Go back

Job: When Friends Become Accusers

from Spoken Gospel

1h 15m 31s

Job: When Friends Become Accusers

The book of Job explores the profound question of whether innocent people can suffer, challenging the common belief that suffering always results from sin. While Job’s friends argue that his suffering proves he has sinned, their reasoning is grounded in a distorted, mechanistic worldview that misapplies biblical truths. They claim divine revelation from spirits, echoing the accuser’s tactics in heaven, and assert that suffering equals guilt, yet they ignore the reality that good people suffer and evil people prosper. Job resists this logic, consistently turning to God in prayer and lament, affirming his innocence without blaming God. He points out that God’s justice operates beyond retribution, showing that good things happen to the wicked and bad things to the righteous—proving that innocent suffering is a legitimate category. Job’s desire to die and enter the grave is not a sign of despair, but a hopeful plea for vindication after death, reflecting a deep faith in God’s ultimate fairness. The narrative culminates in the affirmation that God alone can vindicate Job, not his friends, who fail to see the depth of human suffering or the sovereignty of divine justice. This makes Job a powerful theological reflection on suffering, integrity, and the limits of human reasoning—especially relevant to understanding how God’s character remains consistent even in the face of inexplicable pain. The book does not resolve the mystery of suffering but invites readers to trust in a God who sees, judges, and ultimately justifies the innocent.

Transcription

13972 Words, 73253 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Well, welcome everyone to the Spoken Gospel Podcast. Thank you so much for joining us. We are continuing our walk through the book of Job. And we've got a doozy today for a number of reasons. One, because we, I think, are walking through one of the largest sections of texts we've ever tried to kind of step through on this podcast in its history. It's not a book overview in that sense, but we are going through the argument between Job and his friends, which is what, 30 chapters plus? - I'm terrified. - Yeah, and so that's one reason it's a doozy. The other reason is 'cause we're both terrified because we've spent the last couple of days tracing the argument and seeing how it ends in a life who will get to, but he ends with all of these lofty statements that he can speak for God and that he knows why these things are happening. And he's the young one who shows up with all the answers. And then God says, "Who is this at darkens my counsel?" And we just don't want to be a liar today. I think it's the thing we're bringing into the room into the podcast studio, so bear with us. We're gonna try our best to talk about these arguments that the friends lobby against Job in order to deconstruct them 'cause they're wrong, they're bad, some of the things they say. But it's nuanced because they say a lot of true things but apply them in wrong ways. And so we want to make sure that we're navigating that gray area really clearly. But what we don't want to do is try to attach things to God that Job is not trying to attach to him 'cause the friends often say, "Oh God does this "and God does this and God does this." And they get repute for it at the end. And so we want to remove those things that the friends are trying to attach to God, but not try to add a bunch of things in the process and speak like a lie who speak wrongly about God. So bear with us as we try to do that. We'll try to do that with humility and fear. But how we got here, we've talked about kind of Job in his own world, we've looked at the comparative literature of other Job-like writings and seeing how, this is a question that the world has always asked is why do people who seem to be pious toward their God suffer seemingly by the hand of that same God or without the help of that God? It's a confusing thing to do. - Yeah, or is innocent suffering possible? - Is it a legitimate category that the innocent suffer? - Yes, because the God's can be dubious and we have to placate them. And this is speaking in-- - Pagan terms, yeah. - Ancient Near Eastern, pagan terms. But what can be done when, when as far as you know, you have not done anything to anger the God's and yet you're being smitten by them? - Right. And so we looked at that and we saw what was similar and different about those writings and the book of Job. So if you missed that, go back. We've looked at the role of Satan in the book and the themes of the Garden of Eden and all of that. Can you somewhat set that up for us again, Christine? - Yeah, the way we kind of talked about it and the previous episode was about how, when we set up the world of Job in episode one, we set up the world in Job and how there is the Heavenly Council in the presence of God up there as it were. We see that in Job one and two. And there's this mirroring on earth with Job and his family and how he is acting in his family as like this priestly figure who is an Adam figure as well. And so he traced those themes of how he's also put to the test because in Adam's case, he sinned and he lost Eden. And in this case, Job doesn't sin. The text says that multiple times, but he loses Eden. He is naked and unashamed, unlike Adam, but he is still experiencing this expulsion, this banishment, this attacking of the evil one from all sides. And so we were looking at those tests 'cause his first test was he lost everything, including his children and livestock. And then his second test was that he lost his health. And in both cases, we see him pass that test and we saw how those are prefiguring Jesus as well. And like most good stories, you have three tests that our hero needs to pass. And so we see the third test take up the rest of the book or the majority of the book. And that's what we're jumping into. And we're gonna see like, okay, does Job sin, you can ask like does Job sin in this case or what is the test of the council that comes to earth and would seen in these three friends that are mentioned at the beginning, Ella Faz build that in so far who are kings from neighboring lands who come and try to comfort Job and fail miserably. - Yes, they do. - And you mention they speak truth but misapply it. And that's sort of something that we're kind of trying to navigate is a lot of the times what makes their arguments so compelling is that they're saying true things about God and how the universe operates. But they're misapplying it to Job 'cause their conclusion is always that Job sinned and he has to come clean. And Job is insisting that he has not sinned and he does not have to come clean and nevertheless he is suffering, but they always end up convicting him in their arguments by saying true things about how God runs the world. - Yeah. - So that's our dilemma. - Yeah, that's where we are. And so I like the framing of the three tests, the first test and the idea behind it is the only reason Job is worshipping God and loyal to him is because he's set up this hedge of protection around Job and giving him this flourishing life. And the accuser, the Satan tells God, if you take that away, he'll curse you to your face. Well, he takes the hedge away and loses everything and he doesn't curse him, he blesses God. And then he says, well, bone for bone, flesh for flesh, skin for skin. If you hurt his body and torture him basically, then he'll curse you. Well, that happens and he doesn't curse him, he passes that test. Well, now he's got the test of his friends going, your guilty, your evil, this is happening because you deserve it. Can he pass this test? Can he maintain his integrity, God's integrity, all of this, suffering and accusation, while being berated on every side by these elders and friends in his community? - Yeah, because what's interesting in both the heavenly and the earthly council is that is God good is never on the line. And we kind of talked about that. Satan does not accuse God, he accuses Job. He accuses Job of being a fairweather of worshipper and only loving God because God gives him these good things. And then the accusers on earth and Job's friends, they never accuse God of being bad, God is good. He runs a universe justly, but they insist that Job is accusing God of injustice. And so if he hasn't sinned in the past, he's certainly sinning with his logic against God. So in both cases, Job is in the dock by the accuser. God is never in the dock, but the arguments always end up accusing Job of things that he insists, he's not guilty of. He's not ever claiming in his innocence that God is unjust and he's not ever claiming that he has sinned. And this is what drives the accusers crazy. So that's kind of what we're trying to navigate as well. - Yeah, the idea being that if Job maintains his innocence while suffering, doesn't that maintaining of innocence logically accuse God of mismanaging his universe? - Yes, because as we see in the universe, God punishes the evil-doer and blesses the righteous. - Yes. - So-- - Job's breaking the world if he maintains his innocence. - Yes, because Job is clearly suffering like an evil-doer was in God's well-ordered universe. So their argument is that Job must therefore be sinning. And this is what makes it a great theodicy piece of literature is that is innocence suffering real. And that's what it impacts. And Job is insistent that he is not accusing God of injustice by holding onto his innocence. But this is the third test and it takes up most of the time, so. - So we'll dive into the arguments here, but just to say it one last time before we dive in, the question Job is answering or wrestling with, I should say, is not, is God good when people suffer? That's not the question, that's a question we bring to Job, but it's not what it's written to ask. The question it's wrestling with is, do innocent people suffer? - Yes. - Is that a category? - Yes. And in a way, we have the answer right in the first chapters because the answer is yes, God's himself. - The reason He nominates Job for Satan's consideration is because of his innocence. - Yes, and that's a scary thing because we know why Job is suffering while Satan went after him. Why did Satan go after him? Because he was righteous and blameless. So why do the innocence suffer? Because Satan hates people. Basically is the logic we get or the story we get. And so again to like set the test up, we as readers should know that Job is innocent because we get it in chapter one and chapter two. So six times in chapter one and two, we see Job vindicated as righteous, twice from God's own mouth, and then twice is a conclusion of in all this Job did not sin. And then once at the very beginning, it was righteous, upright, blameless. So we know as readers, Job is innocent. We also know that Satan is after him and we see the suffering that unfolds. But Elif has built that in so far. Much like Job, we're not in the heavenly council and are not the narrator or the reader. So they do not know what's going on. So they are bringing their worldview and understanding to bear on Job's predicament. - Either try it. figure out what's happening invisibly, but they only have the physical to kind of deal with you. Yeah. Okay, so starting off, let's talk about this. There are three cycles of speeches in Job, and they kind of move, and there's a break of the pattern at the end for a reason, but the three cycles are Job Speaks, and then a Friend Speaks, Job Speaks, and a Friend Speaks, Job Speaks, and a Friend Speaks, and you get through all three friends. So it'll be like Job, Elephaz, Job, Buildad, Job, Zofar, and then it gets repeated. Job, Elephaz, Job, Buildad, Job, Zofar. And then in the third cycle, Job, Elephaz, Job, Buildad, Job, and then Elihu comes in in and erupts the cycle. Yes. That's the cycle. And each cycle kind of fleshes out a part of the accusation or argument against Job, and builds on the last one, and it gets more and more intense and pointed as the story goes on. And so there's these kind of softer arguments at the beginning, and they get to straight up accusations, lies, and condemnation at the end. We'll see. But that's kind of the overall structure of the argument. Yeah, and keeping in mind that this is a poorest universe. So heaven is in conversation with earth, earth is in conversation with heaven. These parallel planes of reality are interacting with each other. They aren't removed. And so when the friends claim to bring interpretation to Job's situation, they're often claiming to be inspired. That's right. Yeah. And what's interesting about that is something you'll see as you read through this is you'll see the word wind. A lot of this windy argument that you've brought to me. Now that can mean you're full of hot air, basically. Like it was empty or it was hollow, or you couldn't grasp it because it was just this empty wind, or you know, you're blowing hot air. But it also is the same word for spirit. And that there is this spiritual component to the argument as there was in heaven. The accuser and Yahweh were having a debate of sorts. And now that is fleshing itself out on earth. Yeah. And this is similar to other Anjaneerian theology, things to where there's an oracle that comes. And a spirit brings to bear some kind of interpretation or input into the sufferers situation. So those are similarities. And again, how they talk about true things or how they apply true things is I think an interesting thing to say. Because what makes their arguments compelling and dangerous is that they're misapplying truth. Yeah. We know from the gospels, Satan uses scripture in the wrong way. And so it's not just about knowing the scripture. It's about applying it the right way. Okay. So the first cycle, Job kicks off. And what's fascinating about how Job begins this is Job does not do. I think what anyone who has an idea of what Job is going to be about what he would do. He doesn't say, I'm innocent. Why is this happening to me? He doesn't say God's unjust. He doesn't do any of the things that his friends will then argue against him for doing. Instead, he just is lamenting. And he's lamenting in such a way that it's consistent with the story that came before it because we have this idea that the hedge, the fence, the Eden that was around Job has been taken away. And the wilderness has started to overtake him. And so he basically in chapter three and his first monologue, he basically just asked God to finish the work of uncreation. He's like, Eden has disappeared. The wilderness is swallowing me up. You know what? Can we just turn back the clock on Genesis one and two and go back to the wild and waste? Can you just uncreate me? I wish I was never born. Yeah. Is what he's saying. Very sad. And kind of like what you were saying, Job here is just lamenting. And we talked about this in the first episode too that Job here is not asking questions about why did this happen. Just like you said, he's just, he's very sad. And he wishes he could uncreate the day of his birth. And that's what you kind of see. And we talked about this yesterday. But interestingly, we get a third plane at it here like the geography that we have gotten used to with heaven and earth. There's the heavenly council. There's the earthly council. And here we see Job saying, I want to go to the council of the underworld where everyone is at rest, where everyone is at peace, where slave and king lie beside each other. We don't hear about taxes. We don't hear slave drivers shouts. And we are just all at rest. And if only I were there. And it's very interesting that now we're in the underworld. And that's where Job wants to go interestingly. Yeah, it's really interesting that you have this heavenly council, earthly council. And then the underworld, you've got all three layers of cosmology and a sense here. I think a question being, why does Job want to go to the underworld? Because what we have to be careful here is Job is not suicidal. He's not. Yeah, that's a good. And so it's not like this is the easiest way out of the pain of living. Yeah, he's not asking for a way out. He's just asking for a way there. Hmm. He's not asking for a way out of pain. He's asking for a way into the underworld. Is that what you're saying? Yes. And you can ask why. And I don't know. But because he asked for the day of his birth to be uncreated. And again, this is a lamenting person in this poetry. We can allow for exaggeration. We can allow for extreme. We have to. Yeah, I mean, the underworld is where his family is. Yes. And there's an equality in the grave where he knows this piece. He wants he wants peace. Most of all, so you could make a case that, okay, yeah, he is asking for a way out of suffering. But as the story goes on, it's not his suffering that he's trying to escape from. It's God he wants to come to. He wants to come to God. And he wants to find vindication on the other side of the grave. We're going to find out because the physical manifestation of his reality, which is suffering and shame and loss is telling a story about who he is to himself in the world. That's not true. And that's going to be like this argument that's brought up here. But right now, he's just lamenting. Yeah. I think what's fascinating here is he's sad. He's lamenting. He just wants to be able to get out of this. You know, like what we said in the first episode was what's unique about Job is he's not trying to bargain with God to take the suffering away. That's what all the other theodysies do. They're trying to find a way to give something to the gods that get them out of this. I wish I knew what the gods wanted so that they would take this away. Yeah. He's just like, God's given me this lot. How about he just give me the rest of it and give me death as well. And he's willing to receive any gift from God, even death. Yeah. And that's so different than the pagan reality where they want to escape pain, suffering and death. That's very. Job's like, I would receive even death from the Lord. Yeah. And he wants that so much and his friends are trying to keep him from that. Yes. And what I find interesting is, you know, the whole question was, you know, Job's wife wanted Job to curse God. And his friends want him basically to curse himself. And in this lament of laments, Job does neither. He laments in a way that he curses. He does curse, but he curses the day of his birth. And I find that interesting and specific because in doing so, he doesn't curse himself the image of God. That could be, you know, a cursing of God incorrectly. And it's what his friends, quotes, friends end up doing and trying to find fault in him. But he just curses the day of his birth. Like, yes, this is such a tragedy that it's a fall from Eden as a word, but it's not a fall from grace or a fall from God. Yeah. Even though he laments what he had with God. And that's from the very end. But I just find it interesting that he does in his crying and his, I am sad. I wish I were never born. That's not cursing himself, per se. That's just cursing a day and wanting it to vanish. And yes, by implication, that means Job is not there, but he does not curse his being. Yeah. And so I find that just an interesting place that Job goes when he cries out. Yeah. And so then Ella Faz, here's all this. And he's the first elder king to speak to Job. And basically, he's like, I can't help myself, but respond to you because Ella Faz somehow takes offense to what Job is limiting. Because he hears Job cursing the day of his birth, lamenting, but not repenting as the problem. Because he's saying, oh, this is terrible. Oh, this is bad. And Ella Faz is like, look, man, the arguments right there in front of you, you're suffering because you've sinned. So you need to repent. You need to confess your sin and turn to the Lord. And this will go away. You don't need to like be moving towards the realm of the dead and ask God to finish the job. You need to take this as a sign that you're in sin and you need to turn around and repent. You're wicked. But you sound like you're saying, oh, what was me? I'm innocent. I've done nothing wrong, even though Job hasn't said that yet. Ella Faz takes that as like an inference to Job's lament. And this is what kicks off the whole cycle of the argument is the kings, these friends bring in something to the situation that Job himself has not brought in yet. And that is that Job, you can't be innocent and be suffering. Yeah. And the indictment at the very beginning that kind of, when you notice that it tees you up for how they're using true things against Job because Ella Faz begins with using Job's virtues, Chopes could character against him in a way that he's lying. like how the mighty of fallen in a sense. So, Elephaz in chapter four, verse three says, "Think how you instructed many, how you have strengthened feeble hands. Your words have supported those who stumbled. You have strengthened faltering knees. But now trouble comes to you and you are discouraged. The way he's using Job's past reputation is actually against him. Because in a sense, Elephaz is lamenting that Job has fallen from grace. It's kind of like it would be another way of saying, and we've heard these speeches and stories and movies before. Like, you are such a good man. You have done so much good. I trusted you. I knew you have helped me in very hard times. And it's, you know, talking to like a fallen character or someone who thought they felt like, oh, I, this was all an act that you've made me believe in things like that. So, he's using Job's good reputation in a way that is negative, in a way that's enditing him of like, but all this time you had this behind you or you had this. That's right. I thought you were innocent. I thought you were exemplary. Yes. But the suffering has revealed there must be something wicked in you. Exactly. And which makes it all the worse. Yeah. Because you've been hiding this terrible sense, you know, behind this veil of innocence when God has utterly exposed you as a sinner. Because look at everything he's taken from you. You must be so wicked for all this to happen. It's very sad. And it's the typical tactic of the enemy to use, yes, your sin against you, but your virtue against you too. Because, oh, you've sinned one time and oh my gosh, you call yourself a Christian is. So I think it's important here to set up what is the underlying, I'm going to use scare quotes here. Thea logical assumption of the friends. I say that because it's logical. And they're presenting it as theological that it's God's logic, it's God's knowledge, but it's actually not going to be applied that way. And so what we see here in verse seven of chapter four is the underlying theological assumption of the friends. And that is think now who that was innocent ever perished or where were the upright cut off. As I have seen those who plow iniquity and so trouble reap the same is answers very clear. His worldview is very clear. If you're suffering, you are guilty. If you're guilty, you reap what you sow. If you're innocent, you're going to thrive. If you're guilty, you're going to suffer. You get what you put in. Yeah, that's called affirming the consequent, which is a fallacy. The ground might be wet, but it might not be because of rain. That's right. So you could be right in saying the ground is wet because it's raining, but you can't necessarily make the claim that it's raining because it is true that Job is suffering. Yes, that is the consequent, but it's not necessarily true that Job has sinned. Yeah, or that's the consequent. Yes, yes. Yes. So there's black and white quid pro quo, the evil get evil and the good get good is they're both true, but not always. That's right. And then we hear not only that this is his logical worldview, but we do learn that it is his theological worldview because he, like a lot of other Theodicy texts, receives this information from a spirit. Yeah, we see LF has speak on behalf of a spirit, or he recounts a time when a spirit revealed truth to him. Yeah, in like a vision of the night. Yeah, which is, yeah, just a chilling thing to imagine. Like I remember reading that for the first time, and just being like, what? Yeah, but it's, yeah, it's him basically describing how he got revelation. Yeah. And what that being, what that spiritual being said. Yeah, and that windy argument, that spiritual argument is going to continue throughout. And it is a picture of the satanic accusations that were present in the heavenly council coming down onto earth. And now the friends are full on repeating the lies of the accuser to Job, and maybe even prophetically in a sense that he has heard from a spirit like the satan and is passing on this demonic wisdom to Job. Yeah, just because your spiritual person doesn't mean you're hearing from the Holy Spirit. Yeah, right. There are other spirits you can hear from. Yes, the devil is a spirit. You need to be more specific. Yeah. And so appealing to a spiritual authority or spiritual source is universal for every, every ritual because as Job shows, and as we know from experience, though world is, you know, it's a porous world. The crowd is porous world. Yeah, the scene and unseen come together all the time. And so when you come in with the Holy Spirit, that is one thing. And Paul is adamant that you come in with only the Holy Spirit and not others in a certain way. And so we see this earthly council parallel to heavenly council. We do. And here is really importantly what the spirit says to him. And you're going to see this line repeated throughout the argument of Job. Yeah, we're going to see it in chapter four, verses 16 and 17. This form comes before his eyes. And there was this silence and then he heard a voice. And here's what this spirit voice said to him, quote, can mortals be righteous before God? Can humans be pure before their maker? Now, this is why it's such a good lie. Because I think a lot of us would say, no, they can't. And even Job later is going to say, no, I can't. I'm not saying that if I was before the Almighty God that by comparison, I would be righteous before him. That by level of purity, I would match him. I'm not saying that I never says that. That's what we mean in the true way of using this is compared to God. Are we righteous? Compared to God are we pure? No. Yeah. But that's not how the Satan, how the accuser, how Elephaz is applying it. He's saying can mortals be righteous before God? Can any human be innocent to God? Can God hold any human as blameless? Can God hold any human as pure? And we already know the answer to that question is emphatically yes. Because God himself said to the Satan, said to Elephaz in a sense on the earthly realm, hey, have you considered my servant Job? He's blameless and upright. So can a human be blameless to God? Yeah. And it's Job. And we know it's Job. And so that's the lie that's going to get perpetrated throughout the rest of these arguments here. Yeah. It's using truth and twisting it in a way that leads it to an extreme or never meant to conclude, which we saw at the very beginning in the garden. That's right. Did God really say you should not eat fruit from any tree in the garden? He just made the one tree exclusion an extreme universal wall. Oh, if you can't eat from one tree, you can't eat from any tree. What? It's a tactic of the enemy to turn one thing into an extreme and thereby twisting the truth of it. Wow. Yeah. My brain is filling with versions like like ways that that's happened. Yeah. That's I'm going to leave those unsaid though. I'll let everyone think about it. And then he goes, what you need to be doing, Job, is you need to take this as an opportunity to repent. Is you need to be shown that you're not as innocent as you think and that you're suffering this way because God's trying to show you that there's something you need to repent of. And so Job responds and he doesn't immediately address the accusation that he's not innocent. He doesn't immediately jump on this idea that no, no, no, I am innocent. Trust me. He just kind of keeps lamenting right off the bat and continues to have this underworld desire to go to the grave. And we get a little bit more information around it that he has been fenced in by God. Yeah. We talked about the hedge thing being also equivocal or possibly could go both ways. And Job is entertaining this right now of like your protection of my life is not something I'm experiencing as a blessing. Yeah. I want to go to Hades to be with you. Yeah. And what's fascinating there is Job doesn't necessarily. But we know that God has put a hedge of protection around his soul in a sense around his life force that he must be kept alive. But Satan could do any number of torturous things to him. And yet God would keep him alive through it. And he's like, God, could you please just let go of my life because I feel like with all these afflictions, I should be dead. Like, let me die. But you're holding on to my life force and keeping me alive in this horrible situation. And I know it feels like protection, but it kind of feels like a prison. And so he's asking God to kind of just go ahead and take the hedge of protection all the way off so that he can go into the underworld, go into Hades where there's relief from that. And then he can meet God in different terms away from all the suffering. So this is where we get the development of what he was lamenting in chapter three or why he wants to go to the underworld here. He kind of flushes it out. He says, oh, that I might have my request that God would grant what I hope for, that God would be willing to crush me to let loose his hand and cut me off. Then I would still have this consolation, my joy and unrelenting pain, that I had not denied the words of the Holy One. So Job is saying, basically, I just want to die with my integrity intact and then have you there. Like, I'm holding on to my integrity because I'm holding on to you. and these accusers are not doing me any good right now. - No, they're not. He's like, "Okay, you guys are supposed to be friends to me, "have become absolute calamity to me." He said, "You should just be here comforting me, "but then in chapter six, verses 22 and 23, "he's like, "Look, I haven't gathered you guys around here "to say, "Hey, help me fix this situation. "Would you figure out what offering I could offer to God "to make this right, to give him some kind of bribe, "to get him to stop killing me? "I'm happy for God to give me whatever he wants. "God gives, God takes away, blessed me the name of the Lord. "Even if he gives me death, blessed me the name of the Lord, "I'm not trying to get out of the situation "in terms of like paying God off. "And you're trying to get me to repent of something "I haven't done so I could come back to the land of the living. "I'd rather maintain my integrity and go to the land of the dead." - Yes. - And so he's like, "You guys are trying to fix a problem. "I'm not trying to fix." - Yeah, in fact, Job never called these people over too. So he's like, "I never asked for you to come here. "He never says that too though, but we see that "in Job's lament, which is such a fascinating thing "in chapter three, but chapters one through three "set so much up for us that I think is helpful to keep in mind. "And then the fact that Job just laments, "and again, he doesn't ask for answers or for help. "He's just, he's cursing that day of his birth "and is extremely sad and wishes he were in the underworld "in a more peaceful council and a more peaceful place. "And then Elefaz, Bill Daz and so far, "decided to turn this into an argument "about let's find out how Job's in, "which is not how you go and comfort a sufferer to begin with, "but also just something to mention here "as we talk about how Job talks and how his friends talk. "It's very interesting to note how his friends, "Elefaz, Bill Daz and so far, "have a lot to say about God. "They have theology to unpack for him. "Job answers them, but he always speaks to God. "Job turns his lament, his discourse. "To God, he turns his words into prayer, "which I think is just a good rule of thumb." - Yeah, Job speaks to God, the friends speak for God. - Yes. - Yes. - Okay. - And Job is the one who is vindicated in the end, so that's a nugget for me to tuck away. - Yeah, that's a really good nugget. - I want to be talking to God and not about him, yeah. - And so, but Job does eventually respond to the accusation of his friend in chapter 7, verse 20, because Elefaz says, "You must be sinning "because this horrible stuff is happening to you." And Job ends up saying, "Look, if I sin, "what do I do to you, the watcher of humanity? "Why have you made me your target? "Why have I become a burden to you? "Why do you not pardon my transgression "and take away my iniquity?" And so he's saying, "If I did sin, "what does that do to God that would cause him "to bring all these horrible things to me?" - Yeah, so Job is pushing on the quid pro quo things, like, "Oh, God has to respond to us in "in a certain way." - That's right. - And that's why I'm suffering this way. No, first of all, I did not do that. And too, even if I did, your argument doesn't hold up because God doesn't have to do that. - No. - What is man, and this is where it's interestingly similar to Psalm 8 in the Psalms, because David has this song about, well, what is man that you're mindful of? He man is so small, and it's this-- - Can't believe you think about me. - Yeah, you think about me. You made us lower than the angels, but you crown us, and it's a beautiful song. I love that song. But the tone there is one of awe and admiration. You care so much. And here, Job is talking about the same reality, but saying the other side of the coin is that we are indeed insignificant, and we literally can't do anything to God to change him. - Right. - So that translates into, even if I did do something, God doesn't have to treat me this way. My actions have no bearing on God. - Yeah, I can't affect God, and I can't rouse him to something. He can choose to be roused. - Yes. - But my sin doesn't just make God crush me. - Yeah, yeah. - And so your quid pro quo way that God works is just, it breaks, you have the wrong view of man. You're like, oh, can man be righteous before God? Oh, how is that possible? We're so small, we're mortal, he's immortal. It's like, okay, take that logic and apply it to my sin. - Yeah. - Can the sin of a human entice God to anger? - Not the creator God. Not in the way that you are trying to self. - Yeah, the pagan gods get uptight about humans doing almost nothing. They, yeah, it's like, she's prettier than me. I have to turn her into a spider. It's like, they are so insecure, the pagan gods, that it's, 'cause, yeah, they are capricious, they are insecure, you do the wrong formula, you don't cook, they're dinner right and they are mad, you know, and they also don't tell you how they like it. There's all this magic that has to happen and all this appeasement and you're awesome, you know, we love you, we are definitely the greatest there ever was, no one can beat you, right? And there's all this flattery that goes on towards the gods, and Job is basically saying, I can't flatter God and I can't offend him. He's immune to that, he's a creator, he's not at my back in call, nor am I so significant to him that I can take him off. - Right. - I don't have that power. - He's above that. - Which is such good news. - It's such good news. - I can't make God angry. - Well, okay, so then Bill Dad comes in in chapter eight and responds with, does God pervert justice? - So again, it's taking that truth to an extreme. And, you know, in an argument with, or in a discussion with friends about this and saying, well, are you saying God never punishes sin? - No. - No, that's definitely not what he said. - Or God can't or shouldn't punish sin. - Yeah, that God can't be angry with sin? - Like, let's get out of the mind of God. Let's get out of the mind of God and not pretend we know what he does and does not do. But that's not what I was saying and that's not what the argument is about, basically. - Yeah, and so then, so he's like, he brings in this idea, again, this accusation, again, that for Job to maintain his innocence while suffering, they believe he must be accusing God of injustice, of mismanaging his universe. - Yeah, it's refusing to hold that tension. - That's right, God is good. - That's what suffering doesn't exist. - Yeah, basically. - It still does point. - Yeah. - And so much so that he throws one of the first really harsh blows. - This one hurts. - In this argument, in verse four of chapter eight, if your children sinned against him, he delivered them into the power of their transgression. - Ow. - Yeah, he's like-- - Never say that to a grieving parent, ever. - No, he's saying, "Bill dad, the jerk says, "Oh, Job, you want to know why your kids died?" It's because they sinned. It's like-- - It's so cruel. - It's so cruel. - What Bill dad does differently is, from Elifaz, is that Elifaz accused Job of sin and then Bill dad says, "Well, your kids sinned, that's why they died." - That's why it happened. - And yeah. - First of all, that's just horrible. And he also appeals to an authority, that this is how the world works. This is how we've seen it. This is how we've observed it. This is how the spirits reveal reality to us, and it's very sad. - Yeah, Bill dad basically says, "You've reputged you so." - Yeah. - They think about it. And this is from verse 11, "Can Papyrus grow where there is no marsh? "Can reeds flourish where there is no water?" He's saying, "Look, I'm seeing the fruit "of suffering in your life. "So where there's fruit of suffering, "there's got to be wickedness, "because suffering only grows in the fields of wickedness." - Yeah, there's proof in the pudding. - The proof is in the pudding. This is happening to you because you've done something wrong. - This is also kind of inditing Job's own priesthood, or assuming that you can't intercede or cover over the sins of others. Like it's kind of messing with the whole sacrificial system, pagan or otherwise. - That's all right, 'cause we're told early in the story that Job offered sacrifices for his children, even if maybe possibly they sinned accidentally. - Yes. - And so as the priest of his kingdom, he's saying, "Your kids sinned "and you were unable to intercede for them." - Yeah. - You're a bad priest. Your priesthood and intercession didn't work. Probably because your wicked, and so God didn't accept your wicked sacrifices on behalf of your children. Luckily for Bill Dad, he's wrong. - He is wrong. - 'Cause Job will be able to pray for him. - Yeah, at the end of the book, God is going to tell Job to be a righteous intercessor for these three friends. And so he's gonna need the one whose intercession he says failed on behalf of his children. He's gonna need it. So. - God is merciful. - God is very merciful. All right, Job responds to this. - So yeah, and it's kind of giving the reverse of what he said earlier. He said, "My sin can't do anything to God, but my innocence also can't make God do anything. What you are attacking doesn't really hold water." And that's not what I want anyway. I'm innocent, and I want my life to be over. - Yeah, that's right. In verse 14 of chapter nine, he says, "How can I answer him choosing my words with him, though I am innocent, I cannot answer him. I must appeal to my judge for my right." He's like, "I'm not saying my sin can't do anything to God, I can't cause him to punish me, but my blamelessness also can't cause him to bless me." - Yeah, he doesn't owe me anything. - God doesn't owe me anything. Lord gives, Lord takes away, bless me the name of the Lord. I am innocent, but that also doesn't mean that he owes me a blessing. - Yes. - It's not how the world works. And so, he's willing to hold both. - That's convincing. - Yeah. - It's like, it's the older brother thing. - It's the older brother. - I've been with you. - I'll this time I've served you without complaint, and you haven't given. me. And we're talking about the older brother in Luke 15 and Jesus paraphroned. But it's the, yeah, one of the two. And I so often think, well, if I've done all these things, what good is innocence or what good is a being God if I don't get what I want, which is poking on this thing of why are you obeying God? Is it to get something out of that? We do it out of obedience because God does say you do these things and life will be long for you and that's good. And you'll have these good things. But it's not an automatic, which is what's so uncomfortable about it, too, because we want to point to this verse that says, God said, if I do these things, life will go well for me. And then we look at another place in Scripture where something like brothers betraying Joseph happens and he gets thrown into a sister and then he is falsely accused and thrown into jail. And all these things happen to him that he did not deserve. I'm like, how can we hold all these things together? And this is why I'm so thankful for the Bible doing that because it lets us wrestle with it. And Job is doing the same thing. And he's making the case here that my obedience doesn't give me points with God that I can cash in for some kind of blessing. That's not how this works. This isn't a transactional relationship. And it's not a cause and effect like you are putting it forward. Build that in all of us. Yeah. And so far responds to that in chapter 11 and saying, okay, Job, you say, this is 11 for my conduct is pure. And I am cleaning God's sight. But you should know, Job, that what you're suffering right now isn't even half of what you actually deserve. So far kind of blows past Job's claim for innocence and says, that doesn't exist. Your suffering it proves your wicked. And in fact, you're even more wicked than you think because as bad as you're suffering is, you deserve far worse. It's again so mean, but it's also so tricky because it's presenting God and what makes him appear to be immensely merciful. God is so merciful to Job. He's not even punishing you for half a reason. He's forgotten some of the sins. But what does that make Job out to be doubly as wicked as what he actually is looking like he's suffering? Like if this is actually only the half measure of what Job justly deserves, that indicts him even more. And it presents God's mercy in a light that is just oh, yeah, I've heard it said when people ask about suffering, like, why is this happening to me? And it's like, oh, you shouldn't even be alive right now. But because of God's mercy, he's letting you live. And your suffering isn't even the worse you should be thrown into hell right now. And you should be suffering so much worse, it's a mercy that you're alive and allowed to suffer. And I've heard people say that. It's so sad and not true. It's not true. And even if it were, why would you say that? Yeah, it's right. It's like if someone is grieving the loss of their child and you say, well, you actually deserve he'll be happy. You only lost a child is just my stomach turns at the fact that I just said that it's it's absolutely heinous. It's not how you should treat people. It's not how God treats people. Yeah. And Job responds to all of this by basically saying to his friends, guys, you've not told me anything that I already don't know. It's all these half truths that they're applying in the wrong way. He's like, guys, look, I know that God orders his universe in a good way. I know he can punish the wicked. I know that the wicked fall into traps that they set for themselves. I know that God loves to bless the righteous and uphold them. I know that we're not treated for what we deserve that God's merciful. I know all of this. You guys have said nothing. I don't already know. But what you're missing is that I am innocent. Can I poke a hole in your argument here? And he does this in chapter 12 versus 5 to 6. He starts showing how, look, God doesn't always punish evil. It doesn't always happen the way that you lay it out to be. The world isn't as mechanistic as you want it to be. And that doesn't mean that God's doing something wrong. Yes. He acknowledges the two squares that we already can fill with plenty of examples of God. Good things happen to good people and bad things happen to bad people. And he shows that. And also what is also common knowledge that you guys are not acknowledging right now is that good things happen to bad people too. There are evil doers who prosper. There is innocent blessing. There is wicked suffering. Those are the two boxes you guys are content with. But don't forget there's this third box that there is wicked blessing. There's wicked prosperity. And if there's wicked prosperity, can't that mean that there's innocent suffering? And he turns it kind of slightly on. It's like, how will it turn out of God examines you? You wealthy. You guys aren't suffering. You guys are, you know, he's kind of like, how will it turn out if he puts you under the microscope and examines your ways? You guys are prospering right now. And sometimes God lets the evil prosper. Like he's, he's really is. Yeah. Oh, you guys are the prospering ones. Maybe you're evil. Yeah. Yeah. Just making the point again that affirming these three options, even just the two that Job's friends are comfortable with does not disprove Job's case. It does not disprove Job's innocence. Yes, that's right. And that's a Job keeps harping. And so finally, we get here at the end of the first cycle. Job makes an appeal that's going to kind of define his defense for the rest of the book is that his defense is he wants an audience with God. Chapter 13 verse 18, I have indeed prepared my case. I know that I shall be vindicated. Like his case is, I am innocent. I am suffering. I'm not blaming God. I just want an audience with him because he's the one who actually sees me, knows me. All things are open and available to him. He knows the reality that I am suffering innocently. And I'm not charging God with anything wrong in that. But I do know that though my friends won't vindicate my innocence because I'm suffering, God will. And so he then does this thing that's going to be a consistent theme throughout the rest of his argument. And it goes all the way back to chapter 3 that he again wants to go into shale. He wants to die. And the reason is because he believes that out of the grave will come vindication. And in chapter 14, he equates this idea to a chop down tree where a tree that grows and is flourishing, if it's chopped down, it actually can still be alive because it's roots can go deep into the secret places of groundwater underneath the soil. And it can continue to resprout and to leaf. And he's like, I too, if I'm buried in the ground, God can raise me up from that place like a tree and vindicate me even out of the grave. This can also be seen as why Job wants to go to the grave so much because over against Job's friends who do not want him to go to the grave because they see death as the ultimate punishment. They say you need to do what you need to do to avoid the grave. So repent before you die. And all these are like repent because you sin, repent because God's still holding out a chance for you to repent. All these things and all of this in order to avoid judgment as they would say. And Job is here saying in 13, though he slain me, I will hope. I am not cut off from God by going into heaven. He's like, she would hide me from all this suffering and all this wrath. And it would all pass over. And then God would set an appointed time after I'm in shield. And he would remember me. Then maybe I could live again like this chop down tree. Yeah. It's crazy to think that this is such an old book. And there is such a developed view of a final day of vindication and judgment after death, like some kind of resurrection life after death. It does make it unique. I don't know if I could go surprise, just call it developed. But there is something in Job that is hoping for a God whose vindication transcends even the grave, which is another way of kind of saying what we were saying. I'm just like we get shadows of this hope that again makes Job an apt reading for Holy Week where we talk about this. All right, we know how resurrection is a vindication and even how the cross itself is a vindication. And it's it's crazy. But yeah, Job is like he wants to go down to the grave because there he will be at peace and his integrity intact and his relationship with God intact. And I do not think of the grave that way all the time. Yeah, I don't either. But that is in a sense the first cycle that Job wants to die innocently so that God can vindicate him even from the grave. His friends want him to admit that he's guilty, repent, and stay in the land of the living. And that is the first cycle. Yes. And so as the second cycle starts with Elephaz again, remember it's going to start over again with Elephaz and build that and so far with Job interjecting in between and defending his innocence. It starts to pick up intensity and it starts to take on a character that was kind of absent in the previous one where in the previous one they're like Job your guilty, you clearly are suffering so you must have done something wrong. Repent. Now repentance kind of drops out and they're just trying to prove that he is wicked and that his suffering feels it. That's right. Yeah, there's a development of just indictment I guess and they're still insisting he repent but the emphasis shifts to you are wicked. And Elephaz here starts to question Job stance at all. He's like you keep maintaining this innocent suffering and he brings up something thing that is kind of funny. He's like, what are you basically the first person who ever existed? Are you the wisest of us all? Are you the eldest human that has ever been born? That you know that there's this category of innocent suffering, that all the rest of us elders and spirit-filled people can't ascertain. You clearly, Job, know that there's this category that exists, and then he starts to parade out more evidence to that fact. Beginning with what he heard from the spirit, he repeats it again. So, Elephaz said it from the spirit's mouth. Now he says it again in chapter 15 verse 14, what are mortals that they can be clean or those born of women that they can be righteous? And he ratchets it up in verse 15 saying, "God puts no trust even in His holy ones." Right, I'm guessing that's the celestial realm. - Yeah, they're referring to the divine counsel there. That again, making a distinction that Job takes for granted and is never questioning, but they keep insisting that Job's claim threatens that other one that, well, Job, you are slandering God by saying you're innocent and God can't even consider seraphim innocent. So, what makes you think you are? - Yeah, I'm saying even the heavens aren't clean to him. And what Elephaz is doing is he's making a correct statement in that compared to the glory of Yahweh, the heavens are unclean. Compared to the glory of. - Scripture says that elsewhere. - Yeah, compared to the glory of Yahweh, the angels, the seraphim, the chairbeer, or nothing. What then are you born of woman, O Adam, O man, O dust, O dirt, O clay? You're nothing. - Yeah. - So how can you say that you're innocent? Just do the comparative analysis and you'll see that you're not clean in any way that could justify you before God. And the problem with this argument is that's not what Job's trying to do. He's not saying that he's comparatively good to God, comparatively glorious, comparatively holy, comparatively blameless, that's not what he's saying. What he is saying is that he has not done sin that has gone unrepented for or unclinsed or anything that actually tit for tat warrants what is happening to him, that the retributive principle doesn't apply to his situation, that God's not treating him according to his actions here. It's another tactic of the enemy to accuse you of doing something it is doing. Job is sad and just wants to be Job. He's not asking these big questions. He's sad, he's lamenting, he's asking to be in the grave so he can be in peace. And then the friends say, "Job, you're guilty." Or you're sinful. Job never was entertaining that. And he's like, "No, I'm not." And he's like, "Well, they are saying God is unjust or God is unclean." And Job was like, "No, I'm not saying any of those things." You can't even draw that conclusion. But they're logic of the logic of their worldview and the logic the accuser is enforcing on Job is demanding that Job be culpable of something without letting Job simply just be Job and be sad. So that's what I mean. - And then Eliphaz parades out even more evidence from verses 20 to 35 in chapter 15, basically just showing, "Hey, the wicked suffer." Let me just tell you all about it. The wicked rye then pain all their days through all their years that are laid up for the ruthless. Like it just goes on and on for 15 verses eloquently talking about how the wicked suffer. And so by implication, what he's saying is if the wicked suffer and you're suffering, then you're wicked. - Yeah. And that's kind of what the whole second cycle looks like. Build ad will make that point as well. And I think so far makes that point too that when they talk about how God punishes evil doers, they kind of began to describe Job's situation and Job himself head to toe. - Yes, that is kind of indicative of the second cycle. They're like, "Hey, these things happen to the wicked. "Is it build ad who does that?" - Build ad is like, you're basically the textbook example of what happens to evil doers. - That's what they've seen, right? Or he's like, is that the more he's like, "You know what happens to the land of the wicked? "Marauders come and destroy their land." That's exactly what happened to Job. There's other things that he says, right? - Yeah, he has no offspring or descendants among his people, no survivor where once he lived. Men of the West are appalled at his fate. Men of the Easter seized with horror. And he's describing Job. - That's what the wicked are like, Job. - Yeah. - It would be like, and Christine, I mean none of this, but you know, and you guys can't see her right now, but I would be like, you know what the wicked are like, Christine, they have blonde hair. They're sitting in front of a microphone with a white shirt on smiling awkwardly at me with earrings in. And like, I'm describing Christine, but she's like, wait a second, that's me. That's what Bill Dad's doing in his section. - And I would say, David, you're right. (laughing) - And then how does so far kind of pick up on that in his cycles? Well, just kind of lumping all the guys together here in their arguments and now jumping to chapter 20. - Job refutes both and just sing again like, you guys are terrible friends, and I just want an audience with God basically. And he even kind of pokes back, he's like the evil mock me. So he sort of throws it back at them. That, okay, you can describe me as wicked, but God, evil people are mocking me. I'm surrounded by evil neighbors. He doesn't say it that starkly, but he's also just not being comforted by these accuser friends. And so he continues to hold onto his innocence insisting that while God is treating him like an enemy, he is not punishing him. - Yeah, my face is red with weeping and deep darkness is on my eyelids. Though there is no violence in my hands and my prayer is pure. That's 16, 16 to 17. He's holding onto his innocence, holding onto that, he's suffering and not accusing of God of any baddoing. And in fact, trusting in that God for his vindication, he looks in 16, 18 to 19, which is right after what I just read. He says, "O earth, do not cover my blood. Let my outcry find no resting place. Even now, my witness is in heaven and my advocate is on high." He knows that the God who sees everything will vindicate him, even though his friends refuse to entertain that such a vindication is even possible. - Yeah, especially not after death. Again, they're trying to pull Job out of the grave. He's so desires to lay himself into because they want Job to repent so he can get his life back. And Job is wanting God back. And wanting to be vindicated. And that's very, very acutely stated, very starkly for the Old Testament, especially for the oldest book we have. - In chapter 19. - In chapter 19, when he responds to, build ed. He, and again, he always turns it back to God. He has more words to God than his friends do, who insist that they know a lot about God. But he, you want to read that? - Yes, chapter 19, verse 23. Oh, that my words are written down. Oh, that they were inscribed in a book. Oh, that with an iron pen and with lead, they were engraved on a rock forever. For I know that my vindicator or my redeemer lives and that in the end, he will stand upon the earth. And after my skin has been destroyed, then in my flesh, I shall see God, whom I shall see on my side, and my eyes shall be hold, and not another. - This is one of the most beautiful things I've ever written. God is written with an iron pen. I'm glad I was written in a book like he requested. - Yeah, it's really beautiful. And also that amount of trust, I feel like is also kind of, I don't want to say proof, but that's a very strong argument for Job's innocence. If he's like, God will buy me out of the grave, and I long for that to happen, is definitely not someone who is harboring Simpson. - No, and I think you could make an argument, and I don't know if anybody has, I haven't looked at critical scholarship on this exact idea, but you could probably make the argument that this is poetic exaggeration, that put me in the grave and I'll be vindicated. That's how innocent I am, is that not even the grave and death would reveal something wrong in me. However, I do think Job actually does want to meet God through the grave and trust that there will be a vindicator on the other side. - Yeah, and he trusts in a vindicator or redeemer who buys him out of the grave, meaning gives him his body back. - Yeah, he says, my skin, my flesh, I'm gonna be destroyed. But then in my flesh, I will see God with eyes. - Yes, yes, which is just fascinating. - A reconstituted mortality, a reconstituted humanity. - People haven't gone down into the grave and come back out. There, you could make a case that I could bypass the grave altogether, and that's why he's alive and with God, but everyone who's died, rests with their fathers in the grave. And so, him saying, no, I will go down into the grave and then I'll be bought out of it is so explicitly a resurrection claim and hope that it, I don't know, I don't know where to put it, but it's beautiful. And I know what it points to, and I'm just amazed at Job had, this kind of trust in his innocence and in his God, which obviously reminds me of someone who went down to the grave completely innocent and was vindicated. - Yeah, into your hands, I commit my spirit. Yeah, people couldn't believe that Jesus was the innocent, chosen, righteous, vindicator of Israel sent from God because of how he died. No one who died by crucifixion could possibly be the chosen, holy one of God. - No one who dies by crucifixion could possibly be glorified. That is the epitome of shame, the textbook example of shame. - There's no vindication from a cross. A false Messiah is going on, and Jesus was surrounded by accusers who had all sorts of fabricated accusations. Surely he did this wrong. No, he did that wrong, and other testimonies agreed. And Jesus did not answer those accusers. And then even after his resurrection coming back from the grave, he walks with some of his disciples on the road to Emmaus and they're repeating that same conundrum that we thought he was the one who could redeem Israel, but he died. He fell because he died. And he goes, "Oh, you slow of heart to believe all the law in the prophets." And Job spoke it. Was it not necessary that the Christ would suffer these things and then enter into his glory? We don't like to make suffering necessary for glory, but that's what Jesus showed. Yeah, trusting God to vindicate you in innocent suffering is part of following Jesus. Yeah. And Peter talks about this too that suffering is a crucible. It's something that purges out the evil in you. You can suffer for doing evil, but that's not what's commendable to God. It's suffering for doing right. And Jesus did that for us or showed that. He was an example of that, that though they hurled insults at him, he did not open his mouth. He was led like a sheep to the slaughter. And he entrusted himself to him who judges justly. And that's what Job does here, even unto death and resurrection. We see Job trust God and hold on to his integrity unto death. But now Job is saying something we haven't seen him. Say this explicitly before, which is, "I'm going to rise from the dead." But so far, it pushes back on this in chapter 20, and he goes, "Look, eventually everything good that the evil has is going to rot, and in fact, you can't even escape God's judgment even in the grave, because, sure Job, you might die, but guess who pays for a wicked person's evil once they've passed away, their children, said to a man who's now childless, which is so wicked." Again, horrific, but also, so far, seems to make the opposite case that Job just made with redemption, because how do you live forever? How do you live after the grave? It's through your children. And so far, as essentially saying, "No, your flesh that is alive after you die will not escape God's judgment, or will not be vindicated. They will pay, they your children will pay for the evil that you committed." And that's how God's going to get you, which to its Job responds, "How does it affect a dead person if their children are punished?" They are dead. They don't care. Let me read those two. So, chapter 20, verse 10, this is so far as claim, "Their children will seek the favor of the poor, and their hands will give back their wealth. Their bodies, once full of youth, will lie down in the dust with them. Your children are going to be beggars, and they're going to die." And then Job replies in chapter 21, verse 19, and says, "You say God stores up their iquity for their children, let it be paid back to them so that they may know it, let their own eyes see their destruction, and let them drink the wrath of the Almighty. Or what do they care for their household after them when the number of their months has cut off? What does it do to a dead man and sheel if their children are suffering? It doesn't affect them. He's unaware of it." Yeah, that's not something that is going to directly affect the man. That doesn't come to him. That would come on his children and not the man. Although Job's not doing this, he's like, "That might be injustice." That's not what we're talking about here. He is just pointing out the errors in so far's logic here that that can't hold up and you know why and let me show you. The evil doers are spared from the day of wrath all the time. That's kind of how he finishes it, right? That they go down to the grave in full vigor of life. Yeah, he's saying like, "Oh, you think that death and vengeance of God upon the evil doer is inevitable? What about the fat, happy robbers who live a great life stealing from people and die without any justice being done to them? You've got to have some sense of understanding that there's beyond the grave vindication in the world." Yeah. There are tyrants who prosper and go to the grave piece of it. Yeah, sheal is not a redeemer. It's not. No. It's not a vindicator in that sense or not always. This was a case of the righteous suffer, I think, too, where he's responding to his friend and kind of lamenting that I'm getting poorer and poorer by all my libations to my God that is just not doing me any good here. But there are empires and evil doers that are robbing and pillaging and making themselves rich by all of this evil that they are doing. Why am I suffering the way I am when I am doing the right things when they are prospering? So he kind of points to that same argument and makes points to that same square again. Good things happen to evil people all the time and that kind of ends the second cycle. Yeah. Job, you're totally wicked and you're suffering proves it. Get over it. That's what's happening. This is no longer a corrective. You are clearly in the wrong here. And Job continues to defend his innocence. He now starts to develop his own case that a vindicator will get him even from the grave and that God is good in all of it. So then we start the third cycle, which is the strange one in that it breaks the pattern. While a phasal start, Job will retort. Bill Dad will come in but with his shortest ever, very, very short and then Job will retort and then instead of Zofar coming in, this will lie who wins up and starts blowing hot wind everywhere. Yeah. And he is so interesting because he supposedly speaks up when no one has anything left to say, but we haven't heard from Zofar. So I just, yeah, I don't know what to do with that. Yeah. And it could be with Bill Dad's answer getting so short that they're running out of things to say. A few of them, yeah. With Zofar not responding, it's like, and they couldn't respond anymore. It was over. And so the youngest speaks up. And so Ella Phas comes in in chapter 22. This is where he makes the case that if Job does repent, he will be such a good intercessor he can save wicked people with his prayers. It's so ironic. He's like, you know, repent and then you'll be so great that you can save the wicked and it's exactly what he's going to do at the end of the story. He's going to intercede for his wicked friends. But this third cycle is the most belligerent of them all. And this is where Ella Phas just full on kind of accuses Job of. A horrible thing. You exact it pledges from your family for no reason and strip them naked of their clothing. You have given no water to the weary to drink and you have withheld bread from the hungry. The powerful possessed the land and the favored live in it. You have sent widows away, empty handed, and the arms of the orphans you have crushed. He just starts making up accusations against Job because he's at the point where he is saying in his own logic, Job has to be guilty of such horrible things because of what's happened to him. And it doesn't matter if I've seen it or not, it doesn't matter if I can't prove it or not, his suffering proves it and that's enough. Yeah. His accusation just turns into ad hoc and a very self-eating way, which actually gives Job, I don't want to say a checkmate, but a very pointed move because Ella Phas just admitted that Job was oppressing widows and weak and hungry people. And so Job picks up in 23 and 24, saying, "Okay, what did the widow do to be comable widow?" Yeah, what did the orphan do when he was born as a baby to be orphaned? Yeah. So he deserved to be orphaned for being born, like, what's your system doesn't system? Your system doesn't exist. It doesn't work. Yeah, you keep insisting that my suffering is because I'm evil, but then there's, you just listed a bunch of victims that I supposedly have. Well, why are they victims? Did they commit evil? Is that why they are victims? Yeah, but it is interesting. He's like, "Job, you've been doing this to the orphan." He's like, "Okay, fine. Why was I doing it to them if I did?" Like, because they're wicked, like, where does the cycle end? It proves two points. One is that the evil doers get away with wrongdoing because there are people who create innocent victims. Yes. I agree, good things happen to bad people. And as a result, bad things happen to good people. And so in response to that, Bill, that comes in for the friend's last retort, and he basically just repeats the, if I can call it, the satanic argument that Elif has heard in the beginning. It's very short. He's like, "Man, you are defiling God. All things are under his feet. You just need to admit that he is so much bigger than you that you don't stand a chance before him." And then he repeats this line, "How then can mortals be righteous before God? How can one born of woman be pure?" It's again what the accuser does with Job by accusing Job of something that the accuser himself is doing. And that is Job in claiming that you are innocent. You are claiming that you know how God runs a universe. You are mere human. So let me tell you how God runs His universe. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And Job never made any claims to how God runs a universe. He is responding to what his friends are throwing at him, but he was just sad and mourning and asking God to do something. But he wasn't calling God into account at all, and they are accusing him of doing so. That's right. And so here again, Bill, that in his short phrase, again, throws in the creator, creature category that again, Job never questioned or challenged. And he's saying, "You can't know how God works because no one can know how God works." To which it begs the question, "How do you know how God works?" So that's what I mean. but the accuser is again doing what the accuser does so well. - Yeah, the friends are saying, how dare you say that there's this category of innocent suffering, that you're suffering and you don't deserve it, quote unquote, how do you know that God would order a universe in which innocent suffering is a category? We know how God orders it, and it's the right to suffer and the innocent are blessed. And that's how it works. - And the reason they give for that is that, well, God is unknowable in how He does things. So let me tell you how He runs things. - It doesn't work. - It doesn't work. - That's fascinating. - He is interesting than Job in his closing argument does two really big things. One, He kind of makes these huge vows where He goes, God, search me and know me basically. If I have done any of these things that I've been accused of, if I've done any of these sins that would warrant this, I'm right here, show me. Like point it out, I'm here, I'm not hiding, I would never pray this prayer, just to be clear. I would really struggle to pray this prayer, but He's like, if I have defrauded widows, if I have mistreated an orphan, if I have turned away a stranger, if I have not shown hospitality to somebody, I deserve it, let it all happen to me. And He's just showing, like, I am innocent. It's the strongest version of His claim. And then He goes to this idea of responding to His friends saying that you don't know how the world works we do and arguing about it, He then gives this long song about wisdom, about where can it be found? And it's so beautiful, go read it. But it's all about, how can we know how the world works? How can we know where these deep mechanations of the cosmos operate? And the answer is only God knows. - Yeah, and we've already traveled heaven and earth and under the earth. And Job takes us on that multi-tiered journey again of, well, let's search for wisdom. You accuse me of having wisdom or of claiming God does not have wisdom. I know God has all wisdom. And I'm gonna tell you that, in fact, wisdom lies only with God. You can call into the deep in those, and the deep will say, it's not here. You can call here, you can call there. It's not anywhere you can travel to. Wisdom is bound up in God and in God only. - And so Job is saying, I'm not claiming to know why this is happening. But I am claiming to know at least what is happening that I am suffering. I am innocent and God is good. I can claim all those things and not be projecting on the deep knowledge of God as you are, my friends. Wisdom belongs to Him alone. I don't know it, but I do know what is right in front of my eyes. - Whether or not he's a sinner, I did not know, but this I do. I once was blind, but now I see. There's a slandering of both the blind man and Jesus. Like, we know this man is a sinner. He's like, I don't know that, but he couldn't be a sinner because God doesn't listen to sinners. And then they're like, well, you are steeped in sin and birth. How dare you lecture us in this idea? Like, again, people accusing two people who were claimed to be not sinning. Or Jesus obviously is not a sinner. And Jesus at the beginning of the story says, neither this man nor his parents sinned that he deserved this kind of suffering or that this suffering happened to them, but that the glory of God might be made manifest in his life. And that is that forced circle. - Yeah, that is the suffering of him. And the glory of God is made manifest in that. And we see this in Job, especially at the end when God shows up. The glory of God literally is made manifest. And Job is vindicated. And we see that in Jesus' life. - Yes, we do. Jesus, the innocent sufferer goes faithfully into suffering, not because he did anything to warrant it, but trusting God and trusting in the vindication beyond the grave. And in so doing, he brings all human suffering with him into the grave and out the other side in vindication that when we trust that he vindicates the innocent sufferer, we join him in his death and in his resurrection and in his glorious vindication above all things. And that as we contend with suffering, we silence the lies of the accuser that accuse us, that we deserve it, that accuse God that he's done something wrong. And we get to maintain the justice and the righteousness of both man and God as we suffer faithfully and innocently and trustingly in the God who vindicates the innocent, who suffer well. - And Job opens himself up to-- - That kind of scrutiny. - That, yeah, and to the one who does that same thing. - Yeah, it's so good. Okay, well, this has hopefully been the argument of Job and his friends. Next episode, we will pick up with Elihu, who brings one kind of storm, and then God who brings another kind of storm. And we will talk about the hot air of Elihu and the stormy air of the Theophany of God coming to the end of Job. So thank you all so much for joining us and we will see you next time. (upbeat music) - Thank you for listening to the Spoken Gospel Podcast. Spoken Gospel creates short films, devotionals, and podcasts like this one. Everything we make is free because of generous supporters like you. To see our resources, visit SpokenGospel.com or subscribe to our YouTube channel. Thanks for listening. See you next time. (upbeat music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Job is innocent and suffering, a central question in the book that challenges the idea of retributive justice.
  2. Job’s friends accuse him of sin, applying a flawed worldview that assumes suffering equals guilt, despite knowing God’s goodness.
  3. The friends’ arguments are rooted in a pagan, mechanistic logic
  4. Job consistently speaks to God, not about God, emphasizing his integrity and trust in divine vindication, not repentance.
  5. The friends falsely claim divine revelation from spirits, echoing the accuser’s tactics, and distort theological truths to condemn Job.
  6. Job exposes the contradiction in the friends’ logic—good things happen to bad people, and bad things happen to the good—proving innocent suffering is possible.
  7. Job’s desire to go to the grave is not suicidal but a plea for peace and vindication, reflecting a hope in resurrection and divine justice beyond death.
  8. The book ultimately affirms that God’s justice transcends human judgment, and Job’s vindication comes from God, not from the friends' flawed reasoning.

Summary:

The book of Job explores the profound question of whether innocent people can suffer, challenging the common belief that suffering always results from sin. While Job’s friends argue that his suffering proves he has sinned, their reasoning is grounded in a distorted, mechanistic worldview that misapplies biblical truths. They claim divine revelation from spirits, echoing the accuser’s tactics in heaven, and assert that suffering equals guilt, yet they ignore the reality that good people suffer and evil people prosper.

Job resists this logic, consistently turning to God in prayer and lament, affirming his innocence without blaming God. He points out that God’s justice operates beyond retribution, showing that good things happen to the wicked and bad things to the righteous—proving that innocent suffering is a legitimate category. Job’s desire to die and enter the grave is not a sign of despair, but a hopeful plea for vindication after death, reflecting a deep faith in God’s ultimate fairness.

The narrative culminates in the affirmation that God alone can vindicate Job, not his friends, who fail to see the depth of human suffering or the sovereignty of divine justice. This makes Job a powerful theological reflection on suffering, integrity, and the limits of human reasoning—especially relevant to understanding how God’s character remains consistent even in the face of inexplicable pain. The book does not resolve the mystery of suffering but invites readers to trust in a God who sees, judges, and ultimately justifies the innocent.

FAQs

The central question is not whether God is good when people suffer, but whether innocent people can truly suffer.

Job suffers because he is righteous and blameless, and Satan targets him as a test, not because he has sinned.

They argue that suffering always results from sin, claiming that Job must be guilty because he is suffering, and that God's justice demands retribution.

They use true principles like 'the wicked suffer' or 'God punishes evil' but apply them to Job incorrectly, falsely accusing him of sin without evidence.

No, Job never accuses God of injustice. He maintains his innocence and affirms God's goodness, refusing to blame God for his suffering.

The book follows three cycles: Job speaks, a friend responds, Job responds again. Each cycle builds on the previous, becoming more intense and accusatory.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.