Go back

INFAMY: Ed Gein - The Killer Who Inspired "Psycho"

1h 11m 30s

INFAMY: Ed Gein - The Killer Who Inspired "Psycho"

Ed Geen, a real-life serial killer from 1950s Plainfield, Wisconsin, became one of the most disturbing figures in American true crime history. A deeply religious and emotionally isolated man, he was shaped by his overbearing mother, Augusta, who instilled in him a pathological fear of women and a twisted sense of loyalty to her. After her death, Geen spiraled into a life of violence, murdering at least two women—Bernice Warden and Mary Hogan—both of whom reminded him of his mother. He dismembered their bodies and used body parts to create grotesque items like lampshades, masks, and clothing, which were discovered in his home. Despite initial arrests and confessions, Ed was never convicted; instead, he was declared not guilty by reason of insanity and spent decades in a state hospital due to schizophrenia. His crimes, marked by extreme sadism and a lack of sexual intent, were later cited as major inspirations for horror films like *Texas Chainsaw Massacre* (with Leatherface), *Silence of the Lambs* (Buffalo Bill), and *Psycho* (Norman Bates). The story of Ed Geen is a chilling exploration of how traumatic upbringing, psychological control, and isolation can manifest into violent, irrational behavior. It remains a powerful example of the connection between real crime and fictional horror, deeply embedding itself in popular culture. The episode highlights not only the brutality of the crimes but also the emotional and societal wounds they caused, particularly in a close-knit community. It serves as a reminder of the lasting impact of abuse and the dangers of unchecked psychological unraveling.

Transcription

12320 Words, 66438 Characters

English
- Let's play a quick little game, Sabrina. - Ooh, I wanna play two truths in the live. - Your favorite, I know. So I will give you three facts about today's subject, a 1950s real-life killer named Ed Geen, and you're gonna guess which one is the live. - Okay, ready? - Mm-hmm. - Okay, number one, when police entered Ed Geen's house, they found furniture made of human body parts. - Okay. (laughs) - Number two, Ed was a trusted babysitter around town who was loved by the kids were his magic tricks. And number three, Ed was found guilty of his crimes right away and he spent the rest of his life in prison. - I really want it to be number two, because how could a serial killer be the town beloved babysitter? - Right, it's so weird. - Yeah, it's so creepy and unsettling for all those kids. So, you know, later in life, realize that that was their babysitter, but because it's so outlandish, I feel like that has to be true. - Correct. - So, I'm gonna go with number three. Shockingly, number three is the lie. Ed did not spend the rest of his days behind bars, but instead he did spend it in a hospital because he was found mentally incompetent to stand trial, and then he was later ruled not guilty by reason of insanity. - So today we'll tell you all about Ed's victims, his life and the twisted crimes he committed, and how Ed's warped mental state became the inspiration for not one, but several of the world's most iconic horror films. - Welcome to "Crimes of," the show that takes you into different corners of the true crime universe, to explore the biggest cases that changed the course of history. Each eight to 12 episode season, we will dive deeper into the themes from movies, to music, to scandals, to crimes of passion, and heartbreaking disappearances. Every Tuesday, we will be here to share these stories in a whole new light, and you can catch the show on YouTube where we will include visuals that bring the cases to life. But here, we're not just dishing out the facts. We're pulling you into the heat of the moment, through immersive storytelling, we will take you beyond the headlines, into the turning points that changed everything. The characters, cornerstone memories, detectives explosive interrogations, and the creepy crime scenes packed with hidden clues. You get ready to feel every twist and turn, hear every whisper in secret, and uncover the shocking truths that no one saw coming. We are your hosts, Corinne Bienne and Sabrina Deanna Roca. I will be the one walking you through the chilling facts of every story, and I will be zooming in on the moments and showing you how the very real scenes in these stories played out. We are calling this season, "Crimes of Infamy," because we are going to be exploring one of our own personal obsessions, horror movies. Yeah. So for the next eight episodes, we're ripping off the masks of some of Hollywood's most prolific villains and meeting the real killers who inspired them. From Psycho, to Scream, to It, and Friday the 13th, we are going to examine the true crime killers who were so demonic, they became muses for the biggest horror films to date. So you may know Pennywise, Norman Bates, and Ghostface, but you might not know the full stories behind the real slashers that inspired the men, like John Wayne Gacy, Ed Geen, or Danny Rolling, which is why Corinne and I are here to take you behind the scenes and into the very real worlds, walking you through these true crime stories and the blockbuster horrors that they inspired. As you're watching and listening, go ahead and comment on all the similarities you see between today's subjects and your favorite horror films, because we're curious to know which are your favorite and why, plus also give us your recommendations. Oh yeah, give us your wrecks. And I'm sure you've never wondered what a lampshade made out of real human flesh would look like. No. Or what a pair of pants made from real human legs would be like to wear. But Ed Geen did, and as horrifying and sadistic as that sounds, it is not fiction, it is disturbingly real. It's very real. If you've even dipped a single toe into the true crime universe before, you probably have heard Ed's name mentioned because he might be one of the most iconic and disturbed killers in American history. He's also the real-life monster who inspired the iconic films like Psycho, Silence of the Lams, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and so many more. I was shocked at how many movies he inspired that I didn't even think of until we were doing this episode and prepping for it. And movies that we watched in our childhood inappropriately as children. But you watched inappropriately. I was such a scaredy cat. I didn't watch any horror films until my adulthood. Really? Oh, my first one was signs at eight years old, shout out to Elena's mom for an unsupervised sleepover. And it scarred me. I slept in my brother's room for the next like eight years after that. Oh yeah. But now we're here because we're now here. And we'll talk more about these films right after this. A warning. This episode contains descriptions of murder and dismemberment, so please listen with care. Before we tell you about Edgene's story and talk about the movies that he inspired, it is important for us to point out that there are two women who lost their lives at his hands. Bernice Warden and Mary Hogan-- not to mention their families, their friends, an entire community who experienced their loss in the devastation firsthand. And beyond that, the amount of body parts that were found inside of his home has led investigators to believe that there were many other victims as well. So in telling Ed's story, we are painfully aware that these are not just tales from the past. They are rooted in real devastating loss and for anyone who's been personally affected by a tragedy. Stories like this can really hit close to home. And so our hearts go out to you. We carry that weight with us as we tell this story and all of these stories. And you're always on our minds. I think there's something to be learned about Edgene as a person. And I'm sure a lot of great storytellers would agree, because Ed had a way of burrowing himself deep into people's psyches, ours included. Yes, yes. I feel like I've just been consumed by Edgene for the last couple of weeks. And I've definitely been on edge because of it. Right. And I feel like his name is a name that I will never forget after first hearing about him. There are a lot of true crime stories. And there's a lot of horror out there. And people consume it often. We are two of those people that tend to gravitate towards that genre. But his name is the one that I will never ever forget. Yeah. Because before Ed, monsters like him seem to only exist in nightmares. And Chris and I both have terrifying nightmares, so we can tell you all about those another time. But once people learn that men like Ed really did walk the earth, he became the muse for some of the most impactful horror films to date. Think Noron Bates from Psycho. Leatherface from Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Buffalo Bill from Silence of the Lambs. Which I rewatch Silence of the Lambs yesterday in preparation for this. Hello, Clarice. There's so much about that movie to talk about. And I could talk about that movie for hours. But I feel like my favorite scene from that movie is when Buffalo Bill is dancing to what's the-- Oh, dancing to Goodbye Horses. And he's like in the mirror. And he tucks his penis underneath. And he's like, what do you fuck me? I fuck me. It's so disturbing. I don't really know if that part of Buffalo Bill was inspired by Edgene, who will get into that. But there was a lot taken from Edgene's life. And we will get into Edgene's life, which was also filled with terrifying jump scares and skin crawling scenes that will make you want to hide under the covers. And if you do not believe us, Sabrina will show you. Snow blankets the small town of Plainfield, Wisconsin. The headlights of a cop car cut the mist, lighting up a queen little farmhouse on the outskirts of town. The officers turn off their car, plunging everything into darkness. They get out, click on their flashlights, and ever so slowly venture closer to the darkened home. Frost nips at their fingers and the only sound is their footsteps crunching in the snow and their hearts beating in their chest. They're looking for a local woman who went missing earlier that day. But these small town beat cops have no idea what they're in for. Up until now, they've been lucky enough to avoid any real danger, and nothing has prepared them for the horrors they will face tonight. Inside, a woman hanging from her ankles in the middle of the room, lampshades and chairs upholstered with real human flesh. Women's lips fastened into a windowshade drawstring. Belts made out of female breasts and masks crafted from real human faces. Absolutely sick. Yeah, so you're probably starting to see how moments from Edgene's life inspired the movies that we mentioned earlier. Yes. But before we talk more about that, let us start from the beginning, so you can get a picture of how Ed came to be Ed. Yeah. It's 1914. We are now in a small town of Plainfield, Wisconsin. [BLANK_AUDIO] village of only about 720 residents at the time. And this was a really sleepy community. It had a handful of businesses. There was a general store, a wagon shop. It was surrounded by plenty of farmland, and this is where the Guine family had planted their roots. - It sounds peaceful. - It does sound peaceful. It kind of sounds like our dream. - Right. - Just going to the local farm, picking up. - Right. - Some produce. - The Guines were part of like the local CSA. (laughing) They're at the farmers market with their little pickled fruits and vegetables. - But I thought it was- - But I thought it was feeling, it's not. - That's not exactly how it was. - Actually, thank God that it is no longer taking inspiration because I feel like he would have been into pickling now, knowing what we know. Okay, but they didn't do this. They were just a part of this sleepy little community and George Guine and his wife, a daughter of German immigrants, named Augusta, they find this two-story farmhouse on the outskirts of town, about six miles from the Main Street of Plainfield. And the Guines are sort of private, which we respect. Of course, they want to live somewhere kind of far from any prime eyes. They're not super involved in the community. And so this location is perfect for this couple and for their two sons, a year old Ed and his older brother, 12 year old Henry. The Guines are far from that perfect little Norman Rockwell family. Ed's father, George, has a drinking problem. He's a really hard time holding down a job. He spends a lot of the family's money at a local tavern. And he's also not really religious at all, which is starkly different from Ed's mother, Augusta, who is really strict. She's ultra-religious. She's just got the hammer on the family while her partner is just like dissolving as a puddle on the floor. And it's basically the family almost viewed him as like a burden and useless for most of his life, which is pretty sad. - It is very sad. And I feel like this theme of religion plays such a big role in Ed's life and his upbringing. And in talking about horror movies, it does remind me of the mom and Carrie in Stephen King's film. - Right. - So Augusta is super-super-religious and extreme even for the 1910s in the middle of nowhere, Wisconsin. To the point where Augusta forces her two sons to read the Old Testament over and over again. - Genesis 50, 20. But as for you, you meant evil against me. But God meant it for good in order to bring it about as it is this day to save many people alive. - And Augusta also plans the idea and Ed and Henry's minds that all women are basically sex workers sent to earth to tempt men. Except her, of course. Which one, how inappropriate. And two, I can't even begin to understand the psyche of Augusta herself because she really wanted daughters and so she was super upset when Henry, her firstborn, was her son. So she basically neglected him, almost abandoned him. And then when she had Ed, she decided she was going to do everything in her power to control him and basically make him into the child that she so wanted. Which, to me, it still doesn't make sense that she's like women are evil, women are horrible. It's like you wanted a girl. - Well, I'm also curious what she thinks about herself and I know that this episode is about Ed, but it doesn't start with Augusta. - Wonder about her upbringing and the narrative, her family kind of put into her mind. - Yeah, I read a story about how Augusta once caught Ed with like a girl and the way that she punished him afterwards and then also like one time she caught him masturbating and she completely destroyed him, like psychologically, telling him how dirty it was. So you can imagine that growing up with all of this, just impacted him. - Right, yeah. And I had also read somewhere that she told her sons if they did anything sexual that basically meant that they did not love her. So it was like your mother's love or growing up as a human being going through puberty and doing things that are natural. - As if sex and like going through puberty weren't tough enough. - Right, very tough in Augusta's house. - Yes. - When it comes to her marriage, Augusta definitely wore the pants of this family. She was always ordering George around the house. She was yelling at him for his failures at one point. They owned a shop which she ended up kicking George out of his position and taking over the shop and then when they ended up having farmland, she purchased the farmland in her own name. So she would definitely have a boss move. - It is if you take it out of the context of this story because it is a controlling move when it comes to Augusta. - Yes. - As for Ed, he seemed to always have this almost like obsession with his mother, think Norman Bates. He hung on her every word, he worshiped the ground, she walked on and whether that was maybe at a pure fear or maybe just because of how much she sheltered him. It's anyone's guess because we can never really know what was going on behind closed doors there. But one thing we do know is that Augusta kept Ed so close that he didn't actually start school until he was eight years old, which is wild. - Right, he has no social skills at that point. - No, he's only been with mommy. - He's so stunted in so many different ways and like being stunted socially but it's also intellectually. His whole view of the world is what his mother wants him to have. - And we know that she's not having appropriate conversations for his age either. - So there's a lot that Ed had going against him when he joined school, immediately he feels like an outcast. And whenever he came close to making a new friend on the playground or in the classroom, he would run home, so excited. He'd tell his mom, oh my gosh, I made this new friend on the playground and she was so pure. But she would immediately be like, no, you can never talk to that person, that person is evil. Evil lives within them and she would spend these wild lies about how awful these kids were that he was trying to be a friend. - Which is a very common abusive technique that like a visualization tactic that he's used on their victims. - Yeah, she broke Ed down so much that when he would return to the school yard the next day, he would avoid talking to or making eye contact with that new friend, which was also strange for the kids who were trying to befriend him. And so he started to get this sort of reputation and that meant Augusta got what she wanted which was little Eddie all to herself. - And it's tough 'cause I feel like in this moment, obviously we haven't gotten to the really dark things that Ed does do over time, but I have empathy. And I sympathize with little Ed that's really tough, but then at the same time, I don't want to villainize Augusta because sure, maybe there are parts of his childhood and growing up that contributed to who he became, she is not responsible for his actions. - No, no, there's unfortunately many children who live similar lives as Edgene and their adolescence and they do not go on to turn people into lampshades. - So over time, this created this sort of bizarre dynamic between Augusta and Ed and the dependency that almost put Ed into the role of her partner at times rather than her child. And this must have been very confusing for little Eddie as we can imagine. And at school, the way that he was treated by his peers due to this behavior and due to Augusta's influence did kind of add to everything that would shape Ed as a person. There were some strange quirks about Ed that drove kids away. He had this sort of lopsided grin on his face and his eyes, he had some interesting tactics when it came to making eye contact. - Well yeah, if you don't socialize until you're eight years old. - He was super shy, super nervous, right? But then he also had eye contact as a 32-year-old woman. - Me too, sometimes I count. I'm like, is this an inappropriate amount of time to make eye contact? - How long is too long? - 30 seconds, maybe too long. Look away, but where do I look? I don't know. - It is awkward. - It's awkward, we all feel it. - Yes. - We feel for young Ed in this moment. It's hard to make friends as a kid. It's hard to make friends as adults. - And eye contact does not help. Or maybe it does, I don't know. But that's why we're, are each other's only friends? Exactly. He also had this sort of wildly inappropriate laughter that he burst out at times. So it was just like kind of this whole thing where he was doing his best, he was trying, but his behaviors just were odd enough to the children around him that they did kind of view him as the outcast. Yes, they kept their distance. - And also, we all know children are very mean. We both were bullied as kids and probably at times, believes. - Yeah, exactly. So kids are the worst, but we love them. - And we have a child, we together. But the way Ed saw it in his interactions in the schoolyard, it just proved Augusta, his mother's points even more. - Right. - So all the things she was telling him, these kids are evil, blah, blah, blah. It was just driving home what he was being told at home. And so he soon realized the only person he could really trust was Augusta, his mother. - Really doubling down on that could appendancy. - Hi, everyone. We want to tell you about mother nose murder, a new crime house original hosted by actress Nisi Nash and her daughter, Dia. You've seen Nisi on Reno 9-1-1 and in her Emmy award-winning role on Dahmer. But for Nisi, true crime is personal. When she was 15, She witnessed her mom become the victim of a shooting. Her mom's survived. And today, Misi and Dia bond over true crime, now they're inviting you in. Every Tuesday, one of them brings a case and the other hears it for the first time. They catch different details and lock in their own verdicts, and even when the cases get dark, their humor offers comedic relief. But most importantly, Misi and Dia never lose sight of the real people at the heart of these stories. Follow Mother Nose Murder on Apple Podcasts, modify or subscribe on YouTube at Crime House Studios to watch now. But Ed, like a lot of little boys his age, is out looking for trouble. Ed finds himself standing outside the rundown wooden building that is behind his parent's store, and it's a place that for years has peaked his curiosity, and it's also a place that Ed has been told under no circumstances is he ever allowed to enter. But he's staying, and now standing there, hearing the horrible sounds and screams of the animals within, he wants to see it for himself. He senses that whatever is happening in the back room is not good, and that makes him want to see it for himself even more. So what does he do? He sneaks around the side of the building hoping to get a quick peek inside. He's dying to know what his mother and father are doing back there that he's not allowed to see. Ed finds the door open, just a crack. And there he spots his parents in between them a giant hog hanging from a meat hook in the ceiling. The animal sways as Augusta takes a long blade and runs it down the animal's belly. Little Ed watches as blood pours onto the floor. And in that moment, he feels something he's never felt before. Like something has awakened inside of him, a complicated feeling of pleasure, a feeling that will drive a lot of Ed's behavior in the years to come. See, this is a perfect moment, too, where we can discuss how a lot of people could also see that, and that could be a horrifying moment, a nightmare fuel for a child, but for Ed, it did awaken something in him. So there is this sort of thing that already kind of existed within Ed. Right. And there's a lot of different studies into this moment specifically, because Ed did recall it quite a bit after he was caught for his crimes, that almost attached a sexual desire to this and to his mother. It's the act of his mother cutting open this pig. And it's, I mean, the complexity and darkness here is like, really, it runs deep. Oh my gosh. And it's so unsettling to you and I, Freud would have had a field day. So Ed might have thought that he would take this secret with him to the grave. He certainly didn't have any friends to share this, well, maybe his perversions with, which is even harder, because now he's stuck with it alone in his head. Yeah. And he probably knows it's wrong, but he has no one to share it with and talk to it with. He assesses over it and thinks about it because he knows he's not supposed to, which makes him think about it more and getting punished by his mom, which is either a bad thing or a good thing. I don't know, which is why everyone should go to therapy. Yes. Big therapy advocates here. It gets even worse for Ed too, because he actually dropped out of school after the eighth grade. And it seems like the only person outside of his mom and his life really was Henry, who was five years his senior, but Henry also didn't last long in school either. And so the two started attending to their parents firm full time, working a series of odd jobs around town. And really because their father was also suffering with alcoholism and probably a lot of other things, he wasn't able to pull his weight really. And so they had a lot of work to do to keep the family afloat and help their mother Augusta, which goes back to again, like Ed almost playing this role of partner rather than child. So there's a lot of responsibility to put on a kid. And also based on everything we've learned about Ed and Augusta, the relationship Augusta had with Henry, like she almost kind of despised him. And then favored Ed, which I'm sure created so much conflict between brothers, super weird dynamic. Yeah. But the two are working together on the family farm. And then Ed, he would patch roofs, he would paint houses, repaired broken fences, and he even babysat some of the neighbor's kids. And not just like a one time, oh, we're hiring Ed to babysat, like he was a repeatedly hired, he was a repeat hire people, but he did a great job. The kids loved him, which is just so hard to think about after the fact. Yeah. But I do hope he was actually like a good babysitter and that he might have been. Yeah. That he was good to the kids. Accepted by the young kids. Yeah. Felt at home with them. Because there is, like I even feel this, when I'm in social gatherings because I have severe social anxiety, I cling to my niece, my two year old niece, because it's so much easier. Oh, if there's a dog at the party. Right. Get it. There's no small talk. It's like you're just running around and having fun and it's innocent. And there's less pressure on you to be like, look at me, I have my life together. Totally. So the younger kids that he babysat did seem to love Eddie, he would rough house with the boys. He would do magic tricks for the girls. And he definitely felt more in sync with the children than he did with young adults, his own age. Right. And while most of the kids moved out of their homes, starting their own lives, exploring independence from their families, Ed and Henry did not, they kept living under their parents roof well into their 30s. And it kind of seemed like there was no plan for either of them to move out and be on their own. Which is probably something that a gust of wanted. Yeah. She better reminds me of the board and sisters. Yeah. But in the 1940s, tragedy was brought to the keen family. By the start of the year, Ed's father George was nearly at the end of his life. The years of drinking had really taken a toll on his health. And at 66 years old, on April 1st of that year, George passed away. And after that, the dynamic in the home, it changed a lot. Right. Now with their father gone, the reason that Eddie and his brother, Henry, had never really been close, was more apparent, at least to Henry. It was because of how much Ed worshiped Augusta, a very inappropriate amount. This who always seemed to gang up on Henry, taking each other's side. And eventually it came to the point where Henry just could not keep quiet any longer. He approached Ed one day and expressed some of his concerns about how much of a hold Augusta had over the 37 year old Ed. And it was one concern that Henry probably should have kept to himself, though I don't want to blame Henry for this. But you'll know why because of what came next. It's the evening of May 16th, 1944. Ed Dean runs to his neighbor's house in a panic. He says there's just been a fire on his property. And he and his brother were scrambling to put it out. But he lost sight of his 42 year old brother, Henry. And after the flames and smoke finally cleared, Henry was still nowhere to be found. Ed cries out desperately, he needs his neighbor's help. They assemble a search party, even the deputy sheriff comes out to lend a hand. But there's something strange about how this search goes down. Ed trudges back over to the property and without missing a beat with the team trailing behind him, Ed seems to know exactly where to find his missing brother. And he leads the search party directly to where Henry is now lying face down in the dirt. His pulse no longer beating. While the neighbors call Ed out for having found Henry's body so easily, Ed just shrugs and agrees saying "funny how that works." Even weirder, Henry doesn't appear to be touched by the flames at all. There isn't a single burn on his body. There are however several strange bruises on his head. Bruises that might have been caused by foul play. Funny how that works. Guilty. But apparently not. That's so suspicious. It's so suspicious. And I feel like to you and I, and probably our listeners, everyone who's out there listening, it seems safe to say Ed had some role in this. But yeah, I would see him that way. But for the record, Ed was actually never charged with anything related to Henry's death. But the people of Plainfield definitely whispered about it. And one thing was for certain, Ed did not have to worry about sharing his mommy anymore. He had a gust of all to himself. Why did you have to say it? So creepy. That's how I picture them together. Just odd behaviors. Have you ever seen long legs? No. Ah, so it's Nick Cage in that movie and he plays this very, very creepy role. But there's a scene where he's like driving and he's like "Mommy! Daddy!" So you sounded like that. Well, No offense to Nicolas Cage in that movie, Nicolas Cage, whereas in that, but it does kind of look like he is wearing a skin suit in it. It does. Yeah. Well, I don't think that's a fence. I think that's props to the costume people. Yeah, props to the prosthetics. They did their job. Curious if there's any inspiration there from Edgene's story, but Ed also did not have Augusta to himself for very long after Henry's death, because a short time later Augusta suffered a paralyzing stroke. And just four days after Christmas, on December 29, 1945, a second stroke took her life. And she died at 67 years old. And now Ed was completely beside himself, completely alone, the one person who'd offered him shelter and security and direction, at least in his skewed beliefs, was now gone. It was probably life-shattering. I can't even imagine. His whole reality has changed. What was going on? If he wasn't already broken inside, that had to have destroyed him. Yes. And because that's something that like I remember when my dad's dad passed away, it really, really broke him in many ways. And I think that's something that a lot of people deal with when their parents die. It's really difficult. Right. Yeah. And for Ed and his grief, he had no purpose. And it had no direction. The house completely went to ruin. And it wasn't long before that grief and loneliness manifested into something darker, something twisted and sadistic. And it would only be a matter of time before the monster living inside of him finally emerged. Dundundund. 58-year-old Bernice Warden, her maiden name was Conifer, had lived in Plainfield, Wisconsin ever since she was a little girl. She had married a boy in town named Leon Warden and the two opened a hardware store together. And then they had two children, Frank and Miriam. And it was a very quiet and simple life. And over the years, the family became synonymous with that little hardware store. I picture like Gilmore Girls now. Yeah. So just small town. Everyone knows everyone. Totally. Yeah. And everyone in town knew who Leon and Bernice were because of this hardware store that they ran. And so when Leon suddenly passed away in 1931 at the age of 40, the whole town was mourning his loss. This was a very beloved man. And this was just the kind of place that Plainfield was. Everyone knew each other. Everyone cared about one another. But suddenly Bernice had found herself owning this hardware store, a single mom having to run the shop and have two children all under her care. And for the next 25 years, Bernice learned how to live without Leon by her side. She went to church. She found a love for fishing. She became a grandmother and all while earning the title of Citizen of the Week in 1956. I love that. Bring that back. Yeah. Citizen of the Week. I feel like towns are too big. Like, you need to do something up. Actually, this is that was inappropriate to say in this episode. Sorry. Oh my god. You meant to do that. I did not. But you know where my mind is now. I do. Yes. Okay. Well, there was one person in this town who took an extra special liking to Bernice Warden. And that was Ed Gheen because ever since his mother's passing, Ed, while he hadn't really changed much, he was still odd. He was quite polite and soft-spoken. And most people knew him as such. And he still actually babysat people in the neighborhood. Right? Like still in his 40s. He's babysitting kids. If there was a sudden emergency, I don't think he was like the go-to. But you know, he was still there available. But he looked a little bit more ragged than before. Without his mother around to encourage him to bathe every few days. Maybe that was expected. It wasn't the only one who'd fallen into disrepair, though, because their farmhouse, the Gheen's family farmhouse, it also suffered in the wake of Augusta's death. It was once completely pristine. And now the yard was infested with weeds. The farming equipment had rusted away in the summer sun. And any livestock that once brought life to the land had been sold off by Ed to make some cash. Right. Even from the outside, it was very clear that there was some unsettling darkness that had descended over the Gheen's home. And maybe that is why Ed often found himself wandering all around town. It's like his physical reality was a metaphor for what was happening psychologically too. Oh yeah, completely. And him wandering around just totally lost, looking for direction. Right. And looking for a mom, clearly some companion type of replacement for Augusta. Totally. And one of his chosen haunts was Bernie's warden's hardware store. It started small, stopping by every once in a while, to buy a new wrench or some chemical supplies. But soon he was making daily appearances. And those turned into something more specific, some more specific requests. He would ask Bernie, "Do you want to join me for a movie tonight? Are you free to go roller skating later?" Maybe dancing is more your speed. So it's almost like he wants a romantic connection with her. Which I have to say, after all of these talks about him struggling socially, I do feel like his lines to ask someone on a date is appropriate. Maybe the way he did it in the context. And we're not there to really know how it went down. So we want to imagine it one way, but it might have been a little bit more unsettling. True. Yeah. And while it doesn't seem like Bernie's who was seven years older than Ed was very accepting of his advances, she also wasn't rude to him either. She was very polite in declining these dates, but Ed's feelings for Bernice. They went from fondness to obsession and quickly. And on the morning of November 16th, 1957, Ed Geen could no longer help himself. It's a quiet day in downtown Plainfield, the first day of hunting season. So many of the local men and boys are out in the woods searching for deer. But back in town, Bernice Warden is managing the quiet hardware shop in case any of the men come back for supplies. Even Bernice's grown son, Frank, is out in these woods. When Frank isn't working as Deputy Sheriff in town, he's helping Bernice out in the hardware shop. But today, Bernice figures she can handle it alone. And Ed Geen, who has been watching her closely, sees this as the perfect opportunity. Just after 8am that day, Ed hops in his 49th Ford sedan and heads into town. He parks his car in front of Bernice's shop and goes inside. As the bell over the door rings, Bernice greets Ed politely. He brings an empty jug over to the register, flashes an awkward toothy grin at Bernice and asks if she will refill his antifreeze. Bernice centers to the backroom to get it, making small talk with Ed as she disappears. Then she comes back into view. She writes him a sales receipt, keeping a carbon copy for herself, and then watches as Ed wanders back out the front door. Bernice lets out a sigh of relief, believing she is off the hook, from Ed's flirtatious advances today. But then she hears the bell chime again. Ed is back, and this time he has another request. He's been thinking of trading his rifle for a new one. So he asks Bernice if he can see the model she has on display. Bernice hand the unloaded rifle over and walks over to the window of the shop, giving Ed some time to consider it. She comments to Ed about a big red Chevy parked in front of the general store across the street. "I see Bud has a new car," she says, her back still turned to Ed. And while she's distracted, Ed takes a bullet out of his overalls, loads the pistol, and by the time she turns around, Bernice is face to face with the shotgun. Then Ed pulls the trigger. A few hours later, a man named Bernard, who worked across the street at the gas station, noticed how quiet things were at Bernice's store. And Bernice was always hustling about, but not today. And so he noticed something fell off. And again, like going back to the small town, everyone knows everyone. They're probably two new businesses. Yeah. Exactly. On his break, Bernard strolled over to check on Bernice, and the shop door was locked. And so he thought to himself, well, maybe Mrs. Warden decided to close shop early. But if that were the case, then why had Bernice left all the lights on inside? So he's an investigator, right? He's picking up on the close. This is a time we're having nosy neighbors is a good thing. Oh, it's still a good thing. Yeah. And later that afternoon, Bernice's son, Frank Warden, returned from hunting and stopped by the gas station. And when he heard that his mother was missing from her shop, he rushed right over. And one of the first things he noticed was a pool of blood inside of the shop. And Nierrit was a handwritten receipt for antifreeze. And the person his mother had sold to was none other than Ed Geen, leaving a lot of evidence behind. Yes. Thankfully, we're glad that he did. Right. Which is a little bit ironic that he was so sloppy in his crimes because he did also consume a lot of content at home reading about. Right. Crimes. He's been a lot of time thinking about it probably, but never I guess acting on it is such a different experience. True. I hope to never know, and I hope none of you ever know, and I hope no one kills anyone. - Thank you. - Thank you, bye. - I think that's safe to say. - I'd worry if I took back what I was saying. I was like, uh, walk it back. - Walk it back, walk it back. - So Frank knew Ed had been making some strange passes at his mom and that this had been going on for a while. So when he contacted his fellow officers at the Sheriff's Department, he was certain when he said, quote, he's done something to her. - Oh, that's so sad. - I know. They needed to find Edgene and they needed to find him fast, which shockingly was not that hard because they found Edgene sitting in a neighbor's driveway that evening and they asked Ed to get out of his car where they questioned him. They asked where he'd been that day and the conversation basically ended with one very suspicious comment from Ed. He said, somebody framed me and the police asks, framed you for what? - Oh God. - And then he replies, well Mrs. Warden, she's dead, ain't she? - Guilty! (laughs) - We need to get him on police department. - This is ridiculous. Okay, so this was-- - I was like, I'm angry you just got, but they're about to, yeah. - They're on to the trails or soft, so you can't really feel my frustration. - But this was a huge tell, right? Because no one had suspected that Bernice was dead at the time, no one was talking about it. The town didn't know, the gossip hadn't spread yet. She was just missing. - And sure there was blood, but that doesn't necessarily mean death. - It could have just been injury. - Yeah, exactly, totally. - So Ed is showing all of his cards here, and this was enough to land Ed in handcuffs and get him stuffed into the back of the squad car. And meanwhile, two other officers were dispatched to the Guine farm, instead, arriving around 8 p.m. - With one hand on their flashlights and the other on their holsters, the officers approached the Guine house with a sense of hesitancy. Even though they know that Ed is in custody, there's something about this place that sends shivers down their spines, and it isn't the freezing cold weather. They try several doors finding most of them are locked. Aside from one latch that is a bit flimsier than the rest, the door to the summer kitchen, which is attached to the main house. This bolt is weak and gives with one swift kick. As the door opens, the officers are struck with a horrible stench, an unmistakable decay. The officers cover their noses with their jackets, shining their lights inside to find that the place is covered in trash. They step over weeks if not months of rotting food, empty bottles, old newspapers, and rusted farm tools. They take each corner with a cautiousness you might feel in a haunted house. And that is when one of the officers feels it. It ghostly presents gently caressing his back. He whips his head around to see. It isn't his imagination. His flashlight illuminates a decapitated dead body, hanging upside down from the ceiling. The remains are gutted like livestock. Split down the middle. Despite the dismemberment and lack of a head, there is no question in their mind that this is the body of Bernice Warden. And as they wander from room to room, the officers discover something far worse, something that could only be described as a museum for the macabre. One concocted from Ed's own twisted psyche, bracelets, a waist basket, lampshades and chairs, all made from human skin. And boxes filled with other discarded body parts like noses, sex organs, they are amongst unthinkable horrors. Masks and clothes made of real human flesh that are designed to be worn. Then one of the officers sees a bag hidden behind a door. After what he had just witnessed, he cannot fathom what lies within. And every instinct tells him not to open it, to stay away. But this is his job and duty calls. That is when he reaches in, fingers interlocking with a clump of human hair. And then he pulls out an entire human head. And it is not Bernice Warden's head. He hasn't realized it yet, but it belongs to another woman who went missing in Plainfield three years prior in 1954, a woman named Mary Hogan. This is just so brutal because I feel like one of the things with serial killers is trophies, right? The trophy is the kind of token thing that gets a lot of people caught. But this is so far beyond a trophy. I don't even know what this is. It's a head. It actually-- so I wrote for the show "Proticle Sun" back in what was that, 2021, 2022, those years of the pandemic. And one of the episodes that I wrote, it was season one, episode 18, I think. I can't remember. Anyway, the killer in that resembles Edgine so much. And I didn't even realize it. Like, it must have been in my subconscious, but I didn't realize it. But there's a scene that I wrote where a body is like dismembered in pieces, and the head is found in a paper bag. He's just so disturbing that I do think he's influenced more than what is just been credited to. Yeah. Him, unfortunately. So Mary Hogan, the victim that you just presented, her tavern was a local afterwork watering hole. It was located only seven miles outside of Plainfield. It was one of the places that everyone could just get together after a really long day and drown their sorrows, or disrupt their routines a little bit. And for Edgine, it was kind of a classroom. It was a place where he could learn how the rest of the society, I guess, acted. Which is a common thing with serial killers. I feel like a lot of them have this way of studying other humans to try to be like, oh, this is how I'm supposed to act. Right. And then they mimic it. Yeah. And he also-- he didn't drink either. So he was truly there just to observe people and to get a lesson in blending in. So while Ed didn't need any alcohol, which was his father's obsession. And so he kind of was turned off from it. He was there for a different sort of vice. He was there for the bartender, Mary Hogan herself. Three years before his obsession with Bernie's Warden, in 1954, Ed had set his sights on Mary. She was another middle-aged woman. And she was a little bit heavy set. She had a thick German accent who, again, reminded him of Augusta, reminded Ed of his mother. And Augusta, of course, she was super religious, super cold and stark and rigid in her beliefs and her ways. And so she would have never been caught dead in a bar. Right. But on the outside, Mary Hogan resembled Augusta fully. And on the inside, her morals could not be more different. And for some reason, this is kind of what attracted Ed to Mary even more. And that obsession came to a head in December of 1954. On the afternoon of December 8, the first patron steps inside Mary's tavern for his happy hour beer. The door slams behind him as he walks up to the counter and realizes it's eerily silent in here today. And Mary has not come out yet to pour him his usual ale. The longer the man stands there in the quiet abandoned bar, the more he realizes. Mary isn't in the back changing a keg. She isn't there at all. Something is very, very wrong. So this man peers behind the bar, and that is when he sees a pool of blood on the floor. Minutes later, deputies arrive on the scene, and they find a used 32-calibre cartridge on the bar floor, and a trail of blood that leads out the back door and into the parking lot. But that is where the clues stop. Detective spend weeks searching for more evidence, searching for Mary. But Mary's body never shows up, and neither does a lead. Eventually, Mary's case ran cold. That is, until almost three years later, when on the evening of November 16th, 1957, two detectives found her head in Ed Gaines' home. The officers at Ed's home called for backup prepared to collect every shred of evidence needed to prosecute Ed for Bernice and Mary's deaths. And also, I mean, based on all the evidence they were finding, I'm sure they were like, how many other victims that he-- - There were way more body parts than just two humans. - Noses, sexual organs, nipples. Like, it was dozens of body parts belong to who knows how many victims. - I can't even imagine what those officers were going through. - Yeah. - It turns out, Ed was not looking for a fight, thank goodness, and after his arrest, Ed was willing to tell the truth, and nothing but the truth. As long as they got him some apple pie with a slice of cheese on top. - Which kind of has become a famous reference, I think it's Robert De Niro's character in taxi, in taxi driver, who asks for a slice of apple pie with cheese on top. - And it does make me wonder the history of this, if this was something that Augusta, it was like his special treat for me. - It must have been. 'Cause why have you ever tried that? - No, and it's such a weird combo. - Like, I do love apple pie. - Well, I'm not trying to yuck another person's yawn, but maybe Ed's, yeah. - Yeah, I think it's okay to yuck Ed's, yums. - I'm allergic to apples. I can't have that. But Ed gave the police what they wanted. They wanted answers. They wanted to know why and he began to talk. He told them, yes, he had killed Bernie Swarden, but he couldn't recall the details. He said he remembered by antifreeze, but then after that, he blacked out, which I think is a common thing that either serial killers or murderers in general experience or claim to experience. And again, Norman Bates, this is his character, essentially. Right. But I do believe that there is this weird duality that's probably existing in the mind of the killers where they know something is wrong. Morely, they've been taught murder is wrong. So to protect themselves, they almost have this alter ego, again, not excusing it, but it's like they have to shut that off. It's the same way when people experience trauma, like sometimes they black it out, because it's easier to move on. Right. And also, I don't know what was going on in Ed's mind. Obviously, I feel like he's a really hard person for anyone to understand the psyche of. But there is that kind of back and forth of like he's finally completing his perversion, his dream of doing this thing. But also the person he loves the most in life, his mother would have absolutely probably killed him over. So it's like he's doing the worst thing in his mother's eyes. And probably the joy of doing it and the fear of being caught, even though she's gone. If I were to turn this into another type of movie, I'd picture it very like Dexter-esque where Augusta is showing up, like her ghost, is like this voice in Ed's head all the time. But like almost like he sees her spirit. Oh, maybe talking to him. Yeah. Well, he said he blacked out and that when he came to, he was dragging Bernice's body from the store into his truck and then he took her home where he cut her open like a deer. So yeah, maybe he blacked out during the actual killing portion, but he certainly remembers what he did after the fact. Yeah. And as the conversation continued, he also admitted to killing Mary Hogan in a very similar fashion three years prior. So he's just confessing everything once he's caught. I guess. Like what does he have to look for? He's got nothing. The question now was, who did the rest of the body parts belong to? Right. And that is when Ed confessed to the unthinkable. He told detectives that those body parts actually belonged to people who were already dead. Because it turns out he was super obsessed with grave robbing. And he would crack open caskets and steal the remains of the dead under the cover of night. And usually they were women, freshly deceased. And sometimes they were people he'd known about town. So after he confessed to grave robbing, a team of excavators pulled those bodies from their graves and analyzed their remains and did confirm that, yeah, he did take those body parts. But there was something else detectives were curious about that day. They wanted to know, why did he do it? And after nine hours of questioning, police finally got some answers. Ed admitted to them that both women reminded him of his mother. And whether he felt this urge to kill because of his deep obsession with Augusta or because maybe he had something like misunderstood hatred for her. We don't really know, but it seems too complicated for Ed to unravel himself without a therapist pro therapy. Yep. But it was enough to press charges. And five days later on November 21, 1957, Ed's lawyer helped him plead not guilty by reason of insanity, which is insane to me. Yeah, yeah. It is, but like he also wasn't with it. Like yes, I feel like they weren't premeditated for sure. But was he understanding right from wrong, which may be his part of? I have opinions on that. But yes, I understand either way he's put away, right? Like he's off the streets. Yeah. So the next step was to see whether or not this 51-year-old Ed Gehn was fit to stand trial and a judge ordered Ed to undergo 30 days of observation at the Central State Hospital for the criminally insane and Wapen, Wisconsin. And during his time there, Ed offered even more insight into how his twisted mind worked. Despite what many investigators believed, he insisted that his crimes were not sexually motivated, that he never engaged in any acts of sex with the deceased. Or even the living. Like he was a virgin. He claimed to be a virgin. Yes, his whole life. Yeah, that he did partake in masturbation, but never had sex ever in his entire life. Because what would Augusta think? Right. Yeah, he was evil if he partoken those acts with the evil women that were all around him. After those 30 days of assessment were up, doctors officially diagnosed Ed Gehn with schizophrenia and decided that he was not fit to stand trial after all. Instead, he would remain under the care of the state hospital indefinitely. And the people of Plainfield were pissed. Which, I don't blame them. Right, we're already getting pissed. Yeah, get your gavel out. He'll get you! All right. It is around 2.30 AM on March 20, 1958, when a little boy living near Ed's house wakes up to a brilliant light outside his window. As he peels back the blind, he sees that the Gehn's abandoned farmhouse has erupted into flames. And by the time the fire marshal and a team of firefighters arrive on the scene, there is no saving Ed's childhood home. Come sunrise, the people of Plainfield have gathered around to watch the now-tainted farmhouse crumble. The way they see it, this is one way for Ed Gehn to finally receive some justice. And the local authorities seem to agree, because what, or rather who, started the fire, is never investigated. Later that morning, Ed's psychiatrist comes into the ward after hearing the news on the radio and terrified of how Ed might react. He wonders to himself if he should even bother sharing the news. So he waits for Ed to get up, get dressed, and to eat some breakfast before he finally tells him that his childhood home is no longer standing. And Ed, without much expression, just blinks in his direction before responding very casually just as well. He's so casual in all of his lines. I don't, he's the most confusing person ever. Funny how that works just as well. Well, just as well, 10 years later, in 1968, Ed's doctors announced that he had improved, and he was now fit to stand trial for the murder of Bernie's warden. And on November 14th of that year, 62-year-old Ed's fate was decided, again, still not guilty by reason of insanity. And so Ed was sent back to the hospital where he lived for the next decade and a half and come 1984. 78-year-old Ed was senile. He was living with cancer. And on July 26th of that year, he died of respiratory failure. And the following night, he was buried in an unmarked grave in the Plainfield Cemetery right next to his mother, Augusta. -Eternally at peace. -Which his mother? -I also wonder, was her head returned? Or was he with headless mommy? -I don't know. -The fact that you keep saying mommy, it's so appropriate because he probably was calling her mommy until her death. But it's creepy at hearing you say it. It's mommy. It's mommy. This story is really, really disturbing. And after hearing Ed's story, you can probably see why he's left such a lasting impression on a lot of filmmakers, creatives, even everyday people. Because something about the way Ed expressed those horrific desires lodges itself deep into the psyche, creating what can only be described as nightmare fuel. And like I was saying about with Prodigal Sun, that episode I wrote, I wasn't thinking about Edgene. -But he exists inside your mind somewhere. -He stays there. -Yeah. -Because what is more monstrous than this? -If you're trying to get deeply depraved and write something so horrifying that it doesn't feel real, it's Edgene's story. -It is. -So let's talk about some of the films that were inspired by Edgene. So let's start with one of my favorites. Texas Chainsaw Massacre, which I didn't realize was inspired by Edgene. It is one of the longest running horror franchises out there. And the first movie came out in 1974, written by Kim Henkel and Toby Hooper, and also directed by Toby Hooper as well. He then directed a sequel that came out 12 years later. And this one was written by LM Kit Carson. Seven more movies followed after that, all by different creators, including a remake in 2003, which I think that's the one I saw. -Yeah, me too. -Actually, that was my first-- -That was another single movie. Horror movie I Ever Watched. -Texas Chainsaw Massacre? -I did a double feature. So I really went from never watching horror movies, and then I went to a sleepover where my friend wanted to watch scary movies, and I couldn't be chicken. And we did a double feature of Texas Chainsaw Massacre and House of Wax. -Ooh, I think about that every time the Achilles tendon just snipped underneath the stairs or just being pulled apart at a gas station with two trucks. Horrible. This is what kids born in the '80s and '90s grew up watching. But so throughout all of these movies, the franchise's villain, who Edgene inspired, has remained the same. So if you haven't seen any iteration of the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, I'm going to give a log line. A group of friends are traveling through rural Texas when they stop by this old farmstead. One by one, they're picked off by a chainsaw wielding villain known as. leather face, who is a former butcher, who makes and wears masks of human skin to hide his own identity. So just by that quick synopsis, you can see how leather face was clearly inspired by Edgine and his horrific crimes. Plus also the like a old farm in the middle of nowhere. Right. So then there's the desecration of bodies, the trophies made of human remains. This is all taken from a page in Edgine's book. But there is one interesting fact that I learned in preparation for this episode. In an interview, co-writer and director Toby Hooper said that he learned about Ed when he was just four or five years old. Who told him? He said relatives of his lived just one town over from Edgine in Wisconsin and told his family about the crimes as they were happening. Oh my god. So like he and his family were getting the inside scoop in real time. To live. Yeah. So it was something that always stuck with Hooper, especially with the story hitting so close to home. Have you seen Texas Chainsaw mask? Oh yes. Have you seen multiple versions of it? No, I think I've only seen the one that you did. Yeah. It is unsettling. And as my intro into horror movies, I will say it's a good one to start with. But it is. If you like gore. Yeah, it is. Gory. Yeah. It's very gory. Oh, in the moments of hiding in the old buildings. It's attached to the farmhouse, hearing the Chainsaw going. Your heart's just constantly beating watching that. I know. But if we want to do a more psychological spin on Edgine's story, then let's go to the next movie because this one still gives us nightmares. Silence of the lambs. And if it were an 11 a.m., I'd say let's crack open a bottle of Kianti, get some bowls of fava beans and skip out on the liver. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Well, here's the TLDR. An FBI agent in training, Clarice Starling, played by the iconic Jody Foster, asks for the help of a cannibalistic psychiatrist named Dr. Hannibal Lecter. And she asks for help when she needs to find another serial killer named Buffalo Bill, author Thomas Harris drew inspiration from Edgine when conjuring up Buffalo Bill's character. And if you've read the books or if you've seen the movies, you know that one of Buffalo Bill's identifying traits is dressing up in a suit of female flesh, exactly like the one that was found in Edgine's farmhouse on that fateful day that Bernice disappeared. Buffalo Bill also has the defining trait of mutilating and skinning his victims, again, taken from a page from Edgine's book. Of the movies inspired by Edgine, I think this is the one that sticks with me the most. Because it is, I mean, if you're a horror movie fan, I feel like this is one of your go-to sounds of the lamb. And a psychological thriller. And it still has the gore. It's just so disturbing. It is. There was a time in my life where I would do dinners with friends. And we'd pick a movie and then make a dinner associated to the movie or like relative to the movie. And we did a silence with the lamb's night. Oh God. Okay, at least it was the first one and not the second one. Yeah, no, it was just the first one. Yeah, because the second one, the eats the guy's brain while he's so alive. I was not serving humans at my dinner party. It's an interesting choice for dinner party. I'll say that. I'm a weird person. And I'm proud of that. And that's why we sit here in these chairs tonight. And that's why we're talking about this. No, but I do think it's one of those things where as humans, we want to understand patterns and we want to understand the why behind things. And that's why so many killers and people like Ed Geen are so fascinating to us because they feel so foreign from you and I. Yeah. And thank God. Yeah, yes, exactly. But it's also scary and it feels real. And there are victims that perhaps like like we could be victims. And there's this desire to want to protect ourselves. Right. I was just going to say that like there's something in like studying the clues and studying what happened to see if there was any way of like identifying if this is about to happen to us. And like what are the ways that we could potentially survive? Like how do you catch a killer before they kill? And I think that's the that would be the goal for everyone. But yeah, instead we look back afterwards. So now maybe the most infamous nod to Ed Geen is the character Norman Bates, the main character in Psycho. But before we talk about the movie, let's talk about the book Robert Block because there is something really eerie that happened here. So creepy. And you told me about this. Yes. So you tell me about it again. Okay. So it turns out Block was writing the novel Psycho in 1958, 35 miles away from where Geen lived. And this is when all of these crimes are happening. But Block has no idea the full extent of Geen's history and the murders until after the book was already published. So shockingly his character Norman Bates is eerily similar to Ed Geen. He was writing this book just miles from where Ed Geen was committing these atrusious acts that had no clue. It reminds me of like that book. And I can't remember the name of it, but it was like about a big ship that was doing a transatlantic journey that crashed in a very similar way to the Titanic that was written years before the Titanic crashed. Yes. And it's like what is going on in the universe or like the ether like they're picking up on some sort of energy. And it does make me wonder not to get like woo woo but you were mentioning. But if you know us from two girls when goes we get woo woo sometimes you're going to get a little woo woo here. Yeah. But you were talking about like what if Augusta was whispering an ed's ear. It makes me wonder if somehow this author unknowingly was tapping into like whatever was going on in the paranormal realm in this other dimension. Yeah. And was kind of getting bits and pieces of maybe what Ed was being told or even just Ed's mind himself. Right. Or as a writer like sometimes when I'm writing like I feel like I kind of just the muse writes through me like I feel like I kind of disassociate and then words just like come out automatic writing. Yeah. So is there also an element of that when you're so creative you're in a project that like the universe is kind of speaking through you. But how ironic that writing such a nutritious monster when the monster lives next door. Right. It's like block was channeling Ed and some freaky other well otherworldly way. So then this book was then adapted into a film by Alfred Hitchcock King of Horror in 1960. And while there are some differences like Ed never ran away from like Ed never ran a hotel like Norman Bates did. And he never killed anyone in the shower like that infamous scene in psycho like Norman did. And Ed didn't keep the corpse of his mother in his home. Although arguably he did because he did take the head into his home. Right. So the similarities that the two did share were intricate like the sexual repression both Augusta and Norma encouraged in their sons. They both fostered a deep emotional dependence in their children and that led to a disturbing edifice complex in both men. And then also both men snapped after their mother's untimely deaths. So this movie has so many twists and turns and other similarities to Edgene that we don't want to spoil it for you. But if you haven't seen it, what are you doing? Who are you? What's wrong with you? Sorry. No. No judgment. Pause this episode right now. Go watch it. Come back. Yes. Have a movie marathon after this episode with farphabines and kiadis. Apple pie with a slice of cheese on top. Because this is absolutely one to add to your watch list. And I think all of this begs a more interesting question which is what's more interesting. What is it about Edgene and all of these real-life monsters that makes for such fascinating on-screen characters? Why are they messed up? Why are we messed up watching it? We're all a little bit messed up in the head. But I think in a way they also force us to confront our own darkest fears. Like the idea that not everyone out there has a mind that works like ours. Yeah. Like I don't think about or sexualize murder in this way. So it feels so foreign to me that I want to understand it. And it makes us want to understand someone else's psyche, how they operate, how they think, why do they do the things that they do. And it does expose the unimaginable things in human beings and that human beings are capable of. Like we spend a lot of time talking about the paranormal. But at the end of the day, the scariest thing is truly other living beings. All of this challenges our perception of reality and it upsets the natural order. And then another scary part is the wrong combination of nature and nurture. Like anyone could become someone like Edgene and you reference this or you made a note to this earlier in the episode. But like there are plenty of people who have traumatic childhoods and grow up with unstable parents who then don't become serial killers. Right. So the nature and nurture. There's a mix of it. It was in there. Yeah. Edgene. Right. Like how can you make certain that it doesn't happen to us or it doesn't happen to our children that we raise? And honestly, for some killers, they have a perfectly normal childhood. Like I think of Ted Bundy. He has siblings that are nothing like him. Right. Right. So maybe that's why true crime is as a whole, something we can't look away from because it forces us to not only face our fears, but helps us convince ourselves that we can spot the dangers, allows us to think that maybe we can avoid them or hope we can avoid them and it gives us a feeling that if we can understand it, we can control it. But there's one thing to remember in all of this. At the center of these horror movie muses lie very, very people living very real lives. There's no one calling cut on a scene. There's no heading back to the trailer, to remove the costumes, the makeup, the fake blood. There's no movie premiere or Oscar for best performance. So next time you press play on your favorite horror movie, particularly the ones inspired by true events. Remember that the scariest monsters aren't the ones on the big screen. They're the ones in the shadows lurking amongst us. So maybe don't watch all those movies. Maybe watch Bravo Summer House or something more relaxing after this. Thank you so much for listening. We are your hosts Sabrina De Niroga and Karin Vienn. Join us next Tuesday for another peek inside another crimes of infamy. Here at Crime House, we want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you like what you've heard today, reach out on all social media at Crime House. Don't forget to rate, review, and follow crimes of wherever you get your podcasts. Your feedback truly makes a difference. Thank you so much for joining us and we can't wait to see you next week. We're so excited to be here on Crimes of and we're glad that you're here with us. And if you're watching on YouTube, don't forget to subscribe and also what should we call everyone? What do you want to be called? Tell us. What's this community? Who are you guys? Who are we? All as a group. Coming on YouTube, we'll figure it out. See you next time. Bye!

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Ed Geen, a 1950s killer from Plainfield, Wisconsin, is known for horrific crimes involving dismemberment and body parts used as trophies.
  2. Despite being a beloved babysitter to children in the community, Ed’s twisted psyche and deep obsession with his mother, Augusta, led to violent crimes.
  3. Ed confessed to killing Bernice Warden and Mary Hogan, both of whom reminded him of his mother, and admitted to grave-robbing to collect body parts.
  4. After being arrested, Ed claimed he had no sexual motive and was a lifelong virgin, believing any such acts would violate his mother’s strict religious values.
  5. Ed was found not guilty by reason of insanity and spent decades in a state hospital due to schizophrenia, never being convicted of murder.
  6. His crimes, including grotesque body art and dismemberment, directly inspired iconic horror films like *Texas Chainsaw Massacre*, *Silence of the Lambs*, and *Psycho*.
  7. The surreal and disturbing nature of Ed’s actions—such as human-made furniture and body parts—have made him a central figure in true crime and horror storytelling.
  8. The story of Ed Geen remains deeply unsettling, reflecting broader themes of abuse, control, and the psychological fragility of those raised in extreme environments.

Summary:

Ed Geen, a real-life serial killer from 1950s Plainfield, Wisconsin, became one of the most disturbing figures in American true crime history. A deeply religious and emotionally isolated man, he was shaped by his overbearing mother, Augusta, who instilled in him a pathological fear of women and a twisted sense of loyalty to her. After her death, Geen spiraled into a life of violence, murdering at least two women—Bernice Warden and Mary Hogan—both of whom reminded him of his mother.

He dismembered their bodies and used body parts to create grotesque items like lampshades, masks, and clothing, which were discovered in his home. Despite initial arrests and confessions, Ed was never convicted; instead, he was declared not guilty by reason of insanity and spent decades in a state hospital due to schizophrenia. His crimes, marked by extreme sadism and a lack of sexual intent, were later cited as major inspirations for horror films like *Texas Chainsaw Massacre* (with Leatherface), *Silence of the Lambs* (Buffalo Bill), and *Psycho* (Norman Bates).

The story of Ed Geen is a chilling exploration of how traumatic upbringing, psychological control, and isolation can manifest into violent, irrational behavior. It remains a powerful example of the connection between real crime and fictional horror, deeply embedding itself in popular culture. The episode highlights not only the brutality of the crimes but also the emotional and societal wounds they caused, particularly in a close-knit community.

It serves as a reminder of the lasting impact of abuse and the dangers of unchecked psychological unraveling.

FAQs

Ed Geen murdered at least two women, Bernice Warden and Mary Hogan, and dismembered their bodies. He also committed grave robbing, stealing body parts from deceased women, which he used to create grotesque trophies like lampshades, clothing, and masks made from human flesh.

No, Ed Geen was not convicted of murder and was never sentenced to prison. Instead, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity and was committed to a psychiatric hospital, where he remained for decades.

The film's villain, Leatherface, was directly inspired by Ed Geen's crimes, including his use of human body parts in trophies, dismemberment of victims, and a connection to rural farmhouses and isolation.

Ed Geen was deeply influenced by his mother's strict religious beliefs and obsessive views of women as evil. He believed women were temptations, and his crimes were driven by a psychological fixation on his mother and a desire to emulate or destroy those he saw as evil.

Ed Geen was not charged with murder because he was found not guilty by reason of insanity. He was deemed mentally unfit to stand trial and committed to a psychiatric facility instead of prison.

While not directly inspired by Ed Geen, the character of Norman Bates from Psycho shares traits like a deep psychological dependency on a parent and a distorted sense of identity, reflecting similar themes found in Ed Geen’s story.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.