Jason Segel is not afraid of the ‘dirty underneath’
from Fresh Air ·
45m 38s
Jason Siegel, nominated for an Emmy for his role in the series *Shrinking*, portrays a therapist named Jimmy who is emotionally unraveling after his wife’s death. The show blends comedy and drama to explore how Jimmy, despite his personal trauma, attempts to help patients by giving them direct, practical advice—mirroring a therapy approach pioneered by real practitioners like Phil Stutz, who emphasize hope and actionable steps over lengthy self-reflection. This method, while controversial, reflects a shift in therapy toward immediate solutions. Siegel draws from his own life experiences with anxiety, OCD, and creative blocks, revealing how his emotional vulnerability and introspection inform both his acting and personal life. His career, spanning *Freaks and Geeks*, *The Muppets*, and *Dispatches from Elsewhere*, consistently centers on emotional authenticity. A key emotional arc involves Jimmy’s strained relationship with his mentor, Harrison Ford’s character, who leaves the practice, leading to a powerful scene where Jimmy confronts his feelings of abandonment and realizes the depth of his own emotional journey. Siegel emphasizes that the show’s success lies in its unflinching honesty—showing the messy, painful truths behind human decisions and relationships. His work illustrates how vulnerability, not perfection, fosters connection, both in character and in real life.
This is Fresh Air. I'm Terry Gross. My guest Jason Siegel is nominated for an Emmy for his leading
role in the series Shrinking. The first three seasons are streaming on Apple TV. When we first
meet his character Jimmy, he's a psychotherapist who's having a nervous breakdown but continues
to work with his patients. Believing he's having a breakthrough as a therapist, he intervenes in
his patients' lives. He gives them inappropriate advice to do things Jimmy believes will change
their lives for the better and prevent them from complaining about the same things week after week
without ever making an effort to fix the problems. The reason Jimmy is falling apart is that his wife
was killed in a car accident a year ago. His teenage daughter is in high school when the
series starts. She accuses him of being so absorbed in his own grief he's emotionally abandoned her
instead of helping her through her grief. Jimmy's mentor and colleague is played by Harrison Ford
who's also nominated for an Emmy for Shrinking.
As is co-star Jessica Williams. Siegel got his first memorable role in Freaks and Geeks.
The characters were high school friends. After the show was canceled, Siegel wrote and starred
in the film Forgetting Sarah Marshall. He wrote and was the human star of the movie musical
The Muppets. He was one of the stars of How I Met Your Mother, played writer David Foster Wallace
in the film The End of the Tour, and wrote and starred in the series Dispatches from Elsewhere.
Let's start with a scene where he's in a car accident.
From the first episode of Shrinking, it will give you an idea of how Siegel's character has
lost his bearings as a therapist and is pushing his patients to do what he thinks they need to
do to move forward. Here he is with his patient Grace, played by Heidi Gardner.
Grace, we've been doing this for two years. Two years of your life. I have never seen a guy
tell a woman that she is dumb and lucky she has great d**ks and thought to myself,
wow, they must really be in love. And he keeps telling me how great he is. Well, I saw him. He's
not that great. His muscles are too big. His shirts are too tight. Nobody likes that. It's gross.
I am sorry. I don't know what's happening because I was talking and. Grace, your husband is emotionally abusive. He's not working on it. He doesn't intend to.
He's made you think you're a bad person. He's made you think it's all you deserve. It's not. Just f**k and leave him.
It's not that easy.
It is that easy. You don't have any kids. Just go to your sister's in Vancouver.
But then. Leave him or I'm done being your therapist.
Look.
Okay.
Okay.
Okay.
Jason Siegel, welcome back to Fresh Air and congratulations on the Emmy nomination and on
the series. So I should say the outcome does not go well.
Yeah, it depends on how you look at it. It's good to talk to you again, by the way. I was saying to
you in our little pre-interview session, you're one of my very first interviews when I was a
little guy, I mean, in my early 20s. And it's so nice to be talking to you again.
Oh, it's a pleasure to have you back. We also talked about the Muppets movie. That was a lot
of fun.
Yeah.
Yeah, that's right.
Love that film.
First of all, what should Jimmy have done? What do you think?
Well, it's an interesting thing because this is the extreme example of this kind of therapy
method that the show is based on, this group of therapists who kind of broke convention
and realized that people were spending a lot of time, week after week, rehashing where
things came from in their past. And in reality,
what they really needed was some hope about what to do on Tuesday. It's like, I have to have this
talk with my boss on Tuesday, and I have all these feelings about it. And you're spending week after
week figuring out why you have feelings about authority figures. But Tuesday is coming. And so
this group of therapists decided that they were going to kind of change the rules a bit, tell
people what to do on Tuesday, and they were going to kind of change the rules a bit, and they were
And then in the meantime, we will get to figuring out why you had such a hard time figuring it out.
And so this is the beginning of that approach to therapy that we see, you know, as the show
progresses of, you know, people really just want to be told what to do to some extent. We can figure
out the why of it all, but what am I supposed to do about my abusive husband? What am I supposed
to do about, you know, my work situation? Who are these therapists that you're talking about?
One of them is Phil Stutz, who is a therapist. And he's a therapist. And he's a
who there is a documentary about. And he has a whole web of people that, you know, that he trained
and works with a big group of therapists who all have the same, the same idea that what people
really want is some hope. And if you can send a patient out of the room with some hope and some
direction, they're much more likely to come back and they're much more likely to affect change in
their life. Did you participate in that kind of therapy? Listen, one of these guys has become my
actual therapist. And it totally.
It totally changed my life. He's absolutely incredible. And I had done therapy throughout
my life. And, you know, like they said, I had spent a lot of time talking about the same stuff
from my childhood or this or that. And to finally be given some direction about, hey, next time this
happens, this is what I want you to do. Sometimes as reductive as like, I want you to say this
sentence next time this person does this. And all of a sudden your life starts operating more smoothly.
And and then you start to pick up the why of it all. As a matter of fact, the last lines of this
season that we just finished that aired season three, Jimmy finally gets to the dirty underneath
of why he can't move forward. This this idea of who would want me now? You know, I'm all covered
in scars. That came from a real therapy session I had with with Barry, where I had to show up to
this thing where I was going to be around somebody who.
I had kind of come up with. And I've had a twisty turny life and some some rocky moments. And this
guy I was going to see had just worn it all a lot more lightly than I had. And I was talking to my
therapist, Barry, about it. And I said, you know, I think I feel a little bit embarrassed. I feel
embarrassed to walk into this room. And he has worn it all so lightly. And I'm showing up covered
in scars. And without missing a beat, he said, what a shame it would be to show up anywhere at
four years old, not covered in scars. Isn't that what Harrison Ford says? I got off the phone with
my therapist. I called I called the writer's room and I said, guys, this is how this is how this
ends. That's so interesting. Yeah. That moment released so much personal whatever you would
call it, shame, embarrassment about that. I've lived a complicated life. And the beauty of doing
shrinking is when people come up to you, it's not like I love this job. It's not like I love this
joke or I love the Dracula puppet musical. These are all things that I'm really proud of. But people
come up for shrinking and they say, hey, I was going through X, Y, Z and something that you guys
talked about on there really helped me. I've had a lot of people come up and say, like, that thing
about scars really stuck with me. It's it's a sign of a life fully lived, you know?
No, absolutely. That that stuck with me, too. I've heard you say that at least when you were
younger, and I don't know how it is now, you had trouble making decisions.
And I'm wondering if that relates to how much you like this form of therapy where somebody
suggests what you should do. One of the things that I've come to realize getting to know myself
for this long is I seem to have like the wrong size computer for my needs. You know, it's like
it's just crunching numbers and scenarios instead of letting me settle in and enjoy my life. And
I've been that way since I'm really young. I was a kind of emo, emotional kid and every decision
felt so weighty. And I think that it has been very beneficial to my work because I seem to feel
things like one point five times the normal amount. But it has been kind of stifling in my
personal life. And so, yes, I think having somebody simplify the equation has been a
throughout my past and kind of hesitant to talk about like personal life stuff, but I'm getting
married this year. And my fiancee, thank you so much. My fiancee does a very similar thing for me.
She is a dancer and she kind of lives in her body and is a very grounding force that I have been
needing in my life of someone who just says, hey, I know you're thinking a lot right now,
but you know, our life is great, right?
And I don't have that voice. That voice does not like live in me. And so that's also been
really helpful for kind of kind of calming me down a bit.
But that's the kind of voice that drives so many artists of every sort, writers, musicians, like
you're unhappy and you're frustrated and that that can like paralyze you,
but it could also be an engine that drives you.
Listen, I don't know if you are similar, but I will. be thinking about the worst case scenario or, you know, something dumb like, you know,
I built something too close to the property line and now it can't be permitted. And I'll be thinking
about something like this and I'll be really stewing on it. And I'll think, God, my brain
won't let me relax. This happened just the other night. I'm working on an edit and we're having a
hard time cracking something at 3 a.m. I woke up with the solution. I said, oh, that scene is in
the wrong place. It's not that that scene doesn't work, but it actually ruins a scene three scenes
later without even kind of realizing that's what it's doing. And then I take that scene out and
all of a sudden the thing works and I have to, it's the same brain. You know what I mean? So
it's sort of, you got to take the good with the bad. The same brain that's going to obsess over
the property line and permitting is also the one that is making some pretty cool art.
You know, with decision-making, did you and do you always think that
you're going to be able to do it?
You know, you can see both sides. This decision would be better than that decision. So it's hard
to decide which is best, but you're sure there's going to be consequences if you make the wrong
choice. Yeah. I wish it was more rational than it is. I think it's honestly, I think it's like
a close cousin to OCD. I think that it's like the actual stuff is a little bit of a mask.
I'm like fooling myself if I think any of this obsession,
or worrying is about anything real, but you know, it's as simple as like, oh, you know what?
If I'm worrying about the property line right now, life must actually be in pretty good shape.
It's learning that kind of stuff.
Do you actually have OCD? Were you diagnosed with that?
Yeah. And it, it, it manifests in a bunch of different ways, but like it, you know,
when I was young, really, really young, it was night terrors that turned into like
compulsively checking doorknobs. And I've found a lot of ways to channel it.
Channel it into creativity. Creativity has been a really good friend. I mean,
it's been my beloved since I'm young until I met my partner, like create me and creativity were,
were ride or die.
Do you think that those nightmares figured into your series Dispatches from Elsewhere,
which is a real nightmarish, confusing premise, you wrote and starred in it and you, you know,
the character is suddenly in this like other like world kind of like where the environment is mostly,
but not completely familiar, but everything happening is totally strange, kind of like nightmares.
Yeah. My nightmares figured more. I write these kids books called Nightmares, actually,
that like are very much about that, about night terrors. And that was kind of how I exercised those feelings.
Dispatches from Elsewhere was something different for me.
I had reached this moment of existential crisis around 33 years old where I didn't know why I was doing any of this stuff.
And I was no longer really enjoying myself making things.
And I think I had gotten maybe too strategic about what I was trying to write.
And it also coincided I'm a sober guy for a long time now, but soon 13 years or so, and it coincided with me getting sober and all of a sudden not thinking
things were funny anymore. And, um, I was kind of known for making comedy.
I was, I was just, I was really scared to be honest with you about what the rest of my creative life looked like.
Um, and I had what I guess you would describe as writer's block.
I hadn't written anything since the Muppets, just nothing was happening.
And then I saw this documentary called the Institute about this real life art experiment that happened in San Francisco.
Where all of a sudden these flyers were put on lampposts with nothing pointing you towards them, like it wasn't sweaty at all.
It just said like dolphin communications testing with pull tabs at the bottom, human force field experiments with pull tabs at the bottom.
And if you were the type of person who pulled a pull tab, you were told to, you know, you called this number and you were told to report to this address and you went down and you basically long story short were launched into this grownup scavenger hunt throughout the city of San Francisco.
And, you know, I don't know if you've heard of this, but this is a story that I've been telling for years now that lasted for like three years and grownups were showing up from all sorts of socioeconomic groups and totally different types of people who just felt like there should be more.
I think that was like the underlying thing of it.
And it's like the thing that drives Roald Dahl books or Harry Potter, this idea that someone's going to show up and say like, shh, you're meant for more.
There's magic over here.
You know, it was that for grownups.
And I watched this documentary and I was just like.
I was just like disproportionately moved by it.
And I felt something awaken in me like, right, you've forgotten that this is all supposed to be magic and fun and it can be a little scary.
And this moment you're in personally is a little scary and it's okay.
Like you're on this ride of life.
And where is the guy who wrote the Dracula puppet musical in Forgetting Sarah Marshall?
You know, like where is the guy who wasn't afraid?
And so I called the guy who created the.
Real life San Francisco experiment.
I asked him if I could adapt it into a TV show and he let me adapt this thing.
And it's not something that really caught on.
It's something that I am so proud of.
And it's something that meant so much to me personally, because I really put my insides outside making that show.
Like I wrote from my guts again.
You have talked about how after doing so much comedy and.
Rom-coms that you wanted to do dramatic acting and try that and learn from that.
So you did, you know, the end of the tour where you played David Foster Wallace.
And then, you know, you created the series you're just talking about, Dispatches from Elsewhere.
Shrinking is like part comedy, part drama.
You get to do both.
And you've said in the past that you like to push, even in a comedy, you like to push your character as dark as the character can.
And get because you feel like you can make the character inherently likable so that people, no matter how dark the character is, will root for them.
And I'm wondering if you feel like you have that kind of likability in real life, that even if you're depressed, even if you get really dark, that people will root for you and stick with you.
You know, that you emanate enough likability to get by with other people.
Yeah.
I'm very vulnerable in a way that makes me like, I think I feel a bit like a surrogate for one's self.
Like, it's kind of what I do on screen.
I think I'm open enough about that life is tricky and funny and complicated and hard and weird.
And, man, what a ride.
What a ride life is, you know?
And I'm kind of open about that.
Sometimes I'm shaking around.
You know, I think that sometimes people can look at me, at least on screen, maybe in real life, and think like, oh, me too.
Oh, he's talking about the thing I'm not saying out loud.
Mm-hmm.
You know?
One of the things I look for when I'm doing work, like on a scene or in a show or a movie, is like, what is the dirty underneath?
What is the thing that they're not saying?
Because all of the dialogue is what someone is willing to say.
And we all have this other stuff that we're hiding.
And I think that for whatever reason, I'm like kind of devoid of pride or shame about the dirty underneath.
I'm kind of willing to express it in life and on my face creatively.
And, you know, I'll just. I'll just say the stuff like. I'll say the stuff that a lot of people are trying to hide.
I want to get back to the kind of therapy that inspired the kind of therapy your character is practicing in the series of intervening in people's lives and telling them what they should do, as opposed to trying to, like, gently lead them to question themselves and discover a solution for themselves.
Has that. Has the series been controversial among therapists?
For suggesting that that approach could be a very helpful approach, as well as it could be a destructive approach?
All I can tell. I don't read the Internet at all.
I'm scared of the Internet.
I thought people. I thought you might know therapists who were telling you directly.
Well, all I will tell you is that the therapists who have come up to me about it have almost unanimously said that it is wish fulfillment for therapists.
Because the experience is, for them. You are sitting there knowing exactly what the answer is.
And week after week, you are trying to use, like, the Socratic method to, like, guide them to what to you is a very obvious decision.
You know?
And it's kind of funny, because in real life, your friends who are the least qualified are the most eager to tell you what to do.
And your therapist who is the most qualified feels the least. Enabled to tell you what to do.
And so I think that therapists love the idea of being able to just say, like, oh, my God, just leave him.
Just leave him.
You know?
We actually need to take another break here.
I hate to interrupt our conversation, but here we go.
So if you're just joining us, my guest is Jason Siegel.
He's nominated for an Emmy for his starring role in the comedy drama series Shrinking, in which he plays a psychotherapist.
We'll be right back after a short break.
I'm Terry Gross, and this is Fresh Air.
This is Fresh Air.
I'm Terry Gross.
Let's get back to my interview with Jason Siegel.
He's nominated for an Emmy for his leading role as a psychotherapist who's having his own mental health crisis in the comedy drama series Shrinking.
How is the series pitched to you?
And it was your idea, apparently, to add this kind of therapy?
No, not really.
It was Brett Goldstein and Bill Lawrence came to me.
They had both had similar ideas about a therapist.
We should mention that they are the creators of Ted Lasso.
I think Bill and Jason Sudeikis are the creators of the Lasso.
Brett is a writer on it.
And then Bill, Brett, and I are the creators of Shrinking.
The reality is I kind of got a great free ride on it.
Bill and Brett had thought of these therapy ideas.
And they didn't have a script yet, but they each had this idea about a therapist going through a nervous breakdown.
And they pitched me the idea.
And I think my contribution to it was what you had brought up, which is. I feel like I have garnered a lot of goodwill over my career.
And people are rooting for the characters I play.
Let's push this guy as far as we can into the red.
Because I feel like I can pull him out of the nosedive.
So let's be brave.
And, you know, in the opening. I think it's the opening scene of the show.
I'm in my backyard with sex workers and booze and drugs.
And my daughter is upstairs.
It is. It is a pretty unlikable first depiction, you know?
Because I felt like if you start this guy at the rockiest of rock bottoms, you have a long way to go to pull him out.
And I just believed I could make you feel sympathetic for him.
So then we jumped in and we wrote the pilot and made the show.
And that's history.
The second truth to how it happened, allegedly, is. I have a place in a town called Ojai.
A little country town.
And I love it there.
And I walk around town like Big Bird in Ojai.
I wake up every morning and I take this 45-minute walk through town that's kind of like the beginning of Beauty and the Beast.
I'm like waving at the baker and, you know, like shops are opening.
And I just love it.
I feel very much like myself.
Apparently what really happened is one of the producers was on vacation in Ojai.
And I was taking one of the. One of these Muppety walks through town.
And he saw me from across the street and texted Bill Lawrence.
I just saw Jason Segel.
He seems like a happy guy.
Let's make a show with him.
And here we are.
So we've heard you with a patient in a scene from the series.
And now I want to play a scene with you talking to your mentor, Paul, who is considerably older than you are.
He's played by Harrison Ford.
Paul in the series gets diagnosed with Parkinson's disease in his series.
His symptoms progress through the series.
And you've been really helpful to him as his symptoms have progressed.
You've been there for him.
But at this point in the series, Paul, Harrison Ford's character, is leaving L.A. and moving to Connecticut to be close to his daughter, who he'd been estranged from in the past.
But the relationship. The relationship has started up again.
He owns the building where he practiced along with you and along with Jessica Williams, whose character, Gabby, he gave the building and the practice to because it was her dream to set up a trauma center.
So now she's going to be able to do that.
And he knew from the past that you didn't want to take over the whole practice.
But you feel betrayed because he didn't consult you before giving it to Gabby.
And you found out late that he was moving 3,000 miles away.
So you're feeling very. Abandoned.
And. Oh, man.
I know what you're about to play.
I haven't watched this scene since I did it.
Why?
Were you afraid to?
No.
Quite the opposite.
This scene with Harrison that you're about to play, I knew was coming for the whole season, you know?
Because I get to kind of know the storylines in advance.
And I think the whole season I was thinking to myself, boy, when we get to the end of this season. I'm going to be on a balcony with Harrison Ford acting my guts out, you know?
And it's really important to me that I be great.
You know, it's like you're going to play basketball with Michael Jordan or something.
And, man, when that scene came, I was not afraid.
And I just was honest.
I didn't show off.
And I did all the things that I feel like make a scene good.
And at the end. At the end when they said, cut, Harrison looked at me and he said, so excited, you did it, kid.
And we hugged.
And I didn't need to add any other, like, judgment to that moment.
Does that make sense?
Sure.
And he calls you kid in the series, too.
Yeah, yeah.
No, he's become a really special part of my life.
Yeah, let's hear it.
I haven't heard it before.
Okay.
And to set it up just a little further, the subtext of this is that Jimmy always felt, like, hurt by his own father and emotionally abandoned.
Because his father was always, like, disappearing on him.
And now Jimmy's father is going to go on a fishing trip instead of going to Jimmy's daughter's graduation.
And Jimmy's really angry with his father for now emotionally abandoning his daughter.
At least that's how Jimmy sees it.
So here. Here you are as Jimmy with Harrison Ford, as your mentor and fellow therapist, Paul.
You speak first.
You gave the practice to Gabby.
We talked about this years ago.
You said you hated paperwork and all you wanted to do was spend time with the patients.
People change.
You didn't even check with me, Paul.
Would you have wanted it?
No.
So you're angry with me for not offering you something that you don't. Yes, I am.
I'm supposed to be your guy.
Been your guy.
And this. This is how you treat me?
I don't deserve this!
Easy, kid.
No, I'm mad, Paul!
And I'm embarrassed.
I have to find out from Meg that you're moving?
You don't even have the decency to come and look me in my eyes and tell me that you're leaving me.
Let's take a break.
I think these feelings that you're having might be meant for someone else.
No, I think they're meant for both of you.
I get it now.
I'm not as important to you as you are to me.
I just feel stupid it took me that long to realize it.
So how does the scene sound to you, actually, hearing it now?
Um. I don't want to put you on the spot and feel like you have to brag about your performance.
No, no.
That's. Luckily, that's not how I feel.
Okay.
I always feel vulnerable when I hear or watch myself acting because I think, like,
the feeling you're feeling, if you're doing it right, is so vital that then the, um. It translating to the outside part of you, always, like, by the clumsy act of expression,
is going to be, like, one step less, um. Vital.
But I feel. I feel like I. I feel like I sound like how people sound when they're feeling those things, you know?
Sounds like you're choking.
Yeah.
I try really hard.
I think that this, like, might be the key to acting.
I don't know.
But I try really hard not to show off.
I think that's one of the things that you learn as you're getting more familiar with working with a camera.
Boy, you want to show off.
You want to show off.
Like, the camera's getting ever closer to you as the coverage goes on, you know?
So, some parts of you are activating, like, oh, gosh, it's my turn, you know?
Or, oh, it's getting closer.
Now's the time to really show them, you know?
And so, I think a big thing that I try to do is to be, oh, you know what?
This is maybe an easy way to say it.
I was really interested in why I thought Jeff Bridges was so good at acting.
So, I went back and I, like, read reviews of some. Some of his great performances.
And one of them said,
Jeff Bridges may be the least self-conscious actor working today.
And I thought, oh, yeah, that's the goal.
The goal is to be as unselfconscious between action and cut as possible.
Like, just don't show off.
Don't try to show them.
Just be really. How honest can you be between action and cut?
You know, and then you start adding, like taking it for a spin while you're
out there and that requires some bravery and all that but um i guess during that scene but with
harrison between action and cut i just tried to really know what i was feeling i understand when
people talk about acting like he might call i might call myself the character like understand
what jimmy was feeling that's not really my experience of doing acting i'm like what am i
feeling right now you know um i don't have to search like what is jimmy feeling what am i
feeling and then just like just do that well i have to reintroduce you again here if you're just
joining us my guest is jason siegel he's nominated for an emmy for his leading role in the series
shrinking the first three seasons are streaming on apple tv we'll be right back this is fresh air
this is fresh air i'm terry gross let's get back to my interview with jason siegel he's nominated
for an emmy for his
leading role as a psychotherapist who's having his own mental health crisis in the comedy drama
series shrinking siegel got a start when he was in his late teens and was one of the stars of
freaks and geeks after it was canceled he wrote and starred in the rom-com forgetting sarah marshall
he wrote the movie musical the muppets and was the human star and was one of the stars of how i
your mother i love how you call me the human star of the muppets it gives me such it gives me such
joy
well especially since you've said you sometimes feel like a muppet so for sure i thought i'd
emphasize that you were the human star as opposed to one of the muppets yeah um so this question is
going to lead to something about shrinking i'm taking like the long route around um so this route
starts with dracula's lament so judd apatow was one of the executive producers of freaks and geeks
the the series
that like made you as a known actor um and after it was canceled you you were working on a rock
musical that you were writing about a vampire and it was a you know you played us you made a cd
and played one of the songs for judd apatow and he said don't ever play this for anyone else again
yes um so before we hear the song that you played judd apatow which i played before on the show when
you were on but that was a long time ago and i think it's going to be a long time because it's
a long time ago i love listening to this um but just to set it up tell us what the musical was
just a little a little plot synopsis so i would yeah i mean a little plot synopsis is basically i
it was basically going to be forgetting sarah marshall but it was going to be dracula it was
going to be dracula instead of the human jason siegel um i think it's as simple as that i had
kind of a life-altering breakup at the time and i think it's going to be a life-altering breakup
you know things feel so oh man so meaningful you know when you're experiencing them for the first
time and as soon as um this woman walked out of my apartment i sat down and i wrote this song
first i wrote it as a human and then minutes later i started singing it as dracula and i'm like oh my
god this is it a dracula puppet breakup musical do you want to set up the song at all before we
hear it this is the song in real life
that i wrote minutes after my breakup and in the movie uh i've talked about the dracula musical
and um mila kunis has taken the opportunity to force me to go on stage and sing it to her
she's hearing it for the first time and is essentially mortified okay here we go
it's getting kind of hard to believe things are going to get better
i've been drowning too long to believe that the tide's going to turn
and i've been living too hard to believe things are going to get easier now
i'm still trying to shake off the pain
i'm still trying to shake off the pain
from the lessons i've learned
and if i see van helsing i swear to the lord i will slay him
he'd take him from me but i swear i won't let it be so
blood will run down his face when he is decapitated
his head on my mantle is how i will let this world know
i love you
i can't
okay so what i'm wondering among other things i first of all i love
hearing that song i laugh every time i hear it
i am wondering i know you love the musical les mis
i know les mis made a huge impression on you
i know you've sung duets of it with neil patrick harris
and that you reprise it with another character from shrinking
in the car um i am wondering if dracula's lament is inspired by the confrontation song in les mis
which is the kind of song equivalent of a duel between revolutionary jean valjean and
inspector javert who's been hunting valjean and wants to arrest or maybe kill him
absolutely uh les miserables was i think the first my first intro into musicals i used to go with my
parents every year when it would come through la to the pantages theater and um yeah i was just like
i was obsessed with it and i i know all the songs i sing all the different characters um so yeah
i think about it all the time but
yes the dracula musical is definitely inspired by les miserables for sure great i you know i have
all the puppets that was one of the great takeaways from forgetting sarah marshall all the puppets from
the dracula musical yeah from the dracula musical they let me have them and they were made by the
jim henson company and uh and i've got them in this like secret room in my house that's pretty great
yeah we need to take a short break here so let me reintroduce you my guest is jason siegel he's
nominated for an emmy for his leading role in the series shrinking
the first three seasons are streaming on apple tv we'll be right back this is fresh air
this is fresh air let's get back to my interview with jason siegel he's nominated for an emmy for
his starring role in the comedy drama series shrinking as a psychotherapist who's been
having his own mental health crisis because his wife died a year ago in a car crash
so um you said that you you've been sober for 13 years which is yeah great and i want to say
congratulations oh thanks um but
i was wondering if drinking coincided with one of those periods when you weren't working a lot
and you were questioning like is it over you know am i riding on my past right now
yeah i think i think the drinking was actually pre that um i think that what was kind of confusing
to me was during this period when things were going really really really well um i was really
was being told that i had one life in so many ways like i was having really successful movies
and a really successful tv show and i was writing stuff and making stuff but i was just so unhappy
and i was drinking a bunch to i don't know you know deal with that or um that i just felt like
if this is winning life i don't know how much longer i want to do this you know like it's just
not i'm not enjoying myself at all and so i felt like i had to make a big deal about it and i was
there was no inciting incident you know like there wasn't like a thing that happened i just realized
oh this is gonna just keep going on like this so i just was like i need to change everything
so i stopped drinking and i also was like there is this voice my my i got discovered doing dramas
like in a high school dramas you know and the performances i admired that like made me feel like
alive with acting was like edward norton and primal fear um peter sellers and being there
um martin sheen and badlands and none of these were anywhere close to what i was doing
you know and i think that i had this feeling of like
maybe one of the reasons you are unhappy is that you're not finding out like you're gonna be the
who we're all familiar with who's like resentful at dinner parties like well if i had done the
revenant i would have done this or that you know who never finds out and so i think that
that kind of big life change led me into this moment of like let's go let's go answer all the
questions that you are not answering and that you're kind of like numbing that you're not
answering how do you
do that how do you find the answers to those questions i mean it's so weird how the universe
responds
And I'm not like a woo-woo guy, you know, but end of the tour came to my desk right as I was having this moment.
And it is a drama.
Yeah, that's the David Foster Wallace story.
Yeah, it's David Foster Wallace story.
It was my chance to find out.
It was about everything that I was going through.
It was about a guy who was winning life according to everybody.
He had written the book of the generation.
He was struggling with sobriety and was trying to figure out how to be happy while he was doing all of it.
And I thought, well, here is your chance to find out.
Like, what if you play what would Edward Norton do and dive into this thing in a way that you've never had to dive into a comedy?
And like, I just like prepped the way that I heard, quote unquote, real actors prep.
And I got a dialect coach and I did all this stuff.
And and I spent like 10 years doing that of like chasing that sort of thing.
Yeah.
And I think that it was like one of the most important things I ever did.
And I've realized that maybe strategy for me is is my enemy.
I need to be doing what's interesting to me.
Your father is a lawyer.
I don't know if he's retired now or not.
But what kind of law did he practice and what did you learn from seeing him work or from people he brought home who were also lawyers or maybe clients?
Yeah, my dad did like entertainment law, but not like.
Like Hollywood entertainment, like amusement parks and casinos and things like that.
I think what I learned from my father is just like this crazy work ethic.
My dad worked harder than anyone I'd ever seen.
And I actually like had the honor of doing something a minute ago.
Got a got a house like for next stage of my journey.
Kayla and I found our dream house and we're going to move in.
And it has this office in it.
It has an old timey office.
And.
My dad, when he retired, gave me the desk that he worked at for 40 years and I just got to put it in the office.
It's been sitting in like a storage unit and I finally got to put it in the office.
I had to FaceTime him and thank him and say, like, hey, dad, this desk is the reason I'm here.
Like the work that my dad put in.
I am very, very lucky.
I will constantly be in awe.
Of people who get in a bus from their small town and are like, I'm going to go make it in the entertainment business.
You know, that is a different kind of bravery than I had to do.
I grew up in L.A. and I always knew because of my parents that no matter what, I was going to be OK.
It was an amazing.
It was an amazing way to try to do this.
Is that because they were financially secure?
Yeah, they were financially secure.
They would always be there if I needed.
Like, I knew that they would.
I knew that they had me.
Like, no matter what, I was safe and it gave me the opportunity to try to fly.
And I did, you know, but I only did, I think, because they said, like, hey, go out and go out and do it.
You know, and my dad put in the hours to make that possible.
And my mom put in the hours by raising us.
Like my my mother is the most incredible woman.
And also my mom did this thing like she kind of incepted.
Who I became.
She showed me The Muppet Show that she had taped it.
She had taped every episode to show me The Muppet Show when her kid got old enough because, like, she thought it was special.
She showed me Harold and Maude when I was, like, way too young to see it.
I was like nine years old.
My mom showed me Harold and Maude and showed me Peter Sellers.
And, like, I am definitely the most positive version of, like, a product of my parents.
Jason Siegel, it's been great to talk with you.
I really appreciate you coming back to the show.
And congratulations on your Emmy nomination.
Terry, thanks so much.
It's so nice to both of us still be at it after all these years.
Pretty darn cool.
Jason Siegel is nominated for an Emmy for his starring role in the series Shrinking.
We'll hear from several other Emmy nominees over the next couple of weeks.
Tomorrow on Fresh Air, why has the United States been unable to impose its will on Iran
despite months of punishing attacks from the world's most powerful military force?
We'll get some insights from Stacey Pettyjohn,
director of the Defense Program at the Center for a New American Security.
I hope you'll join us.
To keep up with what's on the show and get highlights of our interviews,
follow us on Instagram at NPR Fresh Air.
Fresh Air's executive producer is Sam Britter.
Our technical director and engineer is Audrey Bentham.
Our engineer today is Adam Staniszewski.
Our interviews and reviews are produced and edited by
Phyllis Myers, Anne-Marie Boldenado, Lauren Krenzel, Teresa Madden, Monique Nazareth,
Thea Chaloner, Susan Yakundi, Anna Bauman, and Nico Gonzalez-Whistler.
Our digital media producer is Molly D.
And I'm Molly C.V. Nesper.
Roberta Shorrock directs the show.
Our co-host is Tanya Mosley.
I'm Terry Gross.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Jason Siegel’s character in Shrinking, a therapist in emotional crisis, practices a therapy approach that gives patients direct, actionable advice to address immediate problems, inspired by real-world therapeutic methods emphasizing hope and practical direction.
The show explores the emotional and psychological toll of grief, particularly through Jimmy’s unresolved trauma after his wife’s death, and how his emotional abandonment of his daughter reflects his internal struggle.
Siegel draws from personal experiences with anxiety, OCD, and creative blocks, linking his mental health journey to the character’s vulnerability and the show’s themes of emotional honesty and self-discovery.
The series is influenced by real therapists like Phil Stutz, whose approach of providing clear next steps to patients has proven effective in fostering real-life change and emotional relief.
Siegel’s career spans comedy, drama, and musicals, with his work in The Muppets, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, and Dispatches from Elsewhere reflecting a deep engagement with emotional truth and vulnerability.
A pivotal scene with Harrison Ford’s character, Paul, reveals themes of betrayal, mentorship, and emotional recognition, highlighting the importance of authentic emotional expression in acting and real relationships.
The show’s therapy model is both praised and controversial among professionals, with some viewing it as empowering wish fulfillment for therapists who want to offer clear solutions.
Siegel emphasizes that emotional authenticity—especially in acting and personal life—comes from vulnerability, and that expressing the "dirty underneath" of emotions creates deep resonance with audiences.
Summary:
Jason Siegel, nominated for an Emmy for his role in the series *Shrinking*, portrays a therapist named Jimmy who is emotionally unraveling after his wife’s death. The show blends comedy and drama to explore how Jimmy, despite his personal trauma, attempts to help patients by giving them direct, practical advice—mirroring a therapy approach pioneered by real practitioners like Phil Stutz, who emphasize hope and actionable steps over lengthy self-reflection. This method, while controversial, reflects a shift in therapy toward immediate solutions.
Siegel draws from his own life experiences with anxiety, OCD, and creative blocks, revealing how his emotional vulnerability and introspection inform both his acting and personal life. His career, spanning *Freaks and Geeks*, *The Muppets*, and *Dispatches from Elsewhere*, consistently centers on emotional authenticity. A key emotional arc involves Jimmy’s strained relationship with his mentor, Harrison Ford’s character, who leaves the practice, leading to a powerful scene where Jimmy confronts his feelings of abandonment and realizes the depth of his own emotional journey.
Siegel emphasizes that the show’s success lies in its unflinching honesty—showing the messy, painful truths behind human decisions and relationships. His work illustrates how vulnerability, not perfection, fosters connection, both in character and in real life.
FAQs
The show is inspired by a real therapy method where therapists give patients direct, actionable advice to address immediate problems, rather than focusing solely on past issues. This approach is based on the belief that people often need hope and direction to make real changes in their lives.
Jimmy's grief over the loss of his wife and emotional distance from his daughter drives his own breakdown, which manifests in his therapy style—where he gives patients blunt, prescriptive advice. His personal pain makes him emotionally unavailable, which mirrors the struggles of his patients.
Yes, it has sparked debate. Some therapists see it as 'wish fulfillment'—offering patients clear solutions that therapists themselves would want—but others believe it can be effective in helping people take practical steps toward change.
Harrison Ford plays Paul, a veteran therapist and mentor to Jimmy. His character, who is diagnosed with Parkinson’s, represents wisdom and emotional depth, and Jason Siegel has described their relationship as deeply personal and impactful.
Siegel has struggled with OCD and decision paralysis since youth, which shaped his approach to character development. He sees the show's therapy method as a way to provide direction, much like how he needed external guidance to manage his own internal chaos.
No, the method was developed by the creators Brett Goldstein and Bill Lawrence, who pitched the idea to Siegel. Siegel contributed by pushing the character into darker, more emotionally raw territory to explore vulnerability and empathy.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.