbing himself clean before he even sat down. Gerald's
reaction was immediate and it was violent. He didn't want to be questioned. He grabbed her
and he threw her against the wall. And he denied it. He insisted he was not with anyone. And she
needed to stop questioning him.
And then as he got him to bed for the nap, he actually turned to her. And he admitted what he
had been doing. Yeah, he wasn't on a winning streak. But he felt like he hit the jackpot when
he spotted Shannon. And before I tell you what Gerald told his wife, you have to understand
who this man is. Gerald Lee Powers was 42 years old in April of 1996. He worked in construction.
He gambled.
He'd been married five times. But on the surface, if you pass this man on the street,
if you saw him at a gas station, or if he even sat down next to you at a blackjack table,
there was nothing about him that would make you move away. He was just a man. Ordinary looking.
Unremarkable. But Gerald Lee Powers had been hurting people for a very long time. And the
people he hurt were almost always women. I walked you through part of his history. Emily. Karen.
Cleo. Three women across two states. Spanning five years before he finally saw the inside of a
prison. But what I want to talk about now is what came afterward. Because a man who does those kind
of things doesn't just come out of prison reformed. He comes out practiced. And there Shannon was,
in a driveway on Gerald Street. The same name as the man who took her. It's horrifically ironic.
Shaq here. What's it like to buy a car from Carvana 100% online and get it delivered to your door?
Let me tell you. Your car is here, Mr. Shaq. Thank you, Mr. Carvana guy. Can't wait to take it for a
spin. Only the best for you, Mr. Shaq. Hey, have you always been so big, tall, and handsome? Not
always. I was 6'10 once. Seven days to love it or return it, Mr. Shaq. Not that I would. You never
do. No, I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our
7-star car at carvana.com.
This episode is brought to you by TXU Energy. If you're looking for a better way to save on
electricity, both night and day, look no further than TXU Energy Free Nights in Cool Summer. It
gives you free energy all night, every night, all year long. Plus a 25% bonus toward your daytime
use every summer. It's the only plan that lets you use free energy to get more savings. So while
nights are always free, summer days are now always discounted. With savings like that,
you'll never look at a free night's plan the same way again. Learn more at TXU.com.
Rep number 1-0-0-0-4.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Shannon Marie Baldridge disappeared from her former father-in-law’s driveway in Memphis on April 19, 1996, after being followed by a man in a red baseball cap who had been a known predator with a pattern of violence.
The man, Gerald Lee Powers, had a history of targeting women, including previous crimes in Tennessee and Mississippi, and was released from prison in 1991 with no significant punishment for his violent behavior.
Surveillance footage from the casino showed Shannon winning and leaving with $5,100, but no signs of conflict or Robert Sanderson, her husband, being present.
A key tip from Sharon Powers, Gerald’s wife, described the same red baseball cap, blue jeans, and maroon Chevrolet Beretta, matching witness accounts, but was dismissed due to lack of follow-up.
Shannon’s body was found in a rural storage shed, with clear signs of violent assault and blunt force trauma, confirmed by dental analysis and forensic examination.
Robert Sanderson and Brett Muskamp were ruled out as suspects due to alibis and lack of physical evidence, despite their personal connections to Shannon.
Shannon’s sister later died of a broken heart, and her children were left emotionally traumatized by the loss of their mother.
The case highlights systemic failure in law enforcement to investigate domestic threats and suspicious behavior, especially when a tip is dismissed due to perceived domestic disputes.
Summary:
Shannon Marie Baldridge, a mother of three, vanished on April 19, 1996, from her former father-in-law’s driveway in Memphis after being followed by a man in a red baseball cap. The incident occurred after she had gambled at Sam’s Town Casino in Tunica, where she won $5,100 and was escorted out by security. Surveillance footage confirmed her presence but showed no signs of foul play or her husband, Robert Sanderson.
A tip from Gerald Lee Powers’ wife, Sharon, described the same man and vehicle as witnesses, but authorities dismissed it as a domestic dispute. Robert, who had a substantial business connection to security, was a primary suspect but lacked physical evidence. Other suspects, including Shannon’s ex-husband and ex-boyfriend Brett Muskamp, were eliminated by alibis and lack of ties.
Shannon’s body was later found in a rural shed, showing signs of severe blunt force trauma and a gunshot wound, confirmed by dental analysis. The case exposed critical failures in investigative practices—particularly the dismissal of credible tips and the lack of attention to patterns of predatory behavior. Shannon’s family suffered deep emotional trauma, and her sister died shortly after, underscoring the devastating impact of unresolved violence.
The man responsible, Gerald Lee Powers, had a detailed history of assaulting women, and his return to the same neighborhood and behavior patterns confirmed his identity as a repeat offender. The case remains a powerful example of how domestic violence, hidden patterns, and institutional negligence can lead to tragic outcomes.
FAQs
Shannon disappeared from her former father-in-law's driveway after being followed by a man in a red baseball cap. She was abducted, dragged, and murdered, with her body later found in a storage shed in rural Mississippi.
The man in the red baseball cap was Gerald Lee Powers, a serial offender with a history of targeting women. He abducted Shannon, dragged her, and killed her with blunt force trauma and a gunshot wound.
Neighbors reported hearing noises and seeing a man in a red baseball cap near Shannon’s driveway. Her car was found there with the door open, and two metal buttons and a pink fingernail were discovered on the ground.
Robert was a suspect due to his alibi gaps and refusal to provide a photo of Shannon, but no evidence linked him to the crime. Surveillance footage showed no signs of him at the casino or in the driveway.
Sharon reported her husband, Gerald Lee Powers, was at the casino wearing a red baseball cap and driving a maroon Beretta—details matching the witnesses. Her tip was ignored, but it later proved crucial in identifying the perpetrator.
Forensic odontologists matched dental impressions from the remains to dental records from Shannon’s 1994 x-rays, confirming her identity. The clothing and injuries matched descriptions from her final night.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.