Go back

Jamelle Bouie: The World's Most Influential Racist Is Bankrolling Republicans

51m 25s

Jamelle Bouie: The World's Most Influential Racist Is Bankrolling Republicans

Jamal Buie critiques the Trump administration through the "cargo cult" metaphor, illustrating how it pursues an authoritarian vision without the practical means or understanding to achieve it—leading to absurd, illegal, and deeply unpopular actions. He dissects the case against Ilhan Omar, arguing it is rooted in a false, racist narrative about 30-year-old paperwork and a violation of constitutional protections for Congress members. The attack reflects a broader pattern of targeting dissenting voices, especially from minority backgrounds, and draws historical parallels to past political suppression. Buie also highlights Elon Musk’s role as a powerful, ideologically extreme figure—funding Republican campaigns, interfering in foreign policy, and promoting white supremacist ideologies—while criticizing the media’s failure to hold Republican leaders accountable. He points to systemic failures within the State Department, where loyalty to Trump overrides national interest, and underscores the need for institutional oversight. Ultimately, Buie sees the administration’s actions as driven by an insatiable ego, not strategic governance, resulting in chaos, erosion of democratic norms, and a dangerous mix of menace and absurdity that undermines the United States’ political and international stability.

Transcription

9347 Words, 51354 Characters

English
(upbeat music) - Hello and welcome to the Board of Daily. I'm your host, Tim Miller. I'd like to welcome back to the show. It's been a minute tick tock sensation. Opinion columnist for the outlet called The New York Times, as well. He's the host of Takes by Jamal Buie. And he's based in the sweater vest capital of the World Charlottesville, Virginia. It's Jamal Buie. What's up, man? - Hey, thank you for having me back. - All right, let's do it. Much to discuss. I was intrigued by your latest column in the Times discussing the manner in which the Trump administration is a cargo cult. And we get into one story in particular. But I think it'd be an interesting place to start to just kind of explain that concept and why you called it that and what we're seeing. - So the classic cargo cult right is that in Polynesian Islands in World War II, there would be these American supply play and shopping supplies and the supplies would come. And the people would be happy about it. And then once the war is over and the planes aren't flying anymore, the people on these islands would develop these rituals basically trying to summon the cargo again. They had no sense of the mechanism. They knew the outcome they wanted. They didn't quite understand the mechanism. So they took almost like a mystification of the thing they think they thought was bringing me cargo. That's I think a useful metaphor for thinking about the administration, which is they have an end in sight, which is a consolidated authoritarian regime. And they think they know how to get there. But often, in my view, what it seems like they're doing is they're kind of trying to summon the energy of that authoritarian consolidated state without actually doing the kind of concrete and practical things you would need to do to make that durable and what that ends up looking like are these aggressive abuses of power that in the end tend to be a wash, right? They're so illegal. They're so out there that they provide the targets a lot of actually ability to push that. - And ridiculous, I just don't legal. They're so like comically absurd. - Right, comically ridiculous. - I mean, like going after James Comey over the seashells is like really not meaningfully different than building a landing strip for an imaginary plane. - Right, exactly, exactly. And so, I use the cargo colt metaphor to kind of capture this thing where it's not that you should not discount the gold that they have. That's very serious. And it isn't that even that you should discount what they're doing, like the actual concrete actions, but that there is a disconnect between one and the other. And that disconnect is both the place where if you are an opponent or target, there's like a lot of place for pushing back. But also that disconnect is I think why after almost two years of this, it's like they don't really have much to show for it. Other than this deeply unpopular administration, which is a real damage and havoc to the American system, but has not succeeded at it. So I think it's actual primary goal, which is to consolidate the authoritarian state. - Yeah, I like that it's a good way to look at kind of a disconnect that I try to explore on the show a lot, which is like the ways in which they are simultaneously like menacing and clownish. - Right. - And trying to figure out how to kind of balance that and how to appropriately contextualize that for people, right? Because if you just look at the menacing part, you know, kind of impending kind of a mega fascist authoritarian regime, you know, where Trump is going to pass down to Baron, you know, the powers and we're going to have concentration, right? You know what I mean? Like if you just focus on that, like I think you're kind of missing the story. If you just focus on the clownishness, though, and I think some of my like, you know, other for the anti-anti-Trumpers, we call them. A lot of times you guys are too alarmist, right? Because they're only focusing on the clownishness. And you kind of have to synthesize like those two elements because they both exist together and sometimes one, you know, more cutely than the other. - Right, that's exactly right. I've always liked to think of it as Trump himself is this almost comical figure, but his will to power is very real. That's not fake, that's a real thing. And simply having an insatiable will to power can cause a lot of destruction. Even if he has a comical figure in some regards, and even if in the end, he ends up, you know, falling on his face. - So the cargo code concept you drilled down in particular on the case involving Ilhan Omar, the article titled The Hunting of Ilhan Omar, we've learned she's now going to have to move out of her house. There's continued developments on it today, but why don't you just kind of frame up, you know, your argument about what you saw about the case? - Sure, I mean, the relevance of the cargo code metaphor to the case is here again, you have a situation of an aggressive abuse of power. Obviously, I think people intuitively think himself, this is a lot, right, going after a sitting Congress person. But I think it's really working through their home. - Yeah, really in their home. - I'm investigating her over this paperwork issue from 30 years ago would have been abuse of power, but, you know, I don't know. Like sometimes people in the other party thought paperwork wrong, but like to take that to be like, hey, we're gonna send agents of the state to like into her house to start rifling through her. - Yeah. - You know, that obviously is just such an overstep, a kind of authoritarian theater. - Treating her like she's John Gotti or something, right? - Right. - That's a lot. So I think that's, people kind of grasp that intuitively. I think it's really worth drilling down and two elements of this that are just, I mean, for lack of a better word, insane. The first is, as you just mentioned, this is about paperwork from 30 years ago that her father filled out, her father who passed away about a half decade ago. Like this actually isn't anything. (laughs) The claim here that the charge is that, as a child, at the 12-year-old, Ilhan Omar was somehow involved in, you know, falsifying, fudging paperwork that her father filled out and has been maintaining a fiction that she is not the age she says she is for 30 years. Despite the fact that on every single legal document you can imagine, Ilhan Omar has been quite consistent about her age. The idea that this is about some good faith, you know, the paperwork's wrong is nonsense, but the other thing is that obviously, she's a target because she's a critic of the president and she's a Somali American critic of the president. And so on the former part, you know, Congress, members of Congress are protected by the Constitution. Not just under the First Amendment, but by what's called the Speech and Debate Clause of Article One. And the Speech and Debate Clause just says, "Listen, if you're a member of Congress, whatever you say in your capacity as a member of Congress is protected speech." And it's like, it's actually quite broad. I mean, there's basically, there's very little you can't say as a member of Congress that isn't protected speech under the Speech and Debate Clause. The other thing is that the Constitution clearly says that Congress is the judge of its own members. Obviously, people are elected, but once they're there, it is either the House or the Senate that decides whether that person can stay if there's some controversy or whatnot. They are the judge of their own members. Both of these, I kind of alluded to this in the piece, but both of these are part of our larger inheritance from the English political tradition, the English Civil War, the long parliament. Like, these things are all about the king's relationship to parliament. And part of what Charles I did was like, try to arrest members of parliament to force them to submit. So this has a long provenance in the Anglo-American political tradition. And Trump, by trying to arrest the naturalized and deport Omar for her views, he is basically also going after these key congressional prerogatives. I really think you should understand this as an attack on Congress, as well as an attack on this particular member. And then the second thing is just the insane racism of the president, the wild racism of the president, I think we get habituated too, that's just sorry is, but I think it's really worth considering Andrew Johnson, the first president to be impeached, was impeached in part because of his rhetoric in the campaign season. He was going around saying wild stuff that was inflammatory, that was extremely racist. And members of Congress were like, that is simply unbecoming of the president because of the important to presidential rhetoric. Those words mean something, they have weight. And the president's hate speech against Somalis. - Do you have an Andrew Johnson statement off the dome? - I don't have an Andrew Johnson statement off the dome. I probably should just memorize one just so I can have it. The president's hate speech actually is very consequential. Like it's genuinely unique. You can think of some very racist presidents in American history, they kept that stuff to themselves out of a recognition that it's just not something the president should say for very practical reasons. The closest comparison I could think of in terms of this happening before is the government's successful attempt to remove Emma Goldman and anarchist activists in the early 20th century from the United States. And this sort of attempt to denaturalize political opponents unfortunately has a history in this country. But most of us look back at that history and we say to ourselves, something to be ashamed of. The administration looks back at that history and really does see it as a proof of concept for what they might try to do to their opponents. It was Article 10, I tried to see if our AI betters could have figured it out to a quote for me, but it was Article 10 of his impeached speech. - Oh, Article 10, all right. Let's see, Cleveland, Ohio, Hureng, the St. Louis, Missouri, Hureng. - It was a campaign tour call to swing around the circle. And so he was like traveling the country by train and saying wild stuff. - Speaking of wild stuff. So here's our current president, this morning on this front, or maybe it was last night, leading about Ilan Omar. It was just revealed that Ilan Omar's name is not Ilan Omar. The one she used to get elected is one of the Congress, but rather it's an entirely different name. Ilan Neur said, "Elmi." And their last name is also the executive of her brother. The person they said she married into children with, when I asked whether or not she was married to her brother, she said not to my knowledge, not the words, "Dada-da-da-da." He says, "Please inform us to your point about the attack on Congress. "Please inform the Speaker of the House of Representatives, James Michael Johnson, that the Dumbo-Crat Party should concede her seat. Ilan Neur said, "Elmi, her real name has admitted to fraud. "She will not be legally allowed "to be a member of this August body from this point forth." - My actual first thought here is that the obsession with middle names is very reminiscent of birtherism. It's very kind of straight from Barack Hussein Obama, just that attempt to treat the middle name as some-- - Dole Muhammad. - El Sayat. - Yeah, yeah. - Right. - Some key to some secret intent that the person has. - There's just many false statements in there, you know, about having children with the brother. And it's just, like this is one of these things. Like I don't, like how do you process or deal with this? Where you have the president like advancing in a kind of wildly racist lies about a member of Congress, simultaneously, to having his justice department target her. - Right. - Aggressively, right? Like, I mean, this is just kind of closing the circle, like together the kind of clownishness and the menacing. Right, you know, in one case. - And part of, I would say part of the larger problem is that the actor that's supposed to respond here is Congress. Right? - Yeah. - Congress is supposed to be the one that, you know, would be asking the Attorney General in hearings to answer for this investigation of one of its members. Congress should be the one, you know, chastising the president for engaging in this kind of thing. Like, you know, Congress has a role here, not just for lawmaking, but for political accountability. And the extent to which the Republican controlled Congress just has no interest in that whatsoever, does make all this work because there's no, there's no institutional pushback. Democrats can complain, but that kind of brings it into the realm of just partisan disagreement, which you really do need is another institution to say, no, you can't, you can't say that. - That's wrong. I think Jamie Ben Raskin is going to, is going to solve that a couple of months. (laughing) - When it comes to oversight of DOJ. Okay, so I went to his true social post to get the text of the Ilana War post. And I try to check in on it, you know, before the pod is part of a obligation that I have to listen or not, it's not a joyous one. But I sometimes skip a few days. And I went today and it's like, so it's just like an Alice in Wonderland moment. It's going to see what's happening in our decaying President's brain. Here's the most recent post as of this taping. Do you want to guess what it's about? - I honestly, I got no idea. (laughing) - I can't even imagine. - The reflecting pool is 85% full. - Okay. - And looking really good. It hasn't worked properly since 1922, but we'll now, we have cameras set up to stop any potential vandalism, including the grass areas, which were destroyed by chemical poisoning with a large and very inappropriate phrase. I can't even translate what he means by that. - I don't know if you can. - We're destroyed by chemical poisoning with a large and very inappropriate phrase. - I have no idea what that could possibly mean. - Maybe not. - You have any deep dots on the reflecting pool obsession? - You know, I mean, obviously this guy, who's obsessed with aesthetics, the reflecting pool obsession, the ballroom obsession, the golf course obsession. Honestly, what this feels like to me, it's a guy making like a city-sized mausoleum for himself. - Yes. - Trying to kind of like build himself into the landscape as like a permanent moral for him after death. - This is Napoleon. - Arctotryolmph. - Right, right. I mean, I do think it brains totally deteriorating, and this is the thing he's fixating on. It's like he's fixating on the things he can build in DC. He's fixating on the shapeliness of John Hestid's ass, and-- - It's not as good as himself. - Which is that particularly shapely. - No. - If I may say so myself. - I'm very mad. (laughing) - Go visit the governor of Maryland if you want to see. (laughing) Something impressive. - Sorry, Lass, I'm sorry. - I mean, he's fixated on his own decline. I mean, he's constantly talking about the mental tests they're giving him. Which if his doctors are testing his cognitive ability as frequently as they appear to be, then they're just tracking. They're just tracking his decline. That's what that is. - If any listeners can figure out what he means by that sentence I'd love to know. So I'm sure we have to have a trump audit of that. - Yeah, I can read it. - I can read it. - I'm trying to figure it out. - The grass is like a word destroyed by chemical poisoning with a large and inappropriate phrase. It must be a word that also has like a pun of some kind or he just mistyped, or it's a cafe situation. I don't know. - Right, right. - Here's another recent bleat of his come just going down the list and we're kind of going down into hell here. And it is about to make and the Amy Acton ad. We've been discussing this all week. You know, yesterday we just talked about how shamefully the vice president acted, you know, and giving affirmation to the message that Amy Acton's abusive and neglectful mother you know, said about her. Like JD Vance affirmatively endorses it and then says that the thing that disgusted him was that people would criticize it. Like that's the vice president's phrase just pretty interesting since he had a mother, not quite that bad, but that he wrote about. Here's Trump getting even lower. Vivek put up a very powerful ad about a mother saying that her daughter Amy Acton is running for governor Ohio is a liar and much worse. Frankly, anybody whose mother spoke about a daughter in that way would normally lead to the daughter being precluded from serving an office, let alone the office of governor. If my mother, the legendary Mary McCloud Trump, middle name again, said anything bad about me, the fake news would play it up. The Democrats would be supportive, et cetera, et cetera. He goes on, Vivek should keep it up and let everyone listen to the mother of a defective dishonest and capable candidate explain how the daughter is a disaster who lies, cheats and steals. That's the president of the United States on the ad of the mother who was complicit in the rape of her child running an advertisement about her. - You know, on one hand, is it really that much of a surprise that the president would immediately sympathize with someone who, as you said, was complicit in the rape of her child? I mean, this is Jeff Epstein's best friend. The thing I'm struck by, I gotta say, is I'm struck that Vance would double down. I don't expect Vance to sort of be like, oh, Vivek should take this down, but I feel like the smart political play for him would just be like, yeah, that was, that was, I wouldn't have done it, right? I wouldn't have done that kind of thing. We can go after the Democrats for other reasons beyond that. Just decision to double down and double that in a way that accentuates all of Vance's negatives. The fact that he seems kind of like nasty and petulant, the fact that like, you know, back in the 24 campaign, he had to apologize for that cat lady remark. Like, he is known for having this real nasty hostility towards women. - Yeah. - And here he is amplifying and defending and advertisement that is really just rooted in this nasty hostility towards a particular woman. Like, it's not like I expect better from JD Vance, right? - Sure. - But I did think he was smarter than this, 'cause what's the upside here? It makes gonna lose. I'm very kind, I like. - Vice-signalling is the upside. - Vice-signalling? - Vice-signalling to the base that like, there is no, you know, bad behavior. You know, there is no bad offensive statement that you could utter that I will not come to your defense for. I was kind of like when he came to the defense of the staffer, who was revealed to have the anti-India remarks. I forget if they're tax or social media posts and like, he could've just said nothing. He's like, I suppose everybody aggressively said, no, you know, we need to circle the wagons around the staffer who said absolutely disgustingly racist things about, you know, my wife's family, basically. It's like asserting to people like, I'm on your team, no matter what. I guess it's the political strategy. - I suppose that is the strategy, but it seems very short-sighted to me. 'Cause it kind of depends, like it hinges on people for getting this and obviously, you know, Americans do have short memories. But if Vance is in a competitive electoral situation, especially just against a Democrat, this stuff is gonna come up again. Like, this is gonna be part of the opposition against him. Sort of like, hey, this is a guy who, when given the choice to disoval, essentially the defense of a child rapist. No, he embraced it. It reflects the sense of which Vance is extremely confident about his political abilities. And I, you know, just obviously, I don't like the guy. But if I try to put on, you know, my John Madden hat here and like try to like, analyze it, analyze this like sports, he does not have the kind of record that would allow you to be like, yeah, you are an exceptional political talent. He's a political talent of some sort. He's vice president. But the evidence that he's the kind of guy that can successfully thread this needle in such a way as to not make him seem like just a total degenerate to a lot of people, It's not fair to me. Maybe he can do it. Maybe he can do it. But he's not, he doesn't have like, he doesn't have his boss as charisma, right? Trump can kind of do it because he's a tongue in cheek. Yeah. You know, kind of element of it. Trump, to a lot of people, does not seem like he's serious. And that's kind of the big asset, right? People, you can say crazy things. And if I was like, yeah, well, you know, this is Donald Trump. It's Trump. Roosevelt Vance says that you're like, is that guy a school shooter? Right? Like is that guy nasty? Yeah, that guy, that seems unphonic. Right. Yeah. I mean, J. J. Wilhelm, associate path yesterday in the newsletter. And I did this already with Kinsinger. And then I did it with Love It on his podcast. I just, I can't get past it. So I want to I need to do it one more time with you to see if you have any insight for me, which is like, the degree to which this it is also just a full abandonment and heel turn on the hillbilly allergy narrative. I just can't help but psychoanalyze that. It's like Amy Acton is the JD Vance hero character of Hillbilly Elegy. Right. And her disgusting mother is, you know, an embodiment of, you know, all of the systemic neglect and drug abuse that JD Vance was critiquing in Hillbilly Elegy. Right. And now you fast forward 10 years. And he's like, he's on the side of the abuser. He's like, the TV commercial by the abuser calls it like it is. He said yesterday, there's a strange psychological thing happening there, I think. So much of this, if we're going to get into psychoanalysis, please in Hillbilly, Hillbilly Elegy, the two kind of major characters are advances, neglectful, you know, addicts mother. And then it's tough knows, you know, kind of crazy grandmother who keeps them on the solid path. Right. I think this guy as much as he's sort of is like, yeah, I love my mom, like, I think I think he hates his mom. I think he hates that woman. Okay. And I think that it has metastasized into kind of like a general hatred of like women and especially independent women. He feels like his mother abandoned the traditional role of a mother and like ruined his childhood. And so he looks at women who do not take on that traditional role with a lot of hostility and a lot of anger. I think part of what's happening here is acting is like a stand-in for all of the cat women, cat ladies. He doesn't see acting as him. I'm going to read advance quote from a couple years ago. We are effectively running this country via the Democrat sphere, a corporate oligarchs by a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives and the choices they have made. And they want to make the rest of the country miserable too. I think that's how we see this in the acting. But the other part of this is I think also advance it's filled with self-loathing. I think, I think, Bant hates himself. Bant's constant attempts to fit some kind of role, to make himself malleable and acceptable to people. I think he has, he compared himself to Nixon recently. And I think that comparison is not great. I think Nixon a lot of ways is like a much more interesting and frankly better person, which is saying a lot. But one thing they share is this relentless commitment to striving, they have to strive, they have to get ahead. But also that striving is connected to a bottomless self-loathing. No matter how much they achieve, no matter how much Nixon achieve. Nixon is the president of the United States in 1972. He's at the top of the world. He's on the verge of winning one of the great re-election victories in American history. And yet this guy still feels like no one likes him. He has to do these terrible things to get ahead. He's obsessed with his critics. Right. And the right kind of people, the people whose, whose affirmation he needs are the people that don't like him. I think Bant has the same thing. And I actually think part of his apparent hatred of acting is like he may well see himself in her and hates it. Right. He sees someone from a similar kind of circumstance and he has nothing but contempt for it. Because he has contempt, he has contempt for himself, for being from the same kind of circumstances. He blames himself probably in some regard for having a tough childhood. Again, this is my cycle. I mean, I needed some aren't your therapy right now. But the guy does seem like a like a tangle of pathologies. Indeed. I want to talk about the other, another big story from a guy, I don't know the Jared Kushner is a tangle of pathologies. I think that he's pretty, pretty easy to read. But there's this vanity fair story. And I just want to say up front, I don't, you know, it's a lot of anonymous sources. And I think it's a little bit, you know, there's obviously Kushner's lawyers dispute parts of it. So, you know, I think that there will continue to be many more investigations into Jared Kushner's finances and stories in the months and years to come. But I just want to say what this report said. Apparently the Dutch, we're loving the Dutch right now. They've got a gay, you know, prime minister handsome. They flipped a Russian hacker. The hacker observed Jared logging into an Abu Dhabi bank account that held more than 700 million in transfers with funds routed through an izer by Johnny bank from Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Kushner described as a signatory not the owner. Source had Kushner appeared to transfer significant sums to various individuals, including a warlord, a mercenary, and a one time hitman. I think the important thing about this is like that necessarily the particulars at this point, but that the book frames this is like part of a broader plot between Kushner, NBC, and UAE, and MBS to remake the Middle East. And that they did so in a lot of ways that violate US disclosure rules, bribery statutes, foreign agent laws, etc. I think that that biggest umbrella narrative is certainly true. And the amazing thing I see posted about this is like, this is all stuff from eight years ago. I mean, who the fuck am I supposed to do it now? I mean, if all of this checks out, right, like if we can get further confirmation of this charge, then certainly this is the most significant bribery scandal in American history. And then you have to wonder like, well, how much money is getting passed around, right? How much influence is being sold? How much access is being sold? We know that they're basically running a pay for play pardon scheme. Like even if this is totally not true. Like even if this reporter got fooled by a fabulous. Okay. Well, like the still again, the broad contours like we do know now that the UAE has given what half a billion and the Trump family, you know, crypto point, you know, which is otherwise worthless. It wasn't for Trump's position. So like we know that like this money is sloshing around from Saudi and UAE. I mean, to me, this is just this is just for a future democratic Congress. This needs a standing subcommittee whose entire job is to just investigate this stuff. Standing subcommittee, give them the funding, give them the personnel and just say your job is to just investigate this stuff and present findings. And then, you know, if there's a democratic administration, 29, those findings become the basis for a criminal charge. There's nothing a little delicious about the fact that like all this money. I mean, you know, when did all gets added up in the end? It'll certainly be in the billions, you know, it gets getting passed around coming from these kind of kind of sharia law, oil, you know, protectors in the Middle East to buy off the Trump family. And now as we stand here today, like you can't even really safely fly into Saudi Arabia. Right, you know, I think there was a moment where where maybe this corrupt vision, you know, where like these guys were going to kind of do this like mercantilists in a different century. And like, maybe it like looked like it was going to work for a second. Like there were smart people who are like the Abraham Accords seem to be working. And what if they figure out how to get out Saudi Arabia in there, you know, we might be through a period of reproche law in the Middle East. And like instead, as we sit here today, like like all of that bribery and all of that corruption has led to like kind of just a non-ravelling of the security state and across the region. Yeah, I mean, there are smart people who looked at what was happening in the first term and said, maybe this worked out, but the people involved in trying to make it happen, not that smart, right? Like Jerry Christian, not that smart. Has a lot of money, you know, I don't have that billionaire. So yeah, good for you. But in terms of having any particular understanding of the dynamics here, I'm not that smart. I didn't even say that for MBS, right? Like I say that for these guys, right? Like they have a lot of money. And no one can tell them no, but that doesn't mean they're particularly smart. And these things kind of at least somewhat like he's read books. But I guess an MBS is a is whatever the Saudi version of a frat brought us. Right. Right. I mean, he's like, he's like Saudi cushioned, right? Like that's that's, I think that's why they were the good ones. Saudi down junior. I don't know. So that all of this would unravel because of both none of these people really understanding the histories or dynamics at work. And because the current administration, you know, takes this incredibly reckless step of starting this war without any any end game in mind or any way of actually resolving it. And then just plunging the Middle East into renewed chaos, to some extent, this is all like predictable. Like, okay, this is this is what you would get with a bunch of idiots at the helm. I don't know how, how else you can put it. And unfortunately, I mean the unfortunate thing is that like, these choices once made cannot be taken back. I mean, what's frustrating about Iran, say, the Trump is like, I think in his life, you can always just take it back, right? You can always kind of revert to the status quo ante. And here is a thing that's been done for, no, you can't go back, right? Choices have been made. This is the way things are. And there's no way for you really to say face here. You kind of have to write out the decisions you've made. And no one involved here is capable of doing that. No one involved here is capable of either taking an L or learning from an L. And so here we are. Well, back to Nixon. You know, these are just not very bright guys and things got out of hand. And to your point about not learning, there's another story I just wanted to flag. It's like relevant to all this about how they see the next two years, you know, particularly with regards to foreign affairs. There's a story out of the Washington Sun yesterday. It says that the State Department is violating a law about neutrality with regards to career civil servants. And they're going to be asking foreign service officers up for promotion who they voted for last three elections. Top officials in the State Department said that only candidates who voted for Trump would be eligible for mid to upper tier foreign service roles. They told candidates that their campaign donation history would be examined in any donations to the Democrats would be disqualified. So Donald Trump, people around him, they don't really have any loyalty to the United States or to its constitution, right? They have a loyalty to Donald Trump and his in the interests of the president, but no particular loyalty to like the actual national interests of the United States. And so yeah, I make total sense that they'd be like, yeah, the litmus chest for our foreign service officers is whether or not you voted for the president, which is insane, right? They're like, and by the way, Donald Trump donated to Democrats. So Jericho and it's like, this is just insane, and it's also this is Marco. By the way, this is Marco, the supposedly institutional one. Well, he's, you know, did he vote for Donald Trump in 2016? I'm not sure about that. He'll never, he'll take it to his grave, but can we be certain that he voted for Trump in 2016? I mean, I just, I just don't know what else there is to say about this like gang of jackals who are like willfully dismantling everything that makes the United States a functional country on the domestic and international stage. And they're doing it for, for what? I mean, like what's the purpose of this? Like what's the aim of this? Just to have a bunch of politically loyal people like, okay, what does that get you? If anything, it probably gets you the bottom of the barrel given who they want him to be, want these people to be loyal to. That's a good question to explore there because in some cases, I think that, okay, you know, we talk about this fair amount. Like why keep cash and hegseth and fire some of these other people and, and the concerning the furious reason for that is that you're keeping your options open for shenanigans and in the end of 2028 staying in power, manipulating the election, whatever, and you want done loyalists in there. And that's the most important thing, even if they're screwing up other stuff. Right. Matter though, like if the person, you know, who is, you know, whatever, the head of the Turkey office, you know, at the State Department is a loyalist, I don't know, some other country, Belgium. I don't know the answer to that. And to me, that is maybe more about just kind of like bitterness and resentfulness and like we want to punish the deep state people that came for us and, you know, whatever, teach a lesson to these, whatever, like Beltway lives. I mean, it goes back, I think to what I said earlier about trying to make the built landscape of Washington, DC, just a grand monument to Trump, arguably trying to do this into the federal bureaucracy itself, like the actual practical things that need to be done are less important than him knowing that everyone there views him as like a god, views him as the censor of the universe. And so he'll purge, purge people who have no particular problem working for him, right? Julia Curly, I interviewed her, but you know, she was a president, our vice president Pence's briefer and you know, purged her because she was transgender, it was totally willing to one wanted to serve the country. Purge them just because he can and because the most important thing to him is that people have given some explicit and affirmative statement of their loyalty to him specifically. I've said this before, my like relative election worries for 2026, it modest, like not nothing, but like I'm not like panic about it or anything. My election worries about 28, much greater, right? We have no evidence that Trump will legally willingly. We have none. It's not happened. Yeah. It's like loyalists make sense for that, but I think beyond that practical reason for him, it is like the only thing this guy cares about is feeding his immense and insatiable ego. That's like, that's that's really it. Nothing else matters to him. You also have a reason to come about somebody else that was tearing apart the federal government for a spell. 25 months, four months, I just went and re looked at it. It felt like he was in there for so long, you know, every day felt like a century with him in there, but he did leave in May. You write this. You want to spend more than a half billion dollars 24 and 26 to elect Republicans, yet hardly anyone in the media seems interested in asking Republicans to comment on his views and preoccupations. He traffics and lurid elimination of fantasies aimed at immigrants and racial minorities. And that's in top of the actual damage that he did to government workers, USAID, to the poorest people in the world, etc. It is pretty, like it's pretty noteworthy, you know. It's weird. Unquestionably, Elon Musk is directly responsible for the deaths of at least hundreds of thousands of children. That's a fact. And you would think that if you are Ken Paxton and you are your campaigns basically being funded by Elon's money. When he's on a candidate, actually, Hanson, do you think actually Hanson has been asked about Elon and Musk one time? Right. And I was on a race. Probably not. I would assume not. Hey, Hanson, your campaigns being backed up by Elon Musk, do you have any thoughts about the fact that he thinks immigrants should be rounded up and murdered? Like it seems like you should ask these people this. It's genuinely strange to me that it's like the political press treats Elon as if he is just like some eccentric inventor, and not someone who for four months was effectively running the federal government. Yeah. There's this interview from earlier this week. It's pretty, it was pretty stomach-turning for me. Did you, have you launched Walter Isaacson's interview with Elon Musk? Oh, no, I heard about it. Yeah. I just want to read just one little bit of it. Isaacson's asking him about like the interview is a sense way about his businesses. So like he starts this question in the premise about like, was that time in the government a distraction from the work that you could have been doing with XAI and the space and all that? And Musk, you know, talks, says, acknowledges, yes, but then he goes on to say it was kind of cool because I'm just there in the Oval Office while all these big moments as decisions are being made and having some impact on what's being done. Isaacson replies, so you seem to get a bit of intoxicated by it. Musk replies, I think that's true. I got carried away basically. Like he said it. He's like, I did it. I'm in there in the Oval Office and the richest man in the world. I'm in the Oval Office and I'm making decisions that led to, you know, as you mentioned, like the deaths of the most vulnerable children in the world, but also, you know, like the weakening of, you know, America's, you know, civil service, people getting fired. Right. Tent of thousands of American livelihoods, irrevocably changed. And who knows funding for research, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, he impacted things across so many different parts of the government in such a short period and he was like, I did it. I was there in the Oval Office and people, I kind of don't ask politicians who he supports to have to carry any of that baggage or, I mean, or maybe they don't see this baggage. They don't have to, you know, carry that with them in the same way that like Democrats have to answer for a son or whatever. Right. I mean, that's the thing. Like it'd be one thing if no one got asked about their associations and it's like, okay, well, that's just consistent. But I remember watching, Democrat after Democrat being asked about Hassan Piker and it's like, I don't know. At certain point, he's a streamer. I mean, Abdul campaigned with him. So I understand I'm doing asked about him sometimes. But like every interview I've told did is like, that was like the main line of questioning for him was like random things to sound said. And like meanwhile, I sounded don't need to at all these other, like Jon Ossoff gets asked about him. And like, you know, Elon Musk is literally funding the Republican Senate campaigns. But I think last, last update, he has spent $440 million, he's the largest single donor in American political history. And it's, it's crickets about, I mean, right now he's actively harming Ukraine. I mean, you're saying you could ask about the USAID stuff or the dismantling of the government. You could ask about all of his racist tweets. He's racist tweeting. Like even, it's not as if he. had only had power in the past. Like he currently has enough power that he's like throttling Ukraine's access to internet and causing deaths of Ukrainian kids. - He's interfering with actual American foreign policy unilaterally. And yeah, I just to repeat by myself, it just seems like Republican should be asked about this. Not even from like a partition, I want them to squirm. I mean, literally, this seems important. You're taking this guy's money. What do you think about this? - I don't know, I don't get it, I don't get it. - John Thun in the majority leader can go days if not weeks without hearing Mus name from a journalist. I think that was generous. I wanted to go find the last time that's John Thun was asked about Elon Musk. - Yeah, I think I was being a little generous. But no, I'd be generally speaking, I actually cannot think of a single Republican candidate for office who has been asked about Musk by anyone in political media. Anyone who'd be in a place to do it. - I mean, I think this week I did see there was some about the Ukraine thing in particular, but to the broader plan, you wrote this before that. I don't even cover this 'cause it's like what's the value and doing, hey, Elon Musk did another wide genocide tweet today. But do you just want to talk just for a second about the scale of the material he's trafficking in online? - Yeah, I mean, I wrote about this over the summer when that movie Citizen Vigilante came out and he was like furiously tweeting about it. This is a movie that's sort of just like, imagine Death Wish, the Charles Bronson movie, except somehow like both worse as a film and also way more fascist and racist. And I'm a Death Wish Defender, like I like that movie. I've seen all those movies. I think they have a certain charm to them. And like I imagine that kind of racist, authoritarian vigilante thriller, except somehow even more base and deprave and that's his vigilante. And so Elon was posting a lot about it and it was lots of stuff like, yeah, like in the movie he kills a bunch of immigrants. That's what you got to do. You got to kill the invaders. And then in the movie, the character, Army, Hammer's character is like killing white Germans who have used his responsible. It's like, yeah, and Elon's like, yeah, you got to kill the traitors before the invaders. He's like kind of repeating that all the time. And then just generally speaking, he's always tweeting things about how, you know, the great threat to the West is that the kind of the white birth rate, you know, the great, he's boosting far right parties that are explicitly, you know, pushing things like re-migration and he himself calls for re-migration, which is just like a term for ethnic cleansing, removing non-whites, forcefully removing non-whites from the society. Like this is what he is obsessed with. It's not hard to just scroll through his feed. In the same way that you scroll through Trump's feed and you found my client in nonsense, you scroll through Elon's feed and you very quickly get the picture of a guy who is not just prejudice, but like as an ideological white supremacist. And I think that's significant, right? I'm especially given that he's the biggest donor to the Republican Party and was shadow president for a little bit and interfering in our foreign affairs. And to go back to USAID took steps that are in line with the ideology, right? Like the kind of guy who's obsessed with white birth rates and obsessed with the idea that white people will be swamped globally than using his authority over the federal government to destroy a program that keeps the sustains hundreds of thousands of non-white black and brown children in Africa and other parts of the world, resulting in their deaths. Like that's all very consistent. And so I think it's like significant just for symbolic reasons, like it's symbolically important that the world's richest man and the top Republican donor in this former shadow president is also, you know, a David Duke level virulent white supremacist, but also this has had practical consequences for people's lives and that's also why it's important. And for whatever reason and, you know, I'm sure Isaacson did not ask about this at all. Like the image that still exists to Elon Musk is of Elon Musk circa 2008. Like he's a Tony Stark, right? But the actual Elon Musk is maybe one of the most important and powerful far-right political organizers and donors in the world. - I mean, in a half century, in the last, I mean, certainly in the 21st century. It's hard to think of anyone who's comparable in terms of his global reach, his global power, his authority, and his wealth. - And he's doing all the stuff Bannon was doing. The people were talking about, you know, kind of uniting all these far-right parties in various countries, and he's just doing it, you know, with money and tweets. And so if like Bannon was like moving into a castle in Italy and having conferences or whatever, but like it's the same. So. - Musk is encouraging pogroms in the UK against immigrants. And it's like, I don't know. I feel like if you take his money in American politics, you should have to answer for that. - I can car. - One thing I noticed when reviewing your material on this front, we were just discussing a son the second it goes, you seem to pretty assiduously avoid the Nira and Maddie versus Maddie and DSA discourse. - Oh yeah. - That's happening out there on the internet. It's like whether, you know, the Dems should go full economic populist or do you have, do you have thoughts on that? Is there a reason why, you know, you're not getting into the Twitter wars on those topics? - The main reason I just don't think it matters. (laughs) I just think, you know, a bunch of people who spend all their time posting on X are arguing about what people post on X is important, seem sort of just like, I don't care. To the extent that this is like a proxy for various factional battles, I think factional battles are gonna be settled on the ground in elections, in how people perform, in what particular political entrepreneurs do with the authority that they've gotten. I don't think these factional battles are gonna be resolved on social media websites. And this is just, you know, speaking to my own, like how I view my own role as a political commentator as a writer, I just don't think it is all that useful for me to wait in to this kind of discourse. What would someone actually learn? Like, my column this week. I can write about Ilhan Omar and I can tell people, I can teach people about the history of dematerialization the United States about, you know, the important parts of the Anglo-American political tradition. Like, I can use that column to not just talk about a particular issue, but instead of a larger questions and concerns, I can help people understand the world and make better political choices for themselves. Versus, I can, I don't argue with some people who post a lot on X. Like, I don't know, it just, it seems, to me, it seems like a waste of time. And that's, that's made, that's the main reason why I don't. I think that's wise. Is there a specific type of political entrepreneurship you're interested in? You're eyeing? I'm always to see how candidates themselves are responding to conditions on the ground. Like, how are they reading where voters are, how they're thinking about electorate, and how are they trying to synthesize various things? Right, that's why part of what I mean by factional values are going to be settled on the ground. So like, okay, should the Democrats be more economically popular? Should they be more centrist moderate? Well, you're seeing candidates attempt to kind of, kind of move and fuse these approaches together. Maybe sidestep cultural questions by elevating other issues and making, turning those into the relevant wedges, right? Like, responding to, you know, I think that the discourse just capture real dynamics that's happening. But because of the way discourse works, people solidify themselves into camps and say, well, either you do it this way or you lose. Whereas in practice, you look at someone like John Assoff, who is running in like a purple reddish state is likely going to blow out his opponent and is doing it by recognizing first that the kind of cultural issues that voters might be wary of Democrats are on are not fruitful for him. So instead, trying to create a new issue that does work for him. And that's corruption, right? Like raising the profile of corruption and making that the thing that you say, oh, if you are, if you care about this then vote for me, right? Raising the salience of a new issue, you know, James Tallerico kind of navigating this not through substance but by affect by being like, you know, I'm a very religious guy. This is my approach to public life, et cetera, et cetera. I think that's the world. Yeah. Well, the Bernie Krauts, I like the house candidates like the Bob Brooks and Sam Forstaggy. We're like, we'll do economic, popular stuff but also kind of culturally sort of tech to the middle and whatever, you know, whether it be immigration or crime or something like the guy and something like that, you know. It's much more interesting to me that you just observe how candidates are responding to the conditions than to argue about, like essentially, a bunch of people who have never run an election to arguing about how to win elections. Like, I don't know. I've learned to end with that some wisdom, especially on what, or in 10 days after the election, if you find yourself tweeting in that factional battle and you've never won an election and you're, maybe just go knock on doors this weekend, you know. Just go call friends. You're not there in the world and try to encourage, encourage friends to vote. I think that would be healthy. And I'll say this. If you are someone who's just interested in politics, go knock on doors. I genuinely think that if you are inclined to argue a lot about politics on the internet, the best thing you can do is knock on doors in the end. talk to actual voters because it will disabuse you of so many things you think you know about the public. Producer Katie had our answer. She figured out we couldn't about what the phrase was that he was talking about. Trump said that the grass areas were destroyed by chemical poisoning with the large and very inappropriate phrase. It was 8, 6, 4, 7. Remember somebody put 8, 6, 4, 7 into the grass. Okay. And now we fixed that. We fixed that. Because I mean, that's what he was elected to do. You know, to crack down on people's free speech rights of saying numbers than an order that he doesn't like because he thinks it's mean to him. All right. That's Jim Elbowey, man. I appreciate you always and hope we can do it again in the new year, right? Yeah. Thank you so much for having me. All right. Everybody else, we'll be back on Monday with another edition of the show. See you all then. Peace. [MUSIC] The board daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper, associate producer Anzali Skipper, and with video editing by Dante DeCicco and audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Jamal Buie uses the "cargo cult" metaphor to describe how the Trump administration acts like it knows how to build an authoritarian state without understanding the actual mechanisms needed, resulting in illegal, absurd, and ineffective actions.
  2. The case against Ilhan Omar involves a baseless accusation of 30-year-old paperwork fraud, which Buie argues is both politically motivated and racially charged, targeting a Somali-American critic of the president.
  3. The attack on Omar violates constitutional protections, including the Speech and Debate Clause and Congress’s right to judge its own members, echoing historical attempts by rulers to undermine parliamentary authority.
  4. The administration’s actions—such as falsely claiming Omar’s name and family ties—are deeply racist and reminiscent of past political suppression, like the removal of Emma Goldman, and show a pattern of targeting minority voices.
  5. Elon Musk’s influence as a top Republican donor and shadow president is highlighted as a dangerous, ideologically extreme force, promoting white supremacy and actively harming foreign policy and global human rights.
  6. The State Department’s policy of promoting only Trump voters for foreign service roles reveals a core loyalty to the president over national interest, undermining institutional integrity and neutrality.
  7. Buie critiques the political media’s failure to hold Republican leaders accountable for ties to figures like Musk, despite their funding and influence on key policy decisions.
  8. The broader issue is the administration’s insatiable, ego-driven will to power, which manifests in both menacing authoritarianism and clownish absurdity, ultimately damaging democratic institutions without achieving its goals.

Summary:

Jamal Buie critiques the Trump administration through the "cargo cult" metaphor, illustrating how it pursues an authoritarian vision without the practical means or understanding to achieve it—leading to absurd, illegal, and deeply unpopular actions. He dissects the case against Ilhan Omar, arguing it is rooted in a false, racist narrative about 30-year-old paperwork and a violation of constitutional protections for Congress members. The attack reflects a broader pattern of targeting dissenting voices, especially from minority backgrounds, and draws historical parallels to past political suppression.

Buie also highlights Elon Musk’s role as a powerful, ideologically extreme figure—funding Republican campaigns, interfering in foreign policy, and promoting white supremacist ideologies—while criticizing the media’s failure to hold Republican leaders accountable. He points to systemic failures within the State Department, where loyalty to Trump overrides national interest, and underscores the need for institutional oversight. Ultimately, Buie sees the administration’s actions as driven by an insatiable ego, not strategic governance, resulting in chaos, erosion of democratic norms, and a dangerous mix of menace and absurdity that undermines the United States’ political and international stability.

FAQs

The 'cargo cult' metaphor refers to people in Polynesian islands during WWII who developed rituals to summon supplies after the war ended and planes stopped flying. It applies to the Trump administration by highlighting a disconnect between its desired authoritarian end state and the actual, practical methods used—suggesting that the administration's actions are more symbolic or performative than effective or legitimate.

Ilhan Omar, a Congresswoman, was targeted for her criticism of the president. Buie argues that the investigation, especially the intrusion into her home, violates the Speech and Debate Clause, which protects members of Congress. He sees this as an attack on Congress's autonomy and a violation of constitutional traditions where Congress is the judge of its own members.

The claims about Ilhan Omar’s name and her being married to her brother are false and racially charged, echoing birtherism and racist stereotypes. Buie sees this as a deliberate, absurd attempt to delegitimize her and show a pattern of using hate speech and misinformation to undermine political opponents.

The State Department has reportedly promoted only those who voted for Trump, disqualifying those who donated to Democrats. This reflects a loyalty-based system that prioritizes political allegiance over national interests, undermining the neutrality and effectiveness of U.S. diplomacy.

Trump’s actions are described as both comically absurd—like targeting a sitting Congresswoman over 30-year-old paperwork—and deeply threatening, such as using aggressive, illegal tactics to undermine democratic institutions. This duality shows a lack of coherent strategy, blending irrationality with a real desire to consolidate authoritarian power.

By making loyalty to Trump a litmus test for foreign service promotions, the administration disregards the principle of merit and neutrality. This undermines the professionalism and effectiveness of the foreign service, prioritizing political loyalty over competence and national interest.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.