Go back

Megachurch Pastor Reacts to James Talarico's INSANE Claims on ABORTION!? | Live Free with Josh Howerton

39m 4s

Megachurch Pastor Reacts to James Talarico's INSANE Claims on ABORTION!? | Live Free with Josh Howerton

James Tallerico’s viral Joe Rogan interview sparked widespread confusion among Christians due to claims that Jesus never addressed homosexuality or abortion. The response highlights that such arguments are flawed, as Jesus affirmed the Old Testament and defined ethical boundaries—such as marriage and sexuality—through clear biblical teaching. The New Testament explicitly condemns homosexual practice, and early Church history, from the Didakay to Tertullian and Augustine, consistently taught that abortion equates to murder. Passages like Numbers 5 are misread as supporting abortion; they actually involve divine judgment for adultery and contain no reference to pregnancy. The Southern Baptist Convention in 1971 affirmed life and allowed abortion only in rare cases, confirming their pro-life stance. Theologically, life begins at conception, and the Bible teaches that intentionally ending a life is murder, grounded in Genesis and the commandment “you shall not murder.” The episode also critiques how political discourse distorts scripture—whether by progressive Christians framing abortion as a reproductive right or conservative figures using selective interpretations. It stresses that Christian leaders must defend biblical truth, especially on life and marriage, and that the Church’s role is to uphold spiritual truth, not to align with political movements. The conclusion emphasizes that Mary’s consent to conceive Jesus is not a precedent for abortion, and that true Christian teaching centers on the sanctity of life, bodily consent, and obedience to God’s Word.

Transcription

7529 Words, 40791 Characters

English
I live free nation. This can be an interesting little react episode. James Tallerico, who's becoming a little, you know, a little pod favorite in some ways here. He is becoming quickly like one of the most popular rising stars in Texas politics, actually a national politics. And he very frequently kind of poses as a, as a Christian pastor and makes some pretty outrageous claims. This clip that we're getting ready to react to right here, Tallerico was on Joe Rogan went like insane viral. And he made some comments that have gone like again, insane viral that are confusing a lot of Christians saying things like the Bible actually supports abortion. And he gives some confusing arguments that confuse Christians on why. And Jesus never said anything about homosexuality. And this went so viral that me, Carlos Barrazo and Chad G. Paul T hopped in the studio. And we're going to react to this Tallerico Joe Rogan clip. So without further ado, here we go. This is for a little bit of context. This is a Joe Rogan interview with James Tallerico. I hope I'm pronouncing his name right. And James is a, he is a American politician. Like you said, a quote unquote pastor, former teacher. And he is what I got, well, you described it as a title pastor, pastor in the synagogue of Satan. That's right. That's why I'm saying that's, that's it. And, uh, self proclaimed, um, and so man, let's, uh, let's just jump in. So it just, I get suspicious when anybody, whether it's a, uh, a televangelist or a politician, tells me that something is central to my faith when Jesus never talks about it. Wait, wait, actually, let him keep going. So we know what he's saying. Jesus never talked about. To me, that should, I think, ring alarm bells, um, as to what is the agenda here? Um, what is someone trying to, to get across? And I think we're looking to last 40, 50 years, the religious right has made a concerted effort to make homosexuality and abortion the two biggest issues for Christians bypass. So he, his, first of all, this, here's why we're doing this. A, the number of people that sent this to me was insane. B, it confused a lot of people and it went like super mega viral. So this is the kind of stuff you're going to hear a lot. So I just want to walk through a biblity. So Paul Cunningham, you start, this, the, James says Jesus never talked about homosexuality. Let's do homosexuality first because he's going to talk about abortion later. Yeah. I get suspicious. Anyone, anytime someone uses the argument, Jesus never talked about, fill in the blank. So my alarm bells are going off when I hear that because usually it just betrays me that the person is generally intentionally or unintentionally ignorant of just how biblical arguments work, biblical reasoning works and things like that. And so I think when I hear things like this, I used to people, three things we need to remember. Number one is Jesus's Bible. Number two, Jesus's identity and number three, Jesus's context. So in terms of Jesus's Bible, he affirmed the authority of the Old Testament. He said, I've not come to abolish the law, but to fulfill it. And so that basically says, Hey, everything on the Old Testament, I affirm that in terms of God's moral commands. The only has to remember his identity that Jesus was God. And so when he says, Oh, Jesus never said that I'm like, well, if it said it in the Old Testament, he is God. Actually, it is his words. Now, it was inspired by the Holy Spirit, but we have to remember in Christian belief, God has one mind, not three. So it's not like the Holy Spirit and the Son of God are thinking different things. Oh, there's a thing in the same thing. And so everything that the Holy Spirit inspired or Jesus's thoughts as well, including everything in the Old Testament. And then finally, I have to remember Jesus's context is Jesus never talked about things like a Dollar Tree either, even though Dollar Tree was the number one sin in the Old Testament. And the reason is because that wasn't being debated. Jesus was around mostly Jewish people. They weren't debating that. They weren't practicing it anymore. So he didn't need to address it. But what you see in Acts and in the Epistles is all of a sudden, as the gospel goes out into the Gentile world, where things like Dollar Tree and homosexuality, you know, the things like that are practiced, they do have to address it because they're in cultures that embrace it and where there is error. That's really good. Yeah. So again, so we have to remember Jesus's Bible, his identity and his context. All right. So here's what I'll say in response to the, because you hear this a lot. Jesus never talked about same sex attraction or marriage or whatever. So one thing I'll say is Jesus never said anything about nuclear warheads, bestiality or paper straws, but they're all awful too. And I just got to throw a paper straws in there because I really want them to go away. But like, you know, so that's number one. This argument from silence is the weakest form of our argument, argument from silence. There's tons of stuff Jesus never explicitly talked about that everyone knows are evil. Everybody knows that. Number two is this. Yeah, please. And yet he did talk about sexuality. Yeah. Yeah. Number two, that's just not true that Jesus never talked about this. So if here's my analogy, if somebody were to ask me, hey, Josh, who if they walk in a lake point and they go, hey, Josh, who's your wife? Which one's your wife? There's two ways that I can make clear who my wife is. Either I can point to 24,999 people and individually say that's not my wife and that's not my wife and that's not my wife and that's not my wife until no one's left with Janna or I can just point to Janna and go, that's my wife. And by implication, everything else is not my wife. Okay. So what Jesus does over and over again, multiple times in the gospels, is he defines what is acceptable sexual expression and what is biblical marriage. So instead of having to literally name, for instance, I mentioned this, Jesus never addresses bestiality or incest. Everyone knows those things are wrong. Only fans. Yeah. Only in order to talk about only fans. So what Jesus did is he went, man, I'm not going to list every single thing that is wrong. That's important. They'll take forever. So let me just go, here's what's right. And then by implication, everything else is out. This is Matthew 19. Some Pharisees came to him to test him. They asked Jesus, is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any and every reason? Jesus response. So words of Jesus right here, haven't you read? He replied that at the beginning, the creator made them male and female. So transgenderism is out. And said for this reason, a man will leave his father and mother. So like, lazy don't work, live in your mom's basement forever. That's out. And be united to his wife. So in other words, we need it, we get married. And the two will become one flesh. So what you have there is you have the definition of marriage. And then he says, therefore, what God has joined together, let no one separate. What you have there is a sexual heterosexual life long covenant union between a man and a woman. And Jesus goes, that's what's right. By implication, everything else is out. And I love you into that text because when Jesus defines marriage, it's usually in response to questions about divorce. So Jesus could have simply said, don't divorce. I can good have answered the question really briefly. He said, no, he could have even quote a part of it said, well, God has brought together a lot of people and I said, right, but I think he knew what he was doing. Ah, he intentionally went back and even defined the host scope of marriage and then went on there. That's just one thing I think is important to point out. So yes, he didn't use specifically language around homosexuality, but he knew what he was doing when he defined it. He could have said, don't get divorced, but he actually gave a positive definition of marriage and identified the target, like you said. You will also, to Paul's point, you'll hear people sometimes. And there's a, there's a wonderful grace in this. You will hear people sometimes mistakenly be like, oh man, there's a few old Testament clobber passages. Actually, this is reaffirmed in the New Testament. So here's your homework. Go read Romans 1 or 1st Corinthians 6. And here's what I love about 1st Corinthians 6 is he lists all these sins and he lists things like theft and murder and you know, there's a few other slanderer, a few other things. And then he goes and men who practice homosexuality. And he goes, man, these people will not inherit the kingdom of God. And he's saying, if you continue in these sins in an unrepentant way, then that is an indication you have not placed your faith in the Lordship of Jesus and submitted to him. So he won't inherit the kingdom of God, but then he goes and such were some of you, but you were washed, you were cleansed, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus. That's gospel. That's a great and good news. So it's simply untrue that Jesus, and especially the New Testament ever talked about this, it specifically does. You want to keep going? Let's keep going. Yeah. Actually, I say one more thing. Please do. Actually, so I'm so sorry. I'll cut you off. I think even just to help people clarify, because it's a common misunderer say, oh, the religious right has made these two issues, big issues. No, no, no. The biggest two issues is the Lordship of Jesus and the authority of His Word. And so anytime you're going to challenge that, we're going to respond. And then with that one thing that sometimes theologians are historians like to say is that heresy often precedes orthodoxy. Not in the sense that we make up what we believe, but when what we believe begins to be challenged, we then have to directly and clearly articulate what Christians have always believed. So it may seem like we're the ones who elevate anything that we're simply responding to what the culture has elevated. Yeah, this one of my as a pastor is like one of our pet peeves is like the entire culture will scream about an issue. And it's like every commercial, every movie, every talk show, everything you read is about this issue. And then a pastor addresses it like you that's the only thing you focus on. Bro, are you kidding like I hate the Bible? Are you guys I hate that? Are let's keep going? Keep going. And you know, the Southern Baptist Convention was pro-choice until the late 19th 70s head pause do we want to do all the do we want to listen to the whole thing and then go arguments You don't want to let's do that. Let's do clip by clip. Yeah, cuz I want to make sure we answer that Paul Cunningham the Southern Baptist Convention was pro-choice until the 1970s what say you? No Just a great example of maybe a half-truth being twisted to try to make your argument I actually think we have the text that we're gonna put up of the resolution from 1971 you pulled it I pulled it. I'm for it. So we're gonna say these things. We're gonna say these things. Let's actually be in context We're gonna skip down actually to where it says be it therefore resolved be it therefore resolved at the Southern Baptist Convention. This is a key line while reaffirming our historic commitment to the sanctity of life What year was this? This is 1971 so in other words what they're about to say before they say while reaffirming They were saying hey, we are pro-life and then it goes on and it does say Call upon Southern Baptist to work for legislation that will allow for the possibility of abortion under such conditions as rate Incess clear evidence of severe fetal deformality and then likelihood of damage the emotional mental and physical health of the mother So they were not pro-choice. They were pro-life But as a denomination did decide that they would say hey There are some exceptions that we believe should be legal now That doesn't mean that we have to agree with what they said by the way because a few years later I do not there was what was called the conservative Research and said there were very liberal elements in the Southern Baptist Convention at this time and over the next 10 to 15 to 20 years There was a research that basically hey, we have Drifted away from the Bible and we need to reclaim that so I'm not saying this to say hey We agree with what Southern Baptist wrote here It's really just trying to give the greater context of saying hey while reaffirming our commitment to the sanctity of human life So they were not pro-choice. They were pro-life with exceptions. I'll add this so the implication that James synagogue of Satan pastor whatever his name is What his implication is like and by the way if somebody's listening to like that's mean I'm gonna explain why I'm saying that later. Yeah, it's not mean It's actually a very loving thing to be very clear about something like that But the implication he's trying to make is man actually this is some of that church just disagreed on and various opinions agree Disagree that's right. That's right. That is just historically radically false It's like all the way back to something called the Didakay, which was a collection of Christian writings I'm like right after actually the Didakay was written before the book of Revelation if I remember right? Yeah, well this late 90s early hundreds of many would say it was written concurrently with the gospel of John There you go. This is this is still in the time when the some deposits were living in early Christians So here's a quote from the Didakay the earliest Christians. What is it? Explain it for the people I have no idea what that it's like a collection of devotional writings How would you describe it? I really just means the teaching. It's like a church manual It's like an early church manual basically saying hey, here's just a list of the things. Yeah, yeah There's a quote from the Didakay AD 70 you's just pretty straightforward. You shall not procure abortion like this It's kind of straightforward This is here's one from what was called the letter of Barnabas. It's an apocryphal deal But it's a dated to around 80 74 Thou shalt not slay the child by procuring abortion Early church father Turtulian 80 197 here's a quote from Turtulian Murder being once for all forbidden. We may not destroy even the fetus in the womb Turtulian 1780 Wow. Here's John Chrysostom Think didn't they call him golden mouth the golden eyes of the greatest preachers in the history? They say yeah, a lot of people say John Chrysostom's like yeah And he refers to in a John Chrysostom sermon Murder before the birth. Mm-hmm. So it's like this is the uniform testimony of the church For if we into the beginning if we fast forward a thousand years Thomas Aquinas talking about Something called the sentences he who destroys life in the womb incurs the guilt of murder So even like sometimes guys think he's just basically the guys trying to say oh, yeah It's just a great issue of people disagreeing like no like if I put you in a travel machine time travel machine And we went to any time before really last 50 years Like this view would have been described as heresy. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I mean just outright heresy Yeah, and just to clarify we're not time to expand too much on this But for somebody that's listening in and it's curious because they're like well, but do you agree with? The 1971 position of like yes pro life, but with some of these exceptions, Josh you would say I do not that's right Yeah, I do not now by the way tremendous overwhelming like compassion for any any circumstance like that But no like and dude is some of people like Josh are you crazy? That's what you believe like actually? No, that's not what I believe That's what the Bible says and I'm a via Bible guy and the Bible is just really clear You shall not murder murder equals the taking of innocent life There's a whole different podcast. There's just there's the just taking of life and the unjust taking of life The just taking of life are things like the death penalty for Appropriate criminal offenses and the unjust taking of life is anything else So I'm just like hey man. I do not think one sin Necessitates another agreed another sin I'm sure we'll address all of this because I'm sure people are gonna be asking some more questions in a future episode just FYI that's fine. I'm in soon. Let's keep going Well, when was abortion even invented? Well, there was certainly abortions in the ancient world there there is some well there's some there's and again I haven't stated this enough to to say this definitively, but there are interpretations of certain passages from the Torah where some folks will even say that there is a There's some subtle Instructions for how to perform an abortion in the ancient world certain things to drink things like that. Let's pass You want to start a you want me You're probably in a more Let me let me talk let me talk about what he's referring to. Okay, he's referring to Numbers chapter 5 Drunk Numbers 5 verse 11 to 31 it gives these it's an Old Testament law and it's giving the Instructions for what the nation of Israel should do when there's a woman accused of adultery But there are not witnesses so the husband has reason maybe biological reasons to believe that his wife has been unfaithful But there's not multiple witnesses numbers. Five is prescribing what should have been done in Old Testament, Israel in that circumstance and here's I'll give a quick description of it So that the priest would put the woman under oath and make her swear under penalty of a curse that she was innocent of adultery After the wife swore her innocence her oath was written on a scroll Next the priest put the scroll into the water until ink came up off off the water at which point he removed the scroll from the cup Then the priest took the grain offering from the woman burned it on the altar and she would drink the bitter water If innocent then the bitter water would have no effect, but then if guilty There would be a physical consequence and there's debate about how the translation of the physical consequence We can get to that in a second, but that's what he's referring to Paul your response three issues number one The text never mentions pregnancy. Ah, yes, very important Interesting number two. This is about a newer basically saying this. It's about divine judgment not human abortion That's right and the number three traditional Jewish interpreters have never seen this is about abortion and so one thing That I actually like when I'm teaching people how to interpret the Bible is that if you're seeing something no one has seen before It's because it isn't there. I mean that that's why even when we are referring to people in their reason this throughout history Tradition can be a bad thing, but conditional can also be a good thing Tradition is the democracy of the dead. It's where dead people get a vote and If if no one really has seen this until I get in last 50 years and interpret the text in this way that should give us pause So yes, those are just the real huge issues with this text in terms of using this of any kind of a reference to justify abortion at the Bible teaches abortion That's exactly right. So the the things to keep in mind so and we don't need to deep dive into this Let's keep going through the clip, but essentially there's There's debate about the translation of the physical consequence that you know the Bible says would happen under the judgment of God Most people translate it the falling away of the thigh What he's doing is some people will translate it as like the shriveling up of the womb and then he's Imputing into the text as Paul mentions pregnancies never mentioned that I will if if she was pregnant because of the adultery Then it's talking about the miscarriage of their and number one Paul mentioned that's Pregnancy's never mentioned number two. That's the that's not the likely interpretation of the passage number three We just need to acknowledge this it is not culturally popular to acknowledge this but The potter has the right over the clay. Yeah Anytime that God decides to take life he can do that because he created it that does not give us the ability to do that and with this If you're listening to this you're not familiar with this is that there was also not just punishment for the woman But for the man as well. So if you're just here and there's like oh, why was it just for what? No, no, no It was also punishment for the man This was just basically the test to see it's something that happened. Yeah, that's right. Let's go on. Yep, that The point is that this idea that there is a set Christian orthodoxy on the issue of abortion It's just not rooted in scripture. We can have a do not pass on us to do that. I just said do not Okay, let's go do not collect 200 hours We are we don't need to talk about this. We already mentioned the uniform It's clear testimony of great rough church history You know we're to come back and sit at this table and tell me you know James. I'm pro-life and anti-borsion. Here's my theological argument, I'm here to listen and respect that opinion. I have dear friends who are anti-abortion. All I'm asking is that for Christians who are pro-choice and who respect the bodily autonomy of women, that we be given the space to make our theological argument, 'cause I think there is a lot of biblical evidence to support that opinion. - What is real quick? - So a couple of things you can do in these arguments. I'll just, so you gotta watch this. I did debate team in high school. Here's what you gotta watch out for. What people always say is whoever controls the terms wins the debate. - Yes. - So if you frame it in terms of bodily, so that's what people do is they'll smuggle in language that also smuggles in assumptions, the bodily autonomy of women, okay? That's actually not what we're talking about, man. Because there's two bodies involved, not just one. That's what you gotta watch out for. There's two bodies involved, not just one. We're not talking about bodily autonomy. We're talking about you're saying you have the right over somebody else's bodily autonomy. That's what happens when you take somebody else's life in utero, all right, let's get going. - What do you think is the biblical evidence to support the opinion of being pro-abortion? - So one, in Genesis, God creates life by breathing life into the first human being, which we later call Adam, that life starts when you take your first breath. And that is actually the main line positioned in Judaism is that that's when life starts. - Okay, so Philan, how are you going to go? - Like appealing to Adam's creation to define when life begins, it's like using the burning bush to define laws of botany and thermodynamics. All right, in the sense of those are, it's a supernatural exception. It's not the norm and the pattern. - Okay, and so I even, like I'd say like, it's just a general thing, I say we gotta be careful about taking a supernatural exception in scripture and then saying, all right, and then this defines the pattern for the rest of scripture, that'd be number one. So Adam was not conceived, he was created uniquely from the dust. - Here's the place, Adam was never a fetus. - He was never a fetus. - And now what I'm saying is he was a supernatural exception. You can't then say, oh, therefore everything is like this. The other thing would be, is that scripture teaches that human life does begin the womb, not at birth. I mean, even just a few places. Number one, in Luke, when it talks about the baby leaping in Elizabeth's womb-- - First person ever worship Jesus. - First person ever worship Jesus in unborn child and the word that is used baby, brefas, is the same word that is used of infant and children. - Wow. - So it doesn't distinguish. It's the same thing. You obviously have texts like Psalm 139, Jeremiah, where it says, before I formed you in the womb, I knew you. But I also think a key thing here is from like, the breath of life is a poetic image and what's interesting is later in Ecclesiastes, we get that same kind of imagery. This is what it says, as you do not know the way the spirit or wind or breath comes to the bones in the womb of a woman with child. So here he's trying to make the argument of all no breath is what gives life that doesn't happen until the baby is outside. Here it says that the breath comes to the baby while it is still in the smells of the womb. And so yeah, yeah. - He got, I don't need anything to add anything. He nailed it. - And he did say that he said that it was like, mainstream Judaism perspective, is that true? - It might be true today, but there's some variations. I mean, like for example, we've got Philo who is an early Jewish rabbi who would have said abortion was wrong and kind of a thing. And so I'm not sure if that's true. - And that's true. - Even if it's our mainstream belief doesn't mean that it's right. - That's right. - That's right. - That's right. - Let's keep going. - Then if you think about it from a Christian perspective, what's something interesting that Jesus does throughout his ministry is he is breaking first century norms about women, talking with women, learning from women, having women lieutenants in his movement. And this was something that was kind of unheard of in the first century. The longest conversation Jesus has with anybody in the whole Bible is with the Samaritan woman at the well. And so this affirmation of women as full and equal people is a huge part of the Jesus movement, especially the early church. - Of course, all we agree with his lessons. - Yeah. - That's really important. We totally agree with his lessons that Jesus did, treat women as full and equal people. He did not, equals, but not equivalents. That's a whole different discussion. But totally agree. But let me just say like, that's quite a leap to go from. Jesus had a long conversation with a woman one time. Therefore, that's quite a leap. - Yeah, with the way I wrote it down, I think I had two bullet points. And one was like, yes. And it gets just like, yeah, I totally agree, man. And we need to remember that too. In terms of how Jesus treated women. But then even going to the dedicated or the writings and the earliest Christians who are the closest to Jesus by the way, then we are. Did not then use that to then justify abortion. - Yes, so. - Yes. Yeah, just want to point out, like I would just be like, yeah, man, but like Jesus forbade murder, really this whole, the whole discussion is, you know, you can have a million emotional situations thrown out and that stuff as Christians, we should care. We should weep with those who weep. We should be the ones that like, that's the reason we give huge amounts of money at Lake Point, crisis pregnancy centers, foster care and adoption, all the, you know, women who are victims of sex trafficking. There's a reason we like, we go all out on that stuff. Our sore ministry for kids especially, there's a reason we go out on that stuff. So you can throw out all of the emotional things that'll pull you emotionally. Really, here's the only question, is it murder? That's the only question that matters, is it murder? - We didn't get to this sort of, but it might be helpful to do it now. Is, can I just briefly state like the historical Christian case in terms of like the reasoning of why we believe this is? - Of course. - Okay. And I actually take this from Andrew Walker, who adapted this from Dave Beckwith, who wrote a book called Defending Life. So basically four premises, number one. An unborn child is a member of the human species. So whatever is in the mother's womb, is it either living or dead? What's living? Okay, well then if it's living, it's a living what? It's a living human. So an unborn child is a member of the human species. We gave texts already throughout the Bible in terms of where we see that life begins to move. That leads to point number two. It is morally wrong to take the life of an innocent member of the human species. But give Exodus, you shall not murder. Parvab 16 through 17. God hates the shedding of innocent blood. I mean, you gotta feel the way that he hates the shedding of innocent blood. Number three, abortion takes the life of a member of the human species, which leads him before. Therefore abortion is immoral. That's the case. It's that simple case. - And again, we're gonna move on, but we'll keep going back to that all of this is, but in the same way, there's a reason the New Testament talks about, and such, where some of you. - Yes. - But you were washed, you were cleansed. So what I always wanna say, and I just wanna interject it, to what like, Jan and I pray with women who have terminated pregnancies, and they, you have the grief that sometimes, we'll pray with somebody in the lobby is unspeakable. And what we always remind them is, "Hey, the death that most defines your life is not the death of your son or your daughter. It's the death of the Son of God that cleanses you from all sin." - There you go. And so you need to sleep really good tonight. Just knowing the Father is pleased with you. So I wanna get that in. Let's keep going. - That's right. - And then the last, I think, story I would go to is the story of Mary. - Dude, this is hilarious. - Mary is probably my favorite figure in the Bible, the mother of Jesus. And, you know, she is, she's an oppressed, peasant, teenage girl, living in poverty under an oppressive empire as a Jew. And, she has a vision from God that she's gonna give birth to a baby who's gonna bring the powerful down from their thrones, gonna scatter the proud, who's gonna send the rich away empty. I mean, this revolutionary song that she sings, it's called the Magnificat. And it's actually been banned by certain authoritarian regimes because it is so radical. But I think all of this in terms of context and proportion because before God, comes over Mary and we have the incarnation. God asks for Mary's consent. No, he didn't, which is remarkable. We go back and read this in Luke. - I'm gonna read it, by the way, more pro-consent, by the way. - Angel comes down and asks Mary, if this is something she wants to do. And she says, if it is God's will, let it be done. Let it be, let it happen. So to me, that is an affirmation in one of our most central stories that creation has to be done with consent. You cannot force someone to create. Creation is one of the most sacred acts that we engage in as human beings. But that has to be done with consent, has to be done with freedom. And to me, that is absolutely consistent with the ministry and life and death of Jesus. - All right, pause. So first of all, I just wanna make very, very clear. All Christians should unequivocally this consent. That's like, let me just, but well, what people do on the internet is like, but so you're saying, so I just like, honestly dude, like Old Testament, I think that forcible rape should be a death penalty. So let me just get that out there, like I thought I'd think. So very, very, very pro-consent. But this is a weird thing to say. Paul, why is it a weird thing to say? - Well, so he said, go back and read it. So I would love to. - Yeah, be great. - Before actually, can we just stop and like, this is when I listen to this is probably the part that infuriated me the most. Like, do you really wanna base your theology of abortion on the fact that Mary could have aborted the Son of God? Yeah, that he could have killed the Son of God 33 years before a body else got a chance Is that really like it or you want to base your theology of abortion on but I can revisit that another time So I actually go and read the text like he told us to so the angel said to her Do not be afraid Mary for you have found favor with God and behold I'm gonna put some emphasis on words because I think you're gonna see pattern you will conceive in your womb in Baris son and you shall call his name Jesus shall be a command he will be great and will be called the Son of the Most High and The Lord God will give him the throne of his father David and he will rain over the house of Jacob forever in his kingdom There will be no end and Mary said to the angel How will this be since I'm a virgin and the angel answered her the Holy Spirit will come upon you and the power of the Most High Will overshadow you therefore the child will be born will be called holy the son of the son of God And behold your relative Elizabeth in a road age has also conceived a son And this is the six months with her who was called barren for nothing will be impossible with God you skipped If it's okay with you would this be okay with you? No, I was literally gonna stop there So did you guys hear like any of my place where God said hey, would it be if it's okay? Yeah, if it's okay So like all these statements are firm. This is going to happen or you shall do this He just raises a while. I just like literally made up a Bible and then while yeah Then it does say in Mary said behold I am the servant of the Lord let it be to me according to your word and the angel apart from her So actually when I was thinking about this if anything this confirms our viewpoint which is she basis says I am going to be obedient. So yeah She innocence did give consent to obey so that question would be if she had not given consent what would that have been Son it would have been disobedient never in any place this you get any any hint of God saying hey as long as it's okay with you So here's so I just want let me boil this down. Is that the end of the clip? I think So I here's one point out here's a big idea zoom out for that dude James synagogue of Satan James All of these obscure passages with like loony interpretations are secretly about abortion But you shall not murder isn't I It's like that's really you zoom out. That's what's going on all these obscure passages that had this you know, we all you know the secret Interpretation that nobody's ever noticed before those are about abortion, but you should not murder isn't that's your problem There's your problem. Yeah a couple questions briefly for you pastor Josh But why are you talking about this? This is a political issue. You're a pastor. Yeah, so what I would say is no People keep saying that the church is getting more political And I'm like, no, the church is not getting political politics are getting spiritual That's it's my little riff I say it all the time because I get accused of this all the time Church getting political. No, it's not politics reading spiritual when the government moved past things like building roads and Issuing drivers licenses and teaching math to things like redefining marriage or racing gender Re-framing abortion as quote unquote reproductive rights and then indoctrinating everybody's kids into believing those things via the government school system Hey, the church didn't move politics did and whenever whenever the government moves out of its lane and Into the church's lane about things like morality Definitions of life and marriage is the job of the church we go like we could someday we should's like super nerd out on like Kuiperians fear sovereignty Abraham Kuiperans fear sovereignty Theology of societal arrangements, but whenever the government moves out of their lane and into the church's lane It's the job of the church to like hey man get back in your lane or I'm have to put you in the dirt And that that's what's happening right now church is going hey man get back in your lane You don't you don't define what life is marriage is gender is no that's God's job get back in your lane and submit to the worship of Jesus Here here's one more wait, but Christians are supposed to be nice and you just called them Pastor of the synagogue of saying yes, so I would just did Paul reference it earlier Jesus said anyone who causes one of these little ones to sin. It would be better for him to have a millstone tied around his neck Then to then to continue so Dude when people accuse us of being clear. This is somebody who is publicly on the largest podcast in the world Influencing Christians towards sin and not just sin but sin that results in the mass taking of innocent human life That is not a moment for measured words. Let's be naive. No, no That's a moment to be like sit down shut up and you're you are resulting in people dying So that so so if somebody's like hey Josh, that's mean. No, no What's mean is allowing someone to continue teaching things that if believed will result in death and people going to hell That's mean in this biblical by the way even when you say synagogue of Satan if people don't realize you're really just referring to a term That's yes. Sorry. That's a I'm quoting revelation three Yeah, and then also is like if you read through the epistles and even look through Jesus where they get heated And they're not afraid to do things like this is when the flock is being attacked in misled So even like in Galatians when false teachers are trying to lead them away Around the issue of circumcision Paul literally says I wish they would just Gonna follow them so 5 6 something and so you see like scripturally anytime the flock is being misled Basically christian leaders have the responsibility to rise up and speak very pointedly and call it out Yeah, that's probably that's why I asked to do this on podcast because again the number of people who sent that clip to me And it was people who like hey, what do you think about this? They were confused And honestly, let me just like gently because there's a lot of pastors that watch this Part of the reason that a lot of Christians are confused is because the pulpits have not been clear So like that's our job. Let's do our job. Jude 1 verse 3 beloved I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once and for all delivered to the saints That's it, man. That's it. Before you finish this I just want point one other thing out about this guy so That clip went insanely viral like in insanely viral. I think Joe Rogan said he should run for president He did say he should run for president, which is terrifying What I want to point out I went and scooped out this guy first of all I think he passed a church of like 11 people It's like I would just you can just tell That's a whole side note like this is a whole different podcast progressive Christianity Grows social media platforms, but shrinks churches. I'll just that is a thing That is totally a thing This guy like came on the scene preaching against Christian nationalism. He was like all these like these These politicians are trying to use the Bible to influence their Their policy and that's evil Christian nationalism Well, what I want to point out is he's preaching against Christian nationalism And then he's using obscure incorrect and loony interpretations of scripture to inform his public policy decisions So you'll see this a lot progressive Christians are extremely politically active like way more politically active than conservative Christians the the someday we should talk about this the data around the political activity of progressive Christians vastly more politically engaged than conservative Christians, which is really interesting. Hold it hold everything But what you'll notice conservative or progressive Christians do is they do Christian nationalism for me, but not for the They constantly do that. So they accuse conservative Christians if you guys are doing Christian national It's not fair for you to bring your personal beliefs into public square And then they'll walk out and they'll be like well, Jesus was an immigrant. So we should have open borders Jesus fed the poor so we should have you know unlimited welfare and USAID and universal basic income Jesus you I you saw this two years ago tons of these statements from progressive Christians where they would talk about Jesus makes a comment about unix and we don't have I don't want to talk about this right now He makes a comment about unix and some people were made unix and some people became unix You know by choice that kind of thing and progressive Christians who were politically engaged pointed to those like see It's okay to be transgender. We should have affirming transgender laws So my point is the same dude they gets famous preaching against Christian nationalism goes on Joe Rogan and is like hey Because of my beliefs about scripture. Here's what the public policy should be Christian nationalism for the For me but not for the girl. You

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. James Tallerico, a self-proclaimed "pastor" and political figure, made viral claims on Joe Rogan that confuse Christians by asserting Jesus never spoke about homosexuality or abortion, which is biblically and historically inaccurate.
  2. The argument that Jesus never addressed certain moral issues is flawed because it misunderstands biblical reasoning—Jesus affirmed the Old Testament law and defined what is right, thereby implying what is wrong by context and authority.
  3. The New Testament explicitly condemns homosexual practice (e.g., 1 Corinthians 6:9–10), and the early Church consistently taught that abortion is a form of murder, with historical testimony from early Christian writings dating back to the 1st century.
  4. Passages like Numbers 5
  5. The Southern Baptist Convention was never pro-choice; in 1971, it affirmed life and allowed abortion only in specific, limited circumstances, reflecting a pro-life stance with exceptions.
  6. The theological foundation for opposing abortion rests on the belief that all human life is sacred from conception, as affirmed in Genesis, Luke, and Ecclesiastes, and that taking life is equivalent to murder.
  7. The claim that Mary’s consent to conceive Jesus justifies abortion is a misapplication of Scripture—her consent was a voluntary, divine affirmation, not a precedent for bodily autonomy.
  8. The episode critiques how both progressive and conservative Christian leaders sometimes use selective or distorted scriptural interpretations to advance political agendas, emphasizing that the Church’s role is to defend biblical truth, not political trends.

Summary:

James Tallerico’s viral Joe Rogan interview sparked widespread confusion among Christians due to claims that Jesus never addressed homosexuality or abortion. The response highlights that such arguments are flawed, as Jesus affirmed the Old Testament and defined ethical boundaries—such as marriage and sexuality—through clear biblical teaching. The New Testament explicitly condemns homosexual practice, and early Church history, from the Didakay to Tertullian and Augustine, consistently taught that abortion equates to murder.

Passages like Numbers 5 are misread as supporting abortion; they actually involve divine judgment for adultery and contain no reference to pregnancy. The Southern Baptist Convention in 1971 affirmed life and allowed abortion only in rare cases, confirming their pro-life stance. ” The episode also critiques how political discourse distorts scripture—whether by progressive Christians framing abortion as a reproductive right or conservative figures using selective interpretations.

It stresses that Christian leaders must defend biblical truth, especially on life and marriage, and that the Church’s role is to uphold spiritual truth, not to align with political movements. The conclusion emphasizes that Mary’s consent to conceive Jesus is not a precedent for abortion, and that true Christian teaching centers on the sanctity of life, bodily consent, and obedience to God’s Word.

FAQs

Jesus does not explicitly mention homosexuality or abortion, but he clearly defines marriage as a heterosexual, lifelong covenant. The New Testament, particularly in 1 Corinthians 6, explicitly addresses homosexuality as a sin that excludes people from inheriting the kingdom of God. Abortion is not addressed directly in Jesus’ teachings, but the principle of 'thou shalt not murder' forms the core of Christian moral teaching on taking life in utero.

This claim is misleading. While Jesus didn't use specific language about homosexuality, he defined marriage as between a man and a woman in Matthew 19. By doing so, he established a clear biblical standard that implies homosexuality is outside the norm. This is consistent with New Testament teaching that such practices are sinful and exclude one from the kingdom of God.

Many Christian traditions view abortion as morally wrong because it involves the taking of an innocent human life. Based on the principle 'thou shalt not murder' (Exodus 20:13), Christians argue that a developing human being in the womb is a member of the human species with a right to life, making abortion an act of murder.

Yes, early Christian leaders such as Tertullian and John Chrysostom clearly taught that destroying a fetus in the womb is equivalent to murder. Early church writings, including the Didache and the Letter of Barnabas, explicitly prohibit abortion, showing a long-standing Christian belief that life begins at conception.

Scripture teaches that life begins in the womb. For example, Psalm 139 says God knew the child before it was formed, and Luke 1:41 uses the word 'baby' for an unborn child, showing the same term is used for infants. Additionally, Ecclesiastes describes the breath of life entering the womb, indicating life begins before birth.

This is a common argument from silence. Jesus didn’t list every sin, but he defined what is right—like marriage and sexuality. By establishing marriage as a lifelong union between man and woman, he implicitly rejected practices like abortion and homosexuality. The argument from silence is weak because it ignores biblical context and definition.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.