Go back

John Lithgow

from Fresh Air ·

45m 24s

John Lithgow

John Lithgow, a prolific actor with nearly 200 stage, screen, and television performances, continues to thrive at age 81, recently playing Dumbledore in the HBO *Harry Potter* series and delivering a Tony-winning performance as Roald Dahl in the play *Giant*. The play, set in 1983, centers on Dahl’s controversial anti-Semitic views in a book review about the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, sparking a passionate debate between Dahl and a young American Jewish publisher. Lithgow’s performance is grounded in empathy, exploring Dahl’s traumatic upbringing, personal losses, and emotional pain that shaped his abrasive character. The play’s relevance grows in today’s political climate, especially with ongoing conflicts in Gaza and Lebanon. Lithgow’s career spans iconic roles like Winston Churchill in *The Crown*, where he blends American energy with authentic British accent and physical preparation. He also wrote children’s books and has long entertained young audiences through interactive shows, driven by a passion for creative expression rather than financial gain. The interview highlights his deep commitment to live performance, the emotional power of storytelling, and the enduring impact of art that challenges audiences to confront complex moral and historical issues.

Transcription

6850 Words, 37948 Characters

English
This is Fresh Air. I'm Dave Davies. Our guest today, John Lithgow, is an actor you can probably recall from a half-dozen roles off the top of your head. But the remarkable thing about his nearly 200 performances on stage, screen, and television is that at age 81, he's still going strong. He plays the character Dumbledore in the new HBO Harry Potter series that premieres on Christmas Day. And you can see his Tony-winning performance portraying a dark side of renowned children's author Roald Dahl in a filmed performance of the play Giant in theaters this weekend. Today, we're going to listen to the interview I recorded with Lithgow in April when he was performing the role on Broadway. Among Lithgow's many career honors are Oscar nominations for his roles in the films The World According to Garp and Terms of Endearment, six Primetime Emmy Awards for playing Winston Churchill in The Crown, a serial killer in the series Dexter, and an alien visiting Earth. In the sitcom Third Rock from the Sun, he's now won three Tony Awards, including one for his very first appearance on Broadway. Lithgow has also written several children's books, a memoir titled Drama, an Actor's Education, and the Dumpty Trilogy, three books of satirical poems inspired by the current occupant of the White House. The play Giant is set in 1983, when Roald Dahl ignited a controversy by writing an article with views that were widely sought-after by the audience. In the play, Dahl and his fiancée are at home in discussion with the British and an American representative of Dahl's publishers. They want him to say something to soften his message and diffuse the controversy. It soon emerges that the American rep is a practicing Jewish woman, and Dahl, played by Lithgow, isn't backing down. The performance, now in theaters, was filmed in London, where Lithgow first played the role before taking it to Broadway. John Lithgow, the actor who played the role in the film, is a great actor. He's a great welcome to Fresh Air. Thank you, Dave. I feel welcome. You're playing Dahl, who is kind of, it's oversimplistically calling him a villain here, but he's a very problematic character. Did you feel empathy for him? How did you connect with him? Oh, man. Well, you look for ways you can empathize with every character. And if you're playing a scoundrel of any stripe, you just try to make it interesting. You try to figure out what made him that way. And I mean, Dahl is a man so famous for one thing and not known at all for this other thing, his kind of overbearing and sometimes cruel nature. I just found it fascinating, the different perceptions of him. And curiously, I have a good friend, the actress Maria Tucci, who is the widow of the editor, Robert Gottlieb, who is the man who fired Roald Dahl from Alfred Knopf because he was just so insufferable and cruel to everybody he worked with there. And I knew this about him before this even came up. This, to me, was fascinating. Anyone who is that successful, that much of an asset for a character like Robert Gottlieb, who is the widow of the editor, Robert Gottlieb, to be fired because he was impossible to work with. I just thought, well, there's something there. Trevor Burrus Why don't you just tell us a bit about the action in this play? It's you as Roald Dahl and your fiancée and two representatives from your publishers. Give us a sense of what the issue is and what happens. Robert Gottlieb Yes. It's set in 1983, but it's about the events of 1982 when Israel, was in deep conflict with Lebanon, mainly because they were trying to purge the PLO from Beirut. And they invaded Beirut brutally. And Dahl wrote a book review a year later of a book about that invasion, which very much took the Palestinians' side. And in that review, he betrayed his own anti-Semitism. Between the lines of the book, he wrote a book about the war between Israel and and in a few of the lines, quite explicitly. And it caused a minor controversy then, which over the years grew into a bigger and bigger controversy about Roald Dahl, because that was the time when he basically admitted to being very anti-Semitic. And yes, the setup is that at the same time, his publishers, Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux in America and Jonathan Cape in London, they're about to release his new book, The Witches, which would be his fifth book. And they've all been sensational successes. And they were very worried that this one wouldn't sell because of the controversy he'd stirred. So that's the setup. They are there to get him to back down and apologize and explain and rationalize what he's written. And he wants nothing to do with that. Trevor Burrus You know, there's a distinction to be made between criticizing the policies of the Israeli government and condemning Jewish people as a whole. But you know, the lines can get fuzzy and assumptions can be made that anti-Semitism is at the heart of anybody criticizing Israel. And I think part of the brilliance of this play is that in the first act, when we don't learn Dahl's exact words from the article he wrote, or other comments that would be made public later, we're kind of invited to explore our own feelings about this and think, maybe. Peter Robinson What role Dahl is just making a point about the conduct of war and not about the Jewish people? Peter Robinson Yeah, it sort of throws an audience off balance, no matter what their political leanings and feelings are. You know, you back away from the phrase villain, and I appreciate that. We don't want him just to be the villain of the piece, but he's a dark character, or he's a character with a very dark side. But. The play becomes this ferocious debate between him and this young American Jewish woman from a New York publishing house. And that debate is extremely articulate. It's very passionate on both sides. And in the case of Dahl's side of the argument, the argument is polluted by anti-Semitism. But he's right on occasion. He's like a broken clock. And the audience. I mean, up on the stage, you can almost hear their anxiety trying to grapple this. Peter Robinson Right. And the debate gets increasingly personal. And in the end, Dahl says some things which. I mean, I was at one performance, and there was one comment, and I'm sure it's the one you know, that the audience audibly gasped. It was something he said to a reporter, right? Peter Robinson Mm-hmm. I deliberately don't quote it in interviews because it has such power in performance. But it is. It is something he literally said. It's an unspeakable turn of phrase. And it's like. It is the moment at which people see the very darkest side of Dahl. And they see it very clearly. And it's right near the end of the play. So in a sense, the whole play has been building to that moment. My challenge in playing the role is to spend the whole play motivating that moment. Peter Robinson By almost explaining that moment, explaining it emotionally as much as politically. And he did have a hard life in a lot of ways, right? Peter Robinson Well, that was my way in. He had a very hard life. There are several elements. You know, when you ask yourself what makes him hate like that, the various clues I found had to do with his upbringing and his experiences. He was born. He was born a Norwegian of a Norwegian family, but that family lived in Wales. His father had been brought to Cardiff to work in the shipping industry. But off he went to English boarding schools at Repton. He was an outsider from the get-go trying to get on the inside. And on. And in his life, he just suffered these terrible losses in the same year. And here, when he was very young, he lost both his father and his older sister. He went off to prep school where he was brutally beaten. He had a horrifying plane accident in World War II when he was an RAF fighter pilot, a solo accident in the Libyan desert when, by rights, it should have killed him. But instead, it just left him in terrible pain for his entire life. And he married Patricia Neal, who had three terrible strokes. And he, even though it was a very troubled marriage, he obsessively nursed her. Their four-month-old son, his pram was hit by a taxi in New York City. And he grew up with brain damage. And he lost his daughter at the age of seven from a variant of the measles. These were tragedies that absolutely haunted him. I'm convinced of that. And it was almost as if he was angry at life, because his life was so desperately difficult. And you take all those things into account, and this is a highly intelligent, extremely clever, witty, and charming man who just has this dark streak of cruelty. It's like he can't resist goading and tormenting people. You know, this play is being performed now and was performed in England at a time when there's very bitter division and controversy about actions of the Israeli military in Gaza. Not unlike, in some ways, this controversy about the invasion of Lebanon, which was launched in response to PLO rocket attacks in Israel. This, of course, the Gaza invasion response to that savage attack, the October 7th attack by Hamas. I'm wondering what reaction you've heard to the play, what kind of conversations it sparked. Well, everybody says it's just a. It's just astounding how timely it is. It's a play about a moment 40 years ago, and here we were rehearsing it once again for Broadway, and the same thing has happened. Not chasing after the PLO, chasing after Hezbollah and trying to put an end to, you know, missiles and raids from Hezbollah forces in Lebanon. There are lines in the play that just, you just hear people gasp. They're so timely. It's. It's almost describing what's happening now. Yeah. We should note that in 2020, Roald Dahl's family posted an apology for his anti-Semitism on the family website, right? Yes. They apologized, and he never did. Right. I wanted to talk about some of your other iconic roles. There are a lot of them, and one of them that I really remembered was you playing Winston Churchill in the series The Crown, which was created by Peter Morgan. I loved that series. And you play this. I mean, he's, well, he's an iconic figure for the English in the 20th century. I wanted to play a clip here. This is one of many meetings that the Prime Minister had with the Sovereign. The Queen here is a fairly young Elizabeth, played by Claire Foy, and the Prime Minister would regularly meet with the Queen. This is one where an argument erupts when the Queen relates that her husband, Prince Philip, wants to become an agent. Let's listen. He's learning to fly. Whatever for? Have we not enough qualified pilots to take him where he needs to go? No, he wants to fly himself. It's a boyhood dream. It's what he's always wanted. Why was government not consulted? Because it's a private matter, and I am in favor. Nothing you or His Royal Highness do is a private matter, and the father of the future King of England, risking his life needlessly, is. quite unacceptable. Please do not curtail my husband's personal freedoms any further. You've taken away his home. You've taken away his name. There comes a time where one must draw a line in the sand. And the job of drawing that line falls to cabinet, ma'am, not to you. Something your dear late papa would certainly have taught you, had he been granted more time to complete your education. And that is John Lithgow practically spitting as Winston Churchill. And the Queen. And the Queen. There are so many of these scenes. When you got this role, I mean, I imagine that Churchill is the kind of guy that everybody in England can do an impression of. Was it daunting to take this on? I mean, the role had been played by a lot of other people. It was extremely daunting, and you're right. I mean, everybody imitates Churchill. Everybody quotes Churchill. There are pubs named for Churchill. And I was completely. I was completely astonished when I was asked to do it by Peter Morgan, the writer, and Stephen Daldry, the lead director. I wasn't about to say no. These were very impressive people. And if they wanted me, I was amazed that they wanted me. But I was flattered and extremely excited to play the part. But, you know, I was a yank. When I sat down with Stephen. Stephen Daldry for breakfast in a diner, after I'd said yes, I said, Stephen, why did you cast me? And he said, well, Churchill's mother was an American. And, you know, she was. And that was the first little gesture of liberation. The other thing that happened was I arrived in England, and all the English actors were so enthusiastic. I mean, I've done a lot of acting in England, playing English roles. Even listening to this clip that you've just played, I can hear my Americanism. But there's a certain excitement to mingling an American energy with an English character. I mean, I'm speaking as objectively as I can about this. I've read this in one or two reviews. It's sometimes. It helps sort of enliven the drama or the comedy. This was particularly true of Churchill. And they somehow felt they wanted to shake things up, as they did in every way on The Crown. The Crown is such a surprising show because these very familiar characters, characters whom you know in the most public way possible, the queen, the king, the prince, the princesses, to actually go into their lives and see them in intimate settings and having very, very human problems and conflicts, that was what was arresting about The Crown. Well, in a sense, that was true of portraying Churchill this way. I really love the series. You know, when you came on, and the first time you were on screen, I tried to think, oh, God, yeah, there's John Lithgow. Yeah, I recognize him. Pretty soon, it wasn't John Lithgow. I mean, you were Churchill. I mean, and one of the things I read is that you placed little balls of some material in the jowls of your cheeks to give you that. That thing going? Yes, yes. I experimented with that when I was still in America before I went over there. I used a melon ball. I used a melon baller to create these little balls of apple, and I put them in the back of my cheeks. And Churchill had this unique lisp that was generated by the back of his tongue. And it worked wonderfully. I even took my melon baller and an apple to one of the first rehearsals, which was nothing but sitting around the table and talking. But I proposed this idea in front of everybody. I carved out two little apple balls and stuck them in the back and spoke. And I spoke some of my lines, and I believe I read one of the scenes. And it was sensational, but my mouth immediately filled up with apple cider, you know. I mean, and I was spitting all over the table. Well, we hired this great toothmeister, a man named Christopher Lyons, who does all the great false teeth for Tilda Swinton and Meryl Streep, as Maggie Thatcher. Well, he made these little silicon plumpers, we called them, that clicked onto my back teeth. It changed everything. I mean, it made me sound like Churchill because he did have this, he sounded like he had marbles in the back of his mouth. But it also just made me feel so different from myself. I mean, I've worked with the RSC, the Royal Shakespeare Company, and at the National. I've done about 10 roles of Englishman in England. And I'm better at it. I must say, listening to myself as Churchill, I still had a lot to learn. You're better at an English accent now than you were when you played Churchill? Oh, I think so. I'm doing Dumbledore and Harry Potter with a marvelous dialect coach watching me like a hawk. And she doesn't give me many notes anymore, but she certainly did the first few months. Yeah, this is for the HBO. This is the HBO series based on Harry Potter. Have you finished shooting the first series? I have finished. They still have another month to go. But they squeezed all my stuff in to allow me to do Giant on Broadway. So my last month of work was brutal. It aged me. But then with Dumbledore, that comes in handy. You know, I have to ask, at age 80, I'm not 80, but I'm older. I'm an older person now. And my short-term memory isn't, isn't what it used to be. And I am just amazed that you, I mean, you're in practically every scene of this play on Broadway. You're doing eight shows a week. Is it hard to remember, to learn lines? That many lines? It's harder than it used to be to learn the lines. But once they're in there, I'm fine. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. My brain is a little bit tired. My body's tired. I mean, 80, 80 is, it was no surprise. You're an old man. - Well, you got plenty left in you. You better, because this HBO production is going to last how many years? Well, the handy thing is I'm playing all these broken-down old men, so I get better cast every year. John Lithgow recorded in April. You can see his Tony-winning role as writer Roald Dahl in a filmed performance of the play Giant this weekend at Select Theaters. We'll hear more about his life and career after this short break. I'm Dave Davies, and this is Fresh Air. You are no stranger to the stage, right? I think you were first on a stage at age two. Your parents were both actors. Your dad was a director and manager of a lot of regional theater. Give us a sense of what your childhood was like and how you had embraced acting. Well, I had a real kind of Midwestern, small-town, Booth Tarkington sort of childhood up until the age of, I guess, 11. Sixth grade. My father was a professor at Antioch College and created this summer Shakespeare festival that lasted for years and years and became more and more professional. And at a certain point, he decided, I'm going to become a professional theater man instead of a university professor. And off we went. And that was at the end of my sixth grade year. And between then and my graduation. From high school, I lived in about eight different places. We just moved and moved and moved because it's not an easy life creating and running regional theaters, God knows. Four Shakespeare festivals in Ohio and ultimately 10 years running the McCarter Theater in Princeton. But I was off to college by that time. So the word is peripatetic. I was like a service brat except in the service of American classical. Classical repertory theater. I know you did a lot of different kinds of jobs, kind of helping your dad out with the theater companies that he managed. When did you really get the acting bug, when you had that experience and said, gosh, this is what I want to do? It was in college. I mean, I arrived at Harvard where all the campus theater was extracurricular. And within two weeks, I was cast in a major role, Reverend Anderson. In The Devil's Disciple at the Big Lobe Theater. And boom, I was the campus star. I mean, I was already an experienced actor without any intention of becoming an actor, which is the best possible way to become an actor. And by the time I finished college, off, I went to London to study in earnest at Lambda. But it was that period of wonderful creative four years where I. Played major roles. I directed and designed. I directed two Mozart operas and staged a ballet. It was just, it was, there was no question. This is what I'm going to do with my life. You know, I know that from your memoir that you have a long and deep relationship with the city of London. I mean, when you returned to the States, your sister was annoyed that you had come back with a British accent. You wrote, That's a nice turn of phrase. I don't remember writing. Yeah, it is a good one. How did you, did you purge it consciously from your? Yeah, I, you know, I was in this wonderful Lambda program. It's the D group, which is foreign language students, which is 80% Americans, young American acting students. And I figured, well, I'm going to make. I made a conscious effort not to absorb an English accent because after all, I'm going back to act in America. But, you know, after two years in London, it's true. My sister simply wouldn't speak to me. She said I sounded so pretentious because of my English accent. And I said, what accent? You know, it's clearly I'd absorbed it without knowing it. I just basically began to tell people, no, I'm not English. I'm just pretentious. I have to talk about third. Rock from the Sun. This was the sitcom you were in for what? Six years, right? Ninety six to 2001. And I thought we'd just start with a clip. You and three others play a group of aliens who've landed on Earth on some kind of observational mission. You look like normal people. But here's the opening scene of episode one when the four of you are in a car and you've just landed on Earth and you're in this parked car and you're examining yourselves in your new human form. Kind of getting. Used to your new bodies. And next to you is another car with a couple making out. And we'll hear that you're you and your fellow aliens notice the couple and make some inaccurate guesses about what they're up to. Let's listen. Everyone fully formed. Oh, yeah, we've got ten fingers, eleven toes. Good. I guess we're in everyone comfortable. I have three holes in my face. Can anyone get your head to swivel? To the rear? No. Oh, and how are you supposed to lick your back? Maybe you do what they're doing. Look, life forms and they're cleaning each other. Look at us. I can't believe we look like them. Is anybody else sweating out of their breasts? No. In fact, I don't have any. I have tiny ones. And that is our guest, John Lithgow, along with Kirsten Johnston, French steward and Joseph Gordon-Levitt from the opening episode of Third Rock from the Sun. Fun to hear? Well, yes, but I, you know, there was a long sort of learning curve for those four aliens. One of the great things about Third Rock is how the comedy got more and more complex and sophisticated as they became more like humans. But it's kind of wonderful. I haven't heard that for, gosh, 20 years, 25 years, that opening scene. It's wonderful. Joseph Gordon-Levitt was one of those voices, and he was only 13 years old. Yeah. And the show was actually taped Tuesday nights, right? In front of a live audience, right? Yeah. And I've heard you say that one of the great things about theater is that you're telling the story at the same instant the audience is experiencing it, which is so different from shooting a movie or a TV show that's, you know, edited. Yes. We were spending four days preparing to perform for a live studio audience, and it was a point of honor for us to make them genuinely laugh their heads off so that no canned laughter was necessary. And we would get them laughing for, like, 15 and 20 seconds. It was just thrilling. And, you know, when I talk about that lightning-in-a-bottle experience of telling a story while the audience is hearing it, we were able to capture that. Actor John Lithgow recorded in April. We'll hear more of our interview after a break. This is Fresh Air. I also wanted to talk about The World According to Garp. This is really taking us back. 1982. You earned an Oscar nomination for playing Roberta Muldoon, a trans woman who is your height, which was 6'4". This is, of course, based on the novel by John Irving. And we'll hear a clip here. Robin Williams plays a writer named T.S. Garp. And in this scene, he's visiting a home that his mother, Jenny, operates for women who've been abused or traumatized. Your character, Roberta, lives there. I guess I mentioned you. You're a trans woman. And in this scene, Garp, who is played by Robin Williams, has just had a tense encounter with one of the women at the home. And you've intervened to break it up. And you walk away and kind of get acquainted with Garp. Let's listen. No sense making things any worse than they are. This whole house is full of— I know. I know. Everyone here has something missing or some wound that won't heal. And your mother tries to nurse them back to health. She's a wonderful person. And she's a wonderful woman. Are you visiting somebody here? No, why? Well, you just seem like the only normal person around the place. Oh, I don't know. Pardon me. I hate to use a corny line like this, but haven't I seen you before? You like football? Oh, yeah. I used to watch it quite a bit. Well, you might have seen me. I was a tight end with the Philadelphia Eagles. Number 90, Robert Muldoon. Oh. Oh, yeah. I had a great time. You had a great pair of hands. Yes, you did. Yeah. And that is Robin Williams with our guest, John Lithgow, in The World According to Garp. Got an Oscar nomination for that performance. What are your memories of that role, getting into that character? Oh, the very, very happy memories. It was a beautifully written character in the novel. And I'd read the novel a couple of years before. Never dreaming it would be a movie. And I loved it. I loved the character of Roberta Muldoon, I was asked to go in and meet George Roy Hill, the director, who was casting World According to Garp. I couldn't figure out what part he would want me for. And my agent's assistant said, well, I'm not sure because there must be a typo on the casting. It's the character of Roberta. And suddenly I remembered the character and I thought, oh, my God, this is my role. This is perfect. I went off and I was very excited to play it because I loved the character in the book. Went off and met with George Roy Hill and the great casting director, Marion Daugherty, who had fingered me for this role. And George ruled it out immediately. He felt I was too tall and pairing me next to Robin would be too comical. And so I was very disappointed. And about eight months passed during which time he must have seen 100 people for the role of Roberta Muldoon, including genuine athletes and genuine transgender women and actors of all stripes. They kept on looking and finally came back to me. And I screen tested for it and finally got the part. You know, they dressed me in drag. And by a coincidence, I had read a book a couple of years ago called Conundrum, a memoir by Jan Morris. A transgender travel journalist from England who fearlessly described in great detail every stage of the process, including the surgical process and the experience of first living her life as a woman and feeling more complete for the first time. And I simply kind of improvised the role of Jan Morris in front of the camera while George. Roy Hill asked me questions from off camera. And that's what got me the role. He just found me completely convincing in the role. Well, you know, that was more than 40 years ago that I saw that. And I still when I think of that film, I think of you in that role. Another one that I remember that's of the same era is you playing a professional killer in the Brian De Palma film Blowout, which is a murder thriller with John Travolta and Nancy Allen. There's particularly a scene where you're in. The phone booth calling the police acting as a sexual predator who kills women and is confessing to a crime as part of the plot. He's actually not that he's a professional assassin. And it was just so affecting that I still remember that. You can't imagine how you're complimenting me, Dave. I remember that so vividly. I was costumed as an electrician with a hard hat, like a city utility worker. And yet on the phone, I was pretending to be sort of. Frail, psychotic killer. And I mean, I had such fun playing that scene for you to invoke it 40 years later. Well, you've made my day. For better or worse, that's one of my images of John Lithgow. And it's one of Brian's great films, I think. And John, one of John Travolta's great performances. You know, one thing we haven't talked about is that you've written children's books and you entertain children, right? You've done children's shows. You've done children's shows quite a bit, which I assume is not the best paying gigs you get. What do you like about entertaining kids? Well, I haven't done it in a while, but there was a good 15-year period there where it was virtually a second career, sort of under the radar. I did write the nine picture books. It's just entertaining children. First of all, it began entertaining my own children. So it was very personal to me. I ended up doing three albums for kids, and I started doing concerts. I started doing concerts with major orchestras. What was thrilling about it, and you're right, it was not for money at all. It was just an ecstatic experience entertaining children. I've always felt that what we actors aspire to is suspension of disbelief, making an audience believe for even a half a second that what they're seeing is what is actually happening. And just that feeling that, oh, I pulled it off. I really feel, I fooled them for a second, like a magician pulling off a great trick. You never really fool adults. You know you're in the same theater with them, and they're watching actors, paid actors speaking other people's words. But kids completely suspend their disbelief, completely. They are absolutely thrilled by everything they see. The concerts with them were these kind of all sorts of interactive games. I would play this game called Guess the Animals, where I would start to draw an animal on an enormous easel, and they would start screaming, it's a hippo, it's a hippo. And I would say, it's a what? It's a what? I thought you would get this. It's a hippo. And I'd say, oh, you got it. It's a hippo. And then I would sing the great hippo song, Mud Mud. Mud, glorious mud by Flanders and Swan. It was just giving them this wonderful time. And in the case of orchestra concerts, giving them a great experience in a concert hall and a great first look at an orchestra. You are prolific. I mean, how do you juggle all this? Do you have a staff of people that help you keep it straight? No, no. Well, I have an indispensable assistant, but unfortunately she's in L.A. and I'm in New York, so everything is done online. I just, I'm always bursting with projects. Far more than half of them I never complete, but bright ideas that just sort of light me up and I have to try them. My brother describes me as that silver dome that you put your hand on in physics class in high school when the static makes your hair stick out on end. He said, that's you. You're just full of ideas all the time. It never stops. Some of it is the kind of fear that I don't have anything else to do. It's that nobody will hire me to act. It's like, let me fill up my time with something creative. I drive my wife completely crazy. And you must be a heck of a granddad with all that kid stuff. Oh, my God. I love my grandchildren so much. And they go from age 20 down to age eight months at the moment. So that's a great crowd. Well, John Lithgow. It's been fun. Thank you so much for spending some time with us. Great to talk to you, Dave. I had a wonderful time. He plays the character Dumbledore in a new HBO Harry Potter series that premieres Christmas Day. And you can see his Tony-winning role as writer Roald Dahl in a film's performance of The Play Giant this weekend at select theaters. Coming up, Justin Chang reviews the new films Elsinore and I Play Rocky. This is Fresh Air. Our film critic Justin Chang has reviews of two new biographical films about actors who overcame enormous adversity. In Elsinore, Andrew Scott plays the Scottish performer Ian Charlson in the late 1980s as he prepares to play Hamlet on stage while battling AIDS. And in I Play Rocky, Anthony Ippolito stars as a young Sylvester Stallone struggling to make the 1976 boxing drama that would make him a Hollywood legend. Both movies are a hit. Both movies are now playing in theaters. Here's Justin's review. It's not rare at this time of year to hear Oscar buzz for actors playing real-life people, like Timothee Chalamet as Bob Dylan, to name a recent example. It's less common to have two biographical films, Elsinore and I Play Rocky, in which the Oscars themselves factor into the story. In Elsinore, set in London in 1989, Andrew Scott plays the actor Ian Charlson, who's best known for. for co-starring in the best-picture-winning Chariots of Fire. It's a frustrating kind of fame. Ian can't even get into a cab without the driver humming Vangelis' memorable theme music. But Ian has much more to worry about. He's a gay man living with AIDS at a time when the diagnosis is a death sentence. Soon, though, a rare career opportunity presents itself. Daniel Day-Lewis has just dropped out of Hamlet at the National Theatre. And the production. needs a new Prince of Denmark. Ian, who loves the play deeply, lands the role. He's determined to make it work, despite the warnings of his doctor, Margaret Johnson, a trailblazer in HIV and AIDS treatment, played by a terrifically stern Olivia Colman. Dr. Johnson knows that rehearsals and performances will take a toll on his already poor health. In this strong scene, she meets with Ian, who's just received chemotherapy, to treat complications of his illness. People told me chemotherapy was horrible. It isn't exactly pleasant. Compared to AIDS, it's a walk in the park. Cancer patients. Spoiled bastards. *Giggles* It could get better. I mean, I could start to live a fairly normal life. You know, go shopping and get a new library book and go to dinner. Yes, and soon. But I don't want that. when it comes to life, life and living, I just, it's quality that I want. It's not quantity. Hamlet again. Not again. It's always been Hamlet. One of Ian's harshest critics is the pioneering queer director Derek Jarman, played by David Dawson, who criticizes him for not going public with his sexuality. It's poignant and meaningful, then, that Charlson is played by an openly gay actor, especially one as good as Andrew Scott, who didn't get the attention he deserved for his delicate, haunting work in the 2023 drama All of Us Strangers. In Elsinore, Scott gives a moving, if more conspicuously effortful performance. He has to declaim lines from Shakespeare's greatest play, and slowly succumb to terminal illness. Scott is much better than the movie, which, as directed by the Australian filmmaker Simon Stone, and written by Stephen Beresford, often plays like a feature-length trailer for itself. Too much of it unfolds in montages that mash Ian's art and his illness clumsily together, ultimately sapping both of meaning. Elsinore is a tearjerker that memorializes an actor's final role. I Play Rocky, directed by Peter Farrelly from a script by Peter Gamble, is a crowd-pleaser that celebrates a legendary arrival. As it begins, the young Sly Stallone, played by an excellent Anthony Ippolito, is a broke New York City nobody, eager to prove himself as an actor and screenwriter. The movie takes us through Sly's early ups and downs. He's nearly evicted, adopts a stray dog, appears in a softcore porn movie to pay some bills, and puts up with his discouraging dad, an almost unrecognizable Matt Dillon. Sly gets more support from his girlfriend and soon-wife, Sasha, who moves with him out to L.A. She's played by Anna-Sophia Robb, doing what she can to liven up a straightforward loyal spouse role. Stallone famously wrote the script for Rocky in three and a half days, inspired by a 1975 boxing match between Muhammad Ali and Chuck Wepner. I Play Rocky, and he glosses over that and other story beats without providing much insight into Sly's creative process. The drama kicks in, though, when the finished script draws interest from the film company United Artists. But Sly refuses to let them have Rocky unless he plays the lead. The ensuing negotiations are pretty entertaining to watch. P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell make a deft comic duo as the producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chardoff. Savvy industry gatekeeper, who eventually come to believe in Sly as passionately as he believes in himself. And Tracy Letts is hilarious as a U.A. executive who wants a more bankable star like Robert Redford or Burt Reynolds. History, of course, will prove him dramatically wrong. Rocky will bring audiences to their feet, become the top-grossing film of 1976, and win the Oscar for Best Picture. But I Play Rocky seems to know this odds-defying outcome at every step. It's an underdog story in which the underdog's triumph feels preordained. A by-the-numbers movie in which the numbers are admittedly irresistible, like the enduring image of Stallone running up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art. It does have a major asset in Ippolito, who's such a dead ringer for young Stallone that you can't help but believe in him, even when the movie around him doesn't go anywhere. Anywhere near the distance. Justin Chang is a film critic at The New Yorker. He reviewed Elsinore and I Play Rocky, now playing in theaters. On Monday's show, rock guitarist Jorma Kalkanen, a founding member of Jefferson Airplane, the pioneering psychedelic rock band that provided the soundtrack for The Summer of Love. Jorma will tell us about his life in music. I hope you can join us. To keep up with what's on the show and get highlights of our interviews, follow us on Instagram, at NPR Fresh Air. And you can subscribe to our YouTube channel at youtube.com slash thisisfreshair. We're rolling out new videos with in-studio guests, behind-the-scenes shorts, and iconic interviews from the archive. Fresh Air's executive producer is Sam Brigger. Our senior producer today is Roberta Shorrock. Our technical director and engineer is Audrey Bentham, with additional engineering support from Julian Hertzfeld and Diana Martinez. Our interviews and reviews are made possible by produced and edited by Phyllis Myers, Anne-Marie Baldonado, Lauren Krenzel, Teresa Madden, Monique Nazareth, Thea Chaloner, Susan Yakundi, Anna Bauman, and Nico Gonzalez-Whistler. Our digital media producer is Molly C.V. Nesper. Our social media video producer is Hillary Kissinger. For Terry Gross and Tanya Mosley, I'm Dave Davies. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. John Lithgow, at age 81, remains actively performing in stage, film, and television, including his role as Dumbledore in the new HBO Harry Potter series and a Tony-winning performance as Roald Dahl in the play *Giant*.
  2. In *Giant*, Lithgow portrays Roald Dahl as a complex, controversial figure, exploring his anti-Semitic views and personal tragedies, with the play sparking emotional and political debate through its raw, timely dialogue.
  3. Lithgow draws empathy for Dahl by examining his difficult upbringing, including early losses, trauma, and a troubled marriage, revealing the psychological roots of his dark and cruel nature.
  4. His acclaimed portrayal of Winston Churchill in *The Crown* blends American energy with English precision, using physical preparation like silicone plumpers to authentically capture Churchill’s voice and demeanor.
  5. Lithgow has a prolific career spanning over 200 performances, with notable roles in *The World According to Garp*, *Blowout*, and *Third Rock from the Sun*, and he continues to write children’s books and entertain young audiences.
  6. He emphasizes the unique power of live theater, where audience reactions and real-time engagement create a dynamic, immersive experience unlike pre-recorded media.
  7. Lithgow remains driven by creative curiosity and a deep desire to entertain, often pursuing bold, under-examined projects despite limited financial reward.
  8. The play *Giant* resonates in contemporary times due to its parallels with current geopolitical tensions and debates over Israel, Gaza, and anti-Semitism, making it a timely and emotionally charged work.

Summary:

John Lithgow, a prolific actor with nearly 200 stage, screen, and television performances, continues to thrive at age 81, recently playing Dumbledore in the HBO *Harry Potter* series and delivering a Tony-winning performance as Roald Dahl in the play *Giant*. The play, set in 1983, centers on Dahl’s controversial anti-Semitic views in a book review about the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, sparking a passionate debate between Dahl and a young American Jewish publisher. Lithgow’s performance is grounded in empathy, exploring Dahl’s traumatic upbringing, personal losses, and emotional pain that shaped his abrasive character.

The play’s relevance grows in today’s political climate, especially with ongoing conflicts in Gaza and Lebanon. Lithgow’s career spans iconic roles like Winston Churchill in *The Crown*, where he blends American energy with authentic British accent and physical preparation. He also wrote children’s books and has long entertained young audiences through interactive shows, driven by a passion for creative expression rather than financial gain.

The interview highlights his deep commitment to live performance, the emotional power of storytelling, and the enduring impact of art that challenges audiences to confront complex moral and historical issues.

FAQs

John Lithgow is playing the character Dumbledore in the new HBO Harry Potter series that premieres on Christmas Day.

Lithgow is starring in a filmed performance of the play *Giant*, where he portrays Roald Dahl in a controversial 1983 discussion with his publishers.

The play centers on Roald Dahl's controversial book review of a war in Lebanon that was perceived as anti-Semitic, which sparked a major public and political controversy.

He seeks empathy by exploring the character's background and trauma, understanding that such characters are shaped by difficult life experiences, not just by being 'villains.'

He draws from Dahl's traumatic upbringing, including losing family members, suffering abuse in boarding school, surviving a wartime plane crash, and enduring a troubled marriage and loss of a child.

Yes, he has won three Tony Awards, including his first on Broadway, and has received six Primetime Emmy Awards for playing Winston Churchill in *The Crown*.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.