'Mississippi is a reflection of the nation': Scott Colom's historic win
from Fresh Air ·
45m 19s
Scott Cologne’s historic election as Mississippi’s first Black U.S. senator represents a profound shift in a state deeply shaped by racial injustice and political suppression. Rooted in a legacy of Black resistance—from Hiram Revels during Reconstruction to Medgar Evers’ assassination—the victory reflects decades of grassroots organizing, cultural resilience, and voter mobilization. Cologne’s campaign succeeded not just through traditional politics, but through culturally grounded messaging, such as the sharp “Pick Another Senator Instead” ad, which responded to his opponent’s dismissive remarks about rising food costs and tapped into shared experiences of economic hardship. The campaign’s success was built on intergenerational engagement, with young voters, including those in hoodies and with cultural markers, joining forces across racial lines. This moment is more than a personal triumph; it signifies a broader reckoning in the South, where Black political power has been suppressed for over a century. The guests emphasize that this win is a reflection of national failure to confront its own racist structures, and they call for sustained accountability, protection of Black leaders, and a commitment to inclusive, community-driven politics. As Cologne takes office, there is a clear hope that he will carry Mississippi’s values—resilience, justice, and community—into Washington, ensuring that the struggle for equity continues beyond the ballot box.
This is Fresh Air. I'm Tanya Mosley.
In the final weeks of Mississippi's Senate race, Democrat Scott Cologne showed up outside a Donald Trump rally for his opponent and started talking to voters waiting to get in.
He spent more than a year traveling across Mississippi, trying to convince people he could win, and last week, he did.
Three years earlier, his opponent, Cindy Hyde-Smith, had blocked Cologne's nomination to become a federal judge.
Now he's headed to Washington to take her seat in the Senate.
But there's a much longer history behind the victory.
Cologne is a seventh-generation Mississippian, descended from an enslaved woman.
He's now the state's first black U.S. senator in nearly 150 years.
It's a remarkable moment in a state where black political power was once built, then violently dismantled in the years after Reconstruction.
During the Great Migration, generations of black Americans—
including my family—fled Mississippi to escape Jim Crow and racial terror.
Others, like Cologne's family, stayed and fought for change.
My guests today are two sons of Mississippi who have spent their lives examining the place they call home.
Eddie Glaude is a professor of African American studies at Princeton University and grew up in Moss Point, a small town on the state's Gulf Coast.
Writer Kiese Lehman grew up in the state's capital of Jackson.
He's the author of the book, The State of Jackson.
He's the author of the memoir, Heavy, and a professor of creative writing at Rice University.
Kiese and Eddie, welcome to Fresh Air.
Thanks for having us.
Good to be here with y'all. Thank you.
Well, Eddie, I want to start with you.
When Cologne won, you talked about being that little boy growing up in Moss Point who never could have imagined a moment like this.
And now we are here, and I'm actually just wondering at what point in this race,
did you start to believe that it was possible?
When the state of Mississippi hinted that it was about to redistrict,
that they were going to engage in that project of gerrymandering that Donald Trump called for,
there were these marches all throughout the South,
and they were organized under the banner, All Roads Lead to the South.
And Derek Johnson gave me a call.
He's the president and CEO of the NAACP,
and I think in addition to that, he is the former president of the Mississippi chapter,
of the NAACP.
So he gave me a call and asked me to come down to Jackson to participate in the march there.
And I did.
And I was overwhelmed.
I saw the organizing.
I saw the infrastructure.
I saw young people and older folk.
And one of the things I did not hear was just this kind of nostalgic longing for the movement of the mid-20th century.
What I heard instead and saw was organizing.
They were counting.
They were doing the math, Tony.
How many people do we need to turn out in DeSoto?
How many people do we need to turn out in Holmes, in Jackson County, in, you know, in Hines?
And what was so fascinating is that I knew then,
and I was on stage with Congressman Benny Thompson and Scott Colon,
and I heard Scott speak, and I believed at that moment that he had a chance.
You know, he's a political athlete.
That's clear.
But what was clear?
Clear to me was that these folk were ready.
They were coming after us, and they were about to see the full weight and power of black voters in Mississippi.
They were going to undermine the math that was informing the redistricting effort.
So I looked at Scott, and I looked at him closely, and I listened.
And, you know, I felt that Mississippi charm.
And I said, OK, all right, we're about to shock the world up in here.
Kiese, how would you describe the mobilization?
What did it look like on the ground there that maybe the national audience didn't really see?
We just kind of, we know about the win and that there was a great mobilization.
I think that's a great question.
You know, one of the things I think with this particular mobilization, unlike what we saw with Espy, and this goes to—
And Espy, just to describe who Espy, Mike Espy, he actually ran against Hyde-Smith several years ago.
Right, ran against Hyde-Smith a few years ago.
I worked hard on that.
I worked hard on that campaign.
I was living in Oxford at the time.
I remember one morning, Espy's—I don't want to say this person's name—but Espy's primary donor knocked on my door, sat on my porch.
And the thing he was trying to, like, get me to understand was that we have to get Mike to let his hands go.
That's what he kept saying.
We have to let Mike let his hands go.
Now, Mike Espy, I think we need to understand—this is important for what Scott Cologne did—was seen as a traditional, clean, electable Democrat.
The people who put Mike Espy forward did not think he would offend many Republicans.
What I loved about what Scott was doing this year was Scott, I think, took off that cloak of what some people call political respectability in terms of the look, and that was part of the galvanization.
And so when I realized that Scott could win was when I saw, obviously, the commercial, the pick-a-protein commercial.
Now, for me, I thought Scott—my mother is a political scientist.
She said, KSA, I think Scott—
Scott's going to have the votes.
But in Mississippi, having the votes doesn't mean you're going to win.
And when I saw that pick-another-protein commercial, I thought that he had the cultural force to stop the Republican Party from doing what a lot of us assumed the Republican Party would do if it was too close.
So for me, on the ground, I saw a different kind of candidate followed by different kinds of potential voters.
And what I love about this moment is that those people, like my mother, who grew up in a political Mississippi.
That was very closed, very contained.
You had to bring your best visual self to every situation.
They walked with those young sisters and brothers in hoodies, you know, with earrings all over their faces.
It was not just like an intergenerational march.
It was an intercultural march and an intercultural election.
And I just feel like that is some of what I don't hear much of the national media talking about.
Also, it's just so interesting, you know, Cologne didn't have—
Much money from the National Democratic Party.
And this particular political ad that you're talking about, it's just one of the creative ways that they were able to reach voters.
And I actually want to play the one that you're talking about, where essentially the background of this ad is that his opponent, Cindy Hyde-Smith,
during an interview suggested that people struggling with the rising price of beef could simply choose another protein.
And here is—
Here is how Cologne's campaign responded.
Let's listen.
The price of beef continuing to go up.
You know, you have so many proteins to choose from.
Pick another protein?
I'd rather pick another senator instead.
She done lost her damn mind.
I'd rather pick another senator.
What the—
Pick another senator instead.
That's a political ad for now, Senator-elect Scott Cologne.
And, Kiesa, you said that when you saw that commercial, you knew that he'd win.
I want to know from you, Eddie, I mean, beyond the humor, he's actually talking about something really real,
the cost of living in one of the poorest states in the country.
How much of this victory do you think was about the way he spoke to people?
And how much was it about actually what he's saying, you know?
It's a conversation.
It's a combination of both, I think.
You know, what was so brilliant about the ad is that you can see and hear, right, the cultural residences.
It's quintessentially Mississippi.
It's Mississippi concentrate.
And what you hear is that it cuts across racial boundaries.
So the rhythm of the speech that you heard in the white man who, you know, who drew out, you know, the expletive, you know, the white woman who asked in a very shrill,
kind of way, what the, you know, that, and the rhythm of it is everybody in Mississippi knows that's how you cuss.
You like really draw it out, huh?
Yeah.
Right.
That's, I mean, so it sounded familiar.
But the thing is that on top of that performance was the substantive issue.
Cindy Hyde-Smith had been absent.
She hasn't been representing the state.
And so here she is in this very kind of crude and callous way saying, let them eat cake too, right?
Having her Marie Antoinette.
moment on television in some ways.
And so they were able to bring these two, these two things together, the kind of cultural resonances that Kiese was talking about, and then connected with the substantive critique of Hyde-Smith that she wasn't representing the state.
She wasn't addressing the fundamental material conditions of Mississippians, no matter what side of town they live on, no matter what color their skin.
And so it was a kind of wonderful distillation of both of those elements.
And can I just say one more thing about that?
And he said, the wonder to me, also just as like a person who creates, you know, words and word culture, is that they made Scott the subject and the viewer.
So the wonder of that is like, yes, the beginning, we see this young white man cussing the way white boys in Mississippi cuss.
We see the older sister in the beginning eating catfish, talking the way all my aunties cuss.
We see the older white woman at the end, at the grocery store, trying to get something.
This is not affordable.
And then we see Scott doing what?
What? Watching as we watched, laughing as we laughed and saying, pick another senator instead.
So that move. Right. He starts to embody the viewer. And I don't care what political persuasion you are.
Every viewer has got Cologne's response to that, which is to laugh.
So so it's it's it's smart and it's genius. But it also does something that I think most word sort of assemblages can't, which is take the subject and then the subject becomes a viewer.
The point of view shifts and we start to look at this ad through Scott or Scott starts to look at this ad through us.
I just think it was like the most impactful political ad of my life by far.
I want to break down something a little bit. I just want us to get a deeper understanding of Cindy Hyde-Smith just for a brief moment, especially through the context of the last few years.
You mentioned, Kiesa, that she ran against Mike Espy, who was a black Democrat who lost in 2018 and then 2020 against her.
But there's this particular moment that you wrote about for Mississippi Today back in 2020.
And it was about a campaign stop she made where she praised a supporter by saying that if that supporter invited her to a public hanging, she'd be in the front row.
Right. When folks asked her about this, she called it a figure of speech and she later went on to win.
And you wrote this essay about that very sentence.
What did you hear when she said that?
It's so easy to sound hyperbolic, I think, when you talk about Mississippi, but specifically Cindy Hyde-Smith.
In some way, that sentence sort of like obliterates analysis.
But what she literally said was if there were public hanging, I'd be on the front row.
And my critique of that was there's so many amazing sentences born of Mississippi one could have said or used as a refrain.
And what I heard was, you know, premature death.
And what I also heard was her giving her voters what they wanted.
I was living in Mississippi at the time.
And so what I really heard was fear and anger.
And at that point, you know, I think we have to be honest, like I knew she was going to win again.
And I think sometimes when you live in Mississippi, you get used to this.
But like, I remember talking to my mother about like, what does it mean that the blackest state in the union is now going to have a senator who publicly says if there were hanging, I'd be on the front row.
So I felt like humiliated, which I feel like what lynchings were supposed to do, public hangings were supposed to do.
I'm not trying to equate my experience of listening to that.
But I did feel I felt humiliated and I felt angry.
I think outsiders of Mississippi might be surprised that someone who says something like that would then get elected.
It's just such a charged statement.
Yeah, especially in the blackest state in the union.
Right.
I mean, this is and those black voters, we don't vote Republican.
So I just think sometimes when you when you live in Mississippi, I love Mississippi.
I live there for so many.
I write to and from it.
I think I talked to Eddie for that piece.
You know, one of the things that Eddie said is that if we solve Mississippi, we solve the Sphinx.
And so after hearing Sidney Highsmith say that out loud, honestly, I just had little faith that the Sphinx could be solved because that wasn't something that we heard her say offline.
You know, I mean, that that's some way was that was a campaign kind of call.
The question specifically that Kiesa, you asked Eddie for that piece, you asked him, essentially, what would it take for Mississippi to live up to its promise?
And and Eddie, you told him Mississippi is where the country's hardest problems sit and that if they can solve the problems there, they can solve them anywhere.
I think that's that's what you were saying when you said it's like solving the riddle of the Sphinx.
Right.
What part of that riddle do you think Mississippi has figured out with this election?
Well, you know, I think it's really important for us to to pump the brakes, you know, as I revel in what I could not have imagined.
You know, I believe that Scott could win.
I just didn't know how I would feel if he did.
Right.
So I'm still grappling with that.
Yes.
Say more on that.
That feeling you just want.
Oh, my God.
I'm you know, this is for me.
This is bigger than Barack Obama's election.
Mississippi, James Silver.
This is the.
Closed society.
Right.
I mean, our soil is soaked in blood.
I mean, all of the contradictions of the country are distilled here.
I mean, you know, Mississippi, I like to say, you know, it has amazing beauty.
I mean, I mean, I grew up on the water with magnolia trees and and moss.
And I mean, just gorgeous.
And then you got black snakes that could chase you down the street.
That's right.
You know, I mean, it's a it's a bundle of contradictions.
People who are sweet and who are murderers.
And monstrous all at the same time.
And so, you know, I think there's a reason why the blues comes out of here.
There's a reason why Faulkner comes out of there.
There's a reason why he comes out of it.
So I think part of what I'm arguing and, you know, Imani Perry makes this claim about the South generally is that the South is the beating heart of the country.
And when you really want to get at the heart of the South, Mississippi is right there.
And so, you know, when you think about the poverty in the Delta, when you think about, you know, organized immigration.
Elites who have seized government.
When you think about, you know, people who are just trying to figure out how to make ends meet.
When you think about race and all of its complexity, Mississippi offers a kind of telescoped view of it all.
So when I said to Kiese back then that if we can figure it out, then we open the black box for the country.
I want to play actually a clip from an interview that Scott Colom gave to MS Now on the weekly podcast.
Clock it.
Shortly after the race was called, he expounds upon what you are talking about there.
He talks about the advances and setbacks of political power in Mississippi, specifically black political power.
And then he goes on to say the rest of the country's responsibility for what happens there.
Let's listen.
People need to know that in America, we've made progress before.
I mean, Hiram Revels gave an amazing prayer that resulted in him getting momentum to be elected.
Not elected, but selected to be a senator.
And there was a lot of progress in Mississippi on public education, on voting rights.
And we lost that progress for a century.
And, you know, oftentimes people look at Mississippi and ignore the fact that the country allowed it to happen, too.
I mean, there was, you know, Mississippi didn't just take away voting rights from African-Americans.
The country allowed that to happen.
Mississippi didn't just do Jim Crow.
The country allowed Jim Crow to happen.
And so, for me, I wanted that story to be a reminder of the progress.
But I also wanted people to understand the promise of our country.
Because here you are at a time where people thought that this was not possible.
And I believed in Mississippi.
I believed in the values of our state.
I believed in the progress.
And so, that faith, those prayers, and that work showed the country that Mississippi matters.
That was Scott Colom speaking shortly.
After his win on the weekly podcast produced by MSNOW Clock It.
And we heard him mention Hiram Revels, who became the first black man to serve in the United States Senate back in 1870 during the Reconstruction era.
But, Eddie, we often talk about Mississippi's racial history.
You're able to speak about it so beautifully and poignantly.
But we often talk about it as though it happened and happens in isolation.
What responsibility does the rest of us have?
What responsibility does the rest of the country bear for what happens there?
I mean, in making people understand this is not just an isolated state win, but it's something that potentially is much bigger.
Well, you know, I mean, this is a kind of southern exceptionalism that defines so much of the nation.
And what I mean by that is that, you know, the South is made to bear the nation's sins.
Right?
Mississippi becomes a kind of exaggerated example of the backwardness of that region that holds the country.
Holds the country back that undermines its democracy.
So if only the South would get itself together, you know, you heard that kind of argument at the heart of Gunner Murdoch's The American Dilemma.
Right.
And, you know, Malcolm X was clear.
As long as you south of the Canadian border, you in the south.
Right.
And so the point is that, you know, and Scott is very clear about this, that, you know, when we think about slavery and the relationship between southern plantation owners and cotton and northern industry, when you think about the Civil War,
the collapse of Reconstruction and the ways in which the North, those interested in the North who thought initially that they could leverage black voter or black enfranchisement for their own ends and aims,
and then they were quick to abandon it as, you know, white men in the South and North reconciled and black folk had to bear the burden of that reconciliation in blood.
So when we talk about the history of the country, you know, the idea is to displace our sins onto the South.
Right.
So that we can absolve the nation of its sins in so many ways.
And what Scott is suggesting in a very, I think, polite way, right, is that, no, no, no, no, Mississippi is a reflection of the nation itself.
And that all the things that we attribute to the state is really a reflection in so many ways of choices, historic choices that have guided the country since its founding.
Kiese, I was giving you a moment because I could hear your mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
I didn't know if you wanted to respond.
- I'm sorry, that's the call and response.
I'm like, this is something
I think Eddie just lays out profoundly.
And in his book, America, USA, you know, I find myself at once being completely elated, overwhelmed with joy because I'm a Mississippian.
And then I find myself soberly looking forward to what the Cologne family and what Cologne, the politician, will have to do going forward.
Our guests today are Professors Eddie Glaude and Kiese Lehman.
We'll be right back after a short break.
I'm Tanya Mosley, and this is Fresh Air.
Okay, we talked for a little bit about Hiram Revels, who became the first black man to serve in the United States Senate in 1870.
I want to delve into his historic win a little bit more, but I want to get into this with an SNL sketch.
I don't know if you guys saw it this weekend.
So Saturday Night Live did this sketch.
With Cam Patterson, who plays Revels, who appears alongside Michael Che on Weekend Update.
Let's listen.
The midterms saw historic wins for black candidates across the country, including an unexpected victory for Mississippi new Senator Scott Cologne.
Here to comment is Mississippi's first ever black senator, Hiram Revels.
Hello, Michael.
Wow.
So you were the first black senator.
First black senator in the United States.
That's right, Michael.
1870, five years after the Civil War.
But I'm sure you've read all about me.
You probably got a national holiday name for me, right?
Oh, no.
Okay, just schools then?
No.
A little statue in the mall?
No.
Oh, maybe a couple of Jay-Z songs?
How do you know Jay-Z?
Everyone knows Jay-Z.
You know who I am, right, Michael?
Look, I don't even think the guy playing you knows who you are.
Hey, leave Cam Patterson out of it.
Okay.
He took a real long glance at my Wikipedia page before coming out here.
That was from this weekend's Saturday Night Live.
Okay, growing up in Mississippi, did you guys grow up learning about Revels?
Well, sadly and wonderfully, I learned a lot about Revels growing up.
My mother wrote her first book.
It was called Legislators.
Law and Public Policy.
She graduated from Jackson State, went to the University of Wisconsin,
and did her graduate work on Legislators.
Law and Public Policy in Mississippi.
So, yeah, I had to write a little short essay about Revels.
And what's interesting about that sketch is that my mother at the time was still one of those encyclopedia mothers,
meaning her mother gave her the greatest gift she could ever give her in the late 50s,
which was a set of encyclopedias.
Right, yes.
So I remember in the 1980s,
I came home and all my boys were getting Nintendos.
And my mom was like,
I got something waiting for you, baby.
And I'm like,
oh, bro, I'm going to get a Nintendo.
Duck Hunt.
Oh, man, I came in there.
And there was these electric blue encyclopedias.
And, you know, my mom didn't want me to just look at the color.
I had to get up in there.
And one of the things was that, you know,
Howard Revels wasn't in those encyclopedias.
So my mother had, you know, made me go back to work.
She worked at Jackson State University.
And, you know,
the critique from my mother and her friends was that
Hiram Revels, because he wasn't elected, right?
He was just like, you know, he was placed, didn't do enough.
Now, this is coming from Mississippi, sort of,
not Mississippi radicals,
but people who were really critical of Mississippi history.
So I definitely had to write a little four or five sentence,
little essay about Hiram Revels when I was a kid
that I forgot until Scott Colom's election.
That's what's so interesting, because mama hit me,
Key, remember when I made you?
And then she was like, I still have it.
See, I didn't have it.
I didn't have that experience at all.
My mom, you know, cleaned toilets at Ingalls Shipyard.
And my dad was a postman.
And, you know, I learned about the Civil War
from my history teacher, Miss Mitchell,
who had a vocal injury.
So she was a little tiny thing.
She had to use a mic to teach.
And she taught the Civil War so well
that I found myself worshiping Stonewall Jackson.
Wow.
You hear that?
Wow.
See, Kiese grew up in Michigan.
I grew up in the big city.
I grew up on New Orleans.
You know, and so, you know, for me,
getting to Hattiesburg and then to Jackson
was, you know, the biggest thing I could ever see
outside of going to, you know,
we rarely went to Mobile and New Orleans.
But, you know, I think for me,
I was educated in the context of the lost cause.
Right?
So Hiram Revels came to me, I think,
probably, you remember that Stevie wanted
to track off of Songs of Key of Life,
that history track first, man.
Oh, yeah.
Was a black man, that track.
Yeah.
So I began to learn a lot of history
from that particular 1976 track.
That's amazing.
But in school, no, no, no, no.
There was no real attention.
In a town that is majority black,
there was no real attention to reconstruction
in any substantive or significant way.
So Hiram Revels never came to me
until I actually got to Morehouse.
But I'm just wondering, both of you are educators,
you're professors, you're teaching young people.
What does it do?
To our understanding of our own possibilities
when we grow up knowing about the oppression
of our ancestors, because you learned that growing up,
I'm sure, Eddie.
Yeah, absolutely.
But not the power they possessed, not a Revels.
Right.
I think, you know, I think it's for me,
there were some things that just came by way
of the household in which I grew up.
You know, even though my dad and my mom weren't readers,
there was a fundamental insistence on the power
of who we were as human beings,
irrespective of what the world told us.
But it's also the case that, you know,
the kinds of stories we tell,
the kinds of histories we tell ourselves have an immediate impact
on the kinds of people we take ourselves to be.
Who and what you choose to leave out of your stories
actually reveal the limits of your conceptions of justice.
So, you know, the kinds of stories we tell ourselves
and what we leave out can actually lead
to a deformation of character.
You have these gaps that you have to fill.
Then those gaps can impact judgment and empathy and the like.
So, and your own sense of possibility.
So, I think it's impactful for young African-American men
and women, young children, irrespective of their gender,
to be denied access to the fullness of our story.
But it's also impacting the folk who are doing the denying.
It distorts and disfigures our story.
And I think it's them.
And they don't have people like my mom and daddy to help them out.
And I'm thinking a lot also, Eddie,
about the way that distortion and disfigurement lands in the sentence.
And as an English professor, you know,
I have to land in the sentence, right?
For better or worse, these sentences have created movements.
You know, make America great again is a sentence.
Black Lives Matter is a sentence.
Right?
I just think it's important that
the sentence that I grew up, because I grew up in Jackson,
named for the most, one of the most,
if not the most destructive members of the Confederate Party.
Oh, I didn't even know that.
Jackson, when I say Jackson, that's what I'm saying.
Jackson, right?
Like Jackson, 95% black.
So, for me, as a professor,
I'm trying to encourage myself and my students
to understand that every sentence that we construct is a possibility.
And every sentence that has,
carried a movement is a possibility to what?
To engage, but to also revise.
And so, what I see in pick another senator is another sentence.
Pick another senator that we've given a profundity to.
But who is the we?
The we is the people, right?
So, I just think it's really important as sentence creators and sentence makers,
as all three of us are, with Mississippi roots,
to really contend with the ways that these sentences have created sentences
for some of our people,
but also that the way that these sentences have created sentences for some of our people,
these sentences are portals of entry into a possibility
that we don't understand, but they necessarily are.
You know what I mean?
Make America Great Again, worst sentence of my life.
But also possibly one of the most profound sentences of my life.
So, I just want, as an English teacher,
it's an occasion for us to recommit
to sort of like the holiness of sentences.
And in creative writing programs, that means a lot
because we're not trained to do that work.
If you're not trained to do that work,
you're just joining us.
My guests are Princeton scholar, Eddie Glaude,
and Rice University professor, Kiese Lehman.
This is Fresh Air.
Something that fascinates me about Scott Colom's history
is his family's political history.
So, his family is very politically active
in the same way Kiese, your family, was.
But his father, Wilbur, was a civil rights activist
who actually became a Republican
and worked on Ronald Reagan's presidential transition.
And his mother, Dorothy, was a lifelong Democrat.
Both of them were lawyers,
deeply engaged in Mississippi politics.
Now, his father argued that Black voters
shouldn't automatically give their votes to Democrats.
And I'm thinking about that standing
as it relates to today.
I would just wonder from you, Kiese,
was his dad making a legitimate argument
about political independence?
What do we lose when we treat Black political independence
allegiance kind of as a foregone conclusion, you know?
This is a discussion that we've been having about the Democratic base in particular.
Yeah, I mean, I think when you treat black vote for Democrat as a foregone conclusion, you lose the people.
And I think the people are perpetually letting candidates know what they need to survive, what they need to thrive.
And, you know, like, again, I grew up in that political class of people where, you know, my mother knew Scott's parents.
And, you know, like early on, I think some of the Democrats were a little questioning of Mr. Wilber for, you know, encouraging us to vote Republican.
But that does not mean that those people who were critical wanted black people in Mississippi to blindly vote Democrat.
And I just want to say this. If I learned anything from my mother and I learned a few things, my mother was like, yes, a the right to vote.
Great. You know, my mother didn't have it till I was 40.
We need it. But the problem, she says, is that we did not have anybody to vote for.
She says that all throughout the late 20th century, there were no incredible candidates in Mississippi to vote for.
If there were an incredible candidate who I think valued clean water and incredible health care, wonderful food that happened to be a Republican, my mother would have loved that person.
But my mother's critique was that person never existed on the Democratic side.
So it was always when we have.
The vote for the lesser of two evils on the larger scale, but on the local scale, I think this is where Mississippi politics gets confused.
The state with one of the most counties that are Democrat has always been Mississippi.
We have half the state is almost in terms of counties, because, again, we're almost 40 percent black.
Half the state is almost Democratic if you look at the counties.
So I'm saying all that to say that my mother's critique has always been that black people vote Democrat and we don't have great candidates running.
And I will say I don't know anybody who's more.
Critical Mississippi politicians than Mary called my mother and when I and actually when I knew he was going to win was when my mother looked at that man in a hoodie and she was like, that's a Mississippi senator.
This is the same mama who told me never wear a hoodie.
I'm just thinking about as we step out more broadly and thinking about the historic first, because Colom is part of an election filled with historic firsts.
Voters turned out and elected, of course, Colom, but Hispanic governor.
In Texas, a black woman governor in Georgia, a Native American woman governor in New Mexico.
But we're also a country that has spent the last few years arguing about identity politics and political correctness and diversity.
We have leaders in the Democratic Party who say the path forward is to not focus on identity politics.
Eddie, what do you think these victories tell us?
Look.
What happened in the South has everything to do with the fact that black folk turned out in historic numbers without Obama on the ticket.
Think about what happened in Texas, y'all.
It wasn't some black celebrity on the on the ballot and black folk in Texas turned out in historic numbers and voted for in Osa.
And then you think about what happened in North Carolina, what happened in South Carolina, what happened in Georgia, what happened in Louisiana, what happened in Florida.
And part of what I'm suggesting here is to kind of reduce that turnout to a return to identity politics is is condescending.
It's it's enraging.
Right.
You have black voters engaging in the process in light of their interest.
That is to say, you had Republicans who sought to disenfranchise us to throw us back to the 1950s.
We organized in defense of our democratic rights and in response to the assault on our economic and material.
I mean, and so to reduce that to identity politics, right, reveals how can I put this in a delicate way?
Well, let's not be delicate.
The Democratic Party all too often thinks of black voters as cattle chewing cud to be herded every two and four years as if we're not a constituency that has interest.
You know, Baldwin used to love this question.
What else does the Negro want?
And Baldwin would say, if you thought of me as a human being, you would know exactly what I want.
I want the exact same things you do for your babies.
Right.
So I think it's a red herring.
That's the short answer.
I think that the worry about identity politics is a red herring.
But you need to speak to the conditions of a constituency that fundamentally just handed the Congress to you.
Let's take a short break.
If you're just joining us, my guests are Princeton scholar Eddie Glaude and Rice University professor Kiese Lehman.
We'll be right back after this.
After a short break, this is Fresh Air.
Cologne's campaign got a lot of attention for its humorous ads, but he closed with a very different ad filmed in Jackson at the home of Medgar Evers, who was the NAACP leader who was assassinated in his own driveway back in 1963.
And I just want to play it.
Let's listen.
There's a house in Jackson.
Every Mississippian ought to walk through once.
It looks like every other house on the street, except for it isn't.
It has no front door.
You come in through the carport where the walls give you some cover.
The children slept on the floor below the windows.
Their father taught them that if they ever heard gunfire, they should crawl to the bathroom.
He made it a game.
I've been a prosecutor for 10 years.
Unfortunately, I've stood in a lot of houses with something terrible.
This isn't any house.
This isn't any tragedy.
This is where Medgar Evers died.
He fought for this country and Normandy.
He came home to Mississippi and they wouldn't let him vote.
So he organized, helping other people register.
Just after midnight on June 12th, 1963, he pulled into here with an armful of T-shirts that said Jim Crow must go.
A man hiding across the street shot him in the back.
Juries let that man walk.
His wife, Murley, never stopped.
It took 31 years that a Mississippi prosecutor reopened the case and a Mississippi jury, both black and white, convicted him.
In Mississippi, no one is above the law and no one should be outside its protection.
He was killed for helping Mississippians vote.
On Tuesday, use your vote and honor everyone who died for that right.
That was one of the last.
That was one of the last ads before the election of Scott Colombe.
And you could hear those flashes.
Those were photo flashes.
That ad made me think about, we keep hearing people call this victory a political miracle.
But this ad is a reminder that in a way calling it a miracle misses the people who made it possible.
What does it make you guys think about?
Well, I can just say, you know, I. For four years that I went to high school, I went to, you had to drive every day, you know, Medgar Evers Boulevard.
My mother's mentor, Margaret Walker, lived a few streets over from Medgar Evers.
We used to play football right in front of Medgar Evers' house.
And it's not one of these situations where we never know who Medgar Evers was.
Like, to us, Medgar Evers wanted the best for black Mississippians and he wanted the best for Mississippi.
And that is why he was shot.
So hearing Scott in his campaign with that ad.
When the tone of the campaign, right, had been so lifted with the pick a protein, pick another senator ad.
One I think speaks to the daring and I think whether or not we know it or not speaks to Scott and his people's desire to connect his ability to govern to historic black activists of the past.
Now, whether or not that is a good idea as far as governance goes, I'm not sure.
Right.
Because Medgar Evers has had a different role.
But what I love about it is that it animates like a reality for Mississippians.
Medgar Evers, like, that's our street.
His house is where we, you know, we play ball there.
And it makes me remember that we grew up living what people call history.
And I think that can be very important for young people trying to find some sense of self in this nation.
Right.
It was the closing ad of the campaign that suggested.
Or presented or projected the fact that the campaign itself carried the weight of history itself.
When I when I saw it, I was trying to process it in a number of different ways.
And ironically, you know, I reached for Faulkner.
And Requiem for None, that line, you know, the past is it's never dead.
It's not even past.
Right.
And so there was a sense in which the invocation of Medgar Evers in that moment is to not just say, you know, I'm going to do this.
To simply recall a horrific act of murder.
Right.
But to bring it into the present in a way such that it can inform and shape our choices in very clear and concrete ways.
Cologne won by exactly eight thousand and thirty one votes.
And I'm thinking about the last time a black man went to the Senate for the state.
Mississippi a very long time ago. It was undone
that progress during Reconstruction, undone within a generation.
What are you both watching for this time?
Wow.
I mean, honestly, because we're talking to y'all,
I'm watching for and hoping for immense health and safety
to come to Scott Colombe, his wife Nadia, and their incredible children.
None of this is possible unless we keep them safe,
which this wasn't something we had to say.
This is something we have to say.
So I have no doubt that that man is going to go out there
and push and make a path for more potential young folks
who have his gumption to lead Mississippi.
I just know that in a state that has taken this long to change,
the movement from candidate Colombe to Senator Colombe
has to be taken seriously and he has to be protected.
Along the way.
And similarly, I will just say, as someone who loves Mississippi,
I expect Scott Colombe to risk for all of Mississippi's children.
Scott Colombe is not an artist.
He's not a writer.
He can't say things we can say.
When I say all of Mississippi's children,
I'm talking about all of Mississippi's children,
the queer children, the poor children, the trans children.
I think his role was made possible because of radical interventions
from folks like Fannie Lou Hamer.
I don't know how much radical intervention we can expect from a senator,
but I expect Scott Colombe.
While keeping himself and his family safe,
to also keep all children in Mississippi safe by all means necessary
or to attempt to.
And I think that will lead to this being not just the first,
but the first of a real sustained movement for love, progress,
and connectivity in Mississippi.
Yeah, that's it.
I pray that he doesn't fall for the siren song of Washington, D.C.
Oh.
Yeah, yeah.
You know, Washington, D.C. offers,
you know, all sorts of temptations about the nature of power,
about what it means to be the first and the like.
I hope he takes that gift of Mississippi
that orients us in a certain sort of way to the world.
I hope he brings it to Washington, D.C.
and he lets all of them see it for what it is and all of its power.
I know that's being abstract, but that has everything to do with, I think,
the power.
of what it means to be from this place.
That's the first thing.
The second thing, I think, you know, politicians inevitably disappoint.
I learned that early on.
But I want to see what Cassandra Welchin and Rekia Lumumba
and Sister Lambright Haynes and all of those organizers on the ground
who made this possible.
I want to see what they do.
And holding Scott Colon accountable.
I can't wait to continue to see what they do
and how Scott plays his role in that effort.
Yes.
I agree with Eddie.
I mean, I hope and if there's any moment where Democrats could learn
that you must follow the people, it is this moment.
And I hope that the Democrats, you follow the people by funding the people,
but also being open to the people's visions.
And I have absolute trust in that group of people that helped Scott get elected.
I have no doubt in my mind.
I have no doubt in my mind that their vision for Mississippi is the vision for Mississippi
and actually the vision for this nation and the world.
Whether the Democratic Party sees that or not is something else.
But it's right there.
It's right there for you.
Kiese Lehman and Eddie Glaude, thank you so much for this conversation.
Thank you.
Thank you so much for giving us space.
Eddie Glaude is a professor of African-American studies at Princeton University
and the author of several books, including Begin Again,
and America, USA.
Kiese Lehman is a professor of English and creative writing at Rice University
and the author of the acclaimed memoir, Heavy.
His new memoir, Good God, A Creation Story, will be published this spring.
If you'd like to catch up on interviews you've missed,
like our conversation with LeVar Burton about his new memoir,
or Lynn Novick about her new documentary on crime and punishment in America,
check out our podcast.
You'll find lots of fresh air interviews.
You can also watch some of our interviews on our YouTube page, This Is Fresh Air.
And to find out what's happening behind the scenes of our show,
and to get our producers' recommendations on what to watch, read, or listen to,
subscribe to our free newsletter at whyy.org slash fresh air.
Fresh Air's executive producer is Sam Brigger.
Our technical director and engineer is Audrey Bentham.
Our interviews and reviews are produced and edited by Phyllis Myers, Roberta Shorrock,
Anne-Marie Baldonado,
Lauren Krenzel,
Teresa Madden,
Monique Nazareth,
Susan Yakundi,
Anna Bauman,
and Nico Gonzalez-Whistler.
Our digital media producer is Molly C.V. Nesper.
Thea Chaloner directed today's show.
With Terry Gross, I'm Tanya Mosley.
Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Scott Cologne's historic victory as Mississippi's first Black U.S. senator marks a turning point in a state with a long and painful history of racial suppression.
The campaign’s success was driven by grassroots mobilization, cultural resonance, and a sharp critique of incumbent Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith’s dismissive rhetoric about economic hardship.
A viral political ad, “Pick Another Senator Instead,” effectively combined humor, cultural specificity, and substantive issues to connect with voters across racial and socioeconomic lines.
The campaign emphasized historical continuity, particularly through references to Medgar Evers and Reconstruction-era figures like Hiram Revels, grounding the victory in a legacy of resistance and civic struggle.
The win reflects broader shifts in Southern politics, where Black voter turnout—driven by economic and racial justice concerns—challenges long-standing gerrymandering and political disenfranchisement.
Both guests stress that the victory is not just a personal triumph but a collective achievement rooted in decades of activism, Black political resilience, and intergenerational resistance.
The success underscores the need for the nation to acknowledge its shared responsibility in the structural racism that shaped Mississippi’s political landscape.
There is a call for ongoing accountability, protection of Black leaders, and a commitment to inclusive, community-driven politics that center the needs of all Mississippians.
Summary:
S. senator represents a profound shift in a state deeply shaped by racial injustice and political suppression. Rooted in a legacy of Black resistance—from Hiram Revels during Reconstruction to Medgar Evers’ assassination—the victory reflects decades of grassroots organizing, cultural resilience, and voter mobilization.
Cologne’s campaign succeeded not just through traditional politics, but through culturally grounded messaging, such as the sharp “Pick Another Senator Instead” ad, which responded to his opponent’s dismissive remarks about rising food costs and tapped into shared experiences of economic hardship. The campaign’s success was built on intergenerational engagement, with young voters, including those in hoodies and with cultural markers, joining forces across racial lines. This moment is more than a personal triumph; it signifies a broader reckoning in the South, where Black political power has been suppressed for over a century.
The guests emphasize that this win is a reflection of national failure to confront its own racist structures, and they call for sustained accountability, protection of Black leaders, and a commitment to inclusive, community-driven politics. As Cologne takes office, there is a clear hope that he will carry Mississippi’s values—resilience, justice, and community—into Washington, ensuring that the struggle for equity continues beyond the ballot box.
FAQs
Scott Cologne is Mississippi's first Black U.S. senator in nearly 150 years, marking a major breakthrough in a state with a long history of racial suppression and political disenfranchisement.
Massive grassroots organizing, including voter outreach and cultural campaigns, demonstrated that Black voters were ready to challenge redistricting efforts and assert their political power in the state.
The ad humorously responded to Cindy Hyde-Smith's suggestion that people could choose another protein instead of beef, highlighting economic struggles in Mississippi and resonating with voters on a cultural and personal level.
The final campaign ad was filmed at Medgar Evers' home, honoring his activism and assassination, and reminded voters that the fight for voting rights was rooted in history and ongoing struggle.
The win reflects a broader shift where Black voters exercised their political power based on shared economic and racial realities, not just identity, challenging the notion that identity politics is a red herring.
Hiram Revels, the first Black U.S. senator, symbolizes early Black political agency during Reconstruction, showing that progress in Mississippi is part of a longer national history of resistance and resilience.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.