Go back

How To Stay Sane, Rested, and Useful During Hard Times | Katherine May

1h 13m 19s

How To Stay Sane, Rested, and Useful During Hard Times | Katherine May

In this insightful conversation, Catherine May introduces the concept of "wintering" as a natural, recurring phase of life that reflects periods of hardship, emotional coldness, and stagnation. She argues that these times are not personal failures but common, biologically rooted experiences shared by all humans—much like how animals and plants endure winter. Rather than viewing such periods as setbacks, May emphasizes their transformative value, allowing individuals to deeply understand themselves and emerge with greater resilience. She critiques the culture of toxic positivity and social media, which often dismiss suffering as unworthy of attention, and advocates for authentic, face-to-face connection and real-life rituals that foster empathy and grounding. These rituals—like marking seasonal transitions, lighting candles, or swimming in cold water—serve as anchors to the present moment, helping people reconnect with awe, nature, and their own inner rhythms. May also highlights the dangers of performative wellness, which reduces self-care to spectacle and individual achievement, and instead promotes rest as a necessary, messy, and deeply human practice. Crucially, she asserts that true agency arises not from denial of pain but from accepting it, allowing space for emotional processing and deeper understanding. This acceptance, rooted in wisdom and humility, enables people to act meaningfully in the world—without being overwhelmed by fear. Ultimately, the message is that in times of crisis, whether personal or global, restoring balance through stillness, ritual, and connection is not indulgent, but essential for enduring and thriving.

Transcription

11528 Words, 60994 Characters

English
Hello, my fellow suffering beings. Welcome to the 10% Happier Podcast. I'm your host, Dan Harris. Winter is coming. I mean that literally, and I also mean it in a more figurative sense, that hard times are always on their way. Good times too, but hard times are inevitable. It's just a part of life. And there are ways to make hard times a little bit easier, to stay saner in these difficult moments. And I'm talking to one of the great experts in what is called wintering. That's the term she coined for hard times. Her name is Catherine May. She's the bestselling author of a book called Wintering, The Power of Rest and Retreat in Difficult Times. Very excited to bring you this conversation. One little caveat, though, before we dive in. If you're watching, you'll notice the video quality is a little lower on this one. Please don't let that get in the way, though, of a conversation that I think will be quite impactful. Here we go with Catherine May. Catherine May, welcome to the show. Oh, thank you for having me. Pleasure to have you here. Let me start with a very basic question, which is, what is wintering? So wintering is a kind of dual purpose word, really. It partly refers to the way that animals and plants survive the winter out in the wild. But it also is something that I use to think about how we endure the times in life when we feel like winter has arrived for us. So the times when we feel frozen, or out in the cold, there's loads of different ways that that comes to us. But I think it's a word that's got real resonance for how those times can feel. Yeah, as I was preparing for this and thinking about the term wintering, it struck me that it's kind of the rough patches, sometimes even worse than rough, the inevitable downturns that all of us face. Yeah, that's right. I think I really wanted to make the point that winter is a kind of dual purpose word. I think I really wanted to make the point in the book that when those times come to us, it's not because we've uniquely failed somehow. And we're not the only ones that have ever either screwed up or had life kind of turn against us, although it can feel incredibly isolating. But actually, these periods of wintering are a normal part of life. And they're in fact quite valuable when we look at them in the long term. In the short term, they're hideous. Wretched. No question. Wretched is a good word. Yeah. Yeah, but I find it and I think this is your intent, really liberating and comforting to know that you have now named this thing and that it's a part of life. It is quite literally nature. And we don't need to view it as some sort of, as you said, personal failing. And I think underlying that conclusion that many of us reach about it. Being a personal failing is this fallacy that life will be an escalator of uninterrupted progress. But that's just not how it goes. I think underlying that conclusion that many of us reach about it. And also another aspect to social media, which is that we can be kind of brutal to people who are bringing the mood down. You know, there's, I talk a bit in the book about toxic positivity and that, that throwing of slogans at people who are unhappy, you know, to tell you to kind of look on the bright side or to, to keep going or to keep striving. And actually what we're really, really bad at on social media is listening. You know, social media is broadcast mode. And it's also people showing up on social media. And it can just be a few hours. They can be a few days. They can be a year. I think one of the challenges is that social media is a narrative form, essentially. We're storytelling when we're on there. And narratives of depression or illness or failure are frustrating narratives to follow because they're quite monotonous. And that's why they're so hard to live through. And I think that's why they get so roundly rejected on social media because they're so monotonous. Because they don't pique interest in us. They don't inspire us. They don't uplift us. But they're also often not particularly dramatic either. And so we don't interest ourselves in them. And I just think, yes, please do share the next time you're having a downturn because it's so valuable to people. I know you do a great job of that anyway. But I think this is where the value of real life contact comes in too. Because I think we behave very differently towards each other. Face to face. I think we listen better. Looking around me at all the trees with no leaves. And I remember as a child thinking that trees actually died in winter and came alive again in the summer. And actually what happens is that they shed their leaves as an act of efficiency so that they're using less energy during the winter. But when we think about what those trees are doing, they're actually the heart and soul of the forest. Their roots are holding the ground together. They're hosting all kinds of hibernating creatures. And particularly insects. They are massing their energies for the next burst of life. And in fact, their buds are already in place by the time those leaves drop off, which I never noticed until I wrote about it in wintering. So there's one really great example of how nature gives us a kind of guide to how we compare back to and how even when we feel like all of our leaves have blown off, that actually we're still doing important work. Yeah. Hibernation, which is a source of great fascination to children always. But when I was researching wintering, I got to hold a hibernating dormouse. And I think you have dormice in America, do you? They are these incredibly cute little kind of amber coloured rodents. And what that really showed me that I'd never understood before was how cold a hibernating animal is. A hibernating dormouse had dropped its temperature down to four degrees centigrade, so just above freezing. And it felt ice cold in my hand, but it was still alive. And there was something that really struck me in that moment about what it really means to pull in all of your unnecessary parts for a little while in order to wait it out until the next phase, which is often what we do in winter. It's too hard for us to be going out in the winter. uh, talk about in the book. I quite like the phrase multifactorial debacle for describing my life that year. I wish I'd thought of that. That's how it felt. Yeah, I mean, I feel like I've wintered many, many times over, you know, and I, growing up as a sort of undiagnosed autistic girl, I found life incredibly difficult, but didn't have a way to express it. I'd had big phases of illness, which came from exhaustion by the time I hit my late teens. And when I was 17, I had a phase of such serious depression that I really didn't know how I'd come back into the world again. But what was interesting about that was that when I did re-emerge after a very long time, I felt like I'd come into contact with my survival instinct in quite a passive way, you know, not in the way that you hear about survival instincts, you know, when people claw their way out of a pile of rubble or whatever, but actually just this sense of clinging on when life felt almost unendurable for a very long time. And that pattern continued through my twenties and thirties. And when I came to write Wintering, I meant to write a book looking back over those times from like the high ground and think and be like, well, everything's fine now, but you know, this is, this is my story. But in fact, while I was trying to write the book, this series of disasters kept coming at me. So first of all, I decided to quit my job because the stress had got so great. Then my husband had a very dramatic appendicitis, like burst appendix, very seriously ill, severe sepsis, absolute nightmare. Once he pulled through, I fell really ill. And then I, it meant that I couldn't work out the rest of my life. And I was like, well, I'm going to have to work out the remaining months of my job. So that felt very humiliating and very difficult, very uncertain about how we'd survive. And then coming to the end of that, my son stopped coping being at school and we had to pull him out. And so it just felt like we were the disaster family for quite some time. And in fact, it was so, it was, I mean, this is the kind of thing that only a writer can say, but it was actually quite helpful going through that as I was writing the book, because you forget the rawness of those times and the huge mix of emotions that come into those moments. That sense of humiliation is so great. And that sense of wanting, like giving everything in your power to claw your way out of it, but nothing working. And yeah, so the book was written from the eye of the storm. If you like. Yeah. Was there any relief in hitting a bottom and just being like, all right, well, okay, this, here I am, this kind of sucks instead of the clawing and scrambling? Yeah. I mean, I think as with being in quicksand, you know, the clawing and scrambling makes it a lot worse, but of course it's human to do it. And we do try everything, but there's something about accepting that space. Because one of the things that happens is, you know, you're not going to be able to do it. You're not going to be able to do it. is that space opens up. We're often kind of outside of mainstream society. I find it always useful to make sure I get outside every day, whether through good times and bad, actually, that it helps in the happy times and it helps in the bad times too. And that's one of the things that kind of punctuates the book really is me getting out, walking, swimming in the sea, which is a couple of minutes from my front door, which I love getting into, noticing the minute changes around me, actually, and the way that nature was working its own way through winter, as I was also working my way through too. And I think also finding the kind of weird moments of joy that come up during those times. They're different to the joy in good times, but they were many moments when I thought, actually, I'm strangely happy in this place. I feel calm and comfortable and kind of pristinely sad. And I think a lot of the book is about allowing sadness to be a safe space, really, trusting it. I think that's such an important thing to learn to do. Obviously, what I'm about to say is going to involve a lot of projection. So please correct me inappropriately. First of all, I love the phrase pristinely sad. And this will just echo the question, my last question. But I'm hearing again that after we go through the quite natural phase of clawing and scrambling, it sounds like I can imagine a peace in the surrender of, here we are, it's winter. And yeah, like I can be, sad without the scramble. And there's an odd bittersweetness in that. I love the bittersweetness idea. Yeah. I mean, I think I quote Alan Watts at the end of the book, who says, I'm very bad at remembering quotes, but something like running from fear is fear, running from pain is pain. And I think a lot of the agony of these times is our denial of the more difficult feelings that come up. And actually, if we can make sense of that, make space to let those really challenging feelings visit us, that's often exactly what we need. Because what's really happening in a wintering is that we are transforming somehow. It's not always a positive transformation. You know, it's not always wanted. It's not always welcome. And we don't, despite a whole world of positive self-help out there, we don't always come out from a wintering better. For example, all of us one day will confront a decline in our health. But what we can reach is a place of acceptance of where we are, of understanding of it, and have a kind of a scheme for how we're going to live with the life that we are given right now, rather than the life that we're wishing for. Well, I'm sorry to be so positive, but isn't, isn't that better? We may not be healthier. We may not be richer, but we, we can be better having gone through this crucible or crucibles. Yeah, absolutely. I think, you know, I mean, I know you spend a lot of time kind of musing on the word happiness and what it, what it means to build happiness. I think a great source of happiness is knowing who you are and what you are at this point in your life. It's a kind of car, arm contentment. And it doesn't mean that life is in any way perfect. And it doesn't mean that life has stopped being challenging. But it is about what is. And I, you know, we live in this world that doesn't really ever acknowledge the is-ness of disability, for example, of long-term illness, of, of loss, of genuine loss. And yet, nobody comes out of their wintering unchanged. And I think when you talk to people about the most vile moments in their life, which I've now done over and over again, what always kind of astonishes me is they, they don't regret it ultimately. They don't regret that awful time because it forged who they are now. And that's all, that's all we have. We only have that, that present self. We can't cling to those past ones. So we're in the often tricky and misunderstood territory now of acceptance, aren't we? It's hard, isn't it? I mean, that, we are surrounded by examples of non-acceptance in this world. You know, we are surrounded now by AI-generated images of a much more perfect, smooth world. We're surrounded by modified faces of bodies. We're surrounded by a public sphere where most kinds of people are actually invisible, you know, where we don't really see carers, where we don't really see the chronically ill, where we don't really see the disabled. You know, these people are not shown to us. And so when we become them, which most of us do on some level at some part in our lives, we really struggle with that acceptance because we lack those, those mirrors on us. And so when we become them, when we become ourselves, nevertheless, our work is acceptance. And one of the ways that we can do that, I think, is to look around us authentically, to step out of the very glossy, fake spaces that we consume and to actually look down our streets and see our neighbours. And we will immediately then see those mirrors that we really need to reach that place of calm. I'm surprised you that I completely agree with you. We need to step out of the hall of mirrors. I'm preaching to the choir. I think. Yeah. Yeah. Well, but but it's, you know, I actually have no problem with preaching to choirs because we just need to hear it over and over again. So because of the power of human forgetting is so power is so strong. If you're a regular listener of this show, you know that we're always adding amazing new teachers and new guided meditations and hosting live sessions over on my app, which is called 10 percent with Dan Harris. What you might not know is that we also now have a full library of not just guided meditations, but also short courses and challenges. We've got a meditation masterclass with Joseph Goldstein. We've got Sharon Salzberg covering the eightfold path. We've got Diana Winston with her reset challenge. And next week we are dropping a new course from Sharon Salzberg and Andy Gonzalez. It's called Taking Care of Yourself So You Can Take Care of the World. It's an eight part course to help you develop skills for resilience and clear seeing. And remember that you're really no good to anybody if you're not taking care of yourself and your mind. You can get started taking care of your own mind by signing up for 10 percent with Dan Harris at DanHarris.com. But so what I was trying to pull off there was to to plus one, what you're saying about the power of stepping out of the digital hall of mirrors as a way to get in touch with reality. But also then to pivot to one of the main beefs. One of the main beefs. You hear when you bring up the subject of acceptance is, well, you, Dan, you, Catherine, are talking about passivity, about being a doormat in an era when unacceptable things are happening all around the world and acceptance, you know, sounds unacceptable in in that context. But, yeah, I say acceptance. I mean, like not being at war with reality in this moment, seeing things clearly as they are. And then from. From that, I think, wiser space, choosing how to respond. Yeah, I agree. I always differentiate between control and agency. I find that a really helpful kind of distinction to make, you know, that one of the things that makes us miserable is believing that we have control, which we just don't. The world is out of our control. Unfortunately, it would be so great, wouldn't it, if it were, but it isn't. What we do have is agency. And that agency can only come from seeing the world as it is and from really understanding it, because we can only take effective action. And to give a kind of real world example, yeah, we are all watching the news right now and feeling horror about so many different things and that horrible sense of powerlessness. That is the truth, though, right? We are actually quite powerless, but we can exercise our agency in lots of different ways. To do what we can in those situations, whatever that choice is, we can, you know, we can donate money, we can give our time, we can realise that we can't affect the thing that we're seeing on the news, but perhaps we can affect something closer to home. You know, there's loads of different things that we have agency to do, despite ultimately not having control over it. I would say that that's different to not seeing the world as it is. And therefore, not thinking that. Anything's wrong at all or not even being aware of it. Like that's that's the difference that I think we're making, that actually we can't take any effective action if we don't feel that powerlessness in the first place, because it's the same as just not engaging with the situation at all. What you're saying, which again, I completely agree with, reminds me of the way Buddhists talk about the difference between empathy and compassion. Yes. Yeah. So empathy is, you know, feeling in this context would be like feeling all the powerlessness and rage that we feel when we look at the news. Compassion is empathy plus agency. OK, well, I have some amount of power and influence in my sphere, whatever that sphere is. And so I will do my best with whatever. I have that's agency and I don't have full control, but it allows me to metabolize all of my feelings and not be swamped in them. I love that. It makes me think about existentialist philosophy, actually, and Sartre saying that even in the most confined circumstances, there's always choice that those choices may be minute, but there's always choice that we take. And I just think that. Looking at the people I know who've affected the most change or been the most, you know, really shown that compassion in action. It doesn't come from a disengagement with how the world actually is. It comes from a profound engagement. And often they've moved through that sense of helplessness first before they've began to think, but actually, but actually, but actually. Here's what I can do. And so, yeah, I'm I'm actually OK with people thinking that it's passive because sometimes that passivity is the phase that we need to be in in order to listen and in order to. I mean, another another concept that I would draw from Buddhism, particularly from the Zen peacemakers and the philosophy of not knowing that's the first action, that's the first stage. And taking meaningful social action is going back to a place of not knowing so that you can truly listen and truly acknowledge the smallness of who you are in order to then move into something that is meaningful social action. Everything about our modern world is pushing us toward knowing right certainty that, you know, those are the bad guys. We're the good guys. This is right. This is right. Wrong. Bright lines everywhere. And and what the Buddha called for and and and the Zen Buddhists really, really highlight this is a profound not knowing open mindedness. And it's not to it's not to encourage you to drop your values. There are some things we know, you know, killings, stealing. These are hopefully. Hopefully we still know that. Yeah. Well, the sane among us know this. The people listening to this show. Yeah. And so we're not saying, you know, when the Zen folks are talking about not knowing there, they don't mean abandon all of your values. And, you know, it's, you know, inescapably postmodern or whatever. It's like really, you know, not knowing. And that being the place of action as opposed to certainty and dogmatism is is really. Really interesting and I think quite effective. I think so. And I think that I really admire people that go through values change as well, actually. I mean, there are there are people who listen hard enough to let their center shift, which has to be admired. I mean, obviously, I think there's a right and a wrong direction that because I have a sense of value, but it also it also makes me think about sorry to, you know, we're reeling out the kind of Buddhist concepts, but the idea of the beginner's mind and how valuable it is to. Approach something. From the start, from a kind of place of emptiness almost. And the way that we approach learning as a beginner is so much more effective and thoughtful and humble than how we approach the world if we think we know about it already. And as we get older, it gets harder and harder to step in that mindset. But that's that's often what I'm interested in in doing in my writing, certainly, is to try and reverse. Reverse back through all my assumptions and think, wait, what if I didn't know anything about this at all? Where would I where would I go? Let me run this by you. This is from Sharon Salzberg is an amazing teacher. Yeah. And she has this whole riff about how. We we and this is true in periods of wintering, and this is true, I think, for many of us in moments of political tumult, we we grasp towards certainty because we. Think that's what's going to make us feel better, but most of us embrace the kind of certainty that is apocalyptic. We think we know how things are going to go and they will suck, but so therefore Sharon's thesis is the not knowing is where the real freedom creativity, to use your word again, agency lies. Yeah, yeah, I think that's so true. And I I'm actually really. Tired of these apocalyptic visions. You know, I I hear them every day, this sense of absolute hopelessness, this sense that the world is ending at the moment that we're at the end of history. I mean, for a start, if you basically study any history, you'll understand that we always think we're at the end of history. We always think that disaster is imminent. But also, I've got no interest in the people who are giving up right now. I've got a lot of interest in the people. Who are not even necessarily expressing hope, but they're just taking the next step forward. just doing what has to be done. They're taking care of people. They are taking the action that is presented in front of them. Again, a lot of people would see that as terribly passive, but those are the people holding the world together right now. And always. I've said, I agree with you so many times in this podcast, but I wonder if we've now reached. I'd love to hear it, Dan, honestly. I don't get that much at home, you know? It really is a great manipulation tactic to just say, I agree with you, even if you don't. I have not done that here. I'm wondering whether we are in the realm of a mild disagreement, though. I agree with you. The most interesting people really are the folks who are just taking that next step forward. This has become so cliche now, but the Mr. Rogers thing of looking for the helpers. Yeah, look for the helpers, yeah. I do have. I do have interest in the people who are giving up, not because I think that's the move, but because I think we need to rile them up. We need to get them off the couch. And I think that. I think people are giving up because they've fallen into the trap of getting exercised and freaked out over and over and over and then bumping up against reality and realizing there's not much they can. or concluding there's not much they can do about it, when in fact, actually, the real model is the folks that you're interested in who are just doing the next right thing. And that is available to all of us. It's the hidden work, isn't it? It's the hidden work of carers, of, you know, the people who work in our social services, who work in our hospitals, who work in our schools, who just get on with it and who are just doing the thing that they know needs to be done. And it's unobtrusive. It's not showy. But that is what life is. I mean, to switch books a bit, I know we're talking about wintering, but this is what I wrote about in Enchantment is the kind of the exhaustion that we feel from years of spreading fear online. And I did half a PhD once in evolutionary storytelling. And I'm still really hooked on this kind of idea that comes from evolutionary science about danger signaling, essentially, and about the way that animals danger signal to each other. So the big example is the. The rabbit who, when a rabbit runs, their tail flashes white behind them. Like the motion of running makes their tail flash. And that sets other rabbits off running. And so you get these chains of running rabbits. They don't even know what they're running from anymore, but they've seen the danger signal, they respond to it. And so then you can get these whole kind of herds of rabbits. I don't think you have a herd of rabbits, but that's fine. Running and running and running for the sake of running. And I think that's what's actually happened to us since the advent of social media. We have learned that one of the effective strategies for gaining followers and interest with our storytelling online is to send out danger signals. Nobody's really interested in safety signals. We're very interested in danger signals. And we spread them. We pass them on because it feels dangerous. So we must tell someone else. And so we're passing on these chains of fear and danger. And then we're exhausted. And we're so exhausted that we can't face social life anymore because that feels dangerous to us now because it's full of these conflicts and arguments and new information that feels even more dangerous. And so the thing that I think we most need to do is to break the danger signaling and to start focusing back on life as it is presented to us. And on what needs to be done on a basic level. And that's just how we've always survived up until now. Is there a middle path here where we can speak clearly about the genuine dangers abroad in the land while also giving people helpful advice for navigating this insane environment? Yeah, absolutely. And of course, you know, not all of these things are fake. I mean, I know there are quite, you know, there's quite a lot of fake stuff going around, but these things are real. But I think we have to understand our capacity to process news on the scale that we're trying to process it. And I think one of the most important things that I've done in the last few years, and I would urge anyone else to do this, is to choose my sources of news, to choose it wisely, and to look at it once a day. To go back to that model of the paper that you read in the morning, but it was limited. You know, there was an end to the news. And unless that news is on my doorstep or affecting a member of my family, in which case I can definitely find more sources, it's enough for me to stay really well informed once a day and then to decide what agency I have in that situation and to take action if I can and need to, but also to put it down. Because actually, we cannot keep functioning with this level of terror rolling towards us all the time. Can I ask you a question? I'd love to ask you what it's like to work in that industry, like whether that affects you as much as it affects the viewers. Like, does the terror feel very close? You know, it's interesting when I, I mean, I've been retired from the news business for coming up on almost five years, or maybe now. That's quite the anniversary. By the time this posts, probably fully five years. I, you know, oddly, there's a, when I was in the news business, I was dealing with it from a very clinical standpoint. Like I was just, I was just working. So how do I deliver this almost? Yeah. How do I deliver it? But then even more embarrassing, like, how am I doing compared to the competition? Am I getting this scoop? Or am I getting, this assignment? And so it was all of that. There were multiple layers of the processing that kept me at a distance from the, the, the horror of it. There were a few points in my career where I really was hit by it. I was very upset, uh, and continue to be, uh, about Trump. Um, that, so that broke through. Um, and then, you know, I spent a lot of time in Iraq and, and other places in, in, in the early aughts. And so that definitely, there were moments where that broke through, but, but largely there's a buffer because you're, you're literally working with all of these facts and trying to figure out the right order in which to present them. And then also then there's the, the, all of the selfish stuff around how am I doing? And so in some ways in now I'm more freaked out because I'm, um, you haven't got that kind of, I don't know, shell around you almost that, that protects you from it. That's so interesting. And I wonder if it's a, there's a little, I mean, it's a little like you hear about the kind of, uh, the soldiers who are now remotely operating drones and things like that, that actually the trauma of that situation hits them much later. It takes them a while. It takes it a while to like catch up with them almost. Yes. Yeah. Because they're playing a video game. Yeah. Yeah. I was kind of playing a video game with the news. Um, that's so interesting. Sorry to ask you questions, but I was really curious. No, it's all good. You mentioned enchantment, uh, and you're right. It wasn't the original plan to talk about it, but I don't care that the fuck the plan that that doesn't really matter. Um, with all due respect and love, uh, to Eleanor Vasily, who worked, the producer worked very hard to prepare us. Um, uh, but, but can you just, since you mentioned enchantment, what is that book about? Enchantment is kind of the book that answers the question. Okay. I'm, I'm coming out of my wintering. What next? Which is something that people ask me a lot. I wrote it mid lockdown and it really is a book about how to work through that really profound sense of dislocation that we can feel and how to make contact with the, with the world again. Um, I actually, I begin, to feel that it's a very relevant book for right now because I'm hearing people say the same things to me again as, as when I was writing enchantment, which is I'm panicking all the time. I don't think I'm allowed to rest. I don't think I'm allowed to have a spiritual life. Oh, I could meditate, but life is too urgent for me to do that. So I will leave that until stuff has settled down. A big symptom seems to be that people can't read. It's like our attention keeps, sliding off the things that we consider to be a bit too soft and, and onto worry all the time and anxiety. And so enchantment is, is a walk through how to reconnect with awe and wonder and how to find it right outside your door, rather than believing that it's, it's always in this kind of glamorous distant place that you can maybe visit once in a lifetime. Um, yeah. So it touches, I think on, on a lot of the things that we've talked about. So if I'm hearing you correctly, your diagnosis is that many people feel that in any form but it also could be reading um is self-indulgent given the state of emergency in which we're living and and so they're running themselves ragged because they feel that's the appropriate response as opposed to resourcing themselves to respond more effectively i think that's exactly right i think it feels like there are so many urgent things going on and yet at the same time for most people and i you know i realize there are there'll be loads of people listening for whom this has come right to their doorstep now and that's a a moment where the action is really obvious but for loads of other people they see it in a distance and are really concerned by it and so feel like they can't allow themselves any of the things that would actually charge them up and restore them in order to be ready for that fight when they can take it action and i i increasingly think that the work for those of us who are not on the front line at the moment apart from giving all the support we can is to almost store up those soft parts of life to kind of maintain them and look after them and tend to them so that they are ready for the people who need them it's almost like we're maintaining a vision of the world as it should be against that that hideous mainstream trumpian vision of bitterness selfishness snatching anger it's the opposite of that it's like the work that we do is to take care of all of those all of the stuff that's beautiful that that those people just don't understand i just want to make sure i'm like effectively disambiguating some of the what you're calling for here and so we can understand it and unpack it you i think you're making a call for rest as um as a necessary component to responding effectively to everything that's happening but but it's not just rest it's kind of some sort of spiritual life too or if you don't like the word spiritual but it's sort of an embrace it's a difficult word isn't it yeah yeah i think so i think it is i mean it really it surprised me that i wrote such a book like it it's a book about the stuff that i've often felt too awkward to confront in my own life you know by the time i wrote it i'd been a meditator for maybe 15 years but i'd always i'd always seen that as like a a tool like almost a neurological tool rather than wanting it to be any more than that and i think one of the things that i came to realize which led to me writing the book was that i needed to be more of a meditator and i needed to be more of a spiritual i needed a concept of what was bigger in the world than me and what felt connective and actually what felt actively magical sometimes you know what felt transcendent those are the things we're at such risk of abandoning in favor of the real world and i i just think we we really really need both and we can we can make space for that as well as as doing all the good that the world needs and i think one feeds the other and and the the exhaustion we feel will burn us out and so we we need something to maintain our our energy our passion our spark and our our sense of of awe at this extraordinary planet we live on that's full of extraordinary people so magic mystery beauty wonder awe um rest they're all really they're big words are they yeah but they don't they can be they can be deployed in an annoyingly vague way but i mean yeah stepping outside and looking up is not no is not impractical and not gauzy and um uh annoying to me um yeah and but what you're really saying is these words can be understood in service of um addressing the emergency of activism yeah and i also think that that they're yes they're big amorphous words but they they can be very simply defined you know like i talk about when you hold a stone it's only a few steps to realize how ancient that stone is and how it was forged and how it got there and how it represents the geology of your landscape and and that can take you downwards through the soil it can help you think about your ancestors and it can help you think about your it can help you think about the folkloric connections that we make to place they're you know like small things very everyday things very ignorable things the kind of things that kids pick up and we say oh come on put that down now we're in a rush we're trying to get to the shops those those things can hold such deep fascination for us and can unpack everything we need to restore our deep deep ancient connection with with the world and i think it's it's immense value okay i'm gonna um alter my relationship to rocks actually and then i'm not even making fun of you i think that's actually a good uh next time i'm on the beach i'm never without a rock she's holding up a rock yes yeah i've got a rock yeah yeah um we go back to rest in the guilt that many of us feel myself included sometimes when i'm just taking a break during the course of the day this is the type of thing that the me of 20 years ago would have scoffed at but now when i get into bed or when i get on the bike to exercise um i will just say to myself i'm doing this to make myself stronger and happier so that i can make other people stronger and happier you know may we all be free of suffering uh it's so hokey um but it's really useful and i think that framing goes right to the guilt i mean it's a yeah it's a annihilation button for the guilt absolutely and you know it speaks to the way that we've often treated the hardest working people in our society for a long time which is just to say keep doing it you know keep working i had an object lesson in that this year my husband got cancer and i had to care for him for quite a extended period of time when he was very very sick and i i mean obviously i had a child i understood what it was to give care but the brutality of that process and the way that there was nothing in our world that made space for me to rest was such an eye-opener about how we treat caregivers and how much invisible work is done without ever having any permission to stop and i you know i'm lucky in that he is getting better he's still not great but he's you know he's looking after himself a bit more now but the exhaustion that i felt at the end of that process and actually the alienation you know the sense of not being cared for myself and an abandonment by the the society around me that just took my intensive labor for granted made me really think about the flip side of that and why it's so right for you to say i need i need the things that basically restore me in order to be able to keep on doing the good that i'm trying to do in the world you know if i'd have carried on with the level of care that i was giving for a few more months i'd have honestly been flattened for a couple of years afterwards i was so so profoundly drained and i it's so important to express that we don't we're not really supposed to talk about that we're supposed to say and it was a privilege to give it and of course i just stepped up and and those things are also true but having an encounter firsthand with that level of exhaustion was so informative for me i think i'm sorry that you went through that that both of you that sounds um awful do you know what though it's ordinary life you know yeah so many people listening right now will be going through exactly the same thing and it's it's so ordinary you know it's just absolutely everyday stuff and it's what people are doing all the time in your discussion of rest and your call for rest you you sometimes speak disapprovingly of what you call performative rest what what is that performative rest is rest that looks good to the outside you know the image that i think we can all conjure up really easily is who i call yoga girl who is this beautiful thin blonde woman in unrumpled yoga clothing and she's sitting in the perfect lotus looking like she's accessed nirvana and she's bullshit i'm so tired of her i'm so tired of her i'm so tired of being pushed that as rest rest is really messy it takes practice i like you know we both talk about meditation quite a lot so it's not even worth me repeating this but we both know that meditation is not a a smooth path you know it's like this crazy bumpy ground that's full of doubt. It's wriggly sometimes. It rarely looks or feels enlightened, but the value of it accumulates nevertheless throughout our messy humanness. And it certainly doesn't make us perfect, but it does make us better and more able to cope. I also think that rest is often not still for lots of people, that rest is found in motion, that it's found in activity, that rest is really guilt-ridden and complicated for loads of us, and that we need to often distract ourselves in order to rest because we just can't bear to sit still like that. The guilt would enfold us. So yeah, I just want to ditch spa day yoga girl vision of rest and get into the real grit of it. That's what I've been exploring in my podcast and it's been so, so interesting. Amen to all of that. Um, is there yoga boy? Is there like the, is there the kind of equivalent for, for men? Yeah, it's the douchebag with the man bun who's, um, you know, uh, playing, uh, ostentatiously spiritual music under his, um, Instagram posts of his, uh, uh, abs. Yeah, of course it's got much worse out the last few years, hasn't it? That's, I mean, we've lived with yoga girl for quite a while, but there's a, there's an upsurge of, of some really grim yoga boy stuff on the other side now. There's usually, there's usually, um, a large dose of biohacking, um, in, in the male version of this. No, I don't like it. I'm not having it. I'm not having any of it. It's gross. No, absolutely not. We're now kind of in practical land, at least I think. Uh, so let's spend a little bit of time there. So in winter, we're going to be doing a lot of yoga. We're going to be doing a lot of yoga. So in wintering, you talk about some just things we can do to get ourselves through rough patches, but I think it very much applies to, um, what you're interested in now is, you know, just living in, um, living in a tumultuous world. Um, and so some of the things you talk about are, um, cold water immersion, you mentioned earlier, swimming in the sea. I'm never going to call it cold water immersion. I'm going to call it swimming. I'm so sick of the cold water stuff. I love swimming. Right. This is cold water. Here we go. Here's performative rest for you. This is where I see, um, what my friend calls, uh, sauna bros. I have a friend and my friend Robbie, who is like very involved in the emergence. I think the healthy reemergence of rediscovery of what is quite ancient sauna, bathhouse culture, hot and cold, um, sometimes in water, sometimes not. And thunders against the sauna bros who are just performatively showing you how much time they can spend in the cold water, uh, in the cold plunge, et cetera, et cetera. But cold water and heat both have a lot to recommend them. So it's just say more about that. Yeah. I mean, I, when we look at these kinds of ancient cultures, like the Finnish culture, which I talk about in wintering of sauna, which has both hot and cold, you know, it's often digging a hole in the ice, getting into the icy lake in, you know, in between bouts of saunering. Those cultures are founded in pleasure and not biohacking. You know, they are not founded in how many calories it's going to burn or whether it's going to, you know, increase your mental acuity or increase your endurance for your, I don't know, whatever crazy sport you're into. It's not what it's about for me. And I just think we take these beautiful things. I love swimming in the cold sea. I always wanted to do it. And when I started writing wintering, it gave me permission to start. People ruin it all the time. The number of times people come up to me and like, did you lose weight when you started doing it? Like, that's none of your business. Also brackets, no. How far do you swim? How long do you stay in? How cold is the water? I don't know. I don't know. And in fact, most of the time I go in there and I just tread water. We wring the joy out of these things and wring the beautiful sociability that is often inherent to loads of these things and make them into work and individualistic, like self-improvement. And I am so tired of it. Like, if you are called to cold swimming, do it, but do it for the pleasure and do it to actually explore the limits of your body. The Tantra teacher, Barbara Karelis, has this beautiful phrase that's the resilient edge of resistance, which is about understanding the limits of your body. And I think that's that line that your body can reach that feels good just before it crosses into, you know, unpleasantness. The way she describes it is that, you know, when you stroke a cat, the cat will show you that line very clearly, you know, that it will show you what's giving it pleasure. And then the minute that you step over it, it will bite you. That happened to me with my cat last night. That's such a beautiful, mindful thing to explore, rather than I'm going to get as cold as I can, set a timer and then put it on Instagram. That's not teaching you anything, honestly. It's giving you nothing. Could be good for your follower count, but yeah. It would. Yeah, it absolutely would. And that's the problem with it, isn't it? But again, it's it almost functions as a kind of danger signal, because what the conversation becomes is if you don't do this, you are not optimizing your body enough and you are not fighting hard enough against your mortality, which I don't even know where to start with some of these things, honestly. Right. It's a tricky line because like I want to be as healthy as possible for as long as possible. But I also don't want to wring the joy out of all of my quote unquote wellness activities, which, by the way, will degrade your health and lifespan. 100 percent. But also, I think we have to think about these very kind of intensive individual pursuits of health and think about how they actually fall within a society and a community. And I I am very skeptical about whether you can pursue these things to the degree that they're pushed online and still be loving, helpful and useful within your family and your community. Like, are you actually taking part and are you helping to carry the load or are you going outside and making videos of yourself in an ice bath? That's the problem. And also, I think also, I think it's important to think about the fact that we're not all of us have to accept that we are not going to live forever. That's that's a more useful place to start from than can I live forever? I think I probably can if I only find the right the right set of things to do. It's it's another illusion. I'm surprisingly grumpy after this conversation. I'm so sorry. I just want people to have a nice time cold swimming. I appreciate that. Well, speaking of having a nice time, a couple of other things that you recommend kind of have to do with rituals. And yeah, so just say a little bit more about that. Yeah, I am really interested in the role of ritual. I think for me, it came up when I was researching wintering and began to look at how we make it through winter psychologically almost. And if we look back into history, one of the effective strategies I think that we had was, for different rituals at different points in time. So we all know Halloween. That is actually an ancient observation of the crossing into winter. We know Christmas, but actually, we don't think too much of the solstice anymore, which is this incredibly important, not moment, which is how we think of it now, not just the shortest day. But it's actually this passage of days when the sun is at its furthest extent and is barely rising. And that has always been a really important ritual space. There's also a ritual space at the beginning of February, which is known as Imolc in the Celtic tradition, St. Bridget's Day in Ireland, or Candlemas in the Christian church. So it's this very early marker of spring. All of those moments are moments that we used to mark. We used to get together and celebrate this change. And they used to be very, very important. And I think that's why I think it's so important to remember that we used to just help us have more beats through winter, which now just feels so long and bleak and interminable. But one of the important things for me about ritual is that I think we need to learn to hold it lightly. So loads of us grew up with rituals that were very kind of, that felt very heavy, that were very dictatorial, that were perhaps like heavy on liturgy or performance and that we didn't necessarily feel our way into. To me, a good ritual space that we bring ourselves to as we are. And often by walking through those steps, whether it's like lighting a candle or walking a path or plunging into cold water, we often get to really see ourselves and to really kind of experience our feelings. And if we set rituals up right, we welcome people in to bring difficult moments to those rituals, rather than to hide them or disguise them or make them look pretty. I think, yeah, I really think that building rituals however we want to build them can really help in winter like winter itself but also you know very difficult times somebody listening to this might rightly ask that does sound real and helpful yeah so how do i do it like i'm not i'm not a member of an organized religion i don't have friends who are into this shit like what do i do yeah i've spent quite a few years now trying to convince my friends that we must absolutely celebrate the winter solstice and gradually gradually they do more people join me every year um i think you can celebrate rituals alone sometimes for example there's a moment in the year that i mark that i can interest absolutely nobody in um and i'll just go outside and watch the sunrise and light a candle and just take that pause that can be enough that's like the simplest form of ritual but actually you might if you talk to the people around you and ask them or invite them to say do you know what i've i've found the last few months really hard there's this moment that i'm going to mark will you will you come with me we'll you know we'll have hot chocolate and light a bonfire outside or we'll watch a film that is deeply significant to me together and enjoy each other's company you can make it an invitation the other thing i would say though is that consider whether there is a group or a or just a particular ceremony that you'd like to join i mean i'll give you an example i live near canterbury cathedral which is quite a cool cool thing to live near um and last september i joined a service where they bless the hops which they've done every year for decades and decades and decades but it's this really unusual cathedral service where morris dancers are brought into uh into the cathedral they dance by the altar and animals are allowed in too and so it feels like the whole space has been completely disrupted it's the very beginning of autumn it's quite near to my birthday which i liked and it's the very end of summer and that was a ritual that i joined in with and and attended for the first time and absolutely loved so there's lots of different ways in i think is there something about rituals that mark transitions that i don't know what i'm trying to get at here but there's a way in which we can just walk through life on autopilot and marking discrete moments of change um can jar us out of that yeah we've got quite bad at marking rites of passage i think actually you know we're okay at birthdays we do marriages we do funerals but we feel a bit weird about them now because we don't really want to acknowledge the death part but there are many others too you know traditionally you know having your first child was a very ritualized space and we've rejected some of those things for good reasons but actually some of the things we could do with coming back you know being held by your community in this moment of great transition would actually be very useful rather than the isolation that that so many people go through losing a loved one is a huge one particularly losing a partner i think or a parent we used to have very clear ways of marking these moments in our lives and of also like marking our progress through that grief and the way that it changes over time so there are there are just loads of moments in life that we could return to i've i've thought about it a lot as my son becomes a teenager as well you know there's very there's very little outside of school which is very achievement based that acknowledges his transition towards adulthood the slow walk towards it the different bits of independence he's gaining the different bits of knowledge and wisdom but also what he also needs in terms of support yeah i i've thought a lot about this the last few years i'm not sure i've truly solved it but i there are so many fascinating fascinating examples of cultures that do this really well my culture or half of my half of my heritage uh is jewish and the bar mitzvah i think properly um yeah properly observed is an as my son won't have one because he's only a quarter jewish um so would he be able to choose to have one if he wanted i don't suppose he would though you know i did i think he would want it just for the money mostly um but which is what was got me to do it when i was a kid um but you know i was half jewish and i opted for i asked for it and therefore did it um i think i think when you get down to a quarter jewish it's i don't know but but there are other things we can do to you know beyond just a birthday to celebrate um the inexorable march toward adulthood um yeah which is is so challenging and so hard and and you know we talk so often about how kids aren't allowed to grow up anymore or how they're going to be living with their parents forever because they can't afford their own places or whatever it is we talk down their progress into adulthood so much and i think we're in desperate need of a way to to to actually mark the the signposts of the move towards it which are actually really remarkable when you're watching it but very hard to to sort of notice and express on a day-to-day basis it's it's such a important thing that we're missing one other practical thing i wanted to ask you about before i let you go is um you you write a lot about insomnia which i am interested in as a lifelong insomniac um yeah so what are your practical tips and tools for for those sleepless hours yeah i've always been a i mean i'm a very light sleeper i suppose you could say but i wake a lot in the night um and one of the i mean many things about writing wintering really changed me but i think the biggest aspect of all was understanding how normal it is to wake in the night particularly in winter um there is a brilliant book called at day's close by a historian called e roger e kirch who shows that there is a a very quiet a very hard to discern but nevertheless definitely their historical record of a space in the night that he calls the watch he's not really sure that it was consistently called anything because it was just such a normal part of the day but before the advent of electric lights he shows that it was completely normal for people to go to bed sleep for roughly four hours let's say wake for a couple of hours and then go back to bed and complete the second half of your sleep so he talks about it as a first and second sleep and this pit not only is it just normal to wake in the night like not not something particularly troubling that we should upset ourselves about because often the anxiety we feel about it makes it way worse but also we used to honor this phase of the night as something really special within the 24 hours that we were living through so it was a time when you prayed or meditated for example or had quiet conversation within your family perhaps had sex as well when we came to research this much more recently and and plunged people back into the conditions that they once would have lived in all the time restricting their light for example we found that people fell right back into this pattern of sleep very naturally and that actually if if we tested their blood chemistry during that that out that couple of hours in the middle of the night that it was very different to the blood chemistry at any other point of the day that it resembled more the blood of a lactating mother than than anyone else in society even for men and that actually it it almost primed us for a very kind of dreamy meditative state of mind so i don't worry so much about my insomnia anymore i just get up and read instead i think that's the ultimate this is not the right word per se but the right hack or mindset shift is don't problematize it yeah get up do something fun and pleasant not instagram and then when you're ready go back to bed that's right and in fact for me it's lovely as a kind of complete introvert it's this lovely time of night when i have the house myself it's quiet i don't turn the lights up too high i don't look at any screens i don't contact the outside world but it's actually very pleasurable to have that that time and to just trust it most of us are not going to die from lack of sleep it's okay you know and and i think we can just it's it comes back to that habit that modern habit of measuring everything not just time but now we all wear these little wristbands that measure our sleep and we're not going to die from sleep i i look at my sleep hours too and they scare us they really scare us but you know in the deep past when we got up in the night we would have found company it wouldn't have been lonely there would have been people looking after children together because children have always woken in the night it's completely normal there would have been older people whose sleep is often quite broken and there would have just been people in their watch it's such a different way to see it one last thing to ask you about you've mentioned reading several times um do you see that as as like a deliberate practice either for periods of wintering or um you know any other time any other difficult time that we might be enduring yeah i mean i think as a writer i would say that wouldn't i but i do i do think that actually thinking about the different kinds of reading can can unlock a load of very wonderful pieces of support during difficult times i mean not enough people read poetry anymore for example but a good well-chosen poem can be the most enormous support in a in a really tough time and it's something that we might return to over and over again you know we're not reading to get through that tbr pile that we've displayed on social media we're reading to comfort and reassure ourselves and to think through a problem i think also i write in wintering about I think also I write in wintering about children's books and how important they are as we grow up, but how important they can continue to be to us as adults. children's books and i think it's a really important thing to do and i think it's a really Because they often use winter as this kind of device to show how we scramble in difficult times and how we come into our own when we're at our most challenged. And when things have got a bit too much, I'll often read back through my favorite children's books, first of all, because they're beautiful pieces of literary art that we should value more. But also they often speak very directly into survival and I find them incredibly helpful. Catherine, it's been a pleasure to meet you. Let me just, before I let you go, ask you to please plug all the books you've written and your podcast, which you mentioned. Oh, yes. So I am the author of Wintering, The Power of Rest and Retreat in Difficult Times. The following book, Enchantment, I have to check the subtitle for that. Awakening, Wondering and Anxious Age. I'm rubbish at subtitles. I don't understand them. I would just like them to be called Wintering and Enchantment, but apparently we have to do other things these days. And I run a newsletter called The Clearing, which is accompanied by a podcast of the same name where I ask people to imagine their dream retreat. And I would love to ask you those questions one day if you ever fancy it. Catherine May, thank you very much for your time. Appreciate it. Thank you so much. It's been an absolute joy. Likewise. Also, a quick ask before I let you go. If you've got a minute, head on over to danharris.com and sign up for my newsletter. It drops in your inbox on Monday mornings, often a busy and stressful time for us. I try to write a short essay that has a little bit of wisdom, actionable, practical wisdom that you can immediately weave into your life on Monday mornings. A lot of people find them helpful and I hope you will too. You can sign up at danharris.com. It's totally free. Now to the credits. a really important thing to do and i think it's a really important thing to do and i think it's a really important thing to do and i think it's a really important thing to do and i think it's a really important thing to do and i think it's a really

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Wintering is a natural, cyclical phase of life that mirrors how animals and plants survive harsh times, representing periods of emotional hardship and stagnation.
  2. These difficult times are not personal failures but a universal, inevitable part of life, offering transformation and deeper self-understanding.
  3. Social media often promotes toxic positivity, ignoring the monotonous reality of struggle and failing to offer empathy or genuine connection.
  4. Nature, like trees and hibernating animals, demonstrates resilience and preparation for renewal, teaching that even in deep stillness, vital work continues.
  5. Acceptance during hardship—acknowledging pain without resistance—is not passive, but a foundational step toward agency, clarity, and meaningful action.
  6. True resilience comes from grounding in daily, small rituals and experiences with nature, rather than performative wellness or self-improvement.
  7. The modern world is saturated with danger signals and fear-based narratives, leading to exhaustion and a loss of connection to wonder and community.
  8. Rest and spiritual practice are not luxuries but essential tools for emotional survival and effective engagement in a turbulent world.

Summary:

In this insightful conversation, Catherine May introduces the concept of "wintering" as a natural, recurring phase of life that reflects periods of hardship, emotional coldness, and stagnation. She argues that these times are not personal failures but common, biologically rooted experiences shared by all humans—much like how animals and plants endure winter. Rather than viewing such periods as setbacks, May emphasizes their transformative value, allowing individuals to deeply understand themselves and emerge with greater resilience.

She critiques the culture of toxic positivity and social media, which often dismiss suffering as unworthy of attention, and advocates for authentic, face-to-face connection and real-life rituals that foster empathy and grounding. These rituals—like marking seasonal transitions, lighting candles, or swimming in cold water—serve as anchors to the present moment, helping people reconnect with awe, nature, and their own inner rhythms. May also highlights the dangers of performative wellness, which reduces self-care to spectacle and individual achievement, and instead promotes rest as a necessary, messy, and deeply human practice.

Crucially, she asserts that true agency arises not from denial of pain but from accepting it, allowing space for emotional processing and deeper understanding. This acceptance, rooted in wisdom and humility, enables people to act meaningfully in the world—without being overwhelmed by fear. Ultimately, the message is that in times of crisis, whether personal or global, restoring balance through stillness, ritual, and connection is not indulgent, but essential for enduring and thriving.

FAQs

Wintering is a term coined to describe the natural, inevitable periods in life when we feel frozen, overwhelmed, or in crisis—like winter for animals and plants. It’s not a personal failure but a normal, even valuable, part of life that allows for transformation and resilience.

Yes, it’s healthy and necessary to feel sadness and despair during wintering. These emotions are not signs of weakness but signals that we’re experiencing a deep, authentic phase of life. Accepting them helps us find peace and clarity rather than trying to push them away.

Performative rest refers to rest that is showy or self-improvement-focused—like yoga in chic clothing or cold plunges shared online. It’s problematic because it turns rest into performance, loses its personal meaning, and can even feel like a danger signal, adding stress rather than relief.

Rituals—like lighting a candle, walking in nature, or celebrating seasonal transitions—provide structure and meaning during difficult periods. They help us connect with our emotions, mark milestones, and feel supported by community rather than isolated.

Yes, wintering often brings deep transformation. While it may feel like a setback in the short term, it can lead to greater self-awareness, emotional resilience, and a deeper understanding of who we are and what truly matters in life.

Nature shows us that even in winter, life continues—trees shed leaves to conserve energy, animals hibernate to survive. These examples teach us that rest is not failure, but a vital, natural part of survival and renewal.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.