Nikita Kucherov's Trade Request Has Left Us Stunned
from What Chaos!
16m 12s
Nikita Kutra’s sudden request to trade on October 30th—despite the Tampa Bay Lightning’s strong record and his own franchise points record—has sparked widespread surprise and analysis. The move defies conventional logic, as Kutra lacks final say in his destination and could weaken the Lightning’s team, which is on pace to win its division. While a $20 million, six-year contract is reported, the reasons behind the trade remain unclear, with speculation pointing to personal dissatisfaction or financial incentives. Potential destinations include Montreal, Chicago, Detroit, and New York, each with different strategic fits and financial capabilities. Montreal and Chicago are seen as ideal for offensive development, while Detroit’s situation is viewed as ironic due to their current roster struggles. The trade raises concerns about long-term team stability, especially as Kutra will be 34 next year and likely decline in performance. Additionally, the lack of transparency about his motivations, preferred teams, or terms adds to the mystery. The situation is considered one of the most unpredictable in recent NHL history, with fans and analysts left questioning what drives such a sudden move from a high-achieving, high-impact player.
If Nikita Kutra I've wanted to say, I'm not going to resign after this season, that's fine,
but it's the requesting a trade on October 30th that is the most surprising to me.
Pete, we might be getting a run of MVP's just getting traded every year. Also,
I'm seeing the R, I'm in an Airbnb. This stuff isn't mine. It's a really pervy Airbnb.
But the MVP of two years ago was traded, Connor Halibuk, the MVP of last year. Now it seems
might get traded, and let's be real. In a couple of years, there's an MVP that might be relocating,
but we'll talk about that later. I would say out of nowhere, but out of Jeff Merrick a couple of
months ago, apparently. Yeah, at least Jeff Merrick said July 1st. I don't think that
anybody has participated in Nikita Kutra requesting a trade on October 30th of all things.
Like the Tampa Bay Lightning are two points out. I think two points out of the Atlantic lead.
This is the part that makes so little sense to me. If Nikita Kutra I've wanted to say,
I'm not going to resign after this season, that's fine, but it's the requesting a trade
on October 30th. That is the most surprising to me. So the Lightning have the best record in the
Atlantic. They have the second best record in the Eastern Conference, and they have the third best
record in the league, which is going to complicate the hell out of this. But yeah, Elliot Friedman
reporting today and other people jumping out of it as well, that the Lightning and Dan Milstein
have met and talked about it. And not only is Nikita Kutra of not resigning, he wants out and
will do a couple of minutes on like where we think he goes, but there's such a big what the hell
element to this. We've talked about the state income tax thing. You make more money if you play
in Florida. I know that the Lightning have a history of taking their stars to the wood shed or
whatever it may be at the negotiating table. Stephen Stamcoes ran away. Stephen Stamcoes almost
ran away before eventually doing it, but like guys have resigned after being like, damn, that was
a real doozy. You should probably take care of me better. And who knows if it's just a money thing
or if it's a relationship thing, but he's told the team and he's told players like everyone on
the Lightning now knows that he doesn't want to be there. I'm astonished by this because
that place should be perfect for him. Yeah, I mean, I saw in Elliot's report that he's apparently
asking for six years, $20 million annually. So I mean, money wise, if Tampa doesn't want to pay
that and that's what pushes him and says, all right, well, I'm not going to sign trade me, but like
again, it's the trade me element. If they're not going to pay you $20 million, why not ride out
where your stuff already is and you're not paying the income tax and you've got a chance to compete
and he doesn't even have full no move protection. So he doesn't have final say on it one where
he gets to go. He gets to say, here are my 10 teams that I'm willing to accept a trade to,
but he doesn't ultimately get the final say on where he ends up going. So that's really surprising
to me. And if he gets traded wherever he's going to end up, he weakens that team. He's on a
worse team than he would have been on if he just waited until free agency and signed with them.
I don't know how the trade thing works because I just mentioned that Lightning have the
third best record in the entire NHL. They're on pace to win their division. They're on pace to
be the second best team in the Eastern Conference, which that's the Lightning kind of every year.
They're always in that mix. There are there are a few teams that have the dough to just add
Nikita Kutraov straight up with no retention. And then there's a few more Boston Winnipeg whatever
that you could add in if they're adding him with half retention. But why would the Lightning?
Like the Lightning aren't going to retain $4.75 million to trade Nikita Kutraov this year
when they're one of the best teams in the NHL. I don't I don't see how a trade it will. I'm sure,
but like I don't see how a trade happens. Yeah, no, I'm saying maybe they do if it maximizes the
value of what they get in return, especially beyond this season. Like I could see if they get a
really good young-ish player who's, you know, who's making, I don't know, six, seven million dollars,
I could see them willing, be willing to eat money in order to kind of gain that security and
maximize the value of the trade. I don't know. I find it very funny though that Kutraov set the
franchise points record. And then immediately was like, all right, fuck you, Bozoz, I'm out of here.
Gas up the bird. Exactly. I don't know. I have a list. I wrote down a list of teams that I would be
very, very intrigued by. And I think that would make a lot of sense. And you mentioned Jeff
Merrick earlier. He's been banging on the Montreal drum for quite a long time. And it makes so much
sense when you consider that they've been going for a big fish offensive winger. And they've struck
out at several different junctures with Matthew Nies, then with Kriel Marchenko. I mean, if you strike
out on those two and then hit a home run before you strike out, third strike with Kutraov,
I think you consider yourself a huge winger. Obviously, it obviously depends on what you have to
give up for him. Montreal would be a really exciting one. How about the Chicago Blackhawks, man?
Like if you put Kutraov on Bidard's wing and let them cook for the next six plus years,
I think that that would be one happy Connor Bidard that, you know, then can maybe brush off a
little bit of frustration and maybe get this team in playoff contention. But he trading cancer off
to do it. That's the old Bert and Bernie trading the paperclip so you can get a soap dish for the
rubber duckie when your boy traded as rubber duckie to get you a paperclip holder. Yeah, but I
mean, I really like cancer off, but we're talking about Nikita Kutraov, man, if you get an extension
in hand and you got the next six years of Bidard and Kutraov instead of Bidard and essentially a
scratch ticket again, I really like cancer off, but there's a lot of reason to do it and push this
thing forward if you're Chicago. And there's a lot of reason for Tampa to be like, well, okay,
this is a really nice young piece that would make sense for us to maybe invest in.
I'm not kicking it out of bed. Yeah, I mean, if I'm Chicago though, my favorite stat, guys,
I want Kutraov just being added. And that would mean waiting till free agency or trying to just,
or just like, like, fuck those picks. Like every year, well, here's a million draft picks. And
you know what, we might stink. These might be good draft picks, but we just need more guys on our
team. I love, I would love, I saw you tweet about Kutraov for Chicago when I was like, oh,
baby, that would be incredible. Has anyone talked about the Red Wings?
Yeah, I just talked about it for CBS. The only thing about the Red Wings, I think it would be a
really interesting premise for two teams with, I don't know how disgruntled I want to call
Nikita Kutraov. I don't think he feels things exactly disgruntled would require an emotion.
That's a feeling. But these two, these two teams looking each other in the face and saying,
we've both got a problem on our hands. What do we do here to maybe solve it for one another?
That would be fascinating. But tell me, tell me the reason outside of just the extension,
why Nikita Kutraov would go, yeah, Detroit sounds awesome for the remainder of this year. When,
again, he could have just played this thing out. And if he wanted to go to Detroit for six by 20,
they probably offer him that in the summer. Why, why then go now, not contend this year and then cost
that team assets to go there and be worse off? Here's what I want. I want the Red Wings to announce
they've made a trade for Nikita Kutraov until in Larkin's like, thank God. And the Red Wings
are like, you're still suspended, brother. And he's like, what? I'm not on the team. We traded
Edvinson for him. Get back to sleep or whatever the fuck you're doing. You're not going anywhere
loser. That would be the best thing to show up in his key card not work and be like, no, no, no, no, no, no.
Yeah, you know, your key card still works in Detroit. You are going to rot there and never play
another game again. That would be hilarious. Red Wings was a quick one that comes to, or the first
one that comes to mind because it's just two pieces that you're wondering if they don't want to
be there. Where will they go? Kraken for me, a little selfishly because we just want the Kraken
to get a star player. They've also got a ton of cap space. Wouldn't really make sense for them.
Wouldn't really like, I don't know which team he's ending up on that is going to give him the
situation he's in in Tampa. Like, I think that if Nikita Kutraov is relocating and granted,
this is the reigning MVP, one of the best players ever. But he's going to be 34 next year. So we're
going to start to look at like in year four or five or six of the six year contract that he wants.
He's going to start getting worse. He hasn't started getting worse yet. But like,
is the team that he arrives to? Is that going to be a perennial every year? You think
think they're, they've really got a chance. The cup, he's opening up Pandora's box here.
Yeah, I mean, it's tough to project six years down the road to ask Dylan Larkin and Connor
Hellebuck, who asked out like four years into their contracts.
Five minutes into their contracts. Yeah. Yeah. So you never know, you know, another team
that I would look at and consider the New York Rangers, like they seem to always be in
the market and they lost Panarin last year. Like they're always in the market for those
those big names. And I mean, I mean, if we want to do the Russian thing, like the Russians
seem to like the big market, it oftentimes were like, that's very, very appealing to them.
I don't know if that's the case for Kutrov, but the, the, the Rangers could certainly be
in the market for that splash. They're bleeding money. I don't know if you saw the reports
that like the Rangers are absolutely costing James Dole in a ton of money. And he's, he's
costing himself a ton of money by doing these fishing scams, scams that then has to get
to pay three million dollars to get rings for all of his Nick's employees. So I don't
know, the Rangers are an interesting one. And then the final one that I was thinking about
was Washington, because Washington with Ovechkin out the door throwing, throwing Kutrov in
there. And if they can get him in there this year and make a real run on it, a last kick
of the can for, for Ovechkin in the final year, that could be fun.
That would be amazing. I have no idea how you add even one. I don't know how you could
add a like five pound baby to Washington. Like there is not room for one. It's like when
you're pack, when you're, when we travel and we have to bring all of our equipment. And
in order to check the bag, it's got to be under 50 pounds or something like that. Whatever
the maximum allowable, like people and wingers situation is, they are every day they need
to reway and remeasure to make sure that they're not over. They are so already loaded that
yes, once Ovechkin's gone, but right now, I don't know what they would move out to make
it fit. Obviously, having an earth, you're getting Nikita Kutrov. Another team that I have
written down, hurricanes, I mean, yeah, always, they're always in the mix, always, always,
always, always, always big game hunting teams with the most money million dollars. That's
the thing, the, the thing about the hurricanes that they always get players under market
value and they don't over commit on dollars are they going to be willing to pay Nikita Kutrov
20 million dollars for the next six years. Well, if we're talking about the Canadians
getting in, it's the same exact story. That's how the Canadians have all this money because
they paid Demadov way below what he's worth because they paid Lane Hudson way below what
he's worth. So you do all that so you can then philosophically, I could see Montreal being
more willing to say, okay, we've made all these savings. So then now we can go out and
make this big splash because they've been trying to do that. Like they've been trying
to go out and get a big fish. I think I more see Tulski and the hurricanes and I guess
Tom Dundin being more frugal. I don't, they were going to pay Renton and they were going
to pay Renton and they were going to pay Renton and like 12 million dollars, right?
Back then. Yeah, back then, which is like top of the market and he wants top of the
market. Pop-ish. No, seriously, he was going to, I don't know exactly what they were offering
him, but they traded for him with the intention of we're probably not going to get a discount
and resigning him, but we want the star player. We're going to do it. Like Tulski always,
Tulski just has not gotten and kept the superstar, but his plan has always been good
roster and then add the superstar on top, which right now the Canadians look like they're
they also close to being able to do. They also have a disgruntled occasion, which is an
obvious trade chip in that sort of deal. So I mean, that's fascinating. That would be scary
as hell if he ends up in Carolina. Or how about another one? We talked about Quentin
Byfield potentially being out the door in LA if they're trying to go big game hunting.
Are Temi Pinaran and Nikita Kutrov on the same team? Oops, all really good Russian wings.
And like no centers. Yeah, they would still miss the playoffs. Yeah, I mean, that one is
less exciting to me, but I'm not willing to, I'm not willing to throw it off the table
because I can't predict the LA King's next move. If this happens, if Nikita Kutrov has
moved before Dylan Larkin, I mean, I'm rooting for that. I'm still, I'm still letting the
shock hit me and trying to process it, but I kind of want a million unexpected things
to happen before Dylan Larkin's very like organized high. Can you just please trade me
ever happens? Well, this is as much mystery as we've ever had in one of these like big
blockbuster things this year because with Hellabuck, with Kutrov, with Larkin, with all
these other guys, we knew they at least wanted to go to an American market. We kind of figured
where a couple of them wanted to go with Larkin, the Minnesota and his, his list was made
pretty public at every step of the way. We don't know really why Kutrov wants out of Tampa
right now. We don't know what he wants in terms of his next landing spot. We don't know
who his 10, 10 teams are. There's so much mystery in this one. And it is just making
my brain twist in a million different directions right now. I'm, I'm flabbergasted by this one.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Nikita Kutra's request to trade on October 30th is highly unexpected, especially given the Lightning's strong playoff position and the fact that he previously set a franchise points record.
Kutra has reportedly asked for a six-year, $20 million annual contract, which raises questions about whether financial incentives or personal dissatisfaction are driving his move.
Unlike traditional free agency, Kutra lacks final say in where he goes, meaning he can name preferred teams but not guarantee his destination, making the trade request unusual and potentially unbalanced.
The Lightning’s decision to trade him — despite being one of the top teams in the NHL — seems illogical, as retaining him would strengthen their roster, and trading him could weaken their team without clear financial or strategic gain.
Teams like Montreal, Chicago, Detroit, and New York are seen as potential destinations, with Montreal and Chicago offering strong offensive fits, while Detroit and NY could benefit from a change of pace.
The trade could disrupt long-term team stability, especially as Kutra will be 34 next year and likely decline in performance, raising concerns about roster sustainability.
Financial prudence is a key factor, with teams like the Hurricanes and Canadiens potentially willing to make moves after building cap space or savings through past under-market deals.
The lack of transparency around Kutra’s motivation, preferred teams, or desired terms adds significant uncertainty and makes the situation one of the most unpredictable in recent NHL history.
Summary:
Nikita Kutra’s sudden request to trade on October 30th—despite the Tampa Bay Lightning’s strong record and his own franchise points record—has sparked widespread surprise and analysis. The move defies conventional logic, as Kutra lacks final say in his destination and could weaken the Lightning’s team, which is on pace to win its division. While a $20 million, six-year contract is reported, the reasons behind the trade remain unclear, with speculation pointing to personal dissatisfaction or financial incentives.
Potential destinations include Montreal, Chicago, Detroit, and New York, each with different strategic fits and financial capabilities. Montreal and Chicago are seen as ideal for offensive development, while Detroit’s situation is viewed as ironic due to their current roster struggles. The trade raises concerns about long-term team stability, especially as Kutra will be 34 next year and likely decline in performance.
Additionally, the lack of transparency about his motivations, preferred teams, or terms adds to the mystery. The situation is considered one of the most unpredictable in recent NHL history, with fans and analysts left questioning what drives such a sudden move from a high-achieving, high-impact player.
FAQs
Kutra has expressed a desire to leave, citing financial incentives like lower income taxes in Florida and a lack of long-term team control. He doesn't have final say in the trade, and the Lightning's strong record makes the move counterintuitive.
He is reportedly seeking a six-year, $20 million annual contract, which would significantly impact the Lightning's cap space and roster strategy.
The Lightning might trade him to acquire a young, affordable player or to gain long-term value, especially if the return would strengthen their future roster or cap flexibility.
Teams like Montreal, Chicago, Detroit, New York Rangers, Washington, and Carolina are mentioned as potential destinations, with Montreal and Chicago seen as strong fits due to offensive needs.
No, he does not have full no-move protection, meaning he cannot guarantee a final say in where he ends up after a trade, which adds uncertainty to the situation.
The reasons are likely a mix of financial incentives—such as avoiding Florida income tax—and personal or relationship factors, though the exact motivations remain unclear.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.