Go back

Jon Ronson discusses culture wars, the ‘superbug’ of shamelessness, and his encounters with ‘unravelling men’

1h 11m 27s

Jon Ronson discusses culture wars, the ‘superbug’ of shamelessness, and his encounters with ‘unravelling men’

John Ronson’s new book, *The Castle*, is a deeply personal and surreal exploration of modern masculinity, triggered by a real-life encounter at a bizarre gothic castle party. The story unfolds as a true-crime narrative where Ronson and his son are invited to a reality show called “101 Princesses,” hosted by a man who obsesses over control, gender roles, and performance. The experience reveals a broader cultural crisis—men navigating purposelessness, identity, and digital influence. Ronson draws connections to his own post-surgery existential struggles and to figures like Graham Linnahann, whose extreme online activism exemplifies how societal disinhibition can spiral into mental breakdowns. A central theme is the rise and fall of Greg Chisholm, a former factory worker who becomes a successful YouTube influencer through algorithm-driven content, only to descend into chaos when his videos—especially those featuring children dressed as babies—go viral and are copied grotesquely by bots and content farms. This illustrates how platforms like YouTube incentivize extreme, often harmful, content, leading to widespread trauma and social outrage. Ronson critiques the dominance of click-driven media, where outrage and absurdity replace depth, and argues that the most powerful stories emerge from moments of mystery, absurdity, and emotional resonance. The book reflects Ronson’s journalistic philosophy: immersive, unsentimental, and grounded in self-awareness, where personal vulnerability meets cultural critique. Ultimately, *The Castle* is not just a story about one man’s misstep—it’s a reflection on how masculinity, technology, and modern media are reshaping individual identity and social bonds.

Transcription

12798 Words, 68485 Characters

English
[Music] Hello there and welcome back to the Louis Thoreau podcast. [Music] You join me in our brand new studio for the start of a new era of the LTP. Yes, we're going to be releasing episodes weekly all through the year. So if you've ever thought, gosh, I love the Louis Thoreau podcast. I just wish there were more of them today's your lucky day. And for our first episode back, it only feels right that I'm joined by writer, broadcaster, friend, the man who once described me as his professional, conjoined twin, John Ronson. John spent his career seeking out remarkable stories from hanging out with the Ku Klux Klan to shadowing David Ike, his bestselling books include Them and Ventures with Extremists, the men who stare at goats later a film starring George Clooney, the psychopath test, and so you've been publicly shamed. I've read all of them. Like me, he's also conquered the medium of podcasting. His latest offering being things fell apart, a look into the origins of the culture wars, which I'm sure you're familiar with, and if not, then do check it out. Why am I speaking to John? Well, because he's fascinating, I love his books, his podcasts, his TV shows, and we've kind of been on parallel tracks through the years. We've even covered the same subjects at different times. And there's a few examples of that over the years of us sort of double dipping on subjects, which, you know, let's call it what it is, it can be awkward, which led to him calling me his professional conjoined twin. And I know it was kind of a joke, but he said that one of us had to die in order that the other should live. He meant no harm by it. We recorded this interview in September this year at Spotify HQ. John was in the midst of a gruelling publicity campaign for his brilliant new book, The Castle, which is out now. Well, we talk about this at the beginning of the chat. It's a look at masculinity. I have also made a program about masculinity, a film called Inside the Manusphere. And so once again, there's a little bit of overlap. And in fact, the main contributor to my film, Harrison Sullivan, also known as H.S. Tiki Tocky, is in John's book. A quick warning, this conversation contains strong language and adult themes, all that as well as much else besides coming up. This episode is brought to you by BT. The smart things in our houses do make life easier, but there is a security risk. That's why BT Broadband has built-in security features that work automatically in the background, helping keep you, your family, and your devices, safer from online scams and scammers. Whether it's your smart doorbell, keeping an eye on your home, or a baby monitor watching over your baby, built into BT's latest smart hub three, hub threat protect, helps stop the wrong people accessing your personal information through vulnerable devices. And when you're out and about, BT's cyber threat protect gives you an extra layer of digital protection on up to 15 devices, including when you're using unfamiliar Wi-Fi or browsing on the move. Search BT Broadband today. Advance threat protection only from the UK's best broadband. BT protecting brilliant things. Verify at BT.com/claims. Nice to see you, John. Welcome. How are you? Um, really good. How are you doing? I'm so tired. I couldn't believe I'm tired. Are you mid-tor? No one wants to hear that at the beginning of an interview. This is going to, I'm going to do this if you're so bad. We're going to wake you right up. You're promoting your new book. We're going to come on to that. You are, um, as if we've begun. Yeah, this is it. Oh, okay. This is, you know me. This is like, it's the bit in the edges. One Michael Moore taught me. If he, if he taught me one thing, he taught me more than one. It was like, film before you think you've begun. Right. When you arrive, you're rolling. You go up and then the person comes to the door. The clan member in his underpants. He's like, what are you doing? I thought we're starting at nine o'clock. Like, yeah, well, we got here fast and then we expected. Sorry. Yes. No, you're right. And you have a golden moment. Yeah, yeah. You were right. Both rights want to interview. Colonel, both rights. You've interviewed. I've interviewed both. Well, let me tell you a story before you tell me this story. Mine's very quick. Okay. He came to the drawers in. You've come on the wrong day. I was like, and I got shaken. And I was like, oh, sorry. Anyway, it was a little moment. Well, I've never told you this story. But it's like the late '90s. I'm driving to interview a friend of both rights. It's called Jack McGlam. We should set up both rights for the general audience. Thank you, Millie. He was characterized as a militial leader. The real-life Rambo. He was special forces. Bluff, kind of, was he a general or a Colonel? Yeah, Colonel Bo Gray. Sounds right. And him and Jack McGlam were very early, until New World Order conspiracy theorists. Mid-90s militia guys. Yeah. So I was making a documentary about Ruby Ridge, about Randy Weaver and this family of white separatists who got into trouble with the ATF and it escalated and escalated and two members of the family were killed and as terrible story. But anyway, as part of that, I wanted to see Jack McGlam and he was right in the middle of nowhere. Like, it couldn't have been further from civilization. We drove like nine hours from Idaho to Montana or vice versa. And at one point, we saw a sign that said winding roads next 76 miles. So that's how remote we were. And we finally got to this tiny little white separatist enclave. And I pulled up and I wound down the window and I said, "Hi, I'm here to see Jack McGlam." And the guy said, "Oh, you're a Brit. We had another Brit here last week, Louis Thru." Really? Yeah. Because this was right at the heart of when there was so much competition between us. I prefer to think of it as overlap. Overlap, you know what I mean? An overlap that we've kind of kept alive. Really, until this very moment and probably on into the future because the new book, I feel like a real broadcaster because I'm doing a segway. The new book is called The Castle. And it's emphatically not about the menace fear. Nevertheless, this emphatically is in it and it's dealing with what you call the crisis of masculinity. I find that, I don't like that. You don't like that term either. The subtitle is Adventures in a World of Unraveling Men. Yeah, the reason I don't like that title is because this is like a very strange, weird, unfolding narrative which goes into places that you'd never anticipate. And that's twists and turns and, you know, revelations. And when you say words like crisis of masculinity, people immediately think boring, plemical, book, and that's the only reason why I. It's more like a true crime investigation threaded with these other bizarre encounters. Often examples of the internet distorting people's behaviour. Yes. Patrick Raddenke for Friend of the Pod called it fantastic and intensely of the moment. Marina Hyde, she works down the corridor. She's part of the Rest is Entertainment. Oh, is that down there? Rival podcast, it isn't a rival. Their numbers are off the chain. It's disgusting. She does a podcast. Have you ever listened to it? Yeah, yeah. It's with, um. Richard Osman. Exactly right. He can sign 15,000 books in the amount of time. It takes me to sign 5,000 I've discovered. But that's because. That's because that's a humble break. Because you're like, I can't sign as many. But we learned that you sign 5,000. I think I did 6,000 once. Okay, so there you go. It's a terrible. Someone should expose that scam, right? Yeah. Because a signed book is a. Sold book. That's an expression they use in retail. Signed book is a sold book. They can't send it back. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Anyway, as I said, the reason why Richard Osman can sign 15,000 books is because his signature is. That. Where's mine is? Yeah. That. So. After 4,000, your signature probably changes. Yes, more like that. It's more like that. Marina Hyde said, "Nobody tells an unbelievable but true story like John Ronson. He's done it again with the castle." Louis Theroux, that fucking guy, said ridiculously compelling and wonderfully weird. Brilliantly phrased. "The castle is vintage, Ronson. Why is timely and extremely funny?" So let's talk about how you came to write the castle. Okay, so I'm asleep. This is a story that crashed unannounced into my life while I was asleep. So I wake up and there's a series of texts from Joel, my son. So I read the last text first and it said, "We left. That was completely fucked. We're okay now." So I read the other texts and it turned out that he and three friends had been invited to a party being held by a stranger that one of them had met a few days earlier on Tinder. So they piled into the car, four of them, drove into the forests of Connecticut to this man's house. And when they arrived, this man's house was a giant newly built, extremely ostentatious gothic castle. I've googled it. Sometimes in America, there's buildings that are castles shaped. This is really a castle. - Yeah. What did you think when you saw the-- - It was way more impressive than I expected. - Yeah, it's got way too many turrets. It fell at the castle, a bit being designed by a man whose brain is like going in all different directions 'cause the castle seems to go in all different directions. - Yes. - And it's not like out in a remote area particularly. - No, it's on a road of otherwise ordinary modest homes. It's like ordinary modest home, ordinary modest home. - Well, weird fucking castle, ordinary home. - Like ruined, despicable me. - Yeah, like a great, garish Disney castle but indistently stranger. So the cross the drawbridge over the moat, passing various relics of war. There's lots of war relics all over the place. And they enter the grand banqueting hall to discover that there's no party. There's just a small number of equally bewildered young people standing around. So nobody knows why they're there. And then the castle owner comes out and he said, "Sorry, where's the party?" And he said, "Oh, no. I'm invited you here for a different reason. I would like you all to take part in my reality show." So Joel said, "What's the name of your reality show?" He said, "101 princesses." Joel said, "What's the core concept?" And he said, "I'm the king. I'm looking for my queen and I have 101 princesses to choose from. Then he said to the women in Joel's party, go downstairs to my basement costume room, put on some princess costumes and come back upstairs for filming." - Is he invited them to a party or is this a characterised as a first date or.? - No, a party. I've seen the text. - Really? - It says castle party. - He wants women. So Joel, does he know Joel's coming or is Joel there as a shaperone? - Joel's a plus one. - He's disappointed to see Joel. - Yes, he only wanted women there. So Joel and Joel's male friends cement were unwanted. - His name's cement? - Yes. - Like the building material? - Yeah, I think it's wrong to focus too much on the fact that he's called cement because there's so much other weirdness in the story. But I think he's a goth. - Right. - In fact, the castle owner had to hastily improvise because there were some unwanted men there. So he apparently got Joel and cement just up in tuxedos for the filming and they hastily devised a skit in which the women would reject Joel and cement in favor of Chris the castle owner. So Joel and cement put on tuxedos. The two women put on Princess costumes. They come back upstairs. A videographer called Nicholas appears and filming begins, but it becomes very clear that this isn't a real reality show. Not least because the videographer had this other job, which was to cut up meat for the castle owner. He had a huge slab of meat that he was, and only the castle owner was allowed to eat the meat. Then he kicked, he's getting more and more annoyed with Joel and his friends for refusing to participate in 101 princesses. He was taking this very seriously and he was very annoyed that they weren't. So he kicked them out and at the end of their story, but a couple of days later they came to my house and told me the story. And I'm sure you would have done the same thing. I went to the castle. - Yeah, obviously Hugh Heffner would be the other comparison. - Well, that was the one that I thought of. I thought, okay, this man, because down in his basement next to his costume room, he has an underground hot tub botanical gardens and also like a pole dancing room with cages. So I thought, okay, this guy's trying to be Hugh Heffner about surely the worst moments in human history to be Hugh Heffner. Unless you're H. S. Tickey-Tockey or one of your guys, you can't lauder over your princesses in your castle like it's the 1970s anymore. So I guess that was my starting point. This was a man out of time. I, as it happened, had just come out of hospital and I was feeling a little bit like a man out of time, all my purpose draining away as I'm supposed to be lying there conversing. - You took quite serious surgery. - Yeah. - Onal surgery. - Colon surgery for diverticulitis. - So you presumably the diverticulum or diverticulitis is a part of your colon? - Colon, yeah. And it gets infected, then you have flare ups and it's agony and you have a fewer than that. But in America, the American healthcare system is like so bad, but one good thing that comes to my, if you've got insurance is that you can do like elective surgery. - It's amazingly bad and amazingly good. - Yeah, right? - That's the weirdness of it. - Yeah, that's exactly it. So they cut out my foot of colon and I'm fine. - How did that kind of prime the pump for you to go on this investigation? - Well, I'd noticed I'd been like convolessing by sitting on benches, trying to think of story ideas, 'cause that's the only way I can get self-esteem is if I'm working on a story. And I wasn't coming up with anything and I would be overwhelmed by these like terrible sort of existential thoughts. Like I've just a man sitting on a bench. And I thought there was like a weird parallel between me and the castel owner. We were both rattling around looking for purpose in our lives. At a time when I think a lot of people are also feeling under purposeful and a lot of people, all of their self-esteem is wrapped up in their work. And A.I.s come along to rob us of our jobs and to try and convince us that we want a world without work and all the old structures and the collapse in it kept people sane. And so I thought there's a weird resonance between me and this castel owner who both should never have known of each other's existence, but now I'm driving towards his castle. Every time my car hits a bump, it kind of tears at my surgery scar. 'Cause I'd only been out surgery like 10 days or something. And I'd like to let out this, ah, I like something 'cause I don't like quasi-bode at Notre Dame or something. How old are you? I am 59. How old are you? - 56. - 56. Just turned 56. Feels quite old, doesn't it being in the upper 50s? I mean, that sort of, I'm sure that inflects or colors one's worldview a bit as well. - Yeah, and I think I wanted that. - It's a time of life when you maybe feels slightly unraveled. - Yeah, and all of that was playing into me wanting to write this book. I think that like all of my books in a way, even when I'm barely in them are like little memoirs, like them, I'm having an adventure and I'm like a young guy, then-- - There is your brilliant, it was your first real shift over or whatever, where you went on an exploration of conspiracy theorists to try and find the smoky room where all the decisions are made. Illuminati, lizards, whoever they may be. - And it culminates and be sneaking into the secret club called Beeming Girl with Alex Jones. - With Alex Jones, not the one show presenter, but the American conspiracy theorist. - Yes. - And to pick up on that, like, you're a willingness to own the part of you that resonates with the weirdness that you explore. There's always been part of what distinguishes your work. You like to go native a bit. - Yeah, I mean, I always think that, you know, you have that yearning to do it too, right? - I do. - Would feel dishonest not to acknowledge that. - No, the worst type of person who does the kind of things that we do are the ones who see themselves as a representative of a hierarchy. Like, I'm going in, I'm perfect. These people are crazy. You have to, like, if you're going to be scrutinising other people's weirdness and absurdities, you have to be willing to do it to yourself. And I've noticed that is happening more and more in your work too. - I appreciate that. I think it's always been slightly the case. And I think perhaps maturing as a journalist is allowing yourself to be okay with, what is it, being okay with exposing the bad parts? - Your own weaknesses, maybe that's a good thing about, maybe that's a good thing about getting a bit older. Somebody said, I can't remember what it was, maybe it was like someone who was balding, maybe someone from like, blah. If anyone from, as somebody said this anyway, that they were losing their hair at the exact same time that they were getting to an age when they didn't care that they were losing their hair. - Right. - Yeah. So maybe when you get a bit older, some of those old vanities and the things get the self-protections kind of go away a bit and you can loosen up and be more open about your weaknesses and felties. Plus, because of things like the mental health, self-advocacy movements and so on, people are like a lot more open and willing to talk about their frailties. So I think ultimately it's like a very positive thing about the way the world is turning. - Continuing on from the idea of self-exposure, you also interrogate and explore intimate relationships, let's be specific that you've had. This is a chapter and this has had a bit of pick up about Graham Linnahann, the writer of Father Ted Black Books, brought some out, I T. Crow, many others. It's a brilliant, brilliant comedy writer. How do we get into this, do you think? I'll be basically, he became very focused on the issue of trans people. - Yeah. - To the point it took over his life. - Yeah. Okay, so I should explain. So the castle half the book is me and the castle owner getting into an increasingly art relationship where he says he has two murderers on his payroll called Carlos Brandon, who are gonna find me if I ever had anything negative about the castle and they've only just come out of prison for killing somebody and I don't wanna make them angry. So all of this weird stuff's going on, but I use him to bounce off to other personal stories. - About Unraveling Men. - Yeah, I'm one of them is, Graham. Because I really want to try about, I think, honestly, I think Graham kind of epitomised two things that I noticed in the culture that I thought were very important to think about. One was disinhibition. The idea that if you start to think that society doesn't have a stake in you, which Graham clearly started to feel, then he will respond in kind and he would, the analogy I used in the book is that it's like he's kind of ripped off his face and just allowed his ear to run wild where anything goes, he can say anything, like any social niceties, just don't matter anymore. And I noticed a lot of people doing that, but Graham was doing it a lot. So one night I was in Edinburgh on a tour and somebody, I was falling asleep on Twitter, somebody said to Graham, why is John Watson still following you and then I fell asleep and then when I woke up the next morning, why is he still following you, what, given what? Given the fact that you've, you know, become this a single issue person. I think John shouldn't be following you because you're toxic and yes, follow please, which isn't that much of a thing anymore, but it was for a while. So one night in 2019, after Graham had been doing this for a couple of years, somebody tweeted that and then I fell asleep and I woke up the next morning and I saw that Graham had replied, the reason John Watson still follows me is because he thinks you're all assholes, meaning his critics. So he'd recruited you to his cause without, as I've ever conversation about it. So my, the one mistake I think that I made in this situation, when I look back on it and it's just like the one thing I did wrong, I messaged back, not, not like an open public, but I've replied. I was visible to people who've followed both of you. Yeah, I don't think that your critics are assholes and I think you've been acting like a bully. And then his, you know, 30 seconds passed, look, but when you, like, when you stop your toe, and it's like a moment before the paid starts, there's like a moment. I then Graham replied, how dare you? And then eight years later, it's, it's just been nonstop. You regret saying it publicly and I said that to him and he said, well, it wouldn't have made a difference. I'd have been just as annoyed if he'd said it privately. So I guess it wasn't that big a mistake. It's fair. It should be acknowledged like Graham, as a result of what he'd call it, that his activism, his advocacy kind of exploded his life. He probably would say he had some sort of a mental health emergency. He, he, he writes in his own memoir about how he would be upstairs, fight him with someone on the internet and then he would hear his wife and children laughing downstairs. And in the old days, he'd have gone downstairs to join them, but he couldn't bear to, to stop the fight. So he would stay upstairs and continue to fight. And that felt like such a kind of modern sickness that any one of us could succumb to, but we pull ourselves back, but he didn't. So this was all the reasons why I wanted to, I was just genuinely very interested in what had happened to our old friend Graham. And, and then for eight years, like, it would be, you know, there were days when he would go, you know, these insults that be publicly like 50 times in a day. Yes. But my, my interest was his, his behavior was the was, you know, the way, the way he expressed himself, what had happened to him in his, in his life. Those were the things I was interested in. He's clapped back in a telegraph article. Did you read it? I did not. Why not? Because I'm on tour and I'm trying to manage my stress levels. Right. It's stressful. I mean, in fact, you talk about it in the book, how stressful it was. Every time you started to write it, you had to stop because it was making use of it. Because all levels were spiking. But then I thought, well, the only reason, like, I wanted to write about disinhibition in the castle. It felt very like the, like, the right place for the book to go to. And I thought, well, who am I going to write about? And I thought I could write about manosphere, type man in this way. But I don't know. You know, Louise done his documentary. I can't beat that. Stop it. You hadn't seen that. He just threw that into butter me up. I saw you coming. So, so I thought, well, Graham, you know, Graham is the right person for me to write about, particularly because I'm so much, he's made me so much part of this story because he's like constantly, constantly posting about me. And I thought the only thing that will stop me from writing about Graham in this context is fear. And when we're led by fear, what we and you do, then, then we lose integrity. I know you said you hadn't read. Should I quote you a couple of small bits? I won't if it's going to completely free too. Well, if it's fine. His, but he's got one main thing, right? John never once asks in all those pages whether I was right, dot, dot, dot, our men women, our women men should men be in women's prisons or their sports should children be castrated in gender clinics. There's two things with, with Graham, it feels to me that they've been elided. One is his beliefs, which I think actually, if you sort of put your finger in the wind, a lot of people might share, right? Certainly, if you look online, they don't feel massively out of the mainstream, whether you believe them or not. But the other is his behavior and the obsessiveness of it. Do you want to take up Graham's invitation? I guess it's the question. Well, Graham, well, so there isn't one I wanted to add about Graham is because I think Graham, because of his behavior, it's a totally different, you know, sort of strata. So I did an interview with him, which I've used in the book. And then about a year later, I tried to do another interview with him for things fellow part. And that's when we had this conversation. I think you're going to put your BBC on our series. Yeah, because he was kind of the reason why I wanted to make the whole service because I was trying to understand why people were losing themselves so much in such a dramatic way. So he said to me, I'm not going to do this interview unless you say, you know, that two plus two equals four whatever his words were. And I said to him, Graham, I can't like, no, I'm not going to submit to your purity test before you agree whether or not to do an interview with me. No journalists would do that. And I said to him, if you want to ruin a journalist's life, make them do a purity test, and then once they've done it, tell everybody, because they're not completely undermines. We do. I mean, obviously you should say in public whatever you want to say, but I think me, you, there's a few of us out there in America, John Wilson and Nathan Fildos about to bring out what looks like a brilliant documentary about Elizabeth Holmes. And we do something different to what Pundits do. We lose ourselves in a story, we dive in, we spend forever thinking about the nuances of it and the characters and what it means and the twists and the turds and the hypocrisies, you know, and then we emerge with a really hopefully good, interesting, long form piece of narrative nonfiction. That is the opposite of being a Pundit of just like blurring out. And I think if I'm a Pundit, like if I splurge out opinions, hey, I'm shitter it. And so why do something that you know, good, that's like asking me to be a, you know, headdress or something. And B, I think it undermines what we do. And my whole point, you know, and things fell apart. What people like about my work is that I'm not part of a tribe. And I think it's totally fine. There's not many of us that have that attitude. But I think you should, those of us who do have that attitude, you should just let us do what we do well. And don't force it to do something that we do badly. You know, the way I try and work is that I'll go out into whatever adventure I'm having with no preconceptions, just trying to be like a sort of feather in the wind of the story. And not, you know, forget about my values, forget about it all. And then get all the information, have the adventures, go where the story takes maybe a twig in the river of the story, and then come back. And when you're back at home, that's when you start to make sense of it. And that's when your values come back in. And that's when you realize, you know, what your morality is. And that's how it works. I'm not going to blare about anything that I haven't spent months doing my own kind of story on. I love that you mentioned Nathan Fielder. He was on my mind a bit partly because of this Elizabeth Holmes documentary that he's just launched, which sounds amazing. Yeah. Are you a fan? Oh, yeah. Yeah. I was watching him last night. Which one? Finding Francis. That might be his best piece of work. I've got 15 minutes to go. I fell asleep. So you must have been very tired. I was very no reflection on the quality. No, no, I was loving it. But I thought I'm falling asleep here. I'm not going to try and watch the last 15 minutes. So don't tell me if he founds her. How would you characterize what Nathan Fielder is doing? He's he kind of does what we do, but he brings like other things into it. He brings the kind of Verde Herzog sort of artistry to it, and also a kind of prankiness, but it's a weird prankiness. It's a little bit like Christmas, but it's sort of slightly more suspicious, very real. They're like pranks that don't really have a point or the point is not immediately apparent. He goes into these hates being called a prankster. We should probably retract all of that. I had John Wilson on. He's like, oh, don't call Nathan a prankster. He does not like that. And I think that's reasonable because parts of it are more about almost art, some sort of avant-garde performance piece, right? Yeah. Yeah. You know, Nathan's probably He's still best known for. or Nathan for you. - Yeah. - Which reminded me a tiny bit of, wait for it, the Ronson mission. - Oh, which you'll remember because you made it in 1993, your first TV outing. - Yeah. - Why'd you say it like that? - Well, I'll tell you exactly why I said it like this. I was, you were one of the few people who liked it. - I believe. - I find that hard to believe. - Do you know what, it's hard to find it. I'd say like, listeners and viewers can check it out. - I don't think they can check it out. - No, it's been scrubbed from YouTube. - Yeah. - Why? - Oh, I've paid a four-known critic. I don't know, I've certainly never tried to get it on YouTube. Yeah. (laughing) It was kind of a prank, so. - Prank show does it a disservice? - Yeah. Although some of my favorite moments were pranky moments. Actually, I did something that Nathan failed to then later did and now I'm thinking about it. I wonder whether he was so. - Well, which bit? - Well, we should say, you'd come up through unconventional, am I right that you didn't go to university? - No, I did two years and then flunked out. - And then you got a job, I guess columnist is a time out, meet basically doing humorous columns. - Yeah, I was very, I liked 23, 24. - Did you know you were a good writer? - Well, when I was at college, my teacher was David Cardiff, who was married to Lynn Barber, who was like the greatest journalist of the age. - Certainly she was the definitive profile journalist. - Yeah, quite scabrous and elegant. Even Barber, she could get spend laugh to do with someone and she had no compunction about skewering them. In a way that at times certainly could feel to the subjects, I'm sure quite cruel. - The moment I remember, and I'm not even sure, it's just the moment I remember, I can't say it's like her best moment, but I remember she asked Jerry Adams if he had a favorite funeral. Yeah, so that's kind of the place that she went to. But we were so impressed with her. She was like Dorothy Parker, you know, so elegant and scabrous and her husband was a writing or in her person. - Just the whole, the whole package. - Did you meet her? - A couple of times 'cause her husband was my teacher and I've met her subsequently. And he took me for coffee and he said, you're the only person who writes for the college newspaper who knows how to write. - Really? - And I think I've always thought that's the moment that cemented my life. - Interesting. - Yeah. (upbeat music) - This episode is brought to you by Boots. We're in the era of optimization. We're being encouraged to max everything in our lives for health reasons and it can feel overwhelming. I'm not impervious to it. I feel like I should take massive steps in order to overhaul my health and then I get paralyzed. My advice is don't make the perfect the enemy of the good. And that's a simple truth that Boots really understands that taking little steps can generate huge results. For example, there's autumn rolls around. You might start to feel those busier schedules and shorter days are catching up with you. But doing something as simple as taking a proactive approach to your health and well-being can help. Boots can help you take those first steps, bringing together pharmacist expertise, health care services, trusted advice, and everyday well-being support in one place, helping with everything from seasonal health concerns to everyday health questions. So go on, give it some Boots. Visit BootsInstore or online at Boots.com to discover how you can stay well and feel more like yourself, this autumn. (upbeat music) (upbeat music) You're writing, I mean, I think what's perhaps under-ignolaged about your writing is the technical aspect. Like, obviously you get into great stories, but really the clarity of your prose and your ability to unfold a yarn or unfurl a yarn is really striking. And I know that's developed over time as you learn more to do it. I'm wondering, did you have models that you were following early on? - Yeah, all the people I like the most back then were people who could put a whole load of ideas into a very small number of simple words. So Kurt Vonnegut, slaughterhouse five. - It's a terrific book and wonderfully simply written. - Yeah, he'd worked in advertising. So it's said that writing advertising copy had partly honed his craft. - That really makes sense. - For people who don't know slaughterhouse five, it's about a young soldier who survives the fire bombing of Dresden and the Marine Corps. And is then kidnapped by space aliens and taken to a planet called Traufabadori. I'd displayed at a zoo with a porn star called Montana Wildhack. And the aliens teach him how to go back and forward in time. So he can be at any point in his life at any moment. - And I'd say it's all, 'cause that makes it sound bit Douglas Adams, he maybe it is, but it's really about, as well, about Kurt Vonnegut processing the trauma of having been involved in this atrocity. Because he was a veteran himself and he'd gone through all of that. - Yes, and I don't think Billy Pilgrim the character was ever one of the questions in the book that's left unsaid is he fantasizing being on this planet and did it really happen. And obviously I think it's kind of form of PTSD. - Yeah. - So, yeah, I was really inspired by that. Raymond Carver for a similar reason, like very simple sentences, but with a hell of a lot going on under the neithosurface. - Short stories. Had you read those, in Cardiff, like growing up? 'Cause he kind of came to fame, late in life, having been a poet, serious alcohol issues. And then fell in with, is it Gordon Lish? - Yes. - Is editor and then together, they created this lapidary pro-style that involved leaving everything out. - Yes, everything. - As just, as did Vanaka, I think he leaves the love out. - He leaves the love out. - He was described. - Yeah. You know, this is one of the main reasons why I wanted to write, so even publicly shamed by public shaming book. Because I noticed like with, so the main character in that book was this woman just in sacco. And she tweeted an ill-advised tweet. She was like the patient zero of public shaming, nothing like this had ever happened before. And she's on her way to Cape Town. And she tweets, "Go into Africa. Hope I don't get AIDS. Just kidding, I'm white." And, got on the plane, fell asleep, woke up 12 hours later, turned on her phone and her phone just like exploded. The first text is somebody saying, "I'm so sorry to see what's. " Somebody said I'm spoken to since high school, saying, "I'm so sorry to see what's happening to you right now." That was the first thing that she saw. When I first saw that tweet, overwhelmed my timeline, my first thought was, "Oh, somebody's fucked." And I kind of put the pillow behind my head and I watched. But then it didn't take me more than a couple of seconds to think, you know, this is a bad version of this literary tradition that I really like. She's leaving it all unsaid. She's leaving unsaid her own privilege. It's like a kind of a little bit like Randy Newman. - We call it irony, don't we? - Yeah. - Just the one word version. And what I noticed after that was that people were so scared that that would happen to them, that everybody was over-explaning everything. And that's my least favorite type of writing. I want there to be a hell of a lot unsaid. I want the writing to be a kind of pact between the writer and the reader, where the writer leaves things unsaid because they trust the reader and knows what's going on and can fill in the gaps and so on. Like, which is what I learned from Carver and from Fanagert. And, yeah, that's what I was trying to do. - There's a danger with irony is that you get taken at face value, which is literally. - Which is exactly what happened to her while she was asleep and oblivious. So, yeah, I was doing all of that stuff. And so, for some reason, I got offered the column in time out and I did it for a few years. And then I got a call from the BBC from Deaf too, which was youth television. - I think your column must have developed quite the following, right? - Yeah, I think it did well. I remember one columnist of the year. Oh, my God! - It was to the year. - I won't columnist of the year. I was 25. And I'm celebrating my win. I'm standing in this crowded ballroom like at one of those big hotels on Park Lane. And someone came up to me and whispered in my ear, how does it feel to have peaked at 25? And then just vanished again into the crowd. I know, no idea who that person was. Well, it couldn't have been further from the truth. - Yeah, well, Janice Street Porter then offered me like my own series on Deaf too. It was just before the little cameras had come along. The little PD 150s. - Yeah, and so I had to drive around in a massive truck with a big camera and boom. And, you know, at the very beginning of your career, did you have to do that too? - Yes. I think it's good to acknowledge the technological substrate in this and many contexts. The fact that certain products are pieces of culture look the way they do because what they were printed on a printing press or a manuscript. In this case, it's like we had huge cameras. You needed a dedicated camera person, sound recordist, which isn't always the case. And certainly at that time in the '90s, you had tapes that lasted about half an hour. Every half hour. Someone would be in the middle of a kind of racist rent. Let's see your coverage. the Ku Klux Klan, you think like this, we're getting it. This is sort of what we needed for the segment to work. And then you'd hear, I got two minutes, you know, like basically their tape was about to run out, and then you had to change it. And then we'd kind of mess up the flow. And for some reason, at the age of 25, I'm giving my own TV show on the BBC, it's like a dream. And I hated it. And I remember the director said to somebody, I just can't do anything to make John happy. And it's so weird looking back on it now, because what a what a break I was gift. I was excited when they proposed it. I think I was nervous the whole time. Because I've said before, when I was offered my series, this is, we've got four episodes, it's called Weird Weekends. I was like, I don't like, it's called Louis Through's Weird Weekends. I said, please start, it's not called it Louis Through it. No one knows who I am. That's ridiculous. It feels overweaning. And also why are we doing four? Like, couldn't we just do one? And also why are they 50 minutes? This seems too long. So I can relate to the sense of, I don't have that level of confidence that any of us have a clue how to do this. I don't think I do. Like, this is folly. Yeah. Well, yeah. And especially in that form, like, you turn up at somebody's house with all of these people and you're setting up and I'm asking questions, I'm not directing it. So I'm not making the choices about the storytelling. And I just this is not what I'm doing. Yeah. Yeah. I'm a writer and suddenly I'm an actor and I'm not an actor. I can't be in front of the camera. Had you pitched it to them? Did they say, would you be interested in doing something and then you came up with ideas? No, it's just really weird. So I had a teacher at college called Frank Hadley. And without telling me, he approached, when he saw my time out column, he approached the BBC and said this could be a TV show. So then Janice Street Porter calls me in and I'm sitting there at Janice Street Porter goes, I think it's a brilliant idea. And I'm sitting there thinking, I have no idea what the idea is. I don't know why I'm here. I feel out about depth. I feel like events are moving fast. And I don't really know. So the whole so right from the beginning, I felt uncomfortable. Like, you know, what I wanted to say is like, can we all just like stop and think about this? So the whole making of the series, I was, I was miserable. I felt like it wasn't right. And it was only later on when they bought out this tiny little cameras and I got to be the director. So I got to make the storytelling decisions. And that's why I started directing myself. We were, we were in a long dog leg, a very enjoyable one. Part of it was Nathan Fielder and to what extent the Ronson mission foreshadowed it. Did you say you thought there was some idea that overlapped it? Yeah. So I did a couple of, so one of the things I did was this celebrity charity pop video called, and this was a prank. I wrote this song called Let's Stamp Out Crime by any means necessary. And this was right at the time when all the slippet like, you know, the we are the worlds coming out. And we got all of these celebrities to say this viciously right wig. There's a lot of bad people about, yeah, let's clean up the grime by any means necessary. So that was one. Who, which celebs did you have involved? Like people for Brooks side, Nicholas Parsons. I do remember Nicholas Parsons coming up to me and saying quietly to me, he's, he's dead now. I can say this right? He said, he said, I'm so glad that, you know, you're saying what everybody's thinking. Really? Yeah. And the people for Brooks side. Shocked. The beloved translation for the younger, for the younger people. He wasn't with. He was part of a comedy double act. Then in the 70s and 80s presented sale of the century, the quiz show. And then now for many years was mainly known as the, as the presenter of just a minute join us. That's right. I feel a minute. I'm now feeling some guilt that I mentioned that he probably was just trying to put you at ease. So, yeah. So that was where I remember the Brooks side people. I heard later on that this had if we have a seat on rocks and again, we're going to beat the shit out of him. After it came out, they realized they'd been pranked. Yeah. Did you have issues with doing pranks? I always found it very stressful and the bad faith involved. I did mind. Yeah. Well, I was, I mean, when I was in my mid 20s and when my ethical framework hadn't been completely. Did Nathan do a version of that for one of his episodes? No, this other thing that I'm about to tell you. Okay. So I interviewed Janet Ellis. This one I remember. Yeah. The presenter of Blue Peter. Yeah. And I had Janet Ellis's biggest fan in a bus outside feeding me the questions. He was a super fan to the point where he might have been possibly neurodivergent, I would argue. Yeah. And I think Nathan field, he had a very similar scene where he's get, he's interviewed somebody and it's like a seven year old kid is asking the questions in his earpiece. So who knows? Can I bring us back to the present tense? We should talk about the chapter on Greg Chisholm. Yes. It's been singled out by a lot of reviewers and in interviews because it's a distillation of something, right? I think something to do with the algorithm, YouTube. Yeah. How would you explain? Yeah. Okay. So as I said, much of the castle is my unfolding relationship with the castle owner, but I wanted to look at how, when the old, you know, all the old structures are collapsing, people are losing their jobs, people are no longer working in institutions. And instead, YouTube's come along to say, come, come to us. We're the wide open country wherever somebody could thrive through gritted perseverance is an influencer. So people are being encouraged in a sort of post-institution world to become into personal brands, institutions of one. And I really wanted to cover that. And it's a really truly incredible story. Greg came from a dying rust belt town. He should have worked at the factory, but the factories closed. He has multiple open heart surgeries and owes the medical insurance companies $200,000 at the age of 18 in a dying rust belt town. Then he gets married, has two kids and his wife leaves him a single father. So he has two daughters under the age of two. So this is a man at rock bottom with no prospects. But he sees a YouTube video made by an Australian fruterian cyclist called Durian Rider. He's cycling through Australia. And he's like, I used to be in prison. I've lived on the streets, but look at me now. I'm making a YouTube video. You could make a YouTube video. Watch your story. You've got a story. Greg, it was Greg's Damascus moment. So we start making YouTube videos. The early days. Now that's like a normal, I mean, everyone's done that. Your kids say like, I want to be a YouTube is probably the most popular job for young people. Well, this is a while ago. But this is also why this is such a relevant story, I think. 39% of Americans now identify as content creators. 20% of boys and 13% of girls say that being a content creator is the only choice of career for them. So it's very important, I think, to look at what happens when somebody gives themselves over to the algorithms, which is what Greg did. So Greg becomes a lawn care influencer and does very well. He makes his hour long lawn care ASMR type videos where people just watch a mowing lawn. And they think, and Greg don't miss that patch. And then he hits it. Is it also for people who want great lawns and they think, you know, he has tips on how to get the best out of your green sward? Yeah, he does a lot of that. He would also do good smile some lawn work where he drive along, find a lawn in need, leap out of his truck, mow the lawn, film himself doing it. I let jump back into truck, vanish into the night like the sorrow of lawn care chores. And he was getting 100,000 views awake. He suddenly was properly. He was making money. Yeah. I mean, at that stage, not making that much money, but yeah, maybe a few hundred dollars a week or something. And then something happens. He has this other channel. It's just called Greg Chism. And it's just a place for him to store his home videos with his daughters. Nobody was watching like a couple of hundred subscribers. So one day he buys, so I think a sister buys the kids a Barbie cruise ship for Christmas. And they're playing in the box. They're running around with the box on their head. So he films it and puts it on the Greg Chism channel. And for some bizarre fluke, it catches fire. And it has a million views. And then it has 10 million views. And then it has 20 million views. And YouTube phone them. And that we can teach you how to replicate this success. And so he goes on a YouTube course where they say follow the algorithm, follow what's popular. Get into search engine optimization. You need a WTF moment. What's the WTF moment? So Greg is just blindly thrilled at this change in his life and does everything that YouTube tell him to do and starts making these more and more. He doesn't realise our extreme videos with his daughters. He's doing this in a disturbing outlandish. Just to the old dressed as babies. That's crazy about each other. Yeah. He's just like, well, sure, some of it's gross. But that's the stuff that people are encouraging us to do. Like the gross of the better. So he's just following. Do you remember that novel, The Dice Man? Yes. Luke Reinhardt. Yeah. I never read it. I read it. People loved it. Yeah. He rolls a dice to decide what he should do. Yeah. And I was Greg instead of rolling a dice. He was doing what the YouTube viewers and the algorithms and YouTube itself were telling him to do. It's like a dice but it's a loaded dice with a built in bias towards our darkest impulses. Yeah. Big tech is encouraging our darknesses and our strangenesses, our encouraging us to go further and further, and I got to say it's not just big tech anymore. The whole media, mainstream media, independent media, we're all following this now because everybody's desperate for clicks, everything. So the headlines are all rage bait and click bait. So this thing that was created I guess by big tech algorithms has swallowed up the entire media. You could say to us ever thus in the sense that headlines have always been slightly histrionic, you know, the weekly world news was a thing. Elvis spotted on the moon. Anything that would peak your interest. So what do you think the difference is now? No, and you're right. I've thought I've thought it like my whole career. I remember years ago I did a story about Amanda Palmer, the singer and the headline at Amanda Palmer, visionary or ego-tist. And I'm always trying to not do things like that. Exactly. And so yes, it's always been that way, but it feels like it's more now. It feels like people feel they have no choice. Everything has to be rage bait or click bait. Anyway, because of the low barrier of entry, you're not required to buy the weekly world news. It's on your phone for free. And one click leads to another and there's pop-ups and it's the level of interactivity and the always oneness. Yeah, everyone's panicking. And there's no bar to it could have, it could be extreme, it could be. There's no real pushback in terms of quality or content moderation. Yeah, yeah. And so Greg was following all of their getting into more more extreme places, making doing incredibly well. Greg's most watched video, which was called something like Victoria, Eradabell and Freak Daddy, Toy Freaks, Family Fun and Real Life food fight or something like that. Because it was like this word-salative search engine optimization. It had 622 million views. And in 2016 and 2017, his videos were watched a total of 13 billion times and everybody loved it until suddenly everybody didn't. You said at one point he was the biggest content creator on YouTube. Yeah. So Greg was following it into more extreme places until suddenly Buzzfeed and Reddit and everybody discovers him and sees a bad and his two daughters call a guy like babies in some random Midwestern house and alarm bells ring and his life is just ruined. Completely ruined people. People start calling the police and SWAT teams turn up and yes, take his kiss to family services and he becomes incredibly panicky and depressed. YouTube kick him out for the very videos that they were encouraging him to make. See, people see the content, it's deemed to be troubling, perhaps even abusive, although in fact turned out it isn't. So his life collapses. I mean, what part of the weirdest is one that it and then it metastasizes around the world in weird bastardized forms. Yeah, yeah, because it's being done by other people or bots. AI, AI is beating it out. This was before AI. So this was humans basically doing what AI is now doing. Humans making what we now call slop. Slop. Yeah. Human created slop. For instance, Greg would do a video where he would take his two daughters dressed as babies at a shopping cart through a Walmart in Granite City in Illinois. And the next day a man in Keith would do exactly the same thing. Ape at all, same dialogue, the same camera angles, the same music, and with two adult women playing the parts of his bad babies. So all over the world, Greg would put out a video and in Hanoi or Keeve or Moscow, people would ape it with an eerie precision. The algorithm started sending it all to all of these kids on YouTube kids. And that's why the scandal exploded because suddenly YouTube kids were watching these bizarre grotesque copycats of copycats of copycats. And suddenly people dressed as Elsa from from Frozen were acting dismemberments or cannibalism. And there were like cartoons of Peppa Pig eating her own father with that blood spurting everywhere. And it was big federal of these children on YouTube kids because the algorithm couldn't tell the difference between real Peppa Pig and grotesque Peppa Pig. And that's why the scandal exploded. James Bridal is one of the people who you mentioned who who discovered this early on in an article called something very what something is wrong on the internet? Something's wrong on the internet. And what I read I went back and read his original post and what I was struck by was how it's difficult for him to assign humans behind the problem. He's signed agency to humans behind it. Like he says what concerns me is not just the violence being done to children that just one aspect of a kind of infrastructural violence being done to all of us all the time. And we're struggling to find a way even to talk about it to describe its mechanisms actions and effects. Yeah it's a beautifully written pace. I struggle where the agency is actually so diffuse. Like I don't have trouble believing that many of the people maybe most of the people in the tech business are people like you and me. And the algorithm is to some extent out of their control like the technology is driving a lot of the decisions. Yeah well YouTube kids they made the active decision to to seed control to the machine. Like there was a moment when YouTube invented YouTube kids where like should we put humans or the algorithm in charge of the contents on YouTube kids. The people who wanted to let the machines do it said kids love trains but no human would think to put trains on YouTube kids. And then the the aunties would say yeah but if we put trains on YouTube kids and we allow the algorithm to decide then there's going to be train crashes because people have to watch train crashes. Google YouTube's parent company decided to let the algorithms do it and it was a terrible mistake. It went haywire with millions of kids being traumatised by these horrific images coming from these Russian content farms that were aping Greg's videos but making it more and more disgusting. How do you find your stories? I'm always struck especially not just in this one with things fell apart you've got a hotline to these great each one is like a little crystal of something strange in the culture. Yeah would you have spent you want to spill any of your secrets? Well I mean my main secret is it's hard like you can spend months going down dead ends. I think what are you scanning now? What do you read? What do you consume? I look everywhere. You're looking for I remember asking Christian Kubrick when I made my document she's standing Kubrick's box is what we see looking for and there's ever lengthening gaps. She said the magical moment of falling in love with the story so that's what I'm always looking for. And what is that magical moment? I suppose it's something that in itself is absurd and mysterious and funny and strange and all these like conflicting emotions. Particularly mysterious something I don't understand but it has to be something that also resonates also tells us something about the way that the world is turning. So it's a very specific combination and then because I'm access driven you can find the most incredible story in the world but if the person won't talk to you you have to dump it so that God Greg talked to me. Are you still on X a lot? No I'm not on X at all. At all? Why not? Well partly because apparently they'll ask a couple of weeks because of Graham's Eyre. There's been caught with a million tweets directed at me have been told. Really? Yeah so I don't want to but the things when you delete the app because of the siloed world we live in just just dissolves. It does but there is a real world out there as well. I was talking to my brother about this like what if you just turn off all the social media and be like yeah but then you'd be like why are there hundreds of men with Balaklava's running down the street? You know what I mean or why is this guy Tommy Robinson able to put a million people or whatever it is hundreds of thousands of people on the street the effects will still take place right? Well that's true. It's a real push and pull because I don't like this siloed world and I think it's weird actually that everybody's consuming very much their own bubble of media where I can be bombarded with a quarter of a million tweets on X of Graham's fans and I don't know if that number's true or not I just read it. Where did you read that? I read it on a site called Cookton Bond who is situously document Graham's online footprint. As fans or critics? As critics. You know I would interview people for say you've been publicly shamed where they would say I stayed up all night reading every tweet and believing every single one believing I was the terrible person that they said I was and after a while people had to for their own sanity rejects that and become unashamed. It's like the only way to survive if you overuse shame as a weapon like hospital super bugs being sanitized and sanitized and they become impervious to treatment the only thing they can do is to become unashamed. So our overuse of shame created a generation of unashamed transgressors which now I think has mutated to disinhibition which is what I'm writing about in you know so so this siloed world became was almost like a kind of defense mechanism for the fact that everybody getting to look into each other's worlds was a disaster because Justin Sackler would make a joke that millions and millions of people would be able to weigh in on but the siloed world it's great for my emotional well being on tour because it means I've done after. to read all of those things, but ultimately is it good if everybody's in their own bubble and that feels like it could be just as bad as the world that it's replacing? The telegraph gave you four stars, very positive and said almost heroically given this theory on narcissism thriving post-COVID, Ronson gets through the whole book without mentioning Donald Trump. Yeah. How do you react to that? I wanted to stay away from the touch points, I want to stay away from in cells. When you made the Manusphere documentary, I decided not to do the Manusphere and it made me, I'm about to better you up, Louis. Well, you're already on the piece of toast. Okay, so the fact that you made that Manusphere documentary so funny and so watchable, I don't think I could have done that and I think that's real testament to you. I want to stay away from all of those touch points because you think, okay, if I don't do the Manusphere, if I don't do in cells, if I don't do Trump, then what will I do? And that kind of forces you into more interesting and unexpected places. A couple of good reads reviews. This one's relevant to what we were saying before. In contrast to Louis through in the Manusphere, Ronson tells a much deeper and more vulnerable story. This is painful to read. Instead of quick, I don't know why they put these in my notes. My team, they, they're very cruel, instead of quick, gotcha interviews with publicity hungry influencers, he spends significant time with his subjects, trying to understand them and place them in a larger cultural context. What do you think about that? I mean, it's disgusting. I prefer the one where they gave you one star and said self-righteous, pretentious, and at its worst. I think Boolean conducted from a position of considerable commercial success and the backing of his liberal elite circles. Oh, that would be a grave limit on the honest, I could do the co-host of that. You didn't tell them. I think I thought that. Yeah. I think we're nearly there. What advice do you give? I'm sure, I mean, I know you have millions of admirers and what advice do you give to young people who say, like, oh, I want to do what you do? Well, find a story that you're passionate about, passionate and mystery as the wind behind your sails, fill your head with curiosity and not pre-judgment, so that's another reason why. Like, if you come up with something like, you want to be open, you want to be open to anything, you want to be a twig in the rhythm of the story, fill your head with curiosity instead of judgment, find a story that you really want to get the answer to, care as much about how you tell the story as what the story is, I think a lot of writers, a lot of nonfiction people have very low creative ambitions, they'll, they see themselves as like an information service. There's so many nonfiction books out there that say, in this book, I'm going to tell you this, in chapter one, I'm going to tell you this, you know, don't do that, be experimental. I think the castle is a really kind of experimental book, it goes a really interesting direction, it's a page turn, it's weird, it doesn't feel like a sort of formulaic book, so I think have those kinds of ambitions. You use some of the devices of fiction if you're writing in prose, like, I was struck in the Greg Chisholm chapter where you say, I'm going to leave Greg here at the height of his success, and now I'm going to take you down to this other part of the story. So you're always conscious of managing the revelations. Yes, it was Ian McEwan, I read a thing where he said, like, suspense is the withholding of information, which is really simple, but actually a great thing to recall, and there's always a temptation to say too much too early on. Yeah, you've really got to think about that stuff. I remember, one of the reasons why I gave up writing screenplays was because to be a good screenwriter, it doesn't matter how well written the screenplayers, you've got to put yourself in the seat of an audience member watching the movie, and I could never quite do that. But for some reason, with writing, I can't, with nonfiction, I can do it, so I'm constantly thinking, what point is the reader going to want there to be a cliffhanger? At what point will they appreciate me withholding some information? So you've got to put yourself in, you've got to think about the reader's experience as you're writing it. Now, as a cultural whisperer, someone who you've always been ahead of the curve, I feel, and sort of had a sense of nose for things that are bubbling off and online, but not always. Do you have a sense of where we're going next? It feels like there was this sort of, what they call the awokening, right? This moment of aspects of progressivism becoming mainstream, and then institutionalized incorporations that sort of 2010 through 2022, more or less, then swirling alongside, you have 2016, Trump and Brexit, and what they're calling the vibe shift, right? And obviously AI as well. Well, yeah. Do you know where it was happening? Well, the two things, I'm okay, so I do have a little prognosis. Go on. And it's not good. Every time I just have a positive prognosis for the future, it turns out to not be true, because things are only getting worse. So I think AI is a real problem. I mean, even if you put aside the possibility that it's going to wipe out humanity within 10 years, even if that doesn't happen, it's robbing us of our jobs. This book, The Castle, is a lot about purpose and how important work is to our lives. And the reason why I wanted to write that is because I think we're entering a world of, we have entered a world of increasing purposelessness, which is why a lot of people are going to YouTube and so on to try and find purpose. There, I heard an AI guru who, who's AI makes music, tried to convince people on a people don't enjoy making music. Right. And Sam Altman says, you know, we're creating a world, a post-work world. Yeah. And then. Musk is saying the same thing. Right. For abundance, there'll be leisure, there won't be, it doesn't really sound like that, but. And then it's so punished. I can't see why everybody doesn't feel the same feeling of rage that I do about all of this. We're not about abundance, per se, right? No, but about the trick that they're all, it's about the trick that we're playing on us. Musk is keeping us all furious down here with these culture wars, prodigate each other, with these culture wars, while he's getting richer and richer up there. The AI gurus, robbing us of our jobs, and then Chuck G.P.T. is coming along to offer this, like, these false flattery, this is a secret scene. Yeah, like in my castel owner is coming up with these different reality TV show ideas, like 101 princesses, and Chuck G.P.T. is telling him it's the most compelling entertainment project ever. Yeah. We've all had a bit of that. Yeah. So what happens is Chuck G.P.T. is robbing us of our jobs, robbing us of our purpose, and then swooping in, you know, sees how lost people are, and is swooping in by saying, come to me. You're not purposeless. You're creating the most compelling entertainment projects ever. It's like a double, it's like a double punch in the face. Yeah. So that's bad, and I think the response to that can only be fight, and I'm not a sort of crazy idea like about this. There's certain aspects of AI that are positive and helpful, of course, but the data centers, the slop, you know, fight it as much as possible, and I think people, I used to go on Instagram to watch videos of unlikely friendships between different species of animals. Can't do that anymore, because the giraffe and the hedgehoggy are not even real. So people are going to be moving away from the shit and moving into a more analogue real life, and that's already happening, and that's has to happen. People have to re-enter a community and realise that we're all just part of the community, we're all humans trying to get by, and we're being brainwashed by these like AI billionaires and so on into disease, kind of cultural battles, and we need to get out into the real world. So that's one thing I think is happening, and it's going to happen. But the other thing, I can't help thinking, there's something on the horizon, and I could be wrong in a year's time, people might think, well, John was wrong to think this, but this El Nino that's coming, I don't know, I wouldn't be surprised if in a year's time, all anyone's going to be talking about is the weather. This dark shit can be dialed the pike with the weather. This El Nino is forming now in the Pacific, and at unprecedented levels, how do you do a story about that? Well, that's the terrible thing about it, it's like there's nothing that can be done. And as I say, look, I might be being catastrophic here, and it may not be as bad. Sometimes people offer catastrophic predictions for the future that I believe, and they don't turn out to be real, that happens quite a lot. But it's a little bit of me that thinks this El Nino is a little bit like Covid, like it's going to happen to everything. It may not, I could be wrong, and I really hope I'm wrong, but I do think it's possible. What a great cliffhanger to end this episode on. Welcome back. I hope you enjoyed that, thank you to John for coming by. It's always a pleasure talking to John, and I have to be careful that it doesn't turn into shop talk. You know, there's a bit of shop talk, but sometimes I forget there are people listening and watching. I think I might have been trying to impress John. Anyway, look to self. Don't talk too much, I'm 56, I'm still learning. You never stop growing, you never stop learning. As Bob Dylan once said, "Those not busy being born are busy dying." I don't know how busy it is dying. It feels like the absence of busyness, but anyway, it's poetic. Mainly, I just want to say mad mad props to John. I literally have read all his books. I admire his writing so much. He's a true craftsman, crafts person. His ability to keep you reading. His light irony, his comic understatement. The first one I read of his was them, which. So you know it's a bit like albums where you like the one you've heard first. So them, for me, is maybe the gold standard, but they're all excellent, and the new one does not disappoint. So check it out. The castle. We've got some other exciting news. Yes, not just a new studio, but brand new social accounts for the podcast, which we'd love if you followed. That's @TheLouithuruPodcast on Instagram and TikTok. That's it for today. Thanks so much for watching, or listening, and I'll see you for another episode next week. [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. John Ronson’s new book *The Castle* explores the crisis of masculinity through a surreal, true-crime-style investigation of a man who hosts a bizarre reality show in a gothic castle.
  2. The narrative begins with a real-life encounter involving Ronson’s son and a stranger’s invitation to a party, which quickly spirals into a chaotic and disturbing experience involving gender roles, absurdity, and internet culture.
  3. The book intertwines personal reflections on masculinity, mental health, and self-exposure, drawing on Ronson’s own post-surgery existential struggles and parallels with figures like Graham Linnahann.
  4. Ronson critiques the normalization of disinhibition in online culture, using Graham’s extreme activism as a case study of how mental health can collapse under social pressure and performative intensity.
  5. A major theme is the influence of algorithms and YouTube, illustrated through Greg Chisholm’s rise and fall as a content creator, showing how platforms exploit and distort human behavior.
  6. Ronson emphasizes the danger of "click-bait" culture, where media and algorithms promote outrage and absurdity, leading to real-world harm, including trauma for children and social collapse.
  7. The book’s style is rooted in narrative clarity and unsaid subtext, inspired by writers like Kurt Vonnegut and Raymond Carver, who use minimalism to convey deep emotional and social truths.
  8. Ronson champions a journalistic approach of immersion and open-ended inquiry, rejecting tribalism and purity tests, instead valuing authenticity, complexity, and moral reflection in storytelling.

Summary:

John Ronson’s new book, *The Castle*, is a deeply personal and surreal exploration of modern masculinity, triggered by a real-life encounter at a bizarre gothic castle party. The story unfolds as a true-crime narrative where Ronson and his son are invited to a reality show called “101 Princesses,” hosted by a man who obsesses over control, gender roles, and performance. The experience reveals a broader cultural crisis—men navigating purposelessness, identity, and digital influence.

Ronson draws connections to his own post-surgery existential struggles and to figures like Graham Linnahann, whose extreme online activism exemplifies how societal disinhibition can spiral into mental breakdowns. A central theme is the rise and fall of Greg Chisholm, a former factory worker who becomes a successful YouTube influencer through algorithm-driven content, only to descend into chaos when his videos—especially those featuring children dressed as babies—go viral and are copied grotesquely by bots and content farms. This illustrates how platforms like YouTube incentivize extreme, often harmful, content, leading to widespread trauma and social outrage.

Ronson critiques the dominance of click-driven media, where outrage and absurdity replace depth, and argues that the most powerful stories emerge from moments of mystery, absurdity, and emotional resonance. The book reflects Ronson’s journalistic philosophy: immersive, unsentimental, and grounded in self-awareness, where personal vulnerability meets cultural critique. Ultimately, *The Castle* is not just a story about one man’s misstep—it’s a reflection on how masculinity, technology, and modern media are reshaping individual identity and social bonds.

FAQs

The book explores the 'crisis of masculinity' through a narrative of a man who hosts a reality show for women, leading to a deep investigation into modern masculinity, societal shifts, and individual identity.

He finds the term clichéd and boring, preferring a more dynamic, unpredictable narrative that reflects the strange and unexpected twists in real-life behavior and societal trends.

After undergoing colon surgery, he felt like a man 'out of time,' which mirrored the sense of disorientation he found in the castle owner's life, creating a personal and emotional resonance for the story.

John Ronson's son and three friends were invited to a man's ostentatious castle in Connecticut, where they were unexpectedly turned into participants in a fake '101 Princesses' reality show, leading to a disturbing and surreal experience.

It examines how algorithms and platforms like YouTube encourage extreme, often disturbing content, using Greg Chisholm’s journey as a case study of how users are drawn into increasingly bizarre and harmful behaviors.

Yes, he openly examines his own insecurities and contradictions, such as his experience with a public shaming incident, to show how personal and societal issues are interconnected.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.