Josh Barro: It’s Not Helping that Idiots Are in Charge
1h 16m 19s
The podcast explores a wave of critical infrastructure outages and political instability, framing them as symptoms of systemic failures. AI has accelerated software updates and patching cycles, increasing the likelihood of errors in aging systems like air traffic control and banking. These technical failures are compounded by weak leadership, such as the DHS director’s dismissive comments, and a lack of accountability in government operations. The administration’s promises—like the DOGE air traffic modernization program—have failed to materialize, highlighting a gap between vision and execution. Politically, the Democratic gains in key states stem from voter frustration with inflation, high interest rates, and perceived lack of economic action, especially among younger voters. Populist economic messaging, such as attacking billionaires or advocating for price relief, has gained traction but often lacks policy substance and consistency. Meanwhile, the economy faces structural challenges: AI-driven capital demand keeps interest rates elevated, making affordability difficult, and deficit reduction remains politically unfeasible due to public resistance. The show concludes by critiquing both the political and technological failures, arguing that while public distrust is growing, real solutions require long-term planning, transparency, and genuine accountability—not just slogans or reactive outbursts. A key takeaway is that crisis response in both tech and government is failing not because of a single event, but due to systemic neglect, poor leadership, and a lack of coherent strategy.
(upbeat music) - Hello and welcome to the Bollock Daily. I'm your host Tim Miller. Glad to welcome back to the show, co-host of the podcast, "Serious Trouble" with Ken White and "Central Air" with Megan McCartle and Ben Dreyfus. He also writes on "Substack at Very Serious." Today we're gonna get a little un-serious. I had promised you yesterday a spicy guess. This is why I never, this is why I never promise guests. Okay, 'cause you never know what's gonna happen. Are you saying I'm not spicy? - Well, you're just, you're different kind of spicy than what was gonna be. - I feel pretty spicy. Well good, that's what I'm saying. They had a kid's doctor's appointment. I needed somebody to come in and inject a little spice into the show. So we didn't let people down. And so we brought in Josh Barrow. - Thank you. - And we're gonna do queer authoritarian dictatorship mandates at the end of the podcast for your enjoyment. - Yeah. And everyone's hair is gonna look like this by the end of the show. - Everyone's hair is gonna look like this. Mandatory pronouns and bio. It's gonna be a good list. We'll get to it at the end. First, I basically have three big topics I'm gonna get to with you. Why is everything breaking? What's happening with the Democrats and very serious policy matters before we get to authoritarian clearness? I don't know why is everything breaking? What is happening? I guess I'll just give it an open-ended opportunity for you to give your theory of the case. - Obviously, I don't know. Although it generally seems like these stories happen and there comes out an explanation of what happened that makes sense that is not like the Iranians hacked into our system. And these things did used to happen from time to time. I mean, I remember a couple of years ago getting stuck in San Francisco for an extra night when that crowd-strike rollout basically shut down Delta Airlines for 12 hours. But so the most convincing story I've seen about why this broadly is happening more now isn't AI-related story, but it's not about like AI assisted attacks on the systems, which is to say that AI has both made it easier to push out more software updates more often. It's made people more efficient at developing patches and updates and that sort of thing. And then also AI has been identifying vulnerabilities in systems and so more often there are patches that need to be pushed and need to be pushed urgently because of a concern that something could be hacked. And so those things are being done more often, they're being done under more time pressure and so sometimes they're just being done incorrectly that we didn't update and everything broke. And that's always been something that sometimes happens with those sorts of updates. But if you're having to make changes more often, you're gonna have errors more often. That's not quite nothing to see here. I mean, that's a problem if that's something that's happening more often in our economy. But I also sort of assume that it's something that we will get better at over time and that in addition to AI breaking more things, AI will also make it easier to fix things. - Yeah. I covered an over-the-off air broke it down this way. Over the past five days, Outlook went down. US air traffic control and down banking systems. NSA, confidential telephone systems go down and now Apple services are down this post was yesterday. - Yeah. - And then she kind of break down. Talked to a bunch of experts, the midnight. And the benign explanation that you lay out is where she lands as well, which is basically there's tons of AI vibe coding plus security patches being put on top of old systems. They also try to, this is an IT nerd thing that I wouldn't have known, but to make sense, which is they try to jam in a lot of these updates before Thanksgiving because they don't want to screw shit up before holiday travel. And so, you know, why are that happening right now? The nefarious case for the paranoia acts out there and it's good to be on guard was that that list of things is a lot of kind of critical infrastructure matters. And you'd feel a little bit better at least about it if the people in charge felt like they had any idea what they were doing. - Yeah, no, I mean, certainly I would like less of this too. I mean, I think the other thing that I think is happening here is that, you know, you had the big event causing the, well, I guess the first big one was Microsoft Outlook, which I don't know, is the bulwark of Microsoft Outlook family? - No, I didn't know that that had happened for days until someone mentioned it to me. - Yeah, I mean, this is also, I mean, sales forces kind of like this. - I was on one team's call the other day recently. I was like, what in the fuck is this? - Right, so, you know, you had that and you had the nationwide ground stop due to the FAA issue and then some other things happened that probably wouldn't have been such big news if it wasn't that those things had just happened. Like, you know, a problem with United Airlines specific system for entering final plane weights that caused 90 minutes of stoppage of United Airlines flight takeoffs. Would that have been a major news story if the other two things hadn't happened first? It's not clear to me. So it's like, you know, summer of 2001 famously before the really big thing that happened at the end of summer of 2001 was the quote unquote summer of the shark because there was one really spectacular shark attack on July 4th weekend in 2001 where like doctors reattached the severed arm of some child that had been bitten off in the Florida panhandle. And after that dominated the news, every other shark attack that happened that summer was covered breathlessly as like, maybe the shark's pre-sage something that happened and so to me, there is something in the water, so to speak. - That is, I suppose that is another possibility, yes. But so all of which is to say, you know, sometimes when, you know, you have a combination of large and medium-sized things happening, I wonder a little bit about how much attention we would have paid to the medium-sized things if the large thing hadn't happened. - I think that's right. I also think that if we felt a little bit better about the leaders in the cabinet, maybe, and there wasn't so much uncertainty around what's happening with, excuse me, Si, maybe people would feel a little differently. I was intrigued by my friend, my, soon to be friend again, I think, she seems to be on a journey, Megan Kelly. - Yep. - She was discussing what she thought about the cabinet's response to these threats. I want to play a little bit of that for you. - DHS director. I'm sorry, no offense to Mark Wayne Mullin, but he seems like an idiot. I have zero faith in this man. Zero, less than zero. And this is a very serious agency, one in which I would like to have him faith in the person heading it up. He goes on cable last night, and I'll give him this. It seemed like a moment of honesty. One guy that's very smart with tech, he asked not to mention his name. No, it's not Elon, so let me just put that out. But I said, I said, what could be causing all these separate alleges? And he says, I believe that it's the Si. He said because these programs aren't designed to work as fast as Si is. - Well, yeah, I believe this is the Si. - Yeah. - That's a little alarming. - I mean, the sad part is he's an upgrade from Christie Nome. - Is he? - Yeah. Yeah, I think with her fleet of airplanes that she brought, bought that they don't even use. - I think it's a pretty lateral move. But it is a little bit concerning. The Si thing is something that's funny, but is indicative. If you feel like you have to do woke right signaling, when you're doing crisis response, it raises an eyebrows, including from Megan Kelly. - I mean, the funny thing is her eyebrows. - The only person who enjoys renaming things as much as very annoying leftists is the president. They both think the solution is, we need a new word for this, the old words bad. You're bad if you use the old word. They even made the all-in podcast guys use the term Si for about two weeks before they couldn't keep it up anymore. - It was a really funny chart online and it was like how much they used Si. And it was like, it was like skyrocketed and then crashed. It's like a crash. - Well, and of course the department of transportation is run by an alumnus of the real world. - Yeah. - Who is also, I would note probably one of the, in the top half of this cabinet in terms of performance quality. - Top of quarter, probably. The very serious Treasury Secretary, it's interesting, this is going around just today. And I think that it's, I think telling about the problem. And that's not necessarily really directly to what we've seen the last week, but just kind of the overall problem of the administration. In 2025, Elon had posted this early 2025. With the support of President Trump, the DOGE team will aim to make rapid safety upgrades to the air traffic control system. You see that post? And it's just really kind of funny to prove the replies 'cause it's all the like mega reply guys like next order. Like this will save lives. Thank you, Elon sir. And like thank you, Elon. And it's like they come in and they supposedly brought in these great tech minds to revamp the stuff. And like we fast forward a year and a half now. And it's like we have Bob McMarquain up there being like, I don't know, the tech guy say that SI. You know, I mean, it's undermined, I would say the case for the DOGE program. Well, then the other thing is you get Sean Duffy out there saying, well, the problem is we didn't get $50 billion to build a new system. I don't know, I've never built an 80s. 50 billion is a lot of money. Brian shots the incoming Senate majority whip was saying, that's an awfully round number to be the number they need. And didn't we just give them $12 billion? And what have they spent it on? But it's funny because you can go back and look at what Sean Duffy's saying in 2023 when Pete was a transportation secretary. And it was to a significant extent what Democrats are saying now, which is like we gave you all this money. And now you want more money. You know, why is the system not fixed? The one thing I will give them is that this goes back decades. You know that they only recently have finally rolled out these systems in the traffic control towers where they're getting rid of the paper slips that they have used to track flights for a long time. It's literally like each flight gets a paper slip, like stuck into a strip that they can move around on a physical board. The first contract replaced that system was issued before I was born in 1983. - Who's bad? - And I believe they have either have just finished the rollout of the new system or are just about to finish it. So this agency has always been kind of a black hole for these technological updates. And there are other countries that have like sort of quasi-non-governmental outside systems that run their ATC
like Canada does, it seemed to have produced better results. So I think that, you know, I think that there's a problem. - I guess this is like the point about Josh, like you laugh about it. - Right. - If you take it seriously, like, there's the idea that the government was gonna bring in some of our most influential tech leaders to come in and handle this stuff. And that's what was promised. And then to fast forward a year and a half. - There are places that you could get a good result from doing that correctly. - Right. - But it's not glamorous. And you know, you can't probably get the good result in six months is a problem. You put in a bunch of work and that's Michael Lewis on your own whole book. And that's where you went into the Josh program. And it's like, yeah, like sure. Like yeah, there's a lot of stuff that cookie got in there. Like people that were working in the existing government that were excited about having new fresh blood come in. And there's gonna be interest in and fixing the systems. And instead you put like a catamene addled brain broken weirdo in charge of it and big balls. And you know, it's kind of undermined the program a little bit. - A little bit. - Yeah. - Yeah. I've been surprised that it has kept the brand value that it has. I mean, you know, Mayor Mamdani here in New York came in and they, you know, announced their code program, which is doge for the city. - Is that cheeky? - Isn't that cheeky though? - No, but I'm making fun of it. - But they do seem to be actually trying to do the thing where you figure out, you know, are we wasting money on a bunch of stuff? Can we not? Like so it's doing the thing that doge was supposed to do. - I guess that's true. That's frustrating. Josh, you know, you're always the one to be the bear of bad news. - I'm really sorry to be your Debbie Downer. You're the one who told people I was going to be spicy. - So, that's on you. - There's so much more to come on, my friend. I want to listen to Vice President's take on this and we'll move on to other matters. He was on Laura Ingram. And in addition, Megan Kelly Laura Ingram is also kind of disappointed with the way things are going. So let's watch that. - Sometimes you have to work on a patchwork of solutions to keep a 50 year old system up and running. Why do we have a 50 year old system in the first place? We should have a new system and we need to rebuild it. - You guys have been in charge last two years. Why isn't it gotten back? - Typically. - We can absolutely do this with Democrats in the new Congress. If they set to side the ridiculous obsession with men and women's sports and did what they said they would do. Which was focus on affordability and focus on rebuilding our infrastructure again. These Democrats, they ran on the Trump agenda of 2024. Let's work together and rebuild American infrastructure. - Lot to unpack there. I mean, personally it is a little frustrating. It's six years, they've been in for six years. It's actually been the first year was 10 years ago. So like a 20% a fifth of the time. - So the COVID happened. - COVID happened so you couldn't do anything during that time? - Yeah, that erased up like men and blacked everything after that. - Yeah, I don't know. Just, it's not really great when if you're in JD Vance's shoes, where Laura Ingram is giving you her skeptical face and then you're going back to the failed message that cost you a 12 point loss in Texas. Well, just being like, well, if the Dems weren't so trans, we could fix this. - Well, and also, you know, I mean, Congress did pass money for this stuff. You had Sean Duffy on Capitol Hill meeting with Senate Republicans getting yelled at by Republicans. 'Cause he's been going on television, not admitting any fault, saying the problem is Congress won't give us the money that we asked for. And they keep saying we gave you $12 billion. You haven't spent most of it. Why are you here asking for more money? So I think that frustration is very real. Not just on a road trip. (laughs) - Right. Yeah. And again, as we note, he's better than your average cabinet member. - He's 12 children, so there's just a lot of time. He's a lot of demands at this time. - And also, by the way, he asked for a billion dollars for upgrades to make airports more family friendly. And individually, the ideas all sound plausible enough. Like, should there be more play equipment inside airport terminals? That seems like a question for local airport authorities to me rather than, you know, a $1 billion federal program. But, you know, people talk about Democrats fail to prioritize. If we have a tremendous technological deficit with our ATC system, maybe $1 billion for family amenities in the airports is a lower priority than that. But they lack the ability to pray. Also, part of the billion was supposed to be for healthy food. So, we had RFK Jr. with him doing like chin-ups at the press conference about how the airports are going to be held here. - Airport chin-up press conference. - Yes. - Yeah. This brings up something kind of melancholy for me. What do we get to next? We're both in Denver for this majority. Dems confound. But I brought my daughter. - Yes. - My hair looks worse in person, by the way. - It does. - Yeah. - Well, this is the space for a radical candle, Josh. - Uh-huh. - Sorry. I got a haircut yesterday. Is it any better? - I don't think I should answer that on the show. But I was bringing my daughter back to New Orleans. - Someone called me Gay Fieri, by the way. I thought that was pretty good. - That's good. Gay Fieri, that is good. - Yeah. - Anywho, we're in the airport and we're there's a little delay. Not too bad. And we walk by the children's play area. My daughter is eight now. Looked at it and she looked at me and she was like, "I used to really like that when I was a kid." And I was like, "Oh boy, this is sad. It's over for me." - Well, my whole childhood, it felt like it was some sort of error that I was treated as a child, that I was like supposed to be an adult. I didn't even like children when I was a child. So like the-- - That's the least surprising anecdote about you. I've ever heard Josh. - I want to do some big picture. I want to look back before we look forward. There's a decent amount of forward looking at this, at this Democrat compound. What the dems should do, but let's marinate in the victory for a bit. - Yeah. - Telleriko is there, as we just saw in Fox, JD, like we're really hard to be like, he's a trans, weirdo, and gay maybe. And that resulted in a historic ass whipping in Texas. The Democrats had one in 30 plus years. Telleriko won by 12. - That's a lot. - That's what carried every person along with him. Raphael Ted Cruz is the only Republican statewide office holder now in Texas. - So I guess it kind of as you look back on it, what is your analysis for like what was working for the dems? - Well, I mean, it seems simultaneously you both had a pretty good result for Democrats on persuasion, winning over voters who'd supported Republicans in the past and a great result on turnout. Just Republican turnout was absolutely through the floor. And some of that I think is nothing that Democrats did. The president made two key promises that he was going to bring down prices and stop the endless wars. And instead, he's done a bunch of policies that make things more expensive and behaved in a way that makes clear that he's not focused at all on prices and he started this war, which is extremely unpopular. There seems to be especially a lot of disappointment among younger Republican voters among whom turnout was absolutely awful. And so, Democrats were more. - I saw an awesome chart yesterday about the Texas colleges. And it's like Baylor went blue. TCU went blue. And it's just, there's no oasis, no bastion for the young croipers any more in Texas. - Democrats won the House Popular Vote in Utah. That's a lot of young Mormons voting Democratic who didn't use to to produce that kind of result. And on that university point, I don't know the Republicans lost provo, but the results in the vicinity of BYU were a lot better for Democrats than they are under any ordinary circumstances. - And you know, Democrats, I think, made good choices and didn't get in their own way. James Tallerico ran a campaign that was designed to build a large tent. And the lefty populist really want to lay claim to Tallerico and they talk about, you know, he talked about, you know, billionaires are doing bad things, trying to buy our politics, which has been a Democratic talking point approximately forever. I mean, I'm old enough to remember Al Gore and the people versus powerful Bob Schrum campaign. But at the same time, you know, Tallerico was talking about how important oil and gases to the Texas economy and the Trump has done a better job on the border than Biden has and that as for Elon Musk, he wishes that Elon would stick to his genuinely really impressive business accomplishments, which he's glad that he's doing in Texas, instead of trying to buy the election for a terrible guy. - So he went after Elon pretty tough. - He went after Elon pretty tough, but he said something there that like Bernie Sanders would never say. It's a new synthesis. And I think a good synthesis. I'm not saying that you shouldn't say tough things about billionaires. I'm saying that to meet the voters where they are, is that they want billionaires to do good, impressive useful things. Oh, right, sorry. I know that's the consultant speak that they all say. But it's 'cause they're right. You do have to meet the voters where they are. The voters decide the election. - It does make sense. You don't want to meet the voters where they aren't. - Right, they're not there. - You wouldn't want to do that. The voters aren't there. You don't meet them. - Just since you brought it up. It's very briefly on the never ending discourse. The progressive mod side analysis of this. I'm happy to report for everybody that they're both wrong. - Okay. - Everyone's wrong. Because there is a lefty case that's being made after the election, which is there was a huge victory for economic populism and kind of the DSA faction of the party and there's this momentum. And look, we won these races and made a Michigan. It's kind of like, okay, the push back to that from the moderate camp. The centrist camp is like, well, but if you look at the war total, the war analysis, like you look at the deep stats. It's like the more moderate candidates did better than lefty candidates. And that's true. And so it's like, it is true. But the weakness of their point, though, is like, Annie Andrews won in South Carolina and Calrico wins in Texas. I'm like, yeah, you're right. I tell Rico through a couple of times like would give some rhetorical aid and comfort to the fact that we need to do in all of the above energy approach. And Annie Andrews did do the ad saying that she didn't want boys and girls sports, they're like, on balance, they didn't sound like your daddy's moderate Democrat. And it wasn't Heidi Hyde camp and Mark Pryor and Joe Donnelly running in these races. I mean, like they ran pretty conventionally liberal races that were at points strategically smart, you know, but it wasn't. I just feel like,
It's a really straining to be like this was a heterodox moderate campaign that Tallariko and Amy Andrews were running. You know, I think Democrats put themselves in a position to capitalize on how unpopular the president was and they mostly didn't make mistakes that mattered at the march and there were a handful. I mean, up in, you know, the main second congressional district, it's funny, this district in northern Maine used to be the most Republican district represented in Congress by a Democrat Jared Golden who's a moderate. It's the only seat that wasn't redistricted that Republicans picked up in this election. Now Paul LaPage will represent it and he will have the most Democratic district represented by a Republican, which shows just how big the wave was and how many of the, we basically ran the pain. The manners are pretty flinty. It's a weird crowd up there. But, you know, we nominated this like progressive champion guy Matt Dunlap, who first was trying to, we did a primary challenge to Jared Golden and may have been one of the reasons Jared Golden decided not to seek reelection, but Washington consultants came in and they tried to get them to nominate this guy Baldacci, who has, you know, deep political roots in the district, him and his family, and as not as far to the left as Dunlap. And if he'd been nominated, we would have held one more, no, I realized that. So then we, we end up 61, we end up with 2.61 instead of 2.60, you know, in a blowout, it doesn't matter at the margin. But, you know, most elections are closer than this and, you know, to do something that can gain you a point across the country, a point is enormous. Like very few campaign interventions are that large. And so, you know, when you, when people say, well, you know, the indulging, all the various left-wing ideas, you know, you, you, you lose X number of points and it doesn't matter in the blowout, there's a lot of elections where it matters. Sure. What a matter for Scott Cologne and all of this sort of stuff. Right. Yeah. And I think that, I guess my point is like, yeah, it's true that a lot of the more mainstream candidates started sounding like Bernie on, on economics. And like also, like, yeah, it's true that a lot of them did not step in it by endorsing the, the stupidest lefty ideas from work one at the, like, in between that, it was kind of like, you also get this Martin Bailey thing where you have candidates go around and say, I'm going to take on the billionaire class and then you get, you know, progressive activists trying to argue that that means that there's now a mandate for a single-payer health care system. Well, I went to have in Holland about this question yesterday, you know, because I, because to try to get her to talk about the specifics about it, because he, you know, Martin Bailey kind of accuses of bad faith, and I'm not accusing, for Van Halen, because Van Halen is running on an enormous tax cut. Doesn't want people to make under $100,000 a year to pay federal income tax, purports to be out here with ideas about how the federal government can spend more money. He's lying to people because his big tax cut proposal and the healthcare proposal don't exist. They're incompatible. If you're right. Yeah. Sure. I mean, this is because you're a very serious white paper person and like, I'm pretty skeptical that any of these, I'm like, none of this stuff is going to happen in the next two years. So like, this is all like political positioning, basically, but there is like an element of this. It is like, okay, people are mad about prices, right? And people want politicians. So they're going to be more responsive to working people's needs than to get to hand out for the corporate class and the billionaire class, right? And so if so Van Hong can say that and then talk about it like at a tagline level. And everybody's like, well, yeah, everybody like Scott Columbus agrees with that. I'm told I'll say it. Roy Cooper agrees with that. I'm told that agrees with that, right? But then you get down into the details and it's like, okay, you know, well, if the argument is that the permitting reform is going to make energy cheaper for people, you know, then okay, is that being responsive to people's, you know, working class people's concerns are the price of energy or is it a handout to the corporations that I want the permitting reform so that it can make it easier for them to build things? It's like kind of both, right? And so like you get into a lot of these discussions where like the tagline, like means different things to different people. >> I think the permitting reform bill is clearly a response to concerns about affordability and I think it's why Democrats have moved on that issue over the last years. And so honestly, it's why Republicans have moved on it too, you know, that the corporations who could make the argument for either side or you should make the argument that being against it is going against what the fucking, you know, corporate class will make it easier to build one. So we're excited. It's populist because it makes things cheaper for people, right? It's both. >> The corporate sector is divided on this. I mean, you know, part of the reason that Republicans used to be ambivalent about it is that a lot of the for-profit utilities don't like the reforms around transmission because it effectively exposes them to more competition. And as electricity prices have gone over the last few years, the utilities basically just don't have as much juice with Republicans as they used to. And that's how it moves from the Senate with only one Republican, Mike Rounds from South Dakota, voting against, proceeding on it. And it's Rounds is the one who still really cares about the utilities thing. It's brought around almost the whole Republican Party. I think similarly on the Democratic side, you know, there's a mandate to do something about prices. Almost everything that you can do about prices either has small effects or is politically difficult. And so this is something that has, you know, a medium size effect and is only medium difficult, although it is requiring Democrats to roll the Sierra Club and certain other groups. So it's, you know, it's still hard. And yet it's the easiest thing that's available. So I think, you know, that's why people are doing it. They're doing a good thing for a good reason. The problem is that, you know, there will be positive price effects, but it's not going to be a sea change on our economy. You know, you see, you know, it'll be a somewhat positive thing. You need to find 12 other things like this and go do them too. And each one's probably harder than the prior one, you know, that's why people like talking about things that don't actually do anything about prices because it's a hard area to produce positive effects and you end up pissing people off along the way. I mean, you know, another thing that would bring down inflation and interest rates is if we had, you know, a significant deficit reduction package. Nobody wants to do a significant deficit reduction package. So that's why you end up talking about other things. All right, y'all, the holidays are upon us businesses are hiring for seasonal roles. They need some mall Santas, a ham glazer. Here we need video editors who work during the holidays because I podcast, okay, I podcast for you. So you have something to listen to to get away from your family. If you want to, maybe you have a family that you love and you don't want to get away from them. But for the people that do, I podcast. So, you know, we, we're looking for little elves to help work. So other editors can be on vacation. Whether you're hiring for one of these roles or any other role, the best way to find qualified people who are genuinely excited about you and your job and your company is at Zippercruder. And right now you can try it for free at zippercruder.com/bullwork. Zippercruder has a new feature that shows you the most interesting qualified candidates first. So you meet the right people faster. Zippercruder's powerful matching technology finds qualified candidates quickly. Candids can tell you in their own words why they're excited about your job. You know, wonders. Zippercruder is the number one rated hiring site based on G2. Let Zippercruder find the right people for your roles seasonal or otherwise. Try it for free today at zippercruder.com/bullwork that zippercruder.com/bullwork meet your match on Zippercruder. The interest rate is what I wanted to get you to talk about on Tuesday because we were talking about this a little bit in Denver because I do think this is important, which is if you disentangled everybody's economic complaints into individual elements, right? I think the most common thing you adhere is gas and fit, right? And so like getting us into the stupid war, I had a huge impact on that. The tariffs had some kind of impact on that. Trying to roll that back would help on the margins of some of the stuff is baked in now. I think that like the next thing that people would probably mention is interest rates. It's either mortgage rates, car interest rates, right? The way that it impacts their daily lives, like if you look at house sales, like there's through the floor, right? It's like people feel stuck, like even people that I talk to people all the time, they're like, I want to downsize and I can't, you know what I mean? Or I want to move from more expensive part of town to a less expensive part of town, but the practical effect of that move is it's going to be more expensive for me because interest rates are so high, right? And I've got a mortgage rate from whatever, from during the COVID days when they're really low. I know nobody is talking about that, really. What besides deficit reduction could plausibly impact that? I mean, it's very hard, which is part of why we don't fix the problem. I mean, and the other thing to note about that is that interest rates are not included in the calculation of inflation. And there are good technical reasons for that. Why you don't make it a component of the consumer price index. But it means that I think something that was happening a lot during the Biden years as people would look at inflation and say, well, it's elevated, but it's not that elevated. Part of the problem is it was not picking up the interest rate burden. Trump came in and they thought, you know, Scott Besson's whole thing was, you know, I'm going to, you know, drive down the 10-year yield and it was working for a while and then the war started and it's just gone back up over five again. One thing is that deficit reduction will tend to push interest rates down or will create space for the Fed to lower interest rates without causing inflation to spike. The problem is the unique kind of a lot of deficit reduction for like, you know, a kind of modest effect on that. And then whatever you do to reduce the deficit annoys people, you raise their taxes or you cut government programs and you can make better and worse choices about what to cut. And they're, we talked about Doge, you know, there is, there is real fraud and Medicaid programs. There's been this sort of insane expansion of veterans disability benefits, some of which is much less well-founded than other parts of it. But you know, I mean, I'm saying right there, well, you can take on the veterans lobby. Like, yeah, good luck. So I think part of the problem is it's a genuinely hard problem. On some horizon, it should also be responsive to changes in productivity and growth. The problem is that the sign on that is sort of ambiguous. you know, if we, if we have big increases in productivity.
and that means that any given amount of capital that's put out there produces more returns than in theory that creates space for rates to come down, but then the problem is that that also creates a lot of demand to do new capital investments. We see that right now with everyone wants to build a data center and so then the people trying to make those investments, they go out and they borrow money, that tends to push interest rates up. So I think part of the reason that we have this anti-data center politics and that I'm in certain ways sympathetic to it is that we have an economy where there's a ton of demand to invest in data centers and that's causing people to want to go out and borrow and that's pushing rates up and making it harder to build anything that's not a data center. Whether that's that you want to, you know, you want to buy a home or it means that you're in some other business and you want a warehouse, you want an office building whatever. And so I think, you know, to some extent, things that bring in a little bit the AI expansion may make some capital available for other things. The problem is that if those AI investments are in fact really economically productive and you prevent them, then you reduce growth and you push the stock market down, they're all hard questions. Well, we could have an AI induced recession. That would lower rates for everybody. That might be the best answer. It would lower rates. I don't think it would make people happy. Why don't we talk about that? How do you assess like the broader state of the tech economy? I've been, you know, naturally extremely locked in on the midterms. And so, you know, I was kind of monitoring what was happening over here with the chip companies and, you know, and then all of a sudden about a week after the election, I opened up my Schwab account and I was like, wow, things are going really badly actually when it comes to the valuations of these companies. And obviously this ties into what's going on with Jensen and then there's kind of the separate, whatever national security corruption element of that. But why don't you just talk about kind of economic impact where things stand? Well, so I mean, first of all, like the market's still up for the year. So I don't think we've seen what it looks like for the stock market to reflect a really negative sentiment about what has happened that certainly could come. I've been amazed by the open public fighting from officials within the administration over this scandal with NVIDIA, where it's clear that the Treasury Department and Scott Bezant have been pushing for the better part of two years, trying to really effectively limit chip exports to China and Howard Letnick, who runs the Commerce Department, standing in their way and purporting to be standing in their way on behalf of the president. And maybe that's, maybe it's right that this is what the president has wanted all along or maybe it's not right and Howard Letnick has been freelancing. I don't know. I think we'll learn, but it's clear that there's a lot of people who just think the really important thing is that NVIDIA should make a lot of money. And if you stop them from selling chips that are going to end up in China, they will make less money. And when I say that's important to a lot of people, I don't actually just mean the president and the certain wealthy business people around him. I think part of why the president has been taking these positions that are bad for our national security is that NVIDIA itself become an enormous component of the stock market. And there's a lot of Americans out there who are very literally and figuratively invested in this company and its growth. And so I think they see a crash, both broadly or even specifically in NVIDIA and some of these other very exposed companies as a political threat. I think that might be right. Now, of course, the stock market going up is not everything. And I think there are good reasons, especially like if you're someone who is serious about the power of AI and really believes the versions of this where it's extremely powerful, then you do have to put weight on keeping it out of Chinese hands, even if that means making less money and even if that means less economic growth in the United States in the short term. I think, unfortunately, we have an administration that is completely incapable of doing long-term thinking or at least the president is. I think I don't, I generally give Scott Bessent sort of a C++ as Secretary Secretary. C++? I mean. C minus. Well, you know. Didn't you go to the naive elite school? Well, I mean, look, like, are we going to completely break the curve here? If we give everyone an F, then we can't figure out who's better than everybody else. But all of which is to say, I think Bessent. I mean, I think Bessent has been, you know, he's overseen an economic calamity so large that the Democrats broke through what every conventional wisdom analyst thought was possible as the number of seats that they've wanted. The economy is still growing. You know, if we call this a calamity, what do we call it in 2028 if there's another landslide because the economy is actually shrinking. We need to save some of this terminology. Okay. All right. But anyway, it seems to be like Bessent has been largely doing the, trying to do the right things for the right reasons here. And I think that's going to be a big political story of the next year. I mean, just because it's very obvious that there's open corruption happening with the Trump and the Nutlook family. And so Bessent's on the other side of that. Yes. Yeah. And so I think, you know, the Democrats get their, get the gavils in Congress and they get to investigate things. Yeah. This is another thing. And I want to get to use some breaking news on Jeffries here that I want to get to after this. About my conversation within Holland yesterday, which is that I think that there's something to be said for, you know, obviously, the American people don't like the status quo. And just like have somebody else knew come in who feels different like an outsider. There's like a fig leaf benefit to that. I think. And I also think that having somebody that is focused on saying, hey, we are going to be taking on the entrenched institutions of people are unhappy about as opposed to somebody has been in league with them in various ways. I think that makes sense. Like both as a positioning matter, like before you get to the specifics, my frustration with him yesterday is we're talking about, and I think this is going to be true about anybody who ever ends up being democratically, this will be my frustration. Like, there is so much open corruption we don't know about in the administration. I'm like, we don't know the details of. And the way he was talking about their oversight role, it was almost like it was a PR thing. Like we're going to shine a light on this and shine a light on that. Yeah. And I'm like, no, you guys got to be hiring fucking lawyers and investigators and people who have experts in financial crimes. And like we have no idea, like the extent to which Jensen and the lot Nick and Trump and the family members were in cahoots about this deal. Or where the fucking Venezuelan money is or, you know, like the other market manipulation elements of this. There's so much that we don't know. Like my view is that kind of these sort of factional fights over like Medicare for more, Medicare for all of the kids, et cetera. It's like, Trump's not going to sign any of that. Like, let's have those fights in the presidential primary for 2028. Like the hills job is to investigate and figure out what is happening, what has been happening last two years. Where do you fall in that? Yeah. Well, the unfortunate thing about congressional investigations is that they tend to favor, you know, members of Congress who love the sound of their own voice, being as, you know, indignant as possible in ways where they're trying to create clips that will be shared around on cable news and on the internet. And sometimes it's because the, you know, everyone knows the facts of the story and what there is to do is to, you know, raise awareness and yell about it. Here, there's lots of questions that like subpoena power can help us answer. We've all read the same stories in the Wall Street Journal about the, like, the throttling and shutdown of, of star shield over Ukraine and, you know, the figure pointing about, was this Elon Musk's idea? Was this the president's idea? You know, that's something I'd like to have them have Elon Musk before Congress and ask him about under oath. And lots of these things that, you know, involve relationships between the Trump administration and large corporations. We don't know exactly what happened. We don't know who did what for what reason. And so that's something that if you can actually use the committees for the purpose of getting people in. And there's public and successfully did this with Hillary. I mean, we found the laptop for the Benghazi hearings. I keep going back to this. The, the, the Hillary server was discovered through the Benghazi hearings. I'd forgotten that. Okay. Well, there you go. See, this is, you know, this is where I come in handy. This is my, your expertise is Baja. My expertise is, you know, random political scandals 2000 to 2018. But anyway. But so, yeah, I mean, my hope is that they will actually use the investigative tools productively like that. Now, the problem is the track record is not great. And also like in the house, you've got how many people are on the oversight committee for each party like 30, like you can't, you can't control what each of them individually will spend their time on. But it would be, it would be great. There's a lot that both would be politically damaging to the administration, but there would also be genuinely important useful to know. Big gay authoritarian in positions. I'm counting on Robert Garcia, um, doing very authoritarian and all the members of the House oversight committee spend their time. I, I hope he has learned his lesson to not talk about how, like, being gay and petty is his job. Our job. That is our job. That's not his job. I also did this with in Holland yesterday. And I'm like, I know I get it, but I want, so I'm torn on this because simultaneously I want politicians to do good pod. That's part of my business. Well, also being a podcast host is different from being the majority leader of the Senate. Yes. And I can, I can say, like, thank God we can say the R word again after John Fetterman talks, right? Like, Chris and Holland probably shouldn't do that, right? Because you might need John Fetterman at some point, anyway, I mean, my main take on having a leadership challenge now is that democratic voters are not going to like whoever is majority leader for the next two years because Trump is still president and the majority leader will not cause him to not be president. And you're not going to end the war through a shutdown fight. I don't even know entirely exactly what it, first you have to define what it even is to end the war. I mean, we're not going to withdraw our troops from the Middle East. We're not bombing around today as far as I know. So part of Chuck Schumer's job here is to be the punching bag and have people be mad at him. And then Schumer's up in 28. I don't think he's going to run again. I don't think he should run again. And then we can come in with a new majority leader with a fresh image when we have a democratic president who can actually deliver some things. Yes. So I don't think Van Hollen's going to win this race. And I don't think he wants to win this race because I think he knows that that job is a shit shit sandwich for the next two years.
but I think he is unfortunately layering on some unrealistic expectations as with him being out here saying, you know, we're going to use a shutdown to end the war. They will only further, you know, so dissension about Democrats having majority, but I think people, you know, they're just not used to it. You don't think you're not for a shutdown down the war? I'm for a shutdown. This is of course. How do you see that? How does the shutdown end? The same way the shutdowns that did ended last time. We just to say that the war is not in fact ended. Yeah, right. You caused a bunch of political, but yeah, this is politics, baby. But I don't know. This is politics. You're a, I keep, but you're a majority leader van Holland. Yeah. And you've told people, or a majority leader designated van Holland, who has won this election somehow on December 1st. And you've told people that you're going to use a shutdown to end the war. And then you shut down the government on December 11th. And, you know, the Smithsonian closes. And for a few weeks, you fight with the president. And the president uses the opportunity of the shutdown to come up with a bunch of ways to screw Democrats. We don't get an unemployment number for December, because like last time, they're like, we can't run the bureau. Or it's the main thing. And then a few weeks later, the government will be open. The war has not ended. Aren't people mad at you? Majority leader van Holland for having broken the very first promise. I know this is where I was the last time. And there are a lot of people that took your view. And I think that I think that the Democrats obviously won both shutdowns. And it was good for them to draw attention to the fact that Donald Trump was cutting people's health care benefits. I think that was a win. So people don't know, but people don't realize what's happening sometimes and why things have happened. And I think they're aware of the war, though. That's true. But like, making it the main thing and like demonstrating that you're not going to be providing any aid and comfort to somebody who wants to continue this war. Except that then you do, because eventually, you allow the government to reopen and you betray them. Okay. Well, I think you may be, I think you take a little more personally than regular people too. As a betrayal, but whatever. We'll see. I don't know. I think that that would be smart. We have a speaker of the House. I came Jeffries. The first black speaker in the history of the country. He won 251 to 11. There are 11 no votes. It's still coming in. Yeah. It looks to make all the no votes. Or at least many of them are all new members. Oh, it's oh, I didn't I thought it was a secret ballot. I didn't realize just send it a secret ballot. House is open. You didn't fucking sit around and watch the 18 Kevin McCarthy ballots. Like, that was like, that was one of the greatest days of my life. But this wasn't actually a surprise. Nine hours. The speaker election will be in January. This is the Democratic conference voting on who their design is for speaker, which definitely. You're correct. I'm sorry. You're correct. This is not these people just put out a statement. You're correct. This is the so. Thank you. So it will be official next year. You're welcome. Yeah. You're welcome. Yeah. The speaker vote is open though in the end. But yes, that's it. That will be January 3rd. Today's vote is it's McKinney, Rab, Malat. You know, it's all it's all the new people. You had all of the like they're calling themselves the block. I guess because they're too big to be a squad now. But like the the leftmost members of the conference, we're clearly planning on this idea that you know, the Democrats were going to win a narrow majority of nine seats or something. Right. And then they were going to sit in there and make some demands about, you know, we insist that you do XYZ before you get our votes. And then inconveniently for them, Democrats won an absolutely enormous majority and their votes aren't needed. And so you have them like trying to figure out how to exert influence. You know, I honestly running around saying that, you know, we need to send bills up to Trump so we can veto them and show our differences. And the first one should be on reparations. Got no crazy. Yeah. I think a lot of them could learn a lot from AOC. I was being very practical at the smarts right now. So yeah, but you know, that's something that comes with experience time on the hill, you know, you get all the questions as long as AOC. But well, I was referring to the people that put it now this time who are all who are most at least from the last I've seen who are all the incoming crowd. All right. Since you were correct about whether this was an open ballot vote. And I was incorrect. I want to discuss one thing where you're incorrect. And I'm correct. And then we get to the gay popery. All right. Okay. You're upset at me the other day on social media because I did a post where I said that there are a lot of non-violent migrants that we have in prison camps right now, including women and children who've done no crimes. And they should be let out immediately on January 4th. Well, you said the ones who have not done violent crimes. Yeah. So actually, there are some criminals you want to let out who are not in there for violent crimes. Well, I mean, sure. Like sometimes I would grab people for like a traffic ticket or something like that. That's a fraction. That's not a crime. Okay. Well, what kind of I will. So we just going to argue about the crimes. I don't know. There's a lot of. I don't think it's fine. We can we can love shoplifting. And there was that was that the the area of your disagreement was just over the specific case of the shop. It's all criminals. It's just not as bad. But no, it is crazy. Like that we have the story of today I've been talking about Miriam Thomas. That'd be a lot. They've now been at her and her son have now been in for over seven months in Delhi camp. They've done nothing. But they they're the mother-in-law or grandmother was whatever bloody Mary or whatever name was in Iran. And so Marco Rubio took away their green card status and threw him in an internment camp. They weren't even here illegally. They haven't even broken any immigration laws. I guess I was talking yesterday about a mother and a daughter who were here on, you know, as refugees from Venezuela from here in New Orleans. Like mom was working at Walmart. The daughter is seven. They took the daughter out of school. Like she's in an internment camp now. She's been there for a month. Like why are these people and why are we doing this? We should take them all out of their camps. Like we like we're a free country. My objection is not about anyone's specific release. It is about having a blanket role that is is where Democrats seem to be coalescing themselves around these days, which is the idea is, you know, we should enforce the border. But that once you're in the country that it's presumptively improper to detain someone from deportation unless they've committed a crime that is unrelated to immigration. If you have that role, then you don't have immigration policy. You're basically saying to people that, you know, once once you come here, if you get here, we're only going to remove you if you're a criminal. I'm sorry. We can't remove. That's tremendous. No, there's no there's for a century. We removed people without having camps. At the end of the day, we have a final removal. If the government says, okay, we have a final let's just say this family we're talking about in the New Orleans, for example, they came from Venezuela on humanitarian relief as asylum seekers. This government decides we're not granting that asylum anymore. You're going to be deported. It's like, okay, well, then, you know, you can send whatever it used to be, I and S to their house and say, whatever, like in two months, like you have a period of time, we have to be deported that you can challenge us in court or whatever. And then if they lose the court hearing, then they get deported. Like, that's fine. Like, why are they in camps? Like shouldn't they be in their home in the period of time between when we identify them as somebody that should be deported and when they actually get deported? Well, sometimes you have people who do have a final order of deportation, but that they have that they're challenging the order. Okay, but shouldn't they be able to challenge the order from their home? It depends on the on the circumstances, not not in all cases. No, because I mean, it's the same thing. It's similar to pretrial detention. You know, sometimes it's, you know, reliable that you can go find. They haven't broken immigration law. You want to have detention for people that only broke immigration law? In so many of these cases, they haven't even broken immigration law, by the way. So you think in certain circumstances now, we can start there. The people who have not even broken immigration laws who are TPS, who are asylum, who are whatever, like green card holders, I think all them out, right? They haven't broken any of them. I think if someone had previously been a, been a TPS holder, I think it is generally, generally going to be improper to be holding that person in detention prior to deportation. Yeah. And you know, when you say we didn't have camps, I mean, we've, we've always had immigration detention. This administration is doing it on a larger scale, which is why they put up larger facilities and the scale does not need to be as large as it is right now, right? Again, it's like, I have the reaction to what you said there is that I, I worry a great deal about January 20, 29 when you have Democrats come back into power because there's, there's hundreds of millions of people around the world who would like to move to the United States if they can. And if they get the sense that if you enter the United States, you'll be able to stay here. Many of them will come. This is what happened in the Biden administration. You had Joe Biden came into office. It was read correctly around the world as a sign that they've got a bunch of people in the world who are scared to come here. They don't want to travel here because they might end up being one of the people that end up in camps. I don't think that is out what we should be like Syria. Can you, can you let me finish my point? Because I'm talking about the thing that destroyed the Biden administration and led to the re-election of Donald Trump, which I think you think was a pretty bad outcome. Yeah. I want Democrats to avoid making repeating mistakes that they made in the past that are being very unpopular. Yeah, I agree with that. And it's not just in the U.S. The number one thing that is that is that is that's about the liberal governments around around the well the rich world is global migration that is that is very unpopular with the with the with the local citizen population. The people are outraged about and they're looking to elect a candidate who will do something about it. And you know, if the if the establishment parties won't do that, then they elect parties at the far right. I want to be able to have a credible immigration policy as Democrats. It tells people not to bother showing up at the southern border because you're not going to be able to come here making a asylum claim, get handed a ticket that says come back to court in seven years and then go out into the interior of the country never to be found again, which is the situation that we had under Biden. And Democrats have an even higher bar to hit than Republicans in order to be credible with population around the world with the idea that if you show up here, you can't walk through a loophole in the system and get into the United States. And to a significant extent, yes, that involves detaining people who we are not able to remove necessarily today because there's a legal process that remains. But who also do not have, you know, that they don't have a valid claim of asylum, they don't have a valid visa. We haven't adjudicated it for them that they may enter the United States. We've hurled enormous numbers of those people into the United States under Biden and that created the poll factor that caused more and more people to try to come here. And I think Democrats have to be able to credibly say, if
if we have not decided to admit you to the United States, you're not getting in, you're not getting out into the interior of the country, we'll detain you in the movie. - You're not getting in, you're not getting out, we get able to detain you in the movie, but we also won't treat you like fucking dogs. This isn't a fucking authoritarian dictatorship. You won't be like, we won't leave your seven year old child like with no food or medical treatment in the fucking desert in Texas for no reason. We won't send mass guys to your face and nab you and send you to camps like, I'm fine, I can't we just deal with all the human rights abuses that we're doing in the country and then send that message, we shouldn't we make it up to the people that we, that we're treating as if like, they're in a weaker concentration camp right now in the middle of Texas or Alexandria, Louisiana. I mean like the way that these people being treated is fucking unconscionable and horrible. And so it's like, I don't, I think if you're saying like, oh, now we're gonna say, hey, we're gonna treat people with respect and human dignity. And like the downside of that is maybe some other people will try to come. I'm just like, okay. - I think a persistent political problem for Democrats and immigration is that as you are doing now, Democrats tend to look at this issue foremost through the eyes of people who are not citizens of the United States. And when they think about immigration-- - Well, we're talking about people in the camps. - So who are not citizens of the United States? - Yeah, sure. I have other concerns about people who are citizens of the United States. But the question at hand is what we should do with the people that we're keeping in prison camps right now. - I think that the Democrats North Star on immigration should be-- - I'm like the lady that was dealing with my Walmart. - I'm a citizen and she was doing Walmart delivery here in New Orleans. That's a service that I like and I use. And I would rather her do doing that rather than my tax dollars being spent for her to be sent across state lines to a prison camp. - And the situation of what Trump has been doing with ICE in the cities is not popular. But what Joe Biden was doing was even less popular. It was unacceptable to the electorate. And immigration, by the way, remains the president's best issue. Like his whole numbers have held up on that better than on virtually anything else. - And they lost the Kansas Senate race and several House races in Texas over it. - No, I don't think they lost the Kansas Senate race over immigration. And they lost all of the Senate races over cost of living. I don't, I, look, I think the president's immigration policy-- - If you look at the biggest, this is-- - I'll be clear, it's not popular. - We're all-- - When you survey Hispanic voters, overwhelmingly, they say the most important issue to them was cost of living. And the ones who say immigration was the most important issue for them tend to be more conservative. A lot of them, to the extent they do say immigration is the only reason-- - But what do you say-- - Because they have a harvest. - I just explained the five biggest flips in the House all being heavily Hispanic districts. - So I think it's two things. One is that the Hispanic vote has been generally more swingy than the wider the black vote over the last decade or so. Hispanic Americans tend to have weaker partisan attachments than white and black voters do. So there's room for more gains and more losses. Those are some of the places where we did the absolute worst compared to prior performances back in '24. And now it's swingback. And the other thing is that, yes, the president's mishandling of immigration policy has been advantageous to us in the 2026 election. It's not that he has the policy right. But if the policy swings back to what it was under Joe Biden, or Democrats basically, they're afraid to do anything that looks like it's mean. And they just wish the issue would go away because they don't like thinking about it. That produced absolute political disaster. They sent Kabbalah Harris down to-- I forget there was Guatemala or Honduras or whatever where she goes, you know, do not come. Like that message needs to be much more forceful next time. And part of how you make the message forceful is that you have to show people that arriving in the United States without authorization is something that tends to lead to bad results, not to good results. This is what I'm going to live now. Speaking of do not come onto the gay popery to close the topic. Earlier this week, I said that Mary Peltola had won the race in Alaska. Some people didn't understand what Google is, what's this like? Who called it? It sounds like I fucking called it, OK? I called it. I'm an observer of the political world. I called it. Now it's been officially called. Now that the Democrats have 56 senators, I am going to ask you as my first question with the gay popery, are you giving her a pass on using the F-slur? I'm sure whatever staffers you call the Faggot deserved it. I mean, you've met these Hill staff. Yeah. I came down on the other side of that one. But that's OK. That's a healthy disagreement. I think that sometimes the straight lips get a little too excited to use it. So I agree with you. I do agree with you that some Hill staffers deserve to be called it. But I also think that some straight Democratic Hill staffers are a little too excited to use it for my taste. I mean, look, I'm being flippant here. Obviously, we're in the flippant segment. Yeah. But here's the thing I actually would say about Peltola. I really like Mary Peltola. I've always really liked Mary Peltola. I think she's a cool lady. I think she's a very good fit for Alaska. I think that these are the kind of candidates that we need to expand the map in the way that she has. I have some bones to pick with the campaign that Peltola ran this time. I mean, people may have followed this. She had this campaign manager that there was this big blow up with who she then ended up firing midway through the campaign. And then the campaign manager went and talked on the record to the New York Times about things that the campaign manager didn't prove that they had done, including exposing this cockamami scheme they came up with to get this other guy named Dan Sullivan, who's not Senator Dan Sullivan on the ballot. And so there's a level of chaos that came from that campaign that is bad, that like she indicates that she was not running a good operation there. You read that New York Times story closely. The ones that profiled them, I mean, the campaign was. Yes. Was not well run. Yes, and so this is, whoever the Democratic Senate leader is, I hope is taking her aside and making sure she gets a really good chief of staff. While I don't think it's a super important thing if she shoved a male staffer once. She's this quite slight lady. Like, I don't know how, I don't think he was hurt. I think the lizard or whatever that had to get fed. Right. You know, justice for me, Paul. RIP that he couldn't see this great victory. These are not like, you know, grand national scandals, but they are all kind of indications of running an operation that's a bit less professional that ought to be. And so I hope she takes a lesson that like, you know, she's a great politician. She connected really well with Alaska voters. She won a very solid result. Maybe we can try to up the professionalism a little bit over the next six years. And I think that'll be good for everyone, including her. Okay. On to the topic of '69, Manny Routino from Colorado 8th, Colorado's 8th District. There was a viral video yesterday from the room draft. We'll throw this up on YouTube where he had his fingers crossed. We're getting a good room. And then he got room number 69, which celebrated. There was a lot of laughter. There's some jokes in the room. Right. A woman named Amanda Kosky, who is one of Eric Swales accusers, then went to the Washington Sun and said that joking overdrawing the number 69 is inappropriate. This is how it starts. One kind of sexual joke where everyone in the room laughs and gives the rest permission to say something worse later on. I was encouraged that there wasn't a lot of support for that position. So I mean, I know a couple of things here. One is that Amanda Kosky is not one of Swales. Just several thoughts on the 69 discourse. So people keep describing her as one of Swales accusers, which is not what she is by her own account. She hasn't held herself out as that. What she described is that Eric Swalwell like creepily added her on Snapchat. And by the way, she's right that is creepy. If you remember of Congress, you should not be adding young women operatives around you. You shouldn't be on Snapchat at all. Like what are you 19? She does not claim that Eric Swalwell sexually harassed her. And the point she had about Eric Swalwell's behavior broadly was completely valid. I do think she is being humorless about this. And also like, this isn't something that many rutinals did. Like he goes up there, he acts like he's manifesting a really low lottery draw number. So he's gonna get a great office. He pulls the number. He's like, well, that worked really well. Then someone else announces that the number is 69 and everyone in the room laughs. And so it's funny 'cause it's a high bad number. Some people in the room probably also were laughing because it's 69, but that's none of that's anything that Congressman elect Rutland did. Like, you know, take it up with the crowd that's laughed. But also like, I don't know, 69 has become so divorced from its actual direct sexual connotation. Which is what. It's when two people simultaneously perform oral sex upon each other. Oh God, because it looks like a six in a nine. We've got it. Where are you at on Mani versus Sam as the hottest incoming member of Congress? I gotta go with Sam. I mean, his literal smoke jumper. I don't even think it's close. Yeah, I'm confused. TMZ gave it to Mani and you can tell it's two straight guys that are working for TMZ. We love them. I love Charlie and I've had them on. But only two straight guys go there. I mean, hand him over. You know, we kill this close to getting Chris Galant in there. I know. And then how was you ended up losing by? About two points, I believe. Yeah, there's there's races that like I forgot, you know, in the after the dust settled races, I forgot to check on. Like one of those was Chris Galant. I was sad to see a couple days later, he'd lost by two. Another one I didn't notice to like a week later and this is not relevant to the gay popery, but is relevant to our status as former moderate Rhino Cucks. Phil Scott survived the wave. Yeah, governor of Vermont, the only remaining moderate Rhino Cuck in America who in elected office, Phil Scott won again. Let's go for it. You don't think Kelly Ock is a moderate Rhino Cuck? No, she's like, she's still kind of a Neocon like. I mean, she's going to be governing with like a democratic supermajority in the House representatives there. So I guess we, her real moderate Rhino Cuck colors make it to come out now. Yeah, she has to, she went a little too Trumpi. I'm sorry to be a full pure Rhino Cucki and being a full anti-Trump. Okay. And now we get to the final topic. Our friend, somebody that I still read a lot and admired a lot. So it's sad that this happened. Andrew Sullivan wrote a lengthy note about me and Sarah Longwell. He thinks we've betrayed our principles because we've become too live and care about the people in the detention centers, et cetera. We're not, we're too mean.
Doron DeSantis, that was among the complaints that he had for us, we're true to our principles. We would have been nicer to Doron DeSantis, unclear what principle required being nicer Doron DeSantis during his disastrous presidential campaign, but that you can ask Andrew. And then he offered a final note about his concerns for us, which I just think of the interest of transparency we should read to the group. Yeah. No one in Longwell are very prominent alleged gay and lesbian conservatives. It's not the most, I think the alleged is supposed to attach to conservatives not to get it. But yeah, but that's, yeah. Okay. Well, this is why one needs editors. I know. And I keep always saying to people like in this discourse, I was like, I was always a moderate rhino cuck. Okay. I worked for John Huntsman. All right. Like, let me be. I was, I was not a movement conservative. Okay. You dorks were reading William F. Buckley in college. I was hitting the ball. Okay. You could say I was an alleged gay and lesbian moderate than five. All right. Then the last 10 years, I've seen a prolonged, furious attempt to end any thought of gay people as normies trying to live and let live in favor of an authoritarian imposition of queerness in language policy and ideology gay men now must include sex with women to be queer. And lesbians must get over their dislike of male genitalia gay kids have been trans and large numbers, blah, blah, blah, Tim said something to me about my op-ed in 2024. And now the queers are here to reclaim all the gays for the hard left. Miller and Longwell are the leaders of the band at very comfortable among the radical queers. So I would like to end the show with what authoritarian impositions of queerness mean you plan to impose on the populace, but before we do that, thoughts on Andrew's critique of me. I mean, you know, it's okay to side with him. If you also think that I was insufficiently in the battlefield in the fight over the authoritarian imposition of queerness, I'm open to that critique. Look, I mean, you know, Andrew is one of the most important thinkers of our age who basically was the key popularizer of gay marriage. Very important to me personally. And part of how Andrew made change is by being a crank. I mean, you know, there's there's there's an important role in our discourse to be played by people who can like grab onto an issue like a dog with a bone and become completely obsessed with it and not let go and be very unreasonable about it. And you have a chance, me on the first appearance, maybe, well, I actually part of what's happening here is that you and Sarah stole his bit, which is that Andrew spent all of this time being like, I'm a real conservative, everyone who says their conservative is not a conservative. The movement left me. I didn't leave them. And so in a way, he's the proto-bull work. And I think, you know, sometimes people get the most upset about the things that are actually the most similar to them. And you know, I mean, what ultimately kicked this off was an argument about whether you and Sarah are just lips now, which I think you kind of are. Well, I died is not Sarah's position, like you may, you may have to take this up with your, with your business. Okay. Well, I don't have to take it up. We talked about this all the time. We've many podcasts. But like, yeah. She said that when she said she was a lip, she meant she was a classical lip. Yeah. But that's not the same thing. I mean, and I think she said, she said that I'm a classical lip and I am arguing in defense of liberal democracy. And we've had, I've had this conversation bill a lot from a more nerdy lens. I think simultaneously, like, obviously, like, we are against mega, it's the central point of the website. I mean, like, literally a defensive liberal democracy and going after Trump and the websites about page. It's not like exactly that, that controversial to say. But also in addition to that, like, I do think that there is like a redefinition of terms happening and a lot of people like in 1982 would have said I'm a liberal, like now say that they're progressive. And I think that there are a lot of leftists that use liberals as a slur. So, you know, some of this stuff is like, you know, we're arguing over nomenclature a little bit. Well, but I'm like, I mean, what do you disagree with liberals on? I mean, probably abortion. What do you want to prohibit it? I'm going to want to prohibit it more than they do. What you like for sure. 12 weeks. What's your policy stance there? Yeah. I mean, 12 is probably a lot. I don't know. I mean, yeah, somewhere between there and 20 probably. So it's so it's that you you would you favor a late term abortion ban, which they would have. Of course. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Well, that's probably various regulation limits like a bunch of stuff. I don't know. Yeah. Some guy some random like AEI nerd was treating up me the other day is like, where are you on right to work? I'm like, I'm for right to work, but I don't keep a fuck. Why aren't you talking about right to work? I'm like, why aren't I talking about right to work? Well, I don't know. Like, we have the aforementioned internment camps and we have a guy in the presidency that tried to do a violent assault on the Capitol and like in the grand scheme of things, I just don't really care that much. If the Democrats want to do the pro act, like I would vote against that. If I was in the Senate, but I'm not running the Senate, I'm a podcaster. And like, I talk about the things that I care about. Okay. Then AEI people care about other things. I think this is all that I think is in the spirit of still being a lib. I think there are plenty of libs that don't like the pro act and have moderate views on abortion. But are there any Democrats in the Senate who oppose the, I mean, because they almost got the pro act or some proto version of it through in 2000. It was like Blanche Lincoln. Yeah, sure. Like hold up the opposition. I don't know the answer. But so I'm spitballing here. One of the things I like about David from is that I think David has like a very clear account of what he's changed his mind about and why and what he hasn't changed his mind about and why. What is unclear about me? I've written most several. No, no. I'm just, I'm saying that, you know, I think that there, as you know, there's been a lot of people who have changed coalitions, changed teams over the last few years. There are perfectly valid reasons for doing that. There's nothing wrong with changing your mind. I think when people do the full Jennifer Rubin bit where it's just like you used to be all on one side and now you've just changed all of your positions because it's clear like you just swap your shirt and then you just like end up with a completely different set of views with no introspection about why you changed anything. I think it annoys people. I think people find it disingenuous. I think it's, and I think it's fine to change your mind. And I think it's good to have an account of why you changed your mind and why you didn't change your mind. Sure. Well, very sensible. Here's not a little bit. We're now we're into the discourse. This is going to be a long podcast now because we do have the fun part. I promise people fun, but we will have finished it. Like the origin of this latest version of discourse of Sarah calling herself a lib though was like herbing on stage at an event and they're like, come on, Libs, we had a great win. And then it begins with a bunch of people doing like sex as jokes about how she needs a Subaru on stage and how she's a Karen and how this is very cringe and then it begins with a bunch of like right wing people retweeting those and like making fun of her and quote tweeting her. And then all of a sudden, it's like, well, she's betrayed the principles of high. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Like, we weren't actually talking. We weren't talking about high. I'm here. You were, you were doing a sexist joke to try to take her down because she's happy that her life's work over the last 10 years has resulted in a positive outcome. And so, okay. I just own that. Like, own that you were being a piece of shit. You don't then be like, oh, well, you know what, this issue is really about. It's whether Sarah has changed her mind, the right amount, appropriate amount on issues of taxation. No, I mean, look, different people hate you all for different reasons. And I'm sure that's okay. Okay. This latest one, though, started it over a particular thing. I look, I like you guys a great deal. And you know, I, you're some of my favorite Libs. Thank you. But your Libs. That's fine. I know. Yeah. Yeah. The final topic, though, before we get started in positions, yeah, you didn't, we got off track there because you didn't really weigh in on whether you did feel like I disappointed you and that I wasn't fighting hard enough against the queer authoritarian leftists. Do you feel like that was a mistake? I'm mostly bothered by your immigration status. That's where I think you're trying to cause us to lose elections in the future. Okay. Yeah. He was really focused on that. The queer authoritarian takeover. I mean, I get the very brief thing to say about that is like, you know, the young, the children. The, I think I don't, I don't recall what the positions either of you ever took on the various disputes about, you know, like when, when glad we had a truck parked outside the New York time, saying science was settled on this stuff where the science is, you know, you're not settled. You don't know. Because that was happening during 2020 or when somebody that had instigated a violent attack on the Capitol was trying to become president again. And so like the glad truck just wasn't like, you know, on the, like, I don't have an opinion on you guys on this. I think that, you know, the, the thing that Andrew was talking about in an extremely hyperbolic term, there's a kernel of truth in there, but that peaked a few years ago. I mean, I think that, you know, that I think there was an effort to really, you know, stop people from doing news reporting on youth gender medicine, where there was like, there were a lot of very open questions and, and the times ended up doing some very good reporting on it in spite of pressure from groups like glad to shut up and basically say that the science had been settled. So I think, you know, I, and I think there was group think also on the transport stuff where you have people with a straight face making claims that, you know, like sex biology doesn't have inherent links to, you know, to athleticism and various things. Obviously. I, I will agree that we're dumb, queers that said dumb things in 2023 and for, and it was politically costly to Democrats. I mean, I think for sure. This is where Andrew agreed. Andrew said that what that he was disappointed that the only, our only critique of them was that it was politically costly to Democrats. But to me, that is, again, coherent in our worldview, which is the thing that I was concerned about was Donald Trump winning and I was annoyed that there were people that were ruining that over sex changes for prisoners or whatever. Yeah. You know, we also
So what happened at last-ditch bar a few months ago in Massachusetts, and there are definitely organizational places where that sort of thing happens, and it's not just weird like uneconomic lesbian bars in fourth-year cities, and Andrew, for example, has personal experience working inside a liberal publication, as I'm sure you're aware, there has been a lot of completely deranged office politics over this stuff and also certain race stuff over the last decade. So people take that personally, and I think that, you know- And sometimes they feel like it's an authoritarian imposition of queerness, and so I think that- Well, in the context of an organization sometimes it even is, even if it's not a public policy matter. As somebody who lives in Louisiana and has not felt the authoritarian imposition of queerness, but has felt some authoritarian right-wing imposition, so I just, I don't really resonate with me, but the more I read is critique, and again, because I admire Andrew, and I tried, yeah, multiple times, to do this privately, and he won't, so whatever. That phrase, it's just great of the authoritarian imposition of queerness. It's a really great phrase, and I want to do it, and so I want to close the pond by doing it with you, and I have a long list, but I'll let you go fist first, excuse me. You're going to let me go fist. Yes, first. Well, that sounds like you have some ideas for the authoritarian imposition of queerness right there. Well, do you have any authoritarian imposition? Do you want to lay? Yeah. This hair is mandatory now. That hair is mandatory. Yeah. We are all gay fearing. I like that. Yeah. Mandatory. I also had on my list a few things, which I'll let you respond to. Cold brew, national drink, available year round, mandated, and all restaurants like water. You're doing this specifically to piss me off. You know about my position on this. Coffee should be hot. It's like because. That's why you can actually. Yeah. That's. You're supposed. Coffee has beautiful aromas. It's supposed to smell great. It's aromatic when it's hot. Yeah. People like it to be cold because then they can guzzle it like some sort of glutton. The hot coffee forces you to consume it at an appropriate tasteful pace. And what are we as gays if we are not tasteful? We are. We continue. This is the nice thing about fascism. It's just like you get a strong man in charge or a weak man in my case, and they get to decide. Mandatory pronouns in bio, but more importantly, mandatory sexuality on forehead like the cards. I can't tell if the Gen Zs are gay or not anymore, and I want to know. I think you're seeing the wrong Gen Zs. I don't know. Like. If you come out to the Fire Island Pines, there's pretty much more continuity than preference across generations in terms of attitudes about sex and personal interaction. All golf courses will be converted into public gardens or gay clubs, depending on climate and location, parking lots will become a roller rink for the lesbians. So we're just. We're taking off the golf courses. Okay. Mandatory dark rooms and all bars. I don't want to go in there. I just like to know it's happening. I like to. I like to feel like it's happening and good happening. What happens in the dark room, Tim? I. I would like to know. I don't know. Do you know? Some day, somebody will tell me. It's dark in there. I. I couldn't see. One skin faced from moisturizing cream in all bathrooms, thanks to a sponsor, one skin. I want to be able to moisturize, okay, with a high quality face cream. Yeah. We want to re-liberate the tanning beds. There's another area where I'm different from the lips. The tanning beds need to come back. We're going to have tanning beds. Stimulus check only for male nurses. Okay. That's the solid energy. Washington Monument, now at Dildo. What's the change? There. That's what we got. I have some other ideas. I'm still working on drag queen story hour for adults. Same Patrick's Day is banned. Call me by your name as a holiday movie now. Everyone has to watch it at the holidays. Do you have any others? Any other queer and positioned mandates? Yeah. I just. I want to. I want mandatory redecorating of people's homes because occasionally. I don't really set foot in a lot of straight people's houses, but occasionally on the internet, I see pictures. There's some horrible things happening there. Things that cabinets should never be made to do. Really horrible things. I have another one. My authoritarian position of queerness I'm going to put on to the queers from the gay. And that is traditional rainbow flag only. The rainbow represents everyone. That was the point of the flag. If we add burnt sienna to the flag to represent the two spirits, that undermines the whole point of the flag. We don't need any additional shapes or colors to represent other groups. If you are queer or if you're like one of the queers that Andrew Sullivan says that we've mandated the men like vaginas or whatever, if you're a queer, we cover you. The rainbow covers everybody. Did Andrew Sullivan write that one for you? I don't mean Andrew. Here's an overlap. I mean, it's just like. I'm just looking forward to 20 years from now, the unhinged letter that you are writing in this vein to your successor. I'm Andrew stealing your bit. I hope Andrew is still alive to see that because he's going to be like, and lesbian must get over their dislike of Cox. Uh huh. All right. That's great. We'll leave it there. Way too long of a show. We might cut some of this. I don't know. I appreciate it, Josh Bear. Thank you for coming in on short notice. You can't cut this gold. Okay. We'll keep it all. I think you were coming in on short notice. We'll let the founding members see the whole thing. Hopefully you're a founding mother. Remember, you're doing pretty well on Sub-Stack. Everybody else will be back here tomorrow with some more very serious podcasting. We'll see you all then. Thank you. Thank you. The Bullwork Daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper, associate producer Anzaly Skipper, and with video editing by Dante DeCicco and audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
AI-driven software updates are being pushed more frequently and urgently, increasing the risk of errors that can cause system failures across critical infrastructure.
Recent outages in services like Outlook, air traffic control, and banking are linked to rapid, high-pressure patching cycles, especially before major holidays like Thanksgiving.
A lack of transparency and competence in government leadership—such as the DHS director’s dismissive response to system failures—has eroded public trust in policy responses.
Long-standing technological stagnation in systems like air traffic control, combined with promises of overhaul (e.g., DOGE program), has led to misplaced expectations and poor execution.
The political response to crises reflects deeper dysfunction
The election results show strong Democratic gains in key states, driven by voter frustration with inflation, high interest rates, and lack of economic relief, despite ideological polarization.
Populist economic messaging—like opposing billionaire power or cutting prices—has gained traction, but often lacks concrete policy depth and can backfire due to contradictions.
The broader economic outlook remains fragile, with AI-driven investment demand pushing interest rates up, making affordability and deficit reduction even more challenging.
Summary:
The podcast explores a wave of critical infrastructure outages and political instability, framing them as symptoms of systemic failures. AI has accelerated software updates and patching cycles, increasing the likelihood of errors in aging systems like air traffic control and banking. These technical failures are compounded by weak leadership, such as the DHS director’s dismissive comments, and a lack of accountability in government operations.
The administration’s promises—like the DOGE air traffic modernization program—have failed to materialize, highlighting a gap between vision and execution. Politically, the Democratic gains in key states stem from voter frustration with inflation, high interest rates, and perceived lack of economic action, especially among younger voters. Populist economic messaging, such as attacking billionaires or advocating for price relief, has gained traction but often lacks policy substance and consistency.
Meanwhile, the economy faces structural challenges: AI-driven capital demand keeps interest rates elevated, making affordability difficult, and deficit reduction remains politically unfeasible due to public resistance. The show concludes by critiquing both the political and technological failures, arguing that while public distrust is growing, real solutions require long-term planning, transparency, and genuine accountability—not just slogans or reactive outbursts. A key takeaway is that crisis response in both tech and government is failing not because of a single event, but due to systemic neglect, poor leadership, and a lack of coherent strategy.
FAQs
The increase in outages is likely due to frequent AI-driven software updates and security patches being applied to aging systems under tight timelines, especially before holidays. These updates, while intended to improve security, can introduce errors when rushed or poorly implemented, leading to system failures.
AI has made software updates and patching faster and more frequent, which can increase the risk of errors. While AI isn't directly causing the breakdowns, it has intensified the pace of changes, making it harder to maintain stability in older systems.
Inadequate leadership and inconsistent messaging—such as the DHS director’s suggestion that 'Si' is causing system failures—raise concerns about poor crisis management. The lack of technical competence and transparency undermines public trust and response effectiveness.
Many tech teams apply critical updates before Thanksgiving to avoid disruptions during peak holiday travel. This surge in updates may have overwhelmed older systems, leading to cascading failures that are now being widely reported.
Critical infrastructure, like air traffic control, still relies on 50-year-old systems that were never designed for digital automation. These outdated systems are vulnerable to errors and cannot keep up with modern demands, especially when under constant patching pressure.
Yes, there are signs of political influence, such as the controversial use of terms like 'Si' instead of technical terms, and the push for high-profile tech programs like DOGE without clear follow-through. This suggests a disconnect between political promises and actual technical implementation.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.