Go back

Misunderstandings with The Maasai: Part One

20m 12s

Misunderstandings with The Maasai: Part One

Dr. Rae Wynn Grant reflects on her transformative study abroad experience in Kenya in 2005, where cultural misunderstandings about Black identity and American history profoundly shaped her worldview. As the first Black American student in a study program, she encountered significant gaps in knowledge among local staff, who held misconceptions about slavery, migration, and racial dynamics in the U.S. A confrontational interaction with a community member who claimed Black Americans were “dead in the water” shocked her, leading to a painful realization when she later read about Hurricane Katrina’s racially disproportionate impact. She admitted her earlier false narrative of racial harmony, apologized sincerely, and shared the truth with locals, who responded with forgiveness and emotional support. This moment deepened her understanding of the diversity within Black experiences and the importance of cultural humility. The episode underscores how personal encounters with racial injustice can foster empathy, self-reflection, and a commitment to truth-telling. These experiences continue to influence her identity as a Black female scientist and a storyteller committed to revealing the human drama behind conservation and cultural survival.

Transcription

3055 Words, 16258 Characters

English
Although most of my stories are about wild animals and my adventures with them, this story is not. It's about cultural misunderstandings, a lot of mistakes I made, and ultimately some of the experiences I had with people that I think also helped turn me into who I am today. Landing at the Nairobi airport is super vivid in my mind because it was so, it was so different. You know, I had never been in a Black country at all, so it was so interesting to me to like land in a place where like everyone was Black. I hadn't taken the time to think about how that would feel to like blend in. And yet at the same time, the staff was meeting. I was there with, you know, a sign, you know, that said School for Field Studies, and they were able to know exactly who we were. And I walked over to the staff member and the person said, oh, excuse me, this is for a American study abroad program. And I said, yeah, yeah, I know. And they said, no, no, no, like this isn't for, this isn't for Kenyans. This is for American students. I was exactly the opposite of what I was. I was the opposite of what they expected. Kind of the story of my life. Like ever since then, I've been like the professionally like the opposite of what people expect. I remember explaining like, no, no, like I'm Rae Wynn Grant and I am American and I'm part of the study abroad program. And of course, the staff member was super apologetic. Not only did they not realize that like a Black student was coming, they really didn't have an understanding of the Black American identity and like how it could properly exist. And that was kind of the beginning. The beginning of so many interesting conversations about race and identity on that trip. And some of them were pretty uncomfortable. And I remember that he looked angry. I mean, he looked furious. You said things are fine, but all the Black people, they're dead in the water. I'm Dr. Rae Wynn Grant, and this is a different kind of nature show. A podcast all about the human drama of saving animals. I want to tell you my story and what it's actually like to track bears in the Sierras, chase lemurs in Madagascar, live with lions in Tanzania, and do all of that as a Black female scientist. This is Going Wild. I'm Nate Hedgie, host of Outside In, a show where curious people can find out more about curiosity and the natural world collide. I call it helium, but that's Sir Helium to you because this is one noble gas. That's exactly what Darwin thought, that song predated speech and human ancestors sang some sort of wordless songs. I have to say, it is just perfectly dry down here. Stay curious with Outside In from NHPR, available wherever you get your podcasts. Usually folks ask me, you know, how did I get my start? Like, what was my first experience that put me on the track of being a wildlife ecologist? And I always, always, always, every single time talk about when I was a junior in college and I studied abroad for a semester in Kenya. I saw my first wild animals. I interacted with them. It was amazing. But what I don't usually have room to talk about is also how complicated that experience was for me. Mentally. Intellectually. Cross-culturally. Like, it was fun and important and powerful and life-changing. And it was also super confusing, super complex. And my identity as a young Black American woman came into play in ways that I was pretty unprepared for. It's so hard for me to be accurate with my description of 2005 Kenya because I've gone back so many times since then. But 2005 Kenya was just, in retrospect, it was on the verge of becoming a big tech hub. But it wasn't quite there yet. Today, if I landed in Kenya, I could text my parents to say I made it. In 2005, I remember writing a letter to my parents. I wrote a letter to them from the camp saying I've made it. And I got a response from my family at the end of the semester. Whereas today, you know, everything would be instant. So the study abroad program was set up as a very intensive model. We did a normal amount of class, but a lot of time in the field. You know, a lot of game drives that took absolutely all day, you know, a lot of time like out there with wild animals. Wildlife in the bush, which was awesome. So most notably, when it comes to free time, you know, this was pre-internet. And in fact, like pre-electricity in this part of the country of Kenya. So our free time was not spent looking at screens. And one of the wonderful things that we were able to do is get to know the staff. They seemed like adults. You know, and adults are like in their 30s and, you know, or older and all of that. But really, the staff members were pretty young. I think the majority of them were in their 20s. Some of the staff members, again, were from Maasai communities and kind of bridged this line between a traditional lifestyle and a Western lifestyle. I came to realize that I had a lot of knowledge and information that the staff members specifically wanted to talk to me about. And it was definitely. Definitely about the Black American experience. I was the first Black student who had ever participated in this program. I was the first African-American student that had ever come. And that opened a world of opportunity for conversation. I remember having two different conversations with two different staff members, one of whom thought that there were no Black people in the United States. So they were curious, like, how did I come to know Black people? How did I come to be just as a person? And then, you know, a different staff member who just came to me with so much pride, you know, saying, isn't it just so wonderful, you know, you're young, but you're the first person in your family to be free, you know, and not a slave? I was totally blown away by that question. In fact, I didn't even understand it at first, but I quickly realized, oh, my gosh, a lot of these people are Black. These people have no idea about American history, about the timing of it, but in particular about the Black experience in the United States and the role of slavery. I mean, I can think of tons of reasons why staff members from my Study Abroad program wouldn't have this deep understanding of African-American history. For one, the country of Kenya wasn't really involved in the American slave trade anyway. And, you know, when I think about how, you know, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was a slave, I was I learned about African history as an American, I would imagine they didn't have a lot of reason to learn about American history either. It didn't take too long for me to figure out that I should just sit down and just teach a full-on history lesson, which is exactly what I did. I would say that different people had different understandings and different people had heard different things. So not everybody knew that slavery had happened in the United States. In the United States, there were a couple of staff members who really thought that anyone Black in America had parents who had deliberately immigrated, you know, to the United States. And so that was, you know, a misconception that we had to kind of put down right away. And at the same time explain that there are tons of Black folks in the United States who had parents who, you know, deliberately immigrated there. So I was feeling like, well, how do I also, you know, explain all of this and then talk about, you know, the 100, 150 years after slavery, you know, of more brutality and, you know, more racism and violence, but it is also possible to have a great life and that the Black community is thriving and doing our best and resilient and all of these things. It was hard. And I made some mistakes in doing that. I know that. But when I did start trying to explain that, like, oh, it's OK today, I really overdid it. You know, I said, well, everything's OK and it's very, very safe and we all get treated really well. And so you should come to the United States sometime if you can. And I think you'll love it. And unfortunately, me selling that point ended up coming back to bite me a little later. It was a day that I. I joined a couple of students in this five kilometer jog. to the nearest village and a community member who had limited English skills but really tried to make an effort to chat with us came up and I remember that he looked angry I mean he looked furious and he stormed up to me with my friends and and yelled and I I mean even before I could comprehend what he was saying I was frightened you know I was really taken aback and he kind of pointed his figure and he said you said everything's okay in America you said things are fine but all the black people they're dead in the water and I thought to myself okay what in the world is going on it's gotta be you know a language barrier here what is he talking about but over and over he pointed in my face and he insisted and he was angry all the black people in America are dead in the water and being completely honest I shut him down I said this isn't true I don't know what news you're getting or where you're getting it from but it's impossible for what you're saying to be true that all the black people in America right now are dead in some water you know and I remember I was trying to make sense of it like well okay if we go back to the slave trade you know that was crossing a huge ocean and there was a lot of death that occurred in the water and you know maybe he heard something about that I mean I think the numbers are in the millions you know and and I tried to bring that up and explain it and he said no today today they're dead in the water shortwave thinks of science as an invisible force showing up in your everyday life powering the food you eat the medicine you use the tech in your pocket science is approachable because it's already part of your life come explore these connections on the short wave podcast from NPR I let this go when this incident happened it it freaked me out but I also let it go I just at that point I'd been having all kinds of language barrier cross-cultural misunderstandings and I let it go and didn't think of it for another moment until weeks later more than one month later one of the staff members did the monthly run to Nairobi in order to pick up our mail I had a big manila envelope from my parents and it was my very very first mail and I remember I ripped it open and there were a whole bunch of individual envelopes a couple postcards my parents had sent a cd and also in that envelope was a time magazine and it was a time magazine from either August or September I can't remember of 2005 it was all about Hurricane Katrina and on the cover of time magazine it literally showed desperate looking black people surrounded by water and utter devastation it hit me all at once and I said oh my gosh and I ripped open the time magazine and read that thousands of people mostly black had perished in this hurricane and that the response to that tragedy had been motivated by race because the people who had been saved were one type of people and the people who had not been evacuated or who were unable to evacuate themselves were low-income African Americans in different parts of Louisiana and Texas that was exactly what that community member had been talking about that day and I had shot him down and I had told him that that wasn't true and I had told all these staff members that things were great that that black people didn't get hurt because of racism anymore just this huge amount of people who had been evacuated and I had told him that that wasn't true and I had told huge exaggeration of what was going on. I don't even know if I can explain it with words, you know, to be away from home for not too, too long, but to have a disaster like that happen and have no idea, you know, not a clue that it had happened. That was strange. I was lonely, you know, receiving that news definitely made some feelings of loneliness surface, you know, feelings of isolation surface. It kind of the reality of where I was and how far away and how much I didn't know and how disconnected I was definitely, definitely surfaced. And that was uncomfortable and scary and made me feel pretty sad. And it was on me to really fess up, to really tell everyone how wrong I was, to show them the truth, you know, through this magazine. I brought the magazine to the village and I sat with a number of people and almost nobody could speak any English. And at that point, my Swahili was pretty poor. And I paged through the magazine and I explained and one of the staff members helped me to translate. And I explained that, yeah, actually, there had been a big hurricane. A lot of people died, even though they shouldn't have. And that it was Black folks that died because of racism. And I admitted that I was completely wrong, that I had led them to believe something that wasn't true and that I was sorry. And that community member who had yelled at me that day, who had pointed his finger in my face, was extremely forgiving, you know, and he said, we just wanted to support you. You know, we just wanted, you to explain this so we could help you grieve because those are your people who are dead. You know, those are your people that are hurting. This is your community that needs help. He offered, you know, like, how can we pay a tribute, essentially, to all those people that died? And it was really, really special. And I cried. And that was definitely the first, but not the last time that I cried over, something so moving that the Maasai folks did for me and, and cared about, even though we were so different, and we misunderstood each other so much. It's so many years later, and yet these stories from these experiences that I had in Kenya way back then, still resonate and are still so important. I think it's a lot because it was my first time truly experiencing, an African American identity, traveling to a part of Africa, allowed me to realize that my Black experience and my Black identity, and my Black history is widely different than the people that I was with, which can be widely different than other groups of Black folks. And it all, it seems so simple. When I say it today, I mean, duh, obviously, you know, not every, you know, every Black person has a singular experience, but I really didn't know that. As I was able to have, you know, a whole bunch of experiences with diversity, seeing diversity within Blackness, being a part of it, teaching and being taught, it made me a more receptive, a more compassionate, a more open-minded person. And yet, it was not the, it was not the biggest misunderstanding that I had while I was a student on this program. There was something else that happened that was so incredibly bizarre, that still stays with me to this day, in a way that always makes me think, what if? That story's coming next week. You just listened to Going Wild with Dr. Ray Wingrant. If you want to support us, you can follow Going Wild on your favorite podcast listening app. While you're there, please leave us a review. It really helps. You can also get updates and bonus content by following me, Dr. Ray Wingrant, and PBS Nature on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and Facebook. You can catch new episodes of Nature Wednesdays at 8, 7 central on PBS and the PBS video app. This episode of Going Wild was hosted and written by me, Dr. Ray Wingrant, production by Rachel Aronoff, Danielle Broza, Nathan Tobey, and Great Feeling Studios, editing by Jacob Lewis, sound design by Cariad Harmon. Danielle Broza is the digital lead, and Fred Kaufman is the executive producer for Nature. Art for this podcast was created by Ariana Bowlers and Karen Brazell. Special thanks to Amanda Schmidt, Blanche Robertson, Jane Lisi, Chelsea Satkamp, Natasha Padilla, and Karen Ho. Going Wild is a new podcast. It's a new podcast by PBS Nature. Nature is an award-winning series created by the WNET group and made possible by all of you. Funding for this podcast was provided by grants from the Anderson Family Fund and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The narrator’s first study abroad experience in Kenya in 2005 exposed deep cultural misunderstandings about Black identity and American history among local staff.
  2. As the first Black American student in the program, the narrator became a bridge for conversations about race, slavery, and the Black American experience.
  3. Staff members held misconceptions, such as believing Black Americans were immigrants or that slavery didn’t exist in the U.S., highlighting a lack of awareness of U.S. racial history.
  4. A tense encounter with a community member who angrily claimed Black Americans were “dead in the water” revealed a painful truth about systemic racism, which the narrator initially dismissed.
  5. The revelation of Hurricane Katrina’s racial disparities in the *Time* magazine triggered emotional realization and regret over her earlier oversimplification of racial safety in America.
  6. The narrator apologized publicly, shared the truth with the community, and received forgiveness and solidarity, demonstrating deep cross-cultural empathy.
  7. The experience reshaped her understanding of Black identity as diverse and complex, reinforcing the importance of cultural humility and vulnerability.
  8. This experience remains a foundational lesson in empathy, resilience, and the power of listening across cultural divides.

Summary:

Dr. Rae Wynn Grant reflects on her transformative study abroad experience in Kenya in 2005, where cultural misunderstandings about Black identity and American history profoundly shaped her worldview. S.

A confrontational interaction with a community member who claimed Black Americans were “dead in the water” shocked her, leading to a painful realization when she later read about Hurricane Katrina’s racially disproportionate impact. She admitted her earlier false narrative of racial harmony, apologized sincerely, and shared the truth with locals, who responded with forgiveness and emotional support. This moment deepened her understanding of the diversity within Black experiences and the importance of cultural humility.

The episode underscores how personal encounters with racial injustice can foster empathy, self-reflection, and a commitment to truth-telling. These experiences continue to influence her identity as a Black female scientist and a storyteller committed to revealing the human drama behind conservation and cultural survival.

FAQs

Nate was the first Black American student in a study abroad program in Kenya, and staff members had no understanding of Black American identity or history. One staff member believed all Black people in the U.S. had immigrated there voluntarily, while another asked about freedom from slavery, showing a lack of knowledge about American history and the experience of Black Americans.

Being the first Black American student, Nate had to explain the Black American experience, including slavery and systemic racism, to Kenyan staff who lacked exposure to U.S. history. This experience deepened his understanding of how diverse Black identities exist across different cultures and shaped his approach to race and identity.

A community member became angry and shouted that 'all Black people in America are dead in the water,' which turned out to refer to the real-life devastation of Hurricane Katrina, where Black residents suffered disproportionately due to racism and inadequate evacuation efforts.

He admitted he was wrong, shared the Time magazine cover showing Hurricane Katrina’s impact, and explained the racial disparities in the disaster response. A community member was deeply moved and offered to help honor those who died, which was a powerful moment of connection and empathy.

He learned that even among people with good intentions, cultural gaps—especially around history, identity, and race—can lead to serious misinterpretations. These misunderstandings required patience, humility, and truth-telling to resolve.

It exposed him to the complexity of cross-cultural identities, especially as a Black woman in science. The experience taught him empathy, resilience, and the importance of acknowledging historical and ongoing racial injustices in different societies.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.