Michael Hartnett: I coined “Mag7” - Here’s What Ends Their Run
from The Master Investor Podcast with Wilfred Frost
1h 27s
The decade has been defined by rapid economic shifts—from globalization to deglobalization, monetary to fiscal stimulus, and rising inequality. This environment fueled a surge in nominal GDP and equities, especially in AI-driven tech firms known as the "Magnificent Seven." These companies generated vast cash without spending, making them highly attractive to investors and causing a historic flight from bonds. However, their current surge in AI capex—now exceeding $1 trillion annually with negative free cash flow—creates vulnerability to rising interest rates. Bond yields have climbed sharply, reaching 5%, which could disrupt funding for AI investment and threaten the broader equity market. Despite this, the market remains skeptical that 2026 marks a regime shift, unlike past pivotal years such as 2008 or 2016. Political dynamics, especially in midterms and state races like Texas, are emerging as key catalysts—where populist movements may pressure fiscal policy and curtail AI spending. The market is also showing signs of overconcentration in AI, with parallels to past tech bubbles. Commodity prices, driven by global resource competition and geopolitical tensions, are expected to remain strong. Ultimately, while equities remain dominant, the risk of a major market reversal looms if bond yields rise sharply or political sentiment shifts toward fiscal austerity. Michael Hartnett concludes with a long-term investment principle: "by humiliation and hubris"—investing in what others overlook (humiliation) while riding the overconfidence of the dominant trend (hubris)—to prepare for inevitable market corrections.
Part of the reason to say they're magnificent is because they made magnificent amounts of cash
and didn't spend any of it. That's why they were magnificent. Now they're spending a trillion
plus a year on AI CapEx and their negative cash flow to the June of 200 billion. So they have
to be kind of subservient to the bond market. The bond market pushed up yields or spreads too much,
you're not going to get the spending. You know, if you look at what happened with the railroads,
you know, what kind of ended it was social upheaval. A kind of a social upheaval that can happen when
an industrial revolution creates enormous inequality and a lot of workers strike. And that's why,
you know, these midterms look quite fascinating in terms of how people will vote. But the other thing
that pops, bubbles and booms and bulls is bonds. That's what we've been talking about. And so we're
still waiting for that level to do that. I feel that the market in its entirety is not yet convinced
that you're at this major secular inflection point. You were in equities in 2008. And as you say,
you were in 2016 when we had Brexit Trump in terms of commodities. Those were regime changing
years. But people don't yet think that 2026 is going to be a regime changing year for bonds.
The question is, is it going to be for AI?
Welcome to the Master Investor podcast with me, Wilfred Frost, where we celebrate and learn from
the success of the greatest investors, business leaders and politicians in the world giving you
our listeners an edge. The Master Investor podcast is sponsored by LSEG, interactive brokers,
the World Gold Council and BNY investments. Please do remember the views expressed in this
podcast are for general information purposes only. Nothing in the podcast constitutes a financial
promotion, investment advice or a personal recommendation, more on that in the show notes.
My guest today is Michael Hartnett, the famed Chief Investment Strategist of Bank of America Global
Research, who is always immaculately researched and focused on the facts, but yet still manages to
make very bold contrarian predictions. And it is also very rare to have him on an extended
podcast. Michael, welcome to the Master Investor podcast. And thanks so much for joining us.
Yeah, thanks very much for having me with pleasure to be here. A great to be with you here in London
to two Brits that have spent lots of time in New York, but connecting here. I also failed to say
in the intro, you coined the phrase magnificent seven. I did. I did. I did. You know, I did it by luck than
judgment. I always thought that was a Jim Kramer coinage. And I in my research for this have corrected
myself on. Yeah, yeah. No, no, no, he's actually once come up to me and congratulated me on that.
Because he'd done Fang, which was a sort of short live breed assessor. Yes, yes. And yours has
lasted much longer. Yeah, seems to have. I mean, you know, remember with the magnificent seven,
only two of them, you know, were alive at the end. So, you know, we'll see we'll see where that
packs out. Well, I was going to say as part of this conversation, maybe we'll explore as to whether
it will be still the key moniker for the next five years or not. And we can unpack that. And
but to start with, if we could just set the scene of sort of not not not all of time, but of this
decade that we're halfway through so far. And you've written about this over a period of time,
but this decade you think is is very much been shaped by the response to COVID.
Yes, I mean, I think this is a decade of extraordinary change. Certainly, you know, comparable,
I would say the only recent comparison is probably the 1980s, you know, in that you have
big things happening, you know, and big things changing. So we've gone from a world of globalization
to deglobalization. We've gone from a world of monetary excess to fiscal excess. We've gone
from peace to war, elitism in terms of our politics to populism. So there's a lot of sort of new
stuff that, you know, the market and the economy has had to, you know, digest. And I think that
all of those things, you know, have created a backdrop for financial markets of an economy
that is booming in nominal terms. I mean, the US in particular, I mean, the US is a massive economy.
Yeah. And yet that massive economy has grown, I kid you not 66% in six years. I mean, the US
has added three united kingdoms in terms of GDP in the past six years. And again, it's driven
by the fiscal excess, nominally. So you've got growth and inflation, which is very important
point to make. And that's why profits, obviously, have done quite well. So I think that right now,
we're just in this steady state. I mean, it's not steady, but an unsteady state, if you like,
of nominal boom. And of course, that in turn has created an environment where people don't want
to own bonds and only want to own equities. Yeah. It's had a pronounced impact on asset
allocations we've gone through the decade. And just to, by the way, to pick up on that, a reminder,
for this episode, we do have some charts for our viewers. If you're listening and want to watch,
there'll be some charts that sort of pair up at times, including that nominal GDP growth to what
Michael's saying, but no need to move if you are listening. And I guess part of what's driven
that that huge nominal growth and accompanying inflation has been the stimulus that came out of
COVID. And that stimulus was what initially, monetary and also fiscal picking up the slack during
that process, fiscal stimulus was well throughout. Yes, I mean, I think, you know, as you remember back
in, you know, the global financial crisis, we responded to that primarily through monetary policy,
quantitative easing, zero rates, negative rates. We didn't, 20 years ago, never heard of this,
this stuff, but that became the norm. But it wasn't fiscal spending, you know, the UK, Europe,
you know, it was still sort of very much trying to balance your budget, especially you can't.
COVID changed that, you know, like you say, there was an enormous monetary response, enormous,
enormous. But at the same time, that was joined, you know, by fiscal policy. And again, I think
COVID obviously was the catalyst for it. But again, I think the rise of populism contributed to that
because there was a big political, we've got to stop the populace from getting power. So we've
got to find ways to spend, to keep the electorate happy. And the other part of it obviously was the
geopolitics is the, you know, war's cost money. So, you know, that was another side of it that
also added to the fiscal excess. But, you know, as I said, all of it is contributed to probably,
you know, you think of the great investment trends this decade. One is ABB, anything but bonds.
The other one is obviously AI, you know, and that's probably, you know, they are connected,
you know, in a big way. I mean, to a certain extent, the rise of the Mag 7 was because nobody wanted
to hold government bonds. I don't want the government balance sheet. They spend like drunk and
sailors. Why do I want a lens of them? I'd rather the lens of the, you know, I'd rather put my
money with companies that have tons of cash and, you know, don't spend any of it. That was the
Mag 7. And I guess just to dwell on that, that what you would expect has happened in the market.
IE equities, particularly those AI companies have done incredibly well. And that's 66% growth in
nominal GDP. And bonds, particularly long bonds, have been the government side of the normal,
have done very poorly. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, the question becomes, you know, can that continue
indefinitely? You know, is there a yield? Is there a cost of capital that impedes that AI
capex story? Because let's not forget that the, you know, the Mag 7, the hype scale is whatever
you want to call them. Part of the reason to say they're magnificent is because they made
magnificence amounts of cash and didn't spend any of it. You
know, now, you know, they're spending a trillion plus a year on AI capex and their negative cash
flow to the tune of, you know, 200 billion. So that's, you know, the bond market now becomes,
they have to be kind of subservient to the bond market. You know, the bond market pushes up yields
or spreads too much. You're not going to get the spending. So, there's lots of things to unpack
there. And I think the first one I just want to kind of dwell on, on one of these big, big shifts,
has been the rise we've seen in yields, which as you said, the turning point might have been a
few years ago, but I think the acceleration has been more recent. Gage for me, Michael, the scale
of the recent increase in yields. And I guess the impact we've seen, but perhaps not seen yet,
I mean, is it underwhelmed that the sell-off inequities you might have expected to see in relation
to such a sharp spot? Yes, I mean, I think, I was thinking, you know, try and keep things super,
super simple. You know, markets, it's about interest rates and earnings. That's it. You know,
if the UK budget, which is coming up, impacts interest rates or corporate earnings, it matters.
If it doesn't, it's irrelevant, you know, so the so but the point of many
that is that you are absolutely right, the cost of capital zero, you know, 2020 and it's now five, you know, plus.
And yet the stock market is close to a record high. How is that possible? Well, it's possible because of the earnings.
You know, that you haven't reached a level of yields, a cost of capital that is compromising the ability of the US corporate sector to make money.
There will be a moment when you get there, but we're obviously not there yet. That's one answer.
The other answer is actually it has, you know, and when we've seen, I mean, 2022 being a great example, when you see a disorderly rise in interest rates, and I think that's what you're referring to more recently.
It's suddenly, it was so disorderly that Bessent has to come in double buybacks on bonds or intervene in currency markets because five percent is the mashing online.
They do not want the tenure treasuries to exceed, you know, five percent, and that's when they intervene and they panic and do things.
So clearly that move to five percent under the hood of the market has caused a tremendous amount of pain and a lot of pain in fixing, you know, because of the flattening of the yield curve, but in the equity market as of last week.
Or sort of early sort of early mid late September, you had more than half the companies in the S&P that were trading below their 200 day moving average. So there is, it has caused pain, but at an index level, unless you hit the big stuff, you know, the index is going to stay relatively high.
And we just unpack that the first explanation that you just just mentioned of when bond the yields rising should or shouldn't hit equities and essentially your point there being at the moment, it's risen, but all of these companies are still able to continue to grow their earnings, it hasn't derailed the economy, which I totally get.
At the same time, you could say the alternative for people who might buy equities or bonds, bonds has got a lot more attractive.
And yet the earnings growth on offer from these companies hasn't got more attractive, it might not collapse, but hasn't got more attractive.
So to what extent does that in all the investors you speak to enter their psyche, I mean, I have to say it really enters my psyche, like I graduated in 2008, could not put any money to work without taking risk until recent years.
And now I can, yeah, it's very attractive, but I don't think many people think like I do, they don't.
So that is not really, it's not really relevant that there's this attractive risk, yes, look, I think that there is a huge amount of money that would very happily, you know, take the gains that they've had in equities and park that.
In a five-year tea bill or a six percent ten-year yield.
And, you know, I would say certainly there is a large body of investors that are waiting for a level, a moment, a catalyst to say, I can now shift from here, shift to there.
Is it an election? Is it a recession? Is it a bubble bursting? You know, there was potential catalysts to say yields are coming down.
The problem is that you still have this huge psyche, which is this is not 1980, 1979.
You know, 1980, 1979, you had a society that said, I am sick of this inflation, I'm sick of being able to, not being able to afford things, I'm sick of the strike, I'm sick of this government, you know, I want something completely different.
I don't care if it's a grossest or I don't care if it's a Hollywood actor, I want people that will reduce, you know, the deficit, reduce the spending and get interest rates lower.
And that was a huge inflection point. And right now, there is not yet a sense that you have not just the politicians, but also the electorate that is willing to vote for people that want to do things, government things that will make bond yields more attractive.
Because why, you know, people will say, you know, you're not yields are not going to go up to in a disorderly well, they'll stop that, but to argue that you've got 200 basis points of declines in yields ahead of you, you kind of need a bigger, bigger signal than you've got right now to generate that outcome.
And so the buy signal for long bonds, government bonds would be government saying we're going to aggressively cut spending.
Well, last year was douche, you know, the first six months of Trump was was was pretty decent for bond returns. And people were sort of like, you know, this looks interesting.
You know, you've got a real someone who's really sort of attacking the debt attacking the deficit. I think the interesting transition for Trump year two is, you know, it's not Department of government efficiencies, Department of government, you know, let's have a boom, let's have a bubble.
You know, that that that that's become much more of the mantra. And of course that's one of the reasons why he's in a little bit of trouble politically, right, because, you know, his inflation and approval is very, very poor.
But again, I think it's it's fine sort of this prime minister or this president. Maybe it's just that we're too close still to COVID and an event where we needed a government.
And the government came, we fell down the government picked us up and we liked that. We, you know, we felt good about that. And I think, you know, that's still in the psyche.
That's why people say we don't need to save, you know, because why, you know, if there's a rainy day, the government will come in and, you know, give me an umbrella.
So I feel that the market in its entirety is not yet convinced that you're at this major secular inflection point.
You were inequities in 2008, you know, as you say, you were in 2016 when we have Brexit Trump in terms of commodities.
Those were regime changing years, but people don't yet think that 2026 is going to be a regime changing year for bonds. This episode is brought to you by LSEG, the leading global financial markets infrastructure data and analytics provider. To learn more about how LSEG connects businesses, investors and markets worldwide, visit lseg.com.
This episode of the master investor podcast with Wilfred Frost is sponsored by BMI investments, a trusted partner for many delivering financial solutions to investors and institutions worldwide.
This sponsorship does not constitute financial advice.
Just final question on these bonds and recent action. Is 5% the right level for Scott Besson to have got worried about? Is it the same level that you get worried about?
Well, half of what I do is listen to smart clients and half of what I do is just watch prices in the market. And it's not me thinking 5% is a magical level. It's just an observation that when you look at the fixed income markets, and as we've done in recent years, a couple of times in the US, you approach that 5% level.
And at the same time, let's just call it really yields are approaching 3%. And at the same time, the yield curve is starting to invert, which we're very close to doing.
A couple of events could happen in 48 hours. The market says financial conditions are too tight. You start to get a sell-off in stuff that's very sensitive to interest rates, the small cap, the reats.
But the trick right now is, as we said earlier on, the magnificent 7 are much more sensitive to interest rates than they are. So if you think about Besson, if you think about Trump, if you think about War, the two drivers of the US economy, AI CapEx.
And if you like the K-shaped consumer, the double case. And how do you destroy those 6, 7, 8% yields? Because then the AI companies can't borrow to do the AI CapEx.
And you really hurt the wealth effect that's been so strong via the equity market.
So for their domestic objectives, there's also geopolitical objectives, because there's one geopolitical objective which is the beat China AI.
They cannot allow a disorderly move in the bond market to a certain extent. That's why I feel that they'll succeed because they'll do anything they can to prevent that.
But they can't necessarily manipulate as well as if voters basically vote against AI.
So the ball street threat is bonds. The main street threat is voters. Those are the two things that you can break the AI CapEx and break the K-shaped economy.
I guess the question, though, to follow up on that is the extent to which the direction of travel, even without 6% or 7% yields or voter.
change in sentiment. It's whether there's already a change in direction of travel of what's
happening with those Magnificent 7 and the AI companies. You've been talking a lot about this
about the cash generation compared to CapEx. Yeah, I mean, you know, the numbers of the numbers.
I mean, you know, next year the MagSet from the hyperscalus will spend, you know,
1.2 trillion on CapEx. You know, you go back three, four years ago, it was 100 billion.
You go back three, four years ago, they were making 300 billion in in free cash flow. Now,
you know, next year will be minus 200 billion. So, you know, that is a big change, a big,
you know, reversal. And again, it's the markets pick up on that. And that's why spreads have started
to widen and and and CDS. You know, these these are all the fixed income markets, basically saying
you know, as the vigilantes, you know, whenever they see a balance sheet that suddenly is
like, watch it, be careful. You know, don't go too fast. You know, and that's kind of what the
bond market is saying. But, you know, at the same time, and again, if if there is a disorderly
move in bonds, that's really when you don't want to own, you know, this stuff, it can get very,
very dangerous. But what's fascinating is a year ago, October 29th, the MagSet has a group peaked.
What happened on October 29th last year? The Fed cut rates. They cut rates. The market said,
you're cutting rates with this, this stuff at all time eyes. You're not serious about inflation.
You know, you cut rates, you lose the long end, inflation will pick up, blah, blah, blah. Yeah.
So they lost credibility. Fast forward a year later or a week ago, what did the MagSet
have to do? They broke out to you. They finally got up. What did the Fed do? It hiked rates. So,
I don't think central banks ever run out of ammunition, ever. But they can run out of credibility.
And so I think recently, you know, coming back to your original question, why hasn't the
the yields and the rates done more damage? It's partly because the Fed has now been forced to do
things to restore its credibility. You restore your credibility. You're not going to lose the long end.
If you don't use the long end, the AI CapEx story can continue. How big a portion of the index
has the broader AI trade got relative to the past? Well, if you take, if you look at the long history of
stock markets and bubbles and what a characteristic of a when it's about to pop,
one of the back of the envelope calculations that you can do is 40%. If you go back to
the tech bubble in 2000, tech was 40% or TMT was 40% of the S&P 500 market cap. Nifty 50.
Exactly the same peak, 73, 74, 40% Japan, late 80s. It became 40% of the global equity market.
And that was the end. I think you can go back to the 2020s. And the sectors that were driving it
in dustreels, cars, all that sort of stuff, 40% of the peak. And today, the AI 10
is 40%. And you look at that chart and it's like, you know, you're just playing for a bubble.
You're playing for a last thrust. You know, higher. You shouldn't be going all in at this particular
levels. But the one exception, of course, is the railroads. In the railroads in the 1880s,
peaked at 63%. I think it was as a share of the S&P 500. And so, you know, the bulls will say,
yeah, it's bubble-ish. It's got characteristics, you know, valuation, momentum, retail,
participation, all these sort of things. But number one, you have seen one that got much,
much bigger, which was, you know, the railroads. And it's comparable to what's happening today.
And you know, if you look at what happened with the railroads, you know, what kind of ended it
with social upheaval. Yes, the wonderful story, I'm not wonderful story, the one of a Pullman,
you know, the Pullman coach is. And he was part of this sort of big expansion of the railroads.
But if you go to Chicago, you know, his grave is in a Chicago cemetery, but it's buried under,
you know, 15 feet of cement, because when he died in '83, '93, after all the Pullman strides,
the family was so concerned about people attacking his grave. So that's a kind of a social upheaval
that can happen when an industrial revolution creates enormous inequality and a lot of worker
strife. I don't think we're there yet. But the other thing that pops, bubbles and booms and bulls, is bonds.
I guess what comes from that for me, though, is 40% of the S&P, but not yet 60%, were in bubble-like
territory, but it bubbles can keep expanding. And, you know, you can play that game if you want to.
What about momentum, though? I mean, maybe it's more sort of thinking about now, but in those moments
where 40% was enough, did they sort of tail off, like we've seen in the last year? And what's
been happening under the surface? It depends. It depends. Again, I think the common, the big common
galaxy. I mean, obviously there's a retail sort of main, you know, you know, go for the course. But the big commonality is, is bonds.
So I'm probably going to get my numbers vaguely wrong here. But roughly, if you look at what JGB yields did
in 89, if you look at what Treasury yields did in 99, if you look at what Treasury yields did in 73, yeah.
You've probably got a trough to peak move of around about 200 basis points. And eventually, you know, the
stock market is like, oh my god, you know, look at where interest rates are. A bubble is kind of when, you
know, most of the time in a bull market, bear market, whatever it is, the bond market is the master. And
the equity market is the servant. In a bubble, it's the opposite way round that the stock market suddenly becomes
the dominant player. And the bond market is sort of reacting to the equity market, you know, Bank of
America, you know, in 2019, I work, work, work for, you know, Merrill Lynch, World Financial Center, small lobby.
In all our infinite wisdom, we had this gigantic inflatable bull in the lobby of the World
Financial Center. And we had the head of Treasury trading was called Tommy. He was known Tommy T-Bills
with his nickname. And I remember going down, squeezing past this inflatable bull and Tommy's like,
you know, New Jersey Square, you know, he's just got out and he's looking up at this and you know,
I said, hey, you know, he told me how are you doing? And he just was shaking his head and just said,
we're screwed, you know, or New Jersey was that effect. And he was right because three months later,
you had completed that journey up to a level of real rates and nominal rates on the equity market,
just said, can't handle it. Buff, you know, down you come. But, you know, Japan, it was more of a
process, but most of them is a sort of peak and a dramatic fall thereafter.
Hi guys, it's Will. I hope you're enjoying this episode. Just a quick reminder to please hit
follow or subscribe on your podcast or video app so that you never miss an episode. And if you've
got time, please do give us a five-star rating and leave us a comment. It really helps other people
find the podcast too. Now, back to the episode. What else has been going on under the surface of the
non-tech part of the S&P 500 over the last year and the last few weeks? You mentioned the breadth,
you mentioned the sort of small cap stocks. And what do you draw from that?
Well, I think that the confidence in the persistence of a boom and the unlikeliness of a recession,
which I think a year ago, you know, partly the trade war, but I think also a year ago, I think,
if you remember, you were starting to get the first stories of here comes AI and here comes a huge
dislocation of the labor market. And even people like myself were just saying, look at youth
unemployment. It's kind of like, you know, and it's still high. But I think what happened in,
you know, 2026 was that the breadth story gained credence because you didn't have that labor
market dislocation and you didn't have, you know, a trade war causing a recession. You haven't
even had a war, you know, creating a recession. So people have become a lot more confident in the
ability of the economy to remain resilient. And so, yeah, you know, we've already got 40 percent
in like seven stocks. I mean, let's have a look at the other 493. And so I think you have seen
the broadening. Now, the bulk of it is the banks and the healthcare, yeah. And the reason for that
is because the AI cycle has moved.
from the spenders two, three years ago,
which is the Mag Seven,
to the builders, which was last year,
the semiconductors, all the people that go
to make the data centers to the adopters.
And of course, the adopter is anyone with a huge tech budget.
And that's the banks and healthcare.
So part of the broadening has also been an AI story,
if you like.
It's just the next sort of phase of it.
But yeah, I think there are also, you know,
people have said, like, if you look at small cap,
I mean, hopefully we'll talk about it,
even if you look globally international.
There are stories there.
And they're unloved, you know, no one's there.
And you don't want to be over concentrated in one theme.
And so I think, you know, that has been one of the factors
that has led to a broadening.
But last couple of weeks,
that move that you keep on talking about,
that moving yields has really hurt the reats,
the banks, you know, the duration stocks,
you know, the small cap and so on and so forth.
So, you know, it's been a story that's been negative.
And do you, when you see those moments,
the last couple of weeks,
what, like how many more weeks of that,
do you have to see till you start changing your calls?
Are you worried by what you're seeing?
No, because I think that they're panicking.
And I think that they'll win.
You know, I don't think that you'll see, you know,
the five-year treasury, the 10-year treasury,
sort of whizz, you know, through 5% up to 6%.
I think that, you know, we also have this phrase,
you know, "Market stop panicking when central banks
or policy makers start panicking."
And, you know, I think, you know, the intervention
and the buybacks and all this sort of stuff,
they're starting to panic.
The Joker is the election.
And just dwell on that point about central banks, though.
So they, in the last week,
reestablished their credibility enough
and signaled enough that they will step in,
essentially, when they have to. Temporarily, yes.
You know, the proof of the pudding, you know,
will be if, you know, the inflation picture,
you know, starts to worsen again.
And, you know, the stock market,
you know, starts to worry about that
or the impact on financial conditions
and the economy sort of, you know, starts sort of rolling over.
If they then raise raise, that's extraordinarily credible.
You know, but, you know,
I think there is still this residual sort of thought
that they're much quicker to cut than they are to hike.
Because at the end of the day, they know
that the stock market is too big to fail.
You cannot allow the stock market to fail
because of not just the economic
or the financial consequences of that,
but possibly also the social
and political consequences of that.
So I, you know, comes back to what we were saying earlier.
It's very tough to buy, to look at bonds.
You know, clearly, no one owns any bonds
or any government bonds.
Yeah, no one owns them.
And so it's very tempting.
But, where's Volker?
You know, where's that guy
that will raise rates into a recession
to just put the inflation, you know,
genie back in the bottle?
And I don't believe, you know,
I just know from the market,
they're not convinced that, you know,
that there's that guy or that lady.
Just in terms of what's worse for the equity market,
is it worse to sort of hike into, you know,
a potentially stagflationary environment
that we could get in the six months ahead
with wars on an oil price is high?
Or is it worse to not and possibly even cut
in that stagflationary environment and lose credibility?
Well, it depends your duration.
I mean, obviously short term not to cut
because, you know, you, you, you,
but I think the key is the long end.
You know, it's not really what the Fed's doing,
it's what the long end is doing.
And the speed with which it's doing it, you know.
So I think that if the Fed is not reacting quickly enough
to inflation, the long end will make it, you know,
which is kind of what we saw in the past couple of months,
you know, you suddenly get the speedy move up in yields
over what's going on, you know.
And people are forced to deliver it, which is what happened.
But, you know, longer term without question,
you want a credible, you know, central bank
because without a credible central bank,
you've got no anchor for the long end.
You know, so it kind of depends, you know,
the duration with which you're looking for the market.
But one last additional point to here, wealth,
which is the, the, the, the, the, the really interesting one.
And this is where you get, you know,
you, you go to the railroads and you've got me, you know,
and you know, you know, legitimate megabet balls.
Yeah, it's just forget about it, you know,
it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it's just
beginning it's a, the megabets are more about the long end
of the yield curve, you know, that, that, you know,
if you get the economy rolling over, the stock market rolling
over, oil rolling over, and yields don't budge,
they don't come down.
That's what people, that, that's what the macro,
that, that would just send the macro people
into a complete sort of tizzy because then they would be,
you know, massively short bonds and they'd be massively
short equities at the same time because suddenly your release
valve is not there.
You, you, you've got no automatic stable.
If you can't make yields go down, and the reason you wouldn't
is because the bond market is saying, if we're going into
recession, that deficit of 6% of GDP is going to 12th.
And what's your, what probability do you put on that?
Low probability on that doomsday?
I mean, I think that, I mean, it's not negligible just
because of the environment we're in of war and deglobalization
and, you know, it's just disrupted capital flows.
I mean, it's, it's, it's non, not negligible.
I mean, you know, I, I don't think it's 50%.
But it's probably 20%.
Yeah, 15, 20%.
Let's say it's significant, though.
This episode is sponsored by the World Gold Council,
the global experts on gold.
They champion gold as a trusted strategic asset provided
market leading research to help investors understand
gold's role and modernize how gold is
owned, traded, and used, developing industry standards
and market infrastructure.
Learn more at goldhub.com.
This episode is sponsored by Interactive Brokers.
Building wealth starts with the right broker.
An Interactive Brokers helps you reach your goals
with powerful tools, global market access, low costs,
and unmatched financial strength.
That's why the best informed investors choose IBKR.
Learn more at IBKR.com/masterinvestor.
He's often your people say midterms aren't that important.
Bit of volunteers, you come out to set sail again afterwards.
You're alluding to the fact that you think this is much
more significant than your typical midterms.
Yes, I mean, look, Trump comes by executive order.
He's not that partial to being told what to do by Congress.
It's a midterms.
It's not a presidential election.
It doesn't feel, as I said, as though it's a regime change.
If you're in 1980, that's a Reagan.
End of inflation start of a great bull market in bonds.
2016, you get Brexit, Trump.
End of globalization start of a great bull market in commodities.
And as I said, the midterms are not being fought over the deficit.
So I don't think you've got a, you know, if you like today,
it's, you know, you think you've like Trump and Mandarmy,
you know, meeting the other day.
Trump is a sort of direct descendant of the Tea Party, really.
And Mandarmy is a direct descendant of Occupy Wall Street.
You know, that's the lineage populist, capitalism,
and populist socialism.
But they're both populists.
And populists want to be popular.
And that's why, you know, they continue spending money.
And of course, the people, the UK, you know,
Germany, France, or whatever, they're busy spending money
to keep the populists on the outside.
You know, they, you know, they'll spend as much as they can
without disrupting the bond market.
It's like you want to keep the vigilantes inside the tent
and the populist outside of the tent.
So there, you can see, you know, when you see these leaders
talking to cameras, you know, there's on the one hand,
it's like, I got a please, you know, mainstream,
but I don't want to.
a Wall Street, you know, you can see this sort of dilemma that they've all got. But, you
know, I think the midterms where they become interesting is in two ways. One is the more
obvious way, you know, the Republicans lose the Senate as well as the House. Then the
implications, future implications for tax, deregulation, direction of travelers you like
to say change. And that's not good for earnings, you know, medium term. And you also sort of
lose your sort of, if you like, your cheerleader in chief in terms of the stock market, you know,
Trump wants the market to go up and feels that there is virtue in that. And, you know, he's
obviously right in the, you know, it tends to make the economy good. You know, I think there
is a legitimate, I want to get young people in the stock market, you know, that's how we'll
solve the, you know, there's some, you know, some decent, you know, ideas behind that. But,
you know, if you've got no political capital, it's very difficult for him to bully, you
know, people into the market. So, you know, if they lose the Senate, yeah, I mean, I think
the stock market's going to probably dip, probably 10% in the following sort of two,
three months. Similarly, if I think the GOP holds the Senate, you're going to get this
big pile on and the market's going to, you know, move into that bubble phase pretty quickly.
The race, though, that everyone, or the, you know, shouldn't say smart people. But like,
you know, the people, you know, smart money's sort of watching is the Texas governor race.
Texas is Texas. It's Republican state, Republican governor, very popular, you know, governor
has been for two, three terms, Abba. He's created the conditions for a massive economic boom
in Texas. You know, a lot of the tech money's come in there. He's opening, you know, AI data
centers like there's more, no, no tomorrow. I mean, you know, winner winner chicken dinner.
How can he lose? I mean, you know, he's up against someone that's no, no, a Democrat
that nobody's ever heard of. And yet they're neck and neck in the polls. Oh, he's at 48.
She's at 45. Why, why is she at 45? She's got one issue. Stop the data center expansion.
Mm-hmm. And that's it. And, and so much so that to stop the decline in his polls, you know,
one of the champions of AI data center, Abba, as basically said, we've got to have a moratorium.
We've got to pause it. Do you see what it means? So again, coming back to the railroads and
Pullman and the electorate, you know, they can control the bonds, but they can't control the
voters. And if the voters now, and again, I doubt Texas is going to, you know, go, you know,
Democrats, so we have some doubts about that. But were it to then it becomes much more of a regime
change election? And, and do you feel like there's a regime change possible? Where's your
probability on it? In this tech trade, this AI trade? Obviously, if the Democrats win big,
in November, you know, that sends a signal to the presidential candidates, you know,
they start running in January, February, they're going to be running on stop the data centers. So,
yeah, I mean, I think it's, it really would be a major, you're to your major reversal in big tech.
I think you'd probably see a major reversal in the dollar, you know, to, I mean, it doesn't matter
what my probability is, you know, who cares what I think. But if you look at Polymarket right now,
it's a 60% probability of that, although the probability that Abbott loses the governorship
of Texas is much, much lower. So I think people are starting to worry about it, think about it,
but they're not going to act on it until they're absolutely sure it's going to happen.
I guess my question, though, as well as absent that, do you think this regime change for
the stock market away from the AI trade is, is somewhere off? No, no, no, no, no. I think, again,
I think if they, if I'm right, that they can hold the line at 5%, I think that re-insensivizes
it. I think right now, people are, they're clearly long equities and they've got no bonds, yeah.
But what they've done within their equities is try and play breadth, which has been legitimate,
it's been right, you know, for much of the last year. I worry that, you know, all of this stuff
war that a little, I worry that actually the next move in equities, it is going to be much more
concentrated. It's back to that, you know, AI only, you know, feel to it because of what's
going on in the long end. That's my belief. Let's touch on something. But again,
as a critical, the elections for them. Let's touch on some of the other areas that you've been
seeing opportunities and do commodities first. As you said, been a great run for commodities
for a decade or so, it's taken off in particular in the last 12 months. You generally bullish
commodities still. Yeah, look, a gold, you know, get some right, get some wrong, but again,
I think there's a hedge against populism, a hedge against anarchy, a hedge against debasement.
You know, I think all of those things are legitimate reasons that you have to have gold
in your portfolio. If you don't want gold and, you know, you're young like you are rather
old like me, it would be crypto or something like that. But. But you've been a belong goal for a long time
and you've been right. It was very nice of you to say so, but I, I mean, but did you want to take
some off the table of 5,000? Did you want to take some off the table of 5,000? Oh, yeah, yeah.
And again, after that happened, we said it's not going above 5,000 before the midterms. I mean,
I think that the way you got to in terms of positioning and, you know, silver and gold trading,
you know, X percent above is two. It was just too frothy, right? And the frosts now come out.
But I think there are still, you know, those reasons that I touted legitimate reasons,
it will go back above 5,000. You know, I think that that's very likely. And I think just commodities
generally, if the AI CapEx boom, you know, continues to be a big stimulant, you know, so far as growth
is concerned, it's not disrupted by the bot, you know, the bond market, you know, AI,
you know, consumes commodities, right? Just absolutely coming. This is why America's foreign
policy is about resource, natural resource monopolization, Greenland, Venezuela, Iran. I mean,
how can you, what's going on? Well, what's going on is that America needs to be China AI and
therefore needs to, you know, monopolize colonizers, many sort of resources as it can around the world.
So I think that, you know, one of the things we've observed about this decade is
what wins is what's in short supply, not necessarily in high demand. But commodities are in
short supply. And yeah, I think that commodities will do, you know, continue to very well as an
asset class. They're in a secular bull market and it'll continue. And what about energy, which is
obviously done very well in light of the, there are more this year. If we get peace deals,
does that correct or is there still? Of course. I think so, but it's gone to the stage where,
you know, people are almost thinking that, you know, there may be sort of longer term damage done
in terms of, you know, Russian supply or Middle Eastern supply such that, you know, partly again,
you know, if America, you know, as America think its beats China AI, well, if the world is totally
dependent on US energy, maybe Latin American, some of Latin American energies, well, the Monro
sort of doctrine, it wins again. But again, I think that to get to a place where
that's the only source of energy, you know, oil prices go right to be, you know, they'll hit
200 before they, you know, come back down again. So, it's very political energy, clearly. You know,
there are a lot of politics, geopolitics involved, less so with gold, less so if you like with
the industrial metals. But yeah, again, again, I think that it will continue to outperform as a
theme commodities. I do think that's the case. Small caps and the breadth argument. Talk us
through where your level of conviction is on that, that's the moment. I love it longer term.
You know, I love commodities. You know, I love, you know, but I also want to participate in
deep contrarian areas. China, bonds, real estate. And I think, you know, up until a year ago, you know,
I'd have thrown in small caps with that as well. So I'm a fan of small cap. I really, really like
small cap tank because I think that, you know, if you remember in, you know, when the Nifty 50,
which is kind of like a decent, many of them things, 1999, it's the only bubble that ever happened.
But actually, the Nifty 50 is probably a better analogy for the Mag 7, the AI 10 and so on and so forth.
You know, everything got crushed. But then after, the adoption of technology was really, really,
you know, strong in the late 70s. It's the start of the personal computers and start
like that. And small cap tech had one of the greatest bull markets of all time. So I think
that where you can find people that can adopt a AI grow from very small to very big because
of it. Fantastic. So I think that that's going to be a very, very good story. But generally
I think that again, the irony of everything I was saying right at the beginning, globalization
to isolationism and monetary policy to fiscal policy, all these sort of stuff, it kind of
hasn't worked. Like you've still got a lot of the electorate that's really angry, you
know, which is what you were meant to be doing all this stuff for. And so I think more will
need to be done there. And part of doing that I think is good for smaller, you know, companies
you have to carry, you know, and you can see it from, you know, any electorate right now
is kind of like, I'm the prime minister of president. I'm going to give all the money
to the big company and none so I don't think about it. What are you crazy? Do you see what
I mean? So I think that the policy will be skewed towards those guys as well. But short
time you're saying it's kind of done all right already, the small cap theme or one that
takes off. You depend it last couple of weeks. It's got, you know, hit very hard because
of this rising yields. But again, if they can hold the line at 5% small cap or be a winner,
the state will be a winner. You know, some duration in X, Y and Z will be a winner. And
yeah. So I think I would stay winner international as in world X US still still very attracted to
that. Yeah. I mean, 18 months ago, you know, we said by international, it's worked in fits
and starts, you know, it was Europe first and then there was a bit of EM this year. It's
been Asia. So, you know, it sort of works in fits and starts. But I think, you know, your
starting point is, you know, US equity market. It's no longer 70%. But it was almost 70%
of the entire world stock market. You know, if you're going to be overweight, you'll be
at 75. I mean, it's just so I think the opportunity set has just grown. There are themes.
You know, there's European defense. There's Korean Taiwanese, you know, Japanese technology.
There's Chinese AI. There's resources in Latin America. You can just have a much more
diversified global basket. And of course, you know, whether you like Trump or you don't
like Trump, you know, you get, if you want to go man or man or with him, you better bring
your A game and the A game is a confident economy that's doing well. And so, you know, Trump
has sort of spurred this fiscal spending elsewhere, you know, the Germans are now spending,
you know, has an happen for a long, long period of time. So I think that global rebalancing
fit theme is still supportive. So yeah, the biggest contrarian call is long bonds without
question. Probably the second is long China. But I think a lot of the stuff that was in
secular bear markets, the international, the small cap. Yeah, I think they've reversed
commodities and that will continue. So but going back to your framing of regime shifts,
is that opportunity big enough and some of the probabilities of rolling over in the US
big enough that we're in a regime change where people should be thinking non-US really
meaningfully for the next five years? I think the short answer is yes. And again, part
of that's the dollar. And I think that part of that's the debt and the deficit and the
spending of the US. And unless there is a regime change in debt and deficits and spending,
it's very difficult in a world where, you know, the US needs foreign capital. And you're
doing things in the world, whether it's, you know, the Europeans. And again, I live in
the States. You've lived in the States. You know, and I do that the perception of America
can be very warped outside America. It's very different from really what's going on
on there. But you know, perceptions matter. And, you know, clearly there has to be some
investors in the Middle East and some investors in Europe, which is like, why do we keep feeding,
you know, the beast and, you know, it only needs less of that. And suddenly you're much
more reliant on Japan or Taiwan or career. And you know, that's why you've had the intervention.
So I think they're on thinner ice in terms of financing the debt. And therefore, one
way what you have to do to finance the debt is make the dollar cheaper. And so the dollar
going down is an opportunity to have, you know, more in international. So yeah, I think we're
in still early stages of that. But again, it's not going to be America going down 20 percent
and the rest of the world going up 20 percent. That never happens. These are correlated
markets. It's just a, you know, better performance from, from the international.
It's interesting to say that because it also going back to what you said earlier that,
you know, where's the Volker, the person that's going to aggressively hike into a slowing
economy and they don't seem to be there yet. But to your point about the dollar and monetizing
the debt, it's almost as if we're just five years away from that point and that we've
got to go through the 70s first and really, look, inflate away the debt, I mean, hit the
nail on there. I mean, it's, I mean, look, you're absolutely right. The way that the
Trump administration, and again, they may be right. But the way that they are saying,
this is how we reduce debt is via growth. It's via a boom, you know, you've got debt,
you've got GDP, you just need GDP to be growing much more faster than the debt, yeah. And
so you get that growth as, as up as, as far as you can, as quick as you can. And that's
kind of been the policy, yeah. But I think again, what you speak to is again, a nagging
doubt that there is everywhere is, will there be this moment where the bond market say
enough is enough, we have to change your ways. If you do not change your ways, you're,
you know, you're going to get more moments saw in the UK in 2022 in the US in 2023. And
again, those moments can be very devastating for an economy built on wealth and an economy
built on AI, you know, capital spending. So I think that I, there's no doubt that I
feel very confident that in coming months, it is in, it is too important for them to fail
in terms of stabilizing yields. But of course, there is that nagging doubt that if you make
an error and something breaks in the system, yeah, that disorderly final move to the upside
that just is the regime changing level of yields or the regime changing move it in yields
is feasible. And again, I think that's partly why at the end of the day that there is, I'm
long equities, I'm short bonds because in bonds, I'm still worried about that final thrust
higher. And in equities, I'm still worried about that final thrust higher. Do you know what
I mean, I mean, that's kind of like the deep down the psyche is. Michael, it's been an
absolute pleasure. I'm picking your thoughts on markets for the last best part of an hour.
And to round things off as I flagged you in advance, like our school, I guess, what is
your overriding piece of advice for our listeners? I always like the phrase, our phrase which
is by humiliation and cell hubris, which I think you've been touching on. You know, you
know the hubris is US, you know, it's AI, you know, it's tech, you know, that's, so that
and the humiliation has been China, it's been bonds, you know, to a certain extent it's
been, you know, commodities for a while, real estate. So I think when you're thinking
longer term, you know, I'm always really interested in where is the humiliation? What
is everyone not just despise, but just that couldn't give a figure about, you know, just
doesn't get. And what is the catalyst to unlock that? And then what is the most popular
thing that, you know, everyone's talking about, you know, and how does that, you know,
unravel? So yeah, I think that you should always have a piece of your
portfolio that is nibbling at humiliation and, and just taking a little bit of profit
in the hubris. So if you really want a piece of investment advice from a longer term
perspective, it's by humiliation, cell hubris. I adore that. It's a great sort of message
for life, I think, as well. Things are never as good as they feel when it's going well
and nor those bad as they might feel when it's a good point. Well, mate. The nicest
dark Michael Hartnett, what a pleasure it's been to catch up with you on the Master Investor
Podcast. Thanks so much for joining us. Pleasure, Will. Pleasure to be here.
Next up on the Master Investor podcast, we'll be talking to Jim Bianco of Bianco Research
who will be rarely in London as well, like Michael has been. So make sure to hit follow
or subscribe on your podcast app if you haven't done so already. Thanks for listening.
The Master Investor podcast is sponsored by LSEG, Interactive Brokers, the World Goal
Council and BNY investments. Nothing in the
podcasts, constitutes a financial promotion, investment advice or a personal recommendation,
more on that in the show notes.
This podcast is produced by Parading Productions and Master Investor Limited in association
with BirdLine Media.
If you've enjoyed the show, please do subscribe on YouTube or click follow on your
podcast platform and you'll be automatically notified each time a new episode drops.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The "Magnificent Seven" thrived due to massive cash generation and minimal spending, leading to strong equity performance and a flight from bonds.
AI-driven capital expenditure has surged to over $1 trillion annually, creating significant negative free cash flow, making the companies vulnerable to rising bond yields.
Rising bond yields—especially reaching 5%—are now threatening the AI capex model, as higher costs of capital could halt growth and trigger market destabilization.
The market remains unconvinced that 2026 marks a major secular shift, unlike 2008 or 2016, due to a lack of broad political or social sentiment demanding fiscal restraint.
The bond market is increasingly seen as a dominant force, with equities acting as servants; however, a reversal could emerge if political shifts—especially in midterms or elections—trigger policy change.
A 40% share of the S&P 500 in AI-related stocks mirrors past tech bubbles, raising concerns about overvaluation and potential market correction.
The Texas governor race highlights how populist sentiment and anti-data-center policies could signal a shift away from AI-driven spending, potentially reversing tech-led growth.
Long-term structural changes, such as global rebalancing, commodity inflation, and geopolitical realignment, suggest a shift toward international diversification and a reevaluation of U.S. dominance.
Summary:
The decade has been defined by rapid economic shifts—from globalization to deglobalization, monetary to fiscal stimulus, and rising inequality. " These companies generated vast cash without spending, making them highly attractive to investors and causing a historic flight from bonds. However, their current surge in AI capex—now exceeding $1 trillion annually with negative free cash flow—creates vulnerability to rising interest rates.
Bond yields have climbed sharply, reaching 5%, which could disrupt funding for AI investment and threaten the broader equity market. Despite this, the market remains skeptical that 2026 marks a regime shift, unlike past pivotal years such as 2008 or 2016. Political dynamics, especially in midterms and state races like Texas, are emerging as key catalysts—where populist movements may pressure fiscal policy and curtail AI spending.
The market is also showing signs of overconcentration in AI, with parallels to past tech bubbles. Commodity prices, driven by global resource competition and geopolitical tensions, are expected to remain strong. Ultimately, while equities remain dominant, the risk of a major market reversal looms if bond yields rise sharply or political sentiment shifts toward fiscal austerity.
Michael Hartnett concludes with a long-term investment principle: "by humiliation and hubris"—investing in what others overlook (humiliation) while riding the overconfidence of the dominant trend (hubris)—to prepare for inevitable market corrections.
FAQs
The 'Magnificent Seven' refers to a group of tech companies that generated massive cash flows without spending it, making them attractive to investors during a period when government bonds were seen as risky. Their success led to a market shift away from bonds and into equities.
The 'Magnificent Seven' are now spending over a trillion dollars annually on AI CapEx, resulting in massive negative free cash flow. This shift makes them vulnerable to rising interest rates, as higher borrowing costs could disrupt their ability to fund AI investments.
Bond yields are rising due to tightening monetary policy, with central banks hiking rates to combat inflation. However, equities remain strong because AI-driven companies continue to generate strong earnings, making them less sensitive to higher interest rates than bonds.
Yes, 5% is a critical level because it marks a point where bond yields have risen significantly, triggering stress in the bond market. At this level, the bond market may start to push up yields further, threatening AI-driven spending and the broader tech sector.
Political elections, especially midterms, influence bond yields because populist leaders often prioritize spending to maintain popularity. This fiscal expansion can delay yield rises, but if voters push for fiscal restraint, it could lead to a significant shift in bond markets.
Yes, the current market is bubble-like, with AI-related stocks making up 40% of the S&P 500—similar to tech bubbles in the 2000s. This concentration poses risks of a sudden correction, especially if interest rates rise or if investor sentiment shifts.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.