[Music]
Hi, I'm Dan Smith and I'm a musician, songwriter and composer.
I'm Emma Lagous, I'm an academic and a tourist.
I've been writing songs about pairs of interesting people and ideas
and I went to Emma a while ago and asked for help
in uncovering stories and people I may not have heard of.
And in this podcast we get to talk about the people in those songs.
We're gonna have conversations about history, music,
mythology, pop culture and how those things can sometimes overlap.
Welcome to Muses, an ampersand podcast.
[Music]
Today we're talking about 17th century French opera singer,
fencer, dualist, all around bisexual icon,
an arsonist, shooer, whatever, moving on.
Julie Dobbinie, because Dan wrote a song about her,
surprise surprise. I think we all know that at this point.
Oh, this guy, right? That's stuff he doesn't know enough about.
Yeah, sure. So yeah, Dan wrote a song about her
called Mademoiselle and the Nunnery Blaise.
You can go and listen to it now but he has a little bit fear.
Because all monomool, say the word and I will go with you and you will.
So twang, 'cause you're tall, you're the off the moon
and the stars, the air in every breath.
Ooh, we could go and we could fly away from there.
[Music]
Wow. Oh, lush. We know what's great about that.
What? I introduced a consonant to the vowel sounds.
Did you? In the riff of that one, yeah.
Wow. It's lower rather than just "ah" in the beginning of the song.
You did. That took a while to meet to understand what you were saying.
I think what's a consonant? I'm trying,
child and carol boredom and I'm counting down.
Yeah, la la, that's true.
Today we're very excited because we have a guest.
We're going to be joined a bit later by author.
Billy Dupinie, back in the day.
Yeah, we've done a say-ons.
We're going to be joined later by author Kelly Gardner, who wrote the novel "Goddess"
about Julia Bernier's life and is firstly an amazing person but also way more of an expert
on Julia and her life than I think me.
I love, I can see the intensity with which you were considering whether it
include me in that sentence and you know what?
You were right to do that. Thank you very much.
Yeah. Your Kelly, having spent five years
in actual archives, the research in, as she says,
walking the ground that Julie walks out in person.
She just goes to Paris. Definitely more of an expert than me.
So yeah, but I appreciate that you can say that.
I'm glad I checked with you first.
And I saw the fear in your eyes that I really did.
What fear, what are you talking about?
More of an expert than the cogs were going.
It's nice to know that I am subtle enough that you can't see the cogs
working overtime all the time.
Yeah. So yeah, we're going to get to know a little bit more about Julia's life,
Justice Girls, which I mean, me and Dan.
And then, when Kelly comes along, we're going to talk about
turning that life into art, which is very nice, because Kelly's obviously written a novel about her.
You've written a song.
Kelly's actually also writing a nonfiction biography at the minute.
Yeah, it's really exciting. I also help make a radio program about her,
just saying, so we all have something to contribute maybe to that conversation,
but mostly Kelly. We do.
And actually, that radio program of yours was the first time I heard
anything about Julie and her life.
So thank you very much for that.
Listen, you're welcome. That's lovely to hear.
So Dan, what made you want to write a song about Julie?
Cause you introduced me to her and the story of her.
And the podcast that you work on, she's just amazing.
Yeah. And I think very much felt like someone I wanted to find out more about.
And explore the life of and try and write a song.
This, the song that we've ended up with, Manuazelle and the nunnery blaze.
Actually, I think I wrote one.
At least one, if not two songs before that, that weren't good enough.
I'm not saying that the one that is on the. Can you play them?
Yeah, I could actually.
Oh, that is, I'd never. You always go absolutely not every time asking like that.
Oh my god, really great.
I've not heard this in ages.
So it could be awful.
And there's a reason that I didn't finish it or put it out.
It took me a few goes to land on sort of what I wanted the sentiment of this to be.
But I think, as we'll hear in a bit,
she had such a kind of varied action-packed life and so many incredible experiences
and sort of romantic experiences, horrifying experiences, challenges.
You know, for someone who was both an amazing sword fighter
and an opera singer and kind of self-made in a celebrity and a criminal in some ways
and many different things, it was a real challenge to pick which of those.
I think I landed probably more on the side of, in my mind,
more on the side of a kind of imagined romantic moment from her life
in the same way that maybe I did on Red Wine and Wild.
But probably with a little bit more biographical information and some French.
Hmm.
It's the first time I've ever sung in French.
Is it?
Yes.
That's, I want to get it.
Yeah.
Oh god, this is seeing me off, I can't do it.
No, right, Dan, I just, you know, I have to put. Oh god, no, I can't do it.
Dan, I have to, you know, I intellectually perform for you every week.
This is true.
And it's really embarrassing.
So this is, I think, actually.
*music*
Oh god, it's awful, I can't see it.
Anyway.
I had a nice little bunge over here.
*laughter*
It's almost like there's a reason that I landed this so I can start again.
No, we can't come up please.
No, I'm good, thanks.
Dan, come on.
We'll come back to it.
But I appreciate the, the small little inside.
Yeah.
Fuck.
Every time I start a song forever from now,
I'll be like, "What would bunge over not do?"
*laughter*
Nothing gets bunge over.
I just don't want to sound like them.
I loved that.
*laughter*
Yeah.
Thank you, Dan.
Just a little insight into the music.
Yeah, you're welcome.
*laughter*
Anyway, so as ever with a lot of these characters,
I guess for me, a lot of my sort of path into them,
is fascinated by the headlines and the idea of them.
But, you know, that's why we're here.
Thank you.
I want to find out a lot more about Julie and her life.
Sorry.
I can't help you there, so.
Sorry.
If only there was an academic in the room.
*laughter*
So apart from being born in France in the 17th century,
when, where exactly was she born?
What was life like?
What would it have been like for her as a child?
And, you know, throughout her quite short lived,
but very eventful life.
Well, first, we need to put a big old probs
in front of, like, most things that we're going to say about her.
So she's one of these people in the past,
where it's really difficult to untangle myth and reality.
A lot of the sources will have for Julie come from, like, decades,
maybe even centuries later, after her life.
So it's difficult to know what's true and what's not.
But we'll have a bloody good crack at it.
Okay.
You know, yep, the Stan holds up a book.
*laughter*
Very good.
It's very good, Stan.
*laughter*
Five minutes after I mentioned it.
Yeah, really?
Just to remind everyone, Dan has read a book.
I have a hell of a book.
And he's really going to remind us of that, which is great.
In fact, Dan, hey, you take the floor.
Come on.
You've read the book.
It tells us about. It's just probably born around 1673.
Yeah.
Julie, Emily, Dobinier.
Julie, Julia, Emily, take your pick.
Oh, maybe a little.
Dan was probably Gaston Dobinier,
who we know fuck all about.
Her mother, but he. A telltale sign that he didn't write that, isn't it?
That little break in the middle of the sentence
that really changed the meaning of it, go on.
I'm sorry.
*laughter*
Sorry, I'm reading some stuff for Emma Rope.
*laughter*
So if you hate it, it's her fault.
*laughter*
Her dad was probably Gaston Dobinier.
We don't know anything about her mom.
But we think that Gaston, her dad,
worked at the King's Royal Stables.
No one works at the Royal Stables, like Gaston.
Yeah.
The King being. King Louis XIV to France.
So, a very big deal.
This is the King, who moved his court
to the incredibly elaborate Versailles.
So, if Julie's dad worked for him,
it's likely she also moved to Versailles.
And the court moved there in 1682.
She'd been nine-ish.
Tell me a bit more about what. How fancy life would have been like in Versailles for her.
Yeah.
And for her and her dad.
It would have been really fucking nice at Versailles.
I mean, not nice as an enjoyable place to be,
but Versailles is an incredibly elaborate,
spectacular, beautiful place.
And Julie is a commoner to her to say in.
A commoner growing up in the orbit of Louis.
Difficult to know what Julie would have been exposed to there.
But it's very likely that Julie so offers there lots of shows.
You know, her dad works in the Stables,
so gets exposed to horse riding.
She may have trained with pages.
And this is how we think, from an early age,
she's exposed to some of the things that she'll be infamous for later,
namely Fenson and Ben and opera singer.
And I guess yes, it kind of makes sense, right?
That she'd be absorbing all of this sword fighting energy
at the same time as.
the sort of cultural side, you know, maybe and that's why we're here at the origin story
of this amazing dualist both in both sense of the thing. I got it. Yeah. He means dualist like
duels like fighting and also like two. Yeah, two hobbies. Three if you include the ladies. Am I right?
Four if you include the boys too. Yeah, four hobbies.
It's worth saying not all swashbuckle and fun done and I'm painting a very idyllic picture here.
You really are. So age 14 and you're the French speaker here. So if you just just like correct
my pronunciation, but he seems to have become the comp to arm and yaks mistress. No, no, no, it's
can we have all the 14 year old and mistress? I mean, that's what a lot of the literature says,
but anyway, there we go. I mean, I guess what is that what she would have been referred to at time?
Well, I don't know, wasn't there? All I'm saying is that now 14 year old,
because he was 46. Yes. I mean, it's on on every level. It's very far. Yeah. Anyway, he was 46
and was a dad's boss. So she lived in Paris after that at the hotel to Arminyak. So she was married
off to Mosseur Jean-Demoper, a tax collector. And this we think was like cover for her being
the comp did at Arminyak's mistress. Right. It's like a reason for her to be there essentially.
So she's in that situation in Paris as a kind of like kept woman mistress, but obviously it's not
that because she's a small child, which is insane. But then she in Kelly's book then runs off
with her sword fighting teacher. So ran. So ran. Yes. Which sounds. Is it a teacher?
Was he is a he's a he's a fan sir. Yes. So we do think that's probably true. Why would she possibly
one of us get a situation she was in. Why would you not? He's tall, dark, handsome, not a 46 year old
creep. No offense to 46 year olds. Listening full offense to any creeps. So yeah. So she runs up
with a fencer, absolute bad lad. So ran. He's in trouble for Julian, which is illegal in France at
the time. That was a real bug brother of the Kings, right? This particular king absolutely hated.
Yeah. In the fact that like he has to continually ban it suggests it's not sticking.
You know what I mean. So they run away together. And from what I'd heard on
podcasts that you worked on and in goddess, I got the sense that when they run away, they're then
kind of on the road doing kind of sword fighting shows. And she's maybe singing a bit in public as
well, sort of like a guest to earn money to fund this sort of road trip escape of this. That
would be a good road trip film, wouldn't it? Yeah. Yeah. Seran and Julie on the road. Like two romance. Yeah. Three roadbants.
That was very good. Yeah. It seems that they did bends together,
part and little shows, but they all saw sang together and they'll get you a girl who can do both,
am I right? And at this point, it's just wild how like wilds the story is. Like it's at that point
that they're at the Marseille opera. And honestly, who knows how that happened? Yeah. I felt like
in Kelly's book, there's a there are a bunch of sort of seemingly factual things about her or
things people have witnessed. I claim were true. Obviously, loads of made up stuff. Obviously,
loads of legend and narrative. And I think in Kelly's book, what's really interesting is seeing
them try and thread red. These moments together is something that is kind of unbelievable. Yeah. You're
like, so sorry, you're on the road and you're really poor. And you're fencing. Fencing. Fencing and
singing. And suddenly at the Marseille opera. Cool. Yeah. You were just in a car with Christine Slayer.
How has this happened? I would love to know a bit more about what would have
been like. Yeah. Do you do an impression? No. And yeah, I can. Actually, I've got a really good
impression of her voice that I'm just going to warm up now before I perform it for you. Okay.
And just off off mic. But it's actually more like, why is it this work? And this is really shot
with my thoughts. Oh, the moment's gone. I'm trying to play believe by share.
Oh, that would have landed wonderfully. Yeah. Just imagine it. Just everybody imagine it.
This is something that confused me a little bit is her voice is referred to with a few different
terms. So she's referred to as a badu su. Do you know what that means? I should never
want because you're like a voice person. Yeah. Or a singer. Some people. Yeah. Actually,
I see myself more as a songwriter than a singer. Do you? Yeah. Okay. Well, that's your
progress, isn't it? I think other people are going to have to do. I did not know what badu su
meant. And it means the low treble, just like a direct translation. But elsewhere, a contralo,
so you know, I'll or being that other that the what's the word abbreviation. Yeah, very good
fellow. It was an answer. I don't know why the absolute no reason in the world, but in my head,
she was quite low for a woman. Yeah. I was imagining her being a soprano just because she was a star.
She was a star. She was a star. She was a star. She was a star. And I always think of the soprano
being the a grabbing headline grabber. That's a really interesting observation. So I talked about
this in some detail to my friend, Dr. Hannah Tricingham Robbins shout out for every
brainstorming this with me because you're absolutely right that that is like the sort of star vocal
range in a lot of instances for like performers. But Hannah was telling me that it takes a while
for these terms with vocal ranges and voice types, which are different things to be fixed. So what
may have been an although in the 17th century may have looked or sounded different a century later.
So actually despite all these terminologies we have for her, we actually really don't know what
she would have sounded like. But the headline is that her voice was likely somewhere between a
metal and an although. So on the lower end for most women, it's a rich and low like shit.
So this is why people actually write entire parts for Julie later on in her career.
Yeah, really interesting. Yeah. What's a what's a force? What's a vocal force?
Like shit. Yeah, like shit. Now all I can hear. What's your voice type? I think I'm a
tenor. I think anything for a tenor. Yeah, she don't know answers on a postcard anyone. But yeah,
what a cool time to bring up your singing your voice specifically because the next big thing for
our story is what you wrote your song about. Yes. So her leaving surround for a another partner
who in I'm imagining quite a sort of high society situation was a younger woman/girl that she fell in
love with and eventually convinced. What are I, Cressa Busy-Roo? Cressa.
You put it so beautifully. I'm a songwriter. So I guess yeah, we now meet the moment that the
song Manuazelle and the Lana Reblades that I wrote. She basically falls in love. I think
mutually falls in love with an unnamed person but who in the book is called Clara. Clara.
Who knows about mutually? Oh wait, maybe we don't even know her name. Let's not make any assumptions
here. Anyway, she falls in love with someone who in the book is called Clara and Clara's family
massively don't improve. So they send her away to a convent and I guess enroll her as a nun and
Julie won't be having none of that and she follows her and enrolls herself as a nun as well.
Manuazelle, it is so fucking funny. If you're a parent and you think your daughter likes women,
then you send her to an actual convent full of women. Yeah. Cressa's ex-he nuns.
Yeah. Moby and Funny, but what do you expect? Yeah, it's a weird choice, isn't it? Sort of like
the modern parenting equivalent of patching your kids' smoking and then making them finish the pack.
Yeah. So this is your big area of expertise with this part of the story because you wrote a song
about it. So do you know what happened sex with Julie? She's not deterred. No, so Julie's not the
turd. She loves this woman and she follows her to the nunnery. I guess enrolls or enlists as a nun
and I can- Enlists as a nun. Yeah. Yeah. Why is that so funny? She enlists as a nun. Yeah.
Yeah. And the parents of this girl's worst night there, she's now locked
away in a nunnery with- In a sexing nunnery. In a sexing nunnery. In France. With the woman
who she loves and who loves her. And then an old lady nun dies. That's supposed to not man nun.
Sorry. An older nun passes away. They find the body and they think we've got a great plan. What if,
what Julie thinks? What if we burn the bedroom and the nunnery down and people might think that
the body of the old nun is actually you, Clara, and then we can run away together. Do they do the
body swap? Yes, they do a body swap. So they think this- That's a normal story.
They think this is a totally flawless plan. Nothing can go wrong here. Nothing can go wrong
the fact that like two of us will go missing with this only one body and also the old nun who
have gone missing as well. They'll never put that together. Come on. Sorry. Come on. Don't be so
joyless about this. He's still I'm really fun to watch a film with. So they burn the nunnery down
and they run away together and all we really know after that is they spend some time together but
ultimately don't end up together quite soon. Which given the sort of commitment to following Clara
to the nunnery, Clara obviously being her fictional given name and burning down an entire building
and burning a corpse maybe to be with her and then not ending up together. Yeah. Speaking of films,
what do you think that third installment of the sister act franchise would be called?
Sister act three with all pleasures. That's amazing. No, you're dead. Oh no. Sister act three.
- Nons on the run.
- Nons on the run.
What happens after you enlistin' a nunnery?
(laughing)
Anyway, all M. Alt-titles for your song, they're done.
You're welcome.
Anyway, Madden, Wazelle sets the nunnery ablaze,
which is very exciting.
Yeah, as you say, the relationship doesn't last long.
There's practicalities of st. together
outside of the La Violin Villa, as we might say.
And then Julie gets caught,
hoydin' the clink in Avignon.
That's chucked in prison in Jordy.
But miraculously dodges the death sentence given to her.
So that is a very nice meet cute.
But do you know how she met her next boy toy,
their comforter, Albert?
- Well, she is pretty rowdy, and she loves the fights.
And so maybe, maybe in a punch-up?
- Yeah.
Basically.
(laughing)
Yeah, he challenges her to a duel,
thinking that she's a lad,
probably 'cause she's doing something naughty.
- And dresses often in men's clothes.
- Yeah, and they fight, she stabs him, or something.
She has, like, post-stab regret.
(laughing)
And looks after him, and they start banging.
And shortly thereafter, I mean, it's a nice bond
and exercise to stab someone in nursing back to health, isn't it?
- So this is after she's been friendly in prison.
So probably she wouldn't necessarily be
with girlfriend from before.
- Yeah, so her and the comforter, Albert,
they stay friends forever.
It's really what fairy tales are made of.
- Oh, nice, nice.
An initial burst of excitement,
and then just a sustainable friendship.
- Yeah.
- And then what happens, what happens next?
So something between all the dueling and the arson
and the relationships with lots of different people,
how does she go from that to becoming France's next top singer?
- So she travels around France more,
she gets singing lessons from a very boozy, older actor
named Marichal.
- Marichal.
- That's probably better.
- And I was made up.
(laughing)
- They don't bang.
- Okay.
- But then she meets a younger guy about her tone.
Gotta watch out for the bassists, don't you?
(laughing)
- Really?
- I don't know.
- And called Gabrielle Vincent Severnard.
Again, my French, I mean, I don't have even a GCSE
in one foreign language, so.
- My best bit of French, which I say.
- Is Bastille.
(laughing)
- Yeah, I just love that.
- But I'm sorry, this is getting less fun
than making fun of you,
'cause you saw resigned to it.
(laughing)
- You just see the weary look in my eye.
- Oh yeah, I just love that.
- So when we have toured in different countries,
and got to play gigs abroad and festivals,
I always feel really self conscious
about getting up on a stage
and not being able to speak the language
of the country that I'm in.
So often I'll like chat to someone that's working
at the show who's local or the promoter,
and I'll write like, for me,
just everything I'd want to say at the gig
in whatever the local language is,
but I have to write it phonetically for myself.
Which often backfires horribly, you know.
- Any specific stories there, Dan?
- No, but.
- None that you want to say.
- All I know in French is,
is just to tell you my French is terrible.
Which means.
- I'm sorry my French is terrible.
- How did you know? - Yeah.
- Wow, I know this type of French as well.
- Jeanette Comprompas, Jesse-Soui, Yonge Lee.
Hey, hey.
(laughing)
And that's from watching a behind the scenes video
from the BBC show Merlin, which is filmed in France.
- What was it?
- Yeah. - Anyway, sorry.
A lovely pronunciation of Gabrielle von Saint-Tévinneau.
I just asked me about what that might sound like.
But what happens with her with Julie and Gabrielle Vincent?
- Well, they do bang.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- That's so enlighten. - It's kind of a surprise.
(laughing)
That's funny.
(laughing)
Anyway, so he auditions and gets into the Paris opera
with the deal. - Okay.
- But on one condition, and you know what that condition is?
- What's that?
- The Julie can come too.
- Oh, that's so romantic.
- In like.
- Nepotism, boyfriend getting you a job.
- Good nepotism. - Good nepotism.
We like that nepotism.
- That's progressive nepotism.
- Aggress nepotism.
But hang on, so she's, hang on.
(laughing)
Hold up. - Hold up.
- Hold up.
Hold up, hold up, hold up French.
(laughing)
I'm confused.
Is she on the run at the moment?
How is she getting from being a kind of criminal
on the run to being going back to Paris?
- I think, as you mentioned in your song,
or like gesture to you in your song,
is it, she gets a lot of pardons,
like royal pardons sometimes?
- Yeah, I guess I read that she was pardons twice,
but at least twice. - At least twice.
- So we think that, remember like, you know,
she was mistress, I mean, court and court mistress,
to like, you know, the comp to Arminyak earlier,
who's like very fancy and powerful,
and she has quite a lot of well-to-do friends,
and we think that people are intervening on her behalf,
and then when later on,
she becomes a celebrity and is really famous,
so for various reasons, yeah, she gets pardoned
for a lot of these things, but you're right,
she has been on the run,
but this is why she's allowed back in Paris,
because she has been pardoned for her court and court crimes.
And also, it is worth mentioning,
she's only fucking 17 at this point still.
- She's insane.
- She's wild, isn't it?
- Yeah, that's really crazy.
- Yeah, anyway, so Julie or stage name.
- Sorry, at 17, I'd done,
I could barely swing a sentence together,
I'd done absolutely nothing.
- I was the back end of a pantomime horse when I was 17.
- Stop it, where are you?
- Flashlighten was the name of the horse.
- Was that your first big role?
- Yeah, in a pantomime.
- Congratulations.
- Yeah, well, when I was in,
I mean, I had other roles, Dan,
but being in the pantomime was a very big deal back there.
- Yeah.
- The school, the school, no, the pro, wow.
- For the pro amdram, anyway.
- So look, you and Julie, both massive,
over to you, is at 17, I had never done nothing.
- Yeah, and here's stage name, stage name was,
and you're the French one.
Do you want to read them out, read them out?
- Madame was elle la moppa.
- Yeah, or?
- Or just la moppa.
- Yeah, she's phenomenally successful.
It's meant to have the most beautiful singing voice.
We think she made casually joules three men at a ball,
but we'll talk more about that later with Kelly.
But she does seem to have fucked off
to Brussels quite sharpish after that.
So, you know what we're saying,
that we don't know what's true and what's not.
That suggests she did get into some sort of trouble.
- Right.
- If she's just like half an hour across.
- So she's a bit of a repeat fender.
- Well, I wouldn't say that, Dan.
But I just said that she went to Brussels,
so probably did some at naughty.
- Just 'cause she got pardoned a few times,
had to go to Brussels.
- Yeah, no, yeah, very no.
- They would apply that she's, you know.
- Yeah, so she's in Brussels,
she gets to know Maximilian Emmanuel.
- Okay.
- Great name.
- Really great name.
- Yeah, the elective Bavaria nor Big Deal.
That doesn't seem to have ended amazing.
Some sources say that he'd like just offered
a loads of money to laugh off.
So yes, she gets into a little bit more trouble
with various people before heading back to Paris again.
Where she is probably pardoned again for various crimes.
And she's back to singing.
- I wonder if she's pushing her luck.
- If you could get away with it, why wouldn't you?
- Honestly, she's back singing, performing.
It really does seem that she's absolutely incredible.
We mentioned earlier that she has this stunning voice
in as credited by lots of people.
As you mentioned earlier,
it introduced in this lower control or voice to France.
- I remember when we first were talking about her
and you were asking me what angle I was going to take
with the song.
And I mentioned that it was a love song.
And I was thinking of the relationship
with the person that she broke out of the nunnery.
But you maybe assumed that I meant another woman
that was a massive relationship in her life
who I at the time didn't know about.
Who is this absolute love of her life
that is there sort of through the closing period
of her days?
- I see what you're doing here.
You've raised that so that I have to be the name out first.
(laughing)
- Which I respect.
- To Florentzac, to Florentzac.
- Yeah.
- The day Florentzac.
- Yeah, yeah.
It seems like, I mean, I would say,
I didn't assume you're writing it about her.
Did I?
- No, no, no, no, I think you just asked.
- I think you just asked.
- Yeah.
- It seems like she was in love with Madame Le Marquis
de Florentzac.
Oh my, I really apologize to the sisters for my French.
It's like, I think it really tanks my credibility.
- I think we should start again
and we will call this whole thing in French.
- Yeah.
- We.
(laughing)
But yeah, she seems to have fallen in love
with Madame Le Marquis de Florentzac in 1703.
Described as the most beautiful woman in France.
- Sorry to just good maths is not my strong point.
How old would she be in 1703?
(laughing)
How old would she be?
- Unlike me, interestingly great at maths.
- How old would she be in 1703?
- We think she was born around 1673.
- Okay.
- 183, 193.
- Oh three.
- 193.
- So 30.
- Okay.
- On the bloody dot, we think.
So around the age of 30,
Described as the most beautiful woman in France.
He was in Brussels.
Do you know why she was in Brussels?
- No.
- Because she was hiding from the pervy prince
who was like absolutely obsessed with her,
probably because Afore mentioned being very hot.
And it seems like they were just like really in love,
living in perfect bliss until de Florentzac died of a fever.
I know, two years later, it's so sad
and Julie was heart sick with grief.
Perhaps enter in a convent, ironically.
Where she died a few years later in 1707,
which because we're really both great at maths.
We can see about day three.
- She was 33.
- Yeah.
- At that point, in her Jesus year, you know.
- In her Jesus year, yeah.
- Also 33, man.
He died.
- It's like the OG 27 club.
- Yeah.
- She made it.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
- I guess.
- Yeah.
- Wow.
What a life.
- Yeah.
- I mean, the amount she did before she was 17
and we sort of fast forwarded quite fast
from 17 to 33 to dead, but I mean, like I said before,
what a daunting life to try and write a song about, eh?
- Yeah.
Why did you do it?
- I know.
(laughing)
- So just to segue perfectly,
I think with a life quite so nuanced, rich and expansive,
why write a three minute song, badly,
when you could write a fictionalized version as a novel.
And now I'm very excited because we're gonna talk
to the brilliant.
- I'm very excited.
- Very.
- Very.
- Very.
- Okay. - Yeah.
- Trey.
- Yeah. - Trey's excited.
- Trey's excited.
- We have the amazing opportunity of speaking
to the absolutely brilliant, hilarious,
and very, very talented Kelly Gardiner,
who wrote Goddess, which is, like we said,
a kind of fictional take on the life.
Fictional, but as we'll hear--
- Incredibly well researched.
- Incredibly well researched.
Kelly is a real authority on the life of Julie.
And obviously took with you--
- And a great time.
- Yes, a really great time.
- Yeah. - Okay, let's hear it from Kelly.
(gentle music)
Kelly Gardiner is an author who writes historical fiction,
crime and fantasy, the readers of all ages.
They also teach creative writing and run retreats.
And my chat with Kelly today is there an expert
on Julie Dobinay, and you can tell me
if I've pronounced that wrong,
'cause you're the expert.
It's been five years research in her life
for the novel Goddess.
Hello, Kelly.
- Hello, thank you.
- Kelly, thank you so much for joining us.
We're so excited to have you here.
- Oh, it's a pleasure.
Great to talk about her at any time, I have to say.
- I think just to kick off,
do you reckon you could maybe summarize your novel
for listeners who may, we, me and Dan have done a whole
whether we read it, but if you could summarize it
in your own words instead of us doing it for you,
that would be incredible.
- Okay, Julie was 17th century French, opera star,
cross dresser, and swordswoman.
And in a way, that's all you need to know.
- Yeah.
- Because she has been portrayed many times
in fiction and on screen.
And people try and do different things with her.
So one of the first questions I had to ask myself
is not just who was she, but how would she have seen herself?
And so I wrote the book, I structured it as a five act opera
with a prologue, which is the sort of opera
she used to perform in.
And it's, nobody knows this, but me,
but it's minutely structured around that kind of idea.
She was seen then, and particularly in the 19th century,
as either a terrible sinner or a goddess,
which is why I gave her that title.
And so the other sort of structure in it is that
it's a deathbed confession to a priest
who never gets a word in.
And she's sort of logging her way through the sins
that people would think she committed,
but whether or not she believes
that she committed any sins is a different matter entirely.
And so they're the two sort of structures about it.
It goes between her deathbed confession in first person
and then a lot of her existence in the world
is about how people saw her.
So then it switches to the third person
so that we can see how people see her
and they're kind of looking in at her.
'Cause she was a celebrity.
And so it is partly about a celebrity.
- Yeah, I love the way that it flips
from chapter to chapter in that way.
How'd you first come across the story of Julie?
- Well, I fenced as a kid, and she's in all the fencing
and sword fighting, you know, encyclopedias and histories,
just often as a little footnote.
And sometimes in the older ones, as a, you know,
there was this terrible woman
who dared to raise her sword against men.
So I feel like I've known her quite a long time.
And then recently the internet's given her an extra life
because, you know, I kind of keep my eye on it
and every week on social media,
there's some, especially young queer person going,
"Oh my God, I just found out about this woman."
And she's incredible.
And so there's been an eruption of interest
and there've been a few articles about her.
And so she was sort of, I was reminded about her.
And as soon as I was reminded that was it,
I couldn't get it out of my brain.
- I loved, there's a quote you gave
when you were explaining who she was in an interview
and you said, "Imagine like Lady Gaga
mixed with an Olympic athlete."
And it is just mind blowing to comprehend
how someone could be that good at so many things
and famous and beautiful and all of these things
and complicated.
I think it must have been really interesting
making loads of decisions in the process
of how to kind of unpick that
and how to represent her as a sort of
video-dimensional nuanced person as well.
- When you were talking about the architecture,
it's clear it's so well researched
because I love all that magnitude deal.
So yeah.
- Well, it was part of a creative writing PhD
and the nonfiction part of it was the research into her life.
And so I did all the archival stuff.
I mean, one of the things about her,
there are lots of legends about her.
So one of the first questions was,
are some of these incredible stories actually true?
And to be honest, I couldn't prove
or disprove many of the main stories
that people tell about her.
But writing a novel means that I sort of early on decided
if something seemed credible,
if it was possible that it might have happened
and it was recorded early on,
either in her life by somebody,
even if it was a rumor spread at that time,
I can't tell now, but it wasn't sort of invented
in the 1920s or something like some of them have been.
If it seemed credible and it was recorded fairly early on,
I would include it 'cause it's part of her story.
It's part of her legend, including the conference story.
Nobody knows now whether that was true,
but we may be able to prove it at some point.
So that was the first thing.
What is the reality of this life?
And then the next part,
so there's a lot of historical research
and archival research and looking back at the letters
and the tabloid newspapers that they had then
and reading all the liberty of the operas she was in
and the opera records and so on.
I had to go to Paris, of course.
- Oh, what a shame.
- Yeah. - What a nightmare for you, though.
- No, this is my hint to any would be writers out there,
set your books somewhere you really wanna go.
I really believe in walking the ground as well.
So this is obviously not a lot of Paris left the way
that she would have known,
but there is some and certainly Avignon
and other places that she was are pretty intact.
So that's research for me as well.
Walking the ground, I went to some of the,
they're not exactly the right opera houses,
they're a little bit later than hers
just to get a sense of the space and how it would feel
'cause opera, of course, then was very different
to the opera that you might go to now.
Everybody stood up and sang along
and smelled, so I did all that sort of experiential research
as well as the archival stuff,
but I mean, the other big questions are,
like if you were her, how would you make sense of yourself?
Has there ever been a sword fighting cross-dressing opera star?
No.
So I had to do a whole lot of research into other women
who were sword fighters or who had fought in wars
and there had been some women who had fought
and have written about their lives in the civil wars
in England and also in France in her sort of lifetime
or just before, some of them were very famous.
How would she have understood sexuality in a world
where they just didn't have the sort of identity words
and language that we have now to explain it
and how would queer people find one another, for example?
Other women at that time were being exiled
or find or thrown in prison
in some countries executed
and the same with homosexual men, of course.
So she transcended that, she transcended class,
she transcended most things
and that's one of the most interesting things about her, really.
And the research was that anything that really sort of took you
by surprise that you weren't expecting to uncover?
Yeah, I mean, one of the things is about how,
she's famous for fighting duels with various men
and one of the things really was that she kept getting
in really big trouble, you could get into really big trouble
for having a duel, the king absolutely disapproved of dueling.
And so she and several of her friends,
various times had to leave Paris.
They'll bear who was her lover
and a lifelong friend was thrown in jail
and he was like really wealthy and really well connected.
But still, he was in jail for quite some months
for having a duel one time.
So the amount of running away she had to do,
which is famous for having to leave Paris,
but the amount of travel that she had to do,
she famously had a duel one night after kissing a girl
at a court ball and three men challenged her to a duel
and she fought them, not all at once,
but one by one at the same time.
And I like to think it's all at once.
Yeah, you can do that if you like.
(laughing)
Well, I mean, who knows?
She might have.
Maybe who knows?
Might have been.
Let's just think that.
Anyway, and so she had to run away.
So she went to Brussels and then Madrid
and even when she was young, after the, again,
her lover at the time had to leave Paris
'cause he'd been involved in a duel
and they'd gone down to Marseille
and then she traveled all around France, by herself.
And at this point, I mean, most of the big dramatic things
that happened to her happened before she was 18,
including her debut at the opera.
That's what's so, just reading her life story
and reading your book as well,
just the amount that she packed into such a,
you know, in modern times considerably short life
is so unbelievable that all those things happened to her
as such a young age is wild.
So it makes an audience, so young.
Yes, I know.
So much notiness, but also like so much really sad stuff.
So I think what you were saying earlier, Kelly,
and what I really like about the book
is that you do flesh out this like quite a normal stuff
about like how Julia may have felt about things
and things that we don't really know
from sources that we have.
But I guess what me and Dan have talked about a lot
And I'd love. to know is how did you decide in the novel of what sort of voice you would give her or how
she might feel about things. So I guess they're burning down the Nunneries, the big example,
because that's what Dan wrote a song about as well in the book. Yeah, in the book she's like
really regretful is I think in like quite remorseful and I don't know if Gile E but she doesn't
go like yeah I burned down a Nunnery sort of thing. Yeah, two questions there. Her voice,
I always heard it. I heard it as soon as I decided I could hear her voice and I still hear it.
The first person voice is very very strong and it is consciously anti-authentic if you like.
It's consciously very modern. Hopefully it's sort of a bit timeless as well but I didn't want it
to be oldy-worldy and she's still nattering in my ear thankfully I don't mind because she's good
company but that never changed. So that voice never changed. I could always hear it very clearly
and that's not always the case when you're writing a novel and one of the things I was very
conscious of is that we all project on to people. I mean this part of the thing about celebrity right?
We project on to people what we want them to be what we need them to be and so all those young
queer people finding her now and getting excited they're making her into this amazing queer icon
which she can be whatever you want because you're projecting your own stuff right but if you go
into something like writing a novel knowing that that is something that you might do then you have
to take that very seriously and I didn't want her to be I wanted her to be iconic but I didn't want
to make her into being a pure feminist icon or a flawless queer icon that people kind of want her
to be sometimes just the way that in the 19th century people either portrays her as an icon of
romanticism and beauty or as a monster. She's one of those people that generations have projected
stuff onto and I tried not to do that and I thought she must have been trouble really if you think about it.
She would have had to just to survive she would have been maybe a little bit arrogant sometimes
maybe not very thoughtful about other people sometimes but we know she was a good friend
and we know she had lots of lovers and we know that she was a fantastic singer and people love
her people used to sing songs about her in the streets and so on. Bram Stoker who wrote Dracula
wrote a short biography once and he had her killing ten men in order to escape.
Wow okay is that not true? No she made that up in 1920 or whenever so I mean we all have to make
things up because there are these big gaps in the record and we don't know. With a bit of distance
now I love what you said about her voice still being in your head and I'm not a writer so I can't
imagine that but I can imagine all the songs. Yeah but they're three minutes. Pithy little three
minute things it's not the same. I'm just I'm just one of those people back in the streets in the
day like singing my song to Julian building up her legend but in a much less cool interesting way
but yes sorry I love it. I'm really oh thank you I'm really yeah I'm interested to know about
the path to make it fiction given how much research you do which you know is completely understandable
and I think amazing and I'm fascinated by that whole process but also yeah now that there's a whole
other audience constantly evolving and constantly emerging that it's fascinated by her you know
if there's anything you change or anything you would readdress or you're quite good at being like
no it's done that's fine I made those decisions. I don't think there's anything I'd change about
the fiction and I think it always needed to be fiction for me but I am now I've returned to the
research and I am going to write if I can get my act together a nonfiction version. Oh the way amazing
oh I'm so excited about that and that will have to say you know this is a story about her and
this is where the story was told and we can't tell whether this is true so that has to be a lot more
sort of objective and woven into it will be so you will love this Dan will be the research that I did
and how I did it so how I felt when I was in the ultra branch holding Dobbe's book that sort of thing
so I love that too I'm the historian I really like sources I just tried to keep cool
this is this is yeah Emma's way more excited than me I want a themed shirt for this
I'm like dress the story I'm sure it's like no I'm gonna put on oh I should have said I thought I've
got quite a few bisexual things in opera singing I'm gonna steal your girl outfits and I thought
this one translated the most for this visually on zoom it does do you have like this is such a
basic question do you have like a favorite myth that you think isn't true but you just want
to lean into it I guess the myth of the or the story of the three jewels on the one night is my
favorite I really really want that to be true but we think that it might have been right because we
did we did we did a little bit on the other podcast that I work on we don't do a lot of primary
research but we did for Julie and there were some sources that were really quite close to her
lifetime very early sources yeah whether she killed them oh I don't think she did the julan seems
like yeah no I think I mean this is one of the things people often say that she killed all these
people I think if she had killed anybody we would definitely know yeah yeah because that would have
been it wouldn't just be a scandal she would have been absolutely thrown in prison and not forgiven
but I think that is one of the stories that was recorded very early on and it is more likely to be
true than others because the other thing is that some of the other blocs they might have been
hopeless so that she was really good it's nice that we can love her more as a loveable rascal
because we know she probably didn't kill anyone she was bad but not that bad yeah me and dine have
talked about this before like so we didn't ever so in oscar wild but a few other people that especially
with queer people a lot of their lives are unknowable but when they're criminalized that's often when
we do know quite a lot about them so as you say if she'd killed someone it seems like there'd be
something in some sort of historical record that would suggest that people are likely that she would
have gotten away with that it's interesting having this person and I think you thread it together
brilliantly in the book but with these kind of iconic moments like you speak of that night
in the three jewels but even the fact that in a very public space she's sort of dressed in men's
pose and just walks straight up to the most beautiful girl there and they have a massive kiss in
public that it speaks so fantastically to her openness and I say brazenness only in that that
would have been frowned on by a lot of people at the time and then they sort of crescendos into
the jewels but these blockbuster moments are amazing the between this sort of nunnery fire and that
and so many other moments is such a spectacular life and it must have been so much fun to constantly
uncover and I imagine if you're writing a nonfiction book at the moment you're probably still
discovering things yeah and things get you know new things get found or well they're not lost but they're
just waiting to be found but they're waiting to be found or they digitized yeah all the time so yeah
and it might not be about who it might be about something else that was going on at that time that
explains some other thing that helps me understand her world yeah yeah because just from like I guess
maybe a boring practical perspective but she's like referred to as Julie Julia Emily Maupat like
that's got to be difficult actually because who knows what she's referred to as in various sources
so there's got to be so much waiting to be found but being able to stitch together who that's
actually referring to might be a challenge but yeah what's it like coming back to this years later
to write nonfiction or is it not really coming back if you see she's always in your head
well no it's different because I can't she can't help me very much with the biography
unfortunately and also it's a long time I mean that book came out in 2014 and so I've been
researching for you know five years before that so there are things that I've just forgotten
there are things that I have to go through all over again and so it's not quite like starting
from scratch because I've gathered the resources but I have to go through them all again
oh I'm so excited for this to become a reality in that selfishly so I can read it
well I better write it now yeah I was so just really interested sort of there's a blog post on
your site about potentially it being option for a film and I'm just really interested to know if
you can talk about that what's the story well yes it has been and I'm not sure what I can say really
it was option by do dumb entertainment and they are working on the script now what do you wish
for it well it's the funny thing you know you have to hand it over you know it's their story now
and they might see her in a completely different way or the scriptwriter might see her in a
completely different way or we have had a chat about it and I have every confidence in them the
story will be different because different people are telling it and that's okay in fact that's how
her story has always been that's such a dreamy answer because you're very generous with the subject
and also just listeners if you go on to Kelly's website the amount of research that you've shared
just open access for so many people is like I quite rare like academically and incredibly helpful
also what I loved is like you made like a map where you pinpointing different locations that she's
saying I love that so I just really encourage people to do that and I guess that maybe that leads
on to another question and I'm like that's quite a lot of work there are a lot of lies told about
her over hundreds of years and I wanted to be transparent about my read.
research, but it hasn't really worked. People still get excited at a few murders in there
and so that she was a spy or whatever. So it was partly about that transparency. I want people to
know what is known, what is credible, what other people made up later about her. So I just wanted
to cut through some of that with some pretty basic knowledge that I'd gathered about her, I suppose.
I see you've talked a lot about how there are lots of myths about Julie and you wanted to maybe
cut through some of that mythology. So that's stuff that you want people to sort of not know,
or maybe unlearn about Julie, but is there something that you wish more people knew about her?
Well, I suppose one of the things that I wonder about is, that's probably true of any artist, right?
There's so much fuss made about her life and in her case, her sword fighting, and very little
fuss made about the fact that she was described as having the most beautiful voice in the world,
that she was a performer, she was a star, and because she was a star, because she was so incandescent
on stage, I mean, people fainted and screamed when she made her debut on the stage. That has been
sort of pushed aside for the excitement of the rest of her life, and I think that sort of does
her a disservice because she was an artist, she was a singer, she introduced a whole new vocal
range to France, she was France's first Contrello, and I think that's what I'd like people to
think about, as well as all the adventures, because of course it's fantastic and it's entertaining
and so on, but at heart, she was an artist. That's amazing, but I mean, it speaks to how
incredible her life is because that's already pretty sensational, and this amazing voice
that causes people to faint, and that's not the most interesting thing about you.
When that's not the headline, you know you've done a lot. So Dan, how many people have fainted
at the sound of your voice, it shows? I was going to say that sounds a lot like our gigs all the time.
But generally they're screaming in horror with their hands on their ears, it's like
fading for the opposite reasons, yeah. Kelly, thank you, I can't thank you enough for this, it's been
such a pleasure to get to speak to you, and yeah, really loves being able to read the book, and I can't
wait to learn more about Julie by what you've got coming next. Thank you, and yeah, everyone,
go and get a hold of Goddess. Kelly, thank you so much. Oh, thank you, happy to talk about her.
You can see how entertaining she is, right? I know, I know, it's amazing. Now we're not recording,
Kelly, watching a dance song, you can tell. Thank you so much to Kelly, and now for my favourite bit
of the podcast, which isn't remotely cringe for me or awful, but you know. Yeah, we're still
doing it, so it doesn't mind that much. Yeah, oh no, don't tell me what you think of the song.
Even though it's exclusively being nice things, and where on episode eight now, aren't we?
So this is the bit where we slash Emma does a deep dive into my song. Deep dives generous.
Okay, I have some thoughts sometimes, should I take a sentence stage? I wish I knew the word
in opera speak for like, look, I will take the head off the horse, and you can step forward,
and beat him out. Thank you. Okay, finally. Okay, so Mademoiselle and the Donnery Blaise, I think it's
great. Thank you. Yeah, I do, especially as you've written this one from the point of view of
Julie, I think, yeah. I think it's lush to think about it after we've heard from Kelly and the
process that they went through of imagining and fleshing out Julie's voice. So the burning down
of the con ven is obviously a very dramatic part of the story, and where with Kelly's interpretation,
Julie is, I think, quite, to a remorseful, but it's like very drama-led, it's very like action-corded,
whereas in your song, it's, you know, it's a lot more romanticized, I think, from like,
this is the way she'll go, I'm a describing music, from like, the la la la, and the twinkly bits.
And how you're like, well, most like science, some of the French, when you sing it,
it just sounds like quite dream-like, but like a dream about a woman who's so intense that they might
burn down a nunnery for you, or like stab herself on the stage in front of you if your gaze
lingers on another nun for too long. That's a true wish story about Julie, by the way. But I also
like how, with Red Wine and Wild, we had a song about a person that we know loads about Oscar Wilde
with a very well-documented life, but a song that, as we discussed, isn't very grounded in biography,
but more of an imagined exploration of a relationship on a fictional night. But here, with someone,
Julie, who's really mythologised, and there's so much imagination put onto her biography,
and we have very little idea what actually happened in their life. But we have a song that actually
gestures to so much of the history that we think we know. So you have the whole nunnery burning down,
hit on the roadness as reference, the cross-dressing, her voice, the pardons, her ahead of timeness,
but also how, although she's a commoner, some of the privilege that she grew up with,
and lived with, is sort of currency to allow her to live the life of the way that she does.
I've resisted listening every lyric I'm referring to there, so you can stay slightly less red.
Thank you. Yeah. But also, I think, as I've said to you before, what I like most about this song
is that if the album was its own narrative world, which it is to me, I like to think of the song
and Eve in Paradise Lost. I hate saying this now, in conversation with each other. So with this
song, you have the whole, come on, let's do it. Let's take a risk and fuck off and not worry
about people judging were, then we're cut to Eve in Paradise Lost, whether vibe is very much for me,
feels like it could be from the other person's point of view in that relationship, where it's very
much, we did a thing, now the shame, one of us will be blamed for it or left behind, probably the
one who had to be convinced to do the thing in the first place, and the runner will keep on running,
sort of like the crash-land and after a dream or the Paradise Lost, if you will, Dan. But yeah,
no, I really love this song. Thank you. Thanks very much. The idea of her in my head was for someone
to do all these things and take all these risks, and in my mind, she's someone that must have felt
stuff really deeply but also massively not cared about a lot of things that people as well. So I kind of
wanted to suggest you towards these quite huge significant kind of crazy events, and I guess with
this I was trying to strike a balance between, I guess, name checking a lot of the things that
happened to her, I wanted it to feel kind of sweeping and romantic and musical. Moira's voice is
quite present in this song in a kind of call and response way, which I love.
And yes, I tried singing in French. Yes, it took a few friends, we are friends.
We, it took a few Constaise friends to help coax me through it. Yes, I might have had to send
the record to one of my friends who is French and I have them send me voice notes back telling me
exactly what to correct. Yes, I might, when I played it to our record label in France, might have
had to leave the room because I didn't want to see their faces when they listened to it. But also,
yeah, I think I wanted the song to feel like it sweeps you away. So it kind of grows and develops
and it starts with this sort of last section that obviously is quite a clunky reference to
how they sing it and sort of take you to the, that's not true, I just made that up.
But yeah, it's mostly, it's the song is in 6/8, which is not the usual time signature that I write
in, but I thought that would give it a kind of, what's the usual 10? 4/4 is like, I'm not going to do it,
but like 6/8 is like 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. So it gives it that kind of like,
part of me wanted to write this song as if it was a sort of tavern song and when we were recording it,
there were a bunch of conversations of like, should we just do this one live in the room,
should we go to a bar and record it in a round, and obviously we didn't. But yeah, there was,
you know, Johnny who arranged a lot of the strings on the album and played a lot of the bass and
was around a bunch during the process, he was very much cheerleading the idea of doing it,
very raw, having a bunch of people sort of almost singing along as if it was a kind of
a folk tale song. I vetoed that and we made it really, really, really,
Lash and Cinematic and said, but yeah, it's got a bunch of guitars, I love the drums in this,
they're kind of, it's basically like quite a complex, almost like jazz drum beat, that is,
this feels really interesting and different for me and for us and it kind of lets us all
escalate as it kind of propels through forward in time in my mind and this melodium comes in
in all these weird kind of keys instruments as it kind of grows and then dissipates off into the distance.
Lovely stuff, Jadol. Mercy. Mercy. Mercy. I think it's time to Orren Bois.
Homework. How do you say homework in French? Oh, oh, fuck. That's not how you say homework.
Pardon your French, am I right? Sorry, I know it, but I don't know it. In the way that my memory works,
it's there somewhere. Anyway, we'll come back to that next week.
So people who haven't listened. Where have you been for one time? Yeah, where have you been? You've got so much good stuff.
to catch up on. So much homework. So much homework to do. Because the whole point of
this podcast is that it's a conversation between Emma's knowledge and my appropriation
of that knowledge and telling them into songs, which is where you know, you know, a cool
dynamic. It's a cool dynamic. Yeah, thanks. A lot of the songs in the first batch of music
that I made for ampersand came from stories that I hadn't heard or didn't know about people
I didn't know about who Emma directed me towards. So I thought we would in every episode
we decided we would discuss people in more depth. And then Emma would in response to that
direct me towards another story that I could and will start a new song about. Great. So
before I set you this week's homework, I'll check in a little bit on some previous
tasks. Okay. I've got a random list here. Yeah. Number one, Shelley Doval. That was the
Edward Monke episode. Yeah, I was thinking about Shelley and the overlook and the idea
that she's been overlooked. And just really like hammering that. Great. How to scream.
Overused joke. Now I know. Okay. Echo and narcissists. Yes. So I have about three different
echo songs that I started. That's funny. It's start. Yeah. Multiple. Yeah. I think with
this one, because the narcissist song is sort of quite gentle and pretty, I quite like
the idea of echo who can't necessarily articulate exactly what she wants to say, because she
can only really speak by the words of others and curating them quite fucking like fuck you
angrily. Yeah. Yeah. So like, I basically, I started a few things. One of them was kind
of really acoustic. One of them is a quite chilled groove. And then I was like, maybe it should
be that I hate you so much right now. Yes. It really fucking showed. Yeah. Also, I also
quite like the idea of like, you know, obviously you can't really control who you fall in love
with. And I like imagine falling in love with. Not necessarily sap who himself then dies
over a flexion of himself. And so the kind of frustration of someone who maybe can't
out loud say exactly what they think. So that's where that one's at. Okay. So today's
homework, what I really like about this is last week, you preempted what the homework
was going to be. And you've bloody done it again, Dan. Is it about the relationship with
the end of her life? Yes, it is. Yes, it is. So instead of giving you something like
tangentally related, a few times, it's like, yeah, a different angle on the same version
of the song. And I think like you're talking about when we were talking about this song
ages ago. And I think you actually said, oh, man, that's because that's how you sound
to me. Oh, man. Oh, man. I'm going to have to write something about their relationship
as well, aren't I? Well, you went off mic when you wouldn't commit to that American.
I think it's completely understandable to gravitate to that incredibly exciting moment
in her life in the drama. But I think there's something really nice, especially with like
stories about queer people to like dwell on those sort of, like, might quite gentle, seemingly
peaceful, like happy moments as well. So this is Julie in Madame Lemarchie's De Florene
sack. And in that quote that we were talking about before, when someone wrote about them
a little bit after their life is their relationship lasted undoubtably from 1703 to 1705. And for
two years, they dwell in such affection, they believed to be perfect, ethereal, and beyond
reach of their contamination of men. The young women isolated themselves enamored, only
appearing in public occasions where their presence was essential. Indeed, there are, after
1702, no songs or satire against the two women, except for critiques of the performances
of Lamopa who continued to be employed by the opera. So a lot of affection from the biographer
there. So I thought, have a crack at that. Yeah, great. Bonne. Bonne. Cest, Bonne. Cest, Bonne.
Okay, mercy, orevoire. Merci, au revoir.
Bye, Fin. Muses, an absent podcast. Muses, been podcasted, dampersand. It's hosted by Dance
5th at M&A goose. It was produced by Ed Mourich, a M&A goose for Let's Mojo. I'm a fucksake.
For Let's Mojo Productions, you can find out more on all the people we're talking about,
at www.ampersand.bastill.com. Bastille, Bastille, Bastille, Bastille, Bastille. And you can email
us at
[email protected]. Merci beaucoup, à bientôt. Bye.
Muses, an absent podcast.