How Worried Should We Be About a Dirty Bomb? | Command Post
45m 56s
A recent report from CNN suggests Iran is planning a potential dirty bomb attack on Washington, D.C., though intelligence sources indicate it remains a low-probability, high-impact scenario. A dirty bomb, unlike a nuclear weapon, uses radioactive material mixed with explosives to spread contamination and induce fear, with only two prior incidents recorded—both neutralized before detonation. The difficulty in assembling and transporting such devices limits their use by terrorist groups. Iran’s potential action may serve as a strategic psychological maneuver to provoke a U.S. military escalation, especially given the president’s known sensitivity to threats. Meanwhile, President Trump’s upcoming meetings with Putin and Xi in China lack clear objectives, raising concerns about inconsistent foreign policy and the risks of engaging with pariah regimes. In Ukraine, criticism of deep strikes targeting Russian infrastructure has been challenged by defense officials like Elbridge Colby, who argue such attacks escalate conflict, though evidence shows Russia has long targeted civilian sites, undermining his claims. On the military front, Navy leadership testimony reveals serious issues with supply chains, food shortages, and mental health on ships—contradicted by dismissive language and "performance-based" responses. These deteriorating conditions, combined with the high cost of maintaining naval presence in volatile regions like the Strait of Hormuz, highlight a broader strategic failure. The episode underscores how asymmetric threats and poor policy coordination could destabilize U.S. military and political institutions, making long-term strategic reassessment urgent.
Hello, everybody. Welcome to Command Post. I am Andrew Eger filling in for the usual host of the show, Ben Parker, joined as always by General Mark Hurtling to talk about all the stuff that's going on in military news and foreign policy around the world today. General, thanks for coming on as always. Yeah, well, thank you for co you know, substitute hosting for my good friend, Ben Parker. He's getting some, as we call on the military, some R&R because he was, he needs some time with that little toddler that he has and it's good to have you taken his place and given him a chance to get some rest. Yeah, well, don't thank me yet. I mean, anytime Ben leaves, I feel like the just wheels start coming off all over the place around here because that guy's doing like 86 different tasks that people don't even necessarily realize he's doing until he's gone with my newsletter with shows like this all around the whole bulwark. He's sort of the, he's sort of like a load bearing pillar of the entire enterprise. But I as I often do when I when I end up having to host this show, you know, he knows everything about everything like you do. I'm more of like an idiot layman when it comes to all this stuff. So we take a little bit more of an idiot layman approach of you just sort of filling me in about a bunch of stuff, which hopefully is also helpful out there. And I wanted to start with some reporting that we got just this Monday out of CNN, very concerning reporting at least on its face and it's not quite clear, you know, how concerning or how freaked out we ought to be about this possibility. But it's exclusive US intel indicates Iran developing plans to potentially detonate a dirty bomb in Washington sources say. So of course, big headline, wow, that would be really bad if that were to happen. We have some audio of the president being asked about this yesterday. Let's just go ahead and play that quick. Iran, is there any imminent threat to Washington DC? Well, if there is, they will pay a price, the likes of which no country has ever paid before. But is there any reason? I hope it's not, but we take it very seriously because they happen to be crazy. But only because this is why they can't have a nuclear weapon by the like case of people that any questions. Now Mark, going from at least CNN's original reporting there, my read of that, it almost seems like the president was overstating the credibility of like an imminent threat here. I mean, can you just talk a little bit about what we do and don't know about this story and then we can maybe talk a little bit more abstractly about what a dirty bomb even is and what such an attack might look like if it were ever to take place. Yeah, well, the first thing I'm happy about to be honest with the Andrew is the president didn't say, oh gee, I hadn't heard about that as he but his response to me tells me that it is something they've discussed in the either the situation room or the Oval Office and he does know about it, although I'm not sure he comprehends exactly what it is. But then the second response of well, if they do, they're going to suffer the consequences is not really the kind of response I would have liked to appear, which is we're actively gaining intelligence on it and trying to prevent it as opposed to waiting until it happens and then bombing the hell out of Iran. Yeah, so it seems like it indicates that there is some type of threat, but when you go deeper into the CNN reporting, the article was a relatively short one. They had six sources from the intelligence community. They did not say which intelligence agency gave the four reporters the information, but basically they also said this is in the plans. It's not like it's going to be executed anytime soon, but there are indicators they are planning courses of actions to do it. And from the sources, they said they actually have potential locations for this to be planted, but I got to tell you that's really jumping far ahead of what could possibly be the truth behind this dirty bomb. Yeah, yeah, so let me just drill in on that a little bit, because I think it can be hard actually for people like me, for laymen, to really know what to do with these reports about what what essentially amount to contingency plans from from from from military leaks, military strategy leaks. I mean, like I think I think back to I believe earlier this year when there was a news report that that Canada was for the first time ever, you know, making military contingency plans for if America were to invade them over the border. And of course, that does say something about the state of the world, right? But it also doesn't necessarily mean we should be increasing our own threat assessment as we're just sort of sitting here thinking about what things to worry about in a given day that that that even necessarily needs to cross the threshold into something we're really thinking about at all, other than just has a fact of the world that we know about that this is going on in the military minds up there. Where does where does a report like this rank on that scale for you know, as we're just here. It is something where, you know, the military classifies threats when they get intelligence or information into three different categories, most likely most dangerous and least likely. Now, when you have something like this, it is probably falling into the least likely, but most dangerous category. I mean, the implications of having a dirty bomb explode in Washington DC is pretty significant. And truthfully, these are the same kind of early warnings, or as they call them in the intel community chatter that were that was occurring before 9/11, that something was going on. They weren't quite sure what it was. They're indicators of something to do with airplanes. So you really didn't have a whole lot of solid intelligence. So there are people, there are analysts in the various 18 intel agencies who were saying, hey, what am I looking for? If this is a potential operation conducted in the United States, what kind of thing should be looking for? And what I did yesterday, actually, Andrew is, I put together a short piece for the bulwark, which will appear either sometime today or tomorrow, about exactly the implications of something like this. Because there's a lot of dynamics of a so-called dirty bomb that, you know, just the phrase dirty bomb sounds kind of scary. And when it's tied to radioactivity, you get a little bit nervous. But what's the rest of the story? Has there ever been one of these before? What kind of damage could it cause? What kind of fear factor? It's a terrorist weapon. No doubt about that. But I think we need to need a little bit more about it. And that's what we can talk about now. Sure. Well, let me just go right to not to spoil your whole piece for future website readers. But I do think that, you know, people have a mental picture for what a nuclear weapon would look like. And they know what conventional bombs look like. I mean, the idea of a dirty bomb is more, you know, theoretical in people's minds. So can you just talk a little bit about like, and again, I don't want to overstate this. This is a very hypothetical possibility. This is not like something that's that the people consider imminent at all. But if Iran were to try to carry, or any actor were to try to carry out an attack like this in DC, what, what do we think that would entail? What, what, what, what, what would the explosion look like? What would the aftermath be? Well, like you were saying, I mean, most people when you talk about radioactive or nuclear weapons, they think about the film that everyone has seen on Hiroshima or Nagasaki, where there's this mushroom cloud coming out and the blast and the radiation effect. So heat blast and radiation are the three components of any kind of nuclear weapon, whether it's hitting the ground above ground or anything like that. That's not what this would be. When you're talking about a dirty bomb, and I'll just give my layman's approach, I've never seen one, never worked with one, because there haven't been a whole lot around. There's been a couple that we can talk about in a minute. But it would likely be radioactive material, not the same kind you would use in a nuclear weapon, but actually potentially even radioactive waste, mixed in a container with some type of explosive device, TNT, a fertilizer, it would be, it would be the equivalent of an improvised explosive device. And the blast of that weapon would be however much TNT or explosives syntax that they put in to the container that was going to explode. Let's think about the potential of the, people remember the Boston Marathon bomber. Those were cookers, small, literally pots that someone had mixed a device into and they exploded under pressure and damaged a whole lot of people, because they included ball bearings and screws and they acted as shrapnel. Instead of acting as shrapnel, a dirty bomb might have that same kind of explosive device, but with radioactive material that will spread and over either a larger or a small area. Now all of that depends on the size of the explosive. If you get a stick of TNT mixed with some radioactive material and explodes, you're going to get the effects of a stick of TNT and you're likely not even going to see the radioactive stuff until you get some type of surveillance equipment that says, "Hey, there's radioactive dust in this area." So it would be contained in the explosive area or where the wind might blow it. Now those are all dangerous, but think about that. Andrew, you're talking about citizens who are going to be told, "Hey, a dirty bomb is just exploded with radioactive waste in it in Washington, DC." And if you live near DuPont Circle and it was blown up there, you're going to be concerned about it. You're going to say, "Oh, my gosh. Can I drink my water? Can I go outside? Can I take my baby for a walk?"
Those are all the kinds of terror aspects of something like this, so that's basically describes what the kind of weapon is and by the way, there have only been two. Through my research, I found there's only been two dirty bombs, both of them were found in diffused before they went off, both of them were in Russia in Russia. Both conducted by Chessian authorities, or Chessian terrorists, and both of them were found before they went off, they were diffused, so we really never know what would happen if they would have exploded. Can I just ask, and maybe this is a silly question, but why is it that this is not something that we have seen groups that want to inspire terror reach for more often? Is it just that they're difficult to sort of assemble and handle and bring around and that it's like, why do you think we haven't seen more before? Well, they're hard to put together. If you're a terrorist and you want to put together a dirty bomb, you're going to be handling radioactive waste to put it in with the explosive device. You're going to be transporting radioactive waste, so it's going to be in the back of your car or in an airplane, and that will send off signals. So those are all the kinds of things that you talk about where you're not only handling the stuff as the individual putting it together and you're going to probably have some kind of radioactive poisoning, but it's going to be easier to pick up by various devices. So those are probably the two key reasons. Yeah. So setting aside the logistics of that, let me just ask you a little bit about the psychology of Iran here, because I think, like you said before, it would be good for Trump to be more focused on the interception and prevention of these sorts of plans than the promises of future retribution. But there would be future retribution. I mean, it would be -- this is something that the experts in the CNN article are unanimous on, and it just seems obvious that if Iran were to carry out an attack like this, it would be an escalation in the war that we would then further escalate far beyond what we have seen yet. Do you think that there's going to be -- I guess just how do you assess the psychology of Iran's leadership here? Do you think that they, in theory, could be willing to push things this far with their backs against the wall or is this more like, you know, again, just for a contingency planning here? Yeah, I think you have to consider it as a potential contingency, and here's why. They know the psyche of our president. They know exactly what he's going to do next. They know that even a small device in Washington that's called a dirty bomb because it spreads a little bit of radio activity is going to be seen by the American people of, hey, the president now really has to do something. You know, this is beyond the pale. We've now been attacked. It is their response in an asymmetric way, which we're seeing more and more of, of, you know, using the psychology of the individual they're going against to persuade him to do more things, commit more troops, and, you know, the president has said multiple times that he's potentially considering invading Iran. And if he did do that, what are the repercussions of that? How much would it draw America into a fight that would be much more devastating to the military forces and our national image than what we saw in Iraq? I mean, you're talking about a country as we said a couple of times it's Iran that's three times bigger than Iraq that has 92 million people, which is much larger than Iraq, and we were in Iraq for 14 years. Imagine the fact that Iranian citizens are going to see this as an even more of an existential threat, and they're going to have insurgencies within that country, which would damage a conventional force that we might send in. This is not something you can deal with with special operators. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I sure hope we will not ever get to the point where we have to be, you know, contemplating these hard decisions. And again, this is a report specifically about Iranian planning to do this that we have intelligence on, and it remains to be seen whether they would ever even try, let alone succeed in pulling that off, but thanks for General Hurtling for breaking that story down. I want to turn now off of Iran and our conflict there. Go a little north of their little east. Donald Trump is in Asia this week. He's stopped in the Philippines yesterday. He's heading through a couple of these conferences, but the big headline event comes tomorrow when President Trump is planning to have, is reported to be having a one-on-one meeting with President Putin in China. And then there's also going to be this trilateral meeting with Trump and Putin and Chairman G of China. What are you looking at? What are you expecting to see? What are you hoping to see or fearing to see out of this trilat? Can you just sort of talk us through that? Well, you know, this is tough, Andrew. I mean, I tried to think about what is happening because whenever a key figure, like a president of the United States, goes to meet with foreign leaders, the State Department and the National Security apparatus usually puts together what the objectives of the visit are. We don't know what the objectives are. He's about to shake hands in this photograph with a guy who has become a pariah on the world stage, who has conducted criminal activities in terms of an invasion, who has an indictment by the Hague against some of his actions of committing war crimes. And standing next to him is a guy that seems to be doing his very best and that's President Xi to co-op some of our intellectual property in terms of artificial intelligence chips. So my question would be and by the way, let's add another figure to this. The president says he also wants to meet with Kim from North Korea. What are the objectives there? Because the last time he met with him, which was six years ago, there were all kinds of promises about Kim eliminating his nuclear program. And yet in the last couple years, the North Koreans have sent soldiers to Russia to fight against Ukraine. They have continued to test ballistic weapon system. They have continued to expand their nuclear program. So those objectives weren't met. So I'm going to go back in a way to answer your question is, what do you think we want from this? I don't know. I mean, it seems like what the president has mostly talked about when he's in a domestic environment are some of the buildings that he's setting up his his teleport is, you know, his ballroom and the renovation of the West Wing. So what he said in terms of what he wants is a big parade when he gets there, which he got yesterday. A grand welcoming ceremony. There's going to be lunches, but my question is, what are his talking points? What are his objectives? What has his staff prepared for him in a book where he says, this is what I want to get out of this visit with all these Asian nations? I don't know because he's dealing with a guy who's been at war against one of our partners in Ukraine, and another guy who's stealing our intelligence in terms of artificial intelligence chips. Is he going to scold them? Not likely. Is he going to make some kind of new deal? Not likely. Are they going to try and play him? Absolutely, because that seems to be the effect we see in every single time. And this is not Trump derangement syndrome playing out here. There has been nothing from the administration saying what it is the president is trying to achieve in this visit. Yeah, I haven't read anything. Have you read anything? No, no, you're you're right about that. I mean, I think when you when you listen to the specific things that the president himself has said, it's been very strange to see because the the biggest thing that he has been at pains to tell reporters is the stuff that he's eager not to talk about. I mean, he's explicitly said repeatedly that he doesn't think that the Ukraine war will come up in his conversations with Putin. I kind of think Putin disagrees with that. By the way, I think Putin will jump to the opportunity to like continue to bend Trump's ear like he always does about how so. And probably say things like you're two guys with cough and Kushner are doing a great job. They're really super and we all know they're not. So anyway, I'm sorry, I interrupted, but that's that case with Putin. Yeah, so 100% and then and then with she, I mean, we heard just yesterday. I think it was just yesterday when when Trump was weighing in on this Nvidia scandal and and the internal rifts in his administration over how hard. How hard of a policy posture they want to have toward China, which is directly working against U.S. policy. I mean, it has been U.S. policy to keep the most advanced Nvidia chips, AI chips out of Chinese hands because of the importance to the U.S. of maintaining a technological advantage over China in the AI race. And it of course has been the policy of China to try to get around those controls anyway they can and everybody knows this and they've had a lot of success in that, by the way, China has. But when but when Trump is asked about this yesterday, he sort of explicitly made the point that that, you know, there's a there's a faction within the White House that wants to take a more conciliatory stance on this issue because they don't want it to be an impediment to making some different kind of deal with China. And it's like, well, one other kind of deal with China is more important than this one. I mean, like this is this is sort of like one of one of the things separating you, but it seems like he's still thinking about, you know, a trade relationship and, and these, you know, rare words and who knows what, what all else. and who knows what, what all else. But it's just, it is very strange, like, like what you,
what you just said about that the asks are not obvious. And in fact, most of what we're hearing from Trump is, well, don't expect me to ask about these key issues because I don't want to make waves. I mean, is sort of the vibe that he is giving going into these talks. - And if he doesn't ask about those key issues from those two individuals, the next question would be, okay, well, what is it you are going to talk about? Are you just going to listen to them? Because they certainly have an agenda. These two guys, Qi and Putin, have been the leaders of their country for multiple decades now and they know diplomacy and they know how to get away with things. That's the danger of all this. And Andrew, if I can, I'll add one more thing to this. Well, while we were talking about what's going on in the East, Elbridge Colby, who's the Undersecretary of Defense for Policy, has been talking in Ukraine. Now, for those of us, for our listeners who don't know who Elbridge Colby is, he's a guy who is an extreme Chinese hawk. And so he has now shifted the dynamics to Ukraine while all of this is going on. And it's perhaps because the president is not being as tough on China as a lot of people would have liked him to have been and which our national security documents that were written by the State Department and the Defense Department all say that China is our number one foe. And yet, we're going in there with open arms. It makes no sense to me. Yeah, I want to drill a little bit more into this. Elbridge Colby stuff and these questions of Ukrainian strikes into Russia in a minute. Before we do that, let's play a quick ad and then we'll talk more about that subject. So far, as you know, is my favorite time of year. The weather gets cooler. The leaves start changing, football's back, even if you have to watch teams like mine, the giants. And already Thanksgiving is coming up. There's just so much to look forward to, and honestly, the last thing I want is to spend a week stuck in bed when I could be out enjoying that perfect fall weather, got my little vest on, came my coffee, breathing in, that crisp air. I want to make the most of the season. And that starts with taking care of my health. Of course, when life gets busy staying on top of doctor's appointments and routine care, can easily fall to the bottom of the to-do list. That's one reason I love Zack Doc, which is today's sponsor. It makes finding the right doctor and actually getting an appointment so much easier. You can search for in-network doctors near you, you can see their real-time appointment availability, and you could choose from more than 150,000 providers across more than 200 specialties nationwide. Plus, you can read reviews from real patients to help find a doctor who is right for you. And the best part about it, it's completely free to use. Taking care of yourself shouldn't feel like a full-time job. So if you've been putting off that appointment, well, now's a great time to get it done. Head to Zack Doc.com/Boretakes to find a doctor and check that appointment off your to-do list. That's z-o-c-d-o-c.com/Boretakes. - I'm not sure what Tom, what I'm sorry. I'm not sure what Sam was talking about about the giants. They aren't they like first in the NFC East. I think all the cowboys and the commanders and eagles are all having these nightmare seasons that I have to do it by. I don't know whatever. I guess it's old habits, diehard complaining about this. Are you an NFL guy? - I am, but my team kind of went away. So I just, I kind of go with the Kansas City cheese. - That's what, were you a Rams guy before? - I was, oh, most definitely a Rams guy. - Okay, very likely I'll never say anything good about the Rams anymore since they moved back after two Super Bulls in St. Louis. - 100%, although I weirdly kind of backed back into an appreciation for the Rams by accident, even though I hated them after moving because I went to school in Michigan. I really liked Matt Stafford. And then when he went out, I was like, all right, all right, it's true, it's true, it's with the Rams. But I'm right there with you anyway. That's not how you're more there. I wanted to talk about some of these strikes. This, specifically we just had, we just saw this Ukrainian strike on the Kirch bridge. President Vladimir Zelensky on November 17th said key but carried out an unprecedented attack on a key bridge linking Moscow annexed Crimea to Russia to avenge Russian strikes on Ukrainian infrastructure. So, you know, you can see it right there. Pretty good hit on that bridge. And let's now turn to Elbridge Colby, who you mentioned before. He is here sort of pouring cold water on the whole idea of these strikes. So let's listen to Bridge Colby. - Is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line. Moreover, such strikes, especially those that target civilian infrastructure such as wild berries, have actually probably hardened the Russian public's resolve and the Kremlin's own willingness to escalate. Moreover, it is important to note that the balance of advantage in deep strikes may well favor Moscow. This is not to say that Ukraine should be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back. Rather, what we should be clear about is that the focus of our support should be on enabling and advancing Ukraine's ability to hold the line of battle and where possible make gains. What do you make of that line from Elbridge Colby? - It is ludicrous. This is an individual who doesn't understand the intent and purpose of deep strikes, what they do to an enemy that is continuing to push people into the front lines. And what Colby is basically saying is, fight close, fight them when they come up to your nose. Well, Ukraine has been, and the other thing, I mean, just some of the commentary of him. Actually, you know, the words actually probably, you know, I don't know what that means. You know, this is a guy who's supposed to be semi-diplomat, but also knows something about military operations, and it's obvious that he doesn't. And a strike on wildberry, wherever he was speaking, I'm not sure where the venue was, but that would invoke higher because wildberries is the Russian equivalent of Amazon. The difference is that wildberry is also shipping parts for Russian drones and other military equipment to different agencies. So it is, in my view, a valid target. And that's tough to say without a whole lot of details, but it's also an indicator of what President Zelensky and his military are attempting to do. They are actually trying to pull forces off the front line, because when you take air defense equipment or artillery equipment or protective forces away from the front line to defend in the rear areas where the deep strikes are hitting, that allows you to regain ground. So it is a complimentary effect, and this is something that I guess Mr. Colby really truly doesn't understand. And, you know, I try to not be as passionate as I could be, but this was just a ridiculous statement on the part of our under-secretary defense for policy. And it's not because he's not a smart guy. He just is leaning as many in the administration are toward favoring Russian activity. And this, by the way, I mean, he's saying, hey, don't hit civilian infrastructure like wildberries, we're at the same time Russia over the last couple weeks have continued to strike schools, hospitals, apartment buildings, energy resources inside of Ukraine. He never mentioned any of that. And that just is amazing to me. - Well, and I wanted to ask you about that bit too, because the strategic argument that he lays out there is that by doing these deep strike attacks, Ukraine is actually sort of giving Russia permission to do the same, and that sort of suggests, and we've seen a lot of this from the administration suggests that Russia is taking its cues for what lines it can and can't or should or shouldn't cross from what Ukraine is doing to it. I mean, is there any reason to believe that that's true, or is it, I mean, again, in sort of my lay view, it seems like it's been sort of the opposite. I mean, it's been Russia's been pushing the envelope and it's Ukraine that's been responding, but it doesn't really seem as though Russia's saying, well, now that you've hit our civilian infrastructure, now we're really taking the gloves off in terms of bombing your apartment buildings and hospitals. - Yeah, Russia has been doing it for five years. They have been bombing civilian infrastructures and committing war crimes. And I think you could defend everything that Ukraine is done in an international court saying, these are dual-purpose facilities that are, yes, they are civilian infrastructure, but they are giving support to the military advances of Russia. And the other thing I just go back to, Andrew, is Russia invaded a sovereign territory. I mean, this is on them from the very beginning, and while doing that, they've killed and captured a lot of, and taken on board a lot of civilians that they shouldn't have done. So I don't give any value to any of that argument. I haven't from the beginning of the Trump administration. - Yeah, yeah. It's weird to even remember, at least for me, it's weird to remember that there are guys like Elbridge Colby out there, because it's like this relic of a few years back this version of conservative military foreign policy thought. And I don't know how you felt about it at the time, but it was this idea that didn't seem completely in reasonable on its face that we just, we keep getting mired in these Middle East conflicts. I mean, while China is completely ascendant, and we just need to find a way to get out of Europe, get out of the Middle East, and just really recalibrate toward China. And none of that seems like it's gone away, but it's weird to think about that now, especially in light of, you know, the summit we were just talking about where it's
you know, suddenly it's Trump and G and Putin kind of all paling around. It just sort of scrambles the whole picture of what that pivot was supposed to be about. Yeah, it also just gets back to the importance of allies and an understanding of foes. What are our national ideals? What are our values in terms of what we aspire to be and who we aspire to connect with? It is not with the pariahs who invade other countries. It is not with the individuals who steal our intellectual property and try and make it their own. It is with democratically like-minded nations that are trying to support their people. Neither one of the people that President Trump is shaking hands with are doing exactly that. They are in it for the wealth and the power and that just is contrary to what we say we believe is a country. I wanted to turn to something a little closer to home. Yesterday it was I believe Senate Armed Services Committee had the confirmation hearing for current acting secretary of the Navy hung cow who is sort of a friend of the show. I know you guys have talked about him a lot. He's been around the horn on bullwork products just because he is one of the more openly- I don't know- is it fair to call him basically openly maga as far as senior military leadership is concerned? I'll let you talk a little bit more about him just to kind of set the stage for this. He had a confirmation hearing yesterday which was just sort of a fascinating exercise in defense of the status quo across a whole bunch of axes here where of course the acting military leadership is going to try to put somewhat of a brave face on whatever is happening but it's just a lot of a lot of hard sound bites, a lot of tough clips for hung cow trying to justify a couple things that we'll talk through. But before we get to the clips can you just sort of set the table here of what his role has been as part of Pete Hagss military infrastructure? Well he is a retired Navy captain. He is I would say a hard conservative. He is bought into the maga agenda in a big way. He's admired by many in the Navy because he does have the credentials of being a naval captain. So I think he runs that middle ground between understanding the military but at the same time being ultra maga and supportive of the president's agenda 100%. So when you're talking about putting someone like that again another individual in a role where it's going to be sycophancy as opposed to supporting the organization you're putting charge of in the best possible way. This is one of the challenges we're facing. The other thing I'd say based on watching some of his hearing is he did not do very well in terms of communicating the intent for his desire to support the Navy. There were just some things from a senior, a former senior leaders perspective of mine in terms of how you take care of your individuals, how you take care of the force which is job one for the secretary of any branch of service. He did not cover himself with glory in some of the answers. He's taking on the role jumping from a Navy captain to be in charge of the man, equip and train the forces of the Navy. That was readily apparent that he hasn't made that leap in many of the answers that he gave to various senators yesterday. Yeah. Let's jump to a couple of those clips because there's one clip of him sparring with Senator Slotkin about the status quo in the straight-of-form moves. But we can wrap back around to that. I want to jump into what you're talking about here, which is it just seems as though there are certain morale problems, certain structural problems, certain problems of having difficulty keeping conditions for the troops good overseas that he comes across in these clips, at least in my view, as a little bit more of a PR agent for things are actually, if you think about it in such-and-such-a-light, maybe not nearly as bad as it's actually been alleged. But I shouldn't just ramble about it. Let's play these clips. These two clips we have here. Yeah. Every day I walk down to our watch floor when I get a brief on current conditions on boarder ships, and I look at the number of days of rations they still have left. Right now, the one that worries me most is USS Gonzales, a destroyer. They have about a week left. Usually, I don't like them to go below two weeks of supplies. Now, Gonzales, going to be- Do you know if those supplies that they have are actually adequate- Yes, to their needs? Senator, they are adequate. It might not be all the- How often does one of those ships get to zero? You say there's a week. Does it ever get down to zero? It has never gone to zero, Senator. Not once. Not no, Senator. So are you saying that these reports of somebody losing 45 pounds are not true? Well, Senator, it's just not what they want. It's like my kids opening up the refrigerator door and saying there's nothing in here. No, I don't think that's- Mr. Secretary, I don't- Somebody doesn't- Somebody doesn't lose 45 pounds just because they don't like the options. That was damning, Andrew. I'll just say, you know, it's like my kids saying there's nothing to eat in the fridge or in there. I mean, that's just ludicrous. There have been- The challenge now with military leadership is social media. And, you know, I experienced when I was still on command, you know, there were folks pasting pictures to Facebook and early days of Twitter. But there have been multiple instances, dozens of instances of sailors on board ships taking pictures of the food that's available. And it's not what you would be giving 18 to 22-year-old sailors that are working 12-hour shifts and spending time on ships. I mean, I know a little bit about the Navy, not much. I've been on a couple of ships. And what I do know is food, the mess, is the number one morale driver on any ship, you know. And some of the best foods are on submarines because they're under water most of the time and they have the best cooks. Some of the lesser- Well, I won't get into that. But when you're starting to talk about people writing home that they don't have anything to eat and is one reporter from MS now suggested a spouse of a sailor said, you know, my husband got his first apple in six months and he cried when he saw it. Those are the kind of stories that are not just anecdotal. They are indicators. And even when you have the secretary of the Navy saying, hey, I go to the watch floor and I see the status of the ships, why don't you take a visit out there? Why don't you do a surprise assault or ask your IGs to take a look for you? It isn't just the red amber or green ship status that are in your watch floor in the Pentagon. It's no kid in what's going on. You got to look beyond the indicators to see what's really happened. I think he would be very surprised. And it's the same thing with secretary Hegsha, same kind of thing. People can do push-ups or everything's okay. Yeah. Yeah. Let's hit. There's a second clip on that same theme. I believe still with still a senator Kelly. So let's hear this one too. Speaking of assessments, have you done a fleet wide assessment of the living conditions, supply shortfalls, mental health resources? We have, Senator. Again, this is why we have five, well, every small boy, all these older stories will have a one chaplain aboard. All the carriers have five chaplains, as well as as mental resiliency counselors, as well as the mental health specialist as well. So that's why you say eight suicides, I see eight suicide mitigations that were able to keep these young men and women. Okay. Well, it's actually both. There were eight individuals that tried to take their own lives. And it was mitigated. I'll give you that. Yes, sir. But we shouldn't have conditions where sailors are wanting to end their lives because of the deteriorating conditions aboard the ship. What do you make of that? Yeah. Well, first of all, the nominee acting secretary child used the wrong word. These are not suicide mitigations. They are suicide ideations. That means when an individual says, I'm going to take my life. It is then mitigated by the mental health team potentially. But when, as I think Secretary Senator Kelly said a little bit later on, no kid, you're going to tell me it's an ideation when a guy jumps overboard, or I'm sorry, it wasn't Kelly that said, I think it was Gillibrand that said that when a guy jumps overboard, what's he going to do? Swim the Guam to mitigate this. It's just that the answers are, you know, when you testify before Congress or members of Congress, as I have done on multiple occasions, you got to tell the truth. It doesn't matter your position. And like you said before, Andrew, this is performative. This is PR stuff. Hey, there are some major problems in the Navy. I know it from talking to my Navy friends. They don't have the capability to fix the ships that have been at sea for over a year. They don't have the dry docks to put them in. And yet they're still sending in the case of the Middle East right now. We have three carrier strike groups in that area. That is devastating from a strategic perspective. And what Senator Kelly, I think, was getting at were strategic questions. It isn't going down to the floor and saying, hey, what's the chart say? It's like, no shit, what's going on in your Navy? Because it doesn't seem to be
doesn't seem to be very good across the board with all the strategic ways it means that you have to operate a major force in the country. That by the way is going to likely be in the Middle East for a very long time. - Yeah, yeah, yeah. And it would be one thing, right? If it were clear that all of these difficulties that are piling up on our actual forces and these strategic problems for the Navy, if they were all in service of goals that we could all see and articulate and ends that they were plainly pursuing and hopefully would be close to achieving, but now I do want to circle back around to that clip from Alyssa Slocke and Senator Slocke and because I think that does kind of underscore how far from being true that is when it comes at least to this conflict in the Middle East and the basically babysitting mission that we are now having to do on a rolling basis in the straight of horror moves just to keep things barely chugging along. So let's hear from Senator Slocke. A year ago today did a ship, a commercial vessel carrying petroleum products, need a military escort through either the Babel Mendeb or the straight of horror moves. In all honesty. - Well, Senator, that's why their insurance rates is $54,000 just for one transit, but it's so dangerous over there, Senator. That's exactly why. - A year ago today where the insurance rates, you're dodging the question, a year ago today, a commercial ship flagged for any nation could successfully transit the Babel Mendeb and the straight of horror moves without a naval escort. - No, always. - Again, Senator, that insurance rate was a year ago, $54,000 today is $64 million just to get across. - I believe it 'cause we launched a war, okay? We launched a war and we do not have the same, we do not have the same freedom of navigation that we had a year ago. And it's not a, you don't have to be a defense professional to understand that. - Yeah, she blew that up. She allowed him to make her argument for her. And, you know, she is a defense professional. I mean, Senator Slacken's been in the CIA, the Department of Defense. She's been in combat zone multiple times. She knows what she's talking about. She's pretty smart. And he's trying to dodge the question. What's interesting to me on all of this, Andrew, is we're going to see more of this. Because what we've seen over the last two years with unfortunately a group of Republican congressmen, I'm not trying to say partisan issues, but it is that we're allowing this kind of BS to continue on. And I think what you now have is the potential for chairments when the new Congress seats to say, no, continue to answer the question. You can't get away with stonewalling or just given the hand wave or everything's okay because it's not okay. They're taking back over the role of oversight. And I hope this brings the Congress together a little bit more when there's a lot more common sense and logic associated with this 'cause that's what they're supposed to do. I mean, that's their power under article one. - Yeah, and unfortunately, I mean, it seems like there's going to be a lot to talk about because I mean, as they were just getting to in that clip, we really are still just in a headlock over there. I mean, the political pain that the president just suffered a couple of weeks ago from just the amount of economic damage that's already piled up from the closure of the straight-up form moves and the rest of the region. It's been so significant. And we're having to commit still extraordinary military resources over there just to keep it this good. And with all sorts of escalating problems because that's one of the big reasons why the deteriorating morale, the deteriorating condition on these ships is so significant because not just about what these people are suffering now, but it's about how long are we going to be around here having to do this exact mission? What's going to change? And we don't know what's going to change. I mean, it's just brilliant. - Alarm it. - It's interesting because if we go back to the hook of what we were talking about in the first segment on the dirty bombs, this is exactly an asymmetric method potentially of Iran saying, we're going to do something that is just so damaging to the United States terror network. I mean, it's so damaging to the institutional basis that the president's going to use his temper and invade us. And when he does, these kind of things where you've already basically contributed a good portion of the Navy are only going to increase. It's only going to cost more. There's only going to be more potential deaths and casualties among our service members. And it bleeds you dry. That's the purpose of asymmetric warfare to take your power and use it against you. So that's the thing I think we've got to be careful of. And with the president that just keeps saying we're going to bomb more to get out of this thing, it's not working and it won't work in the future. - Yeah, yeah. Well, I think that's a cheerful place as any to wrap up this extremely fun and exciting and really fun letting episode of Command Post. But this is important stuff. Thank you, General, as always, for coming on to talk us through all of it. And thanks to you all out there as well for watching, for listening, for subscribing, if you're not subscribed already. I've been told that I am always telling people to click a red button on YouTube. And I'm to my horror, I'm learning now that the subscribe button isn't red anymore. It's a white button in dark mode. And I guess a dark button if you're in light mode on your computer. So my bad, sorry if you've all been hunting for a red button for weeks and months as I've been saying this. But anyway, go subscribe to the feed if you are not. Ben Parker and General Hurtling will be back next week on Command Post and they and we will see you all there. Thanks a lot. - Thanks, thanks.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
CNN reported that U.S. intelligence indicates Iran is developing plans for a potential dirty bomb attack on Washington, D.C., though the threat is not imminent and remains in the "least likely, most dangerous" category.
A dirty bomb uses radioactive material mixed with explosives, not nuclear fission, and would cause contamination and fear rather than blast or radiation like a nuclear weapon; only two such devices have ever been diffused before detonation.
Such attacks are difficult to execute due to handling and transport risks, including detection by radiation monitors, and are not commonly used by terrorist groups.
Iran’s potential action may be a strategic asymmetric move to pressure U.S. leadership, exploiting the psychological impact of a perceived attack to provoke a disproportionate response.
The U.S. is facing a strategic dilemma in its Asia visit with Trump, where meetings with Putin and Xi lack clear objectives, and internal divisions over tech policy and military posture suggest a lack of coherent foreign policy.
Defense official Elbridge Colby criticized Ukrainian strikes on Russian infrastructure, arguing they worsen the conflict, but critics say his views ignore Russia’s ongoing attacks on civilian targets and misrepresent the military purpose of deep strikes.
The Navy’s operational conditions, including food shortages and mental health issues, have been highlighted in testimony, with reports of deteriorating morale and supply chains, raising concerns about force readiness.
The ongoing military presence in the Strait of Hormuz and the rising costs of navigation reflect a costly and unsustainable "babysitting" mission, which could be exploited in asymmetric warfare to destabilize U.S. military and political institutions.
Summary:
, though intelligence sources indicate it remains a low-probability, high-impact scenario. A dirty bomb, unlike a nuclear weapon, uses radioactive material mixed with explosives to spread contamination and induce fear, with only two prior incidents recorded—both neutralized before detonation. The difficulty in assembling and transporting such devices limits their use by terrorist groups.
S. military escalation, especially given the president’s known sensitivity to threats. Meanwhile, President Trump’s upcoming meetings with Putin and Xi in China lack clear objectives, raising concerns about inconsistent foreign policy and the risks of engaging with pariah regimes.
In Ukraine, criticism of deep strikes targeting Russian infrastructure has been challenged by defense officials like Elbridge Colby, who argue such attacks escalate conflict, though evidence shows Russia has long targeted civilian sites, undermining his claims. On the military front, Navy leadership testimony reveals serious issues with supply chains, food shortages, and mental health on ships—contradicted by dismissive language and "performance-based" responses. These deteriorating conditions, combined with the high cost of maintaining naval presence in volatile regions like the Strait of Hormuz, highlight a broader strategic failure.
S. military and political institutions, making long-term strategic reassessment urgent.
FAQs
A dirty bomb mixes radioactive material with an explosive, like TNT, to create a device that spreads radiation. The explosion itself would be similar to a conventional bomb, but the main danger comes from radioactive contamination spreading over an area, causing fear and health risks.
Yes, there have been only two known instances of dirty bombs. Both were discovered before detonation and were carried out by Russian authorities or terrorists. They were never successfully exploded.
While intelligence reports suggest Iran is planning such a scenario, it is not considered an imminent or likely threat. The U.S. intelligence community classifies it as 'least likely but most dangerous' due to the severe psychological and societal impact it could have.
Dirty bombs are difficult to assemble and handle because they require radioactive materials, which are hard to obtain and transport. They also trigger detection systems, and handling them poses serious health risks to the people involved.
The blast would cause damage similar to a conventional explosive, but the real threat would be radioactive contamination. This could lead to widespread fear, restrictions on water and food, and public health concerns, especially in nearby areas.
The U.S. sees these plans as strategic contingency scenarios, not immediate threats. Intelligence suggests Iran may be exploring options, but no evidence indicates a plan to execute such an attack soon.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.