The podcast explores the landmark 2003 Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v. Texas, a turning point in LGBTQ+ civil rights that invalidated state sodomy laws. The story centers on John Lawrence and Tyrone Garner, two ordinary men in Houston who, in 1998, were wrongfully arrested after a police officer, Joe Quinn, reported seeing a black man with a gun in their apartment. The account is deeply flawed—there was no gun, and the officers’ narrative appears to be based on racialized bias and drunk logic. The police, including Quinn, display aggressive, dehumanizing behavior, using derogatory slurs and dragging the men to the station without due process. Though the case was initially treated as a minor offense, the resulting charges and public scrutiny exposed systemic discrimination. The law had long been a tool of social control, enforcing stigma on private, consensual same-sex acts. Despite its minimal penalties, it was used to exclude LGBTQ+ people from employment, education, and public service. The case ultimately reached the Supreme Court, where the justices ruled in favor of privacy and bodily autonomy, affirming that the right to engage in private sexual activity is a fundamental liberty protected under the Constitution. The episode emphasizes that legal change often emerges not from perfect justice, but from human resistance and the persistence of marginalized individuals. It also underscores how the law reflects societal values—especially the ways in which prejudice, power, and policing intersect. The narrative invites listeners to question the role of the judiciary and to recognize that real progress in civil rights comes from lived experiences, not only from legal rulings. The episode concludes with the acknowledgment that stories like this are essential for understanding how law shapes lives.
Well, I just think, look, I'm not an expert imagining myself into another life.
I doubt my ability to maintain interaction after the police have burst into my home and
help me at gunpoint, you know. Welcome to your own about. I'm Sarah Marshall and today
we're talking about Lawrence V. Texas with our friend Marcus McCann. Marcus is a writer
and a lawyer he last was with us earlier this year to talk about George Michael, which
was a wonderful sprawling two-parter that was about one man's life and also pop music
and also part cruising and also queer culture and coming of age and so much more than that.
That's kind of Marcus' thing because today we bring you the first of a two-parter where
we are talking about Lawrence V. Texas, a 2003 Supreme Court decision that was of tremendous
importance. I want to remind you, I guess, said 2003 with regards to America's Sodomy
Laws specifically not to put too fine a point on it, whether you're allowed to have gay
sex in your own home. So like some of our recent Supreme Court focused or adjacent episodes
on the concept of originalism with Mackenzie Joy Brennan and also on the Jane Collective
with Mara Donigan. This is an episode about how talking about the law and its consequences
is for all of us and is something that we must do or else we will see our lives and our
rights decided by a bunch of people who are willing to sell their soul for an RV. And
if you must sell your soul, sell it for something more interesting. So this is an episode about
an important period in American history, an important decision in queer history, legal
history in America, but it's also the kind of episode of your wrong about that you've
been hearing all along with a very familiar cast of characters, a police officer who
sees things that no one else can apparently and two normal people just trying to have an
ordinary day who stumble into an extraordinary legal battle and about what that battle does
to them. And that's about it. Welcome to part one. Thank you so much for joining us.
Thank you so much for listening. Thank you for being here. If you want to hear bonus
episodes, we have some on Patreon and Apple Plus subscriptions and we have one coming out
later on this month about the mystery of Summerton Man. Something that has fascinated
me for quite a while. And if you're fascinated, I hope you check it out. And if you don't
know what I'm talking about, check it out as well. Or do your own research, call down
a little rabbit hole. It's fun. Thank you so much for joining us again. Here's your
episode. Welcome to your wrong about the podcast where every month is Pride Month and also
where we talk about the Supreme Court lately. It would appear. Why not? You know, they're
wacky. And with me today is Marcus McCann who last visited us to tell us the saga of George
Michael and is back. And I'm so happy you're back. Thank you for returning.
Oh, thank you for inviting me. What a treat. What kind of stuff do you do and who are you
and what are you enjoying this summer? I am a lawyer and a writer and I'm the author
of a book about Park Cruising, which was the kind of entry way into talking about George
Michael's life. The topic we're going to be discussing today has some things in common
and some things that are different. And I feel like it's going to have a different
shape a little bit, but I'm excited to talk about it with you. I feel like we've entered
the period of the show for me personally where you know, we are drawing close to an American
election and it feels like a lot is on the line. We are dealing at the moment with the
feeling of hope, which is weird and scary for people. We just did an episode. I don't
know if you've heard it with Mackenzie Brennan on basically like a brief history, the Supreme
Court and why they are the way that they are. And sort of the concept of a originalism
and basically how that can serve as, this is my, you know, summary, how originalism
as a school of thought can sort of serve as a shorthand way of saying, well, you know,
I as someone who is appointed to a lifelong term as one of the nine judges who all of
the legal questions of the country eventually get kicked up to not all of them, but you
know, the final authority, the final boss in these matters. I am able to say that I'm
taking an originalist view of the constitution based to some extent often on this idea
that like I simply know I am the person, I am the one who knocks. I have been appointed
to this position. And therefore, how do we know that Thomas Jefferson would like this
idea? Well, we just do, I just do. I mean, is that accurate to your understanding?
I think that's a great summary. And there'll be a cameo from originalism in the episode.
But yeah, because it's election time, I think it's worth saying, look, the Supreme Court
isn't going to save you. But it is a good, good idea to rally around local candidates
and, you know, putting progressives in the House and Senate. There are referendums going
on right now, especially on abortion in Florida and elsewhere. And, you know, the Democrats
have announced a plan for Supreme Court reform. I don't know if it's practical and they're
actually trying to get it implemented or if they're pulling a FDR, if the Democrats
are really trying to start all the Supreme Court into getting in line. There's like when
there's a long history of a very Supreme Court reactionary court striking down progressive
laws. And the country has has responded in different ways with greater and lesser degrees
of success. And, but I think they're instructive. You know, people get the idea that these US Supreme
Court decisions are the like decisive points, turning points in American history. Yeah, because
it is a comforting idea. Like, wouldn't it be nice if just abortion was something that
we just like won in the early 70s and could never be taken away? And like, whoops, too
bad for that. Right. But it's also like 20 years of really intense work by women's
libers before 1973 is really the reason that we have had ropey weighed. And it's the same
with other important US Supreme Court cases. Like, if you look at something like Brown
View Board of Education, it's not the thing. It's not the reason that schools were desegregated.
It was the tireless efforts of generations of civil rights activists that led to that.
And then the Supreme Court's up there at the top just playing this game of sort of codifying
it. You know, knowing that there's not some some daddy in the sky that's going to to
save us from some of the more scary government interventions that have been planned and will
be planned again, is it in the on the one hand, you know, I think that is scary. But on
the other hand, it's freeing because it means that it's actually the work that happens
on the ground and on the streets. That that's what's decisive in history. Like the Supreme
Court decisions are just a piece of the puzzle and maybe not even the most significant
piece. The case we're going to talk about today, Lawrence V. Texas, is a good example
of how it's a it's a story about some tenacious lawyers, but also about some tenacious non-lawyers
who saw the the value of challenging something that they thought was unfair.
Love a tenacious non-lawyer. Same. So, do you have a do you have a sense of Lawrence
V. Texas, what do you know about the case? Blank slate, please, please tell us.
Well, great. Yeah. In that case, you're in for quite a ride. So, Lawrence V. Texas
is the 2003 decision of the Supreme Court, which struck down a sawdemy law in Texas and
by extension struck the criminal prohibitions that remained in in 13 other states. Wow.
Lambda legal described it this way. The decisions sweeping language about gay people's equal
right to liberty marks a new era of legal respect for the LGBT community. Lawrence V. Texas
is considered the most significant gay rights breakthrough of our time. Passive voice, but
you know, yeah, very impressive. One of the things that's interesting about that formulation
is the organization is calling it a case about gay people's equal rights to liberty, which
is kind of desaxing, right? This is a case that's about primarily sex. Yes, that's right.
And has a kinship with all of the other cases that are about bodily autonomy and the right
to make fundamental personal decisions, but the
- That sort of sphere of intimate decision making,
very often is about sex and sexual.
- Why don't you tell us the story from the beginning?
- This story begins in 1998,
which is obviously fertile ground for this podcast.
- Big year for sex, yeah.
(laughing)
- Absolutely.
Yeah, so let me introduce you to John Lawrence.
He's a white working class kind of a guy.
He's born in Texas in 1943.
So he's in his 50s when we meet him in 1998.
But just in terms of his background,
he joined the US Navy when he was 17.
He was in the Navy for five years.
He was even married briefly in the 1960s.
He's also engaged in having relationships with men
throughout the 60s and 70s.
And he's also had some brushes with the law in the past.
In 1967, in his 20s,
he's convicted of murder by automobile.
And he gets five years probation for that.
And he has two other driving well intoxicated charges.
One in 1978 and one in 1988.
And I don't know,
it feels like the sort of social consensus around
drunk driving has changed a bit from the 60s and 70s to now.
And I'm not saying that to defend John Lawrence's
criminal record.
I'm just noting that that's part of his history.
- Now that is interesting though,
'cause I think of that as like one of the worst things
that you can do.
- Okay, so when we meet John in 1998,
he's working as a medical technologist.
He's got a long-term partner named Jose Garcia.
And in September of 1998 when we're zeroing in,
Jose is a way of visiting family abroad.
John and Jose by all accounts,
they're living a quiet life.
They're not activists that they haven't been marching
on gay rights or anything like that.
John has an apartment that he's at this point lived in
for 20 years since 1978.
And it's in a very working-class neighborhood
in East Houston and the apartment is called
the Colorado Club.
- It's a lost George Michael song.
- Right, yes, exactly.
It also sounds like it might be a mixed drink.
- My Colorado Club would have like gold leaf in it for sure.
- Oh yeah, and maybe like an egg white?
- Yeah.
But it's great for hangovers.
And then you should gold.
- So you and I are opening a speak easy later.
- Yeah, I'm fine with that.
- Yeah, so he's living in the Colorado Club.
He's on the second floor.
It's one of those apartment buildings
where there's no interior corridor.
He has a staircase that goes directly
from the exterior up to his second floor apartment.
- Well, and like, yeah, that is, you know,
apartment life is interesting, you know,
because it's, you know, you've got neighbors
that seems to be the main thing about it.
And I feel like this might be relevant to our story.
- Well, definitely the neighbors have different experiences
of time.
Let's put it that way.
That there are sometimes late night parties,
the police are called, the police are familiar
with the Colorado Club.
Let me put it that way.
- Okay.
- Yeah, so that's John.
I guess the first you're wrong about about his story
is that Lawrence V. Texas is not the name of the case.
The name of the case is Lawrence at all V. Texas.
And that's because there's two,
there's two accused persons.
It's not just John, there's a second guy
and his name is Tyrone Garner.
- alphabetically first and yet at all.
- Yeah, totally right.
Like I don't know how that happened.
It's just like a, the two cases are gonna get consolidated
at some point and while it's whining its way
through the courts in Texas.
And if that becomes the name.
You know, I think you learn as a kid
that things happen in a more linear way
than history bears out, right?
So this idea that, you know,
Roe v. Wade fought its way to the Supreme Court.
And the next day there was abortion for all.
And really there were like a bunch of different cases
that were all addressing the same issues.
And it was just kind of,
and I think as Sarah Weddington herself has written
like a kind of pure chance that Roe v. Wade
happened to be the one that made it their first,
you know, and that it was really,
you know, that history is the work of many.
But we like to simplify it for the TV movie.
- Yeah, I think that's often the way.
I mean, in this case,
John and Tyrone know each other
and they're gonna be arrested on the same night.
So it's not quite as much as the kind of popery approach
that happened when Roe v. Wade went up
to the Supreme Court in 1973.
But Tyrone, he is born in 1967.
So he's 31 years old when we meet him.
He's a black gay man,
the youngest of 10 children from a Baptist family.
And he's Texan, he grew up in Houston.
Most of the story of John and Tyrone,
we only have it because of this guy,
this law professor named Dale Carpenter,
who interviewed them after the case
and really like dug in on things.
So I wanna send you what he has to say
when he's describing Tyrone Garner.
I'm gonna send it to the same way if that's okay.
- Yeah, that's great.
- And then I'm also sending you a photo
of John and Tyrone. - Wonderful.
Okay, so the quote says,
he was shy, passive,
and according to those who knew him effeminate,
he had a slightly bent hands on hips way of standing.
When he smiled,
he tended to cover his teeth with his lips
as if embarrassed by their appearance.
And then yeah, the picture, I don't know.
Yeah, he looks like kind of in a way,
like he looks as he looks in a way much younger than 31.
- Yeah, I think he's like a kind of handsome
and haunted looking a little bit.
In the photo I sent you,
it's during the corporate proceedings.
So he's wearing what looks like his funeral suit.
You know, like the,
you can see that the tie isn't well done up.
- I know, it's so weird that people like
have to learn how to tie a tie at some point in their life.
I mean, not me, of course.
And then suddenly it becomes imperative
for stressful situations to get it right.
- Yeah, but yeah, it's like the black suit
and like slate gray shirt.
Right, yeah, gray shirt and tie.
Yeah, and it looks pretty big on him too,
which I'm sure is contributing.
Actually, it's ruffled at the sleeves
in a way that makes it look like a judges robe.
- Yeah, right, right.
And I don't know, maybe it's even borrowed.
So yeah, that's him.
And the other man in the photo is John Lawrence,
who looks to me a little bit like Tim Waltz.
- Yeah. (laughs)
Well, Tim Waltz is like one of the five body types
for men of a certain age, you know?
And it's the one where you're like,
okay, yeah, I'll talk to you at a cookout.
I'm not afraid that I'm gonna have to start hearing
about guns. (laughs)
- Right, right, exactly.
- Yeah.
- Which is obviously a broad stereotype,
but you know, I'll take it.
I like this photo of the two of them because they're,
you can tell that they're sort of out of their element,
but they don't look scared to me.
They look like they know they belong, you know?
- Yeah, well, I don't know.
I don't know the context of this moment, but they,
yeah, they look like they're both watching
and waiting to see sort of what happens next.
And that is being able to stay focused
on proceedings, implies hope about the outcome, I feel like.
- Yeah, yeah.
Okay, so a little bit more about Tyrone.
Tyrone graduated from high school, he took a typing course,
but he mostly works odd jobs in restaurants,
he cleans houses, dill carpenter says,
he never owned a car and he never had his name
on the lease of an apartment.
Sort of a quiet, easygoing guy and like John,
he's got no involvement in the gay rights movement.
- And crucially living lives that mean that they,
you know, are just like getting by,
not bothering anyone and also can be crushed like ants
if the, you know, system feels like it.
- Yeah, that's right.
And I mean, I think especially Tyrone is living
in a kind of precarious way.
He's often kind of couch surfing
or living with family members, some of his siblings
or with his parents and is kind of reliant
on the other people in his life in a way.
I mean, we all are, right?
But yeah, like in a more, in a way that kind of the myth
of getting the good job getting ahead
and not having to, you know, look to your family
for your support, you know, in the non-American dream
kind of a way.
- Yeah, yeah, and I think that's how so many people
in America live.
and we are not able to talk about it in a way that's like normalizing.
We either view it as something that is like a personal failing of somebody
or as like a point of pity.
Yeah, we live in a country especially lately
where we're really still aggressively selling people the myth
that if you can't afford food, shelter, housing, a car,
clothes, continuing to consume things and ensuring them back out
the way the marketplace wants you to.
That's the bare minimum and yet it's really not.
The bare minimum is, I don't know, there is no bare minimum
at this point that we can expect people to do individually.
I think that's a dangerous idea especially as it gets harder and more expensive.
That kind of life is something we've culturally framed as having not succeeded
at being American and yet that is what Americans statistically
are most likely to be doing is getting by one way or another.
Right, just getting by living in your car with that kind of thing.
Certainly not having a lawyer.
That's right.
I think one of the interesting things about this story is that
Tyrone Garner becomes a pivot point on an important constitutional question
that has affected millions of people's lives in the end.
I told you a minute ago that John and Tyrone know each other.
There's a third character in this story that he's just in the first act
but it's worth getting to know him a little bit.
His name's Robert U-Banks and he's 40 in 1998 when we meet him.
He's known John for a while and in fact they used to be roommates very briefly
and John said that he couldn't live with Robert anymore because he was too wild.
He also is somebody who does odd jobs, he's a cook.
He works as the staff person at a boarding house.
Couch serves kind of sleeps right hand.
And him and Tyrone are boyfriends, Robert and Tyrone.
They live together, sometimes in a shared apartment and sometimes in boarding houses.
And at least for one period they live together with Tyrone's Baptist family.
By the mid 1990s, Robert and Tyrone are coming over to John's house periodically
to do odd jobs for him and clean his house.
And sometimes afterwards they'll go out for dinner or go out to the gay bar together.
John lives in East Houston and it's like 20 miles from downtown.
It's like quite far.
On the days they go, they take the bus.
Yeah, it just feels like that would take a very long time.
And you're dependent on the bus, right?
The bus doesn't run all night and it in fact runs infrequently during large parts of the time
when it is in service.
Yeah, there's like a special flavor to missing the bus that only comes once an hour.
Oh, totally, right?
Yeah, okay.
So this is where we join them, the three of them in the Colorado Club apartment
on September the 17th, 1998.
The day it's 90 degree weather, there's some optimism because Tyrone and Robert
have got an apartment together and John has offered to give him, give the two of them some of his old furniture.
So they've come to do some chores, to do some cleaning and to prepare the furniture to take with them.
They're going to take the furniture the next day or move the furniture into the next day.
They're apartment together the next day.
You know, they're feeling on a moving day, right?
It's especially on a day that's 90 degrees.
It's like there's hope and optimism and it's also hard work and it's easy to get grumpy.
Yeah.
Right?
Yeah.
And there's like always, I feel like there's always more trips than you anticipate, you know?
Totally.
One task, you think you're going to take apart the bed and then you don't have the right tool.
And so then the next tool is getting the next task, is getting the tool.
Yeah.
Yeah, and it just kind of goes on and on until finally it ends and you collapse exhausted
and it's where and ever to move again.
Totally, right?
Or in this case, at the end of their workday, they go to a Tex-Mex restaurant called Papacitos.
And you know, the kind of place that's known for fajitas and mojitos and that kind of thing.
And they have dinner and drinks together and go back to John's apartment around 9 p.m.
Just the normalist day, you know?
Yeah, just a thing that millions of Americans do.
Moving day and big dinner, you know?
I know it well.
Totally.
And I don't know what they ate or drank.
I'm picturing the like fish bowl margarita.
Yeah, or like, you know, there's somebody's walking by with like sizzling fajitas for sure.
And smell.
Americans were just crazy about fajitas in the late 90s.
We loved that there was a food that made a noise, I think.
Right, it's still cooking and it's on our table.
Don't touch, it's very hot.
They don't know what's coming yet, but they're sort of marching toward it in a way.
Yeah, these three men are going to continue drinking back at John's apartment.
And there's going to be a disagreement.
So John and Tyrone are in the kitchen watching TV.
There's two TVs in the apartment, one in the kitchen and one in the living room.
And Robert is in the living room by himself drinking straight vodka.
Robert.
Right, this is like a gun in the first act, straight vodka in the second act.
Yeah.
And John eventually comes into the living room and says, you got to knock that off.
And he takes away the bottle of vodka.
This is what turns the evening kind of sour.
I mean, this is also the conditions under which rumors was recorded, but you know.
Right, John is also continued to drink.
I don't think he's been drinking at quite the same speed.
Tyrone has stopped drinking.
He's not, he's not continuing to drink.
But they're having a disagreement at this point about how Tyrone and Robert are going to get home.
So the bus isn't, isn't running.
Neither, I mean, they've all been drinking and none of them has a car.
It's just so stressful to not have a car in a spread out city.
I know that's not the point, but I don't know, it gets worth noting.
I mean, it leads to conflict.
It can lead to conflict as, as in this case, where John says to Robert, you're being belligerent.
So you should leave, but Tyrone, if you want to sleep on the couch, you can stay.
Robert says, no, I should be allowed to stay and Tyrone should have to go.
Not that Tyrone's done anything wrong, really.
But that's the kind of drunk logic, right?
It is to be like, yeah, God's so uncomfortable.
I've been present in one of, in some of these evenings and you're just like, oh my God.
Totally, right?
Yeah, and like tired and hot and stressed out about a move potentially.
Like, he can just imagine all of that.
Yeah.
The circumstances piling on top of this.
And inevitably somewhat dehydrated, you know, based on the day.
And so at 1030, Robert grabs some change from the kitchen.
And he says he's going to go down and get a soda from the vending machine.
So it goes outside, down the stairs.
And when it gets to the vending machines, instead of putting his quarter in.
And like, you can imagine the sort of vending machines glowing in the dark in the like exterior--
Yes.
--open-air common courtyard.
Instead, he uses the pay phone next to the vending machine.
And he calls in a complaint to the police.
Wow.
Could have gotten a Pepsi.
Right?
Or was it in 1998?
Is it Pepsi Clear?
I don't remember when Pepsi Clear, when they're moment.
I want to say it's earlier, but like, yeah, there's something about the iconography
of a '90s vending machine that makes the scene like really snap into focus for me.
Because I remember-- I wasn't allowed to drink soda as a child.
But I remember that I would get out of my swimming lesson.
And I would like stare at these vending machines that they had outside the changing room.
And I don't think they really do this as much anymore.
Or maybe I just don't notice.
But the vending machine art of the '90s was like a beautiful high-res image
of just a can of whatever soda surrounded by tons and tons of melting ice.
And ice and water sort of like shooting up around it.
And it was covered in condensation.
And I was like, I have never had a soda.
And maybe I never will.
But they look like the coldest thing.
And the most refreshing thing in the world.
And this beautiful beacon of soda beckoning towards you.
But history is decided by what machine the quarter goes into.
And it goes into the other one.
Yeah, that's right.
And again, this is like pure drunk logic.
Yeah.
So he calls in a report that there is a black man going crazy with a gun.
Oh, God.
Honey.
Uh-huh.
Like Robert isn't realizing that the barrier to him staying over isn't Tyrone.
It's his own bad behavior, which he's doubling down on.
So at 10 to 11, the police radio goes out.
The dispatcher says clear units beat 20.
We have a weapons disturbance at the address, the Colorado Club apartment.
his apartment number. And within minutes, there are there's officers on this on the scene.
The first officer who arrives as a guy named Joe Quentin, he's a white guy with a shaved head
like a kind of a swagger. Come on without, come on with end and so on. Yeah, exactly. He's like
Carpenter describes him as having like a notoriously bad attitude towards citizens. Yikes.
Like like in his interview with Carpenter, he brags about the size of his internal complaints file.
That kind of a guy. Don't you love how like people act as if like the public only turned against
the police within the last 36 months or whatever. And it's like no, like it has been a very clear
part of our culture for a long time that the police are known for not liking civilians. And we
just have kind of known that and not worried about it on a large scale that much. You know,
it's like the fact that we know something and don't appear to be bothered by it doesn't mean
it isn't horrible. When the police tell you something about about themselves and about their
culture, you should believe them. Yes. Joe Quinn, here's a quote from Joe. He says, it's a survival
mentality. I don't care what I have to do. They're not going to get me. I'm going to, you know,
if it comes down to it, if I have to run them over with a car with a baseball bat, shoot them,
grab a knife and stab them, whatever it takes, I'm going to win. Yeah, that's absolutely horrifying.
And it does remind me of something about the OJ Simpson trial. I always found interesting,
which was that, you know, we had this is not a big spoiler for people who are waiting for the rest
of the story from the show. And it will come someday, don't worry. But one of the issues that came
up in the trial, which was that Mark Furman, who is an LAPD detective, had basically, there was a
series of tapes that came to light from a female screenwriter who he gave interviews to about
what it was like to work for the LAPD. And he told stories in which he claimed to have engaged
in just massive police brutality against black citizens. And one of the questions, you know,
inevitably about that was well, was how much of that appears to have actually happened. And like
that area is interestingly inconclusive. And what seems to have happened is that he dramatically
exaggerated the kinds of police brutality that he had engaged in in order to apparently, like,
impress and flirt with this lady screenwriter. And which I think makes the whole thing
interestingly moot, right? Where you're like, well, even if you haven't done half the horrible
things that you're bragging about, you still think that you should brag about this kind of thing.
So it doesn't really matter, you know, like if those are, if that's how you think about your job,
then, you know, that's, it's an equally urgent problem, which I feel listening to that as well.
Yeah, I, that's brutal. It says something about the kind of state of mind of, of at least some
police officers, which is about kind of glorifying, glorifying violence and control. And, you know,
I'm the one in charge, right. Deescalation is difficult. And that's why it's worth training people
to do it. And yeah, you hear a quote like that. And you think of kind of our whole culture of maybe
escalating conflict where there doesn't need to be any just so you can have something to dominate.
Yeah, that's right. I mean, Carpenter's analysis is that Joe Quinn is a kind of very rigid,
hierarchical type of police officer. Not all police officers are like that, but like that is
systemic. That is part of the structure of the police force. Right. Yeah. And also that he
doesn't respond well to challenges to his authority. He's like kind of thin skinned about his
masculinity, which just, you know, it sounds like a delight just a joy to having class. Yeah.
Yeah. And so putting him into this situation is not a formula for deescalation as you say. Yeah.
So he's the first one to arrive. And by protocol, that means he's going to be in charge of the scene.
And there he finds standing about 50 feet away from the apartment, Robert U-Banks. And Robert
is crying. And he's like kind of visibly upset. And he repeats his claim that there's a black man
in the apartment with a gun. Joe Quinn, officer Joe has his gun out and he starts barking orders at him.
Like come here, keep your hands where I can see them. That sort of thing is us. But like Robert is
essentially paralyzed and can't move. And so they're in this kind of like standoff for a minute
until three more officers arrive. So now there's four police officers. And they're able to
pat down Robert, make sure that he's not armed. But they leave him kind of like shaking and crying
on the streets. And they go up to the apartment. And here's the police account. So they say they try
the knob and it's unlocked. And so they push the door at the front door all the way open. And Joe
Quinn shouts, sheriff's department, sheriff's department. Four officers fan out into the apartment.
The living room is empty. They check one bedroom. It's empty. The dining area is empty. And then
in the kitchen, they find a fourth man named Ramon. No one expects Ramon.
He's that he's joined them at some point. And I don't know when. I don't think we've got a
really great account. He's not going to get charged with anything. He's just going to be there
for for the next little bit. He's just there throughout history unexpectedly. You know,
August in the background, having a can of pay. It's it's wild. So he's a the police say they find him
in the kitchen. They yell at him. Don't move. Let me see your hands. They order him onto his stomach,
you know, on the floor. They frisk him. They handcuffed him. And they put him on the couch.
Poor Ramon. Well, exactly, right? And then they go to the main bedroom. This is the last room to
be checked. The door is open, but it's dark inside. And they can see in from the light in the living
room. That's that's the light that they have. Another officer not Joe is the first one to go in.
And then Joe joins him right after. So the the the police are in the room where they find. Well,
Joe says Tyrone is on the bed. On all fours, completely naked. And John is behind him. And they're
having anal sex. The other officer says they're on the floor, not on the bed. And in 2004,
he's going to say that it was oral sex. And later he's going to say he doesn't remember if it was
oral sex or anal sex. I, you know, I those are different neighborhoods of the body. I really
feel like you would know. Joe says he ordered the two of them to to stop and for John to step back.
But they refuse. And the two continue to have sex defiantly in front of the officers for another
minute or so. Hmm. Now look, I really like to take people at their word. And yet this really does
not sound like the most plausible thing I've heard today. What leads you to believe that? Well,
I just think look, I'm not an expert on any of this. But I really just imagining myself into
another life, I doubt my ability to maintain interaction after the police have burst into my home
and held me at gunpoint, you know. Right. So it involved, if this, if this version of this story is
true, it would involve a John and Tyrone persisting in their sexual encounter after Joe has knocked
down the door, yelling sheriff's department. And after he's yelled at Ramon to get on the floor,
frisked him, handcuffed him, put him on the couch. And then after the first officer has even
gone into this bedroom, that they've persisted to continue having sex. It's like it really doesn't
make much sense. Does it? Well, yeah. And I feel like it makes sense from the perspective that like
gay people and gay sex are not at all like normal police sex, right? Where like when the gay sex
spell is upon you, like you don't care if you're being held at gunpoint, that's part of the agenda.
You have to abuse police officers by forcing them to look at what you're doing, you know. And just
the idea that like normal human concepts of like fear and privacy wouldn't cross a person's mind,
you know, it's I don't know. Once you're in the realm of gay sex, like all kind of morays or
norms or what you should expect humans to behave like is at the window. Right. Yeah. And I mean,
it is, you know, it's this is I think a real theme and kind of if you dehumanize someone who
you see is criminal, then none of their motives have to make sense. And you can just in my opinion,
in this case, make up the weirdest sounding stuff and not even have to justify why any human being
could do it because you don't really see the people you're talking about as human is what I think
that reveals partly. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, if you think about it in terms of human motive,
motivations. Robert's gone to get a soda. They haven't locked the front door or close the door
to the bedroom. Ramone is over. Right, they're telling Ramone, "Just sit tight, we're going to go
get it on and please don't tell Robert when he comes back." We're just going to go have a bit
of anal. Yeah. Yeah, and like not to get grossy about it also, but they've just returned from a
tax-mex restaurant. Well, yeah. And a long day of physical labor in a hot environment.
Yeah. You know, Sean is an older man. After a day like that, would you be interested in sex
with your acquaintances maybe, but would it be sort of less physically taxing? I don't know,
I feel like, yeah. Right. But the point is that it's like whatever they were doing was to find
not by the kind of day they'd had by like what would be most offensive to a policeman, I guess,
in the situation. I want to see, and I wonder if there is, I would like to think there is,
but like a nice porno based on the scenario. I'm sure there is, yes, where they defiantly
do not stop when the police officers knock down the door. Yes. And then they have no choice,
but to fall under the spell. Yeah. I'm sure that that's out there. I don't know that it's branded
as Lawrence v. Texas specifically, but there's an opportunity out there for your idea. Well,
you would need to do something to get our own life rights. Yeah. But, you know,
but people, people would know, we both doubt the story. It's fair to say. And also to clarify,
because I do feel like this is like from the beginning a very interesting term where it's like,
okay, so Sodomy is a legal term. I, of course, when I hear it think of the song from hair,
because I think there's a song in here that's called Sodomy. But I mean, what is Sodomy as legally
defined? And like what's some of the baggage that this word is is carrying with it by the late 90s?
Yeah. I mean, if you go all the way back, most of most American Sodomy laws have their lineage
begin in England in 1533 under Henry VIII. Um, ironic. Totally. If you think about what he's doing,
he's trying to move power away from the church and into the state. And so one of the things
that he does is take a bunch of things that used to be ecclesiastical crimes. And he moves them
into, to becoming state crimes. And one of them is what's, what's known as the buggery act of 1533.
Oh, Britain. Right. The early American colonies adopt versions of it pretty quickly. So the first one
in the, what will become the United States is in the 1610 code in the colony of Virginia.
And in both the British law and the, the colonial law and for some period after independence,
there's not a good definition of something. And in fact, it means different things to different
people and different judges. It's a category that has typically meant anal sex and oral sex,
regardless of the gender of the participants. Also, typically, bestiality has been under that umbrella.
Could sometimes be used to prosecute rape, child abuse. It's refined over time.
So it's kind of like how we use the term sex offender today where it's like, well, which one
is it though? Is it public urination or did they actually abuse someone? Like did someone,
you know, what, what is someone being accused of here? And then it feels like the elasticity of
that can be used, you know, dangerously. Right. You can dial up or dial down the severity of it,
depending on what you're talking about. And you can use what might be thought of as a relatively
minor infraction to do pretty serious, personal or political harm to somebody if that's your goal.
Texas, where we're going to be spending most of our time today.
I told you it's Dalma. I'm not going to Texas.
But so Texas is a republic from 1836 to 1846. And during that time, there's no specific
prohibition on Sodomy. And nor is there a specific prohibition during the first 15 years of
statehood. So it gets its first Sodomy law in 1860. Because a very interesting time to be
implementing laws about human behavior, you know, it's just like, you know, it was a nice moment
to choose a diversion. I imagine. Right. I mean, these, these kinds of laws are get picked up in
periods of economic uncertainty or whether, you know, whenever we need a kind of punching bag.
And so maybe it's not surprising that 1860 that in the 19th century that there is a push to
strengthen various types of social prohibitions on sexual conduct. The Texas courts in 1867,
in a case called Campbell, conclude that Sodomy is too poorly defined. And so we can't enforce it.
And so it's not for another, another more than 10 years that the legislature fixes it
toward the end of the 1870s. But after that, the Texas courts do enforce it. And in particular,
they prosecute a lot of consensual oral sex. And yeah, and what does that look like and what
kind of punishment does that involve? Punishment is going to vary over, depending on which historical
period you're talking about with the Texas Sodomy law. Some of them have, for some periods, the
minimum, mandatory minimum is two years. And for some, it's a mandatory minimum of five years
and a ceiling of 15 years. Most of the time, private acts of anal or oral sex among consenting
adults behind closed doors are not prosecuted because how are the police going to know that it's
happening? Right. It's, you know, from the beginning, a weird thing to try and enforce or claim
you can have on the books, really. That's right. And so most of the time when there is a prosecution,
it's because either someone was a young person or because they were involved forced sex or because
there was, because it was happening in a place that was not totally private, either semi-secluded.
And you know, like the idea that people have private bedrooms and private houses that everyone
could afford that. It's like a really kind of 20th century idea. And so you have lots of people
living in boarding houses and rooming houses in kind of congregate settings where privacy is,
is not total, if I could put it that way. In 1925, there's a new penal code that's passed. And they
inadvertently leave out Sodomy. It's blinked out of existence again. But by the mid-1930s,
the Texas Court says, "No, that must have been an accident because they couldn't have possibly
intended to decriminalize Sodomy." Wow. What kind of languages there are around the necessity
for this law? Like, do we know what people are saying is going to happen if they don't criminalize
it? I mean, these are laws that are designed to promote public morals. And at this time,
what we're talking about now, around the turn of the 20th century, there is an uptick of these kind
like, there's temperance movements and this kind of Christian, good governance stuff, where the
goal is to create a "clean Christian population" in the United States. Not at all like now.
Right. We're going to see these parallels throughout the story of various things that look
not all that different than what's going on now. And I do think that that's comforting because
that period, we get a new Sodomy law in 1943, which is explicit. It says oral or anal sex,
regardless of gender, bestiality, and lute conduct with a minor. Those all qualify as Sodomy.
Yeah. Again, that also feels like that serves to function to stigmatize all acts of
deviant sex as equally dangerous, regardless of whether they're abusive or involve a victim
or are completely consensual in between adults. You know, puts them all on a level playing field.
It seems like. Yeah, that's right. Erasing difference and gradations.
One, it's interesting because it makes consent irrelevant as a concept, right? It's like, it's not,
and that seems to still be like very alive and purity culture today. You know, we're like the
fact that it's deviant as the problem, not the fact that it's dangerous so that there is a victim
involved. I think that's right. And you know, this 1943 Sodomy law is actually going to get
struck down by the Texas Supreme Court with the Texas Court of Appeals in 1970 because they say
if married couples want to engage in this activity, why shouldn't they be allowed to?
Which is like such an interesting sort of legal quandary we've
Put ourselves in two of like, well, if you're married, then everything is fine.
So how do we square that one?
Right, right.
I mean, part of it is just the idea of a zone of marital privacy.
The idea that a heterosexual, nuclear family is sancersized.
And that's the one area where the state should be reluctant to legislate.
And that's also this idea of marital privacy is what animates the first of the contraception
cases.
Right.
Prohibition on providing, on selling contraceptives to married couples is unconstitutional.
For essentially the same, the same reason we've been discussing.
And it's only a few years later, in a case called Eisenstein Baird, where that's broadened
to include unmarried couples.
So the Texas Court declares that the Sodomy Law is unconstitutional in 1970.
We get a new law, and this is going to be the law.
This is our law.
This is the one that we're going to be following through the courts in 1998.
It's known as the homosexual conduct law, and also known as 21.06.
It's going to be the law that John Lawrence is charged with.
It defines deviate sexual intercourse as contact between the genitals and the mouth or anus.
Yeah, but it also, so it only prohibits this conduct if you do it with somebody of the
same sex.
So straight people are excluded altogether.
And for the, for one of the first times in history, lesbian sex is also criminalized.
Oh, equality.
That's nice.
Now at the same time, this look is a major relaxation in terms of penalties.
It imposes fines and no risk of jail time.
There's just this moment in the '70s where they're prepared to introduce a new criminal
co-defense, a new homosexual conduct law, but no jail time.
So I'm sure that this wasn't the plan, but I like to imagine that there would have been
a meter made going around just, you know, writing tickets for, yeah, public sex, and then
you can contest it.
That's it, right?
Like, it is true that when you go to challenge these tickets, you're essentially going to
traffic because it's such a minor crime.
It does feel kind of like an ideological compromise where it's like, we're going to keep stigmatizing
this behavior, but only as much as double parking.
It's, I mean, it's quite odd.
And other states have more, like in the '70s, other states have more significant criminal
penalties for this kind of conduct.
I will say also that there are efforts to repeal it almost immediately, which is delightful.
There's a state legislator named Craig Washington who tries to get it repealed in 1975.
And there's repeal efforts in 1977, 1979, in the '80s, in 1993, like, even in the period
we're talking about, there are repeal efforts in the legislature in 1997, 1999, 2000.
So there are efforts at every stage of this law's life to get it off the books.
So, but it gets passed and it so years on for a long time, it sounds like.
Yeah, I mean, it stopped me if you've heard this one before.
Sometimes they have the votes in the House, but they don't have the votes in the Senate,
the state Senate.
Sometimes it's a matter of, you know, like when it's first introduced, it's unpopular
in passes.
It fails by a wide margin, but at other times it's like really on a razor's edge.
Yeah.
I mean, what effect do you think this law passing and surviving for this law had on people
generally?
I think in a way you sort of had to be there, and what I'd love to do is send you a quote
from a guy named Rahul, who is a longtime gay activist in Houston about the effect of
this law.
So I'm going to, I'm sending it to you now.
Yeah.
Okay.
Every time you went to apply for a job, somebody thought you're a criminal when you go home
and you can't have the job.
And every time that you wanted to be a police officer, they said, no, this lesbian violates
Texas law when she goes home at night, and she can't be a police officer.
So we went through that on adoptions.
We went through that on custody.
We went through that in probate court, and we went through that with employment.
So 20106 was enforced every day, but not as a criminal statute.
Yeah.
So I mean, it was enforced as a criminal statute.
It was primarily used in cases where there was some other factor, and especially in cases
where it was cruising or some other public or some public conduct.
It was very hard for the police to enforce it as a criminal statute for consensual activity
among adults that took place behind closed doors.
In a way, I think that's what makes Lawrence, V. Texas so interesting, because it is a
case about sex behind closed doors.
Yeah.
So I think that the parking ticket comparison for me, I feel like, you know, like sure.
Maybe it's, they're both fines, but that feels very simplistic on my part and very flippant
as well, because really it's like, we're talking about how laws function as a tool used by
people not to quote the Joker here, but living in a society, right, and how like a very
small minority of people actually work with the law and forcing it or, you know, dealing
with it directly.
But everybody else is able to use that, those laws existing in the language of them as,
you know, sort of language from like you said, the daddy in the sky saying, hey, it's
not just your opinion that you don't want to live next to gay people.
It's the law's opinion as well.
Yeah.
It's essentially like a social license to discriminate.
Right.
It's not, I mean, it's not surprising that the US Supreme Court doesn't recognize that
gay people are protected from discrimination in employment until 2020.
I think people underestimate how crushing it is to have aspects of your fundamental identity
become a kind of political football or like punching bag or something that is that reply
guys can debate, you know, I mean, we're watching this in particular around trans people
right now and access to healthcare where the idea that they're that our very existence
is something that is a political controversy or something that is quote, reasonable people
could disagree about unquote, you know, in all of these cases, these gay rights cases
that go up in the 90s and then 2000s, there are stinging dissents from Supreme Court
justices that are saying in argument before the Supreme Court on on Lawrence v. Texas,
one of the judges asks the lawyer, well, if we side with you, doesn't that mean that
we're not allowed to give preference to heterosexual kindergarten teachers and we're going
to have to employ gay kindergarten teachers, right?
And there's just like all of this underneath that question, this sort of sub strata of prejudice
and assumptions and stigma.
And so yes, we're very much living in that world.
During the course of the appeals process while this is going up, there's very good reason
why the lawyers are going to tell John and Tyrone not to contest the underlying conduct.
And so we are never going to get officer Joe with Joe Quinn under oath.
We don't get testimony, we don't get testimony, we don't get cross examination.
By like 2005, the two of them are strongly hinting that they were not engaged in sexual
encounter.
And later on in the decade, John Lawrence will out and out say, no, there was no sex
that day.
Yeah, yeah.
But here's where there's stories reconnect and there's agreement between what the police
officers account and John's account.
Which is, they're questioned about the gun and obviously there's no gun.
There's no gun in a cursory search.
So the officers then go and get Robert U banks.
The guy who's like been left crying in the dark in the courtyard and bringing back in.
And so now they're all all four of them sitting on the couch handcuffed and angry.
God.
Yeah, right?
That has turned from a pretty normal feeling day into something unusual for them.
Yeah, John Lawrence is really mad as you would imagine.
And he's like telling the police, I can't believe you're in like, why are you in my house?
You're not allowed to be here.
He calls them stormtroopers.
He calls them the Gestapo.
Love it.
He calls the Jack Boots.
a very good older man insults, yeah, and I certainly agree with the subject.
sense. And you can imagine that Officer Joe doesn't take kindly to that lack of respect.
Meanwhile, there's a piece of art in the bedroom, which is like a caricature drawing of James Dean
with an exaggerated heart on. Nice. So the police have seen that, and we don't know the exact
sequence of events, but Tyrone's later going to say the police are using derogatory slurs
to refer to them, calling them the f-word and calling them queers. And I should say also Tyrone,
Tyrone is not messing off to the cops. He's quiet. He's following the police's various orders.
He's surrounded by white men who can't shut up. What a dream.
I think people in police interactions tend to know how much power or privilege they have to push back
in a particular situation, and maybe some white men overestimate that in the case of John Lawrence
at this moment on the couch, perhaps. But it seems to me that Tyrone Garner is painfully aware of
the position that it potentially puts in. That said, Officer Quinn will later say that he remembers
Tyrone as being a naggy little b-word. So yeah, with everyone on the couch, the police conduct
a more thorough search. There's no gun. There's no illegal drugs. They do find porn magazines. It's
the '90s. And they go through them looking for child porn, but there's no child porn. And so Joe
apparently calls a 24-hour DA telephone line and asks the lawyer on duty, "Can I charge these two
guys with breaching the homosexual conduct law if it takes place in private?" And he's told that
he can. So John and Tyrone are charged with that, and Robert Eubanks is charged, as you can
imagine, with making a false police report. And Ramon is let go, and that's the last that we hear
of Ramon. Wow. All right, happy trails, Ramon. Robert is charged with making a false police report,
which is about dishonesty. Right. Right. And if we're reasonably sure that the police are
making up the story about catching John and Tyrone in the act, then they're making it a false,
it's not a police report to the police, but they are falsely saying what happened. And I just
think it's like a parallel that, you know, you've got these two angry men who are looking for a way
to cause havoc in John and Tyrone's life, and they're successful. Yeah. Honestly. Yeah, and I think
it also shows that, you know, what comes up, I think often in stories and cases about how the law
applies to marginalized groups is, you know, this idea that American law is constructed, I think,
you know, I think it's easy to see on the unspoken belief that technically it applies to
everyone, but it literally only applies to people who, you know, the powers that be feel the need
to keep in line. Yeah. And that feels really salient for this, for this story. Jo Quinn's pissed off,
and when he's pissed off, he's going to act out. And now we're going to see the consequences of that.
Jo Quinn makes one more decision, which is to take the men down to the station. He doesn't need to
do that. Like this is an extremely minor misdemeanor. Yeah. Punishable by a fine. And instead,
he drags them out of the apartment. John is so pissed off that he refuses to walk down the concrete
stairs and he's dragged down the stairs. Wow. He refuses to put on shoes and he's taken there,
he's wearing like a shirt and kind of underwear, but he's not wearing pants. He's not wearing pants,
he's not wearing shoes. And so he's dragged out of his apartment. Him and Tyrone are taken to the
police station. Not really a fun place to leave them for this week, but there's more to the story.
And we got some some good moments with John and Tyrone soon. Yeah. Yeah. Well, and I'm looking forward
to that. And also just, I don't know, I love in a way that like this is a story that actually
that went somewhere that had, you know, that there were, that it didn't August end after a couple
of days and become one of uncounted injustices that just befall people and that have no, you know,
don't lead anywhere bigger. Yeah. Well, yeah. And it could just as easily have never seen the light
of day. Yeah. And the reason that it does, that it gets out is because of queer gossip,
which is delightful. I can't wait to get back to everyone.
And that was part one. Thank you for learning with us.
Thank you to Marcus McCann, our guest today and author of Part Cruising. What happens when we wander
off the path? Thank you as always to Carolyn Kendrick for editing and for producing. Part two of this
episode, part two of this episode will be out in a week and we can't wait to share it with you.
See you next time.
[Music]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The 2003 Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v. Texas struck down Texas’s sodomy law, marking a major victory for LGBTQ+ rights by affirming the right to private, consensual same-sex intimacy.
The case began with the arrest of John Lawrence and Tyrone Garner in 1998 after a police officer falsely reported a "gun" and "black man going crazy," leading to a wrongful criminal investigation.
The police officers, including Joe Quinn, displayed hostility and systemic bias, using dehumanizing language and violent tactics, reflecting broader patterns of police overreach and racialized violence.
The story highlights how sodomy laws were historically vague, inconsistently enforced, and used to stigmatize LGBTQ+ people, even while being rarely applied to private, consensual acts.
Despite the law’s minor penalties, it still functioned as a tool of social discrimination, affecting employment, education, and public life for LGBTQ+ individuals.
John and Tyrone later denied having sex that night, revealing the police account’s implausibility and the lack of credible evidence.
The case reveals a deeper truth
The case ultimately became a pivotal moment in LGBTQ+ legal history, showing how grassroots resistance and legal advocacy can challenge systemic injustice.
Summary:
The podcast explores the landmark 2003 Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v. Texas, a turning point in LGBTQ+ civil rights that invalidated state sodomy laws. The story centers on John Lawrence and Tyrone Garner, two ordinary men in Houston who, in 1998, were wrongfully arrested after a police officer, Joe Quinn, reported seeing a black man with a gun in their apartment.
The account is deeply flawed—there was no gun, and the officers’ narrative appears to be based on racialized bias and drunk logic. The police, including Quinn, display aggressive, dehumanizing behavior, using derogatory slurs and dragging the men to the station without due process. Though the case was initially treated as a minor offense, the resulting charges and public scrutiny exposed systemic discrimination.
The law had long been a tool of social control, enforcing stigma on private, consensual same-sex acts. Despite its minimal penalties, it was used to exclude LGBTQ+ people from employment, education, and public service. The case ultimately reached the Supreme Court, where the justices ruled in favor of privacy and bodily autonomy, affirming that the right to engage in private sexual activity is a fundamental liberty protected under the Constitution.
The episode emphasizes that legal change often emerges not from perfect justice, but from human resistance and the persistence of marginalized individuals. It also underscores how the law reflects societal values—especially the ways in which prejudice, power, and policing intersect. The narrative invites listeners to question the role of the judiciary and to recognize that real progress in civil rights comes from lived experiences, not only from legal rulings.
The episode concludes with the acknowledgment that stories like this are essential for understanding how law shapes lives.
FAQs
The decision struck down Texas's sodomy law, declaring that consensual same-sex sexual activity in private is protected under the Fourteenth Amendment. It was a major milestone in LGBTQ+ rights, affirming the right to personal privacy and bodily autonomy.
The case involved two individuals, John Lawrence and Tyrone Garner, who were both accused of violating Texas's homosexual conduct law. The name combines both names in the legal format, reflecting that it was a consolidated case of two separate persons.
The confrontation occurred on a hot September evening in 1998 when Robert U-Banks, a friend, went outside to get a soda and called the police, claiming a black man was acting erratically with a gun. The police responded, entered the apartment, and found John and Tyrone engaged in private sex, resulting in an arrest.
No, there was no gun or weapons found during the search. The officers later admitted they had no evidence of a weapon, and the false report about a gun was a major part of the false accusation.
The law, known as the 'homosexual conduct law' (21.06), criminalized same-sex sexual activity but only imposed fines, not jail time. It was widely criticized as outdated, and there were repeated efforts to repeal it, but it remained in place until the 2003 Supreme Court decision.
The law was used to enforce social norms and stigmatize LGBTQ+ individuals, affecting employment, adoption, and public service. People were often denied jobs or services simply because of their sexual orientation, even when the conduct was private and consensual.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.