Megan Phelps-Roper discusses leaving the Westboro Baptist Church, interviewing J.K. Rowling and how social media amplifies our worst impulses
1h 24m 45s
Megan Phelps-Roper, a former member of the Westboro Baptist Church, shares a deeply personal journey from religious extremism to advocacy for tolerance. Raised in an environment where the church’s teachings—centered on sin, divine punishment, and hatred of LGBTQ+ people—were unquestioned, Megan gradually questioned the logic and morality of these beliefs. Her experience, marked by painful moments such as her brothers’ suicides, became a turning point. She realized that while the church claimed to follow God’s word, its interpretation was distorted, emotionally damaging, and internally inconsistent. Through social media and personal reflection, she began to see her own judgment as valid, challenging the authority of her family. Leaving the church was not a sudden decision but a slow process of psychological transformation, involving immense difficulty in rebuilding a new life without connections or identity. Megan now runs a podcast exploring the Bible’s teachings to discern what is truly valuable, and she uses her platform to speak about healing, forgiveness, and the possibility of change. Her story illustrates how toxic religious environments can produce profound trauma, yet also how personal resilience and empathy can lead to transformation and hope. The conversation underscores the importance of recognizing internal contradictions, the dangers of unchecked ideology, and the power of compassion in overcoming hatred.
[Music] Hello and welcome to another episode of the Louis Thoreau Podcast. [Music] Today I'm joined by author and podcaster Megan Phelps-Roper, an advocate for tolerance Megan is a former member of the Westboro Baptist Church, a Christian sect widely regarded as a hate group, and by some regarded as a cult. Founded by her grandfather Fred Phelps, the church gained notoriety for staging highly provocative public protests in particular at soldiers' funerals while promoting extreme views on the LGBTQ+ community. I first met Megan while filming my documentary The Most Hated Family in America, released in 2007. I spent three weeks getting to know them, trying to understand them. And why they did the strange things that they did, which they still do, by the way, but more of that in the chat. I met her again for a follow-up film in 2011, when she was still a member, and then the next year she left the church, going on to speak openly about her experience growing up in the family. In 2019 she released a memoir, Unfollow, a journey from hatred to hope, which I highly recommend. She stepped into podcasting with a much-discussed series, titled The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling, for which she interviewed the Harry Potter author. It was a hit, I think. We talk about that in the chat. The reviews were, I think, mainly positive. It's a contentious subject, so, as you can imagine, not everyone was a fan. We recorded this interview in August this year at Spotify HQ. Megan joined me on a rare trip over to the UK. She'd recently released a new podcast called Bookkeeper, in which she returns to the Bible and the stories that shaped her to ask which are worth keeping. We spoke for a few hours. Editor Tom had to hack it down. I'm sure there was a lot of good stuff we couldn't use. We wanted to keep it tight. But stick with the conversation, I really think it goes somewhere interesting. A quick warning, this conversation contains strong language, adult themes and discussion of suicide. Two of Megan's brothers ended their lives after leaving Westboro, which is obviously a deeply distressing subject for Megan. But we talked about it. We also talked about much, much else besides all of that coming up. Welcome. This is fun, isn't it? This is a LTP first, because I've never interviewed an alumnus, an alumna of one of my documentaries. That's not really the right word, but someone who's been in one of my documentaries. The first time we filmed together, well, we were mainly filming at your house, and then we were a student at the time studying law at the University of Kansas, and do you remember we walked around the campus? By now, the church members had learned a little about my life, and they knew that I'd had a child with my partner out of wedlock, a detail which seemed to put me in the firing line. Do you like going to the pickets? Yeah, are you kidding? It must get kind of old though. You don't get tired of all the sins, pursuing your sins in your lust. Do I? It's like, I say you don't, because you keep doing it. Are you talking about me specifically? You or everybody else, you don't get tired of serving your lust, I don't get tired of serving my god. So, should I be killed for having extra marital intercourse? According to the mosaic color? Yeah. Actually, I'm not sure. I think so. I think I know what adultery is. And homosexuality was. You want to see me killed for that? I want to tell you the truth. If I can continue the collegial metaphor, you're like my star pupil. Because when people say like, "a people capable of change," do you ever see people, or if they say like, are there any people that you've made films about that you stay in touch with? You are exhibit A. That's really cool. It's pretty cool. From my perspective, it's cool because it gives me grounds for hope. And I can sort of, I can kind of impart an encouraging message that says people are capable of change and growth, right? Which is actually not really always the case. But people who don't know how would you describe the Westboro Baptist Church? It is a group that is almost entirely, you know, my immediate and extended family. About 70 people? About 70 people. And yeah, they just really believe that their understanding of the Bible is the only acceptable true right version. And on that basis, everything else follows. So, we would go from the time I was five years old and protest every single day, into Pika, Kansas. And then very quickly, that spread, we started a protest across the country. Initially, our targets were gay people and anybody who supported them. But that also, ultimately, like everybody outside of our church was a target. Everybody else was doing wrong. And so, yeah, all of our all of our faculties were in our resources. All of our effort was toward understanding what we thought God required of us and why everybody else was wrong. And chapter and verse memorized it. That was our life. And you came to fame. The church came to fame. Initially, locally, from picketing, a gay cruising spot, a gage park. Which was how your grandfather had first become fixated on. What he perceived as kind of a local problem. And then it kind of built from there to pickets of soldiers. The funerals of soldiers killed in Afghanistan and Iraq. And then that gave the church massive nationwide and then international attention. Explain the logic of picketing the funerals. So, my family would say that, you know, when people go to these funerals, they're, you know, thinking about death and heaven and hell and eternity. And it was our job to go and connect the dots. And for my family, the dots were very clear. The first one was your sin. So, God, you know, has all these commandments, these, you know, things that you're supposed to follow. And you are not following them. You are supporting, you know, gay people, adultery, fornication. And so, we're supposed to connect the dot of your sin to your punishment. And the punishment is, in part, those fallen soldiers. And for us, again, those were intimately connected. They're, you know, immediately and, you know, fully intertwined and obvious that the sin is the cause of this punishment. And obviously, for most people, it's, they don't believe them. They don't, they don't see that connection. They see, you know, their family members went and fought, you know, for the freedoms that we were exercising. So, for us to go there in those moments when people were trying to mourn and say goodbye to these people that they love, obviously, you know, a massive amount of controversy and pain came from that. It's worth reminding ourselves of some of the spicy content, some of the provocative and actually hateful and horrible messaging of the signs, trigger warning or just appropriate language warning. Like, I'm going to use the F-bomb, because I just am, because it's, I think you need the full impact of the terms. The famous one is God hates fags. Fags hate God is another one. Yep. AIDS cures fags, fags burn in health. Thank God for dead soldiers, fag troops. Thank God for 9/11. Don't pray for the USA. Why, that's a confusing one. Why not pray for the USA? God told the Prophet Jeremiah, "Pray not for this people for their good." Like, I've already given them up. They are, I've already been fully turned over to their sin and they love it and they hate me in my message and so therefore, pray not for this people. Just to state the obvious, and this is a theme that comes up a lot in, in your book, it's based on selective selection. Well, it's based on a selective quotation from the Bible, right? I don't doubt you could find a passage in the Bible that said, "Do pray for people." You know, if you're worried about them or, you know. Oh, for sure, I mean. Oh yeah, so it's not, I wouldn't say it's selective because that makes it seem like, "Oh, they're picking and choosing which ones." They're doing what everybody is doing, which is like, they're interpreting. They are trying to make all of the pieces fit together in a way that is cohesive and makes sense. So they're not trying to leave anything out. They're not actively attempting to distort or consciously mislead, but in order to create a coherent quilt of understanding and practice they are having to prioritize certain verses. Well, so when they look and they are comparing the times that we live into the times of Jeremiah, they're saying that verse applies, that idea applies. Whereas if you look at whatever a passage where it says, "Do pray for people," then they would say, "Okay, well, this isn't those times. The U.S. is not going to hear us. We know they won't hear us because we've been preaching all these years and they don't hear us." So that's what I mean. It's the only reason I'm like quibbling with your word selective because for them, it's not selective. It's not like they're casting some verses
side, it is a genuine effort to do the right thing. And that's, you know, for me, that's a hopeful thing. For me, the fact that like even Westboro is trying to do the right thing, like that desire to do good is something that you can tap into. Like if you can find a way, which is what people did with me, they were able to recognize that I had good intentions I was trying to do the right thing. I just was coming from a framework that was so far from how most people see the world. And in tapping into the desire to do good and showing me a different way that was consistent enough, like it enabled to sort of help me find internal inconsistencies in my worldview that made me open to seeing things a different way, that absolutely changed my life. Just to dwell in the kind of the hate, if that's the right term, for a second. Yes, that's what I'm making. Because the obvious thing to think about and what I think most people's minds turn to is, well, how could you be comfortable inflicting pain in that way? Surely just at a human level, your response would be to feel bad. And I reflect on the fact that when I first went to Westboro on day two, we went on a picket of a funeral. And truthfully, it's got to be recalled that oftentimes maybe usually you were quite far back from the funeral. Like there were various ordinances that prevented you from getting very close. So that I could imagine a lot of people came to the funerals and weren't aware. Or if they were aware, it was only because they were driving past picket. But once they're at the funeral, it would be either drowned out or too far away. Nevertheless, when I was there, I remember a car came past that there were 20 or so of you and waving the placards and a window came down. And the woman driver was like, what are you doing? And then I think it was Margie's son, Jacob said, well, we're picketing the funeral. So well, why are you doing that? This is her dad. This is the funeral for her dad pointing to the woman next to her. And Jacob said, well, her father's in hell. And you just saw the girl in the passenger seat kind of crumpled in grief and upset and confusion. And then the window went back up and they drove off. And it was like a vignette for how that pain is conveyed and experienced. And I just wonder whether if that had been you or the people who are there. Does that have any impact? To what extent, if any, are you ever aware of the pain that you're actually causing when you're on those pickets? Well, I mean, so that's one example. I mean, the very first soldiers funeral protest that I went to was in Nebraska. And it was, this was before it was early on. So it was before there were any ordinances. And we were directly across the street. And it was an extremely quiet like residential neighborhood, like where this church was. And, you know, we start, you know, belting out these songs. And it's like echoing off of this church front. You would have been about 15? No, I was 19. 19. Yeah, when we started protesting the funerals, the soldiers funerals, which I should say, like the funeral and sort of like celebration of death and tragedy that was way before the soldiers funerals protests. So, you know, it was something that I had like was just, I was sworn into it. Like how, how we saw it as punishment from God, like just punishment from God. So, you know, and then of course, all those years on the picket line, I was very used to dismissing whatever, you know, pain or frustration, you know, that that people were experiencing. Like we did that as a matter of course. But it was different. This was it was a big change for us when we started protesting those funerals because it was visceral in a way that it hadn't been before. And so I remember going to my mom and, you know, asking like I need to understand why we're doing this. It was, I was genuinely wanting to make sure that we were following what the Bible said. Is this really what we're supposed to be doing? And so I think the answer to your question is like often we were not aware and or dismissive of the pain. But even when we were aware of it, we saw it as essentially, you know, it is collateral damage almost. It's like the pain that you're experiencing now for us to come and tell you and warn you do not follow this person to hell. You know, it's just, it's something that has to happen in order to, like, the pain you experience now is much less than what you would experience if you did follow them and ended up in hell yourself. So we really saw, it's, I know it seems so wild to people to look at that, you know, story for instance, that picture you just painted and think, how could these people possibly believe they're doing the right thing? And yet there is a framework and it's not, you know, it's not like they're just making this stuff up. Like it's in this book that so many people claim to believe and that they believe is the literal infallible word of God. And they take it extraordinarily seriously. You know, I'm not a believer anymore in part because I just, I can't, I can't reconcile some of these ideas in the Bible with things that are good. Yeah, there's a lot of weird stuff in the Bible. I remember you saying that actually was your explanation for why West Rose the way it is. I think you said, like, essentially, Gramps was bad and the Bible is weird. Yeah. Well, I probably stand by that. I don't know about bad, but angry. The Gramps had anger issues. Yeah. And in fact, it's probably worth reflecting on that for a second because so much of this comes from is the trickle down of a single person's personality, that being Gramps, Fred Sr. and, you know, he was born in Mississippi, right? So he comes from an ultra-traditionalist milieu to begin with raised in probably a form of Baptist teaching that wasn't that unusual, but nevertheless would strike us nowadays as extremely narrow-minded. And then, but that collides with, because the conventional wisdom has always been, oh, he's a closet case. Like, he must be, which is so basic and kind of, I don't know, just a reductive to say, like, oh, he, he preaches, and he's a really offensive about, he seems to be fixated on gay people. He must be gay. Like, I don't know about you. Like, that was never my takeaway. Like, I don't think he was a closeted homosexual. No. I think he was genuinely angry. And I think, you know, in prepping for this, I realized for the first time his mother died when he was five. He was given to an aunt to be, to be raised by, then returned to his father, who then remarried. I mean, it's a very chaotic, you imagine losing your mom age five, right? Yeah. Yeah. For starters, it's going to, like, maybe this is armchair psychology, but nevertheless, I would think it would make you angry at the world confused. You lose your foundation. Yeah. But I mean, he was also really accomplished. I mean, he graduated school in his valedictorian. I think he was 16 in the class. He was a golden gloves boxer. He's an eagle scout. Like, he, he wasn't, it wasn't just like his mom died. And he just, you know, fell away into, you know, just became a, well, into or what, though, became a crazy, renting, renting creature. Like, he did a venture. I mean, at the time, at the time, I think things can be, yeah, I used to joke, like, they're like the kind of days of hate, like, about your family, like an attractive, highly accomplished, tightly knit, ambitious family that kind of punched above its weight, headline-wise, influence-wise. Instead of being dedicated to politics and, you know, the Democrat party became avid, avid picketers and, and kind of promoters of, God's supposed wrath against a fallen America. But so on Gramps, it felt like, for whatever reason, he was like, I don't know if he was, he was an angry dude, and temperamentally, just volatile, anger-prone, controlling. I know you, you had, and have, I'm sure, a lot of love for him. But also in your book, you detail how he was physically abusive to his wife, your grandma, physically abusive to his children. So there's a lot going on. Yeah, there is. And there really wasn't anybody to restrain him, you know? That's what I think ultimately, what it comes down to. When I think about how, you know, obviously for the other thing was that he was kind of missing from this narrative is the civil rights work that he did. Right. So he spent decades before the picketing started, and I think if he hadn't lost his license to practice law, he, that would have continued the civil rights work. I think I didn't realize this until I was writing my book, but the timeline is, was kind of wild to realize like months after he lost his license to practice law. He, that incident took place in Gage Park, and the protesting started shortly thereafter. So there was almost like, it replaced, it was like, there was an absence, this vacuum and his life of meaning. Yeah. And when you said earlier, just to connect Sothertod, about like why we were so focused, why gramps was so focused on gay people, they would always say it's because you're so focused on gay people. Gay rights was really coming to the fore in those moments, you know, groups like act up and, you know, the AIDS crisis and all these things were very, you know, commonly talked about and written about in, in the media. And so there was something that they felt like they had to respond to. Like this is a crisis of our times that we need to fight back against. So yeah. And so just, I don't feel like we're playing all the, all the hits.
and maybe that's fine. Why, 'cause the other question would be like, "What, but why do you have to use the word "fag"? Like, why not just say it in a nicer way? You know what I mean? It doesn't say in the Bible, like, "Be rude." You know what I mean? (laughing) Maybe it does, somewhere it probably does, but. - Well, they would say, so at the very beginning, like with the very first big sign said God hates gays. - Yes. - Very quickly. - Which, it's also offensive, but maybe slightly better. (laughing) - Also, so they would say gay is a misnomer. Gay means happy and these people are not happy. They commit suicide at, you know, disproportionate rates and God hates them and, you know, this is not a happy lifestyle. And so the word "fag". Honestly, of course, it has the provocation. - He's gonna say he wouldn't do the thing about, oh, he said it was an elegant metaphor. - A 100%. - It also means sticks the bundles of wood and they're. - They're used for kindling. - And they're kindling and then God's gonna stroke the fires of hell. - Yes, and they stroke the fires of God's wrath. They burn in their lust, one toward another, according to Romans 1, we are playing all the hits. (laughing) It's just, it's so funny to me because I haven't thought about, or talked about some of the stuff for so long and it's just right there. Just like comes, I mean, it's just because, you know, you can't spend all those years talking about something. But yes. - What about Fag Sweden, was a popular sign? - This is actually one of the funniest parts of my book to write because are the way that we went after Sweden, and like, of course, you showed this in your film, how funny it was that we ended up protesting a hardware store that sold Swedish vacuum cleaners because we couldn't actually go to Sweden to protest. - Yes. - And so we turned on, you know, we were protesting it. - We were confusing for the hardware store owners. They must have been like, not enough. - We protested an alcohol distributor who's sold, who's wears included absolute vodka. Like a local performance of a Swedish chamber orchestra. - It's absolute a Swedish vodka. - I think so. - I mean, it's not known that. - This is, I mean, this is all funny. Like, this is what I was told. I guess I have an independent link confirmed. - And the reasoning was because Sweden had imprisoned a - A man for preaching. - For preaching against homosexuality. - Right. - Noah, do you know what Fag troops are? - Yeah. - What? - It's this nation of these facts. - It's this nation of facts. That's what Fag troops are. - It is a nation of facts. That's right. - Wait, wait, wait. You're not gonna let them get away with that whole thing. - I'm not a soldier. - Okay. Fag soldiers. - I'm sort of glad that they don't understand it that much. - Well, you understand, Noah, do you know what else you could be besides a Fag to be in trouble with God and be included in that sign? If you're not just a Fag, but what else? - Sweden. - And. - Swedishian. - And. - Soldiers and. - But what are you if you're not a practicing Fag? What are you? - And what if you support Fags? What does that make you? - You're a Dike. - Your grandfather, Gramps, Fred Sr. also commented, quote, "The King of Sweden looks like an anal copulator." And his grinning kids look slutty and gay. Which became a thing in my family. I would say that's slutty and gay, whatever. I'm laughing because there were moments for sure when we were aware of the extremeness and absurdity. - Absurdity. - Yeah, so we would say like it was cold outside where like God hates winter, that kind of thing. Like we would, you know, tongue and cheek use these things including phrases like slutty and gay. - This is a quote from your book. - By age 11, I was standing on the picket line, exultantly repeating the words I'd heard from Gramps, quote, "Two horrors in a week." I fancied myself cutely counterculture to be reveling in the deaths of two widely beloved women that we had little knowledge of either. Mother Teresa or Diana, Princess of Wales. Diana. I mean, I would never use that term. She was beloved and, you know, life ended tragically. Nevertheless, I mean, I've been regretting starting down this conversational path. - Boy, Mother Teresa. - I mean, she was Catholic and Catholic have all kinds of problems according to the church, though. - I don't think anyone ever called her a whore, though, do you? - Well, they would, okay, it's like it's both physical, like sexual hordom and also spiritual hordom. - But she wasn't sexually. - No, no, no, no. - Oh, well, she. - I have no ideas. (laughs) I don't know. - I don't think so. - But spiritual hordom is what they were talking about. Like, she's worshipping false gods and encouraging other people too. So they would say that, oh, they worship Mary, Catholics, worship Mary, they worship these saints. These are, you know, human beings. They don't deserve your, you know, reverence in this way or whatever. So, and of course, all of the false doctrines that Catholics have according to West Row. This is why they would call her a whore. Just staying with the placards for a second because we've given a kind of biblical rationale for it. But there's also a sort of sociological lens which would say that Gramps loved attention and he loved the headlines. And it wasn't just like he liked to upset people. I think probably he did quite. But he also liked commanding, you know, just having a public ministry and that must be intoxicating. Not that different from, well, in a way, it's the DNA for what became large parts of the internet, trolling people, which tends to mean cynically saying things you don't believe. But in this context really means putting a message that's so provocative that you do still believe but is designed to get a reaction and go viral. In a sense, your family went viral before viral was a thing in the new cycle, right? And that was a feedback loop of affirmation for both your grandfather and the family in general that you thought we're doing the right thing because everyone can't stop talking about how much they hate us. And just to reflect also, my documentary, it was one of the most pleasant weird words to use but certainly most enjoyable documentaries I made. In part because I had no anxiety about how you guys would feel afterwards really because you regarded me as a hellbound sinner. And you knew that I regarded you as hopelessly misguided and that when we called it the most hated family in America, I remember your mum saying like, that was perfect. - So great, yeah, that was exactly right. Like yeah, we are the most hated family in America. - Yeah. - And then suggested you should make a follow-up called the most hated family in the world. But it was a perfect alignment of you know, you're going to hell, no, you're going to hell. You know, we can agree kind of. - Yeah. - Like, you're the worst person, like Steve's saying to me when I came back, he said, he said, you're one of the chief workers of iniquity in the whole history of man. You're right up there with Pontius Pilate about me. - Yeah, remember that. - Because I had taken the one ministry that was preaching the true word of God in the world and tried to make them look ridiculous, which made me the worst, kind of the worst. One of the worst people in history. - Yeah. - Anyway, that was a long rambling. - But there's so many things you said that I am ready to run. - But what was the thing I was thinking about? So I think if you wanted to understand it as a sort of sociological matter, you'd say like, are they were drunk on the attention of the world saying, we hate you and that became very affirming paradoxically. - So it's really interesting though, because once again, it all comes back to the Bible. So, you know, I remember this reporter, I was sitting in on an interview that my, my grandma was giving with like a reporter from Oklahoma or something, she'd come from Oklahoma 'cause we were gonna protest there. She's sitting in the office across from my grandma since she said, some people would say that you're just doing this for attention. And I wrote this in my book. They're like, he looks at her, like, she was uncommonly dense. Is that of course I'm doing this to get their attention. If how can I preach to these people? If I don't have their attention. So 100%, it was an attention getting, these were attention getting tactics. And like you said, it was absolutely, the background of this was the 24 hour news cycle. And the fact that if you just say these three to five words, very provocative words on a picket sign, you will get massive amounts of attention. And we had that reinforced everywhere we went, every little town that we went to. Many news articles would get written, people are writing letters to the editor, they're planning counter protests. Sometimes we would not go protests in a place because it had already been completely saturated with our message before we even went there. All we had to do was say we were going there, put out a news release that my Gramps could do only to just swap out the location, leave everything else on the news release the same, and get massive amounts of attention for this message that we thought was what Gramps would say, it's what people need more than they need water to drink, food to eat, or air to breathe. So yes, absolutely, it was about getting attention, but it was for the message. And the part about being hated, like reveling and being hated, 100%, because Jesus said, blessed are you when men will hate you and revile you and say all manner of evil against you falsely, for my namesake, it says, whoa, one to you when men will speak well of you, because that's what their fathers did to the false prophets. So the fact that we were hated was evidence that God was with us. So the attention.
was affirming, the hatred was affirming, and of course, Graham saw himself in, like, think about, like, you know, the prophets, like, he saw himself, like, like Isaiah or Jeremiah, you know, these people who, like, God was speaking to them and through them, and he saw himself in that way. So, all of the attention just absolutely fed into this image that he had of himself as this incredibly important, you know, speaker of truth to the entire world. I went to deliver some papers to him, and he was in the kitchen, and there's always, like, stacks of Bibles everywhere, and he's like, ask me if I could pick up this Bible and read from, I think it was Matthew 5, so I open it up and I start reading, and I get to this passage about praying for your enemies, and I was like, "What does that mean?" And he said, "Well, it doesn't say to pray for their good." I was like, in the context, that's absolutely what it means." And so, like, I take this, and I'm like, and I finish whatever he asked me to do, and then I go back home, and I run into my dad who's, like, coming home from work, and I was like, "Can you talk to me for a second?" How old are you at this point? Has probably, I mean, 2021, but so, and I say this to my dad, and I read the passage, and he goes, "That's not what that means." Like, clearly, that means to pray for their good. And I was like, "Okay, good." But then the moment it occurred to me that we might be not just wrong about, like, one or two, like, small doctrinal issues, but broadly wrong. All of those moments where, of, like, moments like that, of, like, deep questioning, or, like, things that hadn't sat right with me, but I couldn't quite put my finger on why, so let myself pursue it. I just felt like I was assaulted by every one of those moments that I had ever had. Well, that brings us to how you came to leave, and the fact that, and this is all brilliantly recounted in your book, that you were a very valued member of the church, and kind of a golden child. And as you, as you write, when you said goodbye to Gramps, he said, "I thought we had a jewel in this one." I thought we had a jewel here. I thought we had a jewel here, meaning you. You leave with Grace, your sister. She's the young sister. She was kind of on her third strike, so she'd been excluded, but the feeling is like, "You know, she was close to it, yeah, she wasn't quite yet." Getting close. So she's sort of excluded or semi-extric, and then you are there saying, like, "I'm going to," and they're like, "No, you don't have to go." You know, when I reread parts of your book for this, it struck me how many parts of the puzzler are to do with how you came to leave, and part of it is interactions on Twitter. Twitter became like Palantir, the seeing stone in the Lord of the Rings. You were looking out into the world, but the world was also kind of looking into you, and influencing how you thought about things. You were sitting with aspects of inconsistencies and some of the teachings that people had raised. There was also a texting relationship going on with a mysterious man, a spoiler alert. He went on to become your husband. But there's also, in the backdrop, a displacement of your mum from a position of authority in the church, a kind of, she's humiliated, and that when I went, one of the striking aspects of how Westbury was set up, that was on paper, a very patriarchal institution, but as your grandpa faded, increasingly your mum and your aunt Margie were kind of stepping into the role of organizers, and although they wouldn't preach from the pulpit because that was forbidden, they kind of came across as the key people at the church, and along with that was this younger generation of girls, yourself, Jail, Libby, sister Becca. So there was this heavy feminine thing going on, which made it really interesting as a kind of subject of a documentary. So what I should say, like, you'd lost a little bit of your position of privilege at the church, but definitely your mum and dad had been completely sidelined. So it's a few things. First of all, I actually was elevated in a way when my mum was sidelined because some of the work, quite a bit of the work that she did fell to me. And I did not want that. I was not, you know, trying to, I never thought about it in terms of like power and influence. That wasn't the, what it did though, like the conversations on Twitter, a big part of the reason they were so influential is yes, it was making me question the doctrines, but what it also did, like from the first time I realized, wow, the church could be wrong about something. And my view could be right, which it's so funny because even saying that now still sounds like extraordinarily arrogant to my ear. But I was able to see something that I thought they had missed. And so when I see them judging my mum and my sister, the way that I had seen them judge so many other people in the church over the years, I had many times had feelings of, are they right about this person? Like I'm not living in this person's house. Like they seem very sure about this. And I would always take the fact that my judgment didn't align with theirs as like, oh, I'm just not spiritual enough to discern like the clearly there's something happening here that I'm missing because their descriptions of this person and my interactions with them do not line up. And so I would just, I basically took away two things. Like one, I'm clearly missing something here and, you know, I'm just not smart enough, not spiritual enough to understand what it is. And two, I just can never allow myself to get in that position. Those are the two main things I took away. When it started happening to my mum and my sister, these people who live in my house and who I know way better than what these, you know, the men who are judging them and who are making all these accusations against them. The fact that I had this little bit of confidence in my own understanding and my own discernment that came from those conversations on Twitter, that was what allowed me to think in my own mind. They're just wrong about her. They're just like, they're accused of being kind of sharp, being overly, or ascetic. Yeah, basically. I mean, like, and yes, like, I mean, I worked extraordinarily close with my mother. And she was a horrible, horrible micromanager. It made a lot of things very difficult in our relationship. And Angapron at times, erratic, a bit inconsistent. Yes, absolutely. You know, very sharp. Like, she could eviscerate someone. She could eviscerate me. Like, so I was not unaware of her flaws. Like, they went to such an extreme. I could go into detail, but it's going to sound just ridiculous. But for what reason? Why would they do that? To make them understand our way or the highway. Like, you just have to, because obviously the Bible itself is kind of patriotic. We are in charge. Yeah. So were they doing it in good faith? Or do you think behind it was kind of guys just trying to do a power grab? I mean, I think I would say in good faith. I mean, I think they thought that you're exactly what you're saying here. Like, men are supposed to be the head of the church. Shirley is not a man. She should not have this influence. I wrote this in my book too. You know, I didn't realize this until I was writing it. So much of her power, if you want to call it that of her influence, was the fact that she would see things that needed to be done. And she would pick it up and run with it. It was not a matter of like, I'm trying to be in charge here. I'm trying to be in control. It's no one else is doing this and it needs to be done. And so she would just, so what she did and the position that she ended up in that they later saw as unbiblical, it was because they weren't, they weren't the ones picking up, you know, picking up the ore and, you know, going for it. But anyways, take it back to your point though. It, for me, it had nothing to do with like, oh, I'm losing my power. Again, like in many ways, I was gaining side. I don't
, I don't even like to think about it in these terms. It was more for me the fact that I had some confidence in my own understanding and my own judgment and that I could look at my mom and my sister and recognize, yes, they have their flaws and yes, they've made mistakes, but they don't deserve to be cut down in this way. So yeah, it, for me, it was much, it wasn't about power. It was about we are not living according to these standards that you have taught me all these years are, are unquestionable. I think the important takeaway for me is that it wasn't like a momentary thing or a single decision. It was a process and it unfolds and you, you, you, you write about it very clearly and intelligently that it was, it was a series of moments and a kind of, and then a, a period of kind of inhabiting almost two realities and, and, and both of them are horrific. One is that you're going to hell and, and you, you know, made a terrible mistake and the other is that you are, you've inflicted pain for years and years because, you know, leading this life of, of a kind of confused and dangerous misguided Christianity. And so both of them are horrific. But then what happens is you leave and, and I think the other part of the equation that people don't always grapple with is how difficult it is when you leave, that then you're having to piece your life back together or a new life. And, um, you've lost contact with anyone that was in, that is in the church. Your family said, unless you repent and, you know, they sort of left the door open a bit, but for a lot of people who leave, the door isn't even open. Or,
and that you have no contact, like it's a total cutoff. And then what do you do who you would touch with? What does that look like? And then there's a kind of carryover from the psychology that you've been indoctrinated in. Can you talk about that a little bit? And to put the kind of the basic question would be like, oh, well, you leave and isn't that kind of basically like liberation and free? And then you get to have fun and party and be free and not worry about going to hell. Yeah, it's not like that at all. I remember talking to people who had been out for years and realizing, oh my God, they still think they're going to hell. If I still believe that, at that point, and it's not that I didn't have moments for a while after I left where I suddenly think, oh, God's going to give me cancer or my car's going to run off the road here or like very visceral moments. Intrusive thoughts. Very intrusive thoughts. Absolutely. What's the hardest part? So to get your head round, some people still carry the belief they still think they're going to hell. For you, what were the challenges of starting the new life? I had so many challenges, but a major one was I had no experience making decisions for myself. Decision-making was a muscle that had completely atrophied from disuse. I never-- I didn't know. I had no connection in the world. No reason to be anywhere. And so I had no idea where to go. I was so confused, how do people decide where to live? Or what kind of work to do? My first instinct was literally to move half an hour away and get a job at a law office. And I'm so glad I did not do that. Because Grace's instinct was to go as far away as possible. I think she actually wanted to go to France. And I was like, we're going to be totally broke if we go to France. You saved a bit of money, right? Yes, but not that much. It basically got us through that first year. And I had a car that I had bought a couple of years earlier. So-- But we were doing all kinds of things and just going places and visiting people, meeting people. Decompressing. And this, again, is in the book you're reading. Do you kind of figure it out? We ran out of South Dakota to read books. You went to South Dakota, Deadwood. Deadwood, yeah. Why Deadwood? My brother, Sam, had been a fan of the TV series. There's quite weird to go to a place just because you'd seen a TV show about it. But this is to highlight. I hadn't actually seen the series at that point either. It was just-- Sam was a fan of the show. I was looking for someplace that we could do in a day's drive. And Deadwood was 12 hours from where we were. And my friend, a new friend, had told me about Airbnb. And so when I searched Deadwood on Airbnb, the very first listing that came up was this attic room, like a big attic room in this old Victorian house. And I showed it to Grace. And we were like, oh my gosh, this is the place. We were running away to read books for a month in imitating David Foster Wallace, who had taken a year out of school to go and read books. He was a bus driver or something. It's like, we don't have a year. We have a month between Grace's fall and spring semesters. So we'll go to South Dakota to read books. I'm very grateful to my sister because her instinct to not just do the obvious, close, safe thing. That really started to propel me to recognize the world is so much bigger than what I ever understood. And it's just not what we were taught. I think for me, one of the things that was so hopeful was we had the sign, the world is doomed. And the matching website, the world is doomed.com. And God hates the world. And all of these terrible things that we believed about everyone else and their intentions and how horrible they were. And over and over again, I kept meeting wonderful people who were clearly trying to do the right thing. And realizing that there was good in the world was amazing. And then, at first, I thought, well, I'm just going to have to-- there's no way I can ever account for the life that I lived at Westboro. I'm just going to have to go away and change my name and just completely start over. I was going to go by my legal first name and part of my last name and just whatever do that. It eventually pretty quickly became clear that was not possible, obviously, in the age of the internet. And also not desirable, because I realized, in part, my name means something that I don't believe anymore. And if I don't believe it, I have a responsibility to do something different. And so yeah, that eventually started this conversation. I wrote essentially an open letter apologizing. I didn't know what I was going to do or how I was going to try to do good in the world. But it seemed important to say that I had left and explain part of why. And I literally just posted it on Twitter. I said, hi, because I hadn't tweeted in months. I said, hi, and I'll put a link to that. And I didn't expect it. I thought, you know, just the people that followed me might see it or whatever. And it became this really huge story. They got so much attention and so much. And that really surprised me. But it also really surprised me how kind people were and how understanding. And then the work really began. I started writing and speaking and volunteering and in all these many places that offered the chance to do that. And it was incredible. And also at the same time trying to build a normal life. [MUSIC PLAYING] This episode is brought to you by Experian, the UK's most trusted credit score. Throughout my career, I've interviewed people from all walks of life, from everyday folk to Hollywood stars. And each one of them has their own unique story and goals, just like you and me. And that's no different to our financial stories. And with the expenses of summer behind us, now is the perfect time to take stock of your story by checking your Experian credit score. I know it's something that's easy to put off, but just in a few minutes, you could better understand your score, learn how to improve it, and feel confident for your next financial move. That means you can start getting set and feeling confident for what's next, be it a new car, a new home, or maybe-- a copy of "Gotta Get Through This." That's my memoir available at all good bookshops. Download the free Experian app and better your story today. For most trusted, visit xperian.co.uk/claims. [MUSIC PLAYING] You mentioned, I guess, of the 11th of you, five left. That's right. Six left. Your oldest brother, Josh, who'd left before I arrived. He's the second, actually. Second oldest. So Sam is still there. Second oldest. Your youngest brother, what's his name? Luke. Luke. Yeah. Do you leave? Last year. Last year? Yeah. Grace, who you leave with in the book, but also Zach and Noah, both of whom left and then went on to take their own lives. And both of them are in that first film I made. And in fact, Noah, people may remember as the child who's carrying the Fag Sweden placard, kind of confusedly attempting to explain the logic of it. And then in the second one, he's talking about a prophecy that will mean that the church may be moving to the Middle East and living in pink caves. I'd like just exquisitely lovable, talkative, humorous, full of life. In the third one, he's much more subdued and it would have been a year before he probably ended up leaving. Having no Noah a little bit, I guess one thing to reflect on is that it was kind of a little bit strange to turn out like I had figured in his the way he saw the world somewhat. I think you related to me that when you left, he said something to you about me. Yes. So you're talking about the day that I left the church. So I was packing and crying. And my family members were coming to talk to me, trying to talk to me out of it. And Noah texted me. And for years, I mean, if I was like eight and a half years or something after I left, the he left. And that was the last message he sent to me. But one of the things in his message was, if you do leave, don't talk to Louis. He's evil. Basically. (laughing) Basically. I mean, I shouldn't laugh. But it is that he was 13 at the time. Right, he would have been 13. He was 13, yeah. He, I just, I love Noah. I was, he was born the day before my 13th birthday. And he was very much my little guy, you know. And when I, when I, I did my first documentary when I left, and I can't remember if this is in the film or not, but he made a little booklet. Yeah, I think it's at the end. I think it's in the credit. So don't be a snake. Yes. Don't be a fag. Don't join the army. You're doing it for me. Yeah.
I'm going to let her, so you can carry it around so you can know all the rules of a brain guard. Don't tell people, don't tell them to marry two people. Don't lie, I think everyone lies somewhere in their life. Maybe when they're a kid, don't act like you're a snake. What is practically nobody does? Actually, all of these are nobody does. - What does that mean like a snake? - Can't remember. (laughing) - Hey, you've been saying, don't say that. - No, no, don't say that. - You've been saying it like a snake. - You clarify for him. - Yeah, I don't act like a snake and then says, don't be sneaky. - Yeah. - Yeah, you knew him as this like very sweet. - Yeah. - Garenless sort of irrepressible. I mean, it's worth, as a journalist visiting to the church, like visiting the church, you kind of became aware that the family members had starved of outside a companionship. - Yeah. - And so they saw you as a friend when you were coming, but they were just grateful to be able to kind of talk to someone without getting in trouble and find out about someone from the UK and worked in TV. And for a younger person, like a friendly face from the outside world, obviously made an impression. But then evidently, later on he came to see me as something else. What do you think was that? - Well, I mean, he basically, the way that he told me the story and I mean, I don't wanna, like going to all the details, but basically there came a moment when he was like nine years old where he just started to take on what the church believed about humans in general and him in particular, which is, you know, humans are naturally purely evil and there is nothing good in you and you know, you should be ashamed of yourself. And yeah, so he just took on an extraordinary amount of shame and you can see it. Anybody who knew him can look back at him like in your films and see him as a child and how like he was so at ease in the world, he was so talkative, he was so happy, he was so sure of himself. And then after this moment, when he was nine, he did the opposite, like he was, he became sort of quiet and withdrawn and it was a process. It was not like an overnight thing, but it was for sure a process. And that eventually derailed his life and took it, you know. Sorry. - I mean, just to be, you know. - And I just wanna say, like, the amazing thing to me about Noah is that when he left, and I would talk to him about things, like he, I always loved his mind. And I should say, like nine months before he left, he was sending me anonymous messages on Instagram about like things I had said, like theological points that I had disputes with the church about. And after the second message, I looked at my husband and said, I think this is my brother Noah. And then nine months later, or so when he sent me a message on that same thread and said, this is your brother Noah. And I have just left the church. And I was, I immediately burst into tears and I was like, I was like, would you believe me? If I told you that I knew it was you. And then I asked him for his phone number and it was the same number. So when I texted him, the first thing that came up was that message where he told me not to talk to you, from the day that I had left the church. But I started talking to him and he was in law school at the time and he just, the reason I knew it was him is he just had this incredibly interesting mind. And I always loved it. It was so smart and so thoughtful. And I would talk to him about everything. So I had conversations with him about this shame thing. And what amazed me so much is that he did not feel that way about other people. He could see, he was able to let Westboro's judgments of other people go and see them as interesting people, human beings who are trying to do the right thing and just worth thinking about and being kind to and whatever, but he just, he could not get there with himself. He had so deeply internalized it. And again, I don't wanna go into too much detail or anything, but I just saw things after he died, things that he had written where he just, he says it so plainly and so clearly that there's no doubt in my mind that our upbringing just played a huge role in the things that triggered him to take his own life. 'Cause he just couldn't get past it. - It wasn't the case that having left he could see rationally, well, this is incorrect. I shouldn't punish myself that these are intrusive thoughts. It's my mind playing tricks on me based on programming I've had growing up and I was saying really basic, but that would be the, you would hope that leaving would be the beginning of taking a kind of view of yourself, right? - Yeah, and like I said, he did that with other people, so he was clearly capable of it in general, but he could not extend grace to himself. He just couldn't, and it was one of those things where, he would, he had this list of things that like incidents that he would come back to, and he told me them multiple times, like we, and over the course of, you know, 'cause it was three years almost to the day after he left the church that he did it. And so we went through that list so many times and they were such small, like tiny things that he thought that he did wrong. And when I say small, again, I don't wanna go to detail, but like objectively, the smallest, the smallest kinds of missteps that we would all of us make 20 times a day, and he just could not let them go. - And without, if he hadn't grown up in Westborough, your strong feeling is, it would have been a different situation. It would have been a different outcome. - I do, absolutely. Yeah, it's absolutely devastating. No, it was only 24. He was only 24 when he took his own life. And he had so, like I told you, like he just was a wonderful person. He cared about other people. And when you see that version of him in your films, as a child, that like unbridled version of himself, he, at one point, he told me he would look at that version of himself, and he hated himself. It made him hate himself, because like, how could he possibly have felt this way when he clearly is just a terrible person? And I just, I was gonna say. - It's confusing. - Yeah, I just, I wrapped my arms around him. - He hated the easiness and the happiness that he had at the time. - Because how dare he, how dare, like I, again, is. - It's so confusing. - I know. - Is there anything you'd like to say about Zack? Zack took his life the following year? - What's it? - Yeah, it's a little more. It was last July, a year ago, a little bit just over a year ago now. Yeah, Zack had bipolar disorder. And he spoke very publicly about that. And-- - He'd been out for quite a while. - He had, and he had, like, and again, he was very public about this. So I don't, I don't think it's wrong to talk about it, but he said, he attempted suicide multiple times, starting, 'cause like, we didn't discover that he had bipolar disorder until shortly after he left. And, you know, he eventually, like, you know, he continued to, he was a nurse. He, he had also, you know, great aspirations, like he was really wanted to do good in the world and help people. And he did, I hear from people who have also been suicidal and so I know he helped a lot of people too, but yeah, ultimately, like, he just, you know, I was very close with Zack. I think I was closer to him than anybody else in our family, just probably because, like, I knew that he, he just would, you know, bipolar, like, you have these cycles, so he would have these intense highs and that made the lows that much lower. And so, anytime he was in that, you know, mode, like, when, when the fall came, you know, I would be on the phone and texting him and, you know, trying to, and last summer, it's just one of those moments came and I didn't know it, he didn't, he didn't reach out. And so there was, there was nothing anybody could do. - Do you think the upbringing played a role? Was it hard to just hard to say? - Yeah, I mean, it's, it's hard to say. Like, I mean, I, again, like, with bipolar, it's, it's, - Anyone, that can happen to anyone. - It really can't happen to anyone. And the, what, what eventually, like, you know, I'm, I'm a very rational, like, logical, logically minded person and so I would try to talk to Zach and it's like, well, Zach, well, here's why this doesn't make sense. You know, like, in both directions, both the, like, sort of delusionally positive things that he believed he could accomplish and the delusionally, I mean, I don't say that dismissively. I'm not trying to, I just mean, like, he would believe things that to my mind were so clearly so far, I was sorry, the, in the realm of possibility or, or just accuracy, both positively and negatively, depending on where I am.
in the cycle he was, and I realized at a certain point, he could be in the most perfect situation in the world. Imagine the most perfect situation you could have someone in, and it would not matter what the facts were because whatever it is, the brain chemistry or whatever, is going to interpret those facts in a way that is either very positive or very negative. The logic is secondary to the feeling, in other words, that was my experience with Zach. So I do think with Zach it almost certainly would have happened one way or the other, but the fact that Noah took his own life, that really derailed my life, I would say for like a year and a half maybe, it took me less than a day to write the first letter that I wrote to my parents, which was, I was writing to them on our drive to Kansas. We were going to my peasants wedding. I was supposed to see Noah at this wedding that weekend. The letter was just remembering Noah and how much we all loved him and how devastated I knew that my parents were. And sort of doing the opposite to them as we did when we went to people in their moments of grief. It was grieving with them. And I left the letter in the door at my house because when they, my mom and my brother saw me, they ran away. But then it took me a year to write the second letter because I felt like I had an obligation to say something to them. There was essentially like, you should do something differently. That's the thrust of it is like, there are things you can and should do differently. I know you're trying to do what the Bible says. But here's why I think you're wrong and here's where I think you've got to miss. But it's very hard to say you need to do things differently. You should do things differently without saying this happened because of you. This is your fault. Do you have any contact with your mom and dad? No. I mean, I, it's almost, for years and years, it's been almost entirely one-sided. It's me reaching out to them. Again, part of the reason I don't blame my mom and my family, the church, in the way that so many people do. You made the distinction earlier about Westboro or something that you're born into. You didn't make the distinction with my mom's generation. But a lot of people do. They see like, oh, you were adults when the protesting started. But all of the constraints, all of the control that my grandfather exerted over my mom and her siblings. That was already solidly in place long before the picketing started. The sense of shame and the, and submission, like you have to submit yourself to your father and to God and to the church. Like, all of that was there. It's very hard for me to blame the people who were raised there. Any more than I can blame the version of myself who was raised there. So for me, it's, it's not about blame or shame. It's about change and how best that can happen. How's your energy? I'm good. Are you alright? I'm fine, good, yeah. You know, we should talk about, are you okay to talk about which trials for a second? So, I mean, so you've carved out this career as a, as a broadcaster, a podcaster, advocate for understanding, reaching across ideological boundaries. You had a hip podcaster about J.K. Rowling, the witch trials of J.K. Rowling that kind of went through her journey. The fact that she was, there were campaigns against her from the Christian right, accusing her of, I don't know, sorcery or, or, or, promoting witchcraft, promoting witchcraft, demonic activity. And then later on, there was more controversy related to her views, which were characterized as gender critical anti, anti-transist, right, anti-transist. So many people don't like, it's a mind field. It's a time of logical, mind field. It's absolutely because any, there's one of the things we experienced making the show is that every, almost any description of anything that's happening, like, immediately puts you on one side or the other, depending on how you do it. And also, there's just the confusion of terms. The fact that gender critical is the opposite of, like, critical gender theory. Yes. It's like there's this. That's confused. The term gender critical, I'm not a huge fan of. I don't think this is, yeah, no clear. I find it a confusing, sort of, quasi-scientific. This was in 2023. It was a six-part audio documentary. Seven part. Seven because, actually, there was an additional one. Thank you. It's a spicy topic to take on. Like, I think Kudos for even going there, first of all. And then the fact that you made what I view as a compelling and very fair-minded documentary series is all bonus points. And also because J.K. Rowling, Joanne, I don't know her, but I think her first name is Joanne. She hasn't done a lot of speaking on other people's platforms. Obviously, she's been active on what is now X. So what brought you to make it, and then how did you get J.K. Rowling on board? Okay, so my friend Andy Mills, who is now in crime, now is my colleague. Colcast Godfather. Yes, he's incredible. He co-created the daily podcast. The New York Times podcast. Yes. It's a drama for it that's become very widely copied. It's a conversational style, isn't it? Yes. I mean, he just is a brilliant broadcaster. He's a brilliant storyteller, but he called me one day. And it was, actually, I can tell you, it was March 1st of 2021. And wow, that seems like, because it took a while. But he just was telling me about this idea he had for a podcast. He pitched it at the New York Times, and it had been rejected. It was not the moment for it, apparently. And it was the witch trials of J.K. Rowling, and it was this idea that you just said. And it's like, she was, she has drawn the iron of both the right and the left in these two what you could describe as witch hunts. And I had forgotten. Like Westboro had not, we were huge fans. My dad is the one who was an, my dad is an elder on the church, and he brought me those the first book. And he was like, he will love this book. His boss had given it to him. So we were quite a collected reader, your dad. Yeah. Well, we were just, we were big fans. So we had not participated in the backlash from the right. And so as soon as I got off the phone with Andy, I was just, I was just really interested in the subject. And so I went and started looking it up. And I started finding, you know, old like there were films made by the Christian right, like these people who were deeply offended. And they had these incredible accusations against rolling about the kind of person she was. And she maybe a secret Nazi and just all kinds of, it was very fascinating. Like, look at the late 90s, fundamentalist Christianity in the US. Yeah. We started doing all this research and realizing like how much rolling story and is both singular in the sense that, you know, she's written these incredible books that have touched so many people's lives in so many different ways. But also her story is the story of many women, women who have suffered, you know, poverty, the way that rolling did as a new mother, you know, domestic violence, sexual assault, as she wrote about in 2020. And these are the realities of many, many, many women around the world. And also, there's the way that her story intersected with both like the 24 hour news cycle in the 90s and then the social media and how like just all these trends and, yeah, and realize after a while, like we can't tell this story without rolling's voice. And so like seven or eight months maybe into this research that I was doing part time, I wrote her a letter. And like some weeks passed and eventually I heard back and the short version that you said, how did I get her on board? I mean, I wrote with this letter asking for her to take part in this conversation and sort of essentially laying out my background and what we hope to accomplish and a friend of hers had been at an event that you and I did for my book in London. And she had received my book as a gift. Yeah. And so she signed, yeah. Yeah. And she had, I'm sorry, yeah, she had read my book. And she liked it. Yep. So what one of my takeaways from listening to the series was how online, like it's an episode early on when you're talking during, she's, she's got this familiarity with the world of online influencers. And she's talking about Milo, I an opera lesson, figures from the alt rights and people weaponizing free speech to promote hateful content. And I was really striking how engaged she is. Maybe it shouldn't be that she's very, very curious about these sort of, the culture was even prior to her speaking out, right? Yeah. I mean, I think she like many people is very interested in how what is happening online is influencing real life and sort of the trends and the things that like social media, I think often amplifies some of our worst impulses and incentivizes extremes.
just like with my family, right, it's because the louder you are, the more extreme you are, the louder your voice is, because more people are paying attention to it, because it's outrageous, because it's provocative. Because it's amplified, it gets retweeted, it gets more engagement, outrage is apparently the biggest driver of engagement online or one of them. Yeah, and then there's this thing that we covered in episode three of which trials, where I interviewed this internet researcher named Angela Nagel, and she described these reinforcing cultures, opposing cultures on the two examples that she used were Tumblr on the left and 4chan on the right, and the visibility on Tumblr, see what's happening on 4chan. They think, "Oh my God, those people exist in the world, they have to be opposed," and pushes them further to the left and the same thing with people on the right. So they see the extreme sensitivity of places like Tumblr, and they're like, they did the exact opposite. It's this extreme anti-sensitivity. They're going to say the most offensive things. And so yeah, there's all these dynamics, and they're incredibly fascinating. So it doesn't surprise me at all that rolling would be interested in them. Sharda, Angela Nagel, and her book Kill All Normies. Which is so good. Which is a very early text that's basically exactly as you say, so internet, confirmation bias, and echo chambers. The podcast was relatively, it was a big hit. That's the main thing I want to say. And like I said, everyone was listening to it. The podcast was relatively well-reviewed. This sounds like a God's Mac. Though the Guardian argued, it was undermined by Megan's quote, "Mushy, Christian desire to be as kind and even handed as possible." Is that a Christian thing or a journalistic thing? In general. You're asking me. I can't speak for the Guardian. I'm just saying. It also sparked plenty of discourse. The Washington Post argued it was an exhausting lesson. I mean, I think so many people came to it thinking that it was a debate. It was on the left and the right. Some people thought it was too accepting of various trans perspectives and others thought it was platforming JKR in a irresponsible way. So many people came to the show thinking that it was a debate. It's not a debate. If you judge it as a debate between these two sides, that's not what it is though. It is a narrative about the way that the internet has changed. It's sort of using rolling story as a lens to examine these profound changes that society has gone through over the last 30 years. That's really what it's doing. I'm incredibly proud of it. I see that criticism. What was the second question? Oh, platforming JKR rolling. I'm definitely not platforming JKR rolling. JKR is definitely platforming me just by the way. But again, she's platforming you. We couldn't have made this show without her as well. Also, she has her own platform. She does not need a champion. She does not want one. I think some people might think, "Oh, she only agreed to do it because you were nice to her," or whatever. They wanted the strongest possible arguments on the other side. Again, she does not need a champion. She is her own champion, as you can see how she represents herself. She does not need me to platform her. My goal, and one of the things that I wrote in that letter to her, was taking that conversation off of social media where it's happening and it's going to continue happening, but trying to give it context and space and to have people from various perspectives share what are the strongest arguments on and to cover them as extensively as we could in a way that helps people understand where they're coming from and what is at stake for the people in this conversation? It can be very obvious to you what's at stake on your side, but maybe not as obvious. It's easier to dismiss other people's experiences when you don't really understand them, which is why we included many reasons to include Natalie Annoa in episode six. Natalie spoke out and said she regretted taking part. Did you know that? I did know that. Shall I read the sound? This was before she disavowed the podcast before a single episode aired. Yes. I'll read the sound. This is before she'd heard it. Well, I don't know what you're about to read. I'm just saying she. Make it spoke to JK Rowling about me and I thought it seemed only right to speak to me about JKR. This is what was pitched to me. I took the bait and consented to a pretty miserable three-hour interrogation about my transition as well as the usual "concerns" about trans rights. Man, so many things to say. She's brilliant and you can go and look at her YouTube. Like she made, she had made a video about a video meaning a long video essay. She makes these long video essays. I'm one about JK Rowling and one about cancel culture. And so as someone who came to the story, like both as recognizing the dangers and pitfalls and sort of ugliness of canceling someone and knowing that people do it with all good intention. I mean, similar to Westbro. Like they come to this like the way that Natalie put it was. You're trashing someone, but you feel righteous. I think that's how she put it. Something like that. Talking about what she was speaking about how she reacted to JK Rowling? So there was two separate videos. So I think that quote or paraphrase is from the cancel culture video, but she made another one about Rowling. And so as someone who was both critical both of Rowling and of cancel culture, I thought she was an incredibly interesting person to talk to. And I did go to Rowling with some of the things that came from her video. And we played, I think we played some of her video in the series or reference it at least. So absolutely, we wanted to go and talk to her. Like she has an incredibly interesting perspective. And I I hate the fact that she thought the interview was miserable because I thought it was incredibly fascinating. And I was very grateful to Natalie for sitting down with me. And we tried very hard to present her argument and accurately, of course, but she's incredibly intelligent. And we heard from many people, I don't know if it's any consolation to her, but we heard from so many people who walked away from that very persuaded to see that side of the argument in ways that they never had before because of her experience and because of Noah's experience, young trans boy named Noah. Someone on the team was saying, well, it would have been a less polar, it wasn't polarizing, but some people took against witch trials of JK Rowling possibly because they heard the title and thought, okay, you've decided that this was a witch trial. Okay, so this is that I'm really glad you brought it back to this because we cast about for a long time for a different title. And the reason we ultimately settled on it is because the language of witch hunting came up on both sides. So yes, for sure, Rowling's sides see themselves as the subject of a witch hunt. They see themselves as like the word turf, which is, you know, you're a predisclusionary radical feminist. Yes. They see that as like just a new version of the word witch or bitch. And so they for sure see themselves as, you know, being targets of a witch hunt. But so do people on the other side. And like it was very interesting to realize they sit on the other side. They see themselves as being witch hunting as well. Absolutely. Absolutely. Because they like they are being targeted. Like so they are, it's just a very small portion of the population that is transgender. And they are getting inordinate, you know, hatred and cruelty and opposition, they feel, right? So and they. So in that framing, the grammar is is also like, oh, she's leading a witch trial. Yes. So the title, the witch trials of JK Rowling, she could be either the subject or the, the prosecutor, the prosecutor general. Absolutely. And so realizing that it was actually ambiguous and the fact that again, just the fact that the witch hunting me, we, we talked to a, a witch expert. So is a woman who wrote a book on the Salem Witch Trial. It is a theme sort of throughout the series. We talked about the top of episode seven, I think, especially. But anyway, yeah, like it is an ambiguous title. So people come to it thinking like, oh, for sure, they're on rolling side. But obviously we can point out and hope that they hear that the other side is also represented in very, I think very compelling terms. I found both Natalie and Noah extremely compelling. Did you feel by the end you basically, did you feel by the end you sort of agreed with JK Rowling or is it more complicated than that? I think it's complicated. I think there's just a lot that I'm, I'm very, I'm bright. I was talking to Joe Rogan on his show and I said there's two things that people have a hard time saying. I messed up and I don't know. And I'm very comfortable now saying I don't know. I think there's a lot of things that we don't know about a lot of things. And I mean, related to this subject of sex and gender. And I don't have to, I don't have to take a position on all these policy issues. I can, I can inhabit the role of a journalist and say like I'm trying to understand people on all sides and let that, let that be them. When you move through the world and you, if you have people, you're explaining to people what your story is. If they don't know, what do you think is the most common misconception? What do you find yourself having to explain over and over again about?
I think some people, like, think that they're just, I mean, they think they're just bad people. And for me, that's a big part of the story, maybe the biggest part of the story, I don't think they're bad people. I think they're doing bad things because they have been indoctrinated the way I was indoctrinated. And so it's in, like, once again, like, the fact that they have good intentions is the thing that, for me, is hopeful. I think that's the biggest misconception though. Yeah, it's not intrinsic. It's something that was an effect that was wrought by the circumstances. And that the circumstances can change. And that's, for me, that's really what it comes down to. The circumstances, for me, changed. And yeah, it's just an incredibly hopeful thing. And if you, if they are watching or listening, your brother Sam, your sister Becker, still there. Isaiah is still there. Gabe is still there. Those are the siblings, not to mention your uncle's aunt's cousins and your mum and dad. What would you say to them that I love them unconditionally and that I am here for them and that if they, you know, I, I'm not trying to tell people, you know, how to live or what to do. But if they did feel compelled to leave, that I'm here and that I will do everything in my power to help them, that the world is not what we were taught it was, that there is a lot of good and a lot of hope and that I deeply wish for them to experience it because I can't even tell you how much my life has changed in positive ways in the absence of that church. Welcome back. Thank you for listening. I hope you found that interesting, massive, massive thanks to Megan for coming by and talking so openly and sensitively and boughtfully. A lot of people talk about the need for empathy, the need to be less tribal. That's easier to say than to do. Megan is modeling a kind of compassionate attitude, not least with respect to her own family and the way she's kept the door open or attempted to try and communicate with family members, show them that she's still there for them when needed. For me, it's been an extraordinary experience. Being a very small part of that whole story and seeing Megan and her transformation over the course of nearly 20 years, 2007 when I first visited. And obviously, yeah, check out those documentaries. If you haven't seen them, they're all on my player. The first one, I sometimes say about my documentaries that I don't have favorites, but that's one of my favorites. Because of the extraordinary immersion and the combination of positive and negative values, they were very hospitable and kind to me. When I stayed, we would go, we went ice skating or rollerblading and ate Chinese food and then they were spewing hatred on the tickets and the incongruity of those different modes. And the way in which I could see that in other settings, they would have grown up to be positive people, felt like a life lesson in indoctrination. When I last checked, Westboro was still doing tickets, but they had kind of toned it down a bit. Some of the language a bit was a little bit moderated. Mainly, my mind goes to what Shirley and Brent, Megan's parents, must be going through the idea of your children, one or after another, leaving. I think we talked in the chat. How many has she got? They've got four or five still in the church, but two of them actually, having ended their lives. It's a mind boggling thing to consider. [BLANK_AUDIO]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Megan Phelps-Roper left the Westboro Baptist Church after years of indoctrination, driven by personal disillusionment with its extreme doctrines and the pain it caused.
The church’s beliefs were rooted in a selective interpretation of the Bible, combining literalism, anger, and a deep sense of divine punishment for perceived sins.
Picketing funerals and using provocative signs like “God hates fags” were strategic to gain attention, with the group viewing hatred as evidence of divine approval.
Megan’s journey involved confronting internal contradictions in the church’s teachings, especially through interactions on social media, which helped her recognize her own moral agency.
The trauma of her two brothers’ suicides—Noah and Zack—was deeply tied to the church’s toxic environment, with both struggling with severe internalized shame and mental health issues.
Leaving the church was not a simple act of liberation but a long, painful process of rebuilding identity, facing intrusive thoughts, and redefining humanity.
Megan’s new life involved public advocacy, writing, and speaking to promote tolerance, transforming her personal pain into a message of hope.
The Westboro Baptist Church’s rise and influence reflect a broader pattern of extremism, where personal trauma, patriarchal control, and a lack of empathy feed into radicalized messaging.
Summary:
Megan Phelps-Roper, a former member of the Westboro Baptist Church, shares a deeply personal journey from religious extremism to advocacy for tolerance. Raised in an environment where the church’s teachings—centered on sin, divine punishment, and hatred of LGBTQ+ people—were unquestioned, Megan gradually questioned the logic and morality of these beliefs. Her experience, marked by painful moments such as her brothers’ suicides, became a turning point.
She realized that while the church claimed to follow God’s word, its interpretation was distorted, emotionally damaging, and internally inconsistent. Through social media and personal reflection, she began to see her own judgment as valid, challenging the authority of her family. Leaving the church was not a sudden decision but a slow process of psychological transformation, involving immense difficulty in rebuilding a new life without connections or identity.
Megan now runs a podcast exploring the Bible’s teachings to discern what is truly valuable, and she uses her platform to speak about healing, forgiveness, and the possibility of change. Her story illustrates how toxic religious environments can produce profound trauma, yet also how personal resilience and empathy can lead to transformation and hope. The conversation underscores the importance of recognizing internal contradictions, the dangers of unchecked ideology, and the power of compassion in overcoming hatred.
FAQs
The Westboro Baptist Church was known for staging highly provocative protests, especially at soldiers' funerals and at gay events, and for promoting extreme views on LGBTQ+ rights and other social issues, often using inflammatory signs like 'God hates fags.'
Megan grew up in the church with her family, including her grandfather Fred Phelps, who founded it. She was actively involved from a young age, participating in protests and following the church's teachings as a core part of her upbringing.
The church believed that sin—such as homosexuality or adultery—led to punishment, and that fallen soldiers were suffering as a result. They argued that these sins were the cause of the tragedies they witnessed, including military deaths.
Yes, they used selective interpretations of the Bible, focusing on passages that supported their beliefs while ignoring or dismissing others. They often prioritized certain verses to create a coherent narrative, even if it required ignoring other parts of scripture.
The church sought attention and widespread media coverage by using provocative signs and messages, which generated headlines and public reaction. The backlash and media attention were seen as affirming that their message was being heard and accepted by God.
Megan left after years of internal questioning, especially influenced by conversations on social media, where she began to see inconsistencies in the church's teachings. She realized her own judgment aligned with a more compassionate view of people, leading her to distance herself from the group.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.