Go back

How the Primary Wave & Kobalt Deal Came Together w/ Larry Mestel & Laurent Hubert

from Billboard On The Record

1h 20m 26s

How the Primary Wave & Kobalt Deal Came Together w/ Larry Mestel & Laurent Hubert

Primary Wave has acquired Cobalt in a billion-dollar deal, marking a major consolidation in the music publishing industry. The acquisition combines Cobalt’s advanced publishing administration tools—like Amara, which collects digital royalties directly and reduces financial leakage—with Primary Wave’s global marketing and value creation expertise. Cobalt remains fully independent, with its leadership and operations unchanged, ensuring a smooth integration without disruption. Key strengths include Amara’s end-to-end digital royalty collection and Cosine’s flexible, short-term publishing deals for emerging songwriters. This move reflects a broader industry trend of consolidation, driven by financial strain on leveraged competitors and rising interest rates. Both companies prioritize artist legacy through immersive marketing, such as Whitney Houston’s Vegas slot machines and the Rocky Horror immersive experience. The deal underscores a shift from rigid ownership models to consumption-based, technology-driven publishing. Cobalt’s $700M and $2.25B capital funds will expand catalog acquisitions, with each firm targeting different music domains—Primary Wave focusing on legacy catalogs and Cobalt on newer, digitally active content. Critically, the partnership emphasizes artist empowerment, with transparent, flexible deals and a commitment to protecting music legacies through creative innovation, rather than financial extraction. The transaction also highlights evolving artist motivations, including financial planning and legacy planning, especially among older artists, while raising concerns about early-career creators selling rights prematurely. Overall, the deal signals a future where artist-centric, value-driven companies lead the industry, leveraging technology and creativity to sustain long-term music value.

Transcription

13991 Words, 75833 Characters

English
When you shop, Kroger delivery, you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door. Our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right. Carefully selecting and packing your order with care, because bringing you fresh, quality groceries is what we do best. And right now, enjoy $20 off your first online order of $75 or more! Restrictions apply, see site for details. Kroger, fresh for everyone! Today, we have an exclusive first press interview about one of the biggest acquisitions in music in 2026. Primary Wave has officially bought Cobalt, and the deal is reported to be well over a billion dollars. This is a big deal in the music publishing world or the site of the business that's focused on songwriters. And that's because Primary Wave, one of the most dominant players in older catalog music acquisitions, is now going to be the owner of Cobalt, which is arguably the biggest front line or essentially current music independent publisher in the game. And it's also significant because this is part of a larger trend in the music industry of consolidations, mergers, and acquisitions over the last few years. So today, we're going to talk to Laurent Hubert, CEO of Cobalt, and Larry Mistell, CEO of Primary Wave, to talk through the deal, and what deals like this could mean for the future of music. Welcome back to On The Record, a music business podcast from Billboard and Sickbird Productions. As always, I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and today we have two of the biggest CEOs in the music industry, Larry Mistell, a Primary Wave, and Laurent Hubert of Cobalt, to talk about their new business arrangement for the first time in a press interview. We'll also get into the consolidation of the overall music industry in general and the future of publishing. As I noted before, Primary Wave is one of the biggest names in catalog acquisitions. Home to rights for music by everyone from Prince Whitney Houston, Stevie Nicks, James Brown, Bob Marley, notorious B.I.G, Britney Spears, Black Sabbath, Deaf Leopard, and so many more. They're known best for not just acquiring rights to catalogs, but also playing a very active role in marketing those iconic songs and bringing them back into the zeitgeist. So if you see in the Bob Marley stage production in Vegas, the Whitney Houston biopic, or you plan on visiting James Brown's house, which is soon to open as a museum, a lot of Graceland, then congratulations, you actually do know a lot about Primary Wave. And then Cobalt, on the other hand, is arguably the industry's largest independent music publisher today, looking after songwriting careers of everyone from Paul McCartney, Phoebe Bridgers, Max Martin, Skrillex, Phineas, and more. The company first came on the scene in the early 2000s and is credited as revolutionizing publishing deals, offering a tech forward approach where songwriters got flexible publishing administration deals where they didn't have to give away any of their ownership with their songs, like normal publishing deals required. Instead, Cobalt took a percentage fee to collect royalties on the songwriters' behalf. Years later, publishing admin deals have become commonplace across every publisher in the game. Now that you're caught up to speed on who these guys are, let's go ahead and bring them in. Please welcome to the podcast Larry Mistell and Laurent Hubert. Larry Mistell, Laurent Hubert, welcomed on the record. Thank you for being here. Thank you for having us. Thank you. Yes. All right, I'm excited to have you guys here, especially because I know Laurent you live here, but Larry, you're based in New York, so it's rare to get you on this coast. Or actually, do you come back and forth a lot? Uh, three or four times a month. You know, a month. No, it's usually every three or four weeks I'm here. Nice, okay, so do you have any good travel tips for us? You know, um, I rarely notice that I'm even on a plane anymore because I get on the plane and I start returning emails and all of a sudden I've touched down. So, uh, I do feel like whenever I get on a plane, I'm like, this is my opportunity to get so locked in on whatever I'm doing. It's like, whether it's a book or doing some work. That's right. It's the best time to do work because nobody can find you and nobody can bother you. No, these options. Yeah, it's true. It's true. Are you a fan of LA? Oh, wow, you're going right in there starting off with a really tough one. You know what? I have to say, um, it's a nice place to visit. But I live in New York and I am a giant fan, Nick fan, Ranger fan and Metfan. Be very hard to live in LA. Yeah, well, I mean, it's been a good year for you guys in this, but well, Nick. Well, I would say the Nick's, it was a fantastic year. The Metz, uh, you know, we can't even talk about. And uh, it's like, you know, I'm still in the fence about football because I'm a giant fan. So we're in first place for the first time in a long time. Uh, but, uh, yeah, it's, it's good to be a New York fan these days. Yeah, Laura, you've, you've been in LA for a long time now, right? Uh, since 2021. So wait, oh, that's not that long. Oh, I live in New York 30 years. Okay, so I'm adjusting with LA. Okay, so what's your, what's your take on your Queen's by the way? Yeah, definitely Queen's what's your take New York or LA? New York is a practical city. LA isn't. Uh, New York is gritty. LA can be. Um, I like the energy of New York, um, but the quality of life in LA is just hard to be. The weather is hard to be, um, but I like, but you have to have both. I like having both. I spend about 10 days a month in, uh, in New York. So I like traveling. Yeah, yeah, I don't know. They both have their attributes, but the older I get, the more I'm like, I do like that, I can just go take a hike somewhere and then come back. The weather's always nice. So LA does have that going for it that New York doesn't really have. But, um, anyways, okay, we are not here to talk about New York versus LA. Actually, we're here to talk about the facts that primary wave has acquired cobalt and you're the CEO primary wave. You're the CEO of cobalt. Um, I'm excited to get into this with you guys. Um, first, I wanted to ask about how you guys first met because you guys have both worked in music publishing for a long time. So I'm sure your relationship predates this deal. So tell me about that. 2012, yeah. I think, well, Laurent, I've known each other for 14 to 15 years, uh, when Laurent was a BMG and, uh, I was just starting, uh, primary wave in 2006. Uh, and I think we, we'd even met prior to that. But, uh, we've had a long-standing relationship, mutual respect. Uh, he's one of the great, organized, uh, intellectual, uh, and creative, uh, executives in the music publishing business. So, uh, we've had a long-standing good relationship. Yeah. And when did you guys start talking about this deal? Because, I mean, it just closed in what July? July, um, but I'm sure these kind of things take a very long time. So I'm sure this wave predated, even billboard talking about it. So tell us about that. Um, so I think the beginning of the conversation was sometime in the summer of 2025. I think the first conversation, which was not a gig conversation with me, but with another party, uh, was in June of 2025. But a, yeah, particular dinner. Yep. Yeah. Um, you know, I, I remember that dinner and, uh, primary wave has historically been administration agnostic, right? Um, we're, we're into the value creation, not the administration and the business. So we've always used Cobalt or Universal, uh, or some other administrators, um, uh, instead of creating our own internal administration platform. And so the dinner Laurent was speaking about was a dinner, uh, that I believed, uh, Gobern Sachs had, uh, had organized. And I remember at that dinner, uh, Jenny Kim, who works as head of music now at Gobern, came up to me and said, Hey, have you considered Cobalt, um, as an acquisition, as a, as a partner? And I said, well, we're ag, you know, we're administration agnostic. And, uh, you know, I've known Laurent forever. Culturally, I think we're, we're very similar companies. And she said, well, you're going to consider it because I'm bringing you the deal. And so I said, uh, great. Let's consider it. And, uh, listen, at the end of the day, it made a lot of sense for us. Because, um, you know, you could never have, uh, on your team, um, too many great managers. And Laurent has team are fantastic managers. And, um, look, we, uh, we saw some jewels inside of Cobalt, not just the administration platform, which is really fantastic. But, um, divisions like Amara and cosine. And that, that really was, uh, once we started digging in, uh, the real impetus to do the deal, as well as the fact that, uh, the management team is so great. Yeah. I mean, so you touched on something that I've always found interesting about primary wave. You guys haven't ever done the administration. Correct. Like there wasn't some time where there was. Yeah. Yeah. So, um, why not? I think there's some people might not understand the logistics and difficulty of doing admin and house. So can you tell us about why primary wave likes the idea of partnering with different companies rather than building it? For us, the focus has always been on marketing, on branding, on creating content. doing Broadway, doing movies, doing immersive experiences, creating cosmetic lines, you know, gaming, etc. So there's a real core competency to that. And it's very hard for other companies that are our competitors to recreate what we've recreated. To build an administration platform is takes a significant amount of capital and takes a significant amount of effort. And we always viewed it as a commodity where there were a lot of industry players that did administration, right? Not many. In fact, I can't even name any that does really great marketing and value creation. So we've always stayed away for the administration side of the business because we could always rent it at relatively insignificant cost. And we could focus our entire effort on turning a dollar into five dollars instead of collecting a dollar. That's been the strategy from day one. Comprehensive. Witty. Speculative. Critical. Insightful. Profound. Wide-ranging. Hopefully doesn't take itself too too seriously. I'm David Remnick and each week on the New Yorker Radio Hour, my colleagues and I try to make sense of what's happening in this chaotic world. I hope you'll join us for the New Yorker Radio Hour wherever you listen to podcasts. The thoughtful, exquisite, just, you know, real. When you shop Croger Delivery, you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door. Our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right, carefully selecting and packing your order with care. Because bringing you fresh, quality groceries is what we do best. Croger. Fresh for everyone. Yeah, I mean, I know you guys have said when talking about this deal that cobalt's going to stand alone and be its own thing. But I mean, like you were talking about, like you guys have complimentary strengths, you know, cobalt has administration on lock. And then you guys have marketing on lock. So do you expect that some of the marketing that primary wave is known for is going to help out the cobalt owners and vice versa? Like where's the synergy between the two? I mean, it's really about comparing our strengths. And I have to credit Larry for the vision for the business. Because initially, when we first talked, I understood the interest, but I did not fully understand the vision. And I think, like I explained that very clearly in saying, hey, we understand cobalt. We understand what it means in the market that it's a destination today. He says also, he built a destination, which I think is very unique in what he does. And we create value differently, you know, for primary wave is really about how do you create engagement on the properties that they acquired? And for us is how do we unlock greater value from a collection perspective? So from that perspective, we saw a direct opportunity. And some of it will be that we will cost some functionality that we have and will compound those benefits without talking about merger or integration, which is very disruptive. And that was also was, you know, interesting for us from a management perspective, because we felt we don't have to go through an education process about cobalt, about the industry. And we don't have to be disrupted day one on an integration. We could keep going and do what we do the best we can do it. And you mentioned that there were some gems within cobalt that you were super interested in. You mentioned Amra. And it's interesting because I've heard that same phrasing used back when Francisco partners purchased cobalt. And what was it? 2022? Yeah, 2022. They called Amra the unpolished gem. And I remember what I was new at Billboard at that time that really peaked my interest because I was like, I had, frankly, never heard of Amra at this point. You know, it does for anyone who's listening, who doesn't know Amra, it's global digital royalty collections worldwide, XUS and licensing in licensing. That actually spurred me to write a story on Amra to try to get to the bottom of like, why does Francisco partners think that this is such an unpolished gem? So I'm curious why you think it's a gem as well. Can you tell me about why you're so interested in Amra? Those that aren't using Amra that are going local, right? How long does it take for you to collect your money? Eight months, 12 months, 15 months, Amra is going direct. And it's very hard to recreate Amra because of the history of Amra and the licenses that they've put in place. So it's touching your money sooner. And there are less people with their hands in your pocket. It's really that simple. And I think the more people discover Amra, the more people are going to want to use Amra. And if you think about Primary Wave, you know, we have seven and a half billion dollars worth of assets now within Primary Wave. We're going to be putting as much of our repertoire through Amra as we possibly can. And so can you explain a little bit more about exactly what Amra is? Because I do want to make sure that I don't just kind of gloss over exactly what makes it special. So can you kind of describe that all deeper? So it's a vehicle that essentially licenses digital rights ex-US and also corrects this money directly from the DSP. And I think what's important in the context of Kabul is that it really gives us the ability to be vertically integrated. So we have a true end to end solution from the DSP all the way down to the writer or the publisher. That money is not going anywhere else. So you eliminate what this reduced greatly the amount of leakage you have in the ecosystem. That's interesting. So Amra is definitely one of those places where you all can collaborate and run the Primary Wave artists through Amra. You know, are you going to switch over Larry all of the Primary Wave catalogs to do publishing admin through Kabul now as well? It's a great question. No. No. No. Because we have some great partners around the world. And I'll name too, right? Kabul and Universal as an example. We give Universal quite a bit of our administration. Worldwide, they are an excellent administration organization. We have a great relationship with Jody and Mark and David and the team there. Kabul will be getting much more of the Primary Wave repertoire than it has gotten in the past. But we won't be taking anything away that we've given Universal and will continue to give Universal more work in the future because they've done a great job and they've earned it. The way Cobalt has done a great job and enter into it. Got it. Got it. Well, I imagine there's also just like outstanding deals. So you can't just stop in the middle of like let's say you have five years or something on something with Universal. You can't just yank that away from them and say, hey, we have Cobalt now. So. Well, we have very short term deals. When we cut deals, we cut very short term deals. So we have maximum flexibility, but we're not going to do that. We're going to continue to increase our deal flow and Cobalt is going to be a very significant beneficiary and Universal will be a very significant beneficiary. And by the way, we use other administrators as well. But Cobalt happens to be a much better organization than some of those other administrators. Are you able to name those other ones? No. No. Got to ask. Fair enough. Okay. I swear, I'm going to get to a point about this, but I was just reading this old profile in the New York Times of David Bowie from 2002. And he was kind of talking about like the 21st century music business, just as the 21st century was getting started. And I thought it was a really good profile. So highly recommend it. I think it's called like David Bowie 21st century music man or something like that. But I was reading through it. And I thought it was really interesting. He was talking about how he did not want to do any long term deals at this point in 2002, because Bowie was convinced that the music industry was changing so much that he didn't want to be locked in anywhere for too long. And I'm wondering Larry, like if the philosophy that you have on short term admin deals is for a similar reason. Well, you know, that's interesting because that's a small part of it for sure. The industry is changing. It's going through quite a bit of change. But the reason is that when you do short term deals, you keep partners engaged. Right. So you cut a long term deal. Maybe there's less incentive. Yeah. So, you know, I like month to month quarter to quarter year to year. I don't like much more than year to year. Okay. Yeah. I mean, well, that sounds a lot like. And here's the other thing though. When, you know, we are, we are very well capitalized. And the fact that we're very well capitalized means we don't need advances. Because when you take advances, that means you lower your margin. I'd rather have a much higher margin. No advance. And if you want primary waves business, you're going to do a short term deal because we want to make sure that whatever partners we're using or working as hard as we're working for our artists. And that does bring me to talk a little bit about cosine, which is another thing that you shouted out is something that's very interesting. Laura, you and I didn't interview around the time that cosine came out. And I think it's a really interesting solution. It basically targets kind of that middle class songwriter who's not ready to sign a long term publish or even just traditional publishing deal. And you know, through cosine, I believe you can leave after any given quarter, right? Yeah, and I mean, what I think is so interesting about that is that I feel like that's kind of how you see places like AWOL, which used to be a part of cobalt no longer is now it's under Sony. Things move around a lot in the industry, but like on the label side, I feel like everyone's used to that kind of arrangement, these kind of artists services, distribution, super flexible deals. But we didn't really see many options on the publishing side. Can you tell me about why you guys decided to start cosine? Well, for the same reason you just explained this is a market that is underserved. And we saw an opportunity for us to leverage or infrastructure, which we built for cobalt. To also leverage AMR because you have an end to end solution on digital, but yet provide a much more flexible term, because there's no term essentially to your point, you can even any quarter. Right. And where it's different for cosine compared to some other competitors is that it's gated. You have to have a minimum amount of earnings to be able to be within cosine. And the reason for that is because we want to provide great service. The reality is it's not because it's a different market that the quality of service should suffer. And we built an infrastructure where we can manage high volume, obviously, but also making sure that we don't sacrifice on the service quality. Yeah. So basically like the extra extra long tail is not what you're going for there. That's quite so. Yeah. I mean, that is something that I've spoken about several times on the show is, you know, there are 150,000 songs being uploaded every day. That's, that's what luminates a Rob Jonas told us on the podcast recently. And I mean, I kind of wonder from y'all's vantage point. How that impacts the work that you do, just the sheer volume of what's happening now has that changed your approach is that made you double down. And what you're already doing, I'll start with Larry. I want to hear from both of you on that. Well, I think it's much more relevant for the romp than it is for me because, you know, we're in the icon and legend business for the most part. So we're buying the greatest of the great triple A talent. You know, it's, it's Prince and Bob Marley and, you know, Stevie Nicks and Whitney Houston and James Brown. So we're limiting the type of artist that we're willing to work with. You know, we're one of the largest music companies in the world now. Probably the largest owner of legendary music, but we only have 100,000 copyrights. When you compare that to universal, who has eight million, you know, copyrights in their publishing company and Sony, which probably has seven million. You know, we're, we're very, very specific on what we're working with. So the fact that people are uploading, you know, 150,000 songs a day or a million songs a day. It's a different problem. It's much more of a technical administration problem than it is for us when it comes to marketing and creating content and creating value for the songs and the artists we have. But I do imagine, though, like with that much volume and you guys are super active about marketing these iconic artists, you always want to make sure they're staying in the zeitgeist. And I do think that that does present a challenge, maybe even on like social media services, like when you're trying to run these accounts, like promoting. Like, let's say Whitney Houston concert clips or something like that. You're now, you're now going up against so much more content than ever before. There's a lot of content. But look, I've always believed that great content rises above the cream rises above. And that's really the genesis of why we put the infrastructure in place that we have. Why do we have 20 people that just do digital strategy, playlist pitching, why do we have a team that creates content for TikTok, because you have to be, you have to be on TikTok, right? It's radio station and television station in the world, but you have to mark it. You have to do something to create a viral moment, right? You know, so look. You're doubling down icons only. Right. It's, it's just icons. And, you know, how do you get noticed, you know, think back to. Right, March of, I think it was March 20th, 2020, we had just recently bought the Stevie Nicks catalog. And we're pushing content out, pushing content, pushing content out. And sometimes it's better to be lucky than good. Well, this guy, you know, is on a skateboard skateboarding down the 405, drinking an ocean spade cranberry juice bottle and, you know, lip syncing the words to dreams. And 100 million TikTok views later, we had the number one song in the world with dreams. Right, bigger than Dua Lipa, bigger than Taylor Swift, dreams was the number one song in the world that year, because of these moments. And so, you know, that's why Stevie Nicks, right, icons, iconic songs, iconic songs are going to rise to the top. Yeah. And I also kind of wonder like with this much content, some people get probably a little bit fatigued by trying to discover new music with how much is out there and might find themselves. I mean, we've seen the stats that people are returning to catalog music more than they ever have. And that only seems to rise year after year. I don't want to say that. Yeah, two last five years catalog, you know, streams as a percentage of the overall streams have gone up. Yeah, yeah. So, I mean, there's something to be said about just being able to be the name that comes off of someone, the top of someone's head when they're thinking about rock music and they're like, oh, you know, one of the primary way of artists. But Laurent, I want to go back to you with 150,000 songs being uploaded every day. How does that change the nature of what you guys do at Cobalt, if at all? Well, in the past 10, 15 years, the way we manage publishing has changed formally. We went from an ownership to a consumption model. Obviously, we went from a few hundred income sources to really thousands of income sources. But it's not enough. We also have seen fivementation of copyrights. So you have more and more speed copyrights. So it's not in common to see five, seven writers on the song. And you have a fragmentation of consumption. So if you look at those three factors, it has compounded volume in extraordinary ways. And the challenge with volume is you need to manage that with great velocity, because we have to account every quarter. So it's not because you have more to manage that you can delay your accounting period. Obviously, and you also have challenges accuracy. Right. So our job as we built our infrastructure. And it's a continuous exercise. How do we manage this? Like, for instance, I've often a conversation with my city. How do we manage AWS cost? All of it is in a cloud. Because you have volume going at 30, 40% a year. You have your cost of AWS going at 10, 12% a year. And we have to manage a business. So you have to find ways to again, optimally managed adequate system and not, you know, affecting quality, not affecting velocity. And it's frankly a job of every day. It really is. It's a natural tension in the business. Yeah. I mean, does that mean that publishers are spending more than ever to try to collect those like micro pennies all over the world? Do you feel that? Good. And you will. And we are the challenges that that value that micro license that micro transaction is so small, you have to do it cost effectively. Otherwise, you'd be losing money for every moment. You collect. Right. So you have to find that's what technology is obviously a major aspect of what we do, AI, of course, but not only AI. It's really about building that infrastructure that can handle the volume. And it's a challenge. It really is an interesting change almost every day. This is a topic that we talk about almost every day. Yeah. Well, another thing that I wanted to ask you guys about as part of this acquisition of Cobalt. Cobalt is known for publishing administration. It's known for Amaran. It's known for cosine. But also you guys at Cobalt. You have you announced in 2023 that there's a $700 million fund to buy copyrights. And so is that part of the steal or do you retain that at Cobalt? Well, we retain and that's a conversation Larry and I had because we have a different IP strategy and we deploy on different type of copyrights. But we've been in that business for a long time since 2011. That's where we first started what we call today. And again, for us, the idea here was to provide an additional service to your clients. You know, we provided all the services under I mean situation. But if people needed a capital event. So we wanted to be able to say yes, we can do that for you as well. So we created a fund in Ediven and second fund in 16. We could have been in 2023. And we've been deploying a capital obviously not only on clients that we have because we know them and they come to us, but also buying third party copyrights. You know, we turn down many more deals than we do. And so Laurent's team is participating in our deal meetings. So, you know, when there's a deal that we're reviewing that isn't right for primary wave. We're turning it over to Cobalt. So there's, you know, there's another outlet for potential acquisition. Yeah, this is maybe an elementary question, but I've always been curious like how these deals get shopped around these massive catalog deals that we keep seeing headlines of in the news. Is this just kind of like a, if you know, you know, kind of a network where people know what kind of stuff that primary wave typically lights the buy. So you just get approached by certain lawyers or catalog valuation folks. I think that's partially true, right? We've, you know, we like, we like to think we built a brand that artists want to come to where our moniker is homo legends. for it with the Lord the Stoner now in the world of these legendary amazing pieces of creative work. But there's, we very rarely go to auction. A lot of our competitors have to go to auction. I think we've acquired eight or nine catalogs in the last 90 days, none of which were auctioned. All were proprietary. Harry Chapin, Robert Palmer, Donna Summer, foreigner. Oh my gosh, there's one that was just announced. Mary J. Blige, we announced they were all proprietary deals. And, and the reason is simple, that we provide a certain service. So we've developed a brand over 20 years that people understand and know to we partner with artists. We're not buying 100%. Most of the deals we do are partnerships so that if we do well, the artist does well. And we'll never know better than the artist or the errors of the family, what the artist wants from marketing, what they want from content. So we work with the artists to create. The third reason is artists like to be with other artists of similar stature. So when you have prints and you have Bob Marley and you have Whitney and James Brown and Bing Crosby and all these great legendary artists, artists want to be in the same place. And then the other thing is we've created a platform that really is second to none from a marketing and value creation perspective. So artists are attracted to that. And I'm not going to name competitors, but most of the people that have come into the business in the last four or five or six years or two years are really financial players. And financial players have to spend more than we do because we provide a very unique service, which is, hey, you want to buy a film. We can produce it. You want to document it. We can produce it. You want to Broadway show. We can produce it. You want an immersive experience. We're creating eight right now. Oh, God. Wow. You want a brand deal with Coca-Cola or proctor and gamble. That's what we do. You want a digital footprint that's expanding. That's what we do. Most of the competitors in this business are raising money. They're writing a check. They're on to the next thing. There is very, very little artist market and going on in the space today. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, that brings me to, I think I've told you this layer like several times. I think one of the most unique and interesting things that you guys have done from a marketing perspective is the Whitney Houston slot machines. Yeah. I just think that's fascinating. This has been like a huge success in Vegas, right? It has been a giant success for us. And now I'll tell you, we, we had budgeted, we started this in 2004. So two and a half years ago, we budgeted 200 machines a year. We've done over 500 a year. We just renewed the deal with IGT. We are having great success. And, you know, how do you measure success? Well, you can measure success on shipping machines and shipping more than your budget. But the real measure is, you know, we're making more money for the estate of Whitney Houston, which we owned 50% off. Then the entire estate was generating six and a half years ago when we bought into the estate on that one deal. And remember, that's just one deal. We've done a Mac cosmetic line, a recent beauty line that was in, you know, thousands of Walmart stores. We've, we produced the biographical film. We created really, we, you know, when we, when we first did the deal with Whitney, we went into the vault and we found this incredible song called Higher Love that Steve Winwood made famous in the 80s. And our team went to Kaigo, got Kaigo to remix it. And in a month, we had it out up with RCA on streaming services. And we had a number one record in eight countries around the world. That's because we are aggressive marketers. And so, you know, you talk about slot machines. It's just one of many things that we do for the Whitney estate and all the other, you know, artists that we're in business with. But it's important because what these things do is they introduce the music to a new youth culture. Because we are all about the number one thing, our number one, you know, purpose in life at primary wave is to protect legacy of an artist. If you're going to protect legacy, you must continue to reintroduce this music to a new youth. Because otherwise, 20 years, 30 years, and 40 years down the road, you know, people won't be streaming it. They won't be listening to it. In the last, you have kids reintroduced. And, you know, I, I have, I have two 20 year old girls that back when we released higher love, or in their teens, they'd never really heard the music of Whitney Houston, right? Now they love Whitney. And they're listening to more than just higher love. That's what you have to do. And it's more than protect it's expensive, which is what you've done very well. I don't think does anyone in the market doing what Palmer does really because they have a focus. And they actually do what they said they will do. And there's a lot of people talking in the market, but the reality is they've built an infrastructure that can manage what they're doing and the volume that they're doing, which is very different, by the way, from most buyers in the market. I know you talked about how you guys partner with the States, like usually the artist or their representatives if the artist has passed, will work with you guys side by side when you do stuff. And I always have wondered like with various like brand partnerships. Sometimes like the States can be really sensitive about things. Like usually anything that's, you know, sexual nature involves alcohol or even gambling. So I'm wondering what the conversation was like with the Whitney Houston estate to decide that this was like the right choice for you guys. It was easy. Whitney, Whitney loved to place a lot of machines. Oh, I didn't know that. He was very organic. Okay. We will not do a brand deal, a marketing deal, any type of brand alliance, movie, anything, unless the artist of the estate 100% signs off and says, yes, 100%. I'm giving you another example. We partnered with Lou Adler on his catalog. And you know, Lou phenomenal music producer, but he also had another jam in his catalog, which was key was a co-owner of Rocky Horror Picture Show. So he owned the soundtrack, owned a, you know, a big chunk of the movie. So, you know, one of the first things we did was we went out and pitched Rocky Horror Picture Show to the sphere. Earlier this year and the sphere loved it. And we're opening an immersive experience at the sphere in March. But the reason I bring it up is because Lou is very protective of the legacy. Why has it survived, you know, over 50 years because Lou has been very, very protective of that brand. And so Lou is involved in all the conversations with the sphere. He's involved in all the creative. We will not do anything unless Lou Adler signs off. And, you know, he's, I think he's going to be very, he is very proud of the creative to date. He's going to be very proud when this opens up. But he was instrumental in this whole process. We, we wouldn't do it on our own. Yeah. I mean, I can't wait to see that because I think that that actually fits really well with the sphere and what it seems like they seem to be going for with these. I mean, it's, it's really smart for the sphere to have something they can hit play on over and over again that just works. Well, and, and think about Rocky Horror. I mean, what are you going to put in any venue from 11 o'clock at night to 9 a.m.? Right? Yeah. Rocky Horror picture show. Yeah. Absolutely. Well, I mean, okay, so another thing that you mentioned is something where I feel like there might be some synergy between primary wave and cobalt again, which is that, for example, with the Whitney Houston estate, you guys started pitching higher love to producer who ended up being Kaigo to do a remix of it. They really helped to bring it back into the zeitgeist once again. And you guys have been really active on this front of making songwriting camps around some of your catalogs. I think I'll did a death leopard songwriting camp at one point. And that's rubbing up against the front line artist, which are the people that Laurent works with. So are you guys planning on doing anything where you'll be pitching your catalog for your, you know, kind of front line songwriters and producers to work with or anything like that? Well, I'll tell you, we do quite a bit of songwriting camps, Justin Shoukat, who heads our publishing company and creative, organizes, you know, these phenomenal writing camps around the world. And, you know, it's for us, it's about, if for primary wave, it's about taking our legendary songs, our legendary songwriters. And putting those songs in the hands of pop culture producers and writers of which Laurent has a very significant share of the market. So there is absolutely collaboration that's going on more so in the future. Because remember, our partner, she was well, you re-months old. Exactly. I'm like, where's the songwriting camp y'all come on? Yeah, we haven't gotten the bill yet on our closing dinner. That's going to be a big bill. But we, you know, we've started to integrate, that's an area that, that we're going to have a lot of collaboration. And our creative teams, Justin's team and, and Jeanette, Jeanette's team on the couple side, really like each other and they're talking. And they've known each other. for a long time, which is why also it's working. They've worked together before. They actually like each other. So we're not, you know, they're and I don't have to say, dude, let's do this with that. They are organically interacting with each other and look at the opportunities. Justin would call us and say, oh, by the way, I have a client, it doesn't quite work for us, but it may work for cosine. Let me speak to Jason, who runs cosine for us. So there's already generally a lot of back and forth between the organization. - And you have to remember, primer wave and cobalt started just about the same time. - That's a good point. - I remember Willard pitching me, you know, back in like 2007, 2008, we started in 2006. So, you know, we kind of grew up entrepreneurially in the, in the, in the pendant business together. - Yeah, well, that's a good point. I mean, Willard, who is the founder of cobalt, is stepping away as part of the deal or like as the deal closed, he stepped away as chairman. So who's filling that slot now? - Chairman of the board, I'm supposed to see you. - I'm gonna be you. - Okay, listen, the reality is there's only one person that matters, which is the CEO, which is Laurent. And, you know, we, we were clear with each other day one that when primary wave was doing this, a big chunk of the reason was the management team in Laurent at cobalt. It is an entrepreneur company, Laurent runs it with very little interference at all from primary wave. We talk a couple of times a week. So, you know, we're very active on what we're doing together, but cobalt is and will remain a separate entrepreneurial run company. And Laurent's doing a great job. - So, we've talked about briefly that you all both have these funds that you're working with to buy more copyrights. And, okay, so yours was announced for cobalt in 2023. I think it was Morgan Stanley, who was your partner, $700 million to deploy. And then you guys have a new fund as of this year, right? With Brookfield, 2.2 billion. - No, well, so we brought Brookfield in as a minority partner into the company about four and a half years ago. - Okay. - Brookfield has invested in some of the funds that we've been, we've put together. Brookfield is a minority investor in our latest fund for, so that's a $2.25 billion fund. And, yes, so they've been an amazing partner, but Brookfield is one of many institutional investors that have come into the latest. - Got it, got it, got it. And so, I just wanted to see where you guys were at with it. Are you all able to share how much of your two funds you've deployed so far, Larry? - I think I can, okay. - We are way ahead of schedule. - Okay. - We've deployed almost 60% of our most current fund, which we only closed back in April of this year. There have been some very, very large scale deals and our pipeline is pretty significant. So we anticipate being probably 75% invested at the end of the year and fully invested by the first quarter of next year. But we have many pools of capital. We have a permanent Evergreen fund with Brookfield. Brookfield put $2 billion on the primary balance sheet back in four and a half years ago, whenever that was, 2022. And we have a lot of surprises coming. - What about you guys? How much have you deployed from your 700? - Probably about half a billion dollars, that's 700 billion. And we intend to spend in a range of about 300 million that was going forward. So they will be a new fund in our context. And again, what's interesting here is that we also very complimentary. We don't go after the same targets at all. I mean, we typically buy more recent ventures. We buy copyrights where you have a high incidence of digital because we're gonna take advantage of price increases of the AMR capability. So it's a different type of strategy, which is why this was actually a conversation when we said, if we put all of this together, what do we do? And it was evidently clear that we could maintain the cycle without having any conflict issues. - Got it. Yeah, that makes sense. So you guys mentioned before that both primary waving cobalt got started around the same time, like late arts. - 2001 for us, him. - Oh, okay, 2001. And you guys. - Will it start in 2001? - That's the 2050 at hand. - Wow. - Yeah, we started in 2006. - Yeah, well, I mean, that was a very different time in the music industry. And on a previous episode of the show, we had Matt Pinkis on, who's actually a minority owner. - It was? - It was. - Yeah, we have cobalt. And we talked on that episode about the financialization of the music industry and we went really in depth about it. And you guys have had kind of a front row seat to watch the financialization of the music industry take place. So I'm wondering how you've seen that impact, how the music industry works in your time. - Well, look, when we started 20 years ago, I don't think there were any really credible financial institutions that owned any music IP. We started as a music company. We didn't start as a financially driven company. And we're not, right? We view ourselves as a music company that has the ability to raise a lot of capital through different structures and opportunity, which that hasn't changed. But today, as opposed to 20 years ago, there are lots of very large institutions that are trying to get into business because people have woken up to the fact that, hey, music is a fantastic investment. Right, if you think about it, it's uncorrelated to the market. The duration is very long, right? A lot longer than a long-term bond, long-term bonds 30 years. These copyrights, 70 years after the death of the last writer on a song and their inflation positive. So inflation positive is a very good thing. DSPs raise their rates and artists make more money. And in this business, unlike lots of financial instruments that are very credit-heavy or credit-focused, you can actually create value by working these copyrights. It's very hard when you're loaning money to somebody to create value, right? You know, it's just credit is very hard to create value. But in music, if you produce a movie, what happens to the streams? You know, Bob Marley, the Bob Marley movie came out. Our streams went up 200%. We produced a Whitney Moody Houston movie. It comes out, our streams go up 110%. That's what happens with this type of amazing investment, right? You can create a lot of value and grow your income streams. - Yeah, that's a good point. I was also just looking at the Michael Biopic that came out. It's crazy how many young people are listening to Michael Jackson more now than they ever were. And you'd think that Michael Jackson is one of those artists where he really is one of the biggest pop icons ever. And so you'd think that everyone kind of already knows him and there wouldn't be much introduction that's needed. And yet. - Well, I have to say, that's one artist that we have an interest in. - Okay. - But that we don't do a lot of work with because John Branca, who's the trustee of the estate, they're so good at what they do, they don't need help. But we are the beneficiary of. - Oh, I didn't know that. - Okay. - That's an interest in that it's been publicly reported. - Yeah. - You know what, I lose track of your icons. Sorry, there's too many of them. Laurent, what about you with the financialization of the music industry that you've witnessed over the course of your career? How have you seen it change the business? - I think on balance is a positive. You know, when you have more liquidity in the market, I think a lot of good things happen with that, typically transparency investment or focus on some of the issues and the willingness to fix those issues. And I think we have to understand why. So for all the reasons that obviously that I explained, but also you have to remember that between 2002 and 2014, 15A industry actually was contracting. Not so much on the publishing site, but overall as industry. And the change from an ownership to a consuming model has changed that fundamentally, right? So we went from a contracting to a going industry where you also have, which I think is quite unique to music. It's really the crossroad of high engagement and universal access. Much more so by the way than any other form of art. You know, whether it's a ballet, an opera, or video games, a book, a film. Yes, those are form of entertainment, but they take a different type of commitment. Music is really that crossroad. And I think we've seen that in everything that we've done. And if we look at the power of licensing and the ability through licensing to unlock greater value for the scope right. So of course, everything that primary does from creating consumption on repertoire is critical, but the ability to leverage that and making sure that you're paid fairly for those rights that's made a huge difference. 'Cause you compare that to when I joined the industry in 1999, publishing. Two-third of the income was mechanical physical, right? So coming from a few hundred labels, there was it. and you were essentially in the hands of them. to the very very different. We evolve over the licenses, social media has changed everything and I expect that to continue to receive what I'm sure we'll talk about AI. But that's why I think on balance capital who is looking for asset classes as looked at music and we see that as on balance the positive. Yeah. Yeah. I'm glad you brought up AI. Obviously, I'll know that I report on AI quite a lot and I'm curious how you guys are going to approach AI licensing deals as they come in. I know Cobalt, you've already started 11 labs, Spotify, I'm forgetting some UDO. So Cobalt has-- And it maps too. Yes. Yeah. So Cobalt's already done a few AI licensing deals. How does that work between the two of you? Are you guys going to negotiate together from now on or is this still separate? On any copyrights that would be under or preview, obviously, we would be talking to this team and making sure that we align, but otherwise, I'm sure that you have conversation with other key administrators in your case. But it is, again, that's a conversation of every day and how we're looking at is going forward. I think it's a combination of education, trying to understand the space, better education for ourselves, but also education and working with the writers and working with the platform. For instance, today, I don't think people understand exactly which includes us too, that way. What are all the different products that are there that can be done via AI and why? So when you go to market, what is really that product that they are? What does it do and what are the benefits of that product? And those are the type of data that we're having, obviously, with the licensees. And we have a lot of conversation internally and with our writers. The music industry in recent years has started to see a lot of these kind of acquisitions and mergers of major companies, especially in the last year. I mean, you have UMG or Virgin within UMG purchasing downtown. And then you have BMG and Concord and you have primary wave and cobalt. And I'm wondering, just taking a step back on a macro scale, why you think these acquisitions in this consolidation is happening now? Well, I think you're going to see a lot more infrastructure. I think as interest rates go up, I think you're going to see a lot of our competitors that are financially driven, looking to sell. And if you think about it, primary wave, by the way, has no debt. So we're generating returns, significant returns without that, because of the alpha we're creating as we market. A lot of our competitors are highly leveraged. So they're taking very safe assets that generate cash flow every single day that would normally go back out, go into acquisition or go back out in the form of dividends to investors. These companies are paying interest to banks and as interest rates go up and they have to refinance their significant debt, they're going to have a hard time. So I think you're going to see, again, don't want name competitors, but you're going to see a lot of people that are going to be selling, I think, over the course of the next two and three years. So you're going to see a lot more consolidation. And that's great for companies like cobalt and primary wave, especially ones that are very well capitalized and have almost no debt. Yeah, I mean, is it better for artists and songwriters than I'm talking on a macro scale, not y'all specific deal? Well, it's better if you're with a company that has an infrastructure to partner and has an infrastructure to help, has an infrastructure to create content for them and actually, you know, again, market. But, you know, is it, is it any good when a, when an artist is acquired by, you know, private equity firm? Probably not because the first thing on their mind isn't legacy protection and it's not, you know, turning a hit song that was a hit 30 years ago into a hit song again. It's how they going to extract this much cash out of the asset as they possibly can and then likely flip it. So yeah, I think it's very good if the artists are being acquired by a company that has the ability to do something. Yeah, that's a good point. I mean, that's the thing that always makes me a little bit nervous when I see these catalog deals with these major financial players where I know that they're probably going to want to exit within like three to seven years. Yeah. And I don't know. Maybe that's, maybe that is the best deal though is on the table for that artist and they want to do it. I think one of the things that I've found in, I've been making more short form videos about how the music business works since I've been exposed to a lot of people who are just now learning about how it works. And it's interesting how people read catalog headlines sometimes. They hear someone so their catalog and they think, oh my gosh, I can't believe they would do that. That's terrible. And, you know, sometimes an artist is in financial trouble and they're desperate to sell and they're not selling from a great wonderful place. But also a lot of times, the artist did get exactly the deal they wanted. They're very excited. And I mean, if it's a place like primary wave, maybe they've still retained part of it. That's also the thing that gets lost in the headlines is you see a price tag for a deal, but it's like, okay, but they might have only sold 30% of their catalog, not 100%. Well, if you notice when we do press releases when Kitty, oh, I've noticed this. It says partnership. I know. Right. I'll say acquire. I hate the word acquire. It's a partnership. And, you know, the other thing is you just, you just brought this up. It makes me a little sad when I see really young artists selling their music catalogs or their music copyrights. You see, I understand artists that are in their 70s in their 80s, even their late 60s because they're a state planning. You know, maybe they want cash for things that they haven't been able to do as they've gotten older. They want a partner, right, to help reintroduce their music to a new youth culture. I really, it really pains me to say these artists that are in their 20s and early 30s selling their music catalog because, you know, hopefully they have so much more life in what they're doing. Yeah, but I mean, I imagine that a lot of people sell when they're still young right now because the market is still considered to be quite hot. And I think some people are probably making the kind of calculation in their head of like, should I just sell now while the market, I know the market is hot and there is a viable market for this work and, you know, I also wonder if they think about what's the long-term value of the song that I made. Is it going to last 10, 20 years from now? Is it better to sell now or is it better to wait and hope that it lasts? I don't know. I don't know. Yeah, I mean, I think, as you said earlier, the vast majority of transactions is because people are, it's a willing buyer's set of environment, right? So in some cases you're right, people have financial problems and that's the worst reason why you would sell. But there are many other good reasons why you should sell. I mean, asset planning is one of them or if you have value that is exceeding what you think you may be making going forward, obviously, it makes sense. And I also think the relationship, especially with young creators to their own IP is different than it was perhaps 20, 30 or 50 years ago. I think people look at their IP differently and they have perhaps an opportunity to sell at IP early on in that stage. And if you're confident, they can recreate it again and do it again, but we've seen it. But we have, by the way, clients, we've bought three, four trenches of their corporates over time, over a 10-year period, a 15-year period. So I also think that people's mentality around transactions has evolved quite a bit. You see, I have a little bit of a different opinion on that, right? You know, artists that are in their 50, 60, 70s, 80s are a bit more mature. They've been in the business, they've been a little battle-hardened from what they've been through over the years. You know, artists that are in their 20s, ones that are getting pushed by their managers or their lawyers to sell their copyrights, I think that's a tougher for me. We rarely will enter into those conversations because I just think that, you know, it's just a tricky, it's a tricky slope, and should these artists really be selling? Yeah. I think it's important to make the distinction between artists and writers. I think a writer might be more likely to sell than an artist, I think that's true. And I think every person's situation is where it is, right? It's all unique set of circumstances, but I think writers have a different relationship to their IP. But they can't do the active marketing themselves, they're not the faces of a song. That's right. That's right. Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's also interesting because modern artists today are, especially, let's say, the last five years, are getting record deals and publishing deals that are more friendly than ever. So they might actually be retaining their copyrights in the very beginning, which an artist who is in their 70s right now has been through the trenches with. To a capture, a copyright, it was a different matter. Exactly. But, you know, like an artist who is active today, you know, actually probably has more rights to sell. So it's just, it's a totally different calculation, I imagine. It's more optionality. Yeah. And they may decide to transact on that transact. And again, I think many of them feel that they can build it again, and many have, right? I mean, I think the cycle is very different than it was maybe 20 or 30 or 40 years ago. Yeah. I guess, as a final question before we move on to games is, do you think that the, like, we've been talking about how the catalog market is hot right now, and it has been hot for a long time? Is there any chance that it cools off? Larry? 20 years ago, when we came into the space and we started primary wave, if I saw. a good deal a month, that was a lot. Today, I'm seeing a deal a day or a deal every other day. And so, you know, is it going to cool off? I think interestingly, 20 years ago, artists that we were dealing with were in their mid 60s, late 60s, 20 years later. You know, they're in their 80s or they're in their, you know, late 70s. So, and I think you're seeing more and more artists, you know, as they get older, are really open to the idea, hey, you know what? It's a good time to monetize and/or I need a partner. So, I don't see it slowing down. I see it speeding up. And the one thing that could certainly change the dynamic is rising interest rates. Rising interest rates historically don't necessarily affect the greatest to the great, right? When Lieberstolar sold, they were getting a premium. When Joe Betts sold, they were getting a premium, right? When Bruce Springsteen sells or Michael Jackson sells or Prince sells, they're getting a premium. So, I think that you could see the kind of lower half of the market fall a little bit, because as interest rates go up, I think the lower half of the market is going to become cheaper, less value, lower multiples, which made dissuade some people from selling. So, that's a possibility that the bulk of the market may slow down a bit. But where we are has always been the premium end of the business, the premium end of the business, because it's easier to market. It's easier to create opportunity when you know the artist or a producer or director or creative advertising executives knows the artist, that's the place where we live. So, I don't see it slowing down for us, but I do see potentially the kind of B&C level copyrights songs, potentially slowing that. Yeah, I mean, I would say the market today is a product of different factors. I would see supply demand as one, scarcity of quality asset, which is a sub-market, I think, as Director said, we've seen interest rate in a past service go from 0 to 5%. And you would have expected this, we'd have impacted the valuation of the high tier. It hasn't particularly. So, there's some resilience there. But eventually, it's also a factor of category growth. If we are enabled, for instance, if we think about AI, and we are enabled to take that turn successfully and create greater revenue and greater growth, yes, of course, you could have pressure on pricing, because you have to assume social media and standard streaming will at some point mature. I don't think mature, but we're not far off. It's probably five years from now, six years from now. So, you have to ensure that there is still plenty of growth, which I believe there will be. I'm actually quite bullish about the category. But if that were to change, for whatever reason, that would have impact on the valuation. Interesting. Okay, I'm sorry, I actually have one more question, Larry, before we move on to games. So, there are so many catalogs that are being bought and sold right now. Do you ever run out of icons? Look at the, look at the highest end of the market. ACDC hasn't sold, Led Zeppelin hasn't sold, stones. I mean, there is a lot of music out there. And at some point, at some point, these artists are going to get to the point, the old enough, the point they're going to say, you know what? Maybe it's time to sell. Why? Because they want to plan for their families, they want to estate plan, they want to bring the cash in, they don't want their families to have to manage music assets. And they need a partner. So, there's a lot out there. And, you know, at some point, you know, 10 years, 12 years, 20 years down the road, maybe. But don't forget, there are also different rights, right? When I started, I was buying almost exclusively music publishing rights. When we bought Kurt Cobain, it was music publishing. When we bought, Bob Marley was music publishing. We bought Whitney Houston. We bought all rights. So, not only, you know, publishing, she didn't write a lot, but there were master recordings. There was name image and likeness rights. You know, so there's different forms of revenue streams, different rights as well. So, I think there's going to be plenty of rights to buy for quite a bit of time. Okay. Okay. Should we move on to some games? So, this is a game that we call Spend the Record. And on this wheel, which I made myself, there are impressive. You know what? Thank you. Don't look too close. It looks pretty DIY, but it looks great on camera. So, I'm going to spend this wheel and we'll see what it lands on, just a bunch of fun questions. Okay. Who's an artist that early on in your in knowing them, you accurately predicted that they would be a star someday? I'm more in the world of fighters. Well, a star writer. You could be like the, I mean, you guys work with Max Martin, but like, you know, I would tell you there's a fighter which I had dinner with him last week in Nashville is Luke Dick, who co-wrote obviously choosing Texas, massive, massive song. I met Luke over 15, 16 years ago. We had dinner actually in my apartment in New York. And I found him to be fascinating. He has a life story that is quite fascinating, which sort of prepares you for your ability to write about it. It's so true. You know, human conditions. And we were reminiscing that last week and I restarted to him and said, yeah, I just want to, I just want to, you know, with you and talk a bit about the past. And that's a good example of somebody where you could see that there was the substantive experience there and it was not needed an opportunity to be unlocked in some ways. This is an easy one for me. Okay. When I was, when I was a general manager at Ares de Records back in 2000, we signed Avril Lavigne and those songs were no brainers. We knew that they, that she was going to be a monster star. In fact, I tried to start Ares de Music publishing while I was running Ares de Records, right? And, and BMG, who owned Ares de At the time, wouldn't let me do it because it was a BMG music publishing. And BMG couldn't sign. We could have signed the publishing. BMG couldn't, right? And so it, I think it went to off to MCA. But anyway, we knew Avril Lavigne was going to be a star. I love that. That's great. Those are both good ones. Okay. The wheels going to fall apart. This happens at every single show, by the way. What separates a great artist of their day from a lasting icon? I feel like it's, I would feel that. I mean, I, I think it's when music meets culture. That's suddenly what you experience is something that has almost a collective consciousness. And that typically has a lasting impact. I think people feel this. And by the way, it's any type of music, right? I mean, I think it's, it really is the sense of culture, the sense of collective belonging is blind to repertoire. You know, it's an experience. It's a feeling. So I think that's from my perspective, that's the criteria. Yeah. To me, it comes down to the song, right? It's all about songs. You have songs that are great. They're going to be lasting. You have songs that are disposable three years from now. You know, forget it. At the end of the day, though, artists today have a very different environment than artists of years ago. It's very hard to today, very hard today, to create legends. It's very hard to have a long career because, you know, Spotify now is all about singles. But, you know, 30 years ago and 40 years ago in this, in the 67, these 80s and 90s, it was all about the album. It was all about the depth of the work, the body of work. It was about album art. So you could create careers and you could create long-term artists. It's very hard to do that today when you're talking about, hey, what's the next, what's the single? Or what's the song? Forget about the single. What's the song? And people don't necessarily have the patience to sit and listen to a whole album today. There are kids are streaming a song and then moving on to the next thing on their playlist. So that's the big difference. That's a good point. It really is. Okay, I'm going to spin again. Wheel is back in action. We're not winning any money, I see it as money. I know no money. I'm sorry, you know, budget cuts, right? But you don't need the money. You will fund it. Yeah, you can talk about your well-funded this whole time, so fair enough. What is some of the best advice you've been given as an executive? Leading is not the art of being reasonable and you have to push because we never have the time. You know, a lot of people say we have time, but at the end of the day, we really never have the time. And you have to keep running. You have to keep pushing the envelope. As I said, being reasonable is not really what will drive an organization. And that came from, I would say a mentor for me, Nick Firth, who was working for at BMG. And the guy that wouldn't let me sign Avalovina to a evolution. Wow, that's how it connected to this. But it was great advice because it's it's something I think about often in my job that really leading is not the art being reasonable. And you have to push to get outcomes. Look, I grew up in the music business at Island Records. I started in my 20s. I worked for Chris Blackwell for 11 years, who was one of, if not the greatest creative music exec in the business, in least for a certain type of music. And he always told me, just make sure you take care of the artist's first because if you do, everything else will fall into place. And that's why we're an artist first artist friendly company. Never do anything like I said before without getting the artists approved. Those are both good pieces. Okay, I'm going to spend one more time. Larry, this one's for you. What's the craziest catalog marketing idea you've had? The craziest. All right, I'll tell you. But I can't take credit for this. Okay, I'm going to give Adam Loneberg my head of marketing credit for this. There are two ideas that he had. I won't tell you the band. Okay, but but this one particular band, he wanted to put them in space. This is 15 years ago to be the first artist to perform in space. Okay, now that hadn't happened. That hasn't happened yet. The second thing he wanted to do, which I thought again was brilliant. We pitched the NFL on having one superstar band do the half time performances of three Thanksgiving day football games. So we wanted the band to start at the, you know, the one o'clock game, then the four o'clock game, then the eight o'clock game. And the NFL loved the idea. But they were too afraid that weather could potentially derail the band from getting from place to place to place. And logistically moving all the all the equipment became a problem. But yeah, those by the way, you in a sit here, I could, I could spend two hours with you going through some of the crazy ideas we had. We create, but we came up with this idea. We were, we, we have partnered with Smokey Robinson. Right. We came up with this idea where, you know, this is as we're closing the, what Smokey, we gave him a 40 page marketing book. And one of the, he's flipping through the book. He's in his office, flipping through the book and he's, oh my god, I love this. I love this. And then he got to a page and he said, you guys are full of shit. You totally full of shit. And Adam and I looked at him and said, what are you talking about? He goes, you're going to create a holiday for me? And Adam looks at him and says, absolutely. So, you know, with, with, you know, greeting card companies, they, they say it's a holiday. It's a holiday. So American greetings, the second Sunday of every October is Father Dotted Day. Smokey Robinson's Father Dotted Day. Why did we do it? Because we own the salon, my girl. Right. So we created a holiday for Smokey. And every time he'd go out on the golf course, you know, play golf with his friends, he'd talk about, you guys done a holiday. I have a holiday. Because American greetings said it was a holiday. So yeah, we, we could go all day with great ideas. Wow. Man, did not know that that holiday was a marketing scheme in a 40 page book. Second Sunday of every October. All right. Well, we're going to end off as we do on every episode of On the Record with, what would you queue? So I'm going to name out a few scenarios. I want you guys just to pick a song. So what would you queue to take you back to your childhood? I'll start with you, Larry. Oh my gosh. You know, the first album I ever bought was The Sweet. And the song that I played over and over and over again when I was a little kid was Little Willie. And funny enough, we bought the Nikki Chin catalog. So we now own that song and The Sweet. So yeah, no, I, oh my god, I would play that song over and over and over again. Wow. Now you're paying yourself every time that you play the song. There you go. It's true. Do you know the song, by the way? I don't think I do. Well, when we're done, I'm going to play the song. All right. What about you? Not as exciting, but it is actually, it's a TV themes that was in France and like the U.S. At the end of the day, typically around midnight, TV should stand. So you don't have all night at the time today, you do all night programs. And there was a a theme song at the end of that day. And I remember listening to that with my dad, my dad. And I was typically pretty late going to bed. And Jean-Michel Foulon was the French composer. And every time, and I don't hear it frequently here, obviously, but I would put it on and Spotify to take me right back to those evenings with my dad, really 50 years ago. Oh, I love that. I do think there was like an ending song in the U.S. as well, but I don't think it was the same one. How about you, Christine? Come on. Tell us which one. Ooh, a song to take me back to my childhood. I would say Ring of Fire by Johnny Cash. Shout out to my dad. He's a huge-- I think we have the master, by the way. Oh, really? Well, some records. Yeah, we own some records. Oh, yeah. Well, then you-- I think you definitely do have a part of it. Yeah, I love that song because my dad was a huge Johnny Cash fan. I grew up in Texas. We love kind of that classic country. We don't listen to a ton of pop country in my family, but those kind of classic songwriters doesn't get old. But I thought Ring of Fire was such a fun song when I was little. So that is my pick. I've never been asked before, so there you go. Can we spend-- Should we spend the whale and ask you a questions? These don't apply to me. This is like, you know, advice as an executive. I wouldn't say that I am one. But, okay, what would you cue to represent your favorite era of music? I know that's hard for you guys to probably narrow down, but-- So, I'm 58. So for many 80s, it's sort of that time. I would say, "Vending human, I love LA." Ooh, good. Call back to LA. This is a great way to end the show. Okay, what about you? Oh, the 80s without a doubt. Okay. For sure. Okay, was that because it was like during that period, that fertile period where you kind of hone your music taste? I feel like everyone always calls back to their teens and 20s. Yeah, late teens, early 20s. So, you know, for sure. Yeah. But I listen, I mean, I also love the 70s. And we tend to like AC/DC and all those, you know, fantastic bands of the 70s and also 60s, so. Yeah, well, I'll keep going with mine as well. 90s, and I would have to pick something by Nirvana. Ooh. So, I went through a very heavy Nirvana phase. So, that could also work for the childhood one. Okay, and finally, what would you guys queue to represent the best concert you've been to? Okay, so, I'll tell you the loudest concert I've ever been to, was by far Taylor Swift at the metal ends. I took my two daughters. I was a hero for about 24 hours, right? 'Cause, you know, 24 hours of wear was off and dead. What have you done for me lately, right? Yeah, so that was, by the way, that was one of the most incredibly well-produced show. The production value was amazing. It was also the loudest concert I've ever been to. But I think my favorite concert was a number of Paul McCartney shows. I was a giant Beatle fan, still a giant Beatle fan. And every time I see Paul McCartney, it's just an amazing experience. My first show was the police in Providence, Rhode Island. Oh, that's a good first show. Alina show, yeah. Yeah, mine was Hannah Montana. So, I wouldn't say, well, you know, love Miley, but that was a little bit of a kid show. So, that police is a way more mature. I've seen every episode, by the way. I've kids. Every episode. I'm a big Hannah Montana fan. Laurent, what about you? So, for me, it would be Nick K, actually. But, what was it for? Right, it was before the pandemic. And he had real family tragedy, as we know. And that concert was almost felt like a communion. And it was at the Hollywood Wall. I mean, of what, 18,000 people there. I mean, it was a, and that experience was in many ways, almost spiritual. And I don't often have that in a concert. You enjoy the concert. It's a great time, a great moment. But he created an atmosphere of, you know, quasi communion with the audience. And it was quite remarkable. I love that. Well, Laurent, Larry, thank you so much for coming to On The Record. Thank you. Thank you for having me. Thank you, Chris. All right. Thank you so much to Larry Mistell and Laurent Hubert for joining me to talk about primary waves acquisition of cobalt and what deals like this mean for the future of music. And thank you for listening to this week's episode of On The Record. If you like today's show, give us a follow on Instagram or on our TikTok page at Billboard On The Record, where you can find new clips of this show every single week. We'd also appreciate it if you rated our show on your favorite podcast platform. All these things help on the record grow bigger and better than ever. I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and tune in next week for another peek behind the curtain of the music business. I'll see you then. (birds chirping) When you shop Kroger Delivery, you can expect the savings you love. And for. Fresh Groceries delivered right to your door. Carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing you fresh, quality groceries is what we do best. Restriction supplies, seasite for details. Kroger, fresh for everyone.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Primary Wave has acquired Cobalt in a deal valued over a billion dollars, combining Cobalt’s publishing administration expertise with Primary Wave’s marketing and value creation capabilities.
  2. The acquisition strengthens both companies’ positions without merging operations; Cobalt remains independently run with its own leadership and culture.
  3. Cobalt’s Amara platform, which enables direct digital royalty collection and reduces financial leakage, is a key asset being leveraged by Primary Wave for its catalog.
  4. Primary Wave will expand its use of Amara and Cosine—offering flexible, short-term publishing deals for mid-tier songwriters—while maintaining existing partnerships with Universal and other administrators.
  5. The deal reflects a broader industry trend of consolidation, driven by rising interest rates and financial pressure on leveraged competitors, favoring well-capitalized, artist-focused companies.
  6. Both companies emphasize artist legacy protection through creative marketing, immersive experiences, and re-introducing music to new audiences.
  7. Cobalt’s 2023 $700M fund and a new $2.25B fund with Brookfield are actively deploying capital to buy copyrights, with different strategies focused on digital and recent music.
  8. The partnership highlights a shift in music industry dynamics from ownership to consumption, with technology, AI, and flexible publishing models enabling greater value and transparency.

Summary:

Primary Wave has acquired Cobalt in a billion-dollar deal, marking a major consolidation in the music publishing industry. The acquisition combines Cobalt’s advanced publishing administration tools—like Amara, which collects digital royalties directly and reduces financial leakage—with Primary Wave’s global marketing and value creation expertise. Cobalt remains fully independent, with its leadership and operations unchanged, ensuring a smooth integration without disruption.

Key strengths include Amara’s end-to-end digital royalty collection and Cosine’s flexible, short-term publishing deals for emerging songwriters. This move reflects a broader industry trend of consolidation, driven by financial strain on leveraged competitors and rising interest rates. Both companies prioritize artist legacy through immersive marketing, such as Whitney Houston’s Vegas slot machines and the Rocky Horror immersive experience.

The deal underscores a shift from rigid ownership models to consumption-based, technology-driven publishing. 25B capital funds will expand catalog acquisitions, with each firm targeting different music domains—Primary Wave focusing on legacy catalogs and Cobalt on newer, digitally active content. Critically, the partnership emphasizes artist empowerment, with transparent, flexible deals and a commitment to protecting music legacies through creative innovation, rather than financial extraction.

The transaction also highlights evolving artist motivations, including financial planning and legacy planning, especially among older artists, while raising concerns about early-career creators selling rights prematurely. Overall, the deal signals a future where artist-centric, value-driven companies lead the industry, leveraging technology and creativity to sustain long-term music value.

FAQs

The acquisition is significant because it combines Cobalt's strong publishing administration and songwriting support with Primary Wave's expertise in marketing and content creation, creating a powerful, complementary business model in the music industry.

Yes, Cobalt will remain an independent, entrepreneurial company with full operational autonomy. The two companies will maintain separate management teams and continue to operate as distinct entities.

Cobalt excels in publishing administration, flexible deals (like Cosine), and global digital royalty collection via Amara. Primary Wave specializes in marketing, content creation, and value-driven campaigns for iconic music catalogs.

Amara is a global digital royalty collection platform that directly collects payments from DSPs, reducing leakage and improving efficiency. Primary Wave plans to use it extensively for its catalog, but won’t replace existing partners like Universal.

Both companies prioritize legacy protection by reintroducing classic music to new audiences through marketing, immersive experiences, and songwriting camps, ensuring long-term relevance and financial sustainability for artists.

The deal does not involve a full acquisition of Cobalt’s assets. Instead, it is a strategic partnership where each company retains its core operations and funding, with no debt taken on by Primary Wave.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.