Neil deGrasse Tyson On: Happiness, Seeking Friction, Getting Your Mind Blown, and Why Casinos Hate Physicists
1h 27s
Neil deGrasse Tyson shares a deeply reflective perspective on happiness, rooted in doing what one loves and embracing curiosity. He argues that aligning one’s life with passions from childhood leads to profound personal fulfillment and a more vibrant world. The modern world’s erosion of physical and emotional friction—such as the pilgrimage to observe telescopes—has diminished the awe and wonder once central to scientific exploration. Tyson criticizes intellectual stagnation, or “ossification,” which arises from education systems that prioritize memorization over inquiry. He emphasizes that true understanding comes through evidence, repetition, and skepticism, not opinion or emotion. A cosmic perspective, such as seeing Earth as a pale blue dot, fosters awe and a sense of belonging in the universe, not insignificance. He advocates for expanding empathy to include all life forms and for decisions to reflect ecological and holistic truths. Ultimately, happiness isn't about avoiding difficulty but about actively engaging with life, learning daily, and measuring success through effectiveness, not just emotional comfort. Tyson’s insights, drawn from both astrophysics and personal experience, offer a powerful model for human flourishing in a world increasingly dominated by misinformation and emotional reactivity.
(upbeat music) - Hello everybody. Welcome to the 10% Happier Podcast. I'm your host, Dan Harris. It is so easy to get so caught up in the details and frustrations and resentments of daily life that you miss the big picture. In fact, maybe you miss your whole life. What I love, or one of the things I love about my guests today, is that he is relentlessly focused on the big picture, the galactic picture and beyond. My guest is Neil deGrasse Tyson, who's an astrophysicist and the Frederick P. Rose Director of the Hayden Planetarium at the American Museum of Natural History. He's also the host of his own podcast, which is called Star Talk. He's also the author of many, many books. His latest book is called Lost in Space, 5,000 Facts to Navigate the Universe. Neil deGrasse Tyson, welcome to the show. Welcome back to the show. - Why is this only 10% Happier? Why not 20%? - We're gonna hang over math. - Yeah, it's a good stuff, plus. - If you're gonna, you're gonna, I met your size, something in the title of your podcast. I'm just thinking, let's, why stop at 10? - You wanna know the story? - Please. - Okay, when I first got interested in mental health and things like that, I took a brief, but disturbing detour into the self-help world, which is filled with people who will tell you that they can solve all of your problems. - Of course, through many modalities, including things like manifestation and the power of positive thinking. So I wrote a book and then use that title on this podcast with the somewhat tongue in cheek goal of counter-programming against reckless over-promising. - Got it. - So it is, you're under-promising and over-delivering. - Yeah, I hope so. I hope so. I can't, I can't guarantee the over-delivering. - Yeah, all right. - It's kind of on you today, though. (laughing) - Well, I count myself among the ranks of happy people in the world. - So how are you defining happy? - Things that bring me joy, then comfort and delight. Things that I want to happen again, generally, if we like something, you wanna do it more than once. And there are a few things you can like and only do once. Like bungee jumping. (laughing) - There might be some things that are singularly dangerous but thrilling and say, okay, I don't need to do that again, but I'm glad I did it once. I think people's lives should have some of that in it as well. But I would just say overall, I'm a pretty happy person. - Do you think that is connected to your work? - It's almost too easy to say yes to that, but I guess I'm gonna say yes. It's, here's how I've thought about it. Here's how I've unpacked that. I've known what I wanted to do as a grownup since I was nine, and what that meant was, my whole life, I was able to align decisions, actions, places to visit, people to meet, greet. Also, of course, with the help of my parents, that aligned with that goal of being an astrophysicist. So when I was nine, I didn't know you could be an astrophysicist. I just knew I felt good looking up in the universe, getting lost in its immensity. And by the time I was 11, I had the answer to that annoying question that adults always ask kids, what do you wanna be when you grew up? And when I got to college and realized it, half of everyone in college didn't know what they wanted to be when they grew up. I said, wow, maybe what happened to me was unusual. And I knew how much joy and happiness just sitting in front of a telescope brought me. And I concluded from this that if everyone did what they loved, the world would be such a happier place. - Yes, yes. - And, or did what they were best at and were paid for that. Imagine, and so when tasks are the come my way of any kind, opportunities, let's call them that. And if I know someone else can do it, there's no reason for me to do it. I would rather do something that I know my combination of talents and interest would contribute uniquely to it. So then the next level is everyone's doing what they love. Now everyone is doing what no one else can do in this world. Oh my gosh, civilization would be transformed overnight. - Do you think there is something happiness producing about doing what you love in your case? Or do you, I mean, this, I don't wanna create a false choice here, but I will let you create a false choice. - Okay, you're already policing my percentages. So I've prepared these comments. Commenting on your percentages. - All right, well, this was my question. Is it that you're doing what you love, which I don't have any doubt is a source of happiness, but is there also something specifically happiness inducing about what it is you love to do? You said, right, there's something about gazing up into the being lost in the immensity of space. - And one thing that's a bit of a loss, you didn't ask this, but I'm old enough to have been of a generation where you took trains, planes, and automobiles to get to the tops of mountains to where the telescopes are. Then you would spend a day acclimating to living notorially, then you'd start your observing run. And you are there with a telescope, it has an interesting echo inside the dome when the telescope moves. You hear it, the gear is going, and it's a little echo, and then the echo subsides, and it's so quiet outside. You can hear the crunch of the gravel beneath your feet, and almost hear your heartbeat. You gaze up, and it's just you, your telescope, and the universe. That's a certain, a romance that one has with the sky, there's a certain fulfillment to that, especially coming after the long trip to get there, like a pilgrimage. It made the destination all the more pleasing, all the more rewarding. So nowadays, you just assign a technician at the telescope to point the telescope, provide the observation, and then they just send it back to you over the internet. And I was humbled enough to remember the transition where the internet was only just a baby. It would take a week to move the data over the bandwidth of the internet. So we would compare the bandwidth of the internet versus the bandwidth of FedEx. (laughing) You just put 10 in a FedEx box, ship that. That's a higher bandwidth than waiting for the thing to, it was a fun transition over that time. Point is, nowadays there's none of that. You just, you never leave your office. You don't even live neutrally. Just wake up in the morning and the data are sitting in your inbox. So that's a loss, I think. - Yeah. - I'm glad that I had a piece of the romance of the night sky. - This is a common critique of modern life, which is that we're lacking friction. - Oh, that's interesting. I've thought about it, it's of course correct. I have no hesitation to agree with that statement. I used to wrestle in high school and college and there's some friction for you. (laughing) You have something, you want a full button opposing force operating on you. And the only way to get better is to lose. So, friction, I would generalize the word friction there to just opposing forces that you must navigate. I just threw strength of will, physical strength, emotional strength, intellectual strength. And if it doesn't kill you, to repeat an old phrase, it makes you stronger. So yeah, I try to have some force operator in my life every day. Every day. - What does that look like usually? - I try to make sure every day I'm alive and learn something new. And learning something new, I forgot who said this, burning quote, "It was this no greater pain of the human mind than the prospect of having to learn something new." We're so comfortable. And what we already know, or at least what we already think is true, that to take on a new idea can be challenging for some people 'cause it brings a level of discomfort. And I happen to embrace discomfort because I come out with a different person on the other side. And I think there's not enough echo in you. There's not enough of that in people's lives. Otherwise, we'd all be growing every single day and we're not. We're ossifying. - One of the most potent and persistent sources of suffering in my life is this constant or seemingly constant toppling forward into the next moment. Nothing that's happening right now. Why does it for me? And so I'm just kind of reaching for that next thing over and over as my longtime meditation teacher, Joseph Goldstein likes to ask people, how many slices of pizza have you eaten? How many parties have you attended? How many promotions have you received and are you done? Of course not, we are insatiable. And in this way, the pursuit of happiness can become the source of our unhappiness. The good news is that another of my favorite meditation teachers, Vinny Ferraro, a fan favorite in the 10% happier cinematic universe has just created a whole new batch of guided meditations to help you deal with this sense of insufficiency and get to what he calls enoughness.
and these meditations are available over on my app, 10% with Dan Harris, if any, we'll be dropping them throughout the month of November. And on Tuesdays throughout the month of November, Vinny will be meditating with subscribers live and taking your questions. It's a Vinny Ferraro Festival in the month of November, over on 10% with Dan Harris. Just a recap here, Vinny's new meditations drop every week in the month of November, and you can join him live only in the 10% with Dan Harris app. That, that ossification actually has, in my view, and I'd be curious to see if you agree, has not only social and cultural effects, but also political effects. I think it's part of why we have political effects. Yes, we have this polarized debate, nobody wants to learn about the POV, or very few of us want to learn about the POV of the opposing tribe. Right. And I don't care what your opinion is, but as an educator, I care that you've based it on what is objectively true in the world. Lest you're just thinking things are true that aren't, and you can't build a democracy on that. So how's the cards at that level? So I don't argue with people's opinions. On the internet, I don't even post opinions. People think they're opinions, but they're not. That's what's intriguing, because at my level of following on the internet, typically people with that level of following are handing you your opinion that day. All right, you need to do this. Join this movement. There are these people are a-holes. These people are bad. Join me because the internet is an outrage engine, we all know. Right? And so I learned that if you put an opinion on the internet, the people who don't agree with it will fight you for having an opinion different from theirs. And that's an extraordinary fact. Because what it means is that person, I don't think this is an unrealistic extrapolation, that person will only be happy if everyone in the world agreed with them. And we have a word for that. It's a dictatorship. It's not a democracy. Democracy celebrates that we all have different opinions. And you express an opinion and say, oh, that's interesting. That's different from mine. Tell me more about yours. Let's compare. Maybe we'll each learn something that doesn't happen anymore. One other problem with democracy, and again, this isn't my opinion. You can tell me if you agree or not, is the level of distrust is so high that expertise has been devalued. And I wonder if you, again, I wonder if you agree with that. And do you see it as you look at it the world, too? Yeah, it's a susceptible, again, I come to it as an educator. So I ask myself, where did the educational system go awry in the hearts and minds of those who are behaving this way? And do people understand statistics? And we are putty in the hands of people who would manipulate our emotions and our feelings. We know this from advertisers. We know this from algorithms in social media. We just go where they want us to go because we can't help ourselves. It's almost not even our fault. And I'll give an example. We are highly susceptible to someone on the internet who shows they have some pedigree, and they say it all is actually this way. But no one else knows it yet. Or if they did know what they would suppress it, because there the mainstream doesn't want you to do, you're going to click on it and admit it like that. Because you have access to some information here. Now, of course, the mainstream doesn't have a face. You the opponent to mainstream do, and you have platform. How's mainstream at a bar chart going to convince you over someone who speaks passionately on the internet? We are susceptible to that. We're susceptible to someone saying, big farmer is all bad, and they're not interested in your health, but I'm interested in your health. Here, there's these herbs, and here's the QR code. Not only that, speaking, I wrote about this segment of separately in another book. Will you grant me one conspiracy theory? Please. I'll grant you as many as you want. No, no, just one. You're kneeling. Just rest. You can have as many as you want. No, just one. Do you know where most state lottery monies go that are collected by the state, typically? No, I don't. Okay. Typically, people will vote to allow a lottery, because it's gambling. And then, they give you a reason why it would be a good thing for you to vote for, because the revenue from it goes to education, the fund education. Well, of course, why not? It's education, right? Okay. I looked in all 50 states at the curriculum, the math curriculum. Hardly any of them offer probability statistics as a required class. Some of them offer it as an elective. So what's up with that? The educational system that's being paid by a lottery is not teaching you probability and statistics, because if they did, you would graduate high school and never play the lottery. You would understand how badly the odds are against you, okay? Will you grant me that conspiracy? It's fun to think about. So we have entire industries that thrive on your inability to think statistically and probabilistically, they're called casinos. There's someone there betting on a seven and a roulette. Say, "Why do you keep betting on seven?" "It's due." Is that how do you know what to do? Well, look, they show the previous roles. It hasn't come up in 20 times. It's due. Then I say, "No, it's not due. You just didn't learn probability in your life." Okay. And so, again, I can't blame the people. Here's a slightly long story, but keep it quick. The American Physical Society, which is the National Organization of Physicists, meets once a year and one year is going to be in San Diego, and there's some snaffoo with the hotels. The last minute they had to cancel, last minute, MGM grand, in Vegas said, "We'll take you. We're one of the biggest hotels in the world. We have 2,000 rooms. Come on over." So, maybe what pivoted went to Vegas. At the end of seven days, it was a newspaper headline. Physicists in town lowest casino take ever. The APS has been told to never come back to Las Vegas. Because as a physical scientist, we learn probability every year in graduate school. How do you know whether your results are reliable? How do you know when they're not? None of this is, do you learn unless you choose to take it in college or unless you took the elective in high school? So, we all knew not to play the machines and anything, and so we just didn't, and they lost money. Which I thought was kind of cool. Anyhow, so when I see people who, like you said, have ossified in their ways that you can't talk to them, it's because they believe that what they think is correct. Yes. And they think anyone else who does not agree with them is wrong. People are not equipped to probe. How to learn whether something is correct or not. But my wife has a PhD in mathematical physics with two kids. Neither of them are in the sciences. We have no requirement of that for them, but they're scientifically literate. When my son was like 11, we had some adults around the table. And one of them said, "Oh, today's not going well. It must be because Mercury is in retrograde." And he heard this, and he said, "Why do you think the planet Mercury cares about you at all?" Something like that. There are ways to probe it. Just to force people back into their own skin to think about it. And because science literacy is not a measure of how much you know, is how is your brain wired for inquiry? Right. If someone says I have these crystals and I rub them, you'll cure your ailment. If you reject it outright, that is just as intellectually lazy as if you accept it outright. Maybe it does. Okay, start asking questions. What is the mechanism, by the way, this works? By the way, if you know some chemistry you get to say, a crystal is the lowest energy state of those atoms and molecules. You can't get energy out of it. So, what do you mean there's crystal energy that's there? Show me something that measures. So, and then the person walks away because there is no crystal energy. But to ask questions is, and we're not trained to do that. I can't blame people for this. I'm blaming an academic system that throws a book in front of you with bold face words that you memorize for the exam. And then you forget them two weeks later. So, maybe instead of learning stuff, we should have our curiosity stimulated. So that when you graduate, you are so curious you want to keep learning. And then you're spending the rest of your life learning. But for those of you and I sitting here and I don't think anybody listen can wave a magic wand and fix the education system. I'm curious.
your advice for us as individuals navigating an information environment which is corrosive and warped and as you said there's this kind of a symmetry where people with no expertise but power persuasion get rewarded by the alpha right right it's it's even charisma but power persuasion so yeah I mean you have to be on guard is the person selling you something at the end. Is the person saying that they're right and mainstream is wrong. You know science works if you come up with a result that's not what is true. 10 other people have to match your result for that to be true if you come up result and it's true for you and no one else you're wrong. But if I'm a internet surfer and I come upon you and you say I got this result no one else agrees with me but I know this is right they're just suppressing me you better. You know stay on my channel before they close it down and we like the underdog we like the person who's who's oppressed by the big forces that are out there we like the forbidden the forbidden as well. So yeah it's not as fun to go with the average or what the mainstream is it's not as exciting but the mainstream in science is the origin of the truth is the mainstream is where multiple. experiments verified in result and that is a statistical fact that does not have the charismatic face behind it it's just a bar chart a company advertising something for you let's say they do have the best product on the market they can just show a chart a graph that's that says this is the best thing on the market here here is the people who said yes but they don't they get a person to say I've used this product it was the best. I think in my life it changed me why would you listen to one individual ever about anything but it works and advertisers know it yes what I'm taking from you as that this is a show that's preoccupied with human flourishing I think there's a lot to learn from an astrophysicist about human flourishing because there are habits of mind that you have. That are learnable skills I'm not going back to school to become an astrophysicist but curiosity being comfortable not knowing what happened these are these are important skills I think can improve our lives someone wants to ask me. When was the last time you changed your mind I swear to you I didn't understand the question. It's like I had to really think about the question maybe it was just my naïve social naïve today that question almost has no meaning to a scientist because what we. And I'll use the word believe here but it's a little bit misapplied what we believe to be true about this world. The strength with which we believe something to be true is proportional to the evidence that supports it right. So if evidence comes up that tips at the other way I'm tipping with where the evidence goes I don't have emotions invested in the outcome of some experiment being true or not. I have investments in the repeatability of the data which let's call that evidence and I will follow the evidence wherever it takes me. If you did an experiment I said that was a pretty cool result but I don't really believe it let me try I try it I get a different result but they still have something in common a third person someone in a different country someone who has 240 volts on their machine instead of 120 maybe that made a difference in the outcome of your tabletop experiment this happens and as they accumulate an emerging truth arrives an objective truth established by the methods and tools of science and no other enterprise. That's ever been put forth in civilization is as effective and as potent at establishing what is objectively true then the methods of tools of science. The message about something else that I think your job. Forces you to main line that a lot of us miss in our daily lives which is all a w e oh my gosh you know. A version of that would be something I'm quoted as saying I'll say it again here. If not once a day then at least once a week you should have your mind blown learn something to blues your mind. And all and mind blowing knowledge go together okay is a strong overlap if not identical overlap between those two. Circles in the venn diagram I think all sciences have their bit of all but am I biased if I say the universe wins. I think we will have sorry alone in the universe we have big as the universe was around before the universe how the universe and how long will we last. As a species how long will the sun last before dies how will it die but if you take factual astrophysical knowledge. And that package it in ways that force you to pause and reflect on our place in the universe. Then that's a cosmic perspective. It's it's a notch above what you may have heard the astronauts describe as the overview effect where you're in orbit and only in a few places on earth most you don't see national borders. You know it's just land and ocean and cloud and the petty things that go on on earth surface lose significance rapidly when seen from afar let's seen from orbit. Now you go deep space and all of earth is just this floating orb in the sky pale blue dot yeah and to quote out of that book with no hint that help. We'll come from elsewhere to save us from ourselves to us that's important I think I when we open the new planetarium the rose center of earth in space to rebuild Hayden Planetarium the first the inaugural show was a zoom out from Earth. And so you on earth you just here and you zoom out earth get small they see the orbit of the moon and then that gets more and then you see the orbit a version of the sun. The other planet and that gets more than the sun just becomes one other star in the night sky and that all shrinks down and then our entire Milky Way galaxy strength down and then all the other galaxies come in and they're so far away they just look like points of light the way the stars look like a moment ago we zoom you out to the edge of the universe. And then zoom back after we premier that show I got a letter I still have it in my files from a professor psychology university Pennsylvania. He said a paraphrase I'm a professor of a psychology University of Pennsylvania and my research focuses on things that make you feel small. And your space show is the greatest elicitor of feelings of smallness and insignificance I have yet encountered with your permission I would like to set up a a survey of people before and after the experience the show. And I read this and I thought to myself he's got it all wrong when I look out at the night sky I know I'm small and size and time and space I know that but I also know that I'm a participant in the great unfolding of this cosmic story. Not only that and you learn this in the in the books the atoms of your body and the molecules are traceable to stars that manufacture them in their core. So it's not just simply that we are alive in the universe the universe is alive within us. That is I think the greatest gift of 20th century astrophysics to civilization it borders on the spiritual universe is alive within you. That's I'm not even exaggerating to say that these are molecules made within the stars we are we are start us. What to life. Empowered to contemplate the very universe in which we were born. So when I look up and I have those thoughts I feel large I don't feel small. And I don't see how a cosmic perspective could ever depress anyone. I didn't read the letter but I heard it a different way I heard it as smallness not in the pejorative that people go in. Caught up in their daily shit and they come out seeing that their daily problems are taking place in this in this in maybe infinite space. I love that positive spin. It sounds to me like what you're pointing at the sign will today of smallness and largeness. We are tiny but you know what's tinier than us atoms and molecules and insects plenty of stuff is smaller than us. I'm not value judging size I'm putting size in a context so that you can think about it and feel it on a scale.
know that it's not judging who and what and where and when you are, but celebrating who and what and when and where you are, yes, in the 14 billion year history of the universe. You know, I'm on your side on this. I was actually moving past the dude with the letter and more to the bordering on spiritual argument that you were making about the value of this cosmic perspective, which is, and again, I don't know if I have this right, but the kind of thinking of it as, as I said before, the simul today, you have smallness and largeness as a feeling of elevation. Yeah, I'm elevated when I look up in the night sky. I don't feel. By the way, the history of religion, but certainly Christianity tapped into the Jewish traditions of the Bible. It has us at the center of the universe and the object of God's creation. So for thousands of years, people thought and felt this way about our place in the universe and astrophysical discoveries from Copernicus onward has been a systematic demotion of our perceived place in the universe. And if you only think of it, yes, it is a demotion because your ego came in high and I got a hack at that ego. I'm sorry, if truth matters to you, let's lay out the truth. If you can't handle the truth, then go on believing that you are the singular object of God's creation created in God's image. The creator of the universe cares about you. Go ahead. We live in a country that protects those thoughts. You will not find me picketing churches where that is taught. In fact, I celebrate it. I love it. I wouldn't have it any other way. But if you rise to power and have your religious philosophy infusing laws and legislation that then has to apply to everyone, not all of whom agree with your religious philosophies. That's a recipe for disaster. This is why I personally am a fan of a secular version of Buddhism because of unlike all the other religions of the Axial Age, Buddhism is about hacking at the ego. That's good. For me, I'm not any ism at all. Yeah, I try not to. Yes. Having spent my life in an ism in which contrarian ism was baked, in that I'm referring now to journalism, which is my whole career. I found myself drawn to Buddhism because baked into the Buddha's message was literally his signature phrase was come see for yourself. Don't take anything I say at face value. Come check it out. Yeah. And what science has gone so far beyond that because here is a microbe that if it gets inside of you, it will reproduce and kill you. Come see for yourself. No, you can't. Your eyes are in suspicion. And think about it. Why would God give us eyes where the things we can't see that could harm us in the world? That's a hard one to accept. You know that the discovery of infrared light, I briefly tell you, it's a place. A William Herschel was a fan of Isaac Newton wanted to play with Isaac Newton's lenses and prisms and things because Isaac Newton showed that white light passing through a prism breaks out into colors. Those colors weren't in the prism. Those colors were in the white light that came through. How do you get red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet out of white? That was freaky. That's why it was like no one believed it. William Herschel was a good scientist. Good scientists asked good questions. He said, "I wonder if the different colors of the spectrum have different temperatures." So he set up his room, put the prism there, has all the colors of the rainbow, red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet. And he takes up the thermometer and puts it in each one of these colors. But you need a control thermometer. You need to put a thermometer that's not in any of those colors. So he puts one over to the left of the red. It's not in the spectrum. And then he compares the readings of the control thermometer to every one of these colors. And in every measurement, the control thermometer was the hottest. Then he took the control thermometer and put it somewhere else in the room. It went back down to room temperature. Put it back right next to the red, temperature went up. He concluded that the sun was emitting light, quote, "unfit for vision." My boy discovered infrared light that the human eye cannot detect. So do you think come see for yourself? No. We have books called optical illusions. We're seeing for yourself just confused as you more. So I like the principle of see for yourself. But in the end of the day, bring a chart recorder with you. Bring some way to document it that bypasses your physiological senses. Fair. I mentioned at the beginning that you've got a new book. You've had many books, you've written many books, but the new one is called Lost in Space, 5,000 Facts in Advocate to Universe. I want to talk about a few of these facts. Oh, please. Yeah. And by the way, I checked it that is every single fact that exists at all. That's what it's not like. That's what it's all like writing the book. It's like, my God, did we leave anything out? But they're all organized. I mean, it's a joint publication between my podcast, Star Talk, and National Geographic Books. And they don't know ugly, okay? Yeah. The book is completely gorgeous. Yeah. It's like an IV drip of awe, which is the spirit. I'd love that. Say that again. I'll say right to the camera. It's like an IV drip of awe. And I want to talk about it in that context. A few of these facts because I think it's actually this is back to the spirit of the show. It's the awe that contributes to human elevation and flourishing. Yeah. And I would say that you can obviously Google 5,000 Facts. But that's not what this book is. The stock and trade of what we do on Star Talk is putting a fact in a context where it has meaning to you such that you will never forget it. So in one example, we can say, you know, you can Google how wide is the sun. And it'll come back about 865,000 miles across. That's not the fact as I would give it to you. I would say line up 100 Earths across. You will get the width of the sun. Now you will never forget that. Yeah. No, I won't. Do you know the sun has acne bigger than Earth? Acne? We call it sunspots. Okay. Spots on the sun. They're bigger than Earth. It's the comparison contextualization of information that rests more deeply within us. And as an educator, I have found that facts package that way are vastly more potent. So you pull some out. Yeah. For example, I don't know. You'll elaborate on these. But here's one that just struck me, which is the moon is slowly drifting away from the Earth, which means that solar eclipses are a temporary phenomenon on a cosmic time scale. And that the very last total solar eclipse will be roughly 620 million years from now, after which the moon will be too far away to cover the sun. Yes. Yeah. The moon is spiraling away from us. I forgot the number of like an inch and a half a year. And you might ask, how do you know that? How do you know that? Because this is a real calling response. Because on Apollo 11, Neil Armstrong at Buzz Aldrin, other than just go around and take pictures of each other and plant the flag, they also position what's called a corner reflector, which is a system of mirrors where if light comes in at any angle to those mirrors, it reflects and comes back at exactly the same angle. Okay. So it's not a flat mirror because if it comes in at this angle bounces out the other way. But you can configure mirrors so that the light goes no matter, no matter which way the light's coming in, we'll go back to where it came. They'd laid that down on the surface of the moon, came back to Earth, turned on telescopes, reversed them, sent a laser beam out to the moon, tied to the signal back. We can get the distance to the moon within a centimeter. We suspected the moon was spiraling away for reasons of physics. Now we made the measurements to verify it. So right now we have gorgeous total solar eclipses because the moon and the sun are in the sky are about the same size. What's going on there is the the sun is four hundred times bigger than the moon and it's four hundred times farther away. So that makes them the same size it. So the moon comes in front, perfectly covers it. It's just gorgeous. You see the corona. People spend a lot of money travel great distances to see these. They happen every couple of years somewhere on there. So but with the moon is spiraling away, we will come a day where it is too small to cover the sun. It'll still come in front of the sun, but you'll have a ring of sunlight around it. It won't be a total solar eclipse. Still be gorgeous, but it won't be total. I think you also talk in the book about and you mentioned this earlier that at some point the sun's going to die. Oh yeah. That will happen on October 9th. No chance. We're expecting another five billion years of life out of the sun.
And you said on StarTalk your podcast, you said that rather than humanity fleeing the solar system when the Sun eventually dies, assuming we make it that long, it may be easier to move Earth itself or to build artificial Suns. Yeah, so that's fine in the future, and then come on now. Let's let's have fun. Okay. Uh, that's fine. The future of the Sun will lose power in its core and very catastrophic things will happen. So. Oh, and by the way, the Sun is slowly like over billions of years, time is slowly getting hotter. So a billion years from now, it'll be too hot for where we are in our current orbit. So what can we do? We can possibly push Earth to a farther away orbit. Okay. So that we're still in the Goldilocks zone or Mars is already far away. Let's terraform Mars, and then everybody moves there. Or the Sun has a lot of fuel in its outer layers that never participated in the fusion in the core. If you could take the Sun and sort of stir it, bring fresh hydrogen into the core, you can give the Sun could be reborn basically and live for another five billion years. Or just ship everybody to another star system. For me, if I'm a betting person, I'd say let's stir the Sun. What is your gut on whether humans are going to stay in the game much longer. Yeah. I mean, we value our intelligence so much, but from a darn winning point of view, if we don't properly manage our own intelligence, it's our intelligence that could be the seeds of our own extinction. And from a Darwinian point of view, that means the intelligence did not make us more fit for survival, the survival of the fittest made us less fit. Meanwhile, the Roaches is standing around waiting for us to die. It's doing just fine. Well, the Roach kid doesn't have poetry or philosophy or art. Well, the Roaches still be here after we're here. And so that's all the Darwin cares about. Are you fit for survival in the world in which you're placed. So the short answer to your question is, while I see myself as a realistic optimist, I think the remains a chance that we we will not survive ourselves. And I think that chance is smaller than many people would otherwise say. And I give that because evolutionarily, it's expected that you would be distracted. Preoccupied thinking about that, which will kill you. Of course, because you don't want to die. Why is every sci-fi movie? You go into space and something bad happens. Why is that the plot of every single sci-fi movie? It's understandable because evolutionarily, we don't want to die. You want to pay attention to the line and the grass and not the bird on the branch. So, so I get that. So following our emotions, we will portray a bleak future bleaker than what is likely in my read of this. Have you ever heard the theory that the reason why we haven't met aliens is that every civilization that's ever reached a certain point developed an AI that ultimately killed them. Yeah, this is very anthropic. Oh, no pun intended. And for Pomorfic, I should say, where we're thinking that other aliens have exactly the same challenges we do. Maybe all the aliens are completely peace loving. And their intelligence is not one that puts their own lives at risk. Why assume everybody's like us. Most life on Earth is not like us. And we have DNA and common. I'm disappointed that most aliens in Hollywood are humanoid. I mean, think about it. You know, I had two eyes and nose mouth ears, neck, shoulders, arms, legs, torso, fingers and feet. And they walk and they breathe our air. Really? Really? Like I said, most life on Earth with whom we have DNA and common looks nothing like us. There's an alien from another planet that doesn't have DNA and common with us or doesn't have DNA at all. And you're going to and you're going to be phenotypically human. Do you realize a banana and humans have 25% identical genes? A banana and humans. So an alien that has no genes and common at all should look at least as different from humans as humans and bananas look from each other. I like the aliens in that movie of rival. That was good, there's septipoidal aliens, sort of, there's seven legs. That was trying to do something different, although it did resemble something else on Earth. - Like a crab or a-- - No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, they're floating in these tanks like this and they put squid, ink, whatever their species, ink, on the screen, you're not confusing it with Project Hail Mary. - No, no, no, sorry, no. - Because that alien is crab-like, and that's Andy Weir, who says, "I'm not going to fall for this Hollywood," by the way, he's a software engineer turned novelist, I'm not going to fall for this humanoid stuff. So he created a life form that basically made a rock, and it's crab-boyed, and it lives in high atmospheric pressure and breath ammonia. Take that, Hollywood. - Speaking of the survival of the species and Hollywood, you had Spielberg, Steve Spielberg, on the show, after he put out Disclosure Day. - Yes, which I also liked, although I realized I might be in the minority on that one, I liked that movie. - The movie had a point, and he made that point on the show, and I'm going to read it back to you and see if you would get a point. - You're quoting from my interview with him. - On the start talk. He said, "The thesis of the film is empathy," and he called it, and here I'm quoting him again on your show, "The foremost necessary evolutionary quality, "a rejection of this understanding is leading to our extinction." You talked before about managing our intelligence as the variable that could lead to our extinction. Is that in opposition or in agreement with the idea that it's actually about empathy? - I don't think empathy is a mysterious emotion. The challenge is how far from your genetic family will you extend your empathy? Is it just your cousins and aunts and uncles and sisters and brothers? Is it your neighbor? Is it the people living in the next town? Does that extend to plant life? I remember this Gary Larson comic, where there's this huge tree that this guy just cut down, and the guy's telling his young son, "Look, Timmy, here the tree survived three hurricanes, and here to tornadoes, and he's looking at the rings of the tree, and all the things the tree survived after he cut it down." I know there are people have written extensively against empathy. There's an idea of them, and I think that it's a provocative title, of course, but there may be cases where expressing empathy is not in the best interest of the person for whom you're expressing it, because they're going through a challenge that they must overcome, so that they become a better person on the other side of it. You can export psychologically that way, and the problem is if you say people need to pick themselves up by their bootstraps, but, of course, some people have no boots. So I'm quoting Jesse Norman, that I was on the same program with her, and she commented that your own bootstraps only works when you have shoes to pull up. So I don't know that I would say that's the one thing. I mean, we have the urge to find a magic pill. This is the one thing if everybody did this, we'd all be fine. We'll try this or eat the, eat kale, okay? We'll try. You know, at this, I think that's lazy. I think real answers are typically far more complex, take a little more effort and energy to explore, to learn and implement. So I think I value empathy, and I always want more of it within me. I carry enough to know that I have it, and when I invoke it, but, like I said, I think I room for more. So, yet, do you have empathy for other creatures? If you don't have empathy for dogs or other animals on earth, how are you going to have empathy for an alien? In fact, there are no laws against killing an alien. Think about it. It's killing a human. That's the law. Now, if the alien comes down to clearly more intelligence than you because they arrived in a spaceship, and we hadn't left low earth orbit in 50 years, clearly they're smarter than us. What do you do about that? So my philosophy there, if I call it not really a philosophy, it's just every animal on earth has to kill a living thing for its own survival. Every animal. If you choose to say I'm going to kill plants instead of other animals, that's a choice you're making, but you're still killing a living thing. Just be honest with yourself. But here's one, you don't like killing animals, and you live in a house with a basement, and they're mice in the basement. So you together.
But what do you call me? Cumein mouse traps. Okay, you capture the mouse. When you capture it, what do you then do with it? - Let it go. - You let it go outside, okay? Where it is guaranteed to be eaten by some woodland creature. So hawk owl, they're the tastiest snacks in the woods. So the average life expectancy of a mouse in the wild is between six and nine months. In captivity, it can live five or six years. So you want to be nice to the mouse? Leave it in your basement. Let it run in the warmth of your basement. Meanwhile, your house is probably made of wood. The wood of the redeed of 50 trees that would have lived a hundred years. But they didn't, 'cause they were cut down. Trees that housed birds and squirrels and chipmunks and fungus and all manner of life. And every day a tree generates the weight of a mouse in oxygen for everybody else to breathe. What do you think nature cares more about? The tree or the mouse? Think about that. That's how I think about it, holistically. - Just to go back to the top of the conversation, you just describe yourself as pretty happy guy. I'm curious. - I'm happier than most people I've met. Based on when I see and hear them comment on things that bring them anger, distress, or sadness, yes. - What are the biggest challenges if any to your happiness? Is there anything that threatens it or what are the biggest vexations or problems in your life? Or is actually, no, it's all quite smooth. - No, okay, that would misrepresent it. I think happiness is how you navigate things that might otherwise zenge you down a hole. It's what you do about it. How do you think about it? Is this something you cannot control? That's the famous semi-prayer, you know. - Serenity prayer. - Thank you. - I forgot that it's called Lord grant me the power to change the things I can to accept the things I cannot and the power to know the difference or the wisdom. That's the serenity prayer, okay. So if I know I don't have control of the outcome, I don't have control of the outcome. It doesn't get under my skin. If I can control the outcome, I can touch it in a way where I can maximize benefit to the many, I'm gonna do it. - Mm-hmm. - And by the way, these trolley questions, you ever see this? - There's a train coming down the track, do you push somebody over a trolley onto the oncoming train or something like that? - Right, right, it's do you, it's testing your, yes, I think it is morality, but it's testing how you make decisions in moral situation. Yes, so you have a, you're on a train and the train splits. And if you go this way, you kill two people who are strapped to the track, okay. But they're older people. If you go this way, you kill a younger person who's strapped to the track, what do you do, okay. And I made that up, but that's very emblematic of the kinds of questions. - Yeah, that sounds right. - I didn't vent the way to stop the train. (laughing) Okay, I'm not accepting your parameter. I'm cleverer than your experiment, okay. They hate it when I tell them that because they try to probe things. I'm four years older than my sister. So she entered high school, I entered college at the same time. Okay, I came back for holidays and I said, oh, let's go out for lunch. Where do you wanna go? And she said, what are my choices? In that moment, I realized we had been getting multiple choice exams our entire life. So decision making did not involve an original thought. It involved picking choices supplied by somebody else. And I said, I refuse to give you choices. Come up with something on your wife. And she was like, oh my gosh, what am I gonna do? Where am I gonna go? - So, I think in most situations in life, if you have experience, life experience, you have a certain talents. Let's say you're a nurse, you have certain powers that other people don't have, of understanding human physiology and you can save someone's life, this sort of thing. So yeah, the power to change the things you can. Oh, so other things, you said, what gets in the way of my habits, I'm an optimistic realist. I'm not just all optimistic 'cause that could blind you to things that could have bad outcomes that you might have prevented if you look back on it. I'll give a public talk. And I invest a lot of effort and energy and psychomotor efforts. People, two counts of people come up to me after they say, you know, you haven't such a good time on a stage. Okay, I got to crack jokes and things. And another person will say, Neil, you were working hard up there. To a person, those are school teachers. School teachers know what I'm doing. You were working hard. So when people say, oh, did you have a good time? That's not how I think about it. I ask, was I effective? Because if I evaluate everything I do about whether I was having a good time, that would mean sometimes I'm not having a good time and then I'm miserable. It's not how I evaluate events of my life. As an educator, as a scientist, I'm asked to participate. At the end, was I effective? Could I have been more effective? What can I do differently next time to improve that? That did I have a good time. When I have a good time, ask me after I come back from the beach. (laughing) Do what else I'd like? I like sitting on a big comfy couch, eating popcorn with slightly too much butter because slightly too much butter is just the right amount. (laughing) Watching a blockbuster movie with my family on the couch with me. That's a happy day. And you can say, are you happy? I said yes, and that's not am I effective. - Okay, let me, that leads to my last question. We've got this little segment we're doing now to close the show. It's called What's Good. And in this segment, I asked the guest like, what is something good you have experienced recently like a movie, and in this case probably a movie, a record, whatever that you would recommend to others. - I don't recommend things to people 'cause that implies that I have my likes and dislikes and I wanna place the likes and dislikes on you. I'm not gonna say don't see this movie at suck. I'm not gonna say that 'cause you might like the movie. - You are basically doing to me what you do to the trolley experiment people. - Yes, I know. But I can, I'm gonna come around to back side here 'cause watch this, okay? I have a list here, I'm not gonna read it all to you. So I decided this maybe eight months ago to make a list of things I like. - Oh, okay. Have you ever revealed this? - It's not published, but I have read bits of it. - Okay. - But one day I'll find some way to publish it, okay? I like old lines and new friends. I like old books and new ideas. I like simple thoughts written with fancy pens. I like when people speak their thoughts, but sing their feelings. I like words and language for they empower me to communicate with fellow humans. I like mathematics and physics for they allow me to commune with the cosmos. I like magic tricks as reminders that I can still be fooled. I like both the kit and the caboodle, but the caboodle is more fun. This goes on and on and on. But what I found, I found this to be quite, I'm not cathartic as the right word, I found it to be quite, I'm not coming up with these as new likes. These are things I've always liked. And now I took the occasion to write them down. And this happiness that I described to you about me, I think is sustained by my experiencing what's in this list with some frequency each day. - Beautiful. - It's a feeding mechanism. - Wow, that's cool. - Such a pleasure to have you on the show. Thank you for making time. - Well, thanks for the shout out for the books. - I want to shout it out again, please, yeah. - Just for everybody watching and listening, the most recent book is called Lost in Space 5,000 Facts and Advocate to Universe. Also, Neil hosts an excellent podcast called Star Talk. And you should, if you live in New York City or happen to be visiting, go to the Hayden Planetarium at the American Museum of Natural History, anything I missed. - No, and in there, you'll come out with a cosmic perspective. - Yes. - And you'll feel good about it. - Small and a good way. - Neil, thank you again, appreciate it. - Thanks. - Thank you very much for watching and/or listening today, really appreciated if you want to hook me up. And I know a podcast hosts ask for this all the time, but there's a reason why we ask for it because it's genuinely helpful. If you want to hook me and my team up, follow us and like us and rate us and review us on whatever platform you're consuming the show right now. Share with your friends.
and follow us on social media, it all genuinely helps us grow. Now on to the credits. Thank you so much to everybody who worked so hard to make this show. 10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson, Boris S. Schneiderman, DJ Kashmir, David Hart, and Hayden Broome. Post-production is handled by the great folks over at Greenhorn Creative, and Nick Thorburn of the Great Indy Rock Band, islands wrote our theme. Thank you for listening, deuces.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Neil deGrasse Tyson defines happiness as a state of joy, comfort, and the desire to repeat positive experiences, rooted in doing what one loves.
He links personal happiness to aligning one’s life with passions from a young age, arguing that if everyone pursued their unique interests, society would become significantly more fulfilling.
The loss of meaningful friction and experience in modern life—such as the physical journey to observe a telescope—has diminished the emotional depth and wonder of scientific exploration.
Ossification, or intellectual and emotional stagnation, is a key cause of suffering and polarization, rooted in the failure of education systems to foster curiosity and critical inquiry.
Science and skepticism, grounded in repeatable evidence and peer validation, offer a more reliable path to truth than opinion or emotion.
A cosmic perspective—like seeing Earth as a tiny dot in the universe—induces a sense of awe and connection, not insignificance, and fosters humility and wonder.
Empathy should extend beyond humans to all living beings, and decisions involving life or death must be guided by holistic, ecological thinking.
True happiness comes not from avoiding stress, but from actively engaging with challenges, learning new things, and evaluating one’s effectiveness rather than just emotional comfort.
Summary:
Neil deGrasse Tyson shares a deeply reflective perspective on happiness, rooted in doing what one loves and embracing curiosity. He argues that aligning one’s life with passions from childhood leads to profound personal fulfillment and a more vibrant world. The modern world’s erosion of physical and emotional friction—such as the pilgrimage to observe telescopes—has diminished the awe and wonder once central to scientific exploration.
Tyson criticizes intellectual stagnation, or “ossification,” which arises from education systems that prioritize memorization over inquiry. He emphasizes that true understanding comes through evidence, repetition, and skepticism, not opinion or emotion. A cosmic perspective, such as seeing Earth as a pale blue dot, fosters awe and a sense of belonging in the universe, not insignificance.
He advocates for expanding empathy to include all life forms and for decisions to reflect ecological and holistic truths. Ultimately, happiness isn't about avoiding difficulty but about actively engaging with life, learning daily, and measuring success through effectiveness, not just emotional comfort. Tyson’s insights, drawn from both astrophysics and personal experience, offer a powerful model for human flourishing in a world increasingly dominated by misinformation and emotional reactivity.
FAQs
The title is a tongue-in-cheek way to counter the over-promising of self-help solutions. It represents under-promising and over-delivering, emphasizing that happiness comes from realistic, grounded approaches rather than quick fixes.
He defines happiness as feeling joy, comfort, and delight from things he wants to repeat, like gazing at the night sky. He also values experiences that bring a sense of wonder and connection to something greater than himself.
Doing what you love aligns with your passions and talents, creating a sense of purpose and fulfillment. For Neil, the joy of observing the cosmos and the sense of being part of a larger story deeply enriches his life.
Yes, Neil believes modern life lacks friction—challenging experiences that push us out of comfort. He argues that friction, like physical effort or intellectual discomfort, builds strength, resilience, and personal growth.
This insatiable pursuit can stem from a lack of 'enoughness'—a sense that life is never sufficient. Neil suggests this leads to unhappiness, as true contentment comes from appreciating what we have, not chasing more.
Looking up at the universe makes people feel both small and vast. Neil believes this perspective brings a sense of awe and belonging, reminding us that we are part of a cosmic story and that life is meaningful on a grand scale.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.