Kirk Cousins to the Vikings, Josh Downs to the Chiefs, and more splash moves at the deadline
53m 48s
The 2026 NFL trade deadline saw several significant moves, with the Raiders trading Kirk Cousins to the Vikings for a third-round pick, a decision praised for its long-term strategic value in accelerating their quarterback development. The Raiders’ move is seen as a calculated bet on rookie Fernando Mendoza, who now has a clear path to play time, while the Vikings’ acquisition offers a rare chance to stabilize their defense and avoid collapse. The Chiefs bolstered their offense by acquiring Josh Downs, a skilled route-runner who effectively creates separation in man coverage. Meanwhile, the Bills’ trade for a money hooker from the Cardinals is viewed as underwhelming, as more dynamic safeties like Buddha Baker or Jesse Bates were available and better suited to the role. The Jaguars’ massive trade for Jordan Davis—costing a first and second-round pick—raised concerns about overvaluation, especially given his limited playing time and the team’s recent defensive instability. Other smaller trades, such as Keenan Allen’s move to the 49ers and Andre Sisco’s trade to the Lions, reflect a broader trend of teams prioritizing depth and roster flexibility over elite talent. The failed trade involving Arnold Ebbsacetti highlights how complex compensatory draft rules can derail even well-intentioned deals. While several trades show smart, pragmatic decision-making, others reveal overreach or misalignment with team needs, emphasizing the importance of balance between risk, value, and long-term vision in the NFL’s evolving trade landscape.
Welcome to the Athletic Football Show brought to you by the US Bank Smartly Visa Signature Card. I'm Robert Maze. The 2026 trade deadline has come and gone. It was okay. I would have liked a little bit more. We got a Josh down one that Josh downs one at the buzzer dug into the Jaguars trades. Obviously let off the show with Kirk cousins going to the Vikings a deal that I think we all know needed to happen. Hit all of that with me, Dave and Derek. Let's get to it right now. About 27 minutes from the 2026 NFL trade deadline still could have a few more things come down the pike over the next half hour or so. For now, we've got about half dozen or so deals to dig through that have happened over the last couple days. The big one came down about a half an hour before we started recording one that I think everyone saw coming from a long way away, especially after last night. Kirk cousins back to the Minnesota Vikings for a 2027 third round pick. Kind of anticlimactic. A little anticlimactic because if anything, I think we kind of knew that this was probably going to be the quarterback that they were charging most. If anything, it's anticlimactic because we kept saying like the Raiders are just going to work them for more than a third-round pick and they couldn't click it. I'm a little sad the Raiders couldn't get the two out of Minnesota, but I do want to say good for Minnesota for doing something and not just stubbornly writing it out because it does feel anticlimactic because then we Derek you and I did the recap to the game at halftime you were like they have to they have to do something they this had to happen, but that doesn't change the fact that they didn't like it's easy to feel bored by it because it felt so obvious, but I'm more intrigued to watch Vikings football moving forward than I was and so I'll give him credit for that. The price is always going to be interesting to me because I did a show in Nate today and we were going back and forth about it. I think third-round pick is where I landed is like that's probably the right price. I think there are considerations on both sides. For the Vikings, you paid a third-round pick to potentially salvage your season. I think you do that every single time. The chance to look your defense in the eye to look just and Jefferson in the eye and be like we're doing everything we can to try to get the most we can out of this season. It's a fairly steep price for a 38-year-old quarterback on a half-year rental, but because of all those kind of dynamic considerations, I think it's worth it. For the Raiders, you took a third-round pick to move off of your preferred timeline and I wonder if that is worth it. In the end, you take a third-rounder for your bridge quarterback that you signed for nothing every single time. I just wondered like you were saying would they try to twist the knife just a little bit because they were operating from a position of strength here and they had a certain way they wanted for this season to play out. I just really enjoy my mental image of John Spitek, the GM in Vegas, like picking up his phone and being like, hey, he's just like very very facetious. It would have been fun, but at a certain point, if the Vikings weren't willing to move off of it, I do think, and you and I both said you try to get a two out of this situation, but to get a top 100 pick for a guy that the goal, like the hope was that you wouldn't need him to play. I know the Raiders said a lot of stuff about how Fernando might not play this entire season, but I've said this whole time, he needed to get playing time as a group in one way or the other. And so you needed to make this transition, you get a big time draft pick in addition. Keep in mind, it's really easy to imagine a world where like in week four, it's just like, oh shit, okay, Kirk's terrible. This isn't this isn't working and like he's going to be the backup and Fernando goes from here. They got another month out of him from that and a top 100 graphic. It's really, really great business by the Las Vegas Raiders, which I don't know how often I've said that in my career covering the NFL. There's no denying that part of it. I just think it's pretty telling that they were willing to do it at this moment because I think that's a sign that we're willing to turn to the rookie. And we talked about this in the preseason. We talked about it all off season. Like what would be the ideal timing of it? What sort of circumstances would need to exist for you to feel comfortable doing it? And when you watch the Raiders offense over the first nine weeks of the season, we talked about this yesterday. The Raiders passing game is good. Yes. Like they do good shit. That's like a decent spot to drop a rookie quarterback into. And I think that's part of the reason that you're okay with doing this. Well, this moment. Yes, I think you wanted a bet so that if things don't go well for us really on, we don't have to throw our first overall pick to the goal. Yeah, really. And I do think like Kirk cousins gave them really the perfect middle ground was like, he was more than a meet show because he could be like a legitimately good quarterback. And he obviously was for them. But now he doesn't say it could have been a meet show. They was way more than that. And so, but I also think credit to the Raiders for being like, listen, this has gone way better than we thought. We're four and five. We're really competitive. At the same time, when a top 100 pick falls into your lap and we have confidence in this guy, like, I believe every moment of them saying they did not want to play Fernando Mendoza. This year, like I genuinely believe that. But when a first one of this kind of pick falls into your lap, when they think that he can probably play at the offense, which is really good, you kind of just have to do it. These are all, there's a price for everything. There's a price to move off your timeline. There's a price to change course. Like you can entice a team to do something they didn't want to do if you're willing to go over the top and give them something they never thought they'd get. I mean, that was the Jeffery Simmons trade. We'll talk about the Jordan Davis thing here in a bit. Like sometimes, if even if it's not your preferred destination, teams are willing to go a different direction if they're enticed to do so. And I think that's exactly what happened with the Raiders in this situation. And the upshot is you get to see the number one overall pick in the draft and moving forward, which I think you needed to. And Kirk's been phenomenal this year. Like he, he outplayed my expectations. But I just thought you had, you had to see what you had in Mendoza, especially now that we know, like I'll say it again, Kirk cousins was bad in Atlanta. Like there was no guarantee that this was going to look good. And Kirk looking as good as he did, obviously he's played so much football, but it gives me reasonable confidence that like this is in a hopeless ecosystem for Fernando Mendoza is what I'm trying to say. And I think on the other side of it, because of the way that Kirk has played is how you can talk yourself into this if you're the Vikings. There's just no way you could continue going down the road that you were going down. The defense is too good. Even last night, they were in the game. They were in the game for a majority of the game with the worst quarterback play that you could possibly imagine. And so is Kirk cousins at this stage in his career enough for the Vikings to be a Superbowl contender? I don't know. Probably not, but it makes you a real team. It does you an honest shot. It doesn't really, I don't know how much higher I think their ceiling is if you're talking about winning the Superbowl, but you just can't keep doing that week after week. And even when Kyler was the quarterback, that wasn't good enough either. I do one note that I hadn't thought about that I think is worth mentioning. This isn't even as bad as it and not that it's bad, but it's less expensive than it seems on the surface for the Vikings because they had the extra three in the Jon Granartrade. So and according to beat reporting from the people in Minnesota, it's Minnesota's own third going to Vegas. Okay. The Eagles are obviously tanking like that. So they're going to have a better pick in the third round by virtue of the Jonathon Granartrade. So knowing that you still have that in your back pocket, this is a no-brainer. Even if the Vikings don't win a playoff game, the second half of the season should just be much more enjoyable than the first. At least I hope so. Yeah. Again, it's a price worth paying to potentially salvage your season and not let this thing spiral out of control because at a certain point, if you keep doing what you were doing, the defense is going to fall off. It's just invisible. Like we've seen this happen so often. You need those jets seasons with Zach Wilson. You need more Ralph on that on defense specifically. Like the defense needs a will to live. And I think at the very least trading a third round pick for Kirk Cousins potentially. You're star receiver needs. Yes. We said that on the recap. We watched them lose that will late in that game. Like there was a moment where you could just feel the air coming out of the tire. Can I give you guys a new one? Yeah, Josh Downey's on the Kansas City Chiefs. There we go. Like this had to happen. We have the present. Yeah. 2027 fourth and fifth back to India. Okay. Okay. I was wondering if it would get to a three. And so a fourth and a fifth probably takes you there. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I'd rather give up a fourth and a fifth than a three. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, he's the best receiver on the team now. Yeah. Like immediately. This is one of those. I initially was a little bit hesitant about the fit specifically because my the main thing they lost so far this season with the way the receiver room started was losing a guy that has Taikwan Thornton skill set. Yes. And so having somebody that could potentially take the top off that could make you explosive. That was the type of player. I thought they needed to inject back into this thing. But just thinking about what Josh Downey's is and the skill set he's bringing to the table, they need an NFL receiver who can get open. That is exactly what Josh Downey's is. And I do think that we've seen Andy Reed tap into guys that are a little bit undersized that are shifty movers. This is the best route runner of that type of archetype of that archetype of receiver that they've had in quite some time. And I legitimately think it adds an element to the offense that they have not had for a while. I mean, even if it's twice again, they he's just like beating man coverage when they needed to. They literally don't have anybody else. I know they've had some good numbers against man coverage so far this year, but it's not like someone winning like a one-on-on route. It's just like we're going to run mesh and we're going to get somebody open in traffic. And it's like this is a little bit of a different skill set. And it's all underneath too. It's all underneath. It's all like it's right. It's within five hours of the line of scrimmage. Having somebody that he can win 11 to 20. That's exactly my knowledge in 20 plus, but he can win 11 to 20. I would
we were talking about this earlier today and the exact situation I'm imagining is just think about like Josh Downs and like a big crosser return on 3rd and 9th. They do not have a player in their offense right now that can do exactly that. And that's precisely what he does. I would just send Josh Downs out on Whipper out a lot. Just create some separation and I mean it's not as exciting as like it. Somebody asked me for my like if you could just wish cast a trade into happening and I said George pickens to the chiefs. That's not this, but it's the beggars can't be choosers with the state of the chiefs or see record. So this is I mean this it's not as exciting as it could be, but it's going to be very useful. Be free for yourself. Well, I mean, you're the president of the Josh Downs fan club. So I am curious what he will look like within this offense as potentially more of a focal point in a good offense. You know, like last year obviously the the culture were good offense, but he wasn't a focal point of that offense. This year the culture are bad offense. And he's kind of a focal point of that one. So this is like a weird potential Goldilocks scenario where we get a decent offensive infrastructure and Josh Downs being the most important or one a one b were Travis Kelsey in terms of like the past catchers and the hierarchy within this offense. So I like this. I think it's the exact type of thing that they needed to do. Even if at first glance, I didn't love it right away when I started thinking about like two weeks ago. I've come all the way back around on it. I bet Patrick Mahomes loves it. I bet he's really excited just to have a guy who can create separation and catch the ball. Speaking of AFC contenders, making moves, a money hooker to the Buffalo Bills for a stab. Bill sent a second round pick to Tennessee Tennessee sends a fifth round pick back. This is one of those where you look at the price. It's very rich for a money hooker. I can't imagine that Brandon Bean is overly thrilled with James Gladstone right now. Okay. Actually, can we talk about the deal that reportedly didn't happen before we talk about the one that did because the reporting coming out in the wake of this is that the bills made a nice offer with a day to pick as the central component to Arizona for Buddha Baker. And the Cardinal said, thanks, but no thanks, which I think is crazy. A bump up to like go for it. Buddha Baker is a significantly better player than a money hooker's a good player. Actually, we can talk about that different types of players. That's my only, I mean, kind of, that's my only thing is the Buddha Baker is a good player, but Buddha Baker is a very specific type of player. Yeah. And so having somebody that you feel you can just plug in and be a more traditional NFL safety into the back end of your defense, I understand that. But I also think Buddha Baker is a more dynamic player. I thought Jim Leonard's whole thing was like, look, check out all the cool shit, Jim Leonard's gonna do. But they haven't really done it. Maybe because they don't have a Buddha Baker in doing that way. Yeah. That kind of seems like you get a guy like that in the building and like, you can move him around a little bit. You can move cool bishop around a little bit. And like, I do think if they're trying to simplify it and just get by for this season, a money hooker has like a free safety, I think does allow you to do that. But because I'm going to complicated spot where I think with them, I would have loved to see the bills either just go up and do it for Jesse Bates or go and make a play for Buddha Baker, because those are like those are serious playmaking level safety. And I know a money hooker's had a bunch of picks this year. Some of those are freebies. He's a good player. I just like, it's in a weird spot where I think this definitely helps the defense. And I'm just frustrated that they didn't quite go for the stars that they could have. How old do you think a money hooker is? I looked it up really. He's probably he's probably only 26 or 27. Really? He's 28. He's 28. I would have said 30. Yeah. It feels like a money hooker has been in the league for 10 years. I don't feel that way. Really? I would have guessed. I don't know why it just feels like he's been on those Titans teams for as long as I can remember them being existing because the Titans just haven't had that many players worth like being intimately familiar with over that time span. And I do think that that's why like you can't even really make the argument that like, oh, well, they went for a money hooker because he's younger. Now, I know he has a longer like run out on his contract. And so I think that that is definitely part of it. But it's like, I know Bates is a little bit older, Buddha Baker is a little bit older, but it's not like a money hooker's 25 year old safety like about to get a new contract. I like to just, I don't know. I'm in a weird position where I do think this helps them. But I think with the bills, I'm always frustrated that they do the like C plus B minus thing instead of like, you just like make a move. But if they try to do this, if they try to give up, let's just say, I know if this was the price for Buddha Baker paying anymore for this, then this for Buddha Baker would be too much to be clear. I'm not, I'm really not, I'm not mad at the bills for not sweetening the deal. I'm mad at the Cardinals for not trying to get something for 30 year old Buddha Baker. And I saw somebody said something like, oh, the Cardinals were reluctant to part with a franchise icon. Buddha Baker is an amazing player. And he is one of the best things about that team over the last decade. How many people even are familiar with Buddha Baker in the league landscape at large? Like that's more about what if they've done it is about people in the landscape at large? At this point, I would hope Cardinals fans would be like, get us something good for Buddha Baker and let him go play some meaningful football. You know that. I think I think teams think differently about that stuff than we do is we're moving around like numbers on the spreadsheets. I just that's why Jonathan Taylor hasn't been treated. Yes. If you could add, if you could have added a second round pick knowing where the Cardinals are and what they have in front of them, I just, I don't get why you wouldn't do that. But I, I don't blame the bills and at least they pivoted to get a guy who I do think can help them. Yes, look at it. It's a sea price, but a money hooker will help the bills. I mean, Demar Hamlin played the second most snaps on the bill's defense yesterday after Cole Bishop. Like and it's that's not even to like dig Demar Hamlin. The guy who was playing there before was borderline unplayable before he was released. Like C.J. Gardner, I'm glad we can say this now. C.J. Gardner Johnson was the most ridiculous player in the NFL over the first six weeks. Yes. No one talked more shit and no one played worse. Like he was an unacceptable character in the NFL for the first six weeks of the season. I'm like the XY graph. Yes. It's just like it's bad. It's a utility and shit talking. He was at the bottom of that graph. And so they are upgrading here for what this entire season has looked like in Buffalo. I'm putting you on the spot here. If you're pissed at Brandon Bean for not upping the offer from potentially a second round pick for Boota Baker. Yes. What would you have given up for Boota Baker if you were Braden Bean? I mean, I would have been willing to like, I'm not going to give up a first round pick for him, but I would have given up like a second and probably something else or not ask for a fit back. I'm asking you. I don't know. Probably like another fourth round pick or something like that and not ask for like the fifth round pick back. Boota Baker is. I wouldn't be surprised that they offered that though. I mean, that's just offered. There is a chance to Cardinals were being completely ready. I'm pretty confident. I think this is more the Cardinals being jerks. That's not doing enough. Yeah. That's my. But then at that point, like, were they not calling enough about Bates? Like, this is my thing. It's not just Boota Baker. It's like, there were two clearly better players on the market. You got to wake up pretty early in the morning to be more wild than James Glass. That's fair. That's what it's all about. James Glass don't makes more unhinged trend requests. That's for four or nine a.m. than we do for the quarter of the course of an entire day. All right. Before we move on, let's take a quick break. Let's get to some of the other stuff from today before we talk about those Jaguars moves. This one's Taylor made for you. Day on Henley of the Los Angeles Chargers to the Denver Broncos for a 2027th fourth and a 2028th fifth. This feels like a very good move for the Broncos in terms of the price they paid, a player that is still young and it's going to be a free agent. So that's also that's part of this and this part of the reason that he's even available. But somebody that has a skill set and range that they just didn't have that their other linebacker spot like Justin Surnod. We know what he is. He is a downhill player. That is what he's always been having somebody that is just a better space player next to Alex Singleton. I think it makes a lot of sense for the Broncos. This is very pointed problem solving for them. Like Surnod is a player who like on rundowns or between the tackles as a blitzer. He's really good. Alex Singleton like is it like he backs up a lot of tackles. I still think in coverage, Alex Singleton is pretty getable. Henley is immediately their best coverage player. And we'll see how quickly he know he adjusts to the defense and stuff. But I think Henley is still a pretty good player in coverage. His range I think is better than either of the players they have right now. The construction of their room actually in some ways reminds me of like the chiefs when they had Sionol where like Alex Singleton and Nick Bolton are like your leaders of the defense types. Like kind of do a lot of stuff between the tackles. You have what is supposed to be like this coverage runner on player. Drew Trankville down Henley. Henley's a better player than that. And then obviously Sionol and Surnod I think are a little bit similar in some of those ways. And so I'm excited for this. I think Henley like kind of do for a cool fresh start in a new place in the defense that I think is operating in an extremely high level. So I'm excited to see this. I also think too. One of Henley's only deficiencies really. He's just not going to come up and hit very often in the run game. Well, if you're playing behind Zach Galen, Malcolm Roach, DJ Jones, like all these other guys, it's like, well, there's going to be space for that. It's not be as much of a problem. Yeah, this makes perfect sense for the Broncos. I think it's it just is a little bit shrewder than trading a boatload of like real draft capital for Jonathan Taylor based on like where you currently are right now. I think it was always a little bit more realistic that they do something more measured at linebacker than make the huge Jonathan Taylor swing. I am relieved the Broncos apparently don't feel the need to do that. I am noticing a trend where I'm more frustrated by the teams doing or that are in the position to do the trades than the teams trying to get players because it feels like there's a lot of good faith efforts to acquire talent being made over the last couple of weeks. And the teams in the bad positions are just like nah, no. And the chargers finally being willing to deal somebody and it's day on Henley to a division rival while Khalil Mac as of right now where
with eight minutes until the deadline sits on the roster, just kind of aggravates me. That really pisses me off. Kaloomack could be like a, the Marcus Lawrence help shift a super bowl type guy for some team right now. - It does sound like he doesn't want to be trained. - And if that's part of it, I get it, but like-- - If he doesn't want to be traded at this point in his career, and I can understand that. He's what, 35 years old, he's been there for several years now. His family is there like to uproot and change teams in the middle of the year. Kaloomack is probably like a whole famer right now. - Kaloomack doesn't need to start adding, that was hedging just like for humor reasons, but Kaloomack doesn't need to do anything else to like add to his football resume before this is all said and done. The idea, maybe this is just, maybe I'm wired the wrong way, but the idea of like, oh man, I'm gonna go chase one more ring for half a season. I probably won't win it, and I have to leave my family for the next eight weeks, maybe in like the last year of my career. I don't really blame Kaloomack for being like, you know what, I'm all set here. Like I think that I've really done what I needed to do. - Far be it for me to question Kaloomack, and if that's how he feels, then I can get on board with it. I just, I hate the idea of somebody like Kaloomack lacing up for 10 more weeks of meaningless football. And like, I- - He's played a lot of meaningful football. I guess that's what I would say. - I just, I know what these guys put themselves through every Sunday, and like how much it hurts to play NFL football, and I would want stakes if it were me. But again, like that's his life if that's how he feels. - If he thinks this is gonna be the end anyway, ride it out for eight more weeks. - It's very different than like a lot of these other guys who a money hooker's gonna be on the bills for the next three years. He's under contract. Josh Downs is playing for a deal. Josh Downs is playing for like his football future by going to Kansas City. Jeffrey Simmons is going to be a centerpiece of the Chicago Bears in what hopefully is a very cool era of Bears football. Kaloomack getting traded for a fifth round pick to like ship up San Francisco for the next nine weeks and like have to talk to his daughter on face. I don't know where his kid's situation is, but like have to talk to his daughter on FaceTime twice a week. Like I can understand being like, you know what, I'm all set. I don't really need any of that. - That's, that is a very valid way to humanize the situation. I, if that's how he feels, then yeah, I'm not gonna. I don't feel too badly about it. But in general. - Even the forest Buckner, it's like he's been there. - Yeah. - He knows what's up over there. Like even seeing him in the uniform, we didn't talk about this yesterday. - Yesterday we were doing that. - Seeing him in like, seeing him stand next to Bosa, just like walking on the field. I was just like, oh, there's something beautiful about this. There's something right about this. I don't need to have that feeling with Kaloomack unless it was come back here. - That's the only thing I'd be like, what do you want? - Humanities off the board. - Well, that is the human thing that could happen. But to go anywhere else, I completely understand why I just wouldn't be interested in that at all. Speaking of former chargers, Keenan Allen, to the San Francisco 49ers for a 2027 Sixth round pick. This is, they're just collecting them all. How many old receivers that were really good in 2016? Ken, when did Brandon Cooks come in the league? - I think it was 2016. - He was 14, I think. - 14, I think he was 20. - I was a ground one because I did a story about it before that draft. - 'Cause he might have been the same. - He was a long time ago. - He was like Evans, right? - If he wasn't, it was close. He was 2014. - Yeah, so him and Evans came in at the same time. - And so you have a 2013 receiver in Keenan Allen, to 2014 draft class receivers in Mike Evans, and when did Marcus Robinson get drafted? - Oh man, probably not long after that, like 2015, 2016. - 2016. - Yeah, man. - How many old receivers can we rack up on the same team? Is what the Niners are playing? - That's the game the Niners are playing right now. - Typically, when we talk about this, you typically use 30 as the line of demarcation. The Niners blew past that. Keenan Allen is their 11th player age, 32 or older. - I love this. Giving hope to all of us. (laughs) I know how my lower back feels, so Godspeed, fellas. - Keenan Allen at this stage of his career is a hilarious player. I don't know if he's capable of running more than 15 yards past the line of scrimmage. - Don't need him to. - You're good. - Yeah. - You're good. This is a team that sees, I think the fifth lowest rate of man coverage in the NFL, and he's still, even at this stage, has very good zone awareness. Like, he can just sit down in the area where he is supposed to sit down, and the ball will find him in this offense. I don't know how much Keenan Allen's gonna play for the Niners, but they literally, at this point, I think it's Parks and Rec when they're putting together the Valentine's Day brunch, and just like, honestly, we just needed bodies. (laughs) That's what this is. At this point, honestly, we just need bodies. - They're taking out insurance on what is like a super cool team. - That's all that this is. They're just making sure that they have a seventh or eighth receiver if it needs to happen. - Well, honestly, it's a good thought process because everyone on this Niners team should have term life insurance. - Yes. - Where she's like, so much to come to the building, just be like, you guys need to set your families up for the future? - Well, I was joking with belt. Most of these guys will come back, but how many like, rosteral NFL receivers are on the Niners right now between their active roster, and some of the guys that are here, it's Mike Evans, Marcus Robinson, Debo Samuel, Jordan Lockins has been nice. Brandon cooks like at this stage, just like borderline, I know he's technically playing. Now you have Kenan Allen, Christian Kirk has due to come back at some point, John Struppling, and then Ricky Purcell's not going to come back with him as well. So that's like nine or, well, right. - That's what I'm saying. I mean, like right now. - Don't you say that. Did you already mention that Ayyuk's technically reinstated? - No, I'm sorry, I need to. We're not doing that. - All right. Let's get some of their smaller ones. For those smaller ones from today, there's absolutely hilarious. The Arnold Ebbacetti failed trade. - Oh my geez, man. - Which apparently is a product of the Bengals realizing via social media that if they traded for Arnold Ebbacetti because of the rules associated with compensatory draft picks, they would have lost the compensatory draft pick. They would have gotten by losing Trayhendrickson and free agency. And so they ultimately nixed the trade. - That's absolutely what happened, right? Like Nick Corte tweeted out like, "Hey, this looks bad for the comp formula and like duke Tobin or somebody underneath duke Tobin saw it on Twitter." Like that's almost definitely what happened. - And they would have lost a third ground pick. Like this was not like, I don't, this is not like they were looking like a stick for a pick. - Honestly, it was a stick. I'd be like, okay, that might be worth it for helping your past. - Right, exactly. - You think you've got a chance to win the Super Bowl, but a third? - This is, I'm going to make like a, you know, it's where we're deep into the season. I'm going to make a weird analogy here. This is like when an AI company goes and like, tries to buy a land from like a small town business where it's like the biggest companies in the world are taking advantage of this like mom and pop operations. That's the Eagles and the Bengals. Like at this point, you are being taken advantage of by a large corporation and you should think twice about the choice you're about to make. I mean, it's been a meme for a while, like don't answer how Erosman's phone calls. - This is the best example. - No, like this is like the Eagles are like the Wall Street front office and the Bengals are the closest analogy to a mom and pop shop in the NFL. Just don't answer the phone. - I feel like I saw some stuff about like, well, you know, the comp pick formula is always really complicated. I'm like, yeah, but it's somebody's job in the building to know that. Yeah, like I find myself thinking like, oh, who really knows all this stuff anyway? - Like I don't personally. - Somebody, I'll be honest with you. - Somebody in front of me should. - Somebody should. - Yeah, absolutely should. Yeah, this is a scenario where, yeah, this seems like it's good business for us. I promise it's not, I absolutely promise it's not. Speaking of, the Jacksonville Jaguars send a 2027 first and 2029 second round pick to the Philadelphia Eagles for Jordan Davis yesterday. So we were on the hangover yesterday. The Jesse Bates traded already happened, which we can talk about again now that Davis here. So that trade happens and then they traded for Gevon Gacha. And you look at the Jaguars Dept chart and you think about where they needed help and what those players would do at the prices they were paid for them. And it's like, okay, like get it. Like I see the vision for like how you think this makes you better, you're trying to arm yourself up first, you will run, let's get to it. And then they go do this. And it's just a completely different tone. Like I was like, all right, they're done. These are the moves that they made were all set. And then they come in by the cool aid man, busting through the wall here. And I, I really don't know what to make of this. It is an astronomical price for Jordan Davis and what he is as a player. The Bates and Gacha combination was like aggressive, but reasonably so. It's like you're leveraging yourself a little bit, but like Bates is clearly a really good player. Gacha, you make a savvy move to go get like a guy who can help you at nose a little bit. Okay. In a city. Yes. The Jordan Davis traded. You are way over leveraging yourself, I think. And obviously if they win the Super Bowl, nobody's going to care about anything this stuff, but I think that this is to the point of being too aggressive. Like I know that like Hamilton's going to be a free agent. Maybe you keep Davis for a really long time. And I get all of that, the machinations of that. This feels like a little bit too aggressive for this kind of player. Like I think Jordan Davis is good. The other detacles that are getting traded for are like completely change your defense. And I understand that they're already very good, but I just, I don't quite think of him as that level. Like it just feels a little bit too much. I'm going to look up something while you guys are talking because I think it's a very telling essential point here. Can I tell myself a story about why this could be okay? Sure. And I like this. It can be. It can work. I'm just saying they're over leveraging themselves more than I think some of these other teams that have made similar-ish traits. They're definitely over leveraging themselves. And this is definitely an overpay. But for the record, we call Jeffery Simmons and overpay as well. Like in the vacuum, did you see the annoyance on Robert's face right there? It's a different conversation. It is absolutely a different conversation. I'm not trying to compare them as players, but to get something like this in a situation you often have to pay a premium for it. That's how Ryan Poles massaged it, by the way. Just say paying a premium instead of overpaying and everybody will feel fine about it. Exactly. They paid a premium for it. But
First of all, like the, the need was obvious with the Hamilton injury. And then on top of that, plugging Jordan Davis into Jeffrey Simmons came to Chicago to be the focal point of everything. Jordan Davis is getting dropped into a line that has Trayvon Walker and Josh Heinz Allen and the rest of the Jags defense as well. So like, I assume you're hoping rather than Jeffrey Simmons, boying everything up on his own, you're hoping Jordan Davis gets buoyed by the ecosystem on Jacksonville's, but the point to me is you shouldn't need to be buoyed if you're worth a first and second round pick. That's, that's the difference. And that's, I mean, that is why it's an overpay. My other point would be we just made a joke about what a psychopath James Gladstone is. The second round pick is in 2029. I don't think I've ever seen that before. That is, it's in the NFL rules that you can trade up to three years in the future. No one does it because nobody thinks they have the job security to pull off trades like that. And so James Gladstone's probably not even thinking about the two. He's like, we'll, we'll mess around and get that back. Like we'll trade BTJ in the off season and get some capital for that. We'll do this. We'll do that in the other. Like James Gladstone is not worried about something three years from now. So in his mind, it's essentially like the one for Jordan Davis, which is still probably an overpay that that's a fine methodology. That's the mindset I have when I'm making dynasty fantasy football trades. It should be the mindset you have when you're running an NFL franchise. It's borderline reckless, but he came from LA. Yeah. That's, that's what they've done. And it's, I mean, it has worked out for the Rams. It has blown up in their faces a few times too. So the idea of, well, Jeffrey Simmons went for two ones. Right. And so the idea of a defensive tackle going for one and a two. How is that that much different? Jeffrey Simmons on Sunday night against the bucks played 10 pass rush naps on third down. 10. How many think Jordan Davis has played this season? Oh my God. Probably eight. Not a whole lot. 15. Yeah. Jeffrey Simmons played 10 of them on Sunday night. And that's the thing. I think people might be like, well, you pay Dexter Lawrence to be a run stopper. And it's like, well, he's that, but also Jeffrey Simmons. And he has five facts. Exactly. And so it's like, it is complicated too. Because I do think if we're removing whatever the price is like, Jordan Davis is an awesome fit for the defense. And like, it can be two different conversations. I just think that what they're paying the style of player, he is, is, it is a little bit much. It is a little bit much. Oh, in a vacuum, it's a crazy price. Yeah. It's a crazy price. I heard from multiple people in NFL front offices yesterday that were just like, this is the craziest trade I've ever seen. So that can be true on the other side of it. I, I do think you can talk yourself into it if you're the Jags for a couple of different reasons for what you said. Devon Hamilton was, I think the other conclusion that we can reach from this is that Devon Hamilton is one of like the 15 most valuable players in the NFL. Like the idea that he's a long snap or they lost, they lost Devon Hamilton and they needed to trade a first and second round pick to get Devon Hamilton's impact back into the defense hilarious spinning. He's like the whole thing is screwed. Yes. And I think that with these defenses, that's like kind of true. And I understand that. And I understand thinking about it that way to an extent. But I also think if you're James Gladstone and if you're the Jaguars right now, the what, what you saw over the first eight weeks of the season is you saw a situation where we might be the best team of the league. We are and there are not that many opportunities as an NFL franchise where your roster is positioned for you to win the Super Bowl. There are not many of those. They, so many things have to fall into place for that to happen. And you removed Devon Hamilton from the situation. You start to chip away at that idea. You start to chip away at that dream of we have a Super Bowl caliber roster. By bringing getting Jordan Davis and dropping him into this, you're trying to reclaim some of that feel and you're trying to make sure you maximize what is a very rare opportunity. Whether that is worth the price they paid for it is an entirely different conversation. But I get the mindset of making sure like we can't fuck around with this. We can do this right now. The problem is, what do you think the chances are the Jags in the Super Bowl? I mean, it's less than 8% for like any team. Yeah. And I get the odds aren't good for anybody. And so that's, that's where it gets a little bit dicey. I, so I can tell myself that story. And I think I kind of believe it. But the, the big difference is when you do the Jeffrey Simmons trade, even if it's an overpay in the moment, you're like, I know in my bones that Jeffrey Simmons is this good of a player that it's worth paying that type of price. Like I knew that going in and he has delivered on it in every opportunity he's had so far. Are the best defense players in the league? I don't know at all that Jordan Davis is like independently worth that sort of price. He might play up to it because of what's around him in Jacksonville. But like Jeffrey Simmons, I was like, put him anywhere and he will wreck shop like he's that good. I don't care. And here I'm like, well, our Josh Heinz Allen and Drayball Walker going to make him look better. Like I don't know if this is really that caliber of player. I never felt that way about Jeffrey seven every snaps. Do you think Jeffrey Simmons played on Sunday night? I mean, most of them. Yeah, I know. I'm probably 62. I was going to say, okay, yeah, he played 62 snaps on Sunday night. I'm really curious how many snaps Jordan Davis has played this season? I mean, in the game, it can't be. I mean, like they rotate the way that they do for a reason. So Jordan Davis played 323 total snaps this year. He's had he played 44 snaps against the capitalist is the most he's played in a single game. It's he's just a very specific type of player. Like the multifaceted impact is very different than a Galley Jefferson. He's averaging 36 snaps a game for sure. Like it's that it's definitely different. So it's a it's an aggressive, aggressive move, but they have proven to be an aggressive team. So I go ahead. What are we at? I was I was safe with the sake of book a bookkeeping eight past the hour. We're done. No, so no Jonathan Taylor, no Cleal Mac. Those guys all stay put down at least. That's like the wall. I was like, I was still waiting hot. I was still waiting on Malik Willis is going on. I are not a trade, but oh, that's nice. Okay. I mean, you look hobbled in that game. So that totally makes sense. There were four players that we really sat with and talked about a lot on the dolphins in that game yesterday on that game this weekend. It was what Malik Willis wasn't one of them, but like it was the quarterback of the team, right? It's been good. The Zach Seeler. Chopper Robinson and Caleb Douglas. Malik Willis is now an IR. Zach Seeler's now an IR. Cool stuff. Great stuff. There's enough goodwill and enough optimism in Miami to endure that. But who's the backup quarterback for the Miami Dough when he was going to know he got. Oh, man, I can't wait to find the answer to this question. I don't think I'm going to like Kyle McCord. Yeah. I'm not gonna like it. That sucks. That is blue. That sucks. The football gods heard us saying like, don't look now, but the dolphins are a fun watch. That sucks. That's a really good. That's a really tough one. The only other deal we did not hit yet. Andre Sisco yesterday, this came down right after we stopped recording yesterday, going to the Detroit Lions from the Jets for a 2028 sixth round pick. I just make sense. I mean, like Chuck Clark could still get in a lot of snaps for the Lions. And so having one more body that can play in a defense where I assume there's going to be some shared language with him being in with the Jets with Aaron Glenn. I understand this. There are moments. I've like, I liked Andre Sisco early in his career. I still, he was, I was a fan of his. It just has not worked out quite to that degree that you wanted to, but I think there's totally a chance you get into the right defense. Somebody communicates him well, like he just kind of gets in. And like obviously, I don't know if he's going to have to start here, but it's the secondary that you just want bodies. And I know that I think Kirby Joseph's husband has been practicing, but it's like, you don't really know what to run out for. That's actually going to look like as it's another month, like we just don't know. Anything else you guys want to hit? I spoke to you soon. Uh oh. Ryan Newsle to the Ravens. Okay. So what are they going to do with Cam Jergens? Andrew Voorhees is going back to the Falcons along with a 2028 sixth. This is from our own Jonathan Jones. So who's, but somebody has to play guard and somebody has to play center, right? I mean, like they do. If they move Jergens to guard again. Oh, that's the. Jergens that didn't play well at guard. How pissed off would you be if you're Cam Jergens? Well, maybe. Yeah, I mean, if that happens, maybe it's not him that has to move for that. That's weird. Give me that one more time. It is Ryan Newsle to the Ravens for Andrew Voorhees and a 2028 sixth. Man, I mean, is it just insurance? Cause Cam Jergens has been banged up? Pretty consistent. Maybe. Maybe. Why would you do that? The Raven season is dirty, like kind of over because there's no Lamar. It's just a weird. Oh, I'm sure that I'm sure that I really have a good answer for what's that what that deal is. I'm going to be honest. So who's going to play center for the Falcons now? Is it Andrew Voorhees? What's his first name? Corey Levin. He was with the Titans for a little bit. Okay. All right. So I don't, you know, that's not really satisfying, but all right. That's a weird one. I don't really understand that. I'm going to never need someone to explain that a little bit more about what the thought process is behind that. That's Newsle's like basically never played anything but center either. Like it's not like, oh, you could move him to guard. He can play guard. I mean, I guess he could, but he does. He's never done it in the NFL. The only reason that I'm doing like the wind horse fingers with this one is every little move that he and Cunningham has made over the last like a year has been good.
Yeah. Yeah. Every little thing they've done along the fronts has actually been a good thing. Like, Joanne Taylor has been perfectly acceptable for them, for them paying him no money whatsoever. Yeah. Like, it's not, he's not nuking the offense consistently. And then all of the defensive languages that they made, well, I guess everything they've done kind of around the margins is actually worked out. So it's really the only reason I'm like, I'm kind of, all right, maybe I am more interested in this than I should be. Why would the Ravens play? Well, why would the Ravens play Jurgens at guard? Like, none of this mates, if they, if this ends up meaning that, but why would maybe they have you want to and Simpson? So maybe it's just if one of those guys get her Newsle knows ledford and play center. Yeah, that's how that's how it's like. It is like, think about, it's like move around depth. But like, yeah, like, so you want to for them today, you want a doesn't have to play center. I think that's what it is. I think it is. So you, you have actual center depth when you didn't before. That's right. That's the answer. Yes, because it's I, because that's the thought is that Jurgens does get hurt. Then you don't have to move you want to back to center. That's, that's the reason. So this is just depth. It's center. I mean, it is a good job, guys. It was the hardy boys. It is an interesting move to do for like, it feels over to us. I'm sure they might get why they don't feel that way. Yeah, they don't feel that way. But it's also like, again, it's, it's always, all right, even if you understand the thought process, is it worth the price? And so if you're the Ravens, if that actually is the motivation behind this where we drafted a guard in the first round, we are valuing his development. We want to make sure he gets to play the same position all year at the spot he is supposed to be playing. So we're going to bring in a backup center to backstop ourselves there and prevent him from ever having to move over again for the rest of the year. Is that worth the player and a six round pick? I don't know. I kind of think so. If only for you're getting the player back kind of. So like, I'm not really worried about the player, you're basically giving up a six round pick. Also, I think that that's like the worst thing. If you're really trying to make sure that everyone, it's a, and you bring in again, a guy who like shared language, like knows ledford can probably help guys a little bit. Like I, I don't know the state of the Ravens comp situation off the top of my head, but they usually have a couple comp picks waiting in the wings too. I think if Lamar was there, the answer would be emphatically. Yes. The fact that it's not, I think it's, you know, a little bit more pressure. They signed in. That should offset the lender bomb thing. They have. They have several compensatory picks. They have two fifths for the Isaiah, likely, and dream on Jones deals. And then they are going to get a six for Charlie Kohler, according to over the cap right now. Yes. There we go. Like the Ravens at all times are, it's like loose 20s in their pocket. Like, yeah, what's a six? We've got four of those. That's also, by the way, this idea of, I can't remember who with what the messaging was that the charges were trying to get out there. One of the insiders said last week that the thought was, well, you can get mid-round picks anywhere, right? You can just, you can conjure them. And I think that's, I don't really understand what that means. But the, I think the other kind of the other thing that people would go to about like, well, it's a fifth round pick. Why doesn't matter if you get a fifth round pick. Well, even if you aren't going to find useful players in the fifth round, this allows you, fifth round picks allow you to do this on the other side. Yes. Now you can be the team that if you need a Khalil Mac to put you over the top at some point, now you're in a position to do that. Like the thought of like, ah, these did the picks don't matter. Why would we want them? It's like, well, you're seeing all the players that are moving for those picks right now, right? Like there is a market where those things are extremely valuable, even if they hit rate on the fifth round pick is not very high. Yeah. So that was just one of those things like, yeah, fifth round picks. Why do we need them? Well, I don't know. They're better than not. It's better than not having them. Mm-hmm. I'm aggravated that Jonathan Taylor is a cult. I'm annoyed. And I can't help but think like the cults are just salty that they spend two first round picks on sauce gardener and thinks that mean they think that means they're entitled to getting one back for JT. Like just give us a first. We need a first back. Well, I don't. The only thing I get is I thought it would be Nelson that they kept obviously, but Robert and I talked about this like when they were starting to sell or it seemed like they were going to because the season was tanking. It was like they're going to move people, but you need like one guy who is your cornerstone piece and whether or not picking the running back is the one. Well, but here's the thing. I'm not saying that this is like proper team building. Nelson is older. So I do think that that is like a and he's a free agent. And Taylor, there is something sexy about the guy that you give the ball two three hundred times a year. And I get why that even if it's not like actually good team building, I get why you think there is something sexy and fun about keeping that player. Jonathan Taylor is a really good player. Yes, excellent. And so if you're okay. So Christian McCaffrey in 2023 when the Niners made that trade was 27 years old. He is about six months. He's about six months younger than Jonathan Taylor is right now. Okay. I understand if you're the cult saying and they've said this, they put it out there. There was no ambiguity about this. We want a Christian McCaffrey-esque return for Jonathan Taylor. Yeah. That is a fair price to ask based on precedent for running back of that caliber at this point in his career. If you don't get that sort of return on top of all of the franchise icon best player in the building face the franchise type things. In next year or the year after, you are almost certainly going to be drafting a quarterback. Having Jonathan Taylor as part of that plan to be able to lean on while you're bringing your young quarterback along, there's value in that. Like I don't know if there's more value in it than giving yourself every opportunity to completely remake the entirety of the franchise or the draft capital that you would get. But I don't think it's like some abdication of responsibility to say there is a price for a superstar running back that has been established. If you would do not give us that price, we're happy keeping it. All right. Before we move on, let's take one more quick break. My two thoughts off the top of my head. Jonathan Taylor is excellent. I think you would have one offensive player of the year if the cults had maintained the track that they were on last year. I still think what Christian McCaffrey does as a receiver puts him in just a different conversation in terms of being valuable as players. I don't disagree with that, but I don't think that's how these conversations typically go. I get it. It doesn't make it less true in my opinion. And then on top of that, where is the quarterback coming from in 2027 when you don't have a first round pick? And if that's the case, how much tread is going to be left on Jonathan Taylor's tires when you do have that quarterback to work with? He's going to be 29. I mean, like I think he could still be Christian McCaffrey's 30. I think my problem now is who was trading for him? That's the other part. Like the Vikings already kind of gave up some of their capital. The Giants were the other team that they felt like the Giants made their most. Yeah. I guess they would have been the most because I know that you know, the Broncos have been brought up, but I was like, unless the Broncos were getting a steal, I don't, I can't imagine them having really done that. This painting is always like the stable of guys. And I just don't really see them giving up that much capital to go do that. So I guess it really would have just been the Giants. I did the same thing with Breeze Hall when the Jets tagged him. Unfortunately, the Jets at least extended Breeze Hall, which made me feel better, but I just hate great running backs, being stuck on teams that aren't ready to maximize them. And that's, I mean, it's definitely not Jonathan Taylor's fault, but just feels like he's going to, I worry that he's going to give the rest of his prime to a team that's not ready to do anything. And that sucks because he's special. I'm less worried about this stuff than you are. Jonathan Taylor signed a contract with Indianapolis Colts and you're like, and it should be, oh yeah, okay. That's your size to this. Yeah. If you didn't want to be an Indianapolis long term, like you have agency, you can make that decision. Things have changed, but like, that's the business. It's this idea that like Jonathan Taylor has deserves to be in a better situation because the cults have gone like a certain way. It's just like, I don't know, man. I'm Jonathan Taylor's well compensated for his services. That is a valid point. But like, when you, like, when you're the only good thing and you get the shit knocked out of you 40 times a game, it's just, it's tough. They've still got some offensive lineman on that team. All right. We'll see where this goes. I just think that my stance on it is that things turn around in the NFL faster than we think that is probably fair. And if the Colts had their one, I don't think I would feel this way. But that is the complicating fact. But even two years, but let's just say they take a swing on a Tyler Schuck type guy in the second round. Yeah. You want to see what you can get out of that guy. Having Jonathan Taylor as part of that, I do think is important. Yeah, that's fair. I mean, it doesn't have to be who the fuck is going to play receiver for the Colts next year? That's the other problem now. It's like that's it. I don't want to see for one look on treadmill right now. I mean, I think so. I mean, is it not? I really didn't think about that, but they traded it now. And don't forget about Ashton Dullin, as Ashton Dullin, the one trouble, Ashton Dullin, Dion Berks, Nika Keene Westbrook, or Westbrook Keene and Anthony Gould are their active big big opportunity for my guy Dion Berks to shine and so on. In all honesty, the getting blinded by the first half of last season and trading two first on picture sauce gardener is is really bad. Throwing Adnight Mitchell in there, just being like, I just take him. Yeah, that is the part where it's just like holy shit. Yeah. Like that is a former high second round pick that is is absolutely talented in a scenario where you need three receivers. You always need three receivers. You were trading Michael Pittman away in the off season. I will say I'm I'm not about to call James Gladstone like prudent clear like he's a madman, but I'm really
really relieved the Jags didn't deal BTJ for the same reason where everybody's like, well, he's on the back burner now. You don't need Brian Thomas Jr. Go get something for him. I'm like, right now that might be true. Well, you're also, you're one, you're one injury away. You're hoping Meyer injury, Joe Meyer's injury away from it being Josh Cameron and Parker Washington for the rest of the season. Yes. And that's why I'm glad BTJ is still on the team. I told Derek, I'll call my shot and say going back to the Jordan Davis thing, I bet the Jags trade Brian Thomas Jr. win this season's over. Yes. And like he's still got two years of control. Yeah. But right now you never know what, what the next 10 weeks are going to bring. It's the other side of the coin from what we just said about the Jordan Davis trade by trading away Brian Thomas Jr. You once again risk that super bowl quality build that you've done everything that you can to now rip back into your arms. Like I just wouldn't do that. It's just now worth it. The only time that becomes a consideration in my mind, if it's like truly like a culture problem, if he is an active impediment to the way the building wants to feel and he's like an active problem, that's a different situation. But I don't think that's the case now. It doesn't seem like that's the case. It just seems like they have a lot of really good players. Yes. If Brian Thomas Jr. was doing the George Pickens stuff right now, maybe there would be a different sort of consideration. But I don't think that's the case. I think it's there just having trouble folding him into what they want to be offensively. That's also it's, this is a bad. I don't think Brian Thomas Jr. is the player we thought he was going to be as a rookie. I think that ship is obviously sailed. But it's an offense where they just don't really care about featuring players. It's just not a part. And we usually use that. Everybody eats a derogatory like with like the bills at times. This is an offense where like it should work that way. Like it's the way that the ball is distributed. It's just going to the right guy all the time. And it works out. And so if you're a talented guy who's kind of falling down the pecking order in that sort of situation, I assume it can get really, really frustrating, which I there's no doubt it's frustrating for players. And I think not to say guys don't care about winning, but like guys want to show their stuff. Like guys want to show off that they're great and can win and produce stats and be somebody that can carry a passing game. Also fantasy football is like a huge, but like yes. Everybody eats offenses are the women. I watch, I watch Parker Washington play. I have him on every single fantasy team. I it's Parker Washington is like the sixth best receiver in the league. And we're just never going to know because he's going to get two targets a game because the Jagger's going to win every game 35 to eight and throw the ball 12 times. It's maddening. Now I'm just now I'm perusing the 2027 quarterback class looking for guys that the Colts can get in the second round. That's where I'm at right now. Again, Jonathan Taylor will be 29 in two years when they draft quarterback in the first round. He won't be dead. He's an NFL running back. You can't guarantee that. You don't know. It's a long time. I think we've seen like the freakish running backs last a little bit deeper into their careers. And I think Jonathan Taylor applies there. I hope you're right because I love him. This all everything I say is out of concern for Jonathan Taylor's legacy. So I hope you're right. I think it's all I think it's going to be okay. If that good buddy. All right. All right. That is all we've got for the 2026 trade deadline. We'll be back tomorrow with our 2026 midseason awards. Very much looking forward to that one for now. That's all we got. Appreciate you guys listening. If you're watching this on YouTube, please like, subscribe to all of that fun stuff. We'll see you later in the week. (upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The Raiders traded Kirk Cousins to the Vikings for a 2027 third-round pick, a move praised as smart and strategic to accelerate their quarterback development and gain a top-100 draft pick.
The trade reflects a shift in the Raiders’ confidence in rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza, who now has a clear path to play time after a strong start, despite earlier skepticism.
The Vikings’ decision to trade Cousins—though anticlimactic—was driven by a need to stabilize their defense and avoid a season spiral, with a third-round pick seen as a reasonable price given the quarterback’s age and performance.
The Chiefs acquired Josh Downs, a high-impact route-runner, to strengthen their offense, especially in man coverage and deep zones, where his skill set fills a critical void.
The Bills’ trade for a money hooker from the Cardinals is seen as pragmatic but underwhelming, with many questioning why they didn’t pursue stronger, more dynamic safeties like Buddha Baker or Jesse Bates.
The Jaguars' overpay for Jordan Davis—via a 2027 first and 2029 second-round pick—is viewed as excessive, especially given his limited playing time and the team’s need to rebuild after losing Devon Hamilton.
The move to trade Keenan Allen to the 49ers for a sixth-round pick highlights a defensive "body count" strategy, rather than a player-focused acquisition, reflecting a shift toward roster depth over elite talent.
The Arnold Ebbsacetti failed trade underscores how complex compensatory draft pick rules can be and how teams may overleverage themselves in high-stakes trade decisions.
Summary:
The 2026 NFL trade deadline saw several significant moves, with the Raiders trading Kirk Cousins to the Vikings for a third-round pick, a decision praised for its long-term strategic value in accelerating their quarterback development. The Raiders’ move is seen as a calculated bet on rookie Fernando Mendoza, who now has a clear path to play time, while the Vikings’ acquisition offers a rare chance to stabilize their defense and avoid collapse. The Chiefs bolstered their offense by acquiring Josh Downs, a skilled route-runner who effectively creates separation in man coverage.
Meanwhile, the Bills’ trade for a money hooker from the Cardinals is viewed as underwhelming, as more dynamic safeties like Buddha Baker or Jesse Bates were available and better suited to the role. The Jaguars’ massive trade for Jordan Davis—costing a first and second-round pick—raised concerns about overvaluation, especially given his limited playing time and the team’s recent defensive instability. Other smaller trades, such as Keenan Allen’s move to the 49ers and Andre Sisco’s trade to the Lions, reflect a broader trend of teams prioritizing depth and roster flexibility over elite talent.
The failed trade involving Arnold Ebbsacetti highlights how complex compensatory draft rules can derail even well-intentioned deals. While several trades show smart, pragmatic decision-making, others reveal overreach or misalignment with team needs, emphasizing the importance of balance between risk, value, and long-term vision in the NFL’s evolving trade landscape.
FAQs
The Raiders traded a 2027 third-round pick to Minnesota for Kirk Cousins, who was signed as a bridge quarterback. The move was seen as a strategic shift to accelerate their transition to rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza, especially after a strong start to the season.
The Raiders made the trade to move off their preferred timeline and gain flexibility by acquiring a proven, high-impact quarterback. They believed Kirk Cousins could provide stability and immediate improvement, especially as a backup for Fernando Mendoza, who was expected to play a significant role.
Josh Downs was traded from the Los Angeles Chargers to the Kansas City Chiefs in exchange for a 2027 fourth-round pick and a 2028 fifth-round pick. The trade was viewed as beneficial due to Downs' skill set in creating separation and catching the ball in traffic.
The Broncos acquired Dayne Henley from the Chargers in a trade involving a 2027 fourth-round and a 2028 fifth-round pick. Henley is expected to strengthen the Broncos' coverage unit, providing improved range and depth in their defensive scheme.
The Jaguars traded a 2027 first-round and a 2029 second-round pick to Philadelphia for Jordan Davis, aiming to bolster their defensive line following the injury to Devon Hamilton. The trade was seen as aggressive and expensive, with some questioning whether it justified the premium paid.
The 49ers acquired Keenan Allen from the Chargers in a trade for a 2027 sixth-round pick. The move was viewed as a pragmatic addition to provide depth, as Allen is now part of a roster that already has multiple veteran receivers, though his role is expected to be limited.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.