The conversation centers on the rise of economic populism in the 2024 U.S. elections, where voters' frustration over cost of living, inflation, and economic inequality has become the defining political issue. Candidates from across the ideological spectrum—such as Josh Turek, Zoran Omdani, and others—emerged by centering working-class concerns like affordable housing, minimum wage increases, and access to healthcare. The discussion highlights how effective populism is not about rage or division, but about translating public anger into concrete, actionable policies. While some critics warn of unhealthy populism—such as anti-immigrant or anti-trans rhetoric—there is broad agreement that constructive populism must channel frustration toward solutions like regulating big tech, ending harmful tariffs, and supporting rural economies. Notably, the success of candidates in rural states like Iowa shows that economic authenticity and policy results are more critical than ideological purity. The conversation underscores a shared ambition: to rebuild a progressive movement rooted in economic justice, where policy outcomes reflect the lived realities of ordinary people. Ultimately, the dialogue suggests that the future of progressive politics lies not in ideological purity, but in pragmatic, inclusive, and outcome-driven governance that responds to public pain with tangible reforms. This approach unites liberals, social democrats, and economic populists around a common goal: to create a fairer, more stable economy for all.
hey everybody you're about to hear our final episode from cricket con this was my conversation
with faz shakir from a more perfect union jerusalem densis from the argument and derek
thompson from the atlantic we talked about the battle between liberalism socialism and populism
uh what happens when we harness people's anger for good and for ill and we were joined by josh
turek who surprised us by joining us at cricket con and we got to talk to him about uh what it
was like campaigning in iowa and what voters from iowa expect from him as part of this new
democratic majority it was a great discussion about uh some of the biggest divides inside
the progressive movement and then after that you will hear dan's conversation
with arizona senator mark kelly they talked about pushing back on pete hegseth ending the
war in iran and whether he will be running for president uh anytime soon hi everybody welcome
uh really excited for this conversation you know we're talking backstage about how we had planned
to do crooked con rain or shine not a cloud in the sky uh uh very happy to be joined by
derek thompson by jerusalem demsis by faz shakir for a conversation that i that i've been interested
in having because i think a lot of the debate online about uh the left versus the center it
tends to be a lot of people uh you know bringing some baggage over from the last 10 years that
they've been dragging behind them and i think it's worth just stepping back and and talking
about what we can learn and where we can find consensus and uh where that debate can go and
move forward and so i guess i just want to start with each of you uh derek i'll start with you what
what did you take away from uh the victories in terms of what you learned about the policy views
and ideological stances of these candidates well the victories were absolutely fantastic and the
last thing that i want to do is like you know rest defeat from the jaws of victory like tuesday's
result was so sensational that you almost don't want to even look at the inevitable debate that's
going to claim that they're responsible for what happened on tuesday and the other factions the
democratic party or not the way i've seen it certainly for the last year is that online in
the world of posters they tend to think that their factions are zero sum but in the world of
politicians they understand that the factions can be put together so it's kind of like everyone
thinks they're working with their own ingredients whether you're a you know left populist or maybe
you're an abundance pragmatist or you're a liberal or you're a moderate and you you come into this
is the best nothing can beat bacon and then someone else says no bacon is effing terrible
tomato is the best then someone comes in from the left and they say no it's it's lettuce lettuce is
the best idea in the democratic party and then here's james talarico talking like a bernie leftist
while at the same time espousing abundance pragmatism and also moderating on issues like
immigration and energy he's just making a blt and it's like the internet doesn't even know what to do
with the blt because
the factions are so committed to the idea that only their truth can be the ultimate truth i think in
this respect the politicians are smarter than the posters because they understand that to get not
just a hundred people to retweet you but to get tens of millions of people to vote for you you
can't just be about one thing you have to take a little bit from a b and c and i think the candidates
that won on tuesday were very very good at taking a little bit from many different factions and
making something that was all truly their own
jerusalem what about you i have a lot of views personally that are extremely unpopular with the
american public i i believe that there should be basically no restrictions on immigration i don't
really think that a lot of the um rhetoric about trans people has been liberal at all the idea that
we should restrict what people are doing with their own bodies is to me insane um the idea that
we're like legislating what people are doing with their own bodies is to me insane um the idea that
people should should do with their own children and if children have the right with their parents
and their doctors to make decisions about their own health care um i think it's crazy i think it's
like personally i find it ridiculous and i can like look at facts i can look at the country and
i can see that there are lots of people who disagree with me particularly in places like
mississippi like south carolina like texas where you saw a lot of democrats win and i think
historically everyone has understood this i think even now everyone really gets this
um you don't make decisions about whether or not you are going to believe something based on a poll
you believe what you think is true you try to fight for it and you confront the reality of
electoral politics seriously and so to me i think there's like there's just weird debate online about
like well did moderates do better did presses do better like sure whatever like i'm glad someone's
i guess figuring out some some of the math there but i think what's really important here is if you
are someone who is very serious about shifting the scale of politics you're not going to be able to
in your direction you need to be very very clear-eyed about where you're popular and where
you're not and what it looks like to persuade people and so i think that this sense of oh we
shouldn't even like be looking at these like polling questions or we shouldn't even be looking
at these electability questions is actually a abrogation of our responsibility to the future
of the movements we're trying to build if you want a future where everyone agrees with you that we
should have more immigrants in this country that they shouldn't be subject to these insane restrictions
that we have
put in part and both parties have put in place if you believe that trans people should have
this kind of the freedom that cis people do to live their lives to the fullest extent of the law
that means taking very seriously that lots of people in this country disagree with you
faz what do you think
i'm very happy
i have been you know many of us been advocating for politics for a long period of time in which
the democratic party returned to its roots
as the champion for working-class people in this country and in many ways we all know that
president trump and his horrible record towards working-class people and his failed agenda his
lies his hypocrisy his hubris drove working-class people away and that was wonderful thank you
president trump also because so many democrats across the spectrum got the message and i'm
understood that if working class people feel that they have been let down and betrayed,
that if we are honed in on economic questions, who has too much power in society?
Are we angry at a billionaire class?
And what can we do to channel expanding health care, taxing the rich, taking on big tech
and AI data centers?
If we center that conversation, we will get vast majorities of people.
And everyone got that message.
And I'm very pleased to see that when we've centered the economic pain and suffering and
said, we've got an agenda that speaks to it, large numbers of people are there.
And so, John, as I say that, I think we have conquered in many ways the hope and ambition
of politics.
And now the tough part comes because we are in the mode of policy.
And so the question is, if we can all campaign as economic populists, can we govern as one
to sustain those majorities?
And it will be, it will require some of the factions and the tents and the pushes.
And I get that, that that's going to be a healthy and constructive tension.
But I would hope, and I mentioned this when, you know, when the great mayor of New York
City, Zoram Omdani, won.
And many of us went and talked to, you know, DSA activists and people who had helped him
get there.
And I said to them, and I say to you all now is that as we have talented leaders step to
the fore, hopefully we can give them the grace.
That they are going to fight for the best possible outcome, the greatest good for the
greatest number.
That is our ambition.
And we should push on them.
We should provide that tension and give them the space to hopefully find what are the best
ways to expand health care?
What are the best ways to tax the rich?
What are the best ways to regulate AI?
As long as, in my view, we are centered on those major things that the American people
were demanding of us and want answers to, we'll do all right.
Thank you.
So on this question of economic populism, it does seem like a through line that connects
a lot of these candidates, right?
You have Abdul is doing his version of economic populism.
You're seeing that in Texas.
You're seeing that in Mississippi.
But populism can mean a lot of different things.
And I sometimes struggle to understand the difference between populism as a kind of aesthetic,
being angry at the right people, and then what the actual policies would be.
For example, there have been populists campaigning on eliminating income tax for people under
a certain threshold.
And I understand why that would be popular.
But I think in the long run, when we act as if no one gets any value from their taxes,
we're doing some damage.
It could also mean going after the corporations.
It could be stopping AI data centers.
So what is good populism to you?
And how does that then translate into a coherent economic agenda?
When we are doing it best, John.
reflects the passions of people.
grassroots movements matter to you, that you channel those. And as many of us know,
there's unhealthy populism. So first of all, posit that, put that on the table. What is
unhealthy populism? Well, when there are righteous anger from the masses to say,
deport them all, build a wall, I am so angry at the other, then you have autocratic presidents
say, great, I will be a negative populist, cater to those, and do destructive policymaking.
Healthy populism, say, I am angry at big tech. I am angry at the health insurance companies.
And to understand that and channel that into saying, well, great, let's expand Medicare.
Let's put in a data center moratorium. Let's expand social security benefits. That is healthy
populism in which you are channeling that anger and frustration. You're reflecting it back to
people that you are angry and I understand that. I don't sit above you as an elite and say, oh,
my life's pretty good.
That anger and frustration of so many people matters to our policymaking. And what I was
so pleased about in this election cycle, so many people who are candidates went out into town halls
more than we've ever done before. When we got into town halls, many of the people at town halls
course-corrected candidates. And those candidates are learning from them themselves. Oh, I see
how angry you are about data centers. So while maybe my instincts were to say,
I'm pro-AI development and I am very, you know, I think Jensen Huang is a very intelligent
person. I think Jensen Huang is a very intelligent person. And we should all appreciate like the big tech oligarchs have high IQ. Maybe there are
some people who may have had that instinct, but they're course-corrected immediately when they
go into a town hall and say, I'm pessimistic about it. I'm worried that nothing will good
happen in my life. And you saw candidates start to speak out on behalf of people.
That's populism in real time. And when we channel that, then it leads to, I think this is the
question you're raising. What is going to be the policy that comes out of it? We'll have a debate
about that, but we start to channel that. And when we channel that, then it leads to, I think this is
from the place of do people matter to this movement? And, you know, if we channel this
back, John, to like a couple of years ago, I was concerned and many of us were worried and
let's call it progressive populist movement that we were sometimes talking about things that while
important, democracy, Trump's character, negative partisanship on Trump. I get that in my view,
those times while they were righteous and correct, they didn't always speak to working class
chief concerns. And what populism did for you is level that playing field. So, hey, now now when
you're angry about gas prices, you're angry about health care and you're angry about AI.
It's not merely about Trump. It's now about something that is affecting my life. That's
populism. Can I jump in here? Yeah. I guess I saw it rising up in you. Yeah. I mean, I think one of
the distinctions between my worldview and FASO's worldview is on this question of populism, because
there are parts of economic,
economic populism, which I think almost everyone who's on the left agrees with raising corporate
taxes, increased regulation on health care, whether that's Medicare for all or Medicare for
all, whatever the version of that is. There are all of these things which I think are good and I
don't think are just the purview of populists. But I think FASO is eliding a distinction between the
bad kind of populism, the good kind of populism, like you could cordon it off in a very easy way.
And one of the most telling things to me over the past couple of years is that I've been able to
think about this for 12 years, is that this election, the decline in Trump's favorabilities
can be tied majority, not even like, oh, there's one, two, three. It's like number one, it's because
of the tariffs. It's because of the cost of living and what he did with tariffs and what he did to
raise prices for working people. Populists on the left and right before Trump's victory, including
FASO, were pro-tariff. They were telling us the anger that they were seeing in the public about
trade meant that we should not be able to do anything about it. And so I think it's a very
a tariff regime. This is not because populists don't know economics or they don't care about
working people. It's not because they didn't care about what it would do to prices. It's because
when you take anger and you immediately translate that to policy, you often get
political and policy choices that end up destroying your movement.
If Trump had ignored the economic populists in his coalition and listened to the boring, annoying
Democrats and economists, he would not have done as badly as he just did in this midterm.
And it's not like there's number two, like, oh, it was, there's, there's, you know,
immigration was number two. Cost of living is the reason why people were upset. Tariffs. I mean,
I was talking to someone who was running these focus groups. There were individuals who could
tell you about specific tariffs that they themselves had suffered on. I got married last
year and I had to pay a tariff for my wedding dress. And I remember being really pissed off.
And I think most people would be if a couple of weeks before your wedding,
a procrastinator, that's my fault, but you know, can't blame everything on Trump apparently. But
you know, a couple weeks before your wedding, you're like, well, in order to get your wedding
dress that you budgeted for, you have to pay a couple hundred extra dollars. And like, I'm lucky
to have a job where I could afford that extra couple hundred dollars. But like other people
aren't. And for other people, that was a devastating situation to find themselves into.
And so I worry that when we talk about populism, we talk about doing the good kind of populism,
we forget how easily populism becomes the exact thing.
That we're trying to fight.
And you can rest easy with seamless returns and exchanges and a 365-night sleep trial,
part of their Happy with Helix guarantee. Helix is the most awarded mattress brand for a reason,
tested and reviewed by experts like Forbes and Wired. We have Helix mattresses.
I love my Helix mattress.
We have, Charlie has one, Teddy has one. We got one in the guest room.
Great.
In-laws have one. We all love our Helix mattresses.
So comfortable.
They're so comfy.
They're the best.
Go to helixsleep.com slash cricket for up to 30% off. That's helixsleep.com slash cricket.
For up to 30% off, helixsleep.com slash cricket.
Pots of America is brought to you by Walmart.
Every single week, Walmart keeps prices low for 150 million Americans across the country.
It is all part of their decades-long commitment to hardworking families that started back in 1962
with a simple tagline, always low prices, always.
Whether you're stocking up for the week or picking up last-minute supplies,
Walmart helps families save on fresh produce, quality clothing, and essential school supplies,
and hundreds of other things.
They're everyday necessities in every aisle, every single day.
In fact, choosing Walmart's great value product line saves shoppers an average of 35% every year
compared to the national brands, delivering real quality without the steep price tag.
They know that when families save on the essentials they rely on daily,
they can follow through on the special moments that matter most,
like hosting family pizza nights, throwing unforgettable birthday parties,
or buying a shiny new pair of basketball shoes as a well-deserved reward for good grades.
Because when Walmart says,
"Save money, live better," they mean it.
Learn more today at walmart.com/savemoney.
Guys, I want to hear your response, and I want to come back because I want to talk about where that comes from, yeah.
Well, obviously, I hope we all understand that there could be good tariffs and bad tariffs,
and that if you have a president who engages in destructive and goofy and Liberation Day charts
that no one can understand what this tariff is doing and why, and why are we going after Canada that all of us are,
in the sense that that makes no sense.
If the Fed was doing terrible things and it makes no sense,
you don't want to abolish the Fed and say, "Oh, I never want the Fed."
You correct it, you say, "Here's the good things and here's the bad things."
And in my mind, on a tariff regime, we had him under Biden, we've had him under Trump,
in which we were protecting and trying to build industry in America.
If you had auto workers, you have steel workers who are believing that we need to have domestic production,
domestic manufacturing, domestic manufacturing,
we'll make it in America is something that I believe in.
And if you want to protect and ensure that some of our workers here in America are going to produce
some solar panels, are going to produce electric cars, are going to produce high-end batteries,
you're going to have to instill some kind of domestic rulemaking and laws to ensure
we aren't going to lose out those jobs and be competed unfairly against by foreign companies or cheap.
And we're going to have to wait and lie and steal to take away some of those jobs.
This is a very basic fundamental understanding that if we care about some American workers,
there are ways to do tariff regimes that are constructive.
And I don't want anyone to think that just because you have a crazy president who does
crazy and irrational things, that somehow everything, that anything he has ever touched,
we could never do better. We could never improve upon. We could never find a way that you would take
some share of a company and it might be positive and constructive. That if you were going to do
Trump accounts, that you could imagine doing Trump accounts in a positive and effective way.
We're going to do Trump Rx. You could imagine doing those in positive and constructive ways.
We shouldn't blind ourselves to some things, some directions are worth learning from in this moment.
This darkness moment has told us the things that we should absolutely avoid.
But I think this kind of zero-sum approach to tariffs, I just don't agree with. It isn't like
everything that he has ever done is bad. There are some constructive things that we can learn from.
And by the way, there's a lot of things that we can learn from. And by the way, there are some constructive things that we can learn from. And by the way,
of course, during his regime was doing something that he thought were constructive
And by the way, didn't remove all of the Trump tariffs when he became president.
So I think that was a successful administration.
Yeah.
Well, so probably you two would not agree on what a good or a bad tariff is, because
I think you were further to the left on this question.
You were more of a liberal on this question.
But to be clear, we've polled on this and DSA aligned Democrats are the most anti-tariff
of any coalition.
Well, this is probably there's never been a time in the history of polling, I would
imagine, where tariffs have looked worse because we've never had tariffs applied this
stupidly.
So I just think that's a debate and a good debate to have.
But I think stepping back, like what is what's happening here?
Well, I think you're talking about two different things.
You're talking about moral populism and immoral populism, righteous anger directed at people
who deserve it.
And some of the anger we see from Trump that is less righteous as at undocumented people,
a trans people.
And then there's where you put that anger towards immoral or moral solutions.
And that's a policy debate, irrespective of the anger.
What's what I find interesting is why the anger is such a signal.
And I would put this to Derek, which is because you've written about abundance and I've you
know, you've abundance became kind of one of these locus of debate.
But part of what you're getting at, I think, is there's liberalism that actually gets things
done.
But there's also politicians who seem like the people who are willing to do the work
to get things done.
And if I ask Democrats.
Every persuasion, the centrist all the way to the far left.
And I said, all right, I've got Gavin Newsom, Kamala Harris and Chuck Schumer over here.
And I've got AOC, Zoran Mamdani and Bernie Sanders over here.
Which one of these two groups do you think cares more about solving the problems in your
life?
And I don't think there's very many people who wouldn't say it's the left.
And that is not endemic to the project of being a liberal.
That you care.
Less or seem to care less about problems.
And if your solutions are more more market oriented, you're just not as into actually
getting anything done.
And I'm just curious how much you think this policy debate is taking place in a vacuum
that liberalism created.
I think it's really, really important to reflect the anger of the public right now.
If I'm being honest, I do think that economic populists are better at reflecting that anger
than some non economic populists.
That said, what are people angry about?
They're angry about cost of living.
The 2024 election was a cost of living election.
Donald Trump won with a mandate to reduce cost of living.
What's the first thing he does?
Increase the price of anything that we import via tariffs and then start a war in Iran that
mechanically raises the price of gasoline and diesel.
I mean, people were upset about the cost of housing.
He slaps a tariff on timber that comes in from Canada.
He slaps a tariff on the drywall that comes from Mexico.
All of the inputs into a house suddenly become mechanically more expensive despite the fact
that he won a cost of living election.
What was the result of immediately raising the cost of living in response to a cost of
living election?
In 2025, the people who won Spamburger in Virginia, Mikey Sherrill, New Jersey ran on
cost of living and they won in 2026 this midterm.
Why did the Democrats just win?
What did Americans by and large say they were voting on?
Cost of living, inflation, economy, lots of different synonyms for the same idea were mad
about how much everything costs.
If people keep winning cost of living elections, how about a fricking cost of living agenda?
How about an agenda that actually is focused very, very narrowly on reducing the cost of
living that looks at housing and says, why is it so difficult to build a house?
Let's make it easier to build a house that looks at energy and says, why is it so hard
to add different kinds of energy?
Let's pass, for example, a permitting reform bill, which is currently in the Senate to
make it easier.
To extend transmission lines, to have the electrons that are created by a solar farm
over here, power your razor over here.
Let's find a way to end the war in Iran, which is create, which is again, automatically raising
the cost of gasoline and diesel, which is an input into everything in the agricultural
economy, which is I think a huge part of why states like Kansas and Iowa went blue.
I'm glad they went blue, but they went blue because people are feeling pain.
So I agree with Faz.
I think it's really, really important.
It's important to hear that people are angry, but I want the policy responses to actually
solve that anger and not just talk to that anger, right?
I want to solve the problems that people say they have.
And I don't want to suggest here that I think that all economic populism does is simply
like massage the anger of voters in ways that don't fix their problems.
There are there are solutions over here that some people really, really love, but what I'm
focused on and what abundance has been focused on is how do we change the rules and the laws
that make it harder to build things that will actually make people's life more affordable?
To me, there's there's a really, really clear connection between these ideas among abundance
liberals and the things that people are asking for.
And by the way, it's not just like the libs like me who think this Zohar Mamdani is not
going to be mistaken.
You know, a liberal centrist.
But if you look at his housing team, one of the things that they are filthy with abundance
folks, they've tried very, very hard to make it easier to develop housing because he knows
he knows that if you want to bring down the cost of housing, you have to build houses.
There was a really interesting moment last point, really interesting moment in the Branky
Points podcast where Sagar and Jetty was talking to Abdul El-Sayed and he said, you know, Abdul,
you have this this policy where you want to freeze property taxes.
For seniors and I, I just don't I don't like that idea.
I think that's going to make housing more expensive.
It's going to put it out of touch for more young people.
I don't like that idea.
And what else I had said in immediately was that to be clear, Sagar, I support building
more homes to reduce the price of housing boom.
His response in that moment is the first chapter of abundance.
Like that's what I ultimately want.
How people win elections.
What rhetoric they use is less important to me and the policies they pass once they
have power.
And I'm excited for the fact that across the ideological spectrum, I see a lot of people
talking as if they've read the book, even if they haven't.
That's what you're what's your response to that?
There's a lot to learn from how we should clean up and reform government, do deregulation,
prove people's lives.
The thing about many.
Economic populists, and obviously Zoran is one of them, is that in the manner in which
they campaign, they create a mandate for how they will govern.
And so if he's going out and he's talking at a town hall and, you know, he didn't didn't
mention too many of the regulations that Derek did, but he's prepared to govern upon them.
What did he talk about on housing?
Freeze the.
What did he talk about on child care?
Universal child care?
Maybe the whole world isn't universal.
Maybe the whole world isn't New York after all.
Yeah, these are what is he doing there?
He's saying to working class people, I am materially prepared to do something bold to
change your life.
He's not precluding that I will also do changing the staircase regulation and also help, you
know, make sure the construction can happen in the city.
He's not precluding it.
What he's doing is creating a mandate, say working class people will know that you will
see a direct benefit materially in your life.
You will see universal preconditions.
You will see the free kick in the city.
You will see rent being stabilized and reduced in this city.
And that process of thinking about major reforms that would impact the pocketbooks of working
class people is what I'm after.
The big ticket items to my mind are things like housing, buying a car, child care, college
education.
Take those things and you say these are major parts of working class budgets that eat them
up in major ways.
What can we do to reduce the cost of each one of those in major ways?
And I would say many, you know, if you look at Bernie, you look at some of the populace
of what we have campaigned on, that's where he's living, right?
On health care, on education, on universal child care.
Here's the big things.
And then when we get into governing there, you know, Jerusalem, completely correct.
Now you have the world at your disposal.
Lots of things to do.
Many opportunities.
Do them all.
So what I like about that.
I do think that to me is what I'm taking away from this election, because, you know,
I talked to Zoran when he was running about housing, and it isn't just that he talked
about freezing the rent and was open to some of these other policies.
He made a point of saying that he had been persuaded by the need for more market housing.
We just elected Nithya Raman in Los Angeles.
Same thing.
She's somebody who has evolved on housing to come to see why we need much more market
rate housing.
In fact, one of the divides she had with some in the DSA was that she had come out to reform
something in L.A. called the ULA, which is a mansion tax that was also inexplicably applied
to multifamily housing and was really counterproductive.
The city council still stood in the way of fixing it.
But we can talk about the problems in L.A. later.
But what I what I hear in that is kind of a synthesis of what you two are talking about,
which is this is going to be very glib, but I don't think it's what you mean.
But it's a little bit socialism in the streets and liberalism in the sheets.
Right.
This is big, big, important.
populist economic policies, like freezing the rent, free college, Medicare for all,
what I'm about to say doesn't apply to Medicare for all, policies that actually economists would
say can be counterproductive, but backed up with a growth agenda, building houses,
changing building codes that will actually over time have the market-based impact of getting the
results that you want. And there's a lot of, I think, ideological confusion because I think
liberals have been, I think, so timid and feckless in the establishment.
But it's about the anger of the populace being translated into things that will actually
work. Abundance was attacked a lot as like, well, that's not a program anybody's going to get
behind. But it sounds like what Faz is saying, it doesn't need to be the whole program. But if
there's a politician out there that's going to be calling for Medicare for all, well, I'll also
get behind a policy of forcing the AMA to have more doctors. I don't know what you think of
that. There was no point in writing the book where Ezra and I had a phone call where we said,
this book only succeeds if candidates campaign exclusively on pages 14 through 97, right?
The idea was never that these rules would become the only words that people could choose to put on
bumper stickers. People should run based on what's happening in the world and what's happening to the
people's lives that they're trying to get votes from. I mean,
you know, I think someone like, for example, John Ossoff, I wouldn't, I don't know that you
would necessarily think of him as an economic populist. He's a very clear message. Cost of
living, yes, but the other C, corruption. He is incredibly, like, magisterially articulate
on breaking down Trump's corruption. It would be crazy to say that abundance liberals want to stop
people from talking about Trump's corruption because then they're not running on the principles
of abundance. No.
You should run on what works and you should run on what's happening. Trump's corruption
is lurid. Of course you should talk about it. People's cost of living is much higher than it
was six months ago. Gas prices are significantly higher than they were because of an unbelievably
stupid war. You have to talk about these things. But at the end of the day, what I care about
is outcomes. I want people's lives to get better and people's lives get better,
not because of what happens at the ballot box, but because the people who win based on what
happens at the ballot box, they're going to get better. And I want people's lives to get better,
not because of what happens at the ballot box, but because the people who win based on what happens
at the ballot box, but because the people who win based on what happens at the ballot box,
not because of what happens at the ballot box, but because the people who win based on what happens
at the ballot box, do policies that make people's lives better. That's what I care about a hundred
times more. And so I think Jerusalem, one of the things I think that I take from your writing is
you're not motivated by fear and rage. You're a data person and you're an economics person.
And it makes you uncomfortable, even if that anger and those strong emotions lead people in
the right direction because it could lead them in the wrong. But it also means that some of the
more boring and important decisions we could make don't get a lot of attention and obviously don't
become campaign talking points, right? Like no one's going to campaign on the problem of where
we put our stairwells in buildings. Certainly no one's going to make a campaign around the
importance of permitting reform. And yet probably right now, if you could think of what is the most
important thing we could do to have a clean energy economy going forward, it would be to pass a deeply
unsatisfying, complex, confusing, and very difficult decision. And I think that's what I'm
saying in some ways, contradictory permitting bill. Weird town, DC. And so I feel like sometimes
you're sort of screaming from the rafters for everybody to calm down and just listen to the
technocrats. And there's literally no constituency for you. How does that feel?
So I like not being a campaign strategist. That is not my job. I run a magazine and I,
you know, I'm not a campaign strategist. I'm not a campaign strategist. It's called The Argument. And we love, thank you. And I think a couple of things. There is a
view that the anger people feel, which I feel too. And I'm motivated by anger at
what I saw happen to Alex Preddy. I'm motivated by anger watching families get torn apart. I'm
motivated by anger of hearing from friends who feel like they can't live in the states where
they grew up because they don't have the abortion or trans protections that would make them feel
safe to live there. Anger is normal. Anger at reality is correct. But then there's a question
of centering your own emotions in political debates that influence not just the 330 million
people that live in this country, but the billions of people who live all over the world. My anger
does not help a change in the world. It does not help a change in the world. It does not help a
child in Gaza. My anger does not help a child in Tigray, where I'm from. My anger does not change
what's happening under authoritarian regimes all over the world. It does not solve malaria as one
of the leading killers of children. What does do those things? What I care about and who people I
like to support are individuals who understand the anger that I feel that are motivated by the
same principles and values that I have. And I think that's what I'm motivated by. And I think that's what I
hold. But also are not so overwhelmed by their emotions that they can't actually step back and
think, well, then how do I help people? Because over and over again, this is the problem that
happens with populism. Because again, like if we're just talking about whether or not someone
can reflect rage back at an electorate, that's across the political spectrum. You have really
far right authoritarians doing that in some countries. You have far left socialists and
communists. You have centrists who are able to do that. You do this. I mean, that is literally what's happening in Canada right now is you have a
centrist prime minister who's reflecting his country's genuine rage at the American
tariff regime. This is anger. And being a good politician is not the purview of any political
party. What populism does is it says that anger should be your guide for what exactly what to do,
not values, not understanding. But if everyone says in the country, you know what? We're really,
really angry about immigration. And we were really upset about immigration.
That is a signal that democratically elected representatives should use to understand how
to fix the immigration system to actually resolve those concerns. What were those concerns? They
were chaos at the border. They were the fact that state and local dollars were being taken up
by immigrants and not going toward native population. I had very progressive people
telling me under the Biden immigration wave that they felt like New York was full because they
were watching migrants on the streets in downtown Manhattan. What is the reaction to that?
Populism says, okay, stop. It's very, very simple. Just stop. Stop these individuals from coming in.
And you have also, I'll say, left populists who have become also very anti-immigration as a result
of this. But liberalism says, yes, people are angry about immigration. How do we resolve that
while remaining true to the things we believe? Many things you can implement to do this. And I
won't give you my entire dissertation, but you can read about it on theargumentmag.com.
Well, I think that's an important point.
In part, because I think we're, again, trying to figure out how to respond to people's fundamental
dissatisfaction with what is happening in the economy and a feeling like the establishment
hasn't responded to it.
Tonight, I'm going to have a drink because I'm recording this on election night. And either way,
I'm having a drink afterwards. If it's good, we're having a drink. If it's bad,
we're having maybe another drink. And the reason I'm going to take a Z-biotics is because I will
not have a drink without it. Because for me, it is a game changer the next day. And it has just
prevented me from having those rough mornings. Because Z-biotics, pre-alcohol probiotic drink,
is the first genetically engineered probiotic. It was engineered by PhD microbiologists to
break down acetaldehyde, an unwanted byproduct of alcohol metabolism. Make pre-alcohol your
first drink of the night, drink responsibly, and enjoy your next day's activities. Z-biotics has
sold more than 15 million bottles and earned the trust of thousands, including us, again.
Try Z-biotics. Just try it once. If you don't like it, you're not missing out on anything. But for me,
it has been a life-changing thing that just makes it so that, you know, that night when you go out
to like a work dinner, you have one extra drink. You don't wake up the next day regretting every
decision you made. It just, it changes everything.
The holiday season is officially here. And if you're like us, your social calendar is filling up
fast from Friendsgiving with friends to the turkey trot the next morning. These are the
moments you don't want to miss. That's why I make Z-biotics pre-alcohol part of my routine before
drinking, because the best part of the holidays is being present for all of it. Try Z-biotics
pre-alcohol for yourself. And if you're not satisfied, they'll refund your entire order.
No questions asked. Head to zbiotics.com slash crooked and use code crooked for 15%
off your first order. That's zbiotics.com slash crooked, code crooked.
Pazzi of America is brought to you by Bombas. There's no reason to dread the cold days,
nights of winter with Bombas. They make socks, slippers, and footwear that will keep you warm
all winter long. From fuzzy Sunday slippers for lounging around in to water-resistant suede boots
that can handle the snow and the rain, Bombas socks are the winter go-to. Merino wool and
cashmere blend socks for warmth, fuzzy socks and plush gripper socks for cozy vibes when you're at
home. I love Bombas socks. I pretty recently threw out all my old socks and bought a bunch of new
ones all on Bombas. They have the great workout no-show socks, a little hug for your feet. But the
about them is, you know, if you're trying to wear them
them with normal shoes out or something. They have a good elastic grip. They don't fall down
all the time. They don't fall apart. They're not going to just be slipping down your foot all day.
They're super high quality. They last forever. They're great. They're comfortable. I just highly
recommend them. And if you're looking for gifts this season, Bombas is something for everyone.
They have cozy socks. They got slippers. They got cushy footwear. They can take on the winter.
Sport socks for runners, skiers, everybody. There's something for everyone on your list.
And the best part about Bombas, for every item you purchase, they donate an essential clothing item
to someone facing housing insecurity. One purchase equals one donated with over 200
million donations and counting. Head over to bombas.com slash crooked and use code crooked
for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S.com slash crooked. Code crooked at checkout.
One of the ways in which people have signaled their disagreement with that establishment
is by running a little bit against the Democratic Party. They've either run as Democratic
Socialists or just in their kind of presentation as outsiders from the Democratic Party.
But when you look at, say, sort of what Bernie Sanders has argued for, or you look at what some
of the more left candidates outside of, say, city-run grocery stores, it's actually more of a
signal of being willing to fight really hard and do more than what the previous elected leaders have
done. A little bit more than that, John. I think you're on the right track. The in-defense,
of rage and anger channeled constructively into policymaking. One of the biggest problems we face
in our political and economic system is capture of the elites, capture of big money. If you agree
with that, how are you going to take on established corporate monopolies, concentrated power,
if you have the willingness to do it? You may not, right? Some people just want to public-private
partnerships. And there's rules for that, right? Some of the things that Derek has
talking about, there's ways that even the elites would be comfortable with. But there's some things
that the elites are not going to be comfortable with, peer-to-peer tax or some taxing of the rich.
They're going to be angry with. Well, if you are a constructive populist movement, you're going to
know that people are your power. That if I'm going to push against a billionaire class who's going to
say they want every data center in every community in America, the rage of the people constructively
bulwark is to ensure that the policymaking that is going to happen is going to happen for working
class people, because you and I will know that the rage of people matters here. If we're going to tax
the rich, that I'm going to channel what is the actual feeling of working class people into this
debate. I'm not going to tell you I'm smarter than you. I got a better idea than you. I don't
really care. Just now's my time to govern. You can go sit in a corner. No, I'm going to bring you
into governing. We're going to fight this fight together because I know that we're going to have to
do it. I know together we are dealing with too much concentrated power at the top. That I do think
is a fundamental difference just in how we might think about the transition from both politicking
and into governing, that you're creating mandates while you're politicking to do some of this
governing in which the populism that you've created and cultivated is helping you drive
an agenda to work for working people. I guess where I'll leave this is what I'm glad we're
having this conversation.
Because I do think a lot of what becomes these very dug in debates online really ultimately ends
up being a conversation about how we are going to reimagine some version of New Deal liberalism
today, whether it's building very quickly and better or figuring out a set of policies to
have a market economy that doesn't leave a whole swath of the country completely destitute or
building a safety net.
For people, right? And I think whether it's, you know, socialism versus liberalism is really
more of a debate about what it becomes more of an aesthetic debate. I don't mean that in a
pejorative way, like a debate about care and attention as opposed to outcomes and the outcome
debate becomes a little bit more, I think. But John, I do think there is a tension of
fighting against elite power. Yeah, I do think that, I mean, you know, if we, if we got into
some of this, there's a little bit of an, a concern over if we're going to stop,
AI from banning all prior authorizations, right? Or use of AI in medicine. Who's for AI in medicine,
right? We all know, right? The United Health and many of the companies are good with it.
And the question then becomes, do you, are you comfortable taking them on and doing things that,
as you say, are going to possibly be economically deemed to be by an elite economic class?
Not, not great. But starting in progress, right. But what I think what's interesting is,
I would say I'm looking for the kind of liberals who are ready to have that fight
because they're furious about what these companies are going to do. And they believe
in a market economy that works and sees the way these institutions undermine it. And instead we
have kind of ideologically incoherent or just inconsiderate, ill-considered establishment
politicians and people with fire in their belly fighting against these institutions.
And there's this space that I think writers on the outside fill in. And my
hope right now is that we have a new group of politicians, some of whom were able to kind of
quietly run heterodox campaigns because no one thought they were going to win. And now they're
going to be in the Senate. And we actually have one of those candidates here. And so I do want to
bring him into the conversation. And we were so appreciative that he can make the time. Please
welcome the next Senator from Iowa. It's Josh Turek.
Hi. Thanks for being here. Good to see you.
Good to see you.
I'm going all the way around.
Thank you.
Josh Turek.
So we're having a very
intellectual conversation about what it takes to win people back. You just did it on the ground.
You've had, what, 48 hours to think it over, 72 hours?
About.
What are you, what is so far your sort of lesson about going from somebody people
basically had written off to someone who is now going to be a Senator representing Iowa?
You know, I said for 450 days that the right candidate with the right message,
right work ethic, and the right political wins, we can win anywhere. And I'm really,
really proud that the blue tsunami,
absolutely smacked Iowa. We won three congressional seats, a governor's race, and a Senate race.
Do you see yourself as an economic populist? Like how, how do you, and what does that mean to you?
I consider myself a common sense prairie populist, and I'm happy that we once again have representation
in the United States Senate from prairie states. We used to be able to win Tom Harkin for 30 years in
Iowa, uh, Dashiell up in South Dakota. Now that we've got representation, Iowa, uh, Kansas. Yeah,
I, I, I think that this is all about economic populism. The issues that were important in Iowa,
what we heard every single day was cost corruption, kitchen table issues.
I was running for 450 days on a livable wage, affordable housing, affordable healthcare,
drinkable water, functioning public schools, uh, overturning Citizens United, uh, corruption,
term limits, banning Members of Congress from trading stocks. These are the issues that people
care about. So if you think about what Trump has done as the fuel, I think it still matters
what kind of car you're driving. I still think it matters who's driving the car, right? I think
campaigns matters. Candidates matter even in a climate like this, but obviously your campaign
benefits from the fact that this is a moment in which people are extremely dissatisfied.
How do you think of your job to keep a bunch of people who may have voted for
Trump two or three times and could very well, uh, uh, send you or some of your colleagues in two
years packing because, um, you know, they wake up like, like what happened? What happened? What did
we do last night? Kind of a thing. You're absolutely right. What I think we have to do is
from day one, we have to prove that we are the party, the people, the party, the workers, the
party, the middle class. And every single day we have to provide policy solutions to people's
problems. Because what I'm convinced of,
is the reason why people voted for Trump is because he accurately identified the problem
that the status quo was not working for the middle class, for the average Iowan.
Problem is his solution was completely the opposite. So for 450 days, I've been saying
I've got the solution. It's prairie populism. And so now we've got to go out there and immediately
provide results. And, and that's going to be ending the war, uh, repealing these tariffs.
Bringing back ACA subsidies, raising the minimum wage. Uh, these are the issues. If we don't provide
results, that pendulum is going to swing right back. And we are going to be renting these seats
for two years or six years. So big coalition, you know, Hakeem Jeffries, uh, said that, that,
that Americans didn't elect Democrats to get even they elected Democrats to get things done.
And I think that statement has the benefit of both
both being true and making everybody really, really mad
because of what people think it actually might mean.
And Donald Trump says, oh, I want to work with Democrats.
Then he appoints someone like Stephen Miller to be chief of staff,
which suggests he's much more interested in not working with Democrats.
But you're someone clearly elected on this economic message.
There are people that are going to be pushing for big fights on accountability
that are going to make Trump less likely to sign bills, to overturn Medicaid cuts.
Do you view the corruption piece of this, the accountability pieces,
as something that is an equal task?
Is it something that you care about but is not nearly as important as the economic message?
How do you think about it?
We certainly have to have accountability in government.
I mean, people have lost faith in their institutions and lost faith in their representatives.
And so there certainly is an accountability component.
But for me, what I'm really clear of is,
we did this.
I mean, we impeached Trump twice.
Where did it lead us to?
I think that the goal is we provide policy solutions to people's problems in a bipartisan way.
We have to address the cost and corruption.
Kitchen table issues.
That is what I'm laser focused on.
Faz, you mentioned this when we were talking earlier,
that there was a period of time where Democrats were focused on legitimate,
important, but non-persuasive topics.
Yes.
Defending democracy, Trump's terrible character.
We're in this euphoric moment where everybody gets to be for everything.
We're for investigations.
We're for repealing the Medicaid cuts.
We're for ending the war on Iran.
I agree with that.
We should be fighting to do all of those things.
But there's going to come a time of choosing where we're going to have to figure out
what we can get from this president, if we can get anything at all.
And at a certain point, what you just said becomes a question for Congress.
Do we put aside?
Potentially.
Do we put aside some of these questions and focus on getting a deal on something like Medicaid?
Well, first of all, you're going to, in my view, not discount that Trump could sign something.
Like Josh just, Senator has mentioned that he's campaigned on raising the minimum wage, right?
And many people did.
Is it possible that majorities in the House and the Senate could pass
the first raise in the minimum wage since 2007, negotiate what that number will be,
show back to Iowans, we put it on the Trump's desk?
What do you think Trump's going to do?
If you think you know, you don't know, right?
No one knows.
But I think it's our obligation to compel that action.
The last time we raised the minimum wage was when President George W. Bush was president.
The House came in with majority leaders Pelosi and Harry Reid.
It was $5.25 an hour then.
They compelled, they put it on his desk, they put it in a bill, and they said,
Mr. President, you're raising the minimum wage from $5.15 to $7.25 an hour.
That was the last time we did it.
So my point being that don't just think, oh, well, Trump's president,
all we can do is investigate him.
All we can do is, yes, we can do that.
But we've won, to his great credit and to so many prairie populists,
speaking to this economic pain, we can and should deliver on health care expansion,
raising the minimum wage, and so many other things.
He took on big ag in a very successful way.
Cancer rates in Iowa are going up.
Many people angry at the consolidation in agriculture.
Now, is that a world that you could imagine, that working with people who are
similarly minded?
Yeah.
Yeah.
They're similarly minded about wanting to take on that power as possible, right?
I got to believe it's possible.
So, and I want to open this up to everybody, but I'll start with you.
Senator-elect Turek, that's fun to say.
Must be strange to hear this week.
You know, a big part of what we've seen is a shift of rural voters to the right.
And that's happened over many years as these parts of the country has felt as though
the Democratic Party didn't represent them, their policies didn't speak to them.
I think there's been also a lot of propaganda.
There's been a lot of propaganda to make Democrats seem like, you know, outsiders to those communities
trapped in the cities, which many of us are.
What would you like to see now that we have this sort of this new vanguard in places like
Iowa, in Kansas, Democrats do in the Senate and in Congress to prove that we deserve the
support of rural parts of the country again?
And I'm curious what others think about that, too.
Certainly going to have to provide results.
I mean, Iowa has been hurt more by the war in Iran.
You know, gas prices.
Going up diesel prices at an all time high as farmers are out there harvesting their
crops, input prices like fertilizer prices skyrocketing, and they were already skyrocketing
because we had done nothing to address monopolies.
The tariffs were really decimating my state in particular.
So I think we need to have mandatory of country and origin labeling on beef and pork.
We can we can help bring back actually beef producers in this country that way.
I would like to see us pass a farm bill.
I'd like to see us have year.
There's a lot that we can do, but we need to pass a farm bill, but a farm bill that doesn't just benefit big ag that actually benefits rural communities and small family farms because it has been the rural communities that have been hurt the most by the policies the war in Iran, the tariffs, the Medicaid cuts, I mean, in a state like mine, three point two million in the last six years, we've closed eight hundred and forty two health care entities, one hundred and sixty independent pharmacies, and that's what we need to pass a farm bill, but a farm bill that doesn't just benefit big ag that actually benefits rural communities and small family farms because it has been the rural communities that have been hurt the most by the policies, the war in Iran, the tariffs, the Medicaid cuts, I mean, in a state like mine, three point two million in the last six years, we've closed eight hundred and forty two health care entities, one hundred and sixty independent pharmacies.
These are communities that are hurting and struggling.
We've got to pass a farm bill to actually provide results for these people.
I'd love to ask a follow up question about the farm bill.
You know, we were talking earlier about like, what would a real cost of living agenda look like?
It's like it's so ironic that just two years ago, Trump won for the exact same reason that Americans just repudiated him, which was cost of living.
And now there's a real opportunity to build a cost of living agenda.
If we imagine it as like a stool, I definitely know two legs of the stool.
You just said diesel, gas.
Elaine, we got to get out of Iran.
The tariffs, they severely hurt a lot of states.
And I think I was toward the top of that list.
But I'm interested in what the rest of that cost of living agenda looks like.
What actually brings down prices for everyday staples?
And maybe you can talk a little bit about what the farm bill could include, like what policies we could put in a farm bill that doesn't just help, as you said, the biggest companies, but also helps.
And what are some of the things that you would like to see in the future?
I would say one, we've got to make sure that wages keep up.
And so raising the minimum wage, I've said the very first bill I want to sponsor is a dignity and work bill.
Raise the minimum wage, do away with subminimum wage and also pass the PRO Act so our workers can collectively bargain.
Got to end the war, got to repeal the tariffs as well.
Guardrails on insurance companies.
I mean, my God, doctors should be deciding care, not insurance companies.
We've got to bring back the ACA subsidies.
That was 119.
1,000 Iowans that were seeing their health care premiums double or triple in a state like mine as well, prioritizing public education.
I think we were the gold standard because we're giving public dollars to private schools.
We've dropped down to the bottom half.
More infrastructure to address cancer rates and water quality is another point.
Yeah.
And I also have a question.
We're now three interviewers to one subject.
So one thing that we briefly talked about is that we're seeing kind of a nationwide test.
And I think that's a lot to do with people's real struggles with affordability and not wanting to see more of their money going to government.
But, you know, obviously there is raising taxes on the wealthy and raising the corporate tax rate.
But we're seeing people wanting to eliminate income taxes on large swaths of the population, wanting to see people eliminate tax on tips and tax on lots of different kinds of groups that will really drain the ability for us to do things like fund.
Medicaid, Medicare, Social Security, et cetera.
How are you thinking about this moment in the tax revolt we're facing?
I think we're living through a second Gilded Age right now.
And I think two of the biggest issues is tax avoidance and in addressing the wealth divide.
And so one of the best things we can do, tax billionaires and large corporations are fair share.
I actually I say that I do agree with President Trump.
No tax on tips on overtime on Social Security.
Let's stop shifting the tax burden on the backs of the middle class.
And regressive taxations like sales tax.
And let's actually do what we have done for a large part of this country's history.
And let's tax the rich and the billionaires and large corporations.
They're fair share.
So I interviewed Alyssa Slotkin this morning, and she was talking about the dissatisfaction with the possibility of Chuck Schumer being leader.
There seems to be.
Some sort of text chain going on among some new potential senators.
I don't know if you're on that text chain, if you've been added yet.
Are you part of discussions about who the next leader should be?
Are you planning to vote for Chuck Schumer?
Can you unlock your phone and just give it to John?
I think the question.
You wouldn't like the amount of text messages that I've got to respond to.
I am not in that text thread.
I will.
I will tell you what.
I am excited to sit down and meet my colleagues here.
Just got off a plane literally like an hour ago.
And I want to sit down and I want to speak to every single person that is wanting to run for leader.
And I want to ask them a variety of questions.
I want to say, what are you going to do for Iowa?
What are you going to do for Iowans?
What are you going to do for the middle class?
What are you going to do for the workers?
What are you going to do for the rural communities that are being decimated?
What are you going to do for small family farms?
I mean, for 450 days, I've been out here running on this prairie populace agenda.
And that is a livable wage, affordable housing, driving private equity out of housing, health care.
nursing homes. Healthcare is a human right. Affordable pharmaceuticals, drinkable water,
functioning public schools, term limits, banning members of Congress, overturning Citizens United.
The person that I will vote for is the person that most best aligns with that. And I'm excited
to sit down with everybody that wants to run for leadership because we've been given a mandate by
the American people and we need to come through with solutions. It's funny. I'm seeing Faz just
sitting there being like, I don't even have to say anything and I'm winning this conversation.
Credit to Senator Turek. How many events did you do in Iowa during the course of your campaign?
Oh God, I don't know. 450 days, 99 counties. We went to every single large community,
mid-sized community, small community. I think that when you were asking me about,
you know, losing touch with rural communities, I think that's been one of the problems
is that you haven't had enough Democrats that were willing to go into these deeply red counties.
And, you know, for me, what was a benefit was I have been for the last four years,
the Democrat that represents the reddest district in the Iowa legislature.
So the two communities I represent, Trump won by 18 points and 10 points.
I had to talk to a lot of Republicans. And I realized that if you're willing to get face
to face with them and talk to them, say, look, not vilify them. I understand why you voted for them.
I understand why you voted for Trump. Because he accurately identified the status quo wasn't
working for you. But here's the solution to those problems. We could win them over.
So I spent so much time in rural communities with farmers. And I think that's why we were successful.
You know, give me your thought. Are all tariffs bad, Senator Turek?
Not all tariffs are bad, but I'll tell you what, this chaotic, look, I didn't hear that. I just,
I'm not kidding. I got off a plane.
I got off a plane literally a second ago. So I didn't hear earlier part. Here's what I'll say
about tariffs. You were just, honestly, that is, I just want to say something. If you're doing that
inside of your relationships, shame on you. All right. It is not healthy to go look for outside
validators. Just represent yourself and talk to Jerusalem directly if you have a disagreement.
Senator, all I know, you gave me a candidate who has talked to real people and we're going to just
hear because I believe Senator Turek has heard from some real people. Now, honestly, like,
give us the tariffs answer. How do you talk to Iowans about tariffs?
Wait, but what are good tariffs?
Good tariffs are tariffs that protect American jobs and American manufacturing. So, for example,
like the automobile industry is a good example of a tariff that I think is positive, not off the
backs of rural communities or the agriculture industry and not this chaotic tariffs. Farmers
need trade and free markets more than any other group. And when you're going after, they have lost
their markets. It has led to commodities prices being upside down. So, when you're going after
their primary trade partners, Canada, Mexico, I mean, we have completely lost the soybean market
with China because of these ridiculous tariffs. So, smart strategic tariffs to protect American
jobs, not off the backs of the agriculture industry or off the backs of Iowa farmers.
But Jerusalem, I would, I'll ask you a question. Presumably, if we are in some sort of a dispute
with a country like China that does do a lot of anti-trade policies and protectionist policies,
presumably a good tariff is a tariff that we apply as leverage in a negotiation towards
ultimately a more free trade agreement. There certainly are good tariffs that help American
workers. Yeah. I mean, I want to be very clear here. All tariffs raise prices. So, the question
is, what do we think are worth raising prices for? For national security, of course, we should raise
prices. If we're saying that the Chinese government is creating market power in a way that's going to
disrupt our ability as a nation to fight wars, of course. But like, we understand that the way that
we're doing that is raising prices on consumers. We're not pretending that that's somehow like good
for people. I think that most of the ways that people talk about protecting American workers
through tariffs can be done through subsidization just as easily without raising prices. So much of
what the, you know, the climate bill under Biden did was it subsidized a ton of industries in the
United States to make it possible for them to build tons of clean energy. My husband works for
a thermal battery company that got one of these tax credits and is literally right now helping
decarbonize the grid because of these investments. And that's a way you can improve American jobs.
That's a way that you can do that without raising prices. So, every time someone suggests a tariff
to you, first, you should ask yourself, is this worth raising costs to the American people at
the moment when they have told you the number one thing they care about is raising prices?
Sometimes it is. And two, is there any other economic tool you can use other than, you know,
tariffs to get to the same ends? Is there redistribution of taxes towards people that
we think are in economic pain? Is it raising the minimum wage? Is it increasing subsidization of
various industries? All of these are tools that many people can use that don't raise prices.
And so to me, yeah, sure. I agree. There are some strategic tariffs you can do, but
most of what Biden was doing was, I think, quite bad as well as what Trump was doing,
including the tariffs on lumber from Canada, the tariffs that were protecting American jobs.
Which I think did not actually do that.
Well, Senator-elect Josh Turek, thank you so much for taking the time to be here. I'm glad you could
be here and bring some of your experience from being on the ground in Iowa, because I think it's
really helpful. And I appreciate this panel for having this discussion, because I think what's
exciting about this election is it gives us an opportunity to kind of move a lot of these debates
forward and find the places of consensus and brand new stuff to fight about. And so thank you to Derek
Thompson. Thank you to Jerusalem Denses.
Thanks, Shakir. And thank you, Senator-elect Josh Turek.
You can try it for free at ZipRecruiter.com slash Crooked. ZipRecruiter has a new feature that shows
you the most interested, qualified candidates first, so you meet the right people faster.
ZipRecruiter's powerful matching technology finds quality candidates quickly. Candidates can tell
you in their own words why they're excited about the job you're hiring for. No wonder ZipRecruiter
is the number one rated hiring site based on G2. That we've used ZipRecruiter here at Crooked,
it has drastically sped up the process. We found great candidates. We found them faster. We didn't
work through a ton of resumes for folks that just like were not good fits for the job. We highly
recommend it and think you'll love ZipRecruiter too. Let ZipRecruiter find the right people for
your roles, seasonal or otherwise. Try it for free today at ZipRecruiter.com slash Crooked.
That's ZipRecruiter.com slash Crooked. Meet your match on ZipRecruiter.
Please give Senator Kelly a warm welcome.
Thank you for doing this.
I want to ask you about the election results, the campaign,
what's going to come next in the Senate, what may be coming next in your life.
But I want to start with some news we got yesterday. Yesterday, Donald Trump fired Susie
Wiles, being appointed Stephen Miller as chief of staff. To get your reaction to that,
what do you think it means for what the next two years are going to look like in America?
Well, I was really surprised. I thought the president would have learned a
lesson from last Tuesday. Famously introspective, Donald Trump, yes.
Right. Apparently, 80-year-old men like this president don't learn lessons.
He represents the worst of this administration. And the stuff he has done on immigration
enforcement has resulted in dead Americans and people illegally being sent overseas. It's been a
disaster. Now with him as the chief of staff, I don't know if the president can push back against
this guy. So I'm worried about it. And we'll have to see what happens. Donald Trump has the right,
I guess, to put whoever he wants in that job. We have no role in the Senate. We can complain about
it. That's about it. Maybe he won't be there for long. That's the hope.
There's not a long shelf life for most of the chief of staff over the years.
Susie Wiles was the outlier.
Yeah. I mean, two years.
Yeah. And it's interesting, the people that get fired in this administration happen to be women,
right? Yes.
Right. Kristi Noem, Tulsi Gabbard, Pam Bondi, now Susie Wiles. I can think of others that also need
a good firing. Yes. We got a couple of those on our list we're going to get to. Let's talk about
the election. You spent a lot of time, you were traveling all over the country. I just want to
get a sense of what, you know, obviously we thought we might get a blue wave, thought we'd get a blue
wave. We got something even better than that. Just your sense on what drove this election and
reaction to the results. Well, we did a little poll in my Senate office the day before the
election about how this would all turn out. I've been to 23 states campaigning with people this
election cycle, Senate candidates, House candidates, governors, even ledge candidates,
and I could really feel the energy. So when I filled out my little ballot for our in-office
poll, I put us at 55 Democratic senators and 250 House members. That's pretty good.
Yeah. And most people thought I was crazy. But I could really feel it. And we have great
candidates that were running. I was down helping Annie Andrews in South Carolina.
About a year and a half ago, I'm sitting on my daughter's couch in Tucson.
My daughter, Claudia, and she says to me, Dad, do you know Annie Andrews? And I said,
never heard of her. And he says, she's running for Senate in South Carolina. Watch this video.
So a couple days later, I called her, reached out to her, started talking to her and
kept in touch. And I really saw something there. I thought, if things went well, she could win in
South Carolina. And of course, she did. But now we might even win a seat in Mississippi.
I'm so glad you had the reaction to Annie Andrews because I interviewed her on Pod Save America.
And it was sort of when Darlene Graham was already the nominee. It was already
the nominee. And I was like, maybe you have like, just mathematically, maybe there's a shot. But then
you when you meet her, she is a star. Like you just know right away, she is an absolute star.
Yeah, I became a big fan.
You have, you know, now, we're sort of like the dog that caught the car,
right? Voters picked us, picked Democrats because they're angry about costs,
and they want to end the war.
And recognizing that Donald Trump is a veto pen, and the filibuster still exists and all of this,
but what can, what do you think Democrats need to do in the Senate to be responsive to exactly
what voters are want right now? Hey, we have to deliver. We've got to deliver on cost.
We got to deliver on this war and do things to compel this president to end it. He also needs
to get rid of, I talked about firings. He needs to get rid of the Secretary of Defense.
I mean, this guy, I mean, if I was to rank the disasters in this administration as people,
he's the biggest disaster. I mean, he is the one that drove this conflict,
that convinced the president. It seems that he convinced the president this is going to take
a number of days. And now we're over six months. And he is by far the least qualified person for
a cabinet position in this administration.
Thank you.
He also made a decision. I think it was him. We need to find out. And I would like to find out
who drove the war plan. Like, why did we bomb 16,000 targets and use up an enormous amount
of munitions? That, by the way, means that all of us, everybody in here, everybody across the
country is now less safe because Pete Hegseth had no idea what he was doing. That guy needs to be
the president. He needs to go. The president should fire him. If he doesn't, we'll see what
happens this week.
On Hegseth, like Thomas Massey in the House has proposed an impeachment process. Are you open to
that process? If it comes to you in the Senate, do you think he should be impeached?
Did you look at the articles of impeachment?
Yes, yes.
I mean, one of them is about me, specifically.
I just want to get you on the record here. Yes.
So, yeah, of course.
And it's not just because it's me in the articles of impeachment. This guy,
and the worst thing he's done has nothing to do with me.
Though he is trying to silence millions of veterans, especially retired service members
like myself. He wants to shut us up. I mean, I said something, president didn't like it.
President said I should be hanged, executed, prosecuted. He couldn't even get the order right.
And then they tried to prosecute me and five of my colleagues. When that didn't work,
Pete Hegseth tried to reduce me in rank and take away my pension. So then I had to sue him.
So that case is still working its way through the court. I was wondering just the other day,
if he's no longer the secretary of defense, what happens to my lawsuit?
Because it's Kelly versus Hegseth.
I think they just swap out Kelly versus whoever the next Fox Weekend anchor is who gets the job.
Yes.
Right.
Jesse Waters.
I was going to say Fox is Kelly versus Waters. Yes.
Can you talk a little bit about the, like, obviously, as you mentioned,
the idea of the conception and execution of the Iran war plan has been disastrous.
But it's not obviously the only thing that Hegseth is doing to the Pentagon. Just talk about what
do you think about the long-term damage to the morale, the readiness, the safety of the American
people through his leadership at the Pentagon?
Well, all of that.
I mean, it's been a long, long time. has been negatively affected, right? Morales in the gutter, the firings of admirals and generals,
some of our best leaders dismissed without cause, just changing the culture. The culture is about
killing people and lethality. Those are Hegseth's words. He would run around on a stage. I've never
seen anything like this from anybody that I've ever served with. I spent 25 years in the United
States Navy on active duty. From senior enlisted to junior officer to senior officers, I've never
seen anything like that, where it becomes just about how many people can we kill at any given
moment in any given conflict. And then this whole thing about testosterone. I mean, the U.S.
military doesn't need more testosterone. It needs better leadership right now.
And that starts with him. So it's going to take a while to put the pieces back together.
And the damage to the leadership ranks with these admirals and generals being dismissed,
that's one thing. The other problem is that we have a lot of officers, middle grade officers,
that probably thought to themselves, maybe it's a woman or a person of color
that says, hey, there's not a place for me here anymore.
And they'll just leave. And we've already seen that. They've already been leaving.
And that's going to hurt us for more than a generation.
I assume one of the areas that with the Senate Democrats' newfound ability to do oversight and
to look into things that you want to look at is the boat strikes in the Caribbean.
How are you thinking about that?
There's a video out there of the, well, it's not out there yet. It will be eventually.
And it might be in 2029.
When there's a Democrat in the White House, I don't think this president,
under any circumstances, is going to release evidence that that damning of this administration.
But eventually, it'll be out there. That has to be investigated. We got to get to the bottom of
who made the decision to do this. After a period of time, this is one of the Venezuelan,
the first boat that was struck, there were survivors. And then sometime later,
they hit it with a second weapon.
And killed those survivors. And the rationale they gave to do that is complete
bullshit.
I was like, you can say it.
I mean, it was, it makes no sense. And in the law of war manual in the military,
or the law of armed conflict, talks specifically about survivors in the water and how they must
be treated. It's also in the Geneva Conventions.
And I think any analysis of that situation, you're like, well, they didn't get treated in
accordance with the law. So that needs to be investigated. And there needs to be accountability.
But that and the war in Iran, I mean, that's just the tip of the iceberg.
There's all the stuff we don't know.
Yeah.
Right. That's when you see these kind of really bad policy decisions and also corruption in this
administration.
Yeah.
I think the corruption stuff is, we're probably the tip of the iceberg.
It is notable that we're only talking about the war crimes they announced. We don't even know
about the ones they didn't announce.
That's right.
Let's talk a little bit about affordability. And so, like you said, we got to get, you got to get
something and we got to deliver. Are there some specific ideas you think the Senate should get
to work on right away?
Well, I have legislation to suspend the gas tax and also the diesel tax and aviation fuel tax.
That's pretty straightforward. And that will help people.
I mean, it's not everything. We got to get to the root cause of some of these problems. And on fuel,
the root cause is in the Middle East with the Strait of Hormuz. So the president's got to figure
out a way out. He started this thing. And the problem that he immediately got into is he started
it without a well-defined strategic goal. And without the goal, you can't come up with a plan.
So then he turned it over to Pete Hegseth. And that's why he had this ridiculous plan.
To drop an enormous number of munitions on an enormous number of targets unnecessarily,
killing a lot of Iranians that didn't need to die. We've got dead Americans, injured Americans,
all because there wasn't a well-defined strategic goal at the beginning.
He also didn't anticipate something I imagine people must have told them that the Iranians
can shut down the Strait. So we can't leave the Strait closed. We don't want to. I wouldn't
like to see that. So he's got to figure out a way out. And that means a negotiated settlement.
If I gave the president any advice on this, it would be to fire his son-in-law and his
golf buddy.
Dan, there is no chance the best person in our country to negotiate an end to this just
happens to be his son-in-law.
That's not possible.
So they've got to get rid of them.
And then I think Donald Trump is going to have to accept a deal that was like the one
he tore up.
Is he going to be able to do that?
That's the question.
If he doesn't, I think he just kicks the can down the road until he's gone.
Are there things that Democrats and Congress can do to force his hand, either through war
powers resolution or funding?
And Hakeem Jeffries the other day said, we've got to bring this war to an end.
We're going to try to end this war.
I think the funding.
OK, can you talk a little bit about that and how you're thinking about it?
I mean, they've got to come to Congress for money.
They're asking for $1.5 trillion for the defense budget, a ridiculous sum of money.
Also asking for a supplemental on munitions.
There's also ultimately, if you want to use the big hammer, the big hammer is White House
operations funding.
We control that.
So if he can't find a way out of this, we can put pressure on him.
And by the way, that $1.5 trillion, that is an obscene amount of money.
As I said, you know, I'm on the Armed Services Committee.
I served in the United States Navy for decades.
I really care about the capability of the military.
And service members having what they need to defend us.
When I got to the Senate five and a half years ago, well, next month, it'll be six years.
The defense budget was $740 billion.
Now they're asking for $1.5 trillion, more than double.
Let me ask you something.
Do you feel so unsafe that we should be spending twice on defense as we did six years ago?
I don't.
I mean, we've got challenges.
Yes.
We certainly have challenges.
And we've got to build the military we need to deal with those challenges.
But we can't be wasteful about it.
And this president is asking for programs that we don't need, like his Trump-class battleship
with his name on it and stuff that won't work.
The space-based interceptors for Golden Dome being at the top of the list for me.
So we've got to right-size the defense budget.
But in order to get anything done, right, you're going to need just not on the war,
but on whether it's your gas tax legislation or any of the other affordability measures,
you need both Republicans and Trump.
Let's put Trump aside.
I'm not going to even ask you to predict his behavior.
But do you think that there will be, in the wake of this election result, Trump's unpopularity,
the fact that Republican senators now know they're not safe in places like Kansas,
Mississippi?
South Carolina, perhaps a little more willingness to find a spine from your Republican colleagues?
Yeah, I think so.
I also think, you know, Tuesday was a big win for the American people.
I wouldn't even frame it as a win for Democrats.
They just don't like the Republicans more than they don't like us right now.
Right?
So we're given an opportunity.
We've got to deliver for the American people.
And if I was a Republican in the Senate,
I'd want to be on the side of the American people.
And that's not being on the side of Donald Trump right now.
So I think we'll get some more support.
We're going to have to see.
We'll find out more on Monday and Tuesday.
And then we'll be back the following week.
You're going to have a lot of new colleagues in the Senate come January.
Many of them who were elected have said that they
do not intend to support Chuck Schumer for Senate leader.
They are, they say.
They're looking for new leadership.
Just curious how you're thinking about what's going to happen there,
about whether anyone might challenge him, how you think at least even if it's not,
if no one challenges Schumer, how Senate Democrats can be responsive to this view
that we need a fresh approach that's akin to what the voters wanted.
Well, we've got to be responsive and we've got to do things differently than we've done before.
We've got to deliver.
We've got to be aggressive about it.
The corruption thing, I think, is at the top of the list.
The stock trading of members of Congress.
By the way, I don't do that.
Of 535 members, I'm pretty sure this is still accurate.
I'm the only person with a blind trust, a public schedule, and don't take any corporate PAC money.
So I would like everybody to meet that standard.
But we also have to get to the bottom of this.
Get to the bottom of this president and his corruption, the crypto scams,
the $400 million airplane from Qatar, selling the American people crappy phones and bad meat and wine and all this stuff.
I mean, this is just ridiculous.
It's at a level that's almost incomprehensible, right?
Unlike anything we've seen before.
So we've got to get to the bottom of that.
And we've got to.
We've got to show the American people this corruption.
I think it's one of the reasons they lost on Tuesday.
I'd actually put it at the top of the list.
You know, when Donald Trump does the first corrupt thing, like maybe his first crypto scam,
I think a lot of people might be thinking, OK, maybe that's not true.
When you get to, like, through a dozen corrupt things, I think people start to figure it out.
And I'll tell you what, they don't like it.
You know, they don't like hearing.
That there are members of the Ag Committee in the Senate that trade cattle futures.
Think about that for a second.
Do you think you can get the ban on members trading stocks done?
Like, everyone keeps talking about it.
We've been talking about it since 2018.
And it keeps not getting done, which really does feed a lot of cynicism of the American people.
I would recommend to anybody in the House or the Senate, don't be on the wrong side of that boat.
Yes, it is an 80-20 issue, yes.
Yeah, well, the American people now realize what's going on here with folks who are making
millions and millions of dollars on information that the American people don't have and members
of Congress only have because they have this job.
It's it has to stop.
It is.
And I think it will.
I think I think this is the moment after the election.
Hakeem Jeffries was on Morning Joe and he said, I'm paraphrasing here.
The American people sent us here to get stuff done, not just to get even.
A lot of people missed the just in there.
But obviously,
you know, we know that people want to check on Donald Trump, but they also and this is
something that showed up in a lot of focus groups and polling voters sometimes think
that we're too obsessed with Trump at the cost of other stuff.
How are you sort of thinking that balance between making sure that we hold them accountable,
but maybe not making it our entire personality as a party?
Well, you know, I'm thinking of like, put this stuff in like three buckets.
There's the accountability bucket.
We've got to do something there.
We are a country of laws.
And if we abandon the rule of law, then we're just.
We just become a banana republic.
There has to be the delivering for the American people.
We have to send stuff to his desk that he'll sign.
And then I think we've got to be a little bit more ambitious and show the American people what we could do if we were also in charge of the White House.
So I would separate it that way.
But I agree with you.
It can't look like me.
You didn't say this.
These are my words.
I don't want it to look like a witch hunt.
I think it's got to be the most egregious stuff.
And it's also about showing the American people what actually is happening with this administration.
It needs to be part of what we do.
It can't be everything.
Okay.
I'm going to ask you some questions here.
I suspect you're not going to answer them, but we're just going to.
I always answer all the questions.
Well, you say the word.
I mean, everyone says the words after the question.
But so I would say among the people who have been out there, whose names are.
Mentioned about 2028, you have been maybe the most forthright about the idea that you might be thinking about it.
It's because I'm old.
I'm always honest when I give these.
Okay.
So are you Senator Mark Kelly?
Are you planning to run for president?
I am thinking about it.
Okay.
All right.
Okay.
That's good.
Not everyone on the stage has been that explicit.
Talk.
I'm also talking to my my family about it.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I want to talk to me about.
We've had conversations.
We're going to continue to have.
Yeah.
Talk about your your process for making decision.
In addition to talking your family, what you're evaluating, how you think about it and why you think were you to make the decision, you would be the right person for this job.
That's a big part of it.
I don't have the typical resume of somebody in the US Senate.
And I spent the first part of my career flying off of an aircraft carrier.
I flew thirty nine combat missions in the first Gulf War.
I was undergrad in marine engineering, not many of them in the United States Congress.
And then I went to grad school, got a master's degree in aeronautical engineering, went to test pilot school, worked as a Navy test pilot for a while.
Then I was an instructor at the school.
Then I went and became an astronaut.
That's the one I wanted to get to.
I did that for fifteen years.
I don't have the typical resume.
I also never like grew up.
planning to be a U.S. senator.
her. I mean, I'm really here because of what happened to Gabby as part of it. That, and I'll
tell you, let me tell you a quick story. The night before the election in 2018, I'm at a get out the
vote rally in Phoenix with my wife, and we're watching the Gin Blossoms. Gin Blossoms fans in
here. This young woman comes up to me. She didn't seem much older than my eldest daughter. And she
just, she was standing next to me and she leans over and she says, hey, my son has Down syndrome
and I'm terrified he's going to lose his health insurance. Would you please consider running for
the U.S. Senate? So I told her I would consider it. That was in November of 2018. I announced in
February. And that's basically why I'm here in this job. My ambition when I was younger was to
be the first person to walk on the planet. I was the first person to walk on the planet. I was the
first person to walk on the planet Mars and I failed miserably. You still got time. You might have
to work with. I don't have a job anymore, right? I don't have a rocket ship anymore. I've heard if
you're a trillionaire, you can buy one. So there is that option. Do you have a timeline about when
you want to make a decision by? These are important questions, people. Why are you laughing? I do.
Can you share what that is? No. Okay. Well, that was honest. I will say that. Yes. Senator Mark Kelly.
Thank you so much for answering almost all of my questions. You're welcome. Thank you, guys.
Thank you, everybody. All right. Thanks, everybody, for listening. John and Dan will be back in your
feeds with a new episode on Friday.
You're probably unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The election results reveal a shift toward economic populism, where candidates successfully blend diverse ideological viewpoints to build broad coalitions.
Voters are primarily driven by anger over cost of living, inflation, and economic injustice, making policy responses to these issues central to winning support.
Healthy populism channels public frustration into constructive policy—such as expanding healthcare, regulating big tech, or protecting workers—rather than promoting divisive or harmful solutions.
Populism must be distinguished from authoritarian or reactionary rage, with effective politics requiring both emotional resonance and pragmatic, evidence-based solutions.
Candidates like Josh Turek and Zoran Omdani demonstrate that winning requires delivering tangible policy results on housing, minimum wage, and rural economic relief.
There is growing consensus across the left that economic populism, rooted in working-class concerns, can unite diverse factions under a shared agenda.
The Democratic Party’s future depends on balancing emotional appeal with policy depth, especially in areas like housing, energy, and agricultural reform.
A new generation of politicians is emerging who prioritize outcomes over ideological purity, focusing on real-world solutions to economic pain points.
Summary:
S. elections, where voters' frustration over cost of living, inflation, and economic inequality has become the defining political issue. Candidates from across the ideological spectrum—such as Josh Turek, Zoran Omdani, and others—emerged by centering working-class concerns like affordable housing, minimum wage increases, and access to healthcare.
The discussion highlights how effective populism is not about rage or division, but about translating public anger into concrete, actionable policies. While some critics warn of unhealthy populism—such as anti-immigrant or anti-trans rhetoric—there is broad agreement that constructive populism must channel frustration toward solutions like regulating big tech, ending harmful tariffs, and supporting rural economies. Notably, the success of candidates in rural states like Iowa shows that economic authenticity and policy results are more critical than ideological purity.
The conversation underscores a shared ambition: to rebuild a progressive movement rooted in economic justice, where policy outcomes reflect the lived realities of ordinary people. Ultimately, the dialogue suggests that the future of progressive politics lies not in ideological purity, but in pragmatic, inclusive, and outcome-driven governance that responds to public pain with tangible reforms. This approach unites liberals, social democrats, and economic populists around a common goal: to create a fairer, more stable economy for all.
FAQs
Voters are increasingly angry about cost of living, housing, and inflation. Candidates who channel that anger into tangible policy solutions—like affordable housing, minimum wage increases, or ending harmful tariffs—are better able to win support, especially in rural and working-class communities.
Politicians are learning that successful campaigns require blending ideas from various factions—like economic populism, abundance economics, and social justice—instead of sticking to a single ideological stance, creating more inclusive and broadly appealing policies.
Town halls allow candidates to directly hear voter frustrations and adjust their messaging in real time. For example, many candidates shifted from supporting AI development to expressing concern about data centers after hearing public anger about rising costs and job impacts.
Populism can be constructive when it channels anger toward specific policies—like regulating big tech or reducing housing costs—but can become destructive when it leads to simplistic, harmful solutions, such as mass deportations or anti-immigration policies.
Economic populism focuses on solving real-life issues like housing affordability and healthcare costs, while traditional liberalism often emphasizes market-based solutions. The former is more directly responsive to working-class pain points, even if it challenges conventional economic thinking.
Key solutions include raising the minimum wage, expanding universal child care, freezing property taxes for seniors, passing permitting reforms to make housing construction easier, and ending tariffs that raise prices for everyday goods.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.