Go back

How Nvidia Built a Backdoor to China

17m 1s

How Nvidia Built a Backdoor to China

Malaysia is rapidly becoming a global data center hub, hosting massive facilities powered by NVIDIA’s cutting-edge AI chips. Chinese tech giants like Alibaba and ByteDance access these chips through third-party providers such as Aolani Cloud and Day One, operating in Malaysia to circumvent U.S. export restrictions. This arrangement is made possible by Malaysia’s proximity to China, strong business ties, and ethnically Chinese workforce, reducing language and cultural barriers. However, U.S. scrutiny has intensified, with allegations of chip smuggling—such as through Supermicro and Megaspeed—leading to investigations and new export controls targeting re-export of AI chips. The resignation of Jensen Huang has escalated U.S. efforts to crack down on the loophole, though Chinese authorities continue to allow access for key firms to maintain technological competitiveness. While Malaysia risks losing some Chinese clients due to these restrictions, American firms may fill the gap, preserving long-term data center growth. Despite these pressures, NVIDIA remains a dominant force, generating $116 billion in revenue, underscoring the global demand for its chips and the enduring complexity of the U.S.-China AI technology race.

Transcription

2507 Words, 14383 Characters

English
Our colleagues do woo covers tech in Asia, and he recently won on a reporting trip. We're in Malaysia, so we're right by the quater. It's super hot and there are palm trees everywhere. Not the kind you think about in Florida, Miami, but actually these are palm oil plantation, palm trees. Once you got past the plantations, the thing Stu was reporting on finally appeared. Suddenly, you see this giant dirt field with tons of cranes and excavators and bulldozers and dump trucks. Stu was at the construction site of a sprawling data center, the size of 117 football fields. And it looks like they're just transforming the earth, kind of flattening it, so I just saw a bunch of dump trucks coming out with piles of dirt, of land on them. And what chips will this data center be running on? This site and most of the advanced data centers in Malaysia are using NVIDIA's cutting-edge chips. And who is going to be the customer for this data center? The customer will be Alibaba, the really famous Chinese, it's like the Amazon of China. A big Chinese tech company isn't supposed to have access to NVIDIA's most advanced chips. But at this site, and at many others across Southeast Asia, it will. How central is Jensen Huang to this story? How central is he to making this whole data center ecosystem a reality in places like Malaysia? Yeah, Jensen Huang and the NVIDIA that he ran is huge to make this happen. But of course, far from this data center in Malaysia, across the world in Silicon Valley, a lot has changed for Huang. At a high level, what effect could Huang's ouster have on this whole market development? Yeah, Huang getting kicked out of NVIDIA could basically kill this cottage industry. It's a pretty big cottage industry of remotely supplying NVIDIA chips to China from Malaysia. Welcome to the journal, our show about money, business and power. I'm Michelle Hackman, it's Thursday, November 19th. Coming up on the show, Jensen Huang helped build a backdoor to China. It may be closing. The AI race between the U.S. and China first heated up in 2022 around the time OpenAI released chat GPT. Chat GPT, maybe you've heard of it. If you haven't, then get ready. This chat AI is ridiculously smart. It's called chat GPT, and let's give it over. That's when the Biden administration started thinking, okay, we have chat GPT. We have this lead in AI computing. How do we keep that lead? They realized that one huge advantage they had was that American chips made by NVIDIA, designed by NVIDIA, were a lot better than the ones that were being made in China. Their goal was to keep the U.S. ahead a year or two. They decided, okay, we're going to write these rules that restrict NVIDIA from selling their best chips to China. Why did China want NVIDIA's chips so badly? Could they not make their own chips that were similar? China has been able to figure out a lot of things in technology, but one thing they haven't caught up in yet with the U.S. is advanced chips. NVIDIA is really far ahead. There are some bottlenecks that are stopping the Chinese from making equivalent chips. The most sort of famous one is this machine that a Dutch company makes. Under pressure from the U.S. government, the Dutch aren't exporting some of this tech to China. And what this machine does is that it draws really thin lines on a piece of silicon wafer, and you need those really thin lines to make more transistors on a chip. It's almost rocket science. People think China will eventually figure it out, but it'll take years. The Biden administration tried to keep NVIDIA's most advanced chips out by restricting exports. But China kept getting its hands on them. One way was by smuggling chips across the border. One case the journal reported on involved a 26-year-old student in Singapore. He was about to go back to China for vacation and someone asked, "Would you mind packing some NVIDIA chips with you too and bringing them in your suitcase?" And he was paid about $100 per chip to get those chips inside China. This is a really small example, but when you look at the U.S. cases, the people who are being charged are accused of smuggling hundreds of million dollars of chips into China. So, when you add it all up, you have these little cases like this kid smuggling some chips in the suitcase, but you have some really big-scale ones that add up to billions of dollars according to the U.S. charges. That more sophisticated level of smuggling involves conspirators inside the tech industry. I think the most interesting one involves this company called Supermicro. Supermicro Computer is an American server company and a long-time partner with NVIDIA. The U.S. government alleges that a co-founder of Supermicro was part of a conspiracy to ship servers containing advanced NVIDIA chips to China. The first step involved a company in Southeast Asia, which bought and received servers from Supermicro. And then, these people forwarded these servers to China, which is illegal, which breaks U.S. export controls. The alleged conspirators were caught during a planned visit from an official at the U.S. Department of Commerce. So, one day last year, they went to one of these warehouses and something looked a little bit off. There were a bunch of servers that looked like theirs, but upon closer inspection, they were totally fake. Meaning the real servers were in China. These were just decoys according to the indictment. After they reviewed security footage, they saw that somebody had actually used a hairdryer to remove the stickers from their servers and put them on the fake ones. In 2024 and 2025, this Southeast Asian company allegedly bought more than $2.5 billion in servers from Supermicro. The Supermicro co-founder has pleaded not guilty, with a trial set for next year. The company itself hasn't been charged with a crime and says it's a victim in the case. Megasfeed, the Singapore-based company that suspected Chinese by Alice Wong worked for, was also allegedly involved in smuggling. Megasfeed was allegedly buying chips for its data centers, but then just forwarding those on the China. But they were doing it in a really big scale. Record seen by the Wall Street Journal show that Megasfeed arranged to send nearly $12 billion worth of top-of-the-line Nvidia chips to companies in China between March 2024 and June 2025. Megasfeed says it conducts lawful business and designs its supply chain to comply with US export controls. Nvidia says it works to prevent smuggling. According to people in the industry, the US only catches a small fraction of chip smugglers. But there's enough risk involved that Chinese companies are spending billions of dollars on a stealth workaround, renting remote access. Just after the break. Here in the US, there's been a lot of talk about data centers, but they're being built all over the world, especially in countries close to China. Like the sites Stu went to in Malaysia. Can you give us a sense of the scale of the data center market across Southeast Asia? There are a few hotspots, so we're talking Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand. But Malaysia has really stood out, and when you look at the entire world, northern Virginia, the biggest data center hub. But if things keep on going the way they're going right now, Malaysia will be the second biggest in the world. Those data centers are packed with the top of the line in video chips. And Chinese tech companies access those chips remotely. A big chunk of these customers are Chinese companies that want access to Nvidia's best chips train AI, but they can't legally get them in China. But where they can legally go is a third country like Malaysia. Is there any reason why they would have to be close to China? If someone in China is going to be renting compute, does it need to be nearby or could it really be anywhere? Like, why Malaysia? It bad? Imagine that you're a big Chinese tech company, like TikTok's parent company or Alibaba. You need the world's best chips, but you're not legally allowed to get them in China itself. So you want to go to another country, but you don't want to go to a place like India or Australia that has an adversarial relationship with China because if you get into a dispute with the government, they might just shut down that data center. That's where Malaysia comes in and has pretty good relations with China. The second thing is that Malaysia has a pretty long track record of welcoming data centers. You could go to Thailand or Indonesia, but Malaysia has been doing this for a while and they made it really easy to operate a data center there. And the third thing about Malaysia is that about a quarter of its population is ethnically Chinese. A lot of business people there speak Chinese, so if you're a Chinese tech company, you don't even have to learn the local language and you can be up and running within video chips. A Malaysia minister said last week that chips in Malaysia are meant for domestic use. And that the country is working with US authorities. Chinese companies get access to these data centers via several third party firms, like a data center builder called day one. The company is headquartered in Singapore, but one of its largest customers is bite dance, the Chinese parent company of TikTok. There's a bunch of third parties out there that will be the tenant in the day one data center and then rent that competing power to a company like bite dance. Other third party firms in this ecosystem are cloud computing companies. One of them is Aolani Cloud, which rents compute from its data centers in Malaysia to companies in China. That customer base was part of a pitch that Aolani made to potential investors. They gave a presentation to investors last year that said, "Hey, we got data centers in Malaysia and we got Chinese customers. This is a great opportunity because this stuff is so in demand and we're already here in Malaysia, a third country, where we can legally do all this stuff. So you should give us money so we can provide and video computing power to Chinese customers." It worked. Aolani's investors helped it fund about $2.5 billion in hardware in Malaysia. A spokesperson for Aolani Cloud said that, quote, "Any permitted access to our services infrastructure or technology is fully compliant with all applicable regulations." Aolani Cloud and many other firms in Southeast Asia have one big thing in common. They are members of an NVIDIA partnership program. The NVIDIA Cloud partner program is kind of like TSA pre-check. NVIDIA checks you out, makes sure that your legitimate business have good customers. If you pass the checks, then you get priority access, you get to skip the long line wherever Bill's is waiting and have a chance to buy their best chips faster. Among other companies in this partnership program is Megaspeed. According to people familiar with the matter, alleged Chinese spy Alice Wang and her associates leveraged their connections with Jensen Wang to get named as an NVIDIA Cloud partner. One of Megaspeed's biggest customers was the Chinese tech giant Alibaba. If NVIDIA's most advanced chips are in such high demand around the world, why make such an effort to sell them to these companies with Chinese customers? Doesn't NVIDIA just want the business? It's not about the money, at least not in the short term, at least not in the next couple of years. Because if they can't sell the China, an American company or a company in Europe is going to snap those up, right? So why would Wang and NVIDIA do it? When I talk to US government officials who have talked to Jensen and NVIDIA, they just describe the ethos there as super libertarian. Don't get in our way. One of my favorite things to emerge out of the reporting over the past couple of weeks is a story from one of my colleagues that said that Jensen Wang was at this conference, meeting with some of his customers. He told this kind of parable about going to Japan and waiting in a really long line at a soup restaurant, and then he gets a soup, and it's like the best soup that he's ever had. He asked the chef, "Oh, can I have another bowl?" And the chef says, "No." And Jensen thought, "This guy is the greatest businessman in the world. He keeps a really broad base of customers instead of just relying on a few cash cash." The fallout from the resignation of Jensen Huang is still rippling through the US government, and NVIDIA's back toward a China hangs in the balance. And now an update on NVIDIA, the Commerce Department, is moving to close a loophole that has let Chinese companies gain access to those restricted USAI chips. Companies will be required to obtain approval before exporting, re-exporting, or transferring AI chips to countries now with Huang out and the US government taking new steps to crack down. How is China going to try to stay competitive? Well, it's really interesting in China, because on one hand, the Chinese government has officially discouraged its tech companies from relying on NVIDIA chips. But on the other hand, they've also allowed, you know, tacitly allowed big tech companies like Bite Dance and Alibaba to access these chips offshore, because they also want these companies to have access to the best computing power in the world. So I think they'll continue, you know, to allow this to happen. What impact will these new restrictions have on countries like Malaysia and Singapore? Yeah, I've been talking to some people involved in the Malaysian data center industry. And you know, I said earlier, Malaysia was on track to be the world's second biggest data center hub. That might not be the case if they lose some Chinese customers. Now that said, a lot of American companies are also in Malaysia, and maybe they'll snap up this capacity that's suddenly free. But yeah, this is something that people in Malaysia and the industry are really monitoring really closely. However in NVIDIA, meanwhile, the bigger picture hasn't changed much. On Tuesday, the company had an earnings call. NVIDIA's total revenue for the most recent quarter was $116 billion. That's more than double from last year. That's all for today, Thursday, November 19th. The journal is a co-production of Spotify and the Wall Street Journal, additional reporting in this episode by Josh Chan, John E. Mont, Patricia Kausman, and Raphael Wong. Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Malaysia is emerging as a major global data center hub, with a sprawling facility the size of 117 football fields built to house NVIDIA’s advanced AI chips.
  2. Chinese tech giants like Alibaba and ByteDance are accessing these chips via third-party data centers in Malaysia, bypassing U.S. export restrictions.
  3. The data center ecosystem in Southeast Asia—especially Malaysia—relies on strong ties to China, including ethnic Chinese populations and favorable business environments.
  4. U.S. export controls have been circumvented through smuggling, including by companies like Supermicro and Megaspeed, which allegedly shipped servers with NVIDIA chips to China.
  5. Jensen Huang’s leadership at NVIDIA was central to enabling this global AI chip ecosystem, and his ouster has triggered renewed U.S. efforts to close loopholes.
  6. The U.S. Commerce Department is now requiring approval for re-exporting or transferring AI chips, aiming to restrict Chinese access to advanced technology.
  7. Despite official U.S. restrictions, Chinese authorities tacitly allow key tech firms to access top-tier chips overseas to maintain global competitiveness.
  8. NVIDIA’s total revenue surged to $116 billion in the latest quarter, reflecting strong demand for its chips, even as geopolitical tensions intensify.

Summary:

Malaysia is rapidly becoming a global data center hub, hosting massive facilities powered by NVIDIA’s cutting-edge AI chips. S. export restrictions.

This arrangement is made possible by Malaysia’s proximity to China, strong business ties, and ethnically Chinese workforce, reducing language and cultural barriers. S. scrutiny has intensified, with allegations of chip smuggling—such as through Supermicro and Megaspeed—leading to investigations and new export controls targeting re-export of AI chips.

S. efforts to crack down on the loophole, though Chinese authorities continue to allow access for key firms to maintain technological competitiveness. While Malaysia risks losing some Chinese clients due to these restrictions, American firms may fill the gap, preserving long-term data center growth.

-China AI technology race.

FAQs

Malaysia is emerging as a major global data center hub, with plans to become the world's second-largest after northern Virginia. Its strategic location and supportive policies have attracted significant investment, especially from Chinese tech companies seeking access to advanced AI chips.

Malaysia offers a politically stable environment with good relations to China, long-standing data center infrastructure, and a large Chinese-speaking population. These factors make it a safer and more accessible third country for Chinese firms to legally access restricted NVIDIA AI chips.

Major Chinese tech companies like Alibaba and ByteDance (parent company of TikTok) are using third-party providers in Malaysia to rent computing power and access NVIDIA’s most advanced AI chips.

They do so through third-party data center operators like Day One and Aolani Cloud, which act as intermediaries. These companies are certified NVIDIA Cloud Partners and provide compliant, legally sanctioned access to compute resources.

Jensen Huang’s leadership at NVIDIA was central to the development of AI chips used in global data centers. His influence helped shape the global ecosystem, including remote access models that enabled Chinese companies to bypass export restrictions.

The U.S. has intensified efforts to crack down on chip smuggling, including closing loopholes that allowed re-export of NVIDIA chips to China. New rules require approval for exports, re-exports, or transfers, reducing access for smuggled or circumvented chips.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.