Go back

Overtime – Episode #748: Ali Vitali, Coleman Hughes

9m 11s

Overtime – Episode #748: Ali Vitali, Coleman Hughes

The podcast features a lively debate on political and social issues, focusing on Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute all death sentences in California, framed as a strategic move to bolster his image among left-leaning voters. The panel critiques the optics of governing in a far-left city like San Francisco, suggesting that such policies alienate moderates and reflect a deeper disconnection from practical governance. Jay-Z’s potential Super Bowl halftime performance is welcomed with cautious optimism, emphasizing the need for seriousness in such a high-profile role. A key theme is skepticism toward far-left ideologies, particularly socialism, which is described as a harmful ideology with historical failures, especially in economic policy. The discussion turns to public education, highlighting poor outcomes in underfunded or poorly managed schools, such as the one in Brooklyn where Senator Pauline Hanson’s daughter attended. The panel argues that the real issue is not lack of funding but union power that protects underperforming teachers and schools, making it difficult to implement accountability. They stress that teacher unions, while protective of educators, have grown out of control and hinder educational quality. The conversation concludes by noting the absence of serious federal education reform, with recent political debates focused instead on healthcare policies like Medicare for All. The panel underscores the importance of education reform and calls for systemic change, challenging the status quo of union dominance and ideological extremism.

Transcription

1710 Words, 9313 Characters

English
Welcome to an HBO podcast from the HBO late-night series Real Time with Bill Maugh. All right, she is MS now senior capitol reporter and the host of Way To Early, Ali Vitale. And he's the host of the conversations with Coleman podcast and the creativity of the free press. Coleman Hughes. Okay. Thank you. All right. Here are the questions from the people. Gavin Newsom has commuted every death sentence in California to life without parole. I heard that. Why do you think Newsom made this decision? Well, I mean, please, should I go? I mean, he was locked out of the news cycle. He wants to be one of the presidential contenders. He wants to have some credibility with a left cause. And so, you know, good timing. I mean, it doesn't hurt anything. I mean, we were not going to put these people to death anyway. I mean, some of them have been on death row for 20 years. So, I mean, that, but as I said in the show, I think the Tuesday results are not good for him. Because it shows that it is the moderates that the party is going to get behind if they know what they're doing. And he's going, I mean, I like Alvin a lot. And I think he's one of the probably the most talented politician they have in the party. But, I mean, California is a far left place. And he's, his record in California is really tough to stand by. I mean, if you ask for a Republican, like, what's the one thing you don't want to happen to your city in a red state? They're going to tell you San Francisco, right? And so, to preside over that, it's just at minimum, it's bad optics. And that's why you look at someone like John Asaf, or Dr. Shapiro. And you think this is the direction the party should go. And San Francisco, which was always stories we heard about San Francisco for years when it was governed by the far left. Then they got this new mayor, Laurie Daniel Laurie, changed everything back to, oh, normal. You know, let's arrest criminals, not let people like sleep on everything, and people love them. And so, San Francisco, Coleman has a wrap of yourself. What do you think of Jay-Z being the Super Bowl halftime show? I mean, what can you say is Jay-Z. I mean, he's not exactly in his prime anymore, but I'm going to tune in. (laughter and applause) Well, you looked like he was shocked that he said not in his prime. Well, I mean, I don't know, I still think it's exciting. We're like also of the age where the Super Bowl halftime shows are supposed to be for us. I just hope he takes it seriously, because he is the man who once said, "My presence is a gift." I hope he really brings the heat. Who's it beyond say cameo? Yes. That'll be great. One of the panel's thoughts on Nithia Raman, who was endorsed by the DSA being the next. Yes, we have a new mayor here in LA. (applause) We got two choices in LA. Yeah. Left or further left? DC-2, it's the same way there. I don't know, I mean. Look, my issues are high rents and crime. Socialists don't tend to be good on those issues. Because they institute policies like rent control, which sound good, and then end up increasing the rents in the long run. And we got 100 years of data on socialism. It's not good for the economy. It's not a new idea. Young people think it's this cool new idea. What we've been doing isn't working. Let's try this new thing, socialism. Hate to break it to you. Karl Marx wrote Das Kapital in like 1860. No. 1848. (applause) No, and again, socialism, we already have a lot of socialism, and a lot of it is appropriate. That's not what these people are selling, these far-left people. They like to use that term socialism. Socialism is Medicare, social security. It's the Marine Corps. I mean, it's anything the government does and the private sector doesn't. You just read what they say in their manifesto. They want the government to take over everything. That is a prescription for failure. And to me, this is an indictment of our educational system. I just read your great last column on this. (applause) With Paul Hadid-Jones sending a daughter to that school. I mean, the reason why they don't know that socialism didn't work in the past to this degree, or communism, is because nobody taught them in school. And they think they just were just delivered down here on Earth. There was no past. They're worried about the future, who doesn't. I don't blame them. But you have to know where you were. There's no, you are here sign that they're given. Right. Like, I felt I knew where I was on the planet when I was in school. Okay, you're in the United States. There's other countries. This is how many people there are in the world. You know, I could place myself. I don't think they know, and they don't care. I mean, a lot of kids go to underperforming public schools, which is our euphemism for government-funded day care centers with occasional school-like activities. And where, you know, Nicole Hannah Jones wrote this piece about Senator Daughter to one of the most struggling underperforming schools in Brooklyn. As a noble gesture, she could have sent her to a rich school. She has the money, but she wanted to do that. Noble to an ideal, a disservice to her daughter. To her daughter, correct. But it ended up being a public service by her publishing the results of that experiment, which were terrible. It's not just like she got a bad education. She got no education. I mean, she had years where she was asking for homework, and they just weren't giving it to her. Well, and just the quotes that I read in your piece from her, I mean, just running around like wild banshees in the cafeteria. Yeah. No adult supervision. Or they're sitting there just watching it. It was like Lord of the Flies. Right. It was worse than even I am. I knew they weren't learning anything. But they're just, you know, you said, it's like a daycare center and not a good one. Yeah. And I think people on the left want to blame funding, because that's the easy issue. But the truth is, this school is well funded. You know, it's 50,000 per pupil at this school. The problem is in the funding. It's that you can't fire anyone bad. Yes. And that's the essence of your article. And I've been saying it for years. The problem is, the union, the teacher's union is too powerful. We've seen it in results in states where the union is less powerful. The schools do better. I call it the chalkboard mafia. Yeah. The problem, the unions protect bad schools and bad teachers and the party protects the union. It's almost impossible in a lot of these cities to fire a teacher. I mean, literally like you could sell drugs to a kid and it's got to be two offenses before we get. It wasn't that long ago that the unions lobbied for a law in New York state to ban even collecting data that you would use to assess which teachers are better than others. You can't even get the data, right? So obviously the teachers unions serve the teachers. They don't serve the students. And if you're a Democrat or any American that's serious about public school reform, you have to challenge the teachers union period. And I think in this school, (applause) where they were learning nothing with no supervision and absentee, principles and teachers, I think spending $50,000 per year to a student, it's not money. That's what you always hear from the left. Oh, it's underfunded. It's not the funding. The funding isn't the issue. And. No, it hasn't been a very. I think this is the kind of thing I will never hear on MSNOW. I think you hear a lot of perspectives on MSNOW. I don't think I ever hear that one. As the person who has interviewed everyone from Speaker Johnson to prominent Democrats, I can promise you there's a range of perspective. But I do think that the other piece of this, right, is that you're clearly so steeped in this policy conversation and debate. This is not where Washington's focus is. I mean, when has there last been a truly serious conversation about tackling education in a real way from a federal perspective? I mean, W. Bush, right? I mean, that's not where this party is going. The last presidential election for Democrats, the biggest debate was around what healthcare should look like. Is it a public option or Medicare for all? I imagine it's going to look a little bit similar in the coming weeks, months, years. And so it's a crucially important issue. I myself think that unions help to protect teachers. And as someone with many teachers in my family, they have benefited from that. Me too. Right? Yeah, I agree. My sister is a teacher. Oh, absolutely. And there's a lot of great teachers. It's a noble profession. But teachers unions also-- It's out of hand. Sometimes they prevent the best teachers from being awarded for being the best. So for instance, in Wisconsin, they passed Act 10 in 2011, where they had this novel idea, which is we should pay the best teachers more. And what happened when you incentivize quality? The teachers got better. They attracted better teachers. And the students did better. Right? Let's make it work just a little bit more how other jobs work. Right? Yeah. Okay. All right. Thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen. We'll see you next week. Catch all new episodes of Real Time with Bill Maher every Friday night at 10. Or watch him anytime on HBO on demand. For more information, log on to HBO.com.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Gavin Newsom’s commutation of all death sentences in California to life without parole is seen as a strategic move to enhance his political credibility with left-wing audiences ahead of a potential presidential run.
  2. The decision faces criticism for poor optics in a far-left environment like San Francisco, where governing by progressive ideals has led to backlash from moderates and concerns about practical governance.
  3. Jay-Z’s potential performance at the Super Bowl halftime show is viewed with cautious optimism, emphasizing the need for him to take the role seriously given his past statements about influence.
  4. The panel expresses skepticism about far-left political movements endorsing figures like Nithia Raman, arguing that socialist ideology often leads to policies like rent control that worsen long-term economic outcomes.
  5. A central argument is that socialism has failed historically, with Karl Marx’s writings from the 1840s showing it is not a new idea, and modern far-left policies are actually more about centralized control than social welfare.
  6. The discussion highlights how underperforming public schools, like the one in Brooklyn where Senator Pauline Hanson’s daughter attended, show systemic failures due to poor management and union protections, not underfunding.
  7. Critics argue that teacher unions are overly powerful, protecting low-performing teachers and schools, and that federal policy has largely ignored education reform despite its importance.
  8. While unions are acknowledged as providing some protections for educators, the panel contends that their current influence undermines accountability and student outcomes in public schools.

Summary:

The podcast features a lively debate on political and social issues, focusing on Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute all death sentences in California, framed as a strategic move to bolster his image among left-leaning voters. The panel critiques the optics of governing in a far-left city like San Francisco, suggesting that such policies alienate moderates and reflect a deeper disconnection from practical governance. Jay-Z’s potential Super Bowl halftime performance is welcomed with cautious optimism, emphasizing the need for seriousness in such a high-profile role.

A key theme is skepticism toward far-left ideologies, particularly socialism, which is described as a harmful ideology with historical failures, especially in economic policy. The discussion turns to public education, highlighting poor outcomes in underfunded or poorly managed schools, such as the one in Brooklyn where Senator Pauline Hanson’s daughter attended. The panel argues that the real issue is not lack of funding but union power that protects underperforming teachers and schools, making it difficult to implement accountability.

They stress that teacher unions, while protective of educators, have grown out of control and hinder educational quality. The conversation concludes by noting the absence of serious federal education reform, with recent political debates focused instead on healthcare policies like Medicare for All. The panel underscores the importance of education reform and calls for systemic change, challenging the status quo of union dominance and ideological extremism.

FAQs

Newsom's decision may be partly strategic to boost his political credibility with left-leaning audiences and align with progressive values. Many of the inmates had been on death row for decades, and the policy reflects a broader shift away from capital punishment, though it has drawn criticism for poor optics in a far-left political environment.

He acknowledges Jay-Z is not in his prime but believes the performance could still be exciting and impactful. He hopes Jay-Z takes the show seriously, especially given his past statement that 'my presence is a gift,' and that he brings the energy fans expect.

Coleman expresses concern that far-left policies, such as aggressive rent control, may worsen housing affordability and crime. He argues that past economic data shows socialism hasn't worked well in practice, and that these policies often lead to long-term economic harm.

He argues that socialism is often misrepresented by far-left groups, who advocate for government control over nearly all aspects of life. He notes that real socialism includes things like Medicare and Social Security, but not the full government takeover that these movements propose.

He criticizes underperforming public schools as being more like daycare centers than learning environments, citing lack of supervision, no homework, and poor student outcomes. He argues the real issue isn't underfunding but teacher union power and resistance to accountability.

He claims teacher unions protect underperforming teachers and schools, making it nearly impossible to fire ineffective staff. He points to cases like New York where unions blocked data collection on teacher performance, and says this harms student outcomes.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.