Michael McFaul: Trump Is Just 'Fine' with Mass Murder
52m 55s
Michael McFall, a former U.S. ambassador to Russia and political science professor, critiques the prevailing view in U.S. foreign policy that all states act through rational, transactional self-interest. He argues this lens is dangerously naïve, especially when applied to Russia under Putin, whose actions are driven by ideology, historical grievance, and a belief in Slavic unity—not simple economic calculations. Despite failing to achieve his war goals—such as conquering Ukraine or halting NATO expansion—Putin remains entrenched in a costly, stagnant war, while the U.S. under Trump has adopted a transactional approach that offers concessions like reduced military aid and trade deals in exchange for peace. This strategy is not only ineffective but morally indefensible, as it enables Russia’s terror campaign against Ukrainian civilians, with documented killings exceeding 17,000 since 2022. Ukrainian society remains deeply supportive of Zelensky, rejecting surrender. Meanwhile, key U.S. officials, including Steve Whitaker and Karel Demetri, are actively pushing for business partnerships with Russian entities, undermining democratic values. The situation is further complicated by China’s strategic support for Russia—through technology transfers like the Goron 5 drone—and a broader trend of autocratic alignment, while the U.S. fractures its alliances, voting with Russia on key UN issues and abandoning democratic principles. McFall warns that this shift signals a dangerous return to 19th-century power politics, where autocrats coordinate to dominate, while democracies collapse under internal division and moral weakness. The result is not just a lost war, but a deeper erosion of American leadership and global credibility.
Hello and welcome to the Bullwork Daily. I'm your host Tim Miller, delighted to welcome to the show a former US ambassador to Russia and member of the National Security Council during the Obama administration. He's now a political science professor at Stanford. He's written ten books. His last one, he told me in the green room, was autocrats, first Democrats, China, Russia, America and the new global disorder. It's Michael McFall. How you doing, sir? I'm doing great. Thanks for having me. Well, shit, much to talk about in your area of expertise this week. So I appreciate you giving us the time. Yeah. I guess I wanted to start with a big picture before we kind of go with the blow by blow. You posted this yesterday. If you haven't studied the history, culture, politics or language of these countries and it's very convenient to have a theory of the world which asserts that all states behave alike. Unitary actors guided by rational calculations of self-interest. I either just like us, but they aren't. Putin does not think like us. Why did you share that? Where are we out of the biggest picture as far as how Putin is looking at the scenario we're in right now? Well, I shared that in part because there's an academic tradition in international relations called realism. I don't think it's very realistic, but what I just described there is their theory. And there are folks in the Trump administration, around the Trump administration. I don't know about President Trump. I'm guessing he doesn't know what realism is, but they have this attitude that we're all just seeking international interests and transactions. And this is the way the world is, like it or not. This is the way it is. And Putin is just like that. And I don't think that's true for any country. Imagine having that theory for the United States of America that leaders don't matter, ideas don't matter. We just have our rational, national interests. And whether it's Trump or Obama, we behave the same. So that would be ludicrous in my mind to have that theory about us. But a lot of people have that about Putin. And it's just if we could just treat them nicer to transactions that he likes, we'll get along with them, we'll end this war and we can make a lot of money. And I was just pointing out that those theories tend to be championed by people that don't know much about other countries. And I realized there's a selection by a circus. I've lived many years of my life abroad, including in Russia. And I speak Russia. And I've met Putin many times. I've dealt with him. Not lately. He doesn't really like me. He banned me from his country in 2014. But this notion that this is all about a transaction. You just give him another thing. You cut off assistance to Ukraine. He's going to be our friend. You kick, say Ukraine can never be a NATO. The latest rounds, buying his diesel fuel or cutting off the Ukrainians from our intelligence, treat him nicely and then he'll be our friend and I'll do things we want. That's not the Putin I know. And tragically, that's the Putin that Trump thinks he knows. But I don't think it's ended very well for the Ukrainians, for the Europeans, or most importantly for me, for Americans and our national interests. Trump might not know academic realism, but I think he does think he's doing a real estate deal. Which in some ways is similar, right, to our relationship. Yeah, down market version of it at least. So talk about what you think Putin's mindset is right now. I mean, he has been, they have been at a basic stalemate for quite a long time. Obviously, this did not go as he had hoped. He lost a lot of troops. Ukraine's technological advances have run circles around them. But he's in this moment now, where it feels like he has geopolitical momentum, I guess, at the very least with Trump. What he thinks in his mind right now is what is achievable or what they might want. You know, tragically, I think he's just locked into his original war time objectives. He gave a big speech. It was 73 minutes long, two days before he launched his full scale invasion. I watched every word of it. I'm probably the only one that watched at the end, but I wanted to hear the whole thing. And in it, he outlined his strategy. He wanted to unite the Slavic people, right? Because he doesn't think Ukrainians are separate nation. They're just Russians with accents. He said that to he wanted to rule by proxy the territory of Ukraine with his occupied forces. And he uses horrible phrase to describe what he wanted to do with Zelensky did not suffocation. So to get rid of the regime there, three wanted to demilitarize Ukraine and fourth stop NATO. And when you go back and you look at that list, he's failed at all of them, right? He hasn't conquered Ukraine. As you just pointed out, he's stuck in a stalemate and he's even losing territory in the last few weeks, by the way, on the front line. So that hasn't worked out. Zelensky's still in power, despite his best efforts and the efforts now of people like Trump, we say, he needs to step down, but he's the democratically elected president governing under their constitution, including a clause that allows for martial law. He's still there. Militarization, it's gone way up. So that's a giant defeat. And now Finland and Sweden have joined NATO. And those are real countries with real armies, by the way. So he hasn't won on any of those fronts. And if we were talking a year ago, and especially two years ago before Trump was reelected and came back to office, I heard anxiety in Putin's voice because he was losing a lot of soldiers, like he said, his economy was suffering. And it wasn't clear that they could go forward for much longer. But Trump has thrown him this lifeline by getting involved, saying he's going to end the war. Trump has this theory of give him concessions of peace, Putin, and then he'll finally end the war. I don't think it works generally by the way. He's just diplomacy 101, give the other side everything they want, and then hope they'll do what you want. I've negotiated with the Russians. It most certainly doesn't work with the Russians, but that's been his strategy. And so if you're Putin, you now think that time is on your side. We cut military assistance. We cut economic assistance. We're now opening up trading with them, you know, buying some of their assets. You listen to the way Trump speaks. He speaks so insultingly about Zelensky. He never says anything critical about Putin. So you think on that front, the correlation of forces, that's this Russian phrase they have, is moving in his direction, and then add to that on the battlefield a couple of details. So on the front line, stalemate, if not Ukrainians are making progress there, and that's been a big failure. But as a result of that, Putin has now launched this terrorist campaign. I don't think there's any other way to describe it. Killing civilians, wiping out their energy infrastructure, their water infrastructure. That doesn't get enough attention, and his theory is in doing this, Ukrainian society will rise up and say, Zelensky, we had a cut a deal. And in the last several weeks, they have had a technological breakthrough. So you rightly pointed out, Ukrainians have been doing this, but they've had this new one, this drone slash rocket. It's called the Goron 5. It has a rocket motor as opposed to those propellers, and the Ukrainians can't shoot it down. And most certainly can't shoot it down, if Starlinker, Star Shield is not working. And so if you're Putin, you think, well, maybe the tide has now turned, and time is now on your side. A couple of things on that. I want to talk about both the terror and kind of Putin feeling that the tide has turned, but just so on the terror part first. I just was looking at this up before we got on. There's this group, a research group called the Ukraine Evidence Hub that's trying to verify, put out verifiable data about the war crimes that have been happening in Ukraine. And they have 17,605 civilians killed since 2022. And that doesn't include kind of what's happened here over the last month, basically, when they've had this uptick. And I talked to Kailan Robertson for the YouTube the other day, and he was like, they've hit the buses, they hit his old apartment building in Odessa. And so like their terror campaign targeting civilians has, which was already, I mean, 17,000 deaths, but it is now escalating. It's definitely escalating. And Trump always likes to say, well, there would have been no war if our president. He says that 4,000 times. Well, the war has radically escalated since he's been president. And especially this terrorist campaign that you just described. I didn't realize the numbers were that high. You know, I talk to Ukrainians every single day. I do a lot of work with Ukrainians and the feeling of tear, what are we going to do for the winter? Where do we move our kids? Especially if you live in the capital. That is the sentiment. At the same time, you ask me what Putin thinks. And that's what he desires. But it's important to remember what Ukrainians think. Even despite all of that, if you look at opinion poll data, and the best one for those who want to go look at it, it's called KIS. Google KIS Ukraine, you can see this data. It's in English. Pretty steady, solid support for Zelensky and continuing to fight against the Russian. So the idea that they're going to bomb them into capitulation aided by Trump is not working. But the last thing I just want to say to him, just listening to what you just said, like just think about we're talking very analytic right now right fully so.
Yeah, but think about what Trump is doing. He's not just flipped onto the side of the autocrats and banning the Democrats. He's supporting this terrorist campaign. Yes. Like what happened to us as a country where we're now supporting terrorist imperial dictatorships where it's just okay to call him a good guy whose strategy is to literally kill civilians to try to win a war. And I just as an American, I just find this this last couple of days have been really, really deeply infuriating, disappointing, embarrassing for me as an American. Yeah, I'll add sickening on top of that. I mean, just let's just I want to give you a couple of things that they've done. I Trump today said Russia, frankly, has been fine on Ukraine. They haven't done much. As we said, as they're waging a campaign of terror against civilians who are just going about their lives writing the bus. Here was Marco yesterday. I want to contrast sex. Marco will be the secretary of the state of state and national security advisor. The person people go to is like, well, the rational one or the reasonable one that's trying to push Trump the right direction on all this. He like tries to get inside Trump's brain and and present a vision of a totally different person. You know, as Trump says that Russia hasn't done much, here's what Marco said about whether the president likes what Russia's doing. The president does not like to see this image of a ballistic missile hitting into an apartment building in Kiev and innocent civilians being wiped out as a result of it. He doesn't like that either. That's why this has been so frustrating to try to get resolution to it. He doesn't like it. How would we know that? He doesn't say that. You know, that's Marco talking to Breitbart, not unserious propaganda outlet, but it's like, Trump's out there today saying Russia hasn't done anything. So like this whole attempt to, you know, kind of whitewash what what Marco is supporting is almost as sickening as the action itself. I agree. I didn't realize that was with Breitbart. He's in his beckus. Yeah, that was with Breitbart. Two things. One, I've never heard President Trump speak that way. I've never heard him say, I don't like my friend Putin killing civilians. Maybe I'm wrong. You know, somebody can correct me and find one quote. But usually he blames Zelensky for the war. Usually he says, Zelensky just wants to keep fighting. I haven't spoken to the Zelensky for a while, but I do know him, and I hosted him here at Stanford, by the way, six months before the war. And when I was talking to him, he's the last person in the world that wants to keep fighting. I mean, think about it. Every day, he gets the reports that you just told us about are the people dying and he doesn't have a way to defend his citizens. But then he's not just rhetorically not saying that. Trump in his administration, it's a, you know, nobody really wants to own this one, right? But somebody here in the United States, Elon Musk, the Pentagon, the White House, we're not exactly sure. But somebody's helping Putin now kill those civilians by turning off their ability to see these weapons. They need star length, star I keep calling it star shield, star shield. And it's super confusing. I've been talking to all of my friends and experts, including the people that worked on the steel in the Biden administration. What exactly happened? So I don't want to pretend I know. But we do know that the intelligence that Ukrainians used to have to help defend their civilians against these rockets they don't have now. And that's because of the Trump administration and the people around him. So if he wants to save civilians, they're not asking for help to launch offensive rockets against Russians. They're just asking for intelligence help to defend their citizens. And yet, you know, President Trump doesn't want to do that. And one thing on Senator, as I just called him Senator, Secretary Marco Rubio, I don't know him well. Little Marco, we can call him. It's fun. Okay. All right. He was at my confirmation hearings back a long time ago, 2011. I mean, I follow him. He was a hawk then. Well, that's the thing. So two things. Where is he? He had a record. And whether you agreed with it or not, he had a consistent record. He's just completely abandoned it to be in the Trump administration. And then second, he's in his back of stand today, right? Have you ever noticed that he's like never where the action is? He's always where the periphery is. You know, he doesn't go to Kiev. He doesn't go to Moscow. He doesn't go to the Middle East, Gaza, Israel. He's just like avoiding the wars. Somehow thinking that everybody's going to forget that he was a secretary of state. You know more about American politics than all ever know, but I don't understand what the play is here because he doesn't look like a very effective member of the cabinet right now. Marco understands that this is a shit show. I mean, there's a reason he's not the point person on Iran in particular. He wants to keep optionality. He wants to see we seen as a loyal soldier for Trump. And he's trying to navigate that as best as he can. And everything is let's steal me in the best case argument for them. Okay, let's say it's true that there's something else happening that it was not Elon. It was not Trump. It was not somebody in the, you know, Department of War that has caused the throttling of star link. Right. And that has limited their ability to use star shield as Russia's had these advances that have killed innocent Ukrainians. Well, if that happened, like if that was an accident, or if that was some technological failure or something, right? And they couldn't, they didn't really know. How would a country that was on the side of Ukraine and wanted to protect its citizens be acting then? Right. They would be the way that they would be talking about this would be like, you know, we're doing everything we can to help Ukraine. We've offered them our military level star shield in the meantime while we figure this out. Like we want to protect Ukrainian citizens. That's how they're doing. They're attacking Zelensky. Like they're saying that Zelensky should be kicked out of Ukraine. And they're like kind of parsing what's happening, right? You know what I mean? Like, exactly. So to me, just like their actions betray that they knew that they know what they're doing. That's a great point. That's a great way to phrase it because that they wanted to fix it. They couldn't be leaning into try to fix it and not attacking the guy and the country that they're supposedly are trying to help. I'm getting hot back to Zelensky. We'll talk about him. I was watching him on the, he looks tired. I mean, that's like, you know, and he looks really worn down. And I do think that, you know, and he's had to suffer a lot of indignities at the hands of this administration. And so, you know, it's human nature to kind of lash out, but I think that maybe, you know, his his wick might be shorter for, you know, kind of playing the game here. And like some of the things that he said this last week, where maybe, you know, trumping on the wrong side of history or whatever, like it's maybe not that helpful in the grand scheme of things. But he met virtually with US lawmakers on Monday. These are the ass senators to try to pressure Trump to restore the intel sharing and access. Again, like it seems like everybody's actions like Zelensky thinks that this is a choice by the administration and he's trying to get other people to put pressure on Trump. And meanwhile, Trump is kind of saying that did Zelensky should be removed, like basically, right? And is that how you see what's happening basically from Zelensky's point of view right now? Yeah, all of your points I agree with. So on the, you know, just tired, you know, less tolerance of taking these indignities, I also think, you know, because I know that the governments that have been around him, the people around him, he just doesn't have, you know, his close confidence that he'd have back in 2022. He's got a new government, new chief of staff. I think that wears on him. What is the reason for that? I know nothing about that. This is an old history. No, no, this it all has to do with alleged corruption scandals. And but if you go back and you look, there's this very famous photo that they took, you know, at the beginning of the invasion, when when we were asking him to leave and he said, you know, I don't need to ride, I need ammunition. And they took this selfie with his closest folks. I'm pretty sure none of those people still work for him. And some of these people are controversial people, his chief of staff, in particular, this guy, you're mocked. But I know for a fact that he could lean on them and talk to them and he just doesn't, he doesn't have that kind of support right now. Exponation, not excuse, but I think those are some of the reason he had a great press secretary, you know, two years ago that doesn't work for him anymore. So I think you're seeing that. But then in addition, you know, there's a school of thought in Ukraine and among my friends that just say to hell with this guy, like how much more can we put up with him? And they look at others. Hell with Trump. Yeah, tell with Trump. Oh, I should have made that clear. Tell with Trump. And, you know, look how Xi Jinping treated him. Look how Prime Minister Karni treated him. You know, we want to be part of that. And they're kind of, you know, it's not rational. But this intelligence sharing is the main thing, right? Remember, we're not giving him anything in terms of support when Trump claims to give him billions and billions. That's before he came in. He's claiming credit for it. And then he's the one that cut it off. But intelligence sharing is real. But there's just this frustration I hear with Ukrainians with us. And they try to disaggregate between Trump and Americans But they got politics there too, so you
you know, just to acquiesce to Trump and just to say, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you. That doesn't play well in Ukrainian society. That is not what they want from their leader. - And now a message from our sponsor, The Reading Room, here at The Bowl where we talk a lot about Jeffrey Epstein and how important it is to keep the story in the news. Well, some of our friends actually put out all 3.5 million of the released Epstein files bound them into 3,437 volumes and built a free traveling exhibit of the public can bear witness to these crimes. It's called the Donald J. Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Memorial Reading Room, which is a hell of a name and it works how it sounds, you walk in and there are the Epstein files, four to ceiling, plus a timeline of Trump and Epstein's four decade friendship and talks and panels with survivors. The reading room is open now for 20 plus stops. I saw it on our tour across the South, and that's worth it, you should check it out too. Now it turns out moving 17,000 pounds of evidence around the country is in cheap and the reading room relies on donations. If you want to know more about how you can donate or visit the reading room, there's more information in the morning shots newsletter or you can visit Trumpepsteinreadingroom.com/Borke. That's Trumpepsteinreadingroom.com/Borke. - So you're talking about the people around Zelensky. I'll talk a little bit about the people around Trump who are allegedly the people on this deal. There's an Axios report today that Zelensky had proposed a 30-day halt to Ukrainian strikes on racial oil refineries and being responsive to what the administration was asking. Their request in exchange was for patriot interceptors to help defend their people against these missiles you've been talking about. That report said Whitcoff and Kushner have shown little interest in the proposal. Axios is a lot of choice for Whitcoff and Kushner. So I take that to be accurate reporting. The post is also reporting that Hague Seth is opposed to the transfer of interceptor missiles. So, I mean, hey, I just like the rejection of that deal any response to that, but then just more broadly, like having Whitcoff and Kushner be like in a quasi role that you were playing assess kind of what we're getting out of them. - Yeah, so I saw that reporting too and that's disappointing. That seemed like a good trade. And let's all remember these interceptors are defensive weapons. They're not gonna be shot at Russians. They're gonna be shot at Russian missiles and Russian drones. There is a deficit in the world with them because we've launched so many of them in the Middle East. And in this incredible asymmetric way, these are like, you know, a million dollar, two million, three million depending on which one we're talking about, that we are launching against drones, a hundred thousand dollar weapons. That is no way to fight a war. But back to the negotiators, you know, I would just say this. If you go back to the very first meeting that Secretary Rubio had with Foreign Minister Lavrov in Saudi Arabia, I used to do this, you know, and we always wanna know who's at the table and who's where. And on the Russian side, by the way, all the three top guys are all three people that I used to deal with. So 13 never changes. Is Lavrov Yuri Ushekov, who's the foreign policy advisor to Putin, but then a really important guy that I wanna underscore. His name's Karel Demetri. - I was about to ask you about him. So he beat me to the punch. - Okay, so I know him. I used to deal with him. And there he was, and I was like, what is he doing there? He runs the Russian investment fund. Well, on our side was Rubio, and then Whitkoff, and then Kushev. - Well, just just really quick for you, Tarsid. So in what context would you have dealt with? To me, like, why are you surprised that he was there? Like, what was his prior kind of role when you were doing this? - So he's a super sophisticated business guy, you know, he's has degrees. I have to admit it from Stanford and Harvard. It's just a fact you can all look it up. You know, and he worked in investment banks that like a lot of these people did in the 90s. And, you know, with our banks. See, he's part of that whole ecosystem. And then he was made the head of, you know, the equivalent of their sovereign wealth fund. And back when I was ambassador, we were still, you know, this is before the first invasion. We still had companies that were doing business in Russia. And, you know, so they would meet and they would come to events and I would, your job as ambassadors to talk to everybody. And he was one of the guys I talked to. And, but never did he show up at a meeting about arms control. Never did he show up at a meeting. We had, when I was there, we had lots of meetings about how to try to end the war in Syria, right? That was our negotiations. And, you know, Carrie would come over. The various administration officials would come over. Carole Demetrif was never part of that. But with the Trump people, he's there and he's there for a very explicit strategy that they're running. And they pretty much talk about it openly. They want to do business with team Trump. And they've decided, and again, you know this group a lot better than I do, but they're thinking. And this is something, let me make it broader than that. Actually Putin thinks this about all people in the West. I've heard him talk about it. We don't have any values. We don't have any morals. We don't have any sense of history. We just want to make money. And everybody has their price. That's the way he thinks. And that, you know, the kind of quintessential case study of this is the former chancellor of Germany, your heart shredder, who we got close to. And then when he stepped down, he made him, I think the German of the board of Ross Nath, their largest oil company. And then he had a really big role in another company called Nord Stream 2, this gas pipeline. And he just paid him and shrote her. Guess what? Did what he wanted to do and helped him in domestic politics in Germany. So that's the way they think about team Trump. And Karel, in particular, to Mitrev, he keeps saying, let's get this Ukraine thing out of the way so that we can get on with doing business. At one point, he floated a number of $14 trillion in joint ventures that we can do together. The Russian economy, I think, is, you know, under two trillion. But I always thought those were things they were laying out to get Trump to put pressure on Zelensky and the war. And then they were going to do these deals with striking about the last couple of weeks. Is there now starting to do the deals without the war ending? So there was this great reporting about, in the New York Times, about these assets owned by another Russian oil company. It's called Lucoyl. They're sanctioned. These assets are abroad. And now they're working on a deal to sell them to people close to the Trump folks. Nord Stream 2, that I just mentioned, this pipeline. There's all kinds of interesting, not precise reporting. So I want to be careful here. But allegedly, some American, again, close to Whitcoff and Kushner are going to buy that. And then more generally, I would just say, you know, when I hear Mr. Whitcoff speak. And I'm not a real estate guy, you know, I've done big businesses by places there. I don't know how it works there. But I do know how it works in diplomacy. And it's pretty elementary. Like if you give the other side something, you should get something in return. And I can't imagine that Whitcoff is just like, given away buildings and getting nothing in return. Like, you know, that's called a market transaction. I think even in his world, everybody has to benefit from the deal. But when I look at the way he negotiates with Putin, two things are striking. He just gives him everything he wants, a concession after concession, and then puts suppressor on Zelensky. But that's the way he talks about Putin that I've got to tell you, just gets under my skin. Because I've known Putin for a long time, you know, he's killed a couple of my Russian friends. Just so we're clear. So maybe I'm biased, you know, he killed Alexey Navalny. He was a friend of mine. He killed Boris. I think it's pretty fair by us to be upset at somebody who killed your friends. I don't think that's okay. Well, thank you, thank you for that indulgence. But even like set that aside, like, in fact, this is something I learned from George Schultz, former Secretary of State for Ronald Reagan. He was here at Stanford at the Hoover Institution for many decades. He was a mentor of mine. And George, he writes this in his memoirs, 1,200 pages long, so nobody's ever read it. But it's really great about diplomacy. I can't say I've read the whole thing, but I have read the sections on things I care about. And when he writes about dealing with the Soviets, he says, look, you got to deal with bad guys. We have interest, we have to engage with them. But he says, you don't have to check your values at the door. And you don't have to pretend that you're their friends. And I'm just paraphrasing here. That's not exactly what he says. But Whit-Koff is always trying to be Putin's friend. And I can tell you, from experience with that guy and watching him for decades, I met him in 1991. So we have a long history. He looks at that as weakness. When you're trying to, you know, genuinely reflect to him and say what a great guy you are, he doesn't respect that. He just pockets your concession and then say, what are you going to do for me the next time you visit? And that's why I just think these guys are way over their heads. What is weakness? He says it was weakness because it is. And there's almost something. I almost hope that Whit-Koff kids are making bank off of the Russians because the alternative story is so pathetic that it's almost hard to even process. I mean, Steve Whit-Koff just sees himself as some like forest gump, like figure, who's just so excited to be around this mass murder. Or so he has an interesting story for his memoirs. And like that, he seems like that. when he talks, but he's like, oh, we have these greats.
stories together. It's like, "Well, why you've been flying to Moscow over and over again, Putin's been kidnapping children and killing people, killing Ukrainians. How could you possibly sit there and just with the shitty grid on your face?" And so, I mean, I think that the corruption story is the more likely one. And, you know, I mean, that is definitely something to add. I don't know. Whickoff, I think, is feeling the pressure. I heard from a friend he was supposed to speak at Harvard the other day and had a little. I don't know exactly what happened. So, I don't want to make an allegation with a little panic attack. I don't know, a little wimp out. I don't know exactly what happened, but he decided not to go with the last second. And so, I don't know. I wouldn't want to be in the public domain if I were him right now. Yeah. Yeah. That's probably prudent. But, you know, it is interesting. You're two theories, and I obviously, I don't know which is which. Maybe it falls binary. Could be a little both. Could be a little both, of course. But he, just to your point, Tim, like, he goes out of his way to say that, like, that thing we heard about, "Oh, we're all going to be telling war stories some day to our grandchildren." You don't have to say that. I don't know. Something deeply troubling about those comments to me. I like his one more example. I just wanted to mention on the Zelensky thing, just about why this is so urgent right now. And, like, why Zelensky is trying to get senators to put pressure on the administration now is, you know, and there's this story from yesterday morning, where there's a park in Karkiv, and, you know, there's a missile, one of these vessels we've been discussing from Russia, hit the park, three children were among the dead. And it was like another mist warning. These are the kinds of things that Ukraine was able to block up until a week or two ago. And, like, this is happening right now. These kids are dying. And it's like at this moment that the administration seems to be turning harder against them. And I don't understand it. I mean, people make arguments that this is somehow going to help them in the elections. You can speak to that. I don't, I can't connect the dots about that. I just think this is Trump just leaning into the guy. He's always wanted to embrace. But we're still not a dictatorship here. We're still not a monarchy. And, you know, Zelensky's got to lean in to do what he's doing. I mean, on this one, you know, we don't have many polls, as you know, that we get 80% of Americans to agree, but that's most Americans think this is a really bad guy. And I just hope that, you know, we'll have a Congress that might think a little more strategically about putting more pressure to do something. I am not the expert on those kinds of things. I talked to members of Congress and senators from time to time. It would be nice, though, if there was more pushback from that particular body. And people say, well, Mike, just wait till after the elections. It's going to come. It's going to come. And I reported that I just had a group of Ukrainians at my house last week. And there's like, you know, that's a long time from now. Yeah. That was their response. Or is really far away, Professor McFall. Yeah. Kids are dying today. Now, that's right. I do think that there probably will be pressure put on the lame duck. But then again, how much pressure, how much can be done, right? And if these guys are unilaterally stopping intelligence sharing, you know, our is a Republican, other Republican senators really going to be willing to go to the mat to stop some other priority. The Trump ones, I find that hard to believe. So I do think that those, that the tune will change. But that's the problem. This is unilateral stuff. We got off just a little bit on the Demetri of it. I was just kind of wondering if you had any other thoughts on, because he does keep showing up. Yeah. It was him that had, that had kind of the initial piece proposal, initial Russia friendly piece proposal that included taking done at all the stuff. Everybody said, yeah, that it was taken to being real. And he keeps popping up. Is there anything else kind of about, you know what you've been seeing from him lately or, or what you expect there? Well, I'm glad you brought up that peace plan, because I do think, you know, he's the main intermediary as, again, from the reporting, I have no inside information. I have neither inside information with the Trump administration or the Putin I cremated. I know things about the governments in Kiev, but not the of those two. I'm not, I don't, I don't, not being really interested. You met Carol Demetri, and I have not. So you're, you know, you're a step ahead of me. But what was striking to me is, I think he convinced Whitkopf. I can't prove this with evidence, but watching the TV's, and the arc of their conversations and the floating of these ideas, I think he convinced Whitkopf that if Trump could just get Zelensky to give all of Donbass, right? So the Russians have most of it, and Putin's really focused on conquering it all, then that could do a deal. And I think they came with that idea to the Alaska summit, and this is all Demetrius doing, and they must have talked about it. And Trump, you know, Trump will just, again, you know, better than I. But I've hurt, in my work, my domain space, including about me when he said, 2018 at a summit with Putin, Putin ask him, can we interrogate a bunch of Americans? And he said, yeah, that's a great idea. And one of them was me. So he said that about me personally. I've seen that. I'll just say that. And this diesel deal, there's just no doubt Putin floated it and he said, oh, that's a great idea. Let's do this. I think they said that about this deal. And then, you know, maybe it was Rubio, I don't know, but then people are like, really, we're going to go on stage and say we've, we've committed to this. And I think that's why the press conference got pulled down. That's why the lunching got pulled down. Because otherwise, it's really hard to explain. But that's what he's focused on. His big thing is give us Don Boss. And we can, we can then convince the big boss for a ceasefire. And here's one thing that I guess Marco, at least, seems to be being honest about. He discussed this also yesterday. Let's just listen to that really quick. Russians occupy all but about 11% of that area in that province, Denetsk, or in that region of Denetsk, their Ukrainians have a defensive line that they've embedded themselves in. They argue, and military strategists say is true, that it is the last defensive line, that if they give that up, there is nothing to defend Kiev from there. It's just a straight shot into Kiev. The core of this conflict is Russia demands all of Denetsk, including that defensive line as part of their territory. That's what they've defined as victory. That was also part of the bright part interview. It seems like you tell me that the facts of what the argument is and this dispute over territory is accurate, but it's interesting how he phrases it. That that's like the core of the dispute is Russia's desire for Don Ask. I don't think that's correct. I think that they want that now because of their future ambitions. That's the first step. Exactly. So that's the party's leaving out. So in the negotiations that they're involved in, I think he does describe it accurately. And there are these fortress cities, and the Ukrainians will tell you if they fall, it's a straight shot to Kiev. But if the war would end and there'd be peace forever, then they wouldn't have to worry about a straight shot to Kiev. But guess what? They're worrying about the straight shot to Kiev because they've been there before, right? They were invaded in 2014. And so Ukrainians say that we can't give up those cities. And the other thing that's interesting, you know, he sounds like me, he's just like an analyst on TV. This is what they want. You know, the whole lot, man, you're the secretary of state. And you should say, you know, a real leader would say, and under no circumstances should we give Putin those cities because that would lead to more warfare in the future. And we're going to do whatever we can do to create the line before then. And I want to also say something very important. Zelensky, if you listen to him closely, he's ready to allow the Russians to continue to occupy the territory they have right now. He will never say it. He'll never say it that bluntly. I he'll never acknowledge it to Zure, right? He'll never sign a treaty. But the fact, though, he is ready to do that because they, they, you know, they think it can be like a North Korea, South Korea thing. And you know, one day Putin may fall and they'll get their territory back or more like they would prefer West Germany, East Germany, but, but they can't give up these cities because of the reasons that the secretary of state just described, but he shouldn't just be an innocent bystander in this. He should be trying to change history, not just observe it, especially again, going back to Marka, who like what it's once an advocate of the freedom agenda. It's like, oh, you want to subjugate, you know, an additional, whatever, 11% of the non-Boss to authoritarian rule. You know, when they're kidnapping these equals children, it's just, it's sick. I just want to kind of just broaden out to a couple of the geopolitical things. So the relationship, talk about like where China fits in in this relationship. I mean, Putin and Applebaum wrote that, you know, Putin's dream for years was that his country, you know, would be treated as equal to us in China. That's why Putin is pushing for this trilateral, you know, summit to discuss the future of Ukraine, just discussing the Trump wouldn't even have Zelensky there, but talk about like why he wants China involved. Like, what is the China relationship now and kind of how you see that evolving? So Putin, like Trump, thinks in kind of 18th century, 19th century terms, right? Sears influence, I'll take Eurasia, you take Asia, China, Xi Jinping, you know, Trump, you get North America, South America, that's the way he thinks. And Trump does too, like, you know,
we've seen this, right? He thinks in those terms. So that's a play of that, right? Well, we'll get together. We'll just like they did in the 19th century. Let's just carve up Africa. OK, we're going to get together and carve up Ukraine. Or whatever analogy you like, right? Sure. I almost said Yalta, but Yalta was different because we did have people there actually pushing back. And that wasn't such a good outcome. Here, just be three people on one side of the table. Who's on the other side of the table? There's nobody representing Ukraine or the free world. So that's a very odd thing. And I'm, gosh, I hope that will not happen. That would be a horrible outcome. But I think that Chinese and Xi Jinping, there's situations a little more complicated. I'm explaining, not excusing, right? So on the one hand, Putin and Xi Jinping, they are tight. They've had 55,000 meetings. They're united. The autocrats are united. It's the Democrats, you know, on the other side in the world that we're not united. They're united with their side-kicks Iran and North Korea. They're coordinating a lot of stuff. Sharing technology with the North Koreans, sharing soldiers. That's all happening. And most tragically, we were talking about this Goron V, this rocket slash drone that the Russians now have in this escalation game that is killing a lot of Ukrainians, the engine for that, the rocket engine from that came from China. And that was disappointing to the Ukrainians who've been working really hard to keep the Chinese not full in. That was a big move on Xi Jinping's part to put more skin in the game to help Putin. At the same time, at the same time, he's not 100% in. And there's some data points on that. So whenever there's a UN vote about invading Ukraine going back to 2014, it used to be the case that there was six or seven rogue states, you know, Belarus, North Korea. I think Nicaragua, you know, Cuba. They would vote with Russia against the resolution. We in the free world, we would vote for these resolutions condemning Russia's invasion of Ukraine, both in 2014 and 2022. Xi Jinping would always abstain, never voted with Russia, never sided with him because he's got an interest in the international system working. They don't want to blow up the whole system and go back to the 19th century. They want the UN to work. They don't want annexation, you know, here and there, that's chaos. They benefit from the system. By the way, we flipped when Trump came back in in these votes when they happened now. We now vote with Russia, you know, and we're all together now. We vote. Lukashenko, we're now with them. The Chinese are abstaining, we're voting with Putin. Second, you know, Putin has been trying to open up a new gas pipeline to China for years. They met again in May. I actually was in China right when Putin showed up. He came in just a few days after Trump was there. And they said, no, we don't want to do it. And the Russians were really pissed off. We talked about Russian drones, but let's talk about Ukrainian drones. They're not all made in Ukraine, all those components. There's a lot of Chinese components that go into their different drone systems. And so if you're friends without limits, how do you explain that? And I don't want to overplay it. I want to be clear that when Putin comes to shove, Xi Jinping is firmly with Putin. And he most certainly doesn't want Putin to lose. But he also, you know, it's a much more complicated relationship than I think when you dig one or two layers deeper. - And then what about the kind of Putin-Aranian relationship and kind of how the interplay with the two wars is going? Obviously not in one of the other despicable things Trump did. The other day was put out a statement about how Russia's not actually helping Iran that much and kind of absolving them of that. But like what do you think is like the truth about that relationship as it stands? - Well, first, Trump's war against Iran was a giant another gift to Putin, right? First and foremost, because oil prices went up all over the world, Russia makes billions and billions of dollars off of that. But second, because in other parts of the world, you know, I travel a lot for my job, we now look like we're the Russians, right? You know, they have their war, you have your war, you're all the same. And you know whose image in the world has gone way up over the last 18 months, China, including in our Democratic allies, the data, it's a Gallup poll, I have it right here. Many people in the countries now view China more positively than the United States. And we're not talking about the rogue states, I was just trying to remember, we're talking about France, Germany, Australia, Canada. - Canada, the war itself helped Putin. But Putin has not been a great ally for those in trouble, right? When push came to shove, he let Asad go in Syria, he didn't fight for him there. We took out Maduro, he didn't do much there. So, you know, the Iranians must feel that. But at the same time, they don't want them to lose, they want us to be bogged down there. And I don't know, again, it's really hard to report on or comment on intelligence sharing or not, 'cause it's all classified. But there's a lot of reporting out there that the Russians are helping Iran with intelligence. And that would be very consistent with the relationship they had when I was in the government. So, there's no doubt that their allies, whether they're not going to, Russia's not going to go to war for the Iranians, but are they going to help us? Are they going to help Iran fight us? Absolutely. And the notion that Trump floated, well, we got him constrained now because we're doing this diesel deal, you know, we can't judge that evidence, but I'd be very skeptical of that. Somehow they cut them off because we're buying a few billion dollars at a diesel. It is unbelievably humiliating and so weak that Trump. I mean, maybe the weakest thing that he's done in a long list that he is going to absolve the Russians of their efforts to help kill American troops and the Iran war that he started. I mean, if you guys had done that, I just came back when I was in my Republican hat and you were in there working for Obama. If you had done so, I mean Fox News would be wall to wall, just talking about how, you know, in embarrassing and weak Barack Obama is. And like that is what Donald Trump is doing right now. And I don't think that it's really sunk in with people, like, you know, just, you know, the degree to which that he has weakened us on that front. - I agree, I agree. It's tragic and I don't think it sinks in. Partly 'cause it's hard to report on as we were talking about, right? But they're all allies. Let's be clear. Like my book's called Autocrats versus Democrats. The autocrats are all coordinated. They have their clubs, they show up, they coordinate, they're helping each other. They're all helping each other. Remember Putin needed the Iranians in the beginning of his war. He needed their Shahid drones in the beginning of the war. We're the ones that are not united. We're the ones that are fighting amongst our allies. And when I say we, I wanna be clear. I'm talking about the President of the United States. And, you know, my book is a book about, you know, decades of, well, hundreds of years of history in the past, it starts in the 18th century. But it talks about what we're gonna need to compete with this autocratic alliance over the decades. And two of the things, most of the book was written, you know, well before Trump came back into power. But I go through how we prevailed in the Cold War and we had two great things they didn't have. We had allies that were really strong and with us, not just kind of, you know, enduring democratic allies that helped us in the Cold War. And we have better ideas. You know, democracy's better than dictatorship. And we, you know, spread those ideas. By the economic system was better than democracy. - And free markets, yes. And that was, that was too. And on all of those fronts, he's blowing up our allies. He's breaking down the economic trading system that we did so well in the 20th century. And he's abandoning this idea that we are the leader of the free world. And, you know, you know, this is never a debate among Democrats and Republicans, right? You know, we had different nuances about how to do this. But nobody during the Cold War thought for a minute that we were on the side of the autocrats or the Soviets. And now our president flirts with that from time to time, including this week was a pretty bad one for that flirtation. - Indeed. The last thing I have to say, I'm curious, is when to pick your brain access also in the news this week. And you know, you're involved in these sorts of conversations about how to engage in other countries that's happening. And it's just so fraught right now at the Israel. But it was pretty striking to me this week. Trump puts out a video endorsing BB explicitly for reelection. Amidst, you know, the degree to which he's been our partner and control are in the Iran war. And then JD Vance, the nice president earlier today was asked about that. And he said that he doesn't, you know, want to get involved in foreign, political election. - Oh, I didn't see that. - But he had, as you know, endorsed Orbán and AFD a few months ago. And man, if that is not, if that kind of tension is not a preview of layer kind of mega world is going.
in one little nutshell, I don't know what to tell you, but I'm curious what your thoughts were on. I'm just kind of how to gauge. Well, and not only did he endorse them, I was in Munich at the Munich Security Conference when he came and gave that just horrible speech, a vice president advance saying, "You got more problems in democracies here in Europe than we got, and your real problems are not the Russians. Your real problems are here at home. I mean, I was sitting in a room with Europeans just apoplectic, and they're all asking me to explain JD Vance." But then he met with off dead on that trip, and then he went to Hungary because one thing to put out a tweet, it's another thing to fly it to Hungary. So the notion that he doesn't want to enter a medal in the internal affairs of countries, obviously, that's not a principle of his, but I did not know that he did that. That you are right. This is going to be a big battle in within that party coming up. That's Michael McFall, I appreciate the time so much this week. The book, as you mentioned, Autocrats vs. Democrats, your last, so, you know, as you've done 10 of them, people should get the 10th, I would thank you to support you. Exactly. We'll be checking in with you as news develops on this front in Russia and Ukraine, thanks so much for your insight. Appreciate it. Great conversation. Thanks for having me too. Once again, find me a friend, someone to walk with too, too many boys, too small a town. Feels like I'm always wandering the grounds. You call me a high-lettered ring, heartbreaking me, only one thing, got me again, it's the end of the world. Done with this year, a mistrinkled beer, missing a song for you, too slow to hate, summer came late, fires on the west side, I'm rolling the waves, let's miss me, catch it before, it's almost gone, try to pretend it's the end of the world. Don't kiss me to death, there's nothing left to decide, nothing to prove, and nothing that was only told, and go tell me in name, we'll burn our mistakes and destroy, to be the end of the world.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Michael McFall argues that the assumption that all nations act like rational, transactional actors is flawed, especially when applied to Putin, who operates with a deeply ideological and nationalist worldview.
Putin’s war objectives—uniting Slavic populations, removing Zelensky, demilitarizing Ukraine, and stopping NATO—are now all failed, with no territorial gains and continued military stalemate.
The Trump administration’s strategy of offering concessions to Putin, such as cutting aid or opening trade deals, is ineffective and morally bankrupt, particularly given the escalation of Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilians.
Ukrainians maintain strong public support for Zelensky and resistance to Russian aggression, despite the war’s brutality, indicating a clear rejection of surrender or appeasement.
Key figures like Steve Whitaker and Karel Demetri are actively promoting business deals with Russia, signaling a deliberate shift toward enabling authoritarian cooperation over principled diplomacy.
Russia’s new drone technology, including the Goron 5, has a Chinese origin, highlighting how China’s strategic support for Putin undermines Ukrainian defense efforts.
The U.S. has weakened its alliances and international standing under Trump, with decisions like cutting intelligence sharing and downplaying Russian atrocities, damaging trust and strategic coherence.
The growing alignment of autocratic powers—Putin, Xi Jinping, and Iran—contrasts sharply with the fragmented and compromised democratic West, threatening a return to 19th-century power politics.
Summary:
S. S. foreign policy that all states act through rational, transactional self-interest.
He argues this lens is dangerously naïve, especially when applied to Russia under Putin, whose actions are driven by ideology, historical grievance, and a belief in Slavic unity—not simple economic calculations. S. under Trump has adopted a transactional approach that offers concessions like reduced military aid and trade deals in exchange for peace.
This strategy is not only ineffective but morally indefensible, as it enables Russia’s terror campaign against Ukrainian civilians, with documented killings exceeding 17,000 since 2022. Ukrainian society remains deeply supportive of Zelensky, rejecting surrender. S.
officials, including Steve Whitaker and Karel Demetri, are actively pushing for business partnerships with Russian entities, undermining democratic values. S. fractures its alliances, voting with Russia on key UN issues and abandoning democratic principles.
McFall warns that this shift signals a dangerous return to 19th-century power politics, where autocrats coordinate to dominate, while democracies collapse under internal division and moral weakness. The result is not just a lost war, but a deeper erosion of American leadership and global credibility.
FAQs
Mcfall argues that this theory is flawed because it ignores the importance of ideology, leadership, and values. He points out that Putin does not operate like a typical rational actor; he has strong nationalist and anti-Western beliefs, and his actions are driven by a sense of historical destiny and cultural superiority, not just economic calculations.
Mcfall believes Putin still holds to his original war-time objectives: uniting Slavic peoples, removing Zelensky, demilitarizing Ukraine, and stopping NATO expansion. Despite military setbacks and a stalemate on the battlefield, he continues to believe that political and demographic changes will eventually lead to his strategic goals.
Mcfall describes the attacks as a deliberate campaign of terror, including the targeting of civilian infrastructure and public spaces, like buses and apartment buildings. He notes that these attacks have killed over 17,000 civilians since 2022 and have escalated recently, with no equivalent response from the U.S. administration.
Mcfall criticizes Trump’s approach for treating the war as a transaction where concessions to Putin (like cutting military aid or opening trade) would end the conflict. He argues this strategy is naive and morally bankrupt, especially given the terror attacks and the U.S. support for a regime that kills civilians.
Mcfall claims that the Trump administration has undermined Ukraine’s ability to defend itself by cutting off or restricting access to intelligence tools like Starlink and Starshield, which are critical for countering Russian drones and missiles.
Mcfall identifies Karel Demetri as a key Russian intermediary who helps push a business-oriented deal between Trump and Putin. He suggests Demetri promotes a peace plan involving the surrender of Donbas, with the ultimate goal of enabling economic deals and reducing military conflict.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.