Dr. Andrew Huberman’s new book, *Protocols*, presents a comprehensive but deeply questionable guide to optimizing health through highly specific routines, such as drinking 18–24 ounces of water before coffee, cold plunges, and using licorice root to raise cortisol. While the book is well-written and widely promoted, its claims are scientifically unsound. Multiple protocols are based on small, non-generalizable studies or outright contradicted by existing research. For instance, the claim that training each muscle group once per week with four to eight sets works for everyone is contradicted by studies showing higher volumes (12–20 sets) yield better strength and hypertrophy. Cold water exposure is promoted despite a lack of evidence for improved mood or recovery, and its effects on dopamine are speculative and not linked to real-world health outcomes. Similarly, licorice root use is linked to risks like high blood pressure and potassium loss, making it unsafe for many people. The book also contains numerous conflicts of interest, including advisory roles with sleep and hydration brands. Most critically, Huberman lacks clinical experience in the areas he recommends—such as exercise or sleep medicine—making his sweeping assertions about efficacy medically dubious. The overall message is that while the ideas are appealing, they are not supported by robust evidence, and many recommendations ignore fundamental biological principles like homeostasis and individual variability. The book appears more like a well-sourced sales pitch than a reliable health guide.
Would you believe me if I told you that there's a brand new book from one of the biggest
podcasters in the world that wants you to drink 18 to 24 ounces of water before you're
allowed to have your coffee, and then eat some grapefruit on purpose so your cortisol
goes up?
Well, there is, and it's called Protocols by Dr. Andrew Huberman.
It also wants you sitting in cold water until you fit somewhere between two and ten walls,
where a wall is the moment that you want to get out and you stay in anyway.
And if you've got work to do, it also gives you a dosing range for nicotine pouches.
For the lifting program, it says that you should train the muscle directly once per week for
four to eight sets for optimal results.
With a quote, "I've seen it work for everyone I've suggested it to."
I've been coaching for a long time, and I don't think I could say that with a straight
face for anything.
So I read the whole thing, and then I went and pulled the studies that the book cited because
the book says each protocol can work the first time and every time.
That's a direct quote.
And a claim like that ought to have something solid underneath it.
A lot of the time in this book, it doesn't, and more than once, the paper that's being
cited actually says the opposite.
I'm Dr. Jordan Feigenbaum, and this is the Barbell Medicine Podcast.
And help me get through 540 pages of protocols, having read exactly none of them, which was
a deliberate choice on my part.
It's the second most handsome Dr. North America, Dr. Austin Baraki, Austin, before I tell
you anything, what do you know about this book, and what do you expect is in it?
Well, having been in this space for long enough, there's almost no way to avoid, you know,
being Huberman's ideas, shared around, recommended, people in the biohacking, optimization space,
really, you know, nerding out on these things, which is not itself necessarily a bad thing,
but you just want to know like, who is this for?
Does it actually work?
Is it worth your time or potentially your money based on what it is?
And my sense is that, you know, his recommendations historically have overhyped and outstripped much
of the evidence, even if many of them are not necessarily like, you know, very high-risk
or potentially harmful to a great extent.
That's my like, you know, sense coming into this, as you mentioned, this is being sprung
on me with no advanced notice or preparation, which I think you will take great joy in.
Yes.
I do enjoy that.
Also, I'm just, I'm saving you from having to read this.
You have other stuff that you want to do.
Lots of things, yes.
Not to say that I don't have other things to do, but like, you know, this is, I was more
curious about it, right?
Because it's, you know, it just outpublished September, or it just came out September 2026.
It's called protocols, an operating manual for the human body, depending on what format
you get it in, you know, different lengths, but it's like 540 pages, seven chapters, everything
from sleep to personal growth.
A number of disclosures in the book, he's a scientific advisor for Athletic Greens 1, 8
sleep, function health, plus a number of other podcasts, sponsors, I don't know if you've
been keeping up with Scott Carney's sort of audit of this on his substack and YouTube channel,
but that was kind of the inspiration for this.
In addition to a podcast, we both listened to, just called, if books could kill.
The one thing I couldn't do to you is make you come up with a one-liner on the spot, you
know, which I don't know that they entirely do either, but they do kind of happy talk
it up front and riff a little bit.
But yeah, Peter's got the wit, for sure.
100%.
So, here's my question to start off before we get into some of these protocols.
That's what we'll do.
We'll get into some protocols.
We'll play some games along the way, but we just published a signal, our book on Test
Astronomy.
We wrote this together from a lot of information that you had put together for a Test
Astronomy course, which subsequently came from stuff that literally we've been talking
about for, you know, the better part of a decade, right?
That was challenging, like if we were authors, and that's all we did, like maybe it would
have been less onerous, but that was pretty challenging, and you know the process.
But when you see a book, this size come out with what we can only assume is this podcast
host schedule.
What's your guess about how it got made, and who do you think it's for?
Yeah, I mean, you kind of alluded to it here with the sheer number of sponsorships and
relationships and things like that, that he is involved with, slash entangled with in
varying ways.
And so it makes it very apparent why the idea of coming out with a book like this is an
attractive opportunity.
It's likely to be quite lucrative, and why he probably for many years now, if I had to
guess, has had, you know, publishers hounding after him to see who was going to be able to
land his book deal.
And they were probably, you know, offering counter offering, jockeying, potentially offering,
you know, additional assistance and ghost writing support, and basically making it so
that hey, we can basically write this book for you, slap your name on it, market it, give
us the sign off, and we're going to make a lot of money off of it, which is, you know,
fortunately, and unfortunately, not the way that we went about writing our book, but one
that I could easily see being the case for him.
You know, you mentioned that this was a, this was a slog of a book to get through, and
I was not able to read this one.
But in the past, you know, there was a adjacent figure in the space, Dr. Atia, who is also
very popular, and I actually did end up reading his, his book at the time, mainly because
I knew that it was going to be a quite popular.
It also touched on many topics that we touch on frequently, ranging from cardiovascular
disease, neurodegenerative disease, cancer, exercise, nutrition, things like that.
And I was probably going to have patients, if not family members, asking me about this
stuff.
And so in a way, this is likely to be a similar sort of thing.
But just the sheer business opportunity of this book makes it so that I have a bit more
suspicion and skepticism about, you know, the extent to which he carefully and meticulously
wrote and scrutinized each word that ended up in the final text here.
Yeah.
I'm inclined to agree.
And then, you know, the other thing is like, who's this for, right?
I think there's some general, just broadly speaking, discontent with how people view their
lives are going, right?
So if you ask people, like, are you happy, like, that's one thing, but, you know, are
you healthy?
What do you want?
People generally speaking to want more.
I think, you know, it's very rare that you find, you ask somebody, hey, how are things
going?
And they're like, everything's actually totally fine.
And I want nothing more, perfectly content, you know?
So it's understandable, almost like this, this human desire for better.
You want better optimization.
And I think there's a real appeal there, where it's like, look, if you follow these protocols,
you're going to level up.
So all of that is understandable.
And I want to make one other thing clear.
Neither of us have met Dr. Hubertman, like, we don't, none of this is a personal attack
on him.
He's probably like a nice guy, I guess, you know, maybe we'd have a beer, a meal together
to be fine.
Well, we're just talking about what the claims are made in the book, right?
And so on the other hand, if it is, if it was mostly ghost written, maybe you got some
plausible deniability, like, I look, I didn't, you know, mean it that way or whatever.
But none of this is like, oh, we're slamming Hubertman.
It's mostly just like, what are the claims?
Do they stack up?
And, you know, maybe there would be some fun along the way.
So speaking of fun along the way, we're going to play three games.
I want to explain each one of them the first time it comes up.
And the first one is before every claim, you're going to predict what the book tells you
to do or what the book says about a particular thing.
So let's start with the first protocol and the one where we're the most qualified to be
pedantic, which is on lifting weights.
So the book makes a claim about how often to train each muscle and how to go about doing
it.
So often what's your prediction?
How many days a week does the book tell you to directly train each muscle and how close
should you be to failure?
I would guess, somewhere in the range of two to three times per week and not taken to
failure so that one can maintain some semblance of, you know, quote, unquote, proper or perfect
technique or something like that as it relates to some theories on injury risk.
That's going to be my guess.
So he actually says, and I quote, I suggest resistance training for each major muscle
group directly only once per week.
This is not by accident by scheduling this way along with specific types of cardiovascular
training sessions on particular days.
You actually end up training each muscle group twice per week once directly and once indirectly
on chest and back day, your shoulders and arms get some indirect training, for example.
So he also says you only need four to eight sets, which are both necessary and sufficient
to trigger near maximal strength and or hypertrophy adaptations.
He also says, and I quote, I've seen it work for everyone.
I've suggested it to and later he says, I've never seen it not work.
And then he reprints Mike Menser's rules, including most people who lift weights are morons,
which strong, strong claim, if true.
And then he says, Mike wasn't terribly off with this one.
He then says, you really should take all of your work sets to failure.
And on people who train each muscle twice a week with 12 to 20 sets in a session, I will
die on this hill.
He says, pretty bold, pretty bold.
Yeah, yeah.
There was a lot more there than I expected there to be.
A lot of not particularly awesome takes and some interesting claims that, yeah, a little
bit unexpected coming from him.
I think that like I kind of understand how he got there with like, okay, you're going
to train the muscle once directly, like in the gym.
But then the indirectly thing via cardio, I'm like, did nobody edit this out?
We're like, hey, look.
actually doing conditioning doesn't really train the muscles in the same way, the two different
things because they're limited by different energy systems, different signaling systems, whatever.
So like, you can't really say, "Look, if you just run or do sprints one day, that's great for
hypertrophy and strength." Like, nobody picked up on that?
Yeah, I think the other thing that caught my attention is the, well, I think in some ways,
familiar to us claims of, "It works every time, and I've never seen it not work."
We've heard those kind of things before, although in the past, when we heard them,
at least it was from people who were coaches. Now, these were coaches who, you know,
had their own, in our opinion, pretty myopic view of things and sense of confirmation bias and
things like that. In his case, he is neither a clinician who is advising patients on, you know,
strategies for strength training to improve, to treat sarcopenia, for example, to rehabilitate
from a musculoskeletal standpoint, nor is he a coach or a trainer actively working with
large and generally representative swaths of the human population. Because you and I both have
boatloads of experience when it comes to both with patients and with coach and clients,
for whom if we said, "Well, all you really need is four to eight sets a week. It works for 100%
of people. I've never seen anybody for whom it doesn't work to get maximal strength." Like,
you know, for those who have it in them to get to IPF worlds, four to eight sets a week is really
all you really need. And of course, he would say, "Well, no, no, obviously I'm not talking about,
well, then don't make the claim that is so sweeping and broad to say it works 100% of the time
for everyone. It never doesn't work." Or something like that. I mean, imagine when we talk about
exercise as an intervention that is do-that is docible, right, in terms of say volume or intensity
or something like that. I'm translating this in my mind to an analogous situation of, you know,
let's take a common one I'm dealing with these days. Of course, of a GLP1 agonist or it could be
an anti-hypertensive medication. Tell them a certain 20 milligrams. It works every time I've
ever used it. I've never seen it not work for anybody. And it's like, no, there's like a lot of
people who need, you know, additional interventions, higher dose interventions, who don't respond to
that intervention at all and need something else entirely. That's the case for most biological
kind of outcomes in this way is that there's variation in sensitivity and responsiveness. There's
dose responses, things like that that are all variable by individual. There's even variation
within the individual over time. So, yeah, that's like the most egregious thing to me is this
just like sweeping blanket. Like, here is my one singular simple exercise protocol.
Train the muscle once a week to failure four to eight sets per week and that works optimally,
maximally for everyone all the time and never has it worked. Like, come on.
Yeah. Again, just saying it is a little, I mean, we've gone through painstaking methods of saying,
well, look, this is what we, this is our best guess based on x, y, z here are the caveats,
here are the, you know, limits to what we can know and by the way, and everybody is different.
Even in the most charitable take where you view most of the variation in exercise response is a
lot of measurement error, more than actual like inter individual differences, right? Still,
to say it works 100% of the time every time, like, come on, man, the silliness. Now, it gets
weirder because he sites five papers for this four to eight sets being enough and yet all of them
say that actually higher volume works better. For example, one of them is from Vaz and Val in 2022,
recommended 12 to 20 sets per muscle per week for sort of optimal sort of high-perch fee response,
which seems like a weird place to die on a hill if you're recommending, you know, a fraction of that.
All right, so here's another game we're going to play. It's called guess the sample size. So you're
going to guess how big the study was that the book leans on for a particular claim. And if you get it
within half or double the real number, you'll get a point. All right, so he sites one study for
training a muscle once per week. It's the same total work done either all in one day or split
across four days. Austin, how big was the study? 15, and I'm not going to specify, I guess
where it's reasonable to assume that this is actually being done in humans since they're probably
not training right, training mice in this way. But yeah, I'm going to guess 15.
So you'll get a point. The answer is 22. Interestingly, squat strength in this particular study went
up 15 kilos on average in the group that split it up over four days, whereas it was only eight kilos
in the once per week group, which would again suggest like hey, maybe slightly recommendation the
other way. Yeah. Yeah, it's kind of the opposite, right? He does concede that stopping a rep or
two short of failure still works. The citation is the 2026 ACSM position stand, which came out
recently. So again, interested on when this was written versus edited and because that's relatively
recent, kind of curious there. But for the rest of the evidence, what we typically see is that
there's a dose dependent relationship with training load and subsequent training adaptations.
In this case, the training adaptations we're talking about are strength and muscle mass. And so yeah,
the more total training load you do, you're tend to get more strength and more hypertrophy.
The two constraints are time and then what you can recover from. So it seems like a weird
position to paint yourself into, you know, you paint yourself into this corner.
It's like, yeah, not only four to eight sets, it's like that doesn't square with any of the research.
If you wanted to talk about like a minimum effective dose, it would be even lower than that, right?
Like an exercise snack or like even one hard set per week for untrained individuals can work to
improve something. But like the optimal dose, because this is a protocol, that seems that seems
strange. So to me, you know, training load is really the name of the game here, more the better,
generally speaking. And then frequency, how often you do these things is mostly just an instrument
to distribute that training load. If you put them all on one day, logistically, that can be
challenging, particularly if you have more days to train. But if you only have one day or two days
to train, like you can condense them. If you prefer shorter sessions, you could split up over a whole
week. You know, in this case, 10 sets is 10 sets, whether you do it on one day or split up over five
days. I think even when you look at the best data we have on 12 to 20 sets per muscle, you know,
in a single session, which he says is silly. He says many people try to train each muscle group
twice per week with 12 to 20 work sets per group at each session, believing that this is the optimal
frequency for stimulating muscle growth. Like he says this and it's like, yeah, you look at the
research on that frequency has a very small role, potentially. And it's just like, it's just
training load. It's really just training load. So to the extent that adjusting frequency improves
or changes outcomes, strength and hypertrophy, it's mostly because it's changed training load.
People can either do a little bit more, total volume, for example, perhaps they lift a little heavier,
perhaps the quality of the reps are a little bit better, something like that. But it's really a small
and individualized sort of parameter, in my opinion. Austin, anything else you want to add to the
evidence here as far as how this works? Yeah, I just zooming out to think about the expertise
in this space. The folks whose opinions, you know, we look to the things that we look for,
some element of people who are thought leaders and themselves researchers in this space is one
element, practitioners who have a great deal of experience, and then people who themselves are
perhaps highly accomplished. And each of these disparate and sometimes overlapping categories
can have something to bring to the table, right? It just because somebody is an elite level
lifter, that doesn't necessarily mean that they, you know, have the optimal or even the correct ideas
about this, but I would take perhaps something from their opinions or recommendations compared
with somebody who has not accomplished much of anything meaningful. A practitioner who has coached,
you know, many thousands of people compared with somebody who has coached no one, I might put,
again, more weight on the former than the latter. And then somebody who is actively a researcher
in the space who does, you know, executes these kinds of studies, who has meta-analysed the data
themselves, people who we have, you know, befriended over the years hat on the podcast,
been on their podcast, things like that. You know, I think we like to think of ourselves as
some combination of having been relatively, you know, successful athletes ourselves in this space
and also having a great deal of experience with actually coaching athletes, even though we're not,
you know, primary PI researchers in this, in this space. He is none of these three things,
which makes me wonder again, like, why am I listening to your very, very, very confident takes
on this? And not just confident takes, but also, you know, discounting other methods of doing this,
to where he said, you know, that's straight up silly or something like that. And it's like,
I don't really know why I am concerned with your opinion on this when you are neither a coach,
practitioner, you are not a, you know, accomplished strength, power, hypertrophy athlete of any kind.
And you're not a researcher in this space. You're an, you know, an expert in, I believe,
retinal anatomy and physiology. So yeah, I just, I'm having, that's the hurdle I'm having trouble
getting over when it comes to like caring much about his recommendations or being a bit puzzled
as to why would somebody say, I have the protocol to optimize my results from this person who is
neither an athlete nor a coach nor researcher in this space. But yeah, they're giving me this very
confident recommendation. How many programs do you think he's written in his life for other people?
Very few. Yeah, I mean, I'm just guessing, but I'm, I guess it's not very many. Yeah, the other
thing here is like, if we were coming up with, I go back to the episode I did on like
the saturation point for resistance trainings, like, okay, if we're coming up with a protocol
for lifting weights, so the first question has to be, okay, protocol for what? And if it's
for strength, hypertrophy, okay, those will have various saturation points we don't really
know where the ceiling is, like where you, you know, at that point you're doing more,
but you don't get anymore, I don't think we know where that is. And then if it's about how
those pertain to health, if it's about metabolic health, if, you know, whatever the outcome is,
has its own unique saturation point, which would then have its own protocol. So to me,
this is mostly like an ignorance type thing, like, not only do you not know what you're talking
about when it comes to, like, general resistance training, sort of parameters and delivery,
but also, like, like, even how you think about it is a little flawed, because you didn't, like,
start from the right point. All right, so let's move on to the next game. So every time the book
makes a recommendation, you have to guess how many conflicts of interest he has. So either a financial
tie-in, an advisory role, sponsor, ownership stake, et cetera. So how many for this exercise chapter?
Seven. Only two, only two, a little guess of there. So he's got whoop, where he's an advisor,
and then the carbon app, which sponsors the podcast. All right, last game, this is scorecard.
So for every protocol here that we're weighing in on, you're going to give a verdict,
either it holds up, it's number one, two, right idea, but wrong dose. Three doesn't hold up,
or my favorite, the citations that he used say the opposite. So training each muscle directly,
once per week, every set to failure for four to eight sets as optimal. What's the verdict?
Yeah, we, I think we've established that the citations don't hold up. This is not supported.
Yeah, the opposite, which I mean, strong start, strong start here. Speaking of things that feel
intense, but maybe don't work so well. Let's talk about cold plunge. So Austin, the prediction,
how long does the book say to sit in the cold water, and what does it claim that you get for doing so?
I'm going to guess 13 minutes, and what you get is something having to do with dopamine and
impact on mood and clarity of thought. Yeah, well, you know, you're kind of short-changing,
what the book recommends. The dose is one to three minutes, or as he describes, quote, two to ten
walls, which becomes two to eight walls a few pages later. A wall is the moment that you want to
get out, but you stay in anyway. I'm not really sure how you clock that time, time that time.
That's a new new new unit of measure. That's right. Yeah. Nice new jargon. I didn't even know
existed. Sure. Okay. All right. So here's the passage. If the way I'm describing the post cold
state sounds almost drug-like, it is only better. One study found that full body up to the neck
immersion in water at about 57 degrees Fahrenheit for one hour triggered a more than five-fold increase
in nor apron effort levels compared to baseline. It also produced a rise in dopamine levels in the
body, raising them more than two-fold for hours afterward. We call this peripheral dopamine because
it was measured from the body. We don't yet know the exact relationship between dopamine levels in
the body and the brain, but we do know they tend to increase and decrease in parallel. And there's
emerging evidence that when peripheral dopamine is elevated, it increases dopamine in reward and
motivation circuits in the brain in a dose-dependent manner. Oh, boy. He later says that a study show that
even 30 seconds can work. He talks about brown fat, the fat that burns fuel to make heat. People
doing 11 minutes a week enhanced the amount of brown fat in their bodies is the claim.
All right. So let's talk about some receipts here. The dopamine study he mentioned did have young
men sit in 57 degree water for a full hour. Noradrenaline went up five-fold, which matches the book,
and dopamine went up two and a half times. Adrenaline didn't budge, and cortisol didn't go up at all.
It actually tended to go down, which is a little awkward because the book tells you that the cold
triggers a sharp increase in adrenaline and cortisol. And by the way, that was an hour in cold
water, whereas the protocol recommends one to three minutes, which doesn't make sense. And again,
he does admit that this is not brain dopamine, but all of the caveats afterwards could have been
summarized in a sentence. We don't know the significance of this. It might do this other stuff,
but we don't have any clinical outcome data to show that it improves mood or recovery or
sense of well, anything really. Yeah. It's this chain of reasoning with an kind of uncritical
implied assumption that at the end, if in fact your brain dopamine goes up at the end of this
kind of entirely hypothetical chain, right, that that's also a good thing, which is also not proven.
Right. So he says, like, if you get in the water and your blood dopamine goes up, and we assume
that that reflects also a central increase in dopamine in the brain, that this is also a good thing.
And it's like, is it for what outcome? Like you have multiple layers of, you know, assumed
reasoning here or things that you have failed to convince me are worth pursuing at all.
What about drugs that increase dopamine to like too high of levels, right? Like on the one hand,
you could get what is it? Compulsive, compulsive behaviors, risk-taking behaviors, hypersexuality,
gambling disorders, whatever. Also, you know, withdrawal, for example, if they were too high for
too long, like all sorts of stuff. Yeah. I mean, here's, here's a great way to, you know,
illustrate the issues with this is let's strip away, let's take the same study, strip away the
intervention being a cold plunge. But the data are the same, indicating an increase in blood
dopamine levels. However, in my version of this study, the way that we did that is by giving
somebody a dose of dopamine. We can administer IV dopamine to people in the hospital. Generally,
you know, rare these days to use it. I've seen it done still from from time to time in like the
cardiac ICU, or we can give you like Parkinson's meds, which, you know, increase dopamine levels.
There's some other caveats and implications about the brain and things like that there that
will set aside for now. But let's say that we just administered IV dopamine to mimic the same
blood levels. Would he also draw similar conclusions of well, the blood dopamine goes up? It's
reasonable to think that brain dopamine levels also go up and the implication baked into all of
this, although not explicitly said, is that that's a good thing and that is worth pursuing. So,
you know, maybe my protocols, even more effective, because you don't necessarily have to sit
in a cold plunge and suffer through all these walls. I could just, you know, give you a little hit
some IV dopamine. Of course, there are a whole lot of downsides to doing something like that that
will leave for another another day. But yeah, it's, it's kind of that's why you need to show that
the outcome is something that we care about. And the outcome that I care about is not your blood
dopamine levels on to which you like plaster on a bunch of like downstream assumed implications
that may be good. But I'm yet unconvinced that that is the case. Yeah, I mean, if you listen to
our Halloween episode, Dale could have gotten some IV dopamine. He wouldn't even have to get in the
cold plunge and suffer through the 30 second study that he says, I'll look, you can do it for only
30 seconds and you get you get a benefit of people took a normal shower and then finished with
30 to 90 seconds of cold exposure. And the outcome they tracked was how often they called in sick
to work. These people reported calling in sick about 30 percent less, but the number of days they
felt sick didn't clearly change. All this was self reported by people who knew they were in the
cold shower group like how do you do a placebo cold water exposure. So maybe they felt a little
little little less sick or maybe they were just more likely to tough it out and go to work.
Unclear. The Brown Fat study was even more interesting. This should get your attention
because this is a part of our game. It's guess the end, guess the sample size. So how many people
were in the Brown Fat study, Dr. Brocky? Nine. Okay, I think you still get a point for that because
it's 16 total eight winter swimmers versus eight non-swimmers. These are all men. They were measured
once. They measured the Brown Fat adipose tissue uptake of sugar, of glucose and then skin temperature
over the clavicular area. What they actually measured was how much sugar the Brown Fat soaked up
on a PET scan. Just one time in eight swimmers and eight guys who didn't swim. That scan shows you
Brown Fat that's turned on. Not how much Brown Fat that somebody has and nobody was followed
over time to see if the Brown Fat actually went up. At room temperature, the Swimmers Brown Fat
wasn't doing anything at all and the authors say outright that they can't tell whether winter
swimming caused any of what they found. Also, the Swimmers used hot saws on us too, so unclear if
this is a confounding effect. They also didn't measure anything on weight loss. Again, the assumption
is that if you do this thing, Brown adipose tissue is going to go up and that's subsequently going
to be better, whether it's for weight management or flux or something and it's like, uh, unproven.
Prove it? Yeah. Big if true. Yeah. The rest of the evidence, the largest meta-analysis we have
on this today, grouped 11 randomized trials of a cold water exposure for health and well-being
and the authors concluded, and I quote, "The purported benefits remain unsubstantiated."
And on the Brown Fat thing, adults may be burned 15 to 25 calories a day in the people who have
the most amount of Brown Fat, so this isn't like a huge deal otherwise. And there can be a
blunting of resistance training effects if you use it directly after training. The data isn't
super awesome here, but it does show potentially decrease in hypertrophy and strength gain.
So, now on to our question, how many conflicts of interest does he have here?
Maybe. Three surprisingly no conflicts of interest so look you know we're trending we're trending up
All right, and now for the very interest yet. Yes, right and now for the verdict game
Does this hold up is it the right idea, but wrong dose doesn't hold up or the citation says the opposite?
I'm gonna say so far it doesn't hold up. Yeah, I agree with that doesn't hold up
All right, well cortisol came up three different ways in that chapter in this book has a lot of opinions on cortisol
So that's where we're going next. So Austin the first question is
Prediction does the book want your cortisol levels higher or lower and how does it tell you to get there?
I mean, I would think I I hope that given his interest in things like
You know the retina and the light transduction and you know mourning light exposure or circadian biology
That he would be in the ballpark of correct that we would want cortisol to be higher in the morning and lower in the evening
Now as far as how we get there if I just you know alluded to that with the light exposure sort of piece
Maybe that's my best guess. Look all right. I'm gonna give you I'm gonna give you credit on that
Here's here's the quote. I wish I could banner this across the sky
Cortisol is not a stress hormone
In fact, if I could impart this one message about how to improve your health it would be this
Strive to get your morning cortisol high. Yes high and your nighttime cortisol low as far as how to go about doing this
He says consider occasionally once or twice per week using low-dose licorice root or consume grapefruit in the first one to three hours of your day
As far as his own licorice use he says I use it once or twice a month so the reader it gets four times his dose
He says I empty half of a 400 milligram capsule into water or my coffee and I drink that it tastes good
To be fair the same paragraph says if you have high blood pressure don't take this
And he says on morning sunlight can dramatically amplify it
We're talking about cortisol cortisol's rise by as much as 50%
Any any initial takes on those quotes
Yeah
Similar with the licorice root thing. I think that this is something that ought to be taken with a great deal of skepticism
Would need to see again quality evidence showing that it impacts something that I care about and in particular
That it does not cause harms that I do care about and when we know
How widespread the prevalence of high blood pressure is out there
Taking licorice root now granted. He says if you have high blood pressure don't take it
But again optimizers how much are they you know really gonna that they're gonna probably want to you know skate the edge here and say
Yeah, this is a protocol. I'm going for optimal baby. Let's let's do this
Because taking it contains a compound that I believe mimics the effects of aldosterone which can increase blood pressure can lower potassium levels
Which is also something that can be problematic for people other kind of cardiac complications and things like that
So I would not recommend essentially anybody taking licorice root on a regular basis for essentially any reason
And especially as a way to manipulate your cortisol levels also not kind of following the the reasoning or more importantly
Any clear health outcome that is going to be directly benefited by this outside of just like getting a good night of sleep and then
Getting up and living your life in the morning. Yeah, this assumes a few things one that most people have cortisol problems to start with
Right and then two that you can micromanage them in in various various ways and and then three that if you do that that
Gains something will be better, right something would be better. All right, so let's guess the sample size here
So this particular study this is what he uses to support his claim for using light
Sort of exposure to raise your cortisol levels in this particular study
They found that cortisol went up by 50% so what is the sample size, Dr. Brocky?
30 eight so no point
These is eight men they were kept awake for 36 hours and they got exposed to three hours of bright laboratory light
Nobody slept nobody went outside, but yet caused a 50% increase in cortisol
So it's totally not representative situation that doesn't apply to anybody reading this that they're going to be kept awake for 30 hours
And then exposed to light and then drawing upon that to make recommendations to people. Yeah, I mean correctly just to confirm
Yeah, yeah, for the licorice studies in his own and note found that blood cortisol didn't go up into two of the studies
Licorice also can change how the kidney handles cortisol
It also can lower potassium, which can be problematic in some folks
Particularly then because they can also raise blood pressure to usually within about two weeks
The great glass of grapefruit juice per day for three days
Can raise sympathy statin levels so people who are on statins for example, it's inhibits an enzyme
That your your liver uses to process certain statins
And yeah the light therapy thing
Optimizing cortisol. I'm just like
What are we doing here like what's it? It's just a weird I guess it's a weird thing like people
Assume that there's I got high cortisol if they're stressed cortisol levels are high and that's generally bad
So we got to attack the cortisol and it's like well
If you have a major life stressor that cortisol is really helping you, you know to his credit
He's saying look don't we're not trying to keep it low right but that cortisol is helping you
I just think mainly this is taking advantage of people's
lack of knowledge around cortisol and then giving a protocol to kind of placate them in a way even though the protocol seems kind of bogus
Yeah, I hear it from patients all the time honestly
It's so permeated like I think social media the public health kind of conversation where patients will really just use the word cortisol
As a substitute for the word stress like instead of saying like I'm feeling stressed out though
Like I'm worried that my cortisol is high and it's a really interesting kind of thing
And I'm like, but the again to what you just said there the cortisol being high is not itself the problem for the vast majority of these folks
It is perhaps that they're under you know undue chronic stress that has you know some negative health
Consequences and if in fact you were exposed to this chronic stress and you did not have that cortisol response
You would not be in very good shape
This is a scenario that you know I run into clinically when it really happens in terms of
Patients who do have adrenal insufficiency who do not have enough cortisol for the degree of stress that they are under
This is something that we see in patients who have septic shock in the ICU
They can have relative adrenal insufficiency or people who have adrenal insufficiency and don't take their oral you know
steroid their hydrocortezone that actually keeps their cortisol high and so then it comes back to like hey
Dr. Heberman if you want people's cortisol to be high and you're willing to take
Exogenous things like you want to take you know a liquor issue root which itself is not really directly doing that
But you want to take why not just take you know 10 milligrams of hydrocortezone in the morning come on, baby
That would be far more direct way to achieve the thing that you're looking for and then take some you know
Take an inhibitor in the evening
That would be the most direct clean way to it to lead to the result you're looking for instead of like this dancing around it
Yeah, that would be the study right if you were like okay
Look if we think this is all cortisol mediated and we need to increase cortisol
So you basically have one arm take the hydrocortezone. Okay cortisol has gone up for sure
Here's the outcome and then you're like okay, well, maybe it's not cortisol
Maybe it's actually liquorish root the like unique benefits of liquorish root itself
All right, well now you got to test that against placebo right so too many logical leaps all across this whole thing
So I kind of know what I think your verdict is going to be but if you have to give one on this not supported
Yeah, all right
Let's lower the stakes and talk about hydration which I promise is somehow still a whole podcast segment
Austin how much water does the book want in you before you drink your morning coffee
24 ounces
Yep, yes 18 to 24 ounces. He says consume 18 to 24 ounces of water upon waking try to do this first thing in the morning before drinking or eating anything else
Including coffee or other forms of caffeine a few pages later by the way
It's eight to 16 ounces so not not sure that was caught
He also says that drinking water stimulates the sympathetic branch of your autonomic nervous system
The circuitry that increases your alertness and focus
So aim to consume about 80 ounces of water across the first 10 hours of the day
Because our kidneys are simply much better at filtering water and other fluids we drink in the morning and daytime than at night
Oh boy
You guys can't see Austin's face right now unless you're watching on YouTube
What was that look for that that last claim of I guess
substantial and we'll call it clinically significant
I don't know circadian rhythmicity of whether it's he's alluding to GFR or ADH activity
Which there are some you know fluctuations in in ADH action and some folks who are again more prone to
bacteria or peeing more often at night, but yeah, so I'm curious where this goes
Yeah, all right. Well first before we get there we got to go back to one of our games
conflict of interest any guesses with water
I'm gonna get zero. Well, he's got one because I'm a fan of LMNT
The movie that's on electrolyte which is not water just to be clear to be clear about a sponsor of pocket. Yeah, big water sponsors of the podcast
All right, so some receipts
His kidney source says that filtration peaks around two or three p.m. Because that's when quote consumption of water is also at its highest
unclear on how he got to the totally made up
That's right
The kidney seems to follow how much you drink rather than any sort of like um
circadian rhythmicity. All right, now time for the guess the sample size game. This is the alertness
study related to water. So how big was this the study? 11. There's actually much larger, so no
points on this. 47 patients with severe autonomic failure, meaning that their nervous system can't
control their blood pressure. All right, super representative and applicable to people reading this.
Got it, got it. Water raised their blood pressure more than 30 points, but nobody measured
alertness, which unclear why this citation was used. All right, so this idea that you should take
water in before you drink your coffee assumes that coffee isn't hydrating, even though we know
that it is coffee hydrates about as well as water, because the diuretic effect that the effect
of where it made you go to the bathroom is very, very modest, so far less than the amount of fluid
you actually take in with your cup of coffee. As a brief aside, every race that I go to for car
racing, it's the same organizer. He's a nice guy. He's a really nice guy, but invariably we're
in the middle of the desert and he says at the beginning of each thing, I need everybody drinking water
today. Don't you get dehydrated? You know, get dehydrated before you know it, and I'm thinking
just trust your kidneys, just trust your kidneys. And then invariably he says, you can't hydrate
with coffee. And I'm like, I guarantee you, if somebody drank enough coffee, they're not going
to get caffeine toxicity. They're going to get water toxicity long before that, because again,
on balance, on net coffee can hydrate you. Of 18 randomized trials of drinking more water,
a few helped with weight loss, usually in the short term, and kidney stones, eight found nothing
and none tested a particular schedule. Obviously this is all made up. Mainly because your kidneys
and the area in your brain that regulate thirst and water or fluid seeking behaviors will say
are far smarter and more refined and up to date on what's going on inside your body than you are
for most individuals. In fairness, not drinking a lot before bed is fine, reasonable recommendation,
but I think both of us would say, you know, trust your brain and your kidneys. Yeah, fundamentally
the kidneys are homeostatic organs. Their role is to excrete urine in both amount and composition
that can be so variable in order to preserve a steady state internal environment. That is a fancy
way of saying your kidneys can do whatever they want in order to maintain your internal state.
So if you shift more of your water intake earlier in the day, they're going to make you pee more
earlier in the day because they're going to try to return you to that homeostatic state. If you
pee more later in the day or drink more later in the day, they're going to pee more later in the day.
If you drink more dilute fluid, they're going to pee out more dilute urine. They are so good
at doing this. And of course, there are implications for this when you have significantly impaired
kidney function, but the miraculous thing even about this is that you can get to very advanced
degrees of kidney disease before you actually even notice anything. Most of the patients that I see
who have, you know, advanced CKD stage three, it's like all their blood tests aside from their
markers of kidney function, of course, their electrolytes, their volumes at all the other stuff,
still normal to very advanced stages of kidney disease. They're so good. And so the idea that you
need some kind of micromanaging protocol of how much water to take in went, and it's like your
kidneys are just laughing at you, bro, like whatever you, whatever you recommended in this protocol,
your kidneys are like, fine, do what you want. I'm still going to handle this the way I'm going to
handle this. You cannot override them unless you take pharmacology directed at impacting your kidneys,
which is what I enjoy doing when I can, you know, try to as a, you know, simple human manipulate
kidney physiology by giving diuretics or by giving anti-diuretic hormone or by, you know, playing
with other sorts of things that can manipulate what the kidneys are doing over their own will
to anthropomorphize them a little bit. But it's just kind of like when you have that perspective
on the kidneys, what they do, how robust, resilient, elegant of organs they are, it's like, dude,
this is like so silly to think that you're doing anything meaningful here. Yeah, I mean, it's almost
as silly as people drinking like basic water, like water with like a base, you know, pH level or
whatever. And they're like, yeah, no, it improves your, your pH balance. And it's like, thankfully,
you can't change that, you know, without severe derangement because if you were in charge,
you would mess this up. And I think this is the same sort of underlying premise, I think, for almost
all these protocols, right? There is a problem and you need to, you can micromanage it. And if you do
benefit, right? Most people are not walking around dehydrated, right? Like you see, they'll drink
more water, drink more water. It's like, if you were really dehydrated in a way that mattered
significantly, your body would seek out you to consume fluids, whether it's through food, whether it's
through actual, you know, liquids or what, or what have you. But most people, day to day, despite
not carrying around a gallon of water all the time are not dehydrated. So Austin, what is your verdict
on this protocol? Also not terribly well supported. I think I'm going to go like the data points
at the opposite. Like, yeah, this is dumb. It's just one of the interesting thoughts that just came
to mind since one of the papers that you said was cited, involved patients who had like total
autonomic. It makes me wonder whether optimizers, biohackers, people like Dr. Huberman, would they
prefer to have autonomic failure? Because they have to do the thing to micromanage all of the,
you know, biological functions that are autonomic nervous system. Like if you had to consciously
decide to contract your diaphragm and manipulate your own breathing and tidal volume and respiratory
rate, if you had to decide and consciously manipulate your heart rate and say, I'm going to now
increase my heart rate to this degree so that I can sustain this activity. If you had to consciously
constrict and relax your blood vessels to maintain your blood pressure or, you know, decide what to do
with your urine, it's like, would they really enjoy this and like nerd out on like, I am in maximum
control. I mean, there's a mentality around that. Like, I know, you know, critical care doctors and
anesthesiologists, what you ask them, like, what do you love about your job, the clinical aspects
of your job? It's like, I enjoy taking over people's physiology, which they do. And it's a very
cool thing to do in very, you know, emergency situations to commandeer physiology and, you know,
save somebody's life in those sorts of situations. This is not that. And I don't think that you would
enjoy not having an autonomic nervous system or all these functions that happen without your need
to worry about it. And also the implication of that is you don't need to write a 500 page book
about it. Yeah, just imagine, imagine if Dale from the Halloween episode, it was Pan hypo pit,
right? So you got to like, carefully dose everything, right? And autonomic nervous system failure. So
again, you plug it in AI is in control of all of this sort of stuff. And it's like, that's one
extreme. And this is the last aside. And then we'll move on. We really beating this horse today.
So on the one side, you have the biohackers that are like, let's optimize everything. Let's take
control of our own physiology, do everything, right? And the, you know, polar opposite is like,
no, I don't want to mess with anything that my body is doing naturally, right? The environment is
doing naturally. It's like, is it interesting spectrum that we've painted here? Yeah. Yeah. I'm like,
shoot, I don't know. Where am I? I'm in the middle for sure. But like, which poll? All right.
Now that you're all dehydrated, let's go to bed. Austin, the question here is, how many sleep
supplements does the book list as a recommendation? Six. Eleven is the number, magnesium,
apigenin, theanine, GABA, glycine, myone and acetal, kiwi extract, tart cherry,
saffron, valerian, and melatonin. And the quote is, in my opinion, these are much safer than the
majority of prescription sleep medications, which may be an isolation that could be true. But
together, I have more concerns, and depends on how long and why you're taking them and what the
effect is. But that's another, maybe another podcast, maybe we'll do the sleep part three.
All right. For the game, conflict of interest, how many conflicts of interest do we have here? Five.
Looks like we have four. So we have AGZ, which is the sleep powder from AG1. He says, I help design
AGZ. It remains the best sleep supplement I've ever taken. And yes, I am incentivized to say that,
but I am measuring my sleep stats most nights, little orthosomnia, perhaps. Also, he's an advisor
for eight sleep, roca, wind down glasses. Matina is a partial owner, so four potential conflicts
of interest here. He says, stay away from prescription sleep aids if you can. The how-to
for cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, which is like the first line for most most of the
stuff, and is the treatment that works the best, although many patients do not prefer it,
is one sentence in his book. Austin, you want to comment on the claim about just this, you know,
these sleep meds and like, don't avoid them at all costs, take 11 supplements, any sort of
opinion on that? Yeah, I think it would be best if you were going to make that claim to have
some sort of comparative evidence that shows we'll call it non-inferiority, meaning that the
supplements you are recommending are at least not worse than the effects, meaning how effective
the
the particular medications you're concerned about are and ideally have a better safety profile.
That would be the way to make that claim confidently is to show at least as good of an effect
with less risk.
To my knowledge, that does not exist for really any of these.
Now I say this not someone who is a massive fan of, you know, prescription sleep medicines
in general, although there's a lot of different options with a lot of variation between them
and they have different indications for use.
People might have different reasons for which one of these medications might be used in
a shorter term period, over a longer term period, or things like that.
Insomnia is not just one thing.
There are, you know, different forms, different triggers, different causes, different issues.
It can relapse and remit.
And again, as I mentioned, it is not just about insomnia either.
There are also other what we'll call parasomnias or other sleep disorders that can benefit
from various forms of medication treatments.
And it's not really, you know, his place to make sweeping claims about the use of, you
know, gestures broadly, sleeping medicines because they are all different, unique with
particular benefit and safety profiles that would be individualized to the given patient
and the issue that they are presenting with.
And as somebody who deals with this on a regular basis, who speaks with patients about their
sleep challenges, who has, you know, had patients, you know, ripping their hair out in tears
because they can't sleep, who end up benefiting from a relatively low risk low dose of a prescription
medicine.
The idea that I would instead tell them, no, don't take that, take these 11 supplements
that don't have good evidence that they're going to deliver a similar or better clinical
effect.
It's kind of silly and short-sighted.
And again, reflects the fact that he is not in fact a clinician who does this with people.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I mean, to your point, you would have to say, look, insomnia is a number of different things.
These supplements seem to produce the same effect, right, as using a prescription sleep
drug, which does not appear to be the case.
It's kind of the same thing we see with GLP1s, which we're like, look, GLP1s are so risky
for obesity.
You shouldn't use them.
You should just use lifestyle, which assumes that lifestyle produces the same effect on obesity
and subsequent health outcomes from obesity, which is not what we see.
And so it is inferior to use that for most folks, not to say that you shouldn't do it as
well.
So yeah, that's just, again, clinically thinking, rather than just like, I like supplements,
you know, if I--
Totally.
Yeah, boil this down.
It would be a similar situation to what we've described before with, like, say the GLP1
lifestyle argument of, like, just take a head-to-head randomized control trial experiment
and blind the-- like, erase what the-- which intervention was which for which curve?
And then just present it.
Which would you take in this situation?
This intervention that reliably leads to 15, 20% weight loss with this, you know, this
particular risk profile versus this other one that leads to maybe, on average, 5% weight
loss that may not even be very well sustained and has its own kind of risk profile, particularly
the risks of untreated long-term obesity among other things, which would you choose?
And when it is blinded, I think the choice becomes much more straightforward for a lot
of people as we are seeing play out around the world at the moment.
If you have the same thing of tart cherry or something like that, I think you said was
one of the examples.
And compare that to just, like, taking, I don't know, 3 milligrams of doxipin at night
or something like that.
What's the impact on, you know, sleep maintenance insomnia?
I don't think it would be a terribly difficult decision, just even in not to mention the fact
that the risk profile is very low when it is used in the appropriate patient.
Yeah.
All right.
So let's talk about some of the data here.
He said in one investigation, epigenin mildly improved data time function among people
with insomnia, the citation is for chamomile T. chamomile didn't beat placebo on any sleep
measure and the total sleep time actually favored placebo in that stuff.
Love it.
Love it.
Right.
And it's not clear that epigenin or epigenin, I don't really know how to say this, while
it is in chamomile T, there's other stuff in chamomile T. So like, it's just a food matrix
effect where like the beneficial effects of coffee are not just related to the caffeine,
but the other stuff in there.
So hard to separate those.
All right.
It's time for my favorite game, guess the sample size.
The book says that tart cherry improved sleep quality among 10 people, Austin.
How many people were really in the study?
Oh.
It wasn't 10.
I'm going to guess seven.
There were 20.
There were 20.
But he had the sample size of the study that actually agreed with him.
And the book says that a REM sleep study looked at 32 adults over the age of 60 with dementia.
Any I guess is on the sample size there?
17.
321 people without dementia were followed for 12 years.
32 is how many people developed dementia during the follow-up period.
So some accuracy issues here.
The American College of Physicians says that every adult with chronic insomnia should
get CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy first.
It's a short program that retains your sleep and gets people to sleep on average about
20 minutes faster.
For melatonin, the one supplement that most people listen to is probably no.
It gets people to sleep about seven minutes faster.
It's modestly useful for like sleep phase disorders, body clock problems, like jet lag.
Modosis seem to work better, and for women, it doesn't mention anything about hot flashes,
for example, in here, not even mentioned once.
So that is kind of interesting, all right.
So the verdict time, Austin, what are you going to say about the verdict here on the supplements?
I mean, you said, you said it yourself that in at least one of the studies that placebo
seemingly outperformed the T.
So evidence going in the other direction for many years.
Yeah, noticing a trend here.
All right.
And if you didn't sleep while the books got a fix for that too, we're going to talk about
nicotine.
Austin, it's prediction time.
What dose of nicotine does the book recommend for focus?
Oh, boy.
I truly have no idea.
He says it absolutely works to sharply increase focus if you take it occasionally, meaning
no more than two to three times a week at a dose of one to six milligrams each time.
In the same paragraph, he says, that is why so few people can limit their oral nicotine
use to three to six milligrams once per day.
I hear from countless people who started with that amount.
I love the effect.
Then increased it to three milligrams twice per day and now use four to six milligrams
or even eight milligrams pouches pretty much all day long.
And that's why I chose to include it in my book for the general public.
Oh, man, two pages after the dose, he says it's two to four times per week.
He also says that unless it's smoked, vaped, dipped or snuffed, nicotine does not cause
cancer, but it is highly addictive and can raise blood pressure.
When you wrote that sentence or read that when you were editing it, presumably you read
it all the way through, he was like, maybe that's why people can't stop just once a day.
Yeah.
All right.
So guess the sample size here.
This is his focus study on nicotine patches on non-smokers.
Any idea what the sample size is here?
Sixty.
Twelve people were in this study, no point there, all right?
So we're three total that you've gotten, right?
They felt a little bit more alert and reacted a bit faster, but yeah, there's an issue here
in the data on nicotine use and focus because a big thought is that it's really just a relief
from withdrawal.
As effectively, you're not taking nicotine naive people, giving them nicotine sort of
stuff, you know, delivery on some level and then testing them.
You're usually taking either people who have used it before, who use it currently.
And so a lot of this seems to be relief from withdrawal.
And as he, you know, alludes to, but doesn't straight up say, dependence starts quickly.
And middle schoolers, symptoms of dependency began at about two cigarettes one day per week
and his almost six milligrams sort of quote, isn't a little bit of nicotine.
At six milligrams and up, pouches typically deliver more nicotine than a cigarette.
So I don't know that I can, with good, in good conscious, recommend people use nicotine
for like improved performance.
I think if you were trying to be charitable, you would say, look, if you were going to
use nicotine anyway, you're going to smoke it.
That's probably the most harmful way of consuming nicotine.
Same thing with like chewing tobacco.
And if you wanted to use pouches, that's less harmful gum, probably less harmful than that.
But I don't know that I can recommend regular exposure to nicotine and say, there's no
risks here and the benefits clearly outweigh the risks.
I don't think the data supports that. Austin, do you get a take on this?
Yeah.
No, I agree.
100%.
And he even eludes to this kind of explicitly, which is what makes it kind of remarkable
here is like, maybe this has some impact on focus.
But turns out nobody can keep it in that safe range and it's very addictive and everybody
he knows who's ever tried it and is taking too much too often.
So that's why it's in my book.
It's like, did you, did you hear yourself when you were about to read this?
Do you remember, we had that mystery case that guy was using a few pieces of two milligram
nicotine gum and he went up to 15 at once and he ultimately had to get intubated.
That was a mystery case.
So I won't give away the ending.
That'll be a show notes.
But all right, I think the verdict on this is just generally not supported overall.
And now it's time for the lightning round, more games to play here with Dr. Baraki.
So here's how this works.
I'm going to read you a line.
You're going to tell me whether it's really in the book or whether I made it up and I'll
tell you each one of them when we get through them.
All right.
First one.
Parmesan Regiano has so much tyrosine.
How much tyrosine is there?
That the taste combined with the dopamine increase it causes is highly reinforcing.
Is this real or made up?
Real.
Yeah, it's in the book.
These are the crunchy crystals in aged cheeses.
They're mostly tyrosine.
Eating more of it doesn't raise brain dopamine in healthy people, though, because the enzyme
that turns tyrosine into dopamine is already usually maxed out.
He mentions that enzyme himself two sentences later.
The safety point has to do with a different molecule.
Age cheese is loaded with tyramine and in someone on an MAO inhibitor antidepressant, for
example, tyramine can cause hypertensive crisis, which is the classic cheese reaction that
we learn in medical school, so that's not in the book.
Second sort of true or false.
Stand barefoot on grass for at least 10 minutes after sunrise.
The ground's free electrons help offset the oxidative load from your phone's blue light.
I'm going to hope that that's not in the book.
That is fake.
Grounding is a real illness.
The studies behind it are tiny and unblinded, because again, how do you do this?
Would it be on turf or something like that?
For somebody with diabetic neuropathy, barefoot walking is how you can get a wound that you
don't necessarily feel.
I don't know that I'd be universally recommending this, although grounding is pretty innocuous,
generally speaking.
Next one.
For chocolate cravings, slowly develop a taste for raw cacao beans, five or six per day.
I'm going to say that's true and in the book.
It's in the book.
Yeah.
Though the polyphenol pitch, these are the sort of antioxidants that are in the beans,
pretty, pretty weak overall.
In the biggest trial on this called the Cosmos study, it missed its main hard outcome and
two safety notes here.
Cacao carries caffeine and theobromine, and then there's an independent risk, independent
testing, rather, of dark chocolate has found lead and cadmium in a lot of products.
Daily, cacao, I don't generally care if people are having dark chocolate, for example,
but should you have these raw beans?
I don't know what the benefit is.
Yeah.
I also don't know how effective it is to just tell people to, quote, "develop a taste
for something."
Just like this now.
Yeah.
Let's see.
So, the GLP1 study, this is the next one, started when a reptile from South America entered
the picture.
Is this real or fake?
Real?
Yeah.
That's in the book.
The reptile is the Gila monster, which lives in the U.S. Southwest in northern Mexico compound
in its saliva, as it's called Exenden 4, which became Exenotide, the first GLP1 drug that
was released.
So the science credit here is fair.
The angle is gray market, obviously people buying the research grade chemicals at peptides
online with no guarantee of what's in the vial, which is the same zero pumpkins out of
five score I gave it on our Halloween episode.
Yeah.
All right.
Next one.
"Hum a low note for 90 seconds before you, your first bite of food, the vibration primes,
the vagus nerve, and blunts the glucose spike."
Fake.
That is fake, although kind of half true, because humming does raise nitric oxide in the nose
a lot.
It doesn't do anything for blood sugar.
But if you want to blunt the blood sugar rise after a meal, the thing that works is moving.
Exercise.
Yeah.
Core muscles are your abdominals or abs, but also the sheets of muscles below and all around
them, such as the rectus abdominis and obliques.
I'll say that that's in the book.
That is in the book.
That is in the book.
The sentence names the abs as a muscle beyond the abs.
The clinical point is that specific core stabilization training hasn't beaten general
exercise for low back pain.
You don't need specialized core work to protect your back.
You just need to train and be more active, generally speaking.
All right.
If you wake up in the middle of the night, try putting on some socks, sweats, or even a
knit cap, and go back to sleep.
This can increase your core body temperature, which increases the amount of REM sleep you
get.
I'll say that's in the book.
It is in the book, but he has the mechanism backwards.
Your core temperature drops as you fall asleep and warm feet help because they dump the
core heat, which cools the core.
Worming the core generally makes sleep worse.
Clinically, the person who's most likely to be awake at 3 in the morning and warm is
a woman in perimenopause with night sweats, and a knit cap is the opposite, really, what
you would recommend.
Right.
All right.
The next one, chew gum on the left side of your mouth during focused work.
The uneven jaw movement increases blood flow to the right prefrontal cortex.
Oh, God.
This has to be fake.
Thankfully, it is fake.
This is pure invention.
The left brain, right brain framing is old pop neuroscience.
The only clinical note here is that heavy one-sided chewing all day is a good way to aggravate
jaw pain.
I probably wouldn't want to do that.
On matching your sleep schedule to your body clock, tell your boss, you'll have fewer
sick days, you will, tell your partner, you'll be a better partner, you will.
Feel free to cite me during the negotiations.
This is a claim.
I'm missing the claim here.
I'm going to say that this is fake.
This is real.
He actually wrote this.
Tell your boss.
You'll have fewer sick days.
Tell your partner, you'll be a better partner.
Wow.
Or what, man, like what?
Oh, yeah, shout out to shift workers, wonder how that's going to, how that conversation
is going to go.
All right, protein only causes kidney problems above something in the vicinity of more
than three grams of protein per pound of body weight.
I will say that that's in the book.
It is in the book, but like what?
Three grams per pound is about six and a half grams per kilo.
The highest dose I know of anybody testing is about four and a half grams per kilo for
eight weeks in 30 lifters.
So his threshold is past anything that's really been studied.
But the paper he cites for it doesn't give a number at all.
It actually concludes that there's no good reason to eat more protein than the RDA, which
we disagree with for lifters.
But it's still the opposite of the sentence it's cited for.
I think the big problem here is that while it is true that healthy kidneys can handle pretty
much any protein that you throw at them, it's like, do you need that much protein?
Right.
Yeah.
It gets a little thornier, I think, and there's obviously still a lot of controversy here
about what do you do with somebody with chronic kidney disease, because the recommendation
has been to limit protein, limit protein, limit protein, and even that really hasn't shown
great outcomes.
We've done a few episodes on that, but yeah, decided to write that in the book.
He could have just said, you'd be fine, but you don't need that much protein.
That would be more truthy.
Totally.
All right.
Well, I think the patients who still protein very, very popular at the moment, especially
with weight loss and GLP1 concerns and things like that, and I would be way happier if people
put at least as much energy into, oh, I have to go train as they do to, I have to get this
much protein.
In fact, I've had several patients recently who their weight loss progress, even while
using a GLP1 had kind of slowed down, maybe they'd even plateaued for a little bit, and
when we did a closer audit of their intake, they're like, yeah, so I have been trying to
hit my 180 grams of protein a day every day, and I'm like, whoa, this person does not need
to be consuming this much.
We could easily knock off 60 of these grams of protein, and that will also, based on the
food sources that you're getting it from, also lead to additional calories being eliminated,
and help you make some more progress again.
If you're worried about the lean body mass muscle aspect of things, which I think as long
as you're training, you're going to be okay, then just like train more, which would be great
if you can do that, you know.
Yeah.
All right.
The next one.
Morning sunlight works for dogs, cats, cows, and other animals.
Yes, your dog will benefit too.
In the book.
In the book, for sure.
And yeah, I mean, animals also have body clocks set by light, and dairy farms do have
lighting schedules to raise milk output, that said, like, I don't know why this is in
the book.
Yeah.
Exactly.
All right.
Without doing a functional MRI and blood draws, there's no way to know your baseline dopamine
and acetylcholine levels.
It is in the book, despite neither test can actually be able to do that.
A functional MRI measures blood oxygen in the brain as a proxy for activity, not dopamine,
and dopamine in your blood doesn't necessarily reflect dopamine in your brain either.
I'd say they prefer acetylcholine levels, like what the heck are we doing here?
There's no test that I know of that kind of gives you your baseline dopamine.
Like, what are you going to do, serial sampling of your dopamine over like months and years
and be like, well, a decade ago, here was my dopamine level in here.
Yeah.
It doesn't tell you anything.
I'm not even sure there is such thing as a baseline for these things, because again,
they have a physiologic purpose.
I'm also not aware of any clinical reason to measure blood acetylcholine levels.
I could be wrong on that if there's anyone out there with that kind of an idea, at least
in the dopamine and dopamine like adjacent space, they're involved in like the catacletal
amine pathways.
And so there are some of those kind of tests that are done when working up certain very
rare neuroendocrine sort of conditions.
But I'm trying to think of like, is there a situation where measuring anything pertaining
to acetylcholine directly, I'm having a hard time coming up with anything there?
So yeah, not buying it not buying it all right on sunscreen my read of the literature is yes
They can be bad for hormones
In the book it's in the book indeed indeed the FDA ran studies where people put on sunscreens with ingredients like oxy
Benzone and avobenzone and those ingredients showed up in the blood above the level that triggers more safety testing
But as far as harm to hormones that has never been shown the safety point is that sunburn and skin cancer as a result of
those sunburns are proven sort of risks and harms and
People who spend a lot of time outside should be wearing sunscreen generally speaking and mineral sunscreen is a fine choice of people who use that
But the most interesting part is there's a reveal later
He's a partial owner of the brand he names, which is called la rub so tally another one for the old conflict of interest
Yeah
Yeah
Okay, final score Austin you went two for seven guessing sample sizes
We counted eight conflicts of interest across the protocols that we covered today counting the sunscreen company
He part-ones and not one of the protocols got a holds up to the research Scott Carney counted 11 financial ties across the whole book
so
That was my review of the book on the protocols
Austin, I want you to give a final verdict and I'll do one right after you one sentence
Would you give this book to your mom?
That's a great metric by which to assess these kinds of like pop health recommendation sort of books
I would definitively not give this book to my mom or anybody that I cared about
Yeah, yeah, I
Would only give it to somebody who does fancy fancies themselves as a biohacker and they were gonna buy it anyway
So I would just like here's the gift, but I would maybe include the show notes from this podcast
Or if somebody who you want to make themselves miserable because if you think about all of these things like from the moment
You open your eyes in the morning and you have to get started with you know raising your cortisol getting outside drinking your 24 ounces of
Water following whatever nutrition and training advice, you know taking your sets to failure
For that day and then as you get into the evening starting your one of 11, you know sleep supplements and whether you're wearing your
proper fuzzy socks and other things to you know manage your heat
Disappation as you get under the blanket to go to bed. It's like yeah, here you go go off
Be miserable doing all these things every day instead of just like you know living your life
Yeah, it's like it's like people almost want like a codified like way to live
You know the people that were the stuff resonates, but to me that's just you're like erecting your own constraints in a way
Which I don't know it that it's useful. Well, I know that it's not useful for like quality quality life, but it does give you like
A blame if something goes wrong. Well, I didn't do all the things right and just
Morality and such. All right. Let's wrap this up with our protocols. We'll just trade some one-liners back and forth and then wrap this up
We'll go through the same kind of seven things that we're discussed here. So first on lifting
My take is that people should do as much resistance training as possible
with the two constraints
Being time and how much you can actually recover from I'll add a third constraint in balance with enough
Endurance training to maximize your cardiovascular fitness for the amount of time that you have so practically speaking that'd be like 10 to 20
Hard sets per week per muscle
You can spread it out however you want based on your own your own schedule
So you'll actually do it and you can generally you should generally take those sets to somewhere between two to four reps
Affail your Austin any any lifting sort of one-liners you want to give here?
I think that's perfectly fine for the vast majority of folks. There are going to be those you know
In so far as we're giving kind of our own versions of sweeping blanket recommendations of course
They're gonna be you know individual cases where somebody may be more or less able to adhere to something like that
Or they may have you know musculoskeletal
pain or limitations in some way and I would not want to paint it in a way that is like well
If for whatever reason you were limited in being able to achieve this that all hope is lost
There are still plenty of ways that we can find to you know deliver a healthy stimulus to your musculoskeletal system
And even if there is some rehabilitative need that needs to be taken into consideration doing that as well
The subset of situations where you know, it is not safe or you should not do these things from an exercise standpoint are
Fortunately like very very very very uncommon. Yeah, yeah
All right for cold plunge my take is if you like it go for it
It's probably not doing much unless you're using it after like heat stress sort of things like you're in the field
I would advise skipping it right after lifting
And yeah, I probably wouldn't plunge alone just just in case
Austin any other cold plunge takes
Yeah, similarly do it if you like it
I also like don't even care if it's something that you say I like doing it after my lifting session
I'm like okay
Yeah, even if there's some theoretical compromise on like your strength progress or something like that because if you if you
Have that information if you know and you are prioritizing your strength and hypertrophy to such a great degree
You will naturally you know make the choice to not use it
But if you want to use it anyway, then like fine
There's probably dozens of other things that you're doing in your day-to-day life that are not all
Perfectly aligned with optimum strength and hypertrophy results, and that might just be another one of them
Which is you know is what it is I suppose yeah
For cortisol my take is don't try to micromanage it because
You're not going to be able to do it anyway and any sort of like feigned attempt to do so
I think carries more risk than benefit
If you want to go outside in the morning great spend spend time outside. I'm a fan of that
Yeah, I would view this much more as a
situation of
Modifying the
Modifiable stressors in your life to the extent that it improves your quality of life rather than trying to manipulate or modify
Your you know biological stress pathways. This is like saying my my nor my nor Adrenaline is too high today
I need to find a way to to knock that down. It's like well, we don't have people
You know who are so worried about cortisol also taking you know beta blockers all the time to like tamp down there
You know at an urgent signaling or something which would also be a great way to you know tamp down that maybe even overactive to the extent
It is you know kind of activation of that side of things
So just detach from the you know neurobiology and endocrinology of this stuff and just like to the extent that stressors
Are a problem in your life do what you can to modify those and also recognize that not all stressors can be modified
Not all stressors should be modified and you know that kind of perhaps
You know stoic sort of perspective on things can can have its utility as well. Yeah
For water. I think we're both aligned trust your brain and your kidneys
I don't think you need to again micromanage your hydration or fluid intake. You will naturally drink when you're thirsty
Coffee certainly counts, but yeah the idea that you should delay your coffee or that you should drink a certain amount
Nah, I'm out on that
Yeah, I agree if you want to start your day with coffee fine if you want to start your day really with like any zero calorie beverage
I have very little concern about that kind of thing the more calories your beverage contains the more other questions
I have it's not even that you shouldn't have something like that
But it's like what is the purpose? What is the intent if it's for example?
Hey, I'm training for an ironman and I need to you know drink some carb containing beverage before I go trains like go off
That sounds great if it's I have obesity class two and metabolic syndrome and I have a latte in the morning that has
800 calories then there's a conversation to be had around that
But pretty much for anyone else a zero calorie beverage even if it has caffeine even if it is black coffee in the morning
If that's your first beverage of choice, I've like literally no concerns about that. I think there are far more important things to
worry about in your life and
Micro-managing. This is not one of them. Yeah
For protein intake
Would go back to our our standard recommendation right around 1.6
Grounds of protein per kilogram body weight per day if you're lifting
I'd hopefully you are lifting and you can get that from whatever foods you like a protein supplement can be useful if you're shy
Of that most people are eating plenty of protein would probably benefit from maybe one more serving per day
If they're if they're lifting weights if they're very lean and training very hard it can be higher than that
but this general recommendation is not for the people
For those people often any of their protein takes
Yeah, I'm increasingly comfortable with even lower levels of intake down to one call at 1.4 and many cases even 1.2
I generally don't go much lower than that as far as our recommendation in most situations
But at somewhere in that we'll call it 1.2 to 1.6. I'm like sounds great
Cool. Yep. Yep fair enough
Overall for supplements. I think I would just ignore all of the advice here on on supplements
Save for creatine monohydrate
We're
Kind of fans of that although it is weird that we've been kind of pushing back against the sort of creatine sensationalism
That's been going around where it's like this panacea. It's like look. There's a modest effect
It's relatively reliable in in in many individuals
Three to five grams per day. I'm is going to get you most of it take it whenever you remember to do so the cognitive stuff
I'm not sold on quite just quite yet and again the effects are modest
So if you take it you don't like the way it makes you feel or you have an issue. Take it that that's fine
And if you don't take it either like you you're gonna be fine
Yeah, yeah, I think that we have
Beat this one to death over the years. I think that most people
people who are very concerned with their creatine intake would probably derive a greater
degree of benefit from doing a few extra sets or doing a bit more conditioning or getting
an extra half hour of sleep.
I think that the effect of those things is likely to outweigh.
And again, I'm not painting this as like a dichotomy.
It has to be one or the other, but just trying to keep these things in perspective, like the
idea that there are folks who like, oh, I have to like pack my creatine in a ziplock
bag when I go travel or something so that I can stick to my, I'm like, this is definitely
disordered.
I think it's a way it's like, you know, I don't think it that it is giving that level
of like life-changing benefits in the vast majority of situations.
And I prefer not to over-hype it for that reason compared with things that we can feel
more confident, give more reliable benefits to more people.
Yep, I agree, on sleep would recommend generally getting seven or more hours of high quality
sleep per night on a steady schedule if possible.
If it's been bad for a while, would recommend speaking to your physician and asking for
cognitive behavioral therapy, CBT, generally a first-line recommendation there, although
again, most people do not access that.
And if you snore or you wake up unrefreshed daytime tiredness, getting checked for sleep
apnea is a reasonable consideration there, though the full sleep workup is far more extensive
than, hey, just take these 11 supplements and ignore everything else.
I'm also surprised, Austin, I teed you up perfectly and you even mentioned parosomnias.
No comment on iron, the iron master, no comment on iron, come on.
Yeah, I think we need to bring our buddy Dr. Gordon back on for another sleep episode
and get into the weeds on some of this stuff.
I think we're probably overdue for that.
So maybe look out for that in the near future, I hope.
I think that that's overall a reasonable take.
I think that CBTI is appropriate for certainly a fair number of people, but is also challenging
to access for a lot of folks and isn't always necessary for people with more routine sleep
difficulties.
I think that aside from evaluation for sleep apnea and things like vasomotor symptoms and
perimenopause and menopause and iron deficiency to your point of things that I look for very
frequently, the other just kind of general piece of advice that I find myself giving most
often to folks in these situations is establishing a as rigid of a wake up and out of bed time
as possible.
A lot of people focus a lot on what time they go to bed and if they have a poor night
asleep, then they might kind of like dose or nap or something like that to try to catch
up or make up for that sleep debt, which does not lead to very great kind of longer term
outcomes and quality and consistency of sleep compared with suffering through in the short
term of setting a rigid out of bed time in the morning and getting up and out of bed
even if you don't feel ready or feel great, but doing that consistently for the initial
period of time can help to establish that rhythm and develop the kind of sleep pressure that
you need to start to fall asleep at a reasonable time in the evening.
So I put much more emphasis on the wake and out of bed time than I do on the bedtime.
Yep. Agreed. For focus, would not recommend starting nicotine to improve your studying
or focus sleep. Obviously, big factor here, reasonable dose of caffeine if you prefer it
and being a relatively distraction free environment would be my recommendation here.
Yeah. I mean, you actually, if I recall, have some experience with nicotine in the past
that you can kind of speak with more authority on this. I've not taken it or used it in my
academic history. I've just stuck with basics of sleep and caffeine and getting, actually,
a big fan. I came to believe that getting in a good workout, whether at some point in the middle
of my studying day helped to kind of break up the monotony of it, probably help with some degree
of like, I don't know, memory consolidation or something like that. I find that to be a plausible
sort of thing. So those are the things that I would use instead. Yeah. I think most people
wouldn't come to study and need to figure out what works for them as far as best strategies.
For me, it's space for repetition learning. I just, some people like flowcharts, concept mapping,
whatever, but identifying that was really the key to unlocking academic performance for me.
Obviously, there are other contributing factors for generally focus, but I don't think I wouldn't
write a chapter on nicotine in a book for focus. If you're wondering about what we do think you
should do for your health, we have a banger of an article that's been up for a few years now,
recently refreshed in April of this year. Where should my priorities be to improve my health?
That's linked in the show notes below written by Dr. Baraki. But I think that is a wrap here on our
if books could kill version of Dr. Andrew Huberman's book Protocol. Austin, anything before we sign off?
No, that's all. All right. Well, before you guys go anywhere, please leave us a five-star rating
and a review. It really helps drive traffic to our podcast so we can keep bringing you
all of this nuance and health and fitness for everyone at Barba Medicine. I'm Dr. Jordan Feigebom.
That's Dr. Austin Baraki. We'll catch you next week and every week right here on the Barba Medicine
podcast.
[Music]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Dr. Andrew Huberman’s book *Protocols* promotes highly specific, often extreme, lifestyle adjustments with broad claims of universal effectiveness.
The book cites studies that often contradict its own claims, and several key protocols are unsupported or misrepresented by the research.
Multiple protocols—such as cold plunges, licorice root use, and hydration schedules—are based on small, non-generalizable studies or flawed assumptions.
Huberman’s recommendations lack clinical validation, especially in real-world populations, and overstate efficacy with sweeping statements like “it works for everyone.”
The book has significant financial and advisory conflicts of interest, including sponsorships and advisory roles with health brands.
The author critiques the lack of clinical outcomes in studies, such as no proven benefit for mood, recovery, or health from cold exposure or cortisol manipulation.
Core biological mechanisms, like autonomic regulation and hydration, are oversimplified, ignoring the body’s natural homeostasis.
Huberman’s background as a neuroscientist without clinical training in exercise or sleep medicine limits the credibility of his recommendations.
Summary:
Dr. Andrew Huberman’s new book, *Protocols*, presents a comprehensive but deeply questionable guide to optimizing health through highly specific routines, such as drinking 18–24 ounces of water before coffee, cold plunges, and using licorice root to raise cortisol. While the book is well-written and widely promoted, its claims are scientifically unsound.
Multiple protocols are based on small, non-generalizable studies or outright contradicted by existing research. For instance, the claim that training each muscle group once per week with four to eight sets works for everyone is contradicted by studies showing higher volumes (12–20 sets) yield better strength and hypertrophy. Cold water exposure is promoted despite a lack of evidence for improved mood or recovery, and its effects on dopamine are speculative and not linked to real-world health outcomes.
Similarly, licorice root use is linked to risks like high blood pressure and potassium loss, making it unsafe for many people. The book also contains numerous conflicts of interest, including advisory roles with sleep and hydration brands. Most critically, Huberman lacks clinical experience in the areas he recommends—such as exercise or sleep medicine—making his sweeping assertions about efficacy medically dubious.
The overall message is that while the ideas are appealing, they are not supported by robust evidence, and many recommendations ignore fundamental biological principles like homeostasis and individual variability. The book appears more like a well-sourced sales pitch than a reliable health guide.
FAQs
The book recommends training each major muscle group directly only once per week, with 4 to 8 sets, and suggests training to failure. It claims this works for everyone and never fails, but this is contradicted by research, which shows higher volumes (12–20 sets) are more effective for strength and hypertrophy.
The book claims cold immersion boosts dopamine and mood, citing studies with short durations (up to one hour). However, the studies are small, have questionable applicability, and lack evidence of real-world benefits like improved mood or recovery. The link between peripheral dopamine and brain dopamine remains unproven.
The book suggests raising morning cortisol through light exposure or licorice root, but these claims are poorly supported. Studies used extreme conditions (e.g., 36-hour wakefulness) and show no real-world applicability. Licorice root can raise blood pressure and lower potassium, posing health risks.
No. The book's recommendation lacks clinical support. Coffee hydrates as well as water, and the body's kidneys naturally regulate fluid balance. The claim that water intake before coffee boosts alertness is not backed by evidence, and the cited study involved patients with severe autonomic failure.
The book lists 11 sleep supplements, claiming they are safer than prescription meds, but there's no strong evidence showing they match the effectiveness of sleep aids. Most lack proven clinical outcomes, and the claims ignore individual variability in sleep disorders.
Dr. Huberman has financial ties to multiple companies, including Athletic Greens, 8 Sleep, and Wind Down Glasses, and is a scientific advisor or partial owner of several supplement brands. These relationships raise concerns about objectivity in the recommendations.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.