Kevin and Madison's Bachelorette Parties | "Jerry 2.0" (515)
79m 6s
This episode of *This Is Us* explores the emotional complexities of love, commitment, and personal growth through the lens of the Pearson family’s reunion at a cabin. As Kevin and Sophie navigate reconnection after years of long-distance living, their relationship faces reality checks—Sophie expresses that Kevin’s idealized future plans are unkind and unrealistic, while Kevin confronts his own romantic fantasies after watching *Jerry McGuire*. The group engages in heartfelt conversations about love, loss, and the flaws in romanticized narratives, with Toby dismissing rom-com tropes as inauthentic and Miguel and Rebecca finding healing through honest communication. The episode highlights how love is not written in the stars but built through shared experiences, vulnerability, and mutual effort. Personal stories of grief, such as Kate’s loneliness after Jack’s death and Beth’s fear of failure in a long-distance relationship, underscore the emotional weight of commitment. The group also reflects on past relationships and how they’ve evolved, affirming that love is not about perfection but about resilience and choice. Ultimately, the episode presents a realistic, grounded view of romance—one rooted in honesty, self-awareness, and the courage to stay together despite flaws. The narrative balances nostalgia with emotional maturity, reinforcing that meaningful relationships grow through shared struggles and authentic connection.
this is a head gum podcast
on today's episode of that was us we're diving into season 5 episode 15 jerry 2.0 during kevin
and madison's bachelor and bachelorette weekends doubts and cold feet begin to surface kevin
reflects on his history with sophie while the pearson family shares their own perspectives
on romance second chances and whether love is written in the stars or built over time
this episode is brought to you by netflix's new series east of eden a bold reimagining of
john steinbeck's masterpiece following generations of the trask family through love betrayal and the
choices that shape humanity starring mike feist and christopher abbott as the trask brothers
and florence pew as kathy ames the complex anti-heroine determined to build the life she
wants no matter the cost watch east of eden now only on netflix i hate mondays king's hawaiian
cinnamon swirl bite taylor hansen sure i'll try one hey let's get back to work please but taylor
hansen's making my day way better with these new soft and swirly king's hawaiian cinnamon bites
taylor hansen nice
try one
king's hawaiian cinnamon bites there's nothing like it
hello hello hello hello hello
how are we doing good this is so just full disclosure here manny and i have on the exact
same clothes chris took it upon himself i was just kidding i was just kidding i was just kidding i was
not i got hot you are you're bringing it back to like early podcast days remember we had all just
like different outfits also you took your jacket off i did take my jacket off this is true i got
warm we just had to let that out you got muscular um thank you i appreciate that i try 50 man
maintaining the the sexy at 50 is different i told you what barb said what barb said oh you did
yeah that was very sweet i'm giving i'm giving barb a shout out here so barb is
barb does hair she's my she's barb's my girl i love her she's a dear friend she does hair the
best hair in the land and she um saw sterling at an event and she came back and she was like mandy
sterling's the most beautiful man i've ever seen before i was like i know that's he's also my son
so it feels strange to say that but yes i do and she i she was like i i was gonna go up and say hi
and tell them that i knew you but then i just felt weird i was like if anybody
would give you a hug it would be sterling well and now we know there's no fist bumps
yeah there's no picture it's all hugs barb i prefer to hug get a hug barb i really do get a
hug have you guys seen this tangent is it barb and go to vista del mar yeah yeah yeah barb and star
or barb and i've heard it's the best movie ever it's really good mandy it's so good you'll pee
on yourself oh god i love especially after three kids like drenched wait and who it's wig and who
it's wig and her writing partner what's her name she's
so good barb annie mamalow annie mamalow is in rooster have you guys watched rooster i watched
the pilot of rooster keep going keep going is it great it's great you love she is so funny
annie mamalow she's his watch barb and star okay she's great in rooster she's really funny in
rooster i love that show okay yeah i will watch rooster who else what people watching right now
this is a this is a new podcast what are you watching what are you guys watching even amy
bowler wins all the awards and and half of her questions are what makes you laugh these days
what are you watching what are you watching she wins all the awards she wins all these she wins
all the awards in my book i watch the pit i'm a big fan of the pit anybody in the pit no
i have to watch something before i go to bed that gives me anxiety i'm not gonna do it i need to
watch rooster i need to watch something that rooster is light and then i can go to bed understood
how's it go and i can sleep
have you you yeah i've seen the pip season one have you seen again in season two season and a
half i've seen season and a half yeah they're about at a season and a half yeah i think the
work that they're doing is pretty oh i don't doubt it i watched one episode and i was like yeah it's
not for me i can't i can't it's too real yeah it's too real i've seen this there was an episode
about a kid in a pool and i was like i will absolutely not watch that yeah it's like that
don't you remember ever people saying the same thing to you about our show yeah yeah and you get
it and it's like you know maybe one day i will be in the frame of mind where i can watch that stuff
but it's like right now i'm like but by then there'll be new stuff to watch yeah i was telling
you about stand up to uh nikki glazer's got a special on hulu um but also uh kevin hart's got
this comedy show on netflix and it's called funny af and he's looking at like these upcoming comedians
and they have like this whole thing because this was the week of uh netflix funny or dire whatnot
they have a big comedy festival here yeah so this was building up to something i i again i think one
of the reasons why i wanted the roast for the party is that i have such awe and reverence for
the the medium of stand-up uh it's probably the thing that i watch more than anything else me too
because i've always said to myself i'm gonna do five minutes one day i'm gonna do i could see that
i'm gonna do it one day and it's gonna happen it's gonna be fun
but i just feel like the to take things that are deeply personal from your life and to find the
comedic spin on them that doesn't that elevates the energy of the room but doesn't make it may
make them a little uncomfortable but then also give them this release yeah it's that's a gift
man chris have you seen rory scoville oh yeah what's rory's going oh yeah i took taylor to
see him at the at largo okay so we went and just saw him at largo like a couple weeks ago
i have never laughed so hard he's insane like my abs hurt i was like oh this is a good workout
i he has a special like on amazon or something he has a new special that he just taped that's
coming out of what he's been performing yeah it what i was like this is unhinged how funny this
is and how oh my god well thank you for that introduction what scoville scoville s-c-o-v-e-l
okay i think he's maybe and he's on rooster that's what made me think of it yeah he has a
bit part of well i it's just like it's a i listen steve carrell could get it okay yeah cock-a-doodle-doo
yeah he is a silver fox he's a handsome guy oh yeah he's just like i mean he could be my dad but
like i yeah he is so funny i don't follow up he could get it with he's like my dad don't mandy
we can't click this no i'm 62 years old okay he's what 63 i mean technically he's gonna be a young
dad yeah he can't get it
hey steve i say that with affection and respect wanna come on the pod he's dan's neighbor you
know he is dan's neighbor i like that so in watching the pilot the young lady who plays
his daughter is incredible everyone on the show is great and there's something else i know there's
a cop who kind of comes in oh shit he's a piece yes he's because his stuff is so small but
everything he does but you could tell they were like yeah he's so good yeah we have to build his
character more and sometimes like now we're taylor and i're watching the show and they're like
they just like hanging around him because he's so funny and he's so good he's great it's like
part sometimes you're like there's no reason that a cop would be there but it's like hilarious yeah
it's so good what's the cop at the hockey game okay sure are you a bill lawrence person like
are you a lasso i knew bill back in the day because of scrubs okay um and he's so lovely
um and i did at that first season of ted lasso is how i felt about rooster where you're like
this is what we need in the world right now like it's sweet and it's funny but it feels like this
balm of like just goodness i got you like bill is really good at putting like goodness in the
world you know what i mean shrinking and like they're all just like they make you feel good
they're not complicated in a you know annoying way yeah if we could have bill lawrence and
mike sure running everything dan vogelman yes yeah well it's a reason those three guys are
powerhouses they're good people and they make good things that like inherently make you feel good
sure is good place right yeah yeah and parks and rec yeah yeah yeah he's great okay anyway i guess
we should talk about it about our show i do love watching though this is us this is great and that
was us
uh rewatch podcast talk about bringing good into the world
it's the eyes closed it's the eyes
it's the eyes closed and the mouth wide
that that was a podcast okay okay it's a head gum podcast this is interesting because i was as i
was looking at the title of the the cherry 2.0 i was like what does this mean what does this have
anything to do with and they open up and they open up and they open up and they open up and they open up
and jack and kev are at the movies yeah and they're watching this movie and we don't get
a chance to see what the movie is yeah but they both like just turn and look at each other and
just like best movie ever right and i still wasn't remembering yeah what the reference
was what right what could it be all right who do you want to start with let's start with the
the college big three okay everyone's back in pittsburgh yep yeah pilot season didn't work out
for kev he's back home he's with sophie they're reunited yeah because they've been living long
distance they've been living long distance and he is very nonchalant about it like we're back
together it was great i'll probably end up back in california because that's just like well she
says a couple times i'm glad that that's over yeah i'm glad we don't have to yeah let's we put a pin
in that didn't you did it it didn't work and now you're back because clearly long distance is never
great kevin yeah it's not great no yeah for anybody it's not ideal
like the that was us podcast that is ideal beth got an internship offer but the internship is in
boston that's right so she hasn't not ideal hasn't decided what she's gonna do yet because
it would mean that her and randall would have to be long distance the whole group is also heading
to the cabin yep the uh the college big three they're headed
with mom kate is solo she's sort of making fun of herself about being what like the fifth wheel
or something yeah yeah and and randall and beth are still talking about this potential long
distance that's looming kevin keeps talking about how it's not a really big deal and sophie kind of
finally admits like hey can you stop doing that because it was actually really hard for me yeah
i don't i don't like that you keep saying that like yeah it was cute i guess at first but now
it's like that like no that's that wasn't the reality that wasn't my reality at least right
yep and he kind of insists that i'm sorry but like i am gonna my manager told me like if i want to make
it i'm going to have to spend some more time in los angeles i'm sorry i am a walking red flag i'm yeah
exactly get out while you can okay get out while you can and sophie sophie storms out they're they're
at the cabin i should say at this point not really a huge jump but uh they start to watch jerry mcguire
yeah right um and kevin comments how he's
saw this movie with dad and how much he loved it uh at some point beth kind of like leaves i don't
know if she's she's going to the kitchen maybe to get something from the fridge or something and
sees rebecca in the um in the kitchen and she sort of stops her rebecca does and she was like oh by
the way i haven't like been able to say but congratulations on this internship in boston
like that's a really big deal and beth is appreciative she knows you know she's like
i'm not i'm not worried about randall i'm rebecca's like i'm not worried about you guys either and
and the long distance she's like i'm just worried that it's going to be um it's intense and if i'm
not amazing at it i really can't endure any more failure like i just feel like i have failed with
dance um and uh she kind of mentions that like i don't know if randall's told you but i used to
dance and rebecca's like oh i can relate i don't know if randall told you but i used to sing yeah
she's like ah touche essentially and so she gets it and that's kind of like the
end of the conversation right yeah more or less like she just admits that's what's like preventing
me from saying yes to this relationship it's not the distance that might be that might potentially
come between randall and i it's that like this is this this firm for this urban planning like it's
a really special thing to be a part of but if it doesn't work out and if i'm not as good as i want
to be like i i don't know what i'm going to do with myself essentially right right kevin has this
sort of back to him watching the movie of jerry mcguire
the movie ends you know we'll remember that sophie has sort of stormed out so it's just
him watching it with kate and and uh randall and beth yeah and he has this like epiphany
the spiritual experience watching the movie and he's like hold on and he runs upstairs and you're
like what is he doing right so he comes back downstairs having written a mission statement
like jerry and sophie has come back at this point right and he kind of like declares
everything their future what their future is going to be yeah and and he he can see it so
clearly now right is that essentially he's going to be a successful actor we're going to get married
and we're gonna have kids like i can see it all so clearly like it's all together like you're part
of it right yes yeah like my life includes you yes we're going to accomplish all of these things
that i i want but we're going to do it together essentially yeah
and then this sort of uh kind of like dovetails with rebecca getting a call from miguel which
kind of dovetails with them present day as well but miguel calls the cabin he's like i was just
checking in on you guys like i think i called the house and i didn't hear from you and i wanted to
make sure you're okay um and essentially um you know she's talking about how strange it is to be
the cabin with all of these kids in this particular juncture of their lives right
married randall and beth are paired up kate obviously is she's flying solo but it's just
how it's made her sort of realize that maybe that part of her life isn't done
either yeah maybe there's still some capacity of love of having love in a romantic sense
that she hasn't really ever considered before but since jack passed away that she's open to
and it's just interesting it's like she's just kind of like
to this conclusion and just telling a good friend about it i mean obviously it's sweet foreshadowing
of like oh we know what's gonna happen you know if you're uh if you're if you're um if you're open
to something like that uh then i think uh love will find a way yeah like he was he says he says
of course you're you're you're uh you're you're i love you i love you
say it back say it back say it back
i love when we make these guys laugh more that was us after this short break
sleep sets the stage for the rest of your day it's the time when your body quietly goes to
work to heal your mind and body steady your mood and generally restore your energy so you can show
up at work home and throughout life rested and ready
when sleep feels like a struggle it affects everything your energy your focus your patience
productivity they all depend on getting high quality sleep boy do we know that as parents
if you've noticed changes in your sleep patterns or experience symptoms like snoring or excessive
daytime tiredness sleep doctor can help you find a way back to great sleep i need this you guys i
need this in my life we can move past the guesswork to help you understand exactly what's happening
while you are asleep so you can stop powering through the day and start living in it i'll tell
you what sleep doctor offers you guys sleep doctor offers guidance and solutions for all your sleep
problems not sure where to start a sleep consult with a licensed sleep expert or our clinical grade
home sleep study provides the professional insight you need to uncover the root of your fatigue
the test is a simple and affordable alternative to a sleep lab and can be completed in your own bed
over one night and you can sleep well in your own bed and you can sleep well in your own bed and you
can sleep well in your own bed and you can sleep well in your own bed and you can sleep well at night
no more guessing just clear answers and a path back to the rest you deserve
if you've been overlooking your sleep while optimizing everything else this may be the
missing piece visit sleepdoctor.com to stop guessing about your sleep and take the first
step to waking up rested and ready we just finished sort of assembling an outdoor kitchen
situation complete with a grill so this is summer is here and this is going to be our first time
grilling at our house outside i'm so excited i love that smell when people in the neighborhood
start grilling and you're like oh right it's summer tis the season should i go say hi to my
neighbors yeah wouldn't that be a good time yeah that little that little smell wafts and grabs you
by the nostrils like a cartoon and pulls you over the fence into their yard you guys you guys know
what i'm talking about my kids just had hot dogs for the first time for the first time the first
time i'm a paranoid mom because they're choking hazard so i was a little scared i was a little scared
even though you could cut them up yeah but my boys are obsessed with hot dogs now yeah so this is
going to be the season where i master the outdoor grill and my husband too with the hot dog shipped
to the rescue ship to the rescue with shipped it's never just delivery because you can get groceries
more anything that you need same day shopped in the same way that you would listen with exceptional
attention to detail shoppers with shipped ensure your items are shopped and delivered with the
utmost care yeah and you can order from different stores sometimes you need food sometimes you were
saying you need all kind so we can order from safeway albertsons michaels target pet smart
as well as at local grocery stores in your particular area use code podcast to get a year
of shipped for only 49 that's half off the regular 99 price at shipped.com slash offer that's s-h-i-p-t.com
slash offer terms apply this episode is brought to you by
netflix's new series east of eden a bold reimagining of john steinbeck's masterpiece
following generations of the trask family through love betrayal and the choices that shape humanity
starring mike feist and christopher abbott as the trask brothers and florence pew as kathy ames the
complex anti-heroine determined to build the life she wants no matter the cost watch east of eden now
only on netflix i hate mondays
kinks hawaiian cinnamon swirl bite uh taylor hansen sure i'll try one
hmm
Hey, let's get back to work, please.
But Taylor Hansen's making my day way better
with these new soft and swirly King's Hawaiian Cinnamon Bites.
Taylor Hansen? Nice.
Try one.
Mmm.
King's Hawaiian Cinnamon Bites.
There's nothing like it.
This episode is brought to you by Palmolive.
Family time isn't just the big moments.
It's weeknight dinners.
Sitting around the table, everyone talking all at once.
So when the plates are empty and the sink is full,
use Palmolive Ultra.
Palmolive's most powerful formula removes up to 99.9% of grease,
leaving your dishes sparkling clean.
And the new convenient pump makes cleaning even easier,
so you can spend less time tackling dishes and more time together.
Shop now at palmolive.com.
Time table.
How long has Jack been gone, do you think?
Has it been over a year?
It's got to be less than two years.
It's less than two years.
Less than two years.
Over a year, less than two.
Okay.
That sounds right.
17 months.
Sure.
I like that ballpark.
My wife, every once in a while, asks me this question.
Like, would you remarry if something happened to me?
Like, if she passed away or whatnot.
I'm like, not for a few months.
Out of respect.
What is this?
Ham?
Hamlet?
You know what I'm saying?
Oh, man.
What can I say, Ryan?
Time marches on.
What is your answer?
It's something to that effect.
But like, I. Of a few months?
No.
Not the same effect.
But I was like, would you want me to live the rest of my life mourning your loss?
She said yes.
Yeah, she did.
Yeah, she did.
But that's not. I don't think. She says that now.
But I actually believe. But she would be dead and wouldn't know the difference.
There you go.
I actually believe that she wouldn't want that.
Yeah, I don't think she would.
Like, I think she says that in the moment or whatnot.
But like, when I think about, like, if something happened to me, and if love found its way
into Ryan Michelle's life, nothing would make me happier.
Same.
Nothing would make me happier.
Same, same, same.
Yes, of course.
And I feel like, you know, everybody has to go through a necessary grieving process.
But then you also have to allow yourself.
You also have to allow yourself the possibility of experiencing all that life has to offer
while you are still alive.
Do you know what I'm saying?
Life is too short to deny yourself.
That's right.
That's it.
Okay.
That's right.
So that's the past.
So that's the past.
Should we do. There's a lot of ways to go.
Well, how about Randall?
What about Randall?
I mean, it's tough.
Well, Randall just sort of ties into. I know.
They all. This tricky show.
You can do Cabin Cabin.
You can do Present and Past.
All right.
Let's do Cabin Cabin.
And the Present. Well, it does start off. The intro to it is Randall dressed in this fishing gear, which I was like,
Holla, this is one of the best sight gags that I've ever seen in the show.
Yeah.
Because I cracked up instantly.
And Beth was into it.
She was so into it.
Yeah.
Beth is like, who is this man that has replaced my husband?
I have a thing for fishermen now.
She's like, evidently, I like fishermen, right?
Yeah.
Field and stream.
We could. Field and stream.
It's going to be me and Toby and Nikki in Cabin Cabin.
It doesn't sound like it's going to be like a crazy time.
He just wants to go fishing and hang out.
He's like, you're going to put the ho and Poconos?
And he's like, no, we're putting the A and Earl Grey.
Earl Grey, right?
It's going to be much more low-key.
We've seen bachelor and bachelorette parties before, and those took place in Vegas.
They didn't go much better.
No, but they were like. Wilder.
Your idea of like what a bachelor and bachelorette party is.
Did anybody else find it so sad, though?
I was like, oh, they really have no friends.
They really have no friends.
This is where TV writers. They really write themselves into a corner where it's like, well, I guess either we have
a bunch of extras come in or this lady ain't got no friends.
Or it has to be the. Like, you have to have such a large cast in order to honor all those people and to like
give some good actors an opportunity to work where they don't get a chance to be there
that often.
It's hard to hold people.
Yeah.
You brought in four dudes to be Toby's friend.
Toby's got all the friends.
Toby's got friends.
He's healthy.
Nerd squad.
Yeah.
This family, it's just like, nope, it's only family.
It's just family, right?
Yeah.
So before we take off, like, we start a little makeout session and he goes to take off his
boots and she says, uh-uh.
Keep them on.
Keep them off.
You can leave your boots on.
It's Beth about to knock Randall's boots, which is probably incredibly delightful.
Yeah, 100%.
We depart on just old people, just old people bachelor and bachelorette parties.
Yeah.
Just real tame.
We're at the cabin and I say to my brother when he gets. Oh, he gets there because they all come in on a private jet because they're fancy coming
from LA or whatnot.
Well, they're COVID too.
Oh, there's COVID too.
There's COVID too.
Fancy and COVID.
I got the football, which is my favorite prop, if you haven't noticed.
Anytime Brown can hold a football, he will hold a football.
And Dan didn't put me on the land.
Anyway.
Nobody loves football more than Sterling.
Nobody.
Yeah.
Dan likes it a lot.
I know.
Well, look, there's more time.
There's more time.
Let's tell our audience real quick, though.
Kevin might be a big actor, but he's not a big actor.
He's not a big actor.
He's not a PJ actor.
Yeah.
You know what?
How do we find. He's definitely spending money to do the PJ, for sure.
I bet you. Well, if Kevin's not, Justin probably is.
No, I bet he's not.
Oh, you know he is.
No, I don't know.
I'm just saying.
After a couple of years of Tracker. Oh, sure.
Yeah, he's probably. He's rocking the PJ.
Good for him.
My wife asked, she's like, can we take a private?
I'm like, well, who are you?
Who do you think we are?
We could take Jet Sweet X.
I love JSX.
I love JSX.
I've never done it.
It's great.
It's dope?
Yeah.
Okay.
All right, I'll do it.
It's a private thing with you.
It's not.
It's not.
It's not private?
No, no.
No.
It's just local.
It doesn't go very far.
Quick tangent.
I was talking to some friends of mine like a week and a half ago before we were going
to Stanford about how I was flying Southwest, right?
And they were like, are you for real?
I was like, it's a direct flight.
You know, I'm going from here to San Francisco.
Keep it simple.
Keep it sweet.
Da, da, da, da.
And I said, every once in a while, people will look at you and be like, are you?
And I'm like, yeah.
Hey, how you doing?
And then they started talking about like, well, what would keep you from doing Spirit?
And I was like, you know what?
I've never actually had a chance.
But I hear like the hidden prices are the things that get you.
Spirit is no longer.
Yeah, it's gone.
Yeah.
Like within a week and a half.
But dude, you fly JSX up north.
I mean, it's, they're $300.
It's not like a-
Yeah.
Okay, okay, okay.
And there's no security.
Anyway.
They come in from the private plane and whatnot.
And Randall sort of tells his brothers like, hey, man, you did it.
Like, you really did it.
You remember last Thanksgiving when you said, by the time I'm-
By the time I'm 40, I want to be married with kids or whatnot.
Like, it's happened.
Like, it may have done it in the wrong order or something.
But like, here we are.
And you see Kev still, his brain is still reeling from that thing that Zoe said in the
last episode, right?
Like, okay.
His wheels are spinning.
They say it's supposed to rain, but I don't think that God's going to do that to you.
And then as he says it, pretty much the rain comes down and the gents are confined to the
cabin for the rest of this trip, right?
Yeah.
They decide to pop in Jerry Maguire.
Same way that they're going to pop in.
Same way that they did in the past, right?
And everybody has, like, some interesting reactions to it.
I say, like, oh, man, this movie still holds up.
It's good.
Like, what do you think, Kev?
And he's like, yeah, it's pretty cool.
It's like, dude, it's like you had a religious experience the first time we saw it.
Now you seem much more muted by the whole thing, right?
And then Nicky.
I love Griffin Dunn so much.
Go for it.
I can see how you relate to this movie.
It's practically your life.
Just like a vaudeville star comes in.
And Kevin's a little confused.
Like, what?
How is this my life?
Yeah.
I mean, and he just relates, like.
Wait, I think I found, I wrote some of it down.
This is funny.
It's practically your life on film.
Yeah, you're like Jerry Maguire 2.0.
And let's, because Jerry has this thing, does this huge profession of his love at the end
and sweeps her off her feet and blah, blah, blah, and they're going to live happily ever
after.
But there is like a certain era of movie that is post romantic, like, like post, I don't
know when it is, but you look back now and it's just all like, this isn't healthy.
Yeah.
This isn't even, this is barely romantic.
Yeah.
This is like love bomb.
Like some, some.
That he fell in love with the kid and then kind of just stayed with the woman out of
convenience essentially.
And he's like, well, you fell in love with the idea.
You fell in love with the idea of kids and now you got the kids and now you're just going
to stay with Madison because it's convenient kind of.
That's what he was alluding to.
Yeah.
And there's a certain amount of, of, of me like looking back on these movies.
It's like, yeah, of course, romantic, these ideas sweeping each other off our feet.
What are we doing?
What are we even doing?
This is crazy.
Yeah.
This is crazy.
Is this crazy?
Should we do this?
Like that type of movie.
Sure.
It's just like, no, it's crazy.
And you both need therapy and this isn't going to work out.
So.
I've been to these weddings.
So here's the thing.
The rom-com is sort of like, not come and gone completely, but they're not being made in
the same volume that they were.
You can't afford to anymore.
Once upon a time.
Yeah.
Right.
My, I used to get like, Rye used to read these romantic novels and I would see like how they
would infect our lives in terms of like, how come you can't be like this and dah, dah,
dah.
I was like, well, that's, that's a book, right?
Like that's a.
Not reality.
It's not reality per se.
but now I'm scared.
of like on the other side of it and not that you there should be some sort of post-mortem
more than likely because things don't typically in like just happily ever after they they're happy
and then they're not happy and then they're happy and then they're not happy but i do think that
there's something beautiful about about sort of the aspirations of love being put out into the
world sure so i'm just taking the opposite side because like as they've been gone i'd miss them
i miss the rom-coms sure i do too i really do like there's a way that you felt after you left
it like i'm gonna hold your hand and squeeze you and hold you tight and that like we don't get as
much of anymore maybe maybe it is maybe there's too much reality now not enough romance that's
i don't know i second that so okay so so nikki says this and it really gets under kevin's skin
we go we go to commercial it comes back
and cancer's like hey man still staring at him hey man what the is it yeah that was mean
he says that was mean and rude yeah he's like i know you're not used to talking to people and
also mean show up at somebody's bachelor party and just blow it up man he's like i'm with madison
because i'm crazy about madison and you can you don't believe it coming out of his mouth because
i'm crazy about her you feel the room collectively go like okay yeah like everyone shifts like oh is
that what we're going with you're crazy about her you really sold that one i'm with her because i am
crazy about her and that's what the script told me to say crazy about her i'm crazy about her okay
so far toby i don't think has had a word in in this in this episode and he's just like
before we popped in the movie like randall tried to ask you like hey tobias you've been quiet for a
minute like what's going on with you before you could even get anything out yeah it got moved on
that's gonna get steamrolled over right so so the vibe of the party is now off uh kev kev goes to the
bedroom what have you and and randall comes in and checks on him and he says like how do you
ever really know if you're like marrying the right person yeah which i think has a very sort of like
interesting echo and i don't even know if it's a good thing or not i don't think it's a good thing
i don't know if it's a good thing or not i don't even know if it's a good thing or not
for for tobias for for kev right and and even for randall who i think is the person in the
history of the show has been most concrete on his choices but even in season three they had
their moments of like sort of just the answer is you don't know like i asked myself this question
like we all entered into the the three of us have entered into this institution
of matrimony right second time the second was obviously three of us oh three of us the three of
us not together right and there is even though the statistics i think we're at 51 now say that they
end right before death right because we chose to you still enter into it with like all right it's
gonna be different for me or i'm gonna be on that 49 or whatever the the case may be and it takes a
certain level of faith um belief whatever it is to even think that you should be in the minority right
right yeah it's not there is no guarantee right and i think that's the thing that is most
interesting about it for me this is just the tangent of life is like when i proposed to ryan
michelle bathe and i bought this ring it was the happiest i had ever been to spend that there was
the biggest expense i'd ever made in my life and i was like and it was the happiest i'd been with the
expenditure because i was like she's gonna like this and it's important to me that she likes this
as we start this next sort of journey into life right we've been married for 20 years now blessed
right thank you very much and have gone through all the emotions throughout the course of marriage
right yeah and and and moments of like ah we're gonna make it not 100 sure right we go to therapy
we we take moments of just sort of self-reflection or whatnot and you make a decision together
collectively because both people have to decide to stay on the train at the same time
otherwise you know it doesn't work and then there are times in which we'll explore as we get into
like tobias and and and kate where they mutually decide like you know what maybe it has run its
course i've i've heard my cousin who's gotten divorced say like people act like divorce is a
failure and she says well maybe i was just supposed to be married for that amount of time
mm-hmm and i got from that amount of time exactly what i was supposed to get um i think that can be
very very true because you were talking about in the last episode that we're just a generation
removed from or generation and a half two generations from people who just stayed married
and stayed angry and resentful and just hateful towards one another yeah openly yeah yeah nobody
wants that yeah so so he asked the question he's like you know what man come on let's go outside
everybody's sitting around the fire uh he said gentlemen we have been off our game today
uh i've got a we got a brother over here with a case of cold feet like let's have some real talk
essentially let's have some real talk about what's going on with everybody and how we can sort of
pour into this dude and the first person who goes is you is it tobias yeah yeah what do you what do
you share i loved this night of shooting by the way sitting around the fire yeah that must have
been so fun i love a night like that where it's set up it's comfortable yeah it's something we'd
probably be doing anyways like if we were hanging out sure you know there's no heavy lifting involved
everybody has a nice something to say yeah um and yeah toby steps up and and and essentially
gives his his rom-com superhero monologue yeah i'm i'm the king i'm the king of rom-coms and he he
essentially takes the the negative view of jerry maguire yeah now it's like wait a minute they're
not gonna make it yeah that's not how you build a relationship yeah like just going back to what
you were saying earlier in this conversation because you sort of taken the same stance as toby
rom-coms are meant i think for people who aren't necessarily married sure do you understand yeah
because then once you get into it you're like that's not howard yeah it's not called reality tv
yeah it's called a rom-com yeah should be called sci-fi uh
nothing nothing annoys me more uh than the end of um what's the what's the the love british love
movie that comes out at christmas time actually love actually nothing annoys me more than that
movie first of all i put it it might be the worst movie i've ever seen i i listen wow that is real
shots fired people keep a hot take for sure but homeboy with the cards at the end we we didn't know
much to that in paradise i love that listen that's like one of dan's favorite movies it's fine but
it's so creepy him at the door with with her this is just like with his best friend this is him and
he's like like and this is great podcasting and mouthing words well you should be watching it on
hulu yeah so these these types of tropes i don't know they make you mad they make me see it's funny
because like i have this very sort of strong connection to what i call the triumvirate which is
um about a boy love movie love actually and notting hill yeah great movies like i love them
i feel like we're nothing without our hot takes that's right listen nothing without a hot take
everybody loves that every i've never met another person who doesn't like that movie
i understand that i'm on the outside come at us guys in the comments and an old girl when they're
like in the uh on the adult entertainment set and they're like having a short this cat martin
shows like martin short martin freeman i was like martin short it's not in that movie i don't think
sterling likes this movie at all yeah i'm not saying there aren't funny moments in the movie
but but just that sort of like
idealized romanticism is something that you think needs to be checked and also like i just picture
like if that had happened to me like or you know what i mean like if my best friend showed up at my
house and was like sending secret messages i just need you to know that i love you no matter what
and i had to go to i had to go to the fedex office to get these giant poster boards and i had to buy
one of those oversized sharpies to write these letters out so you could see them from a distance
because i don't want to say these things in front of you
your guests but know this i am sexually attracted to you it doesn't matter if you're with my best
friend anyways have a good christmas anyways merry christmas it's like what like this could
turn into a horror film really quickly oh my god she gets abducted off the front steps
what's interesting about this i love your take versus mine because there's this
synchronicity of actor and character that's transpiring because when you finish saying
everything
you say brandel says to you you're going to be okay the both of you are going to be okay that's
right oh wow and it's all parallel right it's all like parallel he can't he's the pressure that we
heard about
in the episode before is getting to him.
Yeah.
He's like, I really need a job.
Like, I really, really, really, really need a job.
This whole opinion was brought to you by,
I need a job.
Yeah.
It's the first time that we heard mention
of an offer from San Francisco,
but you can't really take an offer
when you got two kids at home.
Clearly, I wouldn't consider that.
Entertain that.
I shouldn't, right, guys?
Guys?
I shouldn't consider that.
That's not the end of my marriage, right?
Right?
If I did this?
What do you guys think around this fire?
Should I go and buy a house
without consulting my wife up in San Francisco?
When we get there?
Oh, man.
When we get there, I was like,
come on, bro.
What's going on?
When we get there.
Then Nicodemus.
Nicodemus is next, right?
Yeah.
Nicodemus.
Tobias and Nicodemus.
We're going biblical right now.
There's a spinoff.
There should be.
Uncle Nicky and Toby.
I'd watch it.
I'd totally watch it.
And he says, like, he admits to acting out.
He said, I had one chance at love 50 years ago.
And I blew it.
Wow.
You whiffed it, yeah.
I totally blew it.
And so me sort of speaking out against you
is sort of me sort of acting out against myself.
And he apologized, which was cool to see, right?
Then what does Kev say?
Or what do I?
He didn't say anything.
I think then it's Miguel.
Oh, Miguel.
Then it's Miguel.
Talks about things being written in the stars.
Yeah.
Some things are written in the stars,
like Rebecca and your dad.
Yeah.
And when things started with me and Rebecca,
I knew it wasn't like that for us.
Yeah.
Which is also fine.
Yeah.
Not every story's written in the stars.
Other stories, love stories are written together.
To go on poster board that you hold up as flashcards.
Sure.
For your best friend.
Yeah, yeah.
There's those stories, too.
Do you guys, like, I feel like we all are blessed enough.
Let me not put words into that.
We probably would relate our current relationships
to more of a Jack and Rebecca vibe.
But, like, I can't imagine what that was.
Like, the character of Miguel, just for a second.
Like, the level of, like, ire that he inspired from the audience.
But, like, what this dude has endured
and continues to show up, right?
Like, that's a special, that's a special person.
I don't know if I'm necessarily equipped
to forever be in the shadow of another dude.
Yeah.
And who he necessarily is, like,
I can't feel too bad about it because he was my dude, too.
Like, I love this guy.
Like, I get why the shadow looms as large as it does, right?
But maybe that's what makes it easier.
Yeah?
Yeah.
Because he understands and respects the level of, like,
love and admiration the world and his family had for him
because he had it, too.
And so it's like, it doesn't feel like a threat to him.
Yeah.
Maybe it's, like, back in the day when, like, brothers used to, like,
die in the war and then the wife would marry the other brother.
Yeah.
Take care of Clarice for me.
Yeah, and then. Like that.
Yeah.
Whatever you do, don't let Helen out of your sight.
And brother says, buddy, I won't.
Buddy, you better believe that.
Helen, we're married now.
He's dead.
He's dead.
So maybe it's like that.
Yeah, it's like that.
Probably just like that.
With Miguel and Rebecca.
So that is the end of the cabin, right?
It's the end of the cabin.
I will just say that. Just little wrap-ups.
Little wrap-ups.
Like, Miguel has been so worried this entire time about Rebecca.
Yep.
Rebecca's at Madison's bachelorette party.
He's worried because he's not there.
He's been with her, like, watching her like a hawk for the last, you know, year.
Whenever she got her diagnosis.
And she insists before they both part, like, my meds are working.
I'm going to be with my family.
Like, there's really nothing.
You should go and enjoy, like, give me, like, a little bit of breathing room, essentially.
And he's worried the whole time he's at the cabin because he can't get a hold of her.
And there's, like, a cute. What was the line?
Like, when you finally, like, connect with Kate or something, you're like, Rebecca's fine.
They're just painting, like, naked. They're painting, like, a naked man right now.
That's Miguel's line.
Oh, Miguel's.
Yeah, yeah.
Oh, good news.
Rebecca's fine.
I mean, she's just painting a portrait of a naked man with the other wives.
Yeah.
That's good.
Such a good line.
That's good.
Such a good line.
But at the end of this sort of Rebecca and Miguel finally talk on the phone, she's just gotten home.
He apologized for sort of, like, hovering, right?
Yeah.
And being in limbo.
Yes.
And they kind of look at the stars together.
Yes.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, they look at the sky together.
What's the sky look like?
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's very sweet.
More That Was Us after these words from our sponsors.
You guys, we've been talking about Article for a long time now.
Our entire podcast is furnished by Article.
Our live show when we did that, also furnished by Article.
We love everything we've received.
And we've ordered from all different kind of genres, and it all seems to go together.
Yeah, it's like mid-century.
It's Scandi-designed.
It's coastal.
It's just kind of like a little bit of everything, but somehow it's incredibly easy to mix and match and help create a space that feels like home.
It feels cohesive and also very stylish.
It pulls together.
And we're talking about something that is quality, and we don't have to compromise.
Article takes great care in curating its collection, focusing solely on high-quality, meaningful pieces that will stand the test of time.
And Article also offers fast, affordable shipping across the U.S. and Canada with options for professional assembly if you prefer a hands-off experience.
Yeah, but they have support when you need it, and they also have a 30-day satisfaction guarantee.
I love it.
Please, do not fret.
Shop with confidence.
Article is offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more.
To claim, visit article.com slash TWU, and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout.
That's article.com slash TWU for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more.
Gang, my family and I took a road trip recently.
Yeah.
And there's something about being in a car for an extended period of time that reminds me of this.
It's us, right?
It's everybody talking.
Somebody's telling an old story.
Somebody else remembers it completely differently.
What's your favorite road trip memory?
I love taking road trips right now with my kids.
Like, they talk about it forever.
They talk about stuff we did even two years ago.
Really?
Things that I can't believe they would remember.
Places we stopped and restaurants and little toys that they got.
I mean, it goes such a long way, I think, at these specific ages.
Yeah.
And truthfully, the Pearsons also spent half of their lives talking in cars.
This is serious.
Seriously.
But that's what I love about road trips.
You get these long stretches where you're not rushing anywhere.
You're just experiencing the trip.
And that's, you know what?
That's getting harder to do these days.
Exactly, sir.
Which is why I had this moment halfway through the trip where I thought,
my house is just sitting empty right now.
And meanwhile, you're out creating memories somewhere else.
And it got me thinking about listing my space on Airbnb while I'm away.
The challenge isn't the idea.
It's finding time to manage everything.
Yes, yes.
Especially when you're in a car.
Especially with schedules as busy as ours.
And that is why Airbnb's co-host network is such an interesting option.
Game changer.
You can hire a vetted local co-host to help handle all the logistics.
Yeah.
This is the kind of support that has been holding me back from doing this.
It's like, I don't know if I have the time to be-
Or the bandwidth.
Or the bandwidth.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
The human bandwidth.
Yeah, truly.
To welcome a guest, make sure they have everything they need.
Yes.
Make sure the place is well taken care of, well stocked, all of these things.
You need a co-host, bro.
A co-host can help with guest communication, reservations, on-site support, all of that.
Which means I can spend less time checking my phone and more time enjoying the trip that
I am actually on.
If you are interested in listing your space on Airbnb, find a co-host at airbnb.com slash
host.
This episode is brought to you by Netflix's new series, East of Eden.
A bold reimagining of John Steinbeck's masterpiece following generations of the Trask family
through love, betrayal.
And the choices that shape humanity.
Starring Mike Feist and Christopher Abbott as the Trask brothers.
And Florence Pugh as Kathy Ames.
The complex anti-heroine determined to build the life she wants.
No matter the cost.
Watch East of Eden now.
Only on Netflix.
Ugh, I hate Mondays.
King's Hawaiian cinnamon swirl bite?
Taylor Hansen?
Sure, I'll try one.
Mmm.
Hey, let's get back to work, please.
But Taylor-
Taylor Hansen's making my day way better with these new soft and swirly King's Hawaiian
cinnamon bites.
Taylor Hansen?
Nice.
Try one.
Mmm.
Bites.
Jibba-dabba-doo.
Don't you love them?
Sweet swirling is all good.
So when the plates are empty, you can have a good time.
And when the sink is full, use Palmolive Ultra.
Miguel calls the cabinet strange.
Rebecca, maybe there's some version of love right
and then you can really see the stars cabin present nikki looking for sally we see nikki
looking for sally on his phone toby is considering the san francisco job he calls them leaves a
message like i want to be in the running leaves the message randall's texting texting beth right
i was texting beth in bed as kev okay so earlier was this i'm confused timeline wise is this at
the top of 515 or the bottom of 514 that sophie reaches out to kev i think this is in 515 it's
all in 515 okay so we can just move because that's part of this one i know that sophie
reaches out to kev at the top of this episode yeah okay and says that she saw him on the people
magazine and saw that he was getting married with the kids and she just felt like it wouldn't be
right for her to congratulate it was an unknown phone number she didn't expect him to pick up
the phone she thought she was just going to be leaving a message but he is an inherently curious
person and so like it could because we already did the past
the echoes as we get into the bachelorette party are like sophie was a part of the past sophie was
a part of the manifesto sophie is a person that called to check in and wish the congratulations
and then time got away they had to like break it off but they would call each other back later
and he winds up telling his brother that uh you know sophie reached out what have you
and the last thing we see as randall is texting with beth and says refers to her as uh
regina and she refers to him as cuba from jerry mcguire what have you we see kev deleting
sophie's information from his phone right can i just give one little detail that i was like wait
give it to me so when he she calls she was like oh i didn't think you would pick up it was an unknown
number right and she's like i changed my number he's like why did you change your number and she's
like oh it's like a story for another time so when they he hang up he hangs up with her and he's like
i'll call you back i'm like how is he gonna call her back he doesn't have her number maybe he saved
it was he erasing but it said unknown she goes i didn't think you would pick up it was an unknown
number oh maybe because it i in my mind it said like unknown right no no it's just like a number
that came up without a name okay okay that makes sense not a blocks number yeah or just like you
know how sometimes it'll say like unknown number yeah yeah yeah totally potential spam it was a
potential spam and she's like you i can't believe you picked up hello
hello famous actor kevin pearson i'm feeling lonely who is this
you need how much money wired to you directly you say i can do that that's how that
okay that answers my question bachelorette party i was like wait a second yeah
kate and madison and madison's bachelorette party oh yeah they have kevin masks which are really
cute i remember those
yeah very cute um and then the doorbell rings and kate's like oh who could that be
and it's this like handsome guy who says vaxxed and waxed for your pleasure
she takes her mask off by the way because it just made me think that was the shirt we got that year
season five vaxxed and waxed vaxxed and waxed i like it or this is a shirt yeah yeah i don't think
it was like our crew gift you didn't no it was covid and it said like vaxxed and waxed on like
the front pocket it wasn't a hoodie no it was a t-shirt it was a t-shirt it was a t-shirt it was a
t-shirt season five yeah i probably immediately donated it
i was like you call milo i'm sure he'll figure out how to get you one he most certainly probably
has like boxes yeah boxes yeah it's the top of this episode um okay vaxxed and waxed vaxxed
and waxed for your pleasure and uh and and madison he he says like madison and she's like
joe yeah and we're like oh these guys have a history they have a history right it's um
he's handsome guy vaxxed and waxed and taken him back um but you know what she's actually
totally unbothered about how awkward it could be she's like she's like by the way i won like this
guy ghosted me but jokes on him because like i'm marrying people's like most beautiful and we have
babies and like life life is good essentially do you guys like an awkward situation no explain
what do you mean by like if i had been present at that when he walked in
i would have been like popping popcorn and going i hear you oh not happening to you but
witnessing something i don't even mind sometimes when i'm involved um uh but i especially i
especially enjoy it when it's happening around me i love when you tell a story about how excited
you get about watching something like that i do love it yeah i know no no it's like i can
remember a couple specific examples of sally being like and then we went to this wedding and
like tells the whole story i'm like oh wow i was thinking about that wedding today because it still
holds such a place in my heart that's what i mean it's like i could see you just like
more this is more which is oftentimes when people are like like i'll just say the intro to that to
that story that wedding i won't get to it too into it in case somebody knows what wedding i'm talking
about but rachel essentially goes hey an acquaintance co-worker of mine is getting married
next weekend a couple hours from here and he invited me and i'm like we're going
we'll make a weekend of it we'll spend a couple hours at this thing but the opportunity
for awkwardness at a wedding is never higher and this one delivered this one delivered i don't
think i ever want to go it was the best wedding and we're i i don't want the best worst wedding
i've ever been to it was so uncomfortable and rachel visibly uncomfortable
and me just like this is incredible this is good yeah we went ryan and i went to a wedding
where a friend of hers was getting married and the officiant of the wedding yeah was a former
boyfriend of hers oh and how was that it was awesome yeah it was awesome in the way that
oh yeah i was i was eating a lot of popcorn it was incredible we have to go like i've never been
to a to a like a high school reunion but i think someday i will go you should just
because it'll be fun to reminisce but more than that like let's just get a look yeah
you know let's just get a look let's get a look at each other like me no hair gray beard
hey what have you been up to it's kind of awesome i've gone i go to like almost everyone of course
it's so much fun that's why there's some fist bumping happening you don't need to be taking
pictures with everybody i don't i don't but you know tangent of that my mentor
from school her name was barbara bull at the time is now barbara kraus she is 91 years young
she lives just outside of portland oregon and me and three of my former classmates who are
advisees of her are going to go visit her in portland in september very excited very excited
um okay bachelor party uh did anybody get the sense that while they were painting the nude
and and madison's talking about here's to never dating again and madison starts to recount the
things of her relationship with kev yeah it's not very romantic no it's like it's like everybody's
like listening to it and they're trying to come up with their silver linings to spin but you're
together now and you're like and everything is great and look how it worked out your babies and
yeah rebecca trying to understand what ghosting is was really good yeah he was a ghost to you
was he a ghost to you you tell me right now if kevin was it's the sincerity of the rebecca
delivery that's always sort of like i just want to understand is that a terrible thing
and then you do a ghost beth undercuts it at the very end she's like slight turn for me joe
she's like she goes she goes oh yeah that's it yeah yeah oh but also rebecca did have one
she's like uh i can do it in boxers so i can do fully nude or whatnot and rebecca's like
the latter do you remember that yeah she's like i want to see some young flesh
okay you're terrible joe did you yell to them
yeah joe you did that to her you're terrible terrible
that's just all of it if you told me that there was a gonna be a bachelorette party
with a 65 year old woman that i'm like can i please come can i please come like i just want
to see it all yeah let's get into this newlywed game all right they finished with what a trap
uh beth excuses herself to go check on some opportunities for her for the traditional dance
academy
well she says she's got to go pee she says she gotta go she's like that sangria one right
through me and rebecca's like something's off it's rebecca finding an opportunity both in past
and present to pour into this woman who needs it you know what i'm saying um because beth is
talking about how you know i've gotten these opportunities from these traditional dance
academies but there's something about them that sort of took away the love of dance from me i
don't know if that's necessarily something that i want to do we saw you know because it is
interesting man like
if you are a dancer and ballet in particular and you have curves those curves count against you in
that particular and that's it yeah that's the end of the story it's almost yeah pretty much
and and so she's like i don't want that to happen and rebecca's like well then change them you know
i'm saying go inside of there figure out what it is that you need to do to make them better
new bit of information last episode we learned i was a cheerleader
yeah right in high school uh now you're going to learn that uh right after college i was in a ballet
- Three or four?
- Mm-hmm, three.
year called the metropolis ballet theater come on man what are you talking about what do you mean
what am i talking about you're a ballet dancer no but i was in a ballet company uh what does that
look like when i when what it looks like is this when i was in college i started a in the dance
department a movement for actors course yeah with one of their teachers essentially knowing that i
needed movement but they're any of these i try to take all these dance classes and i'm like not for
me yeah i just i'll try but i'm like interrupting everything like these girls have been dancing
their whole lives and they're very serious about this and i am serious about it too but they don't
need to watch me stumble through this i got you and so we made a whole thing for for actors and
then one of the uh ladies in the dance company in the dance department who was a ballet because
no matter what you do everyone does ballet right yeah little little girls sure growing up they take
ballet and then they take other things and maybe they get better at modern or jazz or whatever the
thing is but everyone does ballet but very soon however you develop if you are not the ballet type
right ballet is no longer an option yeah it's off the table no matter how much you love it no matter
how good you are at it and this particular person named sarah harkness yeah thought that that was
wrong and said you know what there should be a place for us to do this and so she essentially
started like a ballet company for misfits that was like punk rock and avant-garde and all of the
girls who are very good ballet dancers who wouldn't be considered your classic ballet whatever bodies
and they had us actors come in as part lifting partners you know we would move and we would do
our best to do ballet or whatever but yeah that's so cool that's very cool so yeah just letting you
guys know wow i love all this new information about sully used to be so they they get into
the questions nikki
is reading or holding the camera for kevin reading the questions while kate will pause and and give
uh madison an opportunity to see what she thinks kev is going to say right first question is like
what is an ideal sunday right before and madison is like well you know like to have breakfast in
bed and sort of hang out with the kids would be really cool and kev's like you know she's into
this thing about you know hanging out in bed so i think she'd want to sleep in bed and hang out with
the kids right yeah it's like and it's funny too because as soon as this part started i was like
this is going to go awful like it's not going to go i was prepared for it to just be question after
question of just then just being wrong wrong wrong but it was better than that yeah because you get
the first one right then the second question was about like what is your dreams for the future yeah
right like once you're empty nesters once you're empty nesters right wow so far off yeah it's like
whoa we have newborns 18 years from now okay let's see my 18-year plan but it was madison talks about
how love of travel and going all over the place is it whatever i'm missing you let me know and kev's
is really interesting because he sort of pauses and thinks
and he goes like it's a trick question because she knows i never want to grow up so there you go
right and there's this moment that hits you yeah like in like in the gut like
he has not thought anything about an empty nest about tomorrow you know what i'm saying let alone
18 years i'm not even remotely close to that and so my sister clocks it as well and i think
my sister also being the linchpin between the past and the present of i've heard my brother
be passionate about something about the future about the future i've heard him assured
about this thing
yeah and now i'm bearing witness to something very very different and so at the end of the
whole thing like kate just sort of like hey man to madison like talk to me for a second real quick
like are you getting everything you need yeah are you getting everything that you need out of this
right and it's the sort of not the beginning but sort of like us moving over these past couple
episodes into the the last episode of the season of being like man this isn't it's we keep trying
to force like a square peg into a rectangular hole like it looks like they should fit sorry
i'm not trying to even go there dadgummit they look like they should fit yes but they don't but
they don't yes right and this is the first instance that we're seeing of madison sort of considering
that too yeah because at the end she re-watches um that clip and pauses it like on like his face just
being like there's just a split second too where he like is thinking like what do i say here yeah
a joke trick question yeah it's like he just pauses for a millisecond where she's like what
is that too long too long yeah yeah it's women be catching those pauses you know what i mean
i always be saying that and she but here's the here's the thing though when kate asks her that
question madison says you know what i'm saying you know what i'm saying you know what i'm saying you
know what i'm saying you know what i'm saying you know what i'm saying madison says i love him kate
yeah i really do like that brother of yours has shown up in ways that i i couldn't imagine so like
there's real love on her part do you know what i'm saying and i think real love on his part too
oh okay you see that pause yeah i caught even i do i think that he is in love and i think he
probably articulate i can't remember it exactly i'm not saying in love are you making a strong
distinction very big distinction he is a love addict yeah i think he loves madison he loves
what she's brought into his life he loves the stability he loves the idea of what she represents
yeah he's not in love with her right okay fair enough because i also think that what she
represents is also motherhood and family mm-hmm yeah absent of that there wouldn't be it but as as
as as evidenced by when they're talking about early in the relationship like yeah your your
your son didn't really call me that much after i you know but like it was awkward and it was weird
so i understood and they were all listening like he did he ghost you you know what i'm saying like
it's i the idea of family i think is something that he has romanticized that she is now representative
of and he's like well if that's what i need to do in order to have this family then i will accept
what's in front of me as is and dive into that and our show just does a great great way of like
it's not in a heavy-handed sense but as an audience we're left going this is something to consider
are they a love they're they're not a love story written in the stars right like jack and rebecca
but are they a love story written together like rebecca and miguel yeah right or are they something
else entirely are they not a love story in their own way sure you know what i mean i do think that
they're not a love story in their own way but i think they're not a love story in their own way
because i can't remember at all but absent of madison having the conversation that she has
with kevin in the finale of the episode he would have gotten married yes i agree and i think they
would have had a decent marriage yeah i think i think so i think they would have gotten married
they probably wouldn't have stayed together yeah but i think they would have gotten married there's
this thing though and then we'll segue out of it because i think we're at the end of the episode but
i think i think we're at the end of the episode but i think we're at the end of the episode but
my lover to be my confident to be my my lover to be my confident to be my
my lover to be my confident to be my inspiration to be my best friend to be
inspiration to be my best friend to be the mother or slash father of my
best friend to be the mother or slash father of my children
the mother or slash father of my children sometimes business partner like
sometimes business partner like it's a lot that we put on each other that
it's a lot that we put on each other that maybe
maybe we should a lot of that find a way to
we should a lot of that find a way to have a little bit more grace yeah like i
have a little bit more grace yeah like i think about that 80 20 thing
think about that 80 20 thing like the bird is amazing
like the bird is amazing like i love ryan michelle to my core
like i love ryan michelle to my core right but there are certain things that
right but there are certain things that like when i got
like when i got
like when i got no no no
no no no
no no no when i got the food poisonings i didn't
when i got the food poisonings i didn't
when i got the food poisonings i didn't tell her
tell her
tell her and i didn't tell her
and i didn't tell her
and i didn't tell her because her worry
because her worry
because her worry would have caused me more anxiety and i
would have caused me more anxiety and i
would have caused me more anxiety and i knew there was nothing she could do
knew there was nothing she could do
knew there was nothing she could do and so i just kept it to myself until i
and so i just kept it to myself until i
and so i just kept it to myself until i was on the other side of it i don't know
was on the other side of it i don't know
was on the other side of it i don't know if that's right or wrong but you know
if that's right or wrong but you know
if that's right or wrong but you know what's saying it's like you know your
what's saying it's like you know your
what's saying it's like you know your relationship but i did text
relationship but i did text
relationship but i did text the the marco polo thread yeah the the
the the marco polo thread yeah the the
the marco polo thread yeah the the guys who ratted me out and told you that
guys who ratted me out and told you that
guys who ratted me out and told you that like i didn't like my dog yeah i did
like i didn't like my dog yeah i did
like i didn't like my dog yeah i did text them yeah from the toilet pretty
text them yeah from the toilet pretty
text them yeah from the toilet pretty much
much
much to let them know like guys it's not
to let them know like guys it's not
to let them know like guys it's not going well
going well
going well what could they do
what could they do
what could they do they could empathize with me in a way
they could empathize with me in a way
they could empathize with me in a way that wasn't sort of alarming sometimes
that wasn't sort of alarming sometimes
that wasn't sort of alarming sometimes my wife's concern feels alarming
my wife's concern feels alarming
my wife's concern feels alarming you know what i mean yeah and there's
you know what i mean yeah and there's
you know what i mean yeah and there's just like oh you're gonna be all right
just like oh you're gonna be all right
- And that's in that moment. - Like, oh, that sucks, dude.
I'm sorry, I feel better. - Yeah.
- And that's all you needed. - That's all I needed.
- You didn't need Ryan being like, I'm not there.
Should I be there?
What are we gonna do with the boys?
- Correct. - I'll be right there.
- Yeah, yeah, yeah. - That sort of thing.
- Got it. - It'll take me 90 minutes
to get there. - Yeah.
- It takes, it's like over two and a half hours, but.
- Not for her. - Not for her.
But it is one of those things that makes me wonder,
or just makes me contemplate like what we ask
of our partners in modern relationships.
- For sure.
- Especially us who've been married for,
a while like i feel like there's a level of if i could tell 30 year old sterling about like what
50 year old sterling knows now you do have this sort of romanticized he may not but you do have
this sort of romanticized version of what my marriage is going to be sure i was like well
my marriage is not gonna be like that my marriage is gonna be this and it's gonna be all the good
things yeah and my marriage is all the good things my marriage is all the things it's all the things
all the things you know what i'm saying and it is like to this question is like could they have
made it could they have not i don't know i think she deserved someone to be in love with her the
same way that she is in love with him yeah and i feel like when you're unequally yoked that's a
tough that's a tougher road that's a recipe for something not working out in the end yeah
yeah
yeah yeah yeah anything you guys want to say in closing i think we got a fan segment we do have
some emails i believe from from some fans of the show let's come back with a little bit more on the
fan segment and that was us one of the biggest themes in this episode is the idea that love
doesn't always look the way we expect it and that sometimes the most meaningful relationships are
the ones that arrive in a completely different way
different form than we imagine yeah we received two beautiful emails from listeners that connected
with episode 515 in different ways and we are so excited to read them so let's share our first
email who wants to read first i'll start dearest that was us i watched this is us during the early
days of my grief after losing my husband and it quietly helped me through that season it gave me
language for love loss and the unexpected ways life can continue which is why this episode resonated
so deeply with me i'm writing in response to your episode about how some relationships feel as though
they were written in the stars and how others arrive in our lives in a completely different way
season 5 episode 15 jerry 2.0 i lost my husband it's a sentence that still feels heavy no matter
how much time passes loving him was not something i ever questioned it felt destined woven into who
i was becoming when he died it felt as though the future i had imagined vanished with him
for a long time i believed that kind of love could only happen once that lightning doesn't
strike twice especially after loss grief has a way of convincing you that joy has a limit and
that chapter you lived was the chapter you were meant to have and then something unexpected
happened i fell in love again oh wow this relationship didn't arrive with the same
certainty or symmetry as the first it wasn't written in the same stars it came quietly
carefully shaped by grief maturity and a deep awareness of how fragile life truly is this love
didn't replace what i lost it exists alongside it it honors it being remarried after losing my
husband has taught me that love isn't one size fits all some loves are fiery and fated others
are steady chosen and brave this love is different not lesser just different it's rooted in survival
and the courage to open your heart again after it's been shattered i wanted to share this perspective
because conversations about love often forget those of us who carry both grief and gratitude
at the same time loving again after loss isn't a betrayal of the past it's a testament to the
heart's resilience thank you for creating space for conversations that remind us love
doesn't follow one script and that sometimes the most meaningful relationships are the ones we
know and love doesn't follow one script and that sometimes the most meaningful relationships are
the ones we never saw coming lots of love geneva w wow geneva that was so beautiful
geneva with her late husband warren and then geneva with her husband jeff in europe
oh wow incredible beautiful but it's very much like like rebecca like we were saying
completely right like her her love with miguel thank you geneva for sharing that was awesome it's
beautiful email from mary hi mandy sterling and chris i hope this email reaches you in time i'm
writing with the hopes that it will land in your inbox at the right time to be a part of your fan
segment i've re-watched this is us three times wow the third time being with all of you during
the re-watch oh this particular episode touches me because of the small moments between rebecca
and beth at the bridal shower as they walked out beth thanks rebecca for the pep talk and
encouragement about their prospective jobs but i'm going to leave you with a little bit of a
story about it's rebecca's response of thanking beth for making her feel normal that connects
with me in march 2016 my mother-in-law died after a long battle with cancer but it was during her
last few years before her passing that our relationship made all of the difference for
both of us the cancer spread to her brain and formed a tumor that pushed the ocular part
unfortunately after numerous surgeries to shrink the tumor to save her eye in the end her eye was
removed she was so sad and heartbroken knowing that her health would only get worse i would make
light of her no longer having an eye by telling to keep all the unattractive people on that side of
her lol mostly i would call her to get advice about my kids fuss about her son my husband
and overall just shoot the breeze these phone calls were a sense of normalcy for her i didn't
fret about her health i would ask how she was in the regular way
and if she shared i listened and if we talked about husbands kids or life in general that was
fine too she had always thanked me for keeping the conversations light because everyone else was
always worrying i always reminded her that i was there for her however she needed me it was
beautiful to see how the show added this small touch between a mother-in-law and daughter-in-law
in such a simple way thank you for always catching the moments of life that people never notice
mary s thank you mary thank you so much mary oh there's a picture with her and her mother-in-law
so sweet wow it's so it's just so nice to be reminded of how even these tiny little moments
in the show like these storylines can resonate with people and touch them it's like wow just and
it's actually a detail that we kind of glossed over as we were talking about this episode it is
that was sweet that obviously the conversation that we that the two of them had in the room and
sort of you know letting her in on the fact that she was a mother-in-law and she was a mother-in-law
she was a mother-in-law and she was a mother-in-law and she was a mother-in-law and she was a mother-in-law
that she had been talking to this recruiter and was trying to figure her way back into the sort of
the world of dance potentially and um and on the way out rebecca was like by the way like thank
you everyone is always just so focused on me and my health and where i am and my mind and it was
just nice to be of service in such a normal way of just like just being able to have a conversation
mother-in-law to daughter-in-law like i needed that i need to feel that too
so i i yeah that's a i i appreciate mary's email because that was something that we totally forgot
to talk about in the episode and it makes you realize that yeah those small moments those small
gestures and storylines matter to people it reminds me every once in a while like my in-laws
my father-in-law who's since passed away would come to visit or whatnot and when in-laws come
to visit you just kind of want them to relax and have a good time you know see a grandkid
bounce them in the lap etc etc but it reminds me
each time they come i don't know how this is for you guys like there's this desire to like you know
they'll wash the dishes or they'll vacuum or they'll make something and or like i saw something
was out of joint here so i decided to everybody wants to feel a value the whole time they're here
of course and we in western society sometimes don't do the best job as people get older allowing
them to show their value right you know and it is like that simple moment of just being able to pour
into someone yeah mean something
yeah you know what i'm saying and i i remind myself of these moments as i get older and i look forward
to my kids having family and it's like how am i show up and be of value in a way that doesn't
also create chaos or you know what i'm saying like because that's the other side of it is like
i don't need you yeah messing with this thing with jigger yeah but so yeah i think i hold both of
those things in my mind at the same time another great fan segment another great fan segment another
great episode always a joy such a joy always a joy and i think that's what i'm trying to do
enjoy amanda you guys delight me in ways that i cannot can't even articulate likewise thank you
for being a part of my life mandy i think it's your turn you gotta look into your camera tell
them the name of the show that was us that was us is filmed at rabbit grin studios and produced
by rabbit grin productions music by taylor goldsmith and griffin goldsmith
that was us
that was a hate gum podcast
this episode is brought to you by netflix's new series east of eden a bold reimagining of john
steinbeck's masterpiece following generations of the trask family through love betrayal and
the choices that shape humanity starring mike feist and christopher abbott as the trask brothers
and florence pew as kathy ames
The complex anti-heroine determined to build the line
No matter the cost.
Watch East of Eden now, only on Netflix.
Ugh, I hate Mondays.
Taylor Hansen? Sure, I'll try one.
Mmm.
Taylor Hansen? Nice. Try one.
Mmm.
Bites.
There's nothing like it.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Kevin and Sophie's relationship faces strain as long-distance living and emotional distance make reconnection difficult, with Sophie expressing discomfort over Kevin's romanticized future plans.
The group gathers at a cabin for reflection, where they revisit the movie *Jerry McGuire*, prompting introspection on love, commitment, and the unrealistic tropes of romantic comedies.
Characters confront their own insecurities and past relationships—Toby criticizes rom-com ideals as unrealistic, while Miguel and Rebecca share a heartfelt reconciliation rooted in honesty and mutual respect.
The episode explores the idea that love is not predetermined by fate but built through shared experiences, vulnerability, and personal growth over time.
Kevin reflects on his own life and the fantasy of a perfect, idealized future, only to realize it may not align with reality or emotional authenticity.
The group shares personal stories of loss, grief, and reconnection, emphasizing that healing and new beginnings are possible even after past pain.
The conversation highlights the contrast between romanticized love narratives and the messy, real-world complexities of relationships.
Ultimately, the episode suggests that true love is not about flawless outcomes but about mutual commitment, honesty, and choosing to stay together through challenges.
Summary:
This episode of *This Is Us* explores the emotional complexities of love, commitment, and personal growth through the lens of the Pearson family’s reunion at a cabin. As Kevin and Sophie navigate reconnection after years of long-distance living, their relationship faces reality checks—Sophie expresses that Kevin’s idealized future plans are unkind and unrealistic, while Kevin confronts his own romantic fantasies after watching *Jerry McGuire*. The group engages in heartfelt conversations about love, loss, and the flaws in romanticized narratives, with Toby dismissing rom-com tropes as inauthentic and Miguel and Rebecca finding healing through honest communication.
The episode highlights how love is not written in the stars but built through shared experiences, vulnerability, and mutual effort. Personal stories of grief, such as Kate’s loneliness after Jack’s death and Beth’s fear of failure in a long-distance relationship, underscore the emotional weight of commitment. The group also reflects on past relationships and how they’ve evolved, affirming that love is not about perfection but about resilience and choice.
Ultimately, the episode presents a realistic, grounded view of romance—one rooted in honesty, self-awareness, and the courage to stay together despite flaws. The narrative balances nostalgia with emotional maturity, reinforcing that meaningful relationships grow through shared struggles and authentic connection.
FAQs
The episode explores whether love is written in the stars or built over time, questioning the reality of romantic ideals and the authenticity of long-distance relationships.
Kevin is initially curious and surprised when Sophie reaches out, but he later deletes her number, showing emotional distance and a reluctance to reconnect.
The movie serves as a catalyst for reflection, prompting Kevin to have a spiritual moment about love and commitment, while also highlighting the unrealistic romance of rom-coms.
The cabin setting allows characters to confront their fears, doubts, and past relationships, revealing vulnerabilities around commitment, love, and compatibility.
Several characters criticize romantic tropes, arguing that idealized love stories don't reflect real life, and that lasting relationships are built on reality, not fantasy.
Miguel's concern for Rebecca shows that love can persist beyond appearances, and that true connection often comes through patience, presence, and mutual respect.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.