This episode of "Solved" tackles manipulation, arguing that it is not the exclusive domain of villains but a universal spectrum of behavior everyone engages in constantly. The host opens by openly demonstrating six persuasive techniques on the listener without telling a single lie, illustrating that influence and deception are distinct. The episode traces the history of manipulation from Plato and Aristotle, who saw deceit as a failure of reason, through Philippe Pinel's observation of "moral insanity"—rational yet cruel individuals—to James Pritchard's distinction between moral and actual insanity. Hervey Cleckley's "The Mask of Sanity" later argued that psychopaths are largely undetectable, a point lost when high-profile serial killer cases turned the psychopath into a pop-culture monster. Modern research from Goffman, Christie, Geis, and Buss reveals that everyday manipulation is normal, practical, and possibly the evolutionary reason humans developed such large brains. The hosts explore self-deception as the most powerful tool for deceiving others, citing the Lund University card-swap study where most subjects unknowingly justified choices they never made. They note that lie detection is barely better than chance, even for experts, and that this blindness may preserve social cohesion. The episode closes by introducing Kant's formula of humanity as an ethical framework: treating people, including oneself, merely as a means to an end is the root of unethical manipulation.
So I want to start this episode off with a question, which is, am I manipulating you right
now? What if I told you that this episode is potentially life-changing? My team and I spent
months researching and working on it, that some of the ideas and implications within it could have
profound moral impact on how you see the world and every relationship that you have. Am I manipulating
you now? Now, I realize that I'm just a podcaster in your ear, but seriously, I've been researching
and writing about human psychology for almost 20 years, and what I realized prepping for this show
is that manipulation and the ways that we try to influence each other is maybe one of the most
under-discussed topics that impacts every single moment of our lives. And sure, maybe you already
kind of get that, but the fact that these concepts are not widely taught or discussed
has started to shock me. How about that? Was that manipulative? Did it feel manipulative?
Because everything I said was true, but at the same time, I used six persuasive
techniques on you. In sequence, the curiosity gap, an authority marker, superiority flattery,
social proof, strategic self-deprecation, manufactured urgency. But like I said,
none of it was a lie. I didn't fabricate a single thing that I said. We really did spend more time
on this episode than any other episode that we've done this year. I really do think this is one of
the most under-discussed practical topics in this industry. I really have been studying this stuff
for nearly 20 years. I did not deceive you about anything. I really did not deceive you about any
of that. But I am also manipulating you. Because like every good podcast host, I want you to keep
listening. I want to intrigue you. I want to create curiosity. I want to create excitement in you.
And here's the really crazy part. You want me to do it too. You don't click on a podcast like this
to be lectured for hours or bored to death. You want your attention to be swept away into a
fascinating narrative. You want to feel that pull of curiosity. You want to feel the hours bleed away
or minutes. To an extent, you want to be manipulated. You want me to manipulate you.
Today, we are solving manipulation. And the first thing to know is that manipulation is not something
that happens to gullible people at the hands of obvious villains. The science on this is extremely
clear. And what it says is far stranger and more uncomfortable than the story that you and I have
always been told. Because we are all manipulators. And in some contexts, we all seek to be manipulated.
The moral question then is not who does the manipulation, but to what extent and for what
ends. I think this episode is going to blow your mind. And no, I'm not just selling you right now.
Today, we're going to be talking about a lot of fascinating and important topics, including
psychopaths, what they are, how to spot them, how one researcher's understanding of them kicked off
a whole identity crisis. And I'm going to be talking about a lot of fascinating and important topics,
including psychopaths, what they are, how to spot them, how one researcher's understanding of them kicked off a whole identity crisis.
We're going to talk about why law enforcement, psychologists, and body language experts are just
as bad at detecting lies as you and I are, and what that means for us. We're going to talk about
the fact that not only do you manipulate others, but you also manipulate yourself, and why. We're
going to discuss what Immanuel Kant, Niccolo Machiavelli, and a $6,500 payment from the
sugar industry have in common, and why it matters for your marriage. How's that for a spicy hook?
We're going to talk about the experiment where people who
have never met you, armed with nothing but a checkbox, shape your medical decisions more
effectively than your own stated values do. We'll talk about how Sigmund Freud's nephew turned bacon
into breakfast and cigarettes into feminism, and how he built an industry whose entire business
model fails one ethical test that this episode is going to teach you. We're going to talk about the
only evidence-based defense against manipulation that actually works, and why it's been ignored
largely for 50 years, and why it costs you about five cents.
This, and much, much more. We're going to walk through how manipulation actually works,
where the ethical lines fall according to philosophers who genuinely disagree with each
other, how entire industries and governments have weaponized the science of manipulation against us,
and what you can concretely do about all of this.
Because once you understand manipulation, it stops feeling like you need to identify and avoid
the bad people. It stops feeling like you need some supernatural ability to read faces and spot liars.
And it starts to feel like something that you can understand well enough to manage in your own life,
beginning with the manipulator that you know the best, or maybe the least, which is yourself.
I'm the three-time number one New York Times bestselling author Mark Manson, and this is
Drew Birney, my co-host, producer, lead researcher, and a man who thinks massages are weird, but could
really go for a belly rub right now. Where do these come from? It's true.
You don't write this. I don't write. I don't know where these come from.
And this is Solved, the most comprehensive podcast in the world, where every episode,
we aim to solve one problem in your life once and for all. Today, we are solving manipulation,
what it is, where the line falls, why do we all do it, how do we defend against it,
and why it actually might be a beneficial thing at times.
So I actually want to start this episode by talking about madness
psychopaths. But to begin, we need to go way back. I want to go back to the ancient Greeks,
because I think one thing that is interesting about manipulation and lying in general,
misleading people, is that it has generally universally been considered wrong, cross-culturally,
historically. So whether you're looking at Christianity, Islam, the Eastern traditions,
lying and manipulation is pretty much universally considered a bad thing. Philosophically,
if you go back as far as Plato, Plato saw manipulation as a failure of a person to
manage their own emotions. It's basically a situation where emotion overtakes reason.
In Plato's framework, he had this idea of a tripartite soul. So you had kind of your reason,
you had your impulses and animalistic desires, and then you had your emotions. And he saw
lying and deceit as when somebody is overcome with their emotional urges
or their own personal drives, and they allow it to take over their reason. And it is a failure
of rationality, essentially. Aristotle's framework treats it pretty similarly. And then once you get
into the Christian tradition, it's just lying is wrong. And if you're lying too much, you probably
can't really control your own impulses or urges. So there's this psychological connection between
impulsiveness and manipulation. People observe that highly rational people,
people with a lot of self-discipline, a lot of self-control,
generally are able to be more honest and upfront with others. Whereas people who are very impulsive,
very selfish, very self-indulgent, they tend to be the ones who are the most manipulative.
Now, what's interesting is that even as, I mean, as far back as recorded history,
people have always observed that there is a certain class of people that are just so fundamentally
irrational all the time that they are just kind of disconnected from reality. And they are lying 24-7.
They're lying to themselves. They're lying to other people. They are just living in la-la land.
And this became known as madness, just craziness. And for most of human history, these were not seen
as people that we should sympathize with or feel sorry for. They were seen as pariahs, as people
that were problematic to the social order, and they should either be quarantined or punished
appropriately. Now, this all started to change around the Enlightenment. And there was a physician
by the name of Philippe, who was a physician who was a physician who was a physician who was a
in France in the late 18th century, who in many ways is seen as kind of the godfather of psychiatry.
He spent a lot of time with asylum patients and people who suffered from mental disorders.
And he was kind of the first prominent thinker that argued that we should approach these people
with kindness, compassion, and that it's actually through that kindness and compassion
that these people are able to get better and have a better orientation towards reality and
stop behaving so delusionally and so inappropriately all the time. Then in 1801, Pinel made a very
interesting observation. He noticed that there were a certain group of people who actually seemed
fully rational, completely integrated into society, but made highly irrational antisocial choices,
that they could become incredibly violent. They had a propensity to lie and manipulate people,
to use people, to control people.
To take advantage of people's emotions, that they were in many ways evil, but they weren't crazy.
And up until this point, those two things were always associated with one another.
The most evil people were also the most crazy. They were kind of the cackling evil genius maniac
who was, you know, almost like cartoonish in terms of their personality. Pinel was the first
person who came along and said, no, actually, there are some people that are highly rational,
highly functional, and just fucking cruel. Now, this observation was picked up a few decades
later in England by a man named James Pritchard. And he actually started intentionally seeking out
these people to try to understand them a little better. And he noticed a few things. For one,
he said, not all of them are actually violent. In fact, many of them are just as manipulative
and self-serving without being violent. They actually can appear very compassionate on the
surface. And Pritchard drew a very interesting distinction. Up until that point, it was just
known as insanity. Pritchard,
differentiated moral insanity from actual insanity.
So actual insanity.
meant people aren't able to reason correctly, they are impulsive, delusional. Under Pritchard's
definition, somebody who is morally insane is somebody who can intellectually reason appropriately,
but their moral understanding of other human beings, their ability to empathize, consider
other people's emotions, is just completely scrambled or non-existent. Now, nobody really
knew what to do with this, and it kind of just sat untouched. The idea wasn't picked up again
until 100 years later by an American doctor named Hervey Cleckley. Cleckley worked at a mental
hospital in the 1930s, and he became fascinated with these cases. There were a number of patients
who came in who seemed completely normal, could have completely reasonable conversations with him,
who showed no signs of delusions or emotional stress, were very calm and collected, yet had
lives that were in total disarray. What struck Cleckley about these people is that they made
horrible decisions. They made horrible decisions. And in many cases, they couldn't even really explain why they made the decisions,
but they showed no remorse for it whatsoever. In many cases, they could imitate remorse. They could
give you a nice speech about how they felt bad, but underneath, they didn't really feel anything
at all. So in 1941, Cleckley took a collection of interviews that he did with these patients
and put them together into a book called The Mask of Sanity. And this book is kind of the
book that I would today consider psychopaths or sociopaths. And in that book, he distilled all
of the characteristics down into 16 traits that you see in a psychopath. And these are all the
classic ones that we associate with psychopaths today. So total lack of remorse or shame for
their behavior, an absence of nervousness or anxiety, a chronic untruthfulness or insincerity,
an inability to empathize or understand other people's emotions,
failure to learn from prior experiences, to draw lessons from their mistakes.
What's really interesting about Cleckley's work and the reason that I want to start with psychopaths
in a manipulation episode is because Cleckley really forcefully made the argument throughout
all of his work that psychopaths are undetectable throughout daily life. Like you can't really walk
down the street or go to a dinner party or sit down at lunch with somebody for an hour.
And properly detect that this person is a psychopath, that they have absolutely no
empathy or remorse. What concerned Cleckley was how much these people blended into day-to-day
society and how in many cases, a lot of the people in the psychopath's life don't even
understand their condition. Like don't realize that this is a person that doesn't feel remorse
or shame, that doesn't give a fuck at all about what they feel or anything that they've done.
And it's interesting because towards the end of Cleckley's
career, starting in the 1970s and 80s, there were a series of extremely high profile serial
killer cases that kind of swept national media and turned the serial killers into celebrities,
the biggest of which was Ted Bundy. And Cleckley himself was called in on a lot of these cases
to interview, examine the serial killers, get to know them, make diagnoses about them.
And the sad irony about Cleckley is that these serial
killers, because they were so violent, they were so sadistic, and they were psychopaths,
and Cleckley was the one who was called in to verify that they were psychopaths.
Ever since, the concept of a psychopath has been merged directly with this kind of awkward,
sadistic, compulsive killer who does really fucked up things and is extremely violent in
very strange ways. So across pop culture and the mainstream understanding of manipulative behavior,
it completely blew up the main point of Cleckley's work, which was that the most manipulative people
on earth are undetectable. They are so similar to you and I that you actually could not point
them out in a lineup. The truth is that everything you think you know about psychopaths is probably
wrong. Our culture and Hollywood have turned psychopath into this highly visible monster,
this very strange antisocial person who,
who is always behaving erratically and doing very evil and conniving and masterminded things to
innocent people. And the truth is, is that psychopaths completely blend into the crowd.
The vast majority of psychopaths, they're not violent. Many of them are not even antisocial.
Many of them have actually learned very well how to mimic human emotion and empathy to get what
they want from others. And so I actually think the most important lesson from psychopaths is not that
there are these special people who are not violent. There are people who are not violent. There are
specifically evil people in the world that are highly manipulative and highly violent that we
need to figure out how to avoid. It's actually the opposite. It's that manipulation is so common
and so ever present in our day-to-day lives and in our day-to-day relationships. We actually have
to have a better understanding of how these manipulative practices take place, how they're
wielded against us and how we wield them against others. Hold that thought. We will be right back
after this.
is brought to you by AG1. Now at home, my health routine feels pretty locked in, but the road
is where I get tested. Most trips will start the same way. I catch a flight at some ungodly hour,
head straight from the airport to a stage, and then try to remember which city I'm in
before I get to the mic. Those are the days that I'm so glad that AG1 NextGen is so easy to pack.
One scoop has a multivitamin, probiotics, and greens, and I just mix it in with water in
whatever hotel room I'm in. It's formulated to support energy production, and I've noticed
that my energy stays steadier on those crazy days. It's also clinically shown to enrich
gut microbiome, and I've felt less bloating, which on a long flight is good news, not just
for me, but everyone around me. Now in clinical research, when paired with a proper diet,
AG1 helps you meet 94% of your nutritional needs, and it's formulated to support a healthy
immune system as well. AG1 NextGen is backed by four separate gold standard clinical trials
in an industry where not everyone invests heavily in research that is really impressive. For a limited
time, visit drinkag1.com slash solved and get a free immune support bundle, including omega-3 fish
oil and vitamin D3K2, with your first subscription of AG1 NextGen or AG1 Pro. That's drinkag1.com
slash solve. And after checkout, be sure to let them know that Mark Manson sent you.
I don't remember half of the things that I talked about. It's a plot has this amazing little device.
It's about the size of a credit card. It magnetically attaches to your phone. You can
carry it around and it takes notes on any in-person conversation you want it to. It's amazing in
business environments. So when you meet that guy who runs the agency that is doing the cool new
thing that could be really useful and you want to follow up on, it automatically captures it. It
summarizes it and you can go back and check the notes of the conversation at any time. It's great
for in-person meetings to capture the information that you want to hear. It's great for in-person
meetings to capture those summaries of what was talked about or what the action items are.
So all you do is you tap a simple button and it starts capturing. Now, Plod can spit out a
transcript with key insights, next steps, visual infographics. If I need to find specific details
weeks later, I can just ask Plod what I talked about with my content team back in September,
and it will automatically dig through everything and find it for me. So when it's finally time to
it's easy to go back and find it. Some of our best episodes started with a throwaway idea
while Drew and I were just hanging out in the studio shooting the shit. Just make sure everybody
knows and agrees before you hit record, because obviously you don't want to get sued. Now, if you
want to try out Plod, go to plod.ai slash Manson and use the code Manson22 for 22% off. Okay,
we're back with manipulation. Okay, so it was really a shame that
Cleckley got done dirty like that, right? It was a shame that we missed it because in the 50s, 60s,
even before the 70s and 80s series, it was a shame that we missed it. It was a shame that we missed
serial killers came along. There was some kind of interesting ideas and research coming out that
kind of started to, I guess, tilted towards normalization, even though in the literature,
manipulation was still seen as like a deviant behavior for the most part. It wasn't a very
normal behavior. It wasn't good people who did it, right? It was these more psychopathic types
that the popular culture had in their minds around it. That actually did start to change
a little bit, though, in the 50s and 60s. There was this guy, Irving Goffman, in the 50s. He,
was kind of the first in Western psychology, anyway, to kind of call out like, oh, hey,
actually, we're all kind of performing. We're all manipulating the image that we put out into
the world, what I'm trying to get you to think about me or you to try to do something. All of
it's just social interaction. It's all theater to some degree, right? Ralph Waldo Emerson has
this great quote. He says, every man alone is sincere, but at the entrance of a second person,
hypocrisy begins. Left alone, left their own devices in a vacuum. Sure, we're all saints,
right?
It's only when we interact with each other that all of this manipulative behavior comes out. I
mean, that idea really started to germinate in the 50s and 60s in psychology, right? You get to the
70s, and then we tried to get a little more systematic about it. These researchers, Richard,
Christie, and Florence Geis. And they actually came up with like a Machiavellian personality
test almost, right? We'll get into the details of what Machiavellianism really is, but suffice
to say for now that it's manipulative behavior, just in general. How do you get what you want?
Right.
Right.
By manipulating others.
How do you. to instrumentalize other people to achieve some other goal.
Right, right.
For instance, they had this one game.
It was this $10 game.
They had three people.
They would give them $10 between the three of them.
They could divide the money however they wanted to.
The two people who agreed on the split would get the money, right?
And they gave them this kind of Machiavellian personality test first,
and then they had them play this game.
No big shocker, the people who scored high on this Machiavellian personality test
gained almost like four times more money than anybody else in it, right?
They started to do this, like really systematized, like,
what are these personality types?
What is this manipulative behavior in everyday people?
Again, these weren't people who were clinically insane or anything like that.
These were just random people off the street, university students, whatever.
These Machiavellian, high Machiavellian types,
it wasn't that they could read people's emotions,
that they were actually disregarding them altogether.
So like in this $10 game, right?
It's like, I don't care if this person's my friend or not.
I want the money.
That's all there was.
That was the goal.
They went after it.
Not to give too much away,
but I think one of the biggest surprises for me in prepping for this episode
is how much reading other people is not really a thing.
Oh, it's not, yeah, as we'll see.
Yeah, and it's funny because if you look on social media,
there's a lot of content these days about how to spot a liar,
how to guard against manipulation,
how to not be taken advantage of by narcissists and all this stuff.
It's funny that a lot of that is just completely misguided.
Like we're actually pretty terrible at reading other people's intentions in general.
And maybe one of the reasons is that manipulation is so pervasive.
It's everywhere that you could say anything is manipulative.
So any little body language thing you could pick up on,
you could turn it into something that's manipulative.
And it turns out to not mean a whole lot, right?
We get into the 80s and research starts to focus on
even more kind of like everyday situations.
For example, like in your relationship,
David Buss, who's a famous evolutionary psychologist,
he said,
started researching this in the 80s as well.
They studied, originally studied 59 couples.
They found six really common manipulation tactics
that came out of this.
Charm, silent treatment, coercion, reason, regression, and debasement.
Okay.
Now the good news, there's some good news out of this.
The number one tactic was reason.
Using reason with your partner to try to get what you want.
I wouldn't necessarily call that manipulative.
Most people wouldn't, right?
Charm came in second, all right?
So first you try to reason,
and if that doesn't work,
then you try to charm them, okay?
So that's maybe one point for, you know,
the better interests of our nature, right?
What they kind of found though was that
it kind of depended on the context of
whatever conflict or interaction
you were in with your partner, right?
If you're trying to make them do something,
you're more likely to use charm.
If you're trying to get them to stop doing something,
there's usually more coercion involved, okay?
So again, this is an everyday relationship.
You're using some form of manipulation
and almost every interaction you have
with the person that you're probably closest with
and should supposedly love the most, right?
I think we should pause for a second.
Okay.
Because I can already,
I mean, I'm already feeling it myself.
I imagine in listeners,
there's already a little bit of resistance building
of like, I don't manipulate people.
I care about who the fuck are you to tell me
that I'm a manipulative person.
I think it's probably worth kind of taking a moment
and just talking about what is manipulation?
Like what is the definition of manipulation?
So it's,
it actually comes from a Latin root of manus,
which means to handle or like a handful of something.
And so in ancient times,
the concept of manipulation was like rendering
and changing things with your hands.
It was like manipulating this microphone stand, right?
Or it's like the way we would change an object
to fit our own will.
And then at some point that got transferred on to people,
right?
We manipulate people to reshape them to fit our own will.
And of course, all sorts of moral connotations
came along with that.
The word manipulation in,
at least in the English language,
we have a lot of negative connotations around it.
Like there's kind of this implication
that if I'm manipulating you right now,
it is to take advantage of you in some way
or to get something that I want out of you.
Whereas if I'm just trying to influence you
or motivate you or change you,
like those all have very positive implications.
But coming back to Irving Goffman
and his argument that we're kind of always
performing, he used a lot of extremely basic
and simple examples.
For example, like saying thank you
after somebody does something for you, right?
Or like, you know, if you ask me,
how is my day going?
90% chance I'm going to say fine,
regardless of how it's actually going.
There's an intention to kind of meet expectations
or keep the peace that is always happening
in social circumstances.
It requires an extended amount of effort
or an important reason to break
those social expectations
or break with convention
to change your behavior in front of people.
So like in Western culture,
we have almost this like pure idea
that we should be fully authentic with ourselves.
We should be honest at all times.
I think it was when we did the ego episode,
maybe six or eight months ago,
we talked about how this idea
that there is a monolithic identity,
like there's a single Mark Manson
and I should be Mark Manson in every context.
You know, the way I behave,
the way I behave with you on camera
should be the same way I behave
with my mother at Thanksgiving
and the same way I behave with my wife
on a Tuesday night.
And in Eastern cultures,
there's kind of more of a practical understanding
that no, actually,
there's many different versions of yourself
and you actually should behave differently
in different contexts,
in different situations.
And certain things or conversations
that are appropriate at work
are not appropriate with your family
and vice versa.
For some reason,
I don't know what it is about what,
like the Western lineage.
I think we struggle with that concept
and we see it as manipulative, right?
Like if I have the same conversation with you today
that I had with my wife yesterday
and I say something different to you
than I said to her yesterday,
in a Western mind,
that is seen as inauthentic and dishonest.
It's seen as manipulative.
Whereas I think in other cultures,
they would just see that as practical.
The point I want to drive home for listeners
in this first chapter
is that manipulation is practical.
And that we all do it all the time
for very practical reasons
that are not immoral at all.
We have social politeness.
We have niceties.
We do courteous things for each other.
If we disagree with somebody,
but we don't really want to have a fight about it,
we'll like kind of passively,
aggressively nudge them in a certain direction.
We'll discover in later chapters
that there's kind of a game theory around all of this.
That there are certain things,
you know, we tell white lies
to keep the peace with people that we care about.
All of these things,
are completely normal and natural.
I guess the arc that we're covering here
is that for most of human history,
dishonesty and lying was seen
as this uniquely evil and irrational thing
that we should aspire to never do.
But modern psychology has gradually
and almost reluctantly uncovered over and over again
that this sort of manipulation is present
in almost all of our interactions.
And it is happening all the time.
You know, not only is it incredibly common
and incredibly practical and pragmatic,
like you said,
it's probably the reason we have the brains that we have.
In the 80s, there were some researchers
who came up with like the social brain hypothesis
or some of them call it
the Machiavellian intelligence hypothesis.
Whatever you want to call it,
basically they found this relationship between,
especially in primates,
the size of the brain and social group
and social complexity.
For a long time, they thought,
oh, it's tool use that determined the size of your brain
and the complexity of your brain.
Okay.
It's not.
It's social complexity.
Huh.
And so manipulation is one way,
is actually the main way
that we navigate that social complexity.
That takes a lot of brain power too.
And so we probably develop these huge brains.
One of the main reasons for it anyway
was to be able to gently deceive each other
or manipulate the way we come off in a group.
Our standing in group,
we've talked about how important that is
in other episodes too.
Like we need to be able to shape that
in some way, shape or form.
And manipulation is a big part of that.
Deception is a very effective way to do that.
And probably track deception as well.
And tracking it too.
Right?
That's a big, big component of it as well.
Because it's like, if you deceive me,
I need to be able to remember that
in future situations.
You'd be completely ineffective
if you didn't remember that.
Obviously, right?
Part of the definition of manipulation
is being able to track that over time.
It really is not a disorder.
This is where Dunbar's number even comes out of too.
Okay.
We've talked about that in previous episodes as well,
but quick refresher.
Dunbar's number, it's about 150,
which is about the number
of relationships you can effectively manage.
Okay.
Any more than that,
and you start to,
they're not very effectively managed that way.
Really, you have about five close friends,
10 good friends.
You know, it goes out
into concentric circles like that.
This is probably where that comes from as well.
And again, being able to manage those relationships,
track everything you're doing,
and there is some degree of manipulation,
again, within that.
You can only manipulate so much as well.
So keeping those numbers to manageable levels
is something we have to do
and that's, again,
that's probably why we have the brains we have.
I think this probably gets us nicely
into kind of the game theory aspect of this, right?
Like if you look at our evolutionary history,
we lived in largely small bands and tribes
and social status was incredibly important for survival.
Dependability and trust
was incredibly important for survival, right?
Like it's, if you and I are out hunting
woolly mammoths together,
like I need to trust that you're actually going to show up
and do the thing when you're supposed to.
you're supposed to do it. And the fact of the matter is that things like gossip, social exclusion,
delusion reputational damage like these things could have life and death impact on certain
people what happens is that you create a situation where let's say you and i are in a tribe together
we disagree about something but that disagreement can have outsized impact on other people in the
tribe it could like you know put everybody's welfare in danger so instead of you and i
actually like physically duking it out we can find all of these subtle ways to signal to each other
the disagreement without actually having overt conflict right so this is where you get stuff
like passive aggression and um and dropping hints and forming alliances right it's like i can i can
go over to misty and be like wow isn't drew such an asshole like can you believe that he thinks
this and then she like gets on my team and then it's like that creates a new dynamic of social
pressure on you so maybe that will manipulate you to change your
mind in a way that doesn't require actual violent force or violent pressure and so it's it's funny
there's a famous quote from von klausowitz and he said that politics is simply an extension of war
and i think you can kind of see this on a very evolutionary level of like yeah it's so costly
to physically fight people or physically threaten each other that we find all of these manipulations
and machinations to influence each other and to influence each other and to influence each other
in both subtle and overt ways to get what we want out of each other because ultimately it produces
less risk and downside than just openly fighting about stuff okay yeah so it's it's kind of like uh
if you had like i don't know two big bull moose or something like that right and they were about to go
at it and a lot of times they will fight physically but uh what they'll do first is kind of like
they'll show off or you know grunt or whatever they do right humans are a lot more complex than
that though and we found that it's actually much more complex than that and we found that it's
more productive to engage in these machinations and this manipulation in order for us to still
kind of get what we want but also not have to come to like physical violence for it in a way
that would be much more costly there's an outlet for it still yeah kind of okay that's that's pretty
fascinating yeah there are conscious ways we do this right like i think like telling a white lie
is kind of the classic conscious way it's like you know if my wife cooks a nice dinner for me and
it's not really that great. But she asked me how it is. I'm like, oh, it's great. I tell that lie
because I'm like, I don't want to ruin the evening by having a fight over this dinner that she spent
hours preparing. So there's the white lie. That's a very conscious way of doing it. But we also do
this very subconsciously. We're often trying to influence each other in ways that I think in many
cases we're not even aware of. We are just kind of reluctant to be around a certain person or to
agree with a certain idea. And so we find excuses to like procrastinate or delay doing the thing
as kind of a unspoken signal to others that like, hey, this isn't, I'm not really into this,
or I'm not really excited about this. And then we hope that other people subconsciously pick
up on that signal and say like, okay, yeah, Drew doesn't really want to do this thing. So
let's stop bothering him about it. Here's a subtle one too. It's like, oh no, I'll do whatever.
Like somebody who's very agreeable sometimes that could even be manipulative in a way.
Absolutely.
You wouldn't know it at all, right?
Absolutely. You could argue that you're manipulating people into liking you by being
easy. You're suppressing your own desires and interests to keep the peace.
Yeah. Yeah. But that wouldn't be at a conscious level for most people anyway. Yeah. Interesting.
You know, a lot of manipulation of others is rooted in your manipulation of yourself,
right? So I think most people pleasers genuinely think they're happy with whatever. It's because
they haven't allowed themselves to have those desires in the first place, right? So that the
internally with themselves, and then it manifests outwardly in their, in their relationships with
other people. So related to this, there was a cool study that a researcher named Bella DePaulo
did where she had people keep lie diaries. So she had a bunch of people document every single
social interaction that they had for an entire week, and then go back after the fact and,
and analyze whether they said something untrue or not. Young people, college students
averaged about two lies a day. Uh, and then working adults averaged about one lie per day.
Self-serving lies outnumbered white lies, two to one. We're not quite as innocent as we think.
So, so like a self-serving lie would be like something that made you look better.
Yes. As opposed to a white lie that like kept the peace with somebody else and made them look
better. Made them look better. Yeah. All right. The most common thing that people lied about
was how they felt, which kind of comes back to this game theory thing, right? It's, it's,
it's the classic, like, why are you angry? I'm fine. I'm not angry.
I feel attacked, but also I get it. Um, so hold it. The one,
one, one lies for like working adults too, for younger adults. I think that's probably a,
I don't know, 10 times too few. I'm going to guess this is self-report is self-reporting,
which means that this is probably drastically under right. Right. So people report that they
lie one or two times a day. Right. I, yeah. And maybe, and maybe a lot of that, like you already
have alluded to is a self-deception. Like I don't even know that I'm lying, which we can get into
that as well. But yeah, I, I find that to be way too low of an estimate. Yeah. Yeah. What's interesting
too is afterwards in the study, people were asked whether they believe they lied more or less than
other people, their age, and almost universally, every single person said that they lied less
than other people, their age, which is you got to love humans. You got to love humans.
Most of us realize that we do this. You know, we tell the little white lies. We tell a little
self-serving lies when we think we can get away with it. I think too, that the majority of us
it's relatively benign. Like it's, these, these are very small little momentary insignificant
things like little face saving things. They're not like having these drastic repercussions
on ourselves. And I think the reason why all of us do these things consistently repeatedly,
despite the fact that we know that we do them is because the downside risk is so asymmetrically
large, like the downside risk of social exclusion or the loss of a relationship for all of us in
most situations, it's just easier to keep the peace. It's, it's just easier to like go along
with it. You know, don't ruffle any feathers, don't piss anybody off. And there's some, some
interesting research around this. Like they found that even brief social exclusion by complete
strangers in a lab setting increased impulsivity, slowed the subjective sense of time, reduced a
sense of meaning and increased avoidance of self-awareness in people that were studied.
Yeah. And I think that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think
that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think that's, I think
well-being and day-to-day happiness is derived from the people we surround ourselves with and
the quality of relationships that we have with those people. And so if we are put in situations
where even being honest creates like a 5% chance of massively disrupting a relationship that's
important to us, we just fucking lie from a pure expected value perspective. That lie actually
makes a lot of sense.
And is overall better for social cohesion, both for the relationship, but for the group in general.
Okay. So that makes a lot of sense, like in the, in the smaller scale, right? Where you're trying
to maintain those relationships and through subtle manipulations, through benign manipulations,
as you were talking about, where we get into trouble, I think, and this is a little
foreshadowing for later in the episode is when that need or that drive for social inclusion
kind of gets hijacked or somebody intentionally is manipulating that knowing
they're manipulating that to get you to do things that you might not otherwise do or
even against your best interest. I think there's a spectrum of manipulation, right? And I think
on the lower end of the spectrum, it is mostly motivated by social inclusion, not disrupting
social cohesion, generally motivations that I think you and I would consider noble, you know,
and like generally good as you move up that spectrum of manipulation, it starts to become
more status seeking.
I think, and it becomes more like about power struggle and power games. So I have a good
friend and my friend had another good friend who she had known for about 20 years and her
good friend, his business recently went bankrupt, went out of business. So he was broke out
of money in a really tough spot. And fortunately, my friend worked at a very large corporation
and, and was able to help find him a position.
And as soon as he came in, he started really politically manipulating some of the higher ups
and over the course of about two years, like pushed her out, pushed her off kind of the
career track that she was on in terms of promotions and took the promotions himself.
And each time she confronted him about this, he denied it. He said, I don't know what you're
talking about. I'm just doing the best job I can. But she had picked up signals throughout the
workplace.
That like he had very intentionally kind of maneuvered himself in front of her and manipulated
some of her coworkers against her. I mean, she was like very upset about this, not just
because of what it did to her career, but also like this person that she trusted and
like really felt a lot of loyalty to, you know, it was just betrayed and the loss of
the friendship and everything. And so I think once we start getting up the scale of manipulation,
the stakes get much higher. The power that's at play gets higher.
And then I think at the kind of at the tippy top end where I think everybody would agree that it is just kind of universally unethical, that's where you start to get into the things with like violent repercussions or like very serious and catastrophic consequences for individuals or large groups of people.
But what's interesting is that that same kind of self-deception and self-justification continues on all the way up the spectrum or most of the way up the spectrum.
So if you talk to somebody who is very Machiavellian, such as my friend of a friend, they will also justify it to themselves.
They will also have all sorts of pro-social reasons, justifications for certain things that they said or did.
I think that self-deception is still present.
We've covered so many cognitive biases on this show.
Over the years and the propensity and ability for each of us to individually dilute ourselves when it's in our best interest is just unmatched.
Boundless.
Yeah, it's absolutely boundless.
Don't go anywhere.
We're going to take a short break.
We've got a lot more coming.
This episode is brought to you by Macrofactor.
So a while back, I told you that I was using Macrofactor to stop white knuckling my diet and actually figure out what my body was doing.
Update.
It's going pretty well.
And honestly, the way it worked surprised me.
The biggest shift was not the number on the scale, although I did lose a few pounds.
It was that I stopped guessing about everything.
Every week, Macrofactor looked at my actual weight trend and food logs and adjusted my targets based on real data instead of some formula I'd have to fine tune myself.
The first few weeks, my maintenance number was way higher than I expected, which explained a lot about why my old flat macro targets never worked.
It turns out that I wasn't lazy or undisciplined.
I was just targeting the wrong macros.
The other thing that changed was how I think.
I used to treat logging food like a punishment inflicted on myself for a week before quitting.
This time, it felt more like getting feedback from a coach who was actually paying attention.
So I stuck with it a lot easier than I normally do.
Now, if you've got a goal that you keep almost reaching and then abandoning, this is worth trying out.
So click my link in the description below and use the promo code Mark for a 14-day free trial.
This episode is sponsored by Quo.
Most businesses don't get to fully clock out for the holidays.
You've got family in town.
Your uncle is explaining crypto to anybody who will listen and a to-do list a mile long.
Your customers, meanwhile, are still calling.
If you take the call, you're getting glared at over stuffing.
If you let it ring, that customer is calling your competitor before the cookies.
At some point, you're just like, let's f*** Quo.
That's why today's episode is brought to you by Quo, spelled Q-U-O.
It's the business phone built so you never miss a call or customer.
Quo's AI agent handles calls and texts 24-7.
It answers questions, gets the details, and can even text them a link.
To book an appointment.
So the lead gets handled while you're on your second plate.
And there's a summary waiting for you in the morning.
Every call, text, and voicemail lives in one thread.
So anyone on your team can jump in already knowing the story.
Customers only have to explain themselves once.
And the sale does not slip through the cracks.
It's the number one rated business phone on G2.
Trusted by over 90,000 businesses.
This time of year goes by fast enough.
So spend it at the table with family.
Not under it checking your phone.
Money's on the line.
Always say hello with Quo.
Try Quo.
For free.
Plus get 20% off your first six months when you go to Quo.com slash solve.
That's Q-U-O dot com slash solved.
And we're back.
Let's get right back into it.
I think it's useful to take a moment and actually dig into how most of our manipulation is not rooted in malice or bad intentions or taking advantage of people.
A lot of it is just really genuinely us kind of manipulating ourselves.
Convincing ourselves of our own bullshit.
Because it is in our best interest.
And we will be advantaged for it and gain from it.
Yeah.
So there's a few different kind of categories of findings around this too that are really interesting.
It's like we deceive ourselves.
Like we can't even see ourselves doing this.
Like why would that be?
Why would we want to do that?
One kind of group of findings kind of falls under this like self-deception category.
Your self-deception really has a job.
That job is to help you deceive others.
Yes.
And to manipulate others.
But it has a very specific kind of function for that.
There were these two psychologists actually.
Bill Von Hippel.
Bill Von Hippel and Robert Trivers.
They made the argument that sounds a little bit backwards.
Is that we deceive ourselves in order to deceive others more effectively.
Which I mean actually checks out when you dig into it just a little bit.
The deliberate liar has some problems.
Okay.
There's this huge cognitive load.
When you know you're telling a lie you're like oh God am I going to get found out.
Right.
There's this huge cognitive load around the lie.
You have to cover your tracks.
Think through all the different contingencies.
Yeah.
But somebody who believes their own bullshit.
Okay.
They don't have to worry about it.
They don't have to worry about that.
Right.
True.
All of a sudden you're like I'm not even thinking about it because this is just the truth.
It's much more energy efficient.
Right.
Yeah.
Right.
It kind of has these functions where like it's going to erase all of those tells that you have.
Like you're not going to have the weird fidgety stuff that's going to make people think that you're trying to deceive them.
Or you're going to if you believe your own bullshit somebody else is it's much more likely to believe your bullshit too.
And then if you are caught you just plead innocence too.
Right.
Like do you you're like well that's not what my intent was.
At all.
What are you talking about.
I'm not that kind of person.
Of course I wasn't doing it for that reason.
Believing your own story first has huge advantages.
Yeah.
So in order to really effectively I think on that smaller scale at least deceive other people you first have to deceive yourself.
I think it also protects your own self-esteem.
Yes.
Right.
100%.
You're not a bad person.
Right.
I'm just doing my best.
I'm just working hard.
I'm just trying to get along with everybody.
Like what are you getting mad at me for.
Right.
Like it's if you knew you were doing the things that you're doing you would probably feel.
Well assuming you're not a psychopath you would probably you would probably struggle with a lot of remorse and shame and guilt and all sorts of things.
There's also some interesting findings around this about how we rationalize our choices after the fact to justify them to ourselves primarily even if we didn't actually make the choice consciously to begin with.
So one of the cooler studies that I've come across in a long time happened out at Lund University.
So what they did is they actually took magicians who are.
Great at sleight of hand card tricks and use them for this study.
So what they did is they created decks of playing cards with people's faces on them.
They would have subjects come in the magicians and the subjects didn't know they were magicians.
They thought they were researchers.
The magicians would present two cards with faces on on the front of the card.
They would ask the subject which face do you find more attractive.
The subject would choose one of the two faces and then in half of the situations the magician would secretly switch the card.
They would.
Hand the card to the subject and tell him to keep it.
What's fascinating is that later on researchers came in and asked the subjects to pull the card out and explain what they found attractive about that particular face.
And of course half of the subjects are holding cards of faces that they didn't actually choose.
Do you want to guess what percentage of people realize that they actually didn't choose the card that they were holding.
All right.
It's probably pretty high.
It's a shockingly high amount.
It was actually about three quarters of people didn't even realize.
Yeah yeah.
That they were holding different cards than they had actually chosen minutes before.
And then the researchers asked them say why do you like this face so much.
And the people started going into these like elaborate explanations of like oh I really like the jawline and like the hairstyles really cool and all this stuff.
And it's like people are explaining a card that they didn't actually choose why they chose it in like minute detail of what they care about and what they like.
And again it's not that these people realize like oh shit I didn't choose this card let me make up reasons to justify.
Why I might have chosen it.
It's like they didn't even realize they didn't choose it.
They just started justifying it to themselves.
The explanation came automatically without them even having to think about it without them even having to realize that this isn't even a thing that they chose in the first place.
So if you apply that to everyday life right like how many situations on a weekly basis do you kind of just find yourself in and without even like choosing to be there like it just kind of happened like you just go along with it next thing you know.
You're like I don't know at this cafe or something with you and you're like why am I here like I don't know I just kind of like followed this person here and said yes to this thing and.
But then you start justifying it to yourself you're like no no I actually like this this is actually no this is I wanted this even though you had no say in the matter yeah whatsoever yeah yeah I think I kind of did this with you this morning actually on the way in here oh god what did you do what no I was talking about myself I was like it was about being single and stuff I'm like yeah no it's probably like how much should do I actually control.
Oh yeah you did say fine and like I've kind of set up my life this way and it's okay and yeah keep telling yourself all this post I do this all the time post rationalization why I bought the thing I bought or went to the place I went to or said the thing I said all of it is post rationalization yeah we talked about this a little bit in the or the values episode I guess it was a Jonathan height talks about you know the writer and the elephant type of thing oh yeah I think this is related to that big time we post rationalize so most of our decisions right just happens a lot of them a good number of them yeah that's not to say we can't.
Think and then decide obviously we can it just takes a lot more effort to do that we automatically the point here is we so often automatically we don't notice come up with some we don't notice that we're even it's like the slate of hand yeah like it's just it just happens and we think it was always there but god those reasons sound so convincing like it's really not hard to convince yourself of why you did something in many cases there there's like a lot of interesting context where being smarter backfires against you and I think this is one of the reasons.
Is that the smarter you are the more easily and readily you are able to come up with justifications and rationalizations for your own bullshit and like to convince yourself that like you're totally fine and everything everything you're doing is.
great and very noble and very well-intentioned when actually like you're completely full of
shit but you're so smart you don't realize you come up with better reasons yeah you come up with
better bullshit exactly yeah exactly and i i think this is why street smarts versus book smarts you
know like street smart people they seem to have a little bit more self-awareness around this sort
of thing and like kind of just get that like okay everybody's a little bit full of shit but that's
fine because you you just got to play the game whereas like book smart people don't even realize
this stuff's going on because they're so good at rationalizing everything that happens in front of
them it kind of explains a little bit of uh you know the the nutty professor phenomenon of like
being a genius but not even realizing when when like a car salesman is ripping you off or like
why they're trying to rip you off seeing manipulation and out in the world actually
doesn't protect you from it especially if you're smart about it because precisely because of that
yeah and then seeing it in yourself is even harder sometimes which is also a weird little paradox we
yeah coming back to the self-esteem thing too our old friend who demolished self-esteem roy
baumeister did some research in the early 90s that found that when your actions hurt somebody else
you tend to rationalize yourself as being the reasonable one and the person who is hurt as
being the irrational and unreasonable one this seems to happen automatically at a very subconscious
level it is that that self-preservation of we all need to see ourselves as the main character as the
hero as the good guy baumeister even had a quote in one of his papers he called it the myth of pure
evil and he pointed out that this idea that people who are evil know that they're evil
just doesn't seem to exist i mean baumeister studied violent criminals in in the late 90s so
like he consistently didn't come across people who thought that they were evil there's a fantastic
quote from david foster wallace in infinite jest from around the same time coincidentally where he
said that evil people never believe that they are evil people they believe everyone else is an evil
person which is a very important point and i think it's a very important point and i think it's a very
if you think about the ability to deceive yourself into doing awful shit to other people the most
logical way to justify that would be to convince yourself that everybody else is evil and you're
the only good person again we'll go back to those scales already aren't we like yeah in the small
scale you can deceive yourself and it's fine to get you through your day but yeah scale it up and
watch out and the self-deception continues all the way up it's just the nature of the deception
shifts so at the low end it's very like i'm just
being polite you know oh i i just want to be nice right middle of the scale it becomes hey it's not
my like i'm doing my best here i didn't mean for that to happen it's not my fault and then at the
upper end of the scale it's no no i'm not evil they're evil i i'm the good guy i'm trying i i'm
justified i'm the one out here fighting evil all by myself and the last thought around this
and this isn't really pc to say but what you often find is that the people who talk the most
about being a victim are not always the ones who have been hurt the most in fact there's research
that has linked a virtuous victim with high traits of machiavellianism narcissism and
psychopathy the truth is that by framing yourself as a victim both to yourself and to others it
becomes easy to justify a lot of manipulative and violent behavior towards others it becomes
a way to preserve your image of yourself as somebody who is noble and good despite the fact
that you were doing awful shit to other people and so it is actually quite dangerous to overly
sympathize obviously we should sympathize with victims but if you see somebody who is chronically
playing the victim who seems to be victimized in every context in every scenario that is a huge
red flag right because they are weaponizing their victimhood into a justification for victimizing
others there's a fun quote from nassim taleb where he said
half of people lie with their lips the other half lie with their tears you know what the strongest
predictor of believing that other people are willing to conspire against you is it's your
willingness to conspire against other people so there is actually data that finds that people who
believe everyone else is trying to manipulate them and take advantage of them are the ones who are
most willing to manipulate and take advantage of others it takes one to know one exactly yeah
exactly yeah interesting okay i know this is a hard question for us to ask ourselves but i mean
to me it begs the question of like how far up or down that scale do you think you are
how aware of your own lies and manipulation do you think you are you know you have that idea about the
best thing about a person is also sometimes the worst thing right i think that's where we should
look that's where i looked anyway yeah a high value of mine is like helping other people that
can get manipulated pretty quickly though too i i don't outwardly come to somebody be like well i
help you i've done all of these things for you i've done all of these things for you i've done
all of these things for you there's there are people who will just blatantly come out and say
that right yeah i don't i i don't think i've ever said that to anyone before but i think i've probably
felt like i've done all those things these things for this person why can't i get a little bit back
here too that's manipulative yeah it is it is i never ever feel like i'm doing that in the moment
though i never feel like i'm manipulating them right in the moment and never feels feels genuine
yeah yeah only when i look back on it and if i'm really honest about things like i probably did
that to get something out of that didn't i there is a pro-social way to do that you know
there is like yes i'm scratching your back you scratch mine kind of thing that just happens
that's how we function sometimes but it never feels like that's the motivation for me and i'm
not saying that's the motivation all the time a lot of times it isn't i really genuinely don't
expect anything in return but when that's my mode right that's my that's my mo that's what i go to
i think that can pretty quickly i got to be careful with that one well it also this begs
the question of like there probably is like net positive manipulation right like i it's like if i
do a nice thing for a person because i want to be friends with that person and it does help
engender a very wonderful friendship right like that is a pro-social net positive form of better
than black male right yeah absolutely yeah absolutely yeah and i interesting we'll talk
about machiavelli um in in the next chapter i believe but he talked about the difference
between ruling like manipulating via love versus fear and that there are advantages
and disadvantages to each one i like your framing as the the best thing and the worst
yeah
because it's i one of the things that i keep thinking about when i think about this question
is two consistent pieces of feedback i have received my entire life from the people closest
to me one is uh mark is sometimes too honest that is like every woman i've ever dated has said that
uh my family has often said that but i've also been told that i i can be very insensitive
and i can i can say things that are very hurtful without even like realizing that i'm saying them
and i think that is kind of the flip side of that honesty coin is that sometimes
i will say the thing i will not say that the general polite nicety that is supposed to be
said and i will say the thing that most people are not saying and it will be hurtful and it
will like cause a little bit of fallout or people will be very annoyed by me when i think about like
friendships i've lost over the years i think it's often because i do just talk about the elephant in
the room and people get really upset what's interesting too is i think most of the people
who like read my books and listen to this show and follow me on social media like that's also
why they follow me
is because it of this kind of costly form of honesty yeah right this goes back to what you
were talking about in the intro a little bit you want to be manipulated to some degree
somebody comes to you and they're too honest with you oh my god yeah yeah it's not it doesn't feel
good or here's it okay there's the other side of it too maybe sometimes you can use honesty as
manipulation absolutely right like yeah so it's it's everywhere yeah it's absolutely everywhere i
mean one of the thoughts that i had to prep in for this podcast is that in a sense everything this
industry does is a form of manipulation like if you think about actually trying to get people to
change and improve themselves and grow that is manipulation if i put together a youtube video
with this beautiful script that is extremely inspiring and motivating to somebody and they
go out and they make different choices in their life based on what they heard me say in that video
that is manipulation like i'm actively trying to manipulate them into doing better things
or making better decisions in their life and i think that is why this industry has such a
such ethical gray areas and ethical issues because i do think there are a number of people in this
industry who cross that line morally and then justify it to themselves by saying well i'm
helping people right so okay yeah that marketing campaign a little over the top kind of bullshit
made me a bunch of money but look how many people i'm helping right and it becomes a very easy
justification to get by with and then of course you end up with all sorts of horror stories that
we see
out of the self-help industry i guess the last thing we should talk about in this chapter
before we move on is detecting manipulation right so we've we've we've covered how
we all manipulate everybody pretty much all the time we manipulate ourselves pretty much all the
time is there a way to spot this like can we train ourselves to see lies and misdirection
and others deceit and others like can we become better at tracking this within ourselves yeah
i mean give me good news true yeah so digging into this it's basically a coin flip maybe a little bit
better than a coin flip uh for the most part the few meta analyses that have been done on this like
deception detection lie detection manipulation detection of any kind basically comes out
slightly higher than 50 it's statistically it's a coin flip and these are like the best people
these are like doesn't matter this is gonna be lay people or experts too yeah yeah so that's
Protecting people in the world, top out of what, like 55?
For 54, 56-ish percent, something like that. Yeah, that's what they found. I think this, again, goes back to the smarter you are, the more expert you are, you can come up with better reasons. Again, but though it's just a coin flip at that point.
Well, the researcher I mentioned earlier, DePaulo, she found in her research that police officers, judges, psychiatrists, therapists were no better at predicting lies than college students were.
People who dealt with liars every day, basically.
Yes.
Yeah, are no better about it. Governments have spent billions, probably trillions of dollars at this point over that course of history working on this.
Just a small example of this, after 9-11, TSA developed this program to train people to spot deception in-
Shady people.
Shady people, basically, and deception at airports. What was it, 900 million? Basically, a billion dollars they spent on this program, right?
Years of training, and a lot of this was pretty subjective.
But what they basically found was that they weren't any better at spotting the deceiver or the shady people than just a random person on the street was after this.
So they ran this huge experiment, very expensive experiment, very high-stakes experiment, weren't able to produce anything out of this.
Again, we all have this idea, like we were talking about, we can read body language or like averting your gaze is like a tell or something like that.
It's really not, though. People just exhibit all sorts of behaviors all the time.
But our brains will latch on.
We'll latch on to anything that the story that we're creating fits into, right?
And we'll say, oh, no, no, no, he, you know, blinked a few times to me or something like that, right?
Or he covered it, I know, covering your mouth.
Covering your mouth, avoiding eye contact, like all of those things.
None of those really pan out.
Averting your gaze, that's one of the most common ones found around the world.
People are like, oh, if there's a liar, they won't look you in the eye.
A lot of people are just uncomfortable with eye contact, though, too.
Yeah, that's true.
A lot of people are socially insecure or socially anxious.
And by the way, psychopaths probably have-
They have no problem holding eye contact with you.
Exactly.
Exactly, yeah.
Someone you're familiar with, you probably have a better insight into their tells than other people,
just because you have that experience with them.
But just like a random person on the street or somebody you're watching on a video somewhere or something like that, you know,
there's not really a lot of evidence to support any of that kind of stuff.
We're really bad at detecting lies, basically, is what I'm saying.
We can't train ourselves or learn.
Can't really get a lot much better at it, yeah.
There might be some very specialized areas where this can work, but for the most part, no.
Drew, we're right.
We're ruining so many podcasts right now.
Well, but why?
Okay, so why?
So many podcasts have told me that this is how I can spot a liar or this is how I can know I'm dating a narcissist.
Oh, God, it's all over.
Yeah.
No, you can't.
I mean, the truth is, is that the only way to really verify the honesty of somebody is to go actually check if the thing that they said is true or not.
And, like, go verify it yourself.
Go see, like, did they do the behavior that they said they did?
Did you, like, go check with third parties?
The fact of the matter is that's very comfortable.
It's very cumbersome and tiring and a total pain in the ass, and we don't want to have to do that with each other.
So it's more convenient to just trust somebody and assume that they're telling the truth until proven otherwise.
Some psychologists have made this argument that our inability to pick up lies might actually be a feature, not a bug, for this exact reason.
Because if people are telling small lies and deceiving each other in very, like, minuscule ways all the time, if any of us actually were really, really good at picking up on those things, it would drive us fucking crazy.
Like, we would be so distrustful and skeptical of everything and everybody all the time.
It would destroy our social circles.
It would just rock our worldviews in terms of, like, what we believed humanity is and capable of that I think we need to believe.
And these psychologists make the point that people are honest most of the time.
Most people are honest most of the time, so it is better to default towards honesty to maintain that social cohesion and be lied to on the margins here and there every once in a while than the alternative.
The constant distrust, if you distrust people, you can't really build a relationship with them.
You can't rely upon them.
You can't collaborate with them.
And so if you distrust everybody. If you distrust everybody all the time, you are socially. It's another form of social isolation, and it is extremely harmful for your well-being.
So we are kind of forced to trust others.
It's good for us to trust others, and it's, in many cases, probably good for us that many of these white lies do go undetected.
We do benefit from the pro-social cohesion that comes from them.
This kind of goes a little bit back to the evolutionary thing, too.
You know, we evolved in small groups, and we had repeated contact with the same person.
And those situations. It behooves everyone to be honest more often than not.
The little white lies aside.
But it behooves everyone in that situation to interact honestly with each other.
We've talked about this before, like the tit-for-tat, you know, that whole strategy.
It's actually more advantageous for you in a repeated context with someone to be truthful and honest.
And so you may as well just assume honesty.
Yeah, if anybody wants to nerd out really hard on just kind of the evolutionary explanation of. Of human friendship and human collaboration, check out the friendship episode from last November.
We get really deep into a lot of the game theory of just human cooperation and why it matters so much.
Right.
The other interesting thing that we came across that I found fascinating was that a survey in 2010 found that almost 50% of all lies came from 5% of people.
And so very much like the same way. You see this across. Across a lot of crime statistics, right?
So 70% of the burglaries are committed by like 2% of the burglars.
It seems to be similar here where it's like the vast majority of lies are committed by a very small group of compulsive and consistent liars.
As long as you just make a point to avoid those people and kind of give a little bit of grace to everybody else, you're probably fine.
And it's not worth agonizing over every little lie.
Every little. Like being manipulated in every micro situation.
It's really just like avoid that 5% and you're fine.
So this has been a long chapter.
To sum everything up, kind of where we're at, we've established that manipulation is not a certain category of person.
It is a spectrum of behavior exhibited by all people all the time.
We're doing it all the time.
Everybody we know is doing it.
White lies, time compliments, strategic framing.
Stories that are a little bit self-serving, maybe exaggerated or embellished to make ourselves look a little bit better.
The typical lie, it happens a few times a day.
It tends to be very small in its implications.
It is not even worth the effort to spot in the first place, much less call somebody out for.
And not only do we do these things all the time, but we aren't even aware of the fact that we're doing them all the time.
The most effective way we deceive others or manipulate others is by deceiving and manipulating ourselves.
We're extremely adept at it.
Our minds seem to be prone or predisposed to do it.
And it's not because we're horrible people.
It's just because that's how our machinery is built.
And that's how the game theory of human interaction works out, is that it is more cost efficient to believe your own bullshit than to have to spin up some wild tale consciously and then spend a ton of energy and effort and anxiety trying to defend it.
We've talked about how that self-deception and self-justification.
Exist on all parts of the manipulation spectrum.
So even from the smallest white lie to the most heinous, violent assault on somebody, the person who is doing the manipulation is going to have justifications for themselves because they need to maintain that sense of self that they are the good guy, that they are the hero in the story.
And this is why you should be especially skeptical of people who always seem to have a narrative of themselves being a righteous victim, because it is that sense of righteous victimhood.
That justifies the worst and most manipulative behavior.
If the conclusion is, is that we're all manipulative to varying degrees and manipulation is always occurring throughout our lives to varying degrees, the question becomes, where is the line?
At what point does manipulation go from just being kind of this benign, annoying, unfortunate thing to an actual ethical problem, something that is reprehensible or that people should be punished for?
And the truth is, is that that line is.
Kind of murky.
It's not completely clear.
And so in the next chapter, we're going to get into a lot of the different ethical philosophies of where that line is and what manipulation is acceptable in our day-to-day lives and what manipulation is unacceptable and how to distinguish between the two.
All right, we will be right back after this.
This episode is brought to you by Cozy Earth.
Now, for most of my life, I did not give a shit about sheets.
Thread counts.
Who cares?
I'm like a caveman.
I could sleep on a patch of grass.
And a bundle of sticks.
And I'm going to be honest.
I still don't really know anything about sheets.
But when Cozy Earth offered to send me a bed set, my wife got more excited than I have seen her since my last anniversary.
And I have to admit, I got in the bed and I was like, wow.
Okay, yeah, this is really nice.
And this is because they're made from viscose from bamboo.
They're so soft, smooth, and light that old sheets now just feel like a burlap sack.
Now, the sheets are breathable.
They naturally wick away moisture.
So they regulate.
They regulate your body temperature throughout the night more effectively.
You don't wake up with like hot sweats or feeling freezing.
Now we both wake up feeling really refreshed instead of grumpy and sweaty.
Now, every set of sheet comes with 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty so you can try them risk-free.
And worst case, you get 100 great nights of sleep.
So head to CozyEarth.com and use my code SOLVED for up to 20% off.
That's code SOLVED for 20% off all home and sleepwear.
And if you see a post-purchase survey, please be sure to mention that you heard about Cozy Earth right here on the Solve podcast.
Trust me, your girlfriend or wife will thank you.
This episode is brought to you by Ethos.
Remember adulting? Around 2016, millennials were posting about doing their taxes or folding their laundry like they'd won a damn award.
The word has since been deemed cringe, but the feeling has stuck.
Plenty of us are in our 40s now, Gen Zs about to hit their 30s, and nobody feels like an actual grown-up.
So we avoid thinking about all the grown-up stuff, like life insurance.
And I'm guilty of this too.
Then I hit 40, and I figured it was time to stop pretending I'm 25.
Now, I'm not planning on going anywhere.
But if something does happen. If something does happen to me, I don't want my wife dealing with grief and a financial mess at the same time.
My process involved weeks of phone calls and forums, which is a uniquely depressing way to contemplate your own mortality.
My co-host Drew, on the other hand, went through Ethos.
And he was covered in less time than I spent on hold.
Ethos makes getting life insurance fast and easy.
It's 100% online.
You can get a quote in seconds, apply in minutes, and get same-day coverage.
There's no medical exam.
You just answer a few health questions online.
You can get up to $3 million in coverage.
And some policies are as low as $30 a month.
Plus, you'll get your lowest rate from their network of trusted carriers.
Nobody enjoys thinking about this stuff.
But 10 minutes of adulting now can help protect the people you love later.
Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through Ethos.
Get your free quote at ethos.com slash solved.
That's E-T-H-O-S dot com slash solved.
Application times may vary.
Rates may vary.
All right.
We're back with more manipulation.
The philosopher Immanuel Kant was, I think, every biohacking bro's wet dream.
For pretty much the entire back half of his life, he lived such a regimented and planned schedule.
He would wake up at the same time every day, 530 in the morning.
He would read for the same amount of time.
He would write for the same amount of time.
He would go to the local university where he would teach the same class every single day.
He would take classes.
He would take lunch at the same restaurant.
He would go on his afternoon walk through the same park on the same route.
He would arrive at home at the exact same time every single day.
He would work into the evening.
He would hang out with the same group of friends, and he would go to bed at the exact same time every single night.
He ate the same thing every day.
He never left his hometown of Konigsberg, Prussia, in his entire life.
He lived like 30 miles from the ocean and never saw it.
He did not drink.
He did not party.
He did not waste.
Any time, everything was focused and dedicated to either work or his own personal mental and physical health.
And his routine was so predictable that his neighbors used to joke that they could tune their clocks based on Kant coming and leaving.
Now, what's interesting about Kant is that this insane adherence to routine, it was not accidental.
It was actually very intentional, and it was based on his own moral philosophy.
Now, it's useful to kind of place Kant in the context of the Enlightenment.
So he. He is one of the most prominent Enlightenment thinkers, one of the most influential philosophers who's ever lived.
At the time, there was a pretty massive gap around moral philosophy, which was that up until that point in the West, all morality had been based around Christianity.
Everything was in the Bible.
God said you can do this.
You can't do that.
That's just how it is, right?
That's how we're going to live.
When the Enlightenment thinkers came along. They argued that truth should be ascertained not from the Bible, but through critical reason and rationality.
And this worked really, really well for all sorts of things, for the advancement of science, for the improvement of technology, inventing new theories in economics, the later industrialization of the Western world.
All of these things were very much driven by the scientific process, the pursuit of truth via rationality.
Experimentation, learning from failures, so on and so forth.
The problem at the time was that there was still no way to deduce morality rationally through reason.
The same way you can make a scientific prediction and then go verify it through observation, you couldn't necessarily make an ethical or moral prediction and then verify it through somebody's behaviors.
It just seemed to be very much based on people's sentiments and how things made them feel.
And this was Hume's argument.
And earlier in that century, Hume argued that all morality is basically, it's just vibes.
It's just feelings, man.
Like, we tend to associate what is ethical with what makes us and other people feel good and what is unethical with what makes us and other people feel bad.
This was not satisfying for Kant.
And so he took on the project of devising a kind of fully rational or theoretical view of morality that could be argued from. first principles and reason through the same way you would reason through mathematical proofs or through, like, different physics experiments.
One of the things that he realized is that for something to be a moral truth, it needs to be true in every context and in every situation.
You can't have something be morally correct with this person over here, but it's incorrect for that person over there.
Like, if something is a moral truth, the same way the law of gravity is true here in Los Angeles as it is. as in Tokyo, as it is in India, a moral truth has to be true in everywhere and with every individual as well.
And Kant called these moral truths categorical imperatives.
They were basically truths that were self-evident and self-reinforcing and applicable to every situation.
Now, one of these categorical imperatives that he came up with that I personally find to be incredibly profound and also I think is extremely relevant for this ethical discussion of manipulation and. where kind of the moral bounds of influence and manipulating each other is, is something that he called the formula of humanity.
And the exact quote was,. act so that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, never merely as a means to an end, but always at the same time as an end.
So basically, never treat people as a means to some other end, only treat humans as a means unto themselves.
Now, what's brilliant about. the formula of humanity is that I think it explains really nicely so many of our moral intuitions of what is right and wrong.
So for example, if I tell you that I like your jacket and I like it because I just like it, I'm treating you as an end.
The motivation of my behavior is purely for your sake.
And because I am saying something nice about you, because I am inspired to say. something nice about you, makes it feel moral.
It feels like a good thing, like I did a good thing by complimenting you that way.
Now, imagine if I said that you have a nice jacket because I want you to drive me home after this.
And I feel like if I compliment you a bunch, you're going to offer to give me a ride.
That feels like icky, right?
That feels a little gross.
And when people do that to us, it makes us feel a little bit gross.
And Kant would argue that the reason for that. is because I'm not treating you as an end, I'm treating you as a means to another end, right?
The end, the fundamental motivation, is for me to get a ride home.
And so I'm going to say nice things to you because it's going to increase the chances that I get a ride home from you, right?
So I'm treating you as a means to some other end, which Kant would say that is, by definition, unethical.
So if you think about what lying is in general, it is treating people. as a means to some other end.
If you think about stealing, right, it is treating other people's property or possessions as a means to some other end.
Like if I steal your car, I am treating you as a means to some other end, which is to get a car.
If I cheat in some way to impress you or get something that I want out of you, it's the same thing.
Like if you go down the line of kind of all the classic moral principles, lying, cheating, stealing. manipulating, violence, coercion, all of these things have kind of the same underlying principle in that you are using another human being as a means to some other end to benefit yourself.
Now what's beautiful about the formula of humanity is that it also applies to ourselves because we also use ourselves as a means to some other end.
And again, we tend to see people who do this as distasteful or unethical.
So if somebody demeans themselves or degrades themselves. to earn the approval or impression of some other person, we see that as pathetic.
We see that as like somebody who has no integrity or dignity for themselves.
If somebody harms themselves in some way to earn more money or receive gifts from somebody, right, like you have that same ick factor.
You're like prostituting yourself for just like some kind of superficial benefit.
But when you look at things like compulsive behaviors or addictionism,
addictions you could look at it through this lens of like if you are drinking compulsively
you're demeaning yourself for the sake of of fun or social cohesion or or you know some kind of
wild experience or wild night with with a bunch of people like you could look at that as treating
yourself as a means to some other end like that is an unethical way to treat yourself
it's this incredible rubric that you can run almost almost every undesirable behavior you
can imagine you can run it through the formula of humanity and it will come out the same pattern
you're either treating somebody else as a means or you're treating yourself as a means
and by Kant's definition that makes it unethical okay I this this sounds good to me too and I think
you're right you can run lots of shady situations or whatever through this
uh the this this test this is one of that always kind of confused me anyway what about when you're
lying to protect someone else or even rely lying to protect their feelings like somebody
ask you a question and yeah you have an honest answer but like we kind of already talked about
there's these little white lies we tell yeah to smooth things over or you know somebody you don't
want to be rude you want to protect a relationship and you want to protect that person's feelings
maybe even to their self-esteem their self-image of themselves what about a situation like that
mark so Kant's yeah
say it's unethical okay was very radical so it's funny because at the time Kant's critics brought up
very quickly brought up thought experiments like you just suggested and they actually brought up a
very extreme one which was the the murder at the door case right so they said okay what if uh a
murderer knocks on your door and they say very plainly to you I want to kill your friend is your
is your friend at your house currently and your friend is in the back what would you do now
obviously you lie right yeah yeah like there's never been a more obvious situation where you
say I have no idea where they are uh check down the street so Kant actually argued that you should
not lie to the murderer at the door which this has done a huge number I think this single public
defense has probably tarnished his moral moral theory and moral framework more than anything else
uh over the past 200 years because it violates every intuition that we have and and frankly it's
it's fucking stupid so his argument was is that you should be honest with the murderer
but the reasoning is like it's actually quite elegant if you understand it and like even though
it's fucking stupid I still admire kind of the philosophy philosophical framework that it comes
from so Kant's argument the basis of his entire moral framework was that consciousness itself
is the most rare
and special thing in the known universe out of everything we know in the whole universe
there is this brief flickering light of of consciousness and reason that to our knowledge
has never existed before and has never existed anywhere else and will never exist again and so
everything we do should be optimized and designed to protect and promote that consciousness as much
as possible which is a very beautiful realization and and I would argue
that this is the basis basis of a moral framework now if you think about what consciousness is
it's a lot of different things but in in Kant's framework what he identified as ethically unique
about somebody with consciousness is that they have agency that they have the right to choose
their actions and behaviors uh to choose who they're going to become to choose like who they
want to be in the world and so the reason the formula of humanity is a definition of morality
is because it is in principle what violating somebody else's agency is so when I lie to you
it's not just that I'm lying to you to get something out of you it is when I lie to you
I'm distorting or preventing you from acting with full agency in the world I am giving you
false information I am distorting current information you may have I am hiding
intentions that I have what it does is that it interferes with your ability to fully act in the
world with full information and so that's that is actually what Kant's argument is is unethical
and what accompanies that agency is responsibility right he called it duty
right he said that because we are conscious and we have agency we all have a duty to do our best
with everything in our lives to maximize ourselves to our fullest potential
and help maximize other people to their fullest potential and in his framework the way you do that
is by not interfering with their agency at all whatsoever is by like giving them full control
over their own lives and not deciding at any point that you know better than I do what's good for me
or vice versa so coming back to the murderer at the door Kant's argument is that by lying to the
murderer like if the murderer is going to kill your friend and make that horrific mistake
it is not your responsibility to
prevent that okay okay which is stupid right yeah yeah yeah but you can see how he arrives
there okay right like it is this very idealistic moral framework and I think like all moral
frameworks they start very beautiful and elegant and noble and then when you start to get into more
and more extreme situations they all become absolutely absurd and they collapse upon their own
kind of mental scaffolding
okay but that would be Kant's argument okay if we don't take such an extreme example yes okay
let's say you have a friend that comes to you uh who's not going to be murdered
but instead they're like you know do you think my nose is big do you think I have a big nose
and they have a big nose right okay the the best way I've ever heard to deal with this anyway is
to say yes you have a big nose and I don't care because you're my friend and it doesn't matter to
me those types of things don't matter to me right so don't lie to them to say no your nose isn't big
because then you know they're like they know their nose is big right like so they're not gonna be able
to trust you at some point yeah but also tell them that it doesn't matter that they have a big nose
so I like that tactically um Kant did soften on his stance later on towards the end of his life
so about 10 years later he wrote an essay called perpetual peace which by the way he was the first
person to suggest uh a united nations as like a source of global peace totally story for a different podcast
uh but in that essay he came up with something a little bit more practical to navigate a lot of
these situations so basically he acknowledged that the desire to influence each other is is natural
and kind of inevitable what makes it ethical or unethical is whether or not the the other person
once becoming aware of that manipulation would be upset or not so for example if I lied to you and
told you a bunch of stuff hoping that you'll give me a ride home and then you found out about it
you'd probably be like wow that's kind of shitty dude like you should just ask me for a ride home
right whereas like I don't know let's say I do you a favor like like let's say I decide I'm gonna run
down to the corner store I'm gonna I'll and I'll pick something up for you and then I tell you I'm
like hey I'm gonna go pick this thing up but I'm only doing it so you give me a ride home later
that doesn't feel as bad it's kind of like okay well yeah it's like a tit for tat thing yeah sure
all right whatever we could think of this almost as like the publicity test right if if the person
that you're trying to influence became aware of the influence that you're subjecting them to
how upset would they be about it and in a lot of cases they actually wouldn't be upset and in some
cases they might actually be happy that you said it right so I used the example earlier of like
let's say that my wife spent a bunch of hours like prep preparing a really nice dinner and
their dinner is kind of like eh but I keep complimenting her for it and I'm like wow this is so
good thank you so much oh you put so much effort into this now let's say that she became aware that
I actually don't like it that much but I'm telling her that I like it a lot because I appreciate how
much effort she put into it she probably wouldn't be upset about that right like she'd be like oh
actually I'm really glad he did that because it would have made me feel bad and it would have
caused a fight and it would have just made the whole night worse right so basically the algorithm
is expose the manipulation if once exposed the manipulation
upsets people then it's probably unethical if it is met with indifference or even people are
appreciative that you did it it could potentially be a good thing okay so so there is room for some
transactions and relationships or even transactional relationships themselves yeah and this yes as
long as it's like it's above board like hey I'm doing this for you because you did this for me
right people deride transactional relationships so much but if you look around like we need them
yeah yeah I mean if I'm like let's say I'm going to sell my couch to somebody right
like can we get into a negotiation over price obviously there's a whole suite of
behaviors and techniques to like negotiate better in situations like that like you never walk into
a sales negotiation and say okay well I'm going to set my anchor price extremely high hoping that
this manipulates you and like yeah people already know like they get it it's just part of the context
it's part of the situation it is a relatively benign form of manipulation and that's fine
if I'm like negotiating with a car salesman or something it's not that I'm trying to fuck
over the car salesman. I'm just trying to get a good price. And he's doing the same. There's
nothing personal involved. We're not actively trying to harm each other. It's just we're trying
to find mutual ground where we can both agree. The more interesting version of this is that
there's this whole concept of nudges. Are you familiar with nudges in economics? There's a
bunch of research kind of loosely based around Kahneman-Tversky's prospect theory and how to
actually leverage that in policy. So a simple example is organ donation. In Germany, only about
12% of people are registered to donate organs, whereas in Austria, it's like 99% of people are
registered to donate organs. And the reason is that Germany has an opt-in organ donation. So
it's like whenever you go get your driving license, you get an opt-in organ donation.
You have to check the box saying, I am willing to donate organs, whereas Austria has an opt-out
organ donation. So you are by default an organ donor unless you check the box saying, I don't
want to donate organs when you go get a driver's license or whatever. And so this is an example of
what is called like a policy nudge. It is creating policy that manipulates people's environment
to push them into more pro-social behaviors.
Let's say you were automatically opted out to being an organ donor. Would you be upset about,
like, I wouldn't be upset about that. I would actually be kind of glad. I'd be like, wow,
our politician is a little smarter than I thought. To me, it's just like effective policy. So
I think there's just an understanding that human perception is bounded,
right? We're only capable of being aware of very few things at any given time. And so it's not
reasonable to expect everybody to be able to make conscious, rational decisions about everything in
their life at all times. And so I think it's just an understanding that human perception is bounded.
All times. So I think a sign of a functional society and a sign of a function, like functional
social relationships is being able to effectively nudge each other into better behaviors, better
choices, and better options. Yeah. Yeah. There might be some people who still think that that's
a little too paternalistic, though, like in the organ donor case. Yeah. Right. So they actually
did go back and they they set this up a little bit differently, too. So, yes, Austria was,
was opt out. Yeah. They kept it opt out. But then they put a little they made sure everybody knew
that it was opt out. And you even still get the same rate of compliance after that, even to when
it's a social benefit. They told them, they said, OK, this is automatically chosen for you because
it benefits the society, our society more. And because setting the default will give us a higher
compliance rate. Yeah. People were still OK with that. This was a really good example of
publicity test. It's like it survives daylight. Right. Because there were a lot of people like,
no, that's being manipulative. That's paternalism.
That's paternalistic. We shouldn't be doing that. And then. But even when you do provide that for
people, they still will. They're OK with it. Yeah. And so everything's above board at that point.
I just thought of another example from my own life. You know, as you know, I spent about three
years without drinking. And it was funny because there were there were a few different instances
where I went out with friends and they told me explicitly, they said, I'm not going to drink
tonight because I don't want you to feel left out or for you to feel any any like pressure or or any
urge to drink, like have to fight that urge. And like it was completely welcome. It's almost like
it's funny. It comes back to this idea that there are actually like manipulation can sometimes be
almost like a love language. Like it can be it can be something that you you can actually do in a
very loving and and beneficial way for somebody that you care about, which is fascinating because
I never would have that. It never occurred to me that that was even possible before we started
prepping for this this episode. But it's like if you look for them, you can find all sorts of
situations where we actually do manipulate our loved ones into being better versions of themselves.
There's a fine line with that, too. I mean, as long as like if it does survive daylight again,
right, if they're on board with it, right, like a partner came to me and said, I do this just to
like help you do this thing. And I'm like, Oh, that's really sweet of you. Thank you for helping
me do that. Because I suck at this. Yes, you're helping me a lot. That's great. Yeah, it all
comes down to what you desire. Right, right. Like if my friend didn't drink because they didn't want
to influence me, and I actually really did want to drink. I'd be like, dude, stop being like,
fuck, fuck you. Like, I'll do what I want. You know? Yeah, that's a philosophical argument for
where the line is. And that agrees with much of philosophy throughout history as well.
It aligns with our intuition. But then there's more of a pragmatic or like, political definition
of where that line is. Okay, so that was that was Kant's idea. This is this philosophical idea that
I think most of us can kind of agree with, at least in principle, and it's very idealistic,
right? And does a lot of work for us. It gives us a very strong framework, I think, too, to kind of
base a lot of our decisions and a lot of our actions as they regard other people. Great framework
for that, right? But there's another side too, that's more practical sometimes and more political,
I need to address. Because, like you've already mentioned, Kant was pretty idealistic. And he went
to extremes for that idealism. But it sometimes didn't always work, right? He wasn't the first one
to though, to say that manipulation was wrong. This was an idea that had gone back through
philosophy for 1500, 2000 years, right? Yeah, very, very long time. Go all the way back to Cicero in
44 BCE. He wrote on duties, which he said that wrongdoing actually takes two different forms. And
that's animals as a metaphor, right? Force was a lion, okay? Whereas fraud was a fox, okay? So
wrongdoing manipulation can take one of these two forms. You can be very forceful about it,
or you can be very deceptive about it, all right? Cicero thought that both of these things were
really obviously bad. They were unbecoming of being a human being in the first place,
but he thought that fraud was actually more contemptible, okay?
Because it wears this mask of good while actually doing bad, where at least you had a really forceful
dictator of some kind, whatever. You knew what his tactic was. He wasn't lying to you, right?
But the fox was very deceptive and, "Oh, I'm doing this for your own good," when really they were
doing it for their own good, right? This was very much the idea throughout pretty much all of human
history for thousands of years. Do good. Virtue is the way to lead a nation or a group of people, or
a household even, right? It's all about virtue. This is a very stoic idea as well.
Very much so. This was really the prevailing idea for centuries, right?
So we get up to the 16th century, around 1512, the Medici take over Florence,
the Medici from Spain take over Florence, okay? And there just so happened to be a diplomat,
a bureaucrat in the Florentine government at that time named Machiavelli, right? As part
of this takeover, when the Medici came in, he was jailed, he was put into prison, he was ridiculed,
he was told to renounce his government, all of these things, right? He was a very dedicated
Republican though, to his government. He served for like 15, 20 years, something like that,
an advocate of Republican government, of representation, of democracy even too, right?
Right.
Then he sees this happen, right? The Medici were not Republicans. They were not Democratic. They
came in and they ruled with an iron fist.
So he sees this happen. He's thrown in jail. He's exiled to like a farm somewhere,
I think. And he's looking at this and he's like, "Okay, all of these virtues that we had,
that we've been upholding for centuries now, look where it got us. Look where we are now. These
people come in, they have no scruples about them. They rule with an iron fist, and we're the ones
who get screwed over." This is when he wrote "The Prince," his most famous work, right?
Okay. So in "The Prince," Machiavelli argues that cruelty isn't really a scandal of people
and power. It's the fact that the old system was covering up the fact that they were actually cruel,
but they were pretending like they weren't, okay? He's the one who's trying to bring daylight to
all of this here. And so this is actually what's going on, and this is how you actually have to
rule. It's just a necessity of life that rulers have to face. And so he took that metaphor of the
fox and the lion from Cicero. And Cicero said these were two animals that were unworthy of man,
right? Machiavelli said,
"No, actually, the prince, the ruler, has to actually embody both of them. They have to embody
both the fox, deceit and fraud, and the lion, force. But they have to be very cognizant of all
of this in order to rule effectively, right?" He said that leaders have to learn how to not
be good, okay, and use that knowledge as the situation demands. Because just practically
speaking, things come up where they have to use force, they have to use deceit,
in order to save people from, it might be a huge war, or a famine, or it's kind of for their own
good type of, a little bit paternalistic of him. He has this famous line in there where,
"Men judge more by the eye than by the hand. Everyone sees what you seem, but few touch what
you actually are." It is very Machiavellian, what we call Machiavellian today. Keep your promises
when it's convenient, break them when not. Very conditional, conniving, yeah.
This raises so many interesting points,
interesting questions for me. Because I think what Machiavelli is pointing out is that,
ultimately, I mean, we can wax on about virtue, and ethics, and morals,
all day till we're blue in the face but at the end of the day what gets shit done is power yeah and
power is ultimately about leverage it's there's always this game theory aspect of like if somebody
can get away with something they they will so if you leave a vacuum uh somebody will always find a
way to fill it i think what gets missed a lot is that it you know machiavelli he was just writing
what works it's it's not like he's saying rulers should behave this way government should behave
this way he's just writing like this is what works and this is when they do it this is why they do it
but before we keep going a quick word from our sponsors this episode is brought to you by quince
now i've spent a lot of my life on the road living out of my luggage and after enough years of that
you actually get pretty damn picky about what you travel with your bag basically becomes like a
second home now my newest travel upgrade is from quince and yes they're mostly known for cashmere
but their travel gear has built a bit of a cult following and i finally understand why so i just
picked up one of their cool backpacks it's actually pretty sick it's slim enough to slide under the
seat in front of me and it still fits all of my laptops ipads chargers a book and whatever else
i panic pack the way out the door now i'm pretty hard on my bags but this one feels like well it
can take a beating they also make totes duffels garment bags travel accessories hard shells and
a whole range of sizes bundle your bags and you can save up to 25 percent on your travel gear
25 percent on top of their already accessible pricing there's even a limited lifetime warranty
now holiday travel is coming so if your current bag is held together by one stubborn zipper
now is a really good time to upgrade and if someone on your list loves an adventure this is
an easy way to become one of their favorite gifts so give the gift of quality this holiday season
download the quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com get free shipping on your
order and 365 day returns now you have a free gift of quality this holiday season so if you're
interested in buying any of these gifts they're now available in canada as well and when quince
asks you where you heard about them let them know that it was the solve podcast the best way that
you can support the show this episode is sponsored by tello if you ever looked at your phone bill and
then realized that you have no idea when you agreed to pay that much money i mean you signed
up turn on auto pay and you just stop looking right i do it too and then suddenly 80 90 100
a month and you don't even know what you're getting for that but switching sounds like a pain in the
ass so you know i'm not going to do that i'm going to do it right now i'm going to do it right now
you keep paying now i have to apologize in advance for what this sponsor is about to make me say
wireless that doesn't drive you crazy tello me about it i'm so ashamed it turns out there's a
simple uncomplicated solution that doesn't involve bad puns tello is a wireless provider that offers
budget-friendly plans starting at five dollars a month up to an unlimited plan at 25 a month
which includes 50 gigs of high-speed 5g data that rolls over unlimited
data that rolls over unlimited data that rolls over unlimited data that rolls over unlimited
talk and text and 10 gigs of hotspot all on america's largest 5g network now switching to it
is easy keep your phone and your number and you can set it up at home there's no contract plus it
has over 15 000 excellent reviews on trustpilot so if you could use some peace of mind and
flexibility click on the tello link in the description to get started all right let's get
back into it so i feel like we are seeing the two poles of a ethical conundrum which is taught
kind of represents this idealistic philosophical side of us right like where where everything he
says feels correct it feels virtuous it feels true like yes that's how we want people to behave
that's how we want to behave that's how we want our leaders to behave whereas machiavelli has this
very practical look life is a power struggle and this is how it operates whether you like it or not
whether you're virtuous or not
and there is a vacuum somebody will always step forward to fill that vacuum and if the way to do
that is unethical there will always be somebody who is willing to behave unethically to fill that
vacuum and take control of that power so you you have this almost like internal tug of war which i
think happens within all of us right of what we know the better angel of our of our nature right
the angel on our shoulder which is kind of the kantian treat everybody as a not as a means but
to themselves and then you have the machiavellian side of ourselves which is like look you can
probably get away with this so you you should probably go ahead and do it and you know nothing
great is accomplished without you know you can't make an omelet without breaking some eggs and so
on and so forth and i do feel like a lot of us feel that tension within ourselves uh there is
that temptation to cut corners a little bit to maybe piss somebody off or to piss somebody off
hurt somebody occasionally if you believe that it is better off for yourself in the long run or maybe
for a lot of people in the long run and i think this is kind of where that spectrum of manipulation
comes in there is the machiavellian pole which is just pure cynical do what gets me power no matter
what then there's a pure kantian pole which is almost naively virtuous like virtuous to the
times of being honest to a murderer at the door who is looking to kill your friend and i think
the tension we feel is that both of these poles are right they are correct and and the vast majority
of us live in the middle somewhere so we feel the doubt and the second guessing and and a lot of
times the agony of stressing over is it worth it i don't know about you but like i can i can think
about a handful of times in my life where i have
either lied or kept a secret or hurt somebody and i still to this day feel like it's justified
that it was and not not because i'm like such a special virtuous person but it is just
looking at kind of the cost benefit overall right it's like okay this person got hurt
in the short term but it is going to promote all of these other causes or
interests over the long term and so it's worth it and i think what machiavelli was
serving among princes and kings and leaders is that they have to make those difficult decisions
all the time right you kill one person to save a hundred you start a small war to prevent a large
war um you oppress this small group of people to allow this larger group of people to be free
and none of that feels good none of it is in many cases it is downright reprehensible morally
but also life puts you in a lot of situations like that and as much as we would like to be
like kant and be like no you are honest all the time and you promote the freedom and the
uh in the livelihood of everybody equally all the time in practice it's not always that simple
yeah okay so the the question really becomes then okay so how do you pick and choose which one do
you use when um i guess is maybe what we're saying because like you mentioned before there's a
this is a real thing right that we all have to go through at some point where
do you do the the noble ethical thing and you know maybe screw a bunch of people over even though it's
the honest thing to do or do you try to protect them and be paternalistic even at some points
there was this philosopher in the 70s who tried to come up with some sort of reconciliation i guess
for this or at least some sort of uh way for us to navigate this um his name was michael walser and
this was in the 70s
he actually was building off john paul john paul uh sartre's uh play it was called dirty hands
okay okay there was uh this character in this play he was a communist leader
um his name was hoarder hoarder hoarder hoarder
not a very good communist no no but it was this this communist leader um in this play and he had
this this famous line that says i have dirty hands right up to the elbows i plunge them in
blood do you think you can govern innocently kind of stating this whole conundrum that we're talking
about right now um walter's kind of his his conclusion was that there are just certain roles
in life in society in politics even just everyday life too where doing a good job
requires you to do something we would consider wrong at least on the surface deception manipulation
betrayal sometimes these have to be deployed for good ends like you were just talking about right
sacrificing the one to save the hundred or some configuration of that right walter's point though
was that we don't want someone who can just make that deal that's we can find anybody to do that
right yes that could just be a cruel person that we can find to do that what we actually want is
someone who can make that deal and they can feel bad about it they know that they're that it's
wrong and that they just have to accept that yeah so it's a little bit of a reconciliation between
the two because you acknowledge that yes there's this noble good thing over here but at the same
time too in order for us to have a functioning system of any kind and almost any kind of system
anyway you have to be able to sometimes go outside of that uh that box that we put ourselves in right
so a great historical example of this is abraham lincoln uh when the south seceded
from the United States and the Civil War began, Lincoln had to institute
something called habeas corpus which is basically like suspending legal rights suspending the
constitution there was a massive draft of all sorts of people into the war privately lincoln
really struggled with a lot of depression and grief during this period i mean obviously he
believed he was doing the right thing but he sometimes wondered at the time whether he was
actually destroying the republic in order to save it obviously he was assassinated before he left
office so like we never really learned what his long-term views were looking back and like how
much how much guilt he would have ended up sitting with um over his decisions during that period but
we do know that during that period itself he agonized over a lot of this the choices that
he was forced to make and he very openly wondered whether he was making the right choices at all
or not interestingly towards the end of his life
beaches got a lot more religious and he started speaking more publicly about being judged before
god um ironically pretty close before he was assassinated i think it gives a glimpse into
the psyche of somebody who is like forced to wrestle with a lot of these sorts of choices
and decisions um of like making the hard awful choice to prevent an even more awful choice
and coming back to that spectrum of self-deception the danger
there is that as we talked about the more egregious the manipulation the more egregious the
deceit the more we tend to justify it with explanations of the greater moral good really
start to run into a lot of dangerous situations when you start justifying these things like i
just feel like your threshold of certainty needs to be raised so much higher like if there's any
doubt you should probably just default towards error on the side of honesty
and virtue because if you do start subscribing to well i'm doing this for the greater good i'm doing
this to preserve the country the republic my group of people all these things you can start
justifying a lot of heinous acts and there's a lot of counter examples to lincoln throughout history
uh of pretty awful people who use the same justifications that he did and like walter's
point he felt the dirty hands yeah he knew what he was doing was on some level wrong right whereas
a counter example is
like joseph stalin who also used many of the same justifications of like okay we're gonna let
this million people die you know to preserve the the socialist republic or whatever stalin
seemed to be a person of zero remorse there's actually a crazy story where uh the germans
captured one of stalin's sons uh during a battle and they held him captive and then they sent a
ransom to the to the soviet government and they said you know we have your
son these are our demands to let him go and apparently upon receiving the the ransom stalin
looked at it and he said my son's already dead and just left him didn't do anything so yeah
kind of fucked up you can justify a lot of fucked up things yeah um and there's a reading of that
where you could say well that was how noble of him right gave up his own son for the benefit of the
of the soviet republic right so it gets it gets murky and i guess to bring this back home to the
you know the whole point of this chapter is when is it okay to manipulate and when is it okay to
be manipulated and i think so far we have the publicity test is kind of one litmus test i think
this dirty hands test is i think it's less of a litmus test it's just something to be aware of
that like you're gonna have to live with right so it's like even if you find a way to justify
some manipulative behavior even if it's for the greater good even if it
legitimately is the right thing to do there's going to be this kind of persistent
disgust with yourself that you carry throughout your life right and so you have to be prepared
for that like that is part of the price that you have to be willing to pay i think well and we don't
have to be abraham lincoln or joseph stalin either right exactly to talk about this or to to think
about this because there's plenty of examples parenting it's going to be full of these kind
of things like how much do you actually let your kid in on what's going on and what's going on and
what's going on i i don't know about you but the older i get the more like family secrets come out
yes and i'm like holy shit this is fucked up right and i'm kind of like at first i'm indignant about
it right but the more i think about it the more like going through this episode too i'm like
actually i'm not sure if i would have wanted to know all of this as a little kid or even a teenager
or whatever and now that you know there's things coming out you know that i didn't know about
certain people in my family or something like that like extended family especially i'm just like yeah
i don't know i think about that now i think about how
my parents my grandparents they had to carry that right that had to eat at them to some degree and
i'm sure it did and i don't know what the right thing to do there was necessarily right it's funny
because i can relate a lot to that yeah there are a number of family secrets that became known to me
in my 30s and it's and it's interesting because i'm actually really glad i learned about them in
my 30s because i think if i learned about them as a teen or in my 20s i would have known about them
in my 20s uh it would have caused the shit storm i would have caused the shit you already pissed
off and angsty enough right and i had all sorts of baggage with people and yeah things would have
gotten very very ugly i think by the time i did learn about some things in my 30s i think i had
the maturity to realize like okay these things are secrets for a reason um and so i've i've
continued to hold those secrets and and bear those secrets um get my have my my hands dirty
right right and and i and i'm okay with that like it to me it's all the the stuff we talked about
in chapter one about how the the asymmetrical risk of losing relationships is just so much higher
than uh having a slightly uncomfortable but intact relationship with somebody that you love
and care about to even make this less dramatic you know let's like really let's like really try
to get this into the day-to-day i'll give you another example so
really good friend of of uh of mine recently got married and it was one of those situations where
his partner like we're kind of like really like her it's one of those situations where you see
a friend date somebody and you're like wow you could do a lot better than that it's not anybody's
place to say that right and you want them to be happy and if the if the relationship is a dumpster
fire and and the marriage is a disaster like you got to let them find that out themselves
my wife and i like we spent a lot of time with the couple and and we're like you kind of sit
there and you you just kind of put on a smile and you're like that's great guys we're so happy for
sure yeah yeah but it's meanwhile you it feels like you're watching like a you know a a car
careening off the off the highway with no driver and and you're like okay well i hope this turns
out all right but like saying something just feels so much worse like again that i think this is a
perfect example because in a kantian world you know kant's argument would be that you actually
have a duty to honestly voice your opinion and whereas a machiavellian world is like look what's
the cost benefit here right you're probably gonna fuck up a friendship complicate a happy couple
that is like very excited
to to be together um you're not going to really change anybody's minds but you're going to
introduce a lot of like pain and and strife into into a friendship so just shut up yeah and go
along with it there's there's also too like in that situation there's a high chance you know if
it does the the relationship does end yeah you'll still have a good relationship with your friend
yes and you can be there for him when right and when it does end whereas if you say something up
front it's like
you've kind of ended it right there and there's no rebounding or it's not going to be the same
yeah there's no good outcome there's not a good outcome it's like even if if even if even if that
that marriage falls apart like what what am i gonna do like what's gonna happen he's gonna
come back i'm gonna be like told you so you know like it's it it's gonna feel awful either way
well if your friend came to you and asked you directly though yes what do you think
yeah i i think this is kind of the missing piece of kant's framework which is that consent
certain perspectives and opinions is is is almost like necessary right like if you're gonna say
something that is potentially going to jeopardize a lot of relationships or different people's lives
like i don't think the onus is on you to be 100 honest all the time i think the onus is for you
to be honest when the situation presents itself that the person is is ready to hear it right like
if you're if you're going to say something that's true but the person who's receiving it is not going
to receive it well or doesn't want to receive it i think in many ways that's just as damaging as
not saying anything at all yeah well there's actually some research that actually kind of
drives right up with that too i love it when you back up my harebrained theories with research
true this is why you're here they they have found pro-social lies are there's like some
social glue to that right there's like uh it increases trust um even when the person knows
that you're lying for their own benefit they'll at least trust you more now they're not
probably going to trust what you say necessarily but they trust you more as a person they're like
okay this person is more trustworthy even if i can't fully trust what they're saying i know they
have good intentions at least and i can trust their intentions but you also made a really good
point there too this does split when it becomes more paternalistic and people feel like they
haven't consented to that that's when it does become a problem whether it was for their benefit
or not we just have this weird aversion not weird actually version it's just we have an aversion to
someone like blatantly manipulating us blatantly dominating us even too right and that's the so
they do find a split there um when the the kind of boundary that they've kind of found in a lot
of the research they've done and it's not like super uh set in stone type research but pro-social
lies do land when the honesty would cause pain without giving useful information like that's
makes sense it's just like you're you're just being mean to be mean or not even be you're just
being honest for honesty's sake right there's no end uh to it right there's no you see this a lot
with assholes yes like every
asshole you see this a lot with assholes yes like every asshole you see this a lot with assholes
just being honest i'm just being honest yeah just being on don't be mad at me i'm just being honest
it's like well yeah no you're it's it's like the line from the big lebowski right you're not wrong
walter you're just an asshole yeah exactly sometimes you can make the for their own good
defense right so it's for their own good well it's like well okay are they consenting to that
though in some way shape or form or it kind of goes back to a little bit at least to the publicity
test it's like okay i know you're kind of like shading something here to help me out and i
we're going to get into kind of sales and persuasion tactics yeah next chapter but i do
think a lot of this is tactical right there is an elegant way to tell somebody that they're bad at
something right and there's a very inelegant way to tell somebody like the example i have like
if your friend has a big nose and they ask you about it yeah you got a big nose but i don't care
right or another example this is something that i've a very small tactical thing that i've
implemented in my own life right it's like we've all we've all been in the situation where like we
make plans with someone and then we're like we're going to do something that's not going to work
with somebody and then it's like the day of and we're like god i really don't want to do this
and uh it and then you make up an excuse yeah to cancel yeah or not show up or whatever what i do
in those situations is i just i text the friend very plainly i'm like look not really feeling
up to it had a crazy day yeah didn't sleep well not feeling well not really feeling up to it but
i still really want to see you yeah yeah and are you available this weekend let me plan something
and that way it's
like reassuring them that like hey this is not about you this is about me i don't want to come
to your thing but i still like you and i want to see you and so like let me make this up to you
you know on a later day yeah that doesn't feel manipulative yeah it but it is but it is yeah
it's totally manipulative right right don't go anywhere we're going to take a short break
we've got a lot more coming this episode is brought to you by notion now it feels like i
don't think so i think ai will make talented people even more valuable and it'll just let
the machines handle the busy work so that the humans can focus on what humans do best
working together being creative trying to build something great notion sees it the same way and
that's why both of my companies run on notion notion is the ai workspace where your team's
knowledge projects and agents all come together in one place our entire production pipeline lives
there episode planning research meetings everything and we're going to be talking about
because it's all connected and ai has the context that it needs to answer questions instantly
and automate our busy work plus it adjusts to how we already work otherwise my team might
have mutinied by now teams using notion move faster cut friction and costs by consolidating
tools and stay aligned i respect that it's ai designed to strengthen teamwork not replace it
over 100 million people use notion and it's trusted by 95 of the top 50 ai companies including open ai
cursor and lovable so if you want your team thinking together and thinking together and
together better learn more about how notion can support your business at notion.com slash solved
that's all lowercase letters notion.com slash solved to try notion today and when you use our
link you're supporting the show this episode is brought to you by momentous now i'm usually pretty
skeptical of supplements every month there's a new something or other coming onto the market
promising to fix your hormones your gut and your relationship with your father creatine of course
is the rare exception it's one of the most researched supplements in the world and it's
supports everything from strength and lean muscle growth to recovery and even cognitive performance
i started taking creatine almost 10 years ago when i first started getting serious about working out
and now i bounce back faster after hard sessions and get a lot more out of my time at the gym but
once creatine got popular everyone and their dogs started selling it to you and it got hard to know
who to trust that's why i take momentous signature spec creatine it's one of the only creatines made
in a pharmaceutical facility with reverse osmosis which is the only one that's been made in a
water purification and then verified through a six-stage testing process with four independent
agencies that means 10 times fewer impurities two to five times tighter heavy metal limits
and screening for pfas and microplastics it's also an ultra fine powder so it disappears into
whatever you put it in if you've ever had to chew your creatine you know why that matters
and if i'm putting something into my body every day i want to know what's in it with momentous
i feel like i always do so if you want to try momentous signature spec creatine
head to live momentous.com and use the code solved for up to 35 off your entire first order
that's live momentous.com promo code solved for up to 35 off live momentous.com promo code solved
okay we're back with manipulation speaking of you know for a person's benefit i i think some of this
too gets into the definition of like what do you see is for your benefit right so let's say
somebody's like very insecure or worried about their health and they're like oh my god i'm going
to be worried about their job or their performance at something i'm the type of person that if i am
bad at something or something i do is bad i actually get pissed off if people try to tell
me it's good i've had many situations in my life where like friends and family have tried to be
supportive and tell me like you did a good job you like really put all your effort out that i'm like
it's under my skin too dude i'm like just tell me it sucks yeah like if you love me just fucking
tell me it sucks because at least i can learn and get better from it but it's interesting because a
not that way and and so i've ruffled a lot of feathers throughout my life by like being honest
with friends being like hey you know this thing could be better if you did this this and this and
they actually get really upset so again it comes back to the consent thing of like yeah there's
another thing i've seen like that's gotten spread around instagram and tiktok and stuff this is that
like um if a friend reaches out one of the most effective things you can do is ask them up front
um what are you looking for are you looking for a hug are you looking for somebody
to help solve a problem or are you looking for somebody to just hear you listen to you and
sometimes all we need is just somebody to like sit there and listen to our bullshit
yeah or a belly rub don't look for that belly rub uh not we're not there in the episode yet
we're not there next time i want to manipulate you i will give you a belly rub i will blackmail
you with belly rubs i shouldn't open this can of worms okay the last point i want to bring up in
this chapter is is the idea of power within relationships so there was a researcher in the
60s named richard emerson and he had this idea called power dependence theory and he made a
really interesting observation that power is not something that people bring to a relationship i
mean although like sir there are aspects of power that you can bring to a relationship but he said
that power is an inherent part of each relationship that each person in any relationship
has a certain amount of dependency on the other person whether it's emotional financial professional
whatever it is developmental like it's there's always mutual dependencies in any any given
relationship there are always things that we rely on other people uh for and then depending on the
balance of those dependencies you get a power dynamic within the relationship and now what
emerson noted is that relationships with large power imbalances would produce
more manipulative behavior within the relationship and it makes sense because if you are a person who
is without much power in a relationship the way for you to get what you want is to actually kind
of hide your own needs and then manipulate the person with more power to get things out of them
whereas if you are the person with the power in the relationship you don't really have a whole
lot to lose so you can kind of just state what you want and what you need plainly and the other
person is probably going to fall out of the relationship and you're not going to be able to
it's it's their incentive to fall in line and give you what you want and need so i actually think
power dependence theory is the is kind of the missing keystone that links the machiavelli side
of things with the kantian side of things like what kant missed is that okay yes you should always
be honest yes you should not deceive people yes you should always treat people as ends not as means
what he missed is that there are inherent power dynamics in human relationships and the problem
with the murder of a person is that they're not the same person they're not the same person
the murderer at the door is the murderer has all the power and the person at the door has none and
so in that dynamic you actually kind of have to manipulate the murderer it's like it is immoral
to not manipulate them for the greater good whereas machiavelli he's all about power dynamics
like the prince is just a a primer and guidebook to power dynamics how to manage them how to
maximize them how to navigate them i don't know if machiavelli missed it or if he just didn't really
talk about it a whole lot, is that if you are in a relationship where
power dynamics are roughly equal, both people are kind of bringing the same amount to the
relationship, it is in both person's interest to be as honest and virtuous as possible,
because that maximizes trust and that maximizes well-being and collaboration and all the other
good things that we've been talking about. Now, interestingly, some follow-up research has found
that power dynamics within human relationships, they generally are equal. Like one estimate had
it at 70 to 75% of relationships are generally equally powered. And so in most people's relationships
in most circumstances, it is in both people's interests to be honest, not deceitful, not
manipulative, to not overtly try to take advantage of the other person. And coming back to what we
talked about in chapter one about kind of the necessity of transactional relationships at times,
I think a lot of the relationships,
where there is a clear power dynamic, it is a very transactional relationship, right? It's like
you go to work, you have a boss, the boss is paying you money to do a thing, so you do a thing for the
boss. So there's still, it's still largely above the board. Where people get in the trouble is when
there is a very acute power dynamic between two people, and it is non-transactional, it's primarily
emotional. And this can happen within romantic relationships, obviously, it can happen within
family relationships. I think probably the most acute example of this is when you have a relationship
where there is a very acute power imbalance between two people, and that's where you get a
very different kind of moral duty on each person in that relationship. If there is an extreme power
imbalance between two people, I would argue that it is morally incumbent on the person with the
more power to behave in a virtuous way, to act in a way that protects the interest of the person
with the less power. Whereas I don't think you have that same moral weight on the person with
less power. I think it actually is rather important to have that same moral weight on the person with
less power. I think it's rational for the person with less power to be a little bit manipulative
and deceiving at times, simply for the fact of self-preservation. You know, we did an episode
on toxic relationships six months back or so. I think we talked a lot about power dynamics
in that episode, how almost the defining feature of a toxic relationship is a sense of a power
struggle between the two people. What was really interesting in the power dependency line of
research is that they found that in a lot of romantic relationships, both people felt like
they were the person with less power. They even found in one study, when they talked to men who
abused their partners, the men reported feeling powerless in the relationship and that they felt
driven, they felt justified in the violence because they felt like nothing else could help
them get what they needed or get what they wanted. Comes back to the most heinous shit is always
justified through some sort of moral, like I'm the victim. It's interesting in that you can have a
relationship where both people feel disempowered to the other. And like we talked about on that
episode, I think in many ways, the defining trait of a toxic, unhealthy relationship is that both
people feel uniquely disempowered in light of the other one. Right. Whereas the opposite might be
true too, where, because there is some, a lot of times there is a correlation, a direct correlation
between the person who is the victim and the person who is the victim. And so I think that's
where the power, each one feels right. Like what you're saying is, if I feel like I don't have a
whole lot of power, my partner probably feels like they don't have a lot of power too. The
converse is true too though, right? If I feel like I have a lot of power sometimes, then your other,
your partner can feel like they have a lot of power. I don't know. Can we, can we have a
relationship without a power struggle? This is kind of where we landed in the toxic relationships
episode is that the, almost the define, the definition of healthy intimacy is, is a lack
of power struggle, right? It's like kind of just surrendering to your partner and trusting them
to, to love you and treat you well. Right. I mean, every relationship, there's some sort of imbalance
or another. Yeah. Somewhere. Yeah. There's always somebody who makes a little bit more money and
somebody who's a little bit more emotionally intelligent and somebody who is better at
managing the household and somebody who's better at managing the finances. Everybody's going to be
better or worse at something. And so it is, you know, healthy relationship is just trusting that
those imbalances are going to even out in the long run.
And not hold those things, not keep a scorecard. I think where this really gets more problematic is,
is with parenting and kids, right? Because in a parenting relationship, there is a, also a severe
power imbalance. I would argue that it is rational and normal and even healthy in many ways for kids
to try to deceive their parents. It's almost a natural part of development is for kids to kind
of figure out how much they can get away with and you know, how many corners they can cut. And it's
like, you know, there's a lot of things that you can do and you can't do it that way. So it's like,
set a boundary and say, no, no, no, no, you can't do it that way. With adult romantic relationships,
there's always a little bit of a, he said, she said element to it, right? We got into this with
like Johnny Depp and Amber Heard and like kind of how you could look at both of their situations and
see very lots of trauma and lots of emotional dependency and power dynamics going in both
directions. Whereas like with a parent and a child, it's for the most part, the parent needs to be,
they have all the power.
So it is the moral duties on them to behave responsibly and to wield that power in a
responsible way to not take advantage of the child, not manipulate the child, treat the child
poorly, so on and so forth. The other thing I'll say about the power dynamics is that I think when
there are in power imbalances in human relationships, generally the person with the more power kind of
sets the precedent for the other person or for the other people. And I think this is largely what
leadership is, right? Is like good leadership is behaving in a way that the people who are
following you trust and respect what you're doing. And I think Machiavelli talks about this,
that it's like he talks about being loved is not a good in and of itself. It's instrumental in just
driving loyalty from people. But I think it's kind of in practical business advice and managing
advice. One of the things that gets talked about a lot is the leader of an organization kind of sets
how psychologically safe the group is for people to express ideas, to be themselves, to
pitch an idea that maybe gets shot down or that's wrong. You know, it's like, are people going to
get ridiculed for things? Are they going to get judged for things? Are they going to be ostracized
for not fitting in a certain way? And a lot of that hierarchical organizations, the leader sets the precedent.
Because of that power imbalance. Whereas I think in personal relationships, it's, it's a little bit
more of a give and take type situation. Yeah. When you are in those personal relationships,
a lot of us perception too, around power too, right? Because like in an organization is pretty
clear cut who has the power, who doesn't. When it gets into a relationship, it's a lot murkier
and we get these stories in our head, right? Like, oh, I'm the powerless one. And then that's where
the manipulative tactics can come into. Even if you have lower,
lower power, like you're talking about it, it's actually more common for you to be manipulative
in that situation. And so now you start saying, well, no, you have an obligation to make me feel
better in this situation in some way, shape or form. You're not that overt about it. Is there
any value to just like trying to just drop that story altogether and be like, look, I have this
imagined power imbalance that I'm operating from. Um, does that get you very far?
I think in personal relationships, you should go to great lengths to drop that. Yeah. Yeah. This whole
idea that there's a scorecard and that there's a tug of war happening. Like I forget who said it,
but there, there was, I saw a quote that was said the only way to win a status game is to quit
playing. God, that's so true. It's extremely true. Think of all the power that status game has over
you by playing. Right. And again, coming back to the parent child thing, I think it's, it's a
natural part of a child's development to feel the power struggle, right? It's like initially when
the child's very young, the parents have full power and control.
The child is very dependent. The child, the child pretty much goes along with whatever the parent
says or does. They get to adolescence. What do they do? They start testing the power dynamic,
right? They start pushing back. They start manipulating, they start cutting corners,
like, you know, deceiving a little bit. And a lot of that is a natural part of their
psychological development, not only to develop their own identity, but also to like push
boundaries and see what they can get away with and, uh, what they're capable of, of doing.
And what often happens is that power struggle, you know, especially if there's kind of an unhealthy
family dynamic, that power struggle perpetuates well into adulthood for the child. And so you get,
I mean, I know I struggled with this for a long time. It's very, very common. Like people
in their twenties, thirties, forties, they still have a lot of resentment and frustration and
like baggage and bullshit. You know, they go home for the holidays every year and it's like,
they're just butting heads with their mom or their dad or whatever it is. And a lot of times,
they're still in that power struggle. They're still seeing the relationship in terms of the
respect they're not getting or the approval that they never got or the type of relationship they
thought they should have always had, but they never, you know, the parent never showed up in
the way that they wanted. And it's funny because I've seen this at both in my own life. I've seen
it in my wife, uh, with her parents. I've seen it with a lot of friends at this point, you hit a
mom and dad, they weren't perfects.
they fuck some things up who cares like you just stop caring and it's funny because as soon as you
let it go everything gets so much better everything gets better and i think that parent-child
relationship it goes through a lot of different phases that gets very complicated whereas i think
when you're talking about like friendships and romantic relationships i think you should go to
whatever length possible to just not introduce any sort of power dynamic whatsoever yeah because
getting out of that power dynamic that sucks yeah it sucks and it happens i mean in romantic
relationships it gets really ugly emotionally but even friendships like there are a lot of
unhealthy friendships that are ultimately like two people kind of locked in a status game
and uh and yeah it gets it gets ugly and dramatic for for people to remove themselves and it's like
when you're in that status game when you're in that power game that's when you start justifying
all the manipulation to yourself you're like well i'm gonna lie to this person to get this thing
because i deserve it because they haven't treated me right right you start you create all those
stories for yourself and that justifies your bad behavior create stories around how i'm not getting
my needs met here and so i'm gonna act out in some way to get those needs met and right that's
justified now which is emerson's power dependence theory right and it's like he said that it's when
people feel out of power that's when they start becoming manipulative whereas when people feel
empowered in their relationship and they bring machiavelli back to them and they're like oh my
back into it and kant a very practical argument for treating people well is that if people feel
empowered they have no reason to manipulate you right speaking as an employer right it's like
if i empower you guys then hopefully you never feel a need to like lie to me or bullshit me
right because you know you can just come to me and tell me whatever you're thinking or
whatever idea you have uh whereas if somebody is wielding their power over you
and what like weaponizing it against you that's when you have to start justifying a lot of
shitty behavior okay yeah i think that ties up all of this really well actually yeah yeah this
is why i give you tummy rubs if only so you'll keep showing up for podcasts it's a very
transactional relationship oh it's consensual very consensual this is getting very weird
bring us home
oh god all right so so in chapter one we talked about how everybody manipulates it's just a
fundamental part of human social life manipulation is just it is inherent in our communication and
and how we approach the world for better or worse everybody's doing it all the time we're terrible
at detecting it it's really just a question of how much are you doing it and what is motivating
why you're doing it chapter two we've talked about the
ethical concerns around manipulation what makes it okay what makes it not okay what are what are
the different dynamics at play probably the the two most important principles from this chapter is
is one is the publicity test right it's like the way to know if manipulation is ethical is that if
everybody became aware of it they would probably approve of it um we talked about you know the
family secrets that after finding out being like okay yeah that should probably be a secret yeah
um or telling a good friend um you know supporting a good friend in a relationship
um that you don't think is really working out but you know if they found out that you were doing that
they would actually be happy that you were supporting their relationship despite believing
that it's not really going to work out the second key principle here is is the power dependency
theory of record of understanding how power dynamics partly dictate when manipulation can
be ethical and when it can be unethical we also talked about the traps and pitfalls of justifying
terrible behavior by rendering oneself powerless or believing oneself to be powerless um and how
also disempowering people promotes manipulative behavior um which i think is is just a lesson that
seems to be needed to be learned over and over again throughout history um and by every parent
around the world
so i think now that we've spent a couple hours kind of setting the table of explaining all of
the evolutionary and sociological reasons why we manipulate talking about the ethical concerns
around manipulation the organizational behavior around manipulation some of the political concerns
around manipulation so in chapter three we're getting into all of the nitty-gritty tactics
and principles of human persuasion and influence and i think this is something
that everybody should just know it's funny because a lot of the stuff that we're going to talk about
in the next chapter i learned when i studied sales and marketing but after learning it i'm like this
should just be taught in high school like everybody should know these things also most of what we've
talked about up until now has been about individuals and individual manipulators but what happens when
a lot of these tools of manipulation are scaled across entire societies what does that mean for us
hold that thought we will be right back after this
this episode is brought to you by our good friends at shopify now i've talked to a lot of people over
the years about their regrets all the things that they wish they did but they never did and no one
has ever told me man i wish i sat around and waited a few more years before i started that business
idea people do not regret starting they regret the waiting so while there's never a perfect time
to launch an online store right now is as good as there's ever gonna be black friday is only a few
weeks out and that's when more people are already in the buying business and they're already in the
mood which means that they could be buying things from you but mark a few weeks isn't enough time
says who getting a store up takes less time than you would guess and probably less time than you've
spent daydreaming about it in the shower now with shopify you pick a pre-built theme or let the ai
site builder put one together for you and you've got a store that looks legit without touching a
line of code now once you're set up shopify's mobile app lets you run the store from your phone
track inventory while wrapping presents handle payments from the airport or even answer customers
while watching the football game now if you're a shopify user and you're not a shopify user
now shopify makes it so easy there's no reason for that idea to die in your notes app if you're
ready to launch your business before black friday go to shopify.com slash solved to start your free
trial that's shopify.com slash solved go to shopify.com slash solve today to hear your first
this episode is brought to you by purpose it's funny we spend so much time worrying about being
manipulated by other people when most of the time we're actually manipulating ourselves we twist that
friend so that we come out the hero we tell ourselves that we'll write the book or start
the new exercise routine when things finally calm down as if things have ever been calm and sure
after this episode you'll probably notice yourself doing this more but your brain is very invested in
making you look good to yourself which means catching it in the act is nearly impossible
purpose is an ai mentor that will not let you get away with that crap chatbots like chat gbt
manipulate you into liking them they fawn over you and agree with you and you're not going to
with every passing thought purpose on the other hand is built to push back so when your version of
that fight starts to sound a little bit too flattering it will call you out and then give
you the next step to work on it so that it goes different next time over 98 of users have rated
purpose as either life-changing or helpful and it has a 4.9 rating on the app store because it's
pretty fucking awesome you can start for free today by going to mark.deals slash purpose that's
mark.deals slash purpose and we're back let's get right back to it
so the year is 1917 it's april and president woodrow wilson gets congress to declare war to
enter world war one in europe now this was highly unpopular at the time the u.s public was largely
against the war and ironically woodrow wilson ran on a campaign in 1916 bragging that he had
kept the u.s out of the war in europe but he changed his mind he declared war on the u.s.
troops were going to be sent abroad and his administration decided to organize something
called the u.s committee of public information which at the time had the explicit aim of
influencing public opinion to convince people to be more supportive of the war now it's important
to set some context here that back in the early 1900s marketing wasn't really a thing public
relations wasn't really understood in the way that we understand it if you ever go look back
at the history of advertising it's it's it's actually quite amusing if you look at advertisements
from the early 1900s or late 1800s it's all very factual and and like uh technical you know
functional yeah yeah it's like uh use crest toothpaste it is uh 3.8 percent more likely to
prevent cavities with your favorite dentist says and it's just like very bland it's like reading
an instruction manual explaining the features of whatever product
uh is being shown to you there was no concept or understanding of brand mood affiliation
pairing two experiences with one another tapping into people's concept of identity and class and
political views and all that so at the time a committee for public information i mean it was
really the initial goal was to basically just get lots of pamphlets and speeches out to convince
people rationally that the war was a good idea now there was a man on this committee named edward
bernays and bernays was
A little bit of a prodigy. He was incredibly insightful, had a deep understanding of human psychology, and was incredibly prolific during this period. And he was impressed with how well you could manipulate masses of people at scale through the use of information.
Now, the other thing that was really interesting about Edward Bernays is that he was Sigmund Freud's nephew. He had grown up spending summers with Uncle Siggy, as he called him. And so he was, at the time, Sigmund Freud, he was pretty well-renowned in Europe, but his ideas hadn't really permeated much in the United States. And they certainly had not been applied to any sort of commercial use by that point.
But Bernays had the brilliant insight to connect the psychological process.
He had the brilliant principles of Freudian psychoanalysis with the dissemination of information to masses of people to influence opinion and to convince them to maybe buy something that they normally wouldn't buy.
After the war ended, Bernays went off on his own and started what today we would call an advertising or a PR agency. Modern marketing and PR was very much invented by Bernays over the following 20 years.
Bernays went on to apply these psychological principles of influence and manipulation to some of the most successful marketing campaigns that had ever existed in the world up until that point.
So one of his first big successes was American Tobacco came to him in 1929, and they complained that women were not smoking enough cigarettes, that men were smoking cigarettes, but women, it was still seen as unladylike for her to smoke.
And they asked if he could change that.
And so through a series of brilliant publicity stunts, he. He attached smoking to the women's suffrage movement, which was a major political movement at the time, and made it politically fashionable and trendy for smart, educated women to be seen smoking cigarettes in public.
He kind of associated it with a form of political resistance.
This was the first time anything like this had ever been done, and it was massively successful.
The other thing he did around that time is a bacon company.
Money came to him wanting to sell more bacon, and so he did something that's really funny in hindsight, which is that he went out and surveyed 5,000 doctors, and guess what?
90% of those doctors agreed that bacon is the best breakfast for your health.
And so he started running advertisements saying 4,000 doctors have agreed that bacon is the best thing to have for breakfast.
Guess what?
Bacon became really popular for breakfast.
Over the next two to three decades, he had some of the most wildly successful. Advertising and marketing campaigns in the world.
He was the first person who came up with the idea to have celebrities endorse products.
He was the first person to invent the idea of an advertorial, so something that's sadly very common these days, which is that you basically go and pay a magazine to write an article about your product as if it's a piece of journalism, but really it's just kind of a very subtle form of advertising for that product.
He innovated the product concept.
And so he started a contest, so Ivory Soap wanted to appeal to more of a family market, so he created a contest where the kids who carve the best sculpture in their Ivory Soap bar would win a prize, and then that winning soap could be publicized across the country again, so he could almost actually double dip with that campaign.
You get the initial campaign, which is the announcement of the contest, and then you choose the winner of the contest, and then that becomes another newsworthy item to get the product advertised in thousands.
to turn Freud into a brilliant thinker in the US market.
There's a fantastic documentary
called The Century of the Self.
It's on YouTube for free.
It's a four-part series.
It's like four hours long.
It's so good.
But it's so good.
And I think it'll convince you that, yeah, Bernays is probably one of the most, if not
the most influential people of the 20th century, for sure.
For sure.
Even above Freud.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And definitely in terms of people who are not a household name, I would say he's definitely
the most influential person of the 20th century.
It is crazy.
I mean, even the stuff that we do today, we're going to talk about this in this chapter,
like a lot of these sales tactics marketing tactics things that we run on our social media
accounts things that we do on this show originated with bernays yeah yeah and his insights into into
human psychology and how to market to people yeah yeah the ironic thing he wasn't a personable guy
no that's probably why we don't know he wasn't very personal he wasn't very good with the public
himself but he understood the public very well and was able to manipulate them in a lot of ways
too. So yeah, he was not very likable. No, he wasn't. Um, his own daughter will tell you that.
Yeah. Yeah. Freud was also not very likable, but somehow he, he kind of survived, uh, I guess
just the, the nature of his genius, uh, kind of survived a little bit more intact.
Bernays was very unlikable. He was also kind of on the wrong side of history in a lot of ways.
He did write a book in 1928 called propaganda. Um, at the time, all of this stuff that we're
talking about publicity, marketing, advertising, it was all called propaganda and he was a huge
proponent of it. Like he actually believed it was a force for good in society. There's a quote from
his book where he said, the conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized
habits and opinions of the masses is a necessary part of democratic society. So he actually
believed that it was incumbent on the elites to manipulate the masses. Right. To shape public
opinion. To get them to do what was best for themselves. Right. He describes social engineering
as a public service and he called it the engineering of consent there he wrote a book
earlier too called the crystallization of public opinion i think as well and um that it was very
much she was just like no this is this is a good thing we have to use it for good we like we have
to shape this uh in a way that the elite can rule from a a noble place is the way he saw it a lot
of other people did not agree with that yeah yeah as we'll see and unfortunately some of the people
that were paying attention and taking notes on Bernays and his methods were the Nazis. And Joseph
Goebbels in particular was a huge fan of Bernays' work and applied a lot of these same principles
to craft and promote Nazi propaganda across Germany, which was unbelievably effective
when leveraged for political uses. A lot of governments have used a lot of this stuff
to manufacture a consent among the populations
to justify pretty heinous and terrible belief systems
and actions on behalf of the people.
Bernays, I'm not going to say he was a Nazi support.
He was Jewish, first of all.
It's not like he was out there waving a Nazi flag,
but there was a lot of, let's just call it sympathy.
He called it fascism light, right?
Or something like that.
He had a phrase, something like that.
he did he did call it fascism light where it was like you you apply this to market principles and
call it fascism light in service of the greater good right but he was he was appalled when he
found out the gerbils was a fan of his but at the same time too he was like you know he was not he
was not a nazi supporter but it was also like he didn't really have a problem with their propaganda
now i wanted to start with bernays for this section because i think if we're actually going
to study manipulation, I think the best place to study it is sales and marketing. Like when we went
into this episode, it wasn't obvious to me that we were going to talk about a lot of sales and
marketing concepts, but where human influence is practiced, optimized, mastered, it's around sales
and marketing because that's where it's most profitable. Salesmen and marketers have been
crafting a lot of these manipulative techniques. It's often referred to as persuasion, influence,
branding, publicity. But ultimately, what everybody is doing is they are trying to
manipulate you into perceiving a certain product or a certain person in a positive light
to engender a certain demand for it, create curiosity, intrigue. And so in those fields,
This literature is actually incredibly well-developed, and there are techniques and
practices that have been working for almost a century at this point. And I think it's actually
the best place to start to understand, okay, if you want to be persuasive, or if you want to
influence people, or if you want to manipulate people, this is what works. If I was to recommend
a single book for people to read around this, it would be Robert Cialdini's Influence. Anybody who
goes into any sorts of sales job, marketing job, advertising job. It is one of the first books that
it is one of the first books that you have to read.
And it's written by a professor named Robert Cialdini.
The origin of how he got into this research
is actually really funny,
which is when he was a struggling college student
and didn't have a whole lot of money.
he kept finding himself buying a bunch of crap from door-to-door salesmen that he didn't actually
want. And so he was like, barely had any money. Somebody knock on his door, start offering to
sell him a set of encyclopedias or something. And he'd say yes. And he'd like write a check and
hand over like the little bit of money he had in his bank account. And it reached a point after a
while that he was like, why do I keep doing this? Like, I don't want this stuff, but I keep saying
yes to these salespeople. How does this keep happening? So once he got to grad school, he
started studying this question. Like, how do you get people to yes? How do you get people to agree
to things that in many cases they don't actually want to do? What is it about a great salesperson
that convinces people to buy something, even if they initially didn't want to buy it?
Cialdini identified six principles of human influence or persuasion. We're going to start
with those six principles because they cover a lot of ground.
And then we'll get into some other kind of tactical or psychological tricks and things
that people use. You see a lot in sales tactics. As we go, we will see lots and lots and lots of
examples and applications of how this affects our day-to-day life and hopefully how we can
be more aware of all the many ways that we are influenced and manipulated by others.
So the first of Cialdini's six principles is reciprocity. And this is the classic case that
we're going to talk about today. If you go up to somebody and ask them for a favor, chances are they
might say no. But if you approach them with a gift and then ask them for a favor, they are far, far
more likely to say yes to whatever you ask for. So there are tons of experiments that did this.
They did this with students with Coke bottles. So they originally walked up to students and asked
them to buy raffle tickets. The majority of students said no. And then they started handing
out free bottles of Coke and then asked the students who had received the Coke if they wanted
to buy a raffle ticket. And then they started handing out free bottles of Coke and then asked
overwhelmingly the students started buying raffle tickets. You see this with waiters. There was a
study that found that waiters who left a mint or a piece of candy for customers got slightly larger
tips. You see this all the time at grocery stores with free samples in front of the aisles. They're
not doing that just because they're really, really nice. They're doing that because you are actually
much more likely to buy the products after you've tried the free sample. You see this everywhere.
You're creating a debt. They're creating a debt. That's what they're doing, a social debt. And
you're taking advantage of that little urge you have inside of you to repay that debt.
We talked last year on the friendship episode about the tit for tat evolutionary strategy.
Basically, for people who don't recall that episode, we are very much evolutionarily
predisposed to reciprocate to the people around us. So if somebody is nice to us,
we are more likely to be nice back. If somebody is mean to us, we're going to be mean back.
This is kind of our default setting of how we just approach all social interactions. There's a very
evolutionary explanation for it. If you want to nerd out really hard on that explanation,
go check out that episode. But yes, this is essentially the tit for tat strategy
being weaponized to sell shit. Yeah.
We watch out for this one. It was where the imbalance is. So it's never a one-to-one
reciprocity thing usually when it comes to sales and marketing, right? I went on an all-inclusive
trip one time to a resort and they gave, you got a free massage, right? Oh, great. Here's
a free massage. It turned into a six-hour pitch for basically like a timeshare.
More or less. And I had it turned into, it was like a $10,000 package or something like that for
an hour-long massage. The imbalance there is obvious. And so that's where it becomes
real manipulation, right? See, if they had offered you a belly rub,
then we would be doing this in your timeshare in Florida at the moment.
All they had to do is roll me over. That's right. That's right.
That's what she said. So there are ways to abuse this as well. You see in dating, people will just
bombard women with gifts, right? Just start buying them tons and tons of stuff. And there's
a really manipulative motive behind that, which is that the more stuff he buys you,
the more you're going to feel indebted to him to spend time with him, get intimate with him,
whatever it is. Or even just buying somebody a drink at a bar. Like now you have to talk to me.
Right. Yeah. Now you have to sit there for five minutes, right?
This is actually a way that cults recruit people. So cults will send people out
into the world and they will actually just walk around and give people gifts.
They'll give them flowers. They'll give them food. They'll give them all sorts of things
and then offer them to come to a free seminar to learn more about, you know, whatever, whatever,
whatever. When I was in university, we were right next to a Planned Parenthood clinic.
And sometimes there were a lot of like angry religious protesters outside of the clinic,
but other times there would be missionaries and they would stand out there and they would
actually hand out like free snacks, pamphlets, books,
books, copies of the Bible. And they were really friendly. They would like sit there and they'd be
like, Hey man, you want, you want like a, you know, a free popsicle? It'd be like a really hot
day. And I'd be like, yeah, sure. And then they'd be like, do you have a minute for Jesus? I'm like,
oh, fuck. It happened all the time on campus when I was going to college too. Yeah. Handing out free
stuff. Come sign this petition. Come to our church group. Come. Yeah. This happened all the time.
Again, that imbalance is what I always look for though. It's like, here's a little piece of candy.
Now give me, you know, two hours a week for the rest of your life.
Right. Yeah. Not going to happen. I ain't that cheap. Yeah. Yeah. The second principle is
commitment and consistency. So this one is really interesting. Uh, and, and, and you see this
happen a lot, especially around like political views. Basically, if people kind of publicly
take a stance or a position on something, if they are publicly seen doing something or supporting
something, they are going to be massively predisposed to continue to support or
do that thing. Basically, psychologically, we talked about this in the ego episode that like,
there's a, there's a fundamental psychological need for us to have a consistent view of ourselves
to not view ourselves in contradictory ways to, to kind of see ourselves as like,
you know, fundamentally about ABC and D. And of course you can manipulate this. So
one experiment that they did in the 1960s is they went around to homeowners and they asked them to
put a small sticker in their window, asking people to be a safe driver. And a
lot of people said yes to this. And then they went around and they asked people if they would
put these gigantic gaudy, ugly signs in their yards saying, please be a safe driver. Now,
when they just went to random people, the vast majority of people said, no, I don't want that
sign in my yard. But when they went to the people that they had already asked to put a sticker in
the window, the majority of them said, yeah, sure. Put the sign in the yard because they've
already got the sticker. So why not? You see this a lot in sales is kind of like, um, like an
organization, right? So what a lot of savvy salesmen will do is they won't immediately show
up and try to sell you the $10,000 package. They will show up and they will sell you the a hundred
dollar package and make it really enticing and exciting. And then you agree to the a hundred
dollar package. And they're like, well, while you're here, we've got this other exciting add
on for just $900 more. You could have the thousand dollar package and you can get this and this and
this and the other thing. And it turns out you're way more likely to take it. And then once you have
wait, there's more, we've got this super deluxe VIP package that is really only for exclusive
customers that only you happen to qualify for, for $10,000. And sure enough, you're far more
likely to take the package and sales. This is often called upselling. It's a classic in the
internet marketing space. We've done it in the past. Pretty much every online business does it
in some shape or form. If you immediately try to pitch somebody a $150 product, the conversion rate
you know, it'll be so, so kind of piss poor, but if you sell them a $20 product and then offer them
the $150 product, the conversion rate is so much higher because you're, you're trying to generate
that consistency. Oh, you're the type of person, especially with information products, right? And
like learning products, you're the type of person who wants to learn this and get better at this
and upskill at this, right? Well, if you're that type of person, then here's the one that's even
better. And they just, yeah, you could ride the escalator all the way up. Another interesting
example. I'm pretty sure this was in Chialdini's book. And he said one time, I think he said,
I think it was like an attractive woman came, was a door-to-door salesman, kind of attractive woman
started asking him questions, you know, like, oh, are you a, are you a fan of the arts? And he's
like, well, of course I am. You know, I'm a very cultured man. Very sophisticated. And he was like
a young broke guy, you know, whatever, where she was selling packages. I think it was for like a
orchestra or something like that. Right. And so first get them to say, yeah, I'm somebody who
is a fan of the arts and supports the arts. And now I'm going to say, oh, well then you wouldn't
mind buying this, this orchestra package that we have, you know, for a subscription to the orchestra.
Again, it's just like finding a way to make you stay consistent in what you're saying and doing
and thinking. Yeah. So this is weaponized a lot for political causes. So in California,
we have a lot of referendums, which is basically policies that are kind of pitched to the
population, the state population. And then we all vote in November, whether we want that to
become a law or not. In theory, it's great, right? More democracy is great, but in practice,
it gets abused and just misrepresented and manipulated all the time.
And so what I've noticed is like starting around this time of year, we're recording this in
October. We're about a month out from the election. Right now, almost every single day,
I'm getting something in the mail saying like, do you support affordable housing? And I'm like,
well, of course, who fucking does it? And then you open it up and it's like, vote for proposition,
whatever, whatever. And then you actually go to Google and Google the proposition and there's
all this shit in there that has nothing to do with affordable housing. They take something that is
likable and agreeable and then they like staple on whatever
you know whatever thing they actually wanted you to do off the back of that and so you kind of get
you know just strong-armed into doing it next principle this is a big one this is my favorite
social proof ah yeah people tend to value and pay attention to whatever other people value and pay
attention to it's such a simple principle but it applies to so many things in life it's basically
if you can make something appear popular in any way shape or form people are more likely to want
it they're more likely to listen to to a person this works on like even a minuscule scale like
hotels have found that sometimes when you go into a hotel a hotel room and in the bathroom they'll
have like a little card and it says like please reuse your towel or whatever what they found is
that if they change the copy on that card to say most guests reuse their towel people are actually
much more likely to buy it and they're more likely to buy it and they're more likely to buy it and
they're more likely to reuse their towel because it says most other guests are reusing their towels
as well so we tend to default to doing what the other people are doing around us or what we see
other people doing there was another fun experiment where they just had people go stand outside
beneath a skyscraper and stare up at the building and then they just stopped and watched to see how
many other people would stop and stare up at the building and for absolutely no reason whatsoever
and it turns out a lot of people did nightclubs they'll have a line going out the door
right i'll do that's all engineered i got stories man yeah first of all to everybody psa never spend
a dollar in a nightclub okay i was just gonna say mark has mark has plenty of experience about i i
let me get my soapbox out take it from me kids as a guy who spent way too much fucking time and
money in nightclubs for god's sake do not buy a vip table it is the biggest scam in the history
of scams you cross a rope and prices go up by yeah four or five times yeah one of my best friends
is a vip table and he's like i'm gonna buy a vip table and he's like i'm gonna buy a vip table and
uh in boston was a nightclub promoter and man he had such fucked up stories just as an experiment
he was kind of curious it was it was kind of a slower night and then the club wasn't full and
so what he did is he took one of the tables he moved it he pulled it out from the vip section
and kind of put it like right next to the dance floor and then just put four velvet ropes in a
square around that table and put a reserve sign on it it wasn't reserved there was nobody on it and
he said immediately guys started coming up to him
and asking if they could reserve it because it was like the prominence and the social proof and
this like manufactured demand for this non-existent thing just started driving people crazy and they
they wanted to pay tons and tons of money for it i mean obviously you see this with product reviews
you see this with social media likes and follows like the peer pressure of trying to get get
somebody to do something maybe they don't want to do you say like everybody's doing it man this is
like the coolest thing it's really hip right now it's really trendy we all just feel this kind of
role pull of like okay well i guess i should probably do that bernays was the first one to
kind of use the celebrity endorsement too so like the social proof around the status of the person
we'll get into authority here in a second but one area that i think is maybe problematic
these days maybe i want to get your take a little bit on this gambling sites you know
it's like especially in the u.s they've like gone nuts since the uh supreme court ruling like opened
it all up to states right and now you're seeing like lebron james promoting uh sports betting yeah
uh apps these business models are built on you losing money that's how they make predatory it's
it's it is predatory right and yet you have somebody like a lebron james or you know kevin
hart was big on those for a long time too what the hell some of these contracts are bigger than
like lebron james's contract so i've got a crazy story around this um so the the world cup this
past year the way world cup tv rights to work is that every every four years fifa goes to
each country and allows the tv networks in that country to bid on the contract for the world cup
so something crazy happened in brazil this last year the biggest twitch and youtube streamer in
brazil won the contract for the world cup i think he had 40 percent of the games he had rights to
broadcast them he he outbid all the major broadcasters in brazil he but he outbid like
yes all the all the network all all of them except for one there was a the main one down there is
called globo
i think they they they kept the finals and the semi-finals and everything and and like a lot of
the games but i think he ended up with like 35 40 of the games he was the only place you could go
to watch it tens of millions of people started watching this random brazilian streamer
to watch the world cup games and all of my friends down there they said it was
awful because the whole time all he did was promote sports betting and prop bets so so
through the whole game it was just him and his friends betting live on
stream about who was going to score the next goal or like who was going to get the next penalty
or whatever and they had qr codes up on the screen it's very clear that what happened is that the
sports betting sites went to him and they're like we will fund your bid for the world cup games and
and then he actually won like i can't even imagine how much money it required for him to get it it's
really fucked up and what's what was even more fucked up this drove me crazy because you know i
follow a lot of in kind of industry news
sites in our industry you know like the creator industries like podcasters youtubers whatnot
all of these news websites here in the u.s started running these big stories about this guy about how
like he had you know 15 million concurrent viewers brazilian streamers largest streamer in the world
like celebrating him and i'm like dude this is fucking corruption like it's just a sports
betting corruption this is especially true online some crazy post goes viral it has tens of millions
of views and there's this illusion of importance even though
it may not actually be important this is all social proof kind of being leveraged and manipulated
against us and then you bring it down even smaller scale to like reviews like amazon reviews and
stuff like that how much those have been manipulated um or fabricated or people get paid to do them you
know and they try to have checks around it and stuff like that but you know just reviews in
general on any site you used to be able to buy followers yeah right you don't really see it as
much nowadays because i think they've gotten really good at cracking down on it and i think
also just people are a little bit smarter
and and less gullible around stuff like that i can't tell you how many how many messages and
dms i've gotten from people with 10 million followers but like zero engagement on their
account asking me to like come on their show or you know do a collaboration with them or something
and i'm like uh i'm pretty sure that they're trying to leverage that social proof look how
many followers are i'm pretty sure it's a bunch of bots so next one very similar to social proof
is authority so we instinctually defer to people that we perceive as
experts or people who have status people have titles uniforms credentials there's a set of
famous studies from the 1970s called the milgram experiments that tested this to some kind of
horrifying results where they brought people in and had them sit across through through a one-sided
window looking at another person the person on the other side was supposed to answer questions
and each time the person on the other side got a question wrong the person administering the
question was supposed to press a button which would electrocute them and everything was staged
it was all set up the person sitting on the other side of the window was like just another researcher
they were kind of a decoy but the test was to see how often and to what extent each uh subject was
willing to electrocute another person simply because like a scientist with a clipboard was
telling them to and it turns out a lot more than you would like yes yeah like a vast majority of
them even too vast majority of them did it and a lot of them did it to the point where they were
to an extent that like is morally concerning right a lot of scams these days operate on this too you
know they're calling from like the irs if in the u.s or social security or something like that and
you're automatically like oh no it's this big scary bureaucracy that's going to come down on me
and take all my money if they want to or anything like that scam artists will take advantage of that
i've had people in my family actually fall really yeah happens in art industry a lot too um won't
name names but there's you know there's a lot of people who have you know credentials behind their
we've went and fact checked some of them and right that's not no yeah that isn't quite what's
happening here what are you doing i mean we do it to a certain i mean obviously we try to stick to
the data and actually dig into the research and everything but i mean there are times where we're
just like like oh this really smart guy said this thing and you know and we just kind of you go with
it yeah go with it yeah and i think one way to look at all these things that these these are
heuristics for us to manage large quantities of information and make decisions that are usually
going to be correct but not always correct right so
like social proof it makes sense that we evolved a mechanism to be influenced by by the crowd right
because it's generally not always but generally if a bunch of people are running in one direction
yeah probably shouldn't ask questions you should probably run with them more often than not more
often than not yeah uh similarly it's like if somebody has spent their life working on something
developing mastery over something or developing expertise over something and they have the
ability to do that they should probably just listen to them like they probably do know what
they're talking about obviously they don't always know what they're talking about and there are very
notable exceptions where they abuse their authority or abuse the the trust that people put in them but
the whole system of credentials that we've built society upon it exists for a reason it is so that
we can make these quick judgments without having to actually like go fact check every single thing
every person says i like nassim taleb's kind of rule of thumb on this though
to the skin in the game that book he wrote about that where it's like i'm gonna pay more attention
to an expert who actually has some skin in the game like a plumber okay who's been around for a
while i'm gonna trust him yeah his expert opinion on something where it's like you know an economist
or something like that has some crazy theory i don't care if he's at harvard or anything like
that does his paycheck depend on him being right or wrong or is he just throwing out ideas right
that i think is a good heuristic around authority where it's like okay yes this person's a person of
authority do i blindly trust them well if they have a lot of skin in the game more likely that
you can trust that are they just a guy in an ivory tower you know who's never not not to say
that those people don't have something to say like i said you know they there are genuinely
academic experts who you know do have something to contribute i'm just saying the closer they are to
to where the rubber hits the road on on their own theories or yeah or job the more dependable
more dependable you can probably uh rely on them yeah i thought i just had kind of going through
this yeah i would argue that the internet is very much undermining or disrupting our usual
associations with authority yeah right today at least in our lifetime today and probably
definitely in the most like at least the last hundred years i think people are more skeptical
of experts and authorities today than any other time before uh at least in recent history and
similarly i think people are more skeptical of social proof today like if you think back to the
1950s or 1960s it was very much like you go go with the crowd i mean a lot of the problems in
history emerged because everybody kind of just blindly went with the crowd whereas i think today
we almost have the opposite problem which is that people are instinctually skeptical of the crowd
all the time and they're constantly questioning the prevailing ethos or belief system is um and
they're constantly questioning like what the authorities are saying and it's understandable
because i think we are more aware than ever before of like the flaws and mistakes of experts and
authorities and different organizations
and social institutions and whatnot but at the same time like you can't just fact check everything
all the time like we at some point we have to trust some people and just go with it and then
i would say on the flip side i would say the internet has amplified commitment and consistency
because everything everybody does now is so potentially public i think people have gotten
a lot more rigid and yeah and like the stances that they take you said this 15 years ago
you know right what are you going to go back on that now i mean how many people
at this point have been canceled for like something they tweeted in high school like it's it's getting
ridiculous and then i would say reciprocity i think is also gaining an influence and strength
with the internet you're just seeing seeing that with with stuff like this podcast right like if you
just give value to people freely they will they will trust you and they will they will follow you
right whereas if if you just kind of stand up and wave your degree around your phd around they're
going to be a little bit more skeptical right off the bat principle number five is really basic
liking are you likable are you charming are you interesting are you engaging do they find you
friendly i actually think a lot of liking comes down to relatability cialdini like he did a he
did another book maybe about 10 years ago called persuasion and then he tried to argue that there's
a seventh uh principle called unity which i think strikes me as very much kind of captured by the
just how tribal people are being and how in group versus out group people are identity based yeah
yeah i just think people tend to like people that are like them there's tons and tons of research
that backs this up we tend to like people who look like us people who came from the same place
we came from people who do the same things that we do people who like the same things that we like
we are just predisposed to like those people because we relate to them it's easy for us to
there isn't a severe power imbalance like if you're if you don't wield a bunch of authority
over people you're probably better off influencing with the carrot and not the stick appearing
generous and magnanimous and supportive right and like you again coming back to the reciprocity
and then the last one and this one is huge in sales and marketing is scarcity we tend to value
things that seem rare or seem to be disappearing i could spend the rest of the podcast on this
giving examples of manufactured scarcity um you know every countdown timer on every sales page
is manufactured refresh the page see what happens right you know limited time only um you know only
while supplies last like there's just so scarcity is such a powerful lever in in sales and it's
pretty easy to manufacture it is play a little countdown timer you know oh you get to do this
you can make anything up and you i feel it's not i'll be on a website i'm like oh my god
i gotta book this and it's and i will say this as somebody who again i consider myself somewhat
of a kantian and i i try to be as like honest and upfront with my audience as as much as possible
and i try to sell in a way that feels like very ethical and and uh and aligned with my values
it is so fucking upsetting how well manufactured scarcity works like it is it is like literally
if you just go on the same web page and like add one line that says offer a
expires in three days it's like your sales double and it's really upsetting i remember we actually
did this for the subtle art a little bit but it was actually i would say pretty ethical the way
you did it because there was an actual scarcity around it where i think it was like you know the
first 100 people to pre-order the book or something like that right we had certain levels that we did
your haikus for some people are like i can only write so many so we're gonna limit this to 100
people or whatever it was right right or you know i can only give out so much of this one thing that
we have yeah
it's gonna cost me too much if we have more so there was like but we were generating scarcity
around it i mean it was actual scarcity though that we that we were generating for the most
i forgot about the haikus remember the haikus so for people listening there was like i we ran this
this offer when subtle art came out that i think if you pre-ordered i think it was like 10 or 20
copies i would write a personal haiku for you and that's what i said so i ended up writing
probably around like 20 25 haikus it's some of them like especially once i like got you know
15 deep they started getting really weird like i just started
kind of just going with whatever my first impulse was and so there was some really
fucked up stuff and i think some of the people i sent the haiku to like they were actually really
disappointed because i said because some of them were so weird and and just like awkward
shout out if anybody's got one of those haikus oh yeah that would be good send them in i would
love to see them again that'd be a ton of fun so scarcity is also something that i think gets
weaponized in human relationships as well one of the most common ways to manipulate somebody is
well i'm only
going to be around for another day so you better do it while i'm still here or just playing hard
to get yeah exactly it's like well i'm so busy this weekend so you know unless you reply by
tomorrow like i don't know when i'm going to see you again it's kind of this game playing that that
happens a lot you could even argue that no showing or ghosting people is kind of like a form of
manufactured scarcity um or constantly canceling on people like it is that playing hard to get or
like pulling away from people and it's kind of like a form of manufactured scarcity um or
at the precise time that like the the person is going to like you know want you to come back even
more i also think there's an inverse of scarcity that's really interesting which is the abundance
of something makes it feel less meaningful and i mean we've had a lot of episodes where we talked
about how it's the abundance of opportunities and options in modern life is part of our problem
sometimes i think part of the reason people don't take news nearly as seriously these days as they
used to is there's just so much of it
right it's like you have so many stations that are trying to fill 24 hours new news cycles
they are posting constantly all day every day online and so it's inevitable that the average
value of each story that they are broadcasting is is going to decline drastically and so if the
average value of the average story is extremely low at some point people just start tuning out
and they're like well most of this shit doesn't matter so like why am i listening or paying
attention in the first place it's almost like i'm just like i'm just like i'm just like i'm just like
news media became too plentiful and so it started to kind of become absurd and and i also think
that's when it started to become like very politically motivated if there's only so many
useful things to cover um but you need to fill 24 hours a day you might as well fill it with
propaganda yeah it was when the cost of distributing information went down so quickly
and easily so now it's like it's just cheaper to have some pundit on there giving his opinion
you know 24 hours a day instead of somebody doing deep investigative journalism and so when that gets
flooded with just the the opinion pieces right that drives the cost or the price of everything
else down with it and it becomes cheap and everybody wants it i thought about this with
this podcast too like you know we've experimented with doing two two episodes a month three episodes
a month and it's funny because like i do think there is something special about making people
wait a month yeah for a new episode i mean first of all these are long as fuck and it takes people
a long time to get through them but i don't think it's going to be a long time to get through them
i just feel like if we are blasting people like three times a week it all just starts to feel
interchangeable and it doesn't feel like an event it doesn't feel special or unique you know like i
what i hope for for this for the audience is that the first week of every month like a you know
solve dropping is kind of an event like you you see it pop up in your feed and you're just like
oh hell yeah it's that time of the month again yeah i've stopped listening to podcasts or
watch tv shows or whatever that you know went from once a week to three times a week
week or every single day.
Yeah, you could kind of desensitize to it.
To a certain extent. So I have a few more concepts here that are not, they're not Cialdini's, but these are common concepts. Some of these come from cognitive biases. Some of these come from sales tactics. Some of them are just kind of fundamental psychological principles. But I think they're interesting because you do see them show up a lot when people are kind of manipulating each other, trying to get something out of each other.
So the first one is anchoring. This is a sales tactic, but I think it also applies to daily life. Actually, Cialdini talks about this in Influence as well. In sales negotiations, anchoring is really simple. It's like, if I am willing to sell you something for $1,000, I might initially ask for $3,000. And you're like, $3,000, that's absurd. Oh my God. When we settle on $1,000, that's going to feel like a very reasonable compromise to you. Whereas if I just showed up and asked for $1,000, it might feel like a lot.
So anchoring, it's generally like whatever number is said first kind of sets the frame for the rest of the negotiation. So you can be very tactical in terms of like what you lead with to make where you land seem more appealing than maybe it actually is. This can work the other way around as well. And in other ways, like, so we talked earlier about the consistency thing. Like if you get somebody to commit to something small, they're much more likely to commit to something large.
Why do you think there's three tiers for everything?
It's like, oh, they've got this real expensive option over here. You've got this real cheap one over here. This one in the middle looks just about right though, doesn't it?
So those three options are, they are designed in a very specific way so that the expensive one looks a little bit overpriced. The cheap one looks like you're not getting a whole lot. So the middle one looks perfect. And you're like, wow, that's a lot of value for a reasonable price, you know? And it's like, they've studied these things, they've tested it a million times, and they're absolutely locked in on what price that should be.
You can do this with people as well, right? Like it's if you want somebody to do a favor for you, you can show up and ask for a huge favor, and then kind of back down and ask for something simple.
But then when he followed it up with, well, would you take some of these kids to the zoo for a day? Way more people agreed to do it because it seems so less by comparison than the initial ask.
Yeah, your brain is a comparison machine.
It is.
The framing sets, there's an anchoring to the framing that can be set very easily.
This kind of leads into another tactic in general, which is just the concept of framing itself, right? Like you can frame a problem or a story.
And so many different ways to kind of dictate what the narrative is around it.
It actually took me a while to figure this out when I was younger.
But, you know, so there were so many criticisms about news media being dishonest.
But then it's like I would actually go like read an article or like watch a segment.
And I'm like, well, that is like factually correct.
But then what I didn't realize is that they're framing the facts in a certain narrative.
They start with a bunch of assumptions that are actually questionable, but they take them to be true.
And then they present a bunch of facts in the context of those assumptions.
So I remember in the 2000s, like when the Iraq war started, you know, you would see a news story that would say, you know, weapons of mass destruction were like existential threat to the United States.
And they would walk through like all sorts of data about how awful Saddam Hussein was and how he gassed his own people and like all the stores of weapons that he had and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
And like if this got into the hands of terrorists that all these are in, like, it all seems very rational and reasonable.
Until you realize that there are no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, right?
Like they never found anything.
It was never there.
It turns out that the intelligence that everything was based on was made up by a guy for political purposes.
You wouldn't notice that if like if you just saw that news story in a vacuum, you would just assume like, oh, yeah, this is a terrible thing.
Like we should probably go invade Iraq.
But the framing of it led the viewer, the reader into a certain conclusion.
You see this happen on both sides of the spectrum.
You can see the exact same story.
There's actually some really cool news services now these days that will actually go find the same news story on both the right and the left and present them side by side.
It's fascinating.
So that you can actually evaluate the framing that they are doing in real time and kind of make a judgment for yourself.
Some of the stories you'll see, too, and I'm making this up, but like, you know, say there were 500 people in a building and, you know, it got bombed or something like that.
And like 100 people died.
One side might say, oh, you know.
A hundred people killed from this.
And then the other side might say 400 people saved from.
Yes.
Right.
Factually true on both sides.
Right.
But it just depends on who who sent the bomb.
Another thing that you see in news and politics all the time.
And this kind of comes back to to Bernays and kind of manufacturing consent is a concept known as the exposure effect.
So in psychology, what they find is that whether true or not, the more you're exposed to a piece of information, the more likely you are to believe it.
And so if something is repeated over and over and over and over again, you unconsciously just start assuming that it's true.
And you just kind of take it as a plain assumption.
I think this is particularly problematic in the social media age because it is so easy to repeat very incorrect things over and over and over again.
There's a lot of evidence that, you know, Russia and China have broadcast a lot of kind of politically contentious ideas on U.S. social networks, repeated them tens of thousands of times.
And I think it's they're taking advantage of the exposure effect where it's like.
Even if you don't agree with something, if you hear it enough times, you just kind of start assuming that, OK, well, that's what everybody thinks.
And it's almost like working the same way social proof works.
But instead of seeing a crowd of people, you it's almost like you're seeing the same message, a crowd of times over a period of time, if that makes sense.
Yeah.
Well, if I mean, if you hear it so many times and you don't hear any counter argument to it, then, of course, it must be true.
You see this in nutrition all the time, right?
Like, you know, butter's bad one week or it's not the next, you know.
Because it gets repeated for so long.
It's interesting you bring up nutrition because it's nutrition is a classic example of of just rife manipulation, public manipulation at the hands of different food companies, even various academics.
Governments to governments.
Yeah, probably 10 or 20 years ago.
So there was like a single researcher at the University of Minnesota who he was kind of behind all the quote unquote research that fat was bad for you.
It came out after he passed away and then it came out later.
That like he had taken all this funding from like all the different cereal companies and grain companies and had like basically bullshit and a lot of his research and a lot of a lot of the dietary guidelines that you and I grew up with and the schools that you and I went to when we were kids based their their school meals on were based on this guy's bullshit research because, you know, company paid him a bunch of money.
So there's another one here called projection, which is basically accusing somebody.
Of doing the bad thing that you're doing, right?
It's like I'm not lying.
You're lying.
I'm not selfish.
You're selfish, right?
And it's it's kind of this verbal maneuver to put the accuser on the defensive and make it seem like actually they're the problem.
It's a form of gaslighting, right?
It's like taking somebody who's like upset about something that maybe is legitimate and then trying to convince them that actually they're the problem in the first place.
So if you can kind of like twist things around and make it seem like they're actually the problem and you're the one who's being victimized.
This comes back to.
Just, you know, be wary of people who leverage victimization as as a weapon because it can be used as a weapon and it can be used to justify a lot of terrible shit not to compare everything to Hitler, but Hitler very famously.
I mean, they called it I think I believe even internally they called it the big lie, which is that basically all of the stuff that they were doing they accused the Jews of doing and they used it as a justification to do all the awful shit that they were doing to the Jews, right?
So it's like they weren't rounding up and putting Jews into pogroms.
It's.
Like, well, the Jews have been stealing our businesses and pushing us into into poor neighborhoods for the last century.
It's it's a we're just doing it back to them, right?
And it's like everything you want to do.
You accuse your opponent of doing first because then that justifies and opens up the way for you to do it.
A couple other little things.
There's a thing called the because effect.
I love this example from influence.
One of the things that chill DD found was that's really funny is that if you ask somebody for something and you give them a reason.
It doesn't even matter if the reason makes sense.
They're more likely to give it to you.
And so I remember in the experiment that he did.
There was a photocopier line at the library with a bunch of people in it.
And he as an experiment.
He had students walk up and ask if they could cut in line.
And of course majority of the time people were like, no go to the back.
But if students walked up and asked to cut in line and gave a reason no matter what the reason was people were very likely to say yes.
And in some cases the students gave completely non-sense.
Sensical reasons initially they would walk up and say like oh I'm sorry I'm really in a hurry can I get in front of you in line and people be like yeah sure no problem but then later students would walk up and they'd be like I've got to send this to my dad can I get in front of you in line and people be like yeah sure right like it just makes no sense but it just kind of short circuits our brain a little bit another thing that's really fun is that they found that if you ask somebody for something and then you say but feel free not to do it they're more likely to do it because you're like acknowledging their agency and then a lot of times.
Last thing I want to touch on which is kind of a tactic that relates to the consistency piece is that if if you want to get somebody to do something if you label them as the type of person that does that they're more.
likely to do it let's say i want you to come over and and make dinner for me you know i'll be like
you know drew you're such a good cook and a really good friend like why don't you come over and make
dinner tonight like you're way more likely to say yes if i if i kind of preempt it with something
like that or like you know you're always helping me out man can i get a ride home you're you're
kind of setting the expectation in the person's mind and creating that desire for consistency
within them i was getting some quotes uh for some work done in my house had some people come
and they were using this tactic big time so it was going to be some exterior work i was going
to have them do i was just trying to get quotes for it of course they come in they got this long
pitch and they just start pointing out oh i love this about your house the interior of your house
it's got to match the the implication was it's got to match the exterior too look the interior
is so great and they were real specific with their compliments too i had two or three people
two or three different companies come in they all did this every single one of them did it i've seen
this with design
over the years is like the yeah they'll come in and they'll they're like every single one of them
says the same thing they're like wow i love your taste your taste yeah you have such good taste
right which was like the implication is if they can see that i have good taste then they must
have good taste too and then of course they're they're likable it's reciprocity it's all sorts
of things so it is really funny you know when i was younger i thought sales tactics were a little
bit sleazy and scummy again as i get older and i just kind of recognize that a lot of the world
is transactional and that's just kind of unavoidable i almost i
almost have this like sick appreciation for like a really good sales tactic you know like sometimes
if i walk into a store or something or i talk to a contractor or something and like they're just a
great salesperson i actually really admire it i'm like it's like pleasant for me you know to be sold
a good sales letter too oh man oh yeah i know exactly what they're doing sometimes i'm like
that's fantastic and sign me up get me all hot and bothered for real yeah we could keep going
and going and i mean there's there's still so many manipulation tactics
and influence tactics there's intermittent reinforcement love bombing trauma bonding
darvo there's so many levers that you can pull if people want to get access to more of them you
can check out the guide go to solvepodcast.com slash manipulation um there's a lot more detail
there but for now we're going to move on to chapter four because at this point now that we've established
how manipulation happens what are the kind of the psychological levers that we're pulling in each
of what we want out of each other the next question is logically how do we defend ourselves
can we defend ourselves right we just talked about how we both kind of admire a really good
salesperson even though we really know what they're doing and we like completely understand
how we're being manipulated and it's interesting because a lot of the research around this stuff
it shows that being aware of it doesn't really change the effect a whole lot like you're still
you're still just as likely to do a lot of these things
even if you're aware that they're being wielded against you so in the next section we're going to
talk about how you can arm yourself become more aware of the ways that you're being influenced
and manipulated how you can defend yourself when necessary or at least be on an even playing field
with your manipulators so stick around we'll be right back
i hate to be the one to tell you but if you trust nobody then you are the easiest person to
manipulate in the room
after everything that we have described in this episode you would think that it would be logical
to distrust everything don't trust an authority always pay attention to the motive behind
everything people are saying to you question everything you see walk the opposite direction
of every crowd but it turns out that doesn't really work and in fact it actually just makes
the problem even worse the simple reason for this is that if you don't trust anything then you don't
have anything to fall back on when somebody tries to take advantage of you like if you believe
everything you see is the opposite of what you see then you're not going to be able to
change anything you see so if every institution is lying then you are just going to be more
susceptible when a charming engaging person comes along and says oh trust me they're all lying to
you but i'm the one who's going to tell the truth so instead of trusting no one the challenge is to
trust better to have a higher threshold or a better filter for what you go along with and what
you reject it's a healthy sense of skepticism that keeps you connected to multiple people and
multiple groups which means that you're not going to be able to trust anyone and you're not going to
be able to trust anyone and you're not going to be able to trust anyone and you're not going to
ever allowing yourself to be completely isolated so after three chapters of this one response
feels tempting but it actually backfires which is to trust nothing the ads are engineered the news
is pre-selected the science is bent your own introspection is just other people's messaging
so why believe anybody why follow anything why why trust in anyone not only does this make you
more susceptible to manipulation but it also makes you more susceptible to manipulation
it actually just makes you miserable because trust is the bedrock of any relationship to have any
healthy intimacy or connection to anybody else or to any group you have to trust and believe in that
person or in that group and so if you trust and believe in nobody then you will feel profoundly
alone and when you're profoundly alone you actually become more gullible and more susceptible to people
trying to take advantage of you on top of this chronically distrusting everything and everyone
is fucking exactly what you're doing you're not going to be able to trust anyone and you're not
exhausting it's tiring if you have to look into every claim check every popular notion
look for the conspiracy theory behind every major political movement or every
social cause you're going to be spending all day for the rest of your life looking into the nooks
and crannies of the internet assuming the worst about everyone and so the first thing to understand
is that while it is good to be skeptical and it is good to understand that you are inevitably
going to be manipulated and influenced by all sorts of different people and groups it's okay
like this is just part of life the key is not to get rid of all manipulation in your life
the key is to simply protect yourself from the most damaging manipulation in your life what i'm
saying is that if you try to get rid of all manipulation in your life you are ironically
making yourself more susceptible to the most damaging kind yeah and it's it's not just about
being smarter too right it's not about
being skeptical it's not about being even smarter we already alluded to this uh once before but
smarter people are usually better at convincing themselves of their own bullshit and therefore
can be just as easily manipulated if not more so yes right yes educating yourself through stuff
like this sure that helps to some degree but it's not going to completely protect you nor
is it necessarily always going to be all that effective right just one example i came across
this guy dan kahan he um has this motivated numeracy experiments that he ran
basically people who are like really good with math and numbers and running statistics and all
of this he would give them um situations he first he would figure out their politics basically then
give them situations like okay whatever they were about some politically motivated campaign or
whatever give them the numbers around it they were really bad if it was a an argument that ran
counter to their politics but they were really good if it ran in line with their politics right
so there's just some motivated reasoning going around there even with experts who are really
good with numbers and everything like that
being smarter does not help you with this necessarily right being smarter in a specific
way that we'll talk about here in a second does so it's not about being purely skeptical
or purely smart and having just all the information and knowing all the facts about all of this and
being able to protect yourself against every single little manipulation that happens like
you're saying that's not what it's about at all right because in fact the more skeptical and the
smarter you are sometimes the easier you are to con actually it's because you're more sure that
a con is happening you're like no i'm a very skeptical person i'm a very smart person this
could never happen to me right yeah and then that's exactly when it can happen to you and
actually um you could just end up constructing better justifications for why this isn't a con
because obviously i would be able to see it if i couldn't yeah it's interesting there's and if you
look at the the the literature on fraud um there are certain classes of fraud particularly like
investment fraud um that the victims skew much more educated so basically it's like the smarter
and more educated people are the ones who are more educated and the more educated people are the
the people are the more likely they are to buy into certain schemes and part of it is i think
because if the scheme is complex then the smart person feels like because they can understand the
complexity uh it must be true whereas like a dumb person might look at it and be like well that's
really complicated i'm not going to invest in that right i look at crypto right like this is one
thing i sadly was involved with crypto for a number of years and it was funny because this is one of
my favorite things to do in the crypto world was so smart like they had such a strong understanding
of technology finance markets cryptography um lots of like very interesting perspectives on
government and privacy and industry and how ai is going to evolve and all these things like
some of the conversations i would have with crypto people were just so fucking intelligent i mean a
very large percentage of that space is just a gigantic pump and dump scheme right it's like
it's a lot of it has turned out to be a lot of it has turned out to be a lot of it has turned out to
be either fraudulent or just kind of a fancy form of gambling um or just a you know bunch of
shit coins there is a certain flavor of bullshit that involves a certain amount of technical
complexity and instrumentation that i think especially appeals to smart people yeah yeah
the 2008 financial crisis was full of this bernie madoff his yes the victims those were very smart
educated very rich people yeah that he that he ripped off yes yeah
so the goal is don't necessarily become skeptical of everything don't try to be smarter or more
informed about everything. Both of those things are kind of unrealistic proposals. So it raises
the question, how do you inoculate yourself to the worst forms of manipulation? How do you make sure
you're not being just completely bamboozled in the making terrible decisions or going along with
horrible causes? So the answer actually comes from a really interesting place. So back in the 1950s,
when the Korean War ended, a bunch of prisoners were exchanged and they came home. And so it was
the first time ever that American soldiers had been captured and stayed within a communist country
or a communist prison. And interestingly, a lot of the prisoners came back communist. They'd come
back kind of suddenly believing all the political beliefs of China and North Korea. And at the time,
this kind of freaked out. I mean, this was during the Red Scare. It freaked out.
Congress, it freaked out the whole public and especially freaked out the CIA. This idea of
brainwashing became very popular and prevalent for a period of time. And there are all sorts of
controversial experiments that took place over this period that looked at how do you brainwash
somebody and then also do how do you inoculate people from being brainwashed? Now, during this
line of research, there was a psychologist named William McGuire, who took a slightly different
approach to the same question.
The CIA and most psychologists were asking, how is it that these soldiers were overwhelmed and
overpowered and brainwashed with this ideology? McGuire looked at it and said, well, why were
these soldiers kind of so susceptible in the first place? Instead of looking at what the North Korean
Army did or the Chinese Army did, why don't we look at these soldiers' background and maybe
there's a commonality that made them more susceptible to these beliefs than the many,
many prisoners who came home.
Not being brainwashed. And so he started looking into this. And his initial hypothesis was that it
was medical, that there was some sort of like neurological trait or mental trait that these
soldiers had in common. But it turned out it wasn't. It turned out that the commonality that
he found was that all of the brainwashed soldiers were raised in what he called an aseptic ideological
environment, which is basically like they were really coddled. They had never been exposed to
anything ever before.
They were very naive. They had never come into contact with opposing viewpoints, different
ideologies. They didn't know anything about history or geopolitics or the world order or
anything like that. They were just kind of these like naive 18-year-olds who had never done anything
or never been anywhere. And this actually implies something really important, which is that you don't
protect your beliefs by reinforcing your beliefs. You protect your beliefs by actively challenging
them.
Good beliefs are anti-fragile.
They get stronger the more contact they have with reality and they get stronger the more contact they
have with disagreement or people who might challenge them. And so in a sense, McGuire found
that you inoculate people to brainwashing the same way you inoculate them to a pathogen, right?
You give them a very small dose of the thing that you're trying to protect them against. So
before sending soldiers to war with a bunch of communists, you actually expose them to communism
and let them think about it.
And show them the arguments for and against it and let them, you know, arrive at their conclusions about their ideological beliefs in a way that's healthy and normal. So that way, once they're captured by the enemy, they're not just completely naive and susceptible to whatever the enemy like tortures into them.
But McGuire went further because he wanted to show that this principle held just across the population in general. And so what he did is he went specifically looking for beliefs that,
,
McGuire's thesis is that people would actually be more susceptible to change their mind about brushing their teeth than something else that they had been exposed to a lot of competing arguments before.
So what he did is he wrote three essays. Each essay was a strong, apparently factual argument about why toothbrushing was bad and why,
why people had been misled by the toothbrush industry into brushing their teeth every day. And this was all a hoax and this was all bullshit. It was very well reasoned, well written, very convincing. And he sat people down and exposed them to these essays, essentially tried to change their mind about toothbrushing. And sure enough, within a single session, within a single day, he was able to collapse people's confidence in the value of brushing their teeth by over 50%.
Which is crazy. Like, when was the last time you ever changed your mind 50% on anything?
Right. It's something as basic as toothbrushing, too. Like, if I were to predict this, I'd be like, no, you couldn't change my mind on that.
Yeah.
And he did it in one session with these people, yeah.
And so the conclusion he came to is that beliefs that have never been attacked are not strong. They're actually incredibly fragile. And that's because they haven't been stress tested. People have not identified their weaknesses and reinforced those weaknesses or found explanations for those weaknesses.
And so Maguire's recommendation was to pre-expose people. Anybody that you would worry might be brainwashed or, you know, susceptible to terrible beliefs, you need to pre-expose them to weakened counter arguments with refutations so that they can be inoculated when they are presented with kind of the full scale argument for the first time.
And interestingly, when he did this in experiments, it turned out that this actually did improve people's confidence.
It did improve people's abilities to hold their beliefs, whereas just reinforcing people's initial beliefs barely did anything. Barely improved their ability to handle contradiction or counter argument.
The way to protect yourself from being massively manipulated is to expose yourself to counter arguments, is to expose yourself to crazy ideas that maybe seem reasonable on the surface. But after you think about them for a while, you're like, wait, no, that's fucking crazy.
You know, somebody goes up, maybe really religious, like in a small town or something, and they're sent off to university, you know, somewhere else. And all of a sudden, they've never been challenged because of their belief system that they've held all their lives. And then they're sent off to somewhere where all these other counter beliefs are presented to them, and they don't know what to do with that.
It's always been a weird thing to me where people are like, if your whole worldview depends on you not encountering other ideas, that's a pretty flimsy worldview.
But I think the problem is, is people who haven't encountered other worldviews don't realize that they haven't encountered other worldviews.
Right, right. And then they, yeah, and then you see people getting sent off to these places. Oh, they're getting brainwashed.
Yeah.
Well, I can brainwash. I've just never been challenged in any way, shape or form, just like this. Yeah.
It raises a lot of questions and concerns. I mean, I know here in the U.S., there's been a lot of controversies around, like, books being banned, certain points of view not being allowed on campus, teachers not being allowed to teach, you know, certain parts of history.
Or certain perspectives on history. And I think just by and large, like, that is self-defeating, right? Like, it's the best way to preserve the most valuable points of view is to challenge those points of view, show the counterarguments, show the different perspectives, and then let the best idea win on its own merit.
Well, I think one of the reasons that this isn't a really widely known tactic or method that people use, I mean, this was back in the 60s, I think, when McGuire was doing this, right?
Yeah.
In the 60s, where he did a lot of this research. It kind of sat dormant for a very long time, actually.
Okay.
That research did for up until, like, the 2010s. And the argument kind of is, is that, you know, corporations, businesses, governments, too, they didn't really have a need to play defense with a lot of things.
People were buying stuff. It was kind of like the second half of the 20th century was kind of a one big party, right, for a lot of Western civilization anyway. So we didn't really need a whole lot of inoculation going on.
Yeah. Well, you could be persuaded to buy this product or even vote this way, you know, to some extent. And it was okay. Then the 2010s came, though, and we saw, like. Everything went to shit.
There was manipulation at scale with, you know, social media and information technology.
Yes.
That's just, like, the likes of which the world had never seen before.
Right? And so there was a little bit of a revival of this. There was a couple of researchers in the 2010s at the University of Cambridge who started looking a little bit more closely and getting very systematic about this.
Yes.
And revived some of McGuire's research, but then started doing their own. The problem that they ran up against, though, was that there was so much information now. So back in the 60s, yeah, there was a lot of information being produced, sure, but nothing compared to, like, we had seen with the explosion of the Internet and information technology, right?
So the problem was, is that you couldn't inoculate everybody against every little thing, every little claim that was being made, right? That was its own problem, again. And what we started this chapter with, too.
was you can't just be skeptical of everything anyway.
And you can't just inoculate yourself against every little single piece of information, misinformation that comes out anyway, too.
Right. Yeah. So they had to go through several different experiments and iterations of this to figure out what you actually have to do is inoculate at the level of the the technique, the manipulative attack that's going on.
The principles from Chialdini that we went over. Right. Like it's more like targeting those and showing people where those are happening.
That's what you inoculate against, not necessarily just information itself.
You know, you could still do big frameworks, you know, capitalism or communism or whatever you want to inoculate against.
But they're saying, no, no, no. What you what we really need to do is inoculate people against the specific manipulative techniques where they're being manipulated when they don't know it.
That makes a lot of sense to me. As you know, I've been writing about since the early 2010s. Right.
And I remember I did a piece in, I think, 2013 and it was called In the Future Your Attention Will Be Sold.
It's funny because looking back now.
It just seems so quaint. And, you know, like, like, oh, yeah, you know, right.
It's been interesting because I remember a lot of newsletters and articles that I wrote in the 2010s.
I talked about this. I was like, I don't think I know we just talked about toothpaste, but like you can't put the toothpaste back in the tube.
Like the technology is out there. The content machines are running.
The propaganda machines are running. We're not going to turn them off magically.
So the only thing to do is to.
Educate the population on like how the game is being played so that they can at least be aware of the buttons that are being pressed and like how they're being nudged into into different views and others.
And I do think by and large, the population is becoming more sophisticated at understanding this sort of stuff as time goes on.
Like, I think there are things that are just obvious to us today.
Like we talked earlier about bot accounts or fake follower accounts.
Um, or fake authority credential, you know, uh, phishing emails from somebody pretending to be the IRS.
Like that's the sort of stuff that you, you know, 15 years ago, you actually had this sit down and explain to people what was going on.
Whereas I think now everybody's just like, oh yeah, that shit happens all the time.
Like I've seen it. It's happened to everybody so many times.
So in a way, it's almost like, um, it's like an arms race.
Like I think it's as we innovate new technological ways to.
Influence people, um, kind of the population's knowledge and understanding of how they're being influenced has to catch up.
And I think largely we catch up by being influenced in terrible ways, like buying into really stupid fucking beliefs and assumptions that, you know, five, 10 years later, we look back and we're like, oh my God, I can't believe everybody thought that.
Right.
It's very weird.
And I think that, I think the, the lived experience of that is that we all just kind of perpetually live in this state.
Of uncertainty and, you know, feeling a little bit untethered to everything.
I, yeah, I don't know about you, but I remember, I think we have caught up quite a bit.
I remember when like fake things really started showing up on social media back in like late two thousands, early 2010s.
Yeah.
I remember specifically this one incident where it was obviously a video that had been edited.
Um, it's like a news casting and it wasn't really consequential.
It wasn't political even too.
It was just kind of dumb, but somebody had posted it as, and obviously they thought it was real.
And I.
Like replied, I'm like, you know, this is fake, right?
Yeah.
Like, it was like, this is probably 2010, somewhere around there.
And it was somebody my age too.
So I was very surprised by this.
I was like, oh wow, that's wild.
Little did I know what was going to come after that.
Oh my God.
All the time.
All the time for years and years.
And, but I think you're right.
I think now we're catching up to that.
I think that same person would not fall for something like that anymore.
No.
Obviously.
And now we're kind of, especially with AI, everybody's like, well, is this real or not?
I don't know.
I mean, I've noticed this with myself.
Like my threshold to start believing something is, has gotten quite a bit higher.
Even things that like, I'm kind of predisposed to believe in, you know, if I see it pop up
on my feet, I'm like, okay, well let's give it a week or two.
Yeah.
Is that dog really riding a bicycle?
Really?
I don't know.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Which I guess this kind of gets into, you know, I want to talk about like some of the
actual techniques and tools people can implement into their own lives to, to help inoculate
themselves.
So like, we've kind of given everybody the principle now, right?
Which is that.
You do need to, uh, challenge your own beliefs and viewpoints in small doses.
Um, but it's, it's like, okay, well, how do you actually do that?
Like, how do you manage to do that without getting swept away without falling victim
to a lot of these, a lot of these persuasion principles are like psychological tactics
that we talked about in the last chapter.
Um, like what, what is, what is a practical thing that you can do today to safeguard yourself
from just being, you know, whiplashed into, into some.
Some crazy group think, uh, that's that you're, that's going to embarrass you a few years
from now.
Um, so the first one is, I already mentioned it briefly, but is slow down.
And this is something that you'll notice, especially in, in like news and politics these
days, everything is framed as an immediate crisis, like something that has to be acted
on today, that if you don't do something today or this week, all hell's going to break
loose.
The world's going to end.
Like everything's going to be absolutely terrible.
And the truth is, is that that is almost never the case, but things are framed in that way
because when things feel urgent, they leverage that artificial scarcity, right?
It's like, oh my God, if we don't do this, uh, by tomorrow, like Trump's going to like
do this thing and that thing, and it's going to be horrible.
And like all these people are going to suffer, you know, it short circuits your, your ability
to reason because of that sense of urgency.
It's the same reason why a countdown timer on a sales page makes you buy things.
Quicker, it, it, it makes you just buy into that narrative with like, with thinking less.
So the first thing is, is just slow the fuck down, back up the truck, ask yourself, you're
like, okay, if I wait a week, is it going to, is it going to matter 99 times out of
a hundred?
It's not right.
Is there anything I can do about this?
Yeah.
Like I was saying, it's, it's so easy to create that sense of urgency or scarcity.
Yeah.
Like you, if you slow down, you'll recognize that like very easily manufactured and I very
easily.
Fell for it.
Right.
I do this all the time.
I say, I see this all the time too.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And it's, it's like, I kind of started to mention it earlier, but like one of my rules
for myself is that like, if I see something that is upsetting or really interesting to
me, but it seems like it could potentially be bullshit.
I always wait, make myself wait a week.
Right.
Like, it's like, okay, I saw it once might be true.
Let's see.
Let's see.
Let's wait three, four days.
See if I see if stories keep coming up about it.
Let's see.
If there's like other sources start talking about the same thing.
And then I just give it time.
I like, I basically don't really believe something until I've seen like at least three or four
people that I relatively trust talk about it.
And then I'm like, okay, this must be a thing.
Okay.
This must be a thing.
Now let me think.
And by slowing down and giving yourself that time, you like, you give your, you give yourself
time to think about it too.
Right.
Like to actually get a sense of, does this matter?
Does this have any effect on my life?
Is this actually like likely?
Significant in the world, or is this just a bunch of people freaking out and panicking
over something like catastrophizing something?
Because there is, there is a lot of catastrophizing that is going on.
The other thing that, that is good about slowing down is if you look at like aggressive sales
tactics, different kind of fraud tactics, scams, almost all of them rely on speed and
urgency, right?
Like it's like, if somebody is, is trying to cheat you out of a bunch of money, they
likely aren't telling you, go home and think about it for a week and get back to me.
Right?
No, they're like, you know, you have to do this today.
You have to do this now.
You have to, you can't hang up the phone until you do this.
First good for the next 10 minutes.
Exactly.
Like they are trying to put as much time pressure on you as possible because if you do sit and
think about it, you're probably going to, you're going to realize that like, wait, this
doesn't, this doesn't actually make sense.
Like once the emotions go away, the clarity, you'll be able to see it more clearly.
I think this is actually really important too in relationships.
Like if you're having a fight with your partner, simply letting a certain amount of time
pass, uh, I, I, sometimes I don't see it that often, but sometimes I see relationship advice,
which is like, you know, never go to bed angry or like always resolve it.
It's like, no, you actually can't resolve every fight every time it happens.
Some fights, some fights drag out for years.
You will reach a point with your partner where it's like, okay, you know what?
The best thing we can do is probably just go sit on this for a couple of days and
then come back and talk about it again, because we're both emotional.
Like we haven't had time to sit with it.
We haven't had time to think through it.
So like, let's, let's take a pause, take a timeout.
It will come back to this in a day or two.
So another tactic that's very similar to the slowing down and something that can help you
slow down is by writing things out.
This is another benefit of journaling is that it actually takes a long time to kind of write
your thoughts out into the practice of writing your thoughts.
Thoughts out actually forces you to formulate a lot of what you're feeling into a rational
thought.
So yeah, if you're really worked up about something, sit down, journal it out.
Not only is it therapeutic to kind of work through the emotions, but the process of writing
something out, it will force you to think really hard about the beliefs that you're
developing around it and will probably expose some flaws in your thinking if it's not completely
based on, on rationality.
I think a next level skill these days is slowing down.
Yeah.
And writing, like we've already said, slowly.
it down but also writing things down that forces you to slow down a little bit that's a next level
skill these days i think there's so much pressure to hurry up yes and that i think go the opposite
way with that one and i think we're all kind of losing that muscle to to like stop take a beat
think about things like huh what if i'm wrong you know it's just yeah it's getting harder and harder
no for sure um another one too though diversifying your relationships okay this is so there's this
really cool studies classic study um back in the 50s they were doing all this obedience
yeah study uh studies and manipulation studies after world war ii right and there's this classic
study where some people go into a room you sit down in a chair there's two lines on a board in
front of you one is longer than the other one and you just have to say which one's longer than the
other one little do you know that there's a whole bunch of other all the other people in there
are in on the experiment and they pick the shorter line as the longer one and most of the time most
people will
go ahead and agree and say okay yeah i guess that's the longer one the uh ash conformity
the ash conformity experiment right famous right very famous study what they found though is that
so say there's five people in there you're you're one of five people all the other four are they
pick the shorter line yeah saying it's the longer one a lot of times you're going to go with them
like a like 80 of the time or something like that you end up going with them if there's only one
other person in that lineup with you so there's two of the five people who aren't in on it and
they pick the other one even if everybody else has picked the short line saying it's the long
one but no no they're like no i'm going to pick the long one you're way more likely to pick that
other one too to pick the longer line the actual longer line so it's almost like an inoculation with
your your your group it's just having a diversity of relationships of people who think a little bit
differently yeah it might call you out on a few things or question a few things yeah i can like
lead into conspiracy theorist friends or something like that too i hate that this is kind of
controversial these days oh yeah yeah like it's oh to have have a diverse set of friends and
opinions for like people are ending friendships and
cutting off family members because of their some of their beliefs and it's i think that is
the single most unhealthy thing you can do yeah yeah one of the things i worry about a lot in one
of my big criticisms of california in particular not to get on my california soapbox but like
there's so much emphasis put on racial ethnic and gender diversity and there's no emphasis
put on diversity of thought and opinion yeah and so it's funny like living in la
it is a very diverse place there's people all sorts of walks of life different ethnicities
backgrounds races they all think the same fucking thing they all have the same opinions they all do
this like it they have the same political beliefs it drives me crazy i'm like this is not diversity
i mean i grew up in a very undi i grew up in fucking white on white texas yeah and i don't
know there's more political diversity where i grew up then then i think there is where i live in la
yeah which is kind of fucked up i
think it does though if you if you do have people you care about in your life and they have different
like you're much more charitable and you can try to see the humanity in their way of thinking even
if you completely disagree with them i can see how you came to that conclusion at least i
vehemently disagree with you right but i respect your opinion and i see that you're not a bad person
right right and you're not evil and you're not trying to like destroy no matter what the narrative
is you are evil and you are being manipulated or whatever this is how our minds get changed
when somebody we respect and cares about care about has a different opinion than us and we
actually sit there and listen to it with good faith with some compassion and actually consider
like oh maybe they realize something i don't when you're just surrounded by everybody who agrees
with you again back to mcguire your ideas never challenge which makes you much more fragile and
susceptible to being manipulated and brainwashed okay i've got another one here that i wrote down
is use base rates not vibes uh which i actually really like this one because i think it's really
i use this a lot in my my daily life um so what most people do you know if they meet somebody
who is pissing them off or you know is maybe a little bit shady or whatever they try to guess
you know how trustworthy is this person and like you talked about earlier how they start zeroing
in on body language like how's their eye contact like are they shifting on their feet are they
covering their mouth you know what what's the what's the feeling i'm getting from them and it
our feelings our vibe check on like how trustworthy a person is is completely inaccurate we're we're
really bad at it i think what's more useful to do in situations is to remove yourself from the
situation and just ask yourself what is the base rate of this being bullshit you know if i was to
meet a hundred people like this how many of them would be honest and how many of them would be
liars right so it's like a sales guy comes to my door and he's being a little bit mean and i'm
a little shifty or whatever but he like works for a really large company and he said like he's like
seems to have all the credentials and he seems really you know like he's got the fucking logo
on his truck you know he might be shifty but if i ask myself okay out of a hundred people who come
to my door like this how many of them are gonna be scam artists you know probably one out of a
hundred even though this guy's a little bit weird like is he the one out of a hundred probably not
i probably don't know
so whatever you know i can hire him to like fucking fix my my faucet or whatever so you can
do this with suspicious emails right so you know one thing that happens periodically um is i get
somebody emailing me or messaging me extremely angry because they thought that i emailed them
with some incredible offer or that i wanted to set up a call with them or i wanted to hang out
with them obviously it was a scam yeah and they were just using my name and you know a
fake email address and everything but then they email me mad that i they feel cheated or you know
whatever and i just kind of look at i'm like look i don't i don't want to like big shot people here
but i'm like what's the chance that i randomly picked you know jane smith from missouri you know
a retired school teacher to hop on a zoom call and talk about her her finances like what are the
chances that i'm gonna be able to do something like that and i was like i don't know i don't
know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know
i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't
know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know
but you know it's a special world special people yeah yeah this also ties into kind of that that
old maxim that if it seems too good to be true then it probably is right yeah it's like really
what that's saying is that what are the chances that this thing is true like if you removed
yourself from the situation and you were just looking at a spreadsheet like in what percentage
of the situations would this actually be a real opportunity if the answer is like less than one
percent then you're probably being cheated this is similar to the asymmetric gut policy and what
we're calling that is so if something feels off that's probably worth investigating that's
probably worth taking a pause and actually digging into that's usually a pretty good
signal that something actually is off or it's at least worth digging into right yeah whereas
if you're like really excited and something is just so amazing that's probably
you're probably getting conned in some way right like if it if it feels too good to be true like
what you said so there's like this asymmetry that you need to be aware of and it's i mean it is kind
of a negativity bias right like be biased against the downside more than the upside right and it's
contrary to our kind of our default instincts right because it's like generally when we feel
uneasy about something we try to suppress that and ignore it like you know just go along with
it don't don't cause any problems whereas when we're really enthusiastic and super excited about
something that is when we're defenseless and
it's funny i i think it is a good habit to uh question things that you are it doesn't mean
you can't be excited about it just means take a moment and question it kind of the last one that
i'll say is is that i think usually when we are reading people i think most of the time when we
when we are watching somebody and kind of making judgments about their intentions i think in a lot
of cases we're really just projecting our own emotional state onto them so if we feel uneasy
about a situation we will just be like okay i'm gonna do this i'm gonna do this i'm gonna do this
we will convince ourself the person in front of us is untrustworthy if we are really really
enthusiastic about a situation we will convince ourselves that the person is amazing and perfect
and like gonna change our lives um so i i think kind of the underlying principle here is just
be wary of your own emotions like don't buy into them wholeheartedly this is i think a practice that
just applies to so many other things that we talk about on this podcast of developing a kind of a
around your feelings and like understanding okay i'm really excited right now am i excited for a
good reason okay cool just checking right um or yeah i'm feeling really guilty or i'm feeling
really sad or i'm feeling really distrustful or angry is that just my insecurity or is there
actually something weird in my environment here and i think having those conversations with yourself
um it's just very fundamental to like navigating the world at this point final thing i'll say too
is holding your opinions lightly um i i think that is probably more important than ever today
it's fine to be opinionated it's fine to be passionate about something
but the world is changing so quickly uh information is disseminated so widely and so quickly like it
just the the facts and knowledge that we have is changing so fast from year to year
that i think it is incumbent on everybody develop a certain amount of flexibility around their own
beliefs and their own convictions not only is it easier
to be manipulated than ever before but i also think the downside of being manipulated or buying
into bad beliefs wholeheartedly these days is the cost is higher than ever before and we could do a
whole episode on that and maybe we will maybe we will maybe we'll come back for beliefs solved
so to wrap things up you know in chapter one we talked about how manipulation is just the water
we all swim in it is a fundamental part of human interaction and there's kind of no escaping it
that doesn't mean we're all bad people and it doesn't mean that all manipulation is even bad
it just means that it is always going on and this idea that there are certain evil people out there
who are manipulating and using us and the rest of us are good and innocent well-intentioned
that's kind of bullshit um there's just a spectrum of manipulation that we all participate on and we
all move it up and down that spectrum
based on the context where we are in our lives our personalities uh our value system and how we're
feeling that day in chapter two we talked about the ethics of manipulation um on the one end we
have kind of kantian idealism and how we should treat everybody as a as an ends and not a means
and how we should always be upfront and transparent and virtuous and every in every action
respecting our own agency and the agency of others and while that's beautiful and there's fluffy
clouds and rainbows and unicorns uh the reality is is that life is largely a power struggle and
as machiavelli pointed out um whether you want to or not you have to play that power struggle to a
certain extent and uh and what we discovered is that depending on where you are in the power of
hierarchy often determines how justified you feel manipulating others and also how ethical it can
feel to manipulate others there are two key principles from that chapter one was the publicity
test which is that if you manipulate somebody and they become aware of it they would approve of it
then that would be an ethical manipulation and then the other principle from that chapter was
power dependency which is that every relationship has certain power imbalances and those power
imbalances are going to affect basically the person who feels more disempowered is generally
going to be more manipulative they're going to have more incentive to be manipulative and also
i would argue that the person with more power and any dynamic has more moral responsibility
to not be manipulative when at all possible in chapter three we talked about how we manipulate
each other all the marketing and sales tactics and in persuasion tactics uh there are so many
of them that we actually didn't even get through all of them um so obviously you can go check out
the guide if you want to if you want to learn more but is the water we swim in it is all around us
all the time issues the ads
in this podcast is the intro of this podcast that is absolutely everything it is everywhere
all the time the more aware you are of it the more you can navigate the world maintain your
sanity without being straw-armed and buying a set of encyclopedias that you never asked for
and then finally in the last chapter we thought about how to inoculate ourselves from egregious
manipulation it's impossible to defend ourselves from all manipulation we're all very influenceable
and we all
benefit from being influenced in many circumstances and the cases but the question is how do we
protect ourselves from just getting brainwashed into being a fucking knuckle dragon idiot you
know one of those trolls online that is just spouting stupid shit and the truth is is that
the way you protect yourself is by challenging your own beliefs second-guessing your immediate
assumptions not bite into your immediate emotional reactions slowing down writing it out diversifying
your relationships surrounding
yourself by wider variety of perspectives and views and then of course zoomy now asking yourself
on the grand scale things how likely is this to be true how likely is this to matter how much
has this happened before am i really that special is the world really ending because chances are
it's probably not and you're just being a self-indulgent asshole like we all are from time
to time as always thank you guys for tuning in uh the solved guide is available at solve podcast.com
slash manipulation and adds all of our citations references research and a more thorough guide for
everything that we've talked about in this episode so please go check it out it is completely free
and as always if you love this show please the best thing you can do for us needs to leave a
review and a five-star rating it helps the platforms get the show out to more people
i mean think about all the things drew and i have done for you all the help we've given you over the
years leaving a review of the show is going to help you get the show out to more people
how hard is that like that doesn't take very long it's just a quick i'm a five-star thing like it's
quite easy i'm not manipulating you i'm just completely being honest and upfront that this
is something that drew it i work very hard i know we care deeply about and there's a whole team of
people here with their livelihood depends on you leaving a five-star rating and leaving a positive
review for this all right we will be back next month thank you all again appreciate you say
goodbye drew you're bye
you
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The host demonstrates that he is actively using six persuasive techniques (curiosity gap, authority, flattery, social proof, self-deprecation, urgency) while stating only true things, showing that manipulation does not require deception.
Manipulation is a universal spectrum of behavior rather than a trait of obvious villains, and people often want to be manipulated in contexts like entertainment.
Historical thinkers from Plato to Pinel linked manipulation to irrationality, but Pinel and Pritchard identified "moral insanity"—rational yet cruel people—which later shaped the modern concept of psychopathy.
Hervey Cleckley's 1941 work "The Mask of Sanity" argued that psychopaths are largely undetectable and blend into society, but high-profile serial killer cases distorted this into the pop-culture monster stereotype.
Research by Goffman, Christie, Geis, and Buss shows everyday manipulation is normal and practical, with reasoning as the most common tactic in relationships and social complexity likely driving human brain evolution.
Self-deception is the most effective route to deceiving others, as shown by studies like the Lund University card-swap experiment where about three-quarters of subjects unknowingly justified choices they never made.
People are barely better than chance at detecting lies, and experts like police and psychiatrists perform no better than college students, suggesting this blindness may be a feature that preserves social trust.
Kant's formula of humanity holds that treating people (including oneself) merely as a means to an end is the core ethical violation underlying lying, cheating, stealing, and manipulation.
Summary:
This episode of "Solved" tackles manipulation, arguing that it is not the exclusive domain of villains but a universal spectrum of behavior everyone engages in constantly. The host opens by openly demonstrating six persuasive techniques on the listener without telling a single lie, illustrating that influence and deception are distinct. The episode traces the history of manipulation from Plato and Aristotle, who saw deceit as a failure of reason, through Philippe Pinel's observation of "moral insanity"—rational yet cruel individuals—to James Pritchard's distinction between moral and actual insanity.
Hervey Cleckley's "The Mask of Sanity" later argued that psychopaths are largely undetectable, a point lost when high-profile serial killer cases turned the psychopath into a pop-culture monster. Modern research from Goffman, Christie, Geis, and Buss reveals that everyday manipulation is normal, practical, and possibly the evolutionary reason humans developed such large brains. The hosts explore self-deception as the most powerful tool for deceiving others, citing the Lund University card-swap study where most subjects unknowingly justified choices they never made.
They note that lie detection is barely better than chance, even for experts, and that this blindness may preserve social cohesion. The episode closes by introducing Kant's formula of humanity as an ethical framework: treating people, including oneself, merely as a means to an end is the root of unethical manipulation.
FAQs
Manipulation is shaping someone else's behavior to serve your own ends. We all do it constantly, often subconsciously, because it helps us maintain social harmony and avoid costly conflict.
No. The vast majority of psychopaths are not violent and blend into everyday society. Many learn to mimic empathy and emotion to get what they want, which is why they are so hard to detect.
You basically can't. Research shows even trained experts like police, judges, and psychiatrists detect lies only about 54-56% of the time, barely better than a coin flip. Body language cues like avoiding eye contact are not reliable signs of deception.
Self-deception helps us deceive others more convincingly, since believing your own story removes the cognitive load and nervous tells of a deliberate lie. It also protects our self-esteem and lets us see ourselves as the good guy.
Not necessarily. Philosopher Immanuel Kant argued that treating people as a means to your own end is unethical, while treating them as ends in themselves is moral. Manipulation becomes a problem when it serves only your interests at another person's expense.
Be wary of people who constantly play the victim or insist everyone else is evil or out to get them. Research links chronic victimhood and seeing others as conspirators to higher manipulative traits.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.