How much can a Democratic Congress do on the economy?
15m 49s
The U.S. economy remains stable in terms of GDP and employment but is strained by persistent inflation, particularly in fuel, housing, and healthcare, which outpaces wage growth. This has made affordability a central issue in the 2024 and 2026 elections. Democrats are prioritizing swift legislative action in their first 100 days, focusing on reversing cuts to Medicaid and SNAP, restoring Affordable Care Act subsidies, and targeting tariffs and the Iran war to reduce costs. While some bipartisan agreement exists on housing and drug pricing, major policy changes depend on the president’s willingness to sign or veto legislation—especially since Donald Trump has given mixed signals. A key challenge is financing these programs, with budget constraints and high federal debt raising concerns about interest rates and future borrowing. States are stepping in with local relief, such as heating bill assistance. Internal Democratic divisions exist over whether to pursue incremental, targeted reforms or sweeping, transformative policies. Meanwhile, Republicans may face pressure to shift from Trump’s policies due to electoral losses, but many remain entrenched in opposition. The incoming Congress will be closely watched for its ability to manage divided government, communicate realistic expectations to voters, and maintain unity in the face of intraparty disagreements. Ultimately, the success of any cost-of-living reforms hinges on political cooperation, fiscal responsibility, and tangible, immediate benefits for ordinary citizens.
You've heard it a million times, and definitely every time there's an election coming. It's the economy stupid, and there's a reason that line is trotted out so much. Very often, elections hinge on economics. Joe Biden found that out in 2024, and this year, so did Donald Trump. So now that there will be all these new lawmakers, what can they actually do to improve the economy for regular people? It's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Danielle Kurtzleben. I cover the White House. I'm Sam Greenglass. I cover Congress. And NPR's Chief Economics Correspondent Scott Horsley is here. Hello, Scott. Always good to be with you. Always happy to have you. So, Scott, you're our guests, so you get to go first. Let's start with the big picture. How is the U.S. economy doing right now? Well, by a lot of measures, the U.S. economy is doing okay. The gross domestic product is still growing at a reasonably okay clip. Unemployment is still quite low, but the thing that's got everybody kind of feeling down of the dumps is that prices continue to go up, and in particular, prices are going up faster than people's wages. So with every paycheck, people feel as if they're losing ground instead of gaining ground. And as you say, that was the reason that people cast all the Democrats out of office in 2024, and they cast a lot of Republicans out of office in 2026. Well, and the big word of this election was affordability. It's something that Democrats talked about a lot. And a lot of voters did say that was top of mind for them. And is it mainly gas and diesel, and they're not gone effects that people are upset about? Or are there other prices that they're worried about? It's the whole array of stuff. It's housing costs, it's transportation costs, it's health care costs. Everything seems to be getting more expensive. And as I say, wages are not keeping up. But certainly gasoline is a very visible price. We always talk about how gas prices have sort of an outsized impact on people's emotional feeling about the economy. And since the war with Iran began, gasoline prices have been very high. They've come down a good bit in the last month or so. In fact, gasoline prices dropped below $4 a gallon on the national average just last week. But there's still almost a dollar a gallon higher than they were back in February before the US launched its war with Iran. And diesel prices are more than $2 higher than they were before the war began. And of course, diesel prices then have an impact on the cost of everything that has to move by truck or train. So that's just about everything. Now Sam, let's talk about what can be done about this. Because Democrats largely ran in the midterms on bringing down the cost of living. And of course, as we all know, they won big. So what kinds of legislation have they suggested they want to pursue in the way of bringing down prices? Yeah. So there's a bucket of priorities that Democrats say they want to tackle in the first 100 hours of taking power. I've tried to figure out exactly what 100 hours means. How that's counted in the scheme of things. It is a bit unclear. But the point is things they want to do quick. You'd be like business hours versus. Sure, sure. So we'll see you on that front. But in this category, they want to reverse the cuts to Medicaid and SNAP that were made in that Republican past one big beautiful bill last year. They want to restore the expired Affordable Care Act premium subsidies. They want to take action to undo tariffs and then try to end the war in Iran through war power votes and also by cutting off its funding. Democrats say the war and tariffs are really their best shot at being able to swiftly tackle things like gas and grocery prices. On all these priorities, there's a good amount of unity within the Democratic caucus. At least some might get Republican support. It's just not clear how much. Right. And all those things you listed seem to be concrete things that were done under Donald Trump. Either that Congress did in the one big beautiful bill or that he himself did in executive orders. So they can try to unwind those things. But then they would need President Trump's signature to get those to actually take effect, right? Yeah. And Trump has been kind of giving some mixed signals about how much he wants to cooperate with Democrats. He's called himself Mr. Vido. But he has also talked about working with Democrats. So it is a bit of an open question of what Democrats can do. That Trump is actually willing to sign. Well, and there are some places I know where there's been bipartisan agreement on at least trying to get something done. I'm thinking, I'm thinking housing, for example. Can you tell us about a few of those? Yeah, so there is bipartisan interest in doing stuff like raining and prescription drug prices. And then housing is a big one. Congress, of course, did pass a bipartisan housing bill this year. It passed through both chambers. And it eventually became law, though, without Trump's signature. It underscores, again, how difficult the president is to read in terms of the amount of cooperation he wants to have with Congress to actually turn some of these into law. Scott, there was something that Sam mentioned earlier that I was curious about. The realities of having divided government. Is that something that markets react well to? I mean, markets don't like instability, but then again, there's maybe they don't see much uncertainty in a divided government. They just think things won't change. Yeah, to the extent that divided government brings gridlock and sort of sands off the most extreme elements from both Republicans and Democrats, the business community, I think, is pretty much okay with that. That said, we do need our government to operate at least a little bit. So nobody really wants dysfunctional government, but divided government that leads to sort of less, less extreme action by either party. That's something the business community can tolerate just fine. Functional and vaguely predictable. Yes. Well, Scott, I want to ask you about one other issue in particular. And that's the minimum wage. Because you talked about how prices are going up and people's wages aren't keeping up. So wouldn't it just make sense to give people more money? Is that one way that could help people? Well, the minimum wage is certainly something that Congress has control over. And they haven't budged the minimum wage since the early days of the Obama administration. The federal minimum wage is still $7.25 an hour. A lot of states and cities have higher wages than that. And really just the job market has effectively set the minimum wage above seven and a quarter in almost everywhere in the country. But that is certainly something Congress could do. The question there is how high would they move it and would there be some countervailing effect on cost of jobs? You could almost surely raise the wage from $7.25 to some level without having any negative effect on jobs. If you went really high, then there might be some push back in a feeling that it might cost some employment. Right. And the higher you go, the more states it affects, right? Because a lot of states have their own separate minimum wages that are higher than $7.25. That's correct. So Sam, a lot of the stuff we're talking about, minimum wage aside, has to be paid for. So were Democrats and some Republicans to be able to pass some of these bills and were they to be signed? Has there been discussion of how to pay for things like subsidies and that sort of thing? A little bit, not a ton, but I imagine you're going to have to have that conversation at some point. You know, you mentioned the subsidies, restoring the cuts to Medicaid and SNAP, preventing them from taking effect. Those things aren't going to be cheap. Budget and tax writers are talking about looking for payfours or offsets. But that probably won't be enough. Many Democrats have talked about wanting to raise taxes on wealthy individuals and corporations. But that is probably not a good way to get buy-in from Republicans and the president in this particular moment. But it could be, I guess, a roadmap for 2029 if Democrats have both chambers at that point and a Democrat in the White House. What we've seen from Congress in recent years is a lot of just putting stuff on the credit card. And that's why the federal government's running a deficit of around $2 trillion a year right now. In fact, we just ran a $400 billion deficit in the month of October alone. And the more the government has to borrow, that does tend to push up interest rates for everybody else. So one of the reasons, for example, housing is so expensive. As we got mortgage rates north of 7% right now. There are a variety of factors driving that. But one is the big federal debt. So Congress may not help matters if they don't find payfours and take on a lot more debt and just keep the upward pressure on interest rates. Because that makes it more expensive for everyone else to borrow money. And you do hear some Democrats saying that is something we need to keep in mind. But then there's another class of Democrats who say, look, Republicans have run up the deficit with that big tax cut bill that they passed last year. So why should we be worried about this? The debt and deficits are a big potential roadblock at the federal level. Let's bring this to a different level then. Because state governments potentially could step in with their own new policies. Scott, is that a more likely path for things to happen? Well, there are certainly things that some states are doing. For example, right now, where a lot of folks are contending with high heating bills for the winter time. And that's especially the case in the Northeast where people heat with heating oil, which is very expensive. It's a close cousin of diesel fuel. And so folks in the Northeast are contending with very high heating bills this winter. There is some federal money to help low-income families contend with that. But there are also state efforts to deal with that. The challenge for states is, in most cases, states unlike the federal government can't run a deficit. So they really do have to live within their means and what they can raise from tax revenue. OK, it is time for a break, but more in a moment. Welcome back. As you might know, we are recording this mere hours before you hear it.
Because the news is always changing so fast, we try to get new episodes out as quickly as possible. And the best way to make sure you hear those episodes right when they're available is to follow the show wherever you listen. So on Apple, that means look for the big plus sign on our show page. On Spotify and the NPR app, there's a big follow button you can hit. Do that and make sure you are always up to date with the latest show. Okay, so let's get back to the news. We've talked about specific legislation this Congress might pass. But to become law like we've said, the president would have to sign that legislation. Or side note, Congress would have to override his veto. But that's a really high hurdle. So let's set that aside for now. But Sam, like you mentioned earlier, President Trump has given these really mixed signals on whether he would be willing to compromise or not. So how do you see Democrats and Congress reacting to that? Do you see them more trying to push compromise bills that Trump might sign? Or pass messaging bills just so they can say, hey, we tried. There's actually a lot of disagreement about this within the Democratic caucus. You know, so far, yes, shock, surprise. So far, we've been talking about some of these lower lift priorities that Democrats want to tackle in the first 100 hours or so of taking power. But there's also these bigger picture issues that Democrats have formed working groups to tackle. It issues like grocery and gas, caregiving, housing. And that's where this debate is going to become more fraught. I think the incoming likely House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries described it as the caucus will be having a family conversation about how to approach some of these issues. And you can hear the disagreement when you talk to some of these newly elected lawmakers, even I asked Senator elective dual else, say it of Michigan, who's been pitching Medicare for all as a big part of his campaign, how he thought about this. I want us to get to the work of passing legislation. Donald Trump vetoes that, that's on him. But I think you're going to start to see a whole lot of Republicans thinking twice about whether or not they want these Medicaid cuts, for example, to go through. But we've got to make it clear that we are doing what folks elected us to do and force them to decide as Republicans where they stand. So I'll say they're kind of talking about this as we're going to push ahead with the things that we want to do and let Trump and Republicans make the decision to oppose them. But then you have some more centers, Democrats who flipped deep red districts who have a different tack. I talked about this with Rebecca Cook. She flipped a district in Wisconsin. And she told me she's actually one of the people who dropped health coverage after the ACA subsidies went away. And so she really understands how important it is to bring quick tangible change. I think that we need to get things done rather swiftly. And I think big sweeping legislation is not going to come in overnight. I think doing things incrementally is what we need to do now to provide immediate relief for folks. I think that that's going to be critically important that we show people right away that they feel it in their pocket books and they feel it in their bones. That when you vote for a Democrat, your life improves. Is it an either or Sam doing it either, you know, the incremental way or the big way? Is it just a matter of limited time? Yeah, I think it's possible we do see both of these. And it's one of the big things that I'll be watching for to see how this plays out once Democrats take power next year. But there are still Republicans on the hill, right? And ahead of the midterms, we saw some of them a few at least inch away from President Trump on things like tariffs and Iran. Do you see that trend growing? Well, look, on the one hand, I think some Republicans might see more permission to break with the president because of the blue tsunami that happened just a couple of weeks ago in the election. But on the other hand, a lot of the members who have expressed criticism about tariffs about the war, a lot of those folks were in competitive districts or states and lost their elections in that blue tsunami. So there's just going to be less Republicans left in Congress who are apt to want to compromise and work on some of these issues. Let's zoom out. What will you both be watching for as the new Congress comes into power in Scott? Let's start with you. Well, I will certainly be watching to see if there is any way to push back on tariffs and the war. Those are probably the two most concrete things that the Democrats could do to directly affect the cost of living. And when it comes to tariffs, it's not just Congress. You know, the courts have a say in this too. A lot of the president's tariffs are still being challenged in court. He's lost one round in the U.S. Supreme Court. Those outlawed tariffs, he's now replaced with other tariffs. And there's going to be more legal challenges to come on that front. Sam, how about you? Two things I'm watching. One is how much Democrats feel the need to communicate to voters, the realities of divided government. You know, that just because they're taking the House and the Senate does not mean that immediately things are going to change for people in such a big way. Because, you know, you still have a president in the White House who is a Republican. You still have the Senate filibuster that requires 60 votes to pass most legislation in the Senate, which Democrats don't have. How much do lawmakers feel they have to tell people this so folks aren't setting their expectations so high and then they're dashed when inevitably change is slower than people would like. And then I'm also curious whether Democrats will hang together as a caucus when it counts or some of these intraparty fights will continue to disrupt their efforts at showing that they are competent and deserve to keep the reins for another two years in 2028. All right. Well, Scott Horsley, thank you so much for joining us. Good to meet you. All right. I'm Sam Greenglass. I cover Congress. And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics podcast.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The U.S. economy is showing modest growth with low unemployment but faces rising prices, especially in gas, housing, and healthcare, outpacing wage increases.
Affordability is a top voter concern, with inflation in everyday essentials like fuel and transport significantly affecting public sentiment.
Democrats plan to reverse key Republican policies such as Medicaid and SNAP cuts and restore ACA premium subsidies to reduce costs of living.
Tariffs and the Iran war are seen as major drivers of inflation and are central to Democrats' early legislative agenda, though implementation depends on presidential approval.
Bipartisan support exists for housing and prescription drug pricing reforms, with a bipartisan housing bill already passed and enacted without presidential signature.
Raising the federal minimum wage from $7.25 is feasible without significant job loss, though state-level wages already exceed this baseline.
Funding for cost-of-living programs remains a challenge, with Democrats considering tax increases on wealthy individuals and corporations, though bipartisan buy-in is unlikely.
State governments may act independently to address rising costs, such as through targeted heating assistance, while federal deficits and debt could further increase borrowing costs.
Summary:
S. economy remains stable in terms of GDP and employment but is strained by persistent inflation, particularly in fuel, housing, and healthcare, which outpaces wage growth. This has made affordability a central issue in the 2024 and 2026 elections.
Democrats are prioritizing swift legislative action in their first 100 days, focusing on reversing cuts to Medicaid and SNAP, restoring Affordable Care Act subsidies, and targeting tariffs and the Iran war to reduce costs. While some bipartisan agreement exists on housing and drug pricing, major policy changes depend on the president’s willingness to sign or veto legislation—especially since Donald Trump has given mixed signals. A key challenge is financing these programs, with budget constraints and high federal debt raising concerns about interest rates and future borrowing.
States are stepping in with local relief, such as heating bill assistance. Internal Democratic divisions exist over whether to pursue incremental, targeted reforms or sweeping, transformative policies. Meanwhile, Republicans may face pressure to shift from Trump’s policies due to electoral losses, but many remain entrenched in opposition.
The incoming Congress will be closely watched for its ability to manage divided government, communicate realistic expectations to voters, and maintain unity in the face of intraparty disagreements. Ultimately, the success of any cost-of-living reforms hinges on political cooperation, fiscal responsibility, and tangible, immediate benefits for ordinary citizens.
FAQs
The U.S. economy is growing with low unemployment, but inflation is rising faster than wages, making everyday expenses more burdensome for consumers.
Housing, transportation, health care, and gasoline prices are all increasing, with gasoline having a particularly strong emotional impact on people's perceptions of economic health.
Democrats propose reversing cuts to Medicaid and SNAP, restoring Affordable Care Act subsidies, ending tariffs, and cutting off funding for the Iran war to lower prices on goods and services.
No, most of these policies require the president's signature to become law. While Congress can pass bills, they would need Trump's approval or a veto override to take effect.
Yes, there is bipartisan interest in addressing prescription drug prices and housing affordability, and a bipartisan housing bill was passed and became law without Trump's signature.
High government debt increases interest rates, making borrowing more expensive and contributing to higher housing costs and inflationary pressures.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.