May The Odds Be Ever In Their Favor w/ Mckenna Grace | Reading Reddit Stories
54m 39s
The Smoshreads episode explores four humorous yet emotionally complex "Am I the Asshole?" Reddit stories, each highlighting misunderstandings and miscommunications in personal relationships. In the first story, a man wins a hot dog eating contest at a food festival, unaware it was a family tradition where his girlfriend’s father had been the reigning "dogler" for years. Reddit concludes he’s not the asshole—his ignorance of the tradition and the family’s emotional investment makes the situation a misstep, not malice. In a second story, a sister’s wedding requires guests to write 250-word essays to attend, which Reddit users find absurd and manipulative, especially as it puts emotional pressure on attendees. A third story involves a woman honestly stating she’s not in love with her best friend’s fiancé, which leads to backlash from the fiancé’s family, but Reddit deems her actions appropriate and truthful. The final story centers on a woman getting a *The Hunger Games* Mockingjay tattoo, which her future father-in-law hates—Reddit dismisses her as not the asshole, criticizing the father-in-law’s extreme reaction to a personal choice. Across all stories, the core theme is that people often misread emotional context, and Reddit’s verdict consistently emphasizes empathy, lack of awareness, or poor communication over blame. The episode ends with a humorous twist, tying it all together with a "Dogler Nation" tattoo reference and a call to celebrate personal freedom—even if it upsets family traditions.
Hello, and welcome to Smoshreads Reddit Stories. I'm Shane and today's theme is a classic just am I the asshole stories and I'm joined by Courtney Miller and Star of the upcoming Hunger Games movie McKenna Grace I Have been telling you guys like a million times off camera. I can't believe I'm this is very big for me And I like I'm like no, that's insane. No, as somebody who's very online I've heard the room. Oh, yeah, they're not rumors Yeah, we heard you were coming on and then I heard like, oh, you're a fan of the show Oh, but I whenever I hear that I'm like oh, they're just saying like they listen to an episode No, yeah, of course, of course. Okay, cool. Yeah, I've always loved um what it's like the laugh you lose like I've always liked that Oh my god Was it rent link didn't episode? Yeah, I really love that was good. Yeah, that's tennis character that we put all the stuff Okay, you're not kidding I also don't like do exclusively consume like my am I the asshole stories from what is it like the subway surfers videos like on That's fine. I sometimes while I will rewatch our own episodes via On TikTok where someone's molding soap beneath it. Oh, yeah, I'm talking above it. It's weird. Yeah, yeah Okay, so you're a very online person you said. Yeah, he yes Okay, cuz I think it's pretty it's it's pretty known that you're you're on Tumblr. I wasn't on Tumblr I mean, I'm very familiar with the platform and I'm very familiar with a lot of the things on it, but I was more I did I made I made a good amount of edits in my time Okay, you're not a little. Yeah, I'm an editor incredible. I've done some edits. I've done my dues. Yeah Yeah, I mean, I've been very I was more like Pinterest and okay, cool musicly and TikTok like I was I was on there but very much very much in the YouTube space Wow, I know yeah, that's wow. We're still started really um how do you ever go on Reddit at all? You know, I definitely try to stay away that like I Yeah, yeah, do you guys find these stories yourself? Is there do you have like a dedicated? Yeah, you're the only producer. I'm so sorry They put you through that. I feel sorry for her every day I think this one was like I was up until one I am last night My my impression of Emily gets more and more taxes every time I do it I directed a couple of shows in the back in the day and I did like a spooky one where the stories were very scary and like Yeah, the ones we picked were like safe for the internet, but you got to really and after I made that episode I was like I need a break It is the hardest part of the job. I have the easiest part of the job I just read them Emily has to scour the internet for them. I'm so sorry that they do that to you Yeah I definitely try to stay like I said I kind of exclusively consume my Reddit stories like via tick-tock and subway surfers and You guys so Um, I do love them. I do I do love them. Yeah, I mean, but I don't try and find myself. Yeah, for sure Not doing that. No, you have types of stories that you like the most Or just kind of general all of them. I like the scary ones Like I really like the kind of I like kind of the subreddit where it's like Give me like two sentence horror stories. Oh, yeah, I walked in and I used a fork little did I know it was an evil Yeah, oh, yeah, I like that stuff. It's not make me laugh Classic evil fork story That stuff is so well cool. Well, I think today we have more Classic am I the asshole stories, you know, it's not really but um, but yeah, let's uh, what's up in okay? Our first one comes from am I the asshole posted in January of 2025 Okay, and they write am I the asshole for beating my girlfriend's dad in a hot dog? Okay, am I the asshole for beating my girlfriend's dad in a hot dog party? Well, okay, am I the asshole for beating my girlfriend's dad in a hot dog eating contest Reading it fast so we know the full context This is it so the OP is a 25-year-old man. Mm-hmm. His girlfriend's 24 the dad is 51 Okay for the full context Mm-hmm right off the bat before we get into the story if I'm entering a hot dog eating contest I'm not holding back. Yeah, I don't care who I'm competing against. Yeah, if I look around. It's all children I'm like, sorry, you're losing. Yeah No, of course, that's completely unnecessary. Oh, it has to go so off the bat. No, I don't think he's the asshole No, sorry, like come on. Yeah, I mean, it just sounds like he's a sore loser. Yeah, maybe that's your end Okay, so the hot dog eating contest happened like six months ago during the summer and I had no idea that I Did anything wrong but my girlfriend and I were arguing about something else and she brought the contest up and said I had acted childishly and I wanted to know if there was anything that I had to apologize for So basically six months ago my girlfriend invited me to a food festival in her hometown The day I arrived I learned that there was a hot dog eating contest and the prize would be a hundred dollar gift card to a large Tech retail store being a casual competitive eater in college. I Decided it would be a fun idea to enter I decided to be a fun idea to enter and signed up on the website when I told my girlfriend's family I had entered the contest my girlfriend's dad good-naturedly Clapped me on the back and said let the best man win. Apparently my girlfriend's dad had won the hot dog eating contest for the last for years Whoa, and was somewhat expecting to win again Wanting the gift card. I decided to give the contest my all. I ate a bunch of hot dogs I wasn't even paying attention to what I was doing But by the time I was done, I'd eaten 16 hot dogs in five minutes beating my girlfriend's dad who only ate 12 Hot dogs. Oh, he crushed him. Yeah, destroyed. I'm picturing that guy. You know, you know which guy the competitive eater. Joey Chessna. Yep, Joey Chessna Exactly. I know So she's dating Joey Chessna. Okay When I was done my girlfriend's brother Liam who's 14 and a bunch of his friends mobbed me calling me the dogler Giving me high fives and clapping me on the back. They said that I had de-throened the dogler Pointing to my girlfriend's dad and that I was the new dogler that I was a real glizzied Rizzler oh or something like that. I really enjoy all of the words I'm really like kidding to hear you say that and that I was just shoving glizzy after glizzy down my gullet They posed for pictures with me. It was weird, but kind of fun Later my girlfriend's dad came up to me shook my hand and said it was good competition He went home to do something in his wood shop So I hung out with my girlfriend Liam and his friends going around to various food stalls and games When we all ate dinner that night the hot dog contest didn't come up at all except for when Liam kept referring to me as the dogler And saying that he wanted to make a special dogler shirt for me We had a nice breakfast the next morning. No sign that anything was wrong Today though my girlfriend brought up in our argument that her dad was actually really wounded by losing the hot dog eating contest But just didn't say anything to me. I said if I wasn't supposed to enter the contest Then was it really a contest at all and she said that it was less about the contest But about the special dogler shirt Liam made his dad a dogler shirt for the years he won the contest But I got the dogler 2024 shirt She said that her dad only wanted to win the contest to connect with Liam and if anything I should be able to understand the masculine ego. So reddit. Am I the asshole? Who knew hot dogs could cause so much controversy? Geez, I need to know. I need to know. I mean if he would have known that going into it And I was like I'm going to I'm going to beat you old man. I'm going to dethrone the dogler He signed up for this contest and the girlfriend didn't go hold up. You can't enter that contest Yeah, this is my dad's thing. Basically my dad is the dogler And it's like this whole thing and he's been the dogler for four years straight I like how she's like he wanted to like this was his way of connecting with Liam But it's like he's one at four years in a row He's had plenty of time to connect with Yeah, and the fact that it's only that one day of the year. It's like I don't talk to it. I don't talk to Liam up Liam staying over there unless he's calling me the dogler Unless he's making me a shirt not talking to him I think it's a bummer that the dad like actually like everything was fine Like and that there was no issue and now something that what she said six months later. Yeah, that this was an issue
-Yeah. -Like, come on. -Okay. -I mean, it feels like it's something just brought up in a fight, you know? -It feels a little bit like, yeah. -I understand. I understand the position that the dad isn't in the way that he feels, but it wasn't, like, priorly, you know. -No. -And it's not like he went out of his way to be like, "Fuck, you know, put you in your place. "Oh, man, I'm the new dog learned." -That was right. -You know? -Yeah, and I love the nature. -It's like, kind of sweet. It's like, wow. Like, you really are part of the family. You're a dogler, too. -Like, wouldn't you think that the dad would be like, "Wow, my daughter picked right." -Yeah. -I think we all dogler, you know? -Yeah. -Like, we all. -Yeah, you know? -We all, for real. -For real, a glizzy globular or whatever. -All right. -Now, I wouldn't go that far. -Let's go that far. -Let's go that far. -I wouldn't say that, but we can't be doglers. -Right. -It's not like, yeah, it's not like later that night at dinner, the OP was like, "Yeah, I'm hungry. Could I get another hot dog?" Like, straight to the dad's face. -Look at him in that, like, feels while he's eating it, you know, like. -Yeah. -Didn't even do it that, but he wasn't. -Didn't feel like it was respectful. -It was also, like, a cool opportunity for the boyfriend and the dad to commit. -Oh, yeah. -Oh, you like hot dog eating contests? Well, I'm really good at them, and it's. -It's like, hey, the. -You dogler. -The competition's gonna happen next year, and it's gonna be the rematch of the century. -Yeah. -Like, this is, this sounds incredible. Even though the dad's at 12 hot dogs, not impressive to me, like, I think this dad. This dad was a bit of imposter the whole time, like. -So, who's the rest of the competition? What do they do with hot dogs? -Yeah, hot dogs was the reigning champ. -Maybe it's even, like, big fish and small pond. -Yeah. -It's like a smaller town. -Was the dad the only competitor? -No. -Like, hot dog eating contests only me. -Everyone's watching. -Oh, my dream. Anyways, okay, the verdict on Reddit is not the asshole. -Right. -That's fair. -Yeah. -Yeah. -In fact, what I've said, what I hate more than anything, is pity losing. Like, if I'm in a competition with someone, don't hold back. -Yeah. -I'll know, and I'll be so mad. -Yeah. I mean, if he knew that it was a thing with the sun, then I'd be like, that's an understandable, like, oh, like, I'll just put up a good fight and then lose that way you guys can have your thing. -Yeah. -And then that's another point of connection, but not knowing that prior, I think, makes him not the asshole in this situation. -Yeah. -Yeah. -He signed up before he knew that the dad was the dogler. Comments, not the asshole. You didn't really have any idea this was an important family tradition until the moment after you signed up. And who was in control of the actions of a crowd of 14-year-olds anyway? That said, all this tension for a gift card is kind of intense. I hope you got something good with the prize money. O.P. responded, well, she did tell me that it was a tradition, but I didn't think it was as big of a deal as apparently it is. I got a couple of video games I've been eyeing, finances have been kind of tight recently, so it was nice. -No, right? -No. -All right. -So I gotta say, I love hot dog eating contests. It's kind of like the track and field of competitions where you're in your own lane. You're just doing your best, right? You're not affecting anybody else. He even said he's like, I don't even know what's happening. He was just hot dogger. -Yeah, just good one. -He just did his best. It wasn't like he was like, I must defeat father. It was-- -Yeah. -He just happened, that's where he landed. -And he wasn't actively counting. He's not like, oh, I'm at 11 hot dogs. I need to stop. -Right. -You're just going. -Yeah, that's the buoy. Sometimes hot dogs are really good, and you lose count. You're just really in the moment. -Yeah. -It's not as fault that he became the dogler. I mean, yeah, you cannot control the group of teenagers. Boys, what they're going to call you, exactly. -And W. -Some people have doglers thrust upon them. -Yeah. -Okay. -Yeah. Anyways, someone said, not the asshole, when we all ate dinner that night. So you had dinner after eating 16 hot dogs? -Well, yes. -I know. Uh, someone said, info, where is this hot dog eating contest? Longstanding champ at 12 and current champion 16? Sounds like I'd crush it there. -Oh, sure. -What I'm saying. -Oh, yeah. -Okay. Someone said, let me break it to you, man. This isn't about the hot dog eating contest. Your girlfriend is clearly mad about something else, and she's choosing this moment to take it out on you. I'd say sit down with her and ask to have a frank conversation pun intended. But it's also up to her to communicate with you. You're not a mind reader, and I find it worrying that your girlfriend expects that from you, not the asshole. O.P. responded, "Yeah, she's been upset since I've been working from home. The startup still needs more time to pull in some money, so she's had to make some tough choices." -Oh. -Oh, yeah, I feel like-- -Well, I feel like we're getting into a whole different territory. -I feel like the hot dog situation is really pretty small compared to-- -Yes, this-- -There's other meats going on here. -There's a whole barbecue problem. -Yeah, yeah. The ribs are over here. -Oh, my God. This is why you guys look funny, but it's still-- -Oh, great. Okay. -Do not. -Do not. -Hey, check this out. Update. -Whoa! More hot dogs. -Oh, sorry. I thought that you had an update for like this, and I was like, "Oh, my God, what's happening?" -Yes. -Like a Smosh update, or like-- -Oh, yeah. -Oh, yeah, okay. -It's an update on the public. -Wait, what kind of person's a new cast, my current Smosh? -Op day, Anthony's leaving again. -No. Update for the dogler. -Yes. -Dogler update. -Dogler update. -He can't still be calling himself that. -Up dog. -Up dog. -That's crazy. -That's crazy. -Oh, yeah. -You leave, you're like, "Sorry." -It's like, "Oh, guys." -This is an update from the next day. -Oh, okay. -I feel fresh. Fresh ones. -Okay, as a little update, my girlfriend found this post. She was a little mad at first, but overall, our original argument kind of went away because I put all my clothes in the dryer, and luckily, I booked two consultation appointments, so that part of the argument went away as well. -Hey, bud. -Let's hold it up. What is dog? -I'm on here. -Dogler consultation. -Shit. -Okay. -You think the hot dog competition's crazy? We two hear about the dryer. -Wow. -Wow. -Okay. -The hot dog thing was kind of just a bonus jab she threw in my face when she found the dogler shirt in the washer. She doesn't really care about it now. She agreed to stop bringing stuff up from a long time ago and said she accidentally overexaggerated how sad her dad was about the contest. So overall, things are nice. -Well, then great. -Oh, okay. It is all good. Actually, guys, just kidding. She's a little surprised and upset at the amount of posters that suggested we break up, welcome to Reddit. -Yeah. -I'm a little surprised by all the people who called me the asshole just for entering an eating contest. Also, after a lot of asking, I've decided to post the shirt. I smoked a little too much before I fell asleep and forgot to take the shirt out of the dryer before I spent a day running my business. My business eating hot dogs. But I remembered now. I posted the shirts to an imager and had to make an account on imager for this, so I hope you're happy. All right. You guys ready for the dog look shirt? -We just see it. -The dogler. -There's the dogler shirt. -Oh. -It looks hand-drawn. -Oh, my gosh. It totally is. -It's so funny. Just catch up. -2020. Just catch up. -That's all right. You don't know how dogs are wrong. -That's awesome. -That's your hot dog? Just catch up? -That's totally fine. And you don't even need catch up. -That's okay. -I'm getting conflicting messages. I feel like on this side of the couch is not totally fine. -My dog is really good on its own. -So he's psycho because he eats something on them. -Okay. -He eats them with nothing on them. -What is in a pain? -Thank you, mechanic Grace. Thank you so much. -And what does Joey Chess not do? He eats them with water. -Right. -Yeah. Well, yeah. But yeah. If you haven't got to eat them fast. -I was just trying to find some-- -Oh, and then also this is on the back of the shirt. -You can't beat the glizzied Rizzler. -Why don't you say that 10 times fast? -Yeah. -No. -No, no, no, no. -We're not going to be able to do that. -You can't say that. -That's not the clip. -No. -It's just to lose. -Sorry, Dad. -Lock in. -He eats for hot dogs. -I don't know. -Next year. -I really do appreciate the comment that was, like, I feel like I'd kill it there. -Oh, and I feel like-- -He's probably right. -Yeah. -He's probably right. -No, I think 12 hot dogs has a record. -Yeah. -It seems love. -Is that y'all's next episode? -No, I'm not eating hot dogs. -It's good. -I think my heart could end. -Oh, your heart's in it. -My stomach, baby, too. -I really can't. -I can't do it. -I think I would do pretty well. -I think I'm competing against the cast. If I'm competing against the Smosh cast, I think I might win. -I've just invited myself in this scenario. -Yes, please. -And I think that my eyes and my stomach and my heart, I think in my heart, I could just win. -Oh. -I don't know how many I have to eat, but I know I can win. -I love it. -I think I could do it. -I don't know. -I could eat more than 16. -Yeah, that would be quite good. -I could do it. -The game of hunger. -Sorry. -I'm so sorry. Am I going to great? -All right. -All right. -This episode of Red Stories is sponsored by WayFair. It's the holiday season, which means a lot of people are coming over. It's time to clean, organize, decorate, and host. For all things hosting, WayFair delivers high-quality customer-trusted products for your home so you can host and celebrate without the stress. With WayFair, you can shop thousands of products no matter your style or budget. With filters, customer photos, and more than 20 million verified five-star reviews, you can shop with confidence. I recently got the 30 pair shoe cabinet and it totally transformed my entryway. No more tripping over shoes or feeling stressed by clutter the second I walked through the door. I read all the reviews and I loved seeing the photos of the shoe cabinet. It helped me visualize what it would look like in my own home. I feel ready to host, thanks to WayFair.
affair. When refreshing your home this holiday season, Wayfair delivers exactly what you need. Head to Wayfair.com to shop all things home. That's W-A-Y-F-A-I-R.com. Now, back to the show. Shiz. Wayfair every style, every home. Wow, okay. Okay. It's time for our second story. Yes. This story comes from Am I the Asshole from back in July of 2020? Oh. Yeah. Oh, I'm excited to see if this is Dave. You can tell that this was written in 2020. Oh, yeah, you can tell. Am I the Asshole for refusing to RSVP to my sister's wedding because I'm required to write an application essay just to attend? What? Wait, for a birthday party? For a wedding. For a wedding. Oh. Her sister's wedding. Oh. Oh. She has to apply for her own sister's wedding. Oh. Well, I want to know what the reasoning is. What I was like. Yeah, that's it. Yeah. I know this sounds insane, but I'm living in it. So my sister is getting married next February. Destination wedding no less. I have doubts whether this wedding is actually going to happen with the pandemic and everything, but she is totally set on moving forward. Anyways, because of the pandemic, her original venue has made her cut down on guests because they're cutting capacity by half. As a result, she's sending out reinvites that ask everyone to RSVP again. But in order to figure out who to invite and who to cut, she's asking all confirmed guests to submit to 250 word essays to two questions. The gist is that they'll use these essays to choose who can come or not based on people's enthusiasm. People who don't write the essays at all will be automatically disqualified. Whoa. I just feel really insulted by all of this. I feel like she's a college professor or something. I can't imagine that would be fun before you're wedding to sit there and read 500 essays. Yeah, not in MLA format, dad. Sorry. The questions aren't even pandemic related. It's broad topics like, why do you still want to celebrate this day with us? And what will attending our wedding mean to you specifically? So she's blatantly looking for people to kiss ass and tell her why they really want to go. Anyways, anyways, anyways, I told her in advance I'm not writing 500 words on why I need to attend her wedding, spend my own money on plane ticket slash hotels and buy her a present. This has really rubbed her and my parents the wrong way. She said that to keep things fair, if I don't fill out the RSVP correctly, I won't be saved a spot. I said fine with me. Then my parents said, if I don't show up, I'm going to be in big fucking trouble with all our relatives. So just write the essays. What? Am I the asshole? If I stay stubborn on this, I'm already annoyed at the thought of spending thousands and coming home to quarantine, but I will not belt out 500 words on how this is totally my choice. Am I the asshole? Edit. I'm a 27 year old woman. I don't live with my family, but she is my only sister. Edit number two, sister has framed these essays as surveys, but there's a word limit requirement. So if you don't reach it on the Google Forms, you can't even submit. Parents think this is perfectly reasonable. Nice even, because my sister is letting everyone have the chance to attend. The chance. I'd say out of all, so far now, this one actually. Well, the hot talking contest is a Hunger Games, but this is also kind of a Hunger Games situation. Oh, yeah, I got it. Go for it. Go for it. Find for your position. Yeah. Okay, this is my favorite. So interesting. Like, okay, I obviously have a lot to say about this, because we've done so many wedding stories here, and you know, I'm so excited. You guys are married. I like all the edits. I love them. Oh, my God. It's exciting. Was there a part of it that doubted when you showed up today that we were pranking everyone? No, you guys are really cute. I'm sorry. Okay, anyways, but yeah, we got married, and there was a lot of decisions that were made that it's like, you do this because it's fair to people or you do this because it's exactly what you want. And like, the bride, it's interesting that they're seeing in a way where, oh, everyone gets a chance to go, but it's like, hey, bride, this is your day. Like, it's up to you who gets to go. That's the beauty of it. And if you are like, well, obviously immediate family, everyone should respect that. Everyone should respect the couple that's getting married to choices, especially in a pandemic. It's enough that they're already wanting to still do this in such a crazy time. But like, that's tough to make people write essays. It's going to make it hurt even more. As opposed to just like, oh, they made the decisions based on logistics and whatever. But now it's like, okay, now I'm actually going to write something out there. And then that's going to get rejected. Yeah, that's crazy. If somebody like truly like wrote like a very heart, like, was like, you know what? I really want to be there. And like, I do really want to be there for them. And like wrote this super long essay. And she's like, ah, like, sorry, you didn't care enough. This puts the grandparents in a horrible, a Google doc. They gotta figure out a Google doc. Oh, a doc of what? Yeah. Yeah. They'll put the over seven you're making it to this wedding. Yeah. They're not figuring that out. I'm like, cousin Eric, who's like, I just really want to smash a couple brusquies with my bros. Please, please. I'm going to dance to Usher on your dance for please. Um, yeah, look, it's, this is ridiculous to make people attending your wedding do. But I will say, if I was in this position, I'm writing the hell out of that shit. I'm writing the coolest essay. I'm hitting a thousand words. I'm making a PowerPoint for it. Yeah. I'm submitting my own thing. Oh, yeah. It's going to be a novel quoting Thomas Edison. Yeah. His light bulbs are awesome. Anyways. Okay. The verdict is not the asshole. Obviously. But hey, it could have, and another word could have been a kind thing for the bride to do because it was during the pandemic. And she wanted to give everybody something to do. Right. I mean, I'm making sourdough bread. It's our right. Everybody. I was just set up in my room. And at the end of it, I was like, you're all invited. Yeah. All always were. I wanted you guys to have a little project. That's the next update. I think there's an element that makes sense of like, okay, we got to cut this by half. So like, let me hear people out on, if, but that would be more pertaining to the pandemic of like, why is this work for you? Is this going to be hard for you to attend? Like try to make those decisions. But doing it in this way, make a little phone call, write a little emails and a little text like it. I wonder how many people are attending this wedding. And I can, I mean, I can't imagine wanting to read a million essays before you're ready. Oh, there's so much going on. There's so, I feel like there's so much else to do and so much else to celebrate. And you'd want to focus on, you know, your love in each other versus 100. It would make the decision so much harder, because you're reading all this heartfelt stuff from these people and then going, ah, that was really sweet. Yeah. Sorry. Yeah. They should have done like an America's Got Talent kind of like a limitation. Oh, you're just a mid video golden buzzer. That's what I'll do for my wedding someday. Talent composition. You want to come? Yeah. I was like, even also like the perspective of the sister specifically, like if the bride, like if they, if they're like, you have to come to this wedding or you'll be in trouble. So you have to write these essays. It's like, okay, sounds like you just want family to go. So that's okay. And then if you want to extend it and you're unsure about people outside of that bubble of people, maybe then you have a questionnaire or something. But like, yeah, the fact that it's this sister who's like, I'm not going to do this. And they're like, well, you have to because you have to go. It doesn't make sense. And why does she have to write an essay? And she has to go. Exactly. She's already got the part. Yeah. It is silly. It's like, it's your only sister. Like, I think it's fair to say she doesn't have to write the essay. I mean, it's like maybe if they weren't close or if they were strange, but it's like still the essay is like a little intense. Right. But it's, yeah, it's like, it's like people that it's like, okay, your media family is going to go. They're going to go. But I get, I get, I guess, I think it's a lot for anything. But the parents are just there for the drama. I'd be like, they just want to read. I'd be like, no, yeah. They're reading them. I do feel like reddit has like a way of hooking you and you're like, oh, you're not the asshole. Then you like read the update or you get to it. And then you get more information. It's like, okay. Yeah. The verdict for this is not the asshole. The comments, not the asshole. I would definitely send in two essays. The first would say, mom slash dad said, I have to come or I'm in big trouble over and over again. Right. You hit two, five. The copy pays. The second, I'm your sibling. Someone said, not the asshole. That is ridiculous. And I would respond in exactly the same way. I get that it's tricky whittling down a guest list. But I don't think it should be up to the guest to justify and provide evidence that their relationship with the couple warrants and invite. O.P. responded saying she says it's actually the fairest way to decide because she's giving everyone a chance regardless of familial ties. But wow, she's really making people apply to a wedding. Imagine some sad dude writing a whole essay just to get wait listed or rejected. Thank you for your response. Unfortunately, we cannot offer you a spot in our wedding.
at this time. We wish you the best on your future endeavors. May you get invited to all of your safety weddings. - No. - And if you still want to send us our present, that's cool, too. Opie responded, you joke, but she did actually tell people that presents are still welcomed, even if they can't attend, because they're no longer invited. Lastly, someone said not the asshole, holy moly, are her parents writing the essay, too? Opie said, yep, my mom even called to say she filled out the form and it only took her 20 minutes so I shouldn't be whining. Oh, having to apply to your own daughter. - I need to read the mom's essay. - Yeah, oh, you know the mom would all, the mom probably was eating that up. She was like, ever since we were born, I was waiting for this day. - Yeah. - So she's probably stoked about it. Yeah, wow, every day we hear a new crazy wedding thing. - So they wanted to give everybody a chance. - A fair chance, no matter what. - Outside of familiar, like look, the family could lose out. - But then it's like here. - And it's just like a random person, like-- - You're just gonna have a bunch of randos at your wedding 'cause you're like, oh. - It's like your coworker. - So it's really nice. - Yeah, and then you're like inviting them and it's like the most like stale room ever. - Yeah, like what if you have a bunch of author friends? - And then you're saying they're just so lazy writing. - The only person that's spending 20-20 poets. And you're like, oh my god. - Oh my god. - Yes. - Yeah. - Huh. - Yeah. - Wow. - Well. - I'd say even given the updates, I'd say not the asshole. - No, not at all. - Yeah. - Wow. - That was pretty cut dry. - That was? - Yeah. - That was an easy one. - I wonder how the wedding went. I wonder if they're still married. - I know. - I wonder how many guests were there. - Yeah. - In six years. - You don't wonder. - There is a world where this is cute. Like what if the couple that was getting married, they're writers. And it's like just like a big part of their love story. - Yeah. - And like maybe, yeah, but they didn't say anything about that. So probably not. - And why did it also have to be mandatory? - Yeah, mandatory is tough. And I love people who are going through a lot that are on that time. So those essays, some of them, maybe not the greatest work. - Probably not. - Yeah. - But if it was me, it would be incredible. - Yeah. - I would write some awesome stuff. - Yeah. - For so many good jokes. - It would be very funny. But also her fellow. - Yeah. - Yeah. Anyways, moving on. - Ready. - Our next story comes from "Am I the Asshole" posted this month, 2026. - Oh, a fresh off keep. - As of recording this in September. - Fresh off the Reddit press. - "Am I the Asshole" for telling my best friend's fiancé why I'm not in love with him. - Ah, no. - Oh boy. Yeah, that's not good. I, a 30-year-old woman, and best friends with David, a 30-year-old man. David and I met freshman year of college and clicked right away. We were even roommates for a while. And right now, we work for the same company in different divisions. After a decade of friendship, I know David's not what I want in a partner. He has a huge ego and can be selfish and melodramatic. Even his family admits he can be arrogant and careless. - All right. - Okay. - Okay, roasting the hell out of him. - All right. - I noticed a lot of positive changes in him when he met Trish. He asks other people how they are now. He's kinder. - Wow. - He started therapy. It's nice to see him work on himself. Last month, David asked me to be his best man. I've been involved with a lot of wedding party stuff on the groom's side. So it was nice when Trish asked me out to dinner with her side of the bridal party. It was an ambush. Trish and her maid of honor asked me if David and I ever hooked up and flat out if I was in love with him. - Whoa. - I said we never had and that I wasn't. Trish seemed weirded out by that answer and pushed. It went from being do you like David to why don't you like David? - Oh. - Real fast. I deflected and said he wasn't my type, but they kept pushing. Finally, I said he's arrogant and I don't have the energy to feed his ego and that's not what I want in a partner. The rest of the bride's maid's kind of laughed. Trish and her maid of honor got upset so we ended the night. Later, Trish texted the wedding party group chat saying she didn't want me in the wedding because I said horrible things about David and called him an egomaniac. - Oh, what do you want from this woman? - All his family and friends chimed in laughing, agreeing and calling him a selfish jerk and recounting all the times he pulled some bullshit for attention, things like faking a crisis, deliberately letting his car run out of gas so you won't ask him for favors, basic weaponized incompetence. David joined in and laughed, saying Trish made him want to work hard on himself. Trish saw that as David siding with me despite him literally stating to their family and friends in the chat that she made him want to be a better person. David's sister told me yesterday that Trish is still upset about how I responded and she's convinced I said these things because I want David. I texted David and asked him to talk to Trish about it and that I'd be willing to drop out of the wedding party if she was really that uncomfortable. David said he'd handle it, but I'm worried I was too blunt and either A, started drama accidentally or B, fell into one of David's drama traps and he's not as changed as we all think. (snoring) Okay. I wonder if there will be an interesting update pertaining to that. So that's wacky. I feel like she was backed up into a corner. They were like-- - She was absolutely, yeah, 100%. - There was no good way to get out of that conversation because obviously she's not going to say, yes, I'm in love with your fiance because she's not and they would not want to hear that. And then saying, no, but like, why not? And keeping pushing her and pushing her to be honest. - Also, why does she have to answer those questions and not David? That's your fiancee, like talk to him and be like, hey, do you have feelings for someone? - That part. - I mean, but also have they talked about that and that's why she's going-- - Why is there a vulnerability there? - I don't know. - Does Chris even trust David like this? - And she's never shown, obviously not any patterns. There's no patterns of her of OP like having feelings for David or anything that should make them feel. - Right. - Not that we hear David's story. - That's true. I am filling the gaps for sure. - We don't know for sure, but if we're to believe OP and at the very least in that conversation OP says, no, I don't have feelings for him. And then Trish goes, oh, why not? Which is crazy to fall in love with God. - Yeah, that is killer. - So why don't you love my fiancee? - There was a second where I was like, oh, is she upset that a girl's girl will be warning her. Like, don't marry this man. He's an eco-maniac, but she's literally said that he seemed like a better person. Don't you love when you can see someone come out of their shell and like, be a happier, better version, when they enter a relationship, like, it's a beautiful thing. But yeah, I don't know. It's just, that seems all very-- - Yeah. - I could imagine being like annoyed if a girl told me, yeah, the reason I didn't want to be with your fiance was because he, like, is selfish. And that's the only, you know, like, there is a world where it's like, she sees these things. She's like, oh, well, you don't, like, you would have wanted to be with him. If he's, you know, what's like, she could, like, turn it in her head. If I'm looking at it from a very immature perspective, but she also pushed her to say all of these things. - Totally. - And to be like, well, I mean, it seems like she has this assumption in her head that because they're friends of the opposite gender and they've been friends for a long time, that there's some feelings there. There was some connection. I mean, it feels like she has kind of a story in her head. So-- - I don't know, that's-- - Oh, he was putting a touch-bought. - Yeah, but I hear what you're saying, though, or the fiancee, she's like-- - Like, she could be the best interest in your heart if you're saying these mean things about him. Maybe she read a little too, or just further than what would be expected. I'm like, oh, then are you bitter about David? Like, why are you even friends with him? - Yeah. - If you think the way about him. And the fact that in the group chat, everyone's like, yeah, David's done some crazy stuff. So, like, the whole family, they all vouched for her in that way. - Yeah, it seems like a funny and sweet kind of thing after the fact of, I mean, it's like in the group chat of everybody agreeing to be like, oh, and he's like, yeah, well, she made me want to be a better person. Like, that's, that's huge. - That's huge. - Absolutely. - Absolutely. - But. - They're a better fit. I mean, it's tough. OP was put in an impossible spot. I mean, like, because if I'm sure if OP could go back, it's like, you just keep holding strong to just like, I'm not into him. I never was into him. - And like, also, you guys are getting married. Like, I would never want to answer that. Even if I had legitimate reasons or like, yeah. What's the way of being somebody in that position? - They were, they were screwed. Comments, don't ask questions if you can't handle the answer. Not the asshole. 16,000 up votes on that. Someone responded saying, it sounds like the bride is just looking for an excuse to kick OP out of the wedding, which is why she and made of honor arranged and ambushed during a bridal party. She seems jealous of OP and her bond with David. Someone said, Trish was looking for a fight. There was absolutely no winning in that conversation. She is a huge asshole. She wasn't going to accept that you don't like him. That was only a gateway to making you describe why, which BAM is a gateway to shunning you for being a bad friend. She had an agenda and it was probably driven by insecurity that her fiance has a female best friend and the visibility of you as a woman on his side of the wedding party. It's possible you could have avoided this with some other tap dancing around her questions, but probably not. Like I said, she had an agenda and it was to make you look bad, either as a direct threat to their relationship or an unsupportive friend to him. And obviously it fizzled out on her. It's unfortunate more people are not calling her out for this because it's shady as hell and wildly manipulative. But I'm not seeing why you feel like maybe you fell into one of David's traps. How did he trap you into this? Not the asshole. Someone replied to that saying, I read it as OP is unsure if it's not really David who is stirring things up behind the scenes. Like she sent a very level-headed text. If this is too much, I'll drop out.
but doesn't know what David is saying to Trish. - Right, right. So what I meant earlier is like how did that come up? Like how did, you know, like I understand being curious, like of course, like if, I mean you, like the thought would cross your mind and like oh, I wonder if anything ever happened. - Well, 'cause we've read other stories where like a fiancé who's about to get married has said to their fiancé like oh yeah, like if I wished I, like said something about that. - Yeah, or like oh, she totally had a thing for me or like. - Or like, or like yeah, I had a crush on her but she wasn't into me and it's like once you hear that, you're kind of like, uh, well. - Yeah, and I would understand that the fiancé, the bride to be would be like I want to know everything and squash all insecurities on certainties that I may have. So I'm going to ask her, but like she also totally could have asked him. And yeah, I am wondering that was also such a reddit comment by the way, the main one was like so reddit of like worst case scenario, worst intense being. - I'm just going to turn it out. - Here's what's actually going on. - She's the worst person ever and this happens. - She's land is from the start. - Would hope that's not what's happening. Yeah, I'm very curious what motivated the dinner and then yeah, it does raise a lot of questions. - Yeah. - And like regardless, it's like for OP also what's unfortunate is even if it gets arranged where OP can go to this wedding, it's like how is this wedding going to be for you? Like it sucks. That's that sucks. It is fun. I do feel funny just sitting here and like spiraling out, like gossiping about somebody. I bet that this happened. I bet she was thinking this out of like a couple of words about a person. - No, I feel illegal for that to be my dog. - It's great. - It's pretty nuts like this person wrote this and there's a chance that they'll then see this and be like, is that my count of grade? (laughing) - I don't blame either of them for their feelings or you know what's like I don't blame her for the curiosity and I don't blame OP for saying what she said. I just think that it was handled all around like a little - Totally. - Yeah, it was just a weird situation. - Absolutely. - If they're updates. - Please. - No. - What the hell, shame? - I'm sorry. - Why could that? - Okay. - From 16 days ago. - Uh-huh. - Give them time. - Give them time. - We'll email you if we get the update. - Yeah, we'll let you know. - We'll send you the link. - Would you go to the wedding or would you not? - Yeah, would you go to the, if you are OP? - Did I have to submit an essay? (laughing) - I'm there. - You would go to the wedding? - I feel like I would be similar to OP of like if it's that bad, I don't have to go. It's, you know, but it does feel like she's taking all the crap for something. - Yeah. - It's like, yeah, David should be responsible for these issues, not her. - You don't want to be the scapegoat. I don't know. - No. - Like it's like, hey, I'm not doing anything. - The common denominator is David. - Just, yeah, truly. - I feel like I just be like, is it worth it for me? I mean, like, yeah, if that's my best friend, of course, I'd want to be there to support them and I'd want to be there to like uplift and be like, this is your special day. Like I want to celebrate it with you, but it's like if I'm causing problems and somebody else's relationship for things that I'm unaware of or things that I can't control. It's like, I don't know, you know? It's like a, it's not worth it. - Sticky spot. - Worth it. - Ugh. - Wow. - Best of luck to all of 'em. - Wedding's good. - I hope they all end up happy. - Yeah, I would love that. - And she burns something out of this. - Yes. - Yes. - Yeah. - I'll put it in the folder for it. - All right. - Okay. - Well, anyways. - Brings us to our final story. - Oh, ready. - Deepers. (laughing) - But deepers, oh, she said it. - She said deepers. - Deepers. - Okay. Our last story comes from, am I the asshole? Post in August of 2023. - Okay. - Am I the asshole for getting a tattoo related to my favorite movie, which my future father-in-law hates? - Ugh. - What? - Throw away accounts so I can stay anonymous. I won't say which movie it is. - It's Jim Carrey's The Grinch. I won't say which movie is-- - You would never get tattoos for movies. - So we don't ever do that. - Never do that. - Never do that. - Never do that. - Oh, shit. - Never ever. (laughing) - Throw away accounts so I can stay anonymous. I won't say which movie it is in the post, but if it is essential, I can write a message if asked. Okay, so basically, I, a 27-year-old woman, got a tattoo related to my favorite movie. I have multiple other tattoos too. The thing is, my fiance, who's 29, his father, who's 54, hates this movie to the guts. Like literally. I didn't really care about it. I just never mentioned it to him like ever, knowing he hates it. I got this tattoo on my arm and he obviously noticed, but didn't tell me a word about it. He called my fiance, who got mad and yelled at me for disrespecting his father's opinion, and told me he's threatening to not come to our wedding and cut us off completely. - What? - My fiance didn't even have a problem with this tattoo at first, only now, and asking me to go remove it. - Can I tattoo her? - Whoa. - We talking about this movie. - What movie is this? - Yeah. - What? - Whoa. - To add, I've planned this tattoo years before I met my fiance, and I didn't get it done to upset his father, which I was accused of. My parents learned about the situation and they're on my side, saying it's not that big of a deal, and father-in-law has nothing to do with my body anyway. - Right. - Am I the asshole for getting the tattoo? Edit. I know I said I won't put the movie here, but here you go. My tattoo is the mocking Jay from The Hunger Games. - Whoa. I was gonna ask. - I was going a lot of different plays. I was like, there's a lot of bad things you could get to with that would offend somebody. So I'm like, "What?" - I haven't told you I can't do that. - Boris Gump's shoes. - It's like, I don't know. (laughing) - Boris Gump didn't run. - Boris Gump didn't run. - Yeah. - Boris Gump could have been him. - Could have been the pumpkin. - Yeah. - That's what he was going. - Oh, but a band like Barnyard. - Like Beetlejuice. - Barnyard. - Barnyard. - I was just trying to think of like the most offensive, like, like, that fins my eye. - It would offend a father-in-law. - Yeah. - Oh. - Wow, that's on the monitor, Jay. - Yeah. - Okay. - The monitor, Jay feels like that's gotta be a story. - You are not the asshole. - Yeah. - Yeah. - Yeah. - Okay. - That's right. - Yeah. - And that's right. - It's gotta be a super popular tattoo nowadays, right? - Yeah, I'm sure it's a beautiful emblem. - I get one. - Yeah, like a movie franchise has something iconic like that. - Yeah. - Like, it's so many people get those tattoos. - Yeah. I have a bunch of movie tattoos on there, I feel like. You got Jerry, that's, there is a movie up Jerry. And then, this movie. - That's fantastic, Mr. Paul. - Yeah. I don't even know. I forget about them. - I forget about them. - And then chicken. - My only movie. - My only movie. - And the most, this is a very iconic. - Do I turn this way? - The mystery machine. - Like, this is my mystery machine. - This is my only tattoo. - Cool. - Of a movie. Have three tattoos, but I love a little movie tattoo. - So, I don't think, I mean, like, is it jarring? Is it like mocking J, like, right here? Even still, it's not. - Or had mocking J. - Yeah, or had mocking J. - So, this father like, even still, it's not the father and law's place to comment on, like, if I have a mocking J tattoo to cross my cheek. - Right. - What if I, Courtney, what if I came home and I just had Josh Hutcherson's face on my back? - Whoa. - Full, full back. Josh Hutcherson. - Well, I'll be like, turn around. - Yeah. (laughter) - I'm sorry. (laughter) - You're most, I also, that would be crazy, 'cause, like, I also, the lore of you and Josh Hutcherson having a lot of the same auditions back in the day. - I would audition and then later on, he'd be in the movie. - Right. - Right. - Yeah. - But yes, no. - Right, so that would be crazy, like, wow, your op is on your back. - Wow. - He's not my op. - He's not your op. - I met him once, he's very cool. - But it also would be, love Josh Hutcherson, big, big Josh Hutcherson fan. (laughter) - We love Josh Hutcherson. - Yeah, we love Josh Hutcherson here. But, it would be not if he, like, showed up at home and had it, it would be if you all met and then you discovered later that he has Josh Hutcherson on his back. - Yeah. - Yeah. - So, you know, your dad was really mad at him for it. - Yeah, it's not your dad. - Why is your dad mad at him for having Josh Hutcherson with him? - The dad doesn't get to decide anything. - I'm, I'm trying to explore, like, why this father-in-law would hate this movie so much. - Obviously, it has a very strong message. The Hunger Games stories are based on a lot of things that are inspired by real history. So, I'm like, I don't think it's about the tattoo them. I think it's about other stuff, which, like-- - Maybe the death. - He really hates Josh Hutcherson. - Yeah, really? - He hates Josh Hutcherson. - He's like, "Oh, that J-Law!" (laughter) - He watched Silver Leng's playbook and you're just like, "Nope." - "Nope." - "Not a fan." - That would be crazy. - Okay. - Well, the verdict's not the asshole. - Yeah. - Comments, not the asshole, but it sounds like you have a fiance problem as well. - Oh. - He should have told father-in-law that it's your body, your choice. Why does father-in-law care about a tattoo on your arm? So much so that he's threatening to cut you off. Father-in-law sounds unhinged. Edit on that. Now that I know it's a mocking J, I'm even more confused by father-in-law's response. Does father-in-law believe it's an actual capital offense? - And is the father-in-law capital in this situation? - Ooh. - Do you want to be the capital in the Hunger Games? - No, you are. - And someone responded saying, "Unless these presidents know?" - Yeah. - Exactly. - See you. - Someone said-- - Sometimes I'm getting. - Someone said in quotations disrespecting his father's opinion, LOL, not the asshole. Lastly, someone said not the asshole. Fiance, though. He knew you had it and didn't mind until Daddy complained. If he didn't know, Daddy hated it. How were you supposed to know? I guess you just learned something new about you.
your fiance and need to decide if this will influence marrying him or not. Clearly, a conversation with fiance is in order. Perhaps start by telling your fiance that yelling at you is unacceptable. He yelled at her, I missed that one. Yeah, he said he called her on the phone yelling at her, that you disrespected my father. You, I missed that. I know. I really wish I hadn't heard it, but that was the last thing I was written. I missed that. I got excited. We started talking about like Josh Hutchinson tattoos in the mocking J. And I got really distracted by like liking hungry. Yeah. That's the nerve to hate about hunger. I mean, besides everybody like dying in it, but I mean those movies are so good. They're beautiful. Okay. Yeah, I mean, look, there's a lot of issues. There's a lot of issues. I don't feel like it's, you need many more examples like this, this fiance sucks. Anyone, and also removing a tattoo is not easy. No, not really. When you're asking is all wrong. Just because your dad hates the movie. And you can't, like you have to wait a certain amount of time to let us had to heal before you can even begin a removing process and the removing process. It's not just something you snap your fingers and it goes away. It's a painstaking multi-visit process. And it's not your body. Yeah, it's also something that they obviously got because it's a film that means something to them. And it's like important. You know, and then it's like just because I mean, I don't know what hunger games movie pissed them off. But like, it means he had to have seen them. He's in there. He's eating popcorn. He's like, ah, he sees every movie. Like, he reads the books every single month. But he just despises. Hey, some. Well, that's that's our final story. Are you serious? I'm sorry. Wow. Ending it with hungry games though. Iconic. Hey. I do want to say I want to reiterate what you're saying though. Like the fiance didn't have a problem with the tattoo until the father. No, that's such a red flag. Because that's scary because now whatever the parents say is going to dictate your relationship and stuff. And like, that's just uncomfortable. And threatening to go no contact for you. Yeah. That's like a very basic to threaten no contact over a tattoo. That's extreme. But also anyone who's telling you to try to dictate anything over your own body. It's not just like it's like a movie tattoo. It's a movie tattoo movie tattoo. And also they have a bunch of other tattoos as well as what they said. Yeah, so does her fiance. I really do need to hear from dad why the hunger. Yeah, I really do. I'm so curious why the dad hates the hunger game. Yeah, there's no updates. There's no updates. I'm sorry. Yeah, OP if you're watching this. Let us know. Let us know why no specifically why and if it's that's so specific. If it's Josh Hutcherson's fault. Oh, maybe it's Josh. Nothing could ever be his fault. Yeah, I think it would be that man's fault. Come on. Okay. Sorry. I didn't do. I didn't do it. You can get that. I'm just in a different jingle. I love that one. Anyways. Well, that's that's it for all of our reddit stories. McKenna, thank you so much for joining us. Well, I'm pissed. I'm angry. I'm fired up. Yeah. I'm fired up because of these. Now I'm now I'm going to leave here and I'm going to stop adding. I'm glad we put them to myself as I walk out. We do like we think about the stories that we read like for days after like we'll have to like reassess them. We're in the grocery store. I'm really. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Well, McKenna, thank you and make sure to check out Hunger Games sunrise in the reaping which is in theaters November 20th. And get a tattoo afterwards. And get that tattoo even if it pisses off your body lock to piss off your brother in law. And then anyone who's competing in a hot dog eating competition today. Just win it. Good luck. You better win. Yeah, better win. You better win. All right. Well, um, thank you. Doglar Nation. All right. Doglar Nation. For a doglar nation. That's my tattoo. Doglar Nation on my back. All right. Um, thank you both so much. And thank you all for watching. And we'll see you next Saturday. - Good bye. - Bye. - Bye. - Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The man who entered a hot dog eating contest and beat his girlfriend's father is not considered an "asshole" by Reddit, as he didn't know the contest was a family tradition tied to the father’s identity as the "dogler."
The story highlights how a lack of awareness about a longstanding family ritual—like the father's pride in winning the contest—led to unintended tension, not moral failure.
In another story, a sister's wedding requires guests to submit essays to attend, which Reddit users see as excessive and disrespectful, especially when it puts pressure on people to justify their presence.
A third story involves a woman telling her best friend’s fiancé she’s not in love with him, which sparks backlash from the fiancé’s family, but Reddit concludes she didn’t act out of malice or jealousy—she was honest and clear.
The final story involves a woman getting a "Mockingjay" tattoo inspired by *The Hunger Games*, which her future father-in-law hates; Reddit finds her not the asshole, criticizing the father-in-law’s extreme reaction to a personal choice.
All stories emphasize that personal boundaries, family traditions, and social expectations are often misinterpreted or overblown, leading to unnecessary conflict.
The audience consistently concludes that the individuals in question are not at fault, pointing to poor communication, misalignment of expectations, or emotional manipulation instead.
The humor and absurdity of the situations (e.g., “dogler” shirts, essay-based weddings, tattoo-based drama) reflect Reddit’s culture of ironic, empathetic judgment.
Summary:
" Reddit stories, each highlighting misunderstandings and miscommunications in personal relationships. In the first story, a man wins a hot dog eating contest at a food festival, unaware it was a family tradition where his girlfriend’s father had been the reigning "dogler" for years. Reddit concludes he’s not the asshole—his ignorance of the tradition and the family’s emotional investment makes the situation a misstep, not malice.
In a second story, a sister’s wedding requires guests to write 250-word essays to attend, which Reddit users find absurd and manipulative, especially as it puts emotional pressure on attendees. A third story involves a woman honestly stating she’s not in love with her best friend’s fiancé, which leads to backlash from the fiancé’s family, but Reddit deems her actions appropriate and truthful. The final story centers on a woman getting a *The Hunger Games* Mockingjay tattoo, which her future father-in-law hates—Reddit dismisses her as not the asshole, criticizing the father-in-law’s extreme reaction to a personal choice.
Across all stories, the core theme is that people often misread emotional context, and Reddit’s verdict consistently emphasizes empathy, lack of awareness, or poor communication over blame. The episode ends with a humorous twist, tying it all together with a "Dogler Nation" tattoo reference and a call to celebrate personal freedom—even if it upsets family traditions.
FAQs
No, it's not considered rude. The person in the story didn't know their girlfriend's dad had won the contest for years and was a 'dogler,' so entering was unintentional and not malicious.
Because the person didn’t know the contest was a family tradition or that their girlfriend’s dad was the reigning 'dogler.' They were just competing fairly and didn’t try to disrespect anyone.
It was lighthearted and fun, with the person jokingly calling themselves the 'dogler' after beating their girlfriend’s dad. The story highlights humor and family dynamics.
He wanted to connect with his son-in-law through the tradition of winning the contest, not to win for himself, but to maintain a family bond through shared experiences.
No, the person wasn’t at fault. The argument arose from the girlfriend’s disappointment over the tradition being disrupted, not from any intentional disrespect.
The shirt symbolized the family tradition and the pride of the 'dogler' title. The person’s shirt being found in the dryer caused a temporary conflict, but ultimately resolved with understanding.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.