Judd Apatow on making Steve Carell a leading man, attacking the Manosphere and the death of comedy movies
1h 17m 40s
Judd Apatow, a defining figure in modern comedy, shares insights into his career, personal life, and the evolving nature of comedy in American culture. Rooted in formative experiences of parental divorce and early exposure to stand-up and satire, Apatow developed a deep sensitivity to human flaws and power dynamics. His work on shows like *The Larry Sanders Show* and films such as *The 40-Year-Old Virgin* reflects a consistent exploration of masculinity, vulnerability, and social pressures—often using dark humor to expose the absurdity of toxic male behaviors. Apatow notes that comedy has become politically charged, with extremist ideologies now mainstream, creating tension in the industry and broader society. He attributes the current decline in original comedy to the collapse of the DVD era and the shift to streaming, which favors safe, low-risk content over bold, innovative storytelling. Despite these challenges, Apatow remains committed to using comedy as a tool for understanding human nature, emphasizing emotional authenticity and social critique. He reflects on the personal toll of rejection in the entertainment industry, drawing parallels to childhood experiences of parental abandonment and emotional insecurity. Ultimately, he sees comedy as both a mirror and a healing force—one that can process difficult truths without causing harm, but only if it maintains balance, empathy, and creative integrity.
Hello there, welcome back to the Louis Theroux podcast.
For this episode, my guest is director, producer and screenwriter Judd Apatow, one of the most
influential makers of film and TV comedies of the last 30 years. Judd is the man behind
such classics as The 40-Year-Old Virgin, Superbad, Knocked Up, Freaks and Geeks, Forgetting Sarah
Marshall and many, many more. He's produced, directed, written for and mentored some of the
biggest names in comedy, including Paul Rudd, Seth Rogen, Jonah Hill, Lena Dunham, he exec'd
Girls, if you've ever seen that, and his wife, Leslie Mann. That's just a small sampling,
I could go on and on. In fact, if you've laughed at a comedy film in the last two decades,
there's a decent chance.
True. Having cut his teeth on the L.A. stand-up scene, Judd got his big break working on The
Larry Sanders Show for his hero and future mentor, Gary Shandling. We talk about The
Larry Sanders Show. It was a show that mattered to me. I wanted to write on it. We talk about
that. And for those who don't know, it was a show about a fictional talk show host, Larry
Sanders, played by Gary Shandling. But they had real stars coming on playing themselves.
He was a forerunner of extras with that celebrity cameo, but the celebrities playing a kind of
sort of mischievous version of themselves, sending themselves up a bit sometimes. Why am I going to
social detail? Because we talk about that in the show. And also, Larry Sanders Show is often cited
as one of the greatest TV shows of all time. And Judd wrote for it. Judd and I also, well,
we had a sort of online bromance, mutual. fan club. Don't say circle, jerk. You can't, two people can't be in a circle if you think about it.
That's just a line. Line jerk. We were sending messages back and forth saying, I like you. No,
I like you. And then we set up a, we said like, you come on the podcast. And then a year or two
went by and it finally happened. That's the background. We also talk about The Road Not
Taken. The tragic loss to TV sitcoms that were. Was the fact that I never wrote for one, but I wanted to. We recorded this interview in June
this year during London's heat wave. I can't even remember it. It seems a million years ago.
It's quite cold now. I caught Judd in a break between filming and an edit for his upcoming
film starring Glenn Powell, The Comeback King. A warning, this conversation contains the strongest
of languages. Languages, English. Language, singular, the C-bomb.
Which C-bomb?
I've already done this bit.
Millie says, I've already done this bit. In capitals, it looks like Clint.
Have I done that? And adult themes, all that as well as much else besides coming up.
When you shop Kroger Delivery, you can expect the savings you love
and fresh groceries delivered right to your door.
Our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting
every detail right. Carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing
you fresh quality groceries is what we do best. And right now, enjoy $20 off your first online
order of $75 or more. Restrictions apply. See site for details. Kroger, fresh for everyone.
You know what they say. Good things come to those who shop early, especially when we're talking
early Black Friday deals and Lowe's. Get up to 50% off select major appliances. Plus,
get free delivery, haul away, installation, and parts on purchases of $896 or more.
Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's. In-store and online.
Valid through 12-2. While supplies last. Selection varies by location.
♪ music playing ♪
♪ music playing ♪
♪ music playing ♪
Welcome. It's still fussing around.
All right. That's it. It's real. We finally did it.
We finally did it. Because we've been corresponding a little bit, very sporadically. And I was
thinking, like, I think we were DMing on X.
Which I have left.
And then I was like, well, I'll pick up the thread. I'll try and figure out how this started,
how we first got in touch with each other. And then the messages were all gone.
Wiped.
What's that all about?
Wait, but if I wipe, you still get mine?
I couldn't see them. I couldn't see them.
Interesting. Well, that's good to know that I'm fully wiped. That was very hard to do. I had a
real Twitter addiction. But at some point, the evil is too intense.
What caused you to wipe your profile?
I just, well, everyone in my family have been begging me forever to get off of it. Because I
like reaching out and talking to people and strangers and you and. That's the good part. Like, you get to meet people you admire.
Sure. I mean, in the beginning, it really was, like, a lot of comedy on there. And comedians
were funny. And then it just turned into just this political hellscape. And then I realized
that no one was seeing my stuff anymore. Like, I could feel something happened. And no one
is responding.
Were you shadow banned?
I don't even know. But probably in some form. And then I just thought, this has all taken
a dark, manipulative turn when it was sold.
Elon Musk. And I just thought, I don't think I can be a part of it. So then I looked for
new addictions. And I found them.
Did you feel you were your best self when you were tweeting?
Probably not. I mean, I certainly was politically very concerned. And I think everything I was
worried about happened. You know, all the things that I was ranting and raving with my Trump
derangement syndrome occurred.
But it didn't stop. And so then did I just waste a massive amount of time?
Probably.
My family and people always say, well, the thing you do that makes the world a better
place is you make things. And you make comedies. And hopefully that brings people together
or makes people happy or gives people a break. So all the time you spend doing that is a
waste. And maybe destructive because you're not doing the positive thing you do. But in
my gut, I think, aren't we supposed to all kind of be happy?
I think we're supposed to kind of start screaming about what's happening in our country and
make a lot of noise about it. So it's hard for me to figure out what the line is of how
much time to put into it. Or no time.
But unfortunately, it means I can't access the cute little bro flirtation that we had.
I think it was very Judd-sided praising you.
I appreciate that. I think it was mutual. What I confess to you, and we can come onto
this, was that I had originally wanted very much to be a sitcom writer in the '90s. Let's
talk about that later. In the run up to this, I thought, you know what, in order to get
myself back in Apatow world, I'll rewatch a couple of the films. So I rewatched 40-year-old
Virgin and knocked up.
How did it hold up?
So good.
Oh, good.
I never go back and watch it.
I never go back and watch.
Do you not?
Not on purpose, but it just kind of doesn't seem to happen. I'll just watch Step Brothers
and Walk Hard. For some reason, those are the ones--
Why those two?
I don't know. Maybe because I didn't direct either of them. It may be a directing thing
that Adam McKay did Step Brothers and Jay Kazin did Walk Hard. So I was a producer on
Step Brothers and a co-writer on Walk Hard and a producer. So maybe there's something
about the intimacy of directing that you worry that if you watch it again, you're going to
be like, oh, god, what did I do wrong?
But I don't know. I probably will at some point.
It's striking how many of the themes in the films feel very current. And in a world where
there's this obsession with incels, you were in this and the manosphere. This was a more
innocent time, but you were kind of dealing with some early iteration of what does it
mean to be a man and--
I'm the opposite of your manosphere--
Yeah.
That's--
It was kind of like--
I'm the person who doesn't know how to grab the reins of manhood. And I love all your
documentaries. And they're on all sorts of people. But that hits my button. I feel almost
bullied just listening to these people talk. And I feel like almost all of my work in some
way has been an attack on it, even unconsciously, those types of people. I'm the opposite of
Andrew Tate.
Well, it's interesting. How would you--
Yeah.
How would you describe, for someone who'd never seen it, what 40-Year-Old Virgin is
about?
Well, the 40-Year-Old Virgin is about a man who works at a stereo store. And he works
in the storage room. And Seth Rogen works with him.
Played by Steve Carell.
It was based on a sketch or an improv he did at Second City, which he told me about one
day. And I instantly thought, I know exactly what that is. Because when I worked at the
improvisation doing stand-up, there was a guy there--
And one day, I was watching television and I saw the guy who was like,
a patron there had said that he was a 45 year old virgin or something and so when we started writing
it we were like well what would what would you really be like if that had gotten by you and we
kept talking about in those terms a real this is this happened for real well it was just a guy that
i didn't know very well but i saw him like on one of those like oprah winfrey type shows with like
older virgins and i thought well maybe we could handle this very comedically but also very
seriously like what is the psychology of this of someone that it just got by them and then they got
scared and then more scared and feared being rejected and being thought of as less than
we never knew what an incel was it wasn't a word at the time yeah we certainly came it added at a
place of being kind of i i can't speak for steve but for me it's like a nerdier type of
guy not a lothario and that the idea of lotharios made us laugh like guys were like cocky and
give you advice about how to hit on women to us was a joke yeah uh so in a way it's it's kind of
making fun of that kind of uh misogyny and and that's what we were doing with a lot of our
comedies will ferrell and adam mckay with anchorman it's a joke on misogynistic men they
really enjoyed making fun of arrogant men who are really dumb and shouldn't have any of their
arrogance like arrogant men in power and now that's the whole world in a way
we're all in the manosphere yeah um uh what's striking re-watching it was well it's it's about
a 40 year old virgin but it's actually about guys kind of putting a boot camp together to try and
help him lose his virginity with the worst advice ever so he's got a little pack and each one kind
of represents a different problem with masculinity you've got paul rudd he's recently been dumped and
he's going to quite a dark place and he kind of goes mugtow do you know the term mugtow no
like stalkery men going their own way he's like i don't need women
yeah yeah like they're too they're too complicated and weird you just need to cut them out yeah and
then you got jay who's kind of andrew tatey and his advice is like you know you need to go to a
nightclub find the drunkest woman in there and basically uh pick her up yeah and um and that's
leslie man is that how you met her no i had met her years before but she was so funny in that
sequence and it was a sequence we talked a lot about because it is a you should hit a drunk women
and we're like well we should just show this go wrong because we we think it's wrong and we're
we're talking about it as the worst thing you can do so it ends in a car accident her vomiting in
his face and i think that's a lot of what our comedy was uh you know people trying to figure
things out doing the absolute wrong thing and things going horribly wrong yeah and it's it's
a testament to the magic of comedy that it can deal with dark themes like when you subtract
comedy from something sometimes you're like wow this
this is messed up but actually it all works because you assume the goodwill on the part
of the filmmakers yeah does that make sense you know that our heart is in the right place i mean
super bad has a similar theme seth rogan and evan goldberg you know wrote that but the premise is
we're going to try to go to a party bring liquor and get the two girls that we've had a crush on
all of high school to get with us and then literally every single thing goes wrong and
after this terrible night buying slacks with the two girls and you realize that's all the women
wanted was for them to be human beings and normal and that all of this attitude and cockiness and
thinking we should be partying and drinking was the exact opposite of what they wanted
they wanted them to be real people and to respect them what i'm also struck by is how
um you know so much about comedy is the tone right and that actually the steve carell
character the virgin he's both at times kind of absurd like it belongs in the realm of high comedy
fairly broad but then he sometimes he dials into something more recognizably human does that make
sense absolutely and i think that's a little bit of the style that i'm going for which is can you
be real and grounded and have those emotions earn them have credibility and get to big high hard
where it doesn't feel like two different things like how elastic can it be and make sense so for
example there's an opening sequence where you've come to a movie it's called the 40 year old virgin
he wakes up he gets out of bed he goes to take a piss he's visibly tented out at the front due to
a morning glory yes first big laugh and his whole routine you know the precision of how his breakfast
is laid out everything bespeaks a kind of repression a sublimation of some primal instinct
he has a lot of time on his hands he has a lot of time on his hands he has a lot of time on his hands
then later on there's a lot the bit you know how after a movie you remember some random bit the bit
that stayed with me for some reason was um his description of what his weekend was like yeah
we're just kind of dealing with all the cords in his house and how long they should be actually it
was the egg salad oh no that's it that's a funny example because we that's another one we that we
shot which is when we shoot these things i always shoot a lot of different variations because i
seth tells a crazy story about going to a donkey show in mexico and then it's a very good bit and
then he shows an iota of self-awareness right he goes i felt bad i felt bad for the donkey you know
it wasn't as cool as you think it would be which is kind of the premise of the whole movie right
and then steve starts talking about making the perfect chicken salad sandwich for way too long
and it's so boring to seth who starts like miming please kill me it seems like that improvised
they're usually written as well as we can write them we shoot that then we drift a little and then
we drift a lot and then a lot of times you know i'm pitching variations or maybe we're trying
variations that we did in rehearsal and i'm also letting the actress and actresses improvise and
you know especially with seth and steve an enormous amount of it comes out of that play
do you um should we talk a bit about how you got to the place
um where you made four-year-old virgin which kind of actually though was it more anchor man
there was a moment where you kind of arrived is that fair well there was a moment in comedy where
a lot of the people that we wanted to make movies with started doing well so for a long time i wanted
to make movies with jim carrey but he hadn't made a movie yet and we would go pitch movies like let's
make a movie jim carrey and people would just say no or we would try to get movies done with will
really couldn't get them made this is what sort of late 90s the 2001 2002 and then there were a
couple of breakthroughs that weren't our breakthroughs there was a movie called old
school which will ferrell was in and then elf right old school is a todd phillips film yes
who later made the hangover movies hangover sort of bears some little bit of the mark of
the apatow school but well i'm also kind of the influence by
todd who did you know old school first and he you know he made a lot of great great
comedy so there was a lot happening there was wedding crashers a couple years before that
something about mary i think that my tone was trying to figure out how can you get a little
james brooks humanism or cameron crowe vibe into like a big set piece comedy but old school in a
open the door and then before anchorman came out uh elf came out and so will had a resurgence and
then when
anchorman did well people were open to me making the 40 old virgin which happened because i was
talking to steve carell on the set of anchorman and noticing that he seemed like someone who also
could lead a movie yeah i'm just remembering the steve carell scenes in anchorman where he's
actually completely subnormal they wouldn't function in any um office there's a massive
suspension of disbelief yes he just yells i don't know what you're saying right now i'm not doing the
voice right but i love lamp yes i love lamp i love chair uh no it was a really a brilliantly
written character by adam mckay and will that steve carell took to another level and there
was also a lot of improvisation and mckay would pitch him these lines and i was just watching as
a producer thinking i've never seen anybody as on fire as carell and everyone was on fire
you know rudd and dave kechner and then christina applegate and
will but there was something steve was doing where all of us were like wow this guy is really
offering something up right now you know that saying uh i think it's in crimes and misdemeanors
if it if it bends it's funny if it breaks it's not funny yes and you would think i love lamp
it breaks right he's like that doesn't take place in a recognizable yeah universe and yet it's it
works why does it work you know i think that just will and adam created some sort of rules for this
universe yeah that allowed that and i think that's a really good point and i think that's a really good
and that's i think the brilliance of them is they created a completely new uh style and tone which
people hadn't seen before which was really the core of their sense of humor but the funny thing
is that you know they had the script and and we tried to get it made for years and no one got it
we would we would pitch it and get really close to different studios and they ultimately would
just say why is an anchorman funny there's never been a movie that was funny with a journalist
and they just couldn't get their heads around it.
How would you pitch it?
I would always pitch it like it's like The Jerk, the Steve Martin movie.
I would always say you're overthinking it.
It's just an excuse to be really funny and really silly.
And I think that Adam and Will were a lot ahead of their time
in making fun of the arrogant American man
and to make fun of how unfair and hostile workplaces were
and these morons who look down on people who are much smarter and talented than them
and were keeping them down.
And there was a real sense that that was the thing to be mocked.
You talked about studying comedy, right?
And growing up, you were a comedy nerd.
And so you're kind of taking things apart, sketches,
transcribing sketches from Saturday Night Live, figuring out how they work.
Is there a sort of science of comedy?
Do you think there's something you've learned about how it all fits together?
I remember going to see Alan Alda and John Cleese discuss comedy.
And they could talk about all these theories and Freud and why you laugh.
I don't understand any of that other than in a very instinctual way.
I probably could break it down if I really tried to think about it.
But I generally think of it in the simplest terms, which is life is really hard.
We all don't know what we're doing.
We're trying to figure it out.
And we tend to root for people.
And we tend to root for people as they try to get through it.
And when the bad things happen that give us these lessons,
for some reason we find that funny because we relate to it.
But kind of joke for joke and why do you laugh when you see someone get smacked in the head
is not something that I truly get.
But I must get it in some way from just watching a lot of it and absorbing it.
Like someone who knows how to play an instrument but doesn't know how to read music.
I mean, let's talk a bit about Larry Sanders.
Because it feels like you were coming up.
You wanted to be a stand-up for a while.
And then you were in L.A. with your peer group.
And then you start writing for people, Gary Shandling being one of them.
For me, the Larry Sanders show was always kind of a benchmark for what TV could aspire to be.
Yeah.
Something that I wanted to write for when I was living in New York.
As I think I mentioned.
When I was messaging you.
How did you come to work on that?
And what did that sort of represent for you?
Well, I started writing jokes for Gary when he hosted the Grammys.
And then we became very close friends.
And he did a cameo on the pilot episode of the Ben Stiller show,
which is a sketch show that Ben and I were doing.
And then when that was canceled after 12 episodes aired, we shot 13.
I was very depressed.
And Gary said, do you want to work on the second season of the Larry Sanders show?
And I had been around him when he was writing.
I mean, the first season and casting it and knew all about it.
So I worked there as a consulting producer.
And that's when I learned how to write and about stories.
And Gary's theories were all about getting to the core of people.
And the whole show to him was a metaphor for life.
This idea of the curtain and the face you put on for people to try to be accepted.
But it's actually not what you're really thinking.
That people are mainly lying to each other and presenting their best face.
It was a meta, kind of a meta show as well,
because you dip in and out of seeing his cameras, right?
Like you're inside the chat show.
Sometimes it starts with the chat show ending,
and then you go into a behind the scenes sequence.
It was also, I think, alert to the kind of the frailties
and even like just the dark side of the human condition.
Yeah.
And you see a lot of it now.
Like you could do the Larry Sanders show now,
about what's been happening with Jimmy Kimmel and Stephen Colbert.
And this pressure to be funny and political.
And, you know, these people weren't built to do this.
They didn't start talk shows to have to oppose the president.
And, you know, when we were doing the Larry Sanders show,
there was a lot of Johnny Carson was retiring.
And, you know, everyone was switching chairs.
Suddenly Conan O'Brien was there.
And it was like a perfect moment for Gary to talk about it.
And I remember.
When it ended, there was some talk that he would keep the show going
and have Larry Sanders pushed out by Jon Stewart
and keep the show going as the Jon Stewart show.
But ultimately, I think Gary had just ran out of gas with doing the show
and didn't want to keep connected to his manager who he was suing
because they had some business conflicts.
But now would be the perfect time to do the Larry Sanders show.
And, you know, Seth Rogen talks a lot about how the studio was influenced by a world like the Larry
Sanders show.
So in a way, that's the perfect way to talk about everything that's happening now and movies and
streaming and, and, and culture.
A lot of the comedy is close to tragedy.
Does that make sense?
Yeah.
I mean, you know, there's, there is a dark, sad part to most of the stories.
You know, a lot of those stories are about someone whose ego is so big that like he,
like in one episode, he's dating Sharon Stone, but he can't handle that she's more famous than him.
And they ultimately break up or.
The first episode that I ever directed was about him dating Ileana Douglas and, and he didn't know if he could date her
because she wasn't a good talk show guest, but it was also about, you know, it became about the business and how an older
person would be pushed out for a newer person.
You know, things would happen in Gary's life, like this lawsuit with Brad Gray, his manager and producing partner.
And then suddenly the show would be a way for him to talk about what he was going through.
Jeffrey Tambor plays his sidekick, Hank Kingsley.
Rip Torn is the producer, Artie.
For me, a lot of the comedies in, in the Hank Kingsley character, because he's both an imbecile, but also quite sensitive.
And so, and he's constantly on the edge of being humiliated.
And also, uh, almost like one of the characters from Anchorman.
Yeah.
There was, you know, a bit where he was like really hitting on one of the people in the office.
And the whole bit was about her trying to get people to walk her to her car.
And so I think, you know, there was also a lot of discussion of hostile work environments and men behaving badly.
And, you know, he was making fun of a lot of that too.
So, and that's why it's a fascinating character because you love Hank Kingsley, but he's also awful and maybe truly awful.
You know, the best episode, maybe of the whole series was written by Peter Tolan and it was called Hank's Night in the Sun.
And it was about that Larry Sanders can't get to work one day.
And Hank has to host the show.
And strangely, he kills, like the audience gets behind him and it's a triumph.
Because people feel bad for him.
They're rooting for him because he's visibly nervous.
And so suddenly he just does it and he does do a good job and he instantly becomes an asshole.
And he just becomes an egomaniac in the office.
He doesn't want Larry to return.
And then he gets to host again.
And the second night he wants it so bad that he bombs.
And then he does it again.
And then he has to apologize to Larry.
And I remember in the scene he says, I prayed you would stay sick or something like that.
And like, I'm just a terrible man.
And it was kind of the entire arc of showbiz madness in one episode.
And Jeffrey was brilliant doing it.
And sometimes there would be things in the script that we were trying to fix as writers.
And Jeffrey would go leave it.
I wanted to see if I can figure out how to make it funny even though it's not working on the screen.
I wanted to see if I could just find a way to say it or do something physical.
And he would.
The one I watched last night was one you'd written called The Bump.
The Bump, yes.
And there's a bit where Hank's at a meeting and he's talking about his dad's just died.
And he does a little whimper of grief, which made me laugh out loud.
Because there's something so, I mean, it's just weird.
I don't know why that would be funny.
Like using your grief to get something.
Maybe.
Or maybe it's just like kind of.
The nakedness of his, I don't know, his vulnerability.
It's just the way he plays it because he's such a ludicrous character that when he's in pain,
there's something kind of funny about it.
Well, I always remember there was a scene where Hank is so mad at Larry's wife
because she's a journalist and she's investigating this product, the Hankerciser,
some exercise product that turns out to be very dangerous.
Like you connect it to your doorknob, but it'll break and hurt you.
And he says, you're a weirdo.
And he says to his wife, she's a cunt.
I am so sorry.
That hypnotist who was on yesterday put a hex on me.
I remember there was all sorts of other options about like this hay fever medication has really done something.
And it was just him trying to take back that he called her a cunt.
And I remember at the time that was not a word that was said ever in America.
Like here it's thrown around in all sorts of ways, in lighter ways.
But in America, it was the worst.
The worst word you ever could say.
And him backing off of it, knowing he's in trouble, was one of the great acting moments.
Good stuff.
Who did you give your script to?
How come you didn't get hired?
Okay.
So I didn't.
I thought, oh, I don't think I'm equal.
I'll never get hired on an HBO show.
I don't know what my mental process was.
I thought that's too high.
It made me too high.
So Paul Sims, who was one of the original writers, had moved on and started a show.
called NewsRadio, and NewsRadio was
a little bit more in the lane of mainstream NBC.
But also really unique and really funny.
Really funny.
Phil Hartman.
Yeah, I loved it.
Phil Hartman played a very pompous news anchor,
almost like an anchorman type.
Yeah, before that, yeah.
And starred Joe Rogan.
And Joe Rogan.
And Stephen Root.
Joe Rogan plays kind of the office, what, the every, kind of.
The handyman.
Handyman.
And a little piece of trivia,
Ray Romano was supposed to play that part.
Really?
And after maybe the first couple of rehearsals,
Paul's lost the part and they recast it.
Why?
I guess.
He didn't like his performance.
I don't know.
But maybe he just didn't fit in for whatever reason.
And then he went on to be the greatest leading man
in sitcom history in the United States in a lot of ways.
Do you believe that?
Oh, yeah.
I think everybody loves Ray is as good as you can do it.
I mean, obviously there's Archie Bunker in there.
But I put him right up there with the best people to ever do it.
That show really holds up.
And the Joe Rogan character,
he's a conspiracy theorist.
I wonder if Paul was like, let's work with, you know,
Joe's personality a bit.
Well, that happens a lot.
Like on Freaks and Geeks,
we would notice like a tension between some of the kids.
And then we would just start writing to them,
having little fights where like, oh,
those guys are a little edgy with each other.
Let's, let's put that in there.
I remember when Gary was doing the Larry Sanders show,
his girlfriend, Linda, was going to do an episode where she's
offered to be in Playboy magazine and she plays Hank's assistant.
And we were going to have Hugh Hefner on the show.
And Gary's real life girlfriend played Hank's assistant.
Yes.
And then while we were working on the show with Hugh Hefner,
he asked her to be in Playboy magazine and then she was in Playboy magazine.
And so the whole staff went to the Playboy mansion for the reveal of her spread.
And then that became this kind of meta experience where he's making an episode.
And then also in real life, he's dealing with how comfortable he feels about his girlfriend being in Playboy magazine and things like that would happen all the time where like they would just fold in on each other.
And things like that would happen all the time where like they would just fold in on each other.
Was it a happy set?
It wasn't a happy set.
I think everyone knew something great was happening.
It was a set that was tense because the, the bar was so high, but in a way where everybody felt it, where I feel like at a place, like everybody loves Ray, Phil Rosenthal and Ray are very centered, solid, funny guys who like create a world that is supportive.
It was a set that was tense because the, the bar was so high, but in a way where everybody felt it, where I feel like at a place like everybody loves Ray, Phil Rosenthal and Ray are very centered, solid, funny guys who like create a world that is supportive.
It was a breakthrough.
It was just ran in a weird way because part of it was on video.
Part of it was on film.
We had to actually shoot a talk show.
And it was, I think too much work for one man to, to do.
And so I think he was often in a state of this is going to go badly and then trying to make it go better and being really stressed out and not feeling supported when everyone's trying to support him.
But it is like, how do you have your work be on?
The genius level of your boss.
I used to always say it was like, if Picasso said, paint half of this with me and you were like, oh, well, I would do this.
And he's like, why are you doing that?
Well, I'm not Picasso.
I don't, I don't think exactly like you.
So it was tricky that way because it's so in his head.
What was his sensibility?
Like if, could you put your finger on what his unique insight was or his creative vision?
Well, he was certainly mining his own charm.
And his own pain.
And I think on some level, I, you know, he was really into Buddhism and Eastern thought.
And I think he was embarrassed at his own ego.
And so on one level, he wants to be a big comedy star.
He wants to be respected and have his own show.
And on another level, he thinks that it's really silly to care what people think about you.
And it goes against all of his religious thought.
And so he's mocking his own inability to walk the walk, but he would say the difference between me and him.
And the difference between me and Larry Sanders is Larry Sanders couldn't write the Larry Sanders show.
He has no awareness of it.
Yeah.
So to finish my story, I, so I sent in my spec script to news radio.
And then I got a call from Paul Sims saying, it was an answering machine message.
I picked it up.
He said, I got your script and I liked it.
And so if you're in LA, come by the office and blah, blah, blah.
I don't see.
That was one of the most exciting moments of my life.
And then I went by the office and I was like, wow, this maybe doesn't look as fun as I thought it would.
Well, there, I don't think it necessarily was.
I mean, in those years, Paul was a real night owl.
The windows were all blacked up with tinfoil.
Yeah, exactly.
Which, you know, usually is a bad sign.
I took that as a red flag, you know, in the middle of the day.
But he just was someone that really operated at night.
Yeah.
And so with the Larry Sanders show.
And, you know, sometimes we would get all the notes from Gary and I would, you know, work with the staff for a little bit and then give it to Paul.
And then Paul would rewrite the whole script himself from like midnight till dawn or whatever.
And then I think after he left the Larry Sanders show, he created his own work environment, which involved the whole staff writing very late into the night.
And this is in the 90s.
Yeah.
But I guess I'm not sure why.
The windows were blacked out other than maybe they worked past sunrise.
Presumably it's like Vegas, right?
Like you just can't tell what time it is.
Yeah.
So it's like.
But the show was hilarious.
I mean, and as you know, Paul went on to, you know, be, you know, one of the greats of all time.
He did Atlanta.
He does What We Do in the Shadows.
Yeah.
English teacher.
Yeah.
And he was one of the people that really taught me when I was there.
Yeah.
That's when he was there.
And he could not have been better at that job.
So talented.
So basically, you grew up in Long Island, New York.
Pain and fear from the divorce.
Your parents got divorced.
I think you knew that.
I did.
Pain and fear from the divorce became the fuel in my tank.
It has led to every success and good thing in my life.
Isn't that weird?
But I guess that's how it goes.
It just shapes your way of seeing things.
You know, for me, it was like, I don't think they're handling this well.
This is getting really ugly.
I think I need to figure out how to handle things, which led to just being very interested in people's point of views and comedy and people who were attacking, you know, social norms and power structures.
It was kind of like, you know, the whole game fell apart of just adult behavior.
And so it made me look for other.
Mentors and voices.
And they were nice people who just didn't know how to handle their marriage meltdown.
It was, you know, before there was a lot of self-help.
There wasn't conscious uncoupling.
You know, it got dark and ugly in those days.
And as like, you know, a teenager in a very formative stage, it made me very hypervigilant.
Like, oh, you better be on your game and figure out how to get a job and work hard because your stability will come from yourself.
What did your parents do?
My dad.
Uh, worked for my grandfather's record label.
My grandfather was a music producer, produced people like Charlie Parker and Janis Joplin.
I mean, he had this kind of amazing career, uh, in jazz and blues.
And so he owned a label called Mainstream Records.
My dad worked there for a long time and he also worked in real estate development.
And your mom?
And my mom was a, you know, a homemaker who was just very surprised that at this stage of her life, she was going to get divorced.
She just wanted to.
To, uh, just raise the kids.
So, so then she had to go off into the workforce.
And so my mom was like a very, I mean, I, I, I wish I knew like the psychological way to describe it because I don't, I don't think she was bipolar, but she certainly was kind of manic, but very, you know, hilarious and warm, but then would get really angry.
And it was just all over the place and kind of an unpleasable person in a lot of ways, but also hysterical.
And so, you know, even now I.
She's still with us.
She's not.
Okay.
But even now, like I, you know, in therapy or just, you know, I'm a kind of a self-help junkie.
I'm still reading and trying to understand what being around that kind of person did to me in terms of like trying to make her happy and trying to understand her and how it, you know, affected how I saw myself and, and, and saw the world.
But certainly it tuned me into a certain kind of neurotic personality that made me the kind of person who was.
Good at working with Gary Chandling or Roseanne, or even just understanding people's personalities and point and point of view.
Cause I was trying so hard to understand her that I think I became someone that could write characters because I had paid a lot of attention to it on some level that I didn't understand.
Like, why are people doing this?
I think is really the core of it.
Like, why is this happening?
What, what's the point of view of it?
And then when I make.
Now, Gary, he had a similar thing.
He had a, he had a mom who was very difficult and all the trauma we talk about in the documentary about Gary, your Gary Shandling document.
So when I would talk to Gary, it was like, we spoke the same language somehow.
And what if, what was the, this, like, why are they doing this?
Meaning, why can't they get along?
Why are they so mean to each other?
Why can't they figure out their financial, uh, issues?
How come they don't know to stop this so that.
The kids could not
suffer? Like, why are they unable to resolve this? Because they never did resolve it. I mean,
that was the whole thing. They never resolved it. And so there was no divorce settlement. There was
no agreement. It just kind of stopped. Like the fighting went on for a decade and then it just
went away, but they never resolved any aspect of it. So it was something that it was like a year
that was bad. It was just kind of forever bad, you know? And so that's enough to kind of make
you a comedy writer. But at the same time, they were incredibly supportive, you know? So that was
the other part is whenever I wanted to be involved in comedy, you know, my dad would drive me at
night to all these comedy clubs when I was in high school. And they always just said, you're
definitely going to make it. They filled me with a lot of confidence. And when my parents got
divorced, my mom took a job at a comedy club seeding people.
And I always thought, what could she have been paid to do that? Like to seat people for a couple
of hours. And then later on, literally decades later, I thought, oh, she must've done that
because she knew I would want to have access to it. So there were these other like really lovely
levels to it that I talked to, you know, with my parents about and thanked my mom for
later on in life. But in those formative years, you know, it was forming me for sure.
What were you doing?
What were you taking refuge in?
You know, music and comedy, and also the idea of having an obsession that no one had.
I liked that no one cared about comedy in my school. There wasn't another kid to talk to about
it.
You were born in 68?
67.
67.
So Saturday Night Live came out in 75. So everything hit.
So you're like eight years old. And then Monty Python's kind of going.
Yeah. Monty Python, SCTV, Saturday Night Live, like everything's hitting.
Yeah.
I mean, you know, I was like, you know, when I was a kid, I used to watch TV from 3:00 to like 1:00 in the morning as a kid. I would just watch every talk show and I watched the news and every sitcom.
Did you get home from school and just watch for 10 hours?
I literally would do that when my friends were busy with sports. I would just sit home and listen to music and watch TV from the moment I got home till the moment Letterman ended at 1:30 in the morning.
Age 1?
Like an enormous amount of time. I mean, kind of from 14 to 17 or 18, you know, I finally got a girlfriend and I'm sure that slowed it all down. But there were periods where that was very comfortable for me. I loved that there was this thing that I liked that no one cared about at all. There was no one to even talk to about it with.
One of my friends a few years ago said to me, I think I finally get what you were doing back then, watching all those talk shows and all of that. And I also thought this thing's going to save me because no one else is in it.
I think there's a job here. And if I really study and work, I think I'm going to get in. And part of that was because I felt no competition. I think now everyone loves comedy and it's a big thing. But back then it really felt like nobody cared.
Age 1?
Age 2?
Age 3?
Age 4?
Age 5?
Age 6?
Age 7?
Age 8?
Age 9?
Age 10?
Age 11?
Age 12?
Age 13?
Age 14?
Age 15?
Age 16?
Age 17?
Age 18?
Age 19?
Age 20?
Age 21?
Age 22?
Age 23?
Age 24?
Age 25?
Age 26?
Age 26?
Age 27?
Age 28?
Age 29?
Age 30?
Age 31?
Age 32?
Age 33?
Age 34?
Age 35?
Age 36?
Age 38?
Age 39?
Age 40?
Age 41?
Age 41?
Age 42?
Everyone.
A little early, a lot to like.
Lowe's early Black Friday deals are still going strong.
Get up to two free select power tools with the purchase of a select DeWalt,
Craftsman, or Cobalt battery kit.
Plus, get up to 70% off select smart home products.
Savings this good deserve to be in your cart.
In-store and online.
Valid through 1125.
While supplies last, selection varies by location.
Free tools vary based on battery kit purchased.
How generally stressed are you at just the direction of the world?
Like, you have kids.
Wait, whose podcast is this?
Like, because I'm stressed.
Are you interviewing me?
Yeah.
Well, you're in the thick of it.
You went right into it.
Although I know people in the comedy world like that.
And, uh, but. Like, manosphere people?
Yeah, just people that were like, you know, the. In the old days, old comedians were just talking about, like, airplane food.
You know, like, like, you know, cats and dogs.
You never felt any kind of political division or that people were in different places.
And now you feel like, wow, there's kind of different camps of ideology.
Yeah.
Which is terrible for the space, the social space of it.
But also, I guess it reflects what's happening in the world.
But the idea of people moving backwards. Backwards in their beliefs into ways that are, you know, take away rights or hurt people
or diminish people, uh, is really scary and troubling.
And it's, it's getting mainstreamed in a lot of ways.
Like, voices that you never would have heard on normal talk shows talking as if it isn't
weird that they're there.
Like who?
Well, there's, like, these preachers that you go, oh, there's Pete Hegseth's pastor.
Right.
He's called Doug something.
And you're just like, why is this?
He's this guy on a normal show.
Doug Wilson.
And he's, you know. He thinks that women shouldn't be, shouldn't vote.
Shouldn't vote.
And you just go, wow, why?
So we're talking to these people.
And now their word's getting out.
And other people are thinking, I guess some people, I want to get in with this Doug guy.
And I find that all really troubling.
I guess they were always there.
And this has always been bubbling up.
Maybe it's the exposure of it.
But I always wonder if it's growing or just exposed.
And it's good that it's exposed because eventually the pushback will prevent it from growing.
I tend to think that homeopathic amounts of extremist material can be healthy
because you develop antibodies and you kind of, you can metabolize it in some way.
It contributes to maybe a healthy cultural immune system, if you like.
But there comes a time where you're like, actually, that viral load is excessive.
So staying in comedy, though, because this is an interesting.
Comedy's become kind of a wedge issue, right?
In the sense that you've got a form that traditionally was viewed as, I guess, subversive,
maybe progressive, a lot of it, in direction, although not exclusively so.
And then now it's, you've got right-wing comedians or comedians who maybe aren't right-wing,
but who just feel their job is.
To take a shot at the status quo, which they perceive to be maybe orthodox liberal, right?
That's the confusing part about it, is I think if you really look at the stances of most
of the people that people think are right-wing comedians, they're progressive.
It's a lot of it's freedom of speech issues, freedom to give people a hard time,
to say shocking things, to say things that are the types of things you're not supposed to say,
more than a specific ideology.
Even attempting to, like, there's not like an incredibly sharp right-wing political comic.
There's kind of, you know, funny, angry guys who don't want to be told what to do.
Well, did you, how did you, because there was, this became real in the run-up to the last election in the US
when I guess it was a campaign rally, maybe, or maybe it was the Republican National Convention
where Tony Hinchcliffe made a joke where he talked about, he compared Puerto Rico to a large patch of garbage in the ocean.
Which even isolated out of the context of a bit feels a little unfair, but nevertheless.
But it's not even a political stance in a way.
No.
That's what I mean, is it's not like people have opinions and they're using comedy in a way to make a case.
That's just, you know, a shock joke.
That's what I find really interesting about it, because I was thinking about it the other day.
Like, who's got the great bits?
Like, who's got the great bit?
About why Trump needs a ballroom?
You know, who has a great bit?
Why we should have UFC fighting on the White House lawn or any of it?
Like a really good piece of material that's saying you're seeing this wrong.
That's thoughtful and hilarious.
And you don't really see it.
Well, let me throw a quote at you.
We mentioned Todd Phillips, director of The Hangover.
In 2019, he said he'd moved away from making comedies because of, quote, woke.
And this was the quote he gave.
There were articles written about why comedies don't work anymore.
I'll tell you why.
Because all the fucking funny guys are like, fuck this shit, because I don't want to offend you.
It's hard to argue with 30 million people on Twitter.
That hasn't been my experience.
I do think there's an experience people have had where they've made edgy jokes that they thought were funny.
And then people dig up your old tweets.
And then they kind of think that you're this terrible person because maybe you were trying to be shocking.
And then people think that.
The cost of that was way too high because there was a time, you know, 15, 20 years ago.
where people were trying to push the boundaries of jokes.
And I think that was part of what Twitter was,
was there was this kind of fun light thing,
but then there were other people who were, you know,
they were testing it out.
And so there were a lot of really smart people
making some really bad jokes, but it wasn't like who they were.
And so I think there's a lot of anger around that.
I don't know about it with movies,
because I think the reason why comedy films have struggled
is because the comedy business was about selling DVDs.
You'd make a movie for $20.
If it made $40, it would make $40 on DVD, so it really made $80.
And when the DVDs disappeared, that really hurt comedy.
And suddenly it became a better bet
to make a $3 or $4 million horror movie
than to make a $20 or $30 million comedy.
And so comedies, you know, have struggled
and haven't been made at the same volume
as before.
You know, a lot of people left comedy to go make TV comedy.
And a lot of the great people in our business
have just made a lot of streaming material.
And so, you know, you get into like a doom loop
where young people do their comedy on TikTok
or they want to get jobs on streaming TV shows
and young people aren't trying to write screenplays.
And then the studios want old IP.
Well, that means you're not going to break
the next 25-year-old hilarious woman
because they're not. you know, a giant name already.
And then you can't break the next generation.
Then people are like,
well, I guess you can't make comedies.
If you don't create new stars, you can't.
You have to create the next generation.
How come you said DVD sales,
but aren't the ancillary sales to streamers
enough to offset the loss of the DVDs?
I mean, that's, I think, is what the issue is.
Why not?
Whatever they lost, they don't get back
in the same percentages.
So, you know, you would make a movie
and it would gross $100 million
and then it would make another $100 million.
And then it would make another $100 million.
And then it would make another $100 on DVD.
And then so these movies would just, you know,
be something that they really wanted to bet on.
And so maybe a quarter of that comes back now.
It doesn't even out.
What about the Netflix roast of Kevin Hart?
Did you watch?
I haven't seen it, so I can't speak to it.
I was asked to host one of those roasts years ago
and I didn't do it because that's my worst fear.
It's to find out what people really think of me
through roast jokes.
Like, I didn't want to be like the host,
but you, you know, we're roasting someone else,
but then you also make fun of me, you know, so.
So you would have got a kind of low-fat version
of the roast as the host
because everyone roasts everyone else.
Yeah, so I just didn't want to know.
Who was the roast of?
Who was it the roast of?
I remember that Seth Rogen, James Franco,
and Jonah Hill were involved.
I don't remember.
But yeah, I just got scared.
For real?
Yeah.
Like, for real?
Like, you have to be serious.
You haven't seen me near those.
And I've watched some of them.
I used to watch those Dean Martin ones when I was a kid
and I certainly can appreciate them,
but I definitely really, like, fear it.
I don't think my self-esteem can handle it.
I think I would find out some new wrinkle
of a thought about me that I've always feared
was what people thought about me
and that I wouldn't recover.
What do you think it would be?
I remember Jonah Hill said that when he did it,
it was so brutal that it almost,
it almost felt like a baptism.
Like, it freed him from all the ideas
of what certain insults would be.
And he felt better.
Exposure therapy.
Yeah, yeah, he felt better.
I don't think that I would have.
It's an extraordinary thing.
And you see, what's his name?
Pete Davidson.
There's jokes about his father dying in 9-11
and a lot of highly charged racial humor.
And there's a part of you that thinks,
this is amazing.
This is the way it should be.
There'd be,
there'd be no pain and hurt
if these words were robbed of meaning.
It's a bit like Scientology, actually.
You just sit down and you drill on things
that are painful until the e-meter no longer reads.
Well, yeah.
I mean, I think that's one way to look at it.
And one of the issues with,
I think, the way everything is distributed these days
is everybody thinks everyone's supposed to like everything.
And it's just not the case.
I mean, there are people that love
the edgiest, most brutal humor that,
some people find wrong.
And there are other people that watch it.
And it's brutal for them.
And it really bothers them.
And I think most comedians would say,
well, they don't watch it.
You don't have to.
That's the debate, I think,
which is, you know, are we okay with that or not?
I mean, I generally am of the school.
There's a lot I don't agree with.
But, you know, it is a market.
And let people decide if they want to see it
or don't want to see it.
But you seem comfortable, like,
so you're comfortable basically calling out bullshit.
Shall I put it like that?
But this was the thing I liked.
In 2001, you had a show canceled.
It was called Undeclared.
You sent a missive in a Christmas card
to a Fox executive.
It said, I don't know if you just fucked me in the ass again
or you just never took it out in 1992.
Merry Christmas, Judd.
Yeah.
That probably wasn't the right move.
But at the time, you know,
I had made a show for Fox with Ben Stiller
and it got canceled by a certain gentleman.
And then years later, I said to the same person at Fox,
I'll come back and do another show,
but you have to give me the full season.
Just give me the season to find the audience.
And then he canceled me in the middle of the season.
And so there was this incredible review,
like the top 10 shows of the year.
And it was like the first year of the Sopranos.
It was like the Sopranos and us.
And so I just framed it and sent it to him with that note.
I think it's just an example of you work so hard
to make these things.
And people have no idea just how much it takes out of you emotionally
because it is so deeply tied to your self-esteem
and your sense of self.
And so the business is so brutal
that there are moments when you fully snap.
Like you just crack and you send the note.
I wish I could say it's never happened since,
that there hasn't been other notes.
Maybe that was the worst note.
But there are certain moments when you just can't believe it
because you're working on a show and there's just a person
and they can just go, "Don't come to work anymore.
Tell all those people you like hanging out with,
you're not going to see each other anymore, starting Thursday."
And the amount of rage and hurt, you know,
because it's an abandonment, gets nuts.
And I've gotten better.
You know, I've had a lot of therapy, but I think I was very tired.
You think it goes back to abandonment?
Yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah.
Absolutely.
And around that time, I realized, like,
oh, I'm treating these two heads of fox like my mom and my dad.
I need too much approval from them.
I'm hoping that they can be, you know, not parental figures,
but authority figures that treat me well.
And so when it didn't go well, which is the natural way it is on TV.
I mean, ultimately, you know, it always ends that way.
Seinfeld had that great quote where he said, "The show always beats you."
You know, you always get canceled or run out of gas.
But you just put your heart into it.
And that's what I would, you know, appreciate about people like Gary.
Like, the reason why he's so sensitive and explosive and, you know,
there are days he'd be, like, super cold.
It's like, he just so wanted it to be great.
And then on some level, that need is, it's connected to some thought, like,
I don't exist if this isn't great.
Like, this is the essence of who I am.
And so, you know, it took me a long time to unravel.
And I think that's one of the reasons why I think it's so important for me to do that.
I was never as bad as a lot of other people I worked with, but I certainly had a bunch of it.
Because it's like your fuel is a young man.
There was also a, you've never commented on this, and I remember reading it at the time,
a notorious email argument with the creator of that '70s show.
Yeah, well, that's similar, too, is that my show is about to be canceled.
I was trying to book one of the stars of that '70s show
and I actually got one right after it.
-Topher. -Topher Grace.
-Topher Grace. -And so, then I heard that, you know,
a friend of mine who was one of the creators of the show, you know,
didn't want his actor to be on our show.
And it started this, like, email war.
We were so bored at our show and about to be canceled
that he wrote a mean note and then I would use the whole staff to punch up these replies.
And for, like, a week,
we'd have this vicious exchange.
It turned out he felt sore from something.
He thought a sketch on the Ben Stiller show had ripped off an unsolicited contribution he'd made.
So, he was accusing you of plagiarizing.
Well, he had a television pilot.
I mean, it's so funny when you look back at, like, arguments from 35 years ago.
But he had a pilot that was inspired by the grunge era.
That was, like, the monkeys with grunge.
And a writer on our show had written a sketch called "The Grungies."
Right.
And, you know, so he thought in some way that it had been lifted, but none of us had
ever seen it.
Okay.
And so he got really upset.
And then we got upset because, like, well, we didn't even see it and grunge is popular
now.
But I think it had more to do with, you know, there's a certain madness to youth to trying
to make it.
And so in these moments when you have these clashes, whether it's with executives or,
like, friends, and you're all trying to survive and you're all trying to make it, and you
just lose your shit.
You just go too far.
And the weird thing in comedy is it serves us.
Yeah.
you say they're so outrageous and out of line is funny and it's comedy it's you know misbehavior
shall i remind you of a couple of the choice phrases sure your opponent in the feud said i
feel you've made a career out of being a sycophant to carry jim carrey or shandling or rosanne and
when you weren't kissing ass you were stealing from lesser-known comics or leeching off other
people's ideas get cancer love mark that was to you and you came back with well i'll go back to
my life of thievery and leeching as for the cancer i'll wait till you get it and then steal it from
you i think then later i admit that someone else wrote that joke i think you said it was a it was
a run and he said by the way that was a line by rodney rothman exactly we later wanted an oscar
for the animated spider-man did he was that him yeah exactly
you
me yes he wrote on letterman and another guy who i knew was a letterman writer said oh rodney might
be a genius yeah and at the time i did like the early part of my career was writing for jim carrey
and rosanne and different people like it took me a while to find my voice so i'll just say mark was
right he then said die in a fiery accident and taste your own blood well that's just it wasn't
a good joke then you said that's a sam kinnison line you stupid fuck it went it went back and
forth was it real it was real well i don't actually think it was real i think it was real
i think it was like he was running that 70 show and i was running my failed show and i just think
we got caught up and distracted and i think we were amusing ourselves with it not that there
weren't emotions around it but at the same time i think i was emotionally dysregulated as i've
learned from my my current therapist that that like there's some dysregulation in that uh and
and it led to good comedy so what does that mean you know like a weird email exchange
from the year 2001 is still pretty engaging and funny because two guys lost their minds for a
moment i guess that is a roast see i said i didn't like roasts i guess maybe that's why i don't like
roasts because mark mark nailed me so hard maybe maybe we have sudden we have since made up but
mark's wikipedia page it's about one-tenth the size of yours and one of the main entries is about
the feud with judd apatow well
that may say more about my needs he had a he had a word he had a actually hugely successful show
and i had to make a zillion shows uh to still not succeed as well as that so gracious
have you never had a brush with cancellation
uh yeah not over jokes and and things like that i mean i certainly have jokes where people look
back and go like should you be doing that but nothing that people are really super mad about
it's like a
comedian your whole life is talking right so if you just imagine you know 30 years of babbling
how could you not say a dozen things that people think should be career ending just based on
filling the time i think people get in trouble because i think we all like say things that are
too far to our friends and family like we have our own sense of humor in the house like i'll say to
my kids keep that in the house uh and that every once in a while someone forgets they're not in
the house and and slip or or they think i think i'm right on the edge of being allowed to say this
because this is so weird yeah i can get this by and i think that says a lot about social media too
and and the collapsing of categories of private and public like x or twitter sometimes feels like
your front room you're joking intimately but actually it is also viewable by almost anyone
in the world and stays there forever so all these codes that you
switch between of acceptably edgy i mean i make jokes among friends that i wouldn't make um if i
was on a podcast yeah um and then some people are just so great at it like south park where
you may not agree with all of it but you know their heart is in the right place and that's
usually what i think it's like you know i have a sense of people and so if somebody is awful all
the time that's different than like somebody that took a shot and made a mistake and but it's hard
for the world to judge if someone has a good heart or
is this thing that they said you know meaningful in a negative way but people seem to be kind of
tired of it i feel like everyone's going back the other way of being too uh sensitive about
what they're saying i feel like people are getting harsher because they feel like now
they're allowed to a little more it's part of the vibe shift yeah there's like a little blowback
on that do you think you know knowing some people who've been in your films who i'm curious
you know we've got russell brand on maybe further slightly further to one side you got
james franco bear in various ways touched by um whether you call it scandal allegations of
misconduct do you have any insight into what your role is you forgot diddy p diddy you worked with
p diddy thank you for pointing that out i always want to make sure everyone knows i sat next to him
on the set
he never invited me to a party
we don't know what i would have said people confuse the parties with the freak offs
that's true there's many many many layers there's two different those are two different things the
thing that more troubles me on you know sometimes is i just go man i thought he was hilarious
like but but it's interesting because he had a real sense of his persona as someone who was wild
and crazy so in the movie he's very funny and he's improvising and he gets the joke of like the
irrational out of control head of a record label and so so that's the part where you go like oh i
wasn't like i didn't have i wasn't scanning for like this guy is up to something that uh is
terrible i just thought oh isn't it funny that he he gets this he's not offended by this joke he's
embracing this joke
if he emails you and says hey uh judd i'm getting out in a little bit i'd love to meet and talk about
ideas yeah i don't i don't think i would set the meeting i'm sure i wouldn't set the meeting
let me let me be clear i would not be setting that meeting uh did you read lena dunham's book
i haven't read it yet fame sick it's really good you're in it i i i hear i just wrapped a movie so
i can go in uh do you think it's nice about you i heard it is nice about me i've gotten calls where
people are like are you nice because lena said nice things about you she said on season three
you got in touch and said this seems lazy uh the direction is lazy it's stiff it's too static
i guess i was brutal then and she writes um he was right i was phoning it in
and then it's a long lines of judd's instinct for i think but humor and life
are unerring along those something like that well that's nice well i mean that was a great
experience for me with lena we just had a very good uh communication the entire time
you'd seen tiny furniture and you reached out i saw tiny furniture and i just said
turn an email if you ever want someone to do something with and hurt your career i'm here
and uh then i found out that she was just starting an hbo pilot
and so she asked me to come on board but you know that again it's also about these collaborations
you know my job when i'm in you know producer mode is to just try to figure out how to help
her figure out how to do this she'd never done a tv show she just made super low budget movies so
we're going to try to get a good budget but now you have a you don't have a crew of 11 you have
a crew of 100 or 150 and you know a lot of it was me and jenny connor you know working with her
to just set up the show in a way that staffing wise staffing and just just how the whole machine
would work having seen it not work well for shandling and knowing like oh this is a young
woman who's going to write often direct star the dynamic with shandling in the larry sander show
you're talking about the internal dynamics of the outfit yeah the whole relationship with the
network i imagine hbo pretty hands-off like you well they were very positive with her and they
loved the show and they were very productive as they were
with gary uh yes yeah uh i mean they're you know when you get rolling with hbo they're very
supportive and smart and that's why people like working there but it's still a giant machine and
how do you have enough time to write and act and you know it's almost like a pacing thing like how
many months before we start shooting how much can i accomplish what do i need to accomplish while
we're shooting writing wise and editing wise like it's a it'll take most people down uh and so i
think a lot of our job was to just set up the
machine well because she's so brilliant how could you give her the most time to do what she does and
the most support when people go wrong how do they go wrong um well like lena was very collaborative
so she would always have an amazing staff of people and she liked working with them and she
would use their ideas she had no ego about i don't want to do that because i didn't think of it and she
also enjoyed the process and occasionally if she just didn't like a you know a script even when
she was working on she would just go home and over a weekend write a new one and she was able to do
where you would read that script and think that must have taken months to write and literally it
took her two days I mean it was pretty startling so as a producer you're you have to pay attention
to oh how does she work how do you create a world around her that is kind of supporting that you
know sometimes you have a great writer at the helm you have to say to the staff you know this is all
about getting the most out of her it's not about the writers getting the most done it's like we
want to get the most out of her and then we're going to fill in the rest because and the same
with Gary how much energy does he have to write scripts to do the rewrites and we have to step in
when he gets tired I think we're nearly there how's your energy you're right I have I've never
been more energized in my life I haven't had any breakfast usually that's what makes me tired you
know like a french toast some maple syrup but all I've had today is a banana and I'm sharp as a tag
what?
what do you think your secret is um I mean I think I'm in tune with like you know how it's
challenging to be a person and I'm interested in all the ways we deal with it and there's
something about it that I think is comic like that's how I survive as somebody who you know
is maybe slowly discovering spirituality but like that's the the filter which makes everything
deal with it and I think that's something that I think is comic like that's how I survive as somebody
and so and I'm endlessly interested in it you seem to have figured something out because I mean that's
your sensibility but there's also a pragmatic side which is an ability to recognize talent
to get projects off the ground I'm a fan I mean I mean first of all I just you know have always
looked at it like when I see someone just what I like to see them in something you know so if
someone auditions it could be someone I've never met before I might go oh I wish they were in a
movie oh let's put them in this movie you know we did a table read for this Glenn Powell movie
Comeback King here in London about a year and a half ago and you know we just needed people to
read it so we could see if it was getting anywhere I wrote it with Glenn and we needed
someone to play his roommate and someone sent us a video of a comedian
this guy named Jin Hao and we do the table read and he's hysterical like he couldn't be funnier
the table read didn't go well at all it was very like it was a bumpy ride but this one guy
murdered so we were like we're just gonna hire him in the movie we didn't shoot it for another year
but as a fan it doesn't matter that I don't know who he is I just see someone and go oh I love what
that person's doing you know and that's that's about as far as it it goes in my thinking and
it's just oh I'd love to watch that person you make it sound quite easy I mean only from the
sense that it's like if you went to a comedy club and you saw eight people you might go oh I love
these two more than the other six but for me I'm doing the same thing but then trying to work with
them you would have learned all this if you took that job at news radio the road not taken
we're back thanks so much to Judd for joining and to you for listening or watching miscellaneous
plug Judd has a new documentary out called Norm the tale of Norm Macdonald about the legendary
Canadian comedian Canadian comedian that's that's very assonant isn't it um who we didn't talk about
in the in the interview actually we did a little bit and merely cut it out
thanks Millie clarify that I was never offered a job at news radio for outro I was never offered
a job at news radio did it sound like I was no I wasn't it was it was lightly teased it was
mentioned it was tantalizingly dangled but it was never formally offered or informally
uh so just to clear that up do you still have your script I still have my script
uh it's on my computer if you're interested in reading
my never produced news radio I've got it on my computer I've got it on my computer
uh well what would we say so in the comments and I'll think about publishing it online
it's pretty good I watch I read it about three years ago I was like wow that's a good script
maybe I would say that I think I'm a tough critic of my own work
would I take a job in a Judd Apatow film and who would I play
we should have asked Judd I mean there was a small part of me who always thinks like
well Judd you're
super successful like do you want to see my ideas and I do have a couple
you did that with your goss though and it didn't go well I've got an idea for a Will Ferrell vehicle
that's kind of a takeoff on Bear Grylls where they realize he's a survival expert and his brand is
damaged and then he's out in the field and he realizes the producers are trying to kill him
because they'll make more money from him dead that's good that's good Millie actually looks
like she I actually think it's a good idea I think it's a good idea I think it's a good idea
it is quite good it's good and he has to learn real survival skills in order to survive because
he's kind of a he's like a fake and he's got a rivalry with a new up-and-coming I've gone quite
deep into this up-and-coming it's sort of based on the will that sort of Bear Grylls Ray Mears
duel of the late 90s oh this is genuinely good Millie looks impressed I haven't seen that look
before it's kind of unfamiliar
uh I love lamp I've written this I love lamp I love desk after I did the I love rug does he say
that after I the I love lamp bit which Judd mentioned I went back and watched that scene
again so amazing it's Paul Rudd Dave Koechner uh Will Ferrell is it those three oh and Steve
Carell and um and then they're going in and out of close vocal
harmony doing afternoon delights it's so it goes between and also they go between being kind of
Larry and and sort of gross and then kind of childlike and curious one of them goes have you
ever been in love what's it like I'm not really doing it justice watch it we'll include a link
to that maybe um in the show notes and uh that will keep you happy for a good two minutes that's
it for today thanks so much for watching and I'll see you in the next one bye-bye
thanks so much for watching and or listening I'll see you for another episode next week
when you shop Kroger delivery you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered
right to your door our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed
to getting every detail right carefully selecting and packing your order with care
because bringing you fresh quality groceries is what we do best and right now enjoy $20 off your
first online order of $75 or more restrictions apply see site for details Kroger fresh for everyone
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Judd Apatow credits his early career and comedic vision to formative experiences with his parents' divorce and his deep immersion in stand-up and comedy culture.
The *Larry Sanders Show* was a pivotal influence on Apatow’s development as a writer, shaping his understanding of human behavior, deception, and the pressures of media and power.
Apatow reflects on how his comedies—like *The 40-Year-Old Virgin* and *Superbad*—tackle themes of masculinity, insecurity, and toxic male behavior, often with dark irony and satire.
He observes that modern comedy has become polarized, with political extremism and harmful ideologies now mainstream, raising concerns about the health of social discourse.
The decline of DVD sales and the shift to streaming have disrupted the comedy industry, making it harder to sustain original, high-risk comedic projects.
Apatow emphasizes the emotional toll of being rejected in the entertainment business, often drawing parallels to parental abandonment and deep personal insecurities.
His work often blends absurdity with authenticity, creating characters who are flawed, vulnerable, and relatable, reflecting real human struggles with identity and connection.
He believes comedy can serve as a cultural immune system, allowing audiences to process difficult ideas without being overwhelmed, but warns against excessive exposure to toxic content.
Summary:
Judd Apatow, a defining figure in modern comedy, shares insights into his career, personal life, and the evolving nature of comedy in American culture. Rooted in formative experiences of parental divorce and early exposure to stand-up and satire, Apatow developed a deep sensitivity to human flaws and power dynamics. His work on shows like *The Larry Sanders Show* and films such as *The 40-Year-Old Virgin* reflects a consistent exploration of masculinity, vulnerability, and social pressures—often using dark humor to expose the absurdity of toxic male behaviors.
Apatow notes that comedy has become politically charged, with extremist ideologies now mainstream, creating tension in the industry and broader society. He attributes the current decline in original comedy to the collapse of the DVD era and the shift to streaming, which favors safe, low-risk content over bold, innovative storytelling. Despite these challenges, Apatow remains committed to using comedy as a tool for understanding human nature, emphasizing emotional authenticity and social critique.
He reflects on the personal toll of rejection in the entertainment industry, drawing parallels to childhood experiences of parental abandonment and emotional insecurity. Ultimately, he sees comedy as both a mirror and a healing force—one that can process difficult truths without causing harm, but only if it maintains balance, empathy, and creative integrity.
FAQs
Apatow was inspired by early iterations of the manosphere and the absurdity of toxic male behaviors. He sees his work—like in 'The 40-Year-Old Virgin'—as a critique of misguided masculinity, using humor to expose flawed beliefs and behaviors, especially those rooted in arrogance and misogyny.
He started writing jokes for Gary Shandling during the Grammys and later became a consulting producer after being invited to work on the second season. The experience taught him how to write stories and understand human nature through the show’s meta and psychologically complex characters.
Comedy often works by showing people making mistakes or facing emotional struggles, which resonates with audiences because it reflects real-life pain. The humor arises from relatability and the absurdity of missteps, making it a powerful tool to explore serious human issues.
Growing up in Long Island and watching late-night TV, Apatow developed a deep interest in comedy through stand-up, sketches, and shows like Saturday Night Live. This early exposure shaped his comedic sensibilities and instilled a lifelong passion for understanding human behavior through humor.
He left Twitter due to its political toxicity and the feeling that his content was being shadow-banned or misrepresented. He found the experience damaging and emotionally draining, which led him to seek healthier creative outlets and reevaluate his relationship with social media.
He sees comedy as a space where satire can expose harmful ideologies, but also warns that it has become a wedge issue. While some comedians push boundaries for truth and freedom of speech, others are driven by ideology, making it harder for comedy to remain neutral and inclusive.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.