Go back

NHL Salary Cap Smoothing | PuckPedia Cap Central November 17, 2026

from The PuckPedia Hockey Show

32m 41s

NHL Salary Cap Smoothing | PuckPedia Cap Central November 17, 2026

The NHL is considering salary cap smoothing—raising the cap this year and suppressing it next year—but Keith Kaffin argues this is artificial and undermines the true value of player contracts, since players already receive 50% of revenue with a top-up at season's end. He believes the cap should reflect actual revenues, not projections, and that a higher cap—like 130 million—is needed to allow teams to compete in free agency and maintain fan interest. Teams are now signing entry-level players earlier to lock in value before rising caps make future deals more expensive, shifting from past strategies of delaying contracts. Injuries complicate cap management, forcing teams to make difficult in-season moves, such as moving players to season-ending LTIR or recalling injured players, often resulting in inefficient cap space usage. The "10-to-see" rule further reduces player leverage by barring offer sheet eligibility for players who don’t play 10 NHL games, leaving them with fewer negotiation tools. Teams like the Canadiens and Devils face severe cap constraints due to injuries and bonuses, pushing them to make reactive, high-stakes decisions. Overall, the cap system is evolving, with stakeholders advocating for revenue-based projections and more balanced, transparent structures to fairly reflect player and team value.

Transcription

7564 Words, 38878 Characters

English
two three four, let me tell you pop up media stats contracts and capsits are dead by you. One stop shop boy your hockey information. It's a hockey sensation. So look all, look all, look all. If you give a pack, I'm going to pop media come. Welcome to another edition of pop media cap central. It is Tuesday, November 17th. I'm your host Keith Kaffin on alongside Hart, Levine Hart, how are we doing on this marvelous Tuesday? I'm doing great. Yeah, how about yourself? Good. The weather's nice out. You know, it was getting a little cold out there, but now in Jersey, we got maybe a little bit of a fall kind of weather today like high 50s, low 60s, suns out. So I'll take that all day. Pretty slow week on the NHL transactions front though I will say, but there's no shortage of storylines across the national hockey league this year. And before we get into it today, just wanted to say today shows brought to you by our presenting sponsor hard rock bet Ontario's newest sports book app. That's hard rock bet. Now live in Ontario, roll with us. Let's get into it though, because I think it was last week or even maybe a week and a half ago, Elliott Friedman had brought up this whole concept on salary cap smoothing and you had gone deep into it on the puck drop this week. You know, if you're not subscribed to the puck drop, puck pd is newsletter that comes out weekly 7 a.m. Eastern in your inbox is on Saturday mornings get in there. But heart, you have some thoughts on this because and I think the what there's a Alan Walsh always talks about how he thinks that the salary cap should be a lot higher than it is and they're they're artificially suppressing it. But essentially this concept is if the salary cap is projected to be 113.5 next season and then 127.5 the season after the logic is maybe they bump it up a little higher this year, a couple million. So let's say it goes to 115.5 next year, but then they suppress it the following year by that two million. So instead of 127.5 it be 125.5. But you're not a big fan of this rule, this thought process. So just talk to us about maybe why the NHLs discussing it and then your take on it. Well, you know, on this topic, I agree with Alan Walsh for the most part which, you know, make sure we clip that. But, you know, I think the salary cap should be what the formula in the CBA, you know, says it should be call me old fashioned, but like that we just follow the rules. And, you know, we came out of this black cap era and I get it. It made sense to project what the cap should be for three years out. But and that is helpful for teams to like plan forward. I like projecting it out a few years in advance. If you think back, it used to be like at the end of June, like a day or two before July 1st, they would announce the new cap. I think that's kind of that's too late. That's silly. But, you know, by projecting it out three years out, we've been sort of stuck or tied to that number. And it's all sort of irrelevant in terms of like what the players get paid because the players are always getting 50% of revenue. That's the first thing I get. I'll keep repeating that the players are always getting 50%. So if the cap is too low based on revenues, which is what's happened in the last two years, the players still got 50% of revenue. And what happened is at the end of the season, they got a top up on their paycheck. So, you know, if the player made a million dollars on their contract, they got an extra $50,000 check at the end of the year because it was about an average of 5% top up the last two seasons. So, you know, that that works like the players get there. But when you think about what's the impact that I'm having a cap that's lower than it should be, that means less teams can be active in free agents, right? Like contracts stay a little bit lower. Teams are less able to make moves. And that's all the stuff that, you know, that drives fan interest, certainly drives interest on the site. I'm not going to pretend that I'm completely on bias. But I think that's interesting. And it gives teams flexibility to make some moves, especially when the seller cap should be where the revenues dictate that they should be. So next season's cap should never be a hundred and thirteen point five. The race on the formula, it should be significantly more. If they're going to Elliot's report and I've also heard that from people at the meeting that, you know, they're talking that it's going to be a hundred and fifteen point five instead. That's a good step. My understanding is that's still lower than what the actual revenues say that it should be. But at least that's the step in the right direction. But then to take the following season and now deduct two million off of what that projection originally was of one twenty seven and a half and bring it down to one twenty five and a half, my question is why? Like if the if the revenues are going to be at a spot where the the following your cap should be like one hundred and twenty seven and a half or one hundred and thirty million, that's where the cap should be. Like there is concern if you have a massive jump. Like yes, all the players in that free agent class kind of hit the lottery at the expense of everyone else. But if this isn't just a one time thing if we are going to get to where the cap should be, let's just let it roll. Like get the cap up to start where it should be in sub suppressing the cap number. Yeah, it's just artificial, right? Like at the end of the day, you said players were getting fifty percent of revenue regardless. So why make it purposely lower knowing you're going to have to pay them a premium at the end of the season as opposed to letting it be what it should be for all intents and purposes. And if it's somehow for whatever reason they overshot it, like then they have the escrow, right? And they pay it, they pay it back. Yeah. And that's it. You mentioned escrow, which you know, this isn't an issue that's like all teams on one side, all agents on the other. It is kind of mixed. Like this is like an issue that's not just kind of on your partisan divide because there are players that hate escrow. And so again, because players have to get fifty percent of revenue, if the seller cap is set higher at a place where, you know, it's kind of right where the revenue is projected to be, then there would need to be a little bit of escrow held back to make sure that the players actually get the fifty percent. They don't get more. And so, but I'm not talking like going back to where we had ten twenty percent escrow because of course nobody wants to get a paycheck and then see that ten or twenty percent was taken off. But to have a paycheck where maybe five percent's taken off, six percent's taken off for a much higher cap where the contract's going to be a lot higher. And then at the end of the year you get all or most of that back. Like that should be a better system. And, you know, this, but it is like a personal preference saying this like there's a lot of people that, you know, they get a paycheck, they have taxes withheld. And it's like, are you the type of person that would rather get a refund at the end of the year when you file your taxes or would you rather not give the government your money all year, keep it for yourself and then owe them a little bit at the end of the year. Like, I'm that way. I don't, I don't want people having my money if they're not entitled to it. And at the end, I owe them a little bit because of that. That's fine. I'll save put some aside and plan that I might owe and then pay. And so like there are some players and agents and we put a bunch of quotes in the, in the piece in, in our newsletter. Like there are some agents that think that are saying, hey, our players don't want escrow. They would actually rather like not have to be responsible and get a refund or a premium top up at the end of the year. Again, I can respect that some people approach that way. I just think that a much higher cap, which would mean that you knew a little bit of escrow would be better for the game. Yeah, I think it mostly is a byproduct of some of these teams that aren't going to be cap ceiling teams that have these internal budgets and are not going to be able to spend to the cap like I feel like it would benefit them a little bit to not have these massive jumps. And then you got to go to ownership and they're not going to give the green light to spend where they need to spend. So maybe that's part of it too. Like that's why maybe some certain teams would be interested in, but to your point, it's not like a bipartisan split. There's like very much mixed opinions on this. Some people are all for us. Some people are strongly against it. And so we'll see how it plays out. Right? Like we don't know what the situation is going to be. Like you said, it probably at least goes up to 115.5 for next season. But we'll see if they bring it back down because even at that point, like the smoothing effect, for example, it could be closer to like one 30 135 million what it should be. So like if it goes down a couple million from that, it's not going to be one 25.5. It's going to be closer to one 30 one 32 exactly. And so it's part of the piece I pulled a bunch of agents and for an office people. And I said one of the questions was, what do you think the cap will be? And honestly, the most common answer was, well, if Gary says it's going to be 115 and a half next year and 125 and a half year after that sort of will be because he's only saying, if he's saying that, that's what it'll be. And he'll make sure that that happens. And he was going to prove in that, you know, if he says it, you could take that to the bank. So, but you know, again, I think I've been saying for this show and anyone that would listen for a year, that one 13 and a half is way too low for next year. So I'll take the one 15 and a half, even though I saw like that's too low. But then I'm going to start the campaign that you want 25 and a half will be way too low. Because if you think about smoothing, so we're going to go from 104 this year to one 15 and a half, right? So like 11 and a half million increase. And then we're going to go to one 25 and a half year after. So just a 10 million increase. So like that's a smaller increase. So like we could so go to 127 and a half or 129 or something. And it's not like that outrageous to have the same roughly the same amount in a year over years and increase. And again, let's get to where the cap should be. And then if revenue slow down and we get to where, you know, we have a subsequent season where the cap doesn't rise as much. Hey, that's the cost of doing business. And we've seen that teams can manage that. We did like five, six years of a flat cap. Yeah. And the NBA is the prime example of what goes wrong when you just have a massive jump and you start giving role players more money than the NHL's biggest superstars you're making at the time. So we'll see how it all plays out. It's interesting and nothing set and stone at this point. Yeah. And I should just mention because there was one really interesting suggestion from an agent. So one of the people that are kind of against my perspective is that if you have big jumps like in each year, you're rewarding the players that are free agents that year and especially at the top of the class. And as we know, the limit for a player is 20% of the cap, right? So if the higher the cap jumps, these superstar players. So like in, you know, this summer would be Nikita Kutraov, this following summer would be like awesome Matthews, economic David, you know, if the cap jumped significantly and those players take 20%, you know, that's way more than guys that are closer to 20% now. And so one agent, and I'm again, I was surprised to hear this as an agent perspective. He said, well, if we're going to have a massive jump, then maybe a fair thing is to just Temporary lower the toilet. 20% you know 18% or 16% or something so that you don't have like one or two or three guys like taking so much of this Increased that it actually will get spread amongst the players because again That's the argument with getting everyone getting a 5% premium is that's that's kind of like a socialist approach Everyone is sharing it right and so if you don't want to have like a couple big winners I can get on board with that. Let's raise the cap to 130 million and you know Maybe for that year though. It's an 18% limit like I think that makes sense But I was actually really surprised I thought it was no worthy of that suggestion came from an agent that is and just you know For reference to like no player has really taken a 20% like Hail McCarr came the closest but he didn't even take the full 20% And because he signed a year early He's really going to be you know closer to like 19 18% on that cap ceiling when the contract kicks in So we'll see how it plays out. It's interesting gives us something to talk about and it is a it's a big talking point It's as the kind of GM's try to plan for next season and the seasons thereafter like it is challenging if they don't know exactly what the number is going to be here Let's shift gears a little bit hard talking about GM You want to talk about this entry level slide concept, right? And originally over the last like five to ten years There's very much the teams were hoping to slide the player on their entry level as much as possible Because then they'd have them you know Before their prime more they wouldn't have to pay them in their early years 18 19 20 years old They can slide it as they're in juniors and not in the NHL on the roster But now you think that the kind of opinion and the thought process has shifted to where teams want to get those guys signed and and the entry level started earlier on just talk those about like what you think is driving that shift from the team side Yeah, so you know, just sort of refresher players that are on the entry level deals if they're under certain age basically under 20 And they don't play 10 NHL games the contract slides meaning that season doesn't count and it moves forward for Under three or entry level deal. It would still be three years starting the following season and so if you think of like back traditionally Teams wanted the contracts to slide because they kept the players on these cheap entry level deals for longer and agents and the players wanted it to not slide And so there would always be that argument like get them the NHL games not get them the NHL games There used to be a lot of focus on the players that are gonna cross that cross that 10 game threshold that were side eligible And I just this came up because we were you know, we're chatting with the puck community team about There was a bunch of players that crossed the 10 game threshold and it wasn't even discussed like it didn't seem to be an issue Right so this year, you know, it's Albert Smith's Eklin, Stanburg, McKenna, Bjork all those players cross 10 games their contracts now do not slide A player was like a lot right in like the first year after being drafted exactly a player like Clevver played four games But then was sent sent back so he he will slide But we have a player even like Radam Murtka who's in the in the HL who if he doesn't get the 10 NHL games He he will slide but they have control like they could call him up and play the 10 games And so just looking at that and thinking like why is this not such a big topic anymore? And my theory is that you know, we've seen these much bigger deals now for players coming out of their entry level deals And if you're a team like there is some Value now get the player through the entry level deal faster before they really establish themselves as NHL players and get them signed to a long-term contract for much cheaper And then you can get them for you know, in a much better deal Where is if and this the when they slide you know instead of signing them to their deal Let's say you sign them a year earlier when they have one year left on the entry level deal You could be signing them at 20 years old basically right for contract. That's going to start when they're 21 But when the contract slides once or twice now you're signing them at 21-22 now they matured more right They played more NHL games and potentially now there's a risk that they're way more expensive So that's why I think that gets just not as clear-cut an issue anymore for both the player and the team There's some thinking that the sooner you get through the entry level deal You might not have like popped and you might be leaving actually money on the table if you're ready through your second contract Where there could be some benefit to like waiting to your another year or two older and then signing the next contract You might be able to get a much bigger deal Yeah, I mean even looking like Lane Hudson right is like the person that stands out to me in terms of like he signed his His extension pretty early and it's almost immediately a huge discount to the Montreal Canadian And it's like even you go back a few years like map boldies on one of the better contracts They signed him to a long-term deal out of their entry But if they would have slid those players another year or two like who knows what that number would have looked like and to the point of The rising salary cap because it's rising so much like in a flat cap. You knew what it was going to be So like you weren't going to be able to get as much of like trying to kick it down the can may a lot of sense But now when it keeps going up and up and up like you want to lock in those players that you drafted at premium positions to longer-term contracts Earlier on because the price today is not going to be the price tomorrow and there's a lot of teams now who didn't do that a lot of the anaheim docs who kind of waited on some of those deals and now they're kind of kicking themselves because of how much It's it's risen and gone up in the salary cap. And so it's interesting You know chicken chicken dance between the teams and the players right because there's like strategy from both sides of it And it's like the age and trying to maximize the value for their clients The teams are trying to get the best team friendly deals and there's always usually some middle ground that usually gets struck Exactly. Yeah, and that's why wonder like does the strategy change a bit for some players like do teams? You know keep a player up in the start of the year for more for 10 yeet let them play the 10th game Burn a year and then send them back to junior which is allowed like there's no you can send the player back anytime That burns no big deal. Yeah burn it And so now you know like he's got in in another year He could time to an extension and he maybe hasn't matured enough to really earn like top dollar Like I just I think this is something to just track and watch and see what this strategy is going for because again It's not such a clear obvious slide good for team. You know slide bad for player. I think it's more complicated now Yeah, especially if you think the player is going to develop more by playing in that in the juniors And they're not going to have NHL production to use in like negotiations and a lot of these times these players aren't going to have arbitration rights coming out right out of their entry level So they're not they're going to be limited in their options and especially and we'll talk about the 10 to seize in a second But if they're kind of sign early and then don't don't play enough games They won't even be offer sheet eligible so they'll have really limited limited leverage in those situations exactly Yeah, okay. Let's talk about just a couple cat maneuvering situations at teams executed this past week the first is in New York Rangers heart I wanted to talk quickly the Rangers had moved Egor to Sturken from LTIR to season ending LTIR So what that means that essentially this is a new rule in the CBA in the last couple seasons But essentially the Rangers now get the full benefit of Egor's salary minus the room They left off on the LTIR pool So $11.567 million Egor's cap hit they can use almost all of that now And to add on for this season only so That's going to be interesting piece of it. I just want to talk to you like one Do you think the reason was just because doctors gave the go ahead that he's medically not going to be able to return this season Or sometimes in these scenarios like teams are doing it only when they need the cap spaces that mean maybe a move is on the horizon for the Rangers Yeah, I think it's probably both. So yeah, they they went from getting 3.9 million of benefit from him Which is the LTIR benefit limit this year to getting his full 11.6 Right, so that's like over 7 million of extra benefit I think it's a combination they probably now got final word that yeah this guy is not going to be able For the playoffs no matter what advances in AI medicine happened in the next month or two You will not be ready and I think you know they wanted to make some moves I think like if you look at the slaughter warm trade right like they used up some of that space right away Like we have them now with 9 million of space So like certainly they they could have made them move without it But they did just take on an extra million and a half of cap charge with them in the minors And so you know, they're looking like we're going to be adding some cap charge here with this trade Maybe there's some other moves. He's now out for the season. Okay. Now is a good as good a time as I need to put them on season ending out we saw that with St. Louis where they started with crew gone regular LTR and then moved them to season ending And they didn't really make another move like obviously maybe a call up and nothing significant But I think at that point too, it's like well now we have you know, we maybe we have some injuries coming Let's just do it and have like that paper work done and now we have the space if we need it Yeah, exactly. They're not going to be accruing anytime soon They were pretty much up against it with the Egor so it sounds like they're just going to play the LTI Our game throughout the rest of the season and it opens up a lot of possibilities for what they can do If they want to add another goal tender, although it seems like a random corpus solo seems like a solid duo The Rangers are still in the mix right now in the metropolitan division I think a lot of people thought they'd fall off as soon as Egor went down and hasn't been the case they've been playing hard So we'll see how it all plays out for them Another team I want to talk about quickly too is their former GM who's now in charge with the Montreal Canadiens Jeff Gordon along with Kent Hughes. They're an interesting predicament right now because they only have about $225,000 in current cap space. They have a lot of injuries. They haven't put any guys on LTIR Evan Demado has been out for pretty much the whole season Josh Anderson's now on the IR and Chris Criter also went down recently As well as Sam Montenboe. So they don't have much cap space here right now heart I'm curious just like what like they retain this year on Brendan Gallagher 3.25 million dollars And they also carried almost a two million dollar bonus overage So what are your thoughts just on like you know these situations where they had to just call up Preparade who eats up about 800,000 850,000 cap hit but corrorated for the rest of the season But just what are your thoughts on like teams where you know they plan to have a bunch of cap space and then a few injuries hit They have to start calling guys up from the miners. They don't want to put guys on LTIR and then it eats into your caps quicker than you think Yeah, I think it's you know teams especially once you get into the season as an under the cap team Like you really don't want to be using LTIR because Again, that means that you're not a crewing space anymore and you look at Montreal like yeah right now We're showing they can add 226,000 of current like a manual cap it today if they don't make another move It's up to 800,000 of the deadline so that you could see already it grows But like if they were healthier set one or two players down like now you're talking they can have maybe you know three four five million A space of the deadline so it can't agree pretty quickly So you're kind of like holding out and trying not to use LTR if you don't have to now depends like how Long these players are injured, but yeah, I mean if they if they just don't have a not healthy bodies like they're not gonna have a choice and they'll they'll you know Try to get as good a capture as possible. They probably put a player that's the most likely to come back soon On LTR like still gonna be out the 10 games in 24 days, but closer to that than like several months so that they could potentially exit and Like them and off for example if they put them on LTR. He could get activated tomorrow He's already been out for 10 games in 20 years. He only played two games. So he's been out since early October. Yeah, so they could right But yeah, again, it's like the question of do they want to do that and and it's also in season It's really hard to have a almost optimal capture So there's gonna be some space and then they're not occurring on even when they go back under the cap if the players tell injured The other thing with them is like you mentioned they had overages this year They have a they sell a lot of players with performance bonuses for this season too So they also are trying to create some space to Absorb those bonuses at the end of the year and not have another over for next year because it starts to be like a bit of a vicious cycle So that's also something to watch right like they're you know a guy like Fowler has performance bonuses Demano performance bonuses. Although maybe with injury. Don't have to worry about that as much, but Chris Crider has performance bonuses, right? Like he gets two million at 10 games. Yeah, right? So They're they also like for them. There's extra motivation create space Here so they can add players at the deadline But also try to finish with some space so they can absorb some of those bonuses and not have an overage next season Exactly. It's a it's a fun fun game that these cap experts play for teams the last one I want to talk to you about New Jersey Devils too because There's was interesting because we were trying to figure out on Friday when word got out that Anton Solayev was going to be recalled from Utica We knew that he wasn't on the roster the second time around when they set their LTIR Capture and because of that He's actually on the hook for 1.9 to 5 million dollar cap hit because it takes the average of his performance bonuses over the ELC And it adds on to this year's cap hit of 1.075 million dollars and you know They put him on Elk on their roster the first time they set their LTIR pool So I think it was just it was unfortunate that they couldn't actually fit him the second time around They didn't have the cap space for it So in order for them to to get that Situated they had to move shame is Casey from season opening iR to season opening LTIR And because they would have been about 30,000 short and then when they did that move they had about 42,000 in space So just some slick maneuvering and stuff that like you know Michael left through the wayside is like some a casual fan just seeing that all this extra work That has to go on because when Manta went on LTIR they brought up Lenny hominago Because his the performance bonuses wouldn't be on the roster when they did that So there's just a lot of cap Situation with with this devil's move that was kind of two parts But it also like they planted the seeds early on in the season when they initially sent their LTIR with Feudstad But exited once they traded them yeah that to me It's another example of like in season when things are happening and you have injuries and you know The seasons moved along. It's a lot harder to get a more optimal capture and an up LTIR capture And optimal is both You know how close you are to the cap so that you're getting all the cap space But also which players you get in that capture so that you have performance bonuses And so they had a really good capture before with Duke's dad And they had salay on there but yeah you trade your LTIR guy you leave LTIR and hopefully you're hoping you don't have to come back again And you have a bunch of injuries You know everyone has a plan to get punched in the face as Mike Tyson said so you know that that's that's an example of like It's really hard to set an optimal LTIR pool in season you have to just deal with it like I look at a team like Anaheim Who had a really really really good capture you know they they recently Activated Terry right who was the person they put on LTIR and you know they put on pealing at the same time now I on LTIR now Did they need the cast base? No because if you look they're under the cap right now right and occurring But I think that's the smart savvy move where you made a capture that was really really close, you know You never know if you're gonna have more injuries and have to use elsewhere. You don't lose that cap That's not lose the capture. Let's stick another guy that's injured and out on there And I I could see them as long as they have someone that could qualify for LTIR like continually having someone on as long as possible I'm just for a rainy day right so they don't have to try to recapture because That it would be almost impossible to get is get a capture now in mid season as they did on the first day of the season when they did it with Terry I want to just one note here too just because a team has players on LTIR There's a difference between that and teams using and in LTIR so yes if they're if they're not if they're not in LTIR But they have there's an LTIR they can still crew cap space if they're in LTIR using it they cannot I get this question a lot I'm getting it about the oilers now a lot Yes players can be on LTIR does not mean the team is using LTIR when we say a team is Has players on LTIR and they're not using it and they're accruing that's because they're under the cap and accruing space I know the cap they don't again LTIR does not allow a cruel so adding more players to LTIR for those teams doesn't help You don't accru space by adding players to LTIR the only way you accru space is being under the cap Yep, and that's a big important distinction that I think sometimes people get confused about Let's wrap it up here hard We had an article posted on puck pt about an hour or two ago talking about these possible 10 to seize for the upcoming Offseason here guys who are on their entry levels who will not need offer sheets given the their NHL Games played so gay pro's kind of the name that highlights this list here Just talked to us through about like how exactly it's calculated on who's a 10 to see and is not offer sheet eligible versus who is and can receive offer sheets Yeah, so so we you know we hear about a researched for agents RFA's And they can't the the teams hold their rights, but they can sign an offer sheet The exception is what's called a 10 to see which is obviously not a easy name for it not a cool name It just comes from the section in the cba that's article. It's a section. Then it's point 10 to see Um, you know, maybe we can coin a better name for it But basically it's they're like an RFA except they do not have offer sheet eligibility And so the most recent examples in a kitchen and so you know the consequence of not being able to sign an offer sheet Is he was stuck right did he think he's worth a one year three million dollar deal? Obviously not or he would have signed much sooner, but his options are Sign the deal that the team is making you or like offer you or take your talents overseas basically I go back to Russia in his case And so you know without having that offer sheet eligibility like there's not much else you can do Qatar goche was another example like he signed a big contract But he you know, he really didn't have much leverage again because he he wasn't offered sheet eligible So it is definitely shifts leverage from you know to the team's perspective it A player that is coming off their entry-level deal that is a 10 to see that's not an offer sheet eligible That's the least amount of leverage a player ever has in the whole cba so the way to To like be offer sheet eligible you need a certain number of pro years experience and it's based on your entry-level signing age So if you're 18 to 21 You need three years pros three years of pro experience and then you're offered to eligible if you're 22 to 23 It's two years and after 24 plus it's one year and to call it to earn a year pro experience for an 18 to 19 year old It's 10 NHL games but if you're 20 and older, it's it's 10 or more professional games in any league It doesn't have to be the NHL and so with the most common example our college players like a Qatar goche coming out of college Signing at the end of the season and not getting in 10 NHL games that season that they they play to season And so is burned a year of their NHL contract But it did not earn a year of professional experience towards being offered sheet eligible That's the most easy way to explain it and that's the gay pro situation at a bc Signed for the end of the season didn't play 10 years that two games that year Yeah, so like flipping through the list here. Yeah, he's definitely the most from like notable player prominent player Um, I don't know if there's anyone else on the list that you think is I don't know that's just around right you would that just got treated right? Yeah, that's a big one He wouldn't be offered sheet eligible Yeah, Renzel Ryan Green is in his name people have heard of Um, and then there's a couple other a couple players that were going to be ten to seize Demidov and boom they sign extensions, but again like they didn't have leverage and so you know It makes sense for them to get a contract signed while they got it what they thought was maybe decent offer I think you know demidov Everyone talks about what a bargain he took But like again his option would he could have been him if the haves played hardball He could be in an occasion situation. Yeah, the summer not have a contract that have no option But to just sign like a whatever one year deal they were offering just to get to play Um, the other one to watch like I said the most common example is players Signing their their deals entry-level deals out of college and and that first season not getting in ten games Another situation that can happen is that a player just gets injured and they don't play the ten games that they don't get that year pro experience It's a one player to watch is maverick Lamaroo with Utah So he's he was injured to start the year. It's a long term injury If he doesn't get his ten games in this season, he will be a ten to see as well And so that might affect his next contract by not having that offer selectability Yeah, and you mentioned Michael Hage too who's playing at Michigan right now who at the end of the season could you know Sign with the Montreal Canadiens and play less than ten games dependent Michigan's looking pretty good this year. So the longer they go on in the NCAA, the more likely it is that he's not going to be able to play those 10 games. You know, his hands are obscure, right? So they have two guys that could be tend to see now. Playoff games can't just say playoff games do count or don't count. Yeah, they do count. Yeah. Okay, so, so, you know, if he's signs, you know, plays a couple games and goes on a long playoff or on getting into games, then, you know, he might not get is that he might get his offer should eligibility. But he has to play, right? He can't just be silent. Like he can't. It's trust. Yeah, you have to trust in the game. Yep. Okay. Cool. Well, I think that answered. We went through some of the questions during the episode. So I don't know if we have any additional questions, but good episode. That's all the time we have for you guys today. Make sure, like we mentioned, the puck drops coming out to your inbox is 7 a.m. Saturdays. Make sure you're signed up. Go to puckpedia's website to sign up. Get all the new insight information, the tagging room. I know the Maple Leafs did don't want us to talk about that. But tagging room is a is a thing in the national hockey league and that new feature calculation has been added to the puckpedia team cap projection pages for all your teams to see how much tagging room each team has for next season. That's right. And make sure you go back and listen to the Jim Rutherford interview that Keith did in last week's puckpedia hockey show. If you missed it, I'm really good episode. As you'd expect, Jim Rutherford let it fly with on a few opinions and topics. You know, talked about some of these jams that are sort of nervous to make trades and obviously he doesn't suffer from that. He says, if you, if you have a deal, even if it's not the best deal and you want the player, like me pull the trigger and do it. But yeah, I had a lot of interesting nuggets. So I really enjoyed that episode. I encourage everyone to listen to it. Yeah, he was great. And you know, maybe he'll come back on when he's not working for the Pinox and then he could really let it fly. But we don't really, we really appreciate him coming on. We got some good guests lined up in the next few weeks as well. We'll have another puckpedia hockey show dropping next Tuesday and then another live cap central the following week. Maybe we'll get a Dylan Larkin trade. Maybe a Nikita Kutraov trade. That would be nice. I've been send December. December 1st is a Simone Evanson deadline. That's two weeks from today. So I think that'll be a good episode. I think that's our next episode for cap central be December 1st. So the timing of that couldn't work out better. Hopefully we get some interesting news. And he's not a 10 to see for example. He could be offer sheet. So he was having up to the plate. Unfortunately, and I think a lot of that has to do with Detroit's cap situation. And they would probably match most offer sheets, but you know, the Anaheim Ducks didn't care out of the fires. I should say when they made that offer sheet to Gleo Carlson, they said, if you match great, like we're still going to do it. So we'll see how that plays out. But a lot of good stuff coming up in the next couple of weeks. And that's all time we have for you. Make sure you're followed along and subscribed to the puckpedia YouTube page.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The NHL is discussing salary cap smoothing, where the cap is temporarily raised this year and then suppressed next year, but Keith Kaffin argues this is artificial and counterproductive since players already receive a 50% revenue share with a top-up at season end.
  2. A higher cap—such as 130 million—should reflect actual team revenues, and reducing it artificially limits team flexibility, harms free agent market dynamics, and disadvantages players who don’t benefit from massive cap jumps.
  3. Some agents suggest temporarily lowering the 20% cap limit for superstar players during a major cap increase to prevent excessive wealth concentration, but this is a rare and nuanced perspective.
  4. Teams are shifting from delaying entry-level contracts to signing players earlier to lock in value before cap growth makes future deals much more expensive, especially as salary caps rise consistently.
  5. Injury-related cap maneuvers, such as moving players to season-ending LTIR or recalling injured players, create complex and often suboptimal cap space situations, especially when injuries disrupt planned roster moves.
  6. The "10-to-see" rule limits offer sheet eligibility for players who don’t earn 10 NHL games, reducing their leverage and often pushing them toward overseas opportunities or accepting team offers.
  7. Teams like the Canadiens and Devils face tight cap constraints due to injuries and bonus overages, forcing them to make difficult, in-season cap decisions that impact future contract negotiations.
  8. The NHL’s cap structure and rules are evolving, with teams and agents pushing for more transparent, revenue-driven cap projections to better reflect market realities and player value.

Summary:

The NHL is considering salary cap smoothing—raising the cap this year and suppressing it next year—but Keith Kaffin argues this is artificial and undermines the true value of player contracts, since players already receive 50% of revenue with a top-up at season's end. He believes the cap should reflect actual revenues, not projections, and that a higher cap—like 130 million—is needed to allow teams to compete in free agency and maintain fan interest. Teams are now signing entry-level players earlier to lock in value before rising caps make future deals more expensive, shifting from past strategies of delaying contracts.

Injuries complicate cap management, forcing teams to make difficult in-season moves, such as moving players to season-ending LTIR or recalling injured players, often resulting in inefficient cap space usage. The "10-to-see" rule further reduces player leverage by barring offer sheet eligibility for players who don’t play 10 NHL games, leaving them with fewer negotiation tools. Teams like the Canadiens and Devils face severe cap constraints due to injuries and bonuses, pushing them to make reactive, high-stakes decisions.

Overall, the cap system is evolving, with stakeholders advocating for revenue-based projections and more balanced, transparent structures to fairly reflect player and team value.

FAQs

Salary cap smoothing proposes adjusting the cap upward in one year and downward in the next to maintain stability. It's being discussed because teams and players want consistent cap levels that reflect actual revenue, not artificial projections. However, critics argue it's unnecessary since players still receive 50% of revenue and get a top-up at year's end.

Some agents suggest reducing the 20% cap limit during a significant cap increase to prevent a few players from taking a disproportionate share of the increased salaries. This spreads the benefits more evenly across players and avoids inflation of top-tier contracts, which could otherwise create imbalance in the league.

A '10 to see' player is a rookie who doesn't play 10 NHL games in a season, losing offer sheet eligibility. This gives teams significant leverage, as these players can only sign with their original team or move overseas, limiting their negotiating power and contract options.

The entry-level contract slide allows a player to avoid counting a season if they don't play 10 NHL games. Teams now prefer signing players earlier to lock in lower contract values before they mature, as rising cap levels make it more expensive to sign players later.

If a player is placed on LTIR and later injured, they may be moved to a season-ending LTIR. This preserves cap space, but teams must balance this with the risk of losing cap flexibility and the need to manage performance bonuses and roster depth.

Injuries force teams to call up players from the minors, consuming cap space and potentially leading to overages. Teams may also use LTIR to preserve cap space, but they can't use it to generate space if they're already under the cap.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.