The murder of 16-year-old Trey Wright in South Carolina has led to a complex legal case where nine teenagers face murder charges under the “hand of one, hands of all” statute, which holds all participants equally guilty if one person commits the act. While Devon Raper is the only defendant currently in jail, two others—Thompson and O’Clair—were briefly taken into custody for violating house arrest conditions, including DUIs and animal cruelty, but were later returned to house arrest under strict GPS monitoring. Prosecutors argue that the defendants knew of and conspired to participate in a planned confrontation over a romantic dispute with the victim, supported by Snapchat messages. However, defense attorneys claim this is an abuse of prosecutorial power, asserting that mere knowledge of a conflict does not equate to criminal intent or participation. The case has drawn widespread public and legal scrutiny due to its unusual application of murder charges to minors, the lack of trial timelines, and repeated bond violations by defendants. The prosecution’s use of the “hands of all” law, typically reserved for drug or firearm cases, raises questions about proportionality and due process. As the legal process continues, experts stress that a jury’s verdict will ultimately determine whether the defendants are guilty, especially given the absence of direct evidence linking all participants to the shooting. The case remains a focal point in debates over youth justice, prosecutorial discretion, and the fairness of holding minors accountable under severe charges.
It's the so-called love triangle murder that rocked South Carolina and now a shocking new twist involving two of the 19-agers charged with murder in the death of 16-year-old Trey Wright. All but one of the defendants in this case are out on bond. The prosecutors have argued that these two have not been taking their conditions seriously as they picked up more charges. While they were supposed to be on house arrest, the judge took the pair into custody as he thought about whether they should be allowed to be free as this case moves forward and it appears that judge just made his decision. We're on the case presented by Law and Crime. I'm Chris Stewart. All right, I want you to bear with me today because I am losing my voice a little bit. So if it sounds like I'm a little bit raspier than I typically am, that's the reason why. Let's talk about another update in the case of Trey Wright. There's been so much attention on this story and there is a law in South Carolina that we talk about each time this case comes up because it is central to what may happen going forward. It is called hand-of-one, hands-of-all, and it pretty much means if one person pulls the trigger, everyone who is in on it is just as guilty. And that's what prosecutors are arguing in this case as you have 19 agents who are all facing the same charge and that is murder. But when you look at how the legal system has handled this case since the death of 16-year-old Trey Wright, you do find yourself wondering if the system sees these defendants as accused killers. People charge with murder. And it appears we have another example of that this week. And we're talking about the decision that a judge just made in connection to the cases of Braille and Thompson and Jaden O'Clair. They were in court last month after prosecutors say they violated their bond conditions. And that is serious. Yet we did see Jaden O'Clair yawn a couple times before his case was called. Now these two teenagers are charged with murder. They were arrested in August of last year after Trey Wright was murdered. And they bonded out of jail. Now I do want to remind you of this Snapchat that a source sent to us after they bonded out. It's one that Thompson allegedly posted after they posted their $20,000 bonds. And it is them standing outside the Florence County Detention Center in South Carolina. And the caption read, "I'm free with a racial slur that begins with N that I'm not going to say here." Now when we were sent that Snapchat we reached out to the local Sheriff's Office to see if it was real. And we asked them if they were aware of this post and they said that they were. Some time after he was released but at any rate he was sort of someone who would molest his injury to animals. First of all, for the injury of our $2,000 less, driving under suspension and failing to appear after the release of a pistol. Again, you want to vote for these individuals who were ordered to house arrest both of these individuals. Elsewhere they should have been home at the time of their arrest. And on top of that vote for them while it may seem like a very innocuous vote. Again, at least one of them was charged with a death sentence all the alcohol by these children at home on house arrest. And again, these charges of murder that both of these individuals were faced. Again, I think that this place has come to this regard. Now we're going to party at the fourth of August and hopefully violating the special conditions of the police. And again, these are two young individuals who would think would be home again. Thank you, God, they will allow them to go home and say that they were out breaking the law and they were not under house arrest as they were ordered to be out of court. For those reasons you want to worry of the death bond and be respectfully vote for both of these individuals that remain in custody until this matter falls to trial. Prosecutors say these two were supposed to be on house arrest as they were out on bond. And yet last month they were in court because they both allegedly picked up new charges. Police say that Thompson was arrested on a charge of animal cruelty and driving on a suspended license. O'Clayer allegedly got a DUI. Prosecutors demanded that they be taken back into custody. At the end of the hearing, the judge did take Thompson and O'Clayer into custody. But this was not revoking their bond. He took them into custody as he said, he was going to look the case over and decide whether or not they should be given the opportunity to be free as their case continues forward. And he would look into whether or not he would take their bond away. Now the judge just made a decision about bond related to Thompson and O'Clayer. And I'll tell you about that here in just a moment. But I want to talk about the victim in this case and get you caught up on tre right, the 16 year old who lived in Florence County, South Carolina. And on June 24, 2025, he was dating a girl named Gianna Kiston Mocker. And she is very important to this story. She was a cheerleader. She went to another school in nearby Myrtle Beach. Now, tre was also someone we're told who had a ton of friends. And it makes the events of that night so difficult to comprehend. Police say a call came in around 1130 for deputies to respond to a shooting. And they needed to get there fast. When they arrived, they found 16 year old tre right, he had been shot. He was rushed to the hospital. And that's where he was pronounced dead. He had been shot twice in the chest, according to authorities, deputies say, this is the man who fired the shots that killed tre right. Devon Raper. And he is the only one of the nine people charged with murder in this case to be behind bars. He has been in jail since his arrest last year. Now, Raper and Wright reportedly knew each other. We're even told that they considered each other friends. They were new friends, but they got along. They followed each other on social media. But on the night that tre died, they were at odds over a girl. And that is Gianna Kiston Mocker, according to police. Deputies say that tre right did not have a chance encounter with Devon Raper. They believe that this confrontation was planned. And people knew about it. There are alleged provocative Snapchat messages authorities say that fueled this violent confrontation. Deputies say they also have recordings of the confrontation, but those have not been seen by the public. Deputies believe that the person who killed tre right was in a white Mazda SUV that had four people inside. The shooter was wearing a ski mask. Deputies say when the car first arrived, tre right approached it. He banged on the door. Then the shooter opened fire and tre right was shot twice in the chest. Deputies eventually tracked Devon Raper down and put him under arrest. And this is what happened when he faced a judge for the first time last year per WBTW. I did not think none of this. There was four more people on it. I'm not here to try. I understand. I'm doing a date. I'm not here to try a date, but you can speak a little more than you can. I'll take your turn. Raper may be the one who authorities believe fired the shots that killed tre right. But detectives in this case have cast a wide net. Right now, nine teenagers are facing charges of murder. The youngest were 15 and 16 years old. They have not been identified publicly. All these teens are facing murder charges. There are a lot of details in this case. A lot of people are involved in this case. And if you want to see some of the charging documents for yourself, you can head over to Longcrime Plus and go to the court TV case file that we have specifically for this case. And with Longcrime Plus, you also get to watch shows from both Longcrime and court TV ad free. So go to longcrimeplus.com and subscribe today. It's been more than a year. Frankly, it's been nearly a year and a half since tre right was murdered. And none of the defendants in this case have gone to trial. And we don't know when that may happen. Tre right's family has been frustrated that some of the defendants have been accused of violating bond conditions and also making requests to have their restrictions loosened. You also have defendants who as attorneys have argued that the use of the statute that allowed prosecutors to charge nine individuals with murder is an abuse of power and politics. This is what braille and Thompson's attorney said last month in court. This case is probably the greatest abuse across the tutorial of discretion that seems nothing practicing. And we got nine people charged with murder. Only one of which have power, but that person is the thing. And somehow there's an alleged conspiracy that involved a bunch of juveniles, which kind of made rise to some of the decisions made me never hear for a day. I mean, in my opinions, a lot of this is how politically motivated we have these hearings as we, for the pressers of the election. You want to hold a prosecutor back is signs of this. I don't think there's any patients for that and he's annoying off-key because of the President's Attitude Campus, but I don't think there's any basis in fact for that statement I was in and I would have asked for the review as he was referring to. All right, the prosecutor owns that. All right, we're done.
He also said his client should not have his bond taken away. As a race to my clients, failures or regardless, I look for the record that just this bond like water was prior to my foot and I'm used to dealing with juveniles, I would do nothing. Some of the parameters that we're putting here were probably just kind of, I think they were well considered, but there was not enough information before the court to set these parameters at the time. My client was a resident for a county of the town. He was living with his sister and going to school. That was because there were some, you know, family issues that were going on with his father and his stepmother. That's why he was living there. He was 17 at the time. He was not 18, but of course, since it was a murder, he could be charged as an adult without a juvenile proceed. In that regard, the court said he needed to live in 2038's water box east of the highway in Taylor City. That was a temporary residence of my client's family. I don't think the court knew that and they were the board and they were the remainder. Because they subsequently moved back to their permanent residence in Whitewater, North Carolina. And secondly, just as a stat, they shouldn't leave the residence there for court, school, or school activities. Well, when you're charged with felony, you can't go to sleep. Your automatically protruded under state law and South Carolina could have going full campus if you got a pending felony. Now, South Carolina, you are a form of the opportunity to have interventional education, but you was required to move to North Carolina. When he got there, there was a lot of confusion over whether or not you can leave the 10th school and plus some moves so the districts changed. In this patient, this procedure is eye contact with Columbus County Schools in North Carolina. So it's with interventional coordinator and they advised me that my client can because he does move to finish school. In fact, he must have become commercial welfare under the water well. But he can't go on board with medical college due to the same issues related to pending felony. The felony event is just an egregious use of stretch. So in this regard, Judge, we spoke to them and they said that he can apply and then they'll have a joint meeting with the school district to determine what interventions he can have, which could be from those schools, homebound, or even to simply attempt to give the GDP. Those are the exact ones, you guys. And these are options that have been pressed to come in due to this pending felony. So as it relates to the incident, that was involved. When my client found out that he had been charged when this motion was filed just in September 23rd and was blindly emailed to me on October 6th, telling me I had a court on October 26th. Not actually telling me. I got in multitude to find where he was spending months and months on me that we had a court before the school. Yet they can call and tell me I was supposed to be home 26th. Now they moved it because I told them that we were out of town and I told them we'll hear it this week. But there was no contact and so we agreed. We had limited amounts out of the figure out what we could do. I spoke to my client and I could have guessed what had happened with this malicious inquiry for a proper offer. So again, just not trying to step away from the fact that my client is not this home. But again, due to some family relationship issues, there needed to be a decompression period so he left his family's home because now he's 18. You know, when you send a team the state can require you to live in your own home. The parents obligation to do it. It is their obligation for you to be something to CSS and child abuse and neglect to do it. But at this time he was 18 so they allowed him to go back to his sister's house where, temporarily, there'd be a decompression period. So he didn't think he'd be able to stay in your home. Well, that young lady's family found out who Mr. Thompson was. They must have googled him and found out he had any murder charges against him and they told her she had to break up with him. And these young kids, that typically hate to throw themselves regardless of how it's going on, the regardless of what type of charges he had against him. And he banged on the windshield of a vehicle that she wasn't even in. The young lady was not in it. And at the end of the day time she was not having it out of the night. They went to lunch at a Mexican restaurant in Oregon. And it was the price for two o'clock in the afternoon. And she broke up with him because of this. And he banged on the windshield and created and called the crime. So she wasn't in the deal. It's not the best situation. But the parents are the ones who care for express the charges due to the injury they did. That's the issue we're talking about. So again, he's. This issue has been pressed upon him to the point where now he's going to be engaged in counseling because he quite often can't close the situation. And this is not to be trapped in a family. That's the decision statement is to simply talk about the story more with my client. He is more into it. He is attempting to get into the school. He is entering into counseling. And we propose this morning, keeping us to the state as a possible resolution or a flat out. Tell them no. They don't need to go to jail. So again, abuse of discretion. The state wants my client is not even a principal in this case to sit and jail for a multitude of years until we finally get to this case. Not to mention the fact there's going to be a scene around here in some point where we're making this and then where are they going to go? So, you know, I think it's just an absolutely absolute tragedy that we're here sitting here talking about sending my client to jail for many years before they get to this case to be tried because he committed all the houses. The decision may have been prevented. There have been some little bit of additional consideration as to the parameters for the law. So, in order to assuage the court's concerns, we are asking the court to modify this order required him to remain in the house of his court as it will specifically open house of us. Then, do so. He currently lives in 9-1-2. Molly wrote in Whiteville, North Carolina. His father is here along with his stepmother. They own the household. He would be subject to GPS monitoring to ensure the court that he's not going out and down and that is a continued court's concern. He's not a danger to the community. He doesn't even live in the community. He was forced to move back to North Carolina, which prevented him from finishing his school, which is what he wants to do. He was voluntarily undertaken the obligations of attempting to finalize his education or his secondary education because he doesn't want to be a welder. And hopefully at some point he's able to go into that type of school once these terms are resolved. I think that is suddenly perfectly reasonable in the class for the court. I would ask for tonight the state's potential to remove the law on the basis of the court and to simply implement that this is a gradual GPS monitoring. Now, thank you. This is how the prosecutor responded. Most of what he said is believed or response is believed. But I will say this. I can mark him in this post on that. My capacity as a deputy solicitor in the officer of the court and I'm not running for anything. I wouldn't be making this argument if I didn't think it was a good faith basis for so doing. You are the only reason that we believe has nothing to do with our political race, has nothing to do with politics is because these two individuals were given a bond and there was no complaining about the terms of conditions when bond was set. They both agreed to be bound by the terms and they did not honor. They both left their homes when they were not supposed to under house arrest and they both committed additional criminal charges. You wonder if that is concerning to this prosecutor and I dare say we're be concerning to any prosecutor who had any involvement in this case whatsoever. The judge took the pair into custody as he mold over what to do about their bonds. They were supposed to be on house arrest and yet you have one that picked up a DUI and the other allegedly harmed an animal and was driving with a suspended license according to prosecutors and yet they're still facing as serious a charge as you can face murder. Now a day after Thompson and Eau Claire were taken into custody the local sheriff reportedly told television station WMBF television that their bonds had been revoked but it appears the judge has gone the other way this week the judge signed an order allowing Thompson and Eau Claire to go back on house arrest. The order says that both must remain under strict house arrest and they're only allowed to meet with their attorneys go to court or work and what's different this time around according to the order is that they will be on GPS monitor. It also says any violation of this order shall be immediately reported to the state and the court and will result in immediate revocation of the bond. Now this is not the first time a judge in this case has made a decision that has been accommodating or forgiving the girl accused of being at the center of the confrontation between rapper and right. Johnna Kistamocker has asked to get back on social media. Kistamockers also signed a proper agreement with authorities. This is not immunity but it is.
is a written agreement that means that she will speak with authorities, provide information, and what she says to authorities cannot be used against her in court. WPDE also reports that Kiss Demacher has requested to be able to get, let's just say the real college experience as she is waiting for her case to move forward. She's currently going to school close to where she lives in Merdle Beach and living at home, but her attorney has asked that she be allowed to apply to other colleges and be able to go live in campus housing there. The attorney also requested that she be taken off GPS monitoring, and as of right now it is unclear what the judge made aside when it comes to those requests. Now another defendant in this case also charged with murder is Corinne Baviso, and she was earlier this year accused of violating her bond. The day after Tray's murder, she posted this on her social media, a link to a GoFundMe page for Tray's family to cover funeral expenses with the caption. They've made a GoFundMe to help Tray's family. If you're able to donate anything will help. Tray was one of my friends. We're heartbroken to know him was to love him LLT. Now LLT stands for Long Live Tray, which has become a rallying cry for his supporters since his murder. What was your reaction when you saw that? What kind of figured it was going to happen because Corinne was trying to talk to me that night, but I had already figured out what happened, so I didn't want to hear anything from her. And she was just, she was like, I just wrote here, I just wrote here, I didn't do anything. I didn't believe it, not one bit, and I still don't believe it to this day. And then she tried to tell me that I didn't need to watch Tray get take away in the ambulance, but I had already seen him shot in on the ground. So what's the ambulance going to do? That's one of Tray's closest friends, Jasmine. She was by his side on the night that Tray was shot. 10 days after Tray's murder, Belvisa was arrested and charged like the others in this case, and she like several others posted a $20,000 bond. In June of this year, prosecutors wanted her bond to be revoked because they say that she went more than 1300 miles to Western New York without permission of the state. In a June motion, prosecutors wrote, quote, the state of South Carolina through the undersigned as assistant solicitor for the 12th judicial circuit hereby moves for an order of the circuit court revoking the bond of the defendant, Corinne Elizabeth Belviso, as previously issued on August 5th, 2025. The grounds for said motion being that the defendant is in violation of the bond by not complying with the condition set forth in the bond. It has been brought to the state's attention that the defendant has traveled to and possibly residing in New York. The defendant's bond states that she must notify the court immediately of a change of address. It also states that she is not to depart the state of South Carolina without the permission of the court. The defendant was given a $20,000 shirtty bond and placed on house arrests where she has only allowed to leave her home to attend school, work, church, and go to the hospital slash doctor's office if necessary. This bond is for the crime of murder. The state believes that the defendant's bond should be revoked in light of the defendant violating the conditions of her bond. The state prays that the defendant's bond be revoked and that she be held in the Florence County Detention Center pending trial. Belviso's attorney said it was a misunderstanding about traveling out of state and a judge denied the prosecution's motion to take Belviso back into custody. So she is out as her case moves forward. Now another big question at this point is when might any of these cases go to trial? At Thompson and O'Claire's hearing last month, the prosecutor said that resolutions to this case are not years away, but it is unclear what that means as far as a timeline. Join us now once again to talk about this from South Carolina, Tyler Bailey, criminal defense attorney, and a civil rights attorney. Thank you for being here. What do you make of the judge's decision where Thompson and O'Claire are now on house arrest once again? Well, I think that the judge made a good decision in putting them on GPS monitoring in addition to just being on house arrest this time. He could have easily sat them in jail, let them sit there until this case went to trial. At least he didn't put them back in jail for a little bit for them to sit and think about their actions, but these guys are out on bond from murder charges. They are acting like they have some disdain for the law. The system here seems to not really be taking their positions too seriously and their bond conditions, but I think the judge at least made a better decision and requiring some GPS monitoring, which hopefully will keep them on the straight and narrow until they stand for the charges. Because we've talked about this case multiple times and you have nine defendants in total. One of them, Devon Raper, he's the one who's accused of firing the shot. He has been in jail since his arrest, but they aren't the first two to have issues with their bond or make requests related to having those bond conditions loosened. And you look at this situation, you have Thompson who was arrested on an animal cruelty charge and driving on a suspended license, Oclair allegedly got a DUI. And so clearly they were not on house arrest. They weren't at home to be able to get those things. And they are charged with murder, but it just feels like the system isn't exactly treating them, at least to me when I watch, you know, continue to see this case. Like, it's not like they're being treated like murder defendants because I feel like a lot of murder defendants would not be out on bond if they violated the conditions in the way that it appears, at least in this situation, these two defendants did. Well, most murder defendants would have been out on bond period. They would bond would have been denied. Maybe they would have received a bond reconsideration, most that was heard and maybe later on, you know, six months to a year as a sitting in jail. And one thing that the defense lawyer said here is he believes this case is a grave abuse of prosecutorial discretion. And it seems like the court is actually somewhat siding with that as how they're treating the defendants who are out on bond because they've been committing crimes all up and down the East Coast DUIs when they're underage drinking, I assume, cruelty tours, an animal which is somewhat of a violent crime. And they seem like the defendants aren't taking these charges seriously, that they're seriously our charge of murder, which has a pretty high penalty in the court seems to not be taking that murder charge seriously by repeatedly giving them light slaps on the wrist and allowing them to roam free. Because we've talked about the hand of one hands of all statute that is what these individuals are being charged under. Devin Raper may have allegedly pulled the trigger, but, you know, they were in on it according to prosecutors. And that's why they're all facing that charge of murder. How is that statute typically used? And why is it different potentially in this case to the point where the court may see it as a stretch? Mayor Presidents is not enough for hands one hand of all to apply. There needs to be some sort of agreement, some sort of all essentially taking some steps and furtherance of the crime for generally for people to be charged and actually convicted of it. It's oftentimes used in drug cases or a firearm possession cases where you may have three or four people in the car and there could be a drugs in the glove department or the the center console or a weapon. And maybe nobody claims it or maybe one person says it in the state decides to charge them all. It's not usually used in murder cases like this. This is a is a I think a bold step by this solicitor's office or the prosecutor's office to charge them all, but the prosecutors prosecutors have a duty to not abuse the discretion to, you know, render justice as they're supposed to do. And I think they had a good faith basis for charged them all or unless they shouldn't have done it. But it seems like the court because it's maybe novel, they seem to me that they're the way to handling these cases as if they're really not murder charges. I think it's ultimately going to come down to what actually goes to trial and how a jury feels about this in the verdict that they render. But this is not typical how hands the one hand of all is used here in South Carolina, but I believe the prosecutors prosecutors prosecutors here at a basis for charging everybody. And it's more than just one judge who has made decisions related to some of these individuals who have allegedly violated their bond. So it's not just one judge that's kind of allowing them to stay on either house arrest or or be out on bond. In this type of case where you have these individuals that are brought in front of the court, there was, you know, some conversations about what they allegedly did. Then the judge takes them into custody and says, I'm going to make a decision in a couple of days. And then that decision was that they'll be on a little bit of a stricter house arrest. Then they were before with the GPS monitoring. What information? Because there is still a lot of evidence that we haven't seen. What type of information does the judge look at during that period of time when deciding whether or not an individual should be allowed to be on house arrest again? They still look at the normal bond conditions, whether somebody has a flight risk, whether they're a danger to society, if there's other other mechanisms that could allow them some sort of freedom while they're because they're innocent to approve and guilty to stand these charges. And this was a bond revocation hearing. So they made bond on their new charges, but the prosecutor's office moved to re-broad their first bond saying that these conditions clearly aren't working because they're out committing crimes
the violated terms of their bond conditions. So the court took all that under consideration, looked at the facts, what they're accused of doing now, what the original charges were, what the bond was, and if it was working, and their decision here was to apply GPS monitoring. Very well, they could have been, that could have been made from the bench. The judge probably could have had that as mine, literally at the bench, but he probably put them in jail to have him sit there and think, hey, y'all keep it up. This is where you're going to be sitting until you stand in trial. - And it's been more than a year since Trey Wright lost his life in this shooting. And we've had hearings, we've had these issues come up about bond as far as the timeline going forward, the prosecutor in this case at that bond hearing said, we're not talking years until there's potentially a resolution. What do you make of the timeline? Knowing that it was July of 2025, that Trey Wright is shot and killed. And yet here we are almost at the end of 2026, and no word on a trial, no word on any sort of plea deal that may or may not be taken. - That goes to the defense when it comes down to getting their clients bond, because who knows when this case will go to trial, murder cases are very, hard cases to try to prosecutor's have to cross all their teeth, all their eyes, and prove every element of the crime, beyond a reasonable doubt, especially when you're doing under a novel theory, like hands of one hand of all, for multiple defendants. So I'm pretty sure the prosecutor's office is probably making sure they have all that together before this case is going to be ready for trial. And so, most murder cases, it does take some time, you can look at at least a year, or a year or not, a year and a half, sometimes two or even more before a case goes to trial. I think because you have so many defendants here who are charged with murder, it's essentially them charging, having at least four or three murder trials, and could be plead negotiations, different set of facts, different stories. So I'm not surprised it's taking this long, and maybe that's why the court is still allowing them to sit out, well, be free, while they're on bond with GPS monitoring, because who knows when it's gonna go to trial. - And is there a possibility that they would be, you know, that these would be situations, just based on how the system seems to be treating these defendants each time they go to court, that they could end up not seeing, you know, whether it's through a plea deal, or even being found guilty, that they wouldn't have prison time. - It's possible. Anything is possible. - I keep it on a murder charge. - Yeah, it would have to be sub-reduced, maybe they would dismiss the murder, and re-indite for another charge, for something less or included, to that they could plead to. Some of them have been in jail some. Right now, you had these two defense who did, I believe a couple nights in jail, when the judge was considering the bond conditions, it's not uncommon for people that ask for time serve. I would see it hard for the prosecutors to say face, if they charge these individuals with murder, and then ended up giving them some plea that does not call for some serious consequence, or something that doesn't seem like just a slap on the wrist. I don't think the prosecutor's office is going to be inclined to show any grace, because these defendants have not been acting like model citizens, while they're out on bond. They've been acting like they've had the stain for the law, they can care less about what their accused are doing, that they don't take the court system seriously. So I think it would be a different story, they were model citizens, it took three years, and they were cooperating with the government, and they were not violating their bond terms, then maybe you could get a good deal, but with them, I don't see that happen. - And then when it comes to, because we haven't seen really any of the evidence, we know through police reports, what is being alleged happened as far as the narrative, and we know that there is digital evidence that prosecutors have that they say proves that these nine individuals are all involved in this, and that's what they are charging this based on. Snapchat messages potentially, trying to show that there is some sort of conspiracy to take the life of tre right. When it comes to this statute that they're charged under, like what would that Snapchat need to know? Like is knowing that there's going to be an altercation between tre right and Devin Raper, enough to say under this statute that any of these other individuals could be charged with murder. Does it just have to be that they knew that, okay, Devin has a gun allegedly, and he is going to confront tre over this issue, I know about this, is that enough to say, under this statute that you should be guilty of murder? - Guilty of murder, what you just said is, the key difference in charge with murder. I think under that, if they had knowledge of it and they voluntarily with him to the murder scene, I think that's enough for the charge. But if the evidence shows that there was not an agreement, that there wasn't, for example, let's say Snapchat communication is about, "Hey, let's go get 'em, I'm down to ride with you, let's go." That sounds different than, "Hey, I'm going over here," and they knew about it, but they were just in the car with them. Maybe they tried to tell him he shouldn't do this. Maybe they say, "Hey, I want to get out." Those are the things that would allow a jury say, "Absolutely not, they can't prove this beyond a reasonable doubt." But there's a lot of communication and text messages, and that chat message is about knowledge of the beef between the individuals and the teenage girl that was involved with it, and actual agreement to go there, knowing that what he was planning on shooting him, and they went there with him, I think that could be enough to show that they all went there together to do this, versus one going there and them being with them, just their presence, that's different than an actual agreement to commit a murder. - And you look at this hearing for Thompson and O'Claire, and it was Thompson's attorney saying that this was an abuse of the law, he made some accusations, that this was political because elections were coming up. As a lawyer in South Carolina, I know you're in a different part of the state. And in this case, each time we talk about it, seems to get the audience really riled up, like people are very invested in seeing how this plays out, just like what's the buzz in the legal community about what prosecutors are doing in this case, and just the way that it's going? - Those arguments by the Defense Council here did strike a nerve because it was a LexiCease, and I practice in that area frequently. And the community has seen youth violence, we see this across the country, right? Youth violence, kids with guns, murder's happening, and these prosecutors are elected. And so when they're elected, they want to stomp out crime, they make messages about how they could, their system can help make things safer for all. And so this is a novel case, it's a bold case, this happens in other type of charges. If you think of drug conspiracy charges, Rico's, right, investigations, and that's done in federal and state levels. So there are creative ways that the prosecutors can use the law to stomp out crime, right? And this is one I think they're using for youth violence is getting a lot of attention. And the legal community specifically, this is not often seen in murder cases, especially murder cases involving teenagers, or young people. And so that's, it's a different type of a method that's being used, and it's going to be interesting to see what the jury thinks. I think that it's going to be one where, it's going to be difficult, I think, for the prosecutor's office to really prove this, unless there's some things in discovery, whatever is that we, as the members of the public here, do not know. Yeah, and we'll see what happens. I mean, again, it's been more than a year, almost a year and a half at this point. Since the trial was killed, and these defendants all still facing these murder charges, we'll see what happens next, Tyler Bailey, criminal defense attorney, civil rights attorney from South Carolina, always great to have you on long crime, thanks for being with us. Now we'll do it from the case presented by long crime. I'm Chris Stewart. We'll see you next time. (upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Two 19-year-old defendants, Thompson and O’Clair, were taken into custody for violating house arrest conditions, including DUI and animal cruelty charges, though the judge later allowed them back on GPS-monitored house arrest.
South Carolina’s “hand of one, hands of all” law charges all participants in a crime—even if not directly involved—under the theory that one person’s act implicates the group, leading to nine teenagers facing murder charges.
Prosecutors argue that the defendants knowingly participated in a conspiracy, supported by Snapchat messages revealing a planned confrontation over a romantic dispute involving the victim, Trey Wright.
The judge’s decision to impose GPS monitoring reflects a compromise between strict accountability and the defendants’ ongoing legal status, rather than revoking their bonds or sending them to jail.
Defense attorneys claim the prosecution’s actions constitute an abuse of discretion and political overreach, especially given the lack of evidence proving actual agreement to commit murder beyond knowledge of a conflict.
The case has drawn national attention due to unresolved charges, prolonged timeline, and public skepticism about how youth defendants are treated under severe charges.
The victim, 16-year-old Trey Wright, was shot during a planned confrontation with Devon Raper, who is the only defendant currently incarcerated.
Legal experts question whether the “hands of all” statute is appropriately applied in a murder case involving minors, noting its rarity and the burden of proving intent and coordination beyond mere awareness.
Summary:
The murder of 16-year-old Trey Wright in South Carolina has led to a complex legal case where nine teenagers face murder charges under the “hand of one, hands of all” statute, which holds all participants equally guilty if one person commits the act. While Devon Raper is the only defendant currently in jail, two others—Thompson and O’Clair—were briefly taken into custody for violating house arrest conditions, including DUIs and animal cruelty, but were later returned to house arrest under strict GPS monitoring. Prosecutors argue that the defendants knew of and conspired to participate in a planned confrontation over a romantic dispute with the victim, supported by Snapchat messages.
However, defense attorneys claim this is an abuse of prosecutorial power, asserting that mere knowledge of a conflict does not equate to criminal intent or participation. The case has drawn widespread public and legal scrutiny due to its unusual application of murder charges to minors, the lack of trial timelines, and repeated bond violations by defendants. The prosecution’s use of the “hands of all” law, typically reserved for drug or firearm cases, raises questions about proportionality and due process.
As the legal process continues, experts stress that a jury’s verdict will ultimately determine whether the defendants are guilty, especially given the absence of direct evidence linking all participants to the shooting. The case remains a focal point in debates over youth justice, prosecutorial discretion, and the fairness of holding minors accountable under severe charges.
FAQs
The 'hand of one, hands of all' law means that if one person commits a murder, anyone who is involved in the conspiracy or present at the scene can be charged with murder. In the Trey Wright case, prosecutors are charging nine teenagers with murder under this law, arguing they all participated in or knew about the planned attack.
Thompson and O'Clair were taken into custody because they allegedly violated their bond conditions—Thompson for driving with a suspended license and animal cruelty, and O'Clair for a DUI. Prosecutors argued they were not adhering to their house arrest orders, prompting the judge to temporarily take them into custody.
After the hearing, the judge allowed Thompson and O'Clair to return to house arrest with strict new conditions, including GPS monitoring. Any violation of these conditions would result in immediate revocation of their bond and possible incarceration.
As of now, no trial has occurred. The case has been ongoing for over a year, with no clear timeline for when the defendants will go to trial, and all nine accused remain charged with murder.
The prosecutors are applying the 'hand of one, hands of all' law, arguing that all nine participants were involved in or aware of the plan to harm Trey Wright. This includes teens who were in the vehicle or who had Snapchat communications about the conflict over the girl, Gianna Kistamocker.
Defense attorneys argue it may be an abuse of discretion, especially given the rarity of such broad murder charges in youth cases. They claim the prosecution is using the law politically or to make a strong statement rather than based on proven conspiracy or direct involvement.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.