Go back

Justice Neil Gorsuch on the ‘Miracle’ of Agreement on the Court

28m 20s

Justice Neil Gorsuch on the ‘Miracle’ of Agreement on the Court

Justice Neil Gorsuch and author Janie Nizzi discuss their children’s book *Heroes of 1776*, which celebrates the Declaration of Independence and its enduring values. The conversation highlights the historical process behind the Declaration’s creation, emphasizing Thomas Jefferson’s pivotal role, the personal sacrifices of the signers, and the revolutionary ideals of equality and inalienable rights. Gorsuch connects these foundational principles to his own judicial philosophy, describing his originalist approach as rooted in history, tradition, and a deep respect for individual dignity. He underscores that the American experiment is built on shared ideals, not uniformity, and that legal decisions must reflect the nation’s founding commitments. The discussion also touches on the importance of historical awareness in addressing past injustices, such as those faced by Native Americans, and the role of separation of powers in protecting liberty. Gorsuch reflects on the significance of the 250th anniversary as a potential moment for national reflection and unity, reminding listeners that while disagreement is inevitable, shared values—like equal rights and self-rule—can bind a divided nation. He stresses that the judiciary must remain independent, impartial, and faithful to the original meaning of the Constitution, serving as a guardian of the Declaration’s central promise: that every person has inherent worth and the right to self-governance.

Transcription

4697 Words, 25890 Characters

English
I'm David French, I'm an opinion columnist at the New York Times. When I had the opportunity to interview Justice Neil Gorsuch and his co-author, Janie Nizzi, about their new children's book about the Declaration of Independence, I jumped at the chance. For a couple of reasons, one, I'm always happy to talk about the American founding. And number two, it's always a wonderful opportunity to talk to a Justice of the Supreme Court and to get to know more about where they're coming from and what they think. So the conversation you're about to hear was very interesting, but I have to give you some caveats. When you talk to a judge, it is not like talking to a politician. You cannot talk about pending cases. You can't talk about facts or circumstances that might be pending cases. And you definitely absolutely cannot talk about politics. But the conversation was very rich and very interesting, even with those caveats. I talked to Justice Gorsuch about his approach to originalism. I talked to him about his Native American jurisprudence. I talked to him about his approach to writing opinions. There is a lot in here. So I'd invite you to listen to this conversation. Give it some thought. And then in the comments, tell me what you think. Justice Gorsuch, thanks for being here. David, it's a pleasure to be with you. I have to say, it was a really fun trip down memory lane for me to read your book, which is called Heroes of 1776, it's arriving right at the 250th, and it's a beautifully illustrated book about the Declaration of Independence. And for me, it was a trip down memory lane because it reminded me of my childhood what ignited my love for American history was were books just like this. They were called American Heritage Illustrated, I remember them. And I made me curious, what is it that instilled your interest in the Constitution of the United States and our founding? David, my story is very much like yours. And that's exactly why Janie and I wrote this book, right, is to try and inspire the next generation to see the great ideas in our Declaration, their promise, and also the responsibilities that come with it, and maybe inspire them through some stories about some of the framers they know, but maybe some they don't know that might inspire them to pick up the baton themselves. I mean, for me, that was the effect, I would read these stories, I would capture my imagination. And reading your book and going through your book, there were two parts that really stood out to me. And I want to dive into both of them, the process and the results, which exactly is how lawyers think about these things, process and result. The first was the process of actually writing the Declaration, and the way in which John Adams handed the pen to Thomas Jefferson. And how much this declaration really was coming from the mind and heart of Thomas Jefferson. And so talk to a little bit about this process, how is it that Jefferson got the pen? Well, so they fought over it. And not the way you're thinking, though, right, just the opposite. So the story goes, and this is from Adams, this is his own letter that he wrote about it afterwards. And Adams said, I will not. And you should do it for three reasons, but not the reasons. He said, one, I am suspected of noxious and unpopular. You are very much otherwise, two, you're a Virginian and a Virginian should be seen to be head of this business. Can I stop you right there? No, let me finish three. Let me finish three. Okay. We can talk about two. Two is very important, but so is three. He said, you write ten times better than I do. And Jefferson always said, all right, I'll do it. All right. Now you can talk. Okay. Well, it was that humility or strategy or a combination to say that Jefferson writes. Well, I think number one is humility, for sure, and probably true. All right. Number two was strategic for sure, right? I mean, you had the Boston Tea Party and all the goings on in Lexington and Concord. What is it to a Virginian? You got to drag everybody along. And you have to remember, everybody thinks we live in divided times fine. We are whatever we can talk about that. But back then, only about 40% of the country was backing the Patriot cause, even in June and July of 1776. Another percent were devoted loyalists. And then the balance of the country was somewhere in between. Sound familiar? Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. So, Virginian nationalizes this, in other words, it takes it away from being a Massachusetts rebellion as ordinary Puritans, and it turns into an American. Evolution. Now, the other thing that struck me is Jefferson kind of squirls away and does the writing on his own. And so these really seminal words, this American, you know, mission statement, were endowed by our creator with certain and alienable rights. This really does seem to be the Jefferson's heart expressed on paper, not writing by committee. Well, there's some of that, too, right? This is later on, and he called the mutilation is what people did to it, all right? You know, we think of the declarations as this wonderful mutilations, anyway. But yes, he locked himself in rooms he had rented from a bricklayer on the outskirts of Philadelphia, and he did it in two weeks, and he said he didn't consult any book or pamphlet. He tried merely to come up with an expression of the American mind. And I don't think he was thinking about just his mind. I think he was thinking about how people were thinking at the time. And in that, he came up with three, I think, perfect ideas that were all created equal, every one of us, and that each of us has an alienable rights given to us by God, not privileges from government, and that we have a right to rule ourselves. And those ideas were incredibly radical at the time. We forget that. We think of them as the air we breathe, but in 1776 in Europe, it was a shockwave, right? And British newspapers said Americans had declared for themselves an unalienable right to speak nonsense. So the second part we talked about process, there's also results outcome. What was striking to me is about the last third of the book is about the costs that were paid, that we look back on the Revolutionary War as of Gloria's victory, and it was, but at terrible cost. So talk about a little of the cost that the signers of the declaration endured before we leave process. Okay. All right. Lesson, more process to say. We're lawyers, all right? You forget that it wasn't, it wasn't like the snap judgment that it was unanimous, right? We don't talk about this nearly enough. The people behind the declaration. And it's, to my mind, it's always the people and the humanity of them that inspires me. A third of them lost their homes, the signers, destroyed by the British. Many of them were jailed. Some of them had their wives jailed, their children jailed. When they said they devoted one another, their sacred honor, their fortunes, all of that, they meant it. They spent their fortunes on the Revolutionary Cause. One of my favorite stories in the book is Thomas Nelson. One of the signers from Virginia, he was head of the militia, Virginia militia at Yorktown. And when he saw that the British were using his home as a headquarters, he didn't hesitate to have men fire on it. And when he died, impoverished many years later, having spent much of his fortune on the Patriot Cause, so poor that, you know, they buried him in a marked grave so as creditors couldn't use his body as collateral. Think about that. He was asking. He was asked, you know, do you have any regrets? And he said, I'd do it all over again. So let's, there is an interesting symmetry here between this book and your last book overruled. Hang with me here. I'm, I'm waiting. Okay. I promise you I'm going to connect these two because I think there's an interesting way they connect to me with your jurisprudence. Oh, wow. Now that's a trifect if you can do that. We're going for it. We're going for it. Okay. So here's what I see and overruled and here's what I see, especially the last bit of the book where there's such an emphasis on the punitive power of the state attacking and depriving the rights of vulnerable people overruled was a lot about a more peaceful version of this where you have very large bureaucracies, very complex webs of rules and regulation that trap regular folks in their web. And it's always struck me. I have always seen your jurisprudence and forgive me if this is something that you're going to completely disagree with is a combination of originalist and anti-bulley. And I see that in both of these books. And I have seen this in many opinions that you've written. And so I just wanted to float that idea past you about your own jurisprudence. Well, that's like saying, hey, Gorsuch, lie down on this couch and analyze yourself. But I'll take a shot at it. Okay. I'll take a shot at it. I don't know. I don't know. But I would say that one of the most striking and inspirational things about the American experiment to me is it's the emphasis of places on the individual and it is intrinsic value. you. You're not valuable as a cog in a machine to others ends. You have value in your own right. You are my equal. You have inalienable rights. You have every bit as much right to rule yourself as I do. And those ideas, I just think those are perfect ideas. Are they imperfectly executed? Do we have a ways to go even today? You betcha. But those ideas speak to every human heart. They exclude no one. And they inspire me, yes. Well, and I've also noticed, not just from you've written a book about the 250th anniversary of the Declaration, but read many, many of your opinions. And you really focus a lot on history and case after case. And I've been particularly struck by your focus on history in the Native American cases. You have developed reputation as maybe the greatest friend to Native Americans who's ever sat on the Supreme Court. And what I wonder is, has that careful attention to history has that alerted you to a lot of the legal injustice that has been visited upon the Native American population in the United States for so very long? Well, without getting into cases, I think, no, no, that's fine. I'm just trying to abstract from it a little bit in the answer. I do not know how you run this country without knowing its history. I do not know how you can be a good citizen, exercising the responsibilities without knowing something about how it operates. How do you work a machine if you've never read the how-to manual, right? We were talking about this beforehand. History is endlessly fascinating. And it has so much to teach us, so many mistakes that were made. It's like, it's like an example of iterative responses to problems. And you can see how what's worked and what hasn't worked over time. If you bothered to open the book and the problem today, I think we would agree is that too few people opened the book. So I'm hoping instead of maybe Goodnight Moon, maybe a person a little tired of that, perhaps they'll try Goodnight Ben Franklin, you know, Heroes of 76. I love it. So, but let's stick with the history thing for a minute, because I have long thought of myself and have described myself since probably my first year of law school as an originalist. That is how I describe myself to people when I talk about how I think about the law. But there's this phrase that we use when talking about originalism, text, history, and tradition. And the history part to me is both promising and perilous. The promising part is obvious. You're going to learn more, the more you dive into the history, it's going to bring the words the Constitution to life. You're going to understand what they meant when they said what they said. But also history is incredibly complicated and often contradictory. Yes. So here comes the perilous part. When you are looking at the history portion of this text, history and tradition analysis, how are you adjudicating what is aboriginal and exceptional versus consensus? And how do you decide which people to listen to such as like an early American legislature isn't an interpretive body. They're not interpreting the law of the way, say a judge was, but how relevant is what they do? So how are you sorting through this incredibly complicated history that bears on so many of our cases? David, you ask a very good question of an originalist about methodology. Is an important question. Answering it is complicated, difficult to the law. I would say only this. You're asking the right question. Instead of asking what the judge ate for breakfast or what he thinks a perfect world should look like, he's trying to answer what the words, the people of the United States in their constitution or the laws adopted. And in that way, he's bringing real the promise of the declaration of self-rule rather than rule by judges. So yeah, we can have a long, fun academic conversation about sources and sorting mainstream from aberrations. But that's the project of trying to figure out what the original meaning of the law is. You know, as a journalist, I'm very keenly aware of when I write something if people are interested in it and not interested in it. And I've noticed this big flip over the last five years. We've gone from a situation where if I'm writing and talking about Supreme Court cases around some of the classic hot button culture war issues such as, you know, abortion, free speech, the conflict between religious liberty and gay rights, et cetera, there has been much less interest and by contrast, much greater interest around separation of powers. And when we're looking at the declaration of independence, this is a book about the Declaration of Independence, not the 1787 Constitution, but the Declaration of Independence. But it's got this corp American promise to it about we're endowed by a creator with certain unalienable rights among them life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. It's the role of government to protect that. How does separation of powers protect life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness? Well, first of all, I think it's fascinating what you say that people are interested in the separation of powers and I'm delighted to hear it. And the way I think of it is this that, okay, the declarations are mission statement. It's what we're aiming for imperfectly through lots of hardships and battles, but that's what we're hoping for. And we're a credal nation, right, David? I mean, we don't share a religion, we don't share a race, we share an idea, okay? And that idea has to be passed on to generation to generation through the histories we discussed. All right, the Constitution for the separation of powers is our how-to manual, okay? And the one thing Madison knew in devising the Virginia planet, the basis of the Constitution, is that men are not angels, all right, and you have to separate power assiduously to keep us free, to ensure that everybody is treated equally, to make real the idea of self-rule and certainly to protect your unalienable rights. So I'm going to float an idea by you and I would love to hear your reaction. When I like to say I'm a free speech advocate, I don't like the whole concept of trigger words, except I do say I have one trigger phrase. I do not like to hear co-equal branches of government. And I tell you why. That's the good English scrimary in in you. Yeah, I don't like that, but I don't like it because I don't think they are exactly co-equal. Oh, interesting. I think of Article One as Article One for a reason. You might say first among equals would be the Congressional branch. And it strikes me that one of the reasons why, and I'm not going to ask you to cast shade as the kids say on another whole branch of government. But it strikes me as one of the reasons why the Supreme Court is so much in the center of the national conversation right now is that in many ways, Congress has taken steps back. And a lot of your decisions have been, wait a minute, this is something that Congress has to decide that this is a role for Congress only. So in separation of powers, it is just not the case, right, that when one branch steps backwards and another one has to step forward. Well, I do think it would be crazy to say we are a democracy or a republic. And yet simultaneously entertain the notion that nine, old judges in Washington should govern us all. Okay. Now you'd want nine wise old judges to decide the meaning of a law independently without fear of favor to anyone. And it vindicate your rights in a trial. Absolutely. That makes perfect. But to rule everybody to pass the laws, to amend the Constitution, that would make a mockery of the Declaration and of the Constitution. And so yes, it is a responsibility. Now I want to defend them a little bit. Okay. Because back, please, because I don't because because they they pass about two million words in new legislation. I think every year, every term, I can't remember which, but they're doing a lot. They're keeping us pretty busy, David. So I think of when I think of and your book is about the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution. And I think of when I think about the relationship between the two, I think of the Declaration of Independence as to use a corporate analogy is like the mission statement. Yeah. And the Constitution is the bylaws that it effectuates the mission statement. But my question is how much do the sweeping sort of principles of the Declaration of Independence, do they inform your work at all? Or is that more of historical interest than it is sort of practical interest? I think they inform the work of every citizen, right? And we talk about this at the end of the book, right? Okay. Here are these three ideals, were they real for everybody? And so it's certainly not, right? But the women at Seneca Falls in 1848 could appeal to the nation and say, yeah, women are created equal. So are all women and men, all right? And Lincoln could say in the Civil War, how can you possibly maintain a system of slavery when you say, women are equal, come back to the truths in the Declaration? Martin Luther King, down the mall here in 1963, could call it a promissory note that it come due. And he was right, all right? They inform all of us, don't they? There's another aspect of the book that was very interesting to me and you talked about the varied backgrounds of the signers of the Declaration. Let me ask you this about the court itself. Do you think there is value and having people of maybe, and when it comes to future justices, is there a value to have, say, more people with legislative experience, a greater diversity of legal backgrounds? There seems to have been an interesting professionalization of the path to the court, where there is now sort of a judicial career path. That's a little bit different from when I was younger. And I was just wondering what you thought about the possibility of, you know, varying in different backgrounds and what that might bring to the court, if anything. I think we've got a very, very court as it is, right? You have got nine different justices from all over the country. Well, the Aselecourt, or maybe overrepresented, slightly overrepresented, appointed by five different presidents over 30 years. And some of us are originalists, and some of us are very much not, okay? But yet we're able to talk to one another and listen to one another and find common ground a surprising amount of the time. I mean, 40% of our cases we decided animously, right? You give us the 70 hardest cases in the country every year. Every, I mean, we're at lower court judges of disagreeing and we're able to reach unanimity that much. I think that's a miracle, right? And a third, maybe a third of our cases are five, four, six, three, but only half of those are the five, four, six, threes you might be thinking about. And then you compare those numbers back to 1945 when Roosevelt had appointed eight of the nine justices and the figures are the same today as they were then. And when I think about that and the diversity of the court was different than it is now, it does remind me and going back to the men at the Declaration or at the Constitutional Convention coming from around the country with different perspectives, different voices, the rabble rosers, some Massachusetts, the folks down in South Carolina were not sure at all about this project and they debated and they disagreed. And it shows you that people from different perspectives, different walks of life, along whatever axis, can, when they listen to one another, work together in good faith and assume that the guy across from me loves this country every bit as much as I do. Great things can happen. So one thing that is striking about your work is you, you write a lot of concurrences and I'm thinking of the tariffs concurrence and when we just had the tariffs decision, you wrote a pretty long concurrence that was really taking a look at the arguments of the other justices, what is the decision making process that you undertake whether you're going to write a concurrence or not? What are the steps you go through and what are you hoping to accomplish when you write a concurrence? Well, you know, I took an oath to essentially call him like I see him with a fear or favor to anyone. And so that's my job. That's my job. And so when I need to do that, I need to do that. If I don't need to do that, that's all the better, right? It makes for an easier day at the office, but sometimes you have to do it. And when I think about that, I think about actually the declaration, one of the list of grievances against the king was that he had taken away independent judges and juries, right? And made, you know, sent them to vice admiralty courts, right? And colonists, essentially judges were answerable to the king. And they wanted to send cases even back to Britain so that there would be juries there rather than in locality. And I just think what a treasured gift we have, right? Where you know, no matter how unpopular you are, rich poor doesn't matter. The judicial oath says, you know, administer justice without respect to persons, rich or poor. Any difference. That's my job. What a beautiful job it is to just come into the office and say, what does the law as best I can tell is difficult as it sometimes is. I mean, the dangling modifiers and some of the statutes that we're given are, but to fulfill that oath and to try and realize what the framers of the declaration had in mind when they listed as that as one of their grievances against the king to discharge that job is a is a privilege and is humbling. So a last question, when we're talking about the 250th earlier, we're also talking about the 200th, the bicentennial. And there's a lot going on right now in our country at 250. There's a lot of division. There's a lot of contention. We don't like each other. And we were talking earlier about the potential of the 250th to bring us together. And I would just love it if you would reflect back on, we're both old enough to barely remember the 200th. And can the 250th have the same effect on us that the 200th did? David, I hope so, right? I mean, I'm not, I don't want to be polyanna, ship out of it, right? We are always going to be divided over things. They were divided over the declaration. Even during the revolution, they were divided. I mean, Ben Franklin and his son were divided over the revolution. We tell that story in the book, you know, will you minds up living in England as he was a loyalist? They barely spoke for years. So of course, we're going to have our disagreements open up a page of history. America is always going to have its disagreements, but can there be moments and ideas that unite us? And I do think the declaration has that power because it does speak to every one of us. And this anniversary has a little power in that regard. What does semi-quinsen teniel mean? It doesn't roll off the teniel. It doesn't roll off down. It means halfway to 500. It's a journey. We're not at our destination. We are not a perfect union. We have work to do. And this is one of the things we have worked to do. I'm being able to listen to one another, trust one another, recognize that the person I disagree with is usually operating in a good faith in a lot of his country too. Right? All right. But the 200th, you know, we do remember that. And it did have that power. You have to remember is toughest things might seem to date it to you and me. Well, how did it look in 1976? We just came out of Watergate. Men were coming home from Vietnam were very different than the ones who left. Mm-hmm. You're suffering from stagnation. I mean, real. Oh, yes. Oh, and by the way, we had an unelected president. All right. Okay. And it was a moment. You know, I remember going around and painting fire hydrants red, white and blue. I remember the Gema family across the street in Denver took their VW bus. It was red and they painted the stars and stripes on it. And I do think it has a potential for a moment where we can remember that more unites us than divides us in this country. Those three great ideas are perfect in the United States. Thank you so much, Justice. David, thank you very much. We really appreciate it. If you like this show, follow it on YouTube, Spotify or Apple. The opinions is produced by Derek Arthur, Vashaka Darba, Victoria Chamberlain, and Julian Weinberger. It's edited by Julian Weinberger, Jasmine Romero, and Carrie Pitkin. Mixing by Pat McCusker, original music by Isaac Jones, Sonia Herrero, Pat McCusker, Carol Saburo, Epheme Shapiro, and Amin Sahota. The fact-check team is Kate Sinclair, Mary Marge Locker, and Michelle Harris. The head of operations is Shannon Busta, audience support by Christina Samuluski. The director of opinion shows is Annie Rose Straser.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Justice Gorsuch emphasizes the importance of originalism, particularly in understanding the historical and philosophical foundations of the Declaration of Independence.
  2. The drafting process of the Declaration, especially Jefferson's role, reflects humility, strategy, and a deep commitment to expressing the American mind rather than a committee effort.
  3. The signers of the Declaration endured significant personal costs, including imprisonment, loss of property, and poverty, underscoring the human sacrifice behind the revolutionary ideals.
  4. Gorsuch links his judicial philosophy to the Declaration’s core principles—individual dignity, inalienable rights, and self-rule—viewing them as both foundational and enduring.
  5. History, particularly the treatment of Native Americans, informs Gorsuch’s jurisprudence, revealing systemic injustices and the necessity of historical awareness in legal interpretation.
  6. The separation of powers serves as a constitutional "how-to manual" that safeguards the Declaration’s promise of liberty and self-governance.
  7. Gorsuch values judicial independence and impartiality, grounded in the judicial oath to administer justice without favor or bias.
  8. The 250th anniversary of the Declaration offers a potential moment of national unity, reminding Americans of shared ideals despite ongoing divisions.

Summary:

Justice Neil Gorsuch and author Janie Nizzi discuss their children’s book *Heroes of 1776*, which celebrates the Declaration of Independence and its enduring values. The conversation highlights the historical process behind the Declaration’s creation, emphasizing Thomas Jefferson’s pivotal role, the personal sacrifices of the signers, and the revolutionary ideals of equality and inalienable rights. Gorsuch connects these foundational principles to his own judicial philosophy, describing his originalist approach as rooted in history, tradition, and a deep respect for individual dignity.

He underscores that the American experiment is built on shared ideals, not uniformity, and that legal decisions must reflect the nation’s founding commitments. The discussion also touches on the importance of historical awareness in addressing past injustices, such as those faced by Native Americans, and the role of separation of powers in protecting liberty. Gorsuch reflects on the significance of the 250th anniversary as a potential moment for national reflection and unity, reminding listeners that while disagreement is inevitable, shared values—like equal rights and self-rule—can bind a divided nation.

He stresses that the judiciary must remain independent, impartial, and faithful to the original meaning of the Constitution, serving as a guardian of the Declaration’s central promise: that every person has inherent worth and the right to self-governance.

FAQs

Justice Gorsuch was inspired by his childhood love of American history, particularly books like 'American Heritage Illustrated,' and wanted to inspire the next generation to understand the values and responsibilities of the Declaration of Independence.

Jefferson wrote the Declaration in isolation over two weeks, without consulting books or pamphlets, drawing from the American mindset of the time and expressing core ideas like equality and inalienable rights.

Jefferson included the ideas that all people are created equal, that individuals have inalienable rights given by God, and that every person has the right to self-govern, which were radical at the time and deeply influential.

Many signers lost their homes, were imprisoned, or had their families jailed. Some, like Thomas Nelson, spent their fortunes on the cause and died impoverished, with their graves marked so creditors couldn’t claim their bodies.

He sees the Declaration's emphasis on individual value and equal rights as foundational to his originalist views, reflecting a belief that individuals have intrinsic worth and are not mere cogs in a machine.

He believes history is essential to understanding the original meaning of the Constitution, but cautions that history is complex and contradictory, requiring careful judgment to distinguish consensus from anomalies.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.