Go back

“Money Is a Tool To Create a Life You Love”

2h 6m 48s

“Money Is a Tool To Create a Life You Love”

The episode addresses diverse financial questions from listeners, focusing on debt repayment, shared finances, insurance, and long-term financial health. Catherine’s case highlights the power of emotional motivation in debt elimination—using a bonus to pay off high-interest credit card debt despite lower interest on smaller balances. The show emphasizes that while mathematically similar, the psychological impact of removing credit card debt is transformative and motivates sustained financial progress. Ryan and Savannah discuss fair financial contributions in cohabitation, stressing that roommates should share costs equally, not based on income, and that clear agreements prevent resentment. Brenda’s situation as an international student shows that a credit score is not essential for housing or car purchases—proof of income and stability are more critical. Joy’s concern about her partner’s ongoing credit card debt underscores the importance of shared financial values and boundaries in relationships, with advice to communicate expectations before marriage. Annie and Cody explore life insurance needs, recommending coverage based on income multipliers (10–12x) and external policies to avoid employer dependency. Cody’s story of grief and rebuilding finances emphasizes the need for strict budgeting and financial separation during new relationships. Grant’s experience shows how family support can create financial strain, but resolves by aggressively paying off debt within a short timeframe without risking retirement accounts. Across all cases, the core message remains: financial health comes from mindset, clarity, and consistent action—not just numbers. The Ramsey Plan promotes one-goal focus, emotional accountability, and value alignment to build lasting financial stability.

Transcription

23074 Words, 119578 Characters

English
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app, start budgeting for free today. Normal is broke and common sense is weird, so we're here to help you transform your life. From the Ramsey Network in the Fairwinds Credit Union Studio, this is the Ramsey Show. I'm George Campbell, joined by my friend and co-host of Smart Money Happy Hour Rachel Cruz and we're taking your calls at AAA8255225. This show is for you, it's about you, you are the show, so call us with your money and life questions and we'll do our best to help. Catherine is in, Austin, Texas to kick us off. What's going on, Catherine? Hi, how are you? Doing great. Okay, so my question is I have an upcoming bonus that I'll receive this month. And I've been on baby stuff too, paying off my debt all year since January, knocking out of the lowest debt first. I want to use my bonus to pay off my highest debt this month instead of the smaller debt. So I wanted to know what you guys thought about that. How much is your bonus going to be? As I've calculated, take home and take home is going to be like almost $24,000, just under $24,000. Awesome. Great. And what are all your debts? So the debt that I have left right now is I, smallest debt, the largest debt, smallest debt would be decided to do some dental work this year, which I kind of regret doing because anyways, but that's only about $2,000 or $1,800 left. I have a personal loan that is about $14,000 left on it. And then my biggest debt is my credit card that all I've been doing is paying the minimum all year and it is $19,715. And that's the one you want to pay off. That's one card. What are the payments on the person alone in the dental work? Dental work is $231 a month at zero interest. The personal loan, I pay every two weeks and it's, let's see, what is that payment every week? $293 every two weeks. What's the credit card minimum payment? Minimum payment is about $310 and it's almost all interest. Okay. Well, the reason I ask is because sometimes if you can clear a big ol payment, which will then speed up your debt snowball, I go, okay, I can see the logic in that. But so far, I'm not seeing a lot of evidence that tells me that credit card should go first in the debt snowball because you'll clear over $500 in payments just by knocking out the dental work, the personal loan, and still have a good chunk left over to make headway on the credit card. Yeah, I was going to say because the personal loan you said is almost $300 every two weeks, right? So that's $600 a month going to that personal loan. Right. Yeah. Plus the 230 dental work. So we're talking 830. Yeah, exactly. And then, yeah. And then on top of just the minimum payment, I mean, and then anything extra, I mean, you could be throwing, gosh, 1,200 bucks at that credit card a month. And after, if you took the 24 and spread it out, right, knocked out the two, knocked out the 14, and then what's your credit cards are down to like 11 grand? 11 grand. So that's pretty sweet. Yeah. You'll be completely tap free in probably nine months if you really focus in and pay well. Yeah, I actually with my margin, I would be even like, if I, because I plan it all out, paying off the credit card for, and the reason I want to do the credit card and not the other two, but look at it both ways is because it physically hurts me every single time. I see how much interest I'm paying on the credit card, even like even more interest than the personal loan, because what's your income? My take home is for my paycheck, it's $7,898, and then I get a child support payment bi-weekly also. Okay. You're saying with all the margin you have, it's still going to take you nine months to knock out the rest of the credit card. No, no, no, no, no. How long do you think it'll take if you did our way? Well, I didn't, I don't look at doing your way, I looked at doing my way and my way, I would have everything paid off like my last payment would be February. Okay. I think here's the truth. If you map it out, you're going to go, all right, it's February 1st or 7th. Yeah. I think at the end of the day, it's not, I don't think it is, it's a big deal. I mean, genuinely, because you look and you're like, okay, if you took the 24, paid off the 19 through two more thousand at the dental work, right? You got about, you know, what, 12 left on the personal. I mean, it's all, it's basically, you're, I mean, it's, it's basically all the same at that point. It'll be all right. It'll be all right. It'll be fine. It'll be fine. It'll be fine. It'll be fine. I just, I, I hated looking at the credit card all year. Good. That's a good thing to have because that means you're never going to go into credit card debt again. Well, no. It's all open. You can close it and pay the balance. They don't mind. Oh, I know. I have no idea. I'm just, I'm trying to have you draw a line on the sand because of this anger going, why would I play with snakes? Because you knew the interest rate going into this, right? Yeah. There was no baby switch. It cost the 19,000 and credit card debt. I'm just curious. Was it lifestyle stuff or was it like a business or? It was a combination of, I don't know, lifestyle and circumstances. Yeah. I'm a, yeah. I'm a single mom and been a single mom since day one. And I think I didn't really change my lifestyle after she was born, even though all of a sudden I had way more expensive, like, right, childcare. Yeah. And I think at the end of the day, Catherine, I mean, our biggest hope for people is, is changing your mindset and changing your behaviors, right? That follow this mindset shift. And that's happened for you. Like you've, you've done it. You're disgusted with the credit card debt. You hate seeing the end. I mean, this is all, you're on the right track, right? And so, I mean, like, you're going to be debt free either way, right? Right. So I started the journey in January. Yeah. It's amazing. And as a single mom, paying that much off, Catherine, it's incredible. It really is. I've done a great job. I've paid off 24,566 since January. It's amazing. It's amazing. This is the whole stretch. Yes. So Catherine's plan versus our plan. Our plan is all about momentum. It's about psychology. It's about behavior change. And we find when that interest hangs in the balance on that credit card debt, you're angry and you're going to keep going. Whereas if you pay off the credit card today, you might feel some relief. Maybe too much relief to where you get a little bit more comfortable. And you say, well, it's going to get paid off. I like the fuel that you have right now. I want you to use this anger to get out of debt by the end of January. Challenge yourself. To go, all right. I'm going to knock out all these debts with this bonus. It's going nowhere else but the debts. Every ounce I can squeeze out of this $9,000 income is going toward that next debt and it's going to be gone before you know it. Yeah. Yeah. That's okay. Catherine, you're good. We didn't convince you, but it's fine. I tried. I gave you either way. You're going to be out of debt. You're okay. You're okay. You've done a great job. You've done a really great job. Just so you hear us. We're rooting for you. We just want to get you on the Ramsey Plan because we know it works. And part of it too is being focused on one goal, right? And so when you have that smallest debt and you just knock it off, there is something with that momentum. When we talk about this, putting all of your income, all of your margin towards one thing that focus and actually every dollar is built, our app, around this idea of a one goal mindset. And so Catherine's done it though. I mean, I applaud her. I think she's done a fantastic job as a single mom paying off so much debt. And I think, yeah, I think the goal of January would be exciting, a debt for journey in one year. Beautiful. If you've ever thought, I don't even know where to start with life insurance. You're not alone. And that's exactly why I recommend Zander Insurance because the insurance world will throw everything at you, confusing words and add-ons like writers, whole life crap called an investment, return of premium, and it's all total junk. And most of that confusion you feel is by design. When you're confused, you make bad decisions, expensive decisions. But Zander doesn't play that game. They cut through the noise and help you get simple, affordable term life insurance that actually does what it's supposed to do. Check your family. They shop the top term life companies to compare your options on the coverage that your family needs no more, no less, no pressure, and no upsells. Just clear answers and the protection you need. If you've been putting off getting term life because it feels overwhelming, Stop worrying and get it handled the right way. Call 800-356-4282 or go to zander.com. That's zander.com. (upbeat music) Ryan is in Minneapolis, up next. What's going on, Ryan? How can we help today? - Hey guys, thanks for letting me on. - Absolutely. How can Rachel and I help? - So, my girlfriend and I had a little bit of a conflict trying to figure out like what is fair for her to pitch in on the household bills, little backstory is, I got divorced earlier this year. She's been going through a divorce. So when she moved out and then I moved in with her for a few months into an apartment. So she had some expenses for six months for an apartment. But you know, since we've been living at my house, but we were just talking about how much is fair for her to pitch in. She doesn't think that she should pitch in anything above the groceries because my income is much higher than hers. And she doesn't just find, and I do just find either one of us that much that I have a little bit of a mortgage. - Okay, so she's looking at this, not as a, hey, we're roommates, this is 50/50, but you're the breadwinner. You should cover all the bills. I'm a lady. I should just have to pitch in there here and there. - That's exactly right. - Well, here's the quagmire you've put yourself in. You guys. - What a word. - I like to throw it in once in a while. But you guys are obviously not married. You guys have been through a lot. And now all of a sudden we've merged our lives together without the marriage part, right? Which complicates things. 'Cause marriage, it'd be so much simpler for you guys to marry, right? It'd be one pool of money the bills get paid. Correct? - Yeah, that's, yeah, that's normally how a couple will work it out, but since we're not there yet, and who knows how long it'll take to get there. - Yeah, your roommates. I mean, that's financially how I look at it. It should be split. - So then if I had a roommate, I'm not going, will you make more? So therefore you should pay the rent. So now it's up to you guys to decide, okay, well, do we do it by percentages? We're going to do, you know, 50% of your income is going to go to bills, 50% of her income goes to bills. I don't know what makes, what is fair because this is a unique situation. But I also don't think it's okay to say, well, I'm not going to pay for rent. You should cover my life either when you guys aren't married. - Yeah, I'm not sure anyone's going to win here. - In my opinion, financially you guys are roommates. So it would be like if you had a roommate living in an apartment, how does that structure happen? And normally it happens that, yeah, you pay half your rent, I pay half the rent. - Half utility. - Half utilities, we're sharing a space, that's how it goes. But the fact that you guys are living together before your married, it creates this confusion. That's part of one reason I'm not a big fan of it, is because you're acting like you're married emotionally, you're living together, you're playing like you're married and her expectation is, hey, you should be taking care of me because this is the situation we're in, which I don't necessarily fault her for, but I also would tell her, yeah, but you're not married to him. So it's like you're playing like you're married, but you don't want to play finances like you're married as you shouldn't. You shouldn't. So that's where the scramble comes in. But, I mean, the black and white answer to me is no. I think it's, yeah, you're a roommate at that point. - What is the income difference? - I mean, a little bit of the, you know, it's kind of a mess, I mean, he just got out of a divorce. She was, you know, moved in through a divorce and I'm like, at the end of all this, who knows what's gonna happen? So yeah, I mean, out of the goodness of your heart, Josh, if you wanted, oh, Ryan, sorry, gosh, Ryan, if you wanted to chip in more, just because you want to, that's great, but I don't think you're obligated to. I think it's a roommate situation financially. I don't know. - What's the income difference? I'm just curious. The income difference is probably 100,000 more than the other. - Okay, so like you make 160, she makes 60, something like that? - Yeah, exactly. - Okay, and what's the rent? Like, what if your mortgage is huge and she just can't afford it? - Well, the mortgage and the utilities is only 28, 50 a month. All I was asking for was, you know, 100 bucks a week. Doesn't cover much, but it's at least it's like, hey, I'm pitching in and this is-- - So you're asking for $400 a month and she said that's too much? - Yeah, pretty much, and then she also said that, well, that money would be better for us if we put it towards a vacation fund instead. - Oh, boy. - Well, I'm just trying to get, I'm just trying to get, you know, what makes sense here? I don't need a whole new-- - I don't think the situation makes sense. So that's the problem. So starting with a difficult premise here, but what I would do is at least try to get a line on money values 'cause that's gonna be the number one thing. And so that will then dictate, hey, we have some, I have debt to pay off, so I'm not going on vacation. I'm not eating out. And that might turn into you guys going, all right, I'm gonna get groceries for me. We're gonna go on a date once a week and you're gonna pay for that. I think you guys should sit down and decide looking at the actual budget of the household. What is fair for who to pay? And you might realize she's just not wanted to play ball. And then you have a decision to make, don't you? You might decide-- - Yeah. - I'm gonna go get a roommate. I think you should go live elsewhere and this relationship will survive if we do that. 'Cause if not, it might go south. - Yeah. - Don't you think you'll become resentful if you just go along with whatever she says? - I, that's what I'm worried about, yeah. - That's my fear too. So that's where I think you guys need to have some further conversations. Not about percentages, but about what our life's gonna look like. - Yes. And her willingness to chip in and work hard, right? To create a team, 'cause that's what you guys have created in this atmosphere, right? And so when she isolates herself from it and ejects and it's like, I'm good, you just take care of it because you make more. It says something, right? And I don't know what kind of team player, she'll be in the future, I don't know. And it'd be one thing if she couldn't afford where you live, but she gets to live there because you live there and that's the situation you guys have set up. But if you're only asking for $400 a month, you're not being unreasonable, Ryan. - No, 'cause she'd have to pay that somewhere else, more than that. So I don't know. It's, listen, that's the, that's the messiness of playing like you're married and you're not, so, I don't know. - Call us back 'cause I just wanna know how this ends up, Ryan, out of a dark curiosity. We're wishing you the best. Savannah's in Minneapolis up next as well. Savannah, what's going on? Do you know Ryan? - Uh, hello. - Thank you for having me here. - That'd be hilarious if you were Ryan's girlfriend. - Thank you, Ryan's girlfriend. Many apples, many apples. (laughing) - She's like my boyfriend's horrible. - No, how can we help today? - So by boyfriend, I actually planning on moving in about 14 months. So I'm kind of just wondering like a good basis of how much I should have saved to move. And along with that, I am needing to purchase a car in the next year or two. So planning to save for that. And then I'm working on my, saving up my emergency fund right now and I have 2600 in there in a high yield savings account. - Good, any debt? - So I was kind of working at that. Yeah. - How much debt do you have? - No, I don't have any debt. I graduated 18 months ago and I paid off about 1500 so I got off about two months ago. Thank you. - So right now you're just building your emergency fund and I would set aside some of that on top of the emergency fund for a moving expense. So you said it's 14 months from now. You can start factoring out. Okay, what's it gonna cost for movers? What's the first and last months deposit for the rental? All of that will be helpful in calculating exactly how much you need? - Yeah, is it a local move or across the country or where you guys may think? - I'm thinking across state. - Okay, how much do you know what's happening in 14 months? - No, it's all up a mere. It's just kind of wanting to move there since we're young and experiencing something different. - Okay, curious. How much is he pitching in? - He'll be pitching in like half. Like we'll do a 50/50 split on rent and equity. - There we go. - He's talking to Ryan. - Look at that. That feels very fair. (laughing) Oh, well Savannah, the question, you have a lot of priorities now. You won't have moving costs. You have an emergency fund. You want to save up for a car. So I think what would be wise is getting that emergency fund as soon as possible. My guess is you can accomplish a lot of this and then wait on the car until you move, right? - Okay, yes, yeah. - Can you drive what you're driving right now for the next 18 months? - Yeah, I'm thinking so. - Great, then I'll just suck away as much money as you can. - Yeah, what are you making a year, Savannah? - A year I'm making about 50 grand after taxes and then after my gas and everything that comes out, I have about 24,000 and then a year is left over. - Awesome, okay. - Fantastic. - So yeah, build up that emergency fund. You can have a small savings on the side as well for that upcoming move, but also a lot can happen in 14 months. So I would, if you are working and there's a retirement plan, I'd probably start putting some money there after your emergency fund is built. I don't want you to miss that on those early years. - And just set up a sinking fund for that car replacement. Maybe it's 500 bucks a month, a thousand bucks a month, whatever you can put aside there. And when you need a new car, that's your car budget. Whatever's in that fund. If you're being crushed under the way to phone calls from debt collectors at all hours or getting nasty letters threatening a lawsuit, it can feel like there's no way out. But it's not too late. There is real help out there with Guardian litigation group. Guardian is an actual law firm, not one of those debt relief programs that promises sunshine and unicorns. And that matters. Because if a creditor comes after you, you need someone who can do more than negotiate over the phone. Guardian assigns you a real attorney from day one. So if a creditor sues, you've already got someone standing beside you. And Guardian doesn't charge you any extra to represent you in court. Guardian's attorneys have helped over 55,000 people settle more than $600 million in debt. And that is why I trust them and you can too. So look, there is a way out, but the longer this drags on, the fewer options you have. You have to deal with it now while you still can. So go to guardianlit.com/ramz. If you're new to the Ramsey show, every answer we give is rooted in the seven baby steps. So if you want to take a few minutes to learn about that plan, you'll get a whole lot more out of every episode. We're going to drop a link in the description of this episode if you want to learn more. Josh is in St. Paul, Minnesota, up next. What's going on, Josh? Hey, George E. Rachel, thanks for taking my call. Absolutely. What's your question? So I guess, in short, I'm reading the news, I'm kind of spooked about AI these days. It feels a little bit like I'm watching Terminator prequel. I'm wondering, how should I prepare my financial picture to either placate these fears or adjust? I love it. Well, great use of placate. That tells me you are a reader. You said you read the news. I didn't know people still do that. That's awesome. Well, you know, I scroll and see stuff like everybody else, I guess. Sure. Okay. So I'm not a big news guy. Now, I naturally see the headlines, our team sends us kind of the headlines that are in the financial worlds that we can keep up to date. So we're not just in a, you know, under a rock, but I don't follow the news, quote unquote. So I don't actually change anything I do financially based on what anyone in the news is saying or any headline for that matter. So my investing changed 0% with any AI bubble news or doom and gloom or the Nvidia CEOs going down. Should I sell? What's going to say? What a 24 hour news. So I follow the drama for entertainment, but I don't follow it for financial advice if that makes sense. For sure. And I feel like my financial picture is pretty secure. I invest in low cost index funds like you guys recommend that been doing it since I started working. I can weather a bubble. I can weather whatever crash I think is coming. I guess the thing that I'm really concerned about is what if it all comes crashing down. You know, I hear so many tech executives are saying that we need to be more worried about this. And I feel like politicians and executives are more about kind of, you know, adding more fuel to the engine of the market, rather than having any kind of protections or guardrails in place for what feels like a human mouse trap for me. Sure. Well, I would say a couple of things Josh, I think when you are in the drama of it day today, and that's all you're looking at and all you're reading, your mindset becomes pretty marginalized into the focusing on this one thing, right? And it can start to magnify possibly the reality of what's happening because the truth is no one knows what's going to happen. Nobody knows, right? And I think every generation, which I understand, this is like a tech, you know, situation that is newer and different than any other generation, but you go through and you look at, you know, during World War II, you go through the Vietnam, you go through all of these massive parts of history where everyone thought, oh my gosh, you know, the world could collapse, right? I mean, you go back to the recession, like when I got out of college, it was like we're not like the housing market may never come back, they may never be home. I mean, it's just that there is always going to be a moment in time where fear is a driver. And so what we try to do is not be naive to what's happening, but also not let fear be in the driver seat of our financial decisions because usually you make really bad decisions out of fear of what was the quote, who, I don't know, Cameron, who said this and make you make the worst financial decisions when you're afraid and when you're drunk. So don't make big decisions out of those two places, make it out of sound mind, right? And all, and what we can see is the facts of what's happening. And I mean, the market's still at 11.1% on average this year, right? And it's not done. I mean, it's had some ups and downs even over the last couple of months. But what do we know? We know over time, not in a short period of time, over time the market goes up and the American economy pushes through. And so you can choose to continue to believe on what history has shown us or predict a future that you can't predict and make bad calls. So we're saying the course because the truth is too, Josh, if everything hits the fan, if it's all over, it's all over. We're all going to be camping and looking for clean water. I mean, like, do you know what I mean? I'll be the first to go. I'd rather meet Jesus than stick around for that. So take me out. George will not be a rapper. I'll come to you as tributes. George is ready to be out of here if he has to come up. Deloney's not going to let me in. There's bunker. If there is no grid, George is out. George is like, Jesus, take me out. Without Wi-Fi, what's the point of living, you know what I mean? But I think it's a fair question, Josh. We're having a little bit of fun to like, you know, deflate the balloon because I do think if that is stressing you out, I would just delete the news apps and go live your life and you will find that life is better. Because you're now focused on the things you can control. Because what can I control about the AI bubble, the AI boom, the people at the top are saying it could kill us all. Okay, I still got to pay bills and put my daughter to bed. You know what I mean? And so I just kind of go, what are the things I can do day to day to get my family in a good place? Yeah. Don't owe people money. Have money in the stock market. Have money in an emergency fund. And all of those things have created a lot of peace in my life on top of not following all the headlines. Right. That sounds. That's three sound. How old are you, by the way? I'm 30 years old. Okay. I'm 30. Congrats. Well, you've still got a lot of life to live. Yeah. So I hope you get to like meet your grandkids one day and if not, a good, a good local church to make sure you're on the right side of things wouldn't hurt either, Josh. That is a great question. Oh my gosh. My mom always told me he's soon and very soon. We're going to meet the king. So I go, okay. She's been saying that since I was a little boy. It hasn't happened yet. But when it does, that's a silver lining. It's true. It's all a vapor. That's why we have faith because this is not our home. We're just stopping by for a little bit. There you go. There's a new world is created, but we won't get it. That's for another conversation. All right. Brenda's in St. Louis up next. Brenda, save us from ourselves. How can we help? Hello. Hello. Oh my gosh. Such an honor to speak to you both. Yeah. I'm Brenda. So my question is, I am an international student who is a non-resident, and therefore, I guess I'm wondering if your advice for credit cards, for credit schools, still remain for someone like me. I do intend to live here for the next three to five years, or even longer. I'm not sure. But everyone around me says, you need a credit card. You need a credit card, and I tell them, no, I don't. But everyone's like, you have to remember that the restrictions, that the privileges that come with being a resident and your citizens don't apply to you, so you will have difficulty in getting a car or getting renting a place, et cetera, if you don't have a credit score. So I guess, does your night and still remain the same for a situation like mine? That's a great question. And as far as I know, a credit score does not bypass any legal boundaries of being a non-resident or resident. All it does is help you get a loan. And so if you're planning on going to go get a car loan, it might be helpful. But our advice would be, don't go into a car debt, just save up and buy the car you can afford in cash. And when it comes to renting an apartment, what they're going to look for is they're going to do a background check to make sure you're not a criminal, and they're going to look for proof of income. If you have both of those things, they're going to say great. Majority will, yes, you can rent here. And you may need first month rent, last month's rent security deposit in cash, Brenda. But all that upfront, yes, they will treat you from a financial perspective, probably in a very similar way, right? They may pull your credit report. But if you haven't been in debt, there's not going to be anything on it, right? But you can show proof of income. And if you have bills that you have paid like your cell phone or different things that you're paying on a monthly basis, you don't have that proof too. So that's it. I mean, at the end of the day, the credit score is for you to go deeper in debt. But if you don't want to go into debt, which is what we teach, it's really a non-issue at that point. Because your credit is the same as my credit right now. It is invisible. It doesn't exist. It's undeterminable. And so I would have the same process. They're going to go to pull your credit report to make sure that you don't have misbehavior on there, you know, bankruptcies, delinquencies. But if it just shows up indeterminable, you just say, hey, I don't borrow money. So I don't have a credit score. but here's my proof of income. You can do a background check. I've got the first month's rent, and you'll be in great shape. So I would not be concerned. Your friends are, they're just normal and they don't know any different. And so it's hard for them to wrap their brains around how to live outside of this broken system that America's created for itself. Or everything revolves around debt, everything revolves around your three digit number. And then it makes Lenders life easier. To go, we can lend to Brenda. She's got an 800. Or you can just pay with cash and live a simpler life. What are you going to do Brenda? Are you going to live the debt-free life? Yes, that's what Harry wanted to do. There we go. Hey, man, how do we end up? That's the end of the mentality that built this country. So we like, yes. You think they showed up to Ellis Island going, all right, you got to sign up for our discover card now? No. They went and built something. They made some of them themselves. [MUSIC PLAYING] When you take your car to the shop, you're probably thinking two things. How much is this going to cost me? And is it going to get done right? What you need is a mechanic who will give you transparent information so you can make the best decision for your car and your wallet. Christian Brothers Automotive is the official auto repair shop of the Ramsey show because you can trust them to take care of your vehicle the right way. Their digital vehicle inspections let you see exactly what their technicians see, giving you confidence on which repairs are urgent and which ones can wait. Plus, every repair is backed by their nice difference warranty. Three years or 36,000 miles. With a guarantee like that, you can walk away knowing that your car and your wallet are taking care of. Schedule your service today and get 10% off your visit at cbac.com/ramsey or click the link in the description. That's cbac.com/ramsey. 10% off up to a $250 value. See store for details. [MUSIC PLAYING] Joy is in Washington, DC. Up next, Joy, welcome to the show. Hi, thank you for having me. So my question is in regards to, I'm pretty sure my boyfriend is about to propose actually a 100% sure and exciting. Yes, and honestly, a lot of important foundational things in your line pretty well. And I do love him. However, financially, we've done a line. I definitely follow the fence. They run cmeters. I don't have any. That's outside of my mortgage. I have six months of expenses of an emergency fund based up of expenses. I invest 15% into my full-on case from each paycheck. I also invest in a brokerage account as well. Just separate on a monthly basis. However, for him, he does have a substantial amount of credit card debts. We've talked about it in the past and in the past. He took on enough of a second job to try to pay down. He paid it down then and went back up again. So it's almost like a line there. And that worries me a lot because I don't like that at all. And it kind of scares me a little bit. It doesn't scare me because I know it can't be paid off, but it's something I prefer to avoid if I can. That's fair. That would be scary. Money fights and money problems are usually in the top three reasons for divorce. It's a serious contention when it happens and when your value systems are aligned, not that it makes marriage perfect by any means, but it does make it much easier because you're making big decisions about life through the same paradigm, right? And you guys will be coming at this in two different ways. And so you just have to know going in, if that's the case, it's going to be an uphill battle. And what's unfortunate about it is that you can't change him as much as you want to try to talk him into doing it a different way. At the end of the day, it's going to be up to him to kind of face his demons and figure out like, oh my gosh, why do I keep overspending? And what do I keep going into massive amounts of credit card debt? And he's going to have to figure that out. Is it, do you think it's, is it sloppiness and not being detailed and not really just caring? Or is it, um, he, you know, he intentionally is, is going out and knows, you know, exactly what he's doing. I don't know. I'm just trying to get a gauge of his attitude towards it. What do you think the root of this is? I think it's a combination of a few things, um, I think, um, when we talked about it, it's just kind of how he grew up. That's always what he, his parents did, so that's what he did. And also, um, um, just like a lot of lifetimes happened and whenever it happens, rather than preparing for it, um, preparing for it, he just defaults to use in the credit card. What he be willing to cut it out? And he does make, he does make good money if he spends it all. Yeah. That's a legitimate fear. If you said, Hey, I know we're trying to move our future along, but there's something we need to figure out before we move forward. And that's this money stuff because I'm scared. If I'm marrying you, I want a great teammate, I want a partner. I want someone who is stable, who can provide and I'm scared because I know if we get married and you continually go into debt, it's going to drag us both down. And I'm not okay with that. You don't want to babysit him your entire marriage financially, right? Like there's a level you want him to step up and be mature and he can still be a spender and enjoy life, but he also has to show constraints and he has to show that he can create a plan about it with his money, stick to it, right, and be an adult because there's a level of immaturity that can happen where it's like, I'm just going to go do what I want all the time. And that doesn't, I think as a woman, you're like, that's not a very attractive quality. I do want, again, he can still be kind of a free spirit and a spender. I think that's great, but the prioritization of where this money's going and what I'm doing with my money is going to trump my just feelings if I just want to have fun. Does that make sense? Yeah, that makes some things fun. Yeah. So that's what I would want from him. And I think you need to communicate that. And again, at the end of the day, it sucks because you're not going to be able to change him, but these conversations are going to be important for you to have for you joy. And if you don't speak up and say something, then I think that's where the regret comes in. And then if the marriage does go through, probably a lot of resentment and fear around the subject. So I would be as vocal as possible. And then I think joy, you have to make a decision for yourself of, here's a boundary that I'm just not willing to cross, you know. And people do that a lot. Like some people, you know, it's in laws. And someone's like, sorry, I'm going to be living next door to my parents for the rest of my life. And if you don't want to do that, and you're like, I don't want to be that close to my in laws, that's a, that's a boundary, right? Or, you know, spiritually, if someone's like, I want someone that isn't the same realm of my faith. And someone outside of that, I'm probably not going to marry. And that person, if they don't, you know, then you choose not to marry them. I mean, these are boundaries that are really, really difficult, but it's, it's safe guarding you joy. So I think you have to think for yourself, what is a deal breaker and what's not? And that's up to you. That's not for us to decide, right? Yeah. Because we always tell people, too, you can marry people that have debt. It's not like, oh my gosh, someone has to be debt free before I marry them. But also, it's their attitude towards it. Are they wanting to get out and live a debt free life if that's what you want? That's the important part is that that value system alignment. So I would communicate that as much as possible to him. But at the end of the day, he has to make his decisions and you have to make yours. But you're not being cruel or petty or overbearing for saying, I need to align on this before move forward. Yeah. And I think, too, you can, I mean, I don't know. Let's maybe controversial. If you love him, you could still say yes to the proposal and just be like, hey, before we get married, though, you know, I need these things worked out during this engagement. This is the time to really get in the nitty gritty of our relationship to see, are we going to make it right? If you're okay with that, knowing that in the balance, you may break off an engagement or not. Like, I would be, I would be okay with that. You're not, you're not becoming his wife the day you get engaged. I don't know. Would you say yes to an engagement? I'd be fine with it. I would try to have this conversation on a line before him, but if you pops the question tomorrow and you, this is your man, get off the phone and call me and I'm just kidding. But I'm like, he loves you that much and he's gone, nah, but I'm not cutting up my credit card. That's too much. That just tells me something that he, he values this life over here more than this future life with you. And that's the part that worries me more is why hasn't he just cut up the cards because he knows it's something you're so passionate about. Have you asked him to just straight up stop using credit cards all together, cut up the card, close the account? All right. I really had the conversation. I didn't want to tell him to do this. I want to have him to execute it on his phone until his death is important to me. I need you to have a plan. That was in the beginning of the year. I need you to have a plan and I need you to execute on it. And when we had the check out, check in conversation about it, and he seemed like he said he had a plan, he stayed at his plan, he got a part time job, not to add extra income towards the depth when we checked in, the balance had barely moved, which meant his income also increased and the balance hadn't moved. But then a couple months later, there was he paid off one of the credit cards, and that was something he celebrated. My TA happened, however, two months later, out of other check-ins, the balance of that credit card is up again. And the initial conversation when we paid off that one, the first one was he's not going to move it again. Why did he go back into credit card debt joy? Did something happen? And there was an event, or it just was spending. So that's self-control in my head, right? Like at the end of the day, I'm like, okay, if you can't control your spending, I don't know, there's a character thing there for me. And my fear is a lot of people kick this can down the road and say, well, once we're married, we combine things, it'll be easier, we'll figure it out. And then it doesn't get figured out, the behavior stays the same. That same lack of self-control carries on in a marriage, and that's what can destroy it. And so I want to get ahead of that instead of just going, we'll figure it out over time. I'm with Rachel, you can still get engaged if this is your man, but make it very clear that we cannot move forward, pass this until we figure this out. And this is that important to me. I don't know that you've made it that clear to him where you're like, and it's an ultimatum, like cut it up or I'm out, I don't think it has to be at that level, but maybe you've been too kind, you know what I mean? Figure out the boundary and communicate the boundary to him. That's so hard. Yeah, you're welcome joy. You know what? My fear is, I don't want to speak this over them, but it's those kind of couples that end up with a secret credit card, right? And they're like, oh my gosh, how she feels about it. And he has to out our retirement to go spend because he couldn't, because he couldn't stop spending, right? So I'm like, there's a character thing we need if we need to talk through. And in sloppiness and just like, I don't know, your responsibility is one thing, but when it's like deliberately, now I'm going to choose to go back in. That's another. Right now, you've got the opportunity to do two of the best things at the same time. Be outrageously generous and keep more of your money away from the IRS. It's called the education freedom tax credit. Right now, there are kids all over the country who can't get the education they deserve because their families can't afford it. That's just not okay. But when you contribute through ACE scholarships, you'll give a kid a real shot at a better education. And in exchange, you'll get a federal tax credit up to $1,700 for individuals or $3,400 for married couples filing jointly, meaning it could end up costing you nothing to help. They've given over 120,000 scholarships to families almost $400 million. Guys, this is a no-brainer. Learn more about ACE and this amazing opportunity at educationfreedom.org. That's educationfreedom.org. Welcome back to the Ramsey show in the Fairwinds Credit Union studio. I'm George Campbell here with Rachel Cruz taking your calls at AAA8255225. Cody is in Cedar Rapids up next. Cody, what's going on? Are you with us? Cody has us on mute. Just rude, Cody. We tried. We tried. We'll get you. We'll try to get you back on air in a second and instead we will go out to Annie and St. Louis. What's going on, Annie? Hi there. I am calling because it is open enrollment period and I'm trying to figure out if I should get additional supplemental life insurance due to our family size and the fact that I didn't account for bonuses when we got our life insurance. Okay, great question. So do you have life insurance through your employer? Is that what you're talking about? Well, yes. We have two term life and two term life policies outside of work. Good. And then work provides him with I think four times his salary and we can purchase additional supplemental life insurance through work. We're not a ton of money and I'm just trying to figure out do I include his bonuses when I'm calculating how much we need? Yeah, what are they pretty predictable per year? It was big this year but we have gotten one every year. What would be the average for those? I mean, I would say maybe 60,000. Okay. If those bonuses went away, would it affect your family's expenses lifestyle? Do you kind of count on it as far as your spending goes? No. Okay, I would include them. I think you'll feel better. It's not that much extra to ensure at that point if you're already getting 10 to 12 times your income. I would lean towards the 12 side and be done there. So you said you have two policies. What are those add up to as far as the multiplier of your incomes? It's under 10 times outside of work. I think gosh, I can't do the math quickly. No, it's fine. I'm just trying to get it outside of your employer. I think it's great. He has one through his employer, but I always recommend having it outside and having enough outside of it that if he left that job tomorrow, you're not in a lurch because getting life insurance later on is going to be more expensive and more difficult. Right. Well, and also we've been working the plan. We are babies that millionaires, but I just did the math. It looks like we have like between six and seven times his income outside of work because his income has gone up since we got those term policies. Okay. As far as family size, I wouldn't increase it based on family size. That wouldn't be a factor in the multiplier. It's really about do your expenses grow at the family size, and at that point, do you need to increase your term life insurance? Yeah. Is he the only one working, Annie, or are you working? He's the only one working, but I'm thinking, my gosh, if something happened to him and we still need to send seven kids, we're going to send them all to college. Right. But really fast, yeah. Yeah. So I would take his income and I would do that 10 to 12 times, you know, you're ain't going to give him what we teach. And then Annie, you and you need a term life policy on you as well, just as I have that. Okay. Great. Perfect. Yep. So you'll prop. Yeah. So you will up it because you said his income has gone up. And you know, and it's and if you guys are healthy and stuff, to me, it is so worth it. Like Winston, I just went through this probably two years ago, and and we kept ours, you know, because we say at some point, you can be self-insured. If you, you know, if something happens, you know, that you'd be okay. But for us, I was like, it's still just so inexpensive that I'm like a couple hundred bucks a year. It's just worth it. You know, and so so raising it, hopefully, isn't going to be a massive, you're not going to feel a massive swing for what you pay for it. So go ahead and I'd go big because while you're young, right? And put that into and put that term policy in place and yeah, how old the youngest kid? Um, 10. Okay. So 10 years from now, that child may be out of the house. Right. I'm just wondering, maybe you stack a new policy on top of the ones you have for him. Maybe it's a 10 year or a 15 year policy through Zander that you make sure the youngest kid is out of the house by the time this policy is over. That would make me sleep better at night. Yeah, my husband is older. So I don't like, I don't know how expensive it would be to get new term policies even shorter ones. Yeah. Um, so he has one that has another five years and then one that has another 10 years. Okay. Good. Um, I would just jump on as enter.com and just start pricing it out and just see if it's reasonable for his age and if he would qualify and you might find because your income so high and it's so affordable, you might go, you know what? Sure, it's 800 bucks a year for 10 years. But that eight grand we spend is going to be well worth it for the peace of mind, knowing that we got all the kids through college and more of something God forbid would happen. But you would not necessarily do the supplemental life insurance that's offered through work. I would or you maybe would, but you wouldn't count it toward the 10 to 12. Exactly. Yeah. And at that point, okay, I would just try to get it outside of it. Now, if he can, for some reason, he can get it through work, but not through outside of work, then sure, I would take it what I can get. But it just worries me because work can change on a dime. I mean, if he got laid off tomorrow, there goes the policy. And so that's what scares me when people have it through work. It's not the autonomy. It's nice he has four times to work. Generally, it's about one year when you get it through an employer and people think, well, I'm covered through work. And I go, no, you're not. Yeah. You have a 60 grand instead of 600 grand. Yeah. That's a huge difference. All right. Cody, are you there? Yes. We got you, bud. All right. How can we help? So I had a question about finances. Big personal story. So three and a half years ago, my wife passed away. Happy age of 33, four-year-old son. Oh my gosh, Cody. I'm sorry. So hard. Yeah. Hey, I get through. I'm 39, about 340. About a year ago, I started dating again. I have had me on say. For some reason, like, you know, my life is a homemaker, you know, say home life, mother. So, security isn't much. It's about 790 a month. How much do you make? I used to make, used to make about 3200 a month. What do you make now? I still have spine surgery. So I'm on children to the ability. Oh, wow. Okay. When do you think you'll be back working again? It won't be till early December at the latest. Okay. So a few weeks. And then you'll be making 30200 again. Yeah, I make, but you had 4 grand a month. Yeah. It's been really hard. I, um, how can we help today? My boy is seven. And now, you know, my, uh, my fiance is also widow. And she's pulling my from her husband. Okay. So Cody, what I would probably recommend is probably the best, um, action plan for you is we'll get you every dollar. If you, if you hold on the line, we're going to pick up, um, and really concentrate on where that 3200 is going. And don't combine finances with your fiance until you guys are married. So keeping that separate is going to be really important through this engagement, but budgeting every single dollar of that 3200 is going to be key. When I hear the words open enrollment, I'm immediately stressed out. And the same goes when I hear deductible and premium, you probably feel this way too, choosing the best, most affordable healthcare for your family can be overwhelming. Will my premiums go up? Is the doctor I want even in my network? Can I even afford this? Well, the good news is there's a different option. Christian healthcare ministries, CHM isn't insurance. It's a health cost sharing ministry where members share each other's eligible medical bills. So instead of premiums, you make a monthly contribution with programs starting at just $115 a month. And here's something you don't hear often. They're not raising their prices this year. Guys, this is huge. And you also get to choose your own healthcare provider, no network limits. And unlike traditional insurance, you can join at any time. There's no enrollment window. And best of all, you don't have to choose between your health and saving money. With CHM, you can have both. It's why Ramsey has trusted them for over 15 years. Visit CHministries.org/budgets and use promo code Ramsey to get a 50% credit towards your first month of membership. It's that time of the year and a few weeks, we're going to be doing a special giving edition of the Ramsey show. And we want to hear your stories about how you have given generally this season, a generously this season. Maybe you tipped a waitress, a hundred bucks, bought Thanksgiving dinner for a family who couldn't afford one. Maybe you've even blessed someone in need by giving them a car. And on the other side, maybe you've been on the receiving end and you had your life changed by someone who gave generously to you. We want to hear all of those stories. So go to ramseysolutions.com/ask and put giving in the subject line and share. We do this every year at Christmas time. It's one of our most popular shows. It's one of our favorites to do. And it's coming up on December 17th. So start sending in those stories of giving today and let's celebrate living and giving like no one else. Grant is in New Mexico up next. What's going on, Grant? Hey, how's it going? Good. Thank you guys for taking my call. I really appreciate it. Sure. Yeah, how can we help today? So about 18 months ago, I have my wife and three kids. And about 18 months ago, I worked for a federal entity and had to take an emergency transfer. One of my kids has a medical issue that we are having issues resolving. She is going to be three in the next couple of months. She's been under surgery six times and three of them have failed. And so where my wife and I are is about five years ago, we got on the same page and we really wanted to start attacking our debt. We started at 113,000. And a couple of weeks ago, we finalized that 113. And you're dead free? Wow, you paid off all that. Yes, we did. Oh my gosh, Grant. Well done. We started at about 65 and right now we're at about 127 income income. Okay. Yeah. Okay. So that's just with our base salaries, my wife and I both have two jobs. But where we're at right now is when I had to move from a really remote location in Alaska back down to the lower 48 because I was traveling so much for my kid. And we maxed out a credit card with how expensive it is to move. And so what happened was is I talked to my parents and with it, my parents don't have a lot of money, but they were willing to help out with that expense because it had to do with their granddaughter. And so they helped out. They paid off that credit card. And then the idea was is that I would just pay them a set amount of interest. And so and I know I listened to your show and I know you guys don't say ever take loans from family and I completely understand it. This, it has created some friction, I would say between my dad and I. And so it's kind of a double-sided question for you. Do I do I take a look? We have about $85,000 in retirement, but we don't own a home. We are renting right now. And so we're we're really kind of stuck with the idea of I owe my parents roughly 12,000. And do I take a loan on my retirement account and just pay them off? And then because what the market's right now, I mean, roughly I'm doing somewhere between eight and 16% depending on the stock. And then, but if I take that loan, I'll pay myself back at 5.375%. So I understand. Yes. Yes. Just trying to do I take that loan because I have no, I don't really have any aspirations to pay it off early with it being a set amount. So you're getting so interested built in? Yeah. I mean, it's tell me this grant. So you guys, I mean, I know that there's probably a lot of medical expenses with your daughter, but you guys make 127 a year. My question is how much margin do you guys have a month? Like if you could, if you could get this paid off in three months, right, put 4,000 towards it. Is that a, is that a, is that a reality? Like if you were really like, listen, we're doing nothing. We are just going to pay this debt off. Then you don't have to worry about all the hoops, right? If it's going to be done in 90 days. So the idea is like, I don't have like that aspiration to pay it off early because of that interest that is. I don't understand. You said it's damaging the relationship. I mean, you want out. You don't care to pay it off. So are you okay with the relationship being damaged forever at that point? I mean, it's already damaged. Well, I would, I had a good conscious grant. I would, I would be motivated. I would just attack the debt is you're still going to be attached to them. And, and I think for what it is going through the hoops of even going to your credit union and taking out a $12,000 loan, which you could do. I'm just wondering if you just really buckled down and just say we're going to, we're going to just pay this off in the next four months and be done. So there's no agreement on a payment or timeline right now? No, it's just they, they understand. It started out at 17. I'm down to 12. So how much could you realistically throw it at a month if this was your one focus? I could pay it off in about three and a half months. Okay. Just do it. Give yourself 90 days and just be done with it. Robbing your 401k is not the move. It's going to cost you a lot. It's going to then unplug all of the growth of that money and put you in a lurch. If you were for some reason to have a change in employment, you have to pay that back very soon or else it's treated as a withdrawal. So for all those reasons and the relational side, just pay it. Just be done in 90 days. Even with the set amount of interest. Even with, even if it was zero percent interest, I don't care. It's a debt you owe. And we want this relationship to at least stay where it's at and not get worse. Okay. And I think for your own conscious too, I think you'll, I think you will sleep better at night grants with no attachment financially to them. Yeah, absolutely. And you learned, uh, you know, an expensive lesson about borrowing money from family because you've now see what happened, what it does to relationships. It's not worth it. And I get why I mean, like the reasoning, right, is for the dot, the sick kid. So, uh, so yeah, I mean, yes. So, but you would have been better off to paying the hospital in medical bills and negotiating with them versus taking the money from dad. So I'm sorry you're going through that. And we are wishing the best for that, that sweet girl. Jack is in Detroit up next. Jack, how can we help? Hi, all, um, I have a friend who was in some financial strain. Um, he had a little credit card debt, but he invited me in, he took care of it. Um, but now we're trying to build not just like, got the data the way we want to build. Um, he then school has one and a half years of school remaining. He had the full right need based scholarship, um, but he has no financial baseline, no emergency savings, no, not even cash flow to cover expenses long term. But he has a vehicle gifted to him by a family member. That's worth $38,000. Um, he has an attachment to the car, um, but as someone who he's invited me into his life, I've advised him to sell the car and he has him angst about that. Um, so I was just wondering, how you would give me some advice to approach on my friend and how I could help him in a situation? Is it, does he owe money on the car or it was a gift? It was a gift. The car is fully paid off and insurance is covered until he graduates. I think he's fine keeping the car. I just think he probably needs a job to start, you know, having some cash available. What kind of a work is he going to be doing after school? He wants to go into ministry. Oh, well, I'm just looking at the numbers here. We say no more than half your income tied up in cars, a guy starting out ministries, probably not making 80 grand, but he didn't buy it. That's when you are, when you buy a car and you're using your income to fund your life, that's one thing. But when it's a gift, I don't think that's wrong. It's still an upkeep. That's a nice car. The problem isn't the car financially. It's, um, it's a, yeah. But if he wants to put himself in a great position to do ministry without stress, being completely debt-free with an emergency fund is the best way to do that. So here's the thing. If he can't accomplish that by the time he graduates and has a job or can't do it very soon after, I would say, let's sell the truck. He doesn't have to do it today. But the truck is not the issue. No, but it's a get out of jail free card to set him up for a life of serving the Lord, Rachel. Stop. I'm just saying, okay, George and I have different opinions. I don't think the truck is the issue. I think him making money, learning to live on his income, setting his income aside for an emergency fund and doing the baby steps with his income is what's key. If he can do that on a new minister income, props to him. I will be very happy for him. Yeah, but if he sells the truck, George, you get an emergency fund and what? You still have to live off of his income. Get a cheaper car. It'll be all right. Keep the truck. I love a good sale. I also love the holidays, but if you're like me, it's sometimes those two don't mix well because six promo codes and a commercial later, it's so easy to convince yourself that you need just one more scented candle or a waffle maker shaped like a Christmas tree and some flannel pajamas. The temptation to spend more than you budgeted for is real. That's why I love having a bank that keeps my free spirit and check. And for me, that's fair winds credit union with their smart bundle. You can choose a Ramsey themes debit card that says live like no one else. It's a great reminder to stick to your goals and what you're working toward, especially in a season that wants you to spend instead of save. You get a no monthly fee checking account and a high yield savings account. You can even open up additional savings accounts like a holiday fund for gifts. So you can finally pull the trigger on that waffle maker because staying on track for the holidays doesn't mean giving up your free spirit. It just means being smart about it. So get your live like no one else debit card by opening a smart bundle today at fairwinds.org/ramsey. That's fairwinds.org/ramsey insured by the NCUA. Our question of the day is brought to you by Ask Ramsey, your free AI money tool that provides personalized money answers based on Ramsey principles. Visit ramseysolutions.com/askramsey. Today's question comes from Andy in Mississippi. My wife and I work hard and don't want to sacrifice all of our family time just to keep our heads above water. We bring home $4,800 a month, but our monthly budget shows $6,500 in expenses. We have approximately $70,000 in credit card debt and personal debt plus $50,000 in student loans. All accounts are current, but we make minimum payments and then rely on credit cards for everyday expenses. We start using every dollar, cancel subscriptions and reach out to creditors about hardship assistance without success. What do you recommend when you're already living on a tight budget? Your payments exceed your income and you genuinely don't know how to make the numbers work? Wow. Okay. So they got $120,000 in debt. They make about $57,000 take home, but here's the rub. They are spending $78,000 a year. That's frightening. So that means they're going to go deeper into debt by 21 grand a year at this rate, all in order to have family time. I don't know how you're going to have any level of family time. That's peaceful where you're actually present for it. When you have that hanging over your head and it's getting worse. So in my mind, you guys need to get your income way up. It's the only answer. I mean, at this point, because unless you choose to move, like maybe your mortgage or rent is eating up half your income, but you, you mathematically can't do this. You cannot live on more than you make over a long period of time. It's just, it's not going to work. So you have to, you know, yeah, make those sacrifices. And so it may mean switching jobs and for a few years, maybe working in an industry you didn't want to work at, but it's paying you 10 grand more. So you're going to do it, right? I mean, there, there's a given take in this. But from a math perspective, yeah, you cannot live like this much longer because the, the walls will be caving in very, very quickly. And so you do have to make decisions, either continue to cut lifestyle, which it sounds like you have, but then you have to then choose to live and even a cheaper lifestyle. And that's, that's the math of it. Sometimes you can make more and solve the problem. Sometimes you can spend less and solve the problem. This is a situation where you need to do both an drastic way. You need to cut your expenses down to four grand and go make six, seven, eight a month in order to pay this debt off in a reasonable amount of time. So thanks for the question, Andy, but you're going to have to sacrifice because your family deserves a life of peace and not stressful, debt weighing over their heads for the rest of their life. All right, Zach is in New York City up next. What's going on, Zach? Hey, thank you both for taking my call. So my girlfriend and I have been dating for four years, and we're both 25 years old. And we both currently live with our parents. My girlfriend finishes her masters in about a month, and she will graduate with 120 K and student loan debt. So my question is, do we wait to move out until the bulk of the loans are paid off? Wait to move out like the two of you? Correct. And get a place just to kill us. So that's your plan is where once she graduates gets her masters, ideally, you guys would just move in together. So that would be the ideal situation. However, the 120 K and student loan that 50 K of that is private and has an interest rate greater than 9%. And then there's another 50 K between 80% and 5% and then the remainder is just under 5. Well, what should you be making when she graduates? She'd probably make somewhere around 70,000 and I currently make 82,000. Okay. And you make 82. What's your financial situations, Zach? Do you have any debt? No, I don't have any debt. I've been working for around three years now after college. I pretty much saved everything since I don't have to pay any rent. I can't let me live here for free. So I've just been stacking up cash. Gotcha. Okay. So what I would suggest Zach is that you make a financial decision on what's based for you. You're worried a lot about a woman that you're not legally tied to, right? It's your girlfriend, which I understand maybe she's going to be your wife in the future. But from a, from a financial perspective, she shouldn't be holding you back at all. So you need to decide what's best for Zach, what can Zach afford. This is all you, it's really two separate conversations. And so whatever she can afford is what she can do. But I wouldn't be waiting around for her, um, from a financial perspective, because you're not going to be combining finances anyways, because you're not married. Correct. Which makes sense. I mean, the long term goal would be to once we move out, uh, then pursue, uh, see it to get engaged and stuff like that. - Do it now, propose to her. - Yeah, why in that order? - Have a wedding, have a wedding next summer, and you'll be married and start your lives. - Yeah, it's more so, like the thought would be, you know, just like having that debt, it's like why would we spend money on a wedding and engagement? - Because you love her. - You know what? - Your wife and soulmate. - Let's say it takes her. - Should Trump, should Trump your finances, okay? - Here I say that, we never tell people not to get married or have babies if you have debt. Live your life, debt is debt, money is a tool to create a life that you love. It's not the thing we're working towards. We're working towards beautiful things in life and marriage and the love of your life, like that's the valuable stuff, Zach, not the money side. You guys can figure out the money side later. - Yeah, and that makes total sense. - Can we get to the crux of it? - I think you're scared to hit your wagon to her because of this debt and you don't wanna have to sacrifice and pay the price and pay it off with her. Is that somewhat accurate? - No, I would say that I'm like totally in the boat of like, you know, she is low in my life. So I am there to walk with her, be this debt journey. I've been listening to you guys forever. So my main thing would be is we, if we move out and she's paying down this loan and I'm paying off the rent, we would pretty much be living paycheck to paycheck if I pay the rent in full and she pays just sends her money to the loans. - Let's fast forward and say you guys were buried and combined incomes. How would that change things as far as paycheck to paycheck? - I mean, the thing is like, I have money saved up, so like I could-- - How much? - And sends like around like 250K. - What? - Okay, well, there's our answer. - So would you be willing to, you get back from the honeymoon, would you write a check and be done with all the student loans? - I would definitely-- - Why not? - 'Cause it's a clue, no. - No, just tell me why not. - Just because it's like I spent so much time saving all this up for us. - Zach, I'm telling you, bro, there is some resentment here. And it's okay to feel that way. This is a natural feeling. You worked your tail off to save up 250 grand, didn't you? Like you've been stacking acorns over here, and you don't wanna let go of all those acorns for someone else's lack of planning who went into 120 grand as to loan debt. That's fair to say, right? It hurts to let that money go. Half of your savings wiped out. But here's the thing, what are you gonna do? Wait for her to pay off her debt in 12 years to get married? Been together 16 years now. So here's, if I'm in your shoes, if it's the love of my life, you guys are gonna build so much wealth together. I'm gonna go ahead and get engaged, get married, and when you guys are married, combine your lives then, combine your money, and pay off the student loans. And you can save back up over 20 years. - Yes, and she's the one Zach, yes, moving forward, because you guys pretending to play house and pretending like you're married, and well, she's not gonna pay rent, 'cause you can't afford it. And I don't know, you're trying to force a situation that was never supposed to be, right? And so, and it sounds old fashioned, but it's true. So there's been so much research coming out about people waiting and just prolonging it, of like, well, let's just see, let's just see, let's just see. And actually, the quality of marriage of those that just choose it and do it actually ends up higher. And again, I'm not saying to be irresponsible and marry someone you don't know or whatever, right? But if she is it, then I would start your lives together, combine your money, you guys, man, you could be on a best footing, but I wouldn't do it for the money, but I also wouldn't do it because of the money. Yeah, is she marrying you because she knows you have a big old bank account that can pay off her student loans? - No, she has no idea, to be honest. - Oh, juicy. Well, that'd be a fun surprise when you guys get married, you know, let's make a plan to pay this off in 10 years. And you go, "JK, I paid 'em off." Dude, that's a man right there. That's pretty incredible. I'm just saying, you moving together now before you're married with a bunch of debt. - You're not getting engaged. You're gonna call us back three years from now. She's gonna call back and say, "We've been together seven years. "He won't propose 'cause I have student loan debt." I don't wanna be on the other end of that call. (upbeat music) - With all the crud and negativity in movies and TV right now, it's rare to hear a story about someone actually doing something good, which makes Angel's newest movie, the rare exception out there. It's called Hershey, as in Hershey Chocolate. And if you've never heard the backstory of Milton Hershey, it's pretty incredible. I mean, he got knocked down over and over trying to get the business going. Even went bankrupt, but he ended up leaving a really cool legacy of outrageous generosity in his community. It's really inspiring stuff. You can see it in theaters for free by getting an Angel Guild Premium membership. When you sign up, you also get Angels Entire Streaming Library plus free tickets to every Angel movie that comes to theaters. Hershey is in theaters on November 25th. Get your free tickets by signing up for the membership at angel.com/ramsy, or click the link in the description. Limited time offer, visit angel.com/ramsy for details. (upbeat music) The live like no one else, Cruz, is almost full. Don't miss your chance to join us March 14th through the 21st, 2027. It's an all-inclusive Caribbean vacation. Seven days of Ramsey Entertainment, including Time with Dave and all of us Ramsey personalities. All new wealth building teachings. The world's largest yet free-screen live tapings of your favorite Ramsey shows, which I assume is Smart Money Happy Hour with Rachel and I. - As it should be. - We're gonna couple of those. - As it should be. - A lot of shenanigans are gonna happen. It's gonna be an awesome time. And right now you can bring more of your favorite people along because for a limited time, third and fourth passengers, sale free. Plus you can unlock a free cabin upgrade with code sale with Dave, no spaces. So for offer details and to book your cabin, go to ramseysolutions.com/events. Bethany is in Seattle up next. Bethany, welcome to the show. - Hi. - How's it going? - Good. My question is, I am five months pregnant. And as we enter, me and my husband is in the season of life. He is feeling like this is the season to be very proactive on saving for home ownership. And I'm feeling like I just want to enjoy this time and I don't want to stress ourselves out for these maybe year or two. And I'm just wondering if I'm being irresponsible and is it okay to hold off for a season? - Yeah, I mean, I don't think it's you being irresponsible and I think it is okay to hold off for a season. I think you just have to figure out your opportunity cost and the reality that where you guys will be in two years if you don't make a lot of sacrifices and really focus that extra margin towards saving for a house. It's just gonna be a prolonged purchase, right? And so, and I think what's difficult is sometimes when we don't think long term and we just live in what feels good in the moments, we sometimes regret that 'cause it can be kind of fleeting, right? So I wonder if there's like a middle ground here that in your five months pregnant to Bethany. So I'm like, you're about to be, is this your first? - Uh, yes. - Okay. - Yeah, so it's about to be, yeah, so I'm like, you know, first time mom, I understand that you're like, "Whoa, I just wanna be enjoying this moment in time "which I think is great." So maybe you guys say, "Hey, when the baby's six months, "let's reevaluate and look to see how much money "we can put away to start saving for a house." - What are you planning on spending? What's sort of your, if I waived a magic wand, where would you spend it how much? - I just don't wanna have to think about it. I don't, I'm not so keen on our finances. I will, I could see how it could be a prolonged issue that I'm not. Home ownership isn't in my heart the same way it's on his. I really just enjoy the moment and like, that's probably, he's a responsible one in our relationship. I don't know, I just don't wanna have to think about it. I just wanna do. - As far as spending, you just wanna spend without any regard and just go, "Let me just do what I wanna do, man, "you're the free spirit and he's the nerd going cool "but we'll never accomplish any financial goals." So I think we need to compromise here. - Yeah. - I think you guys do need to make a budget, not to restrict you but to actually free you to go, "Oh look, there's fun money laid out for Bethany." Or, "Hey, we're planning a baby move." Is something fun coming up? We're gonna go on a vacation before the baby's here. - Yeah, I would say I'm very reasonable. I'm not, we have no debt, we live within our meetings. - Yeah. - I think I just get a little anxious when I think, "Okay, I'm gonna have this new baby." And, you can't go out to eat. And, this is a great time. - Right, right, yeah, yeah, no, I hear you, I hear you. That's where I wonder if there's a little bit a middle ground of what you guys. save, right? That it doesn't have to be so aggressive if you're both not wanting it, right? Where it's, you know, you're kind of like, hey, I want the flexibility to be able to take the baby to the zoo or like do some things, right? Like, I think that is reasonable. But I would have an amount every single month that makes you feel comfortable that you can go and enjoy some of this money, some of the money you guys have. But I do think there needs to be a limit to that, which is where the budget comes in, so that you're not just spending without a plan because when that happens, then you're going to look up in five years and like, wow, we worked really hard for five years and we have nothing to show for it. And that's what we don't want, right? And so have some money that you can enjoy, but it can't just be free for all all the time, right? Because we kind of have to be grown up and money's finite. And so you do, we'll have this other goal on the side, but maybe you guys just don't be as aggressive as he would want to be. And that's okay. That's a compromise and marriage. Okay. Are you going to be staying home with the baby or going back to work? What's the plan? I do. I will be home with the baby for an extended amount of time. I do work, but it's not. I make like a step of what he makes. Yeah. What do you make? Household wise. Household. I make 30 and he makes 90. Okay. Cool. Yeah. I see it from his perspective. He wants to be a good provider. He wants, you know, he cares about ownership, doesn't want to rent forever. He wants to make good decisions that's going to help the family, and especially becoming a parent. So I think he's being reasonable. You're being reasonable. Well, we can't also say, well, just let me spend whatever I want. And that's where the budget will be the best thing for you guys, because he can lay out his down payment sinking fund every month and say, all right, a thousand bucks a month is going to go towards this fund. You can have your fund money at five hundred bucks a month. And now we're all happy. But now there's some parameters and guard rails around it instead of just emotion and things swirling around in our heads. And the story he tells himself about how much you're spending versus the reality of it. Okay. That feels feasible and doable. And I probably am going to have to reevaluate what I'm thinking this is going to look like. And he will too. Not completely. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And he will too. I think there's, I think there's a middle ground there. I mean, are you guys doing a written budget? You guys have every dollar? No. Okay. We're going to give that to you as a baby gift for me and George. That's right. We weren't invited to a baby shower, but I know. Yes, but we're excited for you. No, but seriously, Bethany, if you guys do this, it's one of the best things couples can do. And this is like our 101 with relationships and money. Both of you sit down and both of you look at every line item. How much are we paying for rent? What are we paying for utilities? Were we paying for our cell phone for insurance? I mean, you go down the list and you put dollar amounts. How much are we spending on restaurants? How much are we going to spend on groceries? And you map out your income. And then out of that, you get to say, hey, one of our goals is saving for a house. So we're going to put some of that in that line item, but Bethany gets a line item. Your husband gets a line item. You get a miscellaneous line item. Baby. Baby. Baby. Make it a line item, right? For things for the for the grocery or you're going to be buying some stuff for the baby. So when you map it all out and see it, it actually feels better. And we say it all the time that a budget doesn't limit your freedom. It gives you freedom. It gives you the ability to spend money, but it actually has this level of control over it, which I think makes it so much better. I feel better having the budget. And so does my wife. And let me tell you, during pregnancy, I really struggled with the budget because it's just based on how she's feeling. She's like, I'm not eating that. Get that away from me. I'm going to throw up. And I'm like, okay, yes, ma'am, we're going out to eat again. You know, it just feels like it's a chaotic time during pregnancy. So it's also not a great barometer of what the future is going to look like because everything's in flux. Yeah, yeah. And there's expenses that you'll never have again, but you're trying to buy a crib or you're doing it. I mean, like things are going to be happening, but it gives you at least a roadmap and for her to be able to go, yeah, we're going to, I'm going to go pick up Chick-fil-A for lunch. And I'm not going to feel bad about it because it's there in the budget and I can do that, right? So that freedom level is really good. And then he, you know, he'll get some savings too. And that might mean, all right, we're getting that house six months later. That's right. Just doing the math to see what this actually means versus now we're never going to have a house because you're spending more. Yeah, yeah. It's actually do the math. Okay, we're going to save 1,500 instead of 1,750. What does that actually mean for our home purchase? And the fact that your income's over that period of time for that down payment, which may take two or three, four years to save, are going to go up to. So you're going to have more margin as the years go on to, which is always encouraging. So hang on the line. We'll get you that every dollar premium budgeting app as our little baby moon. Yep. And every dollar's great to you guys because the way it's based and the way that they've, the team has created it is to focus on one goal. So they probably will put in our goal is to save for a down payment. And so out of that, then you get to choose your numbers and it really does show you and pull this idea of focusing your money in that margin towards that savings for the, for that down payment. You've got to have a priority. If everything's the priority, nothing's the priority. And so I love that that focus goal helps you go. If nothing else happens, we're going to cover the bills and put this money aside for the down payment. Everything else is a nice to have. And so I like straight, you know, using that strategy on the budget because I like to hit a financial goal. That's right. So congrats, Bethany. We're excited for you. That's awesome. [Music] Welcome back to the Ramsey Show and the Fairwinds Credit Union Studio. I'm George Camel joined by Rachel Cruz this hour, taking your calls at triple 8 825 5 2 2 5. Grace joins us up next in Kansas City. Grace, welcome to the Ramsey Show. Hi. Thank you for taking my call. Sure. So my question is, would it be financially smart to take on a mortgage knowing that we will be living off one income for three years? Whoa. Okay. What's going on there? So I'm currently in nursing school. I'm going to graduate in May. My husband worked school time and I'm wanting to continue my education after nursing school and looking into going to a CRNA program. The goal is to have that tuition paid for before the program starts, but I would not be able to work during the program. And so I was just kind of wondering if it would be a bad idea to take on a mortgage before all of that. Do you guys have any debt? We don't. Good. So your cash flowing school, you have an emergency fund as well? Yes, we do. How much do you have for a down payment? Currently, we're just kind of generally saving just because we don't have any debt. So we have about 35,000 just kind of sitting and saving with that separate from an emergency fund. Okay. Good for you. Do you guys have kids? No. No. Okay. I mean, yeah, I probably would, if you were to purchase a house while you were in school, I would do it probably in the last year just because you'll know, okay, in the next year, I'll be jumping into work and working. It does make me nervous to make such a big purchase with a little bit of uncertainty of exactly what that's going to look like. And so I, if I did it, I would do it later in school as you're still in it, still knowing this is exactly what you want to do. And you'll have an idea of what you'll probably make when you graduate. But you guys may not even qualify for the mortgage if your income. Yeah, what's your income? Currently, he's pretty much just working. I make a little bit on the side, but it's about 11,000 a month. Oh, fantastic. income. That's great. So here's another way to look at it. If you guys can do this thing on a 15 year fixed rate mortgage, where the payments no more than a quarter of your after tax monthly income, then just on his income alone, then you could go for it. And you'd be fine. In fact, the mortgage will just get so much easier to pay off early once you're working. Yeah, if you do it based on just his numbers, but if you include her income, then you could have. I just wouldn't include the income. Yeah, how much house do you want right now? Because you could afford more house later on once you're working. But I think it is going to put a strain if you guys jump into it right now and it's tight. If you're, you know, payments going to be four or five thousand bucks a month. Yeah. But I don't have houses. They're not too bad in Kansas. I mean, could you recommend them just renting throughout school then? Yes, unless you do what George says and you guys find a house that you can afford on his income, which afford would mean on a 15 year fixed rate mortgage that the mortgage payments no more than 25% of your take home pay. If you guys want to do that on his income and you find a house in that price range, that feels great. Then go ahead and go and stay in long term. Yes. Don't just pick a house. Well, this is our two or three year house. You want to make this a at least a five to seven plus year decision. So that's the one caveat that if you don't find something you love that you know you'd stay in for that long, then I would just wait. Okay. But he has a great income. When you told me that it does change the number. So I would just use our mortgage path calculator. You can jump on there and type in the home price, type in the down payment. and enter in 15 year fix rate, and then see what that payment would be. And if you can keep it at, you know, two or three grand, you're gonna be in great shape in order to make that sustainable payment every month without you needing to work. But great question, you guys are crushing it. Cash flow in nursing school? - No, no, well done. - Debt free, we love it. All right, Sarah is in Bend, Oregon, up next. Sarah, what's going on? - Hello, great to talk to you guys. - We're excited to talk to you. - I wish I could tell the last car, quite a while ago, I came into our marriage with 80 grand of student loan debt, and my husband says it was, I'm totally worth it. - Oh! - You married the right guy, Sarah. - I love that, Sarah. - I agree, I agree. - Thank you, Rachel. - That's great. - We paid off $13,000 of debt in our first four years of marriage, and took FPU when we first got married, and 11 years later, we haven't had a single money right. - That's amazing. - That's amazing. - What a great testament to the plan and what we teach, 'cause everyone thinks we're crazy, and we're going, we just want you to have a successful marriage. God forbid. - God forbid, I completely agree. - Okay. - God forbid, yeah. - What's your question? - It feels a little bit like a silly question, but we've been with USAA for years. Thank you to my dad who served, and then maybe, and I am, you know, I listen to you smartly. Happy hour, I listen to this show, and so I've been successfully influenced that I'm considering fair wins, and I wanted to know if you guys had any thoughts about your wisdom on if it would be a smart idea to switch over, or if we're good, where we're at. - Yeah, I mean, what if you just added it to the mix right now, 'cause you don't need to like fully switch everything today, but it's, you can just go and start an account, and start moving some money over there, put it in the high-yield savings. What is making you even think about switching over, are there features, or what's really important to you when it comes to banking right now? - I think it's the, I mean, the one thing that's hard to switch is that everything is there, like our home insurance, our auto insurance, but the thing that is really irritating in our life turned out, it's a small thing, but is that our high-yield savings is separate from USA, and it takes days, giving care of our back. And I think that's the thing that I hear you say the most, is like, oh, it's so easy to switch from the checking account to the high-yield savings, and I think I would utilize our high-yield savings more if it were easier. - Yeah, that's a great factor to think about, because with fair ones, it is one of the things that I loved about when I first started using it. I've never seen a high-yield savings connected to a checking, and you can have the 10 different high-yield savings, so you can ear market for all kinds of sinking funds, emergency fund, car replacement fund, so it does make it really easy to keep track. So if I'm in your shoes, obviously it will take a little bit to switch everything over, but if you start to keep track of what's on auto pay and decide, all right, I can make that switch over here and over here, over time, over maybe a couple of weeks, you can have everything switched over. Once you guys are loving it and then direct deposit your checks over to the new account. - Yeah, I mean, kind of. - So that's what I would do, just to make it easy on you, 'cause it is like switching banks, it's like switching your cell phone number. You're like, oh gosh, there's a lot, I gotta text everybody and let 'em know. - Oh, yes. - It's going to be a whole new year. - Yeah, 'cause that's what we did. When we opened up our fair ones account, we just moved a bunch of money over into that checking and put some in the high-yield savings there too, and it's slowly but surely just ended up transferring more and more there, right? But it's a little bit over time, so there's no rush. But having a convenient bank and what we love too with fair ones is that they are so pro-ramsy principles and you just never find that in the banking industry. - It's crazy. I go to their website and their app, I'm like, it feels like Ramsey. - Yes, I know, people get out of debt, this is wild. And you get the Ramsey-themed debit card, which is nice to get your choice of that. And fun fact, Rachel, I'm about to travel, and you can set up a travel notification in the app so that your card isn't declined on your travel. - Oh, I've done, yes. - So I just went, cool. I'm gonna be gone from this time to this time. I'm good, and I just-- - Good to go. - Submit, boom. - Love it. - So a lot of cool features. Check it out if you want, fairwinds.org/ramsey if you want to upgrade your banking experience. (upbeat music) (upbeat music) - You work your butt off for your money, but your money's never going to return the favor if all you do is hope for the best. If you're ready to learn how to make your money work for you, check out the Smart Vester program. Smart Vester can help you find advisors who specialize in retirement planning, charitable giving, advanced investing strategies, and more. Whatever your goals, your pro will take the time to explain your options so you never have to invest in anything you don't understand. Head to ramsysolutions.com/smartvester to get connected. - Ramsey Solutions is a paid non-client promoter for participating pros. Learn more at ramsysolutions.com/smartvester. (upbeat music) - Dr. John Deloney's building the marriage you want is available for pre-order now. Very excited about this new book, because here's the deal. Nobody gets married planning to become roommates, but life gets full between kids, work, pack schedules, and one day you look up, and you realize that's exactly what's happened. And John wrote this book to explain why marriage can feel so hard, why yours still matters, and what you can do to make it great with practical tools to reconnect and build a stronger marriage. You can pre-order now for $24.99 and lock in over 100 bucks of free bonus items, including the audio book, the e-book delivered early, and an exclusive video. Check it all out, go to ramsysolutions.com/store. If you're on YouTube or podcasts, just click the link in the description. All right, Sherry is in Harrison, Arkansas. What's going on? - Hi, how are you? - We're doing great. - So we might have been, we lived in Paris. - Take your time. - We lived in California, and they said it two weeks to Arkansas. So we picked up four years ago. Most Arkansas, just me and him. We bought a house, we put an Airbnb, the RDO on our property, which does decent, about 20,000 a year. - The one in California, Sherry? - No, in Arkansas. We told everything in California. - Okay, okay, okay. - And it's on your property? - Yeah, it's on our property. - Okay. - Okay. - So about 20 grand a year, I would say from that two years ago, after we moved out here, did all that, and we decided to jump into a restaurant. And six months in, my husband got cancer. - Oh, and I was over $150,000 in cash. And my husband died a year and three months ago. - Oh, Sherry. - So sorry. So this situation just doesn't work without the anymore. And I'm just like, do I wait and try to hold out for a spring to sell the house? Because it is a leak house. Or if I should just throw it up on the market now and kinda call it quits and move back to California with my family. - Did you have an income outside of the Airbnb? - Do you have income coming in outside of the Airbnb? - No, I'm unemployed. I just closed my restaurant and in September. - Oh wow, okay. And you said, you said the dollar run $150,000. What was that? Did you say you lost that or you have that? What was it? - No, it was, that was our savings. - Okay, and it went all into the restaurant. - Okay, yeah. Okay, did you get anything out of the restaurant, Sherry? - I got six grand. - Six grand, okay. - Okay. - Do you know much? - Okay. - Considering how much we put into it. - For sure, yes. And that, that's a very hard, hard industry. Do you, where's the six grand now? - I don't, I'm down to like $3,000. - $3,000, okay. Okay, so what do I have? - I have about 13,000 in the credit card debt. - Okay, $5,000 in a student form. - Okay, okay. Well, the debt, we'll worry about later. Let's put that aside for now because what I want you, I want your goal in the next 30 days, Sherry, is we're gonna find enough money for you to be able to pay for your mortgage, utilities. - I don't have a mortgage. - You don't have to pay for that, I don't have. - Amazing. Okay, so how much does it take to live on? So think insurance, cell phone, gas in your car. - About a grand of a month. - Okay, okay, that's great. - So the Airbnb covers that then? - During the summer and I'm gonna be okay this month. - You'll be okay. So you don't have anyone in the Airbnb for December or January, I'm assuming? - No, no. - 'Cause it's a lake house. Okay. February. Okay. So those are dead. Yes. Okay. So what I would do and and George, you give her your game plan too. We'll give you kind of two different perspectives. Maybe you're maybe similar. I don't want my fear for you putting your house up. I think you should. Go ahead and find and contact a great realtor and we will see if we've already done the Ramsey. Oh good. Okay. Come out and talk to me. Perfect. What did he suggest? Did he tell you to wait till spring? No. I mean, he was like, said you could know. So I would go ahead and put it up for sale. Because I think long term, you're not going to want to be there regardless. Okay. But here's the thing, Sherry's. I don't want you out of desperation to make a bad move on this home, meeting someone low balls you and and people in your corner, you know, your family, the realtor, everyone's like, Sherry, don't take this one and you're just like, I just want to get out, right? Because you're so desperate, just to leave. So I would say you need some strength in that because I want you to get as much money out of this place that you can, right? And so I would go ahead and put it on the market. Yes, because you want to get back, which I totally understand. So I'd put the house on the market. I would probably find something temporary in the holidays, just from a job perspective to bring in some money. Yeah, that's great to do some money. And then I think, you know, you could look up come January and make a decision about when you want to move. Like, when would be ideal for you to move? Do you want to move sooner than January? Honestly, I would prefer like my daughter is going to her in school. Her husband works crazy hours. Okay. You know, and I have four grandkids. So you want to move now? Like, if you could snap your fingers, would you be there next week? Or you want to probably, probably. Okay. I mean, I mean, what you've been through, I would be okay to say, Hey, I hate for you to abandon the property and not be there without having it sold yet. Yes. Can you go live with any family? My daughter have, you know, they're renting out the California. Okay. I'm just wondering if there's a spot you can crash. Yeah, you'll move in with them for a little bit. Yeah. Okay, perfect. So you'll keep your expenses low. That's the goal. Yeah. Try to find some work out there that's sustainable, full-time work. And then hopefully this house sells, which gives you a pretty big cushion, hopefully. What do you think you could net from this? Well, I talked to the relative and we kind of discussed. I said, I was thinking 250. Okay. And he kind of agreed. He said, Yeah, I'm pretty well bright in the price line that he's thinking. So you could walk away with over 200 grand. You could invest that with a good financial advisor. And that can create a small nest egg for now as you continue to work in the meantime. Yeah, you'll just have to figure out a living situation. What part of California are they in? The Central Valley. Okay. Because I just know that's an, that is, I mean, I understand why you want to be there for sure. It's a cost of living is going to be higher. Yeah. Cost living will be higher. So just know that going in. Because eventually you do want to own a home out there. And, um, well, what, what the plan was is my daughter and my son-in-law, my grandkids and then we'd get a property with two houses. And you would live in one of them? Yes. Okay. Okay. And they would cover that for you. Would you have to put up for that? I'm not really sure. Like, is that my daughter is getting ready? Well, she already graduated from her in school. She's just finishing up her pre-rex right now. Okay. And then she's got to go take her home. Yeah. I think that'll be a few years down the road probably before that purchase happens. So for in the short term, Sherry, I would, um, yeah, I mean, I think if you want to pack up and, and move, I would just, um, make sure that this house gets sold. So I would work with a good realtor, um, to make sure you, and the only reason I'm okay with you going ahead and moving is because you don't need the money from this house for the move. You can go ahead and move without it and start your life, start applying for jobs out there. Um, sort of planned some routes there. Yeah. Yeah. Did he have a term life insurance? Probably just be in the babysitter. Yeah. Did he have any term life insurance, Sherry? No. And are you getting any social security? No. Unfortunately, right now, um, I'm throwing big sounds, some issues with me and, um, I've got to figure out if it's bad enough or I could try to get on disability. Okay, I was just wondering if he had any survivor benefits that you had an income coming from that, but oh my goodness, I cannot imagine, Sherry. And now I'm so sorry. Oh, we're wishing you the best with the move and the sale of the home and really just starting a whole new chapter in a way that you, you didn't want, but it's, it's the, the hand that was dealt to you. So we are thinking of you. Thanks for the call. Hey, guys, Dave Ramsey here every day on the show, we help people work through real money problems and figure out what to do next. Now you can get that same kind of help anytime with ask Ramsey. Ask your money question and get answers built on Ramsey principles we use on the show, whether you're making a decision or just want something explained ask Ramsey is here to help. It's fast, simple and free to use. Go to Ramsey Solutions dot com and try ask Ramsey today, that's Ramsey Solutions dot com. If you've ever needed proof that the Ramsey plan still works in today's day and age, boy if I got the proof for you, we have Tyler and Julie here on the debt free stage. Hey guys, welcome. Hey guys. So glad you guys are here. Tell us about this debt journey. How much did you pay off? Payed off a total of $475,000. What? Okay. How long did that take? Oh my gosh. Took 10 years. We actually paid it all off about 10 days before our 10 year anniversary. How special. Okay. What was the debt? 275,000 was our house and then the other 200 was consumer debt. What kind of consumer debt? Like credit cards cards? No credit cards. A lot of student loans and a few vehicles. Okay. Okay. Dang. And so that was what 10 years ago. So you said you started this journey? Yeah, about 10 years ago. We started grinding. Okay. So was that the reason you guys kind of kicked off this journey? Is the marriage? Was that the main motivation or what? What happened? Yeah. Our story is actually the quickest engagement ever. I said, if this is going to be for real, those credit cards, the credit card debts have to go. And they were gone in a week. So she was selling everything she could. So the ultimate does work. Yeah. Did in this case, yeah. Not impressive. What was the range of income during that time over 10 years? So we started out around 50,000. And then over the years we're at about 225,000 right now. Okay. What do you guys do for living? I'm a school counselor by day. And then two nights a week. I have a private practice for counseling. Oh, nice. And I'm a teacher. Okay. So great. It's wonderful. What grade do you teach? I'm just curious. My main gig was in fourth grade. But currently I teach anywhere from kindergarten. Oh, sweet. Okay. So great. Oh my gosh, you guys. So 10 years ago, you're like, listen, we're going to be getting married. We got all this debt. Who's student loans? Was it my yours? Yes. Okay. That's okay. I told him when we were here, I was like, you would not be here without me. So we're going. Yeah. Because were you the one that did or do some to the plan or what? No, he introduced me, but I introduced him to the debt. Yeah, she introduced me to that. There would be no debt free journey without you. You're a very boring journey. Yes. I love that attitude. That's a good attitude. That's fantastic. And what area you guys from? I like to say the tri-state area, which is like Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, or they all touch. We're like right right there. Fantastic. In Michigan. Yep. Fantastic. Wow. So great. So a lot of life happened over the 10 years. Because a lot of people go, I could do it for a year or two, but 10 years. I don't know if I can stomach that. What kept you guys motivated along the way? How do you stay on the same path for 10 years? We just, we knocked that consumer it out in about four years. Oh, wow. We just stuck with that lifestyle. And I think having kids helped too. A lot of our friends, they were traveling and buying bigger houses. And we just really didn't have time for that when they were that little. So that honestly really helped us. So people say having kids is expensive. You're saying it actually helped our financial journey. Yes. We didn't have time to go spend. You were trying to raise these kids. Yes. And they were young enough where we're like, let's go to the library, which was free. And it was an excitement, exciting thing for them. Yeah, they didn't care. They didn't care. That's amazing. Okay. So the consumer debt journey was four years. Because I would assume you're probably were pretty intense on that one. Which was what we teach, you're super intense to get that consumer debt. And then when it comes to paying off the house, be intentional, throw as much money, but you don't have to be as strict. So when you look at both journeys, what would you say was the hardest for kind of each one, the consumer debt and pan off the mortgage? Honestly, the in between, save up for the emergency. fun. I think we both found that just kind of boring and I don't know how to explain it like the debt was fun getting rid of the debt. Yeah, it's almost fun and then we got to the emergency fun are like, man, this isn't as fun as we thought. We hear that a lot though. That's okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's a tough one. You don't get like an adrenaline rush when you put away another thousand bucks. I said he's count. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's wild. Okay. How much is the house worth? My I would probably guess around 350. Okay. How much do you guys have in a retirement? About the same about 350. Oh, fantastic. Well on your way to becoming baby steps millionaires. So great. Okay. So what would you tell people the secret of this journey is of getting out of debt living debt free in America today? That's why we really wanted to do this because that's all you hear is it's not possible to do it nowadays and I mean she was a teacher and I'm a counselor and yeah, here we are. I would say teamwork. You got to have a partner that's willing to grind through it with you and that the grinding part is not forever. It's it's a way to point to an end and just the that's what kind of hooked me was to be able to live like no one else and to give like no one else. And now I'm at a part where point in my life where I can give to our girls. We can give to the church. We can give it back to God because none of this would have been possible without him. Yes. Oh, I love that. Yeah. That's beautiful. Did you have a lot of supporters along the way or need detractors? Yeah, we would like to say thank you to God for some foremost without him. Not even our financial just bringing Julie and I together and giving us our kids as well. And then support really good support from family and friends. I have some really good buddies that are big ramsy people as well. That's awesome. I bet they're watching right now cheer and you want. So what's next? People always want to know what's the thing you do after you pay off a house. Yeah, y'all are maybe step seveners like all the way. Yeah. I think I'm excited about investing. Yes. I'm excited about traveling. Yeah. So we are already planning for a trip out west and the girls know we're saving up for it and it's great. It's going to be great. Yeah. There's room for both when you hit baby step seven. That's the beautiful thing is you guys just get to build wealth and give and have amazing experiences. Well, do you want to bring the girls up? Yeah. Okay. Tell us their name. You have all Reagan is eight and Kennedy is six. Reagan is Reagan. This is Kennedy. Sweet, sweet, sweet. Are they a second kindergarten or first and third and first. Yeah, first. Okay. That's a really good question. Sorry. I know. I jump. I have kids about your age. So I'm like, I wonder where Rachel likes to guess it's her favorite game to play. She's usually right. So that is fantastic. Have the girls been practicing the debt free scream on the way here? Yeah, my ear drums. Well, we got a party gift for you. You get two every dollar premium subscriptions. Good for one year. You can give those away. You can use them. Maybe the girls can start budgeting. I think they're going to be just fine with you guys at the helm. So proud of you guys. Thanks for proving this plan still works. Amazing. Thank you for your support throughout the years. Oh, yes. Absolutely. We're honored. Yep. Cheers. You guys on. Okay. The moment we've been waiting for, we've got Tyler and Julie and Reagan and Kennedy $475,000 paid off. That's $200,000 in consumer debt, $275 in the mortgage in 10 years, making 50 to $225 as a teacher and a counselor. No excuses from you guys. Count it down. Let's hear a debt free scream. Three, two, one. We're debt free. Oh, that's a kick. Amazing. Oh, my gosh. Just the best, the absolute best. That's the dream George right there. That's it. You know, it doesn't get much better than that. You know, a lot of people, they overcomplicate life. Sometimes the best thing in life is just having no payments and getting to have amazing experiences with their kids and build wealth and give like when you really think about it, what is this all for other than that? Absolutely. You know, and you look back on their numbers. They had $200,000 a consumer that they paid off in four years. So it's about 50 grand. Crazy. And they started making with making 50 grand, right? So you can see probably adding an extra work, cutting lifestyle like those four years of the grind of getting out of that consumer debt. It speaks long. Working on their career. So if you're that person right now, you're making 50 grand and you're going, okay, we have 10 year journey ahead of us. If we're lucky to pay off this much debt, life is going to look different on the plan. And they had babies along the way. Life happened along the way. That's right. That's okay. But they stayed intentional for a very long period of time because they knew it was worth it. And they had a why behind it all. That's exactly right. They wanted it to give more. They wanted to have these amazing experiences. And they went, what could we do with that mortgage payment? What could we do without all this consumer debt hanging over our heads? Whereas most people just go, I guess I'll die with it or maybe it'll get forgiven. I don't know. Yeah, but it's just it is the way it is. And people like it's so proactive about their life. They change it completely and not just for themselves, but for their whole family and those two sweet girls out there. So it doesn't just change your money. It changes your family tree. It changes your marriage. It's a really easy, peaceful way to live. So highly encourage it. Be more like Tyler and Julie and come visit us and do your debt free-screens someday. Good news. Everything is 100% off if you don't buy it. Bad news. It's the biggest spending season of the year and your money's being pulled in a hundred directions. Like there's a bill due and matching tattoos with Nana would be by one get one. Tempting. But money doesn't make decisions. You do. So decide ahead of time with a focus plan for your money before it's even spent. My wife and I used the every dollar app to do exactly that. It plans every dollar coming in and going out. It shows you where margins hiding too. That's extra money to put toward your biggest goals one at a time and hit them faster. Whether it's paying off debt, saving for a trip or getting tatted up with Nana, get focused with every dollar this holiday season and start for free. Download every dollar in the app store or Google play today. Our scripturing photo of the day, Philippians 3, 13 and 14. One thing I do for getting what is behind and straining toward what is ahead. I press on toward the goal to win the prize for which God has called me heavenward in Christ Jesus. Harry Kemp said the poor man is not he who is without a cent, but he who is without a dream. How nice. Sonia is in Washington DC up next. What's going on Sonia? Hi, I'm so honored to meet you. Hi, Rachel. Hi, George. Hey. Hello. Hello. Hi. I have a quick question and I have a financial decision to make with regards to my pension. I'm turning 62 next year and at the end of next year, I have to retire and I have three options. I worked for an international organization for almost 20 years and I have accumulated a pension that I could receive in a one-time lump sum payment of $850,000. Wow. Taking that option, I will never ever receive a pension. Also, I'm not eligible for social security. So it would be a one-time payment. Okay. Option number two would be not take a lump sum, but get about $65,000 per year in pension. That's about five and a half thousand a month. And the third option would be half the lump sum, 425K and half a pension. That would be about 33K. So now I do have an ethic. Actually, I checked today was about 600,000 from savings. I have no debt. I have no car. I have also no real estate because I travel a lot. I'm currently renting. My annual take-home pay right now is 165. And I still have a child in college finishing in three years. But after that, yeah, what do I do? Do I take the lump sum, the half lump sum or the pension? I don't know. Those are big decisions with a lot of zeros on the end. So you're wise to tread carefully. Generally, we like to say if you're not going to need a lot of this money and you just go invest $850,000 in a lump sum, you're going to do pretty well. So the question is how much will you need to actually live off of? Will you be peeling money off of that or will you live off the other 600,000 first and then tap into it? What would be your game plan there? There would be invested in the same way that it would just add up. It would be, how is that $12,000? Oh gosh, I cannot add it up right now. That's a lot of math. I know. 1450. Yeah. Almost a million and a half. Well, think about it this way. To create that 65,000 a year that you would get monthly, you would need an average return of 8% in the market if you invested. So if you think about that, the average return in the market has been closer to 10 to 12. So you could do better and create that same amount of money yourself, but still own it all and have that as an inheritance one day. So that's the nice part about the lump sum versus the pension, which would go with you. So I like the idea of you investing it because you've done such a good job in every other area and you have a separate nest egg you've created. - Yeah, and you're not just going to do it, probably. - You've shown good diligence too, that right, there's not like a safe guard of a gosh, I'm scared I'm gonna spend all this. But it gives the ability for it to grow. - That's, that's, I would still buy, take some of the money to buy some real estate and I retire, I won't have to travel a much anymore. But I think I will take about 350 to buy something. - You're 600,000, where is that invested? - It's much, the SP 500, but it in the interactive brokers. - So it's just a taxable brokerage account and on retirement? - Yes. - Very cool, okay. - Yeah, that's great. - So you may want to use that one first. - How much money do you need a month so I need to live? - That's hard to say. Right now I spend probably 10,000. - 10,000 right now, but when I retire, I don't have to commute, I don't have to stay in DC. I can live somewhere with cheaper. I have like, you know, I don't think I need more than six, six thousand, six and a half thousand a month. - Okay, that's great. Yeah, yeah, so it's kind of looking at, okay. You know, 75-ish a year is what you're gonna, probably what would be ideal, right? To be able to live off of. So I think sitting down to with a Smart Vester Pro and running some of these numbers and just looking at, okay. What's my end goal here? What are the big things I wanna do? I wanna buy a house. What realistically would be good to live off of? 'Cause you're only gonna be working for how much longer? - Well, a year, two months, maybe, yeah. - Okay, so just another, the next, 2027, at the end of that year, you'll retire. - Uh-huh, okay. - Would you do any other work after that to still create income? - I want to because I'm not feeling old, right? - Yeah, yeah. - You got a lot to give. - If you could make five grand a month, right? And then you'd only have to pull, you know, two grand, one grand out of these investments to live, that would be even more ideal. - Yeah, the longer you can wait without touching it, the best, 'cause it'll just keep compounding. And if you look at, you know, there's something called the rule of 72. And so if you take a 10% rate of return, it would your account would double in 7.2 years. And so that 850,000 would very quickly become 1.7. If you just left it alone for seven years, that's pretty cool. And so that gives me a lot of hope that you're gonna be just fine in retirement. But I do agree, in the meantime, there's, you got a lot of plans. You wanna buy a house, what's that gonna do to the portfolio? And that's where I would sit down with an investment advisor who can walk you through all of the scenarios and then you stay in the driver's seat and you make a decision you feel comfortable with. - That sounds good, yeah. - Awesome. Well, thank you so much for the call. - Yeah, thank you, Sonia. - What an interesting situation. Good place to be. - That's great. - She did great. - All right, Jacob is in Los Angeles up next. Jacob, how can we help? - Hi, so I'm making pretty significant progress towards paying down my student loan debt. It was at 220,000 in January of this year and then I had 170,000 now. - Wow. - And so we're making significant progress. Here's my question. I have just learned that I'm gonna be getting a pretty significant bonus in about three weeks, about $12,000. And after taxes, it'll be about 8,000 ish. I was wondering if you think it would be best to continue attacking this student loan debt, which we have plans of getting it paid off by August of 2028. Or would you think it'd be okay if I took like four to five thousand of that and invested it into myself and to a small business, potentially to give me a chance to make some more money starting around a mayor June next year. - What's the side business? - I work, I'm an audiologist. And so right now I can't really work in clinic 'cause they're the conflict of interest because I work for a manufacturer. But there is a part of my industry, which is making ear molds. Like custom hearing protection, custom swimming swimmers ears protection. - Yeah. - So I would do that. It doesn't compete with my current company. There's no conflict of interest. So I'd be able to use my license for that. And-- - And that's to buy the equipment and all of it. - The money I'm hoping to take out would be a good portion of the, to allow me to cash flow the startup cost. - What could you reasonably make in a year doing that in your first year? - I don't know, I've been the first year, I think 10,000 would be pretty generous. So it wouldn't be like anything big to start off. 'Cause a lot of it would just be setting it up and getting a clientele base in the beginning. - But within probably three to four months you would recoup that money. - That's the hope, yeah. - And do you know other people in the industry doing it? Like is there a pretty plausible case of, yeah, yeah, this is gonna work and I know people that are needing it now. Like you'll be able to actually provide the service to someone that's in need of it. - Yeah, like I know like audiology clinics do it, but they do mostly diagnostics and working with hearing aids and diagnosing hearing losses. There's not a ton of happening with like preventative care with hearing loss. So there's not like clinics will maybe do one year more of the month. It's unique about where I live and I live right by the beach and by a big music population in Los Angeles. And so I think I have a unique demonstration. - Okay, I would just wanna prove and have 10 people in my pocket that are gonna want this 'cause I'm just scared it's a service that you're gonna invest in and then you're like, oh gosh, I get one every two months. - You don't get enough customers. - Yeah, so I would do the due diligence of go ahead and say, hey, if this is open, here's people that would be interested and actually get some interest. And if you have enough to sustain that level of investment, then I think I would be okay if you go forward with it. - Yeah, if you can basically guarantee this is gonna speed up the debt process. - Yeah. - The debt pay off process, then I'm in. Go for it. All right, that puts this hour of the Ramsey show in the books. Thank you, Rachel. Thanks to all the folks in the booth. Remember, there's ultimately only one way to financial peace and that's to walk daily with the Prince of Peace. Christ Jesus. (gentle music) (gentle music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Catherine’s bonus should be used to pay off her highest debt first, not just to build momentum, as the emotional relief from eliminating credit card debt is powerful and motivates long-term financial behavior change.
  2. Paying off smaller debts like dental work and a personal loan first saves significant monthly funds—over $800—leaving more to aggressively target the credit card, which could be eliminated in less than a year.
  3. The debt snowball method works best when driven by emotional motivation, and Catherine’s deep aversion to credit card interest aligns with the mindset shift the Ramsey Plan promotes.
  4. Financial decisions involving shared living arrangements (like roommates or post-divorce cohabitation) require clear boundaries, with financial responsibility based on shared space, not income disparity.
  5. For non-resident students, credit is not essential for renting or buying a car; proof of income and financial responsibility are more important than a credit score.
  6. Financial security in relationships depends on shared values—especially regarding debt—rather than just financial resources, and couples should set clear boundaries before marriage.
  7. Life insurance should be based on total income (10–12x) and future expenses, not just current income, especially with bonuses or changing family needs.
  8. Avoiding debt from family loans or using retirement accounts to pay off obligations is financially risky; instead, focus on paying off debt quickly with dedicated funds and strong financial discipline.

Summary:

The episode addresses diverse financial questions from listeners, focusing on debt repayment, shared finances, insurance, and long-term financial health. Catherine’s case highlights the power of emotional motivation in debt elimination—using a bonus to pay off high-interest credit card debt despite lower interest on smaller balances. The show emphasizes that while mathematically similar, the psychological impact of removing credit card debt is transformative and motivates sustained financial progress.

Ryan and Savannah discuss fair financial contributions in cohabitation, stressing that roommates should share costs equally, not based on income, and that clear agreements prevent resentment. Brenda’s situation as an international student shows that a credit score is not essential for housing or car purchases—proof of income and stability are more critical. Joy’s concern about her partner’s ongoing credit card debt underscores the importance of shared financial values and boundaries in relationships, with advice to communicate expectations before marriage.

Annie and Cody explore life insurance needs, recommending coverage based on income multipliers (10–12x) and external policies to avoid employer dependency. Cody’s story of grief and rebuilding finances emphasizes the need for strict budgeting and financial separation during new relationships. Grant’s experience shows how family support can create financial strain, but resolves by aggressively paying off debt within a short timeframe without risking retirement accounts.

Across all cases, the core message remains: financial health comes from mindset, clarity, and consistent action—not just numbers. The Ramsey Plan promotes one-goal focus, emotional accountability, and value alignment to build lasting financial stability.

FAQs

While paying off a large credit card debt may feel motivating, it's often more effective to tackle smaller debts first to build momentum and confidence. The debt snowball method provides psychological rewards with each small win, making it easier to stay committed and ultimately leading to full debt freedom.

When living together without being married, you're essentially roommates. Expenses should be shared fairly, such as 50/50 for rent and utilities. It's important to set clear agreements and avoid making assumptions about financial responsibility based on income differences, as this can lead to resentment.

Build a solid emergency fund first, and then set aside a separate savings goal for moving costs. Include estimates for movers, rental deposits, and temporary housing. For a cross-state move, plan for at least $5,000–$10,000 depending on distance and logistics, and share costs with your partner if applicable.

A credit score is not strictly necessary, especially if you're a non-resident. You can rent or buy a car without debt by showing proof of income and stable living arrangements. Credit checks may occur, but without prior debt, your record will show no history, which is perfectly acceptable.

Yes, it's important to address this concern early. Persistent credit card debt can be a sign of poor financial habits. Open honest conversations about spending, credit, and money management are crucial. You should establish clear boundaries and ensure both partners share the same financial values before committing to marriage.

No, it's not recommended. Taking a loan from your 401(k) can severely impact long-term growth, and you’ll have to repay it with interest. In addition, it may be required to repay the funds if you change jobs. It's better to pay off family debts through other means, like a personal loan or direct contributions.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.