How to Reset the Course of a Nation, with Rachel Maddow
49m 56s
In this episode of *Pablo Torre Finds Out*, the conversation centers on the 2024 U.S. election results, particularly the victory of Democrat Amy Acton over Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio, a moment seen as both a political triumph and a moral reckoning. Ramaswamy’s campaign, marked by controversial claims and ties to elite real estate, faced strong backlash for being perceived as morally repulsive and out of touch, especially in a traditionally red state. The discussion also examines how right-wing narratives—such as the supposed threat of trans athletes in sports—lack factual grounding and serve as political tools to distract from real issues like economic inequality and corruption. A key theme is the failure of Republican leaders to address systemic problems, including the misallocation of power and spending, as seen in Texas and other battlegrounds. The episode highlights the growing public skepticism toward political elites, especially billionaires and right-wing figures who have fueled policies harming ordinary citizens. Central to the narrative is the decline of the Justice Department under Trump, which lost institutional strength and integrity, undermining constitutional protections. Pablo and Rachel analyze how this breakdown enables authoritarianism and corruption. They argue that a rebirth of the DOJ—rooted in accountability, transparency, and rule of law—is essential to restore trust in democracy. The episode concludes with a powerful call to action: to reject political scapegoating, defend the rule of law, and rebuild institutions that serve the public good. The intersection of sports, politics, and ethics—like the story of Bill Barr’s football incident—illustrates how personal history mirrors broader political failures. Ultimately, the election signals a shift in public confidence, where people are choosing policies that prioritize fairness, affordability, and real human needs over ideological extremism.
Welcome to Pablo Torre Finds Out, brought to you by Apple Card.
I am Pablo Torre, and today we're going to find out what this sound is.
Ah!
Wow.
Right after this.
I'm really excited to talk to you about all this stuff.
Of all the people who I'm going to talk to about the election and the book and everything,
you are the person that everybody in my life is very, very nervous and excited about.
You're the big star in the Rachel Maddowverse.
Oh, boy. Oh, sure.
Well, we do have a couple of surprises for you, Rachel, I hope.
What?
You didn't foresee me wanting to begin this conversation by talking about Vivek Ramaswamy.
I do want to start there for a second, though, and thank you again for being here.
Of course.
And what a delight for me.
To recap what you got to call in a very, very, I would say,
like almost endless conversation.
NFL Red Zone adjacent manor on Tuesday.
We have a big election alert for you.
This is a governor's race very closely watched for all sorts of reasons.
And the Ohio governor's race, the Associated Press has called it.
Democrat Amy Acton has defeated Republican Vivek Ramaswamy to become the next governor of Ohio.
You got to call Vivek Ramaswamy losing to Amy Acton by 52.31% to 44%.
And I don't know if there was more bipartisan delight around any single outcome than that one.
And I wonder if it felt that way to you.
I think that Amy Acton is a very good candidate for governor.
I think that she is she communicates in a way that is like moves people.
And it's also really real and authentic.
And she conveys real information.
I thought, you know, her acceptance speech, you probably saw it.
Ohio has chosen you.
Unity and decency.
Over division and hate.
You're talking about, you know, a win for decency and looking out for each other.
And it's just just a fundamentally decent person.
It's a big deal for Democrats to win Ohio, which they thought was right.
All of that is true.
All of that absolutely pales against how people felt about seeing Vivek Ramaswamy lose this race.
This way and to be punished by the voters of Ohio so resoundingly for having been so morally repulsive.
He was never even allowed to compete.
He didn't get anywhere near her.
And again, red state, Ohio, right?
What used to be red state, Ohio.
And he's been more he's been running for governor since since he ran for president.
Look, we've we've investigated Vivek on this show.
People know the lore.
You know, I was his classmate in college, which means that I have a particular psychosis.
I guess around this and a particular delight around this.
The U.S. Tennis Association has no records of him being a nationally ranked junior tennis player.
But but my favorite detail about Vivek is one that I haven't even mentioned yet, which is I don't know if you know this.
So last November, this is according to the rooster, the blog which broke the story of the ad against Amy Acton and using her her mom by Vivek.
November 2025, the rooster reported that Vivek Ramaswamy agreed in principle to buy a 15 million dollar mansion.
And that's when Vivek Ramaswamy said, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know.
I don't know, I don't know, I don't know.
Less than a thousand feet away from the official Ohio governor's residence.
So if you're wondering, Rachel, what does this property look like?
He wanted to live on the on-ramp.
He wanted to perhaps just be able to occupy the nicer building that he could also have access to while becoming the governor.
According to the Columbus Dispatch, surely this $15 million agreement in principle will not become a thing.
A podcaster I went to school with laughs about on November 6th.
That's what we're dealing with.
Did you say a maze?
Perhaps the coup de grace on the reporting is that his realtor reportedly is Tina Husted.
Husted's wife.
Senator Husted's wife.
Wife of John Husted, who I guess is now.
We found the one person who can consensually enjoy his ass.
There's a lot of ass appreciation in the story of the Ohio gubernatorial collapse.
I actually think the ass talk, forgive me, the ass talk about John Husted, I think it kind of helped him.
Like I think that, yes, Sherrod Brown beat him by I think five points, but I think probably Sherrod Brown would have beat him by more points
had the Republican Party wholesale not turned its eyes to the Sherrod Brown.
The shape of his rump.
It occurred to me that like last election, we almost anthropologically go out as I'm speaking about people in the press.
We go out and talk to, you know.
The Rust Belt.
God, yeah.
And now I feel like the anthropologists must come to you.
They're studying Rachel Maddow.
Please explain your people.
Let's go find a childless pot-bellied lesbian.
In Western, it has to be Western Massachusetts.
Correct.
Yes.
The subject may be fishing at the time that we're looking for this person.
Yeah, this is a David Attenborough documentary now.
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm.
Check at the EV charging stations at the local Whole Foods.
So, actually, I do want to clarify.
And one of the things I do need to bring up to you is that you were an athlete.
Yeah, in a galaxy far, far away, Pablo.
I mean, it's, yeah, look at me.
Come on.
Well, I am looking at you, and I'm also looking at her.
Ah!
Wow.
Could you please describe for those not watching on YouTube who you are looking at?
Can I?
I'm going to give you alt text.
Yes.
Woke 3 demands alt text.
Let's just start with the fact that there is a pink backdrop, and there are pearls and pearl earrings.
There is still a black shirt, which is in keeping with where we are today.
But, yeah, that's my high school graduation photo, and I had long blonde hair.
What sports did you play?
My main sport was volleyball, but I was volleyball, basketball, and swimming.
And I started off, actually, as a little kid playing soccer, too.
But I had to decide.
I had to decide between basketball and soccer, and went with basketball.
My claim to fame in basketball is that I believe, I believe, and memory is fuzzy when you're as old as I am,
but I believe I fouled out of every single game I ever played.
Were you a physical or a clumsy player?
Yes, exactly.
Exactly.
You nailed it.
The most important thing about me, both in soccer and in basketball, is that I'm very slow.
And so I'm big, I'm tall, and I have big limbs.
And I look like I could be, like, bestride the pitch or bestride the court.
But then I start moving, and it's like, what's wrong with that child?
And so I would try to make up for that just with my elbows.
And so lots of getting thrown out of games.
I was pretty good at volleyball, in part because you don't, unless you're really, really good at volleyball,
you don't have to move large distances.
It's more of a small-distance quick response kind of thing.
And I was very tall.
And so I went, I was, like, middle blocker or a right-side hitter.
And I, you know, part of what was being good in high school-level volleyball
was just being in the way of other people trying to do things.
And it turns out that's my skill.
The mental image, again, for those just listening, like, you looked like the prom queen.
I know. Why are we talking about high school?
It makes, still, I'm, like, I can feel the hives rising in me.
I was going to say, you're in palpable discomfort.
I dislike myself in high school so much.
I only, like, we could talk middle school, too, if you want to go real self-loathing.
But, yeah, I was, I did, I was a three-sport varsity athlete.
How much did your athletic career help you when you were calling?
How many hours of live television on Tuesday?
The athletic career helped not a bit.
I mean, one of the things that has more defined, like, my physical being as an adult
is that I have the spine of a 115-year-old.
Like, I can't, even, like, during the course of this interview,
I will get shorter just sitting in this chair.
I'm a complete physical wreck.
But there's also a, there's definitely an adrenaline thing that kicks in
for these nights, for these long nights covering election results.
I mean, like, the first hour, you're really thinking very carefully about
who you're going to book and what the structure is and where the breaks come
and what the plot is and what we have to tease ahead.
And then after you get through the first hour,
you're essentially,
you're essentially just running.
You're just running the whole time.
It's like the dinner rush if you wait tables.
You know, you just don't think.
You just, whatever strategy you had is gone.
You just go.
At what point in the course of you hosting this thing,
did you start noticing, like, the memes on the internet?
I actually don't even think I've seen them yet.
I don't think I've seen them to this day.
Do you have some, you have, you have a folder full of memes?
We're passing a folder full of memes to Rachel.
These are some of the tweets that are, I think,
representative, perhaps what you could not see from the desk
that I was seeing at home.
We're putting clavicular on estrogen.
Mark Zuckerberg got to change his whole look again.
Very good.
We are going to deep fry RFK Jr. in beef tallow
at a tailgate for the Washington vaccines.
And then for the last one from you.
Tonight, the couch a**es you.
Yes, God bless you.
My favorite one that I have seen was
effective, I'm going to paraphrase it,
but was like, the Pope votes in one election
and look what happens.
That was like my Catholic lib meme of the day.
One of the sort of like issues that I also just was tracking,
have been tracking for years on this show and elsewhere
is one that ended up not, it turns out,
winning the election for a lot of these
right-leaning sports figures who ran for office,
like former NFL kicker Jay Feeley.
And that's the trans athlete.
Yeah.
And I'm wondering how that issue feels to you
as it was, as many have said,
an 80-20 winner for the Republican Party.
And simultaneously, the thing that did not work
as Jay Feeley lost to, by the way,
the Democrat who was his team doctor on the New York Jets.
I did not know that.
In one of the more small town, yeah,
election cycles, it turns out.
The trans athletes thing, I mean,
there's a lot of actual very serious,
very serious elements of it.
And number one is just seeing this national,
insistent, now years-long political project
to scapegoat and vilify and try to direct violence
and hate towards a tiny disfavored minority,
which is trans people.
Like that is something that has profound,
profound impact on some of our fellow Americans.
Yes.
And it is repulsive and it is,
politically as transparent
as any other exercise like this has been
in any other, from any other authoritarian movement
in politics in any country in the last century and a half.
Absolutely true.
And politically, it is a fantasy
to invent a fake problem,
to invent something that has literally no contact
with the real lives of 99.99999%
of Americans and say,
this is the problem that the American government
must be reorganized to prioritize
and to never solve for you
so we can continue to run on it forever,
is pitiful,
a sign of profound political weakness
and something that I think has now been exposed
as the fantasist BS cop-out that it is.
And so, yeah,
I think the hard thing and the responsible thing
is to keep both of those things in mind,
the profound unseriousness of this as a political tactic
and the profound, dangerous, life-threatening harm
this is causing to real Americans
who are trans Americans.
It is startling to see,
we did a poll with YouGov
and the bulwark that we commissioned
trying to figure out
what does a bipartisan sample of Americans
think about this stuff?
And this is ahead of the election, obviously,
but a combined 15% of Americans
thought that more than 5% of NCAA athletes,
identify as trans.
- Oh my God.
- And we called the NCAA and we said,
hey, how many trans athletes are competing in women's sports
or at all?
And the NCAA told us there are effectively zero.
They can't find them.
- Wow.
- It was less than 10.
That was what Charlie Baker,
the president of the NCAA said a couple of years ago.
Now it's zero.
I do think the human cost of this
is what is lost as I try at every turn
to like make this also something that we can laugh at.
And so that tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny population of people
who just wanna like be bad at sports like everyone else,
like Rachel Maddow arguably apparently was,
the fact that they become the cudgel
that gives a party credibility
so that they can do everything else that's truly unpopular.
- Yes.
- It's so redeeming
that America didn't fall for it this time.
- Although the way,
when there were trans-related ballot measures
on the ballot in multiple states,
this week in this incredible blue wave election,
a lot of them still passed.
And not everywhere, but a lot of them did.
And I'm glad that you're talking about this the way you are
because again, you gotta think both of these things
at the same time.
This is the equivalent, I mean,
if the Republican Party were out there saying,
the real problem is that we're all getting bludgeoned
because it rains microwaves every day.
Microwave ovens are falling from the sky
and crushing us all and putting holes in our roofs.
And that's what we need.
And it's just a thing that's not happening
that they've invented.
You would wonder like,
A, why do they think they can get away
with saying this crazy thing that's not happening?
But B, why do they wanna be in office?
They're talking about a problem that isn't a real thing.
So the real thing that they want to work on,
that they want to effectuate change about
when they get an option,
when they get an office has to be something different.
That's the one thing that we'd wonder.
But in this case, because it is about,
real human beings,
I mean, the thing that we've learned over generations
in multiple countries, in multiple eras
about scapegoating disfavored minorities
is not only to pay attention to what it does to their lives,
but also what it does to the rest of us.
If you are taught to believe that some disfavored minority
is the cause of everything that's wrong in your culture,
everything that is not attainable within your economy,
every right that you believe is,
is yours, that you can't grasp,
then not only is that disfavored minority being targeted
and subjected to violence
and subjected to all the things you were just talking about,
but we're taught to look at each other
and to try to suss that out,
to try to find that quality in our fellow citizens
so that we can misdirect toward them all of our grievance.
And trying to get us to see some of our fellow citizens
as subhuman is trying to get us to,
to erase our own moral core so that we can do horrible things.
- The other, of course, like tack that got pressure tested
was what if we accuse everybody on the other side
who is brown with a foreign name of being a jihadist?
- Yeah.
- Of course, we're here in New York City.
What Zoran Mamdani has done here as a mayor,
leave it to the side, even though that's metrically,
just by the evidence, a rousing success,
safety and otherwise.
The rhetorical framework,
of how he has talked about politics
as that figure who gets, has been, you know.
- Demonized.
- Demonized, truly, almost literally,
just like he's a demon.
I don't know if it was this clear to you,
but it seemed to me that was,
there was a playbook there
for a lot of national politicians that seemed to work.
His approach to how to respond to this stuff.
And Abdul Al-Sayed, they're not the same person.
Anyone who's watched them long enough knows
they have very different sort of characters in some,
meaningful ways.
But it just seemed like the attempt to make this
the Islamophobic election.
- Yeah.
- Didn't quite work.
- When people use ham-handed tactics against you,
one option is to defend against them earnestly.
And the other one is to point and laugh
at those ham-handed tactics
and to refuse to play their game.
Refuse to let them frame either your character
or the discussion around you.
And that's what I think Mamdani did with such,
such elegance in his campaign.
Culminating in his, you know,
triumphant ascendance to be Donald Trump's
most favorite son.
- Which is just continually hilarious to me.
- It's just amazing.
I mean, Trump gets like hearts in his eyes
when he sees him.
- It's John Husted's ass and Zora Mamdani's smile.
- You are building Donald Trump's dream date.
And then there's the dud, JD.
But then, but the way that like,
look at Al-Sayed's victory speech.
- JD.
Habibi.
There is this delicious irony
in the fact that you're constitutionally obligated
to swear me in, in January.
- When he called JD Vance Habibi, I just, I lost it.
I mean, the refusal to accede to their framing
is a political flex that again, if done elegantly
and if done with good cheer and confidence is,
I think, I just think it's politically bulletproof.
I think it's, I think it's, it's the way.
- JD Vance in his post-mortem.
Again, not to make Twitter a central document here.
But he has the whole thing.
About how he has consulted all these pollsters
and the smartest people he knows on the right are saying
that there are four bullet points.
One, end the war.
Two, focus on cost of living/inflation.
Three, put America first.
Four, change our relationship to Israel.
When you read that post, this is after, by the way,
he tried to take credit for the lower crime here in New York,
by the way.
When you read his post-mortem,
what did you think as actually a political analysis?
- It sounds like JD Vance, by the way, is the guy who said,
might have been listening to Democratic politicians
who are running for high office.
office this year and winning. I mean, do the list again. Yeah. End the war. End the war.
Focus on cost of living slash inflation. Affordability. Put America first. America
first, whatever that means. Change our relationship to Israel. Yeah. To translate it to like, what
have the Democrats been saying that he is now trying to like ape? What if you actually prioritize
the interest of Americans? I mean, contrast that with Donald Trump's diagnosis of what
went wrong for the Republican Party and even setting aside the like, had I been on the ballot
and everything. His first political diagnostic after the election results were in was that Greg
Abbott would have won in Texas had he not been such a rhino. Meaning, had he not been such a
Republican in name only. Meaning, if only Greg Abbott had seemed more Republican, then the
Democrats definitely would not have won Texas. My favorite piece of analysis thus far was actually in
a journalistic piece from CBS News under Barry Weiss. I literally laughed out loud when I read
this yesterday. And they're just like reporting what the White House is telling them about the
election results. And I quote, some White House aides have predicted that some of the blame for
Republican midterm losses will be trained on Admiral Brad Cooper, the head of U.S. Central
Command, and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Dan Kaine, who both played big
roles in guidance on the Iran war. Two guys that everybody definitely knows. You know, Brad.
Brad Cooper and Dan Kaine. That's who did it. That's who did it. Everything else actually is
fine. Pete, Pete, can you fire some? I mean, the idea that that's the problem or that they could
literally try to blame the active duty U.S. military as the reason Gina Hinojosa beat Greg
Abbott. I mean, forgive me for agreeing with Ron DeSantis, but I think the approaching an
extinction level event feels right when you look at that kind of analysis. But speaking of meatball
Ron for a second, this was like a bit of a, I mean, to borrow the terminology of baseball,
a bit of a, like a meatball of a pitch. It's like, and Thomas Massey was ahead of this and
got also defenestrated. But Ron DeSantis, I give him extraordinarily little credit, but nonetheless,
he can plausibly be the guy saying, yeah, of course. Yeah. When you're looking ahead. Yeah,
of course, you know, them not realizing that he would have the ability to say that. I don't know.
This sets that movement back to what? I mean, DeSantis did lose a bunch of Republican members
of Congress and the redistricting effort in Florida was as much of a splat there as it was for anybody
else. And Ron DeSantis still has, I mean, I don't know if he's going to run for president or if he's
going to try to like assume the mantle in the Republican party, but he still has what I think
of as the Jared Kushner problem, which is that on, on paper, when you hear about Ron DeSantis,
or when you see things written down that Ron DeSantis has done, you sort of get this sense
in your mind of, of who he might be as a political figure. Um, same thing with Jared Kushner and his
term. I continue to think this is one of the most crystalline moments of the first John Donald Trump
term, which is that Donald Trump has appointed his son-in-law to be the minister of everything.
And he's in charge of the middle East and he's in charge of COVID and he's in charge of the economy.
And he's, wow, he's really the power behind the throne. Jared must be the brain of the operation.
Maybe Jared is the heavyweight here. And then Jared, for the first time walks up to do a White
House press conference and nobody's ever heard him speak before. And he steps up to the microphone
and everybody's like, this is the guy, this is the brain, this is the heavyweight. And he steps
up to the mic and he goes, hi, I'm Jared. Together, we will unleash the creativity of the private
sector to provide citizen services in a way that has never happened before. Like there's that same
problem with Ron DeSantis. You get to him in the flesh and it's the guy eating the pudding with
the fingers. And, um, you know, Hey, I'm Ron DeSantis. But let's just be clear, uh, about what
happened last night. Uh, this is close to an extinction level event.
For Republicans in many parts of the country, as we have seen probably in the last hundred years.
There is a, uh, an, a corporeal problem with some of these guys who might otherwise reasonably step
up and take the mantle of Republican politics in a way that's just never going to work.
Yeah. I do think, I mean, again, what, what has Trump had his finger on the pulse on
purely superficially? I guess he has a strong sense of like who I would cast.
Until they must be cast out.
It is interesting when you assess vengeance as one possible political approach here. And I'm not
going to sort of put everything under the category of vengeance, but I want to just frame it at
extremes. One is Robert Garcia.
Saying lawyer up, you know, as the chair of the House Oversight Committee. Um, and the other is
the James Tallarico slogan up atop the victory dais where it's love thy neighbor.
Because there is no love of God without love of neighbor.
How do you assess that alleged choice? How do you assess the tension between
lawyer up and love thy neighbor?
I really don't think that they're at odds.
I don't think that they're opposites. Um, I think that Donald Trump's going to be president for
another couple of years. And that means the Trump administration is going to be in place
for another couple of years. And when it comes to love thy neighbor, um, one of the things that
Democrats are going to need to try to assure is that neighbors are not getting absolutely ripped
off by a ruling family that's picking up the U.S. government by its ankles and shaking it till the
change falls out.
Um, I think there has to be a strong message sent by the Democrats and the Democrats with
Robert Garcia's committee and Jamie Raskin's committee and others can do this. There needs
to be a strong message sent that you can't get away with this stuff anymore. You can't keep doing this
for another two years. And to the extent that you did get away for it for two years, that's now going
to end and you're going to be held accountable. And so I think it's really important, really,
really important that Todd Blanch be impeached.
For example, and not because there needs to be a spectacle of Todd Blanch being put in the
stocks, you know, but because of what Todd Blanch has done, like you can't have somebody
pay a million dollars to go to a Mar-a-Lago dinner with Donald Trump. And then less than
three weeks later, her son gets a pardon. You can't have that. You can't have the parent
company of crypto.com giving five million dollars to MAGA Inc. And then 25 days later, the Department
of Justice intervenes in a federal lawsuit on behalf of crypto.com. You can't have days before
the election, the Justice Department filing absolutely frivolous, totally unfounded, not
even procedurally sound, harassing investigations and lawsuits and legal filings against not only
election officials, but candidates for election in that next office in direct contravention of
Justice Department policies. You can't do those things. And so there needs to be a message you
can't get away with this.
To the extent that you've done it already, you're going to pay for it. And with the Democrats in
charge right now, with a mandate from the American people to clean this stuff up, you are going to be
barred forever from public service. And we are going to do that by impeaching you. And it doesn't
need to be a spectacle. It doesn't need to be revenge. It needs to be about making sure that
we don't live in a kleptocracy anymore. It occurs to me as you say all of that,
yeah, that's what the trans athlete stuff was trying to distract from.
Yes.
It's like World Liberty Financial is over here. But what about the
swimmer over, over there?
The one, the one swimmer a few years ago, trust us.
When they tied for fifth. The point, the argument here is,
can you show that corruption and affordability are actually interwoven via this political project
that we're now, yeah, by mandate, asked as a country to reckon with? And I suppose the other
issue here is,
who becomes a subject of those investigations? And how do you prevent that from being politicized?
I mean, we're here to also talk about your book, which is excellent, your new book,
Department of Fate.
Thank you.
And so this is a topic that I want to understand historically in a second.
But just from a present day perspective, there are more billionaires than ever,
and yet not that many of them such that the politics should bend towards them electorally.
Where do you start when it comes?
As to, you know, what Talarico has also said in his rhetoric, which has been very effective of like,
this is top versus bottom.
Well, look at the spending in Texas. I mean, I, when you're saying like, when I made the call
about various, like when I made the Amy Acton call for the Ohio governor's race, when it came
to making the Gina Hinojosa call for governor in Texas, I kind of shouted it out in a way that
makes it a totally unusable soundbite because I think I was distorting on the mic.
will be the next Democratic governor of the United States.
the state of Texas. I'm saying it so loud so you can hear it over the crackling of the burning
piles of hundreds of millions of dollars set alight by Elon Musk. What's the last accounting
of it? How much money? I mean, he spent a half billion dollars roughly in the election, but at
least, I mean, approaching, at least approaching $200 million just for the Ken Paxton race,
just for the James Tallarico-Ken Paxton race, in which Ken Paxton lost by 12.
And so I do think we're in a little bit of a flex period in terms of the politics of money
and politics. Seeing Republican billionaires, right-wing billionaires, from Miriam Adelson to
Jeff Yass to Elon Musk to all of, you know, Andreessen, all of these guys, to see all of
this spending just. Like, in no other midterm election we've ever seen before. And to see it all just curdle,
to see it go nowhere, is very satisfying. But it also, it raises an interesting question as to
whether that kind of takes the foot off the gas in terms of people trying to make sure that we get
big money out of our politics. In normal elections, of which this was not one, having that much money
on one side of any political fight will be determinative. And it just so happened that the
political winds were blowing so hard in one direction here, it didn't matter. But does that
mean that the pressure to try to fix the money and politics problem eases up? I hope not. I think
practically it might. Yeah. It also just seems like a true bipartisan coalition that's available.
That, like, this election was about a lot. And this was kind of the subtext, as you just put it.
But it hasn't really. Well, perhaps now it can be. It hasn't been foregrounded as, like, the,
hey, those who remain.
Let's talk about how we can all agree that Citizens United might be a really important
thing to tackle if we only have a few things to tackle. And I think that hierarchy of what do we
tackle. Yeah. Now that we have, again, this strange new coalition. It's like, how do you
maintain it? Because the cynicism, of course, and I fall prey to this sometimes, is just that we're
riding a pendulum. Mm-hmm. And they pushed it so far.
One direction that we got it swung way back by the midterms. But there is the opportunity.
Yes. And that's what's exciting. And that's where the whole, like, rhetoric. Look, I love every
tweet that you read. Mm-hmm. I do. But if you're going to also now be, like, political strategist
guy or gal, you're thinking to yourself, yeah, like, we should be talking about that.
I think the biggest difference between the two political parties in the United States right now,
is that Democrats have ideas about using the political process for policy purposes
that are designed to make people's lives better. Like, Democrats have this idea that they should
use the oversight function of Congress to oversee the federal government. And they should make
policy that tries to make things cheaper for people. And that gets people to have health
insurance who don't have health insurance now, and to get people who have health insurance to
not lose it. And there's. And people who are overwhelmed by the repayment costs of their student loans should get help from
the government to deal with their student loans. And farmers shouldn't be punished for international
trade policies they have nothing to do with that they couldn't have known about when they decided
what to plant this year. Like, it's very, like, practical, boring policy stuff.
Classic nerd s**t.
Yes. And Republicans are like, how can we end Alzheimer's research? I know that transgenic
and transgender are two different things, but I don't like mice either way. And so therefore,
the National Institutes of Health needs to be dropped from a helicopter in Chile. Like,
the Republican Party has a different kind of agenda. They really want to change the form
of government. They want a monarchical, royalist, presidentialist form of government where the other
two branches fade away. They want judges to be browbeaten into serving as political servants to
the great leader.
They don't want elections to be the grounds on which we move forward with different politicians
or not. You know, they, regardless of the fact that they just lost an election in every conceivable
way, it remains the gospel of the Republican Party that if Democrats win an election, it must
have been cheating. I mean, it's just two different projects. And now that Democrats are going to be
governing not only the legislative branch, but also state governments from coast to coast,
the question is, can we return to government that is about nerd shit? Can we return to government
that's about policy and not just about warfare? What you said was something that, again,
as of last week, could be dismissed as classic Rachel Maddow shit. But now the anthropologist
is looking at you through binoculars being like, oh my God, there's more of them.
They're multiplying. What if this is not quite the pendulum,
but they're trying to build a different device? The physics of this don't need to be the same.
What if one of the ways the pendulum swings is people care about their country or they don't?
People care about participating in the political process or they don't?
I mean, to see the turnout numbers and to see the early turnout numbers and to see the
turnout numbers among African-American and Latino voters in particular. Yes, everybody's looking at
that in terms of what the outcome is. I mean, I think it's a great question. I think it's a great
question. But to see that participation level go up is also a swing of the pendulum toward people believing
that the democratic process is the means by which they can choose a different future.
And part of the authoritarian project is to make you disbelieve that. And people reject it.
Which brings us to your book. So, Department of Fate, The Promise, The Power, and the Collapse
of America's Most Consequential Institution, aka the DOJ. We are the sports show that talks about
the DOJ a lot. Turns out we investigate NBA gambling scandals, which are born out of the
Eastern District of New York. We do these investigations into Steve Ballmer and the
Clippers. We win Pulitzer Prizes for that. And by the way, we are grappling with what's the DOJ's
interest in this, as they now have an interest in that, also out of the Eastern District.
We've interviewed the teammates of Kash Patel's rec league hockey team,
the Dons. Again, a little on the nose. Nonetheless, why and how is the big picture
arc of the DOJ something that you want people to understand? I think the DOJ is a different kind of
cat. I think that it is an institution that is just different than everything else in the U.S.
government and different than everything else in the country. I also think that I was really wrong
about what was going to happen at DOJ under Donald Trump. At the end of the first term,
we had, remember Bill Barr was the Attorney General at that point, and we had like the
Durham investigation, which was this terrible thing. We had U.S. attorneys being pushed out
or resigning over White House demands to bring specific prosecutions, like this botched effort
to prosecute John Kerry. Oh, right. Yeah.
And Obama's White House counsel, Gregory Craig, right? We had demands from President Trump
for the prosecution of Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton and all this stuff.
And before he ultimately bailed at the end, actually in the 2020 election, we had Attorney
General Barr bring the Justice Department on board toward trying to bolster Trump's false
claims about election fraud. And because of that, I and a lot of other people very confidently
predicted that in the second Trump term, the Justice Department would be able to bring the
Justice Department on board toward trying to bolster Trump's false claims about election fraud.
That the Justice Department would just be a nuclear weapon. That the Justice Department would be
the most important story of Trump's first term. And that's the thing that he would supersize
and turn into the instrument of his revenge. And instead, we have not seen that. The agency that
they supersized is Department of Homeland Security and ICE and HSI and all of those guys. That's
who's turned American streets into scenes that look like Civil War. That's who's shooting people
in the street and running them down and everything. And it's not just the Department of Homeland
Security. It's the Department of Homeland Security. And instead, with the Justice Department,
it's kind of turned into this joke. I mean, the U.S. attorney in D.C. is the one Fox News host
who had a worse reputation than Pete Hegseth. Like, the less impressive Fox News host than
Pete Hegseth got U.S. attorney for Washington, D.C. He put not one, but two different podcasters
in charge of the FBI. You're talking about Janine Pirro, Dan Bongino, and Kash Patel,
respectively. Yes.
I mean, the Justice Department, rather than being supersized the way Homeland Security was,
they lost literally thousands of headcount. They shut down the public integrity section. They shut
down the National Security Division. They shut down the tax division. They just ended it. And
why is that? You would think that he would want to use the Justice Department as the biggest,
most powerful weapon that he could. And instead, it's a mess and a clown car and a joke and
everything they do fails. And I think that's important. I think we should see the Justice
Department now as dead. And I think if you look back historically, we should recognize that what the Justice
Department does more than any other institution,
it sets the course of the nation.
Sets the course of the nation
for what's allowed politically.
It sets the course of the nation economically
for who's allowed to have legal standing
to conduct themselves in our economy.
It sets the grounds of who counts
as a first-class citizen and who doesn't.
The Justice Department's really, really important.
And it can be used for really, really good ends
like it was when it was founded
just after the Civil War.
It can also be used for terrible reasons
when you want it to.
But it's important right now
that they've effectively killed it.
It's such a joke when I investigate these stories
and part of the end game of any reporting process
is the question of,
well, what will the DOJ do about this?
What will the feds do about this?
And every answer you get as an analysis of the evidence
has the giant footnote of
unless they hire the lawyer
that can strike a deal with the DOJ.
And Donald Trump personally.
Is there somebody involved in this case
who can buy a million-dollar dinner ticket to Mar-a-Lago
who will then unwire the entire case?
I've had so many conversations
with former federal prosecutors who've sat in that chair.
And the whole thing is moot.
The whole conversation is moot
if that's the end game anyway.
And so I say this just because
what we're saying in this whole conversation
is that there's the opportunity to be a country
that really does nerdily care about the rule of law.
And the Constitution,
the thing that people who once ran for office on the right
would carry pocket-sized versions of.
Little constitutions.
And their approach to this
has been of a piece with the whole general corruption shit
in which it's like, yeah, Keystone Cops.
Yeah.
And so the question of why?
Why did they do this?
Is it because they wanted the ATM
more than they wanted the weapon?
No.
How do you assess it?
I think what's going on here
is that you need a Justice Department
to effectuate the rule of law
and the protections of the Constitution.
And when the Justice Department acts that way,
it can be very, very righteous and very noble
and it has incredible power.
But I also think equally
that because that's the role of the Justice Department,
if you want a dictatorship,
if you want a kleptocracy,
if you want an authoritarian rule by fiat,
steal anything you want kind of country,
you need to not have a Justice Department.
It's just not handy
in that kind of a government structure
to have a building full of skilled lawyers.
It's not.
Who are just, by the way, watching.
Yes.
Who are on email chains,
who have access to computers.
It's probably best if they all leave.
Exactly.
With subpoena power and the whole thing.
And if, yes, it is great
to try to turn a building full of lawyers
into your personal law firm,
which is the way
that people shorthand
what Trump has done
to the Justice Department
to try to turn them
into your weapons or whatever.
But that's a sort of a ham-handed small tool.
Like, it's just as handy
to have a masked secret police force
that will go, you know,
raid Ilhan Omar's home
or whatever it is.
If you want an inward-facing
Praetorian Guard secret police paramilitary force
that answers without accountability
to the president,
they have built that
inside the Department of Homeland Security.
They did not build that.
At the Justice Department.
They instead have essentially decided
to shut down the Justice Department
because if you want to rule by fiat,
you can't have a government agency
that runs well,
that has, say,
a public integrity section,
and have it be operating
and running on all full cylinders
while you are trying to rob the country blind.
You just can't have it.
And so the Justice Department,
I think, was,
in a way that we don't appreciate,
fundamentally broken.
Like, I think it was,
stabbed in the heart
in the first Trump term
by Bill Barr.
And the book sort of makes that case.
And I think that it's effectively dead now.
And I think we need to appreciate
how important it is
to the survival of the Constitutional Republic.
And we need to rebuild,
refound the Justice Department
in a way that appreciates
how important it is
and that never allows it
to be either killed off
or corrupted again.
You mentioned Bill Barr a couple times.
And there's a section of your book
which I greatly enjoyed
because it also has to do
with sports.
There is,
I have it here.
Oh, good.
If you could just tell us
the story of William Barr
through the lens of his personal
athletic career as a young person.
Back in his intramural football days
at Columbia,
an opponent had thrown sand
in Bill Barr's face
at the end of a play,
momentarily blinding him
and causing, quote,
searing pain,
according to Bill Barr's own memoir.
The behavior was,
was unsportsmanlike
and worthy of payback.
But Barr's teammates
had wisely held him back
from retaliating in the moment
and maybe inviting
a costly penalty
or even ending the game early.
Barr explained to President Trump,
quote,
as we played on,
both teams kept a close watch
on me and my antagonist
to ensure we did not come to blows.
By the time the game ended
two hours later,
the matter seemed forgotten
and both fraternities
set out together
on the walk back to campus.
At that point,
I walked over to my assailant
and laid him out,
stupefied on the pavement
with a bloody nose.
The moral of this parable,
as Barr explained it
to the famously hot-headed Donald Trump,
was that sometimes
you had to control your emotions
at least for a time
and wait for the right moment
to exact your revenge,
lest you risk blowing the entire game.
My way, the game was finished
and justice was meted out in the end.
The other obvious takeaway
that Barr did not spell out was this.
It's a lot easier to win a fight
when your opponent
is unaware that he's in one
and has no chance
to put his guard up.
Sucker punches
are the best punches.
Yeah.
A moral portrait
of Bill Barr.
That tracks.
That's a plausible scouting report
as Bill Barr himself wrote
in his own book.
He's bragging about this.
That's the best part.
The Justice Department
is supposed to protect,
supposed to effectuate
the protections of the Constitution,
protect all of us.
We're all supposed to benefit
from those protections.
Not only against other people
in America
who might try to define,
who might try to encroach
on those freedoms,
but against the government
trying to encroach
on those freedoms.
The Justice Department
is supposed to protect us
from all comers
in terms of our constitutionally
protected individual rights.
But the Justice Department
can instead join
with the most powerful forces
in the country,
the ones who are trying to
deprive other people of their rights.
And in so doing,
they can become
incredibly damaging
and they can set the course
of the nation.
It's just the Justice Department
has power that no other institution
in the United States does.
And we should,
when we refound it,
because we're going to need to,
we need to refound it
in a way that is cognizant
of those powers
and treats it specially
in terms of how careful we are
about installing
its political leadership.
Here we have the connectivity
between corruption
and affordability.
Yeah.
Here we have the connectivity
of the very Venn diagram
that maybe isn't this binary,
but the same f***ing thing.
And the person who's been best,
I think, able to articulate that
heading into this mammoth election
we just had is John Ossoff, right?
So John Ossoff wins by,
what did he win by?
17 or 18 points
or something ridiculous.
He won by roughly a zillion points
in Georgia.
And the reason he went from
the most vulnerable Senate Democrat,
the most vulnerable senator
standing for reelection,
to the most vulnerable senator
in America,
to the guy who won
by nearly 20 points,
I think was because
he's had an incredibly
disciplined message
saying they are robbing you blind
and that is why you are poor.
Those things are connected.
When the government
serves the purpose of people
who give the president
millions of dollars,
the government then is turned
against your interests.
And not only are things
not getting better for you,
but things will continually
get worse for you
as long as you're not
as we are governed
by kleptocrats.
Right.
It's not the undocumented immigrant.
It's not the trans athlete.
It's not the alleged jihadist
that goes to school with your kid.
It's perhaps the people
with all the money.
Yeah.
That might be a good. And when the government
sides with them
and against you,
it is your obligation
as a small-D Democrat
to stand up
and throw those bums
out of the government.
Rachel Baddow,
thank you so much for doing this.
You're awesome.
Thank you so much
for having me here.
I'm like,
I just,
I think you're great
and it's really nice
that you asked me to be here.
It's just a pleasure
to talk to a three-sport athlete.
I'm getting fouled
out of this one, too.
The elbows have been pointing.
Exactly.
Thanks, Pablo.
Pablo Torre Finds Out
is produced by
Walter Averoma,
Maxwell Carney,
Ryan Cortez,
Juan Garcia,
Galindo,
Patrick Kim,
Neely Lohman,
Rob McRae,
Laura Newcomb,
Matt Sullivan,
Claire Taylor,
and Chris Tuminello.
Studio engineering
by RG Systems,
sound design
by Andrew Bursick,
digital strategy
by Bailey Carlin
and Andrew Northern,
theme song,
as always,
by John Bravo.
And we'll talk to you
next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Amy Acton defeated Vivek Ramaswamy in the Ohio governor's race by a significant margin, marking a bipartisan victory and a major shift in the political landscape.
The backlash against Ramaswamy was intense, fueled by allegations of moral impropriety, including a reported $15 million mansion purchase near the governor’s residence and ties to Senator John Husted’s wife.
The political campaign against trans athletes by right-wing figures like Jay Feeley failed, as trans athletes are extremely rare in NCAA sports and such claims are demonstrably false and harmful.
The election revealed a deep disconnect between political rhetoric and reality, with Republican attempts to scapegoat marginalized groups—such as trans people or immigrants—exposing their lack of legitimacy and real-world impact.
The Justice Department was undermined during the Trump administration, losing key divisions and becoming ineffective, highlighting how its erosion enables authoritarianism and corruption.
The episode underscores a growing public rejection of elite political power and a shift toward policies focused on affordability, equity, and accountability.
The election outcomes signal a strengthening of democratic participation, especially among African-American and Latino voters, indicating renewed belief in the electoral process.
A reimagined, independent Justice Department is needed to protect constitutional rights, resist political corruption, and restore faith in democratic institutions.
Summary:
S. election results, particularly the victory of Democrat Amy Acton over Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio, a moment seen as both a political triumph and a moral reckoning. Ramaswamy’s campaign, marked by controversial claims and ties to elite real estate, faced strong backlash for being perceived as morally repulsive and out of touch, especially in a traditionally red state.
The discussion also examines how right-wing narratives—such as the supposed threat of trans athletes in sports—lack factual grounding and serve as political tools to distract from real issues like economic inequality and corruption. A key theme is the failure of Republican leaders to address systemic problems, including the misallocation of power and spending, as seen in Texas and other battlegrounds. The episode highlights the growing public skepticism toward political elites, especially billionaires and right-wing figures who have fueled policies harming ordinary citizens.
Central to the narrative is the decline of the Justice Department under Trump, which lost institutional strength and integrity, undermining constitutional protections. Pablo and Rachel analyze how this breakdown enables authoritarianism and corruption. They argue that a rebirth of the DOJ—rooted in accountability, transparency, and rule of law—is essential to restore trust in democracy.
The episode concludes with a powerful call to action: to reject political scapegoating, defend the rule of law, and rebuild institutions that serve the public good. The intersection of sports, politics, and ethics—like the story of Bill Barr’s football incident—illustrates how personal history mirrors broader political failures. Ultimately, the election signals a shift in public confidence, where people are choosing policies that prioritize fairness, affordability, and real human needs over ideological extremism.
FAQs
Democrat Amy Acton won the Ohio governor's race with 52.31% of the vote, defeating Republican Vivek Ramaswamy, who received 44%.
He faced criticism for being seen as morally repulsive, including allegations of inappropriate behavior and a controversial ad that used his opponent's mother. Additionally, he was criticized for wanting to live in a $15 million mansion near the governor's residence.
She described it as a politically transparent and unserious tactic, harmful to real people, and a sign of political weakness, noting that no NCAA athletes identify as trans and that the policy has no basis in reality.
She argued that the Justice Department is a powerful institution that shapes national policy and constitutional protections, but under Trump, it was weakened and used as a tool for political retaliation rather than upholding the rule of law.
Maddow shared that she was a three-sport athlete in high school, playing volleyball, basketball, and swimming, and described her experience as being slow, clumsy, and frequently fouled out of games, which shaped her self-perception.
She noted that Republican candidates lost due to a lack of credible policy, and that the election revealed a shift in public trust, with voters rejecting populist, anti-constitutional narratives and choosing candidates focused on real economic issues.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.