Naomi Klein discusses the dangers of data centres, Steve Bannon’s hip hop musical and why our tech overlords want to be edgelords
1h 6m 44s
Naomi Klein and Astrotailer’s new book, *End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World*, exposes a dangerous political alliance forming between Christian nationalists, tech billionaires, and far-right movements. This coalition, exemplified by events like the "apocalypse ball" hosted by venture capitalist Peter Teal, blends anti-woke ideology, conspiracy theories, and visions of technological utopia with a deep fear of collapse. Klein highlights how figures like Steve Bannon and Elon Musk use rhetoric of crisis and exile to rally support, often redirecting anger toward scapegoats like trans athletes or immigrants. Despite their divergent ideologies—ranging from religious purity to AI-driven immortality—these movements share a belief in a fractured world that justifies retreat into bunkers or digital realms. The book critically examines the environmental costs of AI expansion, especially large data centers that pollute communities, displace workers, and undermine public trust. Klein also confronts the politicization of Zionism and anti-Semitism, arguing that ethno-nationalism under any banner leads to human rights violations and social collapse. She notes that while the political landscape appears fragmented, a growing grassroots resistance—seen in community opposition to data centers—signifies a potential for unity against destructive forces. Ultimately, the book calls for awareness and action, urging readers to recognize the ideological underpinnings of extremism and to defend a shared, sustainable future rooted in democratic values and environmental responsibility.
(upbeat music) - Hello there. Welcome to another episode of The Louis Theroux Podcast. (upbeat music) Today I'm joined by Canadian journalist author and activist best known for her writing on capitalism, corporate power and the climate crisis, Naomi Klein. Naomi has a new book out called End Times Fascism and the fight for the living world. Co-written with astrotailer and it looks at what they see as an increasingly powerful alliance between Christian nationalists, Silicon Valley billionaires and the far right. All things I'm interested in and have even made a few programs about. We discuss the book and the urgency of its manifesto in the chat. We also discuss the themes of Naomi's previous book, "Doppelganger," in which she follows her namesake, feminist author turned conspiracy theorist, Naomi Wolf, down the rabbit hole. I mean, she basically explores the ways in which Naomi Wolf, who's also a feminist author, did I say that, has come unglued politically, ideologically, come to associate herself with or promote conspiracy theories. And that becomes the jumping off point for an exploration of what she calls the mirror world, this world of populist conspiracy theorists, defrocked political commentators, canceled celebrities, Russell Brand, springs to mind. In Naomi Wolf's case, what happened was she had a book out and she appeared on Radio 4 and it was unmasked live on air. Well, unmasked is a strong word, but a significant factual inaccuracy at the heart of the book was disclosed to Naomi Wolf. And then alongside that, or possibly partly because of that, she became more and more fascinated in conspiracy theories and fully embraced well conspiracy culture and became a kind of fellow traveler to aspects of the megaverse. And then because Naomi Klein kept getting confused with Naomi Wolf, that put it on her radar and was awkward and then weird that there were two Naomi's, which was constantly coming up against this mirror version, funhouse mirror version of herself. If you're struggling with your Naomi's, there is a mnemonic. If the Naomi be Klein, then you're fine. If the Naomi be Wolf, oh buddy, oof, oof, sweet. It doesn't rhyme with wolf. That's the number I didn't make up the mnemonic. If you could think of a better one, Klein fine, wolf, oof, there you go. The book also features former aide and strategist to Trump's Steve Bannon. Naomi Klein found herself endlessly listening to Bannon and finally that Naomi Wolf was popping up on Steve Bannon's show. So we talk about that. Naomi grew up in a Jewish family in Montreal. We discuss her views on Israel and Zionism. We also talk generally more about the American political scene and the rise of fascism, what she calls fascism. Others may disagree. The politics of the end times and much, much more. We recorded this interview in September this year. It's Spotify HQ. Naomi came by as part of her promotional tour, Astrotailer was not here. And I think that's all you really need to know, other than the warning that this conversation contains adult themes, as well as much else besides all of that coming up. Louie. Naomi. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you for joining. We're just going to roll straight in. All right, honey. Make the most of our time. Sounds good. You know, I wanted to speak to maybe even a year ago, after I read the previous book, "Doppelganger." Yep. And then it didn't happen for whatever reason. And then the new book came out. So then I thought, perfect. Or I don't know how it worked. But anyway, we hooked it up. So I'd like to talk to you about both of them. Sure. If that's all right. I see them as connected. They're kind of connected. One is more personal. Like the first one, "Doppelganger" is a story about, I guess, the populist right who've taken on the garb of some aspects of progressivism and who you have your own counterpart in the form of a namesake. Naomi Wolf. So that's a kind of personal story that also is a political story in a sort of sense of taking, you know, reading the runes of our times. The new one is, in a way, a more straightforward, polemic about what you describes end times fascism. Some people have taken issue with the word fascism. They have. You know, I've been struck that it's easier to talk about words than talk about what the words describe. Like there's a way in which we get bogged down in these definitions. And it's fine to debate definitions if we eventually talk about what we're talking about. But if you only are just debating what to call something, then you end up running out the clock before you can talk about the thing. I agree. I think that's a good way of putting it. There's sort of three main strands to the so-called or the designated fascism. Religious part, a techno-libertarian part, and then a sort of ethno-nationalist kind of militarized bunker mentality part. So can we start by talking about the apocalypse ball because it's a scene-setting event early in the book. And it kind of crystallizes who parts of this new coalition really are. Yes, sure. Right. So just to back up a little bit, like what I was trying to understand in the book, what my co-author and I astrotailer were trying to understand is like, what is this kind of Frankenstein coalition that brought Trump back to power, right? And these were all important parts of Trump's coalition. Right. So my interest in them isn't just academic. It's that they are a real world coalition, that despite huge differences came together and agreed Donald Trump as the guy who should be president of the United States. And some of them were with him the first time, but some of them were new. At the inauguration, there was a lot of surprise to see the titans of Silicon Valley lined up with better seats than the members of cabinet. So that wasn't true for his first administration. In fact, he was in conflict with a lot of these guys. So, but yeah, so that ball took place four days before the election of Donald Trump. It was a ball attached to a conference that was convened by Peter Teal, the venture capitalist founder of Palantir. He likes the secret society, Peter Teal. So there's a lot of, it's kind of half secret, like there's a website, but people don't put their real names on the program. They can have blank name tags, they can use pseudonyms. They don't share the whole, the program. So it was sort of semi, semi public. And then they had something called an apocalypse ball. And it was at a fancy hotel in Miami called the Fahina. And the tagline was, if you aren't trying to destroy the world, maybe you aren't trying hard enough. So it was kind of trolley, edge lordy, was the vibe. You know, it was kind of, we're so edgy. People who went to the apocalypse ball were encouraged to dress up, you know, in risque costumes. So there was somebody who was dressed up as a Haitian chef. And he had like cats and dogs stuffed animals hanging from his apron. So that was a reference to the Haitians are killing or eating cats and dogs. They're reading about the lives. This famous Donald Trump lie that he told it one of the debates. Yeah. But so the idea was just like here we were leaning into how just anti woke we are. But just like we we're going to say the unsamble and really float close to the edge with fascism. Like if you've got a session called you might be a eugenicist, you're, you know, you're pushing the envelope pretty far. Brian Johnson was there teaching people how to live forever. He's been on the podcast. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know what caught your attention about it. Oh, well, it's one of those things where it's so weird and ludicrous that you're not quite sure what eyes are read. I'm never quite sure how seriously to take it. Yeah. And clearly as you acknowledge mixed in with it is a kind of trolling urge. Yeah. Like we're going to be exactly as creepy and bizarre as you think we are. Therefore, undercutting or thereby undercutting any preempting any critique you may make because you're taking us too seriously. Right. So so in the book we say they want to be they want to be both our overlords and our edge lords and so yeah, it is destabilizing. And it's clever because because you you feel a bit foolish taking them seriously. But of course, four days later, Donald Trump is elected and many of the people at the ball end up, you know, with real influence in the Trump in this new Trump administration. And no one more so than Peter Teal. And by the way, unlike most of the tech oligarchs who have lined up behind Trump, Peter Teal did support him in his first.
term. He backed him and, you know, he has been openly talking about giving up on democracy since 2009. Yeah, it's taking the libertarian story that I've been writing about for a long time about sort of privatizing, you know, you privatize every part of the state until there's nothing left but to like start your own private country. And so he, he has funded various projects where people try to start their own corporate city states. There was, he had an idea called Sea Steading. Remember that. Right? Start your own country on a oil ring. I feel like that hasn't gone that well. The Sea Steading. Sea Steading has turned out rich people don't actually want to live on oil rigs. They like it on land. So then he's been part of a project to, it's kind of like a free trade zone in Honduras. It's called Prospera. So it's a beautiful island that they have, they, they've started their own sort of country. It's basically like a, basically a gated community with a deregulated med spa in it. It's confusing because, and there's attention in the book between these guys, these tech bros, tech oligarchs, and they're urged to remake nations, right, to kind of be subcontractors in some new project of American renewal. And, and many of them have contracts with the government. And as you said, turned up at the inauguration to support Trump. But then there's this secessionist quote, exit kind of dimension where they're like, you know what? We're going to just either live in bunkers or go into space. Those feel there at odds, those two things. They are at odds, definitely. And this is why there's attention. I mean, in that they're presenting themselves as, as, as heretics, you know, voices in the wilderness, no one's listening to them. But then they're not marginal. They're, they're very powerful. They, they lead multi-billion dollar companies. You know, I can't make sense of it. I don't think it's my job to make it make sense. So there is this dream of exodus, like leaving the state. But on the other hand, they are, are clearly extremely interested in states and the infrastructure of existing states. They want contracts. They, they're interested in impunity, in immunity, which is something that states can grant. And in fact, maybe the bunkers and the rockets are a hedge, right? Because they think, well, maybe civil society will function and everyone will be happy. But maybe it won't, in which case, there'll be total social and political collapse. And we will need to retreat into bunkers in Argentina and Maui, where in fact, I think some of them are being built. Yes. Zuckerberg's in Hawaii, Ellison's in Hawaii, yeah. And, and I think Teal's, Teal from choosing New Zealand has switched his, his prospects to Argentina, I guess, liking it. I think some people have multiple bunkers because you don't know where, where, where, where we'll be safe. More than, yeah, with one's good, then two is better. But, you know, the, like, I, I think when we started writing the book, I thought there would be a lot more about the bunkers. The bunkers, the distraction. I think they are a bit of a distraction. Like, I'm more interested in the dream of AI itself as a kind of a rapture fantasy. Like, well, I was interested in that. So, Musk, you've, you've quoted, I think he might have been on Joe Rogan's podcast, saying, increasingly it appears that humanity is a biological bootloader for, I wish I could do the accent. That was a tweet. Was it? He said, increasingly it appears, humanity is a biological bootloader for digital super intelligence. A bootloader, I think is a computer term, right? You put some software in order to. We're grist for Grock. We grist for Grock. We're machine food. It's like the Matrix. Yeah. It does matter that he was mad that day. He was mad because there were a lot of protests against Doge. Okay. So, he was in a bad mood. He was in a bad mood because people were, I think, quite smartly expressing their anger at the fact that he was shutting down federal agencies and laying off huge numbers of workers by protesting at Tesla and the Tesla stocks were starting to go down. So, he was quite angry that day. That feels like important context, because he's also on record getting into a feud with another tech guy who accused him of speciesism because he said, "I prefer humans over AI." So, he kind of speaks out of both sides of his mouth in terms of where he stands on the future of humanity. Well, look, he used to be very. he used to be very doomer about AI. Yes, he knows. He has this long standing feud with Google, because they were ahead in the AI race. And so, he and Sam Altman teamed up to start open AI. And the reason they did that was because they couldn't let Google be the first to reach AGI or superintelligence, because that would end to the world in their view. So, they needed a non-profit, and they needed to do it to make sure that it was good, and Musk talked about being worried that they would summon a demon. That's right. And then Altman decided, "No, open AI is just going to race Google, and it's going to be for profit too." And then Musk was like, "Damn you," and started XAI, which is also for profit. So, the end result is they're all calling each other evil, and they're all for profit. Companies racing each other to the same goal, which many of them have said, "Yeah, it's very, very dangerous, but not so dangerous that they're not doing it." So. We. I mean, just to be. it would be boring if I just agreed with everything. Please don't. Okay. So, did you watch Elon Musk's interview with Xanimate and Beto's? No. It's worth a watch. It's not that long. And in the interview, he said, "AI will create, quote, an age of amazing abundance where anyone can have anything they think of." Blah, blah, blah. If you have vast numbers of robots with vast amounts of digital intelligence, you have a sort of quasi-infinite economy. Yeah, I did. I did see access to it. Money won't matter in 2036. Work will be optional. That's the one way you say it. He's painting this kind of Marxian utopia where people just chill out and have fun all day because there's super abundance. Absolutely. Yeah, it's heaven, actually. I mean, that's why. You know, I'm interested in the parallels between the vision of the future that in one of their rapturous moods, the tech folks will paint and the similarities with, you know, if you were to speak to somebody like a messianic Jew on the West Bank and ask them what heaven was like, it would all just be lawling a bit around reading the Talmud with the secrets of the universe unlocked. And also, like that religious story, the dream, you know, there's the Jewish version, there's a Muslim version, it's in all the Abrahamic religions. It's at its most literal in the, you know, Christian evangelicals who literally believe in the rapture and this idea that there's going to be like a moment when suddenly the faithful get magicked into a golden city in the sky and leave their clothes behind and stuff. But even if you don't believe in that extreme vision, a lot of what organized religion has taught is a hatred of the material world, or at least like an association of the material world with sin. And so one wants to de-materialize, to be free of the prison, the prison of the material of the animate of the body. And I think there's an argument that can be made that that idea that that the goal is ascendance from the material from the animate has not helped us be good caretakers of this earth that that, you know, I happen to believe, you know, our duty as humans is to protect life, you know, and to enhance life. So yeah, so there is this tension, but what I think what is striking about mosque, whatever, you know, he believes different things on different days, but what we do know is that he is building data centers that are enormous. So his like the race to AI, whatever stories they're telling, is in fact like draining our physical material world. It is not good for the earth that in this very consequential moment in on the clock of the climate, as we're seeing disasters spread globally. That's not our imagination. We really are, you know, saying goodbye to the potential to keep warming below 1.5 degrees. We've had UN reports. This is real, you know. They have found a new way to burn a whole lot, a whole lot more fossil fuels in a race that we haven't asked for. Nobody, nobody asked whether we believe this race of the Titans is the best way to spend these really consequential years. So I guess I'm interested, not just in the stories, but how the stories justify a real world attack on our one and only planet. Just to be again, take it to a very basic place. What would be so bad?
about having a data center in your neighborhood? Well, they are absolutely massive. I mean, they're several football stadium size. And I think the problem is that people are not convinced they're doing some good, right? And even in the battles over like an oil pipeline, right? And it's interesting because we have a chapter about Memphis and the battle over Elon Musk building. He built a huge debt, the world's largest supercomputer and called it Colossus after this science fiction novel and film where the AI's take over the nukes. And it doesn't end well. So it seems like a strange decision to name a colossus. That's a musk all over, isn't it? Yeah, and then he opened another one, then he opened another, now he's opening a fourth. So what's the problem? Okay, the problem is noise. They're very loud, they never turn off. In Memphis, the trouble is they are powered by methane gas and he's built, oh, he's rigged together his own power stations. So they're just spewing methane into the community. And the problem is that when they don't rigged together their own methane and they just tap into the grid, it sends people's electricity prices soaring because they're using so much electricity. There are also concerns about water and there's debates about how much water they use. But then there's also concerns about the end product, right? So because like if, for, if it were, the reason why it was interesting around Memphis is that the group that organized to fight the data centers called Memphis Communities Against Pollution. But originally, that group was called Memphis Communities Against the Pipeline because they formed to oppose an oil pipeline that was planned to go through the same community. And they won that battle. But what was interesting was that when this pipeline company was trying to convince the community that they should accept this oil pipeline running through their backyards, they made this presentation where they had a table and on the table were a bunch of products produced with petroleum products like they had like lycra clothing and they had baby diapers, things like that. And the message was we all use products made from oil. So you might not want the oil in your backyard but you want the end product. And I think the reason why we have this data center uprising is because people are really not sure they want the end product, right? They may use it and maybe, you know, kind of convenient. But they also have questions about what this is doing to mental health and they don't love the idea of AI teaching their kids or being their nurse. They don't love what it's doing to our ability to differentiate between what is real and what is fake. And so the end product is under question and, you know, Musk originally decided to go to Memphis because there was an empty building there which would allow him to move faster and catch up faster to the companies that had started before him. And the reason why there was an empty building there was because there had been an Electrolux factory. Electrolux makes homophiliances. Yeah, this one was many ovens. And when Electrolux had moved to Memphis a few years earlier and promised to create thousands of jobs, in the end they only created 700 jobs and then they ended up closing and I think moving to Mexico or somewhere else. But now in that building is just a bunch of computers and a few security guards, right? So you really see how little they're offering because they're moving in that building used to employ 700 people. And, you know, even if it was producing pollution, those people had jobs and they had wages and the wages stayed in the community. But they're really breaking the kind of basic deal of industrialization, which is okay, there's some pollution and there's some noise, there's a lot of jobs and we're making products you use and you like. And now it's like, you don't like the product, you don't get the jobs. We're looking into ways of replacing the security guards with robot dogs. For real? For real? Yeah. It's just a bad deal, you know? I'm about to have a robot dog. No, you would. Do you use AI? No. At all? No. So far as you can avoid it, you don't use it. I sometimes have it switched on if I'm doing a Google search. Yeah. And then an answer pops up. You can disable that. I know you can. Yeah. I know you can. There's a part of me that wants to understand it a little better and sometimes using it can help you to understand it. You know, a bit like Twitter or Facebook or these other platforms where it's, but certainly the infinite scroll, that phenomenon of getting narcotized by an endless entertainment feed. Yeah. I feel like I understand a little better why that's not healthy from being exposed to it. Yeah. Does that make sense? Yeah. I do think, like, I'm glad I understand social media, but I feel like it's had a pretty negative effect on my time management. And I think as somebody who works in the realm of ideas and thought, like, I don't want to go down that road. I understand why people use it as a time-saving device. I think that there are uses of it that are, you know, less insidious. But when it comes to like thinking and I end research, like, what I worry about with what Google is doing with Google embedding it in all the searches is, I mean, it's already having such a negative impact on journalism. Like, these tech companies have already had a, like, taken a lot of the traffic away from news sites. And now what those embedded searches do is mean that you don't click on the link and you don't go to a news site. And it's one more thing that is driving, you know, journalism into the ground. So, yeah, I don't want to be part of that. Because I think it's part of a process where these companies gain a monopoly on truth on where we're able to get information. Like, there's this ongoing lawsuit against open AI from the New York Times and a couple other journalists to go outlets. I mean, and at one point, I think, is a Microsoft executive who says, this is what will probably be seen as the greatest theft of all time. Like, they knew that. So, yeah, so I think it's, we shouldn't. [laughs] One of the people who wants more regulation of AI is Steve Bannon. This is my segue. Uh-huh, okay. Why don't you tell the listeners and the viewers who Steve Bannon is? And it kind of relates to your previous book, doesn't it? So, Steve Bannon is, he came to prominence when he was Donald Trump's campaign manager in his first election campaign, and then he was his chief strategist. He wrote a hip-hop musical. Did you know that? He has had a life. Did you know about the hip-hop musical? No, I didn't. Because I've got research on that. Okay, let's hear it. I think it was based on Carrier Linus, the Shakespeare play. And the one of the lyrics was something about, my peeps are chilling at the crib. It was very basic. It was very root one, hip-hop speak, cringe to the max. Well, he also has a podcast called The War Room. That's a streaming show. Which has its theme music is sort of a rap song sung by a Chinese billionaire. The main lyric is, "Let's take down the CCP." I have a theory that Steve Bannon, I'm going to road test it. I've never said it in public before. But he's kind of the mirror world, Michael Moore. Because he presents somewhat similarly. They both got slightly schlubby, scruffy, all American presentation. Michael Moore's always got his baseball cap. Steve Bannon's always got this carkey jacket. And it actually makes a plausible fist of railing against elites. And speaking for the regular man. And I don't want to mix with those Davos, Liberals. The Davos class. Yeah, the Davos class people. And in fact, as you say like, there's a part of it that kind of, if you squint at it, is reminiscent of aspects of progressivism. And he doesn't like the tech oligarchs, right? Right. So yeah, so I started listening to Steve Bannon a lot when I was writing my book "Doppelganger." I listened to hundreds of hours of him during the pandemic. It was very unhealthy habit because he's on every day, for quite some time. But yeah, I was on like whatever that book. I was following my own doppelganger down the rabbit hole and she became a regular guest on that show. She was on every day sometimes. They did a book together. And he was interested in her because during the pandemic, he was a major platform for people who believed that the vaccines were a plot, the vaccine verification apps, were part of bringing Chinese style social credit to the United States. And that this was all, like there were various contradictory conspiracies that he platformed. But there was certainly a through line that big tech was the enemy. And so when Trump aligned himself with these tech companies at inauguration, I was very happy.
curious to try to to know how this was going to go and what was your fascination with it why do you think you felt that the urge to listen to so much there was there was all the South like almost like a kind of what is it psychological like some kind it was not just research is it well I felt like a guilty pleasure I mean I really felt that I was witnessing a new political formation find itself in real time I was interested when Trump won the first time ban and play this really really important role in in delivering a lot of union guys over to Trump who felt who were furious from the rust belt who were furious about how free trade had destroyed their industrial towns and factory jobs right and you know for me I came up in the in the alter globalization movement you know my first book no logo was about these big protests that started happening outside the World Trade Organization and a new kind of anti-corporate politics that that's that kind of showed up in the late 90s and so I also thought that the Democrats and a lot of the like new labor had sold out their base by signing these corporate deals that the industrialized our countries enrolled back environmental laws and what Bannon did in 2016 is he harvested all of that anger that was directed at at the time and said like you can you know you can trust Trump he's gonna make America great again and it was all this kind of nostalgia bring the industrial jobs back and so I thought he was a pretty smart political strategist an operator and I knew how resident these issues were because like I said these this was like my political you know when I was in my 20s this was like my first political awakening I suppose and so what was interesting during the pandemic was watching Steve Bannon harvest the anger projected all on to the vaccine verification apps but he also had a correspondent who was named Joe Allen who was just talking about like transhumanism and how these guys don't really believe in humans anymore and they want to merge with the machines and that the anger was mostly like from a Christian perspective like like this is this is unchristian this is this is messing with God's plan but once again it sort of felt like Bannon is taking something that should by all rights be the purview of the left like the left should be taking on big tech but because there was a vacuum and and the Democrats were in bed with them he was running away with it and so I yeah like I thought it was inevitable that there would be a rupture within Trump's coalition when he decided after railing against big tech suing the tech companies for de-platforming him that it was inevitable that there were that this coalition would would have some trouble and that was part of the reason why a big part of the reason why I wanted to write this book was I like to better understand and help people better understand where they're vulnerable because I thought that people maybe didn't understand how much anger there was on the right against big tech part part of the narrative as well is the idea that while getting in bed with big tech the Democrats also just became overly focused on culture issues and you know forgot about the working class and also became overly sensorious and do you see I mean you've there's a couple of nods towards that in your books is that is that an analysis you share there was sort of policing of language to the extent where yeah people felt excluded and estranged and and one of the observations in your book is that if you make someone maybe this is tacit rather than explicit but if you make someone ashamed they'll find company where they don't feel ashamed is specifically no me wolf is ashamed because she's exposed as having made this huge academic blunder in one of her books she feels presumably humiliated embarrassed and in a sense although I don't like to use the term canceled and and then pops up in the shadow world where no one's worried about it and that across the board I think maybe in small ways people felt like they were being judged or censored and went to a place where they were feeling less judgment and that explains a lot about political migration yeah I mean I wrote about it a lot in doppelganger and it is something that I I was struck by when I was listening to banan was the way he was building this very broad tent the way he was sort of welcoming people who clearly had very different views than him like Naomi Wolf who was like a long-time feminist and obviously they disagreed on abortion rights but they were sort of putting all of that aside for the the battle against the vaccines but but but more than that he created an a sort of a culture where if you're on the team you're on the team you know if you're in that that's enough there weren't all kinds of litmus tests and the other person he did that with was RFK junior right who's another guy who sort of popped up on the other side of the fence but do you think recently AOC was quoted as saying you know where I'm going with this woke one was crazy which I think speaks to this maybe an aspect to the same issue do you think people got lost in in the kind of certain aspects of the debate at that time at that time they were talking about do you remember a cab yeah it stood for all cops of bastards and remember hearing that thing like well that doesn't sound that doesn't really I can't I don't think I'm lining up behind that yeah I mean I think that there were like there's always going to be slogans that are extreme you know on the left like that's not I don't think that's new I think part of it is that it's playing out in social media and getting amplified and and these these algorithms are like attracted like they amplify the most extreme positions and and they go where the anger is right so the things that get the most response whether denunciation or or or just like I don't know I just think that some of those slogans got more attention than they would have like I think they've been slogans like that the whole time I've been on the left but most people probably didn't know about it because they were fairly marginal um so but but I do think that the culture of expulsion of just of litmus tests of just everybody feeling like they have to watch themselves all the time as opposed to like building what my friend Kiangi amount of Taylor calls a welcoming left like a culture where people feel like they might build the community that they need because lots of you know we're not very good at building community anymore so you join an organization or you get involved in movement and it's gonna it has to be a place you'd want to spend some time in out of place where you're constantly afraid of making a mistake that leads to losing everything and so I like the only reason I'm hesitating is that I think that's that some of it is the left and some of it is social media and the fact that so much of this was playing out on platforms that we weren't fully in control of that were accentuating our worst habits and then the pandemic made it a lot worse because we were all at home and that was our whole world and then we kind of forgot how to do anything else after the pandemic so I do think that we're talking about an intersection of a tendency and a technology that that that that intensified it but I think I think big mistakes were made the quote that you're referring to about woke one I think it was an unfortunate choice of words on AOC's part as an elected official but I think that this is there needs to be introspection you know if I was going to be super real and maybe this is just very basic and you might find this embarrassing that I'm going so root one I feel like the progressive agenda on the environment most people can get behind are in terms of social welfare most people can get behind into care of the elderly most people can get behind infrastructure buses trains all those sort of democratic socialist basics I think when it comes to open borders people are like wait what and trans women in sports which I know it seems like wait that's such a relatively small issue but those last two I think got a lot of people off the bus so what clearly but what's interesting about what's happening now with this backlash against AI and data centers is we are now seeing the bipartisan left and right coming together agreeing maybe not agreeing on you know trans kids and sports and open borders but what if like agreeing we have a common platform we are like the
there's all kinds of reporting about people in neighbors apologizing to each other, you know, the last time town councils had this much, many people coming, you know, to come line up behind the mic. It was over trans athletes and or it was overbook banning. And now it's, we don't want this data center driving up our electricity costs. And you've neighbors apologizing to each other and going, God, I used to think you were the devil, you know, and now it's not that they're agreeing, it's not that they, it's not that they agree on everything, but they have decided that this battle for, you know, self-determination in their community, because the these, you know, the data centers are being foisted on them without their consent and they're being told that they, you know, even if the city council votes against it, they still have to have it. That this is more important, right? So I think, you know, we are in a moment where there is an unraveling, there are real crises and it's a kind of battle over whether the anger is going to go up or it's going to go down. And what somebody like Trump or Banan is really good at is sort of saying, you have a right to be angry at the world's going to hell. And it is all the fault of trans women in sports. It is all the fault of immigrants at the border. And don't talk about any of these systemic crises. Certainly, don't talk about the banks. And I'll, I know you're mad at the tech companies, but somehow I'm going to make that about trans sports, you know, I'm not actually going to go after the tech companies, right? And as we saw with Trump, it was the ultimate bait and switch. He was not mad at them at all the areas, very best friends, you know, they're at the White House all the time. So, you know, you hardest the anger, but you don't actually direct it at the larger targets, you always find a scapegoat. So, now it seems that people are coming together, they're not agreeing on everything, but they're agreeing that they have a broader agenda. And I think that's the most we can ask, because we're not going to agree on everything. Well, we're on the hot button topics. Would you call yourself an anti-zionist? I, yes, I oppose Zionism. I am non-zionist. This is a great, I don't mean this is a great example of the progressive and then the whatever you want to call it, populist or ethno-nationalist, kind of symmetry, because some people would say Zionism is racism, some people would say anti-zionism is racism. You hear both quite frequently. I mean, I've always thought that we should kind of measure projects based on their like real world effects. And and so I'm just looking like I think the debates about Zionism can get very academic because people have an idea of what they were told Zionism could be when they when they were a kid. But I'm looking at how it's actually played out in in in the real world. And and there were many people at the time who had like, I mean, I think that there were there was cultural Zionism, there was a form of Zionism that did not want to be a state, which was what Hunter Rent believed that believed in a kind of a by national project from the beginning. But once it became fused with the state. And I guess I would say that I'm against any fusing of of of religions with state projects. I think that is a very dangerous combination. And you know, whether it's Christian nationalism or the state project that is Zionism. I think it will necessarily end badly. You will start counting babies. Once you start counting Jewish babies versus not Jewish babies and making sure that you have a demographic majority, you are an ethno state. And that is not going to end well. And it is, it is, it is worse than I ever imagined. But I've always seen that and believed that to be a danger. I've done a little bit of reporting from the West Bank. So I've seen, you've seen the worst of it. I've seen what is de facto ethno cleansing, ethnic cleansing up close. But just to present the case, what you hear a lot is, well, this feels selective. We're hearing calls for boycotts of Israeli cultural institutions, Israeli sports people, athletes, much more loudly and frequently than we do of say Afghanistan, where there are obviously also horrific things you know, gender apartheid in Afghanistan specifically. Is there anything in that? Do you think? I mean, I always find it to be a strange debate because the principle that I try to follow is that when people are oppressed and Palestinian people have been under military occupation since 1967 in the West Bank and Gaza, have not had control over movement and borders, you know, and I've reported from both Gaza and one of the like few Western journalists who've been able to get in and reports been a long time. But when the siege was was on. So the idea that they've withdrawn from Gaza is like they never withdrew because they maintained control over, over access. And what got in and who got out? And so, so I think that the people have that that needs to end and and and that that boy that that people who are oppressed have a have a right to call for solidarity, right? And so the this comparison of what about here, what about there? They're they're in most of these cases there is not a boycott divestment and sanctions movement that has been identified by the people affected by these policies that our governments are generally supporting. Saying this will help us, right? I mean, South Africa is a good analogy because that was a call that came from the ANC and that was a call that came from people under living under apartheid saying this will help us end this apartheid, right? And so it, you know, if there was an equivalent campaign in another country, I would support it and I have supported in the past. So, so that's why I've supported that call. Do you see the idea of a of two states as realistic at this point? Do you? Have you been to the West Bank more recently than me? I don't see either. So now I was being very realistic, which is a strange thing to reflect on the idea of two states that the two populations are so intertwined, the settlement project is so far advanced, yeah, that it's there's no line you can really draw. Which there's been a very deliberate strategy. And the idea of a single state, I don't, it feels in theory more equitable, but I don't know how realistic it is politically. And then you're in the position of saying, well, I guess, if someone's, this is what political Zionism has produced. You know, and those settlers weren't just like doing it on their own. They they've you've seen it, they're guarded by soldiers. And this is a strategy, the political strategy of of the Israeli state has been to extinguish a horizon, a political horizon for a Palestinian state. And the settlers are just doing the work for them. Um, I think there are many parts of the Jewish community who still see themselves as connected with Israel. There's a they feel that there's a sense of nervousness in the Jewish community is a lot of fear and and and it said that there are many Jewish people moving to Israel because they no longer feel safe in the West. I don't know what those numbers are, even if that's true. I'd like to know the number. Yeah, but it doesn't seem like a very safe place. Um, do you what do you say to those people who say, well, you know, anti-Semitism is on the rise. Um, what we and what you often hear is like what we let's fight anti-Semitism and we have what you know, as Jewish is ready to proceed.
have one country. This is, you've probably heard this a lot, it's a common conversation piece in Israel. We have one country, they have, I don't know what they say, they meaning Muslim countries, they have 12 or 14, I don't know the number. So those, just to sort of, how do you respond to that? I live in Canada, I am a, I am a dual Canadian U.S. citizen, I'm not an Israeli citizen and I'm not as ionist. I want to fight anti-semitism where, like, I live, I believe that my elected politicians and the movements that I'm a part of should fight anti-semitism alongside all forms of discrimination because I believe that all people are equal and I, like, I believe that my safety, well, and Jewish safety is best guaranteed by supporting human rights and religious freedom and that we need to do that here and I don't think that has anything to do with Israel and I think that it's just, it's a different conversation. Like, whether Jews feel safe going to synagogue, they should feel safe going to synagogue and Jews should feel safe logging on Twitter or X or whatever it's called without facing a barrage of anti-semitism as happens every time I go on that site. We've got lots of work to do to fight racism, anti-semitism, anti-semitism is a form of racism and I think that it's best fought in multi-racial, multi-faith coalition which is what the whole infrastructure of human rights is about which is what it makes me very sad that Israel and its supporters are leading up a campaign of vilification against the United Nations and the whole infrastructure that guaranteed human rights after the Second World War that was part of how we were supposed to, like I grew up in a religious Jewish tradition of like never again means never again to anyone. These are kind of hallowed documents that say we are all equal and we have a responsibility to defend each other's humanity and there's a cruel, cruel historical irony in the fact that the loudest voices against that whole edifice of international humanitarian law are defending Israel because their idea of never again is we get an armed ethno state and we protect ourselves in this bunker and I think we're seeing that idea now proliferating and strengthening around the world. Everyone wants to be an ethno state. The Christian nationalist want to be an ethno state in Europe and in the United States and as things get worse and this is what Astrid and I are writing about is at you know this kind of fascism is a fascism in response to a feeling of collapse and the idea of you know being in a sea of enemies and invaders and rather than trying to address the underlying reasons why things really are much more unstable and we are facing more and more shocks and disasters we just respond by bunkering and if you want to see how that goes take a look at Israel that's that's that's a really good example to me it looks like hell. I think the idea of every person being enlisted into a military machinery where you defend the garrisoned ethno state at which requires more and more violence in order to protect itself whether it's the hand-to-hand combat you know hand to hand house theft in East Jerusalem and the West Bank or the remote AI enabled genocide from the air in Gaza that that is an apocalypse and it's it's it's it is that it is being done in the name of Jewish safety is a great shame to me as a Jewish person that has nothing to do with my safety that's not how I define that's no safety I want to be a part of and no one should have the right to get their safety that way you've got to find another way you were born in 1970 how about you we were born the same year 1970 we could probably talk about Juran Juran haircut 100 it's always it's always easy to know how old you are go on when you're born in 1970 yeah and it's nice because you should have bought yourself into a decade just by the skin of your teeth do you know what I mean I'm so young compared with those 60s oh yeah interesting I thought of that way because we're part of that grouping but yet like I remember I had this drama teacher Mr. Myers who when I was in high school he you say drama I had a drama teacher and he would he would yell at us he was really strange he would yell at us about how we were we were children of the 80s and it was and the last it was like he had this thing about how the real like we were born in 1970s but we're not children of the 70s right because the people who were teenagers in the 70s were like really the in the view of this drama teacher that's fat because we were too young to really live the culture yeah like they were like really genuinely the cool and more kind of 60s yeah but we got a bit of an age in the 80s we got during during we got and blondie the first song you ever heard on a Sony Walkman was hard of glass by blondie and you just look so good yeah your parents were political you've talked a lot about that you grew up in Canada partly as a result of your dad wanted to avoid the draft because he was American and he would have got conscripted he was conscripted was he yeah and so he what and he just decided not to go or not to go to jail right yeah a lot a lot of a lot of Americans came to Canada rather than go to jail my dad joined the Peace Corps okay for the same reason that wasn't an option why not you were drafted I guess this was later because my dad was well maybe not either way he he avoided the draft by joining the Peace Corps I know that's what he said um yeah so then then they stayed because my dad was a doctor and um he was he liked working in the public health care system we went back to the States for a little while and then he decided that we should go back to Canada and you made it sound as though I mean this is based on listening to your appearance on desert island discs on the way here we talked about blondie on that one there was blondie but I was thinking like this gonna be a lot of new wave a lot of synth pop on these discs there was there was well it was it was it wasn't it there's no test and there's no path or fail it just was it was Pete Seeger and Manu Chow and it was it was I shouldn't have been surprised it was political largely in bent um but what I was struck by was you the sense that your parents in some respects there was a time when maybe they were I don't know maybe not concerned but they wanted you to be political and perhaps they saw some of your pursuits as trivial you had an understandable interest in gold golden leggings because of blondie right or Olivia Newton John oh yeah hurt you they both had satin pillets and then this is the narrative and you can disagree or or add and break or amplify in 1989 uh you were kind of political awakening and I'd never heard of this the Montreal massacre this was news to me that this was this played a role this but you would have been 18 or 19 this played a role in you coming to some kind of new way of seeing them well I was in first year university and this was a mass shooting in a in a Canadian university um and it was very political but he was it was a young man who believed that he had he was a victim of a affirmative action that's what he believed so he wanted to study engineering and he had not gotten in and he had decided it was because the engineering schools were letting in too many women so he went into an engineering school at the University of Montreal and he separated the men from the women and he said you're all a bunch of fucking feminists and then he shot 14 women so it was a big political awakening for a lot of women of my generation my cohort um and so yeah like and I think you know this still happens and it still makes me so sad that you have like like the Parkland students you know it kind of birthed a whole generation of of of people organizing around gun control when you when when you are the generation where this stuff is happening it gets you into politics and it did for me was there a changing of the laws at that time um there was a new gun control piece of gun control legislation but it was more like it it led to a kind of a new generation calling themselves feminists did you do you remember boning for Columbine yeah the Michael
more film. And do you remember there's a whole bit where he goes to Canada? And his point is, oh, they have the same gun laws there as we do here more or less, but they're not going around shooting each other. Yeah, we laughed a lot about that scene and boiling for Columbine, because he claimed that most Canadians don't lock their doors, which is, I mean, was there anything? I mean, I worked with Michael for a couple of years and he had it coming from Michigan, which parts of which are actually north of parts of Canada. So there's this sort of strange, like twins of a sort. Yeah. And I think there's some truth to it. I mean, I'm happy I live in Canada, not the US, and I'm there by choice. I lived in the states as well, and chose to come back. And it's part of why I do believe in the importance of politics and policy, because here we are. We are very similar nations, similar demographic makeup, not identical, but, you know, for the most part, speak the same language, accepting Quebec. As Trump says, it's just a line on a border, you could have, you know, but the thing that makes us different is that we've decided to have more of a social safety net. Like we have universal health care, and we have a public broadcaster. Both of those are embattled, but the decision to invest in this idea that everybody should be able to get health care, regardless of whether you have money or not. And just having something of a net to catch people, I think does make us less brutal. And it's not like we're better or worse. It's just that those decisions really change a culture, and they make a huge difference in the kinds of choices you feel you can make, like leaving a job you hate. I mean, in the states, it is so hard, because everything is about health care, and whether or not you're going to lose your health care. You know, the fact that our universities don't cost a fortune, you know. So those things really matter, and my friends in the states that DSA are fighting really hard for the basics, you know, and are getting called socialists for just trying to do some stuff that we have in Canada, you know. -DSA is. -Democratic socialists in America, yeah. But yeah, I think like somebody like Abdullah Sayed, who's running in Michigan, and even Bernie, like being in Vermont, these are border states where you are just aware that just across the border, I think it's quite porous, right? That there's a place that is very similar to you, but different, because of these social investments. And a lot of that is also because we have a third party. It's not a two-party system. We have a Democratic Socialist party, the NDP, which my husband's the leader of. -Okay. -Yeah. Do you feel optimistic looking to the future, taking it zooming out, looking at the big picture? Not really, right? I think we are in a moment pregnant with possibility. I think that I think there are opportunities to build a really broad coalition of people who want to stay here in this world, in this domain, and don't want to exit us, don't want to exit us, and that that, that, I do feel hopeful about that, because I think that what we're describing in this book is a minoritarian position, like even like the stitch together, like whether it's the ethno-nationalists or the religious end-timers or the people who want to upload their consciousness to the AI cloud, they are, like, these are powerful factions that have gotten more powerful, but the reason why it's useful to kind of expose their ideology to the light is that most people when they hear better, like, that's nuts. -Nice. -Yeah. -Thank you so much for coming by. -Thank you. It was a pleasure to meet you. -And likewise, I could have kept going and going, but, you know. Bristol calls. Welcome back. Thank you for listening. So, things I'm picking up on. One is Steve Bannon's hip-hop musical, based on Shakespeare's choreolainus. I was going to find a funny quotation from it. I couldn't find one. It's set during the 1992 riots. It's not supposed to be funny. I don't know. I think we should applaud creativity and genre hopping. -What would you write a hip-hop musical about? -Well, I have thought about. Thank you for that great question, Millie. Did you hear Millie's question? Have you ever read a hero of our time by Lermontov? He's set in the early 19th century. He's a classic of Russian literature and it's got dueling in it. It's the height of the dueling craze. You remember, like, muskets at dawn or whatever? Upon my honest, I demand satisfaction is what they would say. And then you'd have a second and you'd go out. It became a thing. And I often thought, often, I thought once or twice, well, that's a bit like. It's not a drive-by shooting, but it is gun culture and gangs using weapons to settle beef, right? And I was like, well, you could set a hero of our time in modern day. I don't know, Los Angeles or in, you know, with the backdrop of hip-hop. So that would be a good hip-hop musical, I think. You weren't expecting us an actual answer. If you're out there and you're ready to fund a hip-hop musical that the author of Jiggle Jiggle could get behind and be a riseron, or maybe a producer, then contact us in the comments. That's it for today. Thanks so much for watching. I'll be back next week with John Cooper Clark, Mancunian Poets, Recontur, and genuinely funny man. See you then. [BLANK_AUDIO]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Naomi Klein and co-author Astrotailer explore a growing alliance between Christian nationalists, Silicon Valley billionaires, and far-right groups in their new book *End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World*.
The book highlights the "apocalypse ball" hosted by venture capitalist Peter Teal, where tech elites dress up in provocative costumes and promote extreme anti-woke ideologies, signaling a fusion of fringe extremism and political power.
These figures, including Elon Musk and Steve Bannon, present mutually contradictory visions—ranging from ethno-nationalism and bunker survival to AI-driven utopias—reflecting a deep crisis in how societies respond to climate collapse and political instability.
Steve Bannon, a former Trump strategist, is portrayed as a "mirror world" figure who channels populist anger against big tech and vaccines, creating a culture of exclusion and scapegoating that unites diverse anti-establishment factions.
The book critiques the ideological underpinnings of both religious nationalism and techno-libertarianism, arguing that their shared belief in a degraded, hostile world justifies violence, militarization, and retreat from democratic life.
Klein raises concerns about the environmental costs of AI expansion, including massive data centers that pollute communities, displace workers, and erode public trust in institutions.
She challenges the narrative of anti-Zionism as inherently racist, emphasizing that state-sponsored ethnic cleansing and the politicization of religion undermine human rights and global solidarity.
Klein sees hope in a growing cross-partisan resistance to destructive policies, particularly in local communities opposing data centers, as a sign of a broader movement to reclaim democratic self-determination.
Summary:
Naomi Klein and Astrotailer’s new book, *End Times Fascism and the Fight for the Living World*, exposes a dangerous political alliance forming between Christian nationalists, tech billionaires, and far-right movements. This coalition, exemplified by events like the "apocalypse ball" hosted by venture capitalist Peter Teal, blends anti-woke ideology, conspiracy theories, and visions of technological utopia with a deep fear of collapse. Klein highlights how figures like Steve Bannon and Elon Musk use rhetoric of crisis and exile to rally support, often redirecting anger toward scapegoats like trans athletes or immigrants.
Despite their divergent ideologies—ranging from religious purity to AI-driven immortality—these movements share a belief in a fractured world that justifies retreat into bunkers or digital realms. The book critically examines the environmental costs of AI expansion, especially large data centers that pollute communities, displace workers, and undermine public trust. Klein also confronts the politicization of Zionism and anti-Semitism, arguing that ethno-nationalism under any banner leads to human rights violations and social collapse.
She notes that while the political landscape appears fragmented, a growing grassroots resistance—seen in community opposition to data centers—signifies a potential for unity against destructive forces. Ultimately, the book calls for awareness and action, urging readers to recognize the ideological underpinnings of extremism and to defend a shared, sustainable future rooted in democratic values and environmental responsibility.
FAQs
The book explores the growing alliance between Christian nationalists, Silicon Valley billionaires, and the far right, arguing that this coalition represents a form of 'end times fascism' that threatens both democracy and the environment.
The apocalypse ball, held in Miami before Trump's 2016 election, brought together tech oligarchs and far-right figures who dressed provocatively and promoted anti-woke, conspiratorial ideas, showing the early formation of a coalition that would later influence the Trump administration.
She identifies three key strands: religious nationalism, techno-libertarianism (like Silicon Valley billionaires), and a militarized, bunker mentality, which together form a dangerous coalition that seeks to reshape society and retreat from democratic governance.
She argues that debating definitions of 'fascism' without addressing the real-world phenomena it describes is a distraction. The focus should be on understanding the actual political and social trends, not just on semantics.
Bannon is examined as a political figure who mobilized anti-tech, anti-establishment anger, especially during the pandemic, and became a platform for conspiracy theories, representing a mirror to progressive values and a key figure in the populist right.
She argues that the massive data centers being built by tech companies like Elon Musk drain the physical world, contributing to climate change and community harm, especially in areas like Memphis, where pollution and noise have caused significant local backlash.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.