This final episode of the Ampersam podcast reflects on the album’s opening track, “Intros in the Rares,” which serves as both a narrative anchor and a thematic exploration of storytelling. Dan and Emma delve into the ethics of representing people from different backgrounds, discussing whether artists can authentically tell stories outside their own experiences. They emphasize that while artistic empathy is essential, structural inequalities often mean that marginalized voices remain silenced or underrepresented in the public sphere. The song’s sound is intentionally raw and organic—featuring ambient room noises, tape effects, and layered vocals—to mirror the fragmented, subjective nature of memory and narrative. The process of creating the album was deeply personal and collaborative, shaped by Dan’s songwriting and Emma’s academic research, especially her PhD on narrative and perspective. They highlight how writing about others often leads to self-reflection, turning the work personal and complex. A key theme is the responsibility of storytellers to avoid exploitation and to question who gets to tell stories and who gets to be seen as empathetic or creative. The episode also celebrates collaboration, particularly with Bim, whose song “Soprano and Midnight Wanderings” exemplifies emotional depth and authenticity. Finally, the "homework" format—a system where listeners research historical figures and write songs about them—demonstrates a reciprocal relationship between music and academic inquiry, fostering deeper engagement with history, identity, and narrative. The conversation closes with a fun quiz on myths, history, and language, reinforcing the podcast’s playful, intellectual spirit.
Hi, I'm dance with a musician, songwriter and composer.
And I'm Emma Nagus and I'm an academic.
I've been writing songs about pairs of interesting people and ideas.
And I went to Emma a while ago and asked for her help in uncovering stories I'm in or heard of.
And in this podcast, we're going to talk about the people in those songs.
We're going to have conversations about history, music, mythology, pop culture,
and how those things can sometimes overlap.
We're going to use this as an ampersam podcast.
Woo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo,
Do you know the words?
Emma and I are going to take you on a journey to the lies of these really amazing people.
And how they lived and what they did in the music.
Everyone, the ampersam podcast, yay!
You did it, you did it.
Well done.
Thank you for supporting me through that.
Today, Dan, we're going to close out the series by chatting about the track intros and narrators
because it's the opening track of the album.
And that's like symmetry, I suppose.
So that's what we're going to do.
Do we have a historical or mythological figure to talk about?
No.
But we're going to have an interesting chat about storytelling, reflect on the process of making the album,
the process of making the podcast.
And we're going to shoehorn that into our format somehow in hope that it makes sense.
So if you haven't heard intros and narrators,
but I think you probably have,
this is when we normally would play a snippet of the song.
And so we're just going to skip that bit.
If that's all right with you.
No, you're supposed to go, "No, okay, Dan, I'm going to play it."
Never mind, Dan, you're not needed.
Oh, wow.
A chat?
Oh, we both get heckled.
I love this.
Okay, however, it does seem like a bit of a waste.
Have a room full of people or a room full of a dancemith, and not have a dancemith.
Play it for you.
So, play it.
Play it.
Woo!
Play it.
Play it.
Play it.
[Laughter]
[Music]
♪ I never wanted to be me character ♪
♪ Pretty fucked up there in the light ♪
♪ I rather sit at the kitchen table ♪
♪ Just hard to hitchhike ♪
♪ Maybe to me are the storehories ♪
♪ I'm more interesting ♪
♪ May he be to me ♪
♪ There'll mirror back on everything ♪
♪ So much bigger bolder ♪
♪ Braveer than I'll ever be ♪
♪ Mm-hmm, so ♪
♪ Take a walk with me through these lies ♪
♪ I'm your friend, your lover, and your traitor ♪
Take a walk with me through my mind But I'm an unreliable narrator, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I'm your unreliable narrator.
Lovely stuff.
Thank you.
I remember when you first sent me in "Rose in the Rares" ages ago, and I knew you were writing an album sort of about history,
and you said that you didn't want to lay it on too thick, that you were writing an album about history.
So that, like, as in people could listen to the songs and not necessarily think, "This is about Julie Doverney," or "This is about Paul Robeson,"
much to my, like, "Dismay," because that would be ideal for me.
But when you saw you sent "Intros in the Rares," which is, like, quite instructional to me, for the listener to engage with them, like, songs about the past,
I was a bit like, "What? What?"
Yeah.
I think I'm gonna be saying, "This is not what I expected," and it sounds like the opening track of a musical.
I did say that.
But I didn't know. Yeah.
I get what you were doing.
You were trying to make me delete the song.
No!
But I didn't fucking what.
Listen.
I feel like I'm really nice about your songs.
You are, thank you.
And I feel like, if once in a while, I don't give something that. That's not even a criticism.
No, no, no.
But if I don't just say something, then. It's sort of a context.
It came out of the heels of me saying that I wasn't the biggest musicals fan.
Did it?
Maybe.
Well, listen.
Do I feel. Do I feel like it could get the Mamma Mia treatment sometime down the line?
Yes.
Do I feel like there's a lot of exposition in it?
And could I sort of hear an array of a musical being like, "Take a walk with.?"
Yes, I guess.
But I like musicals, so that wasn't pejorative for me.
Okay.
So I'm glad you remembered it and held on to it all this time.
Really, you didn't mind?
I just kept it till today, but now I've let it. Now it's free.
I've let it go.
Okay, great.
So it's the last episode, so we're just letting go of all of our resentments.
I'll remember that.
I'll make some notes in the interval.
Anyway.
Going back to the question that I feel like you're evading.
Yeah, so yeah, I was just surprised because you said that when you write songs about history,
you don't always, like, show it down people's thoughts that it's about history,
so they could listen to it and not really know.
Yeah, this song was very much like, "This is actually about people in the past."
And so why write the song?
I think in the process of writing all of these songs and of thinking about all these lives
and what my position in writing about them was or what write had to be writing about them.
I thought about maybe. It was kind of letting the process, thought about questions that I might get.
And yeah, I guess I thought. I'm just going to get ahead of that and write my defense before anyone says anything.
And preempts of criticism.
I think also it was because I've been thinking loads about the position of the narrator
in pretty much anything and everything.
The idea of storytelling, the idea of how songs used to be,
how people spread news and, you know, and remembered other people.
Yeah, I guess I'd been ruminating on it a bunch and thought it could be interesting to put it into a song.
And also to give context.
So it wasn't just, I don't know, the last few albums that we've done,
I've tried to, at the end, kind of sum up to use a wanky word,
like thesis of what the album is to introduce it.
That hasn't always come at the beginning of an album, but in this one,
it felt like it fitted with this sort of narrative book-esque thing.
Good answer, right?
No, it's a good answer.
I was thinking, like, you always say this album isn't a history lesson,
but you do start it with, like, an introduction, which, you know. I think because I spent quite a lot of time thinking about whether or not I should be telling these stories,
what perspective I should be singing from or not,
but still despite all the questioning plowed ahead and did it naively.
That it would be interesting to sort of. I guess be super honest.
And a thing that happened in this album was even though it's a lot of things reflected through other people
and tries to kind of represent them in ways that I think are honest and fair.
A lot of it kind of came back on me and a bunch of it ended up being quite personal.
I guess this, yeah, also was me thinking about why I so often like to write via other stories and other people,
which is something that I've kind of always done.
But yeah, pretty much anything I can do.
So I thought about it, go write a fucking song about it.
And here we are.
And here we are.
Yeah.
A wanky word such as a thesis.
What's wanky about thesis?
I just think when I say it, a new say is wicked.
Oh, thanks me.
Speak in a few thesises.
Yes.
I'm preempting that you're going to want to ask me a question about mine because you've written it in the script.
Yeah.
Dan says he wants to ask Emma about their thesis.
Well, one of the reasons I wanted to do this episode is because when I first sent you intros
and was talking about the idea of writing this song, you were also writing the introduction to your PhD.
And had these really interesting insights, as you often do, about how the demands of these parallel tasks,
your academia and my attempt of writing songs were both similar and quite different.
So I just, I guess I was really keen because it was interesting to me to sort of in the spirit of this podcast,
ask you to talk about it a little bit.
What you're thinking?
So when you told me about the song, picture it.
It was Rueville Whales.
I'd like driven to Rueville Whales to lock myself away to write my PhD without distractions.
My phone goes on day one.
What you know about Eve?
Also, what's interested about Paul Robeson?
Also, the concept of introductions.
Anyway, it was a great time.
Did I write any of my PhD notes?
But I was there to write introductions to my PhD thesis.
And yeah, it was interesting to me because, yeah, you just said that you were writing this song.
And it's basically the TLDR of it being.
I'm writing about stories that I don't really have a connection to, but that's okay.
yng Nghymru'r ddod, ac mae'r ddod yng Nghymru'r ddod yng Nghymru'r ddod yng Nghymru'r ddod yng
Mae'n fwy'r fwy'r gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith y gallu'r gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwa
Mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny, mae hynny
Mae'n unrhyw yn fawr i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i
dwi'n gwaith ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch ymwch
I don't think you do you want to know that.
I'm just going to call under the table while you answer this.
What do you think?
I definitely sort of naively like skipped ahead and started writing these songs
and then when it came to sort of speaking to you,
actually throughout the process I found myself working on this whilst doing other projects
and other things and at one point was working on some music for a documentary
and spoke to this great media, this production company that do kind of quite thoughtful documentaries
with purpose.
I was sort of chatting to them about the idea of the album,
but how I was reluctant with some of it because I felt like,
does it matter that I maybe don't have the same experiences as some of the people I'm writing about?
And they sort of said that they wrestle with that all the time
so they just try and approach everything as kind of with this much information
and it is like generous and interested away as possible
and it ever feels like exploitation that that's a big alarm,
which you would hope and assume it would be.
But yeah, I guess I don't know really.
I think I have the ability to be, to completely recognise and question it
but I also still plowed ahead with the album.
But he did it anyway.
Which probably says a lot.
But yeah, I guess trying to be as thoughtful and informed as possible.
But yeah, anyway.
So for me, I guess there's, in terms of should or can people tell stories
about, I guess, communities or people they don't belong to?
I mean, that comes up a lot with art.
It comes up a lot in academia as well and I guess there's some similar,
some overlap and some different factors.
I guess there's like an aesthetic or artistic
and a structural aside to that discussion.
So I think like, this is getting wonky really fast.
You probably signed up for like, you know, episode in Marie Curie,
boop, boop, boop, boop, boop, boop, talking about someone's life.
But let's talk about aesthetics, creativity.
No, but yeah.
But there is, I think, an aesthetic aside to this answer in a structural one.
So can an artist is an artist able to write stuff outside of their experience
and should they be able to?
I think like broadly in an ideal world, yes.
Like lots of, like all great artists, like has empathy.
There's a quote that, I don't know who said it, I got to remember.
But it's something like, if artists aren't able to do that,
then there's no fiction, there's just memoir.
So, you know, I think that's a great, a great line.
So yeah, this idea that, yes, that's what the essence of art is.
It's being able to step into other people's experiences.
And you see that as well.
A lot, I think, in public discourse with actors.
So like, should any actor be able to play any role?
And again, I think aesthetically creatively, yes.
However, we don't live in a perfect world.
And we don't live in a world with equitable access, with fair representation.
So there are structural things that play there as well.
And yeah, every actor should be able to play any role they probably can,
especially if they're good at it.
But when not everyone is getting into every room,
and not everyone is being held up enough,
then there are like short and medium term practical things that need to be done,
in order to let us get to that longer term political ideal.
So yeah, so I think, yeah, ideally yes, but there are structural things that play.
So I think if I was going to do it, I would maybe ask myself,
if I didn't belong to that community,
is this group still oppressed?
And is that group able, well, they are able to tell their own stories,
but are they?
Why am I the one being held up being able to do this?
Is there a reason those voices are still being silenced?
And so maybe that's the first question.
But I think also, I guess,
also should people materially profit from the stories of people who are still oppressed.
That's another question.
But then I think a lot of bad art happens,
because people don't have enough empathy to do it well.
And that's when those people's experiences are written about by people
who don't understand, and then that leads to the bad stuff,
like objectifying people or their experiences,
or minimizing them, or misrepresenting them,
which, when they're still oppressed,
can have real world implications in how they're treated.
And I think the flip side to that,
in terms of, should you be able to tell,
it's not you, Dan, one,
should one be able to tell any story,
is the other question of like,
who has the privilege of being engaged with as a storyteller as well?
And like who gets seen is like an empathetic genius creative
and who doesn't.
So you know I'm going to say this,
so I hope you don't get upset.
So even Paradise Lost, let's talk about it.
I love it.
No, I love it.
It's, I love it so much.
It's my favorite song on the album.
And I think, yay.
And yes, Dan.
Woo, Paradise Lost.
You know, I love it.
And I think Dan does,
does well into that category of artists,
who is so great and has enough empathy
that can do it incredibly well.
But I guess it, yay.
I guess the interest and thought experiment, though,
is would it have been received in the same way
is this like stunning practice of empathy
if a woman had written it, for example.
If a woman artist had written about women's pain,
had written about women's mistreatment and ignorance.
And who can say,
and I suspect maybe not?
And that's a separate conversation of like,
who gets to tell stories,
but who gets the,
the acclaim of like empathetic creativity and genius.
I guess I suppose,
and it goes back to the earliest of that we were saying about,
and academia is,
I suspect in like public consciousness,
unaffected people's ability to like creatively communicate empathy,
is usually I think,
prized more than oppressed people's
creative ability to communicate their own experiences.
So I guess that's just,
maybe something that I think about as well.
I don't know me, you know.
Briefly, that would be my answer.
That was difficult for both of us,
but this is safe space.
Thanks for that.
Yeah, and welcome.
Thanks for that.
No, it was, that was amazing.
Like,
what to say.
What to say.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I found your response too,
well, to intros.
Yeah, really,
it was really interesting.
And it was kind of like,
at the beginning of us talking about,
and yeah, just to sort of come back to it,
I guess you didn't expect this collection of songs to have one like that at all.
I'm kind of weird timing that you were also writing your thesis about,
trying to horribly distracted by me.
Sorry about that.
How's that PhD going?
Fuck you.
How dare you attack me like that in this public forum?
Actually,
my deadline's the 15th of January.
So, anyway.
So, should we go back to the comfort zone?
Should we talk about the sound of the song?
Thank you.
Well, normally in the podcast,
by the end of the episode,
we talk about the sound of the song.
Yeah.
But we're going very funky with the format.
We're funky.
You said it.
You said it.
So, I. Just like this.
So. We're going to talk about the sound of the song, Dan.
Okay.
Stay on script.
Fucking hell.
Right.
So, Dan, let's talk about the sound of the song.
to talk about the sound of intros in the raiders.
- I'd say with this song, I guess,
I wanted to start with a kind of chant
that would be maybe a sound that people might expect
from Bastille or from music that I make.
And then we basically recorded it,
ran it through tape and slowed down the tape.
So it kind of falls apart and breaks away, changes key.
- What's the chant?
- Oh, you heard it.
- No, no, no, I couldn't.
In a record and we play a little clip,
but we can't leave out the people in the room.
- It just says I a lot.
- Oh, that's what you're doing, right, right, okay.
I get it.
- And I guess what I wanted to start with the sound
maybe would be familiar or expected from me or from us
and then to kind of immediately undermine it
and drop down into a different key.
♪ I never wanted to be main character ♪
♪ Really fucked up there in the light ♪
I'm seeing a lola and essentially the sound of the song
is it's all kind of real organic sounds,
which was recorded like in a house and in a studio
and you can hear very sort of intentionally
the sort of messiness fingers on guitar strings,
you can hear creaks on the piano stool,
you can hear the rain on the roof,
wanted it to basically just feel as organic as possible.
But also it kind of introduces everyone,
this cast of characters that come up throughout the album.
So there's Moira's vocals, there's BIM's vocals
that are kind of threaded throughout
all the different instruments that kind of come and go.
So yeah, sort of, maybe it is like the opening
of a musical, fuck.
(audience laughing)
- Listen.
(laughing)
- Is there anything wrong with that?
- No, nothing wrong with that sort.
And yeah, so I guess that was it really
with the sound of it.
I wanted it to feel warm and like with a lot of the songs
on this moved everything down so that it felt like,
I felt like with this song and everything I was trying
to say in it, not to mention a lot of the other ones.
It just didn't need me shouting out here.
Didn't need me like holding it.
- You do yell at the end, do you trust me?
♪ Can you trust me? ♪
♪ Do you trust me? ♪
- Yeah, it does.
(laughing)
I don't know if I trust myself.
Yeah, no, that is true.
But yeah, I think it is sort of over the course of it,
it kind of encapsulates everything.
Hopefully, that's the idea with the sound.
And it introduces lots of other voices
and lots of other musicians and instruments
and the sound of the tape
and the sound of the rooms, basically.
- I really like the. I'm really bad at talking about music,
which is what we've discovered throughout this.
- That's true.
- I said the word resonance once.
- You also said the word, you said the word.
- You said the word, like the only thing I've ever heard.
- Let's all forget, you said the word funky.
- Oh!
- Stop it.
Yeah, I did, I did say the word funky.
Okay, so yeah, in terms of the like all the voices
and the vocals, and there's layering of your vocals as well.
Is it?
- Yes, yeah.
- Yeah.
And so I'm assuming it was like really intentional
for that to be like evocative of the idea
that this whole album is about stories being told
and re-talled to support with your version of them.
I guess that's what we were going for.
- Totally.
- With the layering of the vocals.
I thought that was sick.
- Thanks, that was so intentional.
(laughing)
- I sent this to my sister, and she was like, referring
to the middle eight bitch.
She was like, "It's just so clever how you say
"the history repeats itself line twice."
And I was like, "Yeah."
(laughing)
Yeah, yeah, oh, yeah, there, there wasn't it.
Yeah, thanks.
Definitely wasn't going to feel like
there was something else later.
No, yeah, thanks for that, yeah, nice one.
- It's like in a blue sky, the thing there,
I remember you saying, didn't someone say it's amazing
how he says, "Sug about not feeling electric,"
and then the guitar comes in and you were like,
"Yeah, that was totally intentional."
- Oh, very intentional, yeah.
- Did he want to say something about trums?
- Yes, so that was me doing an heir drum.
What you don't see in the podcast booth
is Dan is basically incapable of talking about
an instrument and not heir doing it.
- Oh, yeah, it's so embarrassing.
- So it's very bizarre.
- So it's very bizarre, I was doing this,
and then I was like. - Yeah, cool.
- Shut up.
- What about saxophones?
Any saxophones?
- Yeah.
(laughing)
- Anyway, drums.
- Yeah. - Yeah.
- Well, yeah, I guess as part of the process,
like this song, like with a lot of them,
came down to the spontaneity of what was happening
in the room.
So there's a version of this where in the second verse,
it kind of kicked in and a beat,
oh, yeah, did it, yeah.
(laughing)
I was gonna sit on my hands.
- No, come on.
- Don't express yourself.
- Oh, yeah.
- Yeah, basically, there was no point,
other than that there was a version with drums
that it was awful.
(laughing)
And entirely betraying everything at no more.
- Okay.
(laughing)
- But totally betrays everything I said earlier.
I mean, you're about to hear some demos a bit later,
and. (cheering)
And hopefully, if these songs ever come out,
you'll hear the cosmic disparity between where they start
and where they end up, when people who are much more talented
than me get involved and help me make them better.
But yeah, there was a version with drums kicking in.
I felt like my laptop hid that, but. - Oh, sorry.
- You did it.
- Unfortunately, before he got away with it.
- Yeah, I'm it.
(laughing)
It's fine, if I'm gonna do it, you can do it.
Yeah, but that's just part of the creative process.
It existed, and then we deleted it 'cause it was shit.
(laughing)
- In terms of the demos, you're gonna hear later.
In the green room, you're like, "Where's Dan? Where's Dan?"
And he'd identified a music room back there
that had a piano in, and he was doing them
like his homework literally just now.
So the stuff that you're gonna hear is literally him being like,
"Uh, the Frida Kahlo."
(laughing)
Like, it's so funny.
Anyway, so that bit's all there now.
- Okay.
- Thank God. - Yes.
- So this was the bit that we were both very nervous about,
and it's all there, so now is good times only.
(laughing)
- Yeah, Frida Kahlo.
- That was great. - Yeah.
Okay, so this is what they call in the business a segue,
so just get on board.
Speaking of intros and narrators, Dan.
- Oh yeah.
(laughing)
- That wasn't in the scripts, that was all me.
My only contribution to the night.
- I actually missed it. - Oh yeah.
- All right.
(laughing)
- Listed it straight out of the introduction to one of my songs.
- Oh yeah.
(laughing)
- That's not in the script.
You've thrown me off, no one can.
Right.
Speaking of intros and narrators.
No, okay, rather.
Oh yeah, okay.
Do you think we should intro another narrator
on the album?
- Of that.
- This is the special guest.
(cheering)
Has anyone guessed who it might be?
(cheering)
What was that to a shoutout louder?
- Bim.
- Was it, was it, was it Bim?
- I think it might be Bim.
I think he might be absolutely correct,
'cause it is Bim.
(cheering)
Don't introduce Bim.
- Let's hear it for Bim, everybody.
(cheering)
- Yeah, please sit down.
Bim is an insanely talented songwriter, singer.
(cheering)
Vocal arranger and choir leader.
I'm a huge fan of her voice and her work,
and I've had the massive privilege of touring
and working with Bim for many years now.
She's very generously suggested writing the song
that became the soprano and midnight wanderings
for this album.
And it's one of the most beautiful pieces of music
I think I've ever been involved in making.
So let's hear it for the incredible Bim, everyone.
(cheering)
- Thank you, I'm suitably embarrassed.
- You're suitably embarrassed.
- Thank you so much.
- Basically we invited his day as a massive fan of your work.
And I guess what let's talk about storytelling with you?
- Yes.
- In songwriting.
And I just would love to hear a bit about your process
as a writer, and what's your way into a song
into a story that is it come from a feeling
or an emotional space, or the spark of an idea,
or a desire to say something specific,
or like me, is it just different every time?
- I think it's different every single time.
And it depends on who you're writing for,
what you're writing for, what you're doing with it.
If in the case of the soprano, it's very different
than if someone asked me to come and wail
all over a dance track.
- I also would always want to hear.
- I mean, it's nice wailing.
- Yeah.
(laughing)
- It's kind of loud.
(laughing)
- That'd be like good loud.
- Yeah, it depends on what you're,
I always kind of feel like once I hear something
in the music, then I always hear something in their first.
And always my initial thought is always the right one.
I always go back to my first thought.
So if I listen to it and I thought to myself,
okay, this really is talking about,
it reminds me of the closing night in IBFA
and we need to be talking about dancing
and getting close and so on.
I can go around the houses with about 15 other ideas.
I will go back to that closing night.
- That's really interesting, yeah.
And when you're not writing for on other people's stuff,
like how's that process for you?
And do you think about, like,
I obviously have quite, like I rarely write
from the same perspective or like often,
you know, what I admire and say someone like Laura Marling
is her ability to tell stories that feel really personal.
And I would maybe always assume the songs are about her life
and also about graphical,
but in reading her talk about them,
she speaks so much about how they're often mythological
or from someone else's perspective.
[BLANK_AUDIO]
your writing, is it generally about you,
or do you think about the perspective
and sort of where it's coming from or who it's coming from?
- I think I really write on my mood.
So sometimes depending on the day of the week
or what I've been doing,
some of the things are going to be personal,
but then when I write them down, most of the time,
I end up cutting a lot of that out.
I'm not that kind of person.
I don't really want you to know my business to be fair.
(laughing)
It ends up being like really personal
and then I'm like, "Absolutely not."
And then I kind of think, "What's the wider theme?"
"Shall we go with the wider theme?"
And then I kind of delve a little bit into that.
But yeah, I do like to write about a particular feeling
or sometimes I've read something
or I'm thinking of the perspective of the person.
I'm always trying to kind of think, "Shall we flip it?"
So if I hear something and I'm thinking,
"Oh, that's the first person."
What did the person who heard about it afterwards think?
- Yeah.
- Can I write something from that?
For me, sometimes I just don't exercise for me.
I like to do that and it's not gonna go anywhere.
- Can you talk a bit about the song cinematic?
- Just 'cause I'm fascinated.
When I hear you at a show
and you talk about the song at the beginning
and you're almost set it up like a game
and I think about how it is for the listener
but also how it must have been for you writing it.
- Well, okay, so I wrote a song called cinematic
and it's, it's like, woo, woo, woo, woo.
(laughing)
And basically I kind of set myself a challenge
that I wanted to get as many references
to films in there as possible
but kind of classic films.
So, you know, 90s films.
- Bobbi.
- No?
- Bobbi didn't make it because it was,
it was pre-dates Bobbi.
- It was pre-dates Bobbi.
You said it would have made it.
- Okay, okay.
- But it didn't quite make it.
So I kind of set myself a challenge.
I'm gonna write these this song
and I wanted to kind of talk about cinematic love.
You know, that kind of, I do this kind of intro
when I kind of sing it and I'm like,
well, you know, that overblown love
where people kind of jump through rings of fire
and people are sword fighting just for, you know,
to rescue someone, et cetera, et cetera.
- Totally normal stuff.
And that's the kind of love
that we're kind of set up to want
that kind of unreachable love
where there's a hero in your life, et cetera, et cetera.
Wanted to write about that.
And so I thought, okay,
I am going to write about all of the different films
that I can think of which have those kind of leads in them.
And so I talk about, you know,
running down the street with a tutu
and that talks about sex in a city
and then I talk about, you know, swords and the shields
and we're talking about 300
and we're talking about gladiator and we're talking,
so all of those different bits
and I just thought to myself,
how many references can I get in
and how fast can I sing?
- How many did you get in?
- I think I got about 45.
- Fuck off.
- Yeah, like if I go through line by line,
but also I've got references to Josephine Baker,
I've got references to the first black actress
to ever do ballet in a film, in a mainstream film.
And so there's a tiny references
and maybe referencing free films per line.
- That's amazing.
- Depending in places.
- And it still makes emotional sense as well.
- Yes, 'cause it has to make sense.
So I thought it'd be really nice to be talking about,
like I don't know, Lion King, but like no one cares.
So I just looked back to different.
- You know, I mean, I love Lion King,
but you know, when it comes to romance,
we don't want me to get into that.
- Yeah, so let me get in with romance.
- I mean, it's not a kind of romance though.
Let's move on.
So yeah, there's just, yeah.
So I just wanted to kind of speak on that
and I think from a woman's perspective,
that's what we're set up for.
It's kind of like this is the kind of love that you should have
and you should be expecting someone to swoop in as a hero.
You're the Cinderella, you're the Snow White,
and I kind of thought, well, no, not really,
but we kind of aspire to have that kind of feeling,
that depth of love, but not necessarily the hero section.
- Well, it's such a great song.
If anyone hasn't heard it, go check it out.
It's brilliant.
- Thank you.
- And yeah, I'm really interested just to know
about the idea of collaboration and how you find that.
And if you like writing with other people,
if you prefer writing by yourself,
if you find that it brings out something different or not,
and what you kind of do and don't love about co-writing.
- I'd like to know what it was like writing with Dan.
- Everybody wants to know it's like writing with Dan.
- Can I also say, Dan also wants to know
what it's like writing with Dan.
- And ask me to ask them, and. - Okay, so let's really talk.
- Right, okay, yeah.
- Okay, I'll be very honest.
I'll be very honest.
Writing with Dan is actually really, really nice.
- No.
- I'm not, I kid you not.
Not because he's sitting here and we'll kick him.
And we'll kick me off the broadcast.
It's actually really nice to write with Dan
because he's very accommodating.
So the subject of the soprano is quite close to my heart.
I found it quite difficult to write certain things.
I wanted to put more into it,
but initially I found that quite difficult.
And he was very good at giving me enough space
and giving suggestions without kind of encroaching
and which I really appreciated.
And you don't get that.
I do a lot of co-writing with producers.
Hey, it can get quite difficult.
It can get quite fraught.
But yeah, it was actually a really nice process.
I mean, I'll be very honest.
How much time do we have?
So do you want the truth, do you want the truth?
OK, so when we were on tour,
I made this suggestion about this kind of subject matter.
And Dan was like, cool.
This sounds like a really good story.
Couple of days later, he texted me.
He's like, I really like that's what you said.
I think maybe there could be a song in there
we can write it together.
I was like, lies.
I was like, he's being nice because he's nice,
but these are lies.
So I was like, yeah, sure, sure.
Hmm. Then few weeks later, then he's like, you know,
we should write, we should write this, we should write.
I'm like, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Of course, of course, lies.
[LAUGHTER]
Until we got to the point where we were actually in the room,
I was like, this is never going to happen.
But also, like, bearing in mind that we'd not written
before together.
And it was like, as you might expect a session with me
to be quite chaotic.
And my level of sort of equipment skill,
at the best of times, is very lacking.
I think it was like, probably, we had like one working note
on a keyboard.
Yes.
And it was playing like a sort of toy piano.
So I'm trying to write this song that we're like,
obviously, we talked about a bunch.
And like, it's super heartfelt.
And it was like, ding, ding, ding.
Really set you up there.
Yeah.
I mean, it was a fantastic atmosphere to write in.
More in a window, let's backstage them in.
Yeah, cool.
Yeah.
But to be fair, we have slightly different styles.
So I'm very kind of--
I get an idea, and I sit in a corner.
This is what I like to do.
I sit in a corner, and I have it ruminating rounds,
and rounds, and rounds, until it makes sense to me.
And then I will sing it out.
Dan is throwing.
He's throwing stuff.
So I'm in the corner like this.
And Dan's like, maybe this bit.
Maybe like this, maybe like this.
Maybe like that.
And I'm like, oh, I'm thinking the bunch
of ways, like, Dan's just moving, walking,
back and forth, back and forth.
And there's all these different ideas coming in.
They're all good.
But I can't really hear them properly,
because I've got this one just running around my head.
So collaborations, great.
Yeah, it was fantastic.
But yeah, but it's really good to work with someone
who is constantly having new and fresh ideas,
and coming from different angles on the same line,
on the same lyric.
It makes it really easy.
It makes it really easy to work with you,
because you make it really easy.
Oh.
Really.
Isn't he lovely?
Yeah.
But yes, it was a really nice process.
But it took a few, it took a few goes.
But I am so fucking proud of where I got to,
I think it's insanely beautiful, and entirely down to you.
But I like, I really love him.
Not entirely.
And speaking of this incredibly beautiful song written
by these incredibly amazing people,
should we like hear it?
[CHEERING]
[MUSIC PLAYING]
[MUSIC PLAYING]
[MUSIC PLAYING]
♪ When cage birds can't to see ♪
♪ Does anybody hear them when they do ♪
♪ When cage birds get to fly ♪
♪ Does anybody ever question why ♪
♪ Sometimes when I'm awake and I ♪
♪ I think about it ♪
♪ The story of you ♪
♪ Sometimes when I'm awake and I ♪
♪ I think about it ♪
♪ Things that we're all so so so so so ♪
♪ Like you ♪
♪ Like you and I ♪
♪ About things that we lose ♪
♪ Ooh ♪
♪ Like the light ♪
♪ Like the light ♪
♪ Like the light ♪
♪ Like the light ♪
♪ Like the light ♪
(audience cheering)
♪ You ♪
♪ Lamps and roll ♪
- So, homework, I didn't know has anyone listened
to the podcast before, you familiar with the former.
Thank you.
- So the homework section of this is,
it comes from the fact that a bunch of the songs
on the album wouldn't have existed if it wasn't for Emma,
directing me towards, amazing.
(audience cheering)
Who obviously, as I said earlier,
when I went to her and asked for some suggestions
of people that I'm in or have heard of
or that I've slightly less written about,
she gave me some and I guess because of that
and because of this podcast,
it's more than just us talking about songs on the album.
It's like, it's the whole time it's been a kind of conversation
between your world and your brain and my songwriting.
And so, yeah, as part of that in the podcast,
every week Emma has thinking about the person
that we're talking about, suggested another idea,
another person, another pair of people as homework for me
to then go away and read and learn about them a bit
and then try and write a song,
try being the most important word in that sentence.
And so, here we are.
And it's, many weeks later,
I definitely haven't been working on it all day
and up till five minutes after the show has started.
- Yeah.
- How are you feeling?
- Oh, you know.
- Oh, I need you.
(laughs)
- But there's nothing like bearing your
really embarrassing unfinished demos
in front of a lot of people, but you know.
- Well, but it was your idea, though, wasn't it?
- There was my intention.
(laughs)
- And it's on me that they're not better.
So. (laughs)
- I mean, obviously they're really good.
Anyway, let's get into it.
Instead of just having me respond to the songs
in academic, but the people at home,
we've also got a musician there.
- Yeah.
- Yay!
Okay.
So, we've heard a few of your homework tasks
in our homework check-in special a few weeks ago,
available on any podcast,
listening platform that you have.
And so, there was 19th century abolitionist,
civil and women's rights activist, a journal truth,
and from our even paradise-lost episode,
we had the Dunder in Nymph Echo
from the seasons in Nostasis episode,
for rock, pin, air, archimitri, dental, e-ski,
love her from our Emily Dickinson episode,
which is owned and sung Emily and her penthouse in the sky.
So, I think let's just skip them, quite frankly.
- Okay.
- However, listen, right, I don't wanna be the bad guy,
but there's only so much time,
and there's loads to get through.
Haven't said that.
When we did talk about Echo, the pencil's down then.
- Sorry.
- Okay.
(laughs)
Thank you.
- I'll just give you a nice bed,
definitely not practicing. (laughs)
- When we talked about Echo,
you did see in the hallmark check-in
that you had like three different versions.
- Yeah, sometimes this happens, it happens a lot with me,
but with these songs in particular,
where it takes me a while to land on the right one.
And so, I have an idea of what I want it to be,
and it's really great,
and I currently have not great stuff.
(laughs)
But, I played the beginning of one before,
and it was kind of a bit,
it was like definitely in the soppy of Aene.
- I think, yeah, I guess we talked about,
in the episode of the podcast,
the idea that Echo is literally ignored to death,
and so I thought I'd break that mold
and leave her out the song entirely,
apart from one passing reference.
- Yeah.
- Which is, so the cool, yeah, yeah, you're fine with that.
(laughs)
I've not thought about that loads at all.
(laughs)
So yeah, I wanted to make a song that basically acknowledged
how fucking annoying it must have been for her
to have fallen in love/been kind of fated
to fall in love with a right decade, yeah.
- You called it your "I Hate You" so much right now, demo?
- Well, there's a, there is, (laughs)
which I'm hoping will be the final version of the song,
not this one, not the one I played before,
but I had like the sketch of an idea,
but now I feel like a bit of an idiot playing it.
So, maybe we'll skip to the next one.
- What a good, right.
Do you really want to skip to the next one,
or do you want a bit of encouragement?
- No, no, no, no, no. - Oh, I didn't mean for that
to happen, I'm sorry. (laughs)
Okay, but-- - So, I'm sorry, no.
- No, I'm talking to you in song now.
- Hello. - Hello.
- I thought you didn't like musicals dance,
being clear with your messaging.
Do you want to play a bit of the echo?
New echo one or do you want to move forward?
I don't mind. - I'll play a little bit.
- Yeah. - I'll probably, I'll probably solve.
(audience cheering)
♪ Sorry when the forest looking at yourself ♪
♪ If you were dappled in light, dappled in light ♪
♪ You're not the one ♪
Oh, this is so far from ideal.
♪ How the hell are fallen for narcissists ♪
♪ We don't have the time to hear me right ♪
♪ Oh, you got more than vanity ♪
♪ Oh, this is so far from ideal ♪
♪ How the hell are fallen for narcissists ♪
♪ We don't have the time to hear me right ♪
♪ Oh, you got more than vanity ♪
♪ It's such a leaf fuckin' with me ♪
And then there's a chorus and it's gonna be really good,
but I don't have it yet.
(audience cheering)
(audience laughing)
- I mean, as a critic.
(audience laughing)
- It's very good.
(audience laughing)
- That's literally how we have time for "Move It Go."
- That was great. - That was great though.
- Thanks. - Well done.
- Right, next one, "Shelly to Vol."
- Yes. - Yeah, really fucking excited about.
This is from the blue sky in the painting episode
of the podcast, but listen to it.
- Yes, sorry about it.
- Yeah, go listen to it.
That was also, that was on the same day
that we did "The Emily Dickinson" episodes
in Newcastle.
It was a really fun day and two of my favorite episodes.
So if you haven't listened, go have a listen.
So "Shelly to Vol," who is known for many things.
She was an actress, she was in "Poppie,"
and she was in "The Shining,"
during which she had a fucking horrendous time
filming it with Kubrick, and he made her do basically
a year's worth of hyperventilating and screaming
and being scared and being sad.
And I think it understandably really fucked with her.
But also, she has, I guess like a lot of people
that we've looked at, there's loads more to her
in her career and the depth and breadth of it.
And there's, I've been listening to,
there's a podcast series called "Texas Twiggy,"
where a podcast maker basically decided to trace her whole
career and also dive deep into potentially where she's gone.
Because she had all these production companies.
She started, she was the first person in the states
to have kind of original TV on cable,
like before that it was just films.
And she was like, no, let's make our own shows.
And she started this completely bonkers sounding fairy tale
show where she got the most famous actors and directors
in Hollywood to make what sound like quite like drug-induced,
like very weird adult versions of fairy tales.
But like, kind of quite cool.
And it's just, you know, like with many things
with people who are known, there's one thing
that's remembered.
So I don't have the song yet because I've still,
I've been like reading a lot about her
and I really want to do it justly.
But at the beginning of some production,
do you want to hear like?
Yeah.
And maybe, given what you were saying earlier,
do you want to just, the first thing that comes out
of you? - Oh my god. - I'm sure you know what you're going to do.
- All right, in session, I fucking love this.
- Let's just, this is also just a test of if.
- Just what ever comes to you.
(gentle music)
- What's that? - This is a vibe.
(gentle music)
(laughing)
(gentle music)
All right, don't give me the--
song. Do you think you are, Kanye? Give me the song. That's amazing. Yeah, so that's
what I'm up to on that. But it sounds like Ben's got it covered. Yeah. Moving on again,
are you ready? I am. Is heo Huguichi? Oh, yes. 9th century Trailblazin, Japanese author,
Dyeris Sporning's Poverty, died just age 24, wrote thousands of poems, amazing short stories,
and Dyeris blazing her life is incredible. Yeah, so I have this book, the M.O. Variation
kind of gave me. This is just to show that I'm doing my homework. Did you hear the bit in the
podcast where I was like, I love Dan's behavior when he's read a book, he physically shows it to me
constantly, he's folded up. It's such a rarity. But no, I guess the stories I've been struggling with
the most are the ones I know the least, because I think ones where we, they're like adjacent to
people we've talked about before, I felt way easier just to like immediately know what I want to say.
So I'm excited to get into that. I was meant to go to Japan before the end of this year and sort of
had this stupid romanticised idea of writing it there, but then the trip will cancel. As did the
song. So nothing to report. Nothing to report apart from she is indeed amazing. And like if you
want to read out the title of the book and then people can do their reading ahead of time in the
shade of spring leaves, and it's it's both like a summary of her very very short but prolific life
shifts to 24 and then and then a bunch of the sort of most known short stories translated.
Yeah. Nice. Okay. So the next one, Bachelor from the Bible. We love it.
This is from the Leonard and Marianne episode. The link being in Hallelujah. There's a the song.
There's a line that says sort of her bathing on the roof. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And that's
Bathsheba King David and Bathsheba. Yeah. So so we talked about, sorry. Oh no. I think we did
actually play a clip on the homework episode. We did. Yeah. But I wanted to play a bit more of an
updated clip if that's all right. Yeah. Do you want to give a quick TLDR Bathsheba? She was having
a bath on the roof as you do. And and over in another building King David was out on the roof
perving on her. And essentially some in her they slept together. That's giving it a lot more
equality than I think it actually had. But there she ended up basically becoming pregnant and then
he killed to he like killed her husband. It's really fucked up. Like he's not a nice guy but he's
sort of known and celebrated as like as David from the Bible. So I guess this. This is David and
Goliath David. Yeah. Yeah. King David anyway. I roll soul. That was a really good summary.
Thanks. So do you want to let's hear the bit of the song? Okay. Okay.
I love how your body physically shrinks. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. At one point
I made my okayful set up. This was Dan said you're going to get these notes. I'm here for it.
Yeah. This is like I think if the ones you played me I think this is one of my favorite ones so far.
And thanks. Yeah. So you're welcome. Thank you. And the next one's good as well though.
What's the next one? Yeah. Oh my god. Sorry. It's got a dual lingon notification. That owl.
That fucking owl is going to be knocking on my fucking window. I swear to god. Sorry.
Don't let this fuck your street, man. Sorry. I need to do my Arabic. Give me like five minutes.
So Robbie Ross is it? Yeah. Yeah. Robbie Ross fans. Just us for Robbie Ross.
Yeah. We like Robbie a lot. I've been working on this for a bit and wasn't sure I was going to
maybe play a little bit on the piano and then play a bit of the production and just show how wildly
different they are. But I also do that. Yeah. So well he's preparing and Oscar Wilde. I'm sorry.
Having someone play while I'm talking is a new experience. Get used to it.
And Robbie Ross, do you know who Robbie Ross is? No, I'm not going to put it in the spot like that.
That's stunning. Right. Oscar Wilde, poet, playwright, etc. And Robbie Ross was we think
probably the first man had a relationship and romantic relationship with and then turned into a
lifelong friend who was probably a better friend than Oscar deserved quite frankly. But just my
opinion. But like Robbie Ross's ashes are literally an Oscar Wilde's grave. He was his literary
executive after he died. And basically a turn out of ten hun and Oscar was a bit of a prick actually
all in all. But this song's great. Thanks. I'm really excited to hear that. So I'll play sad
ballad version. Yeah. And then slightly more VB. Boppy version. Boppy version. Yeah. Yeah.
When we first took off you were shaking. You were nervous. Now you caused that local
guys all we did you choose to not see it. Oh, oh, I've seen you lead the darkest of
the rooms. But who's the one who's here beside you now? So good. So great. So let's
speak to this. Yeah. Yeah.
Oh, oh, oh, oh, I've seen you lead the darkest of the rooms. But who's the one that's
here beside you now? Are you going to Western disguise? Is this like the new R&B King is
here? Oh, you want some sappy acoustics? Yeah. I've got you. Okay. Madam. Yes. So. So anyone
that's heard Madam was out on the nunnery blaze on the album. This came from from the episode
of the podcast about Julie W. and basically at the end of her life, she had this really
like wonderful time with a partner called Madame de Florence Zach. Is that right? I think
so. Well, I mean, we know I get French wrong. So that's fine. Bastille. You'll find a French.
So yeah, I guess she had this ill-fated love affair when she was young. But later the love
of her life was this woman, Madame de Florence Zach. And just before she died, both of them
died. They have this two, this sort of two-year kind of amazing honeymoon period where Julie
was Julie, sorry, was out earning money. And then they kind of just, I guess kind of hunked
down and had this really wonderful relationship. And I guess you were talking on the podcast
about wanting to do something that celebrated that. So I did. And this is, this is, I'll
tell you just a bit of this, but this is, yes, currently called Julie too. Not too is sort
of you in French as well. So it's really, it's not clever. Yeah. Much more, you're expecting,
right?
[Music]
[Music]
I love me, I would have time for one more then, so do you want to pick which one you want
to do?
Yeah, where are we at, what are we up to?
So, so, so, Lina Horn, who, um, who is amazing, who I've been like reading about a bunch,
haven't, um, yeah, that's, was one of the more recent ones, do you suggested her during
the SCM pool episode?
I've been reading about her, um, and she's fucking amazing, but I haven't written anything
yet.
So, um, I did, um, I did, um, not that amazing then, no, no, no, no, so, um, so, Rita
Carlo, ideally Rivera is who's left then?
Yes, I, um, love Rita Carlo, and her life is amazing, and, um, there's like, what she
documented about her the other day, I was thinking about her relationship with her body, um,
and she had a, when she was a sort of, like, late teenager, she was in a bus crash with
the, then love of her life, and she was impaled by the sort of rail of the bus, and it completely
changed her life, and so, for her, existing with, with pain, um, was a huge part of, of,
like, her creative life, and she used to lie in bed with this mirror above her that her
mom, her, her mom had made the system of the mirror kind of hanging above her bed, so
she could do her portraits, and that's kind of what, um, the time where she, like, really
flourished as an artist, and that's like, it's an amazing story, anyway, so I tried to
write a song about it.
Did you?
But it's not, but you suggested Frida and Diego, and I, I sort of, I made it more, my
angle, as you all hear, because it's very literally on the nose, and I apologize, these
lyrics are so early, but, um, is more, like, Frida and her relationship with herself.
Yeah, no, I would love that, I guess, for context, this was, because this episode was the
Marie Curie episode, so I guess the, the shoehorned link was, you know, Marie Curie and
Pierre Curie had this, like, intellectual and romantic partnership, so it was finding
another set of people who had the same thing, and find for that not to have been important
in the end.
Well, you know what?
I don't mind.
When I was reading about her.
No, no, no, no, we have to move on.
We're going to read after.
She said that she was, she was her own muse, and she was the only muse that she needed.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So I thought, guys, I got to come back on a point, Frida, it had to happen once, it had
to happen once.
That's what happens when you read one thing.
That's what happens when you read it, that's what happens when you read it, that's what
happens when you read it.
I think you've done some really excellent work, Dan.
Yeah, well done on your homework.
I think that was an excellent song.
She would be proud.
Oh, thank you.
It was great.
Did it answer the essay question?
No.
No.
No, it was really good.
I'm very excited to hear the rest of it.
The number of times backstage when I was trying to, like, pencils down, pencils down,
it was, I liked it.
I liked it.
Yeah.
Well, speaking of pencils down, so I think we've been familiar with Pike Attack.
Looking back over all these conversations and tracks that you've just done now, this
would have been a really good time to give you that pop quiz I threatened you with.
Oh, yeah.
If only I'd have thought to make one ahead of time.
I'm so glad you didn't.
Peter, can I have my clipboard, please?
Oh, it was worth whatever's about to happen, it was just for that.
Don't worry, Dad.
I've got a modster, it could be, but I will let you ask the audience once.
OK.
And I'll let you phone a friend once as well.
If you need to, I think I've gone for easy here.
Is it like specifics?
Well, of course, it's specific facts, Dan.
It's not like an emotional response to your question.
Absolutely not.
There are right and wrong answers to all of these.
OK, are you ready?
No.
No, OK, right.
Number one.
Listen, if you want to help them, don't.
You've had strict instructions.
No, it'll be quite funny for the podcast, I won't mind.
So number one.
In the story of Adam and Eve, well, Eve.
The tree of knowledge of good and evil almost certainly did not refer to an apple tree.
We know this.
Name one of the fruits.
I'm a granite.
Yay.
Yay.
Yeah.
You see?
Is that a soft bull?
It was a soft bull.
Yeah, OK.
And number two, there were lots of versions of the myth of Narcissus, which ancient author
do we think first introduced the nympheth echo to the myth of Narcissus?
Of it.
Yeah.
Yes.
You've got it.
You've got it.
I was like mesmeral faces.
You know, you know.
You know.
Number three.
After the death of the peerless poet Emily Dickinson, her poetic legacy was largely
debuted up between her special friend, Susan Gilbert, they were gay.
In a Mabel Loomistard, I guess Thomas went with Higginson, and named two of the ways Mabel
edited Emily Dickinson's work.
Mabel took out her name and gave them titles.
Took out whose name?
Her girlfriend's name, from all the poems.
Which was.
Oh.
Just said it.
Just said it.
Just said it.
So.
Lovely so.
Yeah.
So took her name out of lots of them.
She gave a lot of them titles.
Yay.
Number four.
The Norwegian painter, creator of the scream Edvard Monk.
What was his star sign?
Oh, fuck.
I don't know.
We go through this in some detail in the podcast.
It's a while ago.
Oh, you're right.
What was it?
Sagittarius.
Sagittarius.
Sagittarius.
I can't see anything more here.
Where were they?
Oh, you're using your asking audience.
Yeah, I'm using my asking audience.
Sagittarius.
Sagittarius.
Sagittarius.
No.
Yeah, no.
Sagittarius.
Yay.
Well done.
Well done.
Okay.
I tried to cheat and you got me.
Before he skyrocketed to themes, songwriter and performer Leonard Cohen spent time on the
Greek island Tidra, and office, absolute tits on acid most of the time.
With his girlfriend and muse, Marianne Ilhan, which city was she born in?
Oh, she was Norwegian.
The question still starts.
Yes.
Also.
Yeah, they're tired.
I haven't.
Lucky for me, she was born in there.
Yeah.
Bonus question.
Marianne spent a tiny amount of time with an all pair of poshnani in which British city?
New castle.
Yes.
Okay.
Number six.
Pyre queen, Zenghi, so I'll head up a massive piracy confederacy that rival the Chinese state,
absolute fucking legend.
According to her law code, what would happen if you were caught skyping on a ship?
I'll walk the plank.
Or like there's another piracy thing that was awesome.
Fuck.
You know this.
Yeah.
Does anyone know?
It's fun to see in the front row of the air.
I have your ears chopped off.
Yeah, you have your ears chopped off.
Okay.
Every one of seven, everyone who's listening to this podcast knows that Dan's playing in Latin.
So, Dipper Fund, Dipper Fundus was a 50,000 word love letter slash disc track.
And that poet slash writer Oscar Wilde sent his lover slash fuck boy Bozy.
What does Dipper Fundus mean in Latin?
Well, in English.
Oh, fuck, I can't remember.
You could go with my friend again.
I don't know anyone that knows Latin.
Can I phone Google Translate?
No, fuck.
You were privately educated.
How'd you know no one who knows Latin?
Sorry.
You could make me.
What's that?
What's that about assumptions?
Sorry.
I didn't do Latin at school, unfortunately.
Dipper Fundus.
Come on.
Dipper Fundus.
Dipper Fundus.
Hmm.
What is it?
From the depths?
Yay!
From the depths.
Right.
Number eight.
We're nearly done.
Julie W.A. was 17th century French opera singer, Jules.
Quest Dresson by Sexual Force of Nature.
Woo!
Describe her maybe historically accurate, maybe not planned to break her girlfriend out of a non-Aryan Avignon.
Okay.
Um, she, her girlfriend is sent by her family into this non-Aryan Avignon.
Julie's like, "I'm gonna, I'm gonna check myself in, too."
So she does.
Check myself in.
Yeah, that's how it works, right?
And then this old lady nun dies.
Which is very sad.
And Julie's like, "What if we burn the bed that she's in and the room and maybe the whole non-Aryan down?"
And because I'm assuming everyone is really fucking thick, they're gonna. think that the old lady bones are your bones and that your sad is sad you're dead but then
we can run away together and go hide in a tree or something for a bit and then yeah, was
that right?
Yeah, that's right.
Yeah.
It's a little more.
Right, two more left and I have every faith that you're going to get these.
Okay.
Number nine, um, what was the colour of Marie Curie's wedding dress?
Sorry, what was the colour of Marie Curie's wedding dress?
I realise I think when we talked about Ralph's involvement in the song in the podcast, that,
because I was so mortified about this, I didn't actually talk about how how brilliant he was
to write this song with and how amazing the song right here.
So I just wanted to shout out to Ralph.
Yeah.
Ralph's incredible.
He was like, oh, listen to that episode and it was like, do I keep listening to this?
Does it get nice ever?
Um, but, uh, so it was, it was dark blue.
Navy blue.
Blue.
Just blue.
Blue, just blue.
Um, but, you know, as Ralph said, A, he's colourblind and B, um, it was a black and white
photo.
Yeah.
It's a great song.
In Ralph's deep dive was amazing.
Absolutely.
Shout out to Ralph.
Big round of applause for Ralph.
Oh, right again.
Love Ralph.
Okay.
Finally.
It's nearly over.
Okay.
And I've got a friend left.
Paul Robson was famous 20th century singer, actor, or at a activist, linguist and husband
of, as lander Robson, um, activist author, Paul's manager, scientist, anthropologist,
world traveller, and drew McCarthyism or McCartneyism.
Is that what you call it?
Americans have been jails threatened for their political beliefs.
Both Essie and Paul were targeted by the House and American activities committee, but
the unflinchingly courageous Essie proclaimed that she was only scared of one thing.
And what was it?
Oh, fuck.
It was like, that was in the trial where she gave, like, an amazing comeback, right?
Yeah.
I'm only scared of one thing.
Imagine if I had a memory.
And what is it?
Um, so, I saw a little bit over here.
Would you like to say it?
Cats.
Cats.
Cats.
Yeah.
Big round of applause, my dad.
You got 10 out of 10.
Woo.
Thanks for the quiz.
Can we hear the, can we hear the jingles?
Thanks for the quiz. Can we hear the jingles? Can we hear it? Can you?
Oh, quiz.
Right. Well, that's the quiz over. And Dan, that's stop having heart palpitations now.
And thank you all.
So now it's time to tear the microphone away from us and for the last 15 minutes or so.
And I think like, we're going to take questions from you.
So there's a, ooh, there's a room in microphone round and I think Ed's got the microphone
somewhere.
Yep.
So.
Yeah, I was just going to ask.
Like I've always been interested in like whether melody or like lyrics come first for
you.
And like, did that change over the course of like the process during Amazon because obviously
it's so sort of heavy on the narrative.
So like, how did that affect like the order in which you sort of brought the song together?
Yeah, thank you for the question.
It did, it did, it did change a bit, like sometimes with me and it would be really interesting
to hear from Ben how it is for her as well.
Sometimes for me, ideas kind of like just tumble out and I think a lot of them with these
ones, the ones I felt more informed on, that was way easier.
I want, you know, the more I knew, the more easy it was to sort of just feel what the song
was going to be.
But there was, there was a lot of rewriting on this and I think a lot of, as I, sometimes
I get excited and start a song and not know that much about the person and then have
to revise a lot the lyrics as I learn more and I was like, that's not true.
So yeah, there was, it was definitely another, another big mistake that I made was with
this album.
I wanted process wise for it to be a bit different for me.
So I wanted the whole thing to be written before we went in and started producing it.
So I recorded demos that, you know, similar to what I just played you all, and I had the
full album done those demos and then sort of stopped, put a line under them, we started
from scratch in the studio and that was amazing and getting to hear everyone else's interpretations
of them and that really, for me, kind of made it what it is important to life.
But in the three weeks that we had to record all 17 songs, I didn't put any vocals down,
which meant that I then had all the time in the world to rewrite and rewrite and rewrite
which is like, as you can tell, I need like an end point otherwise I just keep talking.
So that was, that was a bit annoying and yeah, they were like, you know, I, we talked
on the podcast but the, the Eslander and Paul Robeson song, you know, I felt like I could
never know enough about them and I don't think would ever be as informed enough to speak
to them but did really wanted that song to exist as a kind of, I guess, a love letter to
them and a tribute to them but with the understanding that it was never going to be good enough
all right.
But so, yeah, I'm a nightmare when it comes to creative process, I just like, so when you finish
an album, it gets mixed by someone and then it gets mastered and it should be finished
before it goes to mix and with that song in particular, I like, I recalled it, not
from mix, I recalled it from the mastering process, I mean, our managers are like, fair enough.
Anyway, but I'd be, I'd be really interested to know like for you that process as well.
It depends on, it actually depends on the song because sometimes you have the melody and
that just sticks and you're, you have to hum it out and record that and then you're just
going to revisit it and you're just going to write to that which you know that you're
going to do, but then sometimes you might just get a line, I sometimes just get a line
and I just know that I need to make something out of it.
So I think-
And that kind of spreads out, you have to like-
Yeah, and you have to kind of build around it and then go back and then like you said
just kind of rewrite things because it doesn't quite fit in the same way and then it sometimes
just turns into a completely different song, but you always have something to sell.
And just to caveat, again, everything you just heard that I played in the second half
of this episode, like is subject to heavy revising and editing and improving.
They're all like half of them you could hear like, "I know it's coming, it's coming, it's coming, it's coming."
Three to cut and yeah, no.
But that's part of letting you in on the process.
But yeah, great question, thank you very much.
So you have this really cool and amazing way of describing deep kind of contextual things
from history or social political things or anything like that which I think is a real skill
and it's kind of a gift, it's not something you can really learn so much or something you
just kind of have as an innate capability and with you kind of talking about how your PhDs
coming to an end and obviously this series is coming to an end, what if anything have
you considered as kind of doing next would you do more podcasts like speaking into the
mic rather than behind the scenes because you also have just a very nice voice to listen
to.
What are you going to do next?
That's really nice, thank you.
I have no idea what I'm going to do and yeah, my PhD I do part time and that's been
like seven years and in the last five years I've been in a lot of jobs, I've done my
PhD and worked on your desk made for like five years at this point, first other radio
shows, I also until very recently worked for the University College Union for the good
few years as well, I do like policy work and research work so I'm really bad at picking
one thing and a lot of those things have come to a close at the same time and I actually
have absolutely no idea, so I'm open to office and he's doing something more please, I want
to hear you more.
Thanks, yeah, I don't know, well yeah, maybe I should get unlinked in, did watch the
office all then, yeah, but thank you, it's so nice, you really appreciate it.
It's part three, you still got part four to go, are you thinking about, I know you just
said me, it's coming to an end, but you think maybe bringing it back just for part four,
it would be nice.
Yeah, no, I'd love to, but yeah, I'd love to, but I guess we'll see, we'll see you
in consideration, you've all spoken really eloquently about who gets to tell stories and
whether we should even tell other people's stories at all, are there any stories any of
you have left and decided to not tell or felt that you're not equipped to tell?
Do you want me to start?
Yeah.
The intent stair suggests that you do, I mean the one that comes to my mind specifically
is I don't know if any of you know this about me, I really want to pull in as Landa Robson,
they're like, do you have my favourite people and fascinated by them?
I think I said to Dan early on, I would just love to do more research on Paul Robson,
I don't think anyone needs a book from me about them though, quite frankly.
I would read it.
Oh, thank you.
I mean, what I have thought about is, this is going, maybe this isn't the answer for
what I'm going to do next, what I have thought is that Paul Robson on his music tours of
the UK and Ireland and Wales and Scotland, he'd sort of do like shadow political tours
with like working class communities where he would be playing at Sheffield but he'd be
going to town meeting to Sheffield City Hall and like meeting people and talking to like
strike and minors and performing for them.
And when I did this with lots of other people as episode of the podcast that I work on
on Paul Robson, we actually got loads of people writing in with stories that people still
talk about in their family about Paul, like, oh, when my mum saw him at this place and
I live in Wales and this happened and I'm really into like oral history as a form of
[BLANK_AUDIO]
yn yng Nghymru sy'n wneud i'n gweithio gwneud i'n gwneud i'n gweithio gwneud i'n gweithio gwneud i'n gweithio gwneud i'n gweithio gwneud
Yw'n ni'n ni'n fawr yn fawr yn yw'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'n ni'
i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith i'n gwaith.
I don't know if anybody will ever hear or see them because I know that I'm just one person in this very, very diverse experience.
So I don't feel like I'm equipped to speak at the level that I believe that it needs for other people to really understand what it's like, and I feel like it's almost something that I would have to do as a body, it needs to be a collective, but that's something that I'm thinking about and musing about, but it's not something that I would kind of expose at this point, but yeah, that's definitely something that is always at the back of my mind. It's a lot, I know.
No, I love that and I think that this whole, and one, excellent use of the word muse in there to do that on purpose, love that, and yeah, this idea of like collective storytelling, when you're talking about different experiences, I just think it's really interesting, like when we've had the chaos episode with Charlie Covell, and they were saying, you know, in terms of like trans representation, they've been felt sort of shoehorned into scenarios where it's like it's all up to them to portray one experience when you can't, because it's not a homogenous experience.
So yeah, I feel like with a lot of these things, the answer is always more and more people and more perspectives, so there wouldn't be so much stakes put on one story in one experience, but yeah, another amazing question.
Thank you so much. That was brilliant. Thank you.
And I think that's, that's it. That's all we've got time for. That's the end.
Thank you all so much for coming and for your questions and for your patients.
Yeah, that's the end. And thank you to Ben. Thank you to Ben. Thank you so much to Ben.
How amazing was that performance? That was, and I think let's have the jingle one more time.
On the way out. And everyone, you've heard it twice now in real life. So please.
Muses. Muses, an ampersand podcast was hosted by Dan Smith and Emma Negus with a very special guest
appearance by Ben.
It was recorded and mixed by Miles Weeway, and produced by Ed Marish and Emma Negus for Lead Mojo Productions.
And big shout out to Ian on the sound and lights as well. Thank you so much.
And you can find out more about all the people we've talked about.
Actually, we've have talked about loads of people today at Bastille, Bastille.com.
And you can email us. But no one's going to answer now.
At Muses, at Lead Mojo, at the court of UK.
And you can find out more about the music.
And you can find out more about the music.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The podcast concludes with a reflective discussion on the album's opening track, "Intros in the Rares," which functions as a narrative and thematic introduction rather than a historical story.
Dan and Emma explore the role of storytelling, questioning whether artists can authentically represent lives they don’t personally experience, and the ethical implications of such representation.
The conversation highlights the tension between artistic empathy and structural inequalities, noting that marginalized voices are often excluded from both creative and public recognition.
The song’s sound is intentionally organic, featuring ambient noises and layered vocals to mirror the fragmented, personal nature of storytelling.
The process of writing the album evolved from personal reflection to a collaborative, iterative journey, influenced by Emma’s academic work and shared curiosity.
A major theme is the responsibility of storytellers to avoid exploitation and to ask critical questions about privilege, ownership, and whose stories are celebrated.
The episode celebrates collaboration, especially with Bim, whose songwriting and vocal contributions reflect a deep connection to the project’s emotional and artistic integrity.
The "homework" system, where listeners explore historical figures through songwriting, underscores the mutual exchange between songwriting and academic inquiry.
Summary:
This final episode of the Ampersam podcast reflects on the album’s opening track, “Intros in the Rares,” which serves as both a narrative anchor and a thematic exploration of storytelling. Dan and Emma delve into the ethics of representing people from different backgrounds, discussing whether artists can authentically tell stories outside their own experiences. They emphasize that while artistic empathy is essential, structural inequalities often mean that marginalized voices remain silenced or underrepresented in the public sphere.
The song’s sound is intentionally raw and organic—featuring ambient room noises, tape effects, and layered vocals—to mirror the fragmented, subjective nature of memory and narrative. The process of creating the album was deeply personal and collaborative, shaped by Dan’s songwriting and Emma’s academic research, especially her PhD on narrative and perspective. They highlight how writing about others often leads to self-reflection, turning the work personal and complex.
A key theme is the responsibility of storytellers to avoid exploitation and to question who gets to tell stories and who gets to be seen as empathetic or creative. The episode also celebrates collaboration, particularly with Bim, whose song “Soprano and Midnight Wanderings” exemplifies emotional depth and authenticity. Finally, the "homework" format—a system where listeners research historical figures and write songs about them—demonstrates a reciprocal relationship between music and academic inquiry, fostering deeper engagement with history, identity, and narrative.
The conversation closes with a fun quiz on myths, history, and language, reinforcing the podcast’s playful, intellectual spirit.
FAQs
The song serves as a narrative introduction that reflects on the process of storytelling and the writer's position when writing about historical or fictional figures, offering a personal and reflective thesis to the album.
The podcast examines how narrators shape stories, questioning reliability, perspective, and empathy, and how these elements are mirrored in both music and academic writing.
Yes, artists can write about experiences outside their own life, but it requires empathy and awareness to avoid exploitation or misrepresentation, especially when those communities are still oppressed.
Both the songwriting and the PhD involve deep research into historical figures and stories, with the song acting as a creative expression of the same thoughtful, empathetic inquiry into storytelling and perspective.
The song is structured like an opening number of a musical, evoking a sense of narrative and theatricality, and it prompts reflection on how stories are told and re-told through different perspectives.
Bim is a talented songwriter and vocalist who contributed to the song 'Soprano and Midnight Wanderings,' bringing a deeply emotional and beautiful layer to the album.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.