Know Thyself: The Base Minimum Every Investor Needs to Know
from Value Investing with Legends
1h 18m 9s
The podcast discusses the new book *Investment Wisdom*, which emerged from a personal experience where a friend faced financial uncertainty after her husband’s death and lacked clear guidance. The book, edited by Jenny Harrington and Rebecca Patterson, features 25 essays from leading investors and financial educators, each offering practical, accessible advice on core investing principles. Central to the book is the idea that effective investing begins with self-awareness—understanding one’s risk tolerance, psychological makeup, and financial goals. The authors stress simplicity, discipline, and mechanical investing (like regular, automated contributions) to avoid emotional biases and market panic. They also highlight the importance of financial literacy, advocating for mandatory financial education in schools and support for initiatives like the Council for Economic Education. A recurring theme is the danger of over-reliance on financial news and social media, with the hosts emphasizing the need for skepticism and curated, authoritative sources. The book also promotes the value of a support team—friends or advisors—to provide balance, challenge assumptions, and maintain resilience during market turbulence. Finally, it warns against hoarding cash, which erodes value due to inflation, and instead encourages active, diversified investing with a focus on long-term value. The conversation underscores that investing is not about complexity, but about clarity, discipline, and personal responsibility.
I don't have a TV in my office and that's very intentional.
I think watching too much as a professional investor like, you know, I just need to read.
Welcome to a new edition of The Valley Investing with Legends Podcast.
I'm Tano Santos, the Robert Helbron Professor of Acid Management and Finance at Columbia Vision School
and the Faculty Director at the Helbron Center. Michael Mabison, my usual panel in crime,
is not around today as he's solving the world's problems I believe in the Santa Fe Institute,
but he will be there for future episodes. In these podcasts, as all of you know,
we interview great investors and ask them about their investment philosophies, processes, ideas,
and so on. We try to understand how to be a good investor and hopefully how to perform well for
our clients and for ourselves. Hopefully, whatever we discuss in this podcast has a good impact on
your own practice and personal portfolio. And if you're listening to it, well, that means that you're
interested, but many others for whom investment is important are not interested, but it still
need to manage the financial life responsibly. If you're not interested in investment,
how should you run your investment life? What are the essential things that you need to understand
about investing and managing funds responsibly? So there's a wonderful new book on exactly this topic,
and I thought that it would make for an interesting conversation to talk about that basic knowledge
of finance we all need to have to have financially responsible lives. It helps that my guests are
dear friends and all guests of the podcast, so that's going to make for a fun and casual conversation
about this important topic. The book is Investment Wisdom, and it is a collection of really
terrific essays edited by Jenny Van Lewin Harrington and Rebecca Patterson. To talk about the book,
we have Jenny Harrington herself, previous guest of the podcast, and one of their contributors
to the volume of essays, my friend Jenny Wallace. Hello to you both. Hi, thanks for having us.
Thank you. So Jenny Harrington is the chief executive officer of Gilman Hill Asset Management,
where she's also the portfolio manager of the firm's flagship equity income strategy,
which she created herself, and we had her in the podcast to talk about her wonderful book on
dividend investing, and I hope I want to encourage you all of you to go back and listen into
that podcast. Prior to joining Gilman Hill in 2006, she was the vice president
in private wealth management at Newburger Burman, so she's ideally suited to talk about these issues
of the basic knowledge of financial concepts that we all need to have to have a reasonable financial
life. Jenny Wallace is the co-founder of Summit Street Capital Management, where she's the chief
investment officer and portfolio manager of Summit Street US Equity Value Fund. She's of course a
Columbia Business School alum, an alum of the Helbrun program, and she's a member of the advisor
board, and I've been benefiting from her advice and wisdom for now many years, Jenny, more than a
decade since you convinced me to take over this job. So thank you so much for all that you do for
the center, and for me personally, frankly, I want to talk a little bit about the book and how did it
come about? This idea of investment wisdom. So, Jenny, and I will say Jenny Harrington and Jenny
Wallace, depending on which Jenny I'm talking to, so Jenny Harrington, how did this book with Rebecca
have come about? Why don't you tell us a little bit about the genesis and the origins of this book?
So the origin was a conversation that I had with a friend of mine named Caroline. That's not her
real name. That's what I call her in the book. But a friend of mine named Caroline, who three
years ago, almost from right now at age 50, her husband died of a heart attack. And she's like us,
she's smart, she's sophisticated, she's educated, she's savvy, and she spends her life surrounded
by professional investors. She is not a professional investor, but she's in development. So she has
professional investors aplenty. And when her husband died, she realized that she didn't really know what
to do with their investments. And she called me and she said, hey, you know, this is what happened.
I don't know where to start. Where do I get started? Can you help me? And I said, oh, sure,
of course I can. But then I realized I really couldn't. And that I didn't really have one great
book to give her or one great place to send her. So I said, oh, read this book, read that book,
read these chapters, listen to this podcast, but there is no great starting place. And I was shocked
that there wasn't. And the story of Caroline, we all have that, whether it's a friend getting divorced,
someone passed away, they just inherited money, they, you know, they just realized they need to pay
attention to their 401k that they haven't been paying attention to, but all of my professional
investor friends get that same question for different reasons all the time, which is what should I
know about investing? And sometimes it's what should I know where do I start? And sometimes it's,
hey, I've got a change coming up, where should I go? So I thought, you know what I'll do? I'll ask
a lot of my smart friends to write a chapter. Rebecca and I teamed up. We reached out to 23 of our
friends. So it's 25 chapters, R2 plus our friends and said to them, please write a chapter to your
friends, your loved ones, simply about what you tell them when they ask you about investing and
help us build either build a foundation or strengthen a foundation for them. So that's the objective.
It is amazing how often that question is asked. I mean, it's a fundamental question and we're
going to go deep into some of the themes in the, in the book, Jenny Wallace. I know you're very
interested in this issue of education. So when you tell us a little bit, first of all, how do you
know each other? How do you come to know each other? I'm not responsible for introducing you to
to each other, I believe, but you know, how do you come about? Not quite, but almost. I had
cost in her at a conference. We met at a, at a FEMA conference and realized that we had an enormous
amount in common, both love learning. We both love to see what the younger generation is doing
and we're both interested in sort of how to mentor and give back. We've gotten to know each other
better as Jenny has been a part of the AVI stock pitch as one of the judges on the panel. And
that's been, for me, has always been rewarding, and I think for Jenny as well, because not only
is it a way of giving back and supporting Columbia Business School, but it's a way of showcasing
and creating learning opportunities for students in the AVI program today. I mean, I know that both
of you have a very strong pedagogical aspect to your careers, right, Jenny? You've written
books. We had you when you published your deepening investing book. And Jenny, while as I know
of your passion for teaching, because of your engagement with the board, with the center in the
classroom, and so on and so forth, so can we talk briefly before we go into some deeper themes
in the book about this issue of financial literacy, if you don't mind, which I think is absolutely
central, but we still don't have, you know, accepted practices when it comes to teach teenagers
formally about the basics of how to run your financial life. In fact, I can tell you,
and anecdote about this, we now, some years ago, Angela Lee and now Paulo Costa are teaching
these courses on personal finance here at the Business School to MBA students who are supposed
to know about this. These are most popular courses at the moment. So this is how much hunger and
need there is for these financial literacy. So can I ask you more broadly about that where you think
what is that we should do from a policy point of view in order to have young people being formed
about having a healthy financial life from the world goal? One thing that's really important that
I should mention about this book investment wisdom is that all of the authors' profits are being
donated to the Council for Economic Education, as well as the Boys and Girls Clips of America.
Rebecca Patterson, who I co-wrote it with, is the Chair of the Board of Council for Economic
Education. That's where I met her. We're both on the board together. And so this theme of caring
so much about paying forward and passing on the knowledge that we have for all 25 of the authors
is very near and dear to us. We all know that we're in a unique position of having this knowledge
and that most people don't. So what the Council for Economic Education does is it does a few different
things. One is it lobbies at the state level to have economic education or financial literacy
as a high school graduation requirement. It's been around for 75 years and that's one of their
missions is to bring it to more and more states because that's done at the state level. Another thing
they do is they teach teachers how to teach. So they have they have learning materials for teachers
K through 12. So you can be any kind of teacher, you can be a math teacher, English teacher,
economic teacher, and you can say, hey, I need materials because I know this is important,
but how do I teach it? And you can go to the Council for Economic Education and they'll provide
that. And then they do contests, financial literacy contests, economic education contests,
and they're just creating an investing contest this year to help engage students and help them learn.
It's so critical. And one of the things that I know Jenny Wallace and Rebecca and I share very
much is understanding that if you can speak money, right? In human terms, if you can speak with
credibility and authority and understanding, it is an enormous equalizer. Money, money flattens
everything. There's a comment in here from Catherine Keating. He used drum private
while that JP Morgan and her chapter,
and she just talks it out when she was young
and her dad died, how money was the one thing
that could equalize and save the family.
- So to me, this has always been,
Jenny Herrington and I saw each other last in Omaha,
and you met my son, do you remember Jenny?
And because he was, I don't know if I told you this,
Jenny Wallace, that I was taking my son Lucas
for the first time to the Shea Hall of Meeting.
He was earning a 16-year year.
- You know, I prepared, you know,
he came with a couple of friends,
and I prepared a presentation for them
on exactly how to think about
Berkshire, Warren's and Charlottes' contributions,
basic financial, you know, how to read a balance sheet.
It was absolutely rewarding.
And I think those of us who have some knowledge
about these matters, you know,
should really make an effort to really at least teach
those of us or those who are around us in some of these ideas.
But it's important, actually, to have this engagement
with financial literacy, which makes
the empirical evidences of a woman
about this coming from the academic literature
makes a huge difference in people's lives,
to be exposed to some of those concepts early on.
Let's explore a little bit of these themes,
and I let you jump back and forth.
I don't want to run this conversation too much.
So both of you, this is a question for both of you.
But actually, I'm going to post it to you, Jenny Wallas.
Even though it's something that comes from Jenny Harrington's chapter,
they're who you are, type of question.
Okay, that investing has a process of know-of-ourself.
What is that?
Who is that?
What are your objectives, obviously?
But what are your limitations as well,
when it comes to investing?
So, Jenny, let me ask you this.
When you talk with your clients,
how important is this aspect of knowing yourself
and aligning, say, me giving you my savings
for you to run with my own understanding
of how financial markets work, and more broadly,
its finance and finance lodge for everyone,
can anyone invest in stock markets?
What are the psychological traits that one reasonable can hope to obtain
in order to be a successful manager and store of his own wealth?
That's a great question, Tonel.
And I ate him for a long time, and for many people,
the notion of investing and understanding finance feels hard,
feels foreign, feels complicated.
And I do think that on Wall Street,
there is this push to make products complicated
and to sell products where the firm has the upper hand on the client.
I actually think it was refreshing for me
when I learned about investing and remained so today.
It's fairly straightforward, right?
You do need to understand financial statements.
You need to understand basic math.
And you need to be able to think about what a company does.
How do they generate sales?
What does it cost them to generate those sales?
Are they doing it efficiently?
Is someone else doing it more efficiently?
And ultimately, is the capital that the company puts into the business
to generate sales and profits, earning an attractive return?
That sounds complicated.
It's actually fairly straightforward.
And not that hard.
What is really hard is the psychology.
Understanding that a great business can be a bad investment.
A business going through turmoil can be a great investment.
Fundamentally, you're looking for a company in my view
that has staying power when they've had a hiccup.
I had the pleasure of chatting with Warren Buffett
probably 15 or 20 years ago.
And we were talking about investing.
And he said, well, Jenny, it's not that hard.
You're looking for a wounded athlete.
We're looking for someone who's jumped the high jump
at four feet and one and currently has a sprained ankle.
You're not looking for them to do something heroic
like that has never been done before.
You just need them to get back to what they've done.
And your job is to make sure that the ankle is in fact
sprained and not shattered.
When you're reading our book and you're thinking about finding
yourself and knowing myself too, one of the neat things
is you'll read Jenny Wallace's chapter,
which is really about what she said,
knowing the companies and understanding the companies.
To some people, they'll say, hey, that's
the kind of investor I want to be.
I want to understand the companies and know the companies.
Other people are going to read Jenny's chapter
and say, that's so interesting.
But I want someone else to do that for me.
And then there's Rebecca's chapter,
which is about picking an advisor.
There's Katie Stockton, who's a technician, chapter,
who talks about risk management and investing
through a technical lens.
So you really do need to figure out who you are.
And I think we help people do that.
But one of the other things that Jenny was saying
is like, you know, we need to be able to communicate.
And that's something that she and I do.
I think uniquely, well, Jenny writes a quarterly letter
to her clients and it is excellent.
And if you're one of Jenny's clients, you read that.
And you not only know that you're in the best possible
hands, and definitely the smartest possible hands,
but you understand, you're long for--
it's true, Jenny.
Jenny's laughing, but it's true.
But you're also long for a ride in a way
that gives you great, great confidence.
There are just some investors.
And Jenny and I both see these people all the time
where we're seeing the stock price fluctuate,
gives them like enormous anxiety.
And they might be people who just need
to be in an exchange-traded fund or a mutual fund.
That's totally fine. We can all make money.
But it's definitely different strokes for different folks.
And I think and Jenny touched on behavior too.
The only way to behave well, which
is the ultimate underlying part of investment success,
is to invest the way that makes the most sense for you.
So yeah.
Yeah, I couldn't agree more.
I mean, I think--
I mean, so they know that self-aspect of investing, right?
Find guys. Find guys.
Yeah, I think it's almost find by self, right?
Yeah, it's exactly find that self.
Is the fact that you have to know, to what extent,
when you see that wounded athlete that Jenny was talking about,
are you going to panic and run away from that wounded athlete?
Or are you happy to stick with that athlete?
Because you know that he or she is going to recover.
I think this psychological makeup is very difficult for people
to develop on their own.
And this is one of the aspects on why
delegated asset management works, right?
Because hopefully, to whom we trust our savings
have the right psychological makeup
to manage those funds appropriately.
But let me challenge you a little bit on this.
And I want to push this issue of what
is the minimum that we need to know.
So let me tell you a little bit of an anecdote.
And Jenny Wallace knows about this
because we were talking about that this morning
we had our help from board and we had the intense conversation
about this, which is I just thought a wonderful group
of entrepreneurs, foreign entrepreneurs in the classroom.
These are people who have built massive companies.
And you know that what they like is building companies.
They're great managers, they're great entrepreneurs.
They couldn't care less about finance.
This is not how they think about their own role, their identities.
And my job was, OK, what is the minimum that you need
to know in order to have that informed conversation
with that person who's going to be investing your money
for you managing your wealth?
Can we talk a little bit about this?
Can we talk a little bit about how
do you think about the minimum set of concepts
that you need to have in order to have that productive conversation?
That speaks to the exact reason that this book was written.
And there's no one chapter that answers that question,
but a compilation of approachable digestible chapters
coming from different angles.
I believe gives the reader a base minimum.
Now, if you want to invest fundamentally,
you do need to have some basic finance accounting
and business understanding.
But I have a good friend who was a senior partner at McKinsey
has been the CEO of multiple companies.
And if you ask her how to rationalize SKUs, she gets lit up.
If you ask her how to build a marketing strategy
for the holiday season and the plan of when
you need to acquire the inventory, talk all day.
As soon as you start talking about investing
or the finances of a business and whether or not
it is an attractive investment, eyes glaze over.
Now that she can't understand it, just has no interest.
So she knows herself.
She knows business.
She could discuss business.
She's brilliant.
But she wants to have someone who thinks
about all of that for her.
And it's the same way, if you go to the doctor,
you have to have-- and I don't want
to think anything about how the human body operates and--
Fluids or conditions like that grosses me out. I don't want to think about it. But to be responsible
human being, you know, you have to have a basic medical literacy. So when you're at the doctor,
you can ask the smart questions. You have to have that basic like investment literacy
to take care of your investments. There is a base minimum and it's not just a base minimum.
You could look into a great advisor or whatever. I believe it's a base minimum that you mean
in order to feel confident and comfortable. One of the things that I was thinking about
Tana when you first kind of went down this path, it's not just how do I invest and how am I
comfortable? How are my clients comfortable? What are the things I need to do to help them feel
comfortable? Right, we're having a great year this year. And I don't know, you know, what next
year will bring. So would I like them to know enough about what we are doing so that they feel
confident? They know what they're buying. And by the way, as an investment manager,
it's troubling to have clients who don't know what they're buying. Right, because they are the ones
who to their own detriment will be shaken out whenever there's a tariff tantrum
or, you know, a Middle East uprising or any other stock market termulence. It's just
important to have the level of confidence and comfort. And so, you know, when I think about it
as a professional, I welcome due diligence. I love when people do a lot of work on summit
street. Because then I have the confidence that when we're doing great, they'll be thrilled
and when, you know, for whatever reason or not, they'll have the confidence to stay the course
and potentially add capital at opportune times. And to your point, Jenny, you said before,
you know, the firm has the upper hand off sometimes. And I think the firms have the upper hand
by keeping the clients at a distance and making things sound more complicated than they are.
So you really don't know. So you feel like you don't know. One of the things Rebecca says is she
says she says successful planning and investing need and be rocket science, doing well need and
be complicated. And so whether you're working directly with a portfolio manager like Jenny or me,
or you're working with an investment advisor, they have to bring you along for the ride.
You know, that you have to work with someone who who who makes it not rocket science, who makes it
understandable, who you feel like you're collaborating with in a way that you can totally understand
and isn't boring. You know, like, Jenny, I bet even you or I could make your friend interested.
Oh, I've tried. I have tried. So I also think, Tonnell, what your sort of, what's the base minimum?
Is another way to ask, what's your risk tolerance? And the answer to that question is it all depends
on how you define risk, right? I believe that risk is the chance of permanent capital loss.
And permanent capital loss can occur when you buy companies that could go to zero.
Or when you get shaken out, when the price has fallen, but the value is still there. That is
another very important reason why a base minimum of understanding is so critical. Yeah.
As you avoid the chance of permanent capital loss or you mitigate the chance of permanent capital loss.
Karen Firestone's chapter is actually titled sensible risk taking rules for new investors.
And in it, she says, you know, how do you manage risk? Right sizing, right timing and relying on knowledge
and experience. And then Katie Stockton's chapter, which is again, technical analysis says to avoid
major drawdowns, it's beneficial to have a disciplined approach to managing risk and goes on.
So there's so much, there's so much fleshing out of the concept of risk in here that really builds
the foundational knowledge. And I agree with Jenny, you have to understand risk. That is,
that is, what do they call it, table stakes? Yeah. It's also just, no, if that is a base
requirement for knowing yourself. Yeah. Right. Knowing what you can tolerate, what you can,
what ride are you able to go along for? You know, let me summarize a little bit what I've heard.
And try to kind of organize these two ideas that I think we have, you know, discussing
at the same time. So one of the things is if you're a professional investor, you need to learn
how to communicate with your clients, right? And you to do this beautifully well. And that's why
you're so effective. I would have been the podcasting, the classroom you two are incredibly effective,
your ability to communicate to your clients. And I always tell the students that a good communication
with clients is a form of risk management because as Jenny was saying, Jenny Wallace was saying,
you know, you want them to stick around because they understand the process that you have in
place. And you want, they understand that the market, Mr. Market can go up and down,
but that they are on board with whatever strategy you're pursuing. And you have to have the
psychological makeup and you want to make clear to your clients that they need to have that
psychological makeup to go through these spells where the market is misbehaving and deviating
from fundamental fundamental values. And then just the issue of the basic toolkit that you have
to have in order to communicate with your investment manager, right? So I was writing,
I was writing for my two boys a series of lectures on how to think about financial markets. And I was
so amused when in your chapter, Jenny Harrington, you actually kind of went through the topics,
compounding stocks and equities, bonds and fixed income, funds asset allocation, management fees,
of course. And indices and diversification effectively, which is follows closely to the lectures
that I wrote for my boys as it's look, I don't want you to become finance scholars. That's not the
point of these, but I want you to have a little bit of the frame and the mental model on how to
think about these financial markets. Right. You can understand that it's a language. Hannah
Schomburgert, a beautiful chapter. I really like it. And she comes from, she's the editor-in-chief
of the, what is it, the American banking, whatever, something, the magazine or whatever it is,
American banking magazine. And she says, well, you know, what is that you want to tell your kid
right away? Invest early, invest mechanically. Okay, early, why compounding, the most powerful
force in the universe, mechanically, in order to protect yourself against behavioral biases.
Okay. And the things that come with those behavioral biases, I was very lucky to be Dick
Fala's colleague for many years at the University of Chicago, and I learned enormously from him about how
rules can protect yourself against the perils of behavioral biases. What does this suggest to you
in this particular aspect of investorly, invest mechanically? I think it's just the discipline.
To me, that's what it means. And so I actually just did this with my son, who's 17, and he's working
at the grocery store right across the street. I guess his homemade, maybe $4,000 or $5,000 this year.
He's really working hard. And so what I said to him is if you can just put in $2,000 this year,
you know, spend the other $3,000, do whatever. But if you can simply put in $2,000 this year,
but I had him sit at my desk and write, I'm 17, 24, 31, 38, you know, 45. And if that money doubles,
and I had him do that out, so by the time he's 67 is $2,000 this year, becomes $256,000. And then I
said, so if you can do another $2,000 when you're 18 and another $2,000 when you're 19 and another $2,000
when you're 20 and just put it in, you know, just put it in, don't like, don't overthink it,
don't try to pick stocks. Like it's too little. It's just your Roth IRA that you're doing. But just
do it. By the time you're 70, those $256,000, add up to a million and change, million 24. And so to
me that's invest mechanically, which is like, don't overthink it, don't wait for the right time, don't
beat you, you know, just do it. You know, this is, they just do it aspect of it. I cannot emphasize
this enough. I think it's absolutely crucial to just, and particularly when you're not selecting
specific risks, right, that when you're buying an index or, you know, just to buy that diverse
if I've portfolio and write it along. Even though I think I've read this book through like four or five times,
at this point for edits, new things keep popping up. And one of the things that Rebecca and I have
talked about is that we think that regardless of someone's level of sophistication, everyone's
going to have 10 to 12 chapters that they really love. And it's funny because Hannah's a mechanic,
invest mechanically, like that actually had an even registered with me as such an important framing
until you just said it. You know, when I'm like, that's right, take the emotion out, take everything
out, just do it mechanically. I think it's something that I'm going to need to latch onto for future.
No, I'm this particular trepidation that comes from investing, right? I always tell my students,
look, whenever you're about to buy that particular name, your finger is always shaking a little bit
when you press that Enter key. And it is obviously there's, you're making a risky decision and it's not
obvious, obviously there are many risks that come with that. There's a way of avoiding this just
by the index right along. And you know, as I always tell my sons, you know, I understand the dating
scene in your school.
in your college is more fun topic than stock. So, invest, dating scene. Do you know there's
that mechanical aspect, but don't neglect it. Yeah, and you know there's another chapter in here too
by my friend Nancy Mayer, and she wrote her chapter basically as a letter to her granddaughter
who was just getting married. And she said, here's what I think you should do. I think you should
put 80% because she knows her granddaughter is never going to be interested. Uh-huh. And her
daughter's, you know, in the professional golf business. And this just isn't her thing,
but she says to her, look, put 80% in index ones, but do put 20% in individual stocks,
because it'll keep you sharp and it'll keep you paying attention and it'll keep you engaged
and not checked out. And so that's an interesting concept too, you know, is that balance between
just letting it ride and also making sure that you stay engaged enough.
So, can I then bring a second topic that I think is kind of interesting to talk about, you know,
I think Jamie Franco in her chapter talks about this. The issue of process and discipline,
the issue of discipline has come up already in this conversation that we're having,
let's talk a little bit about process and how do you want to approach that process? So, Jenny,
why don't you tell me a little bit, Jenny Wallace? Why don't you tell me a little bit,
how you think about this process? Tell me a little bit about your own process. And then the process
you recommend to that less well-informed person. Let me flip it. And I'll start with kind of what
do I recommend as a process for someone who just doesn't want to go deep on finance or investing?
I think the key is to be a sensible investor. And what does that mean? That means having your
rainy day cash. There are several chapters that talk about this. We already touched on the notion
of meeting to have a mindset to ride ups and downs, understanding how much cash you actually
need to live, functionally like actually how much you spend, or even emotionally just to keep
you sane in times of fluctuation. View market fluctuations with some level of
cynicism so that you avoid turning a downturn into a permanent capital loss.
That's such an important idea. It's absolutely key. Absolutely critical. And I think that
we talked earlier about how the investment banks like to create products that are sound complicated
are, in many cases, overcomplicated. It's sort of this notion of a bright, shiny object. And Jenny
will come up with the quotes about this topic. But the truth of the matter is that slow and steady
really can win the race. Yeah. And both at the like, I'm an investor, but I got a lot
outsourced to an advisor or at the Jenny Harrington and Jenny Wallace level, where we invest in
the stocks. Slow and steady can run the race. So I would say, in my mind, you need to be a sensible
investor. That is a process that you must go through. The way we find stocks and research them
is a little different, but not so terribly different. We are looking for a set of financial
characteristics that attract us. We like companies that have strong balance sheets, generate
excess cash, do smart things with the cash like either grow their business or return it to shareholders
in the form of regular and special dividends, stock buybacks, or even strategic acquisitions.
And we wait around for those kind of companies to become cheap, to become attractively priced
relative to the cash that we think the company will earn going forward. So that's what we do.
We look for a set of financial characteristics, and then we deep dive to understand the business,
what drives it, what are the actual risks, and all of that feeds into our estimate of what we
think the company will actually earn. So we're looking for a bunch of diamonds in the rough,
and we build a portfolio of them, with a focus on what they're worth at all times,
and where is the trading? So we're constantly thinking about that gap between value and price,
and we view that as our margin of safety, and we think about it as a stock basis and a portfolio
basis. And it's interesting, because we have a very similar process, and it's just research, research,
research, figure out what Jenny is able to figure out the same things Jenny's trying to figure out.
But she and I have slightly different approaches, where you have more of a value and a growth
orientation, where I have this hardcore dividend restriction, where the objective of the whole
portfolio is to have a 5% or bigger dividend on, so what I end up, where Jenny's looking for
diamonds in the rough, because there's a lot of growth potential that's not appreciated.
I'm frequently looking for something that can just produce significant income. So you get the
diamond, Jenny, and I get like the ugly hairy thing, who's a little misunderstood, but I get a lot
of ugly and hairy in my, and starting off in my portfolio. But it's important, right? This is
exactly like market turbulence, which is nothing becomes cheap enough, nothing gets attractively
priced without there being a problem, either real or perceived. And the job of your investment
manager is to find companies that are sort of overly penalized for some element of negativity.
On the issue of process, so I, you know, one of the things that I always tell loved ones, family
members, the type of people we get to know on that, Jenny, you were talking about at the beginning
of our conversation, right? Is that managing your financial life should be, you know, like
something that is part of your responsibilities as almost like as a citizen, as a family member,
as a responsible parent, and so on and so forth, that you have to devote some time every month,
whatever frequency you think is appropriate, to make sure your financial life is in order. And
from time to time to what Jenny was just saying a moment ago, you know, in times of market turbulence,
if you can develop the mindset that those are the times where perhaps some additional capital
can be deployed profitably, if you can develop that mindset, that can be incredibly profitable
for you going forward. And then you're going to get hooked. The problems they're going to get
hooked on that rush that when everybody's running away from the fire, you're running towards
the fire and it worked. You know, you bought that name, that index, that whatever, at a particular
discount and look at those wonderful returns and you can boast to your friends how courageous you
were and how well it worked out, then you will be in business. But absent that and not everyone
going back to one of the things that we brought up early on in this conversation that not everyone has
that kind of psychological makeup, you certainly have to have the discipline to look at it on a
regular basis to make sure that everything is to know the more less and evaluate your managers
and whether those fees have gone up, whether their performance warrants what you're paying them for
and so on and so forth. That simple discipline will take you very far in life.
Right. And you know, getting back to your pointing out the mechanical investing,
if you're investing mechanically, you're still going to get some of those real downturns and then
you can go brag about them, even though you didn't make an unconscious decision, but you still
get bragging rights. Can I then bring some specific issues? And Jenny Wallace brought this issue
of risk. I don't know if you wanted to add anything to that Jenny Harrington about the issue of
risk. I love the idea that actually has been in the context of a beautiful chapter that I really
enjoy reading by and again, I'm not sure I'm pronouncing her name. I'm appropriately
and I apologize to her. Solita Marcelli. Exactly right. I'm the amazing chapter, isn't it?
Amazing chapter. I agree with you. And cash can feel safe, but it's an always
diversification. It's in a freelance, but a well-balanced meal. Jenny Wallace, to your point
that we're yours making beautifully put this line by Solita Marcelli, pain is temporary,
damage is permanent, investing is always personal. So I thought it was a beautiful encapsulation
of many of the messages. So can we talk a little bit? I think I want to give something very practical
to our listeners today. The idea that cash can feel safe, but it's an always. And I'm very worried
about this. I'm very worried about the problems we're having in control of inflation,
that people tend to carry too much cash in their balances, in their banking account. Nana Adai
also brings up the first things she mentions is you have to understand inflation. This would
eat your returns away. Hold on, I need to say one thing. Nana Adai, Columbia Business School graduate.
You see? That's why they don't like it. You know, everything good happens at CBS.
By the way, from the Schronenberger, was I'm a Columbia School Journalism graduate too. Okay, I'll
identity take it from there. Yeah, so this idea of cash. Can we talk a little bit about that as a
fundamental starting point of a good investment in our life? Cash is sort of this interesting thing.
Cash, a level of cash will give you the confidence to ride through cycles. Too much cash becomes an
effort at market timing, which in my career, I've just sort of observed is a fool's errand.
So I think part of the answer to the question of cash is knowing yourself,
knowing what you need in reserve. Is it two years? Is it three years?
years, whatever it takes for you to be able to then turn and say everything else I am investing.
Now, you have to realize that that cash may degrade in an inflationary environment.
I mean, we've sort of had two interesting environments where cash has done really nothing
for you.
We had a non-inflationary zero rate environment where cash paid you nothing.
And in fact, a strategy like Jenny's was one of the best places to get dividend and
capital return.
Now we're in a different environment where rates are higher and so is inflation.
So if you just hold on to that cash, like a tight purse, without holding it for a reason,
right?
You're three years of family capital or whatever you need.
If you hold on to it, it will ultimately degrade and it will degrade at the rate of inflation,
plus opportunity cost.
And you know, we talk a lot about equities because that's what Jenny and I do, but equities
when they are unlevered, no debt, and equities that generate excess cash and pay a dividend
actually give you many of the characteristics and benefits of a fixed income investment
with the possibility for upside as opposed to the almost inevitable certainty of degradation.
I can summarize that up with two quotes from two of the authors chapter.
So Brynn Talkington says, "Be comfortable being uncomfortable.
You're never too late to start."
And then Liz Thomas says, "The beauty of investing is that although it comes with risks,
it also gives you money, the opportunity to work with you."
And I think what we see all the time, which is exactly what you're saying, Tana, is people
just get frozen with this cash, you know, and they always think, "Oh, this is bad timing.
Oh, my God.
Always feels like bad timing."
But you have to be comfortable taking the risk and you have to give your money, the opportunity
to actually do something for you and not degrade.
I couldn't agree more on that, that you know, somehow these palaces that comes with having
cash is really, I mean, it's amazing to me how much cash people take, carry on average.
It's really remarkable.
And paralysis is exactly the right word.
And the more cash you've got, the more paralysis you have, it seems like.
Yeah.
But you know, it goes back, I like Jenny Wallace your answer in that, it goes back to
this team, right, that you need to know yourself and you know, you need to know what makes
you comfortable as insurance against, you know, the unexpected things that will surely
come.
Okay, that obviously that's an important psychological relief that cash provides.
And then you have to be sensible about it.
You carry this because you think that's important.
It gives you some peace, maybe your spouse, your partner, or whatever, you know, your loved
one wants to have that security in their lives.
And then obviously with the rest to be active, at least make sure you're getting your nominal
return to compensate for the rate of inflation.
And I mentioned this by the way, because I think over the next few years, many, many, many
young people don't know what inflation can do to their savings.
You know, my job as an economist, when I became interested in economics for the first
time, you know, I tell my students, the inflation rate in Spain was 25% per year.
And I mean, many things happen with your savings if you have an inflation rate of 25%.
Okay.
Some good things.
Even in the United States, 40 years ago, where were we?
We were at like 14 or 17.
And I think this is an important thing to keep an eye on.
You know, there's another chapter that I enjoy enormously.
The one by Quina Martin Adams on the noise, because I think it's very relevant as well.
And I wanted to talk a little bit with you both about the issue of reading news and reading
financial news and watching TV.
And whether you have, well, what can you tell me a little bit, your habits and the habits
you would recommend to your uninterested son, daughter, friend, you know, that should they
read?
How do we approach financial news?
How do we distinguish noise from signal?
When is that you can ignore it?
When is that you that is giving you a signal to act?
I don't have a TV in my office.
And that's very intentional.
I think watching too much as a professional investor, like, you know, I just need to read.
And I think it's very important that we consider this source of our material more with more
sobriety and more cynicism than we ever have before.
It's so easy to scroll through Twitter and read really interesting things.
And by the way, Jenny and I both do.
And we read fascinating people's pieces on Twitter, but she and I are both very good at
making sure that they're like true authority authoritative sources on it with strong credentials
and strong reputations.
You can read all sorts of garbage.
So I think I think you need to be very careful with the financial news that you do watch.
And by the way, I think CMBC is a great resource, but you just can't watch too much of anything.
And then anyone that you need to be so, so careful, I've been thinking a lot about this
younger generation and how they have a sense of inauthenticity that's like laser focused.
And I don't think, you know, the same way we all have grandparents right now and parents
who are getting online scammed all the time.
I don't think that could happen to our kids.
Our kids are just shooter and they can sense fake fake and falseness in a way that we can't.
So I think that they should be very careful applying that.
But there's a lot of these financial influencers out there who are saying like, hey, if you do
what I do, you could too can I'm 23 years old, I've got an apartment in Miami and a white
Range Rover and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, all you need to do is this.
There just needs to be a shrewdness and a cynicism applied to all of that.
But you need to check the credentials and that's even harder to do today because it can
be faked.
So I'd say like more than that, the irony is right where there's so much noise and there's
so much information available.
All the fakeness kind of pushes you to the mainstream, most reputable sources.
And we've found, we've found for, you know, as much as that's out there, like the research
from Goldman and JP Morgan and Morgan Stanley were enjoying that more than ever.
It's, you know, it's from people who spend their whole days diving into tiny little industries
and thinking.
I like to read the financial times.
I skin the Wall Street Journal.
I read the financial times cover to cover.
I have a handful of journalists that I have followed for many years and Sam goes for
Bloomberg.
I think CNBC is terrific in the sense that you get, but by turning it on for even 15 minutes,
you can get a pulse of what's going on in the market, what's the vibe, what's the noise,
what are the hot takes, but much of that may be completely irrelevant to you and to your
investing process or strategy and to have to, yeah, and to have a TV on all day, or to
be on your phone all day, you cannot do deep thinking.
And this is really like, you're required to do deep thinking and to do that, you need
to quiet, you know, contemplative environment.
I think it's important to read.
I think, you know, as Jenny mentioned, you want to have a very carefully curated source,
set of sort.
I have observed that the best investors I know tend to have a level of skepticism.
And when I see people that have gone astray, it's almost that they, they got to cut up
in and narrative of the moment or the narrative, certainly we see that today where everything
is a hyperscaler. I mean, I think CNBC at 9 a.m. has led with a story about core weave.
Perhaps every day for the last two weeks.
The story is the same story, it's small, it needs a lot of debt and it needs to spend
a lot of money and the cost of capital is going up.
The return on that investment may or may not turn out to be attractive.
Why don't you talk about that every day for two weeks, right?
So I would say that, you know, figure out how to distill the information that you are accumulating
into the thesis that is relevant to you and move on.
But Jenny, Jenny, you said something too, which is like don't fixate on one big thing,
right?
Tano, and the book we asked every author to give us the book that they suggest people
read to help them think about how to think about investing.
And Katherine Nunevara chose one that I was like, what are you talking about?
She chose Moby Dick.
And she says, apart from being one of my favorite books of all time, it has profound lessons
and warnings for investing, illustrating the dangers of fixation, emotional conviction,
and the refusal to adapt, not too epic.
But it is that.
And we see that we see this fixation, right?
On one big thing, like broaden your horizons, people diversify.
Yeah, now this is, I pick up on that and this fixation thing, which I think is so important.
So let me summarize a little bit, because I think it's very important, you know, which
is this, you have to understand where everybody's coming from, right?
When reading the news, because their incentives always in place.
So if you're watching TV, well, they want you to be watching TV and the only way to keep
you watching TV is giving you a sugar rush all the time.
So we're going to try to accelerate the noise.
Sometimes there will be a signal of course there will you know,
there's some signal, but most of the time is noise.
So I'm tend to accelerate the noise.
I want to confuse you by making you think this is a signal
when it's really a noise because I want you to watch TV.
And this is standard when it comes to social media for sure.
It's pretty much standard when it comes to TV.
Sadly, you know, the nice thing about the printed word,
I always tell my students, don't give up on reading.
Don't give up on reading because the pace of reading encourages you
to think critically, okay?
Because it's not going to be obviously that great writers
that can make you think whatever they want
because of the power of their pen.
But you know, there's something about the written word
and the pace at which you're absorbing the information
that invites critical thinking.
I think it's very important too.
So can I add one last topic?
And then you know, we move a little bit
because I really, it's just too tempting.
I don't want you to leave without telling me something
about the stock market and things like that.
But you know, I don't think I would be fulfilling my duties
to a listener if I did.
But just one last thing, by the way, if I may,
there's a chapter that I like very much also.
I like, you know, I recommend this book to everyone.
You're going to have a blast reading it.
It's a book to gift to those
with very little knowledge of finance, you know?
But even I was struck by how many ideas I got
on how to present particular material to my students.
So, but it's just one chapter that I like very much,
which is Jimmy Franco's chapter on Teams.
I will tell my students, you know,
big mountains you climb together, you need a team around.
And in investing, having someone with whom
you can have those conversations that you can have
as a sounding board that is pushing back,
I used to think that this was only important
for investment professionals.
I actually think it's very important for everyone.
You know, as to have that circle of friends to whom
you can ask questions, get referrals,
bounce ideas, compare experiences and so on and so forth.
Can you tell me a little bit about how in your professional
lives you build those teams around you that keep you honest.
So to speak, I know you're very honest,
but you know what I mean, that keep you in line.
- So, my partner, Greg, I realized during the pandemic
is my personal investment advisor.
It never occurred to me.
It didn't occur to me actually until I think liberation day.
When there was something weird about liberation day
where the emotional stress from that intensity
really rocked people in a way that I thought was
maybe even a little bit more than the pandemic.
And I realized the reason I'm able to stay sane
and make good investment decisions
both at the stock level and at the portfolio level
is because I have someone to talk to all the time.
You know, so we have an exceptional team here
of research analysts of operations of admin.
And so that's my investment team,
but then my personal investment team is also them,
but really it's Greg and it's the ability
to have a conversation in the worst of times
during the pandemic, during liberation day,
actually we weren't working together during the financial crisis
but it feels like we were.
And what Greg always says to me,
like what do we do in times of panic?
What do we do in times like this?
We follow the process.
And if he's not saying that to me,
I'm saying that to him.
And we keep each other sane and stable.
And I really appreciated Jamie's chapter two
for that reminder that like whether it's at the stock
investment level or the personal level,
a portfolio level, being able to have that team conversation
and that kind of advisor is invaluable.
You can't, you cannot do this in a silo.
It's too nerve-racking.
- Yeah, I used to say I could not agree with Jenny Moore
and I have almost nothing to add,
but I used to say that when my mentor first retired,
I was seated and investing on my own.
And the market has a way, the stock market has a way
of kind of always letting you know
that you're not so smart.
And if you are sitting alone in a room having that experience,
you start talking to the walls.
And when things go really bad,
the walls start talking back.
So if you don't have a team around you,
as Jenny said, to carry a ball down the field
or push on a research question that's been bugging you
and to question each other and to remind each other,
what do we stand for?
What are we looking for?
How is this either a fit or not a fit for our portfolio?
Those are the critical things that you need to stay grounded in.
And it's, I believe, virtually impossible to do it alone.
- In your chapter, Jenny, I think it's a wonderful answer
than what you gave.
You know that you have, if I remember correctly correct me
if I'm wrong, they're not running with a hurt kind of paragraph
where you basically says something
that I thought it was perfect, right?
You know, which is, you know, the great investors
are naturally skeptic and independent.
That doesn't mean you don't need to check your opinions, right?
I mean, you can be independent.
I can ask you both for an opinion.
I ask you 20 times, you give me different ways
of analyzing that problem.
It may be convergence should occur
because the three of us are very smart
and we share language, so at the end we should agree.
But it may be that you're not able to bring that piece of evidence
to the table that would convince me decisively.
This is standard when it comes to investing, right?
And you have to find that balance between, well,
the two, Jenny's are incredibly smart
and very distinguished investors.
I disagree with them to what extent should I be putting more weight
on my own insight than in their advice when it comes to this, right?
So that balance, that is skepticism
that independent thinking combined with, you know,
hey, Jenny Wallace and Jenny Harrington are telling me
this is a disastrous idea.
I should take that into account.
That balance is difficult, but it's important
to have that people in your life.
I think that's critical pointile.
And I think that the way to think about that is,
there is a big difference between being comfortable,
standing alone and coming to an independent judgment
and being contrary for the sake of it.
And I think that in my career,
I've seen people who have aired on the side
of being a contrarian for the sake of it,
rather than being willing to, which is yes, your skeptical,
yes, your independent, being willing to come to a conclusion
to make a judgment based on your analysis.
And even if no one else is standing with you,
yeah, doesn't mean you're wrong.
I want to pivot a little bit.
And I, as I said, I don't, you know, if I have you both,
we have to talk a little bit about the market.
It's kind of the stock picture that this idea
that you want our listeners to think about, you know,
so to, you know, this was a broader conversation
in a different direction than our usual conversations here,
the value of investing with the latest podcasts,
but I think we should give our audience a little bit
about that name that you're thinking about lately,
that you want to all of us to think about.
Can I go first because I have the perfect one
that follows the exact conversation that we just had?
Absolutely.
And I can do it fast because everybody knows this.
So on the subject of balance and skepticism
to the equity income strategy,
I just added Google's convertible preferred shares,
the ticker is G-O-O-G-N.
And my partner, Greg, who runs our Disling Growth Strategy,
disagrees with the main point,
well, with the main point in my investment thesis, right?
So he has not added GoogleTar Disling Growth Strategy,
where we diverge is I think that the growth from cloud
and TPU sales will ultimately offset
if there is significant erosion in the search business.
Greg does not believe it will be enough to offset
the erosion of the search business.
And so this has been in the works for us for a long time,
and we talk about it all the time.
And on that fundamental point, we disagree.
And it is hard when you have a partner
that you risked as much as I was at Greg Stannick
to go my own way on this.
But in the end, I did.
And I said, look, at 21 times,
with 20 plus percent earnings growth ahead,
the convertible preferred works for me
because it actually has income.
So it's about a six and a half percent yield right now.
So I've got about an 18% buffer on the downside,
by the way, it matures in 2029.
I've got about an 18% buffer on the downside.
And then on the upside, I participate
with a lot of the equity return less 18%
because I'm getting it from income.
But you all know what Google does.
And I also part of my investment thesis is,
if open AI or Claude Stumble, that is to Alphabet's benefit.
If there's any slowdown in the data center AI rollout,
that just boosts their cash flow back up again.
So anyway, it's that.
But I just thought it was like such a perfect follow.
True, you've got two portfolio managers
who are philosophically nearly identical
managing two different strategies.
And on this one point, we disagree.
But I did just say like, OK, I need to make my own decision here.
I was talking about finding a diamond in the rough.
And quite literally, I thought I'd talk today about one.
Originally, I looked at Signet Jewelers in mid 25.
At the time, the company had about a $3 billion enterprise
value.
And by--
By our math, we thought that over the next five years, the company would generate cash
from operations equal to or more than its enterprise value.
At the time, the company had $600 million of cash on hand, no interest bearing debt.
It was trading at around eight times earnings, maybe five times EBITDA, with about a 15% free
cash flow healed.
It is, you've probably know the brands, their Jared, Kay, Lunile, among others.
It was generally ignored by the market as the focus has been over the last year on the
bright shiny object of artificial intelligence.
However, when you think about jewelry demand, jewelry demand is almost the exact opposite.
It is anchored in human rituals.
No algorithm will ever replace that.
Who will still fall in love, get married, and seek ways to sort of mark important life milestones?
And to some degree, you could even argue that the need for self-expression is even greater
in this new tech-focused, tech-heavy world.
So why would such a terrific company get so cheap?
That faced basically a perfect storm, soft consumer spending, tariff noise, COVID actually
did disrupt sort of the normal dating and engagement cycles.
And then there was a general concern about the economics of lab-grown diamonds.
So signate managed to take all of those things and then compound them further through bad
execution, despite all of that, signate continued to generate excess cash with leading scale
in what is basically a highly fragmented market of mom and pop stores.
So the other thing the company's doing with all this cash is giving it back to shareholders.
Over the past five years, they've bought back more than a quarter of their stock outstanding.
We love that, right?
They're also paying a small dividend. Lab-grown diamonds, it turns out, was a fear that was
completely misplaced.
In fact, it's incremental revenue and significantly incremental margin.
Still not clear to me that the market has figured that out.
And a new CEO had just joined the company with a strategy that made enormous sense.
So same store sales are back to growth. The company continues to generate strong free cash.
And for the last year, the stock price has done a whole lot of nothing until the announcement
this summer.
Yeah.
I think it was up 25 or 30% in a couple of days.
We do think that this stock has a lot of room to run.
If you think about it, you're buying a company at one and a half times book that generates
19 plus percent return on equity.
That's effectively a 12% cash on cash yield as an owner of the business.
If you add in another 1.5% dividend and 5% a year for buybacks, you're basically getting
an 18.5% cash on cash yield to buy a company that just chugs along.
So in our mind, this is a diamond that will sparkle greatly, but it's been left for, you
know, in the pile of rough, a very long time.
I like these two ideas on a count of these.
So I'm going to be alone a couple of things and then I will ask your brother a question
if I may.
And I know I'm taking that a bit too much of your time.
But Jenny, I think you're absolutely right that in a world that is coming out way of
digital abundance, where it's going to be very, you know, digital abundance and everything
from any type of services entertainment is streaming.
You name it.
It's going to be very cheap and very much available.
Physical tangible goods are going to remain the way you express appreciation, love and
so on and so forth.
I think you're absolutely right on this.
These things are not going away.
They have been around for thousands of years for a reason.
So those businesses, as far as they well run, of course, I think they have a lot of
sustained power and going back to your idea about protection of principle invested.
I think that that's absolutely right.
I like very much Jenny, your idea of Google.
I think you're absolutely right that, you know, if you want to play AI investment, right,
you know, obviously open AI and throw pick all those companies that are going to come
in.
Important players will see how that plays out and I'll ask you a question about this.
If you want resilience, right, I mean, it's cool as an extraordinary business because
he has a core business that in a way is going to function almost independently of what happens
to AI.
It's very clear to me that it will.
And in that sense, you have the benefit of the upside that you are exposed to the revolution
which is clearly here and the jury is still out to what extent, you know, the rents created
by that revolution are going to accrue to shareholders or to consumers.
I have some strong views about these.
But it seems to me that Google stands to benefit no matter what happens about the Harry.
And one analogy that I've given to, at least the way I'm framing it in my head is it's
like chat and clawed or they're trying to build for our ease, right?
Not everybody needs a Ferrari, most need a CRV.
And so Google alphabet, basically you get the CRV, they've got a whole line of CRVs.
You know, and if you ask a question and it really just needs a CRV to get you there,
you get the CRV.
But if it needs the Ferrari to get you there through whatever the latest Gemini is, you
can have that too.
But they're going to be much more, they're going to be much more energy efficient because
they're not trying that.
You know, they already have a whole search business to answer 99% of questions.
Would you believe my mom asked chat GPT last week, how much is damp should be on a square
envelope?
I'm like, what did you do cause like a water bottle and a half in an environment just
to ask that question?
And it would have answered much more environmentally inexpensively and probably actually dollar and compute
inexpensively just over over Gemini, but also to some huge degree, I'll be able to self
fund.
So their cost of cost of capital is going to a fraction of the others.
I actually was going back and forth throughout the podcast and I was going to do Albertsons
because I was like, oh, that's a perfect example of Harry versus Diamond and the rough.
Yeah.
But then a lead in with, you know, going out and thinking independently, it was too much
to resist.
You ask you like the brother question and then we close the podcast, but I, I cannot resist
temptation.
So Jenny, this morning in the board, we were all talking about the AI stock market.
I mean, how, how are you positioning yourself to protect yourself against what may come
in terms of, you know, this is beginning to look terribly right, like the late 90s and
other episodes.
So how do, what advice do we give the many people listening to us about how you position
your portfolio, how you protecting yourself against that?
I believe it's discipline, discipline, discipline.
And we have owned some memory companies, some semiconductor capital equipment companies.
All of them are excellent businesses with phenomenal balance sheets generating significant
excess cash and returning into shareholders.
So we are participants and have been over the course of this year in this AI world.
But we got interested in these stocks, maybe two, three years ago, maybe more for some
of them when they were kind of ignored and not well followed or loved, right?
And the thesis then was the chipification of everything, right?
Like you can't run your dishwasher without getting an alert on your phone at 2 a.m.
telling you it's, it's, it's finished, right?
So our idea was the, I was not that AI would come and burst onto the scene.
We were not that smart, but what we did see was sort of the growth of need for chips.
So we got interested, we owned those stocks.
And we have trimmed every single month all year long.
And so these went from being very, very full positions down to very, very small positions,
holding them and investing the way we do has allowed us to play offense in this kind
of a market as a value manager, as well as playing defense, because we also own stocks,
you know, in the energy space and fertilizer and whole and consumer.
You know, so I would argue back to the concept of the bright, shiny object, don't become
fixated, focus on, like I don't, I don't do anything really with core weave or even
Tesla.
Do I think, you know, they would never meet your process discipline, exactly do anything
with them.
Just like our discipline growth strategy is, it's called discipline growth for a reason.
And it goes to Jenny's discipline discipline discipline, like the reason we haven't touched
those is because we have a requirement for a 5% or better free cash flow yield in the
growth strategy, like 5% or better yield on average in the dividends, right?
You're precluded from those.
And that sets you up well for this kind of moment where you're just not playing in the
nose bleed area.
Like the bright, shiny object in this kind of a market and recognize that as you had pointed
out earlier, Tonna, rates are likely to go up before they come down.
anyone who is relying on significant debt is going to have an increase in cost of capital
and the economics, which may or may not have made sense a year ago, may make less sense now.
If you can resist the urge to own the things that they talk about on the opening
block of CNBC every day, you will serve yourself quite well. Fog it on businesses that make things
real things for real people and have been ignored, by the way, for the last decade and a half.
Oh, Jenny, you're talking about my whole dividend portfolio. Chlorox can really clog.
Well, I'm worse. I mean, you need a diaper. I ever need a diaper.
Ever needs a diaper. In fact, I used to chloroxype to clean my desk before the podcast.
Oh, great. Can I leave you with one more quote from the book, which is from Nancy Mayer,
resist someone hawking that pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. It will most likely be filled with
coal. Let us close then this conversation with these two questions that Michael and I always ask.
So let me ask mine and then I will ask Michael's question on his behalf. So my question is always
the same, which is what keeps you up at nine with fear or excitement. You know, what is that thing
that your mind drifts to when you have that free minute, either because you're interested in it,
because you're worried about it. And the second question, Michael's question is that book recommendation
or that podcast you've listened to recently that, you know, is that something you would want to
recommend to audience? I'm worried about our debt, our national debt. I think we are, we have
been spending like drunken sailors and we cannot afford to continue along this path. And it does
not seem clear to me that either a political party is particularly interested in finding a way
to rein that in for a very long time rates have been suppressed artificially. And we have had this
idea that the Federal Reserve can control interest rates. That is actually false. Federal Reserve
controls short term interbank lending rates, not the yield curve. And the yield curve is in fact
the price of risk. And the world has become riskier. It has become riskier because of
sovereign indebtedness. It has become riskier because of geopolitical events. And it has become
riskier because we are coming out of a 40 year bond bull market and bond prices and rates
roll in cycles. So I just see, and oh, by the way, the new bright shiny thing is now increasingly
relying on debt financing. So I see leverage through the system and it causes me concerned. So when
I think about our portfolio, I think about how to how to protect the portfolio in a rising rate
increasingly indebted environment. All admit, I'm definitely kind of spooked by like the AI
existential threat. And the like that ultimately the rich frankly like awesome probably everyone
listening to this conversation gets richer and that the poor get poor and that there's massive
future societal unrest by it from it. And that really scares me. And it's interesting to to be
in the position I'm in where like AI from me right now professionally is extraordinary. It's
letting Gilman Hill operate from a research and speed level at, you know, as if we had a 20 million
dollar plus research budget as if I had, you know, as in a just on it's just extraordinary like I can
operate competitively with far larger firms right now. The flip side is I have a 17 year old and
a 19 year old kid and I'm like, I have no idea what jobs are going to be available for them.
And I think it's the first time in parent in the history of parenting for you can't say to your kid,
oh, go go to medical school, go to law school, you know, go to business school, they will definitely
be jobs. We have no idea what jobs are going to be available. So I'm definitely like kind of struggling
with all of those things. And I say it's like the most spooked I've ever been in my life by
something. I usually lose no sleep ever. But this stuff is scaring me a little. I mean this thing of
jobs, I mean, we have children of similar age, you and I and it's remarkable because they ask me,
what do you think is going to happen? And you know, I've spent five years reading the history of
technology for my research that I'm doing on this area. It's just remarkable. I don't think the
past is going to be very good guidance for what is coming, given the normity and the speed at which
this is going to roll out is going to be simply remarkable. Bit gloomy. So that book or podcast
recommendation, which one? So I would say from a business perspective, the thing I've started
listening to on tape, which has been really interesting and helpful is a skeptic sky to the future.
And it's just kind of like a good reminder on how so many of these things that you imagine
don't come to play out. So they're like, what? Neither the Jetsons nor Isaac Asimov,
you know, actually came to pass. And it reminds you of how horrible humans are. It actually imagining
what's coming next, you know, how stuck in the present. So that is kind of helpful and reassuring.
Personally, my algorithm tricked me about a year ago in reading East of Eden. I didn't know
there was a mini series coming up. And so I said, oh, here are the books I like, which I read. It's
at O. R. East of Eden. I read East of Eden. I'm like, what a great book. It is a great book.
And I'm like, that stinker tricked me, you know, because it's trying to feed me into Netflix's
news show. So yeah, you never know what these is recommendations these days. I was like, I like
the shipping news. I like this. I'm in the mood for something lighthearted with good character
development. And I got snuckered. I listened to podcasts sort of for pleasure. And the one I am
listening to now is called Lifespan by David Sinclair about longevity and had a sort of
live longer healthier. It's all about the science. He's a Harvard researcher. And it's super
fun and interesting to me. I listened to, you know, kind of any podcast that has a company I'm
interested in all in. And then the book I have been reading is called Read Your Mind by Oz
Pearlman. He's a mentalist. Oh, yeah, I've seen him before. So he's crazy. I'm obsessed with
mentalists. I think it's so fascinating. Me too. I'm getting that for mind is about how to get,
how to see the world from someone else's perspective. And it is really fascinating and so useful
as an investor. Because when you're buying something, somebody else is selling. How do these see
the world? What? What are what's their calculus? Get inside that side of the trade to understand
and and and test your side of the trade. So I love it. And the guys, you know, it's super easy,
fast read. This has been a wonderful, wonderful conversation. So Jenny Harrington of Gilman,
Hill Asset Management and Jenny Wallas from Summit Street Capital. Thank you so much for coming,
this was phenomenal fun, phenomenal fun. This was terrific. Thanks for having us,
Tano. I think you passed your timeline. Yeah, it's okay. It was all fun and good. Thank you so
much for coming on to all of you. We'll see you and hear you next in the next episode of the
Valley Investing with Leon's podcast. Thank you so much. Thank you for listening to this episode
of the Value Investing with Legends podcast. To subscribe to the show or learn more about
the Halbrun Center for Graham and Dodd Investing at Columbia Business School, please visit
Grahamandodd.com. Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The book *Investment Wisdom* was created in response to a common question
It compiles 25 accessible chapters from experts, each offering a unique perspective on investing, from self-awareness to risk management and financial literacy.
A core theme is that investing requires self-knowledge—understanding one’s risk tolerance, psychological makeup, and financial goals before choosing a strategy.
The book emphasizes simplicity and discipline, promoting mechanical investing (e.g., regular, rule-based contributions) to avoid emotional decision-making and behavioral biases.
Financial literacy is vital, and the authors support policy efforts like requiring financial education in high schools and providing teachers with resources.
The book warns against over-reliance on financial news and social media, advocating for curated, skeptical reading from credible sources.
Successful investing involves a team or circle of trusted advisors to provide balance, challenge assumptions, and maintain mental stability during market volatility.
Cash is not a safe haven—holding too much degrades purchasing power due to inflation, and investors must balance liquidity with active, value-driven portfolios.
Summary:
The podcast discusses the new book *Investment Wisdom*, which emerged from a personal experience where a friend faced financial uncertainty after her husband’s death and lacked clear guidance. The book, edited by Jenny Harrington and Rebecca Patterson, features 25 essays from leading investors and financial educators, each offering practical, accessible advice on core investing principles. Central to the book is the idea that effective investing begins with self-awareness—understanding one’s risk tolerance, psychological makeup, and financial goals.
The authors stress simplicity, discipline, and mechanical investing (like regular, automated contributions) to avoid emotional biases and market panic. They also highlight the importance of financial literacy, advocating for mandatory financial education in schools and support for initiatives like the Council for Economic Education. A recurring theme is the danger of over-reliance on financial news and social media, with the hosts emphasizing the need for skepticism and curated, authoritative sources.
The book also promotes the value of a support team—friends or advisors—to provide balance, challenge assumptions, and maintain resilience during market turbulence. Finally, it warns against hoarding cash, which erodes value due to inflation, and instead encourages active, diversified investing with a focus on long-term value. The conversation underscores that investing is not about complexity, but about clarity, discipline, and personal responsibility.
FAQs
The book emphasizes that everyone needs basic financial literacy to manage their money responsibly. It compiles practical, accessible chapters from expert investors to help readers understand investing fundamentals and make informed decisions without needing to be financial experts.
Financial literacy is crucial because it empowers individuals to make sound financial decisions, understand risk, and avoid common pitfalls like emotional reactions to market volatility. It's especially important for youth, as it builds a foundation for long-term financial stability and independence.
Basic concepts include understanding compound growth, asset allocation, diversification, risk tolerance, reading financial statements, and the difference between market prices and intrinsic value. These fundamentals help anyone invest with confidence and clarity.
By focusing on a simple, disciplined approach—like investing mechanically in index funds—people can build confidence. This reduces emotional decision-making and provides a clear, consistent strategy that works even during market fluctuations.
Financial institutions often create complex products to make clients feel uncertain. Simple, transparent investing—like index funds or dividend-paying stocks—provides clarity, reduces anxiety, and aligns with long-term wealth-building rather than short-term hype.
Risk should be defined as the chance of permanent capital loss. Effective risk management includes maintaining a rainy-day cash reserve, staying diversified, avoiding emotionally driven decisions, and relying on disciplined, evidence-based strategies rather than market noise.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.