M. Fakhry Davids, "Internal Racism: A Psychoanalytic Approach to Race and Difference" (Red Globe, 2011)
from New Books in Psychoanalysis
53m 31s
Focerie David’s *Internal Racism* offers a groundbreaking psychoanalytic framework for understanding how racism is not merely a social phenomenon but a deeply internalized structure of the mind. Rooted in his experience of apartheid South Africa and influenced by Frantz Fanon, David introduces the concept of an "internal racist organization" (IRO)—an unconscious defensive system that forms during early development through splitting and projective identification. This organization, which emerges from the paranoid-schizoid position and solidifies during stranger anxiety, leads to identification with dominant power groups and internalization of societal stereotypes. Unlike traditional psychoanalytic models that focus on pathology, David argues that the IRO is a normal part of the psyche, activated when individuals interact with members of outgroups who challenge the false binary of "us versus them." The book reveals that ordinary human connection—such as conversations with people of different racial backgrounds—triggers internal anxiety, exposing the fragile boundaries of this defensive system. David emphasizes that racism functions as a psychic mechanism to contain destructive impulses, allowing individuals to avoid confronting their own hatred and fear. He critiques the idea that race and gender are interchangeable in psychoanalytic theory, asserting that racial dynamics operate in a more primitive, pre-Oedipal realm, distinct from the Oedipal struggle. The work also highlights a key insight: it is easier to be a victim of racism than a perpetrator, as the psychic work of the former is more visible and reactive, while the perpetrator’s internal work is often hidden and unconscious. This underscores the necessity for psychoanalysts to confront their own biases and white privilege through self-reflection, leading to institutional change. The book has had a significant impact on psychoanalytic discourse, particularly in the United States, where it has inspired movements toward reparative practices and truth and reconciliation in professional institutions. Ultimately, David’s model redefines racism as a developmental and psychic reality, suggesting that healing requires not only external justice but deep internal transformation.
Welcome to the new Books Network.
Hi, my name is Tracy Morgan and I am your host at New Books and Psychoanalysis and
today we're delighted to have with us, Focerie David, who will be discussing his book published
in 2011 by Red Globe Press, I believe, Internal Racism, a Psychoanalytic approach to race
and difference. Welcome, Focerie, to this show and we're delighted to have you here.
Thank you very much, Tracy. It's a real pleasure to be here and thank you for selecting the
book to talk about.
Sure. I was just recalling that I read the book maybe about a year ago and I've taught
it now once and I'm about to teach aspects of it again. So for me, it's an amazing experience
to be able to speak to you while I am working through the material and working through the material
with Psychoanalytic Canada. So I want to give Focerie's bio and a little information about
him. Let's see. So you're in Britain. So MSC is new to me. That means you're a clinical
psychologist. That's correct? Yeah. Okay. Great. So Focerie David is a clinical psychologist
and a psychoanalysis full-time clinical practice. He is a fellow in training analyst of the
British Psychoanalytic Society. A member of the Path of Stock Society of Psychotherapists,
a board member of PCCA partners in confronting collective atrocities, a member of the IPA
Liaison Committee for SAPA South African Psychoanalytic Association, and a member of APSA's
Holmes Commission for Racial Equality in Psychoanalysis. He holds honorary appointments in the
Tabestock Clinic, Psychoanalysis Unit, University College London, and the Department of Psychosocial
and Psychoanalytic Studies at the University. And he is, for previously mentioned, the author
of internal racism, Psychoanalytic approach to race and difference. And I said it was red glow,
but it's actually palgrés in the smell, and it was a little confusing for me who the publisher
was as I read inside. So let's get started. What we tend to do at New Books and Psychoanalysis
focus. We ask every author to the degree that you can tell us your motivation or that
you can know your motivation for what you do. What motivated you to write this book?
It goes back a long way, Tracy. I grew up in apartheid South Africa, which is where I
did my clinical psychology training. And during my postgraduate psychology studies,
I discovered Franz Fanon's work, "Black Skin White Masks," which was the most extraordinary
discovery. You'll know that Fanon speaks in a way that hits you in the solar plexus,
and he opened my eyes to what was going on inside of my head in relation to racism,
the experience of racism, in a way that was just utterly mind-blowing. And of course,
in that book Fanon also makes the case that psychoanalysis needs to account for this
in some sort of meaningful way. And if you've read it, the red black skin white masks,
you'll remember Fanon went almost apoplectic on discovering the way Manoni approached
the problem of colonial interracial relationships. So to put that another way,
psychoanalysis at that time couldn't offer anything that actually helped us to understand
what goes on inside the mind. You know, that would account for some of the stuff
that Fanon articulate so beautifully. You know, some of the agony, some of the pain,
some of the splits inside the mind that are instituted, and which you struggle,
you know, endlessly, it seems, to try and overcome, so that you can become
something that resembles a whole person without bits of your experience,
chronically sort of split off and left outside. So that for me, you know,
became, you know, a bit of a mission I wanted to see, you know, is it possible
to bring that into one sense of who one is as a person? So to put that in a nutshell,
psychoanalysis knows a hell of a lot about how we're helped to become ourselves,
but mostly that excludes considering our experience of racism.
So I was always interested to see, is it possible to find a way to incorporate that
and have we psychoanalysis discipline made any progress in our approach
to these phenomena from the time of Manoni? So that's what brought me.
And of course, you can't do the work before becoming a psychoanalyst yourself,
so that takes decades. But this book sort of represents an attempt,
you know, to go back to that business and to see what could be done.
Now, of course, important because Franz Fanon didn't do the analytic training,
and he wasn't a psychoanalyst, although often he's thought of as one.
So I was curious to see if one went through the rigors of this and became
an insider in this discipline. Was there any way what could return meaningfully to the problem?
So one of the most exciting sort of impact of the book is it's so rare.
I read all the time and do interviews and I'm sort of surveying the field,
the written field of psychoanalysis, and it really is rare to find a new idea.
And when I find one, I really want to do the interview with the author.
And I certainly think your book puts forth not just a new idea,
but an entirely different, in some ways, model of the mind, of psychic structure.
And I want to ask you to, because I think it's so groundbreaking,
and has such incredible implications, this idea of the internal racist organization,
I haven't written down the IRO and all my notes about the IRO, the IRO.
You know, it's thinking about the internal racist organization.
As forming, I think you say somewhere, a kind of almost used to turn bedrock.
Now we know when you say bedrock in psychoanalysis, you're shaking the bedrock.
Because what Freud put as the bedrock was sexual difference, femininity.
So, I want you, I'm assuming that you have, you know, your steeped in a certain kind of cliny,
and neo-cliny, and know you, and you're coming from there,
and you are adding and augmenting and expanding that view of the inner world.
How does this, this is a huge question, but I mean, how does the internal racist organization come into being?
Maybe we can start there, because I think the audience really was going to be fascinated by it.
I'll answer that in two different ways, Tracy.
Firstly, there is a new idea.
You know, I, I mean, yes, nobody's put this quite in this way, but it's not a brand new idea at all.
As you say, you know, it's just if you remember what I say about my sort of underlying interest,
you know, in addition to learning the craft, the business of becoming a psychoanalyst,
I had this unanswered question that I brought into it.
So that in a way, I think there are many cliny and analysts today who operate within this framework
that I operate in, who think in this way, and for whom what I say about defensive organizations
is absolutely nothing new.
My contribution has been that I brought this unanswered question into this milieu,
and then I've had to angle it in, if you see what I mean, to see canvas work.
So the idea of an organized system of defenses in the mind is absolutely not new.
You know, I came here as a trainee, and at that time we were sort of trying to treat
the sort of borderline narcissistic type patient, the patient that's not amenable easy.
to treat treatment. And the idea that one had to think not as a defense, a set of defenses
that the patient has against particular anxieties, but that the patient lived in their heads
with an organized set of defenses to which they pledged to. Like Rosenfeld's gang leader.
That's Rosenfeld, basically, and John Steiner's concept of his psychic retreat.
All of that's where this is formed.
So, you know, the theoretical foundations had been laid.
What I brought into it is simply the observation that the kinds of things we encounter in the consulting
room when we have such difficult patients is not different from when we all normal all of us enter
the terrain of intercultural, interracial engagement. We seem to freeze. We can't be our ordinary selves.
And that then opens up, and very often, we become politically correct, even though we are not racist
in ourselves. So, that's an interesting observation. And if you then take that further,
then you'll think, "Okay, if I'm acting in a politically correct way,
there must be some unconscious way in which something racist is going on inside my head."
So, it's observations like that, which if you put it together,
make you think, "Okay, so we're in the presence then of a defensive organization,
an organized system of defenses operating unconsciously that sort of take a hold of us
at a particular time." And that produces the paralysis.
So, then you've got the idea that there must be, even though we're not very disturbed patients,
there must be something like a psychic retreat that has come into being. It's come into play
at that moment. And that's the sort of thing that I thought, "All right, that's a good beginning."
Now, to understand how it works, I'm going to have to wait until I encounter one of these things
in the consulting room. And then I'd be able to study this a bit further.
So, you know, it's as most things in psychoanalysis, you've got to wait a long time,
you know, for the right, because you can't, you can't, you know, it's not an experiment,
you can set up, and yeah, analysis just doesn't work like that. Anyway, so eventually,
something came along that I thought, "Right, there I've got the sort of phenomenon that I think
is in play, and that's what I describe in the book." So, my first response is it's not new,
it's not a new formulation of mine. It's the application of the formulation regarding
defensive organizations to racist phenomena, per se. That's my contribution to spell that out.
Now, if I can say one more thing, if I can say one more thing, I think you're being quite modest.
No, it's the scaffolding that one builds on. You see, that if, in your life,
you would season it. I think, anyway, I'll be wrong. And I don't mean to underestimate the amount
of work thinking through, looking at theory and so on, that one has to do. I'm not short-changing
that. So, what did I do? I then looked at the formulations of defensive or pathological
organizations and realized that that is associated with psychopathology. So, if you and I deploy
something like that, it must mean that something like that exists in our minds. Now, once one
conceives that, then you've got to give a developmental account of it. So, for the pathological
organization, it's usually something's gone wrong in the course of development, either environmental
failure or the patient starts off with a psychotic predisposition, but they are not frankly psychotic.
They've got enough ego to organize this kind of defense to hold themselves together. That's in
the case of pathology. In the case of normality, I had to really do some hard work and try and give
an account of how one finished up with this thing in the mind. And that's what you're talking about,
the original work that had to be done. So, shall I say a little bit about that? Again, I rely very
much on the clinean model of development, you know. And I say that for cline, it is perfectly normal
that all of us start in the paranoid schizoid position. That means that our earliest relationships,
what we would call good, is not the whole story. It's based on splitting off bits that are bad.
So, we create two separate objects. And so, our beginning is in a paranoid schizoid way,
that we live in a world of friends and enemies. And we try to consolidate what lies on the good side
with the friends and try and keep our enemies at bay. Now, there's the key moment that's not a
moment, of course, but theoretically a moment that cline describes us, the move to the depressive
position, which is essentially where one has matured a bit, one knows a bit about the way things
are in reality, and that it's not so cleaved between good and bad, and that some process of
integration takes place. Now, that is the normal, usual clinean story, and then one goes on and on,
you know, you're ready to do whatever it is you have to do. Now, I looked at that and saw
that the work on stranger anxiety had not been integrated into that model.
So, that what happens with stranger anxiety is that you encounter the original split between
good and bad, but now no longer between one figure and another, but between the familiar,
they are all assimilated to the schema of the good and the familiar and the known and the love,
but the stranger's treated as if he were a complete monster who's going to do terrible things
to you. So, that stranger anxiety sets in at about eight months, and then by about 12 months, the infant
has done what it did in the depressive position. It's made a kind of peace, it's begun to realize
that in reality, you know, the world doesn't cleave into strangers and friends and all good and
all bad on either side of that divide. So, that's the second thing. And then I thought, now,
once that is detoxified, you can think of it, once it's sorted out, then you've kind of got yourself
in line with reality, is that the end of it? And if you look at developmental research,
you find that that's not the end of it. There's another incarnation of it that is less visible
to us ordinarily. And that's the stuff that Clark and Clark drew attention to first with their
dull studies. And I mean, most people will know them because they're such upsetting findings,
honestly, they bring tears to your eyes, you know, and it makes one feel, how could we do
this to our children? But essentially, what Clark and Clark showed is that your group identity,
that is, if you take, they, they looked at black and white kids in the South,
in American South, to begin with. If you look at group identity, at the earliest stages they
measured about three, four, you find that black and white children identify in line with prevailing
anti-black stereotypes. In other words, white kids have positive notions towards a white
dull, a negative ones towards blacks. Now that everybody expects, you know, they're young, they haven't
yet kind of, you know, got to know how people really are. But the surprising thing was so did
black kids. In other words, they identified against their blackness and with whiteness. And often,
if you watch, you can watch these studies on YouTube, you know, you see they make those choices with
[BLANK_AUDIO]
almost you can see how tortured they are, as if their voices are betraying them, you know,
as if that sort of thing. So I think that what you see there, and those studies incidentally as you
probably know have been replicated across the world, and of course we have to remember our world
today is very much a post-colonial world, where the division between white and power and dark
skinned and disempowered very much permeates our world. That's very very powerful you could say
socio-ideological force that operates out there, but if you look at it like that, that what operates
out there somehow finds its way into the mind. And I think there you see the internalization
of the external divine, and you see that it is beginning to be put into a defensive organization.
So the model of development that I propose is that its trajectory is from the normal splitting
through stranger anxiety, and its final resting place is, as I've said, your identification with
the dominant power group. That's what I think. So I think internal racism is about internalizing
that set of power relationships. Now it's going to make another point about that, but that's gone
from me. I'll come back to you. Bobbie 30 had a long day with patients because he's in England,
and we're here. I'm here in New York and it's just just around lunchtime. So we give him a lot
of latitudes after a full day of listening. I think you make a point and maybe I misunderstand it,
and you could help me out here. I've got the relationship between the waning of the editable
and the development of the internal racist organization. Am I correct that you're saying there is
a relationship there, or have I misread something? I think, you know, I've looked at that because,
as you probably know, many people psychoanalysts think that the race distinction,
black, white, call it, or whatever the one in your world, what many people think that
that is simply from a dynamic point of view, it's a variant of the gender one. In other words,
I mean, a friend of mine in South Africa, Sally Swartz, has written a very lovely paper on that,
where she thinks the race class can't be separated out from gender, that they're all internalized
together in an edible moment. Now, I disagree with that. I don't think that it's got the quality.
If that were the case, then the dynamic between black and white, the interracial dynamic,
would be the same as the edible dynamic in the here and now. And I don't think it is.
I go with the original Freudian conception of that the edipus complex is the moment of
tolerating and resolving in the mind neurotic conflict. And I think there's a lot of evidence
that when you get onto the terrain of race, racial difference, you step onto a different terrain,
that is not one in which conflict is tolerated. In other words, in the edible, typically, you face
the defense of repression, where one bit of the conflict is kept unconscious whilst another
dominates. But because they're repressing the force of keeping it out, is that a pressing force?
It lifts more easily. Whereas when you talk about racist interchange, you are in the area of
things being split off. And today, not repressed, but split off. In other words, they are felt not to
be in the mind, my mind, in other words. But usually, they are in somebody else's mind.
So we're talking the language of splitting and projective identification. And those are not
the part of the classical theoretical conception of the edipus. Now many people change edipus
into something that accommodates that. But I don't think like that. I think it's not conceptually
useful to muddy the waters like that. So therefore, I think that this thing, an internal
racist structure, I'll say a bit more about that in a minute, is in place probably just before
the edipial dynamics begin to come to the surface and present themselves as psychic struggle.
So because it's, if we were to think sort of developmentally that it's earlier more primitive,
more chaotic. Like in moments when, you know, their discussions and groups at institutes, etc,
around racism, you really get to see, you witness a particular amongst white analysts,
thinkers, speakers, myself included a kind of a, my capacity to think disintegrate.
And go someplace where I like a sequel's launch, like, you know, the greens idea of like a white
classic, I was like, because you, because you can feel when that, when that happens and you're
talking and you know that you're not communicating anymore, you're using words, but there's,
and people say some of the strange is almost like non-sequitors and things begin to, not quite
words valid, but things begin to stop making sense, you know, that you feel that more primitive
or communication, yeah. But it's those sorts of observations that make one think that that's
not classically edipial struggle, you know, that's something more primitive, more powerful,
you know, and then if you put it in that framework of the more primitive and more powerful,
then you can begin to make some sort of progress, you can begin to understand, you know,
but, I think, go ahead. But no, a key thing though is this, that I think the internal racist structures,
like, you know, we, you were mentioning Rosenfeld's work earlier, it's like an enclave,
but it's an enclave in a normal mind, whereas what we just encounter in psychopathology is that
it's an enclave within a much more troubled mind, so that there's very little ego strength,
and the patient is sort of powerless against the pool of these forces. Whereas for us,
it's only when we stray into that terrain that we are like you describe, we become persecuted,
we lose our, you know, all those psychotic things fall apart, you know, ego functioning,
in other words, is totally impaired, as though we've walked out of the room where the ego is
into a side room, you know, where we really are quite crazy. Now that's very, very important.
There is no floor in that room. That sort of thing. That's a room that doesn't have any floor,
it doesn't have any windows, it doesn't have any fresh air, it's a crazy room.
Yeah, but part of what I think is very compelling, and I, in teaching the book in the fall,
I found quite liberating for the students and for myself, is if you begin to think about this
as the internal racist organization as a normal part of the mind, just like a, you know,
if you're a drive theorist, you accept that, you know, that there's pleasure and destruction,
and we work through our life to not be too destructive, that's the life's worth, and it's
expectable that one, you know, one has that impulse. And in the same way, there's kind of a
fascinating, a useless word normalization, it doesn't quite get to it, but there's something
that you can expect to find this in the mind. And I found that the students began to work,
it was a racially misclass, with the white students with guilt and shame, they were able to hold
themself together more with this idea and the seat, more, without all the sweating, without the,
kind of, you know,
winding, you know, shame. There was something about you could expect to find this in the mind.
Whereas you say in the book, I think that all of us, you don't say you can scratch a little
beneath the surface, but all of us can find our inner biggest. That's not so difficult to do.
And I think that this is a really significant contribution.
Yeah. Yeah. I think you don't want to see a picture of that.
I think that's very important. Yeah. You know, we're not proud of our bigotry. That's absolutely so.
But equally, you know, when you think about it, bigotry is bigotry. You know, it's not killing people.
You know, it's not, but, but part of the problem, if you think of it as a defensive organization,
a thing that has a life of its own, that thing makes you feel that you've done the worst possible
thing to another human being. You know, that's part of the psychotic sort of super ego
persecuting you. It's going to tear you limb from limb. And the cure for it is what you say in
your students. If they can bring the normal ego to bear, if they can think about it, if they can
feel, look, I wish the floor would, you know, open up and swallow me, if they can know those,
those sorts of feelings, of course, that's bringing insight. And that's the very thing that is
actually the antidote to it. You know, because that way, in our language, you develop an awareness
of not only your shame, but what those thoughts are in your mind that bring the shame, you know,
and that is ordinary analysis. It's having insight into, into, you know, what one's unconscious
does without consulting us, usually, you know, the life of its own.
Well, you talked in the book, you write about it. No, there's just, I wanted to make one more
point about the thing I forgot earlier, you know, about the, the, the, the third incarnation
in internal racism of this primitive split object relationship. What's important about it is
that it's usually in alignment with societal stereotypes. And that is absolutely key,
because the thing that persuades you from remaining trapped in paranoid schizophrenic functioning
is reality testing. The same with the stranger you realize at some point that not all strangers
are ogres. It's reality testing that helps you. But once you hit on this solution in which
the societal bad object is the person, the member of the outgroup who, by definition, you will not
encounter, then you can see it's a system that has free reign, you know, it, it, and then it grows
and develops, and it uses selective observation about the other to confirm its stereotypes
internally, so that there's a huge pressure to keep the split going, you know. So, for example,
in South Africa, sometimes when, on the odd occasion that you could talk to somebody who was
of the ruling class, you know, they would have a very decent conversation with you and spontaneously
saying, you know, a part date is not about people like you, you know, you obviously share a lot,
we can talk. And then of course, we, we would, I would think, yeah, but it's not about that.
If a part date, what I experience is applied to some poor backward villages somewhere, it is
still as wrong as, you know, when it's applied to me. So, but there you see beautifully that a
racist system in the mind is challenged by the reality of experience of talking to a darker
skinned man and having a decent time together, you know, a pleasant intercourse across color lines.
It shouldn't be, and you see the defense. You know, this is the exception, but we still need that
to do this. Well, can you teach us about the, the idea you have about ordinaryness?
I think this is very fascinating. In your clinical example, for instance, you know, where your
patients, I think it's from chapter two, what takes place in the session, you link to his having
found you to be too ordinary. And you're describing this interaction between the ruling class in
South Africa, you know, speaking, you know, to a black person and, oh, you know, it's not,
it's not applied to you. There's something, I'm wondering if there's a connection there about
you're thinking about ordinaryness and, and the way it can activate, I think, if I'm understanding
what you've written, the internal racist organization when it's in, when it's a, a biracial duo.
It's exactly that. That's exactly how I think of it. I think there is something in us
that believes that we need to keep some kind of outgroup person at a distance.
I think we seem to believe that it's necessary for psychic life. So that, so the function of it
is to keep the distinction going. Now, every time one has an ordinary interaction with somebody
who's meant to be in that category, it raises the alarm unconsciously on the part of the system.
And I think that is then externalized. So you're absolutely right. I think it's ordinaryness,
ordinary humanness that, that gets through this defensive system. So I don't think black people
are hated in a white race society because they're black. They are hated because they are ordinary
human, like you and anybody else, me, and it's when that, that comes through, that the tension,
the need to violently sometimes reinstate the division becomes absolutely urgent. So for example,
when one thinks about this thing on a macro level, and I don't mean to simplify everything to
psychology, simply to say there's a psychic element involved in the mix of stuff. If you think of
the tremendous thing that what that people in your country felt and that the whole world felt
when you elected Barack Obama as president. Now, what did you elect? You elected a very smart guy,
a young guy, an articulate guy, and you'd had, who was it, push before that? Who came before Obama?
You know, anyways, you elected, George, you elected a foot, yeah, who happened to be brown.
Yeah, a very different guy. George W. was not as educated. I mean Obama was a quite different person.
He was a very special compassionate at ease with himself, using not resentments, but you know,
look, we're all in this, you know, and I'm all view and that sort of thing. Now, I think that kind of
all get a lot of depressive to this, that sort of stuff. But the ordinaryness, I think,
threatens the racist structure that wants to make of blacks something very different to whites.
You know, and I see the backlash as to do, to do with that. You know, so I think, for example,
in the struggle for equal rights and so on, I think this is the way it's going to go, you know,
little victories and then backlashes. And of course, weak clinicians know that. That's how, without
very disturbed patients, it goes, you know. Yeah, absolutely. So in a sense, I mean, you
suggest that our model of development, what does it say? Our picture of maturation through
increasing integration is too smooth. In a way, you're sort of like, I was reminded of this
title of the Joyce McDougal book, "Plee for a measure of abnormality." There's sort of a plea
for a measure of, it's much, it's much messier and we don't ever, it's a life's work working with
one internal racist organization. Is that something you would say? Like,
it seems to me, it could be seen as a live one.
- I think so, I think so.
- And we don't ever get rid of any.
- And might as well, like, yeah.
- Yeah, you might as, but it's a bit like
the edipus complex, isn't it?
It's what Freud said.
You don't outgrow it, you know, and if you're lucky,
you get to know it a bit better and you get to know
its elements and then you are less controlled
by particular configurations inside it.
And I think the same applies to one's racism,
one's, you know, that structure of self and other.
But just again, to make a link, that idea
is very much in line with contemporary climbing thinking.
You know, you find the same idea in people saying,
"Look, we don't ever outgrow the paranoid schizophrenia position."
You know, the depressive position,
it's not the wonderful uplands that we get to
and then we've left behind the torches.
And if you think about ordinary life, it's true.
You know, I'm sure we all, at some point,
when we've had enough, you know, we're in a different space.
But I think the racist structure,
maybe in the mind, provides a resting place
for some of those destructive tendencies.
That's what I mean.
- I explained it maybe incorrectly to students.
I said, you know, when dealing with the anxieties
aroused by resolving the edibles,
they're seen, I'm wondering if, and this is a question,
I say, "So I wonder if Boppy David is telling us
that we can take some sort of a decor, some sort of a pleasure,
arrest it in the internal racist organization."
I don't know if you would see things that way,
but that was one read that came to my mind,
because of course, resolving the edibles,
quite stressful, right?
I think in terms of pre-edical,
and my training is not climbing,
but I think in terms of pre-edical and edible.
On that, you know, if things get edible, you're wealthy.
You know, I used to get up to something edible.
But these disturbances, you know, around racism
are certainly are more of a pre-edible order.
It does not make any sense what I just said.
I mean, does that seem?
- No, absolutely.
I agree with that.
- I agree with that.
- Like a deep thought.
- To the poor.
And that they are, you see that what is,
it's a good question, you know,
why do we have them?
Now, I think they are a way of binding destructiveness.
You see, you said that instead of having to face
our raw, primal hatred of anything that doesn't suit us
or any object that, you know, does, you know,
that gets under our skin and so on.
I mean, to live, if you were to live your instincts,
you would be intolerant.
And I think the burden of destructiveness
is bound up in this kind of way.
I mean, Freud touched on it
where he talked about the narcissism of minor differences.
You'll remember, you know, where he says,
your group identity represents a harmless way
of institutionalizing your love towards your people
in your group and your hatred towards people outside your group.
And I mean, Freud was fond of thinking of the bedrock.
He taught, he didn't quite develop these ideas,
but you could see where he was going.
It's the same as what you were saying earlier
when he talks about the gender distinction
and what's attached to it and so on.
But I, so I do think it's that,
that it institutionalizes it.
And I don't think there's any better way
of institutionalizing our destructiveness, you know?
So I think it's like to stay--
- I think, I think in the book, you say there might,
you might have a sentence, something about like that,
the presses seem to be less racist.
But the aggression, I would, that depressive,
I have a quote somewhere here in my notes about people
who are depressed and that they are less--
I don't know, is this you or somebody else?
I'm in the middle of teaching this class,
which is really actually my--
the title is the tribute to your work, racism,
and the development of the psyche, you know?
But that depressive, y'all know, know it.
I mean, it was clear to me I could design a class
around the idea that racism is a part of how the psyche develops
after I read your book.
Things really fell much more in place.
But I thought it was someplace in the book
where depressive have less racist or something,
and I thought like, oh, that's interesting.
So the energy is against the self rather than externalize.
It's less likely that I don't--
I think this was you.
Maybe not.
I'm not sure, but it may be somewhere in there.
Mm-hmm.
If you look--
You are.
There are studies on racism among seriously ill patients,
psychotic patients, compared to normals.
And there's less racism among psychotic patients.
I mean, but this--
I think I've got it in the books and way in the reviews.
But that's now a long time ago.
I'm not up on the new work.
But that's-- I think it's that observation
that if your destructiveness is tearing your mind apart,
then you don't need this kind of structure
in which to contain it.
That would be the thing.
And there are things like that.
Sure.
It makes sense to me.
If the aggression is turned inward
rather than outward, essentially, one way
that I would look at it, you write about institutional racism.
And we don't have a heck of a lot of time yet.
But you have here in the states,
I mean, the psychoanalytic institute
mind included the Center for Modern Psychoanalytic Studies.
People have really had been undertaking,
trying to ask themselves very hard questions.
And it's almost like an explosion of interest,
of course, in America, since the murder of George Floyd.
But you see in psychoanalytic institutes
in this country an attempt to reckon
why so few black candidates, for instance.
And these conversations, I reread again
your chapter on institutional racism.
I have a faculty meeting on Tuesday
that I'm kind of dreading because I'm
a part of a committee psychoanalysis
against racism committee within the institute.
We're pushing for a stance of reparations, which
you'll understand as reconciliation,
truth and reconciliation, of that sort, of a stance.
So many institutes have said, well, we want diversity.
You know the conversation, we want diversity.
And we said, no, the stance has to be a sense of reparation
is what will create an open and inviting institute.
But diversity is not going to work.
Because who cares about diversity?
What about having a reparative stance?
And you know, it's--
But in the book, you say it's easier
to be a victim of racism than a perpetrator.
And I think about this, when I think about my institute,
and many institutes, colleagues of other institutes,
are having these conversations where
things go off the rails and people lose the ability to think.
And I wondered if he would--
I know you wrote this book 11 years ago or 10 years ago.
But when you say it's easier to be a victim of racism
than a perpetrator, I know you're
talking about something within the total system
that you've developed, that's mind.
Can you say a little bit more about that?
Well, since I wrote that, I have to say I've been very impressed
by the way the conversation within our profession
has moved on, particularly in your country,
where I think people are beginning to think, look,
let's not try and fix it for black people.
Let us try and look at ourselves.
So the conversation has moved on to what
is white privilege involved, to what ex you know.
And some of that is very moving.
And I think that's in the right direction.
Because if one doesn't examine that
and begin to think about that, then it
will be there unconsciously.
as forces that oppose your conscious wish to make your institutions more diverse.
So I'm very much in favor of that. That is a proper psychoanalytic way. Let's look at
us ourselves. And when people talk about whiteness and there's much more talk about it and what have
you done and what are you guilty of and what aren't you guilty of and what can you manage and what
can't you manage, I think it's the fact of having those conversations that will mobilize the
creativity and within all of us that needs to be brought to creating the sort of societies that
we want that are more equitable and open and so on. So I'm very pleased at the way it's gone.
Of course, what I was meaning by that was, I'm not sure I should have put it like that because
what I mean is that the psychic work that the so-called objective racism has to do is different
from the psychic work than the so-called perpetrator of racism has to do. They two very different
tasks all under the same umbrella of internal racism. And you can see if both parties don't do that,
then you'll get an enactment that passes as an attempt to solve a problem. You're trying to
solve something externally that's internal. And I think our profession is in a unique position
to focus internally as well as what must we do. Sure, there are things we must do,
but if we don't accompany that by this internal stuff, then I think we will be undermined
by them going into the unconscious and merely destroy our best efforts.
I think that what you've just said is terrific and it's a good place for us to end
because it's such a wonderful statement for members of the profession as we're trying to
to work things through in a genuine rather than a psychoanalytic as opposed to a behavior therapy
model. I wanted to thank you so much for being with us. I want to ask any current projects,
any other writing projects that you have plans, anything that you're up to, and you want to know that.
No, I don't have anything new coming out, but I'm still working through some of this stuff.
Tracey, thank you very much for having me on. I appreciate it, and very lovely to talk to you.
Very lovely to talk to you too. Okay, so this is Tracey Morgan, your host at New Book's
Psychoanalysis, signing off. Next up we will be interviewing and I don't know a month or so,
Neil Altman on his book on white privilege, so you can tune back in if you want to listen to them,
and it's offering a wonderful evening to you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Focerie David’s book *Internal Racism
The book introduces the concept of an "internal racist organization" (IRO) — an unconscious, defensive system formed during early development that mirrors societal racism, rooted in splitting and projective identification.
The IRO develops from the paranoid-schizoid position through stranger anxiety and culminates in identification with dominant power groups, internalizing societal stereotypes as a normal, not pathological, part of the psyche.
Unlike traditional psychoanalytic models, the IRO operates in ordinary individuals, not just in psychopathology, and is activated by encounters with "ordinary" members of outgroups, which challenge the defensive structure.
The author argues that racism is not a simple expression of prejudice but a structural, developmental mechanism that institutionalizes destructiveness and maintains psychic stability by separating "us" from "them."
Internal racism is distinct from the Oedipal complex; it operates in a pre-Oedipal, more primitive phase of development, where splitting and projection are dominant, and where the defense of the self is threatened by perceived threats of the "other."
The book challenges the idea that white analysts are neutral, showing how white privilege and unconscious biases are embedded in the psyche and must be examined through self-reflection and institutional accountability.
The work contributes to a broader psychoanalytic movement toward self-examination, reparative practices, and institutional change, emphasizing that true progress requires internal transformation, not just external diversity.
Summary:
Focerie David’s *Internal Racism* offers a groundbreaking psychoanalytic framework for understanding how racism is not merely a social phenomenon but a deeply internalized structure of the mind. Rooted in his experience of apartheid South Africa and influenced by Frantz Fanon, David introduces the concept of an "internal racist organization" (IRO)—an unconscious defensive system that forms during early development through splitting and projective identification. This organization, which emerges from the paranoid-schizoid position and solidifies during stranger anxiety, leads to identification with dominant power groups and internalization of societal stereotypes.
" The book reveals that ordinary human connection—such as conversations with people of different racial backgrounds—triggers internal anxiety, exposing the fragile boundaries of this defensive system. David emphasizes that racism functions as a psychic mechanism to contain destructive impulses, allowing individuals to avoid confronting their own hatred and fear. He critiques the idea that race and gender are interchangeable in psychoanalytic theory, asserting that racial dynamics operate in a more primitive, pre-Oedipal realm, distinct from the Oedipal struggle.
The work also highlights a key insight: it is easier to be a victim of racism than a perpetrator, as the psychic work of the former is more visible and reactive, while the perpetrator’s internal work is often hidden and unconscious. This underscores the necessity for psychoanalysts to confront their own biases and white privilege through self-reflection, leading to institutional change. The book has had a significant impact on psychoanalytic discourse, particularly in the United States, where it has inspired movements toward reparative practices and truth and reconciliation in professional institutions.
Ultimately, David’s model redefines racism as a developmental and psychic reality, suggesting that healing requires not only external justice but deep internal transformation.
FAQs
Growing up in apartheid South Africa and discovering Franz Fanon's work, particularly 'Black Skin, White Masks,' profoundly influenced his motivation. Fanon's insights into the psychological effects of racism and the limitations of psychoanalysis in addressing these issues led David to explore how psychoanalysis could better account for racial experiences.
The internal racist organization is an unconscious, defensive system that forms in response to societal racial dynamics. It operates like a psychic retreat, creating a split between self and outgroup, and often manifests as automatic reactions to racial contact, such as shame, guilt, or paralysis when encountering people from different racial backgrounds.
It develops through early childhood experiences, starting in the paranoid-schizoid position where good and bad are split, and progressing through stranger anxiety. At this stage, children begin to identify with dominant groups, internalizing societal stereotypes and forming a defensive structure that persists into adulthood.
David argues that internal racism is a normal, albeit unconscious, part of the psyche for all individuals. It functions as a defensive structure that helps maintain a sense of security in a racially stratified world, even in non-racist individuals who experience shame or discomfort when interacting with people from other racial groups.
While the Edipus complex involves repressed conflict and repression of the other, internal racism involves splitting and projective identification. It is not about repressing a desire but about splitting off the other as a threat, and it operates outside the classical framework of sexual conflict, reflecting a more primitive and powerful form of psychological defense.
Victims of racism experience the internalization of external power structures, which allows them to remain aware of the harm. Perpetrators, on the other hand, often engage in unconscious or disguised forms of racism, which may be less immediately visible but still deeply rooted in their internal psychological systems.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.