Lab Leak or Nuclear War - What Comes Next? | PBD Podcast #893
1h 48m 13s
The speaker argues that biological warfare poses a greater and more imminent threat than nuclear war, primarily due to the absence of deterrence, the high likelihood of accidental release, and the terrifying potential for rapid, uncontrolled spread. Drawing on real-world events like the 2019 explosion at Russia’s Vector Lab, the narrative outlines a plausible scenario: an accidental leak in a high-security bio-lab triggers a global crisis, leading to societal breakdown, insurrection, and the collapse of democratic institutions within six days. The story is grounded in historical facts and scientific reality, including the existence of dangerous pathogens like pneumonic plague and the use of AI to accelerate pathogen design. Unlike nuclear weapons, which are deterred by mutual assured destruction, biological weapons lack such safeguards, making them more likely to be used or leaked. The speaker highlights systemic failures in global oversight, transparency, and national preparedness, especially in pandemic response. Trust in government institutions has plummeted, and the rise of synthetic biology has made creating deadly pathogens increasingly accessible. While the threat may seem abstract, the speaker insists the key to survival lies not in paranoia or panic, but in greater information, cross-party cooperation, and a reformed international framework to monitor and regulate biological research. He warns that without urgent action, the world risks a catastrophic failure of governance and public trust—making the current moment a critical inflection point for global security.
When nuclear war begins, it doesn't end until complete annihilation. Which is more likely to happen. I logical war in nuclear war. No one I know, no one I have shared that with since knows that. For 80 years, there's been no nuclear use. No one would be crazy enough to use a nuclear weapon. Bio is very, very different. Starting with the fact that pathogens are so tiny and they're invisible that could result in absolute chaos andarchy, insurrection and death. You're talking biological warfare. Some people worried about the grid. What blind spots do we have that we're not thinking about? The threats exist. They are not going to go away. Probably the end of the world. Utopia is a strange concept that is not plausible. But dystopia does not have to happen. How many places have that in their hands today? In a full scale nuclear exchange between Russia and the United States. The world could end in the next couple of hours. Any, we're finally doing this. Here we are. Thank you so much for having me. It's an honor to have you here. It's an honor to be here. You do great work. Five-time New York Times, you wrote the book "Nuclear War," the timing was perfect. Now you write the biological war that comes out. For me, I guess the first question would be in the book "Nuclear War," you said, if it were to happen, it was 72 minutes, five billion people will be killed because of a war, if it does happen. In the biological war book that you write, what would happen there? I mean, in nuclear war, you're absolutely right. I take the reader from nuclear launch to nuclear winter in 72 minutes. Biological war, I take the reader from outbreak to anarchy in six days. Outbreak to anarchy in six days. In the United States. Then you have the Insurrection Act and then you have the end of American democracy. Walk me through it. Stop. Minute by minute, day by day. One of the, let me set this up a little bit by saying, you know, I have written about war and weapons, national security secrets, my whole career. And all war gaming is predicated on essentially an attack. Biological war, I learned much to my surprise. There's not necessarily have to be an attack. It can also begin with an accident, but the planning, the preparation, and in essence, the probable outcome can very much be the same. So you can have an accident that has the same results as an attack. And when I learned that, that really shifted my perspective about how I was going to write the narrative, and that's, and then learning my God, same results outbreak to anarchy in six days. So it begins with an accident in my book, a lab leak at a BSL4 facility in Siberia in Russia, a facility called Vector. And I show the reader, it's kind of, I break things up into act one, two, and three. Act one, you see the full intelligence community go into overdrive, trying to discern what happened, and how they're going to deal with it. Act two, pathogen arrives in the United States. You see how the national security apparatus moves into action in a kind of invisible manner. Act three is pretty much the end game, chaos, anarchy, insurrection. And the day new month is something I learned about from Obama's FEMA chief called devolution, whereby a group of officials, pre-determined, pre-selected, completely classified, disappears off into a series of underground bunkers across the United States, called cold sites warm sites and hot sites. They essentially stay there, while the plague burns out, and then they reconstitute the government. And that happens in six days. Six days is when the president declares the Insurrection Act and the devolution protocols begin after something called cog con one is instigated cog, you know, defcon. So cog con is the continuity of operations, continuity of government, cog level one, one is the max. And once that is declared, devolution protocols kick in. Now, when you wrote this book, you use Siberia. Your book came out in June of 2026. October 2nd, story comes out with a leak that 200 people had to be quarantined at a anti-plague lab in Erktsuk, I think it's called Siberia. So what are the correlation between you, right? I'm assuming you chose that city, that area, probably year before the book was published. And then the story comes out four months after your book, that ends in the same, pretty much same area. How does that happen? I mean, it was an astonishing coincidence. Now, the anti-plague institute is known as a former Soviet biological weapons facility. So the Soviets had an illegal probe. Biological war is illegal. Biological weapons are illegal, interesting, unlike nuclear weapons, which are allowed to be held by the nuclear weapon states. That's a whole other debate. Biological war has been illegal, everyone signed a treaty starting in 1972. And so the Soviets had an illegal program. We know about this from the Soviet defector scientist when the wall came down. However, the State Department maintains that the Russia still carries on an illegal biological weapons program. And so the suspicion is that many of these facilities like the anti-plague institute are currently developing biological weapons. And so I chose a facility in Siberia nearby, not exactly the same one, because that too is in known facility or rather the State Department asserts that weapon hearing is going on there. There's an interesting carve out in the treaty, Pat, that like you can do defensive research with dangerous pathogens under the premise that you're working on medical countermeasures, vaccines, therapies, antibiotics, to combat disease. And that's what makes for this incredibly fraught situation. And this is exactly what seems to have unfolded in Siberia just a couple weeks ago. Okay, so that one, the World Health Organization came out, and I think Russia said that it's been controlled. Nothing's happened yet. It's under control. Do you trust them? Are you at a point where, you know, could it still have a breakout? You know, I don't think you can, I would be pretty certain that you cannot trust Russia in any kind of statement. It's going to make about a biological catastrophe or a biological accident. Because Russia knows that the State Department asserts that it has an illegal biological weapons program. This is not, you know, there are only two confirmed or rather two nations that the State Department, current and former, believes have biological weapons program, Russia and North Korea. China and Iran have what are called programs of interest, so programs of concern, so that's a euphemism. But when you consider that out of all the nations, there's only two that the State's are saying you guys have biological weapons and we know about it. Russia is one of them. You can't, you must assume that Russia is going to work to conceal whatever it's doing in those labs. So that would be my firm position. Okay, so in the book you explain how there's an explosion, he goes to a cathedral, I don't know what the church was, and he, you know, father, I have sinned, you know, I made a mistake, you know, and from there the story begins in Siberia. But if a person, if a country's doing illegal biological testing, like let's just say we know Russia's doing and North Korea's doing that the State Department knows, if it does leak, doesn't it hurt the country the most more than any other country? So if that's the case, maybe the answer to that question a second one would be, how do they long-term think, well we're not going to be impacted by this, but we're going to release it to this country in this method. There's two questions I'm curious. Yes. I mean, the idea of blowback is what you're talking about, that a biological weapon is profoundly dangerous to the country that holds it because we're precisely talking about what if it leaks, then you have your own citizens dying. Let's go back for a second about like Cold War 101 biological warfare, which by the way did exist.
the United States used to have an arsenal of biological weapons during the Cold War, we absolutely had one. So did the Soviet Union. And the idea then was, okay, you're going to create a biological weapon. You also at the same time create a vaccine. You vaccinate your own troops. You put the biological weapon on the battlefield. They die, your troops live, okay? Nixon in the late 1960s said we're getting rid of all of our biological weapons. Why? We can get into later. It's a real big debate whether he was, you know, so then the treaty comes along in 1972 saying biological weapons are odious to the conscience of mankind, which kind of points to your position, which is why would you, the risk of harming your own country is so dire. And of course, now we know because of global globalization, because of the way people travel, the pathogen is going to spread through air travel. But back in the Cold War, think about it. Russia was kind of a hassle on a hill, right? People weren't exactly flying to Paris or London for the weekend. So their idea was we can vaccinate everybody and then we'll use it on the battlefield. You know, one of the Soviet defector scientists said this incredibly nefarious line to his CIA handler whom I interviewed, which is that the plan was to kill all the people and leave the infrastructure intact. The people at the lab? No, meaning you would use a biological weapon against America and the West. This was the Soviet idea. And they were also had plans to send biological weapons over in the war head of an ICBM. I mean, it got really involved. And the idea was to kill all the people in America, leave the infrastructure intact. So imagine a nuclear war wiping out everything, you know, even then you've got like radioactive waste and it can't really be, there's nothing that can be done with that territory. Biological weapons, you'd kill all the people, you'd leave everything there and then you'd kind of march in and take over. That was an actual quote from one of the Soviet defector scientists. Do you think that mindset still exists today or today it's a little bit tougher to do? I mean, look, biological weapons to me seem in such a category of sort of outrageousness that I can't imagine working on these pathogens for precisely the reason of what happened in Russia. Now, Russia had, I mean, the story that you just told is precisely what happened in October. There was an accident. And then we know from local reporting that the FSB, which is Russia's federal law enforcement agency, varied draconian measures, steps in, quarantines 200 people. So they were aware, my read, they were completely aware of what happened, whether or not that story with the one worker is actually the real story. Perhaps there was someone before her. But in any case, that was shut down because of the way in which Russia can essentially act very much like the totalitarian government that it once was. Those situations are still in place and I think we saw that in, in Siberia. Which is more likely to happen, biological war and nuclear war. I wish it was only my opinion, but I'm going to quote the Pentagon's opinion here. So there was a threat spectrum I found, which is an unclassified document, weapons of mass destruction on a scale. What, of course, nuclear weapons sit at the very far end of the spectrum, the most dangerous meaning the most destructive, but close second were biological weapons. And even more disconcerting was this line that said they present the greatest overall threat. And that is because they are more likely to be used, an accident or an incident, not just a biological attack, puts them in their own category of serious destruction. I guess also tougher to detect where it comes from, right? But there's a mindset of, you know, well, nuclear war, what's the likelihood of it happening? If you destroy the other country, you're losing customers, you're losing people you don't business with, you're losing, and then there's the element of retaliation. So I won't do it if you don't do it, right? So the first party is the first domino, so they don't want to do it because they know what could happen on the, give the counter argument to that to say, no, that's the wrong way of thinking because somebody would have a different motive to want to destroy a country like America. What would that be? With biological weapons? Specifically nuclear first and an awful biological. I mean, you've hit upon like the central organizing concept of nuclear weapons, which is deterrence. And yes, for 80 years now, there's been no nuclear use. That's because of deterrence. This idea of, like, no one would be crazy enough to use a nuclear weapon because inside of all the war gaming, so maybe this isn't known to the average citizen, but the Pentagon, and certainly the Russian counterpart knows, when nuclear war begins, it doesn't end until complete annihilation, until essentially nuclear armageddon. And that is because nuclear is set up to only send the mother load, like they all go, that's the way it works. Biological war is its own sort of darkhearted animal because there is no concept of deterrence. You can't say, well, we have biological weapons, but we won't use them if you won't use them because we would all die because biological weapons are illegal, so technically you're not supposed to have them, but they do exist. And I think anything that begins with that kind of like false premise gives way to a lot of problems, certainly starting with the fact that an accident or a lab leak could happen and all hell could break loose. How much have we got, we just had COVID a few years ago. It's not like it was a long time ago, right? From the people that you speak to and the research that you do, how much have we improved in our defense that we have against a biological war that could happen? Have we gotten better? Have we gotten smarter? Are we at least unified both Republicans and Democrats to see on this one issue? Let's work together. This is perhaps the most important question to all of us. And probably what I would hope would be the greatest takeaway from the book that when you read it, you realize the level of disaster involved. You realize the level of what is called near existential threat. And then you say, well, what are we going to do about all of this? And then you have to come to the realization because I take readers through the different organizations that are involved in what is called pandemic preparedness. So this is not just a military situation, what you're talking about. Like in the event of the release of a pathogen in society by accident or on purpose, who steps in? Who steps in? It's not the Pentagon. It's a series of bureaucratic institutions inside the United States starting with HHS, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, which CDC is below. NIH is nearby. You've got Asper, I mean, your head's already spinning with like bureaucracy. Who's in charge? Who's on first? Who's right? And this is what we saw in COVID that you kind of remember. And then on the other hand, you have the Department of Homeland Security, who's in charge of protecting the homeland, FEMA's underneath the Department of Homeland Security. And they all begin to buy or jockey for position in their lane of what they are to do. And what you end up seeing is this kind of bureaucratic sort of nightmare of what I found to be because I interviewed subject matter experts and presidential advisors in all of these lanes, like very well-intentioned people, completely realizing that they have almost no power to mitigate the threat. That's how it's spoken of in sort of government terms. Like how do you mitigate the threat? How do you stop the spread? And we know from COVID that that is incredibly tricky. COVID had a 1% case fatality rate. It's really important to consider that when you're talking about biological weapons, which could be leaked, for example, the case fatality rate is you can't take out a country with a 1% case fatality rate. Numeric plague, which I choose as the pathogen in the book, as a case fatality rate of 100%. Stop it. Percent. 100%. 100%. So there are medical countermeasures, antibiotics. But if you don't have antibiotics within 24 hours, so I'm talking one day, you can't like go home and be like, let me see how I feel in the morning. You have
have to get antibiotics into your system within 24 hours? - What kind of antibiotics? - Or your dead. - Doxocycline, all the major. - Okay, so the main ones that we have. - Yeah. - So let me ask you a question. - Yes. - Do you, yourself, are you that concerned your stuff that you have that type of antibiotics at home in case something were to happen? - Okay, so before I answer that, let me tell you, you know, the reality of the biological weapon world, three points. Case fatality rate I'm talking about is the virulence of a pathogen. And when I say pathogen, I say that specifically 'cause a pathogen is a virus or a bacteria. Everyone thinks virus, virus, virus, because that was COVID. Neumonic plague, plague is bacteria. Bacteria is killed with antibiotics, okay? So we all, in our modern world, we think, I get a staff infection, I get a strep throat. Antibiotics will take it away. The viruses need to have a vaccine. Following, so it's a pathogen, okay. Virulence, how quickly, what high of a death rate it has? Transmissibility? - Transmissibility to another person. - Yes, airborne is the top transmissibility. Coffing and spit, different level. Touch, totally different level, okay? Then you have medical countermeasures, vaccines and antibiotics. Can I defeat this pathogen if it gets into my body, okay? Virulence, transmissibility, medical countermeasures. That's it. To have a biological weapon, you're gonna hit all three of those points. It's pretty much gotta be airborne. - Okay. - It's pretty much gotta have a super high case of fatality rate, not 1% like COVID. Now, if you can defeat medical countermeasures, now you have a nightmare scenario. Now you have a biological weapon. And this is why I've been talking to you about the Soviet biological weapons program. Because all things in this book, I tie to science fact, not science fiction. And when the Soviets were engineering their pathogens, this is in the 1980s, so think about 40 years ago. How far behind science was from where it is now? 40 years ago, the Soviet scientists, and we know this because they defected to the United States and told us, they were developing a super plague weapon that could defeat antibiotics. So there you have your ultimate biological weapon, pneumonic plague, pneumonia. It's not bubonic plague, which is your Bubos swell up from a flea bite. pneumonic, it's in the lungs. It's transmissible because it can be airborne. It has 100% case fatality rate if you can't take antibiotics. And that is what they were working on 40 years ago. And that's why that is called a tier one select agent in the biological weapons fear list that the CDC owns and the Pentagon works with. And that's why I chose that weapon. Okay, so let's go back to it. A lot of time when you talk to military guys or preppers, they have food, they have a lot of stuff that they're ready in case something happens, right? You talk to guys in finance, they'll have life insurance, they'll have things in place because they understand, hey, they understand money. Are you prepping yourself? Are you somebody that, if somebody in your home, you have enough of this stuff in place to say, if something were to happen, the Jacobson family is protected. I mean, that's your question about antibiotics for starters. Okay, so you have some antibiotics, let's just say. But then you have to really think about all of the other factors that are involved there. Okay, which is why before we go down this dark rabbit hole, which I'm happy to, this is why you really, like the point of this book is not like panic and prepping. Although, you know, you can do that. Would you say you're one? A prepper? I love doing those podcasts for the preppers. I think that's really interesting. Are you one yourself? Well, you have to define prepper, right? So like, do you have the antibiotics that in case something would happen? You have that. So I happen to have taken a trip to Africa and I have them left over antibiotics, yes. Okay, but is that intentional? Are you worried about it? Or is it just kind of like it's left over and it's not really, if I didn't have it, I wouldn't go get more of it. What's your position on that? My position on that is, first of all, you want to be, look, people ask me this a lot, like actually kind of like, can I have like 10 minute consultation with you? And my number one concept here is fully self-supporting. Like you have to be, you have to take care of yourself and your family, you have to have a plan. And this is, look, you and I both, you grew up in Glendale. Earthquake preparedness. You have a go-bag in the car, you have water. You have these things because you need to be supporting. You need to be self-supporting. Have some, you know, gas in the tank. Well, you don't look worried about it, though. That's why I'm asking a question. Are you worried about a biological war or a nuclear war yourself? What I, look, I mean, people often say to me, like you're such an optimistic person. That's what I'm saying. Your personality is like, you're not giving me, I've had a guy on who is worried about AI, war and how we're going to come to the end that, you know, it's going to put us out, it's going to be a Roman, a Roman Yompovsky, right? And he sounds like a pessimist. You don't give me the vibes of a pessimist. You give me the vibes of an optimist. I'm a super optimist, absolutely. Because I really believe, look, this is a phrase I've said before and I'll say it again, okay? You can't fix what you can't face. But you can fix what you're willing to face. It's true in our own personal lives. How could it not be true in society? That's why I'm an optimist. So I really believe information. It's both king and queen. The more you know, the more you know. And so you can also, if you're a pessimist, you can also pivot your idea to be an optimist. It might take a little bit of extra work, but you don't have to be pessimistic. But you can't be naive. That's the position. I believe in the position of Andy Groves only the paranoid survive. I think we have to be paranoid, educated to make sure we're protected. So do you think America learned enough from the 2020 COVID that happened where we are prepared for the next big one, especially if some like this were to happen? Do you think we're ready for something this massive tier one that you were talking about? Absolutely not. But I want to push back for a second on what you said about paranoid. Only the parent, you know, I write about paranoia in the book. And you can think of paranoia here and trust here. I'm going to always try to push my thinking toward trust. It's the old trust, then Vera. But I think paranoia is incredibly dangerous. And I actually, whenever I think of the word paranoia, given that I'm also a historian in essence, my first six books were history books about the Pentagon, the CIA. My most recent two books are scenarios of what could happen in the future. But the history of our enemies, let's say the Soviet Union, it's so ingrained in paranoia. And these totalitarian governments-- so I really see communism as always sort of veering toward totalitarianism. And that might just be a product of my age. But I find paranoia incredibly dangerous. And I, in my historical research, have seen it time and time again as a tool of a repressive government. To make people paranoid essentially is a way to make you lose trust. And it's interesting that you bring that word up because that's a central theme in this book, at which I actually believe that governments like Russia and China use in a sort of weaponized way against an open society like America. And we are seeing that all over the place, which kind of leads to your second question about whether or not were prepared for a pandemic. And the answer is no. And it's probably why I would hope people would read this book because they can see what's going on. In terms of you have to be aware of what's possible. But if you fall into a paranoid camp, and if you fall for the sort of weaponization of mistrust, what starts with mistrust leads to paranoia. Now you're talking about why I think the sort of tribal nature of America right now is extremely dangerous. And it was exacerbated in COVID. It was exacerbated. COVID forced people or rather made people think they could be forced into different camps. And I find that incredibly dangerous. And I think this is a long-winded way of saying, if we want to be prepared for a future situation, we have to be more willing to hold multiple ideas, including those we disagree with. I think that's fine, but for me to have the whole reason why people read your book is probably because they're paranoid.
because I think, oh, sure, get me, I would say, the ideal reader of your content is the paranoid reader. Is the person, oh, 100%, by the way, the audience can trash me and say disagree or agree. But I think somebody who, the reason why you're fascinating is a lot of things have happened recently that people don't trust government's response to it. And so what are we going to do with something really big happens? Do we, why is CIA's trust at an all-time low? Why is FBI's trust at an all-time low? Why is the US government's trust at an all-time low? Why is the mainstream media's trust at an all-time low? Why? There's a reason for it. That didn't happen accidentally. Yeah. What do you think the reason is? I think you're trying to force me to a position that I have to believe what you think is the way of thinking and trust us and trust us. I don't want to trust you. I don't want to trust that, even the people I vote for, I'm skeptical about because I know man at the end of the day is sinners. So you're going to have individual motives and you have your motives. I have my own motives. Your motives are you want to sell, book and educate people. My motive is to have a good conversation so the audience likes and shares it with others and grows the audience's motive is, "Hey, I want to get being retained and I want to get a perspective that I haven't had before." I think sometimes the government try to play with, "No, this is the right way and trust us and trust us." No way. That's definitely CIA talk when somebody says stuff like that to the people and they don't like that. I think just a couple of mishaps, a couple of mishaps, mishandling where you trust and you're like, "Yeah, I don't know if you have the best interests of people in mind." I think it's more individual motives that's there. So, thankfully, the Constitution is strong and thankfully Supreme Court is there. But for me, the reason why you're fascinating is because I'm a little bit paranoid. That's it. Okay. So I suppose it's how you, the lens through which you see the world because I have so many people come to my book signings and they're all across the country, you know, red states, blue states, big cities, small towns and they're like, "I feel so much more relaxed having read your book." Literally. Now, maybe that's what I want to hear. But it goes back to, "Oh, now I understand the way in which certain things work." And hopefully I've given it to them in a manner that they're like, you know, people say about my books, "Oh, my God, I stayed up all night reading it." Do you think people who read your book trust the government more? That's a really good question. I don't think they do. But you see, I would look at it differently. I mean, I don't even know what trust the government really means. Like, am I, am I on a sort of lifelong journey to understand the way in which governments have worked since the modern era and I'm talking about since World War II because that's my focus, which I study through the lens of the military and the intelligence community and you could say the military industrial complex. Absolutely. Like, that to me is, I look at things across history and I try and, when certain situations arise today, I'm like, "Oh, what does that remind me of?" And then I look, I have enough history in my brain to know about it. But I don't, like, the government is there to do its job. The government is there to function. What I'm really interested in is government collapse. That is fascinating to me because that's kind of like the far end game of what you see all of these individuals and government actually trying to prevent from happen. And that's like pulling back the veil on that has kind of been in the past, you know, in these two most recent books. That is incredibly interesting. But I do differ from a lot of people because I don't see the government. I don't see the CIA or the pen. I don't see anyone like that as the bad guy. I don't see that at all. What I see is a group of, like, any organization, individuals, some of whom are like incredibly sharp, incredibly hardworking, incredibly dedicated and some of whom are phoning in their job. But like, that's like any, any of it. But that's different. I think it's good to be skeptical. I think it's good to hold our officials' feet to the fire and hold them to what promises they made. And not everyone's going to have 100 percent, you know, delivery ratio. Nobody is. But, you know, if somebody's at 70 percent, I think you're doing well. And most of them fail at 70 percent. They get up and they make all these promises and they fall at 30, 40 percent. Now, maybe some of it is because of bureaucracy that we don't see behind closed doors how complicated it is. But on this topic, biological war, how many places in the world currently have the capability of actually having 100 percent, you know, death rate that you're talking about? Yes. Great question. Okay. Let's start with the labs, right? So, BSL bio safety level three and four are really the labs of concern. Four, BSL four lab has pathogens from which there is no cure, Ebola, NIPA, viruses that you have to work in the highest level of PPE. Like you've seen the spacesuits. You have a rebreather. And there are 110 of them around the world. 110. Interestingly, the reason that we know about this number is from academic researchers, not from like some government organization. Right below the BSL four, there is BSL three. You can work in with plague and thracks, pathogens that are extremely dangerous, but there are technically a medical countermeasure for it. But as I show in the book, if you're bio weapons engineering or if you're doing gain a function researcher, you're doing something to tweak a pathogen with genetic engineering that allows it to defeat a medical countermeasure. And by the way, scientists do this to kind of try and find cures to pathogens. This is the, this is the inherent problem. There are 3,500 BSL three labs around the world. 3,500. Why though? I looked at the report with the 110. US leads it with 17, UK is 13, and it's Germany, Australia, Russia, China. But then I asked the question of how many BSL three BSL four labs that we have worldwide in 2000 was only 13. So in 25, 26 years, we went from 13 to 110. What are people worried about? Well, this is the build up. So remember 9/11, and you remember a week or two after 9/11, there were the anthrax attacks. So the government at the time, Dick Cheney in particular, developed what I would call a paranoia about biological weapons. And there began this extraordinary build up of what you could see as the biological military industrial complex. That is where all the labs, the number of labs exploded in the United States. And this extraordinary amount of money came into the system. Most of it sort of classified or at least secret or at least out of the public view. And this build up began to happen. I write about it very quickly in the book because I want to take the reader through the scenario so you don't fall asleep. But I give you the short summary of precisely what happened. Nations abroad say, well, this is what the United States is doing. We better do it, too. And so that began this extraordinary build up of labs. And there is no way of knowing what is going on inside of those labs. There is no--that biological weapons convention treaty I referred to from 1972. There's no enforcement protocol. There's no verification mechanism. So what goes on in there is up for grabs. I'm going to give you an interesting detail that I learned just the other day, actually, after I wrote the book from a sort of biosafety expert named Drew Endy. He told me this fascinating detail. So COVID happens. And within two weeks or so, the Chinese government releases the genetic code. And the genetic code is very different than releasing an actual pathogen sample. A pathogen sample would be other scientists could really look at it and examine it forensically. The genetic code is essentially like a recipe. And that's all China has ever released, which is why we can't get to the origin story. Because it's just like saying, here's--oh, here's the blueprint. This is what we say it is. But this is more interesting to me what Drew Endy said is that scientists in Switzerland in Byrne created in one of their labs--I believe it was a BSL3 lab--COVID. Two weeks after COVID started, they actually created the virus from scratch. This is called synthetic biology. They created it. [BLANK_AUDIO]
paper about it which published in Nature. So what a wild story. And I also find information really interesting that I could write this whole book and never learn that. You could say that's my fault, maybe it is. But then I would learn that from a biosafety expert. And no one I know, no one I have shared that with since knows that. But it speaks to a world behind the veil, behind general perception, behind even expert perception about what is going on inside labs, what can go on inside these labs. And if there's anything that I find really interesting is like the lack of information about the reality. And then you have, on the other end of things, this extraordinary fracturing of public trust over the pandemic. When in fact, to me, the situation should be like, hang on, let's really get a handle of what's going on here with these labs. And what's-- so you said, we don't know who's funding them. We don't know where the money's coming from. Well, that, I-- The BSL4s? I don't-- I think you can find the money. I don't know-- I don't believe that that's the real problem. I think the real problem is what is going on in them? What is the standard for the kind of research that can be done? In other words, that a group of scientists in the lab in Switzerland could recreate the COVID virus in January of 2020 when the entire world was focused at trying to stop COVID from spreading. It's just an extraordinary detail that demonstrates how out of control the whole biosafety world actually is. That would be my biggest point. And so these labs that we have, the BSL4s, roughly 340, 350 to 400 people work at these places. Give or take, that's the number that the unverified number at our BSL4 labs. If somebody wanted to-- I don't know where it was that I read this-- how if somebody wanted to create a bio-weapon today, the language-learning models are teaching the average person on how to produce that. So it's not like it's that complicated to do. The artificial intelligence used to design brand new viruses. Yeah, this is just a few months ago, right? And we're getting more and more of these stories. And they're trying to protect it. But some guys know how to get around that have the AI teach them how to do it. What happens if one of these guys turns negative, turns sour a Chinese nationals working at one of these BSL4 locations and says, hey, instead of having to do it over there, we build the viruses here. We're going to release it here in America and destroy within. How likely is that to happen? Well, these are scenarios that people at the Pentagon think about regularly, not even a question. I think on the other side of that, what you're really asking is like, this has gotten completely out of control. And what you are saying is AI enabled bio, which is this new realm of artificial intelligence being used in the world of biology, has raised the threat level to an extraordinary degree. In the book, I do not involve AI because I wanted to show you that mother nature pathogens created naturally, tweaked with old school genetic modifications, if you can call it that, but you must now, is enough to cause a near extinction level event. When you throw AI enabled bio in the mix, you have a completely new realm of threat, which is why you see a lot of articles about that now. No one is debating that. Even the old CEOs of the AI companies are making serious efforts to try and put guardrails up about what people can access with, like you say, a few keystrokes, because the barrier to entry is so incredibly low. I mean, think about what it takes to have a nuclear weapon. You have to have this isle material. Weapons, grade, uranium, or plutonium. Then you have to have a delivery system, an ICBM, a nuclear-powered submarine, a B2 bomber. That's like nation-state technology. But if you look over on the side of bio, you need a lab and a nefarious idea. The weapon system, if it's airborne, as we've been talking, is the human lungs. That's terrifying. So can the average person develop that? I read an article a couple years ago that if you wanted to build a nuclear bomb, if a civilian wanted to own a nuclear bomb, you could win a billion honors. I don't know if you can find this article or not. We could with a billion dollars. It's interesting. Yeah, you could build a billion honors. I don't know if it was a Forbes story. You'll find it. It's up there. We talked about it on the podcast. So nowadays, we have trillionaires. So if a trillion and wanted to build a nuclear bomb for billion honors, you can go out and build a firm. So for billion honors. Is the barrier to entry or building the types of viruses that has 100% kill rate? That easy? That the average person of maybe four smart kids together could build it? Or no. Still, it's more complicated than that. So the nuclear issue, I think what's interesting to think about is the systems in place to keep nuclear from happening. So for the book, for both books, I interview CIA officers retired who work in counter WMD. So they dedicate their lives, their careers, to going after anyone who is building, potentially trying to build a nuclear weapon, or selling nuclear secrets to another nation. And these are like-- there's like long-term efforts. There are short-term efforts and everything in between. Teams of people working on this. This has been going on for decades. Bio is very, very different, starting with the fact that pathogens are so tiny and they're invisible. And so the whole idea of a low barrier to entry is-- it just simply exists whether you put AI-enabled bio in it or not, surely with AI-enabled bio. It's been easier to shrink the research and development time that it would take to those three things we talked about, virulence, transmissibility, and defeating medical countermeasures. AI shortens the window on some of that research because very few pathogens have the 100% case fatality rate. So could a group of kids, without a BSL-4 lab, get together, they hate America, they hate a country, and them collectively build it, or does it take a certain level of intelligence and access to resources that's so rich and expensive that they can't get? Handcrafted across five Italian factories with build or technology and her foot, it may be the most comfortable shoe you will ever own. Introducing the all-new FLB shoe, finished a new chocolate curates a leather, made to move, built to endure, designed to impress. I mean, if anyone who answers that question, yes, is accused of being a doomsday forecaster. Anyone who answers that question, no, is being overly cautious and naive. So what does that even really mean, what I just said? What it means is that there are serious concerns in the intelligence community, in defense, to look at this. But one of the things I write in the acknowledgement of the book is the point is not panic. Or paranoia, it's pressure. So you have to come to this conclusion, I think, or perhaps you don't have to, but the wisest conclusion is this has to be a diplomatic effort. There has to be a movement among diplomats in the different nation states that have biological labs and that are perhaps running biological weapons programs to have that moment in time where they say, you know what we need to redo that BWC treaty? And have systems in place where we can look at each other's labs and have verification efforts. Let me give you an example. So I begin the book with this accident at the BSL-4 lab in Siberia called Vector. And the reason I do that, like all of this major plot points, if you will, in the book, is I tie them to actual events. Readers can go into the index and look at the notes if they ever say, wait a minute, I'm not sure this could ever happen. And they can see a historical document or a monograph or a report that
that kind of clarifies what I'm talking about. So this accident at Vector sets off the action in the book. Well, in 2019, there was an actual explosion at the Vector Lab in Siberia. All eyes in the scientific community are on this. I mean, this is a very big deal. Imagine an explosion at Fort Dietrich, which is our BSL4 lab in Maryland, right? And what I learned from presidential advisors, subject matter experts, was that in 2019, one of the first things that happened was Moscow says, "Oh, you know, it happened in the janitors' closet," type of metaphor, right? There's nothing dangerous escaped. It was in a building that didn't have the dangerous pathogens that we work on for medical countermeasures. But not only that, I learned from people on the National Security Council, for example, there were relationships between US scientists and Russian scientists in 2019 that allowed those individuals to pick up the phone and say, "Hey, you know, what's really going on there at Vector with that explosion?" And there were reassurances at that level of scientists to scientists, meaning the people. So that's incredibly important because you have government working on one level and, you know, public statements and press releases. And then you have scientists who work together to make sure that we don't actually have, that an outbreak doesn't become an epidemic, doesn't become a pandemic. Well, that is now gone, meaning Russia's war in Ukraine has created this complete skism between any communication that existed in 2019, certainly at the Vector Lab. And that is so incredibly dangerous. Imagine if, for example, what happened in Siberia. People I've spoken to since at the State Department at Fort Detrick, there's no comms anymore to those scientists. No one could really say, "Hey, what actually happened there?" Even if it was kept on the low down. Do you think evil exists? Absolutely. So, then if evil exists and today's access to being able to build a pathogen like this, which by the way, there's a few stories that we just looked at. One of them is explosions and firebreak at a Russian lab. Another one was how. There you go. That's the one I'm talking about in 2019. Yes, but the other one was for the China one, the Chinese National's accused of smuggling dangerous biological pathogen into the U.S. that was a year ago, right? Then you're seeing Asian citrus, silent, how it spreads citrus, green, disease. There's so many little drones you can make to go out there, right? So, but if evil exists, do you think the most. If I were to ask you, "What is the most evil person in the world that has made the biggest devastating event in the world? History wise? So, would you put there?" Yeah. Mao is coming to mind. Mao? Yeah, just because I've also been thinking about this idea of like narrative, you know, like you and I were talking before the show that were both in the business of narrative, like telling stories, talking, communicating, people listening. And I always think about Mao's 1958 effort called the Great Leap Forward, where he was trying to turn the nation from agrarian-based into an industrialized nation. And he came up with this crazy plan. I wrote about this in one of my other books, whereby he wanted. He decided. One of his science advisors, who was deeply uneducated, told him that the reason that crops were failing was because sparrows, the birds, were eating the seeds. And so, literally, well-documented in history, he starts this campaign and gets millions and millions of Chinese people to kill sparrows. They are literally going around killing sparrows with slingshots, scaring them out of trees, tearing down sparrowness. I mean, what I'm saying sounds like some kind of a, you know, of a made-up story. But it's actually what happened. Two billion sparrows died. And of course, it led to absolute famine because of the destruction of the ecosystem. And something like two to ten million Chinese people died because of it. The point of all that is that the government could tell this story to the people in a totalitarian situation. And people followed orders. That to me is a deep form of evil because it's using power and persuasion over the public to where people literally no longer think for themselves. Someone who loves to, someone such as myself that's like very curious and loves to learn about things and talk about things and even have arguments with people or discussions with people who don't see things the way I do. That's the most frightening form of evil is that you could just simply follow the party line. Since 1970, to today, post Hitler, post Mao, post all these guys, right? Let's say last 50 years, who do you think has been the most evil person? And there's a reason why I'm asking this question. What do you think has been the most evil person? I want you to also think about it. Yeah. What do you think has been the most evil person in the last 50 years? You have to tell me. I can't. Can you think of someone? Yeah. It's a good point. And do you know? But by the way, this was a planned question for me to ask you. This is prompted from the conversation. What are you talking? Do you think? Do you think there's a reason why we haven't had that level of evil the last 50 years? That's a great question. I mean, I actually have not thought about that. I'm curious. What do you think? I'm wondering if we either have better defensive protocols for it or two, the level of consequences for evil today is worse. Three, we just haven't had a tier one evil person yet. That's, you know, also has the intellect, the intelligence and proper pain of someone defending them, a mother, a father, a spouse, a sibling, somebody that really, really hurt this person for them to think about true vengeance, because access to wanting to devastate the world is so available to you today. It's not that hard for you to want to destroy one of the things that was asking you, telling me about the billionaire stuff. In 2024, two years ago, a story came out, you know, right, there could have broke billion and make a nuclear weapon. You know what it said? Would a billion dollars and five years, a billionaire could have a nuclear weapon. So maybe we're out of business with evil, which I don't think we are. I don't know, because it's easier today to want to, you know, to be able to hurt the country if not the world. Yeah. Well, you know, what you're talking about is like global existential risk, right? That is what we're talking about. I'm not talking about. Yes. That's like so, I'm talking about existential threat and type of person. Yes. And that precisely is what I'm writing about, and it's interesting because the, you know, we are at an inflection point. You hear that. It's a very zyke, ICT term, and people talk about it because of AI. But when you're looking at weapons of mass destruction, they literally are exactly like they sound. Like the U.M.D., and what is interesting to me on your concept of evil is this build up began in 1947, like really the idea of weapons of mass destruction did not exist in the same way until the development of the atomic bomb. And the idea was we have to counter evil. We had, you know, Soviet Russia, that is why so many of these systems were set up in the national security apparatus, the CIA, the CIA's paramilitary. All of this was because the Soviet Union is so dark and so evil. This is what we must do. We must meet them at their level. And so that's the legacy. This evil would evil, like capabilities, if you go there, we're going to go there as well. Yes, in essence, I mean, obviously the National Security Act doesn't use the word evil. But for example, and I know quite a bit about the CIA's paramilitary organization having written about it and interviewing, you know, countless subject matter experts and actual operators there, going back to when, you know, assassination was legal. So we set up this as the president's guerrilla warfare corps, that's actually what it was called. Specifically to counter Russia's program. So if you really drill down on these programs, you see in the early days of the Cold War the 1950s pretty much, we were setting up things against the Soviet Union. And then China comes into the mix. But I agree with you that the world has completely shifted. there's this idea of the interconnectedness of things.
And so, you know, we, and now here we are with technology having accelerated to such a degree. It's in all of our lives and everything we do. And I feel like you have these lingering sort of legacy weapon systems, the weapons of mass destruction that have gone from being protective. That was the perception there, like you spoke of with deterrence. They're there in case we need them against this terrible threat, to now being more dangerous in their very existence than they offer safety and security. That's like the fundamental core realization I have come to in reporting all of these books. And so then, if we had more evil back in the days, maybe we're overdue for an evil person to come out, maybe, and I know this sounds bad for me to say this, I don't mean to say it in a, oh my God, what I'm saying is like, you know how they say in sports, like a Michael Jordan shows up once he, they say things like once in a generation, type of an athlete, they'll say, so once in a generation, type of an actor, once in a generation, type of a writer, maybe this is like a once in a generation, type of evil that we haven't seen. Some people may say, gee, China knew what they were doing with COVID, they were not happy with Trump. They allowed that virus to leak because it was going to stop the entire world and he was going to blame Trump on it and Trump was not going to get reelected and his aspirations of wanting to attack Taiwan would have been easier because he can do it under Joe Biden more than he could do it under Trump. Maybe that's the most evil thing because still the tribunal court hasn't held them accountable, even with all the trillions of dollars I was lost. Maybe that's the most evil last 50 years, I don't know. So I'll give you a U-turn here with Kim Jong Il, North Korea because the world is so, there's such interchange between different nations and the exception is North Korea. The idea of this isolated country, Kim Jong Un, sorry, Kim Jong Un, my mistake. No, he went to the wrong one. No, in nuclear war, I use, as the inciting incident, it's a bolt out of the blue attack with a one megaton thermonuclear weapon from North Korea to Washington, DC. And I chose that as the inciting incident very specifically because out of all the subject matter experts I interviewed, the United States scientist who actually drew the plans for the world's first thermonuclear bomb, Richard Garwin, was in his 90s when I was writing the book and I interviewed him at length. And he told me, I'm getting to your evil idea here, so stay with me. He told me, I said, what scares you most, how could a nuclear war actually begin? And he said, what scared him was a madman with a nuclear arsenal. And I took that to mean North Korea. And I said to him, but under what conditions would someone use that? And he said, and he actually quoted the French phrase, aprimois la délige. The fact that you remember that is impressive. After me, the flood, okay, meaning like, if I die, what do I care? That's how I would define evil, perhaps. And particularly if you are in charge of an arsenal of weapons of mass destruction. And you simply don't care what happens. That's evil, not in a sort of twirling mustache bad guy way. But in sort of a passive narcissistic way. And so I think that's what frightens me most about North Korea. And that's that you have, again, that goes back to this concept that I think about a lot of a totalitarian government, where a leader, I mean, he is literally the supreme leader, dear leader. This idea that you could all, that an entire society would follow along the ideas of the idea or ideas of one person is really something to think about. The counterbalance to that, hence my optimism is information. The more you know, the more you can see, aha, that's what that is. And probably another reason why I'm a very optimistic person is because I do not get involved in politics whatsoever. Here I am having written eight books on national security, and you don't know what my politics are. And no one knows what my politics are. Because the information is too important and valuable to somebody like me, to get involved in that kind of division. And that's where we are right now. Divided. Yeah. I don't know if I'm interested in your politics. I kind of prefer the way it is to be honest with you like the relationship with someone like we need a you that just writes and hears the information to whatever you want to do with it. Make your own conclusion. Um, but it's a self-fulfilling prophecy because I can hold all these different ideas. When's your birthday? What month's your birthday? June. June 28. June 28. Yeah. My daughter's birthday, 26th, we got married on. So you would be, you would be a what? What is it? Yeah. Not a Gemini, right? What's June 29? The crap. The crap. Got it. Yeah. Interesting. Interesting. Okay. So one of the A.I. says the most evil person is Paul Pot and a lot of people, you know, killed Paul. 72 million people. We killed people that were in glasses. Kind of because they would be identified as Western intellectuals. So maybe him. Yeah. The other person that said is Saddam Hussein, Osama bin Laden, Kim Jong Il, the father. Radco Maladic, and then it's got a few other names. But a tier one, tier one, we haven't had a tier one, you know, and I wonder if a part of it is because the amount of controls we have in place, because what is the ultimate sacrifice? What is the ultimate pain that a person is willing, like are people afraid of death at that level? Probably not. Right? If you are a tier one, you're not afraid of dying. You're thinking legacy protecting Paul's all of that. I wonder because of nuclear weapons that we have all around the world, those people don't want to do anything about it. And maybe the market doesn't allow for somebody like that to become a world leader. I don't know. I don't know if that's the case. But, you know, on the biological warfare side, you know, one thing I've taken so far and I want you to push back on this is I'm not convinced America's ready for the next one if it hits us. That's what's important. I don't think we're ready for it. I absolutely believe that to be true and also because if people have such strong ideas, look, the origin story of something, of anything, of any event is profoundly important for what you're talking about. If you want to know where you're headed, you have to know where you came from and the fact that no one is willing to prosecute, if you will, or examine the true origin of that, of the pandemic, how it went from outbreak to epidemic to pandemic needs to be known. And you know, it starts with China not giving the information. Why aren't we, why aren't we investigating that? Why aren't we pursuing that? Is that politics? It is politics, most certainly because anyone who, there seems to be people that have almost everyone has a horse in the race on that issue. You know, I had an interesting conversation recently with an executive from a pharmaceutical company. The States? Yes. And the organization that he works for, you know, makes incredible vaccines. And he did not want to have any kind of open mind toward a possible lab accident. And I understand why from his perspective, because from a scientific perspective, he perceives, this is my interpretation, that COVID and vaccines suddenly became merged. So you kind of had this opinion and then you had that opinion. Because these are actually completely different issues, like you have labs. You have vaccine efficacy. And then you have, you know, social, sort of cultural movements inside the United States that feel differently about the heavy arm of government. And those are all three very important discussions in a democracy. And they should, I think, be seen in different lands and it would be very helpful to see them. Did you see the story recently? Just came out, I think, yesterday, Pentagon, preparing for 90 days without great electricity, no Wi-Fi, no external power, and, you know, Trump has said about a month ago that right after the midterms.
He's planning on attacking Iran allegedly possibly who knows because of what's going on still upending issues not like that's finalized. Do you read into it? Do you think there's something there? Do you think it's a nothing burger? Well, I'm very interested in narrative and messaging and that is a serious message coupled with the fact that the UK put out a statement to all of its citizens to stockpile water and tinned goods and then so did Japan just yesterday. And so if you look at Japan is certainly an earthquake situation and that's the way we think of preparedness and safety in Los Angeles that we were talking about before the show that you have to go back, you have water, you have food, that's kind of preparedness that I think any family, any individual should think about just as being self-supporting. But these messages coupled together definitely give a greater message and that's what I'm very curious about. So do you think there's something there because Trump said he would use the mother of all bombs on Iran and that Trump will talk like that. He will talk shit to the enemy and just kind of try to get them to react to have a negotiation. Do you think there is something there that something could happen now in the next 90 days because even if you look at what UK said, UK came out yesterday, is it yesterday, Tuesday, today, UK households urge to prepare for emergencies and attacks, here's what to buy. What is UK worried about, UK is an island, you know, it's an interesting time where right before pandemic happens, nobody thinks a pandemic is going to happen. Right before war is going to happen, nobody thinks, I left any run. Right before we got bombed for the first time, no one ever thought we're going to get bombed and Saddam Hussein is attacking Iran and Tavadjo, Tavadjo, Al-Amateq, Ermez, the ret signal means that a plane has crossed the border. You don't think about that stuff like that as a kid, you're like, oh my god, what's happening that? We're getting bombed. We're going to go to a city called Rashed. Then we're going to go to a city called Karaj. Then we're going to escape to a city called Mom, Dad, what is taking place? So zero to war when you're in that mode. Do you think something's happening that the government's preparing for? My thought on that is when I was researching nuclear war, the New York City government put out a statement about how to prepare for a nuclear attack. Not kidding, it was like a PSA, a public service announcement, a video. I mean, besides the fact that it was like full of misinformation, I don't think on purpose, but just because of naivete or misinformation. So I think governments do put messaging out all the time. What I find bizarre is these three situations coming on heels of one another. But I'm probably not the person to read into it because I think that's kind of speculating in an area where it's just my opinion. And I try to show in my books, which some people perceive as incredibly terrifying. Just know this is what would happen in a Pentagon war gaming type situation, if not when. Okay, so let's talk about the history of DARPA. So are you familiar with the history of DARPA and when Facebook got started? Well, you know, I wrote a book on DARPA called the Pentagon's Brain, but I know a bit about DARPA. Yes, yes. Yes. So the timing of it's kind of weird. The day DARPA stops, the next day Facebook starts. Well, what do you mean DARPA stops? Well, if you look at the date, go a little bit lower, go a little bit lower on the date. Keep going lower, keep going lower on the dates. Can you find the article full enough for me? DARPA didn't stop. So DARPA is still in business. The timing of a, it was, I think it's 2004. Can you pull up the story so I can just set it up before we get into it? Same day that it's either DARPA, stop a certain thing with the CIA, tie to it. I want to position this properly before you get into it because this is definitely a very interesting topic. So DARPA shut down its life log program on February 4, 2004, which was the exact same day that Zuck started the Facebook, okay? And a lot of people say, well, you know, that was trying to track what people are doing and Facebook kind of did that and a track what they were doing based on your research and study of this. Is there any correlation there? I don't know about that specifically at all, but, you know, tracking. So the concept of ISR, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance. It's a fundamental to all military operations and all intelligence community operations. So programs exist across every one of these agencies for their entire history, but I don't know anything about the Facebook mystery. So tell us about DARPA, you know, why, you know, the entire story of DARPA? How it got started on why? Well, DARPA is the most powerful, most secretive, I would say, military science agency in the world. It began in response to Sputnik. So remember 1957, the Russians launched a satellite, which is incredible to think about that like there was one satellite. Now there's like, I don't want to actually want to mess up the number because it's changing so radically, but it's just in this short span of time. And people say, well, what was so terrifying about launching a single satellite? Because the Russians beat us into space. And so no one likes to be bested, certainly not the US, but it wasn't just that. It was that to launch a satellite, you need a rocket, you need an ICBM, an intercontinental ballistic missile. And the Pentagon knew that if they can launch a satellite pretty soon, they're going to be able to launch a nuclear warhead. So that is why we created DARPA. And DARPA, if you look at the congressional record of early DARPA, it was said that the mission of DARPA, and that stands for the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, is to create vast weapon systems of the future. And that is precisely what DARPA does. Good, net positive, net negative, needed, how do you view them? Look, I have such a, I have such a historians view of all of these agencies because I absolutely believe you need a strong defense. Not even a question. Like national security is about strength. I mean, offense defense. So, you know, I show specifics about different programs that I think demonstrate how an agency can really go or I, and I'm also very interested in secrecy components because, you know, transparency is incredibly important. People need to know. And if they don't, they can become paranoid. So like, for example, one of the programs that DARPA was responsible for, that I wrote about, which was just such a horrific program, was Agent Orange, spraying chemicals over the battlefield in Vietnam, and this is an old program. But it was incredibly dark, and chemical weapons are weapons of mass destruction. And that is, in essence, what was done. It was this idea. And he might say, well, why would you, why would you spray chemical weapons over a country? Vietnam is a country of jungle. And so imagine the aerial, the bombing campaigns or aerial espionage trying to understand what's happening on the ground from a military or intelligence point of view. You can't see through a triple canopy of jungle. So the idea was, let's defoliate the jungle. And that's why they dropped the chemicals to sort of strip the trees of leaves. But what ended up happening is it poisoned an extraordinary number of people. And it created, because Agent Orange is such a horrific chemical, you know, long-lasting genetic birth defects, which I saw myself when I went to Vietnam. And I went back to Vietnam, interestingly, with Billy Waw, who was the CIA's longest-serving paramilitary operator. And we went back there to kind of trace Billy's steps. It was for a different book I was writing. But we, one of the questions I met with a number of communist officials when I was there. And the big question they always asked me was about Agent Orange. What did you witness? What did you see? Well, you can see in museums really horrific examples of, you know, fetuses that, I mean, it's a really graphic, and it's really horrific. But Agent Orange is a chemical weapon and should never have been used. Wow. And DARPA was behind it. We were behind it. It was this very cold war idea, again, you know, going back to your idea of evil.
- The soap. - Who Greenlit that project? - It was very specifically Greenlit inside DARPA. There was a guy called William Godell. He was in charge of the early program. And then it was actually such a big deal. In the National Archives, I was able to find the sort of really damning line from Walt Rostow, I think, was the National Security Advisor. JFK at the time. And he actually, like, said to the president, like, you know, this could be considered chemical weapons. And Kennedy authorized it. Because we wanted to win the war or stop the war. - Kennedy authorized. - Yes, yes, yes. But I think on balance, I try and look at these national security efforts, these war fighting scenarios that, in retrospect, there's such an extraordinarily bad and dangerous and nefarious idea. But in the moment, the idea was, we need to get out of Vietnam and this will help us and the war. So. - Yeah, that's wild. That should happen. And so, what else? What else is tied to DARPA with stories like that? You know, when you're talking about Walt Rostow and him getting the green light by President Kennedy, what are the events like that are there with DARPA that we don't know about? - I write them, I chronicle them in the book. I mean, you know, all of these different intelligence communities are intelligence agencies, military agencies are filled with sort of tales of, you know, there are many different ways to look at it. You can, there are tales of heroics and there are tales of extreme failure. And that's something that I really, you know, examine in my first six books. And it's also interesting to me the way in which they cross over one another. I'll give you an example, like nuclear weapons. You know, when I wrote nuclear war scenario, that was, yes, it's a future scenario that we hope never happens. But it was based on decades of my reporting in every one of my books. I've interviewed, let's say, 50, 75, 100 sources. So imagine all the people that have fought in every war, including World War II forward. So imagine all the different stories I learned. And often, I would say to people in many of these, whether you're talking about working on the Agent Orange program at DARPA or an assassination program for the CIA, I would say, why did you do what you did? And they would say to prevent nuclear world war III. So there's always kind of the end game that people are conditioned to think of they're preventing. And I think it's really interesting as an author to examine like how the individual person plays a role in that. And I'll give you an example, like Billy Wall, thinking of him because we went to Vietnam. One of the reasons we went back to Vietnam was because he was supposed to kill General Jop, who was the commander of the North Vietnamese army. That was Billy's job. And I write about the operation to do that and we failed and, you know, so many Americans died and we lost something like 14 aircraft. But there was also a plan that is almost completely unknown to anyone in the United States that Billy Wall was training to jump a small tactical nuclear weapon into Vietnam. And this was authorized by General West Moorland. And you can read about Jop? Yes, he was going to Halo Jop. He and a small team, the device was called the Saddam, the Special Atomic Demolition Unition. - What's the size of the small? It's like, imagine putting a small garbage can on your back. - You can see it, there it is, right? - So Billy was part of a very elite team that were training in Vietnam to jump this in. And the idea was to jump into the Ho Chi Minh Trail, which is where all the fighters were bringing weapons from the North to the South. Explode the nuclear weapon and destroy the passage of the trail. I mean, the ideas that come about from secret groups of people are remarkable. And the Pentagon had the Jason scientists do an analysis of whether or not this was a good idea because General West Moorland was really gunning to do this operation. And Billy was supposed to lead it. And the Jason scientists said, if you do that, it will open up the flood gates to nuclear use. So don't do it. And we didn't do it. But I find that really interesting because behind the scenes, you can, you know, so there's an example of restraint. I mean, obviously, restraint was not used in the chemical, the use of agent orange in Vietnam. But restraint was the option when it came to nuclear use. And so that is what I've spent so much of my career doing is looking at the way in which these operations unfold and who makes the decision and why. And it helps me to have a bigger perspective on, you know, DARPA is bad, the CIA is bad, versus this is what they were doing in the time that they were doing it. - Did you ever meet with Peter Pry? Did you ever sneak with Peter Pry? - Agency, CIA. Peter Pry was the EMPX who he was, we had him on twice in a month. He was so fascinating, I asked him to come back. He just passed away, I think a few years ago. Yeah, four years ago. - Absolutely, he's in the nuclear book, yes. - Yeah, he's in the nuclear book, okay. Yeah, so Peter Pry, he talked about EMP's a lot. - Yes. - And he even said at one point, he says, "Look, I'm so convinced that this could happen, "that I have my own land," he had bought as a prepper, fully ready for it, in case something were to happen. What type of warfare, based on the last few wars we've seen, are we not prepared for it? We're seeing what drones are doing. What happens if the, you know, internet goes down, financial systems, you know, you talk about in six days, biological warfare, government comes in, it's chaotic, what blind spots do we have that we're not thinking about? - You've raised like a profoundly interesting question, because what happens is experts like Peter Pry are putting out this extraordinary body of information. He did so much work on EMP. And, you know, what he was really concerned about was if the grid goes down, look at this. And now you're talking about cyber attacks. And with AI enabled, cyber attacks, these are serious concerns. We're in, this brings me back to my inflection point, which is that there are so many existential threats compounding with WMD, artificial intelligence that could negatively, not just negatively impact society, that could result in absolute chaos andarchy insurrection and death. Call me a polyanna, but this is why this idea of communicating with our adversaries and enemies, why diplomacy, why treaties, why all of this is so profoundly important on counterbalance to the threats. The threats exist. Utopia is a strange concept that is not plausible, but dystopia does not have to happen. We have been able to maintain balance throughout, you know, ever since the end of World War II. And we must begin to look at maintaining balance as we move forward in the age of existential threats. But this requires human to human communication. - Yeah, so, and the human to human communication, you know they're not going to reveal all their cards. You know you're not going to do it, but you still have to do it. You still have to speak to one another, right? To make sure what is the outcome of that? What is the benefit of that? I'm with it because I'm a business guy, but what is the outcome? What is the benefit of us speaking to each other? - Well, for starters, you have to begin to unify the country, right? So I'll give you an example. For nuclear war, I was asked to come to the United Nations. And I was speaking to, you know, 180-some odd diplomats on the floor. And I condensed the book, which takes you from nuclear launch to nuclear winter in 72 minutes and ends in nuclear winter. - Five billion people. - Five billion people are dead. I was asked to condense it down to 16 minutes. And then I answered questions with a couple other panelists for two and a half hours. And afterwards, there was a small reception. And a number of the diplomats were speaking to me. And I found this profound, what they said. They said, because some of the questions were when I would explain.
something. And they would say, "Well, how do you know this?" And I would say, "Well, for example, General Keeler, who is the former commander of Stratcom, is the one who told me in a full-scale nuclear exchange between Russia and the United States that the world could end in the next couple of hours." That comes from General Keeler. There is no one more in the chain of command. It goes to President Stratcom Commander launch, okay? And one of the diplomats said to me, and I'm paraphrasing, he said, "You know, it's remarkable that you can talk to former generals at Stratcom. I talked to General. There's generals in all of my books. This is the dialogue I have." And he said to me, "We have been kind of perceiving them as the enemy. That's not as exact word. Forgive me for getting it wrong, but you get the idea." Like the bad guys, like, "Oh, the guys at the Pentagon, they're the ones in charge of the nuclear weapons. So, and this is the diplomats who are working on treaties, who are working on disarmament, who are working on reducing the insane numbers of nuclear weapons that we have." What they cannot and should not see, the military, as the adversary, that America must sort of work together. Everyone has the same interest. Strong national security is a wise position, certainly in the world in which we live. But I believe unity has to start to, we have to start moving toward unity. Maybe that's like a fantasy, but certainly not such aggressive partisanship. It's really dangerous to my eye. And then you can begin to work with your adversaries and your enemies. Yeah. By the way, who were you in high school? If we weren't high school together, 14, 15 years old, who was any at high school in high school? Funny fact about me. Yeah. I was a hockey player. Yeah, I read that. Yeah. I went to a boarding school in New Hampshire called St. Paul's, and it's where hockey was sort of discovered in America, meaning the Native American Indians taught the masters to teach the kids how to play. It goes back to the early 1800s, the foundation of the school. And so I was an athlete, and I was also really interested in learning. I've always kind of been a bit of a nerdy scholar, academic, aspirational person who wants to know about what teachers, both teachers. So you've been in, okay, so got it. So this is the world of reading knowledge. Yeah. Yeah. And then you play sports because you're going to be like fit and fully self-supporting and, you know, capable, right? And I have a Norwegian husband who is like the Norwegians are just absolutely, you know, the bomb, right? Like, you know, chop wood, carry water, and your grandmother also teaches you how to knit. That's like Norway for you. Think about the weather there. They're very self-supporting. Yes. And they have, what is it, six or seven trillion dollars of oil reserves? Yeah. It's one of the biggest oil reserves they got. And apparently they produce a pretty good soccer player as well. They do. They have incredible athletes there. You know, I mean, Norway is an example of what I also like really believe in parenting that you just want your kids to like get out and go. And you want them to be capable. And I remember my husband, Kevin, telling me like, oh, yeah, when I was a kid, we used to, you know, for PE, we would like go off the ski jump. And I remember thinking like, what does that even mean? And then we went there and he took me by the grammar school and sure enough, there's a ski jump, like a big ski jump. And, you know, they have like, you're like five or seven years old and you're going off a ski jump. That's Norway for you. PE. And they also ski to school. So I think there's something really extraordinary. If there's anything I could, I could think should help people, you know, in the United States, it would be when you talk about prepping and all that, it's just like just be capable. Be able to do any job. Going to school and skis. I remember when I first joined the US Army, people would ask me, they would say, so did you go to school on donkeys? I said, I've never seen a donkey in my life. But the impression that people had is that we went to school on donkeys. I said, how does the army and donkeys go together? I have no idea. I have no idea. And camel jockeys. I'm like, yeah, well, you know, some of it, you know, but Norway, of course, you know, this. So CIA, Lula, apparently won the presidency. And it was a very weird plus minus on how it happened. I don't know if you're following a close, you're not. It was a massive controversy that Flavio was way ahead. And then all of a sudden, somehow he asks the areas to be open in Brazil that are going to be voting for him. And even the 15 out of the 17 voting units, they're like, no, Flavio is going to win. And then he wins. Lula wins. The CIA's history of seeing countries that go fully rogue. And then, you know, our involvement to go in and take somebody out, like even the way we did it with Maduro, right? What, what, what is the, what is the process from you studying this and you haven't read this? What is the process of the government sitting there or CIA sitting there and saying, you know what? Next person, we got a target. That guy's going to ruin that country. Let's get involved before it gets bad. And let's do this. What is our history of having done that in a past? There's a long history. There is a long history of that. I'm going to give you an anecdotal piece of information because the Maduro rate, I can't really get over how that went down and I really want to know more about it. They made it look so easy. But here's a thought on that because this goes back to ISR, Intelligent Surveillance Reconnaissance. So I also write television. And I wrote the first two seasons of Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan for Amazon. And our second season, you may recall involved an attack on the Venezuelan compound, the presidential compound. And so I'm kind of the subject matter expert on the CIA in the room, the writer's room. And there was some debate, shall we say, about like writers about how this was going to go down. And I say, well, why don't we bring in some of the experts? And I bring in via Zoom some of my sources from my former books. And everybody in the writers room was shocked to learn that the CIA has and the architectural plans of pretty much every presidential compound around the world. And that gives you an idea of how ISR works. If you know the architectural plans, and I'm talking about how the buildings were built, then you have a serious understanding of how you could assault that building. Right? You know about the HVAC system. You know about entrances and exits. You know about possible tunnels. You get the idea. So you go through the architecture. Yes. Help build it. And from there, you're able to plan your task. Yes. And that's just one example of how a situation would work from bottom to top. Right? So that's what makes me think about, you know, the Maduro rate. And that's what makes me think about the CIA and how they also work in concert with the military community. That's they work together. And I think in in bio war and also a nuclear war, you see that because I take readers through different organizations their role, what they do. And I tried to do it very quickly so that people remain super interested in it. But a lot of people read my book a second time and they're like, oh, I was reading so fast. I didn't realize there's, you know, 17 or 18 intelligence agencies. And they all have a hand in things and how they hand things off to one another. So it's a big system of systems. And when it works, it works. And when it breaks down, it's disaster. Has it ever been where the CIA went rogue and did something against what the president would have done? That's an interesting question. Not that I'm aware of. Not that I'm aware of because the certainly the paramilitary organization that I'm most familiar with is taking orders from the president. It's why operations get to be considered legal. So the CIA is paramilitary. It's called paramilitary because it's not the military. The military has to adhere to a code from that 1947 national security code called title 10 laws of war. The CIA has a special carve out called title 50. And it allows them to do essentially anything that the president says they can do and he needs them to do. So I'm not sure if you went against the president wishes, you would no longer have cover of what you were doing. So I think that would be very dangerous. But I'm sure it's happened. I mean, I'm just not familiar with it. Because I'm sure some of those guys that are there for 20, 30 years, they look at the boss and they're like, you're only going to be here four years or maybe eight years. What do you know? You don't even know what we've been doing for 30 years. I almost see like there's a way of looking down at somebody that comes, especially if you didn't come from
politics. In this example, I'm using Trump, where I think I'm going to have a lot of outside of presidents. By the way, did you see the story that came out to everybody? LaMosc on Cal, should you have that to pull it up? I shared it with you guys in a morning. So apparently, they're working together right now. Let me just read it to you properly. If you want to just pull up and we can wrap up on that, I texted to you guys in a morning. So you should be able to have it. Our friends from Calxi, and I don't know if that's the one or not. You went to Calxi politics. Connor, just go to the text that I sent you. You're making it complicated. It's easy. It was just sent to you in a morning. Right here. I just found it. Right there. Okay. So new, Elon 2028 committee pushes to change the Constitution. So Musk can run for president. Can you go to the info on the top right and ask GROC right there? GROC, just on that. Yeah, there you go. Oh, you're not logged in. Calxi posts highlights a new registered Elon pack that aims to amend Article II of the U.S. Constitution to allow naturalized citizens like Musk, born in South Africa, to run for president. The unafflated committee maintains a website and memecoin promoting the effort. Interesting for that to take place. What do you think about what Elon is doing? Well, my thought on that is if Arnold Schwarzen, if it couldn't happen for Arnold Schwarzenegger, it's not going to happen for Elon Musk. I mean, you're comparing the Arnold to Elon. Well, Arnold was the governor of California. So he had a little more sort of ground movement, I think, politically. Yeah, but I think I think in this case what Elon may be looking at is that Trump became president. Trump was never a player on the inside. He was a businessman and he was a media guy who would make a lot of comments about politics. But I wonder if the folks from CIA, I wonder who, what types of leaders they want? Because they kind of know what's going on in the world. They kind of know what the issues are. They know where the bodies are buried. They've been doing this for 20, 30 years. And some of them also have probably blind spots. I wonder what type of profile of a president they would want. Would they want an insider? Would they want an outsider? I wonder sometimes. Another reason why I stay out of politics. But what I will say is that I never see the CIA as they. It's such a system of systems inside that. And there are so many different components of that organization that I don't think group think leads. I think that certain administrations push the agency in a manner that is not seen in another era. And the Bush, Cheney administration would be that perfect example. You can sort of repopulate an organization and then send it in a direction over time. But all of these agencies I see as made up of individual groups and then a cluster of them that kind of lead in terms of dynamic and direction. Do you see the CIA as a net positive to society? Like they play a positive role? I do. I do. I mean, in government, yes, because the military and the intelligence community is so, they're so entwined. But I'm also fascinated about what happens over time. And I'll just give you another anecdote. The very first book I wrote, Area 51, which is often confused with aliens. There's obviously that narrative. But it really was a CIA base where the agency developed. It's very first, very important for national security spy planes. This idea of aerial espionage didn't exist really in the way it did until the 50s. And so they built the U2 spy plane out there and then the H-12 ox cart, which was the precursor plane of the SR-71. And, you know, there was this idea of, oh, if we can see what the Soviet Union is doing by flying over them out of range of, you know, ground-fired missiles, we'll be able to know more than them and then we'll have an advantage and we don't have to have a war. And in many regards, that was very viable. We flew over the Soviet Union and showed that like they were not lining up for war as was thought. But then, of course, aerial espionage, you know, the Air Force steps in, creates the SR-71. And then suddenly you have weapons on board, you know, spy planes. And so that's to my point that these agencies work together and they have different roles, you know. And what starts out one way can often transform into something else, given the fluid nature of the world and politics and aggression. Do you see the six-generation fighter jet, the S-47, that allegedly was seen above Area 51? And I don't know if you haven't seen that yet. Did that just happen? This just happened, I think, a couple of months ago, it just happened, yeah. Did you put F-47? Yeah, right, the F-47 fighter jet that they just thought out. So, whether it's a kid or even later on, did the CIA ever approach you to try to recruit you or no? No, but so many people think, you know, they have and they do, which is, again, there are some narratives you have to stay out of and that's one of them. But I do, you know, I used to get it. Would you have liked it? Like, would you have liked? I mean, I'm a journalist, you know, I'm a storyteller, but I love my job. I love writing books. I plan on writing a lot more. Oh, I bet. You know, I love telling stories and I love, I don't, I'm one of those individuals who does not, I am not a subject matter expert in the area into which I go. And so, I think that makes, that's what makes me popular, meaning I'm kind of a re, a writer for the people because I can explain things in a really easy to understand manner. And I'm surrounded by subject matter experts. And I notice that they often, it's easy to lose the thread from like very high brow language and specificity and acronyms and, you know, that's something that I think ends up, you lose a lot of people. So I'm just, I'm just here to tell the story in the simplest way possible. When you finish the book, do you already start working on the next one or do you take like a six month break where like, let my brain kind of figure out what I'm doing next? No rest for the wearer. No, no, no, no, no, I just love it. But the decision about exactly what comes next, you know, I think the next one, I get a recommendation for you. If you did nuclear war, biological war, maybe the next one is the AI war. That's a pretty good title, right? You can have a lot. We shall see. We shall see. Yeah, I think there's going to be calcium market on them. And he, thank you so much for coming out. This was fantastic. Appreciate you for your time. Thank you, everybody. And made in Portugal, the craftsmanship is a way of life. For those who move through life differently, from some that decks to nights that never need an occasion, every detail is considered, every step effortless, crafted from fine swayed and built with builder technology designed to move with you. Because true luxury isn't about being noticed. It's about how you feel when you arrive. The FLB icon Lover, made for the life you've earned.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Biological warfare is more likely than nuclear war due to the lack of deterrence and the potential for accidents or leaks.
A single lab accident in a high-security facility, like the Vector Lab in Siberia, could trigger a global cascade leading to societal collapse within six days.
The absence of verification mechanisms in biological weapons treaties allows hidden programs, with countries like Russia and North Korea suspected of ongoing illegal activities.
Pathogens such as pneumonic plague, with 100% fatality and airborne transmissibility, represent a Tier One select agent capable of causing near-total destruction.
The rise of AI in synthetic biology has drastically reduced the barrier to developing dangerous pathogens, making the threat both more accessible and more immediate.
Government response systems are fragmented and underprepared, leading to bureaucratic chaos during crises like pandemics.
Trust in institutions has eroded, especially after events like COVID-19, which exposed gaps in coordination and transparency across agencies.
The true danger lies not in a singular madman, but in systemic failures—such as unchecked lab research, disinformation, and a lack of international oversight.
Summary:
The speaker argues that biological warfare poses a greater and more imminent threat than nuclear war, primarily due to the absence of deterrence, the high likelihood of accidental release, and the terrifying potential for rapid, uncontrolled spread. Drawing on real-world events like the 2019 explosion at Russia’s Vector Lab, the narrative outlines a plausible scenario: an accidental leak in a high-security bio-lab triggers a global crisis, leading to societal breakdown, insurrection, and the collapse of democratic institutions within six days. The story is grounded in historical facts and scientific reality, including the existence of dangerous pathogens like pneumonic plague and the use of AI to accelerate pathogen design.
Unlike nuclear weapons, which are deterred by mutual assured destruction, biological weapons lack such safeguards, making them more likely to be used or leaked. The speaker highlights systemic failures in global oversight, transparency, and national preparedness, especially in pandemic response. Trust in government institutions has plummeted, and the rise of synthetic biology has made creating deadly pathogens increasingly accessible.
While the threat may seem abstract, the speaker insists the key to survival lies not in paranoia or panic, but in greater information, cross-party cooperation, and a reformed international framework to monitor and regulate biological research. He warns that without urgent action, the world risks a catastrophic failure of governance and public trust—making the current moment a critical inflection point for global security.
FAQs
Biological warfare is considered more likely to occur than nuclear war, not because it's more destructive, but because it can result from accidents or negligence, and there's no deterrence mechanism like with nuclear weapons. The Pentagon’s threat assessment ranks biological weapons as the most probable due to their potential for widespread, untraceable spread and high lethality.
In a biological warfare scenario, the story begins with a lab leak in a BSL-4 facility in Siberia, leading to an outbreak. Within six days, the U.S. government collapses into chaos, with the Insurrection Act triggered and a 'devolution' protocol activating, where key officials retreat to underground bunkers to preserve continuity of government.
Nuclear weapons rely on deterrence—no one would use them because of the mutual annihilation they cause. Biological weapons lack this deterrence; they are illegal under international treaties, and their use could lead to catastrophic loss of life within a nation, with no guarantee of retaliation or restraint.
The U.S. State Department asserts that Russia and North Korea possess illegal biological weapons programs. While Russia’s biological labs, such as the Vector facility in Siberia, have been linked to past accidents, and China and Iran are under scrutiny, only Russia and North Korea are officially designated as having such programs.
While the technical barrier to building a pathogen like pneumonic plague is high, advances in AI and synthetic biology have made it easier to design and simulate viruses. However, creating a viable, airborne, and lethal pathogen still requires access to labs and specialized knowledge, making it unlikely for an average person to succeed without significant resources.
Governments have strengthened pandemic preparedness, but bureaucratic inefficiencies and lack of coordination between agencies like the CDC, HHS, and DHS have shown significant gaps. The response during COVID highlighted the lack of clear leadership and real-time decision-making in a crisis.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.