Miley Cyrus rose to fame as Hannah Montana, a role that positioned her as a wholesome, faith-based teen icon under Disney. However, her early career was marred by controversy over provocative photos and leaked images, which drew intense criticism from conservative media and fans. These incidents, combined with public scrutiny and pressure to avoid being perceived as like Britney Spears or Lindsay Lohan, led to a significant crisis of image. In response, Disney and Miley’s team promoted a sanitized narrative through her autobiography, emphasizing her faith, purity, and moral integrity. The story also highlights her relationship with Nick Jonas, which was framed as pure and religious, though later contradicted by leaked photos. A pivotal moment came when she co-starred in The Last Song with Liam Hemsworth, sparking a romantic relationship that brought both acclaim and personal conflict, especially when Liam’s girlfriend publicly objected. The episode illustrates the intense societal pressure placed on young celebrities to maintain an idealized image, often at odds with their evolving identities. Alongside the Miley Cyrus narrative, the transcript features brief mentions of Bumble’s safety features and Bunnings’ support of the "Share the Dignities" campaign, which provides essential items to women and girls facing homelessness or domestic violence. The overall narrative reflects on how fame, media, and cultural expectations shape the lives of young stars, particularly those from conservative backgrounds.
Guys, dating doesn't have to be scary, it can actually be low pressure and fun,
you just need the right support and that's where Bumble comes in.
There are a few great features I want to call out, the ID and selfie verification,
which lets you date with safety and confidence and the feedback prompt.
Think of the last one like your wingman, it helps you figure out how to
best curate your profile and prompts without having to pester your friends.
Download Bumble today to make your move.
Thank you so much to Bumble for making this episode of Shameless Possible.
Guys, at this time of the year, group chats around the country are saying they want
to do something meaningful at Christmas and make the most of the festive spirit.
Well, we have just the thing.
For the 10th year running, Bunnings is supporting share the dignities,
it's in the bag appeal, which provides essential items to women and girls
experiencing homelessness or domestic violence.
This November, you're invited to fill a new or good condition bag with new
and unopened essentials like shampoo, soap, toothpaste and period products
then drop it into your local Bunnings between November 6th and 22nd.
Get the group chat involved and visit sharethedignity.org.au for the full packing checklist
or go to the Bunnings website and buy a pre-packed bag for just $25.
Thank you so much to Bunnings for making this episode of Shameless Possible.
But don't see, yeah, you can call it a clear.
Miley Cyrus became famous for playing Hannah Montana, a girl living a double life.
Only in the real world when she was still just a teenager,
Miley found herself straddling two different worlds,
child stardom and adulthood.
Welcome to Scandal from Shameless Podcast, the stories of the biggest celebrity
controversies revisited.
Hello, Zara Mcdonald.
Hello, Michelle Andrews.
I am so excited for this new series.
Guys, we are doing a three-parter
on the many scandals that have rocked Miley Cyrus's life.
And boy, oh boy, there are a few we need to cover.
Yeah, well, this has been quite the mammoth undertaking, hasn't it?
Sifting through the stuff that Miley has been through,
has been pretty extraordinary.
And I think again, like any big life and any big career,
it was a challenge for us to sort through what we cared about,
what to cover, what was important, because there is so much.
I mean, I know we said there was a heap in Taylor Swift
and there was a heap in Taylor Swift,
but there was almost just as much, if not more,
in the life and career of Miley Cyrus.
It's insane.
Yeah, I think we also, Zara, feel a certain connection to this story,
because we grew up with Miley Cyrus.
I was a big Disney channel kid.
I know you didn't have Foxtail.
RIP. And watching Hannah Montana was one of my real highlights
of my childhood at that time.
It was the show that I would watch with my sisters.
And there was just something about it.
There was something about the way Disney marketed Hannah Montana,
something about Miley Cyrus as its central star
that just made it a rocket ship of a kid show.
It's an incredible premise of a show.
So clever. I know we will get 12 in a second,
but I think I didn't have, I didn't have Foxtail as I say it.
I agree with you.
But I did watch the show somehow.
I must have just caught episodes here and there.
But the thing about this show is when I kind of stripped it all back,
I was like, what a beautiful premise for a television show
that young teenagers, particularly young teenage girls,
are just totally going to get behind.
Yeah.
It's like everybody's stupid little dream
and they packaged it into a television show
that was just glitzy and fun and it was amazing.
And I agree with you, given that Miley was born in 1992,
she's two years older than you and I.
We've really kind of lived this in real time,
watching her try to kind of break the shackles
of Disney's stardom, become an quote unquote adult,
I guess, in the eyes of the public.
And there were a few missteps along the way, as we know.
Missteps that she's acknowledged too.
Yeah, absolutely.
You mentioned it just then.
Miley Cyrus was born in 1992.
So what other year to head back to, guys?
We are rewinding, let's go to Franklin Tennessee in 1992.
Alrighty, Mish.
So Miley Cyrus was born on November 23, 1992,
as you say, in Franklin, Tennessee,
to her mum, Latisha, known as Tish, of course,
Cyrus and her dad, Billy Ray.
Yeah, now growing up, Miley was surrounded by fame.
Her dad, Billy Ray Cyrus, I'm sure most of the listeners
tuning into this will know this very very well,
was a '90s country music star.
He was best known for his signature song, A He Breaky Heart,
which isn't my favorite song.
I'll put it out there, but that's okay.
That did reach number one on the Hot Country Songs Chart.
And, fun fact, was Australia's best selling single in 1991?
Yeah, so it's a popular tune, that's for sure.
Deli Parton, as well, was or is still Miley Cyrus's godmother.
Now, Miley's parents had actually both been married
before they met each other.
Her mum had two kids named Brandy
and Trace from a previous relationship,
while her dad also had a son called Christopher.
Now, this story or this element of the story
is a little bit scandalous, if I may,
because Christopher was born to a woman who got pregnant
six months before Tish got pregnant.
So he had two women who were pregnant at the same time.
This was also when Tish was pregnant with Miley.
So you can imagine at the height of his fame,
Billie Ray Cyrus is accidentally, or deliberately, who knows,
got two women pregnant, but he ended up marrying Tish.
Yeah, he did.
They weren't married at the time that Tish got pregnant,
but after Miley was born soon thereafter,
they did get married.
Miley was sort of a middle child.
She had this kind of blended family.
And after she was born, Tish and Billie Ray
went on to have a son they named Bracen
and a daughter they named Noah.
Noah Cyrus is obviously quite famous now.
For the first eight or so years of Miley's life,
she lived with her family on a farm
just outside of Nashville with horses and cows and chickens.
If you didn't know as well, Miley Cyrus
wasn't actually born Miley Cyrus.
The name on her birth certificate was Destiny Hope Cyrus
until she actually got it legally changed in 2008.
Now, what's quite interesting about this
is the quotes from Billie Ray
about why they chose the name Destiny Hope for Miley.
He once said, "I had a vision, a dream."
I said, "My intuition has told me that the little girl,
her name should be Destiny Hope Cyrus
because I feel like it's her destiny to bring hope to the world."
I don't want to laugh at Billie Ray Cyrus,
but as people will learn,
he's got some interesting quotes on the record.
And this quote did come in a particularly,
dare I say, intriguing interview
where there was lots of interesting quotes like this.
So yes, Destiny Hope wasn't to be though.
It was not to be.
Now, according to Miley, as soon as she was born,
she was given the nickname Smiley
and then Smiley Miley.
And then later on, Miley,
no one ever really referred to her as Destiny.
So her name was legally changed
when she was just a kid in 2008.
Nazara, how did Miley get into acting?
Yes, so she was nine years old when she realized,
I mean, this is according to the family,
these stories are always sort of take with the grain of salt.
That she wanted to pursue a career in acting.
It was early 2001.
And Billie Ray had actually been working in acting himself.
So he'd been working in Toronto,
shooting a TV medical drama called Doc.
And after a few years of traveling back and forth,
Miley's mum relocated the family to Canada
for about a year to be closer to Billie Ray.
Their Miley was homeschooled
and there she apparently fell in love with being on set.
Yeah, she later explained,
being around the TV show set so much,
I absorbed a little bit about filming,
how the camera blocking worked,
what it meant when they said cut,
how important it was to be quiet.
Now while living in Canada,
Miley actually started working with a music coach,
she took singing and acting classes.
And as she later told a reporter, she wanted to,
and I quote, make myself better
because I really wanted to take it seriously.
And I didn't want people to think
that I was just getting a break because of my dad.
So from the age of nine,
she started scoring like a string of small acting jobs.
She had a small part on her dad's show Doc,
the one we just mentioned.
She appeared in a commercial,
she scored a pretty tiny spot in the Tim Burton film Big Fish.
And interestingly, she auditioned but was rejected
from the adventures of Shark Boy and Larva Girl,
which was just huge at the time.
And a few other roles.
The family, as we said,
only lasted about a year in Toronto
and then they moved back to Tennessee.
Yeah, and that brings us to the moment
when Miley Cyrus became Hannah Montana.
It was 2004 and Miley was just 11 years old
when she got a call from a talent agent
who'd taken an interest in her.
Now Disney had actually asked this agent
to send tapes through of all the girls they represented
between the ages of 11 and 16
for a show they were making about a team girl
named Chloe Stewart,
who was secretly a pop star named Hannah Montana.
Now Disney wanted Miley to send a tape
of her reading for a part,
but that part was not for Hannah Montana,
slash Chloe Stewart.
The part was for the character's best friend named Lily.
Yeah, so Miley sent in the tape and Disney called back
and when they called back,
they said they actually wanted her to read
for the part of Hannah Montana.
Now, the day after she sent in the second audition tape,
she got an email from Disney saying,
"Actually, you're too young and too small to play Hannah."
Miley later said.
My dad said, "Disney just made a big mistake.
My intuition tells me that you are Hannah Montana."
(laughing)
This is what this intuition really writes intuition comes in and out of the views on this.
I'll show you that one.
How strong can your intuition be if you like this girl's name is Justin and you hope
and that that is never even.
Yeah, that you rename her yourself.
Not long later though, Disney did ring back.
This time they decided they wanted Miley to come to LA and audition for Hannah in person.
So clearly some flip-flopping around as to what exactly they wanted for this show.
She, as we now know, ended up getting the part of Hannah Montana.
She actually beat out the likes of Gossip Girl's Taylor Momsen to do it.
Yeah, what a blast from the past there.
The creators of Hannah Montana also ended up changing the lead character's name to Miley
Stewart to make the number of different names attached to Miley a little less confusing,
which actually seems like a very clever and well thought out decision to have Miley Cyrus,
Miley Stewart and Hannah Montana, rather than Miley Cyrus, Chloe Stewart and Hannah Montana.
Like for a 12 or 13 year old watching that show, that is a lot to consume.
Yeah, I think it's such a small decision, but such a pivotal one in the brand of building
Miley Cyrus for sure.
It was so funny, though, because when I was a kid watching this, I always thought that it
was the world's biggest coincidence.
But who cares the name was Miley?
And their name was Miley Cyrus?
And I was like, it's not a common name.
Not long after Miley flew to LA so that she could be in the room while Disney auditioned
other actors, particularly for the part of her best friend Lilly and her dad.
Now if you read Miley Cyrus' autobiography, which we will talk about later in this episode,
Miley's mum got friendly with some of the casting people and joked that they should bring
in Billy Ray Cyrus to play Miley's dad on the show.
Now according to your autobiography, it was all very above board, he auditioned with
a bunch of other actors and just happened to get the part.
Yeah, exactly.
Now while her family were concerned that people might think Miley had only scored the lead
because of her famous dad, Miley said that they had actually been, and I quote, "praying
for a way to keep the family together."
And he was the crazy, completely unexpected solution.
We deal with the rumors of who got what part first later.
For now, we were just psyched to be in the same country.
Let's unpack this.
What do you actually think happened here?
Because if I'm putting my analytical hat on, I think on the balance of probability, the
most likely thing is that Miley Cyrus was cast as Hannah Montana, but Disney did give
them a bit of a nudged nudge to say, "And we'd love the star power of Billy Ray Cyrus
on top."
Yeah, or it could have worked the other way in that Billy Ray and Tish were like, "Yeah,
Miley can do this at this young age, but perhaps it would be good to have a parental eye
of his whole thing."
Yeah.
That's how acting experienced, in some way or another, they have been branded as a package
deal to Disney.
Yes.
There is no doubt about that.
What is interesting, though, is that years later, Billy Ray came out and said that he
only took the role to support his daughter and was paid pretty poorly for it considering
how big of a show it was.
He said, "I knew I was working for peanuts.
I'm not the smartest man in the world, but I know the difference.
I went from $12,000 a week to, after four years in the millions that they make, $15,000
a week, hell yeah," he said pretty psychastically.
"I'm intrigued by this because that is still a bit of money."
It's peanuts apparently.
Yeah, but his wording is a bit funky here, isn't it?
And I agree, perhaps maybe his pay rise should have been a bit higher, but Billy Ray is
in no way the star of that show.
Like, he could have, dare I say, he could have sort of been phased out of that show and
he don't think many people would have really cared.
No, not towards the end.
I also am picturing all the Hannah Montana episodes I ever watched and I'm just seeing Billy
Ray standing in the kitchen behind their island bench.
I feel like he was just in that one spot the entire series he did not move.
Yeah, so it's still good money, especially when you kids making heaps of money.
Look at how 15 grand a week you're kidding, that's not peanuts to anyone.
Now, fast forward to 2006, and at this point in the story, Miley is 13 years old.
And in March, her show, Hannah Montana, was premiering to what turned out to be the largest
audience for a Disney Channel program ever.
And so Disney had already turned a number of teen actors like Hillary Duff, Raven Simone,
and Dylan and Colse Brouse into huge stars.
And just like them, Miley quickly rose to fame.
The morning after the premiere, Miley said that her and her aunt had gone to an amusement
park where a group of 13-year-old girls ran up to her and asked her for her autograph.
She said, "That was the moment when I realized that Hannah Montana wasn't just a new job
I loved.
And people out there watching us, real people who recognized me on the street.
And I wasn't just Miley Cyrus anymore, I was carrying Miley Stewart and Hannah Montana
around with me."
Now, by the end of that year, 2006, Walt Disney Records released its first Hannah Montana
soundtrack, which topped the Billboard 200 chart in the U.S. and went on to sell over
3 million copies worldwide.
Miley wasn't just a child actor anymore, she was a certified pop star.
The songs were catchy.
They were very catchy.
Incredible.
Now, in 2006, Miley actually started dating Nick Jonas.
He was a fellow Disney star.
He was also 13.
This feels like this.
Incredibly young.
Yeah, I completely forgot that these two were linked in any way.
Yeah, me too.
And I think what's really, really fascinating about the pairing, I guess, of Miley and Nick,
whether it was a publicity relationship or whether it was a real one is how it was packaged
and sold to the world.
Because publicly, they told everyone that her and Nick bonded over their strong religious
faith, like it felt like the perfect Disney pairing for the network.
Miley later wrote that she told Nick, "I'm a hardcore Christian to which he replied,
'That's what we call ourselves in my family.'
Now, Miley and the Jonas brothers all famously wore purity rings as well, which for essentially
rings that indicated that they had made a promise to God to wait until marriage until
they had sex.
The Jonas brothers actually started wearing them after joining a Chastity program called
True Love Waits."
Miley herself was pretty public about her decision to wear a purity ring.
She spoke to TV guide around this time and said, "I like to think of myself as the girl
that no one can get, that no one can keep in their hand.
Even at my age, a lot of girls are starting to fall.
And I think if staying a virgin is a commitment girls make, that's great."
I want to have a really quick little interlude here about virginity and about purity rings
and how they will lack the cornerstone of the Disney brand because for a time there
so many Disney stars wore one, wore a purity ring, and with hindsight, it feels incredibly
bizarre, doesn't it?
Yeah, absolutely.
We didn't only just have Miley and the Jonas brothers.
We also had likes, Selena Gomez and Hillary Duff being very public and vocal about their
purity rings as well.
This was a movement.
The purity ring movement was massive in the late 1990s over in America and it's interesting
because when you kind of have a bird's eye view on this time, when you have what, 10,
20 years of hindsight to look back, you can kind of see how pop culture and politics ran
in parallel lines to each other.
So this purity ring movement actually coincided with a huge national rollout of abstinence
or only sex education in American schools.
Now this was all under a banner that they called community-based abstinence education.
Yeah, it was a big sort of part of Bush's presidency, right, this idea that like no sex,
not even like a conversation around sex, it's just like a virginity is everything.
Now this kind of abstinence education program was effectively an effort to curb concerns
around and we quote, "Team pregnancy and illegitimacy."
Now, there is a really interesting piece in Jezebel that was written in 2018 that will
pop a link in our show notes where they interviewed a woman called Sarah Moslanar who is the
author of "Virgination" and she said, "The purity movement was about conservative evangelicals
keeping access to political power and it was young people, sexually pure young people
who could best make that case."
And with that kind of hindsight, this whole thing gets a pretty dark sort of feeling to
it because you've got these young teen stars who are pawns to a political movement.
Yeah, absolutely.
Now we know that by 2008, so two years after Miley Cyrus and Nick Jonas were dating, Barack
Obama did win the election and more liberal approaches to sex were broadly adopted culturally.
His 2010 budget actually eliminated federal funding for abstinence-only sex education.
And in the final budget of his administration, he elected to eliminate abstinence-only program
funding completely.
So what we saw was, when Bush was in power, all of our major Disney stars were pushing
purity rings.
But in the 2010s, when we had a more progressive president in Barack Obama take power, Disney
stars like Zendaya weren't telling their fans to put on purity rings.
She was actually giving quotes to the media saying that sex was fine as long as you did
it safely and that you sought and gave consent and got regular STI checks.
A huge flick of the switch, like an insane flick of the switch.
And just such an interesting moment in time.
So this brings us now to 2007 when Miley had become, as Time magazine put it, America's
biggest kids superstar, with the popularity of Hannah Montana.
The magazine wrote that Disney had even overtaken Nickelodeon to become the most watch cable
channel in prime time.
It was around this time that Miley made moves to start establishing her own brand outside
of Hannah Montana as well.
So in 2007, she released a second album called Hannah Montana 2 Meet Miley Cyrus, which
contains
two CDs. One of the CDs had songs performed by Inquisition Marks, Hannah Montana. The other
CD had songs performed by Miley Cyrus. Yeah, the album once again was a huge success. And Miley
took over the one and only Kelly Clarkson to top the Billboard 200. Now, in October that year,
she embarked on her first concert to a performing as Hannah Montana and Miley Cyrus. I feel like
those concerts were totally iconic as well. The concert sold out in minutes and the vice president
of Ticketmaster told the LA Times at the time, people who have been in this business for a long time
are watching what's happening and they say there hasn't been a demand of this level or intensity
since the Beatles or Elvis. You really can't overstate what Miley's influence and power was at this time.
Yeah, it was crazy. During this tour, Miley was joined by the Jonas Brothers and it was also
around this time that she and Nick Jonas ended their relationship. Zara, we're going to talk a little
bit more about the scandals that surrounded Miley Cyrus and Nick Jonas, but all of that will be
coming up after the break. For the 10th year running, Bunnings is supporting Share the Dignities. It's
in the bag appeal, which provides essential items to women and girls experiencing homelessness
or domestic violence. This November, you're invited to fill a new or good condition bag with new
and unopened essentials like shampoo, soap, toothpaste and period products and drop it into your
local Bunnings between November 6 and 22. Alrighty, Mish, let's fast forward to April 2008 and this was when Miley was hit with her first
sort of major scandal. At this point in the story, her career was going from strength to strength.
She was just 15 years old. She had already starred in two seasons of Hannah Montana. She was the
youngest performer to have two number one albums within 12 months and she was telling the world at this
point in time that she hadn't had a day off since Christmas 2006. Yeah, a ridiculously grueling
schedule. Now, the New York Times reported that sales for the Hannah Montana franchise were totaling
about a billion dollars. A major motion picture based on the series was already in the works and
Miley had just signed a seven figure book deal for her autobiography. Condé Nast Portfolio magazine
estimated that she was on track to be worth a billion dollars personally by the age of 18.
So that year, Miley did this photo shoot for Vanity Fair with the very famous photographer,
Annie Leibovitz. And if you remember our episode on Fleetwood Mac, Annie was of course the one
who took that iconic photo of the band lying in bed all together. So it would be fair to say that
this photo shoot was artistically a pretty cool opportunity and a signal at the time that Miley
was a huge deal. Yeah, she was being taken seriously by everyone in the industry. But some did
criticize the photos that Annie Leibovitz did take of Miley Cyrus for Vanity Fair and called them
too provocative and sexualizing for a girl who was just 15 at the time. I think people had a
point as well looking back on this in one photo, the main photo that people were sharing around.
Miley was crouching down. She had a bedsheet held up to her naked body and was kind of covering
her chest and turning to look at the camera. You could say this is a very sexual photo of a girl
who was too young to be sexualized. Yeah, and it was on the cover of the magazine too. And it was
just everywhere, like it was an incredibly big deal. What happened at the same time is that there
were some other photos that came out of Miley online. Now, the Associated Press reported that and
I quote, "less than wholesome photos of a girl bearing a close resemblance to that of the 15
year old superstar were making the rounds on the internet." One photo showed someone who looked
like Miley pulling at the front of her singlet top to show her green bra, another photo showed her
laying across a guy's lap, her midriff exposed. Now, these were hardly the most scandalous
photos in the world, but both of these scandals walked in parallel to each other coming at the
same time. Rolling Stone explained, though, that even though these weren't the most scandalous
photos of all time, they were a big deal for and I quote, "this squeaky clean brand of a rising
Disney star." Yeah, it's also worth noting that the media's coverage of this photo controversy
was really gross in parts. TMZ's reporting on that photo leak, in particular, is really difficult
to read. Their article red as follows. "Holy Hannah's Montana's picks of the scruffy voiced
fast-talking 15 year old, flashing her bit parts and making her best jailbait sexy face
have popped up on the internet again." While she's not shaving her head yet,
Miley Cyrus might want to slow her tractor trailer roll on the road to Spearsville.
Like, this is a 15-year-old. Now, the combination of the leaked photos and the vanity fair shots
sparked backlash, particularly from conservatives and Christians. And truthfully, this was a big
part of the target audience of the show. Not only was Miley on the Disney channel, but she and her
family were from Tennessee. Her dad was a country music star. Like, these are the people they
need the support of. Conservative commentator Bill O'Reilly, who hosted the O'Reilly Factor,
blamed Miley's dad, Billy Ray, for this photo scandal. He said that Billy Ray had put her,
and I quote, "into a situation where she became at 15 a sex symbol. Middle America, they don't
like this." He was also joined by a spokesperson for the Christian Coalition of America,
who told Us Magazine that Disney should reprimand Miley. They said, "If she's going to go out there
and represent wholesome values, she needs to be more accountable for her actions."
The New York Post even made this story their front page news with huge block letters
that yelled Miley's shame. As if that pressure on a teenager wasn't enough,
the New York Times published an article under the headline, "Revealing photo threatens
a major Disney franchise." So, the New York Post and the New York Times are talking about
the vanity fair photo. Some other people are disappointed in the photo leak, and both of these
things compounding together just created a huge shit storm. Yeah, it's like if you had had
one of these scandals happen separately to everything else going on, it would have been like a
flash in a pen and then it would have gone away. But because you had vanity fair and this kind of
teenage risk photo leak happened within the same weeks of each other, it just exploded beyond
anyone's comprehension. Now, Miley did have to come out with a statement in People Magazine where
she apologized profusely for the photos. She said, "My goal in my music and my acting was always
to make people happy. For vanity fair, I was so honored and thrilled to be working with Annie.
I took part in a photo shoot that was supposed to be artistic and now seeing the photographs
and reading the story, I feel so embarrassed." Yeah, she went on. The pictures of me on the internet
were silly inappropriate shots. I appreciate all the support of my fans and hope they understand
that along the way I am going to make mistakes and I am not perfect. I never intended for any of
this to happen and I am truly sorry if I have disappointed anyone. Most of all, I have let myself
down. I will learn from my mistakes and trust my support team, my family and my faith will guide
me through life's journey. It's really hard to read a 15 year old apologizing to adults this
way. Like, I've let myself down. I'm so sorry to anyone who I've disappointed. Like, you're a
fucking child. Shouldn't we all be disappointed in the adults who made this happen?
Also that line, I will learn from my mistakes and trust my support team as if your support team
hasn't been the one to put you in these scenarios the whole time. Disney also came out with a
statement at the time which read, "Unfortunately, as the article suggests, a situation was created
to deliberately manipulate a 15 year old in order to sell magazines." So suddenly Disney's
there wiping their hands clean of this being like this had nothing to do with us.
Yeah, in a statement to the New York Times, a spokesperson for Vanity Fair and the photographer
Annie Leibovitz said that Miley's parents and minders were on the set all day. The quote reads,
"Since the photo is taken digitally, they saw it on the shoot and everyone thought it was a beautiful
and natural portrait of Miley." I think just as a blanket rule, if you're asking a teenager to
strip off their clothing and cover themselves with something, you've crossed a line. Like,
teenagers get to keep their clothes on, adults do not get to tell teenagers to take anything off.
Interestingly, Miley came out 10 years after the incident and retracted her initial apology.
She tweeted a photo of that New York post cover which said Miley's shame and said,
"I am not sorry, fuck you, hashtag 10 years ago." Now, that Vanity Fair article, like what was
written in the article, also added fuel to the fire of this controversy. This article opened with
Miley saying that her favorite TV show was Sex and the City and comparing Hannah Montana
to the show that we all know from the 90s and 90s that put sex on the map. She said,
"Obviously not the scenarios, but if you watch Sex and the City, like the way the friends are,
the way that it's dry and they all have distinct characters, that's the thing we try to do on Hannah
Montana." That show and every other show. Miley also later had to issue a statement about this clarifying
that she only watched the edited video.
version of Sex and the City that aired on the network, TBS, which didn't have nudity
or explicit dialogue. I didn't quite realize the cage that she was living in at this time,
like to not even be able to say at 15 that you watched Sex and the City because there
was sex or explicit language on there is pretty incredible.
It's almost like the expectation of conservatives on Miley Cyrus was not only are you supposed
to be completely pure and asexual, you're not even supposed to know that sex exists
or find any interest in sex.
Yeah, exactly. Now on top of the controversial elements of the profile, there were some
really interesting parts of the piece that detailed how much pressure there is on young
Disney stars to not end up like Britney Spears. There is a quite a common thread here
in a lot of the early stories about Miley Cyrus being there, oh, don't end up like Britney,
which have not aged very well, dare I say. To more specifically quote the journalist
in the piece, Miley was living in an era and I quote, "when every underage actress in
Hollywood is stalked by the ghost of Britney Future, and that with Lindsay Lohan rehabbed
and Britney Spears under psychiatric care, the tabloids are looking to Cyrus to flame
out or at least do something mildly outrageous."
Yeah, in this profile, Miley gave some really interesting quotes about it. She said, "I think
most 21 to 25-year-olds go through this kind of thing. It's not just on the platform,
you know what I mean. Basically, they're being normal 21-year-olds, especially Lindsay.
I mean, most of that's pretty normal. If you went to most high schools, I could point out
Britney's and Lindsay's. She also said that she knew both stars and that she had talked
to them from time to time. The reporter wrote of this, "It's another thing I can't imagine
her mind is at Disney Want to Hear."
Yeah, but Miley went on. I guess that's why I'm so adamant about the Britney's and Lindsay's
and whatever, because I know those people and they have good hearts and they're struggling.
She gave those quotes at 15, at a time when the tabloids and the press were so nasty to Lindsay
Lohan and Britney Spears and had a real complete ignorance about what it meant to be struggling
with mental health. There is Miley Cyrus being like, "But these are human beings and they
have great hearts and they're struggling."
Yeah, being the only compassionate person in the room, really.
Yeah, exactly. Now, what I think is really interesting about this point in time is again,
how much pressure was on Miley Cyrus given how Hannah Montana was Disney's biggest moneymaker.
People were so concerned that this could spell the end of the franchise. These photos
could spell the end of the franchise. That the New York Times interviews several Wall
Street analysts about whether the scandal would impact Disney's profit margins. Now, the
analysts came back and said, "Probably not one scandal. They will be okay." But imagine
15 knowing the New York Times interviewing Wall Street analysts about the future of a franchise
because a photo has been leaked of you or you've posed for a vanity fair photo where everybody
else in the room has nodded and told you it's okay. Yeah, it's just an insane amount of pressure
to put on a young girl. Now, despite all of this going on in the media, Miley was doing really
well in her career. In June, she released her own album Breakout, which meant she was taking
a further step towards defining herself as an artist outside of Hannah Montana. That album
topped the Billboard charts once again. Yeah, in same levels of success, this young,
but then a month later, after the album and just as things were starting to cool down
from the vanity fair photo shoot, a new round of personal photos hacked from Miley's accounts
hit the internet. Now, Michelle, they included a selfie taken from above that showed her standing
in her underwear and pulling up her shirt to reveal her stomach and another selfie that was taken
from above of Miley standing in a bikini in a pool, a photo of her blowing a kiss into a mirror
with her shirt tucked up again and a photo of her in the shower wearing a white t-shirt.
Things that most 15 year olds or 16 year olds would have on their computer or in their email
accounts at some time, like yes, they are a little raunchy. To most 15 and 16 year olds experiment
with a little bit of raunchiness? Yes. Yeah, she was just like any other kid. It's just that in one
of the images, Miley was reportedly wearing a necklace with the name Nick J. And according to
Rolling Stone, these photos were ones that Miley had sent to Nick Jonas, not quite what Disney would
want, not when they're wearing purity rings on their fingers. This isn't what Disney would have
wanted for two of their most conservative stars. So, given these photos on the internet, despite
the fact that Miley and Nick had broken up at least a year prior, Disney had to get their PR
machine in overdrive and they did what they do best. They got to curating this story.
Yeah, in March 2009, which was about nine or so months after these photos broke or leaked,
I should say, Disney's publishing division published Miley Cyrus's autobiography.
She wrote it with a ghost writer when she was 15 and it was released when she was 16.
It was called Miley's To Go. Now, Michelle, this book was a very specific angle on Miley's life.
That angle was that she was a good Christian American girl. It was expressed with stories of
her upbringing were poems, photographs, even her favorite quotes from the Bible. The book sold more
than two million copies and topped the New York Times children's bestseller list.
Yeah. To give you an idea, even more of an idea of what this book was like, we'll read you a
passage from the blurb. Almost overnight, Miley would rock it to superstardom, but coming a television
and singing phenomenon. Quiet days were replaced with sold out concerts, television appearances,
and magazine shoots. But through it all, Miley has remained close to her family and friends and
has stayed connected to the southern roots that made her so strong. So Disney's going for something.
They've clearly observed all of these photo controversies. They've observed the commentary
that maybe Miley and Nick were a little more progressive with their teenage relationship than what
the purity rings would have us believe. And they are trying to rewrite the record.
Absolutely. The book also made an effort to reinforce the importance of Miley's commitment
to her virginity as well. The book read, the press might make fun of some people for wearing
purity rings, but I don't pay attention to that. They can think what they want. I have my morals,
exclamation mark. I also have my faith to my career choices. I want to be a good role model.
Now, she also spoke of her relationship with Nick Jonas in this incredibly wholesome,
like if a little juvenile way. In fact, she referred to him not by name,
but by the moniker of Prince Charming. Prince Charming. Here's a passage from Miley's autobiography
about that relationship. It felt like the whole world stopped. Nothing else mattered.
I know it sounds silly, but my family doesn't set rules around love. My mommy met her husband
on a Monday and they got married on Friday. They were together for 27 years. My mom doesn't
believe that there's such a thing as being too young or too naive to be in love. In my family,
when you fall in love, that's it. No one called a puppy love or made fun of me. He really was
my Prince Charming and I knew it right away. It's really important to remind the listeners
here as well that Miley and Nick weren't a thing anymore. We had already mentioned it. They'd
broken up well before this book came out, but they were clearly trying to rewrite the record,
as you say, and rewrite this relationship to remind people that, yes, don't worry, this was still
pure in the way that we promised you it was. I think it's also really important for people to
remember the kind of Miley Cyrus we saw under the Disney umbrella. This was the Miley that was
known for her trademark dimples, her long, bouncy, curly, brunette hair. She was always wearing lots of
big chunky earrings and bracelets and necklaces. She was known for wearing long dresses over jeans
on the red carpet. This was Disney Miley and Disney Miley was that very like wholesome Christian girl
and Disney needed to maintain that to keep selling all of the various products associated with
the franchise. Yeah, exactly. So at this point in time, you could argue that yes, Miley's career
was absolutely on an upwards trajectory, but I think with any young female that is marred by
any kind of scandal that has to do with the her body or her sex, you could say her reputation
is the perfect, shiny, pure Disney actress had been slightly eroded out, not completely, but we
always have like a little asterix next to women, or in this case, a teenager who finds themselves
in headlines like this. In 2009, new episodes for season three of Hannah Montana came out on Disney,
and in April that year, Hannah Montana the movie was released in cinemas. It was a huge success
and brought in more than $79 million at the box office. That was also the year that Miley started
to work on the film adaptation of the popular Nicholas Sparks novel, The Last Song. Probably my favorite
movie for my teenage years. Amazing. According to Miley's autobiography, Nicholas knew her family
and actually wrote that book with Miley in mind to play the lead character. The book wasn't even finished
when Miley began shooting for the film. At that time, Miley was mostly known for playing Hannah
Montana, which was set to begin airing its final season, so The Last Song was another major step
towards her adult career. Yeah, and if you haven't seen the film wherever you've been,
but it is about a rebellious teenage girl who goes to stay with her divorced father by the beach.
It's while she's there that she falls in love with a guy from a rich family, she finds out her
father is spoiler alert, dying of cancer and writes a song in his honor hence the name of the film.
The reason it was so significant for Miley though wasn't just the career stuff. It was also the fact
that she would meet a guy that she
who would end up dating on and off for the next decade of her life,
a relatively unknown Aussie actor at that point, Zara,
by the name of Liam Hemsworth.
Yeah, now at this point in his career, Liam is 19 years old.
And as you say, Mish, pretty relatively unknown.
He was born and raised in Melbourne before he and his family relocated
to Philip Island when he was 11.
I think the Hemsworths always managed to remind people.
Either the Hemsworth remind people that they moved to Philip Island
or the press are obsessed with reminding ourselves that they are from Philip Island.
Well, I'm just obsessed that the world is so tiny.
Like we always talk about the world being big,
but it is really quite small that in an episode all about Hollywood,
we're mentioning a bloke from Philip Island.
Yeah, exactly. I'm obsessed with it.
Now, he had guest roles on home in a way and McLeod's daughters.
He appeared on 25 episodes of Neighbors.
He also reportedly auditioned for the role of Thor,
but ultimately that went to his older brother Chris.
Now, according to Harper's Bazaar, the last song
really marked a turning point in Liam's career.
He'd only been in LA for about five weeks when he received the script.
He went in and auditioned with the director and producer
and a week later read with Miley.
Initially, Miley said that she wasn't that keen to work with Liam.
She told 17 magazine, "So I heard a rumor that he didn't want the role.
And so when he came into addition for the role,
I'm there thinking here's this guy.
He's amazingly good-looking, super confident.
And he doesn't realize how blessed he is to be in this room
because I know how blessed I am.
This is such a big opportunity for both of us."
And I was thinking, "Oh, gross, you know.
Then I started talking with him and he was just the most genuinely precious sweet person.
And the second audition comes around and the chemistry was instant.
From the time he walked in that door and we saw each other again,
we both lit up and we were excited to get to work and learn together."
Now, Liam was not the original pick for the role in the last song.
In an interview with Sunday today, he said,
"Originally, they cast another kid and it didn't work out with him.
My agent calls me whispering.
He's like, 'All right, you've got to go to Disney right now.
It's not working out with the other guy.
You've got to go in and read with Miley again."
Once he arrived, Liam said that everyone seemed happy about his return.
And he said, "I come in and everyone starts clapping."
They're like, "We should have gone with him first."
Liam said that he and Miley grew close while working together on set.
"We really enjoy being together there.
We spent every day together in Georgia.
And we were pretty much each other's only friends down there.
It is kind of hard not to become close."
By August 2009, at People Magazine,
popped the pair making out at a Nashville Airport,
writing, "It looks like Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth
are more than just friendly co-stars."
Only things weren't absolutely seamless
when it came to Miley and Liam getting together,
because reportedly, back here in Australia,
Liam's girlfriend of five years Laura wasn't exactly stoked.
Yeah, we know about this,
because Laura did an exclusive interview with Woman's Day,
the same month those pap shots came out in the media.
The article in Woman's Day had a huge headline
that read, "Miley Cyrus stole my boyfriend."
Now, poor Laura said that she had met Liam Hemsworth
at high school in Phillip Island.
And I quote, "He was my boyfriend and my best friend.
There is no other reason why we would have broken up."
That would be shattering.
Watching him go to Hollywood and just move on.
In an interview with Seventeen Magazine that year,
Miley said of her relationship with Liam,
"All you want is for one person to say,
you did a really good job today or you look really beautiful
or I was really moved by that.
You just want one person to make you feel good
about something you're doing.
Liam has been a big part of that."
So in August 2009, things in Miley Cyrus' life were pretty great.
She was super successful, famous, rich,
and freshly in love.
Only guys within the next two years,
Miley would finish up her work with Disney.
A video of her smoking a bong would end up on the internet.
Her dad would file for divorce,
and she would work on a global stage with Robin Thick.
She would also swing around on a wrecking ball,
cut her hair, dye up blonde,
and cover her body in tattoos, and that
is the reimagining of Miley Cyrus.
But that is also coming next week.
Next week, guys, thank you so much for sticking with us
until the end of this episode.
Episode two is going to be a big one.
Yeah, I think people will know exactly the kind of stuff
we're about to cover on episode two,
because this was a really incredible time
in Miley Cyrus' life.
But we will get there as we say next Monday.
In the meantime, if you want to support the show,
head to our TikTok account.
We are there at Shameless_Podcast.
We will have little snippets from the episode
there for you to watch.
What else can they do?
Oh, follow us on Instagram while you're at it.
At ShamelessPodcast, we will pop up a gallery
of Miley Cyrus through this time.
And I'm very excited for these galleries, Zara,
because I think the galleries that fit the years
of each episode we're doing
will look completely different to one another.
Yeah, 100%.
This episode was researched by Justine Landers to Hanley.
Guys, thank you so much for listening.
As always, we will be back in your ears on Thursday
for another pop culture app.
That's right. Bye, guys.
Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Miley Cyrus gained fame as Hannah Montana, a role that launched her into stardom and redefined her public image as a wholesome, Christian-driven teen icon.
The show faced early controversy over provocative photos and leaked images, sparking backlash from conservative groups and media, which questioned her innocence and youth.
Disney and Miley’s family worked to reframe her image through her autobiography, emphasizing faith, purity, and a wholesome upbringing to counter public scrutiny.
Miley’s relationship with Nick Jonas was publicly framed as pure and devout, but later challenged by leaked photos and shifting cultural norms around teen sexuality.
Her collaboration with Liam Hemsworth on The Last Song marked a turning point in her career and personal life, leading to a high-profile relationship that sparked personal and public drama.
The episode highlights how young celebrities are under immense pressure to conform to conservative ideals, often at the expense of personal freedom and authenticity.
Bumble and Bunnings are featured as supporting brands, promoting social connection and community service during the festive season.
The narrative reveals how Miley Cyrus evolved from a Disney-era innocent icon to a complex, rebellious artist navigating fame, identity, and personal boundaries.
Summary:
Miley Cyrus rose to fame as Hannah Montana, a role that positioned her as a wholesome, faith-based teen icon under Disney. However, her early career was marred by controversy over provocative photos and leaked images, which drew intense criticism from conservative media and fans. These incidents, combined with public scrutiny and pressure to avoid being perceived as like Britney Spears or Lindsay Lohan, led to a significant crisis of image.
In response, Disney and Miley’s team promoted a sanitized narrative through her autobiography, emphasizing her faith, purity, and moral integrity. The story also highlights her relationship with Nick Jonas, which was framed as pure and religious, though later contradicted by leaked photos. A pivotal moment came when she co-starred in The Last Song with Liam Hemsworth, sparking a romantic relationship that brought both acclaim and personal conflict, especially when Liam’s girlfriend publicly objected.
The episode illustrates the intense societal pressure placed on young celebrities to maintain an idealized image, often at odds with their evolving identities. Alongside the Miley Cyrus narrative, the transcript features brief mentions of Bumble’s safety features and Bunnings’ support of the "Share the Dignities" campaign, which provides essential items to women and girls facing homelessness or domestic violence. The overall narrative reflects on how fame, media, and cultural expectations shape the lives of young stars, particularly those from conservative backgrounds.
FAQs
Bumble's ID and selfie verification helps users date with greater safety and confidence by confirming identities and reducing the risk of scams or meetups with strangers.
The feedback prompt acts like a wingman, helping users evaluate their profile and interactions without having to ask friends, allowing for more thoughtful and authentic profile curation.
For 10 years, Bunnings has supported the 'Share the Dignity' appeal, which provides essential items like shampoo, soap, and period products to women and girls experiencing homelessness or domestic violence.
People can fill a new or good-condition bag with unopened essentials like shampoo, soap, toothpaste, and period products and drop it off at their local Bunnings between November 6 and 22.
Miley Cyrus was born as Destiny Hope Cyrus on her birth certificate, and her name was legally changed to Miley Cyrus in 2008.
Miley was initially considered for the role of Lily, the best friend of Chloe Stewart, but Disney later changed their mind and offered her the role of Hannah Montana after she auditioned in person.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.