Go back

Kidnapping Of Nancy Guthrie: 2 Men Detained & Why Is The Internet Pointing Fingers At Son-in-Law

41m 24s

Kidnapping Of Nancy Guthrie: 2 Men Detained & Why Is The Internet Pointing Fingers At Son-in-Law

The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie has sparked widespread public and media scrutiny, fueled by both family accounts and mounting investigations. A long-standing summer tradition involving a "kidnapping game" adds an eerie, personal dimension to the case. The Pima County Sheriff’s Office, which leads the investigation, faces criticism for its handling of evidence, including directing forensic samples to a private lab instead of federal facilities and failing to share key information with the FBI. These actions have raised concerns about transparency and competence. Multiple detentions—such as of Rio Rico man and Range—were conducted without proven links to the case, leading to accusations of misconduct and overreach. Forensic findings, like blood and gloves, remain inconclusive, with no DNA match found. Theories about motive range from ransom to robbery to homicide, with some suggesting a cartel involvement due to Nancy’s proximity to the U.S.-Mexico border. Despite the lack of concrete progress, the case remains in the public eye, driven by social media engagement and criticism of law enforcement’s reliability. Savannah Guthrie, Nancy’s daughter, has publicly supported the search with a $1 million reward and donations to missing persons organizations, emphasizing the family’s commitment. Nevertheless, critics argue that the investigation lacks focus, is disorganized, and fails to deliver results, leading to growing public frustration and skepticism about whether the authorities are truly committed to finding Nancy or merely managing a high-profile crisis.

Transcription

8269 Words, 43627 Characters

English
there is a segment in savannah guthrie's book that has been heavily discussed online though i think it's not really relevant some people have brought it up just because they believe the whole thing is odd and eerie in one of savannah's books titled mostly what god does she writes about how her and her cousins had this really cute tradition growing up which they called the kidnapping game where her cousin would visit the house stay with them during summer break so her cousin lives in phoenix which is a few hours away from tucson so her cousin would come stay in their family house in tucson and when she's about to leave she would wake everyone up the next morning really early you know savannah and annie and she would say you should come with me they would get in her car drive to phoenix and on the way to phoenix they would stop by a pay phone call nancy savannah and annie's mom and let her know but in like a cute playful way mom cousin has kidnapped us to take her to her house nancy would act shocked because at this point this is like a summer tradition and she would protest how much she would miss her daughters but then assure them that in a few days she will drive up to get them it's like a summer tradition some people think it's eerie i think it just makes the whole situation more devastating i'm sure there's moments where everyone in the family wishes that this was just a joke that this was also just a game and that nancy will be home as if it's just a prank but it is not and nancy guthrie is now going on over a month of being missing and this is part two of the audio podcast for the case of nancy guthrie go listen to part one of the audio podcast if you haven't already we uncovered the whole timeline what authorities have said people's suspicion people's undying suspicion on tomaso which is the son-in-law and the arguments against it and there's just a lot happening in part one but with that being said let's just jump into part two there are so many questions such as does the sheriff's office even know what the hell that they're doing side note the sheriff's office of pima county is the one leading the investigation into nancy guthrie's disappearance they have their own a and e team show called desert law where the sheriff himself does not appear on camera but allegedly he's extensively involved in the production of it in the show they look like this well-organized crime unit that moves in synchrony to stop the bad guys which tucson is about an hour from the border so there is a lot of smuggling of all sorts avocado smuggling is big in that area it's not just smuggling and avocados but drug cartels will conceal the narcotics mixed in with the avocados to get it across the border but they don't really handle a lot of ransom for bitcoin cases in tucson do we know that the sheriff is well equipped to handle this case from the very beginning there were reports coming out that the sheriff and the fbi were not playing well together whilst investigating this case which is the last thing you want and it all stems they've got beef they have beef going back to 2016 this is not like one of those cop shows where it's like oh this is my jurisdiction no it's not they have long stemming issues between the two the sheriff has a lot of information about the fbi and he has come out and since denied that he feels any sort of b for vitriol towards the feds but it is interesting the feds were investigating pima sheriff's department in 2016 believing that they were taking rico forfeiture funds yeah the thing that sean combs was charged with rico so they're like okay if you've been racketeering i'm gonna take your assets they take the assets and then those assets can be used for department things like crime prevention specific law enforcement activities this is the only way to do that so they're like okay i'm gonna take your assets and by the law like by the word right but the fbi started investigating because they're like wait we think we heard from a little tipster a whistleblower that you guys are using rico money to bankroll the remodel of a cafe inside the sheriff's headquarters what can they use it for legally crime prevention but this does not fall under crime prevention okay like how does having a better matcha latte for the sheriff prevent more crime right that was denied by the sheriff's office they said we didn't do that and then a whistleblower comes out to state funds were used to host these special award ceremonies for the cops helping pay for food goodie bags for the officers a santa sleigh rented tuxedos allegedly the total cost of the award ceremonies was around 250 000 over the years that was likely taken from rico money is the allegation the investigation was a big deal like a really big deal one of the things that happened was that the sheriff's own personal account was found dead from self-exit on father's day he was widely considered to be the mastermind of this whole rico money laundering scheme okay well i don't know if i would call it a money laundering scheme this investigation however even the death there were concerns that the death should be investigated independently by a third party because sure he might have reason to want to self-exit but also someone would want him dead because maybe he could go down for everything that's something to consider but the sheriff was allegedly adamant that it be handled by his own people and so the sheriff is the one working this case and some people who know sheriff nano says that he holds a grudge and that he doesn't like the feds after that 2016 investigation but those are allegations those are speculations those are opinions there are more reports though coming out that the sheriff does not want the fbi to take over which i mean it seems like they probably should and that there's just a lot of annoying things happening in this investigation first of all you here's the weird thing there are a few key pieces of forensic evidence that are deemed to be highly important in this case there's probably more that the public doesn't know about but the ones that the public do know about is one obviously the blood tested on the front porch turned out to be nancy guthrie's second they do find a pair of gloves 11 days later near the house off the main highway they think it could be the gloves used by the perpetrator or perpetrators it's like those black nitrile gloves so i mean they found a lot of them so they sent all of them out for testing and a ton of them turned out to be some of the search workers would just like i guess they would put their search gloves into a baggie and maybe that bag blew away in the wind and they just had scattered gloves everywhere but that was a key key piece of evidence then the third key piece of evidence is they did find dna inside the house nancy guthrie's house that did not belong to nancy guthrie or any of her family members relatives or anyone that i guess works in that house frequently but where this information is sent where this data is sent to be tested for the forensics is really important the sheriff interestingly the fbi is like we can take it to quantico why would you not want it tested in quantico i don't know anything but i probably would want it tested in quantico okay but the sheriff is like no i'm gonna send it to our private lab in florida so he sends it to the about this but he does you know kind of defend his decision and in a slightly convoluted way he says why did we give ours to our lab because it's what we've done for years and our labs always have done well in fact we use the fbi before they're very good at solving things and doing things but the fbi not unlike our department of public safety in phoenix they have a lab you know they could have been used but we look at it as this if i use for example a state lab dps or the federal lab quantico you have to understand they have others using those labs too so it really puts a lot of strain on them to prioritize those cases and do what they can with them where if i have my lab my own lab or a contract lab it allows me easier access to those cases that i think are important to us and i'm not talking you know this case but i'm just talking cases in general you know and he's like so now we find a glove fbi says oh we can send it to quantico and i said well you know what let's just keep it all in one place so he's like i've already been sending it to this lab so let's keep sending it to this lab which i will say a lot of people are like okay there is a little bit of validity in that statement as when you have multiple different labs involved and there if there is a criminal trial eventually it's a lot of people testifying okay yeah okay so then he's like let's just keep it all in one place let's just send it to our lab and it's not like no the fbi's got a bad lab or no you know the sheriff's department uses dnl at bad luck no it's about keeping your evidence together in one spot this is the sheriff speaking and when that report comes out it goes to both agencies it just made sense you know out there they said oh the sheriff blocked evidence this conversation i had with the fbi lasted probably a minute and a half and they said makes sense and it was done there was no problem with that so i'm just going to keep it in one place and i'm going to keep it in one place there's no blocking evidence that's just crazy so that glove that they found you said they found multiple gloves why is that glove special or they had reason to believe that it was special they got it tested and there was no codis database match which codis is like the vast network of anyone with a criminal history they have all of their prints but interestingly is kidnapping a lot of experts say is not a first offender crime yeah you know you statistically you don't have can nappers that wake up one day with a clean record that say today is the day that i kidnap someone usually they're going to have some sort of a rap sheet previously so they say that it's very interesting that there's no even more suspicious and then later they came out to say actually maybe it wasn't a glove that was important because it actually belonged to a restaurant worker nearby how do they know it belonged to a restaurant worker we don't know like did they go and test all the restaurant workers they just said it was a restaurant worker the sheriff's department The sheriff has also been criticized for being seen at a basketball game during the investigation and apparently the sheriff didn't even know about savannah guthrie's video that she posted on instagram with her siblings the very first video until his wife told him about it and he mentions this to the media and so everyone is like this feels like a very expensive unproductive investigation if that's the case because it just feels weird we're spending a lot of taxpayer resources and not saying that it shouldn't be spent i'm just saying there are a lot of missing persons out there where maybe they don't get this allocation of funds and personnel to search and this is how you guys are handled like you didn't even know that you they were putting out a video it doesn't even make any sense the sheriff is also probably not used to being analyzed on a national scale for every word that he says he doesn't strike me as particularly organized with his thoughts when he is speaking off the cuff so here's a rundown of questions and answers given by the sheriff during multiple different press conferences sheriff is there any indication so far as to whether this was random abduction or targeted like i said earlier we're looking at all the leads and we don't know we're going to assume both sides of that we'll look at both sides do you have any idea what nancy guthrie was wearing or the type of car that she might have left from or any identifiable information that the public could use to help with the tips we do not sheriff do you believe that one or more than one person was involved in the kidnapping just no clue it could have been one it could have been more is there any indication that nancy guthrie is still alive we know the medication played a critical role here it's been 48 hours she needs it every single day are you still looking for someone that is still alive we hope we are we hope we are sheriff you said earlier that you don't believe that there's a wider threat to the public if you're not sure if it's targeted why do you believe there's no wider threat to the public well we have crime in tucson all the time right like any city and so when you say a threat to the public is there somebody out there who's kidnapping elderly people in the middle of the night every night we've not heard that we don't believe that's the case we do believe that nancy was taken from her own against her will and that's where we're at even about the rumors of there being forced entry he just states i have no clue where that comes from we have been very consistent we are not discussing that at all whether it was forced entry or not forced entry that is something we're just not discussing we don't know where anybody got that information okay well i see so that's a pretty standard question no yeah has there been any proof of life and has there been any sign of life i'm going to anything to deal with the ransom notes i would defer to the fbi but no not to my knowledge we are still looking for nancy do you have any reason to believe that she's still out there alive are you fearful for the worst case scenario here that she won't be found alive well i'm certainly fearful of that i think we all are but we operate from a position that until we know she's out there she's alive we're going to continue thinking that way until we find her is there anything more specific you can say about what you believe the motive to be for the kidnapping at this time motive is always going to be a question and we'll know more as we go what that motive is but right now my guesswork is as good as yours with these types of cases though sometimes the sheriff does appear disorganized and that's not really good one expert states you are broadcasting basically every detail about this case the more that's released to the public the more that is now known by everybody including if there is somebody out there who has nancy guthrie they have to be very careful about what they're letting out of the public and they have to be very careful about what they're letting out of the public they have to be very careful about what they're letting out of the public and they have to be very careful about what they're letting out of the public but the way that he's doing it like he's not really answering questions so i'll give him that but it is weird like it's just not the most well done i will say the fbi the special agent charge of the tucson area like he's a bit more organized with his thoughts during these press conferences oh he's talking as well yeah alongside yeah and he also diverts questions doesn't answer questions and i'm not saying that we deserve answers as the public right they should deem whatever is the best for the investigation however he is able to respond in a way that's very clear succinct and like this is what's happening okay that's it but it's interesting because the police union president was interviewed by brian and i would go watch the full interview but he works with sheriff nanos and he says sheriff nanos what's their relationship exactly so he is the police union president and he's also an officer so he works under sheriff nanos right but he says sheriff nanos he has an ego that's difficult to describe without signing hyperbolic and it drives a lot of his decision making he's very retaliatory favorite version of retaliation is where he works under him yeah but he can't be fired because he is the president of the police union so it's really difficult i'm sure to fire him wow okay yeah and so he's like he's very retaliatory favorite version of retaliation is through transfers which has impacted nearly every unit in this department and decreased our overall readiness in my opinion nearly every unit the experience and expertise that there was you know transferred out for whatever reason and there are real impacts to that and it lowered morale and so there was a lot of hope that in the election in 2024 we would have a change in leadership and when that didn't come to pass that's when we started seeing a mass exodus of deputies and detectives so that's been a huge conversation most of the detectives in the homicide unit at the pima county sheriff's department they're pretty green like they don't have a lot of experience i'm not saying they're not good but it's like do you want the doctor to perform surgery on you that perform surgeries every day or once every few months there's also questions about the team not being well equipped the turnover being high like it's a lot the sheriff states this is a solid team this is a silly to not listen to them when they tell me we spent 20 some hours at the scene we process this scene i'm taking their word that they're good i don't need to hear from some pundit out there who's never done a crime scene i don't need to hear from somebody who's never done a criminal investigation i've got experts that's who i choose to listen to i don't need to hear from somebody who's never done a criminal investigation and that's it it's just all noise in the background the critics who want to run for office go do that stuff i just want to find nancy i want my team focused every morning when they hit that low they know that they have someone who believes in them and their work and they're going to do it i have a hundred percent faith they will solve this case if you are the guy if you are that monster you should be worried you should let her go just let her go and so there's been a lot of talk about monday monday morning quarterbacking i don't know what that means i'm not a quarterback no a lot of yeah a lot of cops have been saying that there are a lot of news anchors tv stations social media content creators netizens who are monday morning quarterbacking which i think is a lot of good news i don't know what they're talking about i don't know what they're talking about i guess it's like when guys give quarterbacks advice when they watch their favorite team play i see yeah so i guess we're all monday morning quarterbacks but 10 days after nancy's disappearance someone is detained a 36 year old delivery driver his house is an hour from nancy's house in rio rico arizona which is really really close to the border into mexico and while we do know his name and it's a little bit different from what we know about nancy's house we know that nancy's house is a little bit different from what we know about nancy's house and it's a little bit different from what we know about nancy's house and it has been publicly stated and used i'm still going to call him rio for rio rico the city that he's from just because this case is getting a lot of attention and he's saying that this has ruined his life rio is detained his house is swatted he's a delivery driver for doordash that lives an hour away from nancy he has no personal connection to nancy what the hell does he have to do with this case why would he want to harm nancy that's the tricky part of this case that's a question that even with rio or any of these people no one knows it does appear to some degree that the motive in this case could be harm i mean that's one of the more reasonable motives if we are to believe that that ransom note is not real because that deadline has since long passed there was no proof of life there was no effort at least publicly known to reach back out to the family to further communication line to get that bitcoin amount if that ransom note is not real then was the intent harm it's been reported that nancy left behind her phone keys id wallet i don't know if this is true this is just what's been reported it has not been authenticated by the law enforcement authorities but these are the things that you would need to slowly drain someone's finances you would need to put in their passwords you would need their phone you would need their id you would need their bank cards so that you could slowly transfer funds so if money was not the motive what's the motive if the ransom note is not real if money's not the motive what is the motive then people thought maybe this is a robbery gone wrong so this person came to the door and they thought okay this is an elderly woman who lives alone and she's probably sleeping at night and it has been reported that she wears hearing aids so when she takes off her hearing aids her hearing is going to be much less than maybe like a younger person in their 30s who has dogs and lives with a whole family of people like it could be different so maybe this is the perfect house and a lot of elderly people have a lot more valuables in terms of like heirloom jewelry i think younger people a lot of experts were saying when you target a house with a lot of young families you have a lot of electronics that are harder to sell when you target older people you're talking about gold you're talking about jewelry necklaces diamonds like you get a lot more of that that's easier to sell in the market so maybe she's targeted because she's an elderly woman who lives alone in this isolated part of town so then you go and you try to do a home invasion at night but maybe she wakes up but the question is why not just run out then because trying to rob someone an elderly woman of her jewelry is very different from kidnapping someone like those don't even correlate like you it's very hard to escalate that way unless you retaliate and perhaps you harm nancy and she passes away at the scene and now you're removing her body because of dna or something of that sort and i know that they sound really grim but i think the only reason that people are even talking about some of these theories now is that savannah's newest videos that she's uploaded it seems like the family have somewhat come to terms with that nancy might not be out there alive and i do think you know people just don't understand and i think that brings a lot of fear especially with a case like this because i mean a lot of other times it's a lot of other crimes you can see why things unfolded not that it's justified but i think everyone's scared for their moms you so then the next theory is okay well maybe it's nancy was harmed and so her body needed to be removed from the scene or other people are saying well maybe she pulled down the mask or pulled off the mask of whoever was robbing her and recognized this person maybe she's like this is my housekeeper's son that i met once you know and i'm just saying housekeeper because it seems like the term that everyone is using it could be a caretaker though it's not verified that she had a live-in caretaker or a regular caretaker it could be the pool guy i'm just saying it could just be someone right that has access to her home but another thing is if this is a robbery gone wrong and these people have probably been scoping out her schedule and her routine in her house why not just target the house when she was gone for so many hours at her daughter's house just previously that night so then there was some people arguing well no because it was bright outside so if they broke into the house when it's bright there's more of a chance that people would see them but nancy didn't get back home until like 9 50 p.m there's still a few hours of darkness that they could have gone in yeah and another thing is why is the backpack so damn full if you're committing a robbery and you're trying to take valuables would you bring a full backpack yeah that doesn't make sense there are some people saying maybe the backpack is full of duffel bags that are empty that you undo and then you fill it with valuables other saying maybe it could contain something darker like a tarp because nancy's blood does stop in the front porch area so it's not like a trail of blood that leads to a vehicle now another thing with the blood though is that a lot of people have been commenting when you're 84 you can bleed very easily if you grab someone's wrist at 84 and yank it their skin is really thin so that could be the blood it doesn't necessarily mean that some big traumatic event had happened it's just i mean questions and no answers i know you look confused and i don't have answers no one has answers it's just question after question and then it's like oh well maybe this theory is ruled out but then it just leads to 10 more questions so now the question is did rio rico man know someone who knew the guthries and knew that nancy lived alone and likely had valuables could he be the one in the doorbell footage which side note about this doorbell footage they did not have this footage for a very long time in the investigation it's not like nancy goes missing and this is the first thing that's released when police get to the scene nancy's doorbell camera was ripped off i believe to this day it has yet to be recovered additionally nancy did not have a google nest subscription so she could view the front door camera live but it did not save and log the video it would write over itself so how did they get the footage they had to reach out to google nest and see if google would somehow get that footage and side note it is believed that the fbi had a lot of pull in this and the sheriff has talked about how they were pleading with google and i mean these the last case that we talked about the krug family case these tech companies do not like to give out information of their customers unless they're really like their hand is on the stove and it's very interesting because a lot of people have a lot of feelings about this the fact that the fbi could get google to do this i think there is a lot of some resentment of why don't you do this in most cases then because if you can do it think of all the cases that could have been solved but then that also comes into the right like when is your camera private right fbi can come in and pull the footage yeah so it does seem like a very yeah but i think the sentiment is more so i think um as the investigation goes on further and the news coverage stays strong which i think it's good that it is staying strong because i think it'll probably help bring nancy home sooner i think there is um some resentment that a lot of people feel that their missing loved ones did not get any attention did not get these types of resources so i think that's where the anger is coming from yeah so they were able to get this footage 10 days later and the fbi tweeted the footage kash patel just tweeted the footage really yeah and so that's that's why we have the footage that is so crazy wow and also there was a lot of questions of like oh i didn't know if you were not recording on google nest that google somehow has that yeah so there was a lot of like conversation about this footage so these footages are always storaged somewhere yeah but i mean the sheriff said that google was working really hard i don't know what they're doing they made it seem like they had to like unpeel the code i don't know he was making it sound like that okay yeah and then now there's speculations that someone was using a wi-fi jammer so there were reports of internet outages in that area and the suspect like the person in the doorbell camera looks like they're holding some sort of jammer at one point so people are wondering if it was like a signal jammer that was being used a signal jammer would indicate a higher level crime like a a much more professional crime to prevent someone using their cell phone calling the cops or or to disable the security systems but they have to be able to use the security systems so they have to be able to use the security systems so they have to be able to use the security systems so they have to be able to use he's like just walking up to the doorbell camera and just ripped it off the wall yeah so a lot of people thought it could be the cartels that are doing this what yeah and i just don't know why um i think the cartel conspiracy and theory came from the fact that nancy needs certain medications and because arizona is pretty close to the border i think that's about it i think there was like a tip that maybe she was in mexico i don't think that tip was verified it seems like the authorities have spoken to mexican authorities and it does not seem like she is in mexico at least as of right now and just the crime does not speak like cartel cartels typically when they're in the united states they like to run under the radar i mean this is like their business right so and when they want to take someone out usually it's someone involved in the cartel it's someone that's associated and they're really professional like they're highly professional so people are saying like if a cartel is coming up to your google nest your camera's getting spray painted before you can even see their face like cartels are not like that's what i'm saying this footage is weird so weird and everyone is like is this an amateur is this not an amateur and then once you say it's an amateur people are like well they haven't been caught so is it not an amateur nobody knows so what does rio rico man have anything to do with this and why is he detained rio's mom is insistent with authorities and later with the media that her son-in-law rio rico man has nothing to do with this in fact he was at home saturday and sunday the day that nancy was taken he was at home an hour away in rio rico on top of that he knows nothing about bitcoin so she's asked did he ever say anything about nancy nothing we never like i told the fbi the investigator if i knew anything about her i said i saw her on facebook but i didn't read what was going on with her because i didn't know her and i didn't have like the right to i mean i didn't want to read the story i didn't want to read the story i didn't want to read the story i just go over keep on going you know on my phone because i don't know her rio's mother-in-law argues they're just invading my property you know i i told them they're going in and out of my house taking a lot of pictures and everything i mean like i told them we're not hiding anything i gave them permission you can go and search there's nothing in my house you won't find anything because we don't have nothing to hide they broke in my house without a warrant or nothing they broke my door they went in my house my son was playing on nintendo he had his headphones on they got him put him in handcuffs and took him out to the hospital and they were like oh my god this is not real no real is her son-in-law this is her son actually right right right and then rio is out he got stopped at a traffic stop with her daughter oh oh rio's wife rio and rio's wife okay and after five hours of being detained rio rico man is released and he does a few interviews where he states the whole thing was just bizarre he says he has no idea how he even got involved in all of this it just wrapped up in this he states right now all i know is that they showed my in-law a picture of somebody wearing a mask or something and they supposedly look like my eyes that's insane he says he was honest with authorities i told them i work in tucson for gls which is a delivery service so he does doordash and gls i might have delivered a package to her house but i never kidnapped anybody he says being detained was terrifying i felt like i was being kidnapped they didn't tell me anything in the beginning they held me against my will they didn't even read me my rights until two hours later and i was like oh my god i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry later he says he kept telling them he's not involved and he thought quote what the fuck am i doing here i didn't do anything to be honest i'm innocent i hope they get the suspect because i'm not it and they better do a better job and find the suspect so that they can clear my name i'm done he says he wasn't given a proper reason why authorities thought it could be him he has an attorney now who has come out to state that his life has been altered quote and now they're living day to day they're living in fear so the first thing i'd like to see is sheriff nanos and the pima county sheriff's office come forward and say rio this was a mistake rio is not a person of interest he's not an investigative lead we messed up we need to see some accountability obviously so this was from the state yes wasn't feds or at least it doesn't seem like they were involved in the detainment i don't know if they okayed it if they were in the know you know but rio has not been formally nor publicly cleared by the sheriff or the fbi as of right now so he could still be involved there's just not enough for an arrest or he could not be involved at all which is what more people are leaning towards so this is all we know yeah and then february 13th a swat operation is executed and another man is detained he's pulled over in a gray range rover handcuffed and placed in the back of a police car his range rover is then covered with a tarp so a lot of people thought that he died like he self-exited there was like a rumor going around but they just used the tarp so that they can open the trunk and i don't know if they're looking for something someone but they don't want the public to see whatever they find so it seems like a very serious operation this is not like a little search and stop or traffic stop like this is a he got swatted his 77 year old mother was also detained and we'll call him range he lives close to nancy he has a significant criminal history possession distribution and fleeing law enforcement the range rover is then taken in to be processed by authorities it has since been released back to the state of nancy and is now back to him which leads netizens to believe that they got the wrong guy because they detained him and then released him he hasn't been formally cleared he hasn't been arrested but because of the intense swat presence everyone thought that this would be like a more fruitful arrest but it wasn't and so now netizens are confused some of them are wondering online quote are they just randomly detaining and questioning people at this point like anybody who matches the physical description is being detained now a month after the event a lot of people are starting to lose sympathy in a way some comments read my sister has been missing since 1979 nobody ever cared for her so i think they're getting frustrated the more the authorities are trying and failing because it just feels like massive resources but no results so it's not like people are upset that they're trying to find nancy i think it's more so do you guys know what you're doing are you guys like it just feels like a mess and you're spending so much resources and allocating so much personnel and are are you doing okay like is it worth it like are you getting what you're doing like it just seems so unorganized other people are commenting i wish y'all cared more about other missing people like y'all do this woman others are just saying the authorities are being so dumb they say quote we can take out other countries presidents and hours in the middle of the night but we can't find nancy guthrie stop it others are commenting distraction case to deflect from the files which we're going to get into all of that in a separate episode because i mean that one won't even really be a nancy guthrie episode it's just all of the conspiracies that people have of what this case could be covering up now i don't know if there's a cover-up i will note that sometimes people get personally involved in things like i imagine if somebody that i personally knew was affected by something i would naturally talk about it more and people are speculating that maybe it's because savannah guthrie is a peer reporting on this case and so while maybe the public also wants reporting on other cases and other things going on they personally want to stay invested in this case but i don't know how much that makes sense when you're working for like a big media corporation who typically don't care who your friends are so i don't know and i'm again not saying that this case does not deserve coverage or does not deserve to stay in the headlines as long as it has it's just i think when it's a one-off situation it's not a one-off situation it's just a one-off situation and i'm where you don't get this type of treatment for most missing persons cases people are wondering what's going on and with everything going on in the u.s i mean there's so much going on now because so much time has passed netizens have found another lead to grasp onto which is the neighbor theory there is a neighbor that lives nearby we'll call him neighbor man he lives according to him 15 minutes away and it's odd because he has been driving to nancy's house nearby nancy guthrie's house to participate in interviews of the local government people have started comparing his face to the masked man on the doorbell footage and they think that it looks like him which i mean you can't really tell also every time he does an interview a press interview he's wearing sunglasses and so everyone's like we want to see your eyeballs because we only really see the door man's face eyeballs he's just why would he keep oh like his interview is really off yeah he just starts talking about and comparing the case to bombings other major crimes he speaks about law enforcement ranting at the fact that they're at baseball games basketball games i'm sorry he's asked about what he thinks happened and he goes on a whole tirade about pointing the finger at tomaso he thinks it's tomaso and he's just okay one interview no one said anything but he shows up in a lot of interviews like random segments with random creators random tiktokers random news anchors just he's everywhere and so everyone's like why is he inserting himself into this investigation one comment just reads my gut is telling me it's you i mean he is an odd odd very odd individual maybe he thinks this is his five seconds in the limelight i don't know but not any of this is particularly damning but it is very weird there is also another picture where he's wearing this very distinct ring it looks like a high school ring you know those like graduation yes and in the gloved photo of the doorbell camera when he covers his hand it looks like there's some sort of crease that could be the doorbell camera that could indicate either a crease or a bigger ring that's not like a wedding band so people think that's odd and that's really it that's all we have we don't really have anything else everything else are more speculations more rumors more unauthenticated information i mean there's conspiracies that she's no longer alive at this point there's also conspiracies about why the fbi would not take over this case if it's a kidnapping so there's a few triggers that a case has to hit in order for it to be in fbi jurisdiction so you have to have a victim that's transported across state lines or an offender who uses interstate commerce like mail phone and internet which happened in this case or a crime on federal property or like a federal agent what do you mean mail phone and internet what does that mean i guess if you commit some sort of like internet crime that is under the fbi jurisdiction and only one of these triggers has to be triggered in order for the fbi to be in control of the case but it's not a situation where they can just force their hand and say this is our case now and it's usually not the best for them to do that because they do need help from local law enforcement as well so it is still pima county sheriff that is heading this case but people just don't like that people don't think that they're competent but then you know you have arguments on the internet that's like i don't know are the fbi that competent these days it's just no one knows i mean the authorities don't even know if it's one person two people three people multiple people if caught they might face the death penalty because that is what trump has been hinting at so what's going on with savannah and the kids and the family and all of them because i've seen some videos yeah um savannah guthrie has gone back to new york she actually just recently visited the today show she wasn't on air or anything she just went to go see her colleagues and she was like i don't know what's going on and she was like i don't know what's going on and there are pictures like paparazzi pictures through the windows and she seems really emotional but it seems like the investigation is still ongoing the fbi has pulled a lot of their personnel but i think the tucson division is still working heavily on it but fbi they have left no they haven't left but they a lot of agents there's way less agents present and investigating interesting yeah and the entire road leading up to nancy guthrie's house has been sectioned off so you cannot park your suv as like a media station legacy media was doing that you cannot set up a tent to film like the five o'clock news you cannot pose for social media pictures in front of it right so it's what was that about you were saying someone was posing yeah i think she's a social media content creator who wanted a thumbnail oh okay okay yeah and then it's just so little has happened that now the conversation is about the conversation and so now like this is what happened with the sean combs case every time there was like a lull in the case where not as explosive things were coming out during the trial days anytime we would go because we would monitor what everyone was talking not monitor but like you know see what everyone is talking about and see what questions people had it started turning into look at the people that are covering the case so that's what's happening here so a lot of legacy media is now covering social media coverage of the case. Interesting. It just feels very meta. and earlier you were saying that savannah and them they have changed their message since then yeah i mean i wouldn't they still want to bring their mother home savannah has put up a 1 million dollar reward she's also donated half a million dollars to the national center for missing and exploited children i don't know maybe she was seeing a lot of the conversations online where maybe you know this led her to do something so incredible and gracious right but yeah so that's where we are there's a million dollar reward and no one seems to still know anything again just to make it clear the family has been officially cleared by the sheriff's office and i know that especially when you read about a lot of crime cases you do think it's always closest to the victim like they must know something or they must be involved but i think in a case like this where it's getting that much coverage and that much attention we just have to hope that the authorities are doing the right thing and i think to point the finger at a relative without much substantial information is pretty reckless so i hope that i was able to comprehensively give you an overview of the conversation but again just to make it so abundantly clear the family has been cleared so with that being said that is it for today's episode let me know your thoughts and i will see you in the next one be safe

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Savannah Guthrie’s family recounts a summer tradition known as the "kidnapping game," where her cousin would visit and falsely claim to have taken them to Phoenix, creating a playful but eerie ritual.
  2. The investigation into Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance reveals significant concerns about the sheriff’s office leadership, including a history of conflict with the FBI, allegations of improper use of Rico funds, and a lack of transparency in evidence handling.
  3. Forensic evidence such as blood on the porch and black nitrile gloves found near the house were key, but their significance was questioned when DNA testing showed no match in national databases and the gloves were later linked to a restaurant worker.
  4. The sheriff’s decision to send forensic evidence to a private lab in Florida rather than to the FBI’s Quantico lab has raised concerns about evidence preservation and impartiality, with critics arguing it undermines investigative integrity.
  5. A 36-year-old delivery driver, Rio Rico man, was detained without sufficient evidence or connection to the case, sparking accusations of wrongful targeting and overreach by law enforcement.
  6. A swat operation led to the detention of another man, Range, with a criminal history, whose vehicle was covered in a tarp—raising suspicions of a failed arrest and potential misuse of force.
  7. The case has been heavily scrutinized online, with theories ranging from cartels, robbery gone wrong, to a possible cover-up, fueled by public frustration over lack of progress and perceived mismanagement.
  8. Despite the family’s official clearance, the case continues to generate intense public attention, with social media and media coverage shifting focus from investigation to speculation and criticism of law enforcement practices.

Summary:

The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie has sparked widespread public and media scrutiny, fueled by both family accounts and mounting investigations. A long-standing summer tradition involving a "kidnapping game" adds an eerie, personal dimension to the case. The Pima County Sheriff’s Office, which leads the investigation, faces criticism for its handling of evidence, including directing forensic samples to a private lab instead of federal facilities and failing to share key information with the FBI.

These actions have raised concerns about transparency and competence. Multiple detentions—such as of Rio Rico man and Range—were conducted without proven links to the case, leading to accusations of misconduct and overreach. Forensic findings, like blood and gloves, remain inconclusive, with no DNA match found.

-Mexico border. Despite the lack of concrete progress, the case remains in the public eye, driven by social media engagement and criticism of law enforcement’s reliability. Savannah Guthrie, Nancy’s daughter, has publicly supported the search with a $1 million reward and donations to missing persons organizations, emphasizing the family’s commitment.

Nevertheless, critics argue that the investigation lacks focus, is disorganized, and fails to deliver results, leading to growing public frustration and skepticism about whether the authorities are truly committed to finding Nancy or merely managing a high-profile crisis.

FAQs

It was a summer tradition where Savannah and her cousin would wake up early, drive to Phoenix, and pretend their mother had 'kidnapped' them for a playful visit. The cousin would act shocked and assure them she would return soon, but it was a recurring family game, not a real abduction.

No, the tradition was a harmless family game. Nancy's disappearance was a real event, and there is no evidence linking it to the game. The tradition is often cited as a source of confusion, but it does not explain her missing status.

Blood on the front porch tested positive for Nancy's DNA, and black nitrile gloves were found near the house. DNA not belonging to Nancy or her family was also discovered inside her home, though the significance of this evidence remains under investigation.

The sheriff claimed it was to maintain control over evidence and ensure consistency with past practices, saying it allows easier access and better coordination. Critics argue this could hinder broader forensic analysis and transparency.

The investigation noted that Nancy required daily medication, and there was no confirmed proof of life after 48 hours. Authorities expressed hope she was still alive but emphasized they had no evidence to prove her current status.

He lived nearby, had no known connection to Nancy, and was detained after authorities believed he could be involved. However, no evidence linked him to the case, and he was released after five hours without charges or formal clearance.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.