Music Fastball: How to build a data-driven sync operation w/ Tim Hayes
45m 4s
Sync licensing remains unpredictable, but data and structured processes can significantly improve revenue outcomes. Tim Hayes, with over 13 years in sync at major rights holders and funds, emphasizes that funds have a strategic advantage by owning rights and earning most sync income. Key due diligence factors include identifying repeatable film/TV revenue, understanding rights structures (like MFN), and assessing approval dynamics. A strong performance history and internal approval rights make catalogs priority targets. Detailed tracking of sync requests—both confirmed and denied—enables accurate forecasting and reveals market patterns. Catalogs can be tiered into high, mid, and low-value tracks to guide targeted strategies. Real-time deal status reporting from administrators ensures timely revenue visibility, while external data like streaming and social media performance signals emerging trends. Ultimately, success hinges on combining data analysis with deep relationships, allowing creative and strategic outreach to music supervisors and brands. Tim recommends starting with a comprehensive sync data audit of at least two years to build a solid foundation for informed decision-making and long-term growth. His consultancy, Turn Music, offers support for rights holders, funds, and artists to implement data-driven, relationship-focused sync strategies.
(upbeat music)
Hello everyone and thank you for joining us
for another episode of Music Fastball.
Recently we have been getting into some of the best ways
to find more upside in your portfolio.
And this week we are joined by Tim Hayes
to get into one of the most effective ways
you can monetize a catalog which is through sync licensing.
So Tim has spent over 13 years working in sync
at both major and independent rights holders
and most recently at recognition music group,
formerly known as hypnosis, of course.
And he has also recently launched a creative consultancy,
turn music.
And he's joining us today to talk about
just how much funds can actually do
to move the needle on sync income
and the role that better data and better processes
can play in making that happen.
So Tim, thank you so much for joining us today.
It's great to have you here.
- Oh good, thanks for having me.
- Yeah and I think this is gonna be a really interesting one
because we know that sync is ultimately quite unpredictable
in nature, but I think that that doesn't mean
that there aren't things that you can do
and processes you can put in place to track things better
and ultimately improve your odds, hopefully.
- Yeah, 100%.
It's the age-old argument of how can we,
how can we have a sync pipeline, you know?
But yeah, we can dive into that
and I can talk about ways that we, you know,
systems we introduced to try and better manage that.
- Yeah, I think that's super helpful.
So let's start.
So as I mentioned just now,
you have worked at traditional record labels and publishers
but you have also worked on the music investment fund side.
So talk us through some of those differences
and how that can create, you know, opportunities
in some cases, but also challenges.
- So the basic difference is that a fund effectively steps
into the shoes of the songwriter,
of the artist, of the creator, right?
It's almost a catalog management system.
A traditional rights holder is giving a service
to that creator and specifically from a sync perspective,
that's pitching, licensing, organization of their sync
business and paying them royalties from sync use, right?
Some funds pitch and license directly,
but the majority of them would have a kind of primary
administrator that would offer that service to them.
The kind of main point between a sync team
at a fund and a traditional rights holder
is that it kind of reframes the way you think about sync.
A fund effectively is the artist or writer, right?
And you're every sync that you get,
you're earning the lion's share of that income, right?
Whereas a publisher or a record label,
you're taking a percentage of that income
then paying through the lion's share
to the songwriter or the artist.
So it kind of makes you rethink how you deal with sync
and how you deal with sync deals.
So it's a really, yeah, it's a really,
it's a really interesting way to kind of explore,
explore the sync industry from a different viewpoint.
I guess that's the basic difference.
I think other pointers of kind of the ways
that you can work differently.
A fund to a rights holder is the funds
generally have approval rights when it comes to sync.
Obviously every deal is different
and some deals don't include those approval rights,
but usually a fund would purchase a catalog
and with it they might purchase the approval right
to sync, name, image, likeness rights,
all of those kinds of things,
which can really again change the way that you do sync.
If you have internal approval over sync,
it can, you know, it means that you can turn a sync deal,
a sync request around in five, 10, 15 minutes.
Whereas a traditional rights holder,
you have to go out to a manager
who then might go to a songwriter or a whole band
or, you know, someone else in a state
and that might take a week, two weeks to hear back
and we all know that sync is a relatively fast game.
So that deal might disappear, you know.
So that's a massive plus of working at a fund
if you do have those rights.
And then I guess the main other thing is licensing, right?
So well, the administration side of it.
So a rights holder generally would traditionally do
the licensing, the invoicing, the quoting,
all of the administrative bits around sync,
whereas a fund has more of a catalog management view, right?
So you have an administrator to handle the paperwork
and handle dealing with the clients and the media space.
A fund you can kind of look holistically at your catalog
and put strategies together to work in collaboration
with your administrator to try and, you know,
better monetize your catalog effectively.
- Yeah, and you mentioned when we spoke before
that there's kind of less pressure
to focus on one specific, you know, frontline catalog
or whatever it is.
And I think that's really interesting in terms of like,
you can have a much more kind of wide approach
of looking at your strategy and how you're gonna go after
whatever you want to go after.
- Yeah, that's a really good point as well.
So at a traditional rights holder or publisher label,
there's, you know, they've been going for years, 50, 60, 70 years.
And they've got this incredible back catalog of music
as well as new music coming out every week, right?
Which the sync teams have to be fully versed on,
fully up to date with and fully understand
where they're gonna try and place these frontline priority releases
as well as the historic releases that came, you know,
years and years ago.
The difference at a fund is that you're effectively acquiring
catalogs and collating of a portfolio, right?
But every time you're, you require a catalog,
you might only, only acquire a few, a few a year.
You're really kind of diving deep into that catalog
and it might only be 2050, maybe 100,000 songs,
but in comparison to the 5 million plus
that a normal rights holder has, a traditional rights holder,
it's a lot more manageable.
- Yeah, which gives you a lot more opportunity
to be a bit more kind of targeted and strategic
with everything, so I think that's super helpful.
- Yeah, exactly.
I think that gives you time to fully understand
the catalog contextualize it and also create it, right?
So you can listen through an entire catalog
when you do purchase one and create it into
lyrical themes, sync themes, all of that kind of stuff
so that you can, you know, you have that
at your fingertips when you're pitching.
- Yeah, so much more manageable than when you're dealing
with, as you said, hundreds of thousands or millions
or whatever it is of songs.
So let's start at the beginning.
What we see are kind of the beginning of the process, right?
So, you know, you're in the diligence phase,
someone brings a catalog to you
and let's say they're saying, you know,
this is a super sync-friendly rock band
or whatever it is, you know, ideally,
I suppose somebody like you Tim would be getting involved
at that stage just to kind of see like, okay,
like, sync, we know as a big driver of upside,
but there's a lot of things that we need to look out for
to see, you know, how much of that can actually be unlocked.
So what kind of things are you looking at, you know,
at the diligence level when someone brings a catalog
to you to assess how much sync potential there is?
- It's a very good question.
It like you say, you know, if a catalog is primarily known
as sync-friendly, that really helps.
A lot of acquisitions that are being done at the moment
are very streaming-focused.
So sometimes there isn't much sync analysis to be done
because there isn't a huge amount of sync history, right?
But when I've previously been involved
in the acquisition side of the business,
there's kind of three key focus points that I'd always,
from a sync perspective, I'd always look at
and flag with our investment team, right?
So the first one is sync income forecasting, right?
As you said at the beginning, sync income
is extremely inconsistent and hard to forecast.
You know, one quarter, you might get a seven figure ad,
a global ad deal, and then for the next 12 quarters,
you get a couple of TV shows, and that's it, you know?
So it's the lumpy nature of it that makes it really hard
to kind of do valuations on sync.
I, in terms of forecasting, I'd always look at
any confirmed repeatable income that's due in coming years.
So there might be a brand partnership, for example, right?
That an artist or a writer has agreed to,
over a 10-year term, for example,
and you might be two years into that.
So you know that for the next eight years,
there's income coming in every year on a specific date,
and so you can already see some upside that, right?
It's something that might be obvious,
but a lot of people might miss it,
because they're so, they're looking at so many things, right?
So it's really important to think about that.
There's not a huge amount of deals like that,
but every now and then, with these big catalogs,
you know, changing hands.
is there's a lot of those to kind of consider.
But then I guess on the flip side of that,
I think it's really important to not
expect a deal to renew as well.
So like contractually if it has to renew
and they've agreed to a 10 year term
and yearly payments, that's great.
If it's an ad with an option to renew
and they might have renewed for 10 years previously.
And so you're kind of forecasting
that that's just gonna be continuous revenue.
It doesn't mean that they're gonna renew it next year, right?
So you could purchase this catalog
and that income suddenly drops off to the face of a cliff
and your sync revenue is suddenly looking terrible, you know?
So you can never guarantee a sync or a renewal, right?
So I'd always avoid forecasting
those kind of long term brand renewals
if there isn't anything contractual to say
there's gonna be a payment next year kind of thing, you know?
Generally, at this last point on forecasting,
generally I'd always kind of try
and forecast primarily on film and TV revenue
just because film and TV is there's loads of it.
Generally catalogs get a lot of that
and there's a boom in it, right?
So there's more TV and more films than ever.
Adds at the moment are quite fragmented
and there's smaller terms, smaller revenue
for smaller media sectors.
- Yeah.
- Film and TV is more repeatable income generally.
So I'd always try and kind of take out those big anomalies
for example of ads and maybe film trailers
and focus on that kind of more steady repeatable income
of a few thousand here and there from film and TV.
- Yeah, that makes sense
'cause you've got the kind of long tail of the royalties
that come off that as well, down the lines, yeah.
- Yeah, exactly.
So that's my first flag for due diligence.
- Red or green, yeah.
- Exactly.
So the next one I would flag, which is very obvious,
is the rights that you're acquiring, right?
Specifically from a sync perspective.
So really understanding the deal terms
and the rights that are packaged up in this catalog, right?
So from a sync perspective, if you're buying a catalog
which is, for example, a songwriter catalog
where the songwriter has an average of,
I don't know, 10 to 25% on their songs,
on maybe the bigger songs.
There isn't much you can do with that catalog
in terms of uplift, right?
It's a songwriter catalog.
So generally, any sync deals that come through the door,
you're very likely to say MFN with the artist.
The artist effectively makes that call.
If they want to bump the fee up, great.
But you don't want to try and push that fee up
and potentially annoy your co-writers and your,
the artist that you wrote this with for your 10, 15%.
- Yeah.
- So I would say understanding that
and understanding exactly where you can move the needle,
you know, on the flip side,
if it's a catalog where it's an artist catalog
and you have like 50% plus on most of the bigger songs,
then you're in the driving seat
and you can really dive in there and negotiate.
There's more potential to work the catalog for uplift
from a sync perspective.
So it's really pivotal and really vital
to understand exactly where you can see any uplift coming
in those rights and it's something that is kind of
sometimes forgotten, sometimes people just think,
oh, even though we've only got 15% of this huge song,
it's not loads of sync revenue previously.
So we could pitch it and land loads more.
But in reality, you're then pitching a song
that you might have 15% of and you're giving
the other 85% of revenue to your competitors, right?
- Yeah, that makes total sense.
And you mentioned a term, Tim MFN,
which is the most favourite nation of course,
can you, for our audience, you might not be aware,
could you just dig into quickly what that means?
- Of course, sorry.
So most favours nations basically means
that in a sync deal, anyone can quote that
and it means that every stakeholder within that deal,
every publisher, every all the label,
if there's more than one label,
effectively gets the same share, right?
So that 100% tea would be pro-rated
with all of the different rights holders
and it just means it's a fair playing field, you know?
- Yeah, yeah, yeah, amazing.
So obviously the rights that you are acquiring
is a massive thing and I think we'll get into later
kind of how that helps you prioritise, right?
Which tracks and catalogs you're gonna work
within the portfolio.
But yeah, carry on with your red and green flags.
- One more flag.
So the last flag is the context, right?
So uplift context.
Can you actually uplift anything?
Is this kind of a sync catalog that will say flat
is their potential for it for you to uplift it?
One really important thing here that people miss
is understanding the approval situation
with other stakeholders that are involved
in that specific song or catalog, right?
So there might be, you might have 80% of a song
on a publishing side.
But the other 20% might be with a songwriter
that fell out with the person
that you bought this catalog from.
And for some reason they might want to block sync
or that other 20% might be, I don't know, a vegan, for example,
and won't approve anything to do with meat.
So any fast food adverts when you think
all of your uplift's gonna come from McDonald adverts, you know?
Is that that kind of thing?
Understanding and contextualising other stakeholders
in the process, making sure that there is
potential for sync revenue to flow,
especially if there hasn't been much previously,
like it's understanding if that is because
there isn't much sync interest or if that's because
all of these songs have been denied,
all of these requests have been denied
because you can approve 99% of a song,
but if there's one percent that denies,
that sync isn't gonna happen
and that money won't flow through, right?
So that's one part of kind of uplift context.
The other part is putting together a plan
that's actually achievable, right?
You can, when you're buying a catalog
or working with an artist or songwriter,
anyone can sell them the world and don't deliver on it.
And I think, I think, you know,
having an achievable plan that has kind of a 12 month,
24 month, five year plan that is really, you know,
actually achievable and everyone kind of understands
what the measures are to get there is really key.
I would say, if the plan is solely to pitch a catalog
for sync activity, you know, you might have a few wins,
but you can't ever really guarantee uplift there
or like significant uplift at least.
- Yeah.
- I would say the best uplift you can see
from a sync perspective is usually
if there's openness from your seller
and other people involved in that catalog
to creative projects, right?
Whether that's biopics, documentaries,
cover versions, samples, and interpolations, you know,
anything that can introduce this music
to potentially a new audience
and effectively make more money from doing that, you know?
So yeah, they're my three flags, no more.
- I like it.
And I think that makes perfect sense.
And it also feeds into, of course,
like what's your strategy as a fund in the first place
because, you know, we see some people are much more passive,
whereas, you know, increasingly,
I think it's moving more towards the active sphere
because, you know, people realize there's a lot more,
you cannot unlock from the catalog,
but all of those things you're talking about with biopics
and those things that you can unlock
that takes a certain kind of catalog, right?
So I think that just feeds into like, you know,
what your capabilities are and where you're looking.
- 100%.
And we can see in the last few years, you know,
the growth of music documentaries and biopics
is crazy, right?
And what it does to that catalog in terms of streaming uplift
is nuts.
So I think that's where you can really move the needle.
- Yeah, 'cause we see there, like, you know,
everyone talks about paper, stranger things
and this, but it's like that's like one
in a, probably not even a million,
like a billion, a billion, a billion.
- I love the paper, stranger things.
- Yeah, they're hard to come by for sure.
- Yeah, no, that's great.
And I think that's kind of, it's good to be understanding
of like where the, you know, as we said in the intro,
like where you can potentially move the needle the most.
So yeah, that's super interesting.
And then let's move more on to kind of the operational side
now of sync at a fund.
So when we talked before, you mentioned that
one of the biggest blind spots, if you like,
and it obviously comes out as that, you know,
not necessarily doing the administration in-house
is that you don't necessarily know whether a sync has happened
or not until six months, a year.
God knows what it is down the line.
You might get a royalty statement associated with that.
So that's obviously not ideal for an investment fund
that needs to be able to track and forecast things
as accurately as possible.
So you talked about kind of how you can put processes
in place to help some of that.
So be great.
I understand a little bit more about that.
Yeah, of course.
And I'll kind of preface this with you can put processes in place.
But there's always going to be something that throws it out of whack, right?
And there's always going to be some money missing or extra money that no one can really work at.
Why it's there.
But yeah, like you said, there's a fun generally would usually have a administration partner who would hand over the licensing,
the invoicing, receive the payment from a sync client, and then send it over to you.
The area where there can be a slight breakdown in communication is where you've approved a sync deal.
But the administrator doesn't necessarily tell you that it's confirmed, right?
Because you might receive 100 sync requests a day, right?
They can't go back to every sync request that you've approved and say this one confirmed, this one's dead now.
So, yeah, there's a slight kind of miscommunication and information loss there, which can be quite pivotal,
because you then don't necessarily know when deals are confirmed, when you can expect payment, right?
So in this instance, I always kind of think of a fund before they were a fund as their individual songwriters or artists, right?
As an individual songwriter or an artist, it's usually really hard to know what kind of sync payments to expect in a statement,
or to be honest, any payments to expect in a statement.
It's always an exciting thing to open up a statement and see how much of being paid, right?
So a fund is that on like a mass scale.
There's various different elements to it that can make it really confusing.
It depends, A, like, where a sync was licensed from.
So say I'm an American artist, right?
Signed into an American publisher who, and I've then sold my catalog to a fund.
But a sync, an ad sync request has come in from the UK market and they want to use my song.
So the UK brand would pay the UK entity of that publishing company and it might take a month, three months, hopefully not longer than that, but it might take longer to receive that money from the client.
And then it takes a quarter for the UK company to pay the US company.
And then another quarter for the US company to pay the writer or fund, right? So there, there's at least a six month, maybe a nine month or longer gap from the deal confirming to revenue actually flowing through.
There's like a real need for regular deal status reporting from your admin partner to a fund, because they can tell you, right, this deal is still on the table.
It's still not confirmed. And then one month, they could say, actually, this is confirmed and this is the fee.
And then a two months later, they can say, we've now received payment. So as of that, you can say, right, so the UK companies receive payment, they're sending there and you can kind of work it out to some extent, but it's still a slight finger in the air kind of thing, you know.
And I think it's also really key to have that that reporting from admin partners, because there's a variety of different elements that could change, right, we spoke about MFN and I might approve a sync request of a big sync request at $500,000, right.
But a co-writer could could approve it at a million dollars. So when that deal confirms, I'd be expecting my share of the 500,000 when actually I'd receive double that in a statement.
And so having regular deals data subdates so that you can see where fees are changing is really key.
And also, like, it's those high value syncs, we're always tracking and we're always very aware of when they're confirming and when we're receiving that might ain't, but there's a lot of sync requests that allow value, you know, we're talking about Australia's Got Talent or the voice USA, you know, all of those small, smaller kind of MFN clearance shows where they clear thousands of songs all at the same level, and it might be 300 to $500 a year.
It's really hard to keep track of because you're approving thousands of them a year, right. But if you do get a thousand of them confirmed in a year, that's a sizable amount of money, right.
So having regular deal status reporting across every sync request that you've received from your admin partner is really key so that you can be forecasting and having kind of a payment pipeline that is relatively accurate.
Otherwise, it does kind of just all get lost.
Yeah. And what kind of system are you using to track all of that and have like a single source of truth or whatever it is, is that something that you kind of have just built previously internally yourself or like, what does that look like.
Yeah. So it's always, I've always built something internally. There are systems you can use. There's effectively CRM systems, right. But instead of, you know, you're tracking your tracking sync lines and sync requests.
Yeah.
Yeah, we've always built something internally because it's always quite nuanced as well. So you need your own system so that you know exactly what you need to track what data you want to keep in that system. And then you can kind of see it go through the stages of a request receive to approve to confirm to awaiting payment to paid.
Yeah, that makes sense. So let's now talk about a little, you know, this is the more on the financial side of things. But if we talk about, you know, now specifically how you can use some of that data to look at the performance of the catalog and then digging into that to see how that can help to drive upside.
So how can you use data to, you know, really assess outside of the financials, like how, how catalogs are performing and, you know, what can you actually do with some of that insight.
Yeah, of course, I mean, it depends hugely on the kind of data you're tracking. If, if the data, if the sync data you're tracking is solely for financial purposes, like we just discussed to track payments and reconcile payments to statements.
There are almost definitely data points you're missing and you're not tracking that could be really vital to give you insights into your sync business, right. Yeah. So you might be tracking the fees and the song, but you're not tracking the territory or the media type or the brand vertical, for example, right.
Exactly. So tracking all of that context gives you kind of a full picture of performance of your catalog in the marketplace, but also, I guess, a full view of the global sync market, which is really key when you're kind of planning future strategy within sync.
So I would say that data, when you are tracking it, it gives you like a good indication of your portfolio where it sits. And, and kind of you can, you can then dive into it and do some analysis right on fees on, on, you know, songs on catalogs on your whole portfolio.
So one, one, one kind of strategy that that I've done before is is dive into a catalog that isn't performing as well as we want. And looking at, you know, it might be a catalog of 100 songs say over the last three years, 10 of them have had sync money flying through like decent activity of sync.
And the other 90, a dormant, not, not earning. So I've tried kind of tear them right. So those 10 that are earning money, your, your tirades, your top tiers, where, as and when you get requests in for them, they're, they're kind of market level or above.
There might be a, a tier B, which are recognizable songs, but for whatever reason they're not being requested in, in the sync market. Or you could also put into TV songs that haven't been requested that aren't recognizable, but lyrically could work really well for a specific brand for TV shows for, for anything like that.
And then TSC, a songs that have never had any syncing come and you can be quite flexible with, right. So you suddenly got a kind of gold silver bronze and you can take it to the market and say, look, here are the really recognizable high value ones, here are the mid tier ones that you might recognize.
Here are the, here are the TSC songs that still have that iconic vocal, that, you know, artist, presence that, you know, that the same kind of delivery, the same sonic identity, they're just not as recognizable.
And you could potentially cut a deal on them to try and monetize them through sync, through sync.
So I think using data in that, in that perspective is really interesting, and you can do that on a territory specific way, right. So if you can see that in, I don't know, Australia, this car belongs never had, hasn't had a sync in five years, you can suddenly go and target there.
Or if you can see where really overperforming in, in, I don't know, in Germany, you can go and target the German market even more.
So I think, I think using data in sync is really important, and I think it's the future, I think sync has historically been slightly finger in the air, you know, we think it should be this price or what song do you want, why don't you use.
So using data to kind of lead your strategy is really key.
And that's just like internal data as well.
There's other data sources that you can use to kind of advise you on that strategy that you can tie into your systems.
Yeah, I think that's so it's so funny that you said that because I was literally about the same thing because you talk about pricing strategy and how that can inform using data can help inform that.
And yeah, I think that's definitely an area where I was like, well, we think that is this, you know what I mean?
So how like talk a little bit about how specific data points, you know, whether it's like, well, this is how much something was synced for before or like, how does that?
How does having access to data help you kind of find those cost points or whatever it is?
Well, I think the really interesting thing is like, I'd hope that most sync teams, funds or traditional publishers and labels are tracking tracking sync data to some extent.
It might only be the syncs that confirm and they're expecting payments for in which case you can go through when you do get a sync request in for a song and you can see the sync history of that song.
So you can kind of say, we approved a TV show that's similar for 20,000 US last year, let's let's go for a similar kind of fee for that, right?
One thing that I have found has changed the game in my career is actually not just tracking confirmations but tracking every sync request, whether it whether it's denied, whether it dies because they don't use that song or whether it confirms.
Because you can then see how the market is reacting to your song, you can see that actually this song's been requested 20 times but it's never actually confirmed and is that because they like the idea of the song but it doesn't actually fit with a brand or a TV show or is it because it's been denied 19 times out of 20 because that band are really specific on what they're approved.
So what kind of different levels are there at play, for example, and giving context behind that.
So yeah, no, there's there's a multitude of things you can use, you can use data for I think another key one which I touched on earlier is Brad vertical.
You know, you can always log ads as another ad, another six figure song, it's great, but if you can start to really quantify them and put them in buckets of motor, motor vehicles, you know, retail, all sorts of things like that sports, then you can start to see where certain catalogs are really over or under performing in those sectors.
And you can start to look at the genres as well and you can start to say actually weirdly country music's doing really well at retail in Germany, why is that.
And kind of yeah, you get that context and you can kind of build build out from there, you know.
And I loved what you said before about like, you know, everybody to some degree has sync data, so they're capturing something, you know, whether that's just on the PR statement level or, you know, there's probably it sounds to me that you've probably got more, whether it's in your emails or systems or spreadsheets like there's probably more you can put together that you have the new probably think you have.
And that's a very compelling, a compelling kind of motivation towards looking at some of this a little bit closer.
Yeah, definitely. And I think, I mean, another element that I haven't even touched on is pitching data, right?
So from your pitching systems, looking at where you're pitching and, you know, every right's hold of is pitching to some some degrees, so looking at where you're pitching where that's actually converting into a request or where that's, you know, pitching into the void.
So, so yeah, there's various different data sources and the really hard thing is is is pulling them all together and trying to analyze them and and kind of have some outcomes to take away from it, you know.
And how much when you're at a fund, just talking about pitching, like how much of it is outbound focus versus like the end bounds, because obviously you have a mixture of like the iconic.
I mean, obviously it depends which fund we're talking about, but let's say recognition group recognition music group, you've got some pretty iconic tracks, but then they'll also be, you know, some lesser known, for example, so how much of the like what's the balance between just those inbound requests versus how much you're pitching.
Yeah, I mean, it's, there's a lot of inbound when you've got a catalog like that, obviously, it's, it's pretty mind blowing how many same requests we have.
It's a real, it's a real balance, right, like when I was at recognition, for example, we had administrators, so almost every publisher had had some kind of involvement with us across our catalogs.
And the job wasn't necessarily my job originally started as go out new business pitch to anyone and ever on right and it gradually evolved into actually we've got teams in every city in the world pitching via our administrators, so my job effectively turned into like almost an account management role.
And I was kind of managing them and ensuring that they were pitching our catalog ahead of other catalogs to give us the best, the best chance of of earning more sync revenue, you know, and I think that's, it's really interesting because you're effectively them working instead of me going and pitching to, I don't know, Australia, for example, you're working with the major publishers and labels and, and the end is in.
In Australia, who are experts in, in that, in that territory, and know the right people to talk to the right kind of fees to quote on certain brands and the right kind of studios to talk to about films coming out, you know, so you can kind of work collaboratively with them to, to really push your catalog and, you know, give them.
So I think I think, on them with the analysis that we've just been talking about, right, all of that data, if you can arm them, arm them with with with all of the info that they need to take that to market that puts them head and shoulders above of of others, you know, so yes, I think like if there's one takeaway that I would, you know, think about from the time I spent working at sync and working in sync and text surrounding the sync world is just.
Yes, there's data, yes, there's technology, but it is so relationship focused says I gave you combine those two that's kind of like a superpower right.
Yeah, 100% I mean yeah sync sync is so relationship focused and it's it's making sure that you're the person at the end of the phone that that music supervisor or that director or that.
You know, marketing person at brand wants to talk to right so yeah, I completely agree it's it's harnessing data and and information in an interesting way and then using that with your network to try and market your catalog even further, you know.
In terms of thinking about where to focus efforts across the catalog, I know you said that you're dealing typically with a smaller catalog than you would have, you know, major rights holder, but there's still quite a lot to consider.
So what are some of the data points that you would use to help you understand where you should be focusing.
That's a good question I'd say so so my my kind of workflow has always been I need to find those priority catalogs right so like we said earlier with the due with the diligence side looking at the rights that you own whether it's 15% and external approval or 100% and internal approval has a massive difference to how much you can actually work at catalog right so.
Yeah for for a catalog to be a priority catalog for me it would have to have a strong sync history strong earnings from sync over the last five 10 years, high percentages so you know that you're earning the lion share on almost all of that catalog should it be synced.
And quick approval whether that's you are the approval party as as a fund or you have a very collaborative manager or artist or songwriter that you know it's always at the end of the phone and and we'll give you an answer within 24 48 hours.
And also openness to opportunities as well like you can have all of that but if they don't want to do sync they don't want to do sync right so so they can't necessarily be a priority catalog.
I'd have kind of that they're almost like the golden the golden geese of your catalogs right and that could you know that that that kind of that thinking can also work in the reverse right so if you see a catalog that is really strong and really recognizable but has awful sync history.
And isn't open to opportunities as a fund and like earning the majority of that income you kind of have to look at it and think why is that can we change it has that catalog being requested or is it sorry has it been requested at all or is it being requested a lot and consistently denied previously.
So so looking at catalogs that potentially don't do sync or where the market thinks they're too expensive we're not even going to try and drilling down into why that is an effectively try and change the narrative on on those catalogs which we've had some success with with previously as well.
I mean that's great and I think
like, you know, the tiering system that you talked about earlier, like that makes perfect sense
in terms of how to approach things. Yeah, so that tiering system, ideally, would be for a priority
catalogue, right? That might not have had much sync history in recent years, but you can really
dive down deep into it and you can kind of be the driving force because you've got 100% of these
of these songs, for example. And then I guess one other source that I talk about with prioritisation
of catalogue is using, obviously, internal data, like we've spoken about, the external as well.
So looking at systems that you can license, like streaming data, broadcast and radio data,
social media data, so that you can see how your songs are performing, and that can then give you
a strategy to make sure, like if a song suddenly risen 150% in the last week on streaming,
you know that there's some kind of TikTok trend, or there's something that is generating
those streams, right? We don't want to just be reactive and hope that that lasts forever.
I think the best thing that you can do is prioritise that song, prioritise that catalogue,
and try and jump on that, and make sure that that bump, although it might be temporary,
has a lasting effect in the sync market, and hopefully we can capitalise by earning some more
revenue for it. Yeah, totally. I think that's such an important point. And Tim, I feel like you've
given us so many great points to consider in this episode. And I think for our listeners who
might be sitting there thinking, well this all sounds great, you know, I think my takeaway really
is that there is so much that you can do, but where would you recommend to start if you're thinking,
right, I've got to get my shirt together, start looking at sync in a bit of a more data-driven way,
like what would your point as be for anyone listening who, you know, one of the first steps to get
in place? Yeah, of course. I'd say if a fundal rights holder isn't actively tracking sync
request and pitch data currently, then that's the best place to start, right? Start that as soon
as possible, and ideally try and backdate that so that you've got a whole picture of at least
two years, maybe three years, you know, so it's a heavy lift and it's a lot of work to do, but
that can give you a holistic view on your business, on your portfolio, and where the performance
is strong, where it's weak, and give you a full dataset to work with effectively. If they are
already tracking sync data, try and harness that information as best as possible to give strategic
targets to either on a catalog level or a whole portfolio level, because that progresses
for sync business, also the whole business, right? I guess if they're already doing all of that,
then try and use the tech to automate it more, to make the system better, and also look at
experimenting with creative opportunities across that catalog. Obviously, the priority catalog
should would be first, but there's also, I'm sure, in every portfolio, there's songs that might
not sit in that priority catalog, but you could do amazing sync focused cover or an interpolation
of it that could introduce it to a completely new audience and make that song live forever.
So yeah, there's a few little tidbits there, and I'm here to help if anyone needs them.
I love that. Well, Tim, it's been a pleasure. Thank you so much for all that amazing advice.
And I think just to end off, where can people get in touch with you if they would love to get
more advice from you? Of course. So my website is www.turnmusic.co. So you can have a look there.
My email address is Tim @turnmusic.co as well. So yeah, I've just started turn music as a creative
consultancy, primarily focused on on sync, but all aspects of creative. I'm going to work with
hoping to work with funds, rights holders, management companies, artists, tech companies,
to have a dated, driven sync strategy and try and implement that. Yeah, amazing. Well, thank you
so much again, and thank you for everybody who has tuned in today. As always, if you can subscribe
and like and do all of those things that always helps us, and we will see you next time.
Lovely. Thanks, Emma.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Funds act as the primary rights holder in sync licensing, allowing full control and earning the lion’s share of sync income, unlike traditional rights holders who share royalties.
Key diligence flags include identifying repeatable film/TV revenue, understanding sync rights (e.g., MFN or internal approval), and assessing uplift potential through stakeholder context and approval dynamics.
Strong sync performance and internal approval rights are critical for prioritizing catalogs, with high-performing, actively approved songs offering the most upside.
Detailed tracking of sync requests—including denials, confirmations, and territories—enables accurate forecasting, reveals market trends, and identifies opportunities for strategic targeting.
Data-driven analysis allows for tiering songs into high, mid, and low-value categories, enabling focused pitching and creative strategies like cover versions or interpolations.
Regular deal status reporting from administrators ensures real-time visibility into sync confirmations, payments, and revenue timelines, reducing forecasting inaccuracies.
External data (streaming, social media, broadcast) can signal emerging trends, prompting proactive sync strategies to capitalize on temporary spikes.
A successful sync strategy combines data insights with strong relationships, using networks to pitch effectively and build trust with music supervisors and brand teams.
Summary:
Sync licensing remains unpredictable, but data and structured processes can significantly improve revenue outcomes. Tim Hayes, with over 13 years in sync at major rights holders and funds, emphasizes that funds have a strategic advantage by owning rights and earning most sync income. Key due diligence factors include identifying repeatable film/TV revenue, understanding rights structures (like MFN), and assessing approval dynamics.
A strong performance history and internal approval rights make catalogs priority targets. Detailed tracking of sync requests—both confirmed and denied—enables accurate forecasting and reveals market patterns. Catalogs can be tiered into high, mid, and low-value tracks to guide targeted strategies.
Real-time deal status reporting from administrators ensures timely revenue visibility, while external data like streaming and social media performance signals emerging trends. Ultimately, success hinges on combining data analysis with deep relationships, allowing creative and strategic outreach to music supervisors and brands. Tim recommends starting with a comprehensive sync data audit of at least two years to build a solid foundation for informed decision-making and long-term growth.
His consultancy, Turn Music, offers support for rights holders, funds, and artists to implement data-driven, relationship-focused sync strategies.
FAQs
At a music fund, the fund acts like the artist or songwriter and earns the lion's share of sync income, whereas traditional rights holders typically take a percentage and pay the majority to the creator. Funds often have approval rights over sync, enabling faster deal decisions, and they can manage catalogs more strategically and holistically.
MFN stands for 'Most Favoured Nations' and means that all stakeholders in a sync deal receive the same royalty share. If a deal is MFN, every rights holder gets a pro-rated share, which prevents one party from getting a better deal than others and creates a fair playing field.
First, assess sync income forecasting by identifying repeatable revenue (e.g., long-term brand deals) and avoiding overestimation of renewals. Second, evaluate the rights structure—especially ownership percentages—to determine if you can negotiate uplift. Third, examine uplift context, including approval rights of other stakeholders and whether sync requests are being denied due to specific restrictions.
Data on sync requests, territories, media types, and brand verticals helps identify underperforming or high-potential songs. It enables tiering catalogs (gold, silver, bronze) and targeted outreach to markets where a song is gaining traction, leading to more strategic and data-driven pitching decisions.
Tracking all requests—confirmed, denied, or declined—reveals market trends, such as why a song is frequently requested but never confirmed. This data helps understand brand preferences, song fit, and approval barriers, improving future pitch strategies and catalog performance.
Funds prioritize catalogs with strong sync histories, high royalty percentages (e.g., 50%+), internal approval rights, and openness to creative opportunities. They also assess catalogs with poor sync performance to investigate whether market perceptions or denial patterns can be changed.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.