MNC: Tuchel’s best England win yet? And Trafford over Pickford?
1h 6m 38s
This podcast blends promotional content with in-depth football analysis, covering a range of topics from Thanksgiving shopping at Whole Foods to the tactical evolution of England’s national team. Whole Foods is promoted as a premium, health-conscious destination with no antibiotics and no high fructose corn syrup, appealing to consumers seeking quality. In football, England’s decisive 3-2 win over Spain—despite playing with 10 men—is hailed as a breakthrough, showcasing a physically aggressive, Premier League-inspired style that contrasts with Spain’s possession-heavy tactics. Analysts debate whether this performance reflects a lasting identity shift or a temporary surge, noting the importance of consistency in high-stakes matches. The discussion also extends to tactical and managerial decisions, such as Pochettino’s appointment at Manchester United, where concerns over lack of clear team identity and front-office control are raised. Additionally, the Nations League’s structural changes are explored, aiming to improve competitiveness and inclusivity by spreading team quality and creating new pathways for smaller nations. Overall, the conversation underscores how football is evolving—not just in style and strategy, but in how clubs manage performance, identity, and long-term planning.
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
Host Thanksgiving with industry leading quality standards from whole foods market.
There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever.
So carve up turkey and spiral cut ham with peace of mind.
Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand.
And guess what?
All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup.
Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want only at whole foods market.
Formula one is all about precision, tiny margins, massive ambition, flat out performance.
And that's exactly why it's exciting to see Cadillac entering Formula one,
bringing an American luxury brand with performance pedigree onto the biggest stage in motorsport.
But this isn't just about the grid.
That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection,
lives in the Cadillac V series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision
and performance of the grid on the open road.
Cadillac V series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill,
discover the V series lineup at Cadillac.com.
This is the Monday nightclub with Mark Chapman on the football daily podcast.
Monday nightclub on the way with Chris Sutton, Rory Smith,
Nathan Manua, plenty of international football to talk about.
We'll talk about Thomas Ramp being a point of crystal palace manager.
Today we'll look at Maurizio Pochettino as well as he gets ready to take over Manchester United
during the week.
Did you not get the invite to be in the studio with us all Chris or was that?
Obviously not. You know, I would have made the effort.
Oh, I don't. I've made the effort over the years, as you will know, a long drive
from where I live in Norfolk to Manchester and back.
Didn't get the invite, but that's fine. I'm happy on my own.
That's the way I live my life.
Have you asked about the Christmas tree before in the show?
Yes, when did it go on?
It goes up at the end of November.
Start in November. Start in November.
I like it. I like it too.
I saw Stephen Warwick having like a fit on Instagram saying,
"Why do people put the decorations up?"
He was like really angry over such an obstacle.
I mean, how can you be angry about somebody putting decorations up?
The lights that you have over your right shoulder.
Are they going to be put up somewhere or is that?
No, that's a little display shop, as that is.
Is it? It just sort of like they've been thrown under the telly.
I'll pass that on, but I will pass that on.
Yeah, I know, but is that the display that is?
It's a display which I quite like.
It's subjective, you clearly don't like it.
Isn't that fine? That's fine.
Let's talk football, shall we?
England held on for a remarkable win against Spain last night.
There were three nil up. They eventually won 3-2.
They had 10 men for the last 25 minutes of the game.
Elliot Anderson sent off.
James Trufford made some big saves in that last 25 minutes.
I suppose there are two questions here for everybody.
I'm partly being swayed by what Marcel von Rory
is talking about off air, which is,
is that the best performance under Thomas Tuchel, Chris?
And bearing in mind its four months after a World Cup, does it matter?
Well, there is a case of, if only England were as brave
against Argentina as they were against Spain yesterday.
That was the best hour of football I've seen from an England team.
I can't even remember for how long.
I mean, the fact it was Spain who were on this incredible run,
what 43 game unbeaten run.
And just the way that England physically mauled Spain.
And they started ferociously and Spain, the way they play.
That's what they do, and they back themselves to play through
any press, but England would just relentless with it.
It was actually like many against boys.
But just the physicality of the England team was so, so impressive.
And the confidence and, you know, you can't not be excited by it.
Watch the game against Croatia.
And it was all a bit lethargic and dull and nation's leak.
And then all of a sudden, you know, that performance,
that, you know, the atmosphere within the stadium,
the way the England players performed, you have to say, well done to Thomas Tuchel and the team.
Yeah, absolutely.
I agree.
And I think you're right about the physical side of things,
because England did look a lot stronger, a lot faster.
But tactically, I love how aggressive they were from the moment the game started.
I think there's a sense of like anxiety that some teams will have going to play in Spain.
They'll almost take it back for, you know, Spain or get into a rhythm,
but in setting, England never allowed them to do that.
And I think that shocked Spain in some ways.
I don't know if you'd agree, Chris, but I think there's an argument to say
that maybe Delaforente got the starting team wrong.
I think for me, having a Zubimendi and a Marino in that team against the England side
who're going to be on the front floor, I don't think that really worked as such.
And as a consequence, I felt that aside from Salimini mild on one side,
I think Spain did look slow, they felt slow and England almost capsized on that.
Because if you have this fear of speed and this energy,
you will think about taking a step back,
but instead England was very much taking a step forward.
And as far as like performances goes,
yeah, I think it's that first 60 minutes before the red card, it's as good as I've seen.
There were three in a lot, very much deserving of being three in a lot.
And yeah, they've come a long way.
They've still got the same players, they've got the right ideas.
I don't know if you can agree.
Come a long way from where to where?
From the first 20 minutes when they played against Spain a couple of months ago.
OK.
When they were, say, making tons of mistakes against Spain and it looks like
the occasion was possibly a bit too big for them to all of a sudden arrive in Spain,
knowing exactly what the plan was and every single one of them.
They're sticking to it times when like a center half would follow a striker right
the way, you know, 40 yards forward and having those 1v1 matchups, those jewels,
which they did really well and yeah, it was, it was really good.
And then obviously they go down to 10 and then everyone's having,
have we seen this before?
And in reality, you haven't seen it before because it's a nation's league.
You know, it's a different sort of feeling whatsoever.
But all the eyes were on to cool.
What's you going to do next?
Is he going to just tuck himself in like last time or is he going to wear, give it a go?
I thought that was kind of, that was fitting for England to finish 2026 like that.
Because I think that rightly or wrongly that will be the defining memory of this year
for England lands is the half an hour and it's the Argentina when they sat back.
That is, that is the thing that Thomas Tutel will have to overcome at some point.
So would you go along with Michelle Plattini that the English aligns in winter
and lambs in spring?
It's a great phrase, but no, I won't.
I think there's, there is an issue with, or there has historically been an issue
with English football being draining, which means that by the time international teams arrive
at tournaments, there's a fatigued element that keeps in.
I think that has been previously been a factor.
But the thing is, you know, half the French side has been affected.
How has that been affected when?
No, no, I just historically in terms of performance.
But you look, I don't think it's relevant now, just half of the French team plays in England.
Well, exactly, so that's not, that's not affected.
I think, okay, it's good to be back.
I think, I think if anything, it was a style of play yesterday, which I really enjoyed,
because it was very much on the front foot, you know, whether they had possession or they didn't.
It felt in some ways, the close I can imagine is,
do you know, like sometimes in the Premier League, where you see like a bright inside,
gone really disrupts an opposition to where they don't really know what to do next?
That's the style that it was.
It felt like a real, like, an amalgamation of the best bits of the domestic league.
And then obviously you've got players who play all around Europe and so on.
But it was very aggressive.
But do you not think that that is what's been so interesting about,
about both the Spain and England games in this nation's lead cycle,
has been really positive, like the 7-0-1, 7-0-0 win in Croatia,
regardless of states is a really impressive achievement.
Tutorial after the disappointment of Atlanta has managed to get like a really positive end
to this year for England.
But do you not think that those two games at Wembley and at the Metropolitan have basically been
the dominant idea of football in the 2010s, early 2020s, which is a Spanish possession against the Premier League?
Does England play a really Premier League style now?
Yeah, I would agree, but yeah, do you know, I do agree with that, I do agree with that.
And in some ways, it was good to see, because I think for some people,
they saw the Spanish team or Spain just as a name in general.
And think the best way to approach this is to be defensively solid at the back,
you know, have a certain back for it.
But I've been trying to say to, like, a few of my friends and so on,
defense starts at the front.
If you've got a really aggressive press, then the defender at the back becomes a lot easier.
If you decide to be more passive, then you get picked apart.
What's a Premier League style?
Well, I think, as Nadem says, it feels that it's that kind of that really aggressive press.
It's the speed of it.
And you'll shoot this down, Chris.
But it's, to me, it's almost like thinking the way the Spanish approach is a game is a whole thing.
And you dominate it and you shape it and you play it as a, as a 90 minutes instant, like a whole.
Whereas the Premier League at the moment is duals.
It's individual moments, each one can potentially be decisive.
And I think what England have done, what Tutla has lent into much more than SouthJay,
and I liked SouthJay a lot for he did a brilliant job for England, is say,
well, that's English football's identity now, is the Premier League.
It's that kind of very physical, very intense.
Tutla will not say that the World Cup as well, the way that the England team were going to approach the World Cup.
And they did for all but half an hour.
And then they forgot to do it for half an hour and they're not knocked out by Argentina.
But that, we haven't, we haven't, we haven't, we haven't.
- You never saw a display like that from England.
- Do you know where it happened?
- In the first game.
- After, it was in a second half,
'cause remember these things, coach was saying something
at halftime to the media, was like,
"Oh, people are really nervous," and so on.
But at what I think in some ways is good.
The nation's league is supposed to pit teams
at the same level against each other.
- Yeah, well, not--
- Allegedly. - Not in the future,
but we'll come onto that.
- Oh, yeah, of course, yeah.
- That's what--
- All of a sudden, they have something to work
and they're about to, of course, if it works well
after, say, five years and everyone gets used to it,
change it.
- Yeah, it's what we like about football, of course, yeah.
But then England coming away from this nation's league
campaign with 19 goal scored in six games.
Like, that comes down to a level of really aggressive football.
And the way it was stuck to me was like,
in the crucial game, away.
That was a seven-0, could have been 10.
They gave up a couple of chances or whatever,
but it was so intense, so high-press.
And usually, when we see England go up against teams
who are of a similar level, relatively speaking,
it's usually a bit more negative.
You know, they tend to, say, dominate the side
to, would be in, like, nation's league group B or C's or something.
But also, sorry, but with the nation's league,
it wasn't that long ago, England were in league B.
They were in league B and now they've got with them.
- But the test, the lines in, in winter,
lambs in some of the thing, the test is,
can you do this in a major tournament?
Not just because you've, in May, when you've, June,
when you've dropped the miles in your legs.
But when you know it's a European championship semi-final,
when you know it's a World Cup semi-final,
that's when it's really hard.
- Well, you could even go as far as saying, Chris,
can they do it next summer,
if they get through their quad-tooler game quarter final,
and then get down to the final four wherever that's going to be played,
and say, come up against Spain or the French in the final?
- Yeah, look, it's a starting point, isn't it really,
for Thomas Tuchel now, that's the level,
which we all will be demanding from here on in.
I mean, you know, and the consistency side of that,
you know, is, you know, it is going to be crucial.
You know, they've set the standards, they've set the stall out,
you know, they set the stall out with the start of the game.
But I just, you know, it was, it was an incredible performance
to watch, because I've not seen England perform like that
for a long, long time.
Just on your, on the 19 goals scene,
how many goals of those were crucial?
How many were, were luxury of England's goals?
- Do they count, do you separate your goals, Tally,
in the same way, Tristan?
- It was interesting, 'cause I mean, we had this debate marked,
didn't we, a few weeks ago, the crucial and luxury goals,
and when Ben White's goal went in,
I said to the family that that's a luxury goal,
and then it. - It became crucial.
- That three, two, just, you know. - It's got the winner. - Yeah.
- Yeah. - Yeah, well, that's exactly it.
So was it a luxury goal at the time,
but then it became crucial? - Well, well, I don't know.
That's, that was crucial.
- Well, yes. - They're all crucial.
- Absolutely.
- Yeah, I think if it was 19 goals
and the group featured like some arena
and stuff like that, you'd be like, come on.
But like, as I say, they played against the Croatia team
and they scored seven away from home.
I don't think that's the type of stuff
which we've seen from any sort of England side.
And obviously some people are getting frustrated.
Like, oh, you guys are overregging it too much.
But right now, this England team
is one of the best teams in the world.
And yes, it is winter times, maybe it's easier.
But then when tournament season comes round,
say, well, not talk about this summer, the next summer,
the teams of play games
won't want to play the same as Spain or Les Spain, you know?
And then for the nation's league in the summer,
should they make it through to the quarters and semis?
At least you've seen a proof of concept
that they can be aggressive against the really good side.
- But also, what else can you do?
You can't artificially create the tension
of a World Cup semi-final in November.
The all you can do is play those games,
prove, as Nendem says, like prove that you can win them,
prove that your idea works against that style of football
and then hope that you can execute
when the states are really high.
- Given Celtic's dominance,
when most of your goal's luxury.
(all laughing)
- No, lucky.
(all laughing)
- And I don't know.
- Louis de la Fuente said after it's on the different style
of players, I'd prefer the Spanish model,
you would say that, I suppose.
It's very recognizable.
The players are perfectly adapted.
The English model is very good,
but you have to have that type of player.
Now, their England can play like Spain
or Spain like England, for you.
- I think that's true, I think there is a difference
in the way that they've both been arrived at.
I think the Spanish model is what,
kind of the England DNA project was aiming
for 10, 12 years ago of kind of this universal,
basically quite holistic style,
that cuts across regions and clubs and teams
and kind of most Spanish kids,
a little bit different in the best country, I think,
but most Spanish kids play a very similar kind of principles.
Whereas I think England, it's not that,
you don't have to English Academy's most
of the cultures of Spanish anyway, but the. It's not that they don't have those principles
and there's not a massive technical gap,
but I do think England has. It strikes me as being an identifiably
but modern English style,
basically the England now play.
It is more intense, it is based on kind of industry
and dynamism and all those qualities
that have always shot through English football
with a level of technical expertise that maybe wasn't. Hasn't always been the case,
although obviously when Chris was playing,
the technically they were all perfect, we all know that.
They were just. You're saying industry and dynamism in. You know, I'll go back.
It wasn't necessarily industry and dynamism
from the England team at the World Cup.
We're talking about one game.
It wasn't industry and dynamism against Croatia.
You know, England had a lethargy about them,
so that's the one danger, is it?
I don't think. Thomas Tuchal would say,
England haven't cracked anything yet.
Do you want me to give you the fine margins
that show how you can spin these things from what you've seen?
But how much, are there a bit of luck comes into it
or an inspired goalkeeping performance?
So in the final half hour against Spain,
they faced 19 shots to England, seven on target
and the XG was 2.53.
Yeah.
Argentina in the last half hour of the semi-final
had 10 shots and just four on target
and the next year of 1.41.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It is very interesting how we spin it sometimes,
but it is fine, man.
For sure, but if you notice, as we're talking about this,
we're talking about the first 60 minutes,
not the last half hour when they were holding on for dear life.
You know, that first 60 minutes itself was the sort of more equal match
of where there weren't any big, sort of like moments within the game,
like the red card itself.
After the red card itself, Spain playing a home,
being 3.0 down, having this record of being on beaten
in two and a bit years and whatever.
They've got a center pride.
They're going to go at you, go at you, go at you.
And for England, like the instinct is to take a step back.
So that changes the nature of that game in that sense,
but it was the start, it was the intent,
like you sort of show what your hand's going to be
at the start of the game.
Are you going to be a team that say retreats?
Like look at, say PSG in Europe.
It's a kickoff right in the corner,
put you under pressure straight away.
Go for the line out, go for the line out,
you know, and bring the forwards across whatever you need.
And for England, it was the case of we're playing against Spain,
we're away from home, but we're not intimidated by you.
And we're going to give you this punch
and see how you deal with it.
And that kind of set the tone for the first part of the game.
And then before you know it, go, go, go, and the leads there.
Yeah, it's difficult isn't it, because the last half hour
doesn't actually kind of shape how you think of the game.
No.
But that first hour, when it was 11 and it's 11,
and it doesn't mean that what happens in the last 30 minutes
doesn't count, but when it was 11 and it's 11,
that is what Tutor will use for the players next time they meet up
and say, that is, that's the standard.
That's what we try and do.
And the challenges, can you produce that same performance?
Yeah.
Similarly, sort of, quality opposition in 18 months time.
I think the Del Fuente quote is an interesting one,
because for Spain, they'll never really budge
from their style of play.
So the way that England approached that game
is very specific to how Spain will play.
If you try and think of another team that would play in that manner,
well, it's probably not going to be France.
That's probably not going to be Germany.
You've got teams who can be more sort of like direct.
So I can't off the submair, think of which other ones like the Netherlands
will necessarily play that way.
So some of the teams in England will play in the quarterfinals.
Might be very different to the Spain side,
but I think the fact that England have finally beat in Spain
in a game that feels not as significant,
obviously, as a tournament, lost in a final to them.
You know, lost at this occasion, that occasion.
But they've beaten them, so that should they see them again?
The fear won't be there.
Let's talk the goalkeeping situation.
And before I come to you, Chris, I'll read Paul Robinson's quote.
He says, "We're so guilty as a nation
"of taking one goalkeeper to a tournament
"who has 70, 80 or 90 caps.
"And then the two or three below them
"have less than double figures combined."
So competitive and tournament caps gives you the type of experience
you can't get as a number two or three keeper.
Therefore, you can see exactly what Tuchel is doing.
Trafford is only 24 and has five caps, three of them competitive.
I, I, they can't go into the euros with him stock on five caps
and pickford on the hundred.
No, I think is, I think it's really interesting
because before the game against Spain, when I heard that he was,
you know, he said that Trafford was going to play instead of pickford,
I was a little bit surprised because I thought, you know,
if you are, if you're playing the best team in the world,
you want to put your best team out.
And I don't think Jordan Pickford has done anything wrong
in an England jersey as such.
I admire James Trafford.
I admire the fact that he moved from Manchester City
to leads to get more game time.
And that seems to be absolutely crucial in his sort of,
you know, getting the nod now for England,
the fact that he wanted to play first team football.
I think that that's been a matter.
massive help for him. But I also do think that Thomas Tuchel, I get his thought process,
but I think he could, you know, he could well get himself in the muddle further down the
line, you know, and because it's about, it is about choice goalkeepers. I'm not saying
that the whole team is about choice. Yeah, but let's not pretend goalkeepers over the
years have been treated differently to normal outfield players, you know, as such. So it's,
you know, it's one of those traffic made, you know, a brilliant double save. I mean, that
was off the set of stuff, the double save at the end. But, you know, when England come
to the next big game, does he put, does he keep traffic in? Does he put pick foot back
in? It's good having, having two good goalkeepers, but, you know, it would you pick traffic,
because he's taller. Right. It's fair enough. High level analysis from Chris. He feels
the goal. I like it. I understand. I understand. I understand that. The concept of someone
being bigger, feeling more of the goal. Surely it makes sense not just to get traffic
at experience, but also you are thick. Tuchel has to some extent think about the Euro's.
And as much as there's no sign that pick foot is starting to wane, there's no, no reason
to believe this process. He's never done anything particularly wrong in in England.
Sure. No one would say he's been the weakling or anything like that. You do have to do
what? Completely the opposite. Sorry to interrupt, but according to Opta, he's only made two
errors leads into goals across his whole England career. That's pretty good. Yeah. Yeah.
Slight pivot. The other side, the other case against that, because I think pick foot is
done very, very well for England. But if you go back to the Argentina game, there was
a lot said about the tactics when England were under pressure a little bit. I think
Jordan Kickford picks Jordan Pickford kicks it away too much. And at times you need to take
the sting out of the game by being somebody that will receive a pass, being able to have
the team sort of like move it around and say to sting out of a game. And I don't think
that's Pickford's strong suit. Why don't you count this better with this?
Trafford. Trafford is better with his feet. I don't think he's like the beyond end
all of it. Easy though. Better than Pickford with his feet. Yeah. I think Pickford is incredible
with his feet. I think pickford's better long range with his feet. I think Trafford's
better short to medium range with his feet. And I think that's what I think I would like
to see from England team that's under pressure a little bit. Sure, the personality to play
it because we were too cool in the summer saying England don't have the DNA to like suffer
and so on. And then I see midfield of like Rice Anderson and you know, Bellingham. And
I think maybe I'll deviate from that. Maybe I disagree. But I just think the other thing
you need to do is future proof yourself. So it might, I mean, we don't know what will
happen in the next 18 months, but it may well be that by the time we get to the Euros,
maybe James Trafford has really kind of flourished and Pickford, and I'm not saying that I want
this to happen or even that I think it will, but Pickford might have started to dip because
he is, he's later on in his career and I don't want to show any sign of it. No, there's
no sign of it, but it doesn't, it isn't always telegraphed. Yeah. That's the thing. It
can, it can happen and two, it'll just have to be conscious of that, of that possibility.
So having, having Trafford play those high pressure games, having given him that experience,
I just think it's, it's only a good thing. Yeah, I, I, I think Pickford's very, very good.
But what I think is different, some of the players coming up now, some of the younger
ones, they don't carry the trauma that older players have because there's a group of 21s
and there's 21s who've won the Euros two years in a row. Like James Trafford is on the
same pitch playing against like an Alex Baena for Spain, who's won a World Cup, but Trafford
beat Baena, say three years ago at the Euros, they're all the same age, they've seen
this person before, they're not overroading by them and they're used to wearing a white
shirt, Fringland, which means that they'll be successful at those new phases. And I think
to have that on the field, whether it's right or wrong, I think that makes a difference
because those people will not doubt themselves because they've done it before. And, and therefore
they're starting to get quite a group of players. Yeah. So concert, without having, without
having to use the under 21s winning team in front of me, concert presumably. Yeah. And
Dyson, Kwanzaa, Anderson, previously then last international break. No, no, it's not.
He's a bit younger. Ordinarily, would you not have Googled that? Did Shay shame you last
way to them? Yeah, I've stopped the internet. Yeah. Just, just, just relying on, on, on
non-ancy Gordon struggling, because Anthony Gordon, there was Liverpool and so there was
Alex Scott in the last international sort of break as well. He can add in James Trafford.
back for people we might get the chance to play them but then in the future like all parlors for
example you know there's a there's a group of them there that really do like playing for England.
So Chris goes traffic who would you go for what? To goal in goal for which game if it was a massive
I don't know if it was the Nero's final in two years time or you could take a nation's lead. He's
ruled Pickford out because he was getting on the beat. I can't see the future. I don't know.
Nations lead final next summer. Probably I think it would I think it will still be picked for
the answer first choice next summer. Right. You still haven't answered it. I'm not going to press.
It was I think I think today you'd be picked for two years I'd say traffic. Okay. Yeah.
Do you think city of regressing less in traffic? Well if my name is city than yes.
If what? Yes. I would have I think Don Ramon obviously you know he's an incredible career
but there was a sense of like disappointment to see somebody who you know throughout our lives
they might as well say oh this is going to be the next England keeper and you could see who's
going to be the next England keeper and then he left and you know things aren't going great at
the moment but maybe maybe things are done for Don Ramon. Let's let's talk you away for restructuring
the nation's league. Another fun topic for you Dale. I've been waiting for this all day. I can see
the eyes about to glaze over with a stat to describe it's that complicate. I've actually had to
bring in a printout this time. I've actually described it. Right. So at the moment they have a
format that appears to be working like this nation's league. It's really simple. It's really
simple. A lot of people seem to have praised it and enjoyed it and now they're then to change it.
Yeah. Now they're going to change it. So at the moment you've got four groups of four teams
and now they're going to change it to three groups of six teams. Now it's still going to be six
fixtures so you're going to play. No, he's gone. He's gone. Tell you what. I know it's ridiculous.
If you're laughing, I'm used to me laughing at everything that you come up with. So when you'll
have the three pots of six teams for the draw and when you're drawing into your group you will play
one team home and away from the same pot you're in. So let's say for instance England would
probably be in a pot with France, Portugal, Netherlands, Spain and Belgium. So they will get one of
those teams and play them home and away. But for the other two pots they will play a different team,
one home, one away. So it's a bit like the Champions League is now in the league phase whereby
you get two from each pot, one home and one way away. You don't have the regular home and away
format apart from the team that's in your pot. And they will be teams from lower down the rankings.
The team in your pot will be, so in them will get a major team home and away and then they might get
one of your middleweight nations. Yeah, so pot two at the moment, it's not quite like that because
pot two at the moment you've got Italy and Germany in there. Middleweight. And then of course you go
down to the third pot where you might have got the Wales to be a turkey. So that's the way it's
now going to be structured for the nation's league. Now they say this is for to aid competitiveness.
And if you look at the bottom of the league air tables for this edition, you've got Serbia,
Turkey and Czech Republic who've lost every single match. So you're here for a sort of saying at
the moment, they've probably got a certain tier of teams that are competitive in league air,
but not really enough. And so if they spread out the quality a bit more in league air by adding
an extra couple of teams, then it might not be a case where you have these teams adrift at the
bottom. That's that's their thinking. But presumably, it's just more matches. No, it's exactly the
same number of matches. Right. So one of the things you've done with the nation's league, which is
probably sort of misunderstood is they've kept the same number of actual league games, but they've
added more playoffs. Yeah. But they added more playoffs by making fewer matches in the actual
qualifying program for the Euros and the World Cup. So they're trying to reduce international
friendlies even further by having these playoffs between promotion and relegation between the
between lower leagues. But this is then going to this is then going to feed into a new system
for qualifying for the World Cup in 2030. Oh, right. Whereby. Again, it's like the Champions League
system is going to be there's going to be three leagues of 12 and you get six games like the Champions
League and then it's in into into those the league formats and probably the top four will qualify
for the World Cup. So you're not going to have your regular system anymore. They're splitting away
all the small teams, your Samarinos, etc. They're not going to be in the main qualifying process
anymore. The top 36 European nations will play in the null in in the qualifying process, which
will be based on how you finish in this next round of the year you were for nations league.
So hang on a minute. So if you're Samarino, how can you get into the World Cup qualifying?
So those remaining as it is at the moment 18 nations will have their own qualifying process
and that will get them a place in the playoff path, but they won't be able to qualify automatically.
So 18 nations will will will not have a chance of qualifying automatically for the World Cup.
Yep, they will depend your way you finish in the 2028-29 nations league. But arguably that
gives them a better chance of qualifying for the World Cup because they probably would not have
a chance of finishing the top two anyway.
have a normal qualifying process.
- What is this? - Hang on, could you be clever
and try and not get into--
(laughing)
- What? - What?
- Yeah, clever, clever and lose.
- No, clever and not get, no, clever,
but not by not getting into the main qualifying
because you're never gonna finish in the top,
whatever to get through there.
But then go through the kind of mediocre 12, was it, or 18?
- 18. - So the mediocre 18
because you might have a better chance of getting into the pile.
- There's always been this quirk of the nation's league,
whereby you would better off to be in league B, for instance,
in a certain cycle, whereby if you win league B,
you'd get a playoff for the tournament.
That was always like, you'd be better off
probably not ended up in league A, in a certain cycle,
where those playoff places existed.
- Right. - So--
- And there was the Sweden exception,
wasn't there from this tournament, where--
- That's a good example, yeah. - They didn't win
any qualifying games and they knocked the World Cup.
It's a good example whereby they were in league C,
which they were obviously far stronger
than most of the countries in that league C,
but they obviously won the group,
which then gave them that playoff for it.
That's exactly the example of that.
- How does this affect in the world?
- How does this work? - Yeah.
How does it work in, say, the US,
I'm sorry, in the US, in the other confederations,
where they also have nations league,
is it the same sort of concept as the UEFA thing?
- They all have their own qualifying process,
which is separate.
The UEFA have been trying to push everything down
the nations league group for a while now,
and they moved it for the qualifying,
for the last World Cup, they did actually use the nations league.
Now it's becoming very much all attached
to the qualifying process.
- So how do the qualifiers for the UROs work there?
- Qualifiers, this is a normal system, apart from--
Are you ready for this now?
- Yeah, well, absolutely.
- Right, so obviously we've got four home nations
taking the hosting, but they're also taking part in qualifying.
So what's going to work is there are two places
in qualifying reserved for host nations.
If they don't finish first or second.
So if all four nations finish in the top two places,
then there will be four playoff rooms.
If, say, one host nation underneath it,
there will be three, if there's two,
there will be two playoff rooms.
So exactly how many teams in the playoff
is going to depend on the performance of the home nations,
just to confuse everybody a little bit more.
- So is there a genuine possibility
that a host nation might not be at the UROs?
- Yes, there is, yeah.
- Right.
- Exactly, so if they finish outside the top two,
there will be a playoff route for two home nations,
but if three home nations finish outside the top two,
then only two of those will get a playoff pass,
and the one with the worst record won't get the chance to play in the UROs.
- Chris started making notes at one point for him.
- And then he looked like you gave up.
- No, yeah, I'm really confused,
but just a general premise that you were saying
is good to play in league B.
That's not a great example for kids who are listening
to not even you grow up and be the best that you want to be,
but you're better off playing in league B in the nation's league.
That's not reaching for the top, is it?
But I mean, there is still going to be this playoff pass
for the nations, the league winners.
So there is still going to be that carrot to be in league B
and win your group and maybe get yourself a playoff.
- I am very confused by this whole thing,
but the one thing I would say without understanding it fully
is that UEFA in their defence do have to balance up.
We tend to look at things from a kind of major nation point of view,
because it's here, it's the kind of well-qualified boring
just in and win every game.
But UEFA have to think about all of the nations
and how they experience qualifiers.
There are a group of nations who are locked out of it,
whatever the system is.
So I understand that they're desire to fiddle around with things
in the hope of trying to maybe keep more people interested for longer.
Does it, you can't just run everything by,
is it boring for Germany?
The problem is-- - No, no, I think the old,
the old qualifier system was incredibly tedious.
- Yeah, we knew who was going through, there was one team in every group,
they won every match, and then some of them don't--
then it was the playoffs where you get bull-gary
or it ain't Norway or whatever, and suddenly it would be exciting.
The problem or the shame is, the real success of the nations lead
hasn't just been at the top level.
It's the fact that in Leeds, C&D,
you get teams for whom international football for a long time
was, in the coming to town, we're done to lose 7-0.
They are playing teams of their level,
and that has revitalised, they're not minnowes,
but kind of the middle weights of European football.
- I was actually looking at the group tables yesterday.
- That's on a wide, really.
- I thought, I don't know.
- What a way to spend it somewhere.
- And I thought, you got nothing else going on?
- I know, I know, I know.
And I thought, I'm the Faroe Islands.
- Exactly, I'm the Faroe Islands.
- I'm the Faroe Islands, Dunwellin, in group three of--
- You're a terrible hipster, chap, as that's the problem with you.
- So you're looking at the Faroe Islands,
but there's an ample much closer to home.
There's Northern Ireland.
Northern Ireland, I think, could qualify for lead A.
- Yes, it could, yeah.
- In the next cycle, they would end up playing,
I mean, Scotland had a little spell there
as well, if it were to play here today, didn't they?
Northern Ireland might have Spain and Italy and France
going to winter park, and that's incredible
for Northern Irish football.
- There is obviously one benefit from being league A,
if you managed to be in it,
and obviously Wales are going to have a playoff likely,
likely to have a playoff to sustain it.
You guarantee, then, to be put one or put two for the draw
for the World Cup, for World Cup qualifying.
So that is a benefit to--
- I did put the pots into it there.
- And really good.
- I've got another interesting pot point for you here.
You're like--
(laughing)
- Tails, Tails, interesting pot point.
(laughing)
- It's got a new feature.
- Yeah, it'll be easy to say.
- So you talked about Faroe Islands,
but they're obviously improved quite a lot,
but in league C this time, a Samarino,
and because they're in league C,
they're going to be in pot four for the Euro's draw.
So some one group is going to have Samarino,
and potentially two minors.
And because the best second place is based on record,
only four of the eight of the 12 do,
having Samarino in your group gives you a real good chance
of being one of the best runners up
because essentially you would expect that to be two wins.
- Thanks, I think.
- Any more questions?
- No, no, no, no.
- And Nathan was looking like he's about to drop off.
- I think to be fair, they might be following up.
- Yeah, expect plenty following up.
- Thank you, Dale.
Dale, just some winners on the Monday night one.
- For more than a decade,
British Boxing has been shaped by two men.
- Two completely different personalities,
two extraordinary careers.
And one fight that just won't go away.
- There's never been a fight like this
in the history of British Boxing.
Never, never.
- This is the story of how we got here.
- And how the AJ Fury rivalry
read a fine boxing forever.
- This was political trick.
Half Fury fans, half AJ fans.
- Five light boxing, Fury, V Joshua.
- Listen on BBC Sounds.
- This is the Monday night club with Mark Chapman.
- On the football daily podcast.
- Thomas Frank has been appointed as a crystal palace manager.
Today, we'll talk about that in a moment.
Mauricio Pochettino's assistant
have already left the USA camp and flown to Manchester
to get started ahead of his arrival.
The USA won there first, like,
of whatever stage their nations lead.
- There's four final quarter, thank you.
Six nil.
So that was the first leg.
How Pochettino stayed for the second leg?
The assistance of arrived in Manchester.
There's a piece in the time by Tom Olnott at the moment.
The lesson from Mauricio Pochettino's career,
he needs full control.
Which begs the question, Chris,
why has he gone to Manchester United?
- Yeah, but that's how I don't, yeah.
- I don't. - I don't, dot, dot, dot.
- Yeah.
I don't know where to stand on this one.
The full control thing.
On the face of it, stuff which I've read suggests
that he will have more control than Michael Carrick.
What does that mean?
You know, the whole set up that Manchester United
have with, you know, with Jason Wilcox, director of football.
Who gets the final say on players?
I think that that's a gray area at, you know, at a lot of clubs.
So I mean, it ended at Chelsea, I think, with Pochettino,
because, you know, I think there were disagreements
between him and the hierarchy there.
He certainly wasn't happy with the situation.
So I'll be interested to see how this pans out.
But yeah, I couldn't tell you whether he would have
as much control as he did say to Tottenham Hotspur.
- I'm curious to know, like, what do we think?
We were talking about when we say like control.
We were talking about control over transfers.
And we were talking about scheduling.
Is it as simple as like, some places,
there's pressure to pick certain players?
Like, what do you think that means, Roy?
- I think it probably means recruitment more than anything.
But I'm not sure.
I've got to admit, it feels in the show a long time, haven't we?
- Yeah. - It does feel like this is a sort of conversation
we should have left behind about 10 years ago.
This stuff is not that hard.
- In what sense? - It really isn't difficult.
The way that most, most half decent,
vaguely competent football teams work
is you have a recruitment staff and that might be a technical director and a head of scouting it might be
Director of football or whatever, you can call the jobs whatever you want.
They are the head of a team who will send out sound into the world or they'll have the
data and they'll go through the players, they'll do their due diligence, some will be numbers,
some will be eyes, they'll have people finding out what the players get up to at night in
case they're problematic behind the scenes or whatever.
They'll call as many people as they can to find out like is this person going to be
helpful or disruptive, whatever it might be.
The director of the manager and say these are the three players you've got on the left
back.
These are the three best options we have.
Most managers I think will be like well yeah do you know what maybe there's a fellow
at Torino who I really like if you thought about him and you'll have an adult conversation
and you'll reach a conclusion it's not that complicated with United it would almost
worry me more.
Now maybe Michael Carrot I don't know maybe Carrot said I'll just take whatever you give
me don't worry I don't want and maybe I just want to be a kind of cones and badges coach.
I just want to be out on the training pitch, coaching the players not interested in recruitment
I don't know maybe that's what Carrot said but if they've switched it to say to Torino
you can have more control that's almost more worrying.
Partly because he's only signed the two and a half year contract and partly because
it suggests that you don't really believe in the model.
Okay but but from your knowledge of the model of football clubs right do United is United's
model overly complicated by the number of people that they have doing different roles.
So they have a director of football in Jason Wilngogs but they then have a director of
recruitment in Christopher Vivell.
They then have Carr McCauley who's been brought in he was like Graham Potter's right hand
man on recruitment so I don't know what he says that job title is cheap scare to thing.
They then also have Michael Sonsoni who is a director of data who they brought him from
Mercedes and that's before you then get to the chief exec there's also a director of
negotiations in all of this as well and then Ratcliffe who has and the glazers who presumably
both have to sign off on the money so I think that sounds like too many cook in all honestly
it probably is because again none of this is actually that complicated but I don't think
that's that much more complicated than most clubs though there will be clubs who we regularly
praise for being well run and do it recruitment who have similar kind of front office organisations
that's the way they've gone because I suspect the glazers involvement is okay we'll allow
that bank transfer I don't think there's any more detail than that Ratcliffe might be more
involved but as American corporate ownership has come into football what they've constructed
around themselves are the same structures that they understand from their from the business
world so you want you want your data person you yeah you'll have a director of negotiations
sounds like a ridiculous title to me but I'm guessing in a finance firm you will have
someone who does your mergers and acquisitions or whatever you're you are used to having
big rooms full of lots of people makes up getting sign off it sounds like corporate bloke
to me and I suspect chap as it sounds like corporate bloke to you but I don't think with
the United is that they've got more people the issue would either be maybe they're not
not the right people or you don't have the right mix of people those are those are the
two kind of things that maybe separate a well run club from a poorly run club I think
for me if you had one person doing say four of those jobs and they weren't greater those
individual parts than you'd probably be in a poor system but I think the biggest issue
in my opinion with United and I could be completely off base here is that when you compare
them to other clubs who we quote as being say being well run well run is relative to what
the club wants to be and I think when you know what the club wants to be then you recruit
managers and players that suit a particular style I think again I could be completely wrong
here but every club wants to be well run no but I'm talking about the style though relatively
speaking because if it became a style type thing then the players that would be brought
in would always suit style manager would always suit a style but I think eight for United
given the last like ten to fifteen years where they've gone from a position of real dominance
seeing the league changing out to where like a club like Brighton could be top of the league
with a 30 something year old manager who has players who most people wouldn't have been
sort of like seeing those youtube hype videos for we need this guy we need that guy like
that's feels like that's what's missing all the other clubs especially not near the top
seem to have an identity and as a content identity and says what they want to do so when
say for example managers losing their job you'd be of a mindset to know that there are
only certain amount of managers that would be linked to this job because of the style
of players they have but United you've had Amarim you've had Kerrick you've had Poccheteen
or if Poccheteen doesn't work out it could go in any which direction again Pocchete the
Poccheteen nothing broke after our last show yes and we we sat here on last Monday and
we would discuss in what Emory was still kind of it was that was after the whole Carrad
run pleasantness Eddie how we think they they were interested in Nardle's man I think
they looked at in the summer Antonio Conte is what there's always been the shadow of
Antonio Conte they have looked at Pocchete in our three times previously United at least
most recently I think in 2024 according to his version of events they got in touch with
him last Sunday which would be after the four or draw I would imagine realistically
someone would have said prior to that if we made an offer for Maritzio do you think you
would be interested you're not going to kind of make contact if you don't think there's
any reason to but it does seem like it's come around pretty twitly and the key thing
with all of those candidates they're nothing like each other which is gets to Nadeham's
point which is that the issue with United I think isn't necessarily not too many probably
do have too many people in their front office it seems like a model system but the biggest
thing is I'm not sure they know what they're working to walk well no and actually because
they don't know what they're working towards Chris and therefore the impressions they haven't
know what they're working towards for however long they've got a squad full of players
that have been bought for various different managers or to to satisfy what they wanted
or what they needed from their system so dogoo for example was brought as a left wim back
to play in Ruben Amarim's system although in his first game Ruben Amarim then played
him on the right I don't remember that I mean you know the positive thing from from
Pocciatino's perspective is is is taking over a club in a in a real model what's the you
know what's the ambition short term you know this season if he can get them into the into
the top half of the table you would probably as ridiculous as it sounds in the nature of
the Premier League this season regard it as success but he's taking over a real mess in terms of
I mean you know you you look at the you know the you mentioned Dawga but just the Manchester
United defense in general you know you've got you've got you know playersless Andrew Martin
as in Bruno Fernandez who you know we're we're happy to to snipe at Michael Carrick so you
know it's it's not going to be an easy an easy task for them it's not going to be like Tottenham
first time round you know where where he had a lot of time but I'll say he necessary had a lot of
time but you know he he built something and there was time there I just I think January's going
to be fascinating you know what who can he bring in in January you know what you know defensively
they you know certainly need additions they need a center forward stylistically how are
are they going to play under potchartino you know are they going to be a pressing team which I'm
not such a Manchester United can be so he's got a lot to sort out you know if they brought him in
because they want his style of football they seem to have constructed a squad that doesn't look
like it could play that stuff or hasn't given the impression that it could play that style of
football and if it does now start to show that it can play that style of football then there are
questions to be asked about why they haven't been doing it already I mean yeah look I mean you know
the oddity about Michael Carrick how could how could that team be so good last season and then
this season be you know at the opposite end of the spectrum I mean that so that was a you know
a real head scratcher I mean potchartino will come in and pick the piece up but it doesn't
I actually thought the decision to get rid of Carrick was was the was the right decision
and my worry for potchartino after you know watching Manchester United this season you know how
is he going to turn things around in a short space of time with this group of players it doesn't
seem that simple but then you know Carrick did it last season when when he took over from
Emmerim didn't he and the team were you know pretty wofl so it's but it's going to be really
interesting how this pans out but you know how this at the power situation works but I'm sure
potchartino you know he's of he's you know he's he's reputation you know is that he's a strong
character so where I think that Michael Carrick I'm not saying he was just happy to be there that
would be slightly disrespectful but where you always felt that Carrick could be maneuvered around
yeah but you don't know though do I don't know no but that's yeah that maybe I may be wrong with that
but it does seem that potchartino has a bit more has a bit more clout than Carrick I think the
big thing is is Chris is right that generally be interested in terms of who they're signed
United have to start selling players they've got to make some difficult decisions I mean Bruno
could have gone to Saudi certainly last summer maybe this summer before he's 32 he's that he's
their best player but at the same time you have to start thinking about what again what are we building
towards and there's a lot of players in that squad who will be on a lot of money who
probably don't have a kind of an ongoing future at Man United long term.
So you have to try and shift them before you can add more plays into the mates.
But the problem is it's not just the United have got this issue, where do you sell them to?
Does the Premier League brought so much more money than everybody else?
You can't offload your unwanted left winner to Valencia anymore,
but it's Valencia to probably only pay about a tenth of his wages.
And that is a genuine problem for them.
I don't see how you can start to reshape the squad without shedding quite a few players.
Yeah, do you know you mentioned Brilliant Fernandez there? I think he's an interesting one,
because the way that this month or so has gone almost feels like politically you can't extend him,
because he almost created a position where you either supported Man United or Fernandez,
but not both. I don't know for some people that might not necessarily be a thing,
but the fact that they have the option to just extend him regardless is also really interesting.
And I think from what you see in his perspective, this job will probably be one of these trickiest jobs,
because say the other teams he's been at, you did a great job at Spurs, where they ended up,
well, I say great job, obviously some people just that based on whether they want titles or they
didn't, but that was probably the last time Spurs would really competitive when it comes out to
win a league title. Then this press and demand that you look at say Chelsea coming in when it's
a bit more chaotic, not the Chelsea of the say the 20 turns is a different Chelsea.
Well, now he's coming to the club that gets more coverage than anywhere else, more people
speaking about them than anywhere else. And relative to expectation, probably performing the worst
to say many of the huge clubs around Europe, I think you may have just highlighted the whole
control issue in one answer there, because if you go back to our test results,
when he wanted to move players on, they basically told the contractor to move them on,
and the club I suppose took the hit, I'm not taking a transfer fee. So. But what do you do in the short term if you are Pochettino? What do you do with Bruno?
But that's exactly the crux of the issue, isn't it? So let's say, for argument's sake,
it may not be him. There are a couple of others, I think, who have an option of their contracts
being ascended. If you're here, you're going, "I want to move with a player, player-axe. I want
to move on." And the club go, "Well, we want to still get some value more than by extending
them." Yeah, but why because if you don't sell them, we've then extended them, and they're hanging
around, and I didn't want them here. That would be the crux of it, Chris. That's the control issue.
Surely, he should have that file. I don't care if you miss out on toilet. I'll just want. You're totally right. And the smart move, whether you agree or not, but I think if we're all in
Pochettino shoes, going in at Manchester, you're thinking, "This is a club who have played
poorly all season, but you look back to Bruno the way he performed last season." You'd probably
put an arm around him and really try hard to get him on-side and get him playing, because
if not, who else is there within that side who are really capable of being that spark and
lifting Manchester United? So it has to be very short term for him in the immediacy, and that's not
going to be easy to go in and flick a switch. But we did see that last season, didn't we?
That they had six brilliant months under Carrick. And I'm not. I mean, I don't know enough about
football to know exactly what he did tactically to make them better, but I'm like, Chris, I'm baffled
by how bad they've been this year compared to how do they were last season. But we know
that this squad of players are capable of. Better. Better. Yeah.
That's it. Who, Barryminder, this has happened over the course of, you know, Ender last week, and now
today, who do you think has got the harder job? Potsch Tino or Frank? Probably Potsch Tino,
because like every former United player works in media, so there'll always be discussion around
everything that he's doing. Whereas I think for Thomas Franco, Crystal Palace, I feel like Crystal
Palace itself. Again, I don't like speaking on behalf of Life I'm basically just my perception.
It's a place where you can go to play and enjoy your football. You can do well, if you do well,
then it's great. If things aren't great, then it's okay. And as I was coming over here today,
I thought, if Thomas Franco doesn't manage to turn around for Palace and say, "We're
going to snare for them," they went down. I feel like they'd keep Thomas Franco, as opposed,
as a manager who came from the championship, I believe, with Brentford, so he has that level of
experience. And they could almost look at this season and say, you know, it's disappointing,
we're going to try and build back up, you know, so many key players have left across the time,
but I think from a purchasing up perspective, if the United Finisher season are like 15th,
I think some of the, whether we like it or not, I think there will be some criticism of him,
because he's actually having 28 games to do something. Nobody's expecting great things,
but he's 28 games to do something, which makes you be positive for the next year.
There's a cycle element to United, which is where they always fall down, which is that
the manager comes in, it makes things a bit better. And then within a year, 18 months,
they're not challenging for titles, but as the Premier League has changed since the United
of the dominant force, and the bitters of the scale of United, that brings pressure. I think,
I think Frank just got the harder job, because Palace looked to me like they have sold one
player to many. And I'm not sure, there's question marks over Sarah Matetta, if they can return to
fitness, if they can kind of, if you can get them firing again, fully fit and then firing,
then I think you stand a fighting chance. But they, if you look at the players that they've lost over
the last 18 months, two years, in a lead that is very competitive at the bottom, that, I think,
is a big ask. But then if you asked who's more likely to be under intense pressure in 18
months time, it's probably Pochettino. There are probably similarities between the two jobs
and the two appointments, aren't there, Chris, which is as probably there should be if it's two clubs
in the bottom three who are changing their managers. Frank is also going into a club where
the squad doesn't look right, balanced, particularly age-wise, defensively. They've lost a lot of
experience. So questions being asked about their recruitment in the same way that they are being
asked about with United. Yeah, I actually think that PSR's leaving with Thomas Frank coming in,
it's not a bad position. I know they're bottom, so that's bad. But it's not like they are,
they are absolutely cut a drift. I think that of the 28 games to go in the season,
they're two points off Coventry, they're four points off Ipswich and Hull the newly promoted
teams, you think, well, we've had a disastrous start to the season. We should be able to
sort of reel that back in. But this wasn't just the end to last season, was a little bit deceiving
from Palace because they ended up winning the Europa conference league. There was this sort of
thing, well, add a brilliant season again, but the Premier League form, I think they got only
nine points in the last eight games, something like that, there was the unhappiness with Oliver
Glasner, who was disgruntled about the whole situation. He ended up leaving. So I've got sympathy
with PSR's, and then you mentioned the recruitment key players. Gone, they lost Gaye last January,
they lost LaQua, who was a real rock for them at the back, and they haven't done a lot of
their Los Munoz, who was an outstanding wing back for them, and they haven't done a lot of work
in the transfer market over the summer. But then if you were conceding goals at the alarming rate,
which they were under PSR's, then that would have been the concern. And Thomas Frank, I suppose,
it's still not going to be an easy job, and there'll be palace fans who are thinking,
well, what version of Thomas Frank are we going to get here? Are we going to get the Brentford
version? But at Brentford, he was allowed time to nurture. Last eight of his first 10 matches
in charge of Brentford when we talk about him being allowed time. Yeah, absolutely. But then
you've got Tottenham, who were just on another level to most clubs in terms of just being
absolutely wild. And Thomas Frank, every time you saw him at Brentford, he always looked so
well and handsome and fit, and he loved his paddle. At Tottenham, he looked absolutely
naked, didn't he? He looked so unhappy. Well, we all have rough days to rest.
Tottenham just does that. It's done that to a lot of managers. So I hope, you know,
I hope things work out. Don't be gets his love for paddle back.
Yeah, it's like, he's been playing quite a lot of paddle.
But I think from his point of view, he wouldn't go into this job if he didn't think he could,
he could keep palace up. You know, he needed to choose his next job carefully
after Tottenham, whether we like it or not, and he'll think that there's enough
within that team where they can stay up. And that's the aim. You know, he's got, you know,
Matetta, who was, you know, an outstanding striker, had star there, but they've both
disgruntled players at the end of last season, wanted a way. So, you know, he's still got a lot
of work to do. But, you know, in the, in the short term, it's about tightening them up at the
back. And I think that he will do that. I think, I could be wrong here, but I think palace
have only sacked two managers in the last nine years. So that makes me think that Tottenham's
Frank will be given time to fix the situation. But the big test with Frank is the same as we've
seen at Chelsea, whenever they've taken a Brighton manager, which is that we still don't know
with those, those three system clubs, I guess, Bournemouth Brentford and Brighton.
How good their managers are when they're taken out of that system. It's really hard.
And Graham Potter at Brighton looked incredible. At Chelsea, it looks out of his depth at West
London, isn't it?
well. It's the same with with Frank that when he went to Spurs, I think everybody thought,
"Well, yeah, that makes perfect sense." He'd been brilliant at Brentford. He was that slightly
more pragmatic choice for Tottenham and he thought this makes this works. And he did it was the
exact opposite. It started poorly and got worse. It's a real test for Thomas Frank, whether he can
get a tune out of Palace, which is not a club, it's not a badly run club at all, but it's not
quite as smooth a machine as Brentford. Yeah, it's not, but I would say in the last couple of years,
expectation of Brentford and Palace is probably closer than that of what Spurs is. And I think that
is something that will possibly play into his hands, not to say that Palace just accepts
whatever it accepts, because they've made history. You know, they've won the FA Cup, they've won
the conference league, you know, for them, they've won the community shield. That's great, but that's
not really what the club is, otherwise we'd have heard about that, say many times before. He needs
also, doesn't need to get a bit of a feel-good factor back, because despite winning the trophies,
there is a spouse, an element of having to think it got it was so good, and maybe we could have
kicked on, and we haven't. Yeah, I'm sure there is, but then look at, say the way Klasn has spoken,
how disappointed he was when there wasn't that sense of like matching his own ambition, you know,
across the years, they've lost the likes of as a gay, he at least say to name, but just those three,
you know, like one hour as well, they've lost, they've lost tons of players, Munoz, so maybe they're just,
they're a club that's done very, very well, but I'd really like for some, they've probably
punched him above their way. What did you say? They've sacked, what was it? I think it's, they think
they've sacked two managers in nine years. Okay, I think it may be. Who's the third? Well, hang on,
it depends when you're, so you're not, you're not crossing the bull. Yeah, I've disregarded him,
because he never happened. He's like a joke when it comes to that. Well, that was, because that was
September, 2070, so it falls just outside the nine-year period. No, he's very specifically selected.
Yeah, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, just, no, just to break my Google balance, just to get that,
just to get that, just to get that, just to get that. Save, for example, I think Roy Hodgden stepped
away because of health issues in it. Yeah, yeah. So Patrick Vieira was the last manager before
size that they sacked, and before that, Roy Hodgden was in play for a long time. Yeah. So it's not
really a club that is looking to be chopping and changing managers all the time. So, yeah, that's
why I have a belief that he'll do well, and as well, he's, I think he's somebody who speaks very
well as a coach for his football club, and I think the energy that he can bring to Palace is one
where he understands the club, understands where they've been, what they want to try and achieve,
and I think it will suit his identity, probably a bit more so than supposed it. Does it,
do you think his appointment, Chris, makes more clubs further up the Premier League worry? Do you
think there are some clubs who may have been thinking, oh, if one of the relegation places goes to
Palace, we could be in quite a good position. Yeah, well, that's why I think it's, I think Palace
of viewing this appointment as a safe pair of hands with what he achieved at, you know, at Brentford.
So I think, you know, as I said, if he goes in and he looks up the table, he looks at the three clubs
who came up, he must be thinking we can, with respect, we can haul them in, you know, we're not
on a hopeless position, eight, ten points are drifted at the bottom, you know, this is, this is
very manageable. They go to Coventry, that's his first game in charge, Saturday, three o'clock,
win that, they're above Coventry. Well, yeah, I mean, I've tried to make this point several times
and I can't so I apologise, I'm going to go again. You know, you get those years when one of the big
teams has a really poor start, and you think, well, that's them done for the Champions League,
and then they win two games and they're fifth, and it turns out that everyone's dropping points.
You're getting something similar at the bottom this season, where, I mean, Sunland have had a bad start
this season. Win one game, they'll be 14th. It's so compact, there's so many teams picking up points,
dropping points. It's so evenly balanced that, yeah, Palace win two games in 10 days, and Palace
will be mid-table. Well, there is a possibility if you get to a decent start, we'll be back here in
three weeks, four weeks time, so can they get into Europe? It's true, it's very, very true, and you
know, obviously Palace is speaking being terrible, that's why the bottom of the league is at this point,
but as Chris said, which was the best and most important point, is your two points away
from Coventry, four points away from State Ipswich and Hall. In reality, those teams are doing
really well, but that's still very, very close. Unfortunately, we're out of time, so
they don't thank you, Rory, thank you, Chris. Thank you. See you soon. We don't need to
rearrange your Christmas lights. Oh, no, no, no, no, it's a lovely display, they don't need to rearrange.
So wherever the conversation takes us, on the Monday night club we'll round up all the
major talking points from the weekend's football. Every Tuesday and Wednesday we get stuck into
all the actions from the Premier League and Champions League. Every Friday the commentator's
view takes you behind the microphone with stories from the road, your questions, plus a look
ahead to the weekend's actions, and kick off your Saturday with the football interview featuring
some of the biggest names in the game. The football day of the new episode throughout the week,
subscribe now on BBC Sounds. Sometimes we all need an extra help in hand,
especially with the tricky business problem you've been putting off.
Claude is an AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow
and thinks with you, not for you, and Claude isn't just for quick questions,
handed a whole task like turning a folder or scattered notes into a report and it does the work
and hands back something finish that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a doc or
deck right in front of you, and Claude design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website
or prototype your picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design
language ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already
use, like Gmail and Slack, and whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial
model or strategising your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the
problems at Meta, for problems worth solving, get started with Claude at Claude.ai/solve.
That's Claude.ai/solve, and check out ClaudePro, which includes access to all of the features
mentioned in today's episode, Claude.ai/solve.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Whole Foods Market offers antibiotic-free meat and organic sides, with no high fructose corn syrup in their pies, emphasizing quality and health.
Cadillac’s entry into Formula One reflects a racing mindset of precision, engineering excellence, and performance, which is mirrored in its V Series luxury vehicles.
England delivered a standout performance against Spain, showcasing physical intensity, aggression, and tactical discipline, marking a turning point in their international football identity.
The shift toward a more aggressive, Premier League-style football is seen as a key evolution in England’s game, contrasting with Spain’s possession-based approach.
Goalkeeper selection in England’s team is under debate, with James Trafford gaining experience in high-pressure matches, raising questions about long-term squad stability.
The Nations League format is being restructured to increase competitiveness and inclusivity, with changes to group structures and a new qualifying pathway for the 2030 World Cup.
Manchester United’s appointment of Mauricio Pochettino raises questions about managerial control and squad identity, amid complex front-office structures and inconsistent playing styles.
The evolving football landscape highlights a growing need for clubs to define clear identities, balance player recruitment, and adapt to new competition formats.
Summary:
This podcast blends promotional content with in-depth football analysis, covering a range of topics from Thanksgiving shopping at Whole Foods to the tactical evolution of England’s national team. Whole Foods is promoted as a premium, health-conscious destination with no antibiotics and no high fructose corn syrup, appealing to consumers seeking quality. In football, England’s decisive 3-2 win over Spain—despite playing with 10 men—is hailed as a breakthrough, showcasing a physically aggressive, Premier League-inspired style that contrasts with Spain’s possession-heavy tactics.
Analysts debate whether this performance reflects a lasting identity shift or a temporary surge, noting the importance of consistency in high-stakes matches. The discussion also extends to tactical and managerial decisions, such as Pochettino’s appointment at Manchester United, where concerns over lack of clear team identity and front-office control are raised. Additionally, the Nations League’s structural changes are explored, aiming to improve competitiveness and inclusivity by spreading team quality and creating new pathways for smaller nations.
Overall, the conversation underscores how football is evolving—not just in style and strategy, but in how clubs manage performance, identity, and long-term planning.
FAQs
Whole Foods Market offers high-quality, organic Thanksgiving items like meat without antibiotics, stuffing mix, cranberry sauce from the 365 brand, and pies made without high fructose corn syrup.
No, there are no antibiotics in Whole Foods Market's meat department.
It brings an American luxury brand with a strong performance and engineering background onto the biggest stage in motorsport, reflecting a racing mindset that influences their luxury vehicle lineup.
The Cadillac V Series offers distinctive luxury performance, engineered with precision and performance inspired by Formula One's racing mindset.
England won 3-2 against Spain despite playing with 10 men for the last 25 minutes, showing strong physicality, aggression, and defensive intensity in a game that marked a significant improvement in their performance.
The new format changes group structures to three groups of six teams, adding more diversity in matchups while maintaining the same number of games, aiming to increase competitiveness and reduce the dominance of top-tier teams.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.