Listening to Ella Fitzgerald with those Who Played Alongside Her
41m 59s
Ella Fitzgerald’s mastery of jazz vocals goes far beyond technical skill—it’s rooted in deep musical integration, emotional authenticity, and an intimate connection with her bandmates. Her singing functions as an instrument, with precise timing, groove, and phrasing that directly influences the ensemble, creating a unified and dynamic performance. From her early days with Chick-Web’s band, where she overcame personal and societal challenges to become a central figure, to her later work with legends like Louis Armstrong, Ella demonstrated an unmatched ability to blend tradition with improvisation. Her vocal tone, described as cello-like and even, provides a warm, resonant quality that draws listeners into the music. Crucially, her performances are infused with personal history—her struggles, insecurities, and resilience shine through in the emotional depth and sincerity of her delivery. She exemplifies how a genuine human experience can coexist with extraordinary artistry. The conversation highlights not only her technical brilliance but also her profound humanity, showing how personal adversity, mentorship, and joy shape one of jazz’s most enduring legacies. Ella Fitzgerald’s career stands as a testament to the power of perseverance, musical intuition, and emotional authenticity in live performance.
Today we're going to talk about Elephant Cheryl. [MUSIC] Good place to start. >> Yeah. [LAUGH] >> Can you all just introduce yourselves? >> I'm Janice Eagle. I am a founding member of the vocal group, the Manhattan Transfer, and sang Harmony for 50 years as the alto in the group. >> I'm John Clayton, I'm a bass player, also a writer, arranger, composer, and pedagogue, teacher, whatever, that's what I do. >> Hi, I'm a Kevin Kuele, and I am a vocalist. I don't really know what else to say. >> All right, so tell me about that song. >> Man, she does so much, but she doesn't have to raise her voice. That's something that I had to learn coming from the church, where at some point we always take it there. >> [LAUGH] >> She didn't have to take it there to go there, right? In volume, there's just so much information in how she presented the melody, but never strayed too far away from it. You could always hear the melody in everything that she sang, even when she was taking her solos. And she, after a certain point, maybe in that second chorus, was weaving back and forth between the traditional melody and her own melody that she was coming up with, but still rooted so deeply in honoring Ellington's melody. Because satan doll is just, I mean, it's a classic and it's beautiful. And so I think hearing that at such a young age, it taught me how to still give a lot of soul and information and passion without feeling like in volume, I have to raise it up. It's like, no, you can still deliver a classic, a beautiful song and just relax. Just chill. So yeah, you hear anything in there? >> Do I hear a lot? I hear so much. So what people don't realize, and I don't expect them to, they don't hear how Ella affects the musicians. And that's what I was, I was listening to her delivery and her timing and her note choice and her energy and all that and how it affects the musicians. I could hear, as a bass player, I could hear how that bass player, when she was just really digging in, I could hear him doing the same. I could hear the piano player adding a little bit more accent. And the whole thing had this drive that was led by her. If she kind of chilled, then they would have. And that's when you are focused on people around you, then it drives your music. It drives what you do, your note choice, your groove, everything. And I know that's what was happening on that, it's great to hear. >> To the untrained ear, I think about vocals as almost separate from the rest of the band. Maybe because for someone who doesn't play an instrument, it's the most relatable part of the band. But with this, it sounds, she's singing as if she's playing an instrument. She's playing a horn or something. >> Well, absolutely. She's singing as an instrumentalist. And that's one thing that you can learn from Mellifett's Gerald. She's part of the band, she's totally integrated into the band, and she's leading it too. She's singing in a very celloistic manner in the front as well. No words, she's using syllables. And even when she improvises, she's improvising with words for a while. And then she goes back to scatting. That's an interesting choice. And something that singers don't realize they can do also. And the way she develops her solo is very instrumentalists like. She starts off slowly, and then she's increasing her velocity a little bit. But she never does the whole bebop really, really fast lines things. She's always very much rooted in the chord and just one little section where she's increasing her velocity in her solo. And then she goes back to the beautiful improvisation. >> I feel like she was lulling me into the mood that she was experiencing. I felt like I was on the sofa, and she was just humming, just feel like this is the song that's in my head, and I'm singing it, and I'm glad you're here. And I was kind of in the Ella world there, versus, okay guys, we're going to do this song. Here we go. It wasn't like that. >> She sounds like she's very comfortable with the musicians, which I'm sure she was. She probably knew everybody, I'm sure, very well. >> Yeah. >> Very cool. >> So this is from the mid-1950s, I think, that song? >> The only songbook, yeah, it's right, right? >> Yeah, that's right. >> Why don't we go back to the early days and then see if we can track some change? Because that comfortable ability, maybe that wasn't, I don't know if that was, if that's just natural, if that's always there, or if that's something that develops over time. >> Well, I think her ability to sing as an instrumentalist comes from her beginnings as a big band singer. >> Yeah. >> She was part of the band. [MUSIC] >> So, what do we got? >> Well, this is a song she came up with, this is Nursery Rhyme, an old Nursery Rhyme. She brings it to the band's arranger Van Alexander and says, let's swing this Nursery Rhyme. So together they work out the arrangement. She sounds like a little girl. I mean, she never really lost that quality, that girlish innocent quality, and it's perfect for this song, and it appears in an Abbott and Castello movies. >> This was a massive hit song, like kind of the biggest, of the decade, right? >> Chick-web orchestra. >> So, can you, does anyone have a little background on where she was in her career and where she came from to get to this point? >> I think the beginning of her career started at the Apollo, the talent show, where she was going to dance, because she was, she was a dancer, her idol with snake hips, Tucker. >> Right? So, she-- >> By the way, great name. >> Yeah, by the way. >> I also idolized snake hips. >> I mean, do snakes have hips? Anyway, she realizes she's, the person before her is a dancer, so she decides to sing at the last minute. It's like, what am I going to sing? Her idol at the time is Connie Boswell from the Boswell Sisters, so she picks it tune from Connie Boswell's repertoire, Judy. >> I think it was the name of the tune, right? Right? >> She's the one for me, heaven sent her to me, my Judy, my Judy, she's the sweetest pie, and I know that I die for Judy. >> And she sings it and wins, and you know, I guess the band leaders used to go to these talent shows to pick out the new talent, but she was, she was very ungainly and unsophisticated, but Chick-Web said, you know what, I'm going to hire you and if the audience likes you, you'll stay with the band. If the people love you, then you'll stay with the band. >> Chick-Web was like her father, I think, a father figure, and people obviously loved her. And she, she, not only did she stay with the band, she took over the band when he died. >> Before she was able to make it into Chick-Web's band, he didn't necessarily want her in the band, right, and regardless of this talent that was obvious to all the rest of the members of the band, he was used to working with male singers. >> Also, the paradigm of the time, the was very beautiful blonde glamour girls in fronching the bands, and she was not, so it was, it was a risk. >> One worth taking, obviously. >> And the cool thing about being in Chick-Web's band for her was that she also heard those amazing players, and she could learn those solos and how to improvise from them, to synchronize her singing and groove with the other members of the band, because she heard that, it was on to the left and to the right of her, of her every night, therein lies her ability to draw from and create a vocabulary that music on those ideas and the spirit and the groove and all that stuff.
[Music] So swing it. Flying home in 1945. So what's happening in the 40s? Well, that's happening. It's still big band time. It's still big band. It's not, it's not be about time yet. A lot of dancing. Almost, but not quite. Dancing is happening. Yeah. You can feel it just by, I mean, clearly all of our reactions. As soon as that cut on, she's swinging the band. Stop. That's what I was going to say. Okay, what does that mean? I think it's like a way that any front person, not even just a vocalist, right? That any front man or woman, the way that you play in the pocket. And you feel like some of those underlying rhythms, it helps to direct and swing the band. Give them like a central point for them to go off of. But Mr. Clean, I feel like you can speak to that a little bit better. Like as a basis. Oh, I mean, maybe not better, but I definitely can. When I listen to Ella Fitzgerald sing, for instance, that song, I always know that she's connected to the band. She went a step further. She actually became a section of the band. She was like when there's one power, she was going on and going. And she had to be exactly in sync as that replication of a sac section or whatever in order to connect with the band. And then sure enough, when she stopped the end of that line, the band took over. And a few times in that, where she would sing something and basically pass the baton onto the band. And that connection, that synchronicity has to be so tight and so exact. So that groove is so deeply in her that as you said, she was swinging the band. Do you have any idea how that communication is happening? First of all, she's patting her foot. She's not just standing there dead and just singing the groove. Yeah, that's right. So she's patting her feet. We've seen you see around videos. We've seen many times when she's singing. So that's an important aspect because the groove is a very physical thing. And you want to latch it onto it. She's definitely doing that. But there's eye contact. She's looking around. She's smiling. She's connected to the band. She's not in her own world just singing and her own booth. Doing her own thing with the band behind her. With the singer, it's really fascinating all the microprocesses that go on in your head. It's math, really. You've got four or four groove. But then there are all of these subdivisions of the beat. And she's in all of them. She's singing on updates precisely. So she's like doing math in her head unconsciously, like we all do. And that's called phrasing, really. I'm going to play a little bit of this, then I'm going to play a little something else. ♪ High the moon is the nameless song ♪ ♪ High the moon though the words may be wrong ♪ ♪ We're singing it because you ask for it ♪ ♪ So we're swinging it just for you ♪ ♪ High the moon doesn't touch the stars ♪ ♪ High the moon doesn't reach out too much ♪ ♪ Though the words made it wrong to the song ♪ ♪ We're math coming high high high high high high high high high high ♪ Oh, in Tiana, she quotes like eight, eight, at least eight tunes in your soul. Okay. How many makes sense of this? The set 1960? Yes. Okay, live in Berlin. Live in Berlin. Yeah. She's obviously become very comfortable with this song. What are you hearing? A lot of songs. Live in Berlin. And also, I'm hearing something that not many vocalists do. There are vocalists who burn out in solos. But not many of us just choose to do that. For one reason or another, whether it's because you know how long the set is that you have to do. You know the restraints of your voice, whatever it might be. We ran out of ideas. Exactly. But just how much of a wellspring do you have to be to know that many songs, right? And that well that you can just throw them out on the fly. I think when I hear this, it challenges me. How well do I know my repertoire? How well do I know this music to just be able to, yeah, just allow things to flow and just like burn out like that. It's incredible. Here's the question I've got. How much did she work these out in advance? Because this part with Ben joins her. Yes, yeah. I think she worked out a lot of these. And you also hear like the earlier recording that you played of How High the Moon. You hear her starting off this solo in the same way for maybe about two or three courses. Right. So yeah, I completely agree with you. Yeah. And one of the things that she does is what she learned from the Big Band era is she has ensembles. In other words, she's the Big Band for a while. Then she allows herself that space to solo to totally improvise. Then suddenly she goes back to the Big Band sort of riffs ideas. And then another area where she's soloing. And so many musicians do that. Instrumentalists do that. One of the things I've learned is that when you are with a band for a while and you get used to singing and playing certain songs. As time goes on, you get so comfortable that there's something in you that's not satisfied if it's the same tempo. And you need a little boost of excitement. So collectively, you make it a little bit faster. Do that times however many years. And next thing, you know, you get this version versus the, you know, 10 or 15 years earlier version. Also, don't you find that when you do things live, you tend to do them a little faster anyway. So you can imagine coming off of the song before and the audience is screaming and they're super excited. And it's like, okay, we'll give it back to you. They were probably feeding off of the crowd reaction and that's stirring them to go fast. That's true for sure. I always think of music as sort of an exchange of energy, you know. So in the beginning, the vibe is okay. I'm going to get it with my friends here. And we're going to do whatever we can, combining our energy and uplifting the music. And then suddenly there's five people in the audience or maybe there's 50 or maybe there's 5,000. And that's just an addition to collection of energy. And as artists, we learn that it doesn't matter how many people are in the audience or not in the audience. You got to deliver 100%. I remember Ernie Andrews, great vocalist, Ernie Andrews. Yeah, Los Angeles. And so I had written something for him. I had saw him. I wrote this thing for you. We're going to rehearse next week and want to come by. He said, yeah, sure, let's do it. So he goes to rehearsal. He doesn't read music. He's never heard the arrangement before. And I said, the band's got an introduction. We'll play it. I'll point you in. And the band played the intro. I pointed Ernie and he just went. And he sang like he was singing. He didn't know the arrangement. Didn't know what was happening. But he sang like he was singing for 50,000 people. I don't know how many weeks later I saw Barbara Morrison. Another great LA vocalist. And that was a period of her life when she'd had her feet amputated. So she was in a wheelchair. And I said, hey, we're going to do this piece. I wrote for you, you know, with the big band. You want to come by the verse? She said, okay, honey. Yeah, I love it. So she comes into the rehearsal. Same thing. She doesn't read music. She doesn't know the arrangement. The band plays the intro. And she just goes. And I thought, these people don't not have a rehearse. They only perform. No, it's very interesting. I always felt that about Ella as well. And pretty much every vocalist I can think about. The ones that really impressed me. They always delivered the way Ella just delivered then. And the way she always did. So big lesson for me. There's a story that she was like pretty shy. She was. Doesn't seem like it. I think she came alive on stage. That's where she lived. And I think her personal life was great. The impression that I had. But she would only come alive on stage. Which accounts for the fact that she sang right up until the very end. When she was in her wheelchair, she was blind. She, you know, she lost her legs. She had a heart condition, but she kept on singing to the very end. She was also insecure. So when she was finished set, my best friend is Jeff Hamilton drummer. And he toured with her. And he said that when he finished set, there is first set with her. She said to him, did I do okay? Was that? Was it okay? And he's thinking, you're Ella Fitzgerald. [laughter]
Oh, that's funny because I have a very similar story go ahead you transfer net transfer saying with Ella on the Grammys On a right at a podium just with one little mic. We sang how high the moon So we're at rehearsal she skats at the end. She says was that okay? Was that was that all right? And it was like Why are you talking about it? It's like, you know, isn't that a lesson for us to totally I'm not talking about the insecurity of you know Did I do okay, but she didn't really wanted to know yeah, you know if that was okay Exactly if you said how about if we try it this way next time she would have been totally open to that Yeah, that's just a human thing Outside of performing that's like what we all want when we connect with people is just that reassure and it's like are we connecting? But how many times have we been around artists who are not that way. Yeah, I got my job. Yeah, exactly my drop But that's maybe that's just a defense right that people put that shield up people who'd that shield up with that confidence and that ego But but if they're hard as in the right place, you're right. Yeah, if it ain't Then they drank the Kool-Aid and they they feel it at my drop. I'm done. I was killing. I Learned some big lessons from Ella Fitzgerald. I made a record with her with Cal Basie band I've been he-carted to the arrangements and at the recording session the song that we're gonna record It was called organ grinder swing and she said to herself out loud boy this song she has some dumb lyrics and at that point as a 20-something year old I should have known but I I thought to myself wow singers pay attention to this to the lyrics They don't just sing you know she was affected by the message or in this case the non-message of the song So that was my first lesson to pay attention to what the story is about it can't just be kind of cool sounding words No, there's a message there and Ella's the one who opened that door for me. This isn't the lyrics Sounds like when she gets to the Whatever like each of the lyrics that go by It feels like she's just getting through that part Like she's just kind of just singing it but like when she's singing like the other lyrics of her seating lyrics You can hear a kind of playing with the melody, but every time she gets there. She just sings it I think she she could have done a great I bet I mean it would be great without words actually this song So at the end of this song there was a part Where there was a vamp and she just Solo she just scat on top of that and they were gonna fade it out So I'm playing bass I'm like still pinching myself Tainlessly because I'm doing this with these amazing people and and I saw Norman Grans when we got to that last bit Where she was just scatting I saw him just makes circular motions with his hands in the air like keep it going keep it going Keep it going and the mantra in my head Pardon my language. Oh God. Please don't let me fuck up. Please don't let me fuck up But because I didn't want to be that one that stopped this amazing thing You know the elephant's Gerald was doing that so that when I hear that song, I just think of that end and that mantra Should we talk about Norman Grants? They had a special relationship, I guess. Yeah, well he was the one that Suggested she'd do the songbook series which sort of brought her into a new part of her career and So he did what a great manager does. He guided her career. It was almost like he was a bodyguard No one could get her to do anything without going through Norman Grants. I was reading I think two years ago I'm a book by Judith Tick becoming a lawyer. Yes, that's a great book and I didn't finish it and that'll be obvious My question, but was he always a good manager or was the I'll use a word and correct me if I'm wrong But that sense of being a bodyguard as a manager. It has like a tinge of micro-managing Yeah, and so I wonder was he always the best? Did they always have the best relationship? Pretty much yes because She needed him she needed someone like that before Norman Grants was around There was a period that she was married to my mentor my teacher Ray Brown, you know And then after they broke up I think you're right in sensing that she was sort of floating looking she was life was not easy and because she was such a shy person She she really leaned on him and he accepted that I don't know the details obviously But I did see that he was her protector. He really loved her and it's not like he was trying to make money off of her He was already rich. He was a wealthy guy. So he didn't need the money He just loved her and he was that same felt that same way about Count Basie Likewise, he had so much respect and was a close friend to Oscar Peterson So yeah, I'm sure there was a side of him that was like, hmm, you know, but I Saw it up close and he was actually very kind to me just out of the blue no reason no ulterior motive just backstage one day We're talking about Artaidam and he said do you have all the Pablo by the anyway had Pablo records He said do you have all the Pablo recordings? I said No, I have some he said Okay, I'll get you all of them and sure enough. He shipped all of the Pablo label tune that my house You know some 27 year old kid who was hungry for the music so I saw I Think I saw what he was capable of, but I know that wasn't only who he was so If if as you said she really like came alive and her comfort zone was on the stage He's someone that enables like it gets rid of a lot of other stuff that you have to do so that you can just I don't want to do all the Conversations and everything else in the label stuff and say and let me just go there Don't forget it was the Jim Crow era and she experienced some you know racism And he protected her from that as well. He could as well as he could There's a saying old says and love is blind Still we're often told seek and ye shall find So I'm going to seek a certain that I've had In my I mean talk about respect for the melody and storytelling Yeah, and pure tone No melisma no fancy pants licks Tell me about the tone. What does that mean? I want to hear from from both of you It means the timbre of her voice is so rich and Her vibrato is so even Again, I say I say it's it's almost like hearing a cello sing No The tone is is really the color of the voice I think yeah, it feels Even like you mentioning the cello It's like the way that she's singing. It's like orchestral It's like a string instrument and it's it's just it's absolutely beautiful the richness as I'm probably just gonna Go everything you said, but Ella Fitzgerald has one of my favorite vibrato's I'm like really big on different vibrato's Some can be slower and heavier some can be really fast like serivans But Ella Fitzgerald's was always like right down the center extremely even And it never messed with the integrity of the pitch at all her intonation was always fabulous really great And so I think that really helps with the ballad you don't get distracted at all And you can close your eyes from start to finish and not have anything startling like you know make you wake up Or get out of that trance because as you were saying earlier mystically and it's like as if she's loving you She's like you're like with like your grandma sitting at the couch or sitting you know at her foot side, right? And she's singing you the songs that she grew up with that she knows that are in her heart And so there's something so personal About listening to Ella Fitzgerald's saying in this tune in particular. I think she did want someone to watch over
her. But going back to Norman Grants, like she's feeling it. She's feeling it in a different way. I sense. Yeah, I sense that she was looking for that love, that lover, you know, that person to watch over her. She'd had some, you know, unfortunate experiences. We all end up kissing frogs now. But, you know, and she never, never got to that prince part. And she never did. So I think that was, that was very personal, like you said. I mean, where is Ella Fitzgerald going to find a partner at a certain point in her life? I don't know. I mean, I think there was a Danish businessman or something towards the end, but oh, tell me more. I am not privy to details, but rumor has it. It's being a partner. Well, there it is, right there. That's it. There's so much in that there, you, if you play jazz, analyze that. Then you'll be close to done. So here's, here's something that I, here is, he's sounds much more sort of straightforward. And she's much more experimental and sort of ex-trying different things and moving different directions. Am I imagining that? Or does he? And he also says to her, all right, swing it. I think it comes from a different type of swinging. Nobody plays quarter notes, I think, like Louis Armstrong. They're fat. And all he says, that's, that's where he comes from, I think with his upbringing in New Orleans. And she's, she's already been through the whole bebop era and swing and sing with the big band. And, and yeah, she's looser. She's looser with her improvisation and with, of the melody with her permutation of the melody. And yeah, just, just more floating. And, and, and he's, but he's under there giving her those quarter notes. What I really enjoy, I'm not sure if this is their first or second album that they did together. This is Ellen Lewis. Ellen Lewis again. Okay, the first one. It's probably the first. Between both of those albums, I always enjoy hearing when they do the harmony at the end. Hearing Lewis Armstrong kind of just sing what he wants to sing. It's not the traditional harmony, but he's going back and forth between like the alto or the tenor or whatever. He's just kind of, and all of it is complimentary and all of it is so good. I think that's my favorite part once we get to the end. I'm always, okay, what is he going to sing this time, right? Or what is he going to play behind her when she's singing the melody? None of it is distracting. And you can hear those parts where he completely lays out. And I think there's some instrumentalists whether young or maybe they haven't played with vocalists as much that they're not sure if space is okay, but space is okay, right? Space is the place. Space is the place. You know what, I'm thinking when I heard this, I go into two kinds of modes simultaneously. One is just enjoying it, you know, and the other is kind of like analysis mode. This just sounds so killing what's going on. And if you analyze what every musician is doing, you'll have an understanding of the basis of the core of what you have to do as a player in this situation. The drummer with brushes, the bass player playing with a kind of a two-feel, which is boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, that kind of thing versus boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, Ray Brown, I was Ray Brown playing that. Then Oscar Peterson doing his very light because Oscar Peterson, he was a beast, he commanded that piano, but he had the breath to play Alla Count Basie, which he did on that track. And he mixed the Count Basie stuff with his love of the blues, so you could actually hear the kinds of Count Basie ideas that he was embracing were also tinged with bluesy kinds of notes, which gave it a different flair. And then Lewis Armstrong, you know, how he approached the melody, Ray Brown actually told me that during Jezeth Philharmonic, they play a concert, they go back to the hotel, and Norman Grands would announce, okay, everybody downstairs in the lobby in the morning at 10 o'clock, we're going to go to a studio. That morning you got to the studio, Norman Grands would say, okay, I'd like something swinging in the beginning of jump tune that features all the horns. Next, I want to feature Dizzy on this one, and Bird on this one, and Ella on this one, blah, blah, blah. He just kind of ran down, how he was up to the musicians to choose the songs and figured out. But then in the studio, and this part I'm getting to, they'd figure out how it was going to flow, which is exactly what happened here. So they came up with that introduction that they played as a riff that they used underneath Lewis Armstrong's melody. And Ella and Lewis realized, we can't really sing this one together very well because my key is too low for you, Ella. And so what did they do? They had a modulation to bring it up to Ella's key. And then they changed to rhythmic feel. Exactly. And then they went into swing instead of the two feel. So I could just hear all, that's what I was saying. It's all there. There's so much information there for, for those music junkies and those musicians who want to learn how to do this right there. And that advances you to, to Miles and to Train and to, to Herbie, et cetera, the people that we also love and move toward. So there's a lot in that song. Did we miss anything? I'm sorry. I know. I know it's a master class of how to sing a duet. I know that, no, I don't even mean in that song. I just mean in general. There's so much we could go on. But I think it is there one thing that we really need to, to cover. I'll just share a story. I got asked to do a dear Ella album by Dee Dee Bridgewater. And in the song that she wanted me to arrange was for an orchestra. We went to, to London and use this orchestra. That was amazing. And she gave me my heart belongs to daddy, which was kind of a hit for Ella with Chick-Webs band. And I thought, okay, here's Ella with the song that she had to sing every night. My heart belongs to daddy. And she was an orphan child. So she never really had that daddy. You know, she's done with the show and she goes, my heart belongs to daddy. All great artists, I think, bring that feeling right from their life like that, that personal story. That's not necessarily on the surface, but underneath that it's informing. I think that's something that we've kind of like touched on a little bit through this conversation, is how she brought that, her life and her experience into the performance and you can hear it. Not directly in the lyrics necessarily, but in the tone and the way that she sounds and performs everything. Do you have anything? I feel like maybe it was even too painful for her to really access the pain that she had growing up. She had a stepfather, I think, that maybe wasn't great to her. She ran away from home. She lived on the street. For emotional depth, I don't know if I listen to other singers for that. But for pure swing and joy and tone and inventiveness and creativity, there's nobody like Elephant Cheryl. Could you hear on that last song, by the way? Could you hear them smile? Yes, but they loved each other. Yeah, they did. They clearly did. Something happened. I was like, I'm hearing a smile. It sounds different when you smile when you say, it does sound good. I can always hear it. It brightens up. I think for me, it's a mixture of the joy and the pain. When I listen to Elephant Cheryl now, after knowing a little bit more about her, taking, studying her from high school, and then taking the information I've gained through incredible musicians who either worked with her or were one step away from her, and then the book that I read by Judith Tick, taking all of that information, I think now.
I bask in her humanity, but also her extreme ability, right? Both of those things can exist at the same time. Her being like just a genuine real human, but her also being an incredible artist, an incredible person, to go through all of the experiences, you know, having her father leave, her mother, and then moving from Newport News to Yonkers, and then running away from home and then being in that, it was an institution for troubled girls. - Yes, home for wayward girls. - Yes, crazy, yeah. - And then fast forward to getting into Chick-Websband, having him take a chance on her, and then whatever experiences she might have gone through in that season of her life, and having insecurities being conscious about her sound, but also being, her looks as well, and being told explicitly that she didn't have the best looks, but then going on to being, in my opinion, next to Louis Armstrong, those two are the most famous jazz musicians in the world, right? To being that while also having that upbringing in those circumstances, to me, it speaks to what is possible for us as humans. - Beautiful, and her strength, and her bravery, to go through that and come out the way she did, bringing joy to so many people. - Thank you, thank you for coming, and having this conversation with us. That was really great. - The track star podcast is a presentation of public opinion created by me, Jack Coyne, Kieran Coyne, and Henry Cornaros, produced by Haley Sobel, edited by Simone Warnoff, theme and original composition by Kieran Coyne, mixing by Devin Klein. Our agent is Joanne Orland at UTA. Thanks for listening. See you next Wednesday.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Ella Fitzgerald’s singing style is deeply integrated into the band, functioning like an instrumentalist with precise timing, groove, and phrasing that synchronizes with musicians and influences their performance.
Her ability to sing with emotional authenticity and technical precision stems from years in big band settings, where she learned to absorb and respond to the collective energy and improvisation of the ensemble.
Ella’s performances, especially in songs like *How High the Moon*, showcase a seamless blend of traditional melody, personal improvisation, and scatting, demonstrating musical intelligence and emotional connection.
She maintained a strong personal connection with her bandmates, using subtle cues like foot tapping, eye contact, and vocal intonation to create a shared musical space that felt organic and collaborative.
Ella’s career was shaped by both personal challenges—including early instability, insecurity, and a difficult upbringing—and a supportive figure, Norman Grans, who protected her and guided her professionally during a time of racial and social adversity.
Her voice has a rich, cello-like timbre with even, steady vibrato that enhances musical clarity, allowing listeners to remain immersed in the performance without distraction.
Ella’s performances often reflect deep personal history, where emotional truth and joy coexist, showing how lived experience informs artistic expression.
Her ability to improvise, shift keys, and adapt to real-time energy from the audience demonstrates a mastery of live performance and a profound understanding of musical dynamics.
Summary:
Ella Fitzgerald’s mastery of jazz vocals goes far beyond technical skill—it’s rooted in deep musical integration, emotional authenticity, and an intimate connection with her bandmates. Her singing functions as an instrument, with precise timing, groove, and phrasing that directly influences the ensemble, creating a unified and dynamic performance. From her early days with Chick-Web’s band, where she overcame personal and societal challenges to become a central figure, to her later work with legends like Louis Armstrong, Ella demonstrated an unmatched ability to blend tradition with improvisation.
Her vocal tone, described as cello-like and even, provides a warm, resonant quality that draws listeners into the music. Crucially, her performances are infused with personal history—her struggles, insecurities, and resilience shine through in the emotional depth and sincerity of her delivery. She exemplifies how a genuine human experience can coexist with extraordinary artistry.
The conversation highlights not only her technical brilliance but also her profound humanity, showing how personal adversity, mentorship, and joy shape one of jazz’s most enduring legacies. Ella Fitzgerald’s career stands as a testament to the power of perseverance, musical intuition, and emotional authenticity in live performance.
FAQs
Her voice has a rich, even tone reminiscent of a cello, and she sings with deep emotional connection, maintaining the melody while allowing room for improvisation. She integrates seamlessly into the band, guiding the rhythm and energy, making her sound like an instrumentalist rather than a separate vocalist.
She spent years in big band settings, where she learned to sync her singing with the musicians’ grooves, rhythms, and improvisations. Her physical cues—like patting her feet and maintaining eye contact—showed her deep connection to the band, allowing her to lead and respond in real time.
He acted as a protective manager and career guide, ensuring she had stability and protection from racism and personal challenges. He gave her creative freedom and helped shape her career, often guiding song choices and studio sessions.
Her performances carry emotional depth rooted in her early life—such as being an orphan, running away from home, and facing emotional hardship. This vulnerability is evident in her tone, phrasing, and sincerity, adding authenticity to her music.
She starts solos slowly, building velocity thoughtfully and staying rooted in the chord structure. She often shifts between traditional melodies and original improvisations, blending scat singing with word-based phrases, showing both discipline and creativity.
She sang with genuine emotion and a sense of nostalgia, as if sharing stories from her own life. Listeners felt like they were in a private moment, sitting with her, rather than watching a performance, creating a deeply human connection.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.