'If You Can Keep It': The Ins And Outs Of Congressional Investigations
from 1A
42m 50s
Following the Democrats’ takeover of both chambers of Congress, a major push for investigations into corruption and accountability within the Trump administration has begun. Representative Sue Subramanium and others emphasize that the focus is on transparency, public trust, and addressing systemic issues like pay-for-play, corporate influence, and self-dealing—particularly in foreign policy and federal agencies. These investigations, which prioritize legislative outcomes over retribution, are seen as a constitutional duty to oversee executive power. The White House has warned of legal consequences, but Democrats assert these threats are meant to intimidate, not deter, and that investigations are grounded in public concern and legal authority. Congress has a range of tools—including subpoenas, contempt proceedings, and the appropriations process—to compel cooperation, while critics highlight the erosion of the inspector general system and the weaponization of agencies. Whistleblower protections and transparency laws like the Freedom of Information Act are being called for stronger enforcement. The broader goal is not only to expose misconduct but to reform institutional safeguards, ensuring future accountability and restoring public confidence in government.
(upbeat music)
In the lead up to the midterms,
multiple polls suggested corruption
was one of voters' top concerns.
Now Democrats will control both chambers of Congress,
and with that, the power to launch
with their promising will be a blitz of investigations.
- Congressman Robert Garcia, a Democrat from California,
is expected to chair the oversight committee in the House.
On election night, he told Trump administration
officials to quote "lawyer up."
The White House warned the investigations themselves
could be criminal, while Democrats say oversight
is their constitutional duty.
- I'm Jen White.
- And I'm Todd Zwillek.
- You're listening to the 1A podcast.
Today, as part of our weekly series,
if you can keep it, when we explore
the biggest politics stories of the moment,
and what they mean for the state of our democracy,
we look at how congressional investigations work,
what limits they face, and what coming fights
could look like.
That's all after this.
(upbeat music)
- Let's start the conversation with Democratic Representative
and member of the House Committee on Oversight
and Reform, Sue has Subramanium.
Congressman, welcome to the program.
- Thanks for having me.
- So you're pushing for investigations
into the Trump administration.
What are the top investigative priorities for you?
- Yeah, well, people are asking us
what we should do, affordability or accountability,
and my answer is they're related.
And so there's a lot of corruption that's happening
in this administration.
That has had an impact on our governing
and the ability to deliver for the American people.
And so we're talking about, if our foreign policy is for sale,
then the impact being tariffs and the Iran war perhaps,
could end up raising costs on the American people,
can end up putting people in harm's way.
We're talking about the corporate corruption
that we're seeing, the pay for play.
A lot of that that's been rumored or it's been reported,
that has an impact on costs for the American people.
Maybe some industries are not regulated,
like they should be, so it's a safety issue.
So to me, the focus is gonna be on how the lack of accountability
and the corruption, the self-dealing,
the corporate favoritism has impacted the American people.
- Now, not all Democrats are necessarily on board
with a muscular investigation physique
from the new Democrats in control.
We've been hearing from some of you this week.
- I'm in Florida and a lifetime Democrat,
but right now I want the Democrats to focus on governing,
to find a way to govern, identify whatever significant issues
they can address with bipartisan support.
They also need to keep the current administration
in check as much as they possibly can.
Investigations into corruption and illegal behaviors
can be addressed eventually,
but the immediate actions should focus on helping American.
- And we got this from Stu in Michigan,
who says on the other hand, the corruption
and lawlessness of this administration
needs to be investigated and carried through
to prosecution by the new House and Senate,
alongside their goals of passing legislation
that improves everyday life for all Americans.
I think Congressman, you might agree with Stu,
but what do you say to people like this caller from Florida
who called in to say, don't waste time on tit for tat
and retribution, we want lower prices
and too muscular and investigation is just
investigative culture from Democrats
is just gonna slow things down and get partisan.
- I would tell her that our priority is the American people
and that it's our job to provide oversight,
but that oversight is a big part
of trying to deliver for the American people.
A lot of these agencies, they deliver critical services
and they deliver programs like Medicaid, Medicare,
social security, and for instance, those offices
need, there's a lack of oversight
over what's going on there,
whether it's the federal fireings that have impacted
workers in my district, federal workers and contractors
in Virginia, or whether it's the lack of accountability
with ICE and the impact that's had on immigrant communities.
All of that is related and so absolutely,
we need to prioritize delivering for the American people,
but in order to do that, oversight is a big part of that.
- You mentioned self-dealing, you also mentioned regulation
around certain industries.
President Trump has earned billions of dollars
in his first years back in office.
Mostly from his family's cryptocurrency businesses
and international real estate licensing fees,
do you plan to investigate the president
or any of his family members?
- We have to, so giving an example,
his son-in-law is going around negotiating deals
for his own companies and his family's companies
while at the same time negotiating our foreign policy
with countries and intertwining those negotiations.
There's so many examples with Trump
and other cabinet officials with them getting rich
off of our policy making.
And so we have to, it's our job.
And I talked to so many people,
including Republicans who tell me that they don't trust DC
anymore because the corruption is rampant.
And so we have to make sure,
one, I'm on the ethics committee too,
that members of Congress are bringing hell
to that same standard,
but two, that this administration doesn't continue
this corruption without any sort of oversight over it.
Otherwise, this will continue to happen
in multiple presidencies in the future.
- So when you say that Congress members
are held to that same standard,
what does that look like in terms of legislation?
- Well, so we already have a lot of rules
on what members of Congress can't and can't do
and their relationship, their families,
how their families can make money, for instance.
But I support making sure that we cannot trade individual stocks.
That's something that's missing.
It's going to be a high priority of ask leadership
that we could prioritize this.
And I think it will be in the new Congress
with a democratic majority.
But we look at the president's stock trading.
We look at members of his cabinet
and their stock trading directly or indirectly
through family.
That's a huge conflict of interest.
And you put on top of that the corruption,
put on top of the lack of accountability
for different agencies and the weaponization of agencies
against the political opponents.
There's just so much to tackle.
- There's so much to tackle.
As you say, one thing that a lot of people
who worry about ethics also worry about,
you mentioned pay for play.
People talk about the need to reattach a stigma
to open corruption or pay for play.
Here's a prime example.
Companies with business before the federal government
basically rushed to give tens of millions of dollars
to Donald Trump's ballroom when he threw open that door.
Google 25 million, Nvidia 25 million.
Not necessarily illegal, but ethically harmful
eroding of the public trust.
Did Democrats talk about that when you talk about
what your investigative schedule is going to look like?
Is it all legislative purpose or do you talk about
sort of reattaching a stigma to corporate America
for how they've played over these last several years?
- Yeah, our future chair, Robert Garcia,
put out a list of priorities for when it comes to oversight.
And the first thing was corruption.
And the second thing was corporate corruption
and corporate pay for play.
And so those are two top priorities.
And again, when our policy making is influenced
by these factors, then how do you pass good policies?
How do you make sure the American people can trust
what's coming out of DC?
And so that's a big part of why delivering
for the American people has to include this oversight
over what's going on and the accountability for it too.
- Well, the White House and the Department of Justice
have been warning that lawmakers who investigate them
could be in legal jeopardy.
Congressman Robert Garcia and Senator Richard Blumenthal
got letters to that effect.
You received a letter as well, what did it say?
- It said that we need to make sure
that our investigations have a legislative purpose.
I promise this administration, our investigations
have always had a legislative purpose
and we'll continue to.
We're not doing this to be gratuitous.
We're doing this for the American people.
We're doing this to make sure people can trust
this administration again.
- And so what is that legislative connection?
- So let's start with corruption.
Corruption has a clear legislative connection.
We're seeing this administration put out executive orders
about the best of people who are doing business
with their family and then their families
are being enriched because of it.
There's a clear legislative purpose there
to make sure that our executive branch
isn't being co-opted so that people can pocket money
off of the American taxpayer.
There's all the investigations that we put out
as priorities have legislative purposes.
And what the administration is trying to do
is intimidate us because that's what they were able to do
with Republicans when they were in charge
over these past few years.
They were able to intimidate individual members
and say that we're going to play in your primary.
We're going to make sure your political career comes to an end
if you do anything to investigate us.
But it's not going to work with Democrats.
We owe the president nothing.
We're not intimidated by him.
- Well, I want us to listen to White House counsel
Will Sharf speaking on Fox News on Sunday.
- Congressmen Garcia, other Democrat members of Congress
are intent on threatening and intimidating members
of this administration from the president
on down to the most junior staffer.
If that's the approach that they're going to take,
they're going to be met with a vigorous response
for my office and from the Department of Justice
every single time.
- Congressmen, how do you think Democrats
should handle the White House's preemptive resistance
to these investigations?
They're trying to intimidate Democrats.
- They don't want to be investigated bottom line.
They don't want to have a light shined on
the things that they've been doing.
And so we are going to do our jobs.
Our job is to make sure that there's oversight
and accountability of this administration.
If they have nothing to hide,
then they should just come to us, come before our Congress,
make sure that they hand over documents.
- But if they request subpoenas,
if they resist subpoenas,
if they refuse to turn over documents, what do you do?
- There is a whole list of things we can do.
It's criminal contempt, which would be referred
to the DOJ, which the president controls, right?
So there will be issues with that.
There's civil contempt, which would be referred to the court.
And then there's a third option we haven't used since 1935,
which is empowering the sergeant and arms
to actually go out there and try to get someone
if they don't respond to our subpoenas?
Well, that's--
Representative Sue Hass, supermodium from Virginia's 10th congressional district.
Congressman, thank you for speaking with us.
Thank you.
We'll have more on what tackling corruption could look like under a new Congress after the
break.
Let's get back into the conversation with some new guests.
Joining us in studio now is Don Sherman.
He's president and CEO of the nonpartisan, non-profit citizens for responsibility and
ethics in Washington.
Who has been focused on exposing pay-to-play corruption in the current administration.
Donald, welcome.
Thanks for having me.
Also with us, Mark Eppley.
He's an attorney and partner at Arnold and Porter, where he leads the firm's congressional
oversight and investigations practice.
Mark, welcome.
Thanks for including me in this conversation.
And Lauren Harper is with us.
She's the Daniel Ellsberg chair on government secrecy at the Freedom of the Press Foundation.
She's an advocate for secrecy reform and expanded whistleblower protections.
Lauren, welcome back.
Well, Donald, let's just start with some basis.
So what exactly are congressional investigations, and how are they different from a criminal
investigation?
So one of the fundamental powers of Congress is to do oversight.
And that stems from its legislative function.
And so the Constitution gives Congress these tools to conduct investigations of the executive
branch, not just to look at waste-fraud-abusing corruption in the executive branch, tools
like public hearings, tools like investigative letters, document requests, and interviews
and subpoenas.
But also, it gives Congress now, especially in 2026, has the ability to shine a light
on problems and alert the public of problems facing the government.
One of the mandates that this next Congress got from the American public is not just that
corruption in government is a problem, and affordability is a problem.
But that corruption is directly impacting the costs that Americans are facing.
Corruption is directly impacting their concerns about gas prices and things like that.
And so oversight investigations are a tool to explore waste-fraud and abuse, to learn about
any subject so that Congress can legislate.
The oversight committee, which its primary function is to conduct oversight, can investigate
any matter at any time, really to give Congress not just the tools that it needs, but the
information that it needs, so that the entire body can make policy choices.
And so the investigative function is not about retribution, it's about gaining information
so that members of Congress can make laws and can make reforms when there are things
going wrong.
All right.
So you have served on the Democratic side of investigative committees in the past, Mark
Epley.
You have served on the Republican side of investigative functions for Paul Ryan, for
Republican-led investigative committees in the past.
Mark, what's your take, given how we just heard the description of how investigations
function under Congress's constitutional authorities?
I assume you agree with what you heard.
What's your take on the White House's warnings now that investigations might cross the line
into blatant criminality if they come from members of Congress?
Well, first, I thought Donald's description of the lawmaking power, the inherent power
to examine things as part of the legislative power was spot on.
And I think just to add to that, really, Congress, one is given this authority.
The Supreme Court teaching has been that the power to make laws include the power to investigate
and examine things, both what is law and what could be law.
But also, I want to sort of put a fine point on that the power really comes from speaking
to matters of public concern.
That when Congress speaks to matters of public concern, their power is really at their zenith.
When it's an obscure, petty or small issue, public is less interested in it.
They're less invested in it.
So for context, when we were examining the Tea Party targeting investigation, it's
the one for which we perceive President Obama was very, he didn't like the idea that the
IRS might be targeting people on the basis of their views and names and so on.
And so we got significant compliance from the administration, at least in the first instance,
because we were speaking to a matter of public concern.
I wanted to sort of highlight that up front, because we'll talk about the ways in which
Congress might enforce its powers.
But that's the chief authority.
So it matters of public concern, can a member of Congress be criminally liable for pursuing
those matters of public concern, because that's the line, the White House, seems to be trying
to draw here.
So the Supreme Court teaching is that if Congress is examining matters within its lawmaking
jurisdiction or things that could be within their lawmaking jurisdiction, that's wholly
appropriate.
So the answer is no.
You know, the court has been pretty clear that you really even can't get behind the motives
of the lawmakers in examining those things.
Maybe this isn't the extremist where it's something, where it's undertaken just for
the purpose of bothering someone or threatening someone, maybe, but at least the core of the
power is as I described it.
Lauren, we mentioned already that the White House is, as we've said, threatening criminal
probes against Democrats planning investigations of administration officials.
So that doesn't bode well for the White House's compliance with these investigations.
House Democrats demand that the Interior Department retain documents related to the president's
construction projects around DC.
So things like the ballroom and the arch, after whistleblowers warned that the Department
was destroying documents.
And the Interior Department says the whistleblower claims are 100 percent false.
But how far can these investigations get if the White House and federal agencies refuse
to cooperate, refuse to submit documents to Congress?
That is such a good question, because as you point out, as we've already talked about,
we're getting the impression, the indication, this administration is going to be very aggressive
at any attempts at oversight.
And the answer is Congress is going to hit a wall at some point, and the reason for that
is multifaceted, you know, historically oversight really is an accommodation.
It's a negotiation between Congress and the executive branch, and it also requires
the Justice Department to play ball.
So for example, if we see, you know, a contempt of Congress, that has to be referred to
the Justice Department.
If they don't pick that up, then we've got a real problem.
But the big picture is, you know, the success of any of these investigations really depends
on the records and the quality of records.
The lawmakers are able to unearth from these agencies, and that requires federal agencies
and the White House, first and foremost, are creating the records they're supposed to
create in the first place, in the second instance that they're preserving them, and the independence
of the system that's charged with releasing them.
So lawmakers are going to be stymied if agencies, for example, are destroying records as
the whistleblower complaints have alleged at the Department of the Interior, if the conversations
that we want access into are being conducted over a signal.
Another problem we might see is agencies weaponizing the classification system.
You might see agencies classifying records that might not warrant classification to keep
them out of the hands of Congress.
So we have big issues on our plate that require systemic fixes.
Donald, speak on potential administration in trans agents refusal to comply with subpoenas,
hiding things behind classification.
The whole idea, I think it's fair to say, of telling lawmakers they might be veering into
blatant criminality is not to charge them with crimes, but to convince them to be scared
of their own shadow and back off.
So they seem to be sending a pretty clear message about what their posture is going to be going
forward.
Well, the Trump administration has sent a pretty clear message from day one.
As you may recall early in the president's tenure of the second term, he fired the inspectors
general, 18 of them in one day.
That was the first sign that this administration is openly hostile to any kind of oversight,
and then the weaponized prosecutions of people like just James, like James Comey, who dame
to enforce the law against the administration.
I think Congress does have a lot of tools in its toolkit to compel compliance.
I think the example of interiors actually illustrative, because one of the things that the
administration will try and do is create this posture of, well, we're not going to give
you anything, but when you have a whistleblower come forward, all of a sudden the legitimacy
argument shifts, right, and it's, well, this person has come forward with damaging information.
What is the administration trying to hide?
And so immediately, there's a shift in posture.
But also the Congress has lots of tools at its disposal.
In addition to the content powers that Mark mentioned, they have the nominations power in
the Senate, right?
They can use that power in order to leverage documents out of the administration.
Chuck Grassley do this many, many times from his perch.
They have the appropriations process, where they can make sure that taxpayer dollars are
in some cases withheld for administration priorities if they don't get, if they don't
get documents.
This is one of the things that has not been covered a lot in the news.
But this week, Rand Paul is trying to push through a potential nominee, none has been
name yet.
for the government accountability office,
which oversees appropriations law
and is Congress's chief oversight body.
People should call his office
and make sure that they know
that he is breaking the law by speeding up this process,
not going through an independent commission,
but GAO and the appropriations law
is one of the other tools that Congress has
to get documents and to launch investigations
and get information not just to congressmen
to the American public.
And so I think just as the administration
has been openly recalcitrant,
we are seeing members of Congress,
there is a need for members of Congress
to be more dynamic and more aggressive
with the tools that they're disposal.
- Well, Lorna, I saw you nodding as Donald was speaking there,
but he mentioned whistleblowers,
and you think that the whistleblower protections
we currently have in place are not strong enough.
What has changed in recent years,
what do you think needs to be improved to create an environment
in which people who feel they are,
there's wrong doing happening within our government,
can be protected if they come forward?
- Absolutely.
No, Donald mentioned one of the big issues,
which is the integrity of the inspector's general system.
Now this was established after the abuses of Watergate,
the Inspector Generals Act.
And one of the things we saw at the beginning
of this administration was the removal of 20 to 21
inspectors general.
Now these are supposed to be independent officials
who are charged with investigating waste fraud
and abuse at agencies, but we saw a lot of them fired
and their replacements are starting to show worrying signs
about what oversight is going to look like at agencies.
For example, last week there was a bipartisan letter submitted
by Congress to the newly appointed inspector general
at the Pentagon requesting that he investigate
the slowdown of Starlink in Ukraine.
Now this is a satellite service company
that the slowdown, it's owned by SpaceX,
the slowdown of which enabled Russian attacks on Ukraine.
Now the Pentagon, newly installed Pentagon IG refused
to comply with that request, he rebuffed it.
We've also seen inspectors acting inspectors generals
refused to release audits or investigations
that are fear of reprisal.
We've also seen inspectors general being stoned
by their own agencies.
We've seen this at the Department of Education.
So that system is really in trouble.
And that puts Congress's ability to track
how taxpayers' money is being spent in jeopardy.
Now whistleblowers are the main reason,
you know, they can go to their inspector general,
they can go to the press.
They are the main reason that the public knows
about so much of the administrations with misconduct.
You know, we go back to allegation or whistleblower leaks
at the beginning of last year,
indicating that the Trump administration
had perhaps misconstruing its reasons
for invoking the Alien Enemies Act
to deport Venezuelans to El Salvador.
We come all the way today to see that importance
with the allegations about the Department of Interior.
You know, whistleblowers are always essential,
but they are especially important right now
in an era where the executive branch is so hostile
to trends of transparency.
And I think as we look forward to bolstering that system,
you know, we need to expand whistleblower protections
to contractors, increase protections for whistleblowers
and intelligence community.
And I would also encourage Congress
to pass representative Rashida Talib's Daniel Ellsberg
whistleblower protection act,
because this really gets at, you know,
differentiating between leaks
that are in the public interest, you know,
for example, some of the things that we've talked about
versus leaks that are intended to cause harm.
- We're talking to Lauren Harper
from the Freedom of the Press Foundation
and two former congressional staffers,
Donald Sherman from the nonprofit citizens
for responsibility and ethics in Washington
and Mark Eppley and attorney and partner
at Arnold and Porter, where he co-leads
the firm's congressional oversight
and investigations practice.
- And we got this question from Jim in Nebraska,
who says, "How much influence do the ranking minority
members of both houses of Congress have in authorizing
subpoenas?"
Now, Mark, you've been on the majority side
of lots of investigations.
I assume you've been on the minority side
of more than one, two.
Who can launch an investigation?
How are those probes coordinated
between committees in the House and Senate?
And then down to Jim's question,
where does the rubber meet the road in terms of
who gets hauled in front of the committee?
Who has the power?
And can the minority affect that?
- Very good, good question, Jim.
- So, Congress is a forum like no other.
It's not a civil proceeding, it's not a criminal proceeding.
You might call it "Planet Congress."
It's all a thing of its own.
Because I mentioned that upfront
because the way in which a civil complaint starts,
you get served with something
or maybe you get served with a criminal investigative demand
or something like this, that doesn't happen in Congress.
It can happen sort of as indirectly as a staff inquiry
or it could lead in the very first instance
from a social media announcement
that I have subpoended someone to come and testify
and you may get the corresponding letter
on or about the same time.
It can be anything in between.
So there's really no set way
in which an investigation gets underway.
The way in which the compulsory process, though, is expressed.
Again, we talked earlier about Supreme Court teaching
that the power to investigate is inherent
in the power to make laws.
And a part of that is the power to compel documents
and testimony in order to do that work.
So that authority is vested in Congress
and in the House, that authority is delegated to the committees.
And each committee has its own rules,
but generally speaking in the House,
the chair on his or her own initiative can issue a subpoena.
Sometimes there's a requirement
that you give notice to the minority,
but that power is vested with the chair.
- Does this mean when you boil it down,
if you have the votes, you have the power?
- Well, if you're the majority of the House,
you have the power in the first instance.
Once the Congress organizes and the committee's organized,
that chair has that.
- So a ranking member who wants to be part of an investigation
or help steer it.
Does that person have any power to issue subpoenas?
- Well, in the Senate, the rules are a bit different.
It's a deliberative body.
And so you might expect that's how they run their committees.
The House, excuse me,
the Homeland Security and Government Accountability Committee,
the Hizgak, it has the power,
the chair to initiate subpoenas on his or her own initiative,
same with the permanent select committee on investigations.
That committee can, or subcommittee can issue subpoenas
on their initiative.
Other committees have some mixture of the requirement
to give notice to the minority,
but chiefly, the other committees are going to need
to convene a vote if the minority objects.
- Okay, so if you're in the minority,
especially on a House committee,
you don't only get to drive the bus to you.
- Not when it concerns the issuing of subpoenas.
- Well, we have to take another quick break,
but we'll have more from our guests
and from you in a moment.
- So let's talk about executive privilege,
because this is one of the key ways
that the executive, the White House can
probably will use to withhold documents and testimony
from Congress.
Donald typically, it's used to protect
the president's communications with advisors,
the Justice Department is trying to claim.
Now, a new expansive definition of executive privilege
that it covers communications with people outside
of the government too, even if they've communicated
with White House staff.
How far do you think the White House can stretch
the concept of executive privilege over the next two years
and how effective a shield can it be for them?
- I think this administration has already tried to do that.
The Office of the council, for example,
tried to invalidate the Presidential Records Act.
And so I think that we're litigating that
with our partners at the Free Press Foundation.
But this administration has already tried that.
They've lost in court.
And I think they will ultimately fail in their effort
to expand executive privilege to guy on the corner
that the president happens to talk to.
Not everyone is a presidential advisor.
I mean, we know this just by the fact
that people like Jared Kushner have not even complied
with the appointments clause,
having gone through the Senate confirmation process,
haven't filed a public financial disclosure statement,
and apparently the Trump administration thinks
that anybody and everybody that the White House
teams and advisor should be afforded executive privilege.
All of this arguing that you and others are doing in court
and will continue to do can keep the documents
and the people away from Capitol Hill
while you're arguing about it, right?
- That's certainly true.
And I think we've seen this time and time again,
the administration has gone to court
and litigated up and down to the US Supreme Court,
we're going to Supreme Court to get documents
from Doge this next year.
And so it is a delay tactic.
Again, this is why I think Congress needs to use more tools
than it has traditionally used,
like the appointments process,
like the nominations process, like inherent contempt
in order to ratchet up the pressure
so that the administration can't just hold the ball
and keep documents away.
- So Mark, you're a private lawyer now,
trading of course on your experience
and investigations, your long experience on Capitol Hill.
Let's just pretend for a moment you have a corporate client,
I'll call them Weasel.
They're a huge internet company
and they gave $20 million for the president's ballroom
and Congress wants to talk to them about it.
Would you advise Weasel to maybe get under this new blanket
of executive privilege and kind of litigate it out
and let the courts take care of it
before they have to testify?
- Well, how about act?
me corp. You see my point, though? Sure. So our big company is going to be advised to take
advantage of the White House's new definition of executive privilege to avoid accountability.
So you're right to point out third parties because the executive, under current laws,
it's understood the power, the executive to hold with hold certain things to protect
presidential decision making is already a robust authority. One of the tools that Congress uses
is to go to proxies for the administration. Third parties that are softer targets, they cannot
resist a subpoena, the same way the administration can. So not limited to this sort of question of
executive authority, but we can fully expect that Congress will go to third parties, both to examine
things like donations to the ballroom for sure, but also any number of policy decisions made by
the administration. We've focused chiefly on sort of corruption and accountability, which will
certainly be, that is a top matter of public concern, but congressional oversight has been used
historically to commend good policy, to commend bad policy, or to argue against bad policy.
So examining third parties will all be of a piece with congressional investigators.
But I think the question that Todd is getting at is, is there a legal argument that those third
parties would be covered under executive privilege? One that you would be comfortable with
as a lawyer, let's say, hey, look, the White House has said this is executive privilege, take
it while you can. Right. It really, it's too much of hypothetical for a meeting engaged with.
But you see the point of the reason I'm entertaining this hypothetical is about where this goes.
When weasel gets a subpoena, because the members of Congress want to know, and they know that this is
what they thought was a softer target, the White House is saying, no, no, no, climb under our blanket.
Right. We'll protect you. Well, I think that, but the White House has to offer it, right? The
power is the president's power. So third party can assert its executive privilege. The power
lives with the executive. So the real question is, are the stakes high enough for the president
to assert this power? And then it makes, it makes it seem like what people think it will be a
cover-up. And so I don't know that that puts a company in a good position to now have, you know,
the White House basically endorsing that they're engaged in a cover-up with the administration.
Well, I want to get to this message we got from Patrick who says, one thing has become
abundantly clear in the Trump era. The custom, quote-unquote norms and personal ethics are not adequate
to restrain misbehavior of all sorts and elected officials. To a much greater degree than was
thought necessary before such control must be codified into laws and have real teeth. And Lauren,
this is something we've talked about before that there have been, there are laws and then there are
norms. There are laws and then there is expected behavior. And is this an opportunity for Congress
to codify the way administrations, the way Congress can behave so that it's not just an understanding
that this is the way we do things? It's such a good question. It absolutely ought to be. And there's
historical precedent that Congress can do this after periods of excessive executive abuse and overreach.
So after Nixon resigned and Watergate, Congress, bipartisan initiative, really overhauled our
transparency and infrastructure. They passed the president a record's act. They put teeth into
the Freedom of Information Act. They laid the groundwork for the inspector's general framework.
They really did this to help prevent abuse from really starting to fester again. And there's
absolutely an opportunity to do that here because, you know, there are laws and there are norms,
but even with the laws that we have, you know, there's always been compliance issues,
particularly with record keeping or, you know, compliance with the Freedom of Information Act.
But I think for the most part, when we've seen non-compliance with these statutes that are on the
books, it's kind of this mix of bid nine bureaucratic, bureaucratic neglect or inertia mixed with a few
attempts to really evade transparency. But now we're really seeing that on a more systemic level
I'd argue. And I think this is exacerbated by a couple flaws that exist that could be short
up in our record keeping laws. These are, you know, the Federal Records Act, which governs
records from agencies as well as the Presidential Records Act, which obviously covers records of
the President, you know, the way that these laws currently work and their enforcement is they
rely on agency heads, the Attorney General, the Archivist of the United States, all wanting to
do their job and to follow up when records aren't preserved or destroyed. And the indication that we've
got from this administration over the last two years is perhaps there is not that inclination
within the executive branch to really police itself. Congress could shore up these deficiencies
by adding private rights of action to both of those laws that would allow journalists watch
darker organizations like crew and mine to sue when we know that these things are being exacerbated.
So we know the problem is structural. They've been that way, but they're being blown open by
an administration that learned about these loopholsterings. The first term and is really exploiting
them systematically in its second term. Congress has the ability to really close those now and they
should work your thoughts. So I don't know that I quarrel with some of the legislative remedies
that Lauren is suggesting, but I do think when we reflect on our system of government very limited
constitution, it just gives authorities to the respective article branches and not a lot more,
our democracy really depends on self-control in a lot of ways. It depends on norms. And so one of
the things that we talked about earlier is Congress speaking to matters of public concern. It was
very clear from exit polls that voters were very concerned about corruption. This is a new thing.
It's extraordinary, actually. I just came back from a developing country this last week,
and I would just remind it about how blessed we are to live in America that generally speaking,
corruption, political corruption is not a major feature of our republic. It's not an everyday
feature. And I think the ways in which if the democratic majority are effective in speaking to
matters of public concern, then I think voters next in 2028 and successive elections will insist
upon public integrity from the people that they elect. Well, I do want to read this message. We
got from Stephen who says the way I see it, if society decides something is wrong and we have laws
or constitutional provisions to reflect that decision, but we do nothing when the wrong behavior
occurs, then there was no point in declaring it wrong to begin with. Everyone sees there are no
consequences. The offenders repeat and more people offend in the future, which is a little counter
to what you're saying there, Mark, which is if there is no accountability and if we say no, the
norms are enough and we're going to trust people to do the right thing and they don't, then we're
creating a cycle where that behavior is repeated. Yeah, I don't know that norms are necessarily enough,
but it's a core component of ordered liberty that along with good laws that are enforced is self-control
and norms that that we speak to and expect that our elected officials will emulate.
So let's talk about Doge because that's the that's the former Department of Government
Efficiency that was tasked with making broad cuts to federal spending. We've covered it extensively
on this show. Employees at Doge improperly accessed. We know this now and accessed and shared
millions of American sensitive personal data uploaded them to an unsecured cloud server. The
Social Security Administration also says that two Doge employees secretly talk to a political
advocacy group to match social security data with state voter rolls to find, quote, evidence of
voter fraud and a lot more. We don't know whether any data actually went to the group, but Donald,
when you when you hear about a story like Doge and the investigative path that seems to be laid
out here, what can Congress do to investigate breaches like this? So it's important to remind
people that Doge was led by Elon Musk who the president chose his largest campaign benefactor
to run this far sweeping government apparatus. I think the first thing that Congress can do is
ask for documents. As we did, we asked for documents. We sent a freedom of information act
request back in March of last year. We are still fighting with Doge and litigating up to the
Supreme Court next year to get documents information. I think again, this is this is important
about Congress now having oversight authority or exercising oversight authority that it didn't
before. Now we can have some of these whistleblowers in public in congressional hearings.
That turns up the volume, turns up the pressure for the administration to provide documents.
These folks may have documents themselves, but it gives the public more visibility into what Doge
was doing, which I think makes it easier for then us to get documents and information from Doge.
Well, I want to go to another clip here. Here's President Trump in an interview with Ross
Douthhead on CBS 60 Minutes on November 8th. First, do you expect to issue a lot of pardons when you leave office?
Yes, I do. Do you expect to pardon yourself? I don't, but I certainly. Do you think you have the power to pardon yourself?
I do, but more importantly, I don't want to have good people that are serving this country
and doing the great job. Spending the rest of their life, like I had to do for four years,
defending myself by radical left lunatics, by people that were very nasty and mean.
I intend to issue tremendous numbers of pardons.
tremendous numbers of parlance, but how can parlance make people more susceptible to oversight?
If you face no legal jeopardy for testifying, what happens then?
Well, I think that, Jen, if we're sort of asking whether parlance may invite congressional
investigations about how it is that whether a parlance was meritorious or not, I think
that that will certainly happen.
Talk about the Fifth Amendment, though.
What happens to me?
If I've been pardoned, can I go in front of Congress and say, "I'm taking the Fifth,
I don't want to talk about that."
Self-incrimination, I'm worried about legal jeopardy.
So I don't know that these are well settled questions, and it could be that you're pardoned
for things that in the past, and now you're sitting before Congress and you're being
compelled to testify.
I think that defying Congress in that context may be a separate crime for which you could
interpose your Fifth Amendment rights to--
So we're heading to the end of the program, but I just briefly went here for me to view,
and just a quick sentence, how do you like to see Congress exercise the power it already
has?
We've talked about, perhaps, other laws that are needed, Lauren, really briefly?
Yeah, I'd encourage Congress to shore up our transparency infrastructure, the Federal
Records Act, the Presidential Records Act, and the Freedom of Information Act.
Mark?
I would encourage them to speak to matters of public concern, corruptions of matter of
public concern, put sunshine on it, change behavior.
Donald.
Congress should use all the tools at its disposal to get information from the administration,
but it should also pass laws and rules to hold itself accountable as well.
Well, that's Donald Sherman, he's president and CEO of the nonpartisan nonprofit citizens
for responsibility and ethics in Washington.
Mark Eppley was also with us.
He's an attorney and partner at Arnold & Porter, where he leads the firm's congressional
oversight and investigations practice.
And Lauren Harper, the Daniel Ellsberg chair on government secrecy at the Freedom of the
Press Foundation.
Thanks to you all.
This has all been part of our ongoing series.
If you can keep it where we talk about the biggest political stories of the moment, what
they mean to our democracy, what do you want us to tackle next?
And A, at wamu.org, is our email.
Today's producer, Wes Claire Muff, said, "And this program comes to you from WAMU, part
of American University in Washington Distributed by NPR.
I'm Jen White."
And I'm Todd Zwillick.
Thanks for listening, and we'll talk again tomorrow.
This is OneA.
(upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Democrats in control of Congress are launching investigations into alleged corruption and pay-for-play within the Trump administration, focusing on foreign policy, corporate influence, and lack of accountability.
Key priorities include examining family wealth accumulation, executive stock trading, and the weaponization of federal agencies, with a particular emphasis on self-dealing and corporate favoritism.
Investigations are framed as having a legislative purpose to restore public trust and ensure transparency, not as retribution, and are seen as a constitutional duty of oversight.
The White House has issued warnings that such investigations could lead to legal jeopardy, but Democrats argue these threats are intended to intimidate and not to justify unlawful actions.
Congress has tools—including subpoenas, civil and criminal contempt, and the appropriations process—to compel cooperation, and is also pushing to strengthen whistleblower protections and record-keeping laws.
The integrity of the inspector general system has been undermined, with multiple firings and refusals to comply, raising concerns about systemic oversight failures.
Investigations may target third parties, such as corporations that donated to the president’s events, to uncover broader patterns of influence and corruption.
Historical precedent shows Congress can enact structural reforms after periods of executive overreach, and there is a growing call to codify accountability into law to prevent future abuses.
Summary:
Following the Democrats’ takeover of both chambers of Congress, a major push for investigations into corruption and accountability within the Trump administration has begun. Representative Sue Subramanium and others emphasize that the focus is on transparency, public trust, and addressing systemic issues like pay-for-play, corporate influence, and self-dealing—particularly in foreign policy and federal agencies. These investigations, which prioritize legislative outcomes over retribution, are seen as a constitutional duty to oversee executive power.
The White House has warned of legal consequences, but Democrats assert these threats are meant to intimidate, not deter, and that investigations are grounded in public concern and legal authority. Congress has a range of tools—including subpoenas, contempt proceedings, and the appropriations process—to compel cooperation, while critics highlight the erosion of the inspector general system and the weaponization of agencies. Whistleblower protections and transparency laws like the Freedom of Information Act are being called for stronger enforcement.
The broader goal is not only to expose misconduct but to reform institutional safeguards, ensuring future accountability and restoring public confidence in government.
FAQs
The top priorities include corruption, corporate pay-for-play, and lack of accountability in agencies like ICE and the Department of Interior. These issues are seen as impacting public trust and government services.
Congressional investigations are primarily aimed at legislative oversight, not criminal prosecution. However, if investigations uncover illegal activity, they may lead to criminal charges, though the White House has warned of legal jeopardy.
Congress has tools like civil contempt, criminal contempt, and the power to use the sergeant at arms to enforce subpoenas. Refusal can lead to legal action, especially if agencies destroy records or withhold information.
Congress uses investigations, subpoenas, public hearings, and oversight committees to uncover waste, fraud, and corruption. It also pushes for stronger laws like the Freedom of Information Act and better record-keeping standards.
Yes, investigations must have a legislative purpose and focus on matters of public concern. The Supreme Court has affirmed that Congress has the power to investigate for lawmaking, not just retribution.
Whistleblowers provide critical information about misconduct, such as improper use of funds or policy decisions. Their reports are essential for Congress to launch investigations, especially when agencies resist transparency.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.