Managing Portfolio Losses: Lessons From 12 Top Stock Market Maestros
from The Art of Investing
1h 9m 6s
This episode features Lee Freeman Shore, author of *The Art of Execution* and *Stop Market Maestros*, reflecting on investor behavior during market volatility. The discussion centers on how top investors manage wins and losses, using real-world examples to illustrate disciplined strategies. Key lessons include identifying pre-defined risk triggers, such as trailing stops or time-based rules, to prevent emotional decision-making. Investors are encouraged to distinguish between cyclical and fundamental assets, adjusting their positions accordingly. The core insight is that success isn’t about predicting the market perfectly but about managing position size wisely and exiting at the right time. Shore highlights that top performers don’t rely on high hit rates but instead focus on sizing their best ideas correctly and maintaining mental discipline. Emotional triggers—like analyst downgrades, speculative headlines, or market sentiment shifts—are emphasized as early warning signs for profit-taking. Examples from investors like Josh Goldberg and Dirk Enderline demonstrate how structured rules improve consistency. The episode concludes by urging listeners to assess their own investing psychology, recognizing that success requires adapting strategies to personal traits, not blindly copying others. The portfolio’s recent underperformance underscores the need for such self-awareness and disciplined exit behavior.
In this week's episode in times of trouble for the portfolio, we welcome back our hero of the top episode from last year is Lee Freeman Shore.
Welcome to the Art of Investing brought to you by IG the Global Investment Platform.
So our good friend of the show Lee Freeman Shore is back with us, welcome Lee.
Thank you. Of course, the author of the Art of Execution, which give us a lot to discuss on episode 19 Chris.
Yeah, it's a fantastic episode. Everybody should go back and listen to that for no other reason maybe than the fact we're going to be discussing a lot of things about the way we're running our portfolio today and we're going to be critiqued by the expert critiqued Lee.
I'm getting my hat and coat now. No, Lee, anybody that hasn't seen it, episode 19, please introduce yourself.
So I'm a former fund manager and now an author and when I was on previously, I discussed my first book, The Art of Execution and earlier this year I came out my second book, which is Stop Market Maestroys, which obviously we can talk about that maybe.
Excellent. We look forward to it and yeah, going more into actual particular fund managers and how they've operated.
Yeah, so this, the second book is a follow up from the first book. The first book, you know, I introduced, you know, rabbits, hunters, assassins, connoisseurs and raiders, which we'll talk about later, no doubt.
But people, after writing that off an ask question, how do I know whether to stay or go when I'm winning or losing.
So this book, you've got 12 of the best invest in the world and we literally look at what they do when they're losing and winning.
What is it that persuades them to stay or go in a name? So that's the, that's the point of it.
Fantastic. Well, certainly talking about rabbit in the headlights are performance this week, look at that down to 0.2%.
So year to date, that takes us back to only up 7.1%. So let's get on to the spice market update and see where has that come from.
Well, thanks Rich and welcome back Lee. Good to have you back on. It's been a brutal week actually for lots of assets across many asset classes.
And that's despite the all price being down 2% remember, sort of ordinarily when the all price goes down, other assets tend to do better.
You know, bonds tend to better because inflation expectations drop and equities sort of tend to rally as well because that means that obviously their input costs are quite often lower.
And all those sort of things tend to work, but this time the all prices down still know straights or humours piece deal.
But what's happened this week to make the all price a bit weaker is that actual global stocks and we get that weekly data come out from American places like that.
A showing that stocks are rebuilding again for the first time really since the conflict started and rising quite rapidly.
And some people are worried that now this supply is going to outstrip the demand.
And because this is in perhaps in the background there's a little bit of nerves about global growth that's been sort of sparked by two things really obviously the midterm elections.
At the big landslide for the Democrats and them saying well, they're going to cut back on AI sort of development and data centers and rest up to we know is make about half of the global growth pretty much out there, but particularly in America is very important.
So people worry if they if they control it too much growth might fall demand for oil fall that's why the oil price might go down. So yeah, those are sort of nerves that are jangling in the background.
But I think it's interesting that the places that have been importing the most oil that we know were suffering when the oil price went up the most have benefits.
So the only all time higher can really talk about this week is Germany stacks in which took out is all time high, which is interesting full of industrial companies that use a lot of oil and chemical companies and all the rest of it.
So that was the only time high the FTSE 100 CJ and the mid 250 just failed to make it.
I mean, how many times have we seen them the FTSE 100 get to 10,900 and change and we're going 11,000 here we come.
I've got the caps ready back to 10,600 and something here we go and that's been the story of this week again, unfortunately.
What about our Eurostock 600 was that?
It's so close, but didn't quite get there, didn't quite get there, but you know, it's good to see that the DAX took it out and again benefiting from this slightly lower oil price.
I mean, you know, only two percent down this week, but over the last few weeks, it's down over 20% as we've talked about last week, very important.
One of the big movies, which is surprising a lot of people is the dollar, the US dollar is up another 1.2% this week.
Now, you know, currencies don't move in percentage terms very much now the last two weeks, the dollars up nearly two and a half percent against the global basket.
And that's really hurt things like our S&P 500 hedged because we hedged it back because we were worried about the dollar being weak.
So that's actually hurt us a little bit, unfortunately, but other things that are affected by that strong dollar Bitcoin and crypto currency have been absolutely slammed again.
I think Bitcoin is down 12.5% over the week. Gold is down 7% silver down 13% copper down 6.
I remember gold silver copper commodities in general are priced in US dollars.
So when the dollar is stronger, their prices actually go down.
And that's what's one of the many reasons probably that's hurt gold silver and copper this week.
I see our crypto experts seem very quiet as you mentioned Bitcoin.
To be honest, as Mark says, there being absolutely horrendous and you know, you could argue as the dollar, you could argue as interest rates expectations both sides of the same coin.
And so to me, there seems to be a feeling out there that with the further rate rises that we expect to come that that's undermining those other asset classes.
It makes more sense for me to think that the losses in the AI space having to be paid for by profits elsewhere.
And so I think sometimes and Mark and I have had this conversation a number of times in the past.
If you're watching the market all the time and you watch CNBC, you get CNBC headlines.
This is why that's happened. And actually it's all that rubbish.
The reason is that people need cash at the moment and say they're selling what they've got.
And the first thing they sell are the things that most close.
He says, you know, the next things are sell where they've got profits and a number of these things they still got profits on.
And they want to make themselves look a little better.
And therefore in the old days, we were all window dressing.
People don't want to look to be a bit stupid.
So they sell things on a profit to buy some things which have done badly.
I always like to think of it as the sort of what's the stone that's rolling down the hill.
The stone starts off quite small and that's the AI stone.
And as it rolls down, it picks up more and more as it goes down.
And that's what every other asset cost because it's been no safety anywhere in the last week.
As Mark says, it's been terrible.
But Spice, there is another reason for people selling in the last week, isn't there?
Because they're making way for a hundred billion dollars or something else coming along.
Exactly. This hotly anticipated IPO of anthropic obviously own Claude.
And it'll be the first opportunity to people to invest in a direct AI generator.
Actually, if I look at my watch, it's just about to go live.
Depending on when you're listening to this, all right, we're recording on Wednesday.
But I would imagine anthropic will be up and running by the time you listen to this.
So you are ahead of us in the future.
Well, I mean, it's plastered all over the press.
But when you look at the index, when you look it up, there's going to be ANT.
It's supposedly over seven times over subscribed, which is huge.
I know Rich has probably helped that along quite a lot.
I've actually put Austin for it as well.
And a couple of weeks ago, we were worried about whether it would happen at all.
And whether the valuation would be at the very low end to encourage people into it.
Now, it seems, and this is rumored, and we'll find out for sure tomorrow.
But it's meant to be priced, being priced at the top end of the range, around $78 a share.
Or above?
Or above.
And the top end of the valuation was about 1.4 trillion.
There's range between about 1.2 trillion and 1.4.
And it looks like it's coming at about 1.4.
That's fully diluted.
That's if all the shares were issued at the same time.
So they're going to raise about $90 billion.
And 15 to 20 percent of that is going to be retail investors.
So people like yourselves, CJ, and you know, it'll be very interesting to see how it performs.
As you say, as this comes out live, it'll probably just have started trading.
So watch that space, it'll be hotly anticipated.
Should we have a little guess where it is?
Should we have a guess?
So IG currently are making $100.
So they think after the IPO starts trading, it will trade at 100.
So now, of course, you've got to do your own research.
As your stock market manager was duly, but what's a little guess?
I'll throw my hat in the ring for us.
I'll go 111.
Oh, I was going to go.
The magic number.
I can't do that.
It's the magic number.
111.
98 dollars.
98.
And this is by the end of the close of trading on the first.
Oh, no, no, no, no.
This is whenever our listener is listening to it.
Well, there'd be 98 dollars in that case.
Right.
98.
I'm not bothering with this ridiculously stupid short-term discussion.
As a long-term investor and chairman of this podcast.
Can I say how, how bitterly upset I am that you're doing this?
And there is one other thing I would like to say.
Rich said that we'd applied for it on the portfolio.
We haven't.
Go on, Lee, you get a guess as well.
I don't do short term stuff like this.
I leave it to you guys for traders.
Right.
Yeah, I'll date us in the comments where it is trading when you listen to this.
Yeah, it should be very interesting.
Another sort of area of the market that's been very. week was the chip sector, the semiconductor index. We can look at the Philadelphia semiconductor index,
that's down about 6% this week. It's been really hurt the last few weeks, but it's recovered a
little bit today after some very good Nvidia figures, and I'll touch on those in a minute. The
magnificent 7, they're down about 3%. And that's partly because Voldemort has come out and has
imposed new restrictions on selling high-end chips to China, funny old game. Now actually the Chinese
tech companies have been really, really badly hurt this week. We think ours have been badly
hit. The semiconductor index is down about 6%. Things like Alibaba, Baidu, down 10 to 15% in China.
So he stuck his knife out there and certainly hurt the Chinese tech stocks. Talking about one
closer to home or one just across the Atlantic anyway, Nvidia, they had their results last night,
and we know that this is going to be a very important sentiment driver for stock markets around the
world. And so far overnight, it's had a positive effect. So the Nvidia shares were trading down
2% or 3% before the results yesterday. And they came out at 9 o'clock, this is on a Tuesday night.
And they're up about 4% since then as we speak in the pre-market trading. Still down about 10%
over the week. So they've had a bad week. And remember that's partly because Jensen Wang,
the chief executive's been ousted or he resigned. And he's been replaced by a lady could collect
Cress, who's the interim CEO, so they're clearly looking for someone else. Jensen Wang has basically
put his hands up and said, I'd very happily come back. And Voldemort said, we'd love to have him
back. But of course, the board have said, nah, we don't want to even entertain that idea.
The chairman ruled it out straight away. First thing on the call, he's not welcome back.
I mean, you know, the shares are down a third from their October height, a third. So you know,
that's a big, big fool. But yes, those results were fantastic. They upgraded the revenue forecast.
They beat expectations pretty much across the board. Very good margins at 74, 75%. And they've now
guided. They say it should be a bit lower than that because we've got some higher costs. And
there's a bit of a mix of change of mix in our business, which means that margin was to be 71,
72%. So in the press conference, they're talking about possibility of having 750 billion dollars
of revenue next year, which is absolutely huge. And they also said they're going to add 150 billion
dollars to their share buybacks. Now, if they, they've got about, if you add that to 150
billions to what they're already doing, there's about 227 billion dollars of share buyback.
If they did all that, the current share price, that would reduce the amount of equity
in issuance by about 6%, which is huge by no means. So anyone thinks that in video short cash,
you need to think again. And that's one of the things that I think reassured the market.
So it would not be right for me not for me not to remind people around this table that at
the last week's podcast, when we talked about Jensen and Nvidia, everybody said there's no way
on earth he's going to go. Someone said that they put on their sub stack that Jensen would not
be, be else. So my question isn't who's looking stupid now. My question is, it was a shock,
but was it really that much of a shock? Do we think at the end of the day, I mean, market
reacted, but hasn't done too badly or am I completely wrong? Well, I mean, the shares are down the
third since October. Someone knew that was coming, right? And I hate to say it, there was certainly
out insiders out there because that way, that share price just fell and fell and fell and fell and fell.
And everyone's searching for why and then it all came out funny all again. Do you want to hear my new
sub stack? Yes, please. Jensen to join SpaceX to be kind of AI at SpaceX with Elon. Can you imagine
the power of that company if you've got those two mines running it? There's a lot of leather jackets
going to be sold on that. So I suppose somebody who's not watching it's closely as you guys,
even I watched Nvidia last night because one realizes that if one's positions are exposed,
one needs to be watching this stuff. And you know, it was a very impressive set of results. There's
no doubts about it. And they also announced guidance for long way in the future, which they had no
reason or no need to do in any way, shape or form. I mean, surely that makes us feel, you know,
that was, you know, even more confident about this company and delivered and over delivered and
did things they didn't need to to make people feel good. And the analysts have to change all the
numbers because she gave great guidance for Q4. And then she provided guidance for the next year,
which she didn't have to do at all. It was the opposite of kitchen syncing, which is, of course,
when a new CEO comes in or an interim CEO and sort of gets all the dirty washing out.
And the phrase is kitchen sync because when you're removing and renovating a house, of course,
normally you keep a kitchen sink, wouldn't you? Now get rid of everything. She came out with as many
positive things as she possibly could. I've done the quick back of the envelope calculation.
And on the 72 to 73% margin guidance, that is an EPS of $17 next year, earnings per share of
$17. Now, that leaves the stock on about nine times. Yeah, nine and a half times earnings
for Nvidia. On the face of it, very cheap. It's giving you an extra 150 billion back of share by
backs. So it's throwing off cash. So one of the questions we need to answer, which we'll answer
when we get to the portfolio section is, are we missing something? Because something that's on nine
and a half times earnings, throwing off cash at the rate is going, would straight down to be
extremely cheap. Listen for later when we go through what that means for our portfolio.
Well, away from the Nvidia and Anthropic sort of headlines you will have been reading about a week,
only one I wanted to mention otherwise was the Swiss company Rishmal, which is known for its
luxury goods. Those of you who revel in Cartier. Cartier actually suffering. So they're shares
of down about seven percent. Their revenues are slowed up. The cost are up. I mean, their revenues
are still growing at 14% a year, right? But they were growing at sort of 20 plus percent last year.
The big area that's hurt them, not just China, because everyone's expected China to be bad.
The domestic economy we've talked about a number of times on the podcast is suffering badly.
But actually the Middle East inside is doing bad. Well, no shit, sure lot. The people aren't
traveling through the Middle East and buying stuff in GD3. People should have known that. We just
said the analyst should have known that really. But nevertheless, they highlighted that as one of
the areas of weakness. Now, just to please the Chairman, because the portfolio hasn't done this week,
I'm pleased to say that UK's GDP or gross domestic product beat expectations this week,
and has grown by 0.7%. The burn and bounce perhaps. So yeah, the GDP last quarter drew by
0.7%. It was expected to be 0.5%. So that was good beat. Interestingly, they pointed out about half
that growth is coming from AI. You're all you've all you've been who said that AI has got nothing
to do with the UK. I've been I've been to the Vanguard saying it's changing everything. And
here we go. This start of a massive rise going on now. Your capital is at risk. The value of your
shares, ETFs and ETCs can fall as well as rise, which could mean getting back less than you
originally put in this content is for information purposes only and is not investment advice.
Pass performance is not an indication of future results. Right, that takes us on to the portfolio
performance. Then what has hurt us this week? Well, everything. Let's be honest, the worst
performers, BlackRock world mining down 7% on the week, Russell 2000 down 3.4, emerging markets
that we added to last week, down 3.2% and then copper week as well. Did we have any savior as
well? It was our cash holding. Remember our cash holding pays on the IG platform, pays you
interest. So we get a little bit back there, but even FTSE 100, FTSE 250 and Eurostock 600 all
down between half and one and a half percent. Chairman, it's not looking great. Is it? No, it's
been a week of sort of two halves. It's like the old football analogy. You started the week with
everybody, the week that we're measuring ourselves on here, which is obviously Wednesday to Wednesday.
At the end of last week, everything was looking really good and perky, new highs were coming,
we were starting to get to exactly the right spot. And then the first few days of this week
absolutely atrocious. And so it's been quite all volatility in there as well. I think the
VIX index has picked up a little bit as well. So everyone's getting a little bit nervous,
but it's certainly not a great time in terms of our performance, what you haven't mentioned,
which I think we should mention is that the second year of our performance, we're down 6.3%.
If we were in a trustee meeting now, we'd be saying, well guys, you've had a great start,
but you're not doing very well at the moment. Now, no one would be too worried because since
inception was still well ahead, but they would be starting to say, hmm, are you sticking to your
methodology? Are you investing the way that you should be investing? And so we've got tough week,
tough three months, we've clearly missed quite a lot of why the markets are selling off.
That's all here. Although we raised some cash, we've put some money back in, but it's not
turning things at the moment. So I decided that, apart from getting my coat in hat and saying,
thank you very much, I'm retiring on a good overall performance, decided now is perhaps time for us to
introduce a bit of counseling into the podcast and into the way we're running our money.
And I'm hoping this will be useful for everybody listening because they'll have their own portfolios,
and they'll be seeing how things aren't looking great, and they'll be wondering what they should do,
And so
So it's good for us today to be able to welcome back Lee.
And he can be our counsellor because he's just written this fantastic book.
We've already talked about podcast 19 where we introduced the concept of how you manage
your money.
And that I say to everybody, go back and listen to that really, really worthwhile.
We're going to be using some of those terms to death and now.
But what we really wanted to get to is to say to Lee, based on, and ask him, he's written
this second book about lessons from good managers when things have gone right and when they've
gone wrong.
And what we really want to know is, look, it's going wrong here.
We're obviously good managers.
What should we be learning or doing differently and help us through this period?
Now I think before we do that, it might be wise to quickly go through the definitions
of investor type that we discussed in our earlier podcast, just a couple of lines about
each one, just to bring everybody up to speed on those types and let's start there.
Okay.
So thanks for having me back.
I don't know about counselling, though.
I think that's maybe somewhere else.
Invested types.
So in an actual, there are five.
When you're losing, people tend to join one of three tribes, if you like.
You become a rabbit hunter or an assassin.
So a rabbit, you don't want to be a rabbit, they're people that do nothing when they're
losing.
And that tends to be disastrous because you permanently pay capital sooner or later.
Others are very brave, they add to the position, very few professionals that work with the
hunters, because it's very difficult to do psychologically emotionally.
And assassin, assassin is when you're losing, you're down, I know, 20 to 40% of your side
cut run for the hill was get out.
So that's when you're losing.
When you're winning, people tend to fall into one of two tribes, which will be basically
a raider or a connoisseur.
Apparently, someone on this table is a raider.
I will say, I won't say heeled it.
But a raider is someone that takes their profits too soon and doesn't win big.
And the connoisseur is someone that basically who runs his winners and wins massively.
And in a nutshell, the whole point of the first book, The Art of Execution was basically
saying, all the fun, as I worked with the investor I worked with, the ones that were very
successful were connoisseurs when winning.
And basically, let's say we're assassins when losing, basically.
So cut your losers run your winners in simple terms.
Very, very easy to say.
Yes.
As anybody listening to this podcast will know, or run their own money, much, much more
difficult to do in practice.
So if we go to your new book, you have dedicated a chapter to individual experts, investors,
and how they run their money.
And I suppose the first thing I would be very interested in is talking about when things
are looking and going a bit wrong, like they are at the moment, you know, we're down
to 6.3% in our second year.
What stories have you got of people who have had similar, who have faced faced with this,
what would they be doing now?
And before you start, we just need you to sign that this isn't research for a third book.
Stop marketing monkeys or stop marketing monks.
Oh, dear.
I like that.
You can actually say that right now.
Okay, so it's publisher.
So I think this, okay.
So you got a miser, I'm losing, what should I do?
I'm winning, what should I do?
There are the two frames people are usually in, right?
I think the context of this discussion is pretty interesting because you come from position
where you're winning, and it's come off, right?
So it's that kind of position.
So I think the first thing I talk about is, you know, I've heard you talk about put imports
of fundamentals on why you invested.
So one of the managers in the book, Greg Badea, fantastic manager in the USA, he has this
acronym called Why Are We?
So why are we idiots?
So before he goes in anything, he'll have identified things that could trip him up.
So when if he's in a winning position, it starts coming off, the first thing he would
do, he would look through the short term noise and he'd look at his list, or any of the
things we're identified as risks, are they showing or not?
He's written that list down before he's invested.
Exactly.
So he can say, oh, this is risk five or risk eight or it was not my list.
Exactly.
And that's important because when you're in that state of losing, you're emotionally charged,
aren't you?
You're not necessarily going to think straight in the time, whereas when you did it at the
beginning, you got no money in the position, play a mind.
So that's one of the tricks he does together, another one which--
And sorry, Lee.
Yes.
When he's got the list, does he say, well, this should make me cut it, this one I'm okay
with?
It depends on the risk, you know, it might make him trim the position or get out, but
these are risks that they've highlighted.
And then it's, you know, if it does happen, what's the magnitude of it, what's the impact
on the thesis, the reason we go in and should we cut?
Yeah.
So that's what he does there.
So I'm going to get one more there.
So when he identifies those risks, does he actually, at the same time, when his mind
is free, you say, well, if that happened, I would cut my position or I would reduce
it or I would do something.
So when it does happen, it's a sort of formula for what is actually, or is it not as a
prescriptive?
Prescriptive, thank you.
Yeah.
It's systematic in terms of this happens get out, but basically if you've identified, if
he's identified the risk and it comes up, then obviously that, then they have the discussion
around the team when we flagged this risk, you know, as it's going on, it may discomfort
about it before.
Should we be, no, no, it's a reason.
Should we be very concerned?
Should we get out?
So, you know, that's the, I guess it's, is it a temporary phenomenon or is it something
that's more permanent?
If it's more permanent, then you probably want to sell out, that would be my instinct.
If it was something that you think, oh, well, you know, there's, there's a big wobbling
AI sort of going on at the moment.
I think that will run its course, therefore it's temporary, therefore should I buy more
or that sort of discussion, rather, I'm just going to sell because that risk has popped
up.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And this is, and then the book, because we've got 12 investors, you'll see they all have
different things that they look at to decide to, to help them decide should I stay
or should I go.
I mean, if we, if we look at it slightly differently, so he's got this, wow, we're looking at it.
Other people will handle it by adjusting the position size if they get concerned in a
certain way.
So, you know, one of the investors, you know, James Hambrey, for example, he's very good
at moving in an incremental fashion like Chris here, you know, he'll move in a little
piece, you know, half sent positions there, one, one and a half to, but he'll take position
up to 9% if he's really, you know, if he really believes in it, he's doing well, but
when he gets concerned, he'll dial the position down, but he won't go from 9 to nothing because
you're setting yourself up, make the wrong call there and hold your head doing all.
So what do we do?
I mean, to wait in a half, eight half to eight, and that's very clever because it takes
the emotion out of moving in the direction, you just feel you want to go without making
it a binary call.
And so he's really going to just adjusting his position size, reducing and increasing
in increments.
It doesn't, it's not binary, you know, you don't go, oh, this came out, should I stay
or should I go in one go, you know, and I think that's really interesting because that's,
we've talked about before.
We've all got to look at ourselves as to what we do well and what we don't do well, learn
what you do well, and when you find you don't do things well, stop doing them, right?
And that's a perfect example of what I do badly, which I haven't stopped doing, which
is that I will enter my position.
And then I'll say, oh, it's doing really good, oh, it's done really well.
And I'll sell too much as my first chunk.
So I might half or three quarter my position.
And then I can never bring myself to sell the last bit when it goes rocketing up because
I'm always too early.
It goes rocketing up further, but I won't sell anymore because I think, oh, God, I sold
that bit too much before.
So I'll stay with it just in case it's a 50 backer or 100 backer, but that means it's
gone up 50 times or a hundred times.
And then it turns around and comes back off and I said, why don't I sell the whole lot?
So it's affecting the emotion inside you.
So that's a useful thing.
I must, I'll try and learn from that one.
And you did actually have somebody that had a hundred backer on a stock that the original
position went up 100 times, didn't it?
Oh, yeah.
I mean, you're seeing the book we got because part of it is looking at, okay, how are you
able to stay in something that wins big?
You know, because most of us, for make a hundred percent, we're out, we'll make fifty
or a hundred percent.
We're out.
Yeah, we've got to say.
Five percent on.
Right.
At the moment.
And I'm the reader.
Exactly.
It's very hard to do.
And John Bar is the guy you're alluding to, I mean, you know, he's got names we talk about
in there where basically he's made a hundred times in, in, in, start you go, how is, and
the way he does it, but he's a small cap US major, but he, he, he starts very small in
his positions and builds and very slowly and gradually.
And that's important because he's, names to me, tend to be very volatile.
I mean, we talked about James Hambrey, legendary head from major in the global space.
And he's moving incrementally.
And actually, a, a good point of the importance of moving incrementally with what he does
is in the book that we talk about plus five hundred and it's a name in the UK where he's
made over six thousand, probably as we talked a lot more than six thousand, which is a hell
of a lot of money.
But if you look at a stock price of that, it's very volatile up down, so it, it moves around
a lot and most people get shaken out, you know, by, you know, they won't be able to ride
that.
How do you have that volatility?
And I think the way he does it is just so simple, but so genius, you know, just
incrementally move, you know, from, you know, by half percent positions every time up
and down.
And you can, you can weather the ride, you know, and that's how you win big.
That still feel you're doing something.
So you're not rabbit.
Exactly.
Exactly.
Yeah.
So, I'd point to those two, I mean, there's other things you, you can do.
I mean, do you talk to early about commodities and gold and things?
Well, you know, we've got John Lynn in the book from who's a chief investment officer in
other lines, Bernstein in China.
Now, what's interesting about that is, you know, a lot of times he will find himself investing
in cyclicals and commodities and obviously they have a very different ride to a structural
growth stock.
And because of the nature of those things, what he would do, he'll let the market tell
him when to get out and what, you know, so what would you mean by that?
He's sort of like, when a stock turns over and it's a, he's high, it's off 20%.
He knows it's cyclical.
He gets out.
[BLANK_AUDIO]
lot of people, they don't fathom their sequels, they tend to overextend either way up and down,
and that, you know, that's one of his geniuses in terms of how he's done so well.
But, you know, sequels are very hard to ride because of the nature of them and he's come up with
that approach, but that's very specific to those types of names. The real insight there is to
recognize the type of asset you're buying as to whether it's cyclical or whether it's a long-term
growth story or what it is because that will influence what you do. We've seen commodities
over the years, have that cycle of very low price, then zoom up, zoom up, zoom up, and then it's,
everybody's very bullish at that stage, and then of course it starts coming off again and people forget
it's cyclical, and they sit with it and it goes down, and it goes down, it goes down, and then in
70's time, or something, it picked it back up again, they make a lot of money out of it, but they sit
with it, and they hold it as a longer-term view rather than that cyclicality. So, that point is
another key point for people to remember. You know, there are some investments that are cyclical,
there are some that are absolutely fundamental long-term growth, and make sure you've thought
about that maybe when you go into it to make sure you know where you're going to be taking that
profit now. Exactly. Know the type of beast you're getting involved with and also know yourself as well,
which is another thing, I mean the reason why it's, you know, 12 investors in there is because there's
no right or wrong way to skin the cat, and what works for one, if you try to invent it yourself,
and you go against your nature, you won't be able to do it because you'd find yourself losing,
go, oh this guy usually does this, but if you can't, if it's not in you to do that, you're not
going to do it. So, you know, that's why we've got 12 investors, you can look at each of them as
to what helps them decide to stay or go, and hopefully something resonates and you can take
something from them. Yeah, that's really important, isn't it, because everybody listening and the
three of us sitting here, you've all got different personality traits, you've all got different
levels of ego and levels of humility, so you can't just read a book and copy a strategy, can you?
Adapting it to your own personality is something that comes through a lot in the book in each of
the 12 cases, isn't it? It's so important. I mean, I think it was James Hambrey actually said,
you know, you can't ape another person and start, and he's absolutely right. I mean, you've
got to make it your own, otherwise, the point where you need to do something, you're not going to
have to live with it, you know, if you've got a weak constitution, and the person in the book is,
you know, you're trying to be a hunter and throw more money at it, well, if you've lost a lot of
money, you're going to be going to feel sick doing that, you're not going to be able to follow
through, you're just not. The psychology investing is fascinating, and I think you'd like to say in
your first book, The Art of Investing, oh, that was a slip of the tongue, wasn't it? The Art of
Execution, an excellent book, and it's interesting, I know some my own traits, I'm someone who
I hate losing money and something, so I will cut, I will sell it out and get out completely,
so I'm an assassin, I'm just like, when I'm losing, I well, I wouldn't done with it, even though
in case in point we had India or in our portfolio, I was one of the people that an advocate went in,
and one of the advocates, well, I said, let's get out of it, and I'll just fed up with it being
down week in week out, and just psychologically it was weighing me, I'll just do my, you know,
Excel spreadsheet update and then down again and go, oh no, here we go again, we've probably sold
it virtually at the bottom actually, no problem at all, and it promptly bounced 10%, right?
But actually, you were the one who pointed out that's 10%, because me, I didn't even look at it again,
that was it, it was out my portfolio as far as I was concerned, I didn't even think about it,
and you know, that's just me clearing my head so I can then make a different investment decision.
But I think you've hit on something really poor, the power of clearing your mind to look at
something afresh, because I think, you know, we talked about in the past podcast, but you know,
if you had a blank piece of paper and you weren't investing something, could you put the money
in that idea today, oftentimes you'll go, no, so then you've got it, why am I in it? But actually,
in the book we share, we share like Andrew Hall invests go, really good global manager.
One of the things he'll do, if he's in a name that he likes, fundamentally likes, and it's done
really, really well, but he's got some concerns in the near term, maybe it's the valuation or whatever,
he will instead of getting out completely, because as you said, a lot of people want you out,
you don't want to look at it again, not least because it might have gone up, and then you have,
you know, regret aversion by a big time, you're like, oh, I don't know what my idiot.
So he would die right down to a very small position in his portfolio, then a key key is
able to keep his eye on it, but it's not doing any damage to your P&L, and you know, it makes,
you know, it's a good way of doing things, it calls it the farm team, you know, because it's like
hatchlings, if you like, but in that way, it also enables you to stay with long term investments,
that you've made a lot of money with, but in the short term, maybe you've got some concerns about,
so it's like, you know, it's similar way in James Humbery, you know, just slowly douse it down,
instead of making it a binary in or out, just gradually reduce it down to live with the near-term
pain to get through it. I mean, if you're wrong, you should cut, I mean, don't get wrong,
if you shouldn't be in, you've got to be a satin get out, you know.
And one of Andrew Hall's stories is in videos, isn't it?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. He was in it originally before most of us were.
Yeah, but then perhaps felt that he maybe cut it a bit too early.
Well, the story changed, right? I mean, he went to, when it was gaming companies and the chips
were gaming computers and PC consoles and stuff, so, but, you know, you got an update your thesis,
right? Which is what he did. You know, this has happened. How's it impact a thesis?
Do we like it? And obviously he did, so he stuck with it. I don't know where he's at today,
and in terms of, in terms of that name, but, well, actually, are you reminding me, I know that,
I mean, we've talked about James Humbery a few times, but he's got a good story for James Humbery in
his book. He's got a company called Plug Power, and we're going to what it does or whatever,
but it is a fascinating. He went in it, and then all of a sudden, he's in it for a normal reason,
and then he goes parabolic share price, and he realises he's in a bubble. Yeah.
But he's also, he's also learned from all the good and the great that if you're in a bubble,
you've got to, you've got to kind of make it pay you, right? You've got to, you know, some,
you know, some people go, you're right, get the hell out. Oh, it's gone up parabolic, get that.
So he had to figure out, well, how do I, how do I play this? And what he decided,
which is not his usual way of doing things, but he decided, I'm going to adopt a 15%
trailing stop in his name. And by doing that, having a simple rule, which is, you know,
he made 3,000% in it in a short space of time, when the 15% training loss was hit,
since then, the stocks down 90%. Yeah. Having a plan, I think, is the key thing, right? Even if you find
yourself in an unexpected situation, sit back, a bit like Andrew Hauded, what does this mean?
A bit like James and what do we mean? What are we going to do? And have a sort of think about
how you're going to play the game. Don't just be passive because you don't want to be a rabbit,
you don't want to be a raider because, you know, they definitely don't want to be either of those
things. How do they stop themselves staying in too long? You know, because, you know, and I think
the good thing about this sort of conversation is we can talk about with our portfolio,
because we've got a portfolio. People can see we've had a portfolio, we can see what we've done,
you can see when we've taken our profits. Spices already talked about India as a perfect example.
But we identified back in March, April, May, there were bubble-like tendency at a number of things.
Right. Whatever it was. Gold, silver, if you remember, back in January, February, time,
and other stuff like that. Now, the temptation then is to say, and we laugh about this many times,
is different this time. Right. And I think if we were in hindsight, we were listening back,
I think there wasn't been that going on. But we'll resist that for the moment. At the end of
the day, when do you say, or how do they say, and then you give them one example, the 15%,
what are the other stories? How do you say, do you know what? I'm sticking with it. It's done something. I'm out now. And I'm not letting the fundamentals
drive me. I'm not letting that steer my mind. I'm just out. Okay. Well, that's a great point,
because the whole point of this book is trying to get the nuance. So what is it that helps
some people decide to stay or go? Well, I'll give you a few examples. I'll give you a few examples.
So if we go to the US, there's a fantastic hedge manager called Josh Goldberg's in the book,
a phenomenal investor. He has a 50 month rule. And he goes, what's his 50 month rule? He's
realized, when he's analyzed all his data over time, that he makes most of his money, like 10X,
when we're talking about talking a bit about 10X in 50 months. And if he holds on after that, he tends
to, he tends to round trip and he gives it back. And he learned that by my co-author on book,
clearly in Levy Hurfer, my central analytics, he worked with them to find out the strengths of
weakness. And then he discovered this 50 month rule. It's going, that's interesting. And he
implemented it. So for him, you know, as he gets near the 50 month rule, he's thinking it's time
to get out or dial down, but he's looked at his own data. And does it make sense in way invests,
looking at earnings, he's got an earnings revision space approach, so it's a momentumy kind
approach. I've heard it made sense. For other people, Dirk Enderline, who, you know, best growth
marriage in Europe, you're at full stock, close to new money, you'd love to give new money, but he's
got waiting list as long as he's on. So he's a growth guy. So you look at growth. And I discuss
with him, valuation, because, you know, value growth, sort of growth manager, you know, it's never
seen to be a valuation. I mean, and he does a lot of work in terms of this company, where is it
traded? Historically, it's trading range from valuation perspectives. So assuming your point,
fundamental is a fine, nothing there to make you stay or go. So you can't look at that. What is it,
is it? And you're not looking at price, what is it? So for him, he's just going to say, oh,
this name, it might trade on two times the market. That's how his language, it was talked about two
times the market, three times. So two times marks in order for this company's history. Two times,
there's just, that's just about the clear. So are you saying two times the market multiple?
Yes. So if the market is a 16 times, it trades in a range of X to 32, let's say, two times.
If it trades outside that. Yeah. So if it trades outside that, he'll start to get concerned,
because it will look at that company, it'll look at its industry and other names, and he'll go,
it's always trades two times, so it's expensive. And people shorten it again, so he won't be,
But if he sees it, two and a half.
half-time earnings, he'll go, it's never treated that high.
So at that point, he may dial it right down or get out.
And I think throwing that in there,
'cause it's quite interesting,
'cause usually for a growth manager like him,
he's usually fundamentals or the earning story
that's gonna persuade him one way or the other,
but even he has a, this is getting a bit rich,
we need to do something.
So there are a couple of examples I'd throw in there.
- I mean, this is what I think is the really important thing.
I mean, we all think different things are important clearly,
and that 'cause we said it was independent
in the way they think.
But to me, the big issue is where you sell.
I'm fairly confident that most of the things I buy
are going to work at some stage.
They may not work immediately, fully accept that,
maybe you can send us a hunter and rice and more.
But over time, they're going to work.
It's when do you sell them?
Now, we're all only up here.
January, February, March time.
I was looking, we sat in this podcast,
I was saying, look how extended these are
relative to their moving averages,
which is where I looked at it,
which is the same thing as saying,
have this valuation, or it's the 15 month rule, whatever.
And we sold some, but because I sold a lot,
I never sold the last bit.
And of course, the market then went even higher,
and then crashed.
And so there is a perfect example for everybody here,
valuation doesn't tell you, in my view, went to sell,
because you get emotionally caught up in it.
And I think my friend, opposite me,
would say that when it comes to the AI trade,
he's been very, very right about it the whole way,
but it can start to clear your judgment.
It's never time to sell.
And you never sell it.
- Well, there's an old saying,
valuations don't matter until they matter.
- Yeah, yeah.
- So growth investor particularly would go,
I don't care, I'll pay 100 times, 300, 300.
It doesn't matter till someone wakes up in the morning,
go, oh my God, this should be on 10 times,
and then the whole thing collapses.
But it's more than just one person doing.
You need to have that sort of animal effect
and going on to it.
And that's where I think the psychology is really important,
but I think also one thing you bring out in the book,
which I think is really interesting,
and it came out in both of your books,
is that actually the best investors
don't have the massive hit rate,
so they don't get 90% of decisions right.
It's only just over 50% if I remember right.
- Four, four, nine and a half.
- That's less than 50%.
- Yeah, yeah.
But what they do is they get the positions that they have,
they get the best positions in the biggest size.
They make the most money by sizing it correctly.
And that I think is the lesson that we should all learn,
that if you think, you know,
this might be your strongest idea,
and you then getting evidence that it is becoming
your strongest idea,
and you get that fundamental to begin to work in your favor,
then make it a big position, yeah.
Be prepared to add to it.
And I think your old friend George Soros,
that was one of his traits, wasn't it,
that he, you know, if he really liked the position,
he backed up the trap, you know.
He was not, he was actually a hunter in that he would always add
into the position he fundamentally believed in.
There was no way he would do anything else.
But in the first stages of any trade,
he could quickly change his fundamental view.
It was only when it started to move a long way away
from where he bought it, where it re-inforted his fundamentally.
So I saw him trade the Euro dollar rate,
and I saw him trade that way three or four times
in a day, once in enormous size, put on a trade,
went against him.
I've got this completely wrong.
I'm useless, he's going around the dining room.
I'm absolutely useless.
I don't know what I'm talking about.
Can't my positions go the other way?
And literally, back out again to him,
he said, I was absolutely right to start with.
And I'm throwing them all back.
And that's your, that's clearing your mind,
and it's about that sizing.
So let's go to this counseling point,
'cause I'm really interested in this gathering point, right?
I have already said that I think the cell discipline
is the critical piece.
And I'm going to ask my colleagues here,
what is their cell discipline?
Right?
Yeah, interesting.
Okay, so I'm fairly sure I know where Richie's is.
I'm not sure I know where Spice is.
So this will be quite interesting to hear the answer to that,
because I think that's what's critical for most people
to do a great job.
When people get greedy, it is as simple as that
when everybody's cheering about their wins
and celebrating and popping the champagne corks.
And they're saying that this can keep on going,
then that's me, I'm out.
And what sign are you looking for that, Rich?
Because you can say about those things.
I told you, but can you identify sort of a light bulb?
Well, we've identified it in the past
that it's the front page of the economist.
And I've got a story about that in a moment.
Well, it's something classic like that.
It's the Maryland Fund Manager survey.
You know, that everybody's bullish and equities are going higher.
It's when analysts come out,
we're ridiculous ratings.
Beard capital came out this week
and cut their Nvidia price target from 500 to 200.
Wow.
What on earth was it doing up at $500?
That's a $10 trillion market cap.
It was ridiculous.
So when I started to see things like that,
that's just nonsensical.
So when you see that, that's your sort of look,
start to look at that for that trigger.
Let's not get sucked in, Spice, we're about yourself.
Yeah, I mean, the old saying, if the taxi driver turns around
to you and said, oh, I should buy a few of these
and you've got them in your portfolio,
you should probably go straight back to the office and sell them.
In fact, ring them on your mobile, get out there and then.
Because that's happened to me before.
As Chris will know, we had an example we went to hotel
and I in the big position is something.
And the dormant said, oh, so, you know,
I've got this particular stock and isn't it doing well?
And that was probably about the top of it, actually,
almost within a week or so.
Yeah, but I think, you know, if fundamentals change,
that's the thing I look for, something's really changed.
I think the market's grappling with this a little bit
at the moment.
Yes, the AI bubble and a lot of that's been washed out.
Not these stocks down 40%, 50% if not more.
I'm certainly from their highs.
But, you know, I think the market's grappling a little bit
with the moment about the interest rate backdrop
because we've talked on this podcast a number of times.
You know, if we're in about six months,
the market was probably still looking for flat
to maybe one interest rate cut.
And now we're looking for three interest rate rises
in the US and this meeting on the 9th of December
in less than two weeks time, you have a situation
where basically you've got the expectations
have been winging around between, sort of,
are they going to keep it flat?
How are they going to put one interest rate rise
through another as a quarter of a percent?
Well, they're going to do double that and do a half percent rise.
And then the last week or so, it's gone from being,
you know, sort of zero to one quarter of a percent rise
to now half percent is sort of the odds of moving that
and the federal officials are talking about it.
And that's wobbled market investors,
and particularly areas that are sensitive to interest rates
like long duration stocks, which are typically growth stocks
that are heavily in the NASDAQ, AI, all these sort of things.
And then people have been grappling with that, you know,
but that's now maybe that we're all talking about it
is in the price, maybe there's an opportunity there.
And when we come to talk about what we've done
before earlier, that's important.
But I think if you get something, if that really changes,
you said, oh my God, they're going to do five interest
rate rises in the next six months,
then fundamentally that is a big change.
And therefore, I would want to take some of those big positions
that are exposed to that off and sort of, you know,
and panic a little bit if you like.
And the only time, am I my personal best investor,
my best investment ever was I bought a company
called Acorn Computers.
And in that, that owns the BBC computer.
And there was a little--
- If you're showing your age here.
- Exactly.
And that, and that's right, had a--
- That's why it's way enough.
- How did you trip it that?
- That jumper.
- It became arm holdings,
which became the UK's biggest and most successful
and arguably still is the UK's biggest and most successful
growth company.
And I hold it from Acorn Computers at about 17 P.
And about that, oh, '96, '97, I started buying it
in the year '96, '97, '97, and I sold it in April 2000.
And it got to sort of 10 pounds 50, I think.
And I sold it 25% down in a day,
when it had fallen 25% in the teeth of the tech bubble bursting
and selling off.
And I sold it, and I think I ended up buying it back
at about a pound sort of a year and a half later.
But I was prepared to go, oh my God,
it's the whole, everything's changed.
Everything has changed.
And that was a time just to shut your eyes and get out.
- Just based on what you two said,
you're probably have something an interesting story
from Gorma Tomasson in the book,
who's a CIO of AKO capital.
Now, this is a award-winning hedge fund guy's legend, right?
I mean, everyone knows him, well, in the city.
- No, it doesn't. - We are in the same place.
(laughing)
- So he's a legend.
But combining two things you said,
when things get frothy and speculative
and have the fundamentals change,
if you work for him, he has this fantastic screen,
which if you're an analyst or a fund manager,
it pops upon you on your piece of screen saying,
"Are you feeling lucky, punk?"
There, if you're not like me, make my day.
- Make my day.
So, and the point of this is,
if he's invested in something in short term,
the share price has gone up a lot.
So it's moved, re-rate, it's gone up a lot.
The point of that is to say, "Should we be worried?"
"Should we take some profit from this?
Should we reduce the position or not?
"Is this justified by fundamentals?"
And engage forces of conversation.
And then they have a conversation.
And I love that idea because it's a recognition of,
could be speculation going on here?
What's the fundamentals like?
Do we need to reduce it?
Do we stick with it?
What do we do?
And it's simple, but it's beautiful, you know?
So I love that.
- One of his stocks was just deep, wasn't it?
He managed it out as the US growth field.
- Yeah, and that was again, because he had his thesis
and he had his risk things that he'd identified.
And that was one of the things.
So, you knew when to get out.
- Make your money move with IG.
With zero commission and no annual fees,
back your next move with IG.
Don't look the app and get started.
IG, trade, invest, progress.
- Let's return to our majestic portfolio
and how that's doing at the moment.
Now, I mean, maybe I'm wrong here, but I think of ourselves as in the eyes of many of
our listeners, we're changing our portfolio once a week at maximum, we're probably not
changing each week, but we're changing, that's when we can change it.
We can't be active in and out the whole time, like most professional investors, so we
have our hands tied a little bit by what we can do.
And so we have a situation where the portfolio is down 6% to the second year, and really
we're getting to the stage where we've got to say, you know, what should we be doing
with that position?
We've added a little bit on the way down, so we're not quite rabbits, but, you know,
are we going to turn into hunters, or are we going to turn into assassins?
And I think that's a very, if that is where we are.
So for people listening who want to translation, are we going to cut out quite a lot, saying,
we've got it wrong, clear the decks, get our minds set, or do we believe the story
is strong, and therefore we should be buying more, so we lower our entry prices.
First of all, do you think that's the sensible way for us to look at it?
Are we missing something from your understanding?
And then I'm going to give my view on what Rich was saying about the columnist from pages,
because I think that's a very interesting situation going on.
Yeah, so I think it's entirely the right way of looking at things, but I'd reframe it
in terms of what we're looking at, you're looking at your portfolio today.
You know, simple, blank piece of paper, and just go by each position.
Would we have that position today?
If yes, what size?
That will kind of tell you one way you should cut it or not, and secondly, have you got
the right size?
It's such a simple, blank piece of paper test, but it's a good way.
I mean, I had that discussion with my, you know, when I was a fan manager, I imagined
a team.
I'd get you going there and you'd go, you know, if I was giving you the, you know, 100
millions of managers for me today, would you buy it today?
And it's amazing, the amount of times you go, well, probably not, and you got a strong
hold.
There's the broker, there's the broker in him.
I've been asked that question, trust me, like, well, I think it's a strong hold.
But it's, but it's, but it's so simple and powerful.
So that's a test, I, you know, it's a simple test that we do straight here today is, you
know, just go, go, go through each name you hold.
Would you hold it there?
Yes or no?
If you, if you see, yes, is that the right way to think, you know, making sure they take
out all the bias from the emotions that they've been clinging on to with the position?
Yeah, because every position in there is going to have a profit or loss next to it, which
will influence the way you play the game, which is the whole point in my books were to try
to teach people out, which is how you react when you're winning and losing determines your
success.
And when you're losing going to be in a losing frame of mind, you're going to be impacted
by something, cost bias and diamond bias, all these wonderful things that impact you and
screw you up, basically.
And the same when you're winning, you know, you know, there's a disposition fact prospect
here, which makes you take profits too soon.
So being aware that having money in the game does cloud your mind, particularly when you're
going through a difficult patch, you know, that's why it's important having a plan
before you go in knowing what you're doing, certain environments.
But if not that, blank piece of paper test, try to be honest with yourself in case a good
exercise.
I think this is a good time quickly, just to ask you, if you were taking our list, there's
for example, and all into into a room, could you teach them a sort of basic framework
of how to think, you know, forgetting, you know, that they've got to put their own personality
and choose certain things.
But would you be able to do that?
Holding lots of cats.
That's true.
I mean, the reason for the second book is a price, you can do anything.
But it's a treat, but the reason for the second book is the first book, he's like, you
know, here's these five tribes, when you're losing, don't be a rabbit and do nothing, be
a hunter or a satin.
But then had people approach me saying, I'm losing and I should do something and I can't
decide where to stay or go and, you know, to your point, Chris earlier, whatever I do,
if I stay in a bit of the wrong thing, if I could be the wrong thing and I regret it.
So it's a regret a virgin bias.
So you can teach these general principles, but the reason for the second book is people
want more than that.
The one insights is do something that helped them trigger them to stay or go.
So they know what the generally should do, but then it's, I can't, I need a bit more.
So each, they can look at each of these investors in the book, called 11 and 12 of them and
just say, well, this guy, what persuaded him to act at that point or just stay at that
point?
And everyone's got their own way of doing things.
So there's no right or wrong way.
You've got to do what's right for you, but the general rule is, cut your losses and
run your winners.
If you embrace losses, you're going to permanently pay your capital and you're going to lose
over long term.
So maybe that's a good exercise for next week, a sheet of paper with all our positions
on it.
I think we should just talk about the portfolio with Lee here as well, given that we have
a market that's moving around a lot, we've just had the NVIDIA numbers come out.
They've done pretty well.
We've got an anthropic coming on tomorrow, the Thursday.
And I've been searching around thinking, well, what should one do here?
Personally, what, what are my views and my views is to be the hunter.
I'd much rather be a hunter here.
If I was training every minute of the day, then maybe I would be a assassin and I would
cut some positions, but I can't do that.
That's not what we're doing in this job.
So let's stick to the fact that that's where we are.
And I think there's been some really important developments, literally in the last 24 hours,
which I just want to share with everybody.
The first important development is that those who were at Lords will remember, we on our
live podcast did a discussion on what are the signals that the market's got a bit perky.
And I can't put my hand up, say, that was my area and I got that right.
Of course, I didn't do any about it, but I smashed it on the day, but one of the things
we mentioned was the front page of the FT or the economist.
And we, I mentioned at the time, you had Chuck Prince of City Group back in 2007 saying,
well, as long as the music playing, you've got to get up and dance.
We're still dancing, ding, ding, ding, top, ding, ding, ding.
And then of course, you had Goldman Sachs saying, we're doing God's work in November 2009,
which was another example.
Now I talked to that, that LiveVed about was there signed in with the front page of the
economist in September, has Jensen Wang on it, CEO of Nvidia titled the Sorcerer of
Silicon.
And I said, the Long Bells are ringing in our live podcast, we were absolutely right.
Yeah.
Well, I've got another one to add.
This week's economist has, and now I'm going to try and describe it, but if you can go
on the internet, we're going to on screen.
There's a big A and a big I, and the bottom of the A and the I have fallen out, money's
collapsing and Jensen Wang's falling out.
And it says, why you should expect an AI crash.
Now I have to say, given what I said before, and given what we all believe, if that isn't
a signal that everybody wants to get out of AI has got out, and now everybody thinks
it's attractive to start talking about the end of AI, ie, that's where their positions
are.
I don't know what is.
So that, to me, is a very bullish thing to see.
Can I add to that?
Because the Bank of America, Merrill Lynch, do a fund managers survey every month.
And the one from October, which was, they were asked about a week ago, so it's actually
quite real time.
But what, you know, the ideal sort of situation.
And these fund managers, there's nearly 200 of them, I think, they run about 460 billion
pounds of assets.
The biggest move in October was that they've seen the biggest reduction in technology exposure
in their portfolios for 20 years, right?
And they've gone from a 37% overweight to position back in sort of September.
They're now just net 12% overweight.
So they're still a little bit overweight, but they've had the biggest cut for 20 years.
And exactly at the same time, Jensen Wangles is a job, and Chris points out that the economist
is running an article saying AI is over, because they still say the biggest tail risk is an
AI bubble, which we've had, I suspect.
And I would add to it, Chris, so I've spoken about when I like to sell.
And, you know, I've been the bearish and the cautious one and, you know, somewhat boring
as well, especially for my age having so much in non-risk, let's see.
But it's times like this I start to get excited.
And this is when my bullish horns come out, and I look at the blood on the streets, and
the fear out there, and the performance and, like, spices described there, and the fun
man is a surveying you have in the front page of the economist.
But also in the rates world, right?
We've gone from expecting three interest rate cuts to five rate increases.
And this is when I start to pick things up, and I would be interested to go specifically
for the semiconductor ETF this week, and get money into that as well as adding to copper.
Wow.
So you see, use that opportunity to get those buy ideas in, you know, always important
to get in there first before the people, with spices, I was going to sell copper today.
Now he's going, oh, no, no, no, no, no, no, it's okay.
That's the way the Maestro is doing apparently.
Yeah.
So, so, in fairness, there were two other things in that survey, which I'm, what spice
says absolute right, biggest fall, the record fall since 2006, that's 20 years.
Now, that does age is a little, but, you know, I can remember 2006, but that's
a huge fall. 38% of respondents to the survey felt companies are over investing in AI,
which is a record. So more people now think they're over investing than they have ever
done, which is another body sign to me. While a whopping 52% of investors think at least
one hyperscaler will cut capex in the next six months. So expecting cuts in capex, they're
over investing and they're reducing their overweight massively in AI and we've got the economists
lined up as well. The only thing against our portfolio, the only thing against our portfolio,
you'll know me, I've mentioned this before, the other headlong is a little bit more worrying
is that there's a record 23% of people who think gold is undervalued. So people are longer
gold than no doubt about it and getting caught. So that doesn't help our portfolio, but
we're only small in that. We've got black, black world mining, which has some in there,
but it doesn't matter. We've only got a small piece if we can add to that. So it's clear
to me, it's time to do some more stuff in our portfolio and we have some cash there,
sitting there at 15% of the portfolio and I think we should be putting 5% into the market.
We just keep doing it a little bit at the time, 5% this week. Now interestingly, you've
put your sum share with copper and you've got your assumptions also with the semiconductor
index. I don't know enough about semiconductor index, so I can't say that. I was thinking
about NASDAQ, which is very similar in the sense that if that works, NASDAQ will work,
but clearly it'll be less aggressive form or actually another way you would be to put
some more in Japan. Japan actually has done pretty well this week and it's responded
well when NASDAQ has done quite well. So I'm actually looking at the relative strengths
of Japan and that hasn't hurt us so much, but I think it will do well if the AI trade
picks up here. Spice, why don't you give us your thoughts? Don't be influenced by the
fact that we're saying by 5% or what we're saying, what do you think?
Because I'm a good big, I'm a good 10% in, so you're 10% in this week.
Morgan Stanley, who I know slouches be fair to them, basically going limit long in their
model portfolios of equities this week. In fact, that was announced yesterday. Now, I
think we've all expressed it in different ways, but there has been a huge drawdown in
the AI trade. The bubble in my mind has burst. I mean, it's already bursting. In videos
on 9 times P on fantastic numbers and they're buying 150 billion extra shares by the
stream that got lots of cash. So to me, I think you've got to go, you've got to go hunting
in that area of the market that has been sold off aggressively. So how aggressively do
we want to do that? Is the only question. If you want to the chicken's trade, you probably
go by the S&P 500, which has probably got 30 plus percent in technology in AI and all
that sort of area. Well, you go NASDAQ, which is near 50%, 60%. So that's less of a chicken
trade or you go full in. I was going to say something like that, which would be cut out,
full of balls in, which is 98% AI, which goes, you know, semiconductor index exposure,
like the Philadelphia S&P, that's all the global S&P's SEMI as the secure. So, you know,
but again, going back to one of these lessons in his book, it's all about sizing. So if
I were sizing those positions, I would go and buy 10% of the S&P 500 or I'd go and buy
5% NASDAQ or I'd buy 2.5% of the SEMI conductor ETF. And that would be my relative sizing because
the SEMI conductor index could move 5, 6% in a day without, without, no, no, but it does
it regularly. So, you know, we could be seeing it next week. It could be down to valet.
Exactly. It could be down 25% this time next week. But there again, it could be up 25%.
But you have to size it accordingly. So I'm, I'm, I'm hopefully learned from our
counsellor over there, Lee, that the sizing is important. That's the way I would size it.
He's a voice will be in the boat. Yeah. But I did, I do think we need to be in that space
because it has been so oversold in my opinion. And you don't think Japan is just another
way of trade. It's another way of doing that trade. I mean, I think Japan, if you look
at the Nikkei and NASDAQ, they're moving pretty much in sync as is the emerging markets.
The emerging markets being weighed down by China being a real drag on it. Now, when we added
to our emerging markets last week, we put a two and a half percent into emerging markets.
We added to our Japan last week as well. And we added to gold. That's, so we put seven
and a half percent in because we had 22 and a half percent cash last week. And we moved
that down to 15, as you say. So I would personally, like, say, that I would go America
were and or big semis and go for it. I specifically looked at Nvidia exposure. I want
the highest percentage of Nvidia exposure. We don't do single stocks with the semi-conductors
I get 7.9% Nvidia with NASDAQ, I think it's under seven. And then with the S and P, it's
only about 6%. So Japan, I get none. That's that was my choice there.
I suppose the difficulty for me is if I buy, I'm quite tempted by the semi because, you
know, Rich Rich has got a good strong view on it. And I want back the guys, I think,
you know, a rise in their spaces, Rich has always been good at that sort of calling.
It's how much you want to put in it, given how volatile it is. And maybe you want to put
two and a half in rather than a bigger position. You know, if it moves, if it's 5%, and it moves
up up and down 5, it's quarter, that's quarter percent of the fund each time it does that.
You might do regard that as too heavy. But what would you pair it with because just buying
two and a half percent isn't really finishing off our exposure in my book. That's why I
come with someone like Japan, where Japan is more broader, and it's not just the air trade.
It's other things as well. And what I've liked is the way it's come back and held and
hasn't done terribly. I can't buy a merger market. I can't buy copper because copper
is 7.5% fund already. But why don't you buy another just by 2.5%
more in Japan? That would take us to 12.5% because we added to it last week. We're effectively
averaging down, which is not all bad necessarily. And I think the highest position we have had
in Japan, I think was 12.5%. We took it all the way down to 7.5. We've gone to 10, so
12.5. I would actually push back. I would argue for 5% in the semis because we've sat on 25%
cash for this exact reason. Now we've seen the sale off. If you listen to Collette
Cress on the call last night, remember she knows best because she's had TSMC in her offices
in the past week. She's spoken to all their suppliers. She's spoken to all their customers.
She knows what the demand outlook is like, and her demand is much bigger than her supply
can keep up with. So AI is not going anywhere. And the share prices have already gone where
I feel that they've gone and they've overshot. And we knew that they overshot on the upside
and this is the more we shouldn't and they don't say.
So my sort of view is that if we're going to do 5 in semis, I wouldn't do anything else.
I would stick with that. So let's do that. Let's stick with 5 in semis. Let's say we're
going to add 5 in semis, we'll put the details in the podcast of the exact thing that
we're buying in the podcast notes. And we'll take that 5% out of the cash position.
Before we close, remind us what your book's called.
Stop marketing, Maestro.
For everybody who wants that book, I'm sure we can have another signed copy, which for
people who write in and amuse us the best, but if you don't want to do that, you can just
buy a local bookstore. And thank you so much, Lea, for coming in today.
No, thank you for coming. It's been a pleasure.
It's insightful, as ever. And it was nice. We had Claire, your co-author on Claire Flynn-Levy,
not that long ago. So it's great. Thank you.
Fantastic. So big reveal, one Amazon.
Yep, everywhere. Oh, you're all booked.
All your best bookstores.
Yeah, excellent. Well, we look forward to seeing us going up in the next couple of weeks.
Thank you very much for joining us this week, and remind us to leave us a review if possible.
Please, there's still time yet to get the entries in for the Good Money Guide awards as well
that we are nominated for details in the show notes as well.
And Gents, I feel we'll be getting a few emails this week. Where should people write
into?
The art of investing at IG dot com.
Let's see how this emigods. I feel like I'm going to be under the cost. It goes
wrong.
Join us next week to find out.
And to see where Anthropic is trading.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Lee Freeman Shore returns to discuss investor behavior during market downturns, drawing on insights from his new book *Stop Market Maestros*.
The book analyzes 12 top investors’ decisions when winning or losing, highlighting how they manage risk and exit strategies.
A key lesson is the importance of pre-defined risk triggers and disciplined exit rules—such as trailing stops or time-based rules—rather than emotional reactions.
Investors should recognize the difference between cyclical assets and long-term growth stocks, adjusting their strategies accordingly.
Successful investors don’t rely on perfect timing or hit rates; instead, they maximize returns by sizing positions correctly and staying in strong fundamentals.
Psychological discipline is critical
Case studies from investors like Josh Goldberg (50-month rule) and Dirk Enderline (valuation thresholds) show how systematic approaches improve decision-making.
The episode emphasizes that even seasoned investors must adapt personal styles to their psychology, avoiding behaviors like over-leveraging or premature exits.
Summary:
This episode features Lee Freeman Shore, author of *The Art of Execution* and *Stop Market Maestros*, reflecting on investor behavior during market volatility. The discussion centers on how top investors manage wins and losses, using real-world examples to illustrate disciplined strategies. Key lessons include identifying pre-defined risk triggers, such as trailing stops or time-based rules, to prevent emotional decision-making.
Investors are encouraged to distinguish between cyclical and fundamental assets, adjusting their positions accordingly. The core insight is that success isn’t about predicting the market perfectly but about managing position size wisely and exiting at the right time. Shore highlights that top performers don’t rely on high hit rates but instead focus on sizing their best ideas correctly and maintaining mental discipline.
Emotional triggers—like analyst downgrades, speculative headlines, or market sentiment shifts—are emphasized as early warning signs for profit-taking. Examples from investors like Josh Goldberg and Dirk Enderline demonstrate how structured rules improve consistency. The episode concludes by urging listeners to assess their own investing psychology, recognizing that success requires adapting strategies to personal traits, not blindly copying others.
The portfolio’s recent underperformance underscores the need for such self-awareness and disciplined exit behavior.
FAQs
The book identifies five investor types: rabbits (who do nothing when losing), hunters (who add to positions when winning), assassins (who exit when losing), raiders (who take profits too early), and connoisseurs (who let winners grow significantly).
A defined exit strategy helps investors avoid emotional decisions, prevents overexposure to risk, and ensures alignment with long-term goals—especially during market downturns when panic is common.
Josh Goldberg uses a 50-month rule: if a position has performed well over 50 months, he reduces exposure to avoid 'round-trip' losses, even if the fundamental case remains strong.
Adjusting position size—like reducing by small increments—helps investors maintain discipline, avoid extreme emotional reactions, and gradually adapt to changing market conditions without making binary in-or-out decisions.
Cyclical assets have predictable price swings and cycles, so investors should let market signals guide exits. Growth stocks, by contrast, are long-term bets and require patience and fundamental reassessment before exiting.
Psychological discipline ensures investors don't react emotionally to short-term noise, avoid chasing trends, and stick to a pre-defined plan—such as reducing exposure when fundamentals change or valuation becomes excessive.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.