India's Crypto Crackdown: What the ED Raids Mean for Investors
17m 41s
India’s Enforcement Directorate is intensifying scrutiny of leading crypto exchanges like CoinDCX and Delta, alleging violations of foreign exchange laws. These investigations center on cross-border crypto transactions that require fund transfers, which fall under FEMA regulations. Despite this, India lacks a formal crypto policy or regulatory framework, even as crypto use grows in daily life—evident in payments for groceries, fuel, and even ice cream via platforms like Goat.cash. Crypto futures further complicate matters with high leverage and reliance on offshore liquidity, creating compliance and tax issues. While the U.S. has introduced the Genius Act to regulate stablecoins, India remains reactive, with regulators only now noticing widespread adoption. The absence of clear laws means crypto transactions operate in a legal gray zone, allowing tax evasion and bypassing traditional financial systems. Authorities are struggling to keep pace with fast-evolving crypto technologies, such as crypto cards and peer-to-peer payments, which mirror familiar digital payment experiences like UPI. This growing use underscores a critical gap: India’s regulatory bodies are not only behind the curve but also in denial of crypto’s systemic integration. A proactive, comprehensive policy is urgently needed to balance innovation with financial stability, tax compliance, and anti-money laundering safeguards.
EDI has done something which strikes up the very heart of cryptos.
It would mean the end of cryptos in India.
Cryptocurrencies are back in the news, but this time the story is not just limited to
stable coins, speculative beds and wins or losses overnight.
Two of India's leading cryptocurrency trading platforms, CoinDCX which is actually
number one in terms of transactions and delta recently came under the scrutiny of India's
finance police, the enforcement directorate.
Why?
Because allegedly they violated India's foreign exchange laws.
Also, Cryptocurrency is selectiously creeping deeper and deeper into our everyday transactions.
From groceries and fuel to something as innocuous as ice cream, crypto is making its way into
India's ubiquitous digital payment system.
These may be fringe experiments, but they point to a significant shift.
Meanwhile, the global regulatory landscape is changing.
The United States, for example, has enacted something called the Genius Act, establishing
a regulatory framework for payment stable coins including requirements for reserves and
oversight for issuers.
India, on the other hand, taxes, crypto, games and transactions, but as of yet has no regulatory
framework around the industry.
And yet, the industry is evolving and that creates an uncomfortable contradiction.
So what's really happening?
What explains this renewed regulatory scrutiny on the two trading platforms?
Cryptocurrencies have been moving much faster than Indian currencies can keep up.
And is that delta now wider than ever?
Can there be a clamp down on the way crypto is creeping into our daily payments?
And is it finally time for the policy makers to decide what place crypto should have in
our financial system, rather than being in denial mode that it even exists?
To explain this, I'm joined by my colleague Shugata Ghosh.
It's Friday, the 20th of November, I'm Anirban Chaudhary, this is the morning brief.
Hi Shugata, very warm welcome to the morning brief decode.
Hi Anirban.
Okay, so cryptos are back in the news.
Let's start with the latest development.
How do you interpret this two leading crypto platforms, CoinDCX, which is the top platform
actually, and delta's recent rush with the law?
Well, the line of investigation that ED is pursuing, that is the enforcement directorate.
It rated these exchanges, questioning certain transactions.
If it really sticks to this line of inquiry, it would mean the end of cryptos in India.
Because either unwittingly or consciously, ED has done something which strikes at the
very heart of cryptos.
Understand one thing, cryptos are not mind in India, right?
Well, most of the cryptos we get from abroad.
Now exchanges source those cryptos, people buy those cryptos, that's how cryptos come
to India.
It's not secure case, which are issued in India.
So if you have to get cryptos from abroad, you have to pay them.
So, there would be a cross-border transfer of funds.
That's how it survives.
Now, if you question that, it is just not CoinDCX and delta, all exchanges are doing this.
So, where do you draw the line?
Because if you can't supply cryptos from abroad, in that case, there is no crypto trade
in India.
But, you know, can't they buy cryptos locally?
Well, they do.
They do buy locally, because some of the exchanges they want to be on the right side
of law, no matter how you interpret the law, that is the law, by law, I mean here a
FEMA, that is a foreign exchange management act, which deals with cross-border transfer
of funds, where RBI has the last word.
Now, many exchanges buy cryptos from local liquidity providers.
Now, these are domestic entities, domestic local people, who get the crypto from abroad.
But then the question remains, even if the exchanges are not violating FEMA, somebody else
from in their buying, their violating, because you have to get the cryptos from abroad.
Right.
Now, the point is that if you go to a bank and say that I want to transfer money, because
I want to import cryptos, right.
I don't think any bank would allow that purpose code, because banks, any year, extremely
KG, about handling transactions, they can't do a formal slam down because of the Supreme
Code ruling of 2020.
And no bank would entertain handling, no authorized dealer of foreign exchange, would entertain
handling foreign exchange transfers abroad to buy cryptos from overseas entities.
So, when they buy locally from this liquidity providers, they have to pay extra, because
those guys will be keeping their magic.
So, Shuganthu, what I don't understand is the use of the word violation, like for a layperson
like me, crypto is just another currency, no?
But it is used as a currency, but India, it is not recognized as a currency.
It is not recognized as a currency by the government, it is not recognized as a currency by the
Reserve Bank of India, and there are court rulings which says that it is not a currency.
So, there is no debate on that.
In fact, people who take an aggressive interpretation of the law and support the exchanges in transfer
of funds, they say that look, we are not transferring currency, so why is it a violation?
The very percent question which you are asking, but then if you are transferring any asset,
remember crypto is recognized in the law as a virtual digital asset, right?
So, if you are selling, just imagine if you are selling securities to a overseas investor,
or if you are taking securities from overseas investors and making an investment, right?
That's an asset, right?
That's a movable asset.
So, if you compare that with crypto, that is very much under the contours of FEMO, right?
So, if there are no laws which clearly define whether you can do it, in that case, it's
a gray area where the ED can step in, and it is stepping in.
Got it, got it.
Now, talk to me about crypto futures, I mean this is a new beast, does it complicate things,
how do you see it?
Well, very much complicate things, because crypto futures interestingly was something which
the authorities had no clue about.
They almost sensed it a year after it was launched, right?
And the exchanges were very clever, they analyzed the original crypto ads which you saw,
full page advertised bands, social media, on television, they did not consciously advertise
crypto futures, because crypto futures, just like stock futures, there is a leverage.
So, in stock futures, you can put in one lakh and bet on five lakhs, right?
In crypto, that leverage can go to 10 times, 20 times, 30 times, in some cases 100 times.
So, by putting in one lakh margin, you are taking an exposure of one crore, right?
Now, the point is, when you put in the margin, you put in as stable coins, what are stable
coins?
These are USGT and USDC, right?
These are picked to the dollar.
So, roughly one stable coin is one dollar, it is slightly more expensive in India, because
India you do not have cryptos, there is no supply.
So, there is a premium on USGT in India.
Now, first of all, investors can take far bigger bets, that is the number one.
Secondly, and this is a more technical point, which the finance ministry is still grappling
with, I guess, is that you do not pay TDS, that is a tax deducted at source, which you
have to pay for normal crypto transactions, whenever you sell cryptos, you have to pay
a TDS, right?
That is one percent.
And one percent is very high.
But in case of crypto futures, you are not paying any TDS, why?
Because you are not buying and selling cryptos, you are trading a contract which derives
its value from crypto.
So, there is no crypto changing hands, because you are taking a bet on the movement of
crypto.
So, when do you pay TDS, only initially, when you buy USGT, to put in as margins.
So, unlike stock trades, here you do not put your FDs or cash or securities as margin.
And secondly, the leverage is far higher, so the risk is significantly higher.
But then the trader has the thrill.
So, Shuvata does this complications trend in EDS case.
Of course, it does, because future volumes have far outstripped the spot volumes in cryptos.
Right, right.
There are a couple of multiples, three times, four times the spot volumes.
So, the same way, an exchange generates liquidity.
It has to do the same for cryptos.
Suppose, you have bought futures or you have sold futures and there is no immediate counterparty.
Right.
So, what do you do?
The exchange cuts a deal with a large crypto entity abroad, it could be Binance, it could
be some other exchange.
Right.
It could be a private individual or private entity, which supplies the crypto or which runs
a counter position.
Right.
Now, the beauty here is that the crypto exchange and that is a fundamental difference between
to achieve in a stock exchange. A stock exchange where the
the buyer and the seller is matched by the engine, the trading engine with the stock exchange,
the software in the stock exchange pass, right.
The crypto exchange is just not that.
There is an order matching, but at the same time, if there is no counterparty, it is either
the buyer on the seller.
So in case there is no counterparty, in that case, the local crypto exchange has to get
the liquidity from abroad.
So the same problem, that means dealing with an overseas party, either to receive money
from the overseas party or you pay money to the overseas party, depending on how the
crypto futures move, the future prices move.
So the same dilemma about transfer of funds, where the underlying is crypto, right.
That crops up.
Got it.
Got it.
Okay, now you started your previous answer by saying that the authorities weren't even aware
of crypto futures.
Now one more thing that a lot of people aren't aware of is how ubiquitous crypto has actually
become.
In a sense, you have reported about crypto cards, for instance, or payments in the UPN market
using crypto.
There are videos in fact of Gen Z is buying ice cream by making crypto payments.
How is this happening?
Well, it reminds me of the words of this legal scholar, Professor Richard Suscrind.
He had said that we are dealing with 21st century technology and 19th century laws and legal
structures.
And nothing better captures this than the crypto.
Right.
First of all, the law authorities took years to understand what is crypto.
I mean, there were law enforcement authorities which were taking regular lessons from crypto
exchanges to understand this new beast.
The point is here is that how do you stop it?
Now internationally, there are crypto cards available.
So crypto cards means just as a debit card is linked to your bank account.
So when you spend your bank, your money in the bank account, that's debatable.
In a crypto card, the crypto is in the crypto wallet, which is linked to the card.
Those cryptos get debatable.
Right.
This is a technology which is supported by no other than Visa and Mastercard.
Visa and Mastercard, they are the leading software providers.
They have perfected the card system.
Now the card is issued by international agencies, like RIDOT, but the software and the entire
back and thing that is being supported by Visa and Mastercard.
Right.
Right.
So, suppose you have cryptos, withdrawn those cryptos from the exchange wallet and then
you transfer the cryptos to a designated wallet and you subscribe to a RIDOT card.
Okay.
And then you start transacting.
So off-late, the government has got a brief of it.
And the financial intelligence unit and the Reserve Bank of India, they are trying to stop
it.
In fact, many have been deactivated.
That's fairly simple because if the FIU tells Visa or Mastercard to stop it, they will
deactivate it.
Right.
Right.
Right.
But it's far more difficult in case of EPA.
Why is that?
Because the EPA transaction is simpler.
What happens is that there are sites like Goat.cash, Goat, UAT, Goat Cash.
Now these are, there's not an app yet to download.
Right.
Right.
You enter the verification.
Right.
You give your name.
You give your country where you are located.
The value of something you want to buy and your email ID.
Right.
And then you scan the QR code of the ice cream seller, as you said.
This information goes to a intermediary.
Right.
It has cryptos and your crypto, the moment you do that, your crypto wallet gets debited
and gets transferred to that intermediary.
Right.
That intermediary sells that crypto, generates INR, either INR or dollars or converts into
INR and pays it to the merchant selling ice cream.
Got it.
So there are two legs.
One is the crypto leg, the conversion leg.
One is the payment in rupees.
Got it.
Now how do you stop this?
There is no law to transfer crypto from one person to another.
The trick is that the two legs of the transactions are being unified here.
And the payment experience is just like UPI or GP, it can really spread.
And but imagine the fiscal, the legal implications.
First of all, you are trampling on multiple laws.
And secondly, suppose somebody gets paid in cryptos, your crypto is lying there.
You don't pay income tax on that, right?
Now, these people were paid in cryptos, but even simple, you know, post transactions.
When you were paid in crypto, it can be fabulous, we do a skip tax.
Got it.
Finally, we come back to the same question that I've always ended on in our previous conversations
around cryptos.
So, why is there no crypto policy yet and isn't it about time that the government and,
you know, take other stakeholders, sit together and formulate one?
Well, it is high time, but I think that the government is on a denial mode, right?
It is neither US nor China, right?
China has clamped down on cryptos, it is banned, right?
It doesn't want to do that.
At the same time, it is not coming out with legislations like the Genius Act, which regulations
came into effect last month on the US, in the US, which gives a framework for the stable
corners.
Right.
Right.
The reason the government is not doing it is because of the constraints.
Yeah.
Possibly they have figured out now that exchanges share the data, they have figured out
only a few cross at crypto wallets.
So, even if there is a meltdown, right?
These are reckless traders who are traded on crypto and other things.
So, it doesn't matter, even if a small constancy loses money, but at the same time, they are
taxing it.
Right.
Of course, there is no law which says that you cannot tax something which is illegal, which
is quasi illegal.
Right.
Right.
So, there is a half recognition of crypto, as far as taxation is concerned, as far as the
EB actions are concerned, in the sense that there could be a violation of the amount, but
at the same time, there are no rules to regularize this transaction or to spell out the dos and
don'ts.
Right.
Now, the reason they don't want to do it, possibly they don't think that it's as big a problem,
but it will be, it will well be, if kids are buying ice creams or there was this software
engineer who was, who's video clips are doing the rounds, he bought a Bombay suburban local
train ticket with cryptos, when using the UPI system, right?
Right.
Now, these are total size.
So, oblivious to the government or the authorities, transactions are happening and sadly, the
regulators, the authorities, the anti-money laundering agencies like the FIU, they're reacting
to these developments.
Right.
Yeah.
First of all, they're getting to know these developments with a lag and then they're reacting.
Right.
Right.
So, they are behind the curve.
On that note, thank you so much for joining us.
Thank you.
Thank you.
That's it for today.
You were listening to this episode on The Morning Brief.
It was produced by me, Sound Designed by Amrit Redji.
Following our podcasts on your favorite platforms, you can catch the video episode on ET Digital
Platform.
Look for the playlist, The Morning Brief Decode.
Stay tuned.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
India’s Enforcement Directorate (ED) is investigating top crypto platforms CoinDCX and Delta for allegedly violating foreign exchange laws under FEMA.
The scrutiny targets cross-border crypto transactions, which require foreign fund transfers—actions that fall under existing regulatory frameworks governing asset transfers.
Crypto futures introduce high leverage and complex liquidity mechanisms, often involving overseas counterparties, raising regulatory and tax compliance challenges.
The absence of a comprehensive crypto policy means transactions remain unregulated, despite growing use in daily payments like buying ice cream or fuel.
Crypto payment methods via cards and peer-to-peer platforms like Goat.cash enable seamless, frictionless transactions that bypass traditional banking and tax systems.
There is no legal framework to define crypto as a currency or to regulate its use, leading to a gap between technology and outdated legal structures.
India lags behind global regulators like the U.S., which recently passed the Genius Act to regulate stablecoins with clear reserve and oversight requirements.
Regulatory bodies are reactive, reacting after widespread adoption, rather than proactively shaping a policy framework to address crypto’s integration into everyday life.
Summary:
India’s Enforcement Directorate is intensifying scrutiny of leading crypto exchanges like CoinDCX and Delta, alleging violations of foreign exchange laws. These investigations center on cross-border crypto transactions that require fund transfers, which fall under FEMA regulations. cash.
Crypto futures further complicate matters with high leverage and reliance on offshore liquidity, creating compliance and tax issues. S. has introduced the Genius Act to regulate stablecoins, India remains reactive, with regulators only now noticing widespread adoption.
The absence of clear laws means crypto transactions operate in a legal gray zone, allowing tax evasion and bypassing traditional financial systems. Authorities are struggling to keep pace with fast-evolving crypto technologies, such as crypto cards and peer-to-peer payments, which mirror familiar digital payment experiences like UPI. This growing use underscores a critical gap: India’s regulatory bodies are not only behind the curve but also in denial of crypto’s systemic integration.
A proactive, comprehensive policy is urgently needed to balance innovation with financial stability, tax compliance, and anti-money laundering safeguards.
FAQs
The Enforcement Directorate is investigating whether these leading crypto exchanges violate foreign exchange laws by facilitating cross-border crypto transactions, which are seen as potential violations of FEMA regulations.
No, cryptocurrency is not recognized as a currency by the government or the Reserve Bank of India. It is legally classified as a virtual digital asset, not a currency, and is subject to specific regulatory scrutiny.
Crypto futures involve high leverage, often up to 100 times, allow trading without buying or selling actual crypto, and are not subject to TDS, creating a distinct and riskier trading environment compared to spot trading.
Crypto is being used through platforms like Goat.cash, where users pay with crypto, and intermediaries convert it to rupees. This creates a seamless payment experience that mimics UPI, making crypto increasingly accessible to everyday users.
No, banks are generally not allowed to handle foreign exchange transfers for the purpose of buying cryptocurrencies due to legal and regulatory restrictions under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA).
India lacks a formal regulatory framework despite growing crypto usage. Authorities are behind the curve, and the government may be hesitant due to concerns over enforcement, data sharing, and the complexity of regulating a rapidly evolving technology.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.