Go back

How To Feel Safer In A Chaotic World | Dr. Raj Panjabi

57m 50s

How To Feel Safer In A Chaotic World | Dr. Raj Panjabi

Dr. Raj Punjabi, a Harvard physician and former White House official, presents a practical, science-backed approach to navigating modern life’s uncertainties in his book *Safer: A Playbook, Turning Fear into Action and Crisis into Community*. He argues that denial and normalcy bias are not weaknesses but evolutionary tools that help protect us from constant alertness. To counteract paralysis, he introduces eight actionable "plays," such as using pre-mortems to simulate crises and set clear thresholds for action. He emphasizes the critical role of community, showing how shared responsibility and trust—especially in times of crisis—can provide both emotional and practical support. Punjabi also highlights how control and fear-based reactions escalate conflict, while curiosity and empathy foster connection. Central to his framework is flexibility: anchoring to purpose while remaining open to change, allowing individuals to adapt through iteration. He distinguishes between measurable risk and unquantifiable uncertainty, advocating for transparency in acknowledging unknowns to build trust. A key insight is that embracing uncertainty through small, concrete actions—like shifting the locus of control or practicing choice-point check-ins—builds resilience over time. Drawing on personal and global examples, from pandemic responses to family crises, he demonstrates how uncertainty can be transformed into growth. Ultimately, the book promotes a balanced, grounded response to chaos: neither denial nor panic, but a proactive, human-centered approach rooted in self-awareness, community, and mindful action.

Transcription

9633 Words, 52338 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Hello everybody, welcome to the 10% happier podcast. I'm your host, Dan Harris. We live in an increasingly uncertain and unstable world, at least it feels that way. And quite understandably, you might be tempted to approach this constant upheaval by trying to control everything compulsively or alternatively curling up into a ball of denial. Neither of these is a winning strategy. We are gonna talk to somebody today who has some much better ideas about how to navigate the dumpster fire of modern life. His name is Dr. Raj Punjabi. He's a Harvard Medical School physician who also served as a Senior Director for Global Health Security and Bio-Defense at the White House National Security Council under President Biden. A time magazine has listed him as one of the 100 most influential people in the world, which is not bad. And his new book is called Safer, a playbook, turning fear into action and crisis into community. Dr. Rajabi, welcome to the show. - Thanks for having me on, Dan. - Pleasure to have you on. Nobody's put me on any lists of 100 most influential people. So I'm gonna just try to sit here and control my resentment, but very, very nice to meet you. And I'm really interested in talking about the book. One of the things that you talk about is that in the face of uncertainty and a people a common kind of signature move of a human is denial. Why do we do that? Is there an evolutionary explanation? - I found out that there is. I used to think it was a character flaw. If you didn't take a threat seriously enough and then it came back to the bite you. And I kind of experienced that the hard way. I start the book off talking about this experience of our infant daughter developing a life threatening illness and I missed it as my own living room. And for a while, you know, felt a deep amount of guilt as a parent, but also as a doctor. I trained health workers around the world to find heart failure. That's what she ended up having. And when I started to do the research on safer, I found that denials the first feeling we tend to experience in a crisis. Or at times of deep uncertainty. And it turns out it's not a character flaw. What you learn is that it's actually hardwired into our brain evolutionarily. And here's the thing I learned. If you think back to our pre-human ancestors out on the Savannah, they'd have to kind of be aware of a leopard was gonna jump off a branch and try to attack you. But if you always thought a leopard was gonna jump off a branch and attack you, your brain simply can't sustain that level of vigilance. And so it became a way to adapt. And we started to believe that whatever is happening today is how tomorrow will be as well. And that's a phenomenon that psychologists actually refer to as normalcy bias. And that is actually a good thing, but it also makes us less capable of assessing when tomorrow won't be like today. We need normalcy bias or else we're just constantly on high alert and running our nervous systems into the ground. However, we also need a system for recognizing threats as they arise. - Yes, yes, we do. And part of the reason I wrote this book as a playbook, it's an eight play guide for navigating crisis and uncertainty is because I wanted to figure out how we overcome that denial. When it's the right time to do it, like if your child has a slow moving health condition, like mine did, that just tips over all of a sudden and you don't see the signs coming. How do you see the signs coming? Or you're sitting there doing scrolling on your screen and thinking about all the bad things happening in the world, should we be alarmed or not alarmed? So the macro crisis and the ones that happen every day turns out there is a way to deal with it. I experience like many people crisis as chaos. But what I learned is actually there's, it's not formless. There's really eight themes that come up and one of them's denial, but we also tend to, the next experience is usually feeling alone. You think about someone in your life or if you've had a severe diagnosis or you just got laid off that you'll feel isolated. We're often assessing our risk. Change happens often in a crisis. Critical information's always shifting. And then there's other themes that come up like conflict. You know, remember during the pandemic that challenged during mandates, people felt controlled. And then there's vulnerability that pops up and hopefully some add adaptation, but you have to change and evolve when there's a crisis. And the last one is uncertainty. I mean, sometimes like in the case of my daughter, we're not sure why the heart failure happened. She's still alive, thankfully. She's nine now. But we don't know if it was an infectious cause which she did have a virus grow out of her heart or it was a genetic cause. And we may never know what the cause is. So it may come back, it may not come back. And that sometimes is what happens with the crisis is that it persists or the uncertainty around it persists. First of all, I'm glad your daughter, whose name I think is Karuna. Karuna, yeah. Which means compassion. Yes. I come out of the Buddhist tradition. Oh, sure. We use Karuna quite a bit in my world. Well, our kids are named Abe Sohan and Karuna. Abe is courage. Sohan is consciousness and Karuna is compassion. Nice. I love that. Yeah, I'm also, I have a problem with eliteration. So it's the only way I can remember things in medical school. We're gonna get to many of your plays for dealing with uncertainty. But let's start with denial. And because you do actually have some recommendations for how do we counteract the normalcy bias without, again, throwing ourselves into perennial hair on fire. What do you recommend? So a few things I've learned. Number one, when you're trying to distinguish crisis from normalcy, one of the first things you can do is to do a pre-mortem. So imagine things going wrong and you work backwards from there and say, why would they have gone wrong? And you essentially simulate something going wrong. So this could be your at work and you sense there's volatility in your sector. I'm in the biotech sector. Imagine the stock market crashes tomorrow and I'm worried about having been laid off. Simulate what it would mean to get laid off for you. Who would you call first? Do you have enough cash in the bank to help you during that period? That helps prepare your mind for dealing with that even when it happens. That's one idea, another tool. - Wait, I'm gonna get up it on there. - Yeah, yeah. - Because I don't know if you know this, but in stoicism they have this idea of pre-meditation of evil, where you deliberately envision horrible shit that could happen so that you actually, it has the counterintuitive effect of relaxing your nervous system because you develop a plan and see that in the case of whatever evil might arise, you can survive it. So for example, in my company, I'm in the creator economy. I have a podcast that gives speeches, I write books, I have a social media operation, I have a meditation app. Like there are these five or six revenue streams. At any given moment, Apple changes the way its algorithms work, or Instagram changes the way its algorithm works, or the ad market for podcasting collapses, any number of these things can happen and have happened. So every once in a while, sitting down with my CEO and doing what you're calling a pre-mortem or what the Stokes would call pre-metatio malorum, which is pre-meditation of evil. It's just thinking, okay, we've had many crises in our past. Let's imagine some future crises. What would we do in those cases? And that interrupts the normalcy bias, but not in the way that makes you feel terrified all the time. It actually soothes you because you know some bad chick could happen, but we're prepared for it. - That's right. I think there's that old adage better to be safe than sorry. It turns out better to be prepared than to be sorry. It's the way you probably practice how to be safer. This practice you're describing, maybe the CIA trains people in Buddhism because I've seen that the pre-mortem work being done by intelligence officials at the National Security Council. I mean, we would do these tabletop exercises, right? To predict a future flu pandemic, for instance. And we would, you know, you kind of feed a story the head of the National Security Council and you'd say, hey, there's a new flu outbreak in Cambodia and it is spreading quickly between people and it's killing a number of them. Okay, when do you start warning the public? Do you have enough information to do that or are you just gonna freak everybody out? When do you start putting billions of dollars to invest in a vaccine? 'Cause every day is lies and an emergency. And then I saw, I've seen it, the other place I've seen it, Dan, is in my own practice as a doctor. I spent most of my career in intro medicine just trying to help people deal with common conditions like diabetes and high cholesterol and trying to persuade them that if they take action now Eat better, more physical activity, they could prevent heart disease. And I kept stumbling. Like I just failed at when I said heart disease. But the moment I asked them to visualize concretely what they would lose if they had a heart attack or a stroke. Like what would you miss if you actually had a stroke and couldn't use a part of your body? Then people would start saying, "Oh, I don't want to lose the chance to take my kids out into the playground and push them on a swing or I don't want to mess up my golf stroke." Then people realized if you could make risk, concrete and emotional. You know, Daniel Kahneman's fame is for having written about how people are more likely to take an action of it is framed as avoiding a loss than for the equivalent gain. And I think that's the same psychology of denial and fear that's probably playing out in the situation room and perhaps in stoicism and Buddhism as it is in the exam room, I think. That's really interesting. I did interrupt you, though, because you were going to move from remortem to some other play. Yeah, there's another one that's for turning denial into action and that's the first play in the book. It's called turn denial into action. So you pre-define a metric or threshold at which point you would take an action. So as a epidemiologist, when you're trying to detect a new outbreak, you're essentially asking a very basic question, are there more cases of measles, for instance, than you expect? And you just look at past years and you say, well, there were 10 cases of measles last year and now there's 100 cases. So there's like, something's going on. So what do you do? You then are going to send a team to go investigate that. But what you've done is you pre-define and the pre is the key part. You've written down on the left side of the paper, here's the thing objectively. In that case, the number of cases, if that trigger is met, then I'm going to take an action which is to send an investigation team. And so there are ways to apply that in our lives as well, whether you're leading a business or you're trying to help your child deal with how they're navigating a school test, for instance, that trigger action discipline is critical. And the psychology behind it, Dan, is for a slow moving crisis. What psychologists have found is that we have a very hard time of identifying that threat getting worse until it reaches an acute tipping point, the classic frog in a boiling pot of water. Exactly. Exactly. And they have a term for this, it's called liminality. You've heard of the word subliminal, right? And so liminality, liminal threshold, once a crisis in your home or in the world reaches an acute tipping point, liminality, at that point, how is that defined? It's defined by that point after which things will no longer be the same that you have to adapt. And everyone remembers March 2020 when you had this thing COVID going around for a while and then all of a sudden Stockmark crashed the National Basketball Association shut down and school shut down. All of a sudden, that was the tipping point, but the idea of a predefined metric or threshold it being objective measurable is that you have a better chance of seeing those early warning signals before you hit that acute tipping point. So it's funny. I am hearing all of this as kind of the middle path between denial and constant freaking out. So these strategies you're giving us feel like ways to not be in denial, not be suckered by normalcy bias, but then also not be so worried all the time that you're burning yourself out. So if I hear your thing about these triggers, I could just think about my son, for example, my son's almost 12, he's really smart. But we don't yet know what kind of student he is. Do I want to spend all my time wondering and worrying about this kid going to be a good student? Or do I want to say, look, if he starts getting seas, we're going to have a serious conversation about is he in the right school? Does he need more tutors? Does he need a contract that my parents when I was a bad student gave me a contract and said if you get above a certain grade, I'll pay you a bigger allowance. Then I will take action, but now the best use of my energy is neither denial nor unrestrained anxiety. And this helps me cope. A hundred percent. It helps you avoid overreaction and underreaction, both. And I think that's right. That's the value I found in it, like with my daughter, for instance, Dan, you know, when she fell sick, I got a call from a pediatrician. I'm holding my other two sons who were like four and six. My daughter was just turned to, and the pediatrician said, we just got the X-ray results back. My wife was with her and your daughter's heart is twice the size of normal. And the only time, like I've been on the giving end of that news, and it's usually a 75-year-old who has heart failure. That night, we're in the intensive care unit the next three weeks where in the hospital at Boston Children's Hospital, amazing care for her. And she comes out of it and, you know, she's on medicines for the next two years. And I'm sitting there in her intensive care unit room, cuddling my wife the first night. Thankfully, she is a psychologist. My wife's, she's way more like Stoic and calm than I was. I got on my phone and started looking up all the medical studies to try to predict whether my daughter would be the one third that needs a heart transplant or would die if there's no, not available, whether she'd recover or she'd need medicines the whole life. So I think now what I've thought is, well, she's recovered. We don't know the cause fully. It could come back. It may not come back. That's what we've been told by her pediatric cardiologist. And the good news is they've given us a way to measure if it will come back. And what is that? Maybe two years, she has to go get an ultrasound of her heart. And the ultrasound of her heart measures how good her heart squeezes. And there's a, there's a fraction in medicine. We call it an ejection fraction. It's like supposed to be, you know, a certain percentage. And the nice thing is now I can just see if it starts to slide rather than what I probably would have been doing is ruminating about whether this will happen again. And I think that's just that objective calibration as you describe the middle path between panic and denial is certainly a more sane path. Yes. Yes. And it's a safe, it feels like I feel safer, but I don't feel like I'm neglecting my dog. Exactly. Exactly. Yes. It's about the appropriate amount of vigilance, not hyper vigilance and not hypo vigilance. Okay. So let's talk about another play in your book. One of your core arguments is that when we're in a crisis, one of the most powerful tools is community. I believe that your people like your wife, psychologists often refer to this as social support. Yeah. Let me start with a very basic question. Why is that so important when you're in a crisis? The second place called don't go it alone. It's critical for a lot of reasons. Number one, you might get more information about a threat that you may otherwise not know about. Number two, you may get more resources than you may otherwise get if you try to pursue something alone. So let me, let me just give you an example for my own life. When I was nine years old, so I grew up in West Africa in a country called Liberia. In Manerovia, the capital. My parents migrated there from India in the 70s. We lived under an authoritarian dictator and eventually the country devolved into civil war. My parents had no idea about whether we should flee. When you have to make a decision to leave everything behind your home, the store that you've, the home goods store you've set up, your kids school, uproot yourself and try to find life somewhere else when the airport, the airport in the country shut down and rebels are marching on your hometown. But you're hearing the dictator on TV say everything's under control and there's no independent media. That was the situation my parents face. I was nine. My sister was four. You're trying to make a really tough decision. Do I stay or do I go? Well, my parents could not rely on the information that they were seeing on TV because you couldn't trust the guy who was leading the country. So where do they reach out to? This group of ethnic Indians, Cindy's were called sort of migrated around the world. They had friends in the US who were getting information from the US embassy as Americans saying these rebels are literally marching on the road coming to your town now. You need to get out. My dad started helping evacuate people on planes. He sent my mother, sister and I out and eventually he got out on one of the very last planes that he helped organize. I mean, quite literally if we hadn't been able to depend on the community that we were connected to that in that case by our ethnicity, we may have been caught in the inferno. And then when we ended up here in America and North Carolina, that family took my family in. We got physical support, I found out where to go to school, my parents learned new jobs. So there are some really practical things that social connection can help you with. In addition to emotional support, there are some very physical things that can help you with that are sometimes existential. You know, for your survival or how you're going to thrive. This is one of the rifts I go on a lot on the show. I suspect my staff has a little drinking game every time I give this speech. But I'm going to give it again. We are living in a counter evolutionary way in a society that is built around consumerism, individualism and tech driven isolation. I don't think it's coincidence that we're also seeing unprecedented levels of anxiety, depression, suicide addiction and loneliness. So you want to be healthy and happy and as anxiety-free as possible, pay attention to the quality of your relationships. It's much more important than tracking your steps or achieving ketosis or all the other bullshit that we get obsessed with on Instagram. So I'm fully with you on all of that. And by the way, Dan, just my friend Vivek Morthy, who has been on the show. And as you know, as our 19th and 21st Surgeon General, he issued a Surgeon General's advisory, sort of like the highest call you can make from that office. And essentially found that having loneliness and isolation pervasive throughout your life is as bad as smoking 15 cigarettes is to your health. I sometimes worry about Dr. Morthy's framing, because I think a lot of people don't see themselves in the word lonely. But I just reframe it more as pay attention to your relationships at all levels from so-called micro interactions or making eye contact and saying hello to the barista, to your family relationships, to don't let your friendships weather, which is very easy to do when we're made career really obsessed with what we're working on. Let me just frame it in the really positive as I did before. If you're interested in longevity, which is what everybody's obsessed with these days, longevity and happiness, this is the most powerful lever and that's supported by data. Your institution Harvard has been running the study for 90 years, I believe, called the Harvard Study for Adult Development. That's Baldinger in the team, who's also a frequent guest on the show. And they have found that the number one variable for long healthy happy life is the quality of your relationships. So yeah, so I think the loneliness thing is a problem. I just worry that he doesn't speak to many people who qualify as lonely, but not see themselves. Right, and what your point is that even if you don't feel that way, investing in those and nurturing those relationships still gives you positive benefits. Yes, and I agree with that. Actually, in the book, I was trying to figure out how do you practically, because my wife and I are always talking about how do you build community and community? The definition I like is shared responsibility, people who share responsibility to one another. And in the book, what I wrote and we're practicing now is I think of three circles. Your inner circle, these are your partner, people you live with, your immediate relatives. Have you checked in with them daily? Your middle circle. And this is the harder one, I think. You described it given the kind of lives we live now, text-avvy lives. These are like friends, neighbors, colleagues at work, maybe your extended family. You know, more of us migrate our lives, social lives online. We kind of have lost touch with those folks. And so one of the things I, we try to do, my wife and I, is like, can you pick one person once a week that you could do an act of kindness for? Yeah. We're not always good at keeping up with that practice, but every time we have it, it just has felt, you know, it might just be getting a meal for someone who's having a hard time. It might be like picking up somebody's kid from school after school if they're, you know, overwhelmed. We found that that really sharpens that sense of responsibility between people who otherwise might not be related. And you said there are three consent groups. Yeah, and the third one is at the outer circle. And this one, describe as sort of community leaders, experts, people in your community that you trust that are. And we actually argue like, you, you should at least know who those are. And in medicine, you know, given how much, how many crises we're facing now, this country's had twice as many measles cases in the last two years and in the prior two decades combined, a lot of people in Washington are saying, we need to rebuild trust in public health. I've never seen trust be rebuilt from Washington. It's rebuilt by, and I'm not saying that's a partisan statement. I think, you know, it's, it comes from your local doctor. Your local nurse, your local trusted community leader. But if you identify that trusted community voice in advance of a crisis, that's critical. And we also, I also argue that you should try to diversify that outer circle. Because I think that's another challenge we have is a lot of the people in our circles are people who think and look like us. Sort of pushing people to ask, like, is your circle the outer circle think and look like you? Or can you push yourself a little bit to add somebody who may not have the same lived experience? I think one of the biggest problems with this outside ring that we're describing is, and there was a big piece about this in the times the other day, distrust is on the rise in this country in a massive and corrosive way, distrust, especially of so-called experts. We are in the, do your own research era, which is fucking insane, in my opinion. And honestly, with respect to you, because I think you and many others did heroic work during COVID, public health officials made some mistakes. Don't wear masks, do wear masks, keep the schools closed longer than they probably should have been, et cetera, et cetera, that added to the mistrust. And then you have what are sometimes called conflict entrepreneurs. You know, people like Trump and Tucker Carlson coming in and stoking this mistrust for their personal gain, and a democracy cannot work if we can't stipulate to the same set of facts. So I worry about, I mean, I feel much safer telling people, hey, work on your first two circles, your inner circle, and then the slightly wider circle. But knowing who to trust in an age of rampant mistrust is super tricky. Very hard. It's very hard. In fact, the fifth play in the book is called "Find Common Ground," because this theme of conflict, either conflict within yourself, within your family, or within your workplace, or just broadly in our society comes up often when there's a crisis, right, when things are in upheaval. What I learned is there's this part of the reason the distrust is persistent during those times, and escalating as you describe is because we've in public health officials to their fault, which is appealed to control instead of curiosity. And what I mean by that is just an example. Again, I'm using measles because we have a lot of it right now. It's on a lot of our mind, certainly a lot of parents like me who are sending their kids into under vaccinated communities are worried, but you could talk about this in other situations as well. So we spent measles vaccine came out 1963. We spent about 37 years getting into place where we eliminated measles. And to get there, yes, we had school mandates, but we also had like outreach, meeting people face-to-face. All of a sudden you eliminated. We stopped doing the outreach and the education. We rely on this brittle foundation of mandates alone. And of course, it takes just another 14 years for the first outbreaks to come back and now we're in a place where we're likely to lose our elimination status, which like very few countries that are like level of wealth have ever lost. And I think it's a lot of it has to do is if you only apply appeal to forcing someone to do something, but not curious about what might make them do something. People ask me all the time, well, if they're vaccinated, they're worried about a loved one who isn't. You know, the first instinct is to ask a blame-oriented question. Why aren't you following the guidelines? Actually, what I've learned a more useful question to be is what's in the way? Yeah. Because then you're and you often need to do that in person, which is harder and harder to do when you can communicate so easily by text and phone people don't even use as much anymore, but by text and email and social media. And what you're doing when you do that, certainly as an official, but I think you're doing it as a parent with a kid or you're doing it as a brother with a sister or a friend with a friend is you're humanizing yourself. You're in your understanding their humanity because you're meeting face to face and you can listen to their concern. I think we should talk about this not only in the in the context of public health because most people watching and listening are not public health officials. It's about how can you get the people in your life to do what's in their best interest and will keep them safe without having it backfire. And if you call them an idiot all the time and/or impose rigid rules, they're unlikely to listen to you. Yeah. In case and points are 14-year-old at home, our teenager who really wanted a smartphone when he went to middle school. And my wife's a psychologist just remember so she's consuming all the pieces of information that say really should have a smartphone until you're 16 and above and your brains aren't fully developed to 26. Mine might take an even longer to get developed. And our 14-year-old comes home from school. like a lot of kids, their friends have the phones and the smart phones and they want the device to. And, you know, we sat down with him and initially we were like, no, you can't have one. What I learned doing this research is when you do that, there's a part of our brains called the prefrontal cortex and many will have heard that. It's kind of like the part of the brain that reasons. When you tell someone, no, you can't. That part of the brain is signal dampens. At the very time you want them to be open to reasoning. So of course we said no and he came back with the vengeance and kind of pushed us and he started acting up. And then we got to a point where we said, well, why is this important to you? And he said, you know, what's really important to me is I don't want to be on social media, which is what we were worried that he would want to be on. He's like, yeah, my friends have it. But I can't be in touch with my friends in the evening like they are over text and I feel like I'm being left out. My wife, give her all the credit for this because she does a lot of the tech management in her home, set the phone up so that allows him to text and he's got like the New York Times app, but no social media. And I think if we hadn't listened to his concern, we wouldn't have found that insight. Curiosity not control. Just a reset. We're talking about strategies or plays as you call them for keeping yourself safe and an increasingly uncertain and chaotic world. Another of the plays that I found particularly interested is you put a high, high premium on flexibility. I think there's a tendency. This may be the opposite of our tendency toward denial. Some of us, I'm not gonna name any names, but his initials are Dan Harris would try to deal with uncertainty by compulsively planning, rigid plans for everything that can get brittle. As I said, plays a high premium on flexibility and the willingness to pivot. So can you talk about how that keeps us safe? When you're in a crisis or a period of deep uncertainty, so let's just take AI, for instance, in my line of work in medical research, we are constantly trying to keep up with AI and how it's shaping how we find cures for treatments for cancer, heart disease, dementia. And it's really tough to keep up as a business. We have scientists, we have entrepreneurs. They are constantly hearing every day in the news some latest advance of how AI or some other companies already gotten the answer to it. So that's just an example. Our economy is very volatile when there's such rapid technological change. So how do you deal with that? Well, one of the key things whether you're a business leader or you're the head of a household is to anchor tightly to purpose so that you can hold loosely to your plans. And the way I translate that in my own life is to ask the question or at my workplace with the entrepreneurs and medical researchers I work with is to say, don't give me a perfect plan. Tell me what the next experiment is. And that is a way to hold tightly to the mission of the company, but also what the purpose is is that a cancer treatment you're trying to develop but also be able almost by proactively being wanting to experiment. And I think that's something that's going to, a skill set that's going to be more and more critical as we enter an age where, as they say, the fourth industrial revolution with AI sort of pervasively both upending but also accelerating many parts of our lives and economy. So to put that in language that might resonate with just a regular person running a household, whether it's a single person household or you've got a full family. Your purpose is to stay safe in every changing world in particular, like to figure out how you're going to have enough money to support your life in the midst of the emerging fourth industrial revolution about which none of us know anything. And we're hearing differing predictions every day. It's going to turn us into paper clips in a decade. It's going to create unprecedented abundance in 20 years, who knows? Your idea is, okay, be clear about what your purpose is, which is, I want to have, I want to create a happy and healthy life for myself and the people around me. And instead of coming up with one rigid plan, run a series of experiments tied back to your values and purpose. - That's right, that's exactly right. - Yeah, yeah, I describe it in the book as sort of iterative navigation, a Apollo 8 before they had GPS, goes up to the moon, they had to program the rocket and the computer to keep reprogramming, but they always knew they wanted to go to the moon. As long as they kept that as their purpose, they could iterate how they got there. And so I think in many ways in our families, the many of us are worried about our jobs, getting disrupted, I've worked with executive assistants, for instance, who are deeply worried that a gentick AI that can schedule an executive is going to out. Displace you from the job career you've always had and what I've told some of the colleagues I've worked with who are working as executive assistants is, if you enjoy that work, you can still anchor to that path. But you probably want to experiment with AI yourself. Maybe you could become the executive assistant that learns how to use a gentick AI so well that you become the executive assistant, all the executives in the company have to work with, the want to work with. And that's one way of implementing this idea of holding tightly to purpose and loosely to our plans. - Another thing you talk about in a crisis in terms of maintaining a simultaneity of focus on your purpose and goals and also a willingness to stay flexible is to label the unknowns. - Yeah, yes. The idea being when there's critical information and lots of shifting data, it's really easy for the mind to trick itself into believing that there is certainty in that fact. And you brought up masks and schools closures during COVID as an example in New Zealand. They did something very different. This their prime minister at the time, just Sinda Ardern, sort of famous for leading with kindness and humility during that time. She and her health secretary equivalent would get on Facebook and social media and they would brief the public and they would not withhold any information known or unknown. They would tell the public what they didn't know. And it's simply saying in real life or in practically in life is I have a crystal ball and the crystal ball can only tell me how far I can see for these three or four things and it can only tell me for these two or three weeks. And then I'll need to recalibrate. And I think that naming of the unknown also breeds trust because people don't follow especially at times of distrust. They don't follow invincibility. Whether you're parent leading your family, you're an executive leading your company, you're a leader like just Sinda Ardern leading a country. People don't follow invincibility. They follow authenticity. Actually conveying you don't know, but with the message that we're gonna figure this out together actually brings more people along. - Do you think there's also something, I mean, I always look at everything through the lens of just an anxious individual. There's something about listing the known unknowns to put it in Donald Rumsfeld's speak for young people out there. Donald Rumsfeld was the secretary of defense during the war in Iraq and in my opinion, not a great actor, but he had this idea of known unknowns and known unknowns and unknown unknowns anyway. But listing the known unknowns is a way to wrap your arms around uncertainty that makes it just feel a little better if that makes sense. I think it does, I think it does. We sometimes conflate uncertainty, the unknown unknowns with the known unknowns in that phrase, which is actually risk. The difference between risk and uncertainty is in my mind at least, is risk is you can quantify it. It's either high, medium or low. Uncertainty, you cannot calculate. So you think back to the maps and the medieval times and when they didn't know, people hadn't gone on a ship to various lands on earth. And they would put hereby dragons if you, you know, on it. And it was a void. And so risk would be, hey, we're going to get on that ship and charter that sea and get to that land no one's been to. Risk would be, hey, there's a storm. There's clouds coming. Our ship may sink or we may go through, you know, very difficult journey. It's high or low. There's a high chance of a low chance. As you can see, a cloud, there's a signal. Uncertainty is when we get to that land, we don't know what we're going to meet. When we get there, we don't know whether we're gonna try to attack us or it's gonna be a wonderful paradise to live in. That's the way I think about risk and uncertainty. And so naming the known unknowns at least lets you calibrate risk. And then with uncertainty, which is harder to measure, you just have to take a different approach. I mean, this is, I think, why we struggle sometimes is AI is a great example. Like, you know, you have these reports in recent weeks about AI, a bunch of CEOs of various AI companies saying like AI could end humanity, you know, and somebody said there's a 10% chance all of humanity will end. Well, I think that's uncertainty. It's not, you're attributing 10% as if there's a risk. It could be 10% today and 5% tomorrow, like there's a chance of rain tomorrow or sunshine tomorrow. But I think it's a mistake because uncertainty is unincalculable. And that's actually incalculable. It doesn't mean you can relax and say because I can't do anything about it. I shouldn't do anything about it. You still have to, even when we feel out of control, we still have this desire when we feel out of control that is to feel steadier. And so the way we do that is by taking a very small practical step, right? The next meaningful step can still be in our control. And in the book, for instance, in the eighth play, the chapters actually called Embrace Uncertainty, I learned about this idea called shift the locus of control. It's a very common idea and psychology. It turns out what basically what you do is if you feel totally overwhelmed by not knowing if the risk is higher low. And it's just uncertain AI, for instance, is it going to be great? Is it going to be bad for us? Take that situation and put a circle on a piece of paper, everything outside that circle, as in like, is AI going to take my job or not? Keep it outside the circle. Within the circle, what's the one practical step you can take in the next 24 hours? And then you commit to do it. And in the case of, like I mentioned, executive assistance, it would be, let me go sign up for an AI webinar, because whether it's good or bad, that's a step I can control is at least understanding what it is. I do want to highlight, you called it play number eight. And it is, I think, a core argument in your book and it's counterintuitive. Your argument is that we should embrace uncertainty. The thing most of us dislike the most, you say we should embrace it. Why? Well, first of all, I think it's per, it's pervasive. And the second reason is because ignoring it is sometimes not possible and often can cause us harm. So I'll give you an example. In the case of, you know, the origins of COVID, just to put that out there for a second, I help oversee the White House's review of the declassification of whether it did it come from a lab, did it come from a bio weapon, did it, did it, was it naturally occurring? I'm not going to share anything on this podcast that I couldn't share. The declassified report showed that it either is from a lab or it's naturally occurring and it's certainly not, or almost certainly not a biological weapon. That's what it showed in 2023. Now I believe that when that report was being released from the White House or from the Office of Director of National Intelligence in 2023, there was a lot of concern that the public was going to struggle with not having a clear answer to this horrific pandemic that took the lives of a million Americans and millions more around the world. We would want some closure, right? We're not getting it. We don't know if it came from a lab or it came from nature. What did we decide to do? We decided to deal with all three potential causes, whether it came from labs, nature, or a potential biological weapon. And my point being is that if we had avoided the uncertainty or just ignored it, then we would not be taking as potentially effective actions. We could be to reduce risk from all three potential causes and make ourselves safer. So that's at a macro level. How we can think about why addressing uncertainty matters and managing through it. But then the last thing I'd say Dan and turn it back to you is there's two or three practical things we can do to make ourselves feel a lot less uncomfortable with uncertainty. One example is the idea of that shifting the locust to control. That's one. A second is updating your story. And my parents, when they came here, could not know after losing their home and their jobs and their careers in West Africa, whether they would be able to build a life to keep a roof over our head and have successful careers. They updated their story. My dad would say this thing all the time, no condition is permanent. It has come to mean for me that we can't control the conditions we face, but we can control how we respond to them. And so they dedicated that moment of their lives to invest fully in their kids' education. I got to become a doctor because they got me so focused on school, but they were thinking long-term. And then the other thing, Dan, you can do to manage uncertainty is something they use in the VA system. There's this idea of called acceptance and commitment therapy. I don't know if you've heard of it. Yeah. And for listeners who may not have heard of it, there's a real nifty tool that's called choice point check-ins. And here's what it is simply. When you feel uncertain about a decision, should I take that job that I've been offered or not, for instance? You often hit a fork in the road. One part of the fork is the away move. The other part of the fork is the toward move. You could take the away move, which is away from what you value and believe in. The toward move is aligned with your values. And what they found through research with vets who've experienced PTSD and a lot of anxiety is that if you take the toward move towards your values, even if you feel more anxious, over time you actually learn not to be your fear, but to live with your fear and still actually align yourself with your values and be connected to your values. And you have less regret over time. So that's the third way to think about it is to do these choice point check-ins with yourself. At a high high level, are you also in some way saying, look, uncertainty is just the ground truth of this being a live thing. So you either embrace it because it's non-negotiable or you're just going to suffer indefinitely. I think that's right. I mean, you're not going to be able to avoid it. And I think that if you find some practical ways to manage through it, that's possible. You will at least find you can mitigate its impact on your life emotionally. What else may be true is you might find yourself getting stronger every time you face it. And I talk about this idea of using tension to adapt in the book, meaning it's or inspired by our biology. So our immune systems are designed such that if they face a threat and infection, for instance, they remember that threat so that the next time they face it, they get stronger. And the only way they can get stronger in the first place is by facing the first threat. What if we could approach uncertainty that way? That every time we feel a threat, some uncertainty, that we could build an emotional memory cell, like our B cells in our body build that memory for that infection. And by documenting who showed up for me, what skills helped me through this, what did it reveal about who I want to be, what my strengths are, what my limits are? Might we build an emotional memory cell so that the next time we face uncertainty, we could, as Nassim Talib talks about, not just be resilient, but be anti-fragile. The idea of not just bouncing back, which is what resilience is about, anti-fragility, as he describes it, is about getting stronger only because you got went through that threat. And you start to then ask a question when difficult things happen in our lives, not what can't I be because this happened to me. But what can I only be because this happened to me? I've never met this guy, Jaco Willink, who's a former Navy SEAL and podcaster. And I've mentioned this a few times on the show, so Jaco, if you or anybody you know is listening, you're welcome to come on and talk about it, but there's this viral clip of Jaco talking about how he developed the muscle when something shitty happened to say, "Good." Oh, I just lost my job. Good. Or I just tried this project and it failed. Good. Because there's always some opportunity in whatever, quote unquote, disaster you're facing. How does that land for you? I think it's very resonant. Just give you a very simple example. I now commute for work from the Washington DC area to Boston almost every week. And that's the least favorite part of my job is having to leave my team. age and pre-teenage kids at home and my wife with them. And yet, I'm stuck because this is the way I kind of keep the roof over the head of our family. And I like what I do. And so the first year of the job, I was struggling with it. And in the second year, I told my wife, again, I have the advantage of being married to a psychologist, but she has the disadvantage of me being her 11th patient every day. And I talked to her and I was writing that chapter and learning about embracing uncertainty and asking that question, not what can't I be because of this because I'm, because I'm commuting. But what have I asked what could I only be because of this? And two very simple things came to my mind. This is through some journaling as well. One is I realized actually in the evenings I'm by myself. And when I'm with my kids at NDC, I rarely have gotten to go to an evening lecture or, you know, a play or that, you know, I would have enjoyed doing. And so now when I'm in Boston, I'll just go down and actually go watch a lecture from somebody I hadn't seen before. Now that's lectures not necessarily everybody's cup of tea in the evening. But the other thing I realized is, well, what if the kids could come in summer camp with me in Boston and all of a sudden they're doing camps they wouldn't otherwise do. But importantly, they're getting one on one time with me that for a week at a time that they otherwise wouldn't have gotten when I was at home. And so yes, I agree with what he said. I think that there is opportunity in every situation. But we have to pause and reflect to imagine it. And for you probably can't be told what that is, you kind of have to ask yourself. Yes. Two expressions from the meditation world are coming to mind. One is everything is workable. Like no matter what's happening, there's a way to work with it. The other comes from a guy I quote, on almost every episode Joseph Goldstein my long time friend and meditation teacher. And he always says, don't waste your suffering. We are going to suffer because life either we're going to screw up in some way or life is going to voice some certain unwanted circumstances on us. But don't waste it because there's always an opportunity embedded in the shit show. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely. My dad that mantra, no condition is permanent. We can't control the conditions we face, but we can control how we respond. I think he would probably agree with what you just said as well. I think that's very powerful. We have a segment we do at the end of the show now where it's called What's Good. And so it's an opportunity for the guests to recommend something. It could be a book, a movie, a play, could be some little practice. They've integrated into their lives. And then I'll reciprocate with something from my side. One of the things I find good in my life is morning pages. And if listeners don't know the practice, Julia Cameron in her book, The Artist's Way writes about this practice where you, the moment you wake up in the morning, you get out three pages of paper and it's really important. You write, get a pen or pencil and write whatever comes to your mind. I didn't hear it from her first. I heard it from my friend, physician author, a tool, Goandee, who was recently on the show. Oh, okay. I'm not surprised. He's so terrific. He described it as a way he writes his writing practice. When I read it in Julia's book, I learned it as a spiritual practice. And I will just spend time taking questions like that one. In fact, that's how I discovered the answer to what could I only be because I commute was through morning pages and just writing out three pages in a row. Whatever comes off your mind, you might start with as I did, I feel tired. I feel groggy. And that's fine. Just like it's a way of like releasing the cobwebs from your mind so that then clarity comes. And I recommend that practice for writers, but just for any individual morning pages. There's also a bunch of research around a related practice therapeutic journaling where for one or two days in a row, you spend I think 15 minutes and you just write with no particular agenda and no finiciness about the quality of the writing and in the wake of a traumatic event or just if you're doing it for no particular reason at all, it's been shown to have all sorts of positive benefits. So there's something about writing out what's going on in a kind of discursive unplanned no going back in editing it. And then in fact, like usually burning it afterwards that really does help people. So your your on's is something and so is Julia Cameron. Mine is much more low brow. I've found in the few weeks that we've been doing this that guests always recommend something really like high-minded and beautiful. And mine is always like some TV show I'm watching. And in this case, it is literally a TV show I'm watching on HBO. There's a show a new documentary series, although by the time this posts, it may not be that new. It's called a killer story. And I will admit that one of my guilty pleasures is true crime. HBO documentaries are always so the filmmaking and the storytelling is always of such high quality. I mean, I'll watch shitty true crime because I love first of all, I love mysteries. I love seeing I love watching the act of people figuring something out. But also from a Buddhist lens crime really is about the the unwholesome aspects of our mind unregulated, unrestrained. But in this, this actually is quite an interesting story because it's about this couple that identified what they thought was an injustice a woman who was convicted for killing her ex-husband and her ex-husband's current wife. And nobody believed this woman was not guilty. She was convicted and in prison. And these two people have dedicated their lives to getting her out. And and the stories kind of told through the POV of a grizzled cynical hard-bitten New York Times investigative reporter who this couple had reached out to for years and he had ignored them until actually her case was overturned. And then he started to get interested. And you see him go there for her retrial. I'm not yet done with it. But it's the characters are really vibrant and it's it's an elevated version of true crime on HBO killer story. I recommend it. Well, my wife is a big fan of those like CSI and so I've got something to take back to her. Yes. Yes. That's a recommendation. I feel much better that your wife as a psychologist is interested in CSI because it makes me feel like less of a reprobate. The book everybody I have it for if you're watching you can see me holding it in my hands. If you're not watching the book is called "Safe for a Playbook" turning fear into action and crisis into community written by my new friend Dr. Rajpin Jabi. And you can get it wherever you find your books. All right. Go check it out in the meantime. Thank you very much for doing this. Thank you Dan. Thanks for making the time.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Denial is an evolutionary survival mechanism, not a character flaw, rooted in normalcy bias that helps humans avoid constant vigilance.
  2. The book offers an eight-play framework to navigate crisis, including turning denial into action through predefined thresholds and measurable triggers.
  3. Community and social support are vital during uncertainty, providing both emotional and practical resources, with shared responsibility forming the foundation of trust.
  4. Conflict arises in crises due to a lack of curiosity and overreach of control; instead, asking “what’s in the way” builds empathy and encourages cooperation.
  5. Flexibility and purpose are more effective than rigid planning; embracing uncertainty through iterative actions strengthens resilience and adaptability.
  6. Labeling known unknowns helps manage uncertainty by distinguishing risk (quantifiable) from uncertainty (unquantifiable), fostering trust and clarity.
  7. Shifting the locus of control—taking one small, actionable step in response to uncertainty—empowers individuals to act despite fear.
  8. Uncertainty is inevitable and should be embraced as a source of growth, with practices like journaling and choice-point check-ins building emotional resilience and anti-fragile responses.

Summary:

Dr. Raj Punjabi, a Harvard physician and former White House official, presents a practical, science-backed approach to navigating modern life’s uncertainties in his book *Safer: A Playbook, Turning Fear into Action and Crisis into Community*. He argues that denial and normalcy bias are not weaknesses but evolutionary tools that help protect us from constant alertness.

To counteract paralysis, he introduces eight actionable "plays," such as using pre-mortems to simulate crises and set clear thresholds for action. He emphasizes the critical role of community, showing how shared responsibility and trust—especially in times of crisis—can provide both emotional and practical support. Punjabi also highlights how control and fear-based reactions escalate conflict, while curiosity and empathy foster connection.

Central to his framework is flexibility: anchoring to purpose while remaining open to change, allowing individuals to adapt through iteration. He distinguishes between measurable risk and unquantifiable uncertainty, advocating for transparency in acknowledging unknowns to build trust. A key insight is that embracing uncertainty through small, concrete actions—like shifting the locus of control or practicing choice-point check-ins—builds resilience over time.

Drawing on personal and global examples, from pandemic responses to family crises, he demonstrates how uncertainty can be transformed into growth. Ultimately, the book promotes a balanced, grounded response to chaos: neither denial nor panic, but a proactive, human-centered approach rooted in self-awareness, community, and mindful action.

FAQs

Denial is an evolutionary survival mechanism. It prevents constant vigilance that would exhaust the brain. Our ancestors needed to believe that things would remain stable to avoid being in a constant state of alert, which is known as normalcy bias.

Normalcy bias is the tendency to assume that things will continue as they have in the past. It’s helpful because it reduces anxiety and conserves mental energy. However, it can prevent us from recognizing when a crisis is actually emerging, leading to delayed responses.

Practice a pre-mortem by imagining a crisis and working backward to identify how it could have happened. This helps build preparedness, reduces fear, and provides a clear plan of action, making it easier to respond calmly when a crisis arises.

This strategy involves setting a clear, objective threshold or trigger—like a number of cases or symptoms—above which you take action. This helps detect slow-moving crises early and prevents both denial and overreaction by creating a measurable decision point.

Community provides emotional support, access to vital information, and practical resources. In times of uncertainty, people rely on shared experiences and trusted networks to make better decisions and survive, as shown in Dr. Punjabi’s experience during civil war in Liberia.

Instead of blaming or enforcing rules, asking 'what's in the way?' fosters empathy and understanding. This approach builds trust, encourages open dialogue, and leads to more effective, sustainable solutions—especially in health, parenting, or public policy.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.